Normalized to: Saida, H.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.06219 [pdf] - 2112723
Constraints on the dark mass distribution surrounding Sgr A*: simple
$\chi^2$ analysis for the redshift of photons from orbiting stars
Submitted: 2020-06-11
Sagittarius A* (Sgr A*) is the central supermassive black hole with the mass
$\sim 4\times 10^6 M_{\odot}$ in the Milky Way and stars are orbiting around
it. In May 2018, one of the nearest stars to Sgr A* named S0-2/S2 experienced
the pericenter passage. The redshift of photons from S0-2 had varied from
$4000\>{\rm km\>s^{-1}}$ to $-2000\>{\rm km\>s^{-1}}$ during the pericenter
passage, which is within $0.5\>{\rm yr}$. In this paper, we show that this
steep variation of the redshift gives a strong constraint on a dark mass
distribution inside the orbit of S0-2. By applying a simple $\chi^2$ analysis
to the observed redshift, we can easily distinguish between the two models, the
point mass model and the point mass plus an extended mass model without the
best-fitting parameter search. Our redshift data during the pericenter passage
in 2018 with Subaru/IRCS bound the amount of the extended mass inside the orbit
of S0-2 less than $0.5\,\%$ ($\sim 2 \times 10^4 M_\odot$) of the mass of Sgr
A*. This constraint obtained by our simple analysis is comparable to previous
works with the best-fitting parameter search to the motion of S0-2 including
the effect of the extended mass. We consider both the power-law and the Plummer
models for the dark mass distribution model, but the significant difference
between these results is not found.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.11567 [pdf] - 2055858
Search for a Variation of the Fine Structure around the Supermassive
Black Hole in Our Galactic Center
Hees, A.;
Do, T.;
Roberts, B. M.;
Ghez, A. M.;
Nishiyama, S.;
Bentley, R. O.;
Gautam, A. K.;
Jia, S.;
Kara, T.;
Lu, J. R.;
Saida, H.;
Sakai, S.;
Takahashi, M.;
Takamori, Y.
Submitted: 2020-02-26
Searching for space-time variations of the constants of Nature is a promising
way to search for new physics beyond General Relativity and the standard model
motivated by unification theories and models of dark matter and dark energy. We
propose a new way to search for a variation of the fine-structure constant
using measurements of late-type evolved giant stars from the S-star cluster
orbiting the supermassive black hole in our Galactic Center. A measurement of
the difference between distinct absorption lines (with different sensitivity to
the fine structure constant) from a star leads to a direct estimate of a
variation of the fine structure constant between the star's location and Earth.
Using spectroscopic measurements of 5 stars, we obtain a constraint on the
relative variation of the fine structure constant below $10^{-5}$. This is the
first time a varying constant of Nature is searched for around a black hole and
in a high gravitational potential. This analysis shows new ways the monitoring
of stars in the Galactic Center can be used to probe fundamental physics.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.02632 [pdf] - 1974584
A Significant Feature in the General Relativistic Time Evolution of the
Redshift of Photons Coming from a Star Orbiting Sgr A*
Saida, Hiromi;
Nishiyama, Shogo;
Ohgami, Takayuki;
Takamori, Yohsuke;
Takahashi, Masaaki;
Minowa, Yosuke;
Najarro, Francisco;
Hamano, Satoshi;
Omiya, Masashi;
Iwamatsu, Atsushi;
Takahashi, Mizuki;
Gorin, Haruka;
Kara, Tomohiro;
Koyama, Akinori;
Ohashi, Yosuke;
Tamura, Motohide;
Nagatomo, Schun;
Zenko, Tetsuya;
Nagata, Tetsuya
Submitted: 2019-10-07
The star S0-2, orbiting the Galactic central massive black hole candidate Sgr
A*, passed its pericenter in May 2018. This event is the first chance to detect
the general relativistic (GR) effect of a massive black hole, free from
non-gravitational physics. The observable GR evidence in the event is the
difference between the GR redshift and the Newtonian redshift of photons coming
from S0-2. Within the present observational precision, the 1st post-Newtonian
(1PN) GR evidence is detectable. In this paper, we give a theoretical analysis
of the time evolution of the 1PN GR evidence, under a presupposition that is
different from used in previous papers. Our presupposition is that the
GR/Newtonian redshift is always calculated with the parameter values (the mass
of Sgr A*, the initial conditions of S0-2, and so on) determined by fitting the
GR/Newtonian motion of S0-2 with the observational data. It is then revealed
that the difference of the GR redshift and the Newtonian one shows two peaks
before and after the pericenter passage. This double-peak-appearance is due to
our presupposition, and reduces to a single peak if the same parameter values
are used in both GR and Newtonian redshifts as considered in previous papers.
In addition to this theoretical discussion, we report our observational data
obtained with the Subaru telescope by 2018. The quality and the number of
Subaru data in 2018 are not sufficient to confirm the detection of the
double-peak-appearance.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.10731 [pdf] - 1953676
Relativistic redshift of the star S0-2 orbiting the Galactic center
supermassive black hole
Do, Tuan;
Hees, Aurelien;
Ghez, Andrea;
Martinez, Gregory D.;
Chu, Devin S.;
Jia, Siyao;
Sakai, Shoko;
Lu, Jessica R.;
Gautam, Abhimat K.;
O'Neil, Kelly Kosmo;
Becklin, Eric E.;
Morris, Mark R.;
Matthews, Keith;
Nishiyama, Shogo;
Campbell, Randy;
Chappell, Samantha;
Chen, Zhuo;
Ciurlo, Anna;
Dehghanfar, Arezu;
Gallego-Cano, Eulalia;
Kerzendorf, Wolfgang E.;
Lyke, James E.;
Naoz, Smadar;
Saida, Hiromi;
Schödel, Rainer;
Takahashi, Masaaki;
Takamori, Yohsuke;
Witzel, Gunther;
Wizinowich, Peter
Submitted: 2019-07-24
General Relativity predicts that a star passing close to a supermassive black
hole should exhibit a relativistic redshift. We test this using observations of
the Galactic center star S0-2. We combine existing spectroscopic and
astrometric measurements from 1995-2017, which cover S0-2's 16-year orbit, with
measurements in 2018 March to September which cover three events during its
closest approach to the black hole. We detect the combination of special
relativistic- and gravitational-redshift, quantified using a redshift
parameter, $\Upsilon$. Our result, $\Upsilon=0.88 \pm 0.17$, is consistent with
General Relativity ($\Upsilon=1$) and excludes a Newtonian model ($\Upsilon=0$
) with a statistical significance of 5 $\sigma$.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.01598 [pdf] - 1732533
Radial Velocity Measurements of an Orbiting Star Around Sgr A*
Nishiyama, Shogo;
Saida, Hiromi;
Takamori, Yohsuke;
Takahashi, Masaaki;
Schoedel, Rainer;
Najarro, Francisco;
Hamano, Satoshi;
Omiya, Masashi;
Tamura, Motohide;
Takahashi, Mizuki;
Gorin, Haruka;
Nagatomo, Schun;
Nagata, Tetsuya
Submitted: 2017-09-05, last modified: 2017-09-06
During the next closest approach of the orbiting star S2/S0-2 to the Galactic
supermassive black hole (SMBH), it is estimated that RV uncertainties of ~ 10
km/s allow us to detect post-Newtonian effects throughout 2018. To evaluate an
achievable uncertainty in RV and its stability, we have carried out
near-infrared, high resolution (R ~ 20,000) spectroscopic monitoring
observations of S2 using the Subaru telescope and the near-infrared
spectrograph IRCS from 2014 to 2016. The Br-gamma absorption lines are used to
determine the RVs of S2. The RVs we obtained are 497 km/s, 877 km/s, and 1108
km/s in 2014, 2015, and 2016, respectively. The statistical uncertainties are
derived using the jackknife analysis. The wavelength calibrations in our
three-year monitoring are stable: short-term (hours to days) uncertainties in
RVs are < 0.5 km/s, and a long-term (three years) uncertainty is 1.2 km/s. The
uncertainties from different smoothing parameter, and from the partial
exclusion of the spectra, are found to be a few km/s. The final results using
the Br-gamma line are 497 +- 17 (stat.) +- 3 (sys.) km/s in 2014, 877 +- 15
(stat.) +- 4 (sys.) km/s in 2015, and 1108 +- 12 (stat.) +- 4 (sys.) km/s in
2016. When we use two He I lines at 2.113\mum in addition to Br-gamma, the mean
RVs are 513 km/s and 1114 km/s for 2014 and 2016, respectively. The standard
errors of the mean are 16.2 km/s (2014) and 5.4 km/s (2016), confirming the
reliability of our measurements. The difference between the RVs estimated by
Newtonian mechanics and general relativity will reach about 200 km/s near the
next pericenter passage in 2018. Therefore our RV uncertainties of 13 - 17 km/s
with Subaru enable us to detect the general relativistic effects in the RV
measurements with more than 10 sigma in 2018.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1606.04716 [pdf] - 1577992
How to Measure Black Hole's Mass, Spin and Direction of Spin Axis in
Kerr Lens Effect 1: test case with simple source emission near BH
Submitted: 2016-06-15, last modified: 2017-05-16
We propose a theoretical principle to measure the mass, spin and direction of
spin axis of Kerr black holes (BHs) through observing 2 quantities of the
spinning strong gravitational lens effect of BHs. Those observable quantities
are generated by 2 light rays emitted at the same time by a source near the BH:
the primary and secondary rays that reach a distant observer, respectively, the
earliest and secondary temporally. The time delay between detection times and
the ratio of observed specific fluxes of those rays are the observable
quantities. Rigorously, our proposal is applicable to a single burst-like
(short duration) isotropic emission by the source. An extension of our
principle to cases of complicated emissions may be constructed by summing up
appropriately the result of this paper, which will be treated in future works.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.05521 [pdf] - 1578152
An Axiomatic Review of Israel-Stewart Hydrodynamics and Extended
Irreversible Thermodynamics
Submitted: 2017-05-16
The causality of dissipative phenomena can not be treated in traditional
theories of dissipations, Fourier laws and Navier-Stokes equations. This is the
reason why the dissipative phenomena have not been studies well in relativistic
situations. Furthermore, the interactions among dissipations, e.g. the heating
of fluid due to viscous flow and the occurrence of viscous flow due to heat
flux, are not explicitly described in those traditional laws. One of the
phenomenologies which describe the causality and interaction of dissipations is
the Extended Irreversible Thermodynamics (EIT). (Israel-Stewart theory of
dissipative hydrodynamics is one approximate form of EIT.) This manuscript
reviews an axiomatic construction of EIT and Israel-Stewart hydrodynamic
theory. Also, we point out that the EIT is also applicable to radiative
transfer in optically \emph{thick} matters. However, radiative transfer in
optically \emph{thin} matters can not be described by EIT, because the
non-self-interacting nature of photons is incompatible with a basic requirement
of EIT, "the bilinear form of entropy production rate". The break down of EIT
in optically thin situation is not explicitly recognized in standard references
of EIT and Israel-Stewart theory. Some detail of how EIT fails to describe a
radiative transfer in optically thin situations is also explained. (This
manuscript is a revision of the contribution to a book Ref.[26] published in
2011. So, recent developments made after 2011 may not be cited.)
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.01840 [pdf] - 1423612
Spherical polytropic balls cannot mimic black holes
Submitted: 2015-03-05, last modified: 2016-03-06
The so-called black hole shadow is a dark region which is expected to appear
in a fine image of optical observation of black holes. It is essentially an
absorption cross section of black hole, and the boundary of shadow is
determined by unstable circular orbits of photons (UCOP). If there exists a
compact object possessing UCOP but no black hole horizon, it can provide us
with the same shadow image with black holes, and a detection of shadow image
cannot be a direct evidence of black hole existence. Then, this paper examine
whether or not such compact objects can exist under some suitable conditions.
We investigate thoroughly the static spherical polytropic ball of perfect fluid
with single polytrope index, and then investigate a representative example of
the piecewise polytropic ball. Our result is that the spherical polytropic ball
which we have investigated cannot possess UCOP, if the sound speed at center is
subluminal (slower-than-light). This means that, if the polytrope treated in
this paper is a good model of stellar matter in compact objects, the detection
of shadow image is regarded as a good evidence of black hole existence. As a
by-product, we have found the upper bound of the mass-to-radius radio (M/R) of
polytropic ball with single index, M/R < 0.281, under the
subluminal-sound-speed condition.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.01517 [pdf] - 1423611
Maximum mass of a barotropic spherical star
Submitted: 2015-03-04, last modified: 2015-10-01
The ratio of total mass $M$ to surface radius $R$ of spherical perfect fluid
ball has an upper bound, $M/R < B$. Buchdahl obtained $B = 4/9$ under the
assumptions; non-increasing mass density in outward direction, and barotropic
equation of states. Barraco and Hamity decreased the Buchdahl's bound to a
lower value $B = 3/8$ $(< 4/9)$ by adding the dominant energy condition to
Buchdahl's assumptions. In this paper, we further decrease the Barraco-Hamity's
bound to $B \simeq 0.3636403$ $(< 3/8)$ by adding the subluminal
(slower-than-light) condition of sound speed. In our analysis, we solve
numerically Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff equations, and the mass-to-radius ratio
is maximized by variation of mass, radius and pressure inside the fluid ball as
functions of mass density.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:0908.3041 [pdf] - 741370
de Sitter thermodynamics in the canonical ensemble
Submitted: 2009-08-20, last modified: 2013-11-03
The existing thermodynamics of the cosmological horizon in de-Sitter
spacetime is established in the micro-canonical ensemble, while thermodynamics
of black hole horizons are established in the canonical ensemble. Generally in
the ordinary thermodynamics and statistical mechanics, both of the
micro-canonical and canonical ensembles yield the same equation of state for
any thermodynamic system. This implies the existence of a formulation of
de-Sitter thermodynamics based on the canonical ensemble. This paper reproduces
the de-Sitter thermodynamics in the canonical ensemble. The procedure is as
follows: We put a spherical wall at the center of de-Sitter spacetime, whose
mass is negligible and perfectly reflects the Hawking radiation coming from the
cosmological horizon. Then the region enclosed by the wall and horizon settles
down to a thermal equilibrium state, for which the Euclidean action is
evaluated and the partition function is obtained. The integration constant
(subtraction term) of Euclidean action is determined to reproduce the equation
of state (e.g. entropy-area law) verified already in the micro-canonical
ensemble. Our de-Sitter canonical ensemble is well-defined to preserve the
"thermodynamic consistency", which means that the state variables satisfy not
only the four laws of thermodynamics but also the appropriate differential
relations with thermodynamic functions; e.g. partial derivatives of the free
energy give the entropy, pressure, and so on. The special role of cosmological
constant in de-Sitter thermodynamics is also revealed.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.0187 [pdf] - 33368
Relativistic Dissipative Accretion Flow onto Black Hole
Submitted: 2010-02-01, last modified: 2010-02-08
Dissipations, e.g. heat flow and bulk and shear viscosities, cause the
transport of energy, momentum and angular momentum, which is the essence of
accretion of matters onto celestial objects. Dissipations are usually described
by the Fourier and Navier-Stokes laws ("classic laws" of dissipations). However
the classic laws result in an infinitely fast propagation of dissipations. In
relativistic formulation, the classic laws of dissipations violate the
causality, and hence no relativistic theory of accretion flow onto celestial
object is formulated. In this short report, we summarize the causal dissipative
hydrodynamics, so-called "Extended Irreversible Thermodynamics" (EIT), with a
supplemental comment of which the original works of EIT are not aware, and then
show two theorems about relativistic dissipative flows around a Schwarzschild
black hole. By these theorems, a significant property of EIT in contrast with
classic laws of dissipations is clarified, and a dissipative instability of an
exact solution of relativistic perfect fluid flow is also obtained.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:0705.4012 [pdf] - 1656
Black Hole Evaporation in an Expanding Universe
Submitted: 2007-05-28, last modified: 2007-08-16
We calculate the quantum radiation power of black holes which are asymptotic
to the Einstein-de Sitter universe at spatial and null infinities. We consider
two limiting mass accretion scenarios, no accretion and significant accretion.
We find that the radiation power strongly depends on not only the asymptotic
condition but also the mass accretion scenario. For the no accretion case, we
consider the Einstein-Straus solution, where a black hole of constant mass
resides in the dust Friedmann universe. We find negative cosmological
correction besides the expected redshift factor. This is given in terms of the
cubic root of ratio in size of the black hole to the cosmological horizon, so
that it is currently of order $10^{-5} (M/10^{6}M_{\odot})^{1/3} (t/14
{Gyr})^{-1/3}$ but could have been significant at the formation epoch of
primordial black holes. Due to the cosmological effects, this black hole has
not settled down to an equilibrium state. This cosmological correction may be
interpreted in an analogy with the radiation from a moving mirror in a flat
spacetime. For the significant accretion case, we consider the Sultana-Dyer
solution, where a black hole tends to increase its mass in proportion to the
cosmological scale factor. In this model, we find that the radiation power is
apparently the same as the Hawking radiation from the Schwarzschild black hole
of which mass is that of the growing mass at each moment. Hence, the energy
loss rate decreases and tends to vanish as time proceeds. Consequently, the
energy loss due to evaporation is insignificant compared to huge mass accretion
onto the black hole. Based on this model, we propose a definition of
quasi-equilibrium temperature for general conformal stationary black holes.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:gr-qc/0701030 [pdf] - 112448
Black hole evaporation in a heat bath as a nonequilibrium process and
its final fate
Submitted: 2007-01-03, last modified: 2007-01-10
When a black hole evaporates, there arises a net energy flow from black hole
into its outside environment (heat bath). The existence of energy flow means
that the thermodynamic state of the whole system, which consists of the black
hole and the heat bath, is in a nonequilibrium state. Therefore, in order to
study the detail of evaporation process, the nonequilibrium effects of the
energy flow should be taken into account. Using the nonequilibrium
thermodynamics which has been formulated recently, this paper shows the
following: (1) Time scale of black hole evaporation in a heat bath becomes
shorter than that of the evaporation in an empty space (a situation without
heat bath), because a nonequilibrium effect of temperature difference between
the black hole and heat bath appears as a strong energy extraction from the
black hole by the heat bath. (2) Consequently a huge energy burst (stronger
than that of the evaporation in an empty space) arises at the end of
semi-classical stage of evaporation. (3) It is suggested that a remnant of
Planck size remains after the quantum stage of evaporation in order to
guarantee the increase of total entropy of the whole system.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:gr-qc/0609022 [pdf] - 112306
The generalised second law and the black hole evaporation in an empty
space as a nonequilibrium process
Submitted: 2006-09-06, last modified: 2006-09-12
When a black hole is in an empty space on which there is no matter field
except that of the Hawking radiation (Hawking field), then the black hole
evaporates and the entropy of the black hole decreases. The generalised second
law guarantees the increase of the total entropy of the whole system which
consists of the black hole and the Hawking field. That is, the increase of the
entropy of the Hawking field is faster than the decrease of the black hole
entropy. In naive sense, one may expect that the entropy increase of the
Hawking field is due to the self-interaction among the composite particles of
the Hawking field, and that the "self"-relaxation of the Hawking field results
in the entropy increase. Then, when one consider a non-self-interacting matter
field as the Hawking field, it is obvious that the self-relaxation does not
take place, and one may think that the total entropy does not increase.
However, using nonequilibrium thermodynamics which has been developed recently,
we find for the non-self-interacting Hawking field that the rate of entropy
increase of the Hawking field (the entropy emission rate by the black hole)
grows faster than the rate of entropy decrease of the black hole along the
black hole evaporation in the empty space. The origin of the entropy increase
of the Hawking field is the increase of the black hole temperature. Hence an
understanding of the generalised second law in the context of the
nonequilibrium thermodynamics is suggested; even if the self-relaxation of the
Hawking field does not take place, the temperature increase of the black hole
during the evaporation process causes the entropy increase of the Hawking field
to result in the increase of the total entropy.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:cond-mat/0505223 [pdf] - 1237387
Two-temperature Steady State Thermodynamics for a Radiation Field
Submitted: 2005-05-09, last modified: 2005-09-05
A candidate for a consistent steady state thermodynamics is constructed for a
radiation field in vacuum sandwiched by two black bodies of different
temperatures. Because of the collisionless nature of photons, a steady state of
a radiation field is completely determined by the temperatures of the two black
bodies. Then the zeroth, first, second and third laws can be extended to steady
states, where the idea of local steady states plays an important role for the
system whose geometrical shape is anisotropic and inhomogeneous. The
thermodynamic formalism presented in this paper does not include an energy flux
as a state variable. This is consistent with the notable conclusion by "C.
Essex, Adv. Thermodyn. 3 (1990) 435; Planet. Space. Sci. 32 (1984) 1035" that,
contrary to the success in the irreversible thermodynamics for dissipative
systems, a nonequilibrium radiation field does not obey the bilinear formalism
of the entropy production rate using an energy flux and its conjugate force.
Though the formalism given in this paper may be unique to a radiation field, a
nonequilibrium order parameter of steady states of a radiation field is
explicitly defined. This order parameter denotes that the geometrical shape of
the system determines how a steady state is far from an equilibrium. The higher
the geometrical symmetry is, the more distant the steady state is.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:gr-qc/0006058 [pdf] - 110555
Black holes and a scalar field in an expanding universe
Submitted: 2000-06-16, last modified: 2000-11-14
We consider a model of an inhomogeneous universe including a massless scalar
field, where the inhomogeneity is assumed to consist of many black holes. This
model can be constructed by following Lindquist and Wheeler, which has already
been investigated without including scalar field to show that an averaged scale
factor coincides with that of the Friedmann model. In this work we construct
the inhomogeneous universe with an massless scalar field, where we assume that
the averaged scale factor and scalar field are given by those of the Friedmann
model including a scalar field. All of our calculations are carried out in the
framework of Brans-Dicke gravity. In constructing the model of an inhomogeneous
universe, we define the mass of a black hole in the Brans-Dicke expanding
universe which is equivalent to ADM mass if the mass evolves adiabatically, and
obtain an equation relating our mass to the averaged scalar field and scale
factor. As the results we find that the mass has an adiabatic time dependence
in a sufficiently late stage of the expansion of the universe, and that the
time dependence is qualitatively diffenrent according to the sign of the
curvature of the universe: the mass increases decelerating in the closed
universe case, is constant in the flat case and decreases decelerating in the
open case. It is also noted that the mass in the Einstein frame depends on
time. Our results that the mass has a time dependence should be retained even
in the general scalar-tensor gravitiy with a scalar field potential.
Furthermore, we discuss the relation of our results to the uniqueness theorem
of black hole spacetime and gravitational memory effect.