Normalized to: Nettelmann, N.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.04891 [pdf] - 2076648
Uranus and Neptune: Origin, Evolution and Internal Structure
Submitted: 2019-09-11, last modified: 2020-04-14
There are still many open questions regarding the nature of Uranus and
Neptune, the outermost planets in the Solar System. In this review we summarize
the current-knowledge about Uranus and Neptune with a focus on their
composition and internal structure, formation including potential subsequent
giant impacts, and thermal evolution. We present key open questions and discuss
the uncertainty in the internal structures of the planets due to the
possibility of non-adiabatic and inhomogeneous interiors. We also provide the
reasoning for improved observational constraints on their fundamental physical
parameters such as their gravitational and magnetic fields, rotation rates, and
deep atmospheric composition and temperature. Only this way will we be able to
improve our understating of these planetary objects, and the many similar-sized
objects orbiting other stars.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.12745 [pdf] - 2036845
Machine learning inference of the interior structure of low-mass
exoplanets
Submitted: 2019-11-28
We explore the application of machine learning based on mixture density
neural networks (MDNs) to the interior characterization of low-mass exoplanets
up to 25 Earth masses constrained by mass, radius, and fluid Love number $k_2$.
We create a dataset of 900$\:$000 synthetic planets, consisting of an iron-rich
core, a silicate mantle, a high-pressure ice shell, and a gaseous H/He
envelope, to train a MDN using planetary mass and radius as inputs to the
network. For this layered structure, we show that the MDN is able to infer the
distribution of possible thicknesses of each planetary layer from mass and
radius of the planet. This approach obviates the time-consuming task of
calculating such distributions with a dedicated set of forward models for each
individual planet. While gas-rich planets may be characterized by compositional
gradients rather than distinct layers, the method presented here can be easily
extended to any interior structure model. The fluid Love number $k_2$ bears
constraints on the mass distribution in the planets' interior and will be
measured for an increasing number of exoplanets in the future. Adding $k_2$as
an input to the MDN significantly decreases the degeneracy of the possible
interior structures.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.01191 [pdf] - 1990464
The Effect of Clouds as an Additional Opacity Source on the Inferred
Metallicity of Giant Exoplanets
Submitted: 2019-11-04
Atmospheres regulate the planetary heat loss and therefore influence
planetary thermal evolution. Uncertainty in a giant planet's thermal state
contributes to the uncertainty in the inferred abundance of heavy elements it
contains. Within an analytic atmosphere model, we here investigate the
influence that different cloud opacities and cloud depths can have on the
metallicity of irradiated extrasolar gas giants, which is inferred from
interior models. In this work, the link between inferred metallicity and
assumed cloud properties is the thermal profile of atmosphere and interior.
Therefore, we perform coupled atmosphere, interior, and evolution calculations.
The atmosphere model includes clouds in a much simplified manner; it includes
long-wave absorption but neglects shortwave scattering. Within that model, we
show that optically thick, high clouds have negligible influence, whereas
deep-seated, optically very thick clouds can lead to warmer deep tropospheres
and therefore higher bulk heavy element mass estimates. For the young hot
Jupiter WASP-10b, we find a possible enhancement in inferred metallicity of up
to 10% due to possible silicate clouds at $\sim$0.3 bar. For WASP-39b, whose
observationally derived metallicity is higher than predicted by cloudless
models, we find an enhancement by at most 50%. However, further work on cloud
properties and their self-consistent coupling to the atmospheric structure is
needed in order to reduce uncertainties in the choice of model parameter
values, in particular of cloud opacities.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.00447 [pdf] - 2008028
Thermal evolution of Uranus and Neptune I: adiabatic models
Submitted: 2019-11-01
The brightness of Neptune is often found to be in accordance with an
adiabatic interior, while the low luminosity of Uranus challenges this
assumption. Here we apply revised equation of state data of hydrogen, helium,
and water and compute the thermal evolution of Uranus and Neptune assuming an
adiabatic interior. For this purpose, we have developed a new planetary model
and evolution code. We investigate the influence of albedo, solar energy
influx, and equations of state of H and He, and water on the cooling time. Our
cooling times of about $\tau_\text{U}=5.1\times 10^9\text{ years}$ for Uranus
and $\tau_\text{N}=3.7\times 10^9\text{ years}$ for Neptune bracket the known
age of the planets of $4.56\times 10^9\text{ years}$ implying that neither
planet's present-day luminosity can be explained by adiabatic cooling. We also
find that uncertainties on input parameters such as the level of irradiation
matter generally more for Uranus than for Neptune. Our results suggest that in
contrast to common assumptions, neither planet is fully adiabatic in the deeper
interior.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.00749 [pdf] - 1864016
Tesseral harmonics of Jupiter from static tidal response
Submitted: 2019-03-02
The Juno Orbiter is measuring the three-dimensional gravity field
perturbation of Jupiter induced by its rapid rotation, zonal flows, and tidal
response to its major natural satellites. This paper aims to provide the
contributions to the tesseral harmonics coefficients Cnm, Snm, and the Love
numbers knm to be expected from static tidal response in the gravity field of
rotating Jupiter. For that purpose, we apply the method of Concentric Maclaurin
Ellipsoids (CMS). As we are interested in the variation of the tidal potential
with the longitudes of the moons, we take into account the simultaneous
presence of the satellites Io, Europa, and Ganymede. We assume co-planar,
circular orbits with normals parallel to Jupiter's spin axis. The
planet-centered longitude of Io in the three-moon case is arbitrarily assumed
varphi = 0. Under these assumptions we find maximum amplitudes and fluctuations
of 3.5 times 10^-8 +- 15% for C22. For the Love numbers, largest variation of
10% to 20% is seen in k42 and k62, whereas the values k2, k33, and k44 fall
into narrow ranges of 0.1% uncertainty or less. In particular, we find
k2=k2,Io(1 +- 0.02%) where k2,Io=0.5897 is the static tidal response to lone
Io. Our obtained gravity field perturbation leads to a maximum equatorial shape
deformation of up to 28m. We suggest that should Juno measurements of the knm
deviate from those values, it may be due to dynamic or dissipative effects on
Jupiter's tidal response. Finally, an analytic expression is provided to
calculate the tesseral harmonics contribution from static tidal response for
any configuration of the satellites.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.04133 [pdf] - 1727642
Planetary Ices and the Linear Mixing Approximation
Bethkenhagen, Mandy;
Meyer, Edmund R.;
Hamel, Sebastien;
Nettelmann, Nadine;
French, Martin;
Scheibe, Ludwig;
Ticknor, Christopher;
Collins, Lee A.;
Kress, Joel D.;
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Redmer, Ronald
Submitted: 2017-09-13
The validity of the widely used linear mixing approximation for the equations
of state (EOS) of planetary ices is investigated at pressure-temperature
conditions typical for the interior of Uranus and Neptune. The basis of this
study are ab initio data ranging up to 1000 GPa and 20 000 K calculated via
density functional theory molecular dynamics simulations. In particular, we
calculate a new EOS for methane and EOS data for the 1:1 binary mixtures of
methane, ammonia, and water, as well as their 2:1:4 ternary mixture.
Additionally, the self-diffusion coefficients in the ternary mixture are
calculated along three different Uranus interior profiles and compared to the
values of the pure compounds. We find that deviations of the linear mixing
approximation from the results of the real mixture are generally small; for the
thermal EOS they amount to 4% or less. The diffusion coefficients in the
mixture agree with those of the pure compounds within 20% or better. Finally, a
new adiabatic model of Uranus with an inner layer of almost pure ices is
developed. The model is consistent with the gravity field data and results in a
rather cold interior ($\mathrm{T_{core}} \mathtt{\sim}$ 4000 K).
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1708.06177 [pdf] - 1587305
Low- and high-order gravitational harmonics of rigidly rotating Jupiter
Submitted: 2017-08-21
The Juno Orbiter has provided improved estimates of the even gravitational
harmonics J2 to J8 of Jupiter. To compute higher-order moments, new methods
such as the Concentric Maclaurin Spheroids (CMS) method have been developed
which surpass the so far commonly used Theory of Figures (ToF) method in
accuracy. This progress rises the question whether ToF can still provide a
useful service for deriving the internal structure of giant planets in the
Solar system. In this paper, I apply both the ToF and the CMS method to compare
results for polytropic Jupiter and for the physical equation of state
H/He-REOS.3 based models. An accuracy in the computed values of J2 and J4 of
0.1% is found to be sufficient in order to obtain the core mass safely within
0.5 Mearth numerical accuracy and the atmospheric metallicity within about
0.0004. ToF to 4th order provides that accuracy, while ToF to 3rd order does
not for J4. Furthermore, I find that the assumption of rigid rotation yields J6
and J8 values in agreement with the current Juno estimates, and that higher
order terms (J10 to J18) deviate by about 10% from predictions by polytropic
models. This work suggests that ToF4 can still be applied to infer the deep
internal structure, and that the zonal winds on Jupiter reach less deep than
0.9 RJup.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.06324 [pdf] - 1484756
The Interior of Saturn
Submitted: 2016-09-20
We review our current understanding of the interior structure and thermal
evolution of Saturn, with a focus on recent results in the Cassini era. There
has been important progress in understanding physical inputs, including
equations of state of planetary materials and their mixtures, physical
parameters like the gravity field and rotation rate, and constraints on
Saturnian free oscillations. At the same time, new methods of calculation,
including work on the gravity field of rotating fluid bodies, and the role of
interior composition gradients, should help to better constrain the state of
Saturn's interior, now and earlier in its history. However, a better
appreciation of modeling uncertainties and degeneracies, along with a greater
exploration of modeling phase space, still leave great uncertainties in our
understanding of Saturn's interior. Further analysis of Cassini data sets, as
well as precise gravity field measurements from the Cassini Grand Finale
orbits, will further revolutionize our understanding of Saturn's interior over
the next few years.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.07424 [pdf] - 1426369
The Hunt for Planet Nine: Atmosphere, Spectra, Evolution, and
Detectability
Fortney, Jonathan J.;
Marley, Mark S.;
Laughlin, Gregory;
Nettelmann, Nadine;
Morley, Caroline V.;
Lupu, Roxana E.;
Visscher, Channon;
Jeremic, Pavle;
Khadder, Wade G.;
Hargrave, Mason
Submitted: 2016-04-25, last modified: 2016-06-06
We investigate the physical characteristics of the Solar System's proposed
Planet Nine using modeling tools with a heritage in studying Uranus and
Neptune. For a range of plausible masses and interior structures, we find upper
limits on the intrinsic Teff, from ~35-50 K for masses of 5-20 M_Earth, and we
also explore lower Teff values. Possible planetary radii could readily span
from 3 to 6 R_Earth depending on the mass fraction of any H/He envelope. Given
its cold temperature, the planet encounters significant methane condensation,
which dramatically alters the atmosphere away from simple Neptune-like
expectations. We find the atmosphere is strongly depleted in molecular
absorption at visible wavelengths, suggesting a Rayleigh scattering atmosphere
with a high geometric albedo approaching 0.75. We highlight two diagnostics for
the atmosphere's temperature structure, the first being the value of the
methane mixing ratio above the methane cloud. The second is the wavelength at
which cloud scattering can be seen, which yields the cloud-top pressure.
Surface reflection may be seen if the atmosphere is thin. Due to
collision-induced opacity of H2 in the infrared, the planet would be extremely
blue (instead of red) in the shortest wavelength WISE colors if methane is
depleted, and would, in some cases, exist on the verge of detectability by
WISE. For a range of models, thermal fluxes from ~3-5 microns are ~20 orders of
magnitude larger than blackbody expectations. We report a search of the AllWISE
Source Catalog for Planet Nine, but find no detection.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.00171 [pdf] - 1399848
Uranus evolution models with simple thermal boundary layers
Submitted: 2016-04-30
The strikingly low luminosity of Uranus (Teff ~ Teq) constitutes a
long-standing challenge to our understanding of Ice Giant planets. Here we
present the first Uranus structure and evolution models that are constructed to
agree with both the observed low luminosity and the gravity field data. Our
models make use of modern ab initio equations of state at high pressures for
the icy components water, methane, and ammonia. Proceeding step by step, we
confirm that adiabatic models yield cooling times that are too long, even when
uncertainties in the ice:rock ratio (I:R) are taken into account. We then argue
that the transition between the ice/rock-rich interior and the H/He-rich outer
envelope should be stably stratified. Therefore, we introduce a simple thermal
boundary and adjust it to reproduce the low luminosity. Due to this thermal
boundary, the deep interior of the Uranus models are up to 2--3 warmer than
adiabatic models, necessitating the presence of rocks in the deep interior with
a possible I:R of $1\times$ solar. Finally, we allow for an equilibrium
evolution (Teff ~ Teq) that begun prior to the present day, which would
therefore no longer require the current era to be a "special time" in Uranus'
evolution. In this scenario, the thermal boundary leads to more rapid cooling
of the outer envelope. When Teff ~ Teq is reached, a shallow, subadiabatic zone
in the atmosphere begins to develop. Its depth is adjusted to meet the
luminosity constraint. This work provides a simple foundation for future Ice
Giant structure and evolution models, that can be improved by properly treating
the heat and particle fluxes in the diffusive zones.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1412.4202 [pdf] - 1223634
An Exploration of Double Diffusive Convection in Jupiter as a Result of
Hydrogen-Helium Phase Separation
Submitted: 2014-12-13
Jupiter's atmosphere has been observed to be depleted in helium (Yatm~0.24),
suggesting active helium sedimentation in the interior. This is accounted for
in standard Jupiter structure and evolution models through the assumption of an
outer, He-depleted envelope that is separated from the He-enriched deep
interior by a sharp boundary. Here we aim to develop a model for Jupiter's
inhomogeneous thermal evolution that relies on a more self-consistent
description of the internal profiles of He abundance, temperature, and heat
flux. We make use of recent numerical simulations on H/He demixing, and on
layered (LDD) and oscillatory (ODD) double diffusive convection, and assume an
idealized planet model composed of a H/He envelope and a massive core. A
general framework for the construction of interior models with He rain is
described. Despite, or perhaps because of, our simplifications made we find
that self-consistent models are rare. For instance, no model for ODD convection
is found. We modify the H/He phase diagram of Lorenzen et al. to reproduce
Jupiter's atmospheric helium abundance and examine evolution models as a
function of the LDD layer height, from those that prolong Jupiter's cooling
time to those that actually shorten it. Resulting models that meet the
luminosity constraint have layer heights of about 0.1-1 km, corresponding to
~10,-20,000 layers in the rain zone between ~1 and 3-4.5 Mbars. Present
limitations and directions for future work are discussed, such as the formation
and sinking of He droplets.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1411.4010 [pdf] - 903985
Ab initio equations of state for hydrogen (H-REOS.3) and helium
(He-REOS.3) and their implications for the interior of Brown Dwarfs
Submitted: 2014-11-14
We present new equations of state (EOS) for hydrogen and helium covering a
wide range of temperatures from 60 K to 10$^7$ K and densities from $10^{-10}$
g/cm$^3$ to $10^3$ g/cm$^3$. They include an extended set of ab initio EOS data
for the strongly correlated quantum regime with an accurate connection to data
derived from other approaches for the neighboring regions. We compare
linear-mixing isotherms based on our EOS tables with available real-mixture
data. A first important astrophysical application of this new EOS data is the
calculation of interior models for Jupiter and the comparison with recent
results. Secondly, mass-radius relations are calculated for Brown Dwarfs which
we compare with predictions derived from the widely used EOS of Saumon,
Chabrier and van Horn. Furthermore, we calculate interior models for typical
Brown Dwarfs with different masses, namely Corot-3b, Gliese-229b and Corot-15b,
and the Giant Planet KOI-889b. The predictions for the central pressures and
densities differ by up to 10$\%$ dependent on the EOS used. Our EOS tables are
made available in the supplemental material of this paper.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1404.4811 [pdf] - 1209042
Scientific rationale of Saturn's in situ exploration
Mousis, O.;
Fletcher, L. N.;
Lebreton, J. -P.;
Wurz, P.;
Cavalié, T.;
Coustenis, A.;
Courtin, R.;
Gautier, D.;
Helled, R.;
Irwin, P. G. J.;
Morse, A. D.;
Nettelmann, N.;
Marty, B.;
Rousselot, P.;
Venot, O.;
Atkinson, D. H.;
Waite, J. H.;
Reh, K. R.;
Simon-Miller, A.;
Atreya, S.;
André, N.;
Blanc, M.;
Daglis, I. A.;
Fischer, G.;
Geppert, W. D.;
Guillot, T.;
Hedman, M. M.;
Hueso, R.;
Lellouch, E.;
Lunine, J. I.;
Murray, C. D.;
O'Donoghue, J.;
Rengel, M.;
Sanchez-Lavega, A.;
Schmider, F. -X.;
Spiga, A.;
Spilker, T.;
Petit, J. -M.;
Tiscareno, M. S.;
Ali-Dib, M.;
Altwegg, K.;
Bouquet, A.;
Briois, C.;
Fouchet, T.;
Guerlet, S.;
Kostiuk, T.;
Lebleu, D.;
Moreno, R.;
Orton, G. S.;
Poncy, J.
Submitted: 2014-04-18
Remote sensing observations meet some limitations when used to study the bulk
atmospheric composition of the giant planets of our solar system. A remarkable
example of the superiority of in situ probe measurements is illustrated by the
exploration of Jupiter, where key measurements such as the determination of the
noble gases abundances and the precise measurement of the helium mixing ratio
have only been made available through in situ measurements by the Galileo
probe. This paper describes the main scientific goals to be addressed by the
future in situ exploration of Saturn placing the Galileo probe exploration of
Jupiter in a broader context and before the future probe exploration of the
more remote ice giants. In situ exploration of Saturn's atmosphere addresses
two broad themes that are discussed throughout this paper: first, the formation
history of our solar system and second, the processes at play in planetary
atmospheres. In this context, we detail the reasons why measurements of
Saturn's bulk elemental and isotopic composition would place important
constraints on the volatile reservoirs in the protosolar nebula. We also show
that the in situ measurement of CO (or any other disequilibrium species that is
depleted by reaction with water) in Saturn's upper troposphere would constrain
its bulk O/H ratio. We highlight the key measurements required to distinguish
competing theories to shed light on giant planet formation as a common process
in planetary systems with potential applications to most extrasolar systems. In
situ measurements of Saturn's stratospheric and tropospheric dynamics,
chemistry and cloud-forming processes will provide access to phenomena
unreachable to remote sensing studies. Different mission architectures are
envisaged, which would benefit from strong international collaborations.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.4329 [pdf] - 1172133
A Framework for Characterizing the Atmospheres of Low-Mass Low-Density
Transiting Planets
Submitted: 2013-06-18, last modified: 2013-09-03
We perform modeling investigations to aid in understanding the atmospheres
and composition of small planets of ~2-4 Earth radii, which are now known to be
common in our galaxy. GJ 1214b is a well studied example whose atmospheric
transmission spectrum has been observed by many investigators. Here we take a
step back from GJ 1214b to investigate the role that planetary mass,
composition, and temperature play in impacting the transmission spectra of
these low-mass low-density (LMLD) planets. Under the assumption that these
planets accrete modest hydrogen-dominated atmospheres and planetesimals, we use
population synthesis models to show that predicted metal enrichments of the
H/He envelope are high, with metal mass fraction Z_env values commonly 0.6 to
0.9, or ~100 to 400+ times solar. The high mean molecular weight of such
atmospheres (\mu ~ 5-12) would naturally help to flatten the transmission
spectrum of most LMLD planets. The high metal abundance would also provide
significant condensible material for cloud formation. It is known that the H/He
abundance in Uranus and Neptune decreases with depth, and we show that
atmospheric evaporation of LMLD planets could expose atmospheric layers with
gradually higher Z_env. However, values of Z_env close to solar composition can
also arise, so diversity should be expected. Photochemically produced hazes,
potentially due to methane photolysis, are another possibility for obscuring
transmission spectra. Such hazes may not form above T_eq of ~800-1100 K, which
is testable if such warm, otherwise low mean molecular weight atmospheres are
stable against atmospheric evaporation. We find that available transmission
data are consistent with relatively high mean molecular weight atmospheres for
GJ 1214b and "warm Neptune" GJ 436b. We examine future prospects for
characterizing GJ 1214b with Hubble and the James Webb Space Telescope.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.5178 [pdf] - 1172201
Compositional diversity in the atmospheres of hot Neptunes, with
application to GJ 436b
Submitted: 2013-06-21
Neptune-sized extrasolar planets that orbit relatively close to their host
stars -- often called "hot Neptunes" -- are common within the known population
of exoplanets and planetary candidates. Similar to our own Uranus and Neptune,
inefficient accretion of nebular gas is expected produce hot Neptunes whose
masses are dominated by elements heavier than hydrogen and helium. At high
atmospheric metallicities of 10-10,000x solar, hot Neptunes will exhibit an
interesting continuum of atmospheric compositions, ranging from more
Neptune-like, H2-dominated atmospheres to more Venus-like, CO2-dominated
atmospheres. We explore the predicted equilibrium and disequilibrium chemistry
of generic hot Neptunes and find that the atmospheric composition varies
strongly as a function of temperature and bulk atmospheric properties such as
metallicity and the C/O ratio. Relatively exotic H2O, CO, CO2, and even
O2-dominated atmospheres are possible for hot Neptunes. We apply our models to
the case of GJ 436b, where we find that a CO-rich, CH4-poor atmosphere can be a
natural consequence of a very high atmospheric metallicity. From comparisons of
our results with Spitzer eclipse data for GJ 436b, we conclude that although
the spectral fit from the high-metallicity forward models is not quite as good
as the fit obtained from pure retrieval methods, the atmospheric composition
predicted by these forward models is more physically and chemically plausible.
High-metallicity atmospheres (orders of magnitude in excess of solar) should
therefore be considered as a possibility for GJ 436b and other hot Neptunes.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.4707 [pdf] - 1166028
Saturn layered structure and homogeneous evolution models with different
EOSs
Submitted: 2013-04-17
The core mass of Saturn is commonly assumed to be 10-25 ME as predicted by
interior models with various equations of state (EOSs) and the Voyager gravity
data, and hence larger than that of Jupiter (0-10 ME). We here re-analyze
Saturn's internal structure and evolution by using more recent gravity data
from the Cassini mission and different physical equations of state: the ab
initio LM-REOS which is rather soft in Saturn's outer regions but stiff at high
pressures, the standard Sesame-EOS which shows the opposite behavior, and the
commonly used SCvH-i EOS. For all three EOS we find similar core mass ranges,
i.e. of 0-20 ME for SCvH-i and Sesame EOS and of 0-17 ME for LM-REOS. Assuming
an atmospheric helium mass abundance of 18%, we find maximum atmospheric
metallicities, Zatm of 7x solar for SCvH-i and Sesame-based models and a total
mass of heavy elements, MZ of 25-30 ME. Some models are Jupiter-like. With
LM-REOS, we find MZ=16-20 ME, less than for Jupiter, and Zatm less than 3x
solar. For Saturn, we compute moment of inertia values lambda=0.2355(5).
Furthermore, we confirm that homogeneous evolution leads to cooling times of
only about 2.5 Gyr, independent on the applied EOS. Our results demonstrate the
need for accurately measured atmospheric helium and oxygen abundances, and of
the moment of inertia for a better understanding of Saturn's structure and
evolution.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.2309 [pdf] - 1124713
New indication for a dichotomy in the interior structure of Uranus and
Neptune from the application of modified shape and rotation data
Submitted: 2012-07-10
Since the Voyager fly-bys of Uranus and Neptune, improved gravity field data
have been derived from long-term observations of the planets' satellite
motions, and modified shape and solid-body rotation periods were suggested. A
faster rotation period (-40 min) for Uranus and a slower rotation period
(+1h20) of Neptune compared to the Voyager data were found to minimize the
dynamical heights and wind speeds. We apply the improved gravity data, the
modified shape and rotation data, and the physical LM-R equation of state to
compute adiabatic three-layer structure models, where rocks are confined to the
core, and homogeneous thermal evolution models of Uranus and Neptune. We
present the full range of structure models for both the Voyager and the
modified shape and rotation data. In contrast to previous studies based solely
on the Voyager data or on empirical EOS, we find that Uranus and Neptune may
differ to an observationally significant level in their atmospheric heavy
element mass fraction Z1 and nondimensional moment of inertia, nI. For Uranus,
we find Z1 < 8% and nI=0.2224(1), while for Neptune Z1 < 65% and nI=0.2555(2)
when applying the modified shape and rotation data, while for the unmodified
data we compute Z1 < 17% and nI=0.230(1) for Uranus and Z1 < 54% and
nI=0.2410(8) for Neptune. In each of these cases, solar metallicity models
(Z1=0.015) are still possible. The cooling times obtained for each planet are
similar to recent calculations with the Voyager rotation periods: Neptune's
luminosity can be explained by assuming an adiabatic interior while Uranus
cools far too slowly. More accurate determinations of these planets' gravity
fields, shapes, rotation periods, atmospheric heavy element abundances, and
intrinsic luminosities are essential for improving our understanding of the
internal structure and evolution of icy planets.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.4380 [pdf] - 537469
Forward and Inverse Modeling for Jovian Seismology
Submitted: 2012-06-20
Jupiter is expected to pulsate in a spectrum of acoustic modes and recent
re-analysis of a spectroscopic time series has identified a regular pattern in
the spacing of the frequencies \citep{gaulme2011}. This exciting result can
provide constraints on gross Jovian properties and warrants a more in-depth
theoretical study of the seismic structure of Jupiter. With current
instrumentation, such as the SYMPA instrument \citep{schmider2007} used for the
\citet{gaulme2011} analysis, we assume that, at minimum, a set of global
frequencies extending up to angular degree $\ell=25$ could be observed. In
order to identify which modes would best constrain models of Jupiter's interior
and thus help motivate the next generation of observations, we explore the
sensitivity of derived parameters to this mode set. Three different models of
the Jovian interior are computed and the theoretical pulsation spectrum from
these models for $\ell\leq 25$ is obtained. We compute sensitivity kernels and
perform linear inversions to infer details of the expected discontinuities in
the profiles in the Jovian interior. We find that the amplitude of the
sound-speed jump of a few percent in the inner/outer envelope boundary seen in
two of the applied models should be reasonably inferred with these particular
modes. Near the core boundary where models predict large density
discontinuities, the location of such features can be accurately measured,
while their amplitudes have more uncertainty. These results suggest that this
mode set would be sufficient to infer the radial location and strength of
expected discontinuities in Jupiter's interior, and place strong constraints on
the core size and mass. We encourage new observations to detect these Jovian
oscillations.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1109.5644 [pdf] - 507865
Jupiter models with improved ab initio hydrogen EOS (H-REOS.2)
Submitted: 2011-09-26, last modified: 2012-02-27
The amount and distribution of heavy elements in Jupiter gives indications on
the process of its formation and evolution. Core mass and metallicity
predictions however depend on the equations of state used, and on model
assumptions. We present an improved ab initio hydrogen equation of state,
H-REOS.2 and compute the internal structure and thermal evolution of Jupiter
within the standard three-layer approach. The advance over our previous Jupiter
models with H-REOS.1 by Nettelmann et al.(2008) is that the new models are also
consistent with the observed 2 or more times solar heavy element abundances in
Jupiter's atmosphere. Such models have a rock core mass Mcore=0-8 ME, total
mass of heavy elements MZ=28-32 ME, a deep internal layer boundary at 4 or more
Mbar, and a cooling time of 4.4-5.0 Gyrs when assuming homogeneous evolution.
We also calculate two-layer models in the manner of Militzer et al.(2008) and
find a comparable large core of 16-21 ME, out of which ~11 ME is helium, but a
significantly higher envelope metallicity of 4.5 times solar. According to our
preferred three-layer models, neither the characteristic frequency (nu0 ~156
microHz) nor the normalized moment of inertia (~0.276) are sensitive to the
core mass but accurate measurements could well help to rule out some classes of
models.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1201.2622 [pdf] - 1092918
Probing the interiors of the ice giants: Shock compression of water to
700 GPa and 3.8 g/ccm
Submitted: 2012-01-12
Recently there has been tremendous increase in the number of identified
extra-solar planetary systems. Our understanding of their formation is tied to
exoplanet internal structure models, which rely upon equations of state of
light elements and compounds like water. Here we present shock compression data
for water with unprecedented accuracy that shows water equations of state
commonly used in planetary modeling significantly overestimate the
compressibility at conditions relevant to planetary interiors. Furthermore, we
show its behavior at these conditions, including reflectivity and isentropic
response, is well described by a recent first-principles based equation of
state. These findings advocate this water model be used as the standard for
modeling Neptune, Uranus, and "hot Neptune" exoplanets, and should improve our
understanding of these types of planets.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1112.2087 [pdf] - 449702
Constraining the interior of extrasolar giant planets with the tidal
Love number k_2 using the example of HAT-P-13b
Submitted: 2011-12-09
Transit and radial velocity observations continuously discover an increasing
number of exoplanets. However, when it comes to the composition of the observed
planets the data are compatible with several interior structure models. Thus, a
planetary parameter sensitive to the planet's density distribution could help
constrain this large number of possible models even further. We aim to
investigate to what extent an exoplanet's interior can be constrained in terms
of core mass and envelope metallicity by taking the tidal Love number k_2 into
account as an additional possibly observable parameter. Because it is the only
planet with an observationally determined k_2, we constructed interior models
for the Hot Jupiter exoplanet HAT-P-13b by solving the equations of hydrostatic
equilibrium and mass conservation for different boundary conditions. In
particular, we varied the surface temperature and the outer temperature
profile, as well as the envelope metallicity within the widest possible
parameter range. We also considered atmospheric conditions that are consistent
with nongray atmosphere models. For all these models we calculated the Love
number k_2 and compared it to the allowed range of k_2 values that could be
obtained from eccentricity measurements of HAT-P-13b. We use the example of
HAT-P-13b to show the general relationships between the quantities temperature,
envelope metallicity, core mass, and Love number of a planet. For any given k_2
value a maximum possible core mass can be determined. For HAT-P-13b we find
Mcore < 27 ME, based on the latest eccentricity measurement. We are able to
constrain both the envelope and bulk metallicity of HAT-P-13b to 1 -- 11 times
stellar metallicity and the extension of the isothermal layer in the planet's
atmosphere to 3 -- 44 bar. Assuming equilibrium tidal theory, we find lower
limits on the tidal Q consistent with 10^3 - 10^5.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1109.4749 [pdf] - 1084307
Analysis of new high-precision transit light curves of WASP-10 b:
starspot occultations, small planetary radius, and high metallicity
Submitted: 2011-09-22
The WASP-10 planetary system is intriguing because different values of radius
have been reported for its transiting exoplanet. The host star exhibits
activity in terms of photometric variability, which is caused by the rotational
modulation of the spots. Moreover, a periodic modulation has been discovered in
transit timing of WASP-10 b, which could be a sign of an additional body
perturbing the orbital motion of the transiting planet. We attempt to refine
the physical parameters of the system, in particular the planetary radius,
which is crucial for studying the internal structure of the transiting planet.
We also determine new mid-transit times to confirm or refute observed anomalies
in transit timing. We acquired high-precision light curves for four transits of
WASP-10 b in 2010. Assuming various limb-darkening laws, we generated best-fit
models and redetermined parameters of the system. The prayer-bead method and
Monte Carlo simulations were used to derive error estimates. Three transit
light curves exhibit signatures of the occultations of dark spots by the planet
during its passage across the stellar disk. The influence of stellar activity
on transit depth is taken into account while determining system parameters. The
radius of WASP-10 b is found to be no greater than 1.03 Jupiter radii, a value
significantly smaller than most previous studies indicate. We calculate
interior structure models of the planet, assuming a two-layer structure with
one homogeneous envelope atop a rock core. The high value of the WASP-10 b's
mean density allows one to consider the planet's internal structure including
270 to 450 Earth masses of heavy elements. Our new mid-transit times confirm
that transit timing cannot be explained by a constant period if all literature
data points are considered. They are consistent with the ephemeris assuming a
periodic variation of transit timing...
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1001.4851 [pdf] - 451639
Mass-radius relationships for exoplanets
Submitted: 2010-01-26, last modified: 2011-09-15
For planets other than Earth, interpretation of the composition and structure
depends largely on comparing the mass and radius with the composition expected
given their distance from the parent star. The composition implies a
mass-radius relation which relies heavily on equations of state calculated from
electronic structure theory and measured experimentally on Earth. We lay out a
method for deriving and testing equations of state, and deduce mass-radius and
mass-pressure relations for key materials whose equation of state is reasonably
well established, and for differentiated Fe/rock. We find that variations in
the equation of state, such as may arise when extrapolating from low pressure
data, can have significant effects on predicted mass- radius relations, and on
planetary pressure profiles. The relations are compared with the observed
masses and radii of planets and exoplanets. Kepler-10b is apparently 'Earth-
like,' likely with a proportionately larger core than Earth's, nominally 2/3 of
the mass of the planet. CoRoT-7b is consistent with a rocky mantle over an
Fe-based core which is likely to be proportionately smaller than Earth's. GJ
1214b lies between the mass-radius curves for H2O and CH4, suggesting an 'icy'
composition with a relatively large core or a relatively large proportion of
H2O. CoRoT-2b is less dense than the hydrogen relation, which could be
explained by an anomalously high degree of heating or by higher than assumed
atmospheric opacity. HAT-P-2b is slightly denser than the mass-radius relation
for hydrogen, suggesting the presence of a significant amount of matter of
higher atomic number. CoRoT-3b lies close to the hydrogen relation. The
pressure at the center of Kepler-10b is 1.5+1.2-1.0 TPa. The central pressure
in CoRoT-7b is probably close to 0.8TPa, though may be up to 2TPa.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.4244 [pdf] - 1077445
Young Exoplanet Transit Initiative (YETI)
Neuhäuser, R.;
Errmann, R.;
Berndt, A.;
Maciejewski, G.;
Takahashi, H.;
Chen, W. P.;
Dimitrov, D. P.;
Pribulla, T.;
Nikogossian, E. H.;
Jensen, E. L. N.;
Marschall, L.;
Wu, Z. -Y.;
Kellerer, A.;
Walter, F. M.;
Briceño, C.;
Chini, R.;
Fernandez, M.;
Raetz, St.;
Torres, G.;
Latham, D. W.;
Quinn, S. N.;
Niedzielski, A.;
Bukowiecki, Ł.;
Nowak, G.;
Tomov, T.;
Tachihara, K.;
Hu, S. C. -L.;
Hung, L. W.;
Kjurkchieva, D. P.;
Radeva, V. S.;
Mihov, B. M.;
Slavcheva-Mihova, L.;
Bozhinova, I. N.;
Budaj, J.;
Vaňko, M.;
Kundra, E.;
Hambálek, Ľ.;
Krushevska, V.;
Movsessian, T.;
Harutyunyan, H.;
Downes, J. J.;
Hernandez, J.;
Hoffmeister, V. H.;
Cohen, D. H.;
Abel, I.;
Ahmad, R.;
Chapman, S.;
Eckert, S.;
Goodman, J.;
Guerard, A.;
Kim, H. M.;
Koontharana, A.;
Sokol, J.;
Trinh, J.;
Wang, Y.;
Zhou, X.;
Redmer, R.;
Kramm, U.;
Nettelmann, N.;
Mugrauer, M.;
Schmidt, J.;
Moualla, M.;
Ginski, C.;
Marka, C.;
Adam, C.;
Seeliger, M.;
Baar, S.;
Roell, T.;
Schmidt, T. O. B.;
Trepl, L.;
Eisenbeiß, T.;
Fiedler, S.;
Tetzlaff, N.;
Schmidt, E.;
Hohle, M. M.;
Kitze, M.;
Chakrova, N.;
Gräfe, C.;
Schreyer, K.;
Hambaryan, V. V.;
Broeg, C. H.;
Koppenhoefer, J.;
Pandey, A. K.
Submitted: 2011-06-21
We present the Young Exoplanet Transit Initiative (YETI), in which we use
several 0.2 to 2.6m telescopes around the world to monitor continuously young
(< 100 Myr), nearby (< 1 kpc) stellar clusters mainly to detect young
transiting planets (and to study other variability phenomena on time-scales
from minutes to years). The telescope network enables us to observe the targets
continuously for several days in order not to miss any transit. The runs are
typically one to two weeks long, about three runs per year per cluster in two
or three subsequent years for about ten clusters. There are thousands of stars
detectable in each field with several hundred known cluster members, e.g. in
the first cluster observed, Tr-37, a typical cluster for the YETI survey, there
are at least 469 known young stars detected in YETI data down to R=16.5 mag
with sufficient precision of 50 milli-mag rms (5 mmag rms down to R=14.5 mag)
to detect transits, so that we can expect at least about one young transiting
object in this cluster. If we observe 10 similar clusters, we can expect to
detect approximately 10 young transiting planets with radius determinations.
The precision given above is for a typical telescope of the YETI network,
namely the 60/90-cm Jena telescope (similar brightness limit, namely within
+/-1 mag, for the others) so that planetary transits can be detected. For
planets with mass and radius determinations, we can calculate the mean density
and probe the internal structure. We aim to constrain planet formation models
and their time-scales by discovering planets younger than 100 Myr and
determining not only their orbital parameters, but also measuring their true
masses and radii, which is possible so far only by the transit method. Here, we
present an overview and first results. (Abstract shortened)
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1010.0277 [pdf] - 1041013
Thermal evolution and structure models of the transiting super-Earth GJ
1214b
Submitted: 2010-10-01, last modified: 2011-03-08
The planet GJ 1214b is the second known super-Earth with a measured mass and
radius. Orbiting a quiet M-star, it receives considerably less mass-loss
driving X-ray and UV radiation than CoRoT-7b, so that the interior may be quite
dissimilar in composition, including the possibility of a large fraction of
water. We model the interior of GJ 1214b assuming a two-layer (envelope+rock
core) structure where the envelope material is either H/He, pure water, or a
mixture of H/He and H2O. Within this framework we perform models of the thermal
evolution and contraction of the planet. We discuss possible compositions that
are consistent with Mp=6.55 ME, Rp=2.678 RE, an age tau=3-10 Gyr, and the
irradiation level of the atmosphere. These conditions require that if water
exists in the interior, it must remain in a fluid state, with important
consequences for magnetic field generation. These conditions also require the
atmosphere to have a deep isothermal region extending down to 80-800 bar,
depending on composition. Our results bolster the suggestion of a
metal-enriched H/He atmosphere for the planet, as we find water-world models
that lack an H/He atmosphere to require an implausibly large water-to-rock
ratio of more than 6:1. We instead favor a H/He/H2O envelope with high water
mass fraction (~0.5-0.85), similar to recent models of the deep envelope of
Uranus and Neptune. Even with these high water mass fractions in the H/He
envelope, generally the bulk composition of the planet can have subsolar
water:rock ratios. Dry, water-enriched, and pure water envelope models differ
to an observationally significant level in their tidal Love numbers k2 of
respectively ~0.018, 0.15, and 0.7.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1103.1263 [pdf] - 1052534
Predictions on the core mass of Jupiter and of giant planets in general
Submitted: 2011-03-07
More than 80 giant planets are known by mass and radius. Their interior
structure in terms of core mass, number of layers, and composition however is
still poorly known. An overview is presented about the core mass Mcore and
envelope mass of metals MZ in Jupiter as predicted by various equations of
state. It is argued that the uncertainty about the true H/He EOS in a pressure
regime where the gravitational moments J2 and J4 are most sensitive, i.e.
between 0.5 and 4 Mbar, is in part responsible for the broad range Mcore=0-18
Mearth, MZ=0-38 Mearth, and Mcore+MZ=14-38 Mearth currently offered for
Jupiter. We then compare the Jupiter models obtained when we only match J2 with
the range of solutions for the exoplanet GJ436b, when we match an assumed tidal
Love number k2 value.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1101.0997 [pdf] - 955846
On the degeneracy of the tidal Love number k2 in multi-layer planetary
models: application to Saturn and GJ436b
Submitted: 2011-01-05
In order to accurately model giant planets, a whole set of observational
constraints is needed. As the conventional constraints for extrasolar planets
like mass, radius, and temperature allow for a large number of acceptable
models, a new planetary parameter is desirable in order to further constrain
planetary models. Such a parameter may be the tidal Love number k2. In this
paper we aim to study the capability of k2 to reveal further information about
the interior structure of a planet. With theoretical planetary models we
investigate how the tidal Love number k2 responds to the internal density
distribution of a planet. In particular, we demonstrate the effect of the
degeneracy of k2 due to a density discontinuity in the envelope of a
three-layer planetary model. The effect of a possible outer density
discontinuity masks the effect of the core mass on the Love number k2. Hence,
there is no unique relationship between the Love number k2 and the core mass of
a planet. We show that the degeneracy of k2 with respect to a layer boundary in
the envelope also occurs in existing planets, e.g. Saturn and the Hot Neptune
GJ436b. As a result of the degeneracy, the planetary parameter k2 cannot be
used to further constrain Saturnian models and for GJ436b only a maximum
possible core mass can be derived from a given k2. To significantly narrow the
uncertainty about the core mass of GJ436b the combined knowledge of k2 and
atmospheric metallicity and temperature profile is necessary.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1101.0606 [pdf] - 1042850
Self-Consistent Model Atmospheres and the Cooling of the Solar System's
Giant Planets
Submitted: 2011-01-03
We compute grids of radiative-convective model atmospheres for Jupiter,
Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune over a range of intrinsic fluxes and surface
gravities. The atmosphere grids serve as an upper boundary condition for models
of the thermal evolution of the planets. Unlike previous work, we customize
these grids for the specific properties of each planet, including the
appropriate chemical abundances and incident fluxes as a function of solar
system age. Using these grids, we compute new models of the thermal evolution
of the major planets in an attempt to match their measured luminosities at
their known ages. Compared to previous work, we find longer cooling times,
predominantly due to higher atmospheric opacity at young ages. For all planets,
we employ simple "standard" cooling models that feature adiabatic temperature
gradients in the interior H/He and water layers, and an initially hot starting
point for the calculation of subsequent cooling. For Jupiter we find a model
cooling age 10% longer than previous work, a modest quantitative difference.
This may indicate that the hydrogen equation of state used here overestimates
the temperatures in the deep interior of the planet. For Saturn we find a model
cooling age 20% longer than previous work. However, an additional energy
source, such as that due to helium phase separation, is still clearly needed.
For Neptune, unlike in work from the 1980s and 1990s, we match the measured
Teff of the planet with a model that also matches the planet's current gravity
field. This is predominantly due to advances in the equation of state of water.
This may indicate that the planet possesses no barriers to efficient convection
in its deep interior. However, for Uranus, our models exacerbate the well-known
problem that Uranus is far cooler than calculations predict, which could imply
strong barriers to interior convective cooling.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.4447 [pdf] - 1025349
Interior structure models of GJ 436b
Submitted: 2010-02-23, last modified: 2010-10-01
GJ 436b is the first extrasolar planet discovered that resembles Neptune in
mass and radius. The particularly interesting property of Neptune-sized planets
is that their mass Mp and radius Rp are close to theoretical M-R relations of
water planets. Given Mp, Rp, and equilibrium temperature, however, various
internal compositions are possible. A broad set of interior structure models is
presented here that illustrates the dependence of internal composition and
possible phases of water occurring in presumably water-rich planets, such as GJ
436b on the uncertainty in atmospheric temperature profile and mean density. We
show how the set of solutions can be narrowed down if theoretical constraints
from formation and model atmospheres are applied or potentially observational
constraints for the atmospheric metallicity Z1 and the tidal Love number k2. We
model the interior by assuming either three layers (hydrogen-helium envelope,
water layer, rock core) or two layers (H/He/H2O envelope, rocky core). For
water, we use the equation of state H2O-REOS based on FT-DFT-MD simulations.
Some admixture of H/He appears mandatory for explaining the measured radius.
For the warmest considered models, the H/He mass fraction can reduce to 10^-3,
still extending over ~0.7 REarth. If water occurs, it will be essentially in
the plasma phase or in the superionic phase, but not in an ice phase.
Metal-free envelope models have 0.02<k2<0.2, and the core mass cannot be
determined from a measurement of k2. In contrast, models with 0.3<k2<0.82
require high metallicities Z1<0.89 in the outer envelope. The uncertainty in
core mass decreases to 0.4 Mp, if k2>0.3, and further to 0.2 Mp, if k2>0.5, and
core mass and Z1 become sensitive functions of k2. To further narrow the set of
solutions, a proper treatment of the atmosphere and the evolution is necessary.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:0907.3067 [pdf] - 1002949
Composition and fate of short-period super-Earths: The case of CoRoT-7b
Submitted: 2009-07-17, last modified: 2010-02-08
The discovery of CoRoT-7b, a planet of radius 1.68 +/- 0.09 R_E, mass 4.8 +/-
0.8 M_E and orbital period of 0.854 days demonstrates that small planets can
orbit extremely close to their star. We use knowledge of hot Jupiters, mass
loss estimates and models for the interior structure and evolution of planets
to understand its composition, structure and evolution. The inferred mass and
radius of CoRoT-7b are consistent with a rocky planet that would be depleted in
iron relative to Earth. However, a one sigma increase in mass (5.6 M_E) and
decrease in size (1.59 R_E) are compatible with an Earth-like composition (33%
iron, 67% silicates). Alternatively, it is possible that CoRoT-7b contains a
significant amount of volatiles. An equally good fit to the data is found for a
vapor envelope equal to 3% (and up to 10%) by mass above an Earth-like nucleus.
Because of its intense irradiation and small size, the planet cannot possess an
envelope of H and He of more than 1/10,000 of its total mass. We show that the
mass loss is significant (~ 10^11 g/s) and independent of planetary
composition. This is because the hydrodynamical escape rate is independent of
the atmosphere's mean molecular mass, and owing to the intense irradiation,
even a bare rocky planet would possess an equilibrium vapor atmosphere thick
enough to capture stellar UV photons. This escape rate rules out the
possibility of a H-He envelope as it would escape in only ~1 Ma. A water vapor
atmosphere would escape in ~ 1 Ga, and thus it is a plausible scenario. The
origin of CoRoT-7b cannot be inferred from present observations: It may have
formed rocky; or be the remnant of a Uranus-like ice giant, or a gas giant with
a small core that was stripped of its gaseous envelope.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.0533 [pdf] - 902618
The Interior Structure, Composition, and Evolution of Giant Planets
Submitted: 2009-12-02
We discuss our current understanding of the interior structure and thermal
evolution of giant planets. This includes the gas giants, such as Jupiter and
Saturn, that are primarily composed of hydrogen and helium, as well as the "ice
giants," such as Uranus and Neptune, which are primarily composed of elements
heavier than H/He. The effect of different hydrogen equations of state
(including new first-principles computations) on Jupiter's core mass and heavy
element distribution is detailed. This variety of the hydrogen equations of
state translate into an uncertainty in Jupiter's core mass of 18 M_Earth. For
Uranus and Neptune we find deep envelope metallicities up to 0.95, perhaps
indicating the existence of an eroded core, as also supported by their low
luminosity. We discuss the results of simple cooling models of our solar
system's planets, and show that more complex thermal evolution models may be
necessary to understand their cooling history. We review how measurements of
the masses and radii of the ~50 transiting extrasolar giant planets are
changing our understanding of giant planets. In particular a fraction of these
planets appear to be larger than can be accommodated by standard models of
planetary contraction. We review the proposed explanations for the radii of
these planets. We also discuss very young giant planets, which are being
directly imaged with ground- and space-based telescopes.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:0712.1019 [pdf] - 7819
Ab initio Equation of State data for hydrogen, helium, and water and the
internal structure of Jupiter
Submitted: 2007-12-06, last modified: 2008-06-06
The equation of state of hydrogen, helium, and water effects interior
structure models of giant planets significantly. We present a new equation of
state data table, LM-REOS, generated by large scale quantum molecular dynamics
simulations for hydrogen, helium, and water in the warm dense matter regime,
i.e.for megabar pressures and temperatures of several thousand Kelvin, and by
advanced chemical methods in the complementary regions. The influence of
LM-REOS on the structure of Jupiter is investigated and compared with
state-of-the-art results within a standard three-layer model consistent with
astrophysical observations of Jupiter. Our new Jupiter models predict an
important impact of mixing effects of helium in hydrogen with respect to an
altered compressibility and immiscibility.