Normalized to: Funato, Y.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1101.5504 [pdf] - 1051751
Particle-Particle Particle-Tree: A Direct-Tree Hybrid Scheme for
Collisional N-Body Simulations
Submitted: 2011-01-28
In this paper, we present a new hybrid algorithm for the time integration of
collisional N-body systems. In this algorithm, gravitational force between two
particles is divided into short-range and long-range terms, using a
distance-dependent cutoff function. The long-range interaction is calculated
using the tree algorithm and integrated with the constant-timestep leapfrog
integrator. The short-range term is calculated directly and integrated with the
high-order Hermite scheme. We can reduce the calculation cost per orbital
period from O(N^2) to O(N log N), without significantly increasing the
long-term integration error. The results of our test simulations show that
close encounters are integrated accurately. Long-term errors of the total
energy shows random-walk behaviour, because it is dominated by the error caused
by tree approximation.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1011.4017 [pdf] - 1042028
Eccentric evolution of SMBH binaries
Submitted: 2010-11-17
In recent numerical simulations \citep{matsubayashi07,lockmann08}, it has
been found that the eccentricity of supermassive black hole(SMBH) -
intermediate black hole(IMBH) binaries grows toward unity through interactions
with stellar background. This increase of eccentricity reduces the merging
timescale of the binary through the gravitational radiation to the value well
below the Hubble Time. It also gives the theoretical explanation of the
existence of eccentric binary such as that in OJ287 \citep{lehto96,
valtonen08}. In self-consistent N-body simulations, this increase of
eccentricity is always observed. On the other hand, the result of scattering
experiment between SMBH binaries and field stars \citep{quinlan96} indicated no
increase of eccentricity. This discrepancy leaves the high eccentricity of the
SMBH binaries in $N$-body simulations unexplained. Here we present a
stellar-dynamical mechanism that drives the increase of the eccentricity of an
SMBH binary with large mass ratio. There are two key processes involved. The
first one is the Kozai mechanism under non-axisymmetric potential, which
effectively randomizes the angular momenta of surrounding stars. The other is
the selective ejection of stars with prograde orbits. Through these two
mechanisms, field stars extract the orbital angular momentum of the SMBH
binary. Our proposed mechanism causes the increase in the eccentricity of most
of SMBH binaries, resulting in the rapid merger through gravitational wave
radiation. Our result has given a definite solution to the "last-parsec
problem".
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1003.4125 [pdf] - 1025850
The origin of S-stars and a young stellar disk: distribution of debris
stars of a sinking star cluster
Submitted: 2010-03-22, last modified: 2010-05-21
Within the distance of 1 pc from the Galactic center (GC), more than 100
young massive stars have been found. The massive stars at 0.1-1 pc from the GC
are located in one or two disks, while those within 0.1 pc from the GC,
S-stars, have an isotropic distribution. How these stars are formed is not well
understood, especially for S-stars. Here we propose that a young star cluster
with an intermediate-mass black hole (IMBH) can form both the disks and
S-stars. We performed a fully self-consistent $N$-body simulation of a star
cluster near the GC. Stars escaped from the tidally disrupted star cluster were
carried to the GC due to an 1:1 mean motion resonance with the IMBH formed in
the cluster. In the final phase of the evolution, the eccentricity of the IMBH
becomes very high. In this phase, stars carried by the 1:1 resonance with the
IMBH were dropped from the resonance and their orbits are randomized by a
chaotic Kozai mechanism. The mass function of these carried stars is extremely
top-heavy within 10". The surface density distributions of young massive stars
has a slope of -1.5 within 10" from the GC. The distribution of stars in the
most central region is isotropic. These characteristics agree well with those
of stars observed within 10" from the GC.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:0807.2818 [pdf] - 314996
Trojan Stars in the Galactic Center
Submitted: 2008-07-17, last modified: 2009-01-15
We performed, for the first time, the simulation of spiral-in of a star
cluster formed close to the Galactic center (GC) using a fully self-consistent
$N$-body model. In our model, the central super-massive black hole (SMBH) is
surrounded by stars and the star cluster. Not only are the orbits of stars and
the cluster stars integrated self-consistently, but the stellar evolution,
collisions and merging of the cluster stars are also included. We found that an
intermediate-mass black hole (IMBH) is formed in the star cluster and stars
escaped from the cluster are captured into a 1:1 mean motion resonance with the
IMBH. These "Trojan" stars are brought close to the SMBH by the IMBH, which
spirals into the GC due to the dynamical friction. Our results show that, once
the IMBH is formed, it brings the massive stars to the vicinity of the central
SMBH even after the star cluster itself is disrupted. Stars carried by the IMBH
form a disk similar to the observed disks and the core of the cluster including
the IMBH has properties similar to those of IRS13E, which is a compact assembly
of several young stars.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:0708.3719 [pdf] - 4313
Evolution of Star Clusters near the Galactic Center: Fully
Self-consistent N-body Simulations
Submitted: 2007-08-28, last modified: 2008-07-08
We have performed fully self-consistent $N$-body simulations of star clusters
near the Galactic center (GC). Such simulations have not been performed because
it is difficult to perform fast and accurate simulations of such systems using
conventional methods. We used the Bridge code, which integrates the parent
galaxy using the tree algorithm and the star cluster using the fourth-order
Hermite scheme with individual timestep. The interaction between the parent
galaxy and the star cluster is calculate with the tree algorithm. Therefore,
the Bridge code can handle both the orbital and internal evolutions of star
clusters correctly at the same time. We investigated the evolution of star
clusters using the Bridge code and compared the results with previous studies.
We found that 1) the inspiral timescale of the star clusters is shorter than
that obtained with "traditional" simulations, in which the orbital evolution of
star clusters is calculated analytically using the dynamical friction formula
and 2) the core collapse of the star cluster increases the core density and
help the cluster survive. The initial conditions of star clusters is not so
severe as previously suggested.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:0801.0859 [pdf] - 8675
Evolution of Massive Blackhole Triples II -- The effect of the BH
triples dynamics on the structure of the galactic nuclear
Submitted: 2008-01-06
In this paper, we investigate the structures of galaxies which either have or
have had three BHs using $N$-body simulations, and compare them with those of
galaxies with binary BHs. We found that the cusp region of a galaxy which have
(or had) triple BHs is significantly larger and less dense than that of a
galaxy with binary BHs of the same mass. Moreover, the size of the cusp region
depends strongly on the evolution history of triple BHs, while in the case of
binary BHs, the size of the cusp is determined by the mass of the BHs. In
galaxies which have (or had) three BHs, there is a region with significant
radial velocity anisotropy, while such a region is not observed in galaxies
with binary BH. These differences come from the fact that with triple BHs the
energy deposit to the central region of the galaxy can be much larger due to
multiple binary-single BH scatterings. Our result suggests that we can
discriminate between galaxies which experienced triple BH interactions with
those which did not, through the observable signatures such as the cusp size
and velocity anisotropy.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:0706.2059 [pdf] - 1000421
BRIDGE: A Direct-tree Hybrid N-body Algorithm for Fully Self-consistent
Simulations of Star Clusters and their Parent Galaxies
Submitted: 2007-06-14, last modified: 2007-07-27
We developed a new direct-tree hybrid N-body algorithm for fully
self-consistent N-body simulations of star clusters in their parent galaxies.
In such simulations, star clusters need high accuracy, while galaxies need a
fast scheme because of the large number of the particles required to model it.
In our new algorithm, the internal motion of the star cluster is calculated
accurately using the direct Hermite scheme with individual timesteps and all
other motions are calculated using the tree code with second-order leapfrog
integrator. The direct and tree schemes are combined using an extension of the
mixed variable symplectic (MVS) scheme. Thus, the Hamiltonian corresponding to
everything other than the internal motion of the star cluster is integrated
with the leapfrog, which is symplectic. Using this algorithm, we performed
fully self-consistent N-body simulations of star clusters in their parent
galaxy. The internal and orbital evolutions of the star cluster agreed well
with those obtained using the direct scheme. We also performed fully
self-consistent N-body simulation for large-N models ($N=2\times 10^6$). In
this case, the calculation speed was seven times faster than what would be if
the direct scheme was used.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0511651 [pdf] - 1233663
Dynamical friction on satellite galaxies
Submitted: 2005-11-22, last modified: 2006-06-23
For a rigid model satellite, Chandrasekhar's dynamical friction formula
describes the orbital evolution quite accurately, when the Coulomb logarithm is
chosen appropriately. However, it is not known if the orbital evolution of a
real satellite with the internal degree of freedom can be described by the
dynamical friction formula. We performed N-body simulation of the orbital
evolution of a self-consistent satellite galaxy within a self-consistent parent
galaxy. We found that the orbital decay of the simulated satellite is
significantly faster than the estimate from the dynamical friction formula. The
main cause of this discrepancy is that the stars stripped out of the satellite
are still close to the satellite, and increase the drag force on the satellite
through two mechanisms. One is the direct drag force from particles in the
trailing tidal arm, a non-axisymmetric force that slows the satellite down. The
other is the indirect effect that is caused by the particles remaining close to
the satellite after escape. The force from them enhances the wake caused in the
parent galaxy by dynamical friction, and this larger wake in turn slows the
satellite down more than expected from the contribution of its bound mass. We
found these two have comparable effects, and the combined effect can be as
large as 20% of the total drag force on the satellite.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0603074 [pdf] - 1233747
Missing Dwarf Problem in Galaxy Clusters
Submitted: 2006-03-03
We investigated the formation and evolution of CDM subhalos in galaxy-sized
and cluster-sized halos by means of N-body simulations. Our aim is to make
clear what the ``dwarf galaxy problem'' is. It has been argued that the number
of subhalos in simulated galaxy-sized halos is too large compared to the
observed number of dwarfs in the local group, while that in cluster-sized halos
is consistent with observed number of galaxies in clusters such as the Virgo
cluster. We simulated nine halos with several different mass resolutions and
physical scales. We found that the dependence of the cumulative number of
subhalos N_c on their maximum circular velocity V_c is given by N_c \propto
V_c^-3, down to the reliability limit, independent of the mass of the main
halo. This implies that simulations for cluster-sized halos give too many halos
with V_c ~ 140km/s or less. Previous comparisons of cluster-sized halos gave
much smaller number of subhalos in this regime simply because of their limited
resolution. Our result implies that any theory which attempts to resolve the
missing dwarf problem should also explain the discrepancy of the simulation and
observation in cluster-sized halos.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0512075 [pdf] - 78275
Three-Body Affairs in the Outer Solar System
Submitted: 2005-12-03
Recent observations (Burnes2002,Veillet2002,Margot2002a) have revealed an
unexpectedly high binary fraction among the Trans-Neptunian Objects (TNOs) that
populate the Kuiper Belt. The TNO binaries are strikingly different from
asteroid binaries in four respects (Veillet2002): their frequency is an order
of magnitude larger, the mass ratio of their components is closer to unity, and
their orbits are wider and highly eccentric. Two explanations have been
proposed for their formation, one assuming large numbers of massive bodies
(Weidenschilling2002), and one assuming large numbers of light bodies
(Goldreich2002). We argue that both assumptions are unwarranted, and we show
how TNO binaries can be produced from a modest number of intermediate-mass
bodies of the type predicted by the gravitational instability theory for the
formation of planetesimals (Goldreich and Ward1973). We start with a TNO binary
population similar to the asteroid binary population, but subsequently modified
by three-body exchange reactions, a process that is far more efficient in the
Kuiper belt, because of the much smaller tidal perturbations by the Sun. Our
mechanism can naturally account for all four characteristics that distinguish
TNO binaries from main-belt asteroid binaries.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0511391 [pdf] - 77749
Evolution of Massive Blackhole Triples I -- Equal-mass binary-single
systems
Submitted: 2005-11-14
We present the result of $N$-body simulations of dynamical evolution of
triple massive blackhole (BH) systems in galactic nuclei. We found that in most
cases two of the three BHs merge through gravitational wave (GW) radiation in
the timescale much shorter than the Hubble time, before ejecting one BH through
a slingshot. In order for a binary BH to merge before ejecting out the third
one, it has to become highly eccentric since the gravitational wave timescale
would be much longer than the Hubble time unless the eccentricity is very high.
We found that two mechanisms drive the increase of the eccentricity of the
binary. One is the strong binary-single BH interaction resulting in the
thermalization of the eccentricity. The second is the Kozai mechanism which
drives the cyclic change of the inclination and eccentricity of the inner
binary of a stable hierarchical triple system. Our result implies that many of
supermassive blackholes are binaries.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0402328 [pdf] - 1233331
The formation of Kuiper-belt Binaries through Exchange Reactions
Submitted: 2004-02-13
Recent observations have revealed an unexpectedly high binary fraction among
the Trans-Neptunian Objects (TNOs) that populate the Kuiper-belt. The
discovered binaries have four characteristics they comprise a few percent of
the TNOs, the mass ratio of their components is close to unity, their internal
orbits are highly eccentric, and the orbits are more than 100 times wider than
the primary's radius. In contrast, theories of binary asteroid formation tend
to produce close, circular binaries. Therefore, a new approach is required to
explain the unique characteristics of the TNO binaries. Two models have been
proposed. Both, however, require extreme assumptions on the size distribution
of TNOs. Here we show a mechanism which is guaranteed to produces binaries of
the required type during the early TNO growth phase, based on only one
plausible assumption, namely that initially TNOs were formed through
gravitational instabilities of the protoplanetary dust layer.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0307327 [pdf] - 58040
Evolution of Massive Black Hole Binaries
Submitted: 2003-07-16, last modified: 2003-10-24
We present the result of large-scale N-body simulations of the
stellar-dynamical evolution of a massive black-hole binary at the center of a
spherical galaxy. We focus on the dependence of the hardening rate on the
relaxation timescale of the parent galaxy. A simple theoretical argument
predicts that a binary black hole creates the ``loss cone'' around it. Once the
loss cone is formed, the hardening rate is determined by the rate at which
field stars diffuse into the loss cone. Therefore the hardening timescale
becomes proportional to the relaxation timescale. Recent N-body simulations,
however, have failed to confirm this theory and various explanations have been
proposed. By performing simulations with sufficiently large N (up to $10^6$)
for sufficiently long time, we found that the hardening rate does depend on N.
Our result is consistent with the simple theoretical prediction that the
hardening timescale is proportional to the relaxation timescale. This
dependence implies that most massive black hole binaries are unlikely to merge
within the Hubble time through interaction with field stars and gravitational
wave radiation alone.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0303113 [pdf] - 55352
Kuiper-belt Binary Formation through Exchange Reactions
Submitted: 2003-03-05, last modified: 2003-03-28
Recent observations (Burnes et al 2002,Veillet et al 2002, Margot et al
2002a) have revealed an unexpectedly high binary fraction among the
Trans-Neptunian Objects (TNOs) that populate the Kuiper Belt. The TNO binaries
are strikingly different from asteroid binaries in four respects (Veillet et al
2002): their frequency is an order of magnitude larger, the mass ratio of their
components is closer to unity, and their orbits are wider and highly eccentric.
Two explanations have been proposed for their formation, one assuming large
numbers of massive bodies (Weidenschilling 2002), and one assuming large
numbers of light bodies (Goldreich et al 2002). We argue that both assumptions
are unwarranted, and we show how TNO binaries can be produced from a modest
number of intermediate-mass bodies of the type predicted by the gravitational
instability theory for the formation of planetesimals (Goldreich and Ward
1973). We start with a TNO binary population similar to the asteroid binary
population, but subsequently modified by three-body exchange reactions, a
process that is far more efficient in the Kuiper belt, because of the much
smaller tidal perturbations by the Sun. Our mechanism can naturally account for
all four characteristics that distinguish TNO binaries from main-belt asteroid
binaries.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0208452 [pdf] - 51268
To Circularize or Not to Circularize? -- Orbital Evolution of Satellite
Galaxies
Submitted: 2002-08-26
We investigated the orbital evolution of satellite galaxies using numerical
simulations. It has been long believed that the orbit suffers circularization
due to the dynamical friction from the galactic halo during orbital decay. This
circularization was confirmed by numerous simulations where dynamical friction
is added as external force. However, some of the resent N-body simulations
demonstrated that circularization is much slower than expected from approximate
calculations. We found that the dominant reason for this discrepancy is the
assumption that Coulomb logarithm log Lambda is constant, which has been used
in practically all recent calculations. Since the size of the satellite is
relatively large, accurate determination of the outer cutoff radius is crucial
to obtain good estimate for the dynamical friction. An excellent agreement
between $N$-body simulations and approximate calculations was observed when the
outer cutoff radius is taken to be the distance of the satellite to the center
of the galaxy. When satellite is at the perigalacticon, the distance to the
center is smaller and therefore log Lambda becomes smaller. As a result, the
dynamical friction becomes less effective.
We apply our result to the Large Magellanic Cloud. We found that the expected
lifetime of the LMC is twice as long as that would be predicted with previous
calculations. Previous study predicts that the LMC will merge into the Milky
Way after 7 G years, while we found that the merging will take place after 14 G
years from now. Our result suggests that generally satellites formed around a
galaxy have longer lifetime than previous estimates.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0106521 [pdf] - 1232704
Collisional Evolution of Galaxy Clusters and the Growth of Common Halos
Submitted: 2001-06-28, last modified: 2002-01-24
We investigated the dynamical evolution of clusters of galaxies in virial
equilibrium using Fokker-Planck models and self-consistent N-body models. In
particular, we focused on the growth of a common halo, which is a cluster-wide
halo formed by matter stripped from galaxies, and the development of a central
density cusp. The Fokker-Planck models include the effects of two-body
gravitational encounters both between galaxies and between galaxies and common
halo particles. The effects of tidal mass stripping from the galaxies due to
close galaxy-galaxy encounters and accompanying dissipation of the orbital
kinetic energies of the galaxies were also taken into account in the
Fokker-Planck models. We find that the results of the Fokker-Planck models are
in excellent agreement with those of the N-body models regarding the growth of
the common halo mass and the evolution of the cluster density profiles. In the
central region of the cluster, a shallow density cusp, approximated by $\rho
(r) \propto r^{-\alpha}$ ($\alpha \sim$ 1), develops. This shallow cusp results
from the combined effects of two-body relaxation and tidal stripping. The cusp
steepness, $\alpha$, weakly depends on the relative importance of the tidal
stripping. When the effect of stripping is important, the central velocity
dispersion decreases as the central density increases and, consequently, a
shallow ($\alpha <2$) cusp is formed. In the limit of no stripping, usual
gravothermal core collapse occurs, i.e. the central velocity dispersion
increases as the central density increases with a steep ($\alpha >2$) cusp
left. We conclude from our consideration of the origin of the cusp demonstrated
here that shallow cusps should develop in real galaxy clusters.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0106252 [pdf] - 43048
Missing Link Found? --- The ``runaway'' path to supermassive black holes
Ebisuzaki, Toshikazu;
Makino, Junichiro;
Tsuru, Takeshi Go;
Funato, Yoko;
Zwart, Simon Portegies;
Hut, Piet;
McMillan, Steve;
Matsushita, Satoki;
Matsumoto, Hironori;
Kawabe, Ryohei
Submitted: 2001-06-14
Observations of stellar kinematics, gas dynamics and masers around galactic
nuclei have now firmly established that many galaxies host central supermassive
black holes (SMBHs) with masses in the range $10^6 \sim 10^9$M$_{\odot}$.
However, how these SMBHs formed is not well understood. One reason for this
situation is the lack of observations of intermediate-mass BHs (IMBHs), which
could bridge the gap between stellar-mass BHs and SMBHs. Recently, this missing
link (i.e., an IMBH) has been found in observations made by the ASCA and the
Chandra of the central region of the starburst galaxy M82 \citep{MT99, PG99,
MT01, Ka01}. Subsequent observations by SUBARU have revealed that this IMBH
apparently coincides with a young compact star cluster. Based on these
findings, we suggest a new formation scenario for SMBHs. In this scenario,
IMBHs first form in young compact star clusters through runaway merging of
massive stars. While these IMBHs are forming, the host star clusters sink
toward the galactic nucleus through dynamical friction, and upon evaporation
deposit their IMBHs near the galactic center. The IMBHs then form binaries and
eventually merge via gravitational radiation, forming an SMBH.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0012092 [pdf] - 1468192
Evolution of Clusters of Galaxies II: Dependence on Initial Cluster
Model
Submitted: 2000-12-05
We investigated the evolution of clusters of galaxies using self-consistent
N-body simulations. We varied the initial model of galaxies and clusters, and
studied the dependence of evolution on initial conditions. We found that the
growth rate of the common halo depends only weakly on galaxy models. On the
other hand, the growth rate depends strongly on cluster models. Initially the
growth rate is higher for cluster models with higher central density. However,
this high growth rate drops in a few crossing times of the cluster, and after
several crossing times, roughly half of the total mass is in the common halo in
all models we considered. In the central region of clusters density cusps with
the profile \rho ~ r^{-1.2} develops regardless of the models of clusters and
galaxies. We also found that the galaxies evolved so as to satisfy the relation
between the masses of galaxies m_{gx} and their velocity dispersion \sigma_{gx}
expressed as m_{gx} \propto \sigma_{gx}^{3~4} for all galaxy models as a
consequence of their dynamical evolution through galaxy-galaxy interactions. We
discuss the relation between our result and the observed Faber-Jackson
relation.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9906263 [pdf] - 1235349
Evolution of Clusters of Galaxies: Mass Stripping from Galaxies and
Growth of Common Halos
Submitted: 1999-06-16, last modified: 1999-10-29
We investigated the evolution of clusters of galaxies using self-consistent
$N$-body simulations in which each galaxy was modeled by many particles. We
carried out simulations for about 20 cases using different initial conditions.
In all simulations, clusters were initially in virial equilibrium. We found
that more than half of the total mass escaped from individual galaxies within a
few crossing times of the cluster, and that a diffuse halo was formed. The
growth rate of the common halo depended on the size of individual galaxies only
weakly. The stripping of the mass from galaxies was mainly due to the
interaction of galaxies, not due to the effect of the tidal field of the
cluster potential. The amount of stripped mass was larger for galaxies in the
central region than for those in the outer region, since the interactions were
more frequent in the central region. As a result, a positive correlation
between the distance from the center and the mass of the galaxy developed. The
volume-density profile of the common halo is expressed as $\rho\propto r^{-1}$
in the central region. This mass distribution is consistent with the mass
distribution in clusters estimated using X-ray observations.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9704276 [pdf] - 97238
Time Symmetrization Meta-Algorithms
Submitted: 1997-04-28
We present two types of meta-algorithm that can greatly improve the accuracy
of existing algorithms for integrating the equations of motion of dynamical
systems. The first meta-algorithm takes an integrator that is time-symmetric
only for constant time steps, and ensures time-symmetry even in the case of
varying time steps. The second meta-algorithm can be applied to any
self-starting integration scheme to create time-symmetry, both for constant and
for variable time steps, even if the original scheme was not time-symmetric.
Our meta-algorithms are most effective for Hamilton systems or systems with
periodic solutions. If the system is not Hamiltonian (for example, if some
dissipative force exists), our methods are still useful so long as the
dissipation is small.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9604025 [pdf] - 1942421
Time-Symmetrized Kustaanheimo-Stiefel Regularization
Submitted: 1996-04-04
In this paper we describe a new algorithm for the long-term numerical
integration of the two-body problem, in which two particles interact under a
Newtonian gravitational potential. Although analytical solutions exist in the
unperturbed and weakly perturbed cases, numerical integration is necessary in
situations where the perturbation is relatively strong. Kustaanheimo--Stiefel
(KS) regularization is widely used to remove the singularity in the equations
of motion, making it possible to integrate orbits having very high
eccentricity. However, even with KS regularization, long-term integration is
difficult, simply because the required accuracy is usually very high. We
present a new time-integration algorithm which has no secular error in either
the binding energy or the eccentricity, while allowing variable stepsize. The
basic approach is to take a time-symmetric algorithm, then apply an implicit
criterion for the stepsize to ensure strict time reversibility. We describe the
algorithm in detail and present the results of numerical tests involving
long-term integration of binaries and hierarchical triples. In all cases
studied, we found no systematic error in either the energy or the angular
momentum. We also found that its calculation cost does not become higher than
those of existing algorithms. By contrast, the stabilization technique, which
has been widely used in the field of collisional stellar dynamics, conserves
energy very well but does not conserve angular momentum.