Normalized to: Wurm, G.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.00997 [pdf] - 2126896
Drifting inwards in protoplanetary discs I Sticking of chondritic dust
at increasing temperatures
Submitted: 2020-07-02
Sticking properties rule the early phases of pebble growth in protoplanetary
discs in which grains regularly travel from cold, water-rich regions to the
warm inner part. This drift affects composition, grain size, morphology, and
water content as grains experience ever higher temperatures. In this study we
tempered chondritic dust under vacuum up to 1400 K. Afterwards, we measured the
splitting tensile strength of millimetre-sized dust aggregates. The deduced
effective surface energy starts out as $\gamma_e = 0.07\,\rm J/m^2$. This value
is dominated by abundant iron-oxides as measured by M\"ossbauer spectroscopy.
Up to 1250 K, $\gamma_e$ continuously decreases by up to a factor five.
Olivines dominate at higher temperature. Beyond 1300 K dust grains
significantly grow in size. The $\gamma_e$ no longer decreases but the large
grain size restricts the capability of growing aggregates. Beyond 1400 K
aggregation is no longer possible. Overall, under the conditions probed, the
stability of dust pebbles would decrease towards the star. In view of a minimum
aggregate size required to trigger drag instabilities it becomes increasingly
harder to seed planetesimal formation closer to a star.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.01130 [pdf] - 2126908
Laboratory Impact Splash Experiments to Simulate Asteroid Surfaces
Submitted: 2020-07-02
Granular material that is bound by the low gravity of a small asteroid is
mobilized by slow velocity impacts. These splashes generated by impacts might
play an important role in sculpting the asteroid's surface. In laboratory
experiments we characterize the ejecta generated by spherical 150 $\rm \mu m$
diameter basalt grains impacting a granular bed at 0.8 m/s. We find that such
an impact typically leads to less than 10 particles being ejected from the
granular bed, with typical ejecta trajectories rising to less than one particle
diameter above the surface. That is, the observed impacts are highly
dissipative and only a small fraction of the impact energy is imparted onto the
ejecta. While the impactor itself still rebounds, it typically slows down
significantly to an average of about 20 % of its impact velocity. Scaled to
asteroids, impactor and ejecta generated from impacts of sand sized grains are
not able to spread over the asteroid's surface but will stay close to the
impact site. Therefore these highly inelastic impacts into soft granular beds
efficiently trap grains, in contrast to more elastic impacts on bare, rocky
surfaces confirming suggestions by Shinbrot (2017). This is also in agreement
to observed features on asteroids as this topological elasticity bias suggests
that redistribution of grains leads to a size segregation.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.13692 [pdf] - 2121579
Composition and Size Dependent Sorting in Preplanetary Growth: Seeding
the Formation of Mercury-like Planets
Submitted: 2020-06-24
In an earlier work, we found that large metallic iron fractions in dust
aggregates and strong magnetic fields boost preplanetary growth. This sets an
initial bias for the formation of Mercury-like planets in the inner part of
protoplanetary disks. We extended these experiments here by adding pure quartz
aggregates to the iron-rich aggregates. Magnetic boost still leads to the
formation of larger clusters of aggregates. These clusters now include silicate
aggregates, which can also be connecting bridges between chains. However, at
least a certain fraction of iron-rich aggregates are needed to trigger magnetic
boost. Without a magnetic field, the sticking properties of the aggregates and
their constituents determine the composition of clusters of a given size. This
introduces a new fractionation and sorting mechanism by cluster formation at
the bouncing barrier.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.09237 [pdf] - 2067628
Planetesimals in Rarefied Gas: Wind Erosion in Slip Flow
Submitted: 2020-03-20
A planetesimal moves through the gas of its protoplanetary disc where it
experiences a head wind. Though the ambient pressure is low, this wind can
erode and ultimately destroy the planetesimal if the flow is strong enough. For
the first time, we observe wind erosion in ground based and microgravity
experiments at pressures relevant in protoplanetary discs, i.e. down to
$10^{-1}\, \rm mbar$. We find that the required shear stress for erosion
depends on the Knudsen number related to the grains at the surface. The
critical shear stress to initiate erosion increases as particles become
comparable to or larger than the mean free path of the gas molecules. This
makes pebble pile planetesimals more stable at lower pressure. However, it does
not save them as the experiments also show that the critical shear stress to
initiate erosion is very low for sub-millimetre sized grains.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.06064 [pdf] - 2050465
Lifting Grains by the Transient Low Pressure in a Martian Dust Devil
Submitted: 2020-02-14
Lifting dust and sand into the thin Martian atmosphere is a challenging
problem. Atmospheric pressure excursions within dust devils have been proposed
to support lifting. We verify this idea in laboratory experiments. Pressure
differences up to a few Pa are applied along particle layers of 50 to 400 $\rm
\mu m$. As samples we used glass beads of $\sim$50 $\rm \mu m$ diameter and
irregular basalt grains of $\sim$20 $\rm \mu m$ in size. The total ambient
pressure of air was set to 600 Pa. Particles are ejected at pressure
differences as low as 2.0 $\rm \pm$ 0.8 Pa. In the case of glass beads, the
ejected grains returning to the particle bed can trigger new particle ejections
as they reduce cohesion and release the tension from other grains. Therefore,
few impacting grains might be sufficient to sustain dust lifting in a dust
devil at even lower pressure differences. Particle lift requires a very thin,
$\sim$100 $\rm \mu m$, low permeability particle layer on top of supporting
ground with larger pore space. Assuming this, our experiments support the idea
that pressure excursions in Martian dust devils release grains from the ground.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.01714 [pdf] - 2009565
Laboratory Experiments on the Motion of Dense Dust Clouds
Submitted: 2019-11-29
In laboratory experiments, we study the motion of levitated, sedimenting
clouds of sub-mm grains at low ambient pressure and at high solid-to-gas ratios
$\epsilon$. The experiments show a collective behavior of particles, i.e.
grains in clouds settle faster than an isolated grain. In collective particle
clouds, the sedimentation velocity linearly depends on $\epsilon$ and linearly
depends on the particle closeness $C$. However, collective behavior only sets
in at a critical value $\epsilon_{\rm crit}$ which linearly increases with the
experiment Stokes number St. For $\rm St <0.003 $ particles always behave
collectively. For large Stokes numbers, large solid-to-gas ratios are needed to
trigger collective behavior, e.g. $\epsilon_{\rm crit} = 0.04$ at $\rm St =
0.01$. Applied to protoplanetary disks, particles in dense environments will
settle faster. In balance with upward gas motions (turbulent diffusion,
convection) the thickness of the midplane particle layer will be smaller than
calculated based on individual grains, especially for dust. For pebbles, large
solid-to-gas ratios are needed to trigger instabilities based on back-reaction.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.05429 [pdf] - 1998153
ARISE: A granular matter experiment on the International Space Station
Steinpilz, Tobias;
Musiolik, Grzegorz;
Kruss, Maximilian;
Jungmann, Felix;
Demirci, Tunahan;
Aderholz, Manfred;
Kollmer, Jonathan E.;
Teiser, Jens;
Bila, Tetyana;
Guay, Evelyn;
Wurm, Gerhard
Submitted: 2019-11-13
We developed an experiment to study different aspects of granular matter
under microgravity. The 1.5U small experiment was carried out on the
International Space Station. About 3500 almost identical spherical glass
particles with 856 um diameter were placed in a container of 50*50 mm cross
section. Adjusting the height between 5 and 50 mm, the filling factor can be
varied. The sample was vibrated under different frequencies and amplitudes. The
majority of the data are video images of the particles motion. Here, we first
give an overview of the general setup and a first qualitative account of
different phenomena observed in about 700 experimental runs. These phenomena
include collisional cooling, collective motion via gas-cluster coupling, and
the influence of electrostatic forces on particle-particle interactions.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.01692 [pdf] - 1994388
Wind erosion on Mars and other small terrestrial planets
Submitted: 2019-11-05
We carried out wind tunnel experiments on parabolic flights with 100 $\mu$m
Mojave Mars simulant sand. The experiments result in shear stress thresholds
and erosion rates for varying g-levels at 600 Pa pressure. Our data confirm
former results on JSC Mars 1A simulant where the threshold shear stress is
lower under Martian gravity than extrapolated from earlier ground-based studies
which fits observations of Martian sand activity. The data are consistent with
a model by Shao and Lu (2000) and can also be applied to other small
terrestrial (exo)-planets with low pressure atmospheres.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.11657 [pdf] - 2067498
Onset of planet formation in the warm inner disk -- Colliding dust
aggregates at high temperatures
Submitted: 2019-08-30
Collisional growth of dust occurs in all regions of protoplanetary disks with
certain materials dominating between various condensation lines. The sticking
properties of the prevalent dust species depend on the specific temperatures.
The inner disk is the realm of silicates spanning a wide range of temperatures
from room temperature up to sublimation beyond $1500\,\mathrm{K}$. For the
first time, we carried out laboratory collision experiments with hot levitated
basalt dust aggregates of $1\, \rm mm$ in size. The aggregates are compact with
a filling factor of $0.37 \pm 0.06$. The constituent grains have a wide size
distribution that peaks at about $0.6\,\mu \mathrm{m}$. Temperatures in the
experiments are varied between approximately $600\,\mathrm{K}$ and
$1100\,\mathrm{K}$. Collisions are slow with velocities between
$0.002\,\mathrm{m}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}$ and $0.15\,\mathrm{m}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}$,
i.e., relevant for protoplanetary disks. Aside from variations of the
coefficients of restitution due to varying collision velocities, the
experiments show low sticking probability below $900\,\mathrm{K}$ and an
increasing sticking probability starting at $900\,\mathrm{K}$. This implies
that dust can grow to larger size in hot regions, which might change planet
formation. One scenario is an enhanced probability for local planetesimal
formation. Another scenario is a reduction of planetesimal formation as larger
grains are more readily removed as a consequence of radial drift. However, the
increased growth at high temperatures likely changes planetesimal formation one
way or the other.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.11864 [pdf] - 1890603
Sticking Properties of Silicates in Planetesimal Formation Revisited
Submitted: 2019-05-28
In the past, laboratory experiments and theoretical calculations showed a
mismatch in derived sticking properties of silicates in the context of
planetesimal formation. It has been proposed by Kimura et al. (2015) that this
mismatch is due to the value of the surface energy assumed, supposedly
correlated to the presence or lack of water layers of different thickness on a
grain's surface. We present tensile strength measurements of dust aggregates
with different water content here. The results are in support of the suggestion
by Kimura et al. (2015). Dry samples show increased strengths by a factor of up
to 10 over wet samples. A high value of $\gamma = 0.2 J/m^2$ likely applies to
the dry low pressure conditions of protoplanetary disks and should be used in
the future.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.11138 [pdf] - 1889697
A challenge for Martian lightning: Limits of collisional charging at low
pressure
Submitted: 2019-05-27
Collisional charging is one potential initial step in generating lightning.
In this work, we study the charging of colliding monodisperse, spherical basalt
grains depending on ambient pressure. We used grains of 1.0 to 1.2 mm in one
set and 2.0 to 2.4 mm in another set. We varied the ambient pressure between
0.03 mbar and 80 mbar. This especially includes Martian pressure being 6 mbar
on average. At a few mbar the net charge gathering on colliding grains has a
minimum. A smooth incline in charging occurs for larger pressures. Toward lower
pressure the charge increases steeply. The pressure dependence is in agreement
to a model where the maximum charge is limited by a gas discharge occurring
between two charged colliding grains shortly after or before a collision. The
capability of building up charge is at a minimum exactly in the range of
Martian pressures. The charges on grains are at least a factor 5 smaller than
at the highest pressure tested and still smaller compared to ambient pressure
on Earth. This implies that on Mars collisional charging and the potential of
subsequent generation of lightning or other large scale discharges are strongly
reduced compared to Earth. This might result in less frequent and less
energetic lightning on Mars.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.08503 [pdf] - 1846937
Contacts of Water Ice in Protoplanetary Disks - Laboratory Experiments
Submitted: 2019-02-22
Water ice is abundant in protoplanetary disks. Its sticking properties are
therefore important during phases of collisional growth. In this work, we study
the sticking and rolling of 1.1 mm ice grains at different temperatures. We
find a strong increase in sticking between 175 K to 200 K which levels off at
higher temperatures. In terms of surface energy this is an increase with a
factor of 63.4, e.g. from $\gamma = 0.0029 \rm J/m^2$ to $\gamma = \rm 0.19
J/m^2$, respectively. We also measured critical forces for inelastic rolling.
The critical rolling distance is constant with a value of 0.19 mm. In view of
planetesimal formation at low temperatures in protoplanetary disks, the surface
energy is not larger than for silicate dust and ice aggregation will share the
same shortcommings. In general, water ice has no advantage over silicates for
sticking and collisional growth might not favor ice over silicates.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.02549 [pdf] - 1828434
Dense Particle Clouds in Laboratory Experiments in Context of Drafting
and Streaming Instability
Submitted: 2019-02-07
The streaming instability, as an example of instabilities driven by particle
feedback on a gas flow, has been proven to have a major role in controlling the
formation of planetesimals. Here, we present experiments to approach this
situation in the laboratory for particles in the Knudsen flow regime. In these
experiments, we observe a particle cloud trapped for about 30 s in a rotating
system under Earth's gravity. For average dust-to-gas ratios up to 0.08,
particles behave like individual test particles. Their sedimentation speed is
identical to that of a single free-falling particle, even in locally denser
regions. However, for higher dust-to-gas ratios, the motion of particles
becomes sensitive to clumping. Particles in locally denser regions now sediment
faster. Their sedimentation speed then depends linearly on the overall
dust-to-gas ratio. This clearly shows a transition from tracerlike behavior to
collective behavior. Beyond these findings, these types of experiments can now
be used as a gauge to test the particle feedback models in astrophysical
hydrocodes which are currently used for numerical simulations of streaming
instabilities.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.07919 [pdf] - 2067470
Are Pebble Pile Planetesimals Doomed?
Submitted: 2019-01-23
In parabolic flight experiments we studied the wind induced erosion of
granular beds composed of spherical glass beads at low gravity and low ambient
pressure. Varying g-levels were set by centrifugal forces. Expanding existing
parameter sets to a pressure range between $p=300-1200\,$Pa and to g-levels of
$g=1.1-2.2\,\rm m\,s^{-2}$ erosion thresholds are still consistent with the
existing model for wind erosion on planetary surfaces by Shao & Lu (2000).
These parameters were the lowest values that could technically be reached by
the experiment. The experiments decrease the necessary range of extrapolation
of erosion thresholds from verified to currently still unknown values at the
conditions of planetesimals in protoplanetary discs. We apply our results to
the stability of planetesimals. In inner regions of protoplanetary discs,
pebble pile planetesimals below a certain size are not stable but will be
disassembled by a head wind.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.05338 [pdf] - 1797765
Seeding the Formation of Mercurys: An Iron-sensitive Bouncing Barrier in
Disk Magnetic Fields
Submitted: 2018-12-13
The inner part of protoplanetary disks can be threaded by strong magnetic
fields. In laboratory levitation experiments, we study how magnetic fields up
to 7 mT influence the aggregation of dust by observing the self-consistent
collisional evolution of particle ensembles. As dust samples we use mixtures of
iron and quartz in different ratios. Without magnetic fields, particles in all
samples grow into a bouncing barrier. These aggregates reversibly form larger
clusters in the presence of magnetic fields. The size of these clusters depends
on the strength of the magnetic field and the ratio between iron and quartz.
The clustering increases the size of the largest entities by a factor of a few.
If planetesimal formation is sensitive to the size of the largest aggregates,
e.g., relying on streaming instabilities, then planetesimals will
preferentially grow iron-rich in the inner region of protoplanetary disks. This
might explain the iron gradient in the solar system and the formation of dense
Mercury-like planets.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.02905 [pdf] - 1781201
Constraints on Compound Chondrule Formation from Laboratory
High-Temperature Collisions
Submitted: 2018-11-07
In laboratory experiments, spherical 1 mm-wide glass and basalt particles are
heated, and the hot particles collide at about 1m/s with a flat glass target
that is at room temperature. When the particles are heated below 900 K, the
collisions are essentially elastic with coefficients of restitution of about
0.9, but above 900K collisions become increasingly inelastic and the
coefficient of restitution decreases with increasing temperature. At 1100K the
glass particles approach sticking but, simultaneously, at the same temperature
the particles melt on timescales of minutes. The basalt particles approach
sticking at 1200 K. Only above 1400K do basalt grains in contact with each
other fuse together, forming compounds on timescales of hours, and at 1500K
basalt grains completely fuse together. Therefore, cooling basalt grains only
have a 100K window for compound formation, and velocities very likely have to
be below 1m/s for sticking in the first place. We predict that this puts
constraints on compound chondrule formation and particle densities in the solar
nebula.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.10246 [pdf] - 1742145
Selective Aggregation Experiments on Planetesimal Formation and
Mercury-Like Planets
Submitted: 2018-08-30
Much of a planet's composition could be determined right at the onset of
formation. Laboratory experiments can constrain these early steps. This
includes static tensile strength measurements or collisions carried out under
Earth's gravity and on various microgravity platforms. Among the variety of
extrasolar planets which eventually form are (Exo)-Mercury, terrestrial planets
with high density. If they form in inner protoplanetary disks, high temperature
experiments are mandatory but they are still rare. Beyond the initial process
of hit-and-stick collisions, some additional selective processing might be
needed to explain Mercury. In analogy to icy worlds, such planets might, e.g.,
form in environments which are enriched in iron. This requires methods to
separate iron and silicate at early stages. Photophoresis might be one viable
way. Mercury and Mercury-like planets might also form due to the ferromagnetic
properties of iron and mechanisms like magnetic aggregation in disk magnetic
fields might become important. This review highlights some of the mechanisms
with the potential to trigger Mercury formation.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.08787 [pdf] - 1624914
Saltation under Martian Gravity and its Influence on the Global Dust
Distribution
Submitted: 2018-01-26
Dust and sand motion are a common sight on Mars. Understanding the
interaction of atmosphere and Martian soil is fundamental to describe the
planet's weather, climate and surface morphology.
We set up a wind tunnel to study the lift of a mixture between very fine sand
and dust in a Mars simulant soil. The experiments were carried out under
Martian gravity in a parabolic flight. The reduced gravity was provided by a
centrifuge under external microgravity. The onset of saltation was measured for
a fluid threshold shear velocity of 0.82$\pm$0.04 m/s. This is considerably
lower than found under Earth gravity.
In addition to a reduction in weight, this low threshold can be attributed to
gravity dependent cohesive forces within the sand bed, which drop by 2/3 under
Martian gravity. The new threshold for saltation leads to a simulation of the
annual dust cycle with a Mars GCM that is in agreement with observations.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.00606 [pdf] - 1589136
Is There a Temperature Limit in Planet Formation at 1000 K?
Submitted: 2017-10-02
Dust drifting inward in protoplanetary disks is subject to increasing
temperatures. In laboratory experiments, we tempered basaltic dust between 873
K and 1273 K and find that the dust grains change in size and composition.
These modifications influence the outcome of self-consistent low speed
aggregation experiments showing a transition temperature of 1000\,K. Dust
tempered at lower temperatures grows to a maximum aggregate size of $2.02 \pm
0.06$ mm, which is $1.49 \pm 0.08$ times the value for dust tempered at higher
temperatures. A similar size ratio of $1.75 \pm 0.16$ results for a different
set of collision velocities. This transition temperature is in agreement with
orbit temperatures deduced for observed extrasolar planets. Most terrestrial
planets are observed at positions equivalent to less than 1000 K. Dust
aggregation on the millimeter-scale at elevated temperatures might therefore be
a key factor for terrestrial planet formation.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.02566 [pdf] - 1584423
Analog Experiments on Tensile Strength of Dusty and Cometary Matter
Submitted: 2017-06-08
The tensile strength of small dusty bodies in the solar system is determined
by the interaction between the composing grains. In the transition regime
between small and sticky dust ($\rm \mu m$) and non cohesive large grains (mm),
particles still stick to each other but are easily separated. In laboratory
experiments we find that thermal creep gas flow at low ambient pressure
generates an overpressure sufficient to overcome the tensile strength. For the
first time it allows a direct measurement of the tensile strength of
individual, very small (sub)-mm aggregates which consist of only tens of grains
in the (sub)-mm size range. We traced the disintegration of aggregates by
optical imaging in ground based as well as microgravity experiments and present
first results for basalt, palagonite and vitreous carbon samples with up to a
few hundred Pa. These measurements show that low tensile strength can be the
result of building loose aggregates with compact (sub)-mm units. This is in
favour of a combined cometary formation scenario by aggregation to compact
aggreates and gravitational instability of these units.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.07124 [pdf] - 1561237
Growing into and out of the bouncing barrier in planetesimal formation
Submitted: 2017-03-21
In recent laboratory studies the robustness of a bouncing barrier in
planetesimal formation was studied with an ensemble of preformed compact
mm-sized aggregates. Here we show that a bouncing barrier indeed evolves
self-consistently by hit-and-stick from an ensemble of smaller dust aggregates.
In addition, we feed small aggregates to an ensemble of larger bouncing
aggregates. The stickiness temporarily increases, but the final number of
aggregates still bouncing remains the same. However, feeding on the small
particle supply, the size of the bouncing aggregates increases. This suggests
that in the presence of a dust reservoir aggregates grow into but also out of a
bouncing barrier at larger size.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.02096 [pdf] - 1488431
The motion of chondrules and other particles in a protoplanetary disc
with temperature fluctuations
Submitted: 2016-09-07, last modified: 2016-09-28
We consider the mechanism of photophoretic transport in protoplanetary disks
that are optically thick to radiation. Here, photophoresis is not caused by the
central star but by temperature fluctuations that subject suspended solid
particles, including chondrules, to non-isotropic thermal radiation within the
disk. These short-lived temperature fluctuations can explain time-of-flight
size sorting and general number density enhancements. The same mechanism will
also lead to velocity fluctuations of dust aggregates beyond
$100\,\mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$ for mm-sized particles in protoplanetary disks.
Applying this in future research will change our understanding of the early
phases of collisional dust evolution and aggregate growth as particles cross
the bouncing barrier and as mass transfer rates are altered.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.03475 [pdf] - 1490878
Self-Sustained Recycling in the Inner Dust Ring of Pre-Transitional
Disks
Submitted: 2016-09-12
Observations of pre-transitional disks show a narrow inner dust ring and a
larger outer one. They are separated by a cavity with no or only little dust.
We propose an efficient recycling mechanism for the inner dust ring which keeps
it in a steady-state. No major particle sources are needed for replenishment.
Dust particles and pebbles drift outwards by radiation pressure and
photophoresis. The pebbles grow during outward drift until they reach a
balanced position where residual gravity compensates photophoresis. While still
growing larger they reverse their motion and drift inwards. Eventually, their
speed is fast enough that they get destroyed in collisions with other pebbles
and drift outwards again. We quantify the force balance and drift velocities
for the disks LkCa15 and HD135344B. We simulate single particle evolution and
show that this scenario is viable. Growth and drift timescales are on the same
order and a steady state can be established in the inner dust ring.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.01022 [pdf] - 1477614
Photophoresis on particles hotter/colder than the ambient gas in the
free molecular flow
Submitted: 2016-04-26, last modified: 2016-09-08
Aerosol particles experience significant photophoretic forces at low
pressure. Previous work assumed the average particle temperature to be very
close to the gas temperature. This might not always be the case. If the
particle temperature or the thermal radiation field differs significantly from
the gas temperature (optically thin gases), given approximations overestimate
the photophoretic force by an order of magnitude on average with maximum errors
up to more than three magnitudes. We therefore developed a new general
approximation which on average only differs by 1 % from the true value.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.00501 [pdf] - 1473481
Failed Growth at the Bouncing Barrier in Planetesimal Formation
Submitted: 2016-09-02
In laboratory experiments, we studied collisions of ensembles of compact
(filling factor 0.33) millimeter dust aggregates composed of micrometer quartz
grains. We used cylindrical aggregates, triangular aggregates, square
aggregates, and rectangular aggregates. Ensembles of equal size aggregates as
well as ensembles with embedded larger aggregates were studied. The typical
collision velocities are 10-20 mm $\rm s^{-1}$. High spatial and temporal
resolution imaging unambiguously shows that individual collisions lead to
sticking with a high probability of 20 percent. This leads to connected
clusters of aggregates. The contact areas between two aggregates increase with
collision velocity. However, this cluster growth is only temporary, as
subsequent collisions of aggregates and clusters eventually lead to the
detachment of all aggregates from a cluster. The contacts are very fragile as
aggregates cannot be compressed further or fragment under our experimental
conditions to enhance the contact stability. Therefore, the evolution of the
ensemble always leads back to a distribution of individual aggregates of
initial size. This supports and extends earlier experiments showing that a
bouncing barrier in planetesimal formation would be robust against shape and
size variations.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.05017 [pdf] - 1461004
Ice Grain Collisions in Comparison: CO$_2$, H$_2$O and their Mixtures
Submitted: 2016-08-17
Collisions of ice particles play an important role in the formation of
planetesimals and comets. In recent work we showed, that CO$_2$ ice behaves
like silicates in collisions. The resulting assumption was that it should
therefore stick less efficiently than H$_2$O ice. Within this paper a
quantification of the latter is presented. We used the same experimental setup
to study collisions of pure CO$_2$ ice, pure water ice and 50\% mixtures by
mass between CO$_2$ and water at 80K, 1 mbar and an average particle size of
$\sim 90 \mu$m. The results show a strong increase of the threshold velocity
between sticking and bouncing with increasing water content. This supports the
idea that water ice is favorable for early growth phases of planets in a zone
within the H$_2$O and the CO$_2$ iceline.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.08141 [pdf] - 1381656
Amplification of dust loading in Martian dust devils by self-shadowing
Submitted: 2016-03-26
Insolation of the Martian soil leads to a sub-surface overpressure due to
thermal creep gas flow. This could support particle entrainment into the
atmosphere. Short time shadowing e.g. by the traverse of a larger dust devil
would enhance this effect. We find in microgravity experiments that mass
ejection rates are increased by a factor of 10 for several seconds if a light
source of 12.6 kW/$\rm m^2$ is turned off. Scaled to Mars this implies that
self-shadowing of a partially opaque dust devil might lead to a strongly
amplified flux of lifted material. We therefore suggest that self-shadowing
might be a mechanism on Mars to increase the total dust loading of a dust devil
and keep it self-sustained.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1601.04854 [pdf] - 1353226
Collisions of CO$_2$ Ice Grains in Planet Formation
Submitted: 2016-01-19
In protoplanetary disks, CO$_2$ is solid ice beyond its snow line at $\sim 10
\rm AU$. Due to its high abundance, it contributes heavily to the collisional
evolution in this region of the disk. For the first time, we carried out
laboratory collision experiments with CO$_2$ ice particles and a CO$_2$-covered
wall at a temperature of 80 K. Collision velocities varied between 0 - 2.5 m/s.
Particle sizes were on the order of $\sim$ 100 $\mu$m. We find a threshold
velocity between the sticking and the bouncing regime at 0.04 m/s. Particles
with greater velocities but below 1 m/s bounce off the wall. For yet greater
velocities, fragmentation occurs. We give analytical models for the
coefficients of restitution and fragmentation strength consistent with the
experimental data. Set in context, our data show that CO$_2$ ice and silicate
dust resemble each other in the collisional behavior. Compared to water ice the
sticking velocity is an order of magnitude smaller. One immediate consequence
as example is that water ice particles mantled by CO$_2$ ice lose any "sticking
advantage." In this case, preferential planetesimal growth attributed to the
sticking properties of water ice will be limited to the region between the
H$_2$O ice line and the CO$_2$ ice line.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1508.01047 [pdf] - 1259215
Thermal creep assisted dust lifting on Mars: Wind tunnel experiments for
the entrainment threshold velocity
Submitted: 2015-08-05
In this work we present laboratory measurements on the reduction of the
threshold friction velocity necessary for lifting dust if the dust bed is
illuminated. Insolation of a porous soil establishes a temperature gradient. At
low ambient pressure this gradient leads to thermal creep gas flow within the
soil. This flow leads to a sub-surface overpressure which supports lift imposed
by wind. The wind tunnel was run with Mojave Mars Simulant and air at 3, 6 and
9 mbar, to cover most of the pressure range at martian surface levels. Our
first measurements imply that the insolation of the martian surface can reduce
the entrainment threshold velocity between 4 % and 19 % for the conditions
sampled with our experiments. An insolation activated soil might therefore
provide additional support for aeolian particle transport at low wind speeds.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.05764 [pdf] - 1249204
An Insolation Activated Dust Layer on Mars
Submitted: 2015-07-21
The illuminated dusty surface of Mars acts like a gas pump. It is driven by
thermal creep at low pressure within the soil. In the top soil layer this gas
flow has to be sustained by a pressure gradient. This is equivalent to a
lifting force on the dust grains. The top layer is therefore under tension
which reduces the threshold wind speed for saltation. We carried out laboratory
experiments to quantify the thickness of this activated layer. We use basalt
with an average particle size of 67 $\mu$m. We find a depth of the active layer
of 100 to 200 $\rm \mu m$. Scaled to Mars the activation will reduce threshold
wind speeds for saltation by about 10%.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1408.1813 [pdf] - 1388056
Photophoretic Strength on Chondrules. 2. Experiment
Submitted: 2014-08-08
Photophoretic motion can transport illuminated particles in protoplanetary
disks. In a previous paper we focused on the modeling of steady state
photophoretic forces based on the compositions derived from tomography and heat
transfer. Here, we present microgravity experiments which deviate significantly
from the steady state calculations of the first paper. The experiments on
average show a significantly smaller force than predicted with a large
variation in absolute photophoretic force and in the direction of motion with
respect to the illumination. Time-dependent modeling of photophoretic forces
for heat-up and rotation show that the variations in strength and direction
observed can be well explained by the particle reorientation in the limited
experiment time of a drop tower experiment. In protoplanetary disks, random
rotation subsides due to gas friction on short timescales and the results of
our earlier paper hold. Rotation has a significant influence in short duration
laboratory studies. Observing particle motion and rotation under the influence
of photophoresis can be considered as a basic laboratory analog experiment to
Yarkovsky and YORP effects.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1401.4280 [pdf] - 805893
Experimental Study on Bouncing Barriers in Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2014-01-17, last modified: 2014-04-03
For dust aggregates in protoplanetary discs a transition between sticking and
bouncing in individual collisions at mm to cm size has been observed in the
past. This lead to the notion of a bouncing barrier for which growth gets
stalled. Here, we present long term laboratory experiments on the outcome of
repeated aggregate collisions at the bouncing barrier. About 100 SiO$_2$ dust
aggregates of 1 mm in size were observed interacting with each other.
Collisions occured within a velocity range from below mm/s up to cm/s.
Aggregates continuously interacted with each other over a period of 900 s.
During this time more than $10^5$ collisions occured. Nearly 2000 collisions
were analyzed in detail. No temporal stable net growth of larger aggregates was
observed even though sticking collision occur. Larger ensembles of aggregates
sticking together are formed but were disassembled again during the further
collisional evolution. The concept of a bouncing barrier supports the formation
of planetesimals by seeded collisional growth as well as by gravitational
instability favouring a significant total mass being limited to certain size
ranges. Within our parameter set the experiments confirm that bouncing barriers
are one possible and likely evolutionary limit of a self consistent particle
growth.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1311.6651 [pdf] - 752953
Preplanetary scavengers: Growing tall in dust collisions
Submitted: 2013-11-26, last modified: 2013-11-28
Dust collisions in protoplanetary disks are one means to grow planetesimals,
but the destructive or constructive nature of high speed collisions is still
unsettled. In laboratory experiments, we study the self-consistent evolution of
a target upon continuous impacts of submm dust aggregates at collision
velocities of up to 71m/s. Earlier studies analyzed individual collisions,
which were more speculative for high velocities and low projectile masses.
Here, we confirm earlier findings that high speed collisions result in mass
gain of the target. We also quantify the accretion efficiency for the used SiO2
(quartz) dust sample. For two different average masses of dust aggregates
(0.29g and 2.67g) accretion efficiencies are decreasing with velocity from 58%
to 18% and from 25% to 7% at 27m/s to 71m/s, respectively. The accretion
efficiency decreases approximately as logarithmic with impact energy. At the
impact velocity of 49m/s the target acquires a volume filling factor of 38%.
These data extend earlier work that pointed to the filling factor leveling off
at 8m/s to a value of 33%. Our results imply that high speed collisions are an
important mode of particle evolution. It especially allows existing large
bodies to grow further by scavenging smaller aggregates with high efficiency.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1311.6660 [pdf] - 1388052
Photophoretic Strength on Chondrules 1: Modeling
Submitted: 2013-11-26
Photophoresis is a physical process that transports particles in optical thin
parts of protoplanetary disks, especially at the inner edge and at the
optically surface. To model the transport and resulting effects in detail, it
is necessary to quantify the strength of photophoresis for different particle
classes as a fundamental input. Here, we explore photophoresis for a set of
chondrules. The composition and surface morphology of these chondrules was
measured by X-ray tomography. Based on the three-dimensional models, heat
transfer through illuminated chondrules was calculated. The resulting surface
temperature map was then used to calculate the photophoretic strength. We found
that irregularities in particle shape and variations in composition induce
variations in the photophoretic force. These depend on the orientation of a
particle with respect to the light source. The variations of the absolute value
of the photophoretic force on average over all chondrules is $4.17\%$. The
deviation between the direction of the photophoretic force and illumination is
$3.0^\circ \pm 1.5^\circ$. The average photophoretic force can be well
approximated and calculated analytically assuming a homogeneous sphere with a
volume equivalent mean radius and an effective thermal conductivity. We found
an analytic expression for the effective thermal conductivity. The expression
depends on the two main phases of a chondrule, and decreases with the amount of
fine-grained devitrified, plagioclase-normative mesostasis up to factor of
three. For the chondrule sample studied (Bjurb\"ole chondrite), we found a
dependence of the photophoretic force on chondrule size.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1311.1957 [pdf] - 744088
Ice aggregate contacts at the nm-scale
Submitted: 2013-11-08
Aggregation of ice particles is a fundamental process in the interstellar
medium as well as in planet formation. Dedicated to study the contact physics
of nm-ice particles we developed a thermal gradient force microscope. This
allows us and was used to measure pull-off forces with a resolution on the
nN-scale and to measure rolling. Furthermore, based on a free probe, it also
allows us to study twisting torques for the first time. The experiments show
that torques required to twist are significantly larger than that macroscopic
models scaled down to the nm-size range would predict. This implies that (ice)
aggregates in astrophysical settings with small constituents are more robust
against restructuring than previously thought. They likely grow as fractal
aggregates to larger size before they restructure and during later compact
growth they likely retain a higher porosity during further evolution towards
planetesimals.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.3967 [pdf] - 719532
Radiative forces on macroscopic porous bodies in protoplanetary disks:
laboratory experiments
Submitted: 2013-09-16
In optically thin parts of protoplanetary disks photophoresis is a
significant force not just for dust grains, but also for macroscopic bodies.
The absolute strength on the supposedly highly porous objects is not known in
detail as yet. We set up a low pressure torsion balance and studied
photophoretic forces. We investigated the dependence on plate dimensions and on
ambient pressure and considered the influence of channels through the plates.
As samples for full (no channel) plates we used tissue with 2mm thickness and
circular shape with diameters of 10mm, 30mm and 50mm. The influence of channels
was probed on rectangular-shaped circuit boards of 35mm x 35mm area and 1.5mm
thickness. The number of channels was 169 and 352. At low pressure, the
absolute photophoretic force is proportional to the cross section of the
plates. At high pressure, gas flow through the channels enhances the
photophoretic force. The pressure dependence of the radiative force can
(formally) be calculated by photophoresis on particles with a characteristic
length. We derived two characteristic length scales l depending on the plate
radius r_1, the channel radius r_2, and the thickness of the plate which equals
the length of the channel d as l=r^{0.35} x d^{0.65}. The highest force is
found at a pressure p_max = 15 x l^{-1}Pa mm. In total, the photophoretic force
on a plate with channels can be well described by a superposition of the two
components: photophoresis due to the overall size and cross section of the
plate and photophoresis due to the channels, both with their characteristic
pressure dependencies. We applied these results to the transport of large
solids in protoplanetary disks and found that the influence of porosity on the
photophoretic force can reverse the inward drift of large solids, for instance
meter-sized bodies, and push them outward within the optically thin parts of
the disk.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1308.0921 [pdf] - 1173201
Accretion through the inner edges of protoplanetary disks by a giant
solid state pump
Submitted: 2013-08-05
At the inner edge of a protoplanetary disk solids are illuminated by stellar
light. This illumination heats the solids and creates temperature gradients
along their surfaces. Interactions with ambient gas molecules lead to a radial
net gas flow. Every illuminated solid particle within the edge is an individual
small gas pump transporting gas inward. In total the inner edge can provide
local mass flow rates as high as $\dot{M} = 10^{-5} M_{\odot}$ yr$^{-1}$.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.0689 [pdf] - 1166392
Photophoretic separation of metals and silicates: the formation of
Mercury like planets and metal depletion in chondrites
Submitted: 2013-05-03
Mercury's high uncompressed mass density suggests that the planet is largely
composed of iron, either bound within metal (mainly Fe-Ni), or iron sulfide.
Recent results from the MESSENGER mission to Mercury imply a low temperature
history of the planet which questions the standard formation models of impact
mantle stripping or evaporation to explain the high metal content. Like
Mercury, the two smallest extrasolar rocky planets with mass and size
determination, CoRoT-7b and Kepler-10b, were found to be of high density. As
they orbit close to their host stars this indicates that iron rich inner
planets might not be a nuisance of the solar system but be part of a general
scheme of planet formation. From undifferentiated chondrites it is also known
that the metal to silicate ratio is highly variable which must be ascribed to
pre-planetary fractionation processes. Due to this fractionation most
chondritic parent bodies - most of them originated in the asteroid belt - are
depleted in iron relative to average solar system abundances. The astrophysical
processes leading to metal silicate fractionation in the solar nebula are
essentially unknown. Here, we consider photophoretic forces. As these forces
particularly act on irradiated solids, they might play a significant role for
the composition of planetesimals forming at the inner edge of protoplanetary
discs. Photophoresis can separate high thermal conductivity materials (iron)
from lower thermal conductivity solids (silicate). We suggest that the
silicates are preferentially pushed into the optical thick disk. Subsequent
planetesimal formation at the edge moving outwards leads to metal rich
planetesimals close to the star and metal depleted planetesimals further out in
the nebula.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:1301.1874 [pdf] - 1248473
From Planetesimals to Dust: Low Gravity Experiments on Recycling Solids
at the Inner Edge of Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2013-01-09
Transporting solids of different sizes is an essential process in the
evolution of protoplanetary disks and planet formation. Large solids are
supposed to drift inward; high-temperature minerals found in comets are assumed
to have been transported outward. From low-gravity experiments on parabolic
flights we studied the light-induced erosion of dusty bodies caused by a
solid-state greenhouse effect and photophoresis within a dust bed's upper
layers. The gravity levels studied were 0.16g, 0.38g, 1g, and 1.7g. The light
flux during the experiments was 12 +/- 2 kW/m^2 and the ambient pressure was 6
+/- 0.9 mbar. Light-induced erosion is strongly gravity dependent, which is in
agreement with a developed model. In particular for small dusty bodies
((sub)-planetesimals), efficient erosion is possible at the optically thin
inner edges of protoplanetary disks. Light-induced erosion prevents significant
parts of a larger body from moving too close to the host star and be being
subsequently accreted. The small dust produced continues to be subject to
photophoresis and is partially transported upward and outward over the surface
of the disk; the resulting small dust particles observed over the disk's
lifetime. The fraction of eroded dust participates in subsequent cycles of
growth during planetesimal formation. Another fraction of dust might be
collected by a body of planetary size if this body is already present close to
the disk edge. Either way, light induced erosion is an efficient recycling
process in protoplanetary disks.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.3656 [pdf] - 1388048
Thermal and Photophoretic Properties of Dust Mantled Chondrules and
Sorting in the Solar Nebula
Submitted: 2012-07-16, last modified: 2012-08-24
Many chondrules are found to be surrounded by a fine grained rim. Supposedly,
these rims were acquired from dust accreted to the chondrules in a
protoplanetary disk. In numerical simulations we study the heat transfer in
illuminated bare and dust mantled chondrules. The calculations consider the
chondrule size, the dust mantle size, and the thermal conductivities of both
components as parameters. We calculate the photophoretic force and compare the
numerical results to analytical approximations. We give an expression to
quantify the photophoretic force on a spherical particle in the free molecular
regime to better than 2%. We describe the influence of a dust mantle on the
photophoretic strength by an effective thermal conductivity of the core-mantle
particle. The effective thermal conductivity significantly depends on the size
ratio between mantle and chondrule but not on the absolute sizes. It also
strongly depends on the thermal conductivity of the mantle with minor influence
of the thermal conductivity of the chondrule. The size ratio between rim and
chondrule in meteorites is found to vary systematically with overall size by
other authors. Based on this, our calculations show that a photophoretic size
sorting can occur for dust mantled chondrules in optically thin disks or at the
evolving inner edge of the solar nebula.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.3669 [pdf] - 1124848
Experiments on centimeter-sized dust aggregates and their implications
for planetesimal formation
Submitted: 2012-07-16
The first macroscopic bodies in protoplanetary disks are dust aggregates. We
report on a number of experimental studies with dust aggregates formed from
micron-size quartz grains. We confirm in laboratory collision experiments an
earlier finding that producing macroscopic bodies by the random impact of
sub-mm aggregates results in a well-defined upper-filling factor of 0.31 \pm
0.01. Compared to earlier experiments, we increase the projectile mass by about
a factor of 100. The collision experiments also show that a highly porous
dust-aggregate can retain its highly porous core if collisions get more
energetic and a denser shell forms on top of the porous core. We measure the
mechanical properties of cm-sized dust samples of different filling factors
between 0.34 and 0.50. The tensile strength measured by a Brazilian test,
varies between 1 kPa and 6 kPa. The sound speed is determined by a runtime
measurement to range between 80 m/s and 140 m/s while Young's modulus is
derived from the sound speed and varies between 7MPa and 25MPa. The samples
were also subjected to quasi-static omni- and uni-directional compression
todetermine their compression strengths and flow functions. Applied to planet
formation, our experiments provide basic data for future simulations, explain
the specific collisional outcomes observed in earlier experiments, and in
general support a scenario where collisional growth of planetesimals is
possible.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.1234 [pdf] - 533675
Crossing barriers in planetesimal formation: The growth of mm-dust
aggregates with large constituent grains
Submitted: 2012-07-05
Collisions of mm-size dust aggregates play a crucial role in the early phases
of planet formation. We developed a laboratory setup to observe collisions of
dust aggregates levitating at mbar pressures and elevated temperatures of 800
K. We report on collisions between basalt dust aggregates of from 0.3 to 5 mm
in size at velocities between 0.1 and 15 cm/s. Individual grains are smaller
than 25 \mum in size. We find that for all impact energies in the studied range
sticking occurs at a probability of 32.1 \pm 2.5% on average. In general, the
sticking probability decreases with increasing impact parameter. The sticking
probability increases with energy density (impact energy per contact area). We
also observe collisions of aggregates that were formed by a previous sticking
of two larger aggregates. Partners of these aggregates can be detached by a
second collision with a probability of on average 19.8 \pm 4.0%. The measured
accretion efficiencies are remarkably high compared to other experimental
results. We attribute this to the rel. large dust grains used in our
experiments, which make aggregates more susceptible to restructuring and energy
dissipation. Collisional hardening by compaction might not occur as the
aggregates are already very compact with only 54 \pm 1% porosity. The
disassembly of previously grown aggregates in collisions might stall further
aggregate growth. However, owing to the levitation technique and the limited
data statistics, no conclusive statement about this aspect can yet be given. We
find that the detachment efficiency decreases with increasing velocities and
accretion dominates in the higher velocity range. For high accretion
efficiencies, our experiments suggest that continued growth in the mm-range
with larger constituent grains would be a viable way to produce larger
aggregates, which might in turn form the seeds to proceed to growing
planetesimals.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.1066 [pdf] - 434548
A Mechanism to Produce the Small Dust Observed in Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2011-11-04
Small (sub)-micron dust is present over the entire lifetime of protoplanetary
disks. As aggregation readily depletes small particles, one explanation might
be that dust is continuously generated by larger bodies in the midplane and
transported to the surface of the disks. In general, in a first step of this
scenario, the larger bodies have to be destroyed again and different mechanisms
exist with the potential to accomplish this. Possible destructive mechanisms
are fragmentation in collisions, erosion by gas drag or light induced erosion.
In laboratory experiments we find that the latter, light induced erosion by
Knudsen compression and photophoresis, can provide small particles. It might be
a preferred candidate as the dust is released into a low particle density
region. The working principle of this mechanism prevents or decreases the
likelihood for instant re-accretion or re-growth of large dense aggregates.
Provided that there is a particle lift, e.g. turbulence, these particles might
readily reach the surface of the disk.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:1110.3675 [pdf] - 1084900
The implications of particle rotation on the effect of photophoresis
Submitted: 2011-10-17
In a laboratory experiment, water-ice aggregates are trapped in a vacuum
chamber at a pressure of 2 mbar due to photophoresis and thermophoresis. The
particles are located between a Peltier element at the bottom at 250 K and a
reservoir of liquid nitrogen at the top at 77 K. Particle sizes vary between 20
micrometres and a few hundred micrometres. It is found that 95% of all the
particles rotate about their vertical axis. A qualitative model is developed
which explains why particles should mainly align to and rotate around the
vertical. The results imply that rotation does not decrease the vertical
strength of photophoretically driven motion in, e.g., protoplanetary discs.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:1108.1271 [pdf] - 431821
Porosities of Protoplanetary Dust Agglomerates from Collision
Experiments
Submitted: 2011-08-05
Aggregation of dust through sticking collisions is the first step of planet
formation. Basic physical properties of the evolving dust aggregates strongly
depend on the porosity of the aggregates, e.g. mechanical strength, thermal
conductivity, gas-grain coupling time. Also the outcome of further collisions
depends on the porosity of the colliding aggregates. In laboratory experiments
we study the growth of large aggregates of $\sim$ 3 mm to 3 cm through
continuous impacts of small dust agglomerates of 100 $\mu$m size, consisting of
$\mu$m grains at different impact velocities. The experiments show that
agglomerates grow by direct sticking as well as gravitational reaccretion. The
latter can be regarded as suitable analog to reaccretion of fragments by gas
drag in protoplanetary disks. Experiments were carried out in the velocity
range between 1.5 m/s and 7 m/s. With increasing impact velocities the volume
filling factor of the resulting agglomerates increases from $\phi = 0.2$ for
1.5 m/s to $\phi = 0.32$ for 7 m/s. These values are independent of the target
size. Extrapolation of the measured velocity dependence of the volume filling
factor implies that higher collision velocities will not lead to more compact
aggregates. Therefore, $\phi = 0.32$ marks a degree of compaction suitable to
describe structures forming at $\rm v > 6\, m/s$. At small collision velocities
below 1 m/s highly porous structures with $\phi \approx 0.10$ will form. For
intermediate collision velocities porosities vary. Depending on the disk model
and resulting relative velocities, objects in protoplanetary disks up to
dm-size might evolve from highly porous ($\phi \approx 0.10$) to compact ($\phi
= 0.32$) with a more complex intermediate size range of varying porosity.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:1108.0785 [pdf] - 420074
Impact Angle Influence in High Velocity Dust Collisions during
Planetesimal Formation
Submitted: 2011-08-03
We have examined the influence of impact angle in collisions between small
dust aggregates and larger dust targets through laboratory experiments. Targets
consisted of \mum-sized quartz dust and had a porosity of about 67%; the
projectiles, between 1 and 5 mm in diameter, were slightly more compact (64%
porosity). The collision velocity was centered at 20 m/s and impact angles
range from 0{\deg} to 45{\deg}. At a given impact angle, the target gained mass
for projectiles smaller than a threshold size, which decreases with increasing
angle from about 3 mm to 1 mm. The fact that growth is possible up to the
largest angles studied supports the idea of planetesimal formation by sweep-up
of small dust aggregates.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:1108.0794 [pdf] - 394429
Decimetre dust aggregates in protoplanetary discs
Submitted: 2011-08-03
The growth of planetesimals is an essential step in planet formation.
Decimetre-size dust agglomerates mark a transition point in this growth
process. In laboratory experiments we simulated the formation, evolution, and
properties of decimetre-scale dusty bodies in protoplanetary discs. Small
sub-mm size dust aggregates consisting of micron-size SiO$_2$ particles
randomly interacted with dust targets of varying initial conditions in a
continuous sequence of independent collisions. Impact velocities were 7.7 m/s
on average and in the range expected for collisions with decimetre bodies in
protoplanetary discs. The targets all evolved by forming dust \emph{crusts}
with up to several cm thickness and a unique filling factor of 31% $\pm$3%. A
part of the projectiles sticks directly. In addition, some projectile fragments
slowly return to the target by gravity. All initially porous parts of the
surface, i.e. built from the slowly returning fragments, are compacted and
firmly attached to the underlying dust layers by the subsequent impacts. Growth
is possible at impact angles from 0$^{\circ}$ (central collision) to
70$^{\circ}$. No growth occurs at steeper dust surfaces. We measured the
velocity, angle, and size distribution of collision fragments. The average
restitution coefficient is 3.8% or 0.29 m/s ejection velocity. Ejecta sizes are
comparable to the projectile sizes. The high filling factor is close to the
most compact configuration of dust aggregates by local compression ($\sim
33$%). This implies that the history of the surface formation and target growth
is completely erased. In view of this, the filling factor of 31% seems to be a
universal value in the collision experiments of all self-consistently evolving
targets at the given impact velocities. We suggest that decimetre and probably
larger bodies can simply be characterised by one single filling factor.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:1108.0805 [pdf] - 1521894
Breaking the Ice: Planetesimal Formation at the Snowline
Submitted: 2011-08-03
Recently Saito & Sirono (2011) proposed that large ice aggregates which drift
in- wards in protoplanetary disks break up during sublimation, ejecting
embedded silicate particles. This would lead to a concentration of small solid
particles close to the snow- line. In view of this model we carried out
laboratory experiments where we observed freely levitating ice aggregates
sublimating. We find that frequent break up is indeed very common. Scaled to a
10 cm aggregate about 2x10^4 small silicate aggregates might result. This
supports the idea that sublimation of drifting ice aggregates might locally
increase the density of small dust (silicate) particles which might more easily
be swept up by larger dust aggregates or trigger gravitational instability.
Either way this might locally boost the formation of planetesimals at the
snowline.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:1105.6259 [pdf] - 1076988
Photophoretic transport of hot minerals in the solar nebula
Submitted: 2011-05-31
Hot temperature minerals have been detected in a large number of comets and
were also identified in the samples of Comet Wild 2 that were returned by the
Stardust mission. Meanwhile, observations of the distribution of hot minerals
in young stellar systems suggest that these materials were produced in the
inner part of the primordial nebula and have been transported outward in the
formation zone of comets. We investigate the possibility that photophoresis
provides a viable mechanism to transport high-temperature materials from the
inner solar system to the regions in which the comets were forming. We use a
grid of time-dependent disk models of the solar nebula to quantify the distance
range at which hot minerals can be transported from the inner part of the disk
toward its outer regions as a function of their size and density. The particles
considered here are in the form of aggregates that presumably were assembled
from hot mineral individual grains ranging down to submicron sizes and formed
by condensation within the hottest portion of the solar nebula. Our
particle-transport model includes the photophoresis, radiation pressure, and
gas drag. Depending on the postulated disk parameters and the density of
particles, 10-2 to 10-1 m aggregates can reach heliocentric distances up to 35
AU in the primordial nebula over very short timescales (no more than a few
hundred thousand years). 10-3 m particles follow the same trajectory as the
larger ones but their maximum migration distance does not exceed 26 AU and is
reached at later epochs in the disks. On the other hand, 10-5 to 10-4 m
aggregates are continuously pushed outward during the evolution of the solar
nebula. Our simulations suggest that irrespective of the employed solar nebula
model, photophoresis is a mechanism that can explain the presence of hot
temperature minerals in the formation region of comets.
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:1102.4441 [pdf] - 1052260
Low-velocity collisions of centimeter-sized dust aggregates
Submitted: 2011-02-22, last modified: 2011-05-02
Collisions between centimeter- to decimeter-sized dusty bodies are important
to understand the mechanisms leading to the formation of planetesimals. We thus
performed laboratory experiments to study the collisional behavior of dust
aggregates in this size range at velocities below and around the fragmentation
threshold. We developed two independent experimental setups with the same goal
to study the effects of bouncing, fragmentation, and mass transfer in free
particle-particle collisions. The first setup is an evacuated drop tower with a
free-fall height of 1.5 m, providing us with 0.56 s of microgravity time so
that we observed collisions with velocities between 8 mm/s and 2 m/s. The
second setup is designed to study the effect of partial fragmentation (when
only one of the two aggregates is destroyed) and mass transfer in more detail.
It allows for the measurement of the accretion efficiency as the samples are
safely recovered after the encounter. Our results are that for very low
velocities we found bouncing as could be expected while the fragmentation
velocity of 20 cm/s was significantly lower than expected. We present the
critical energy for disruptive collisions Q*, which showed up to be at least
two orders of magnitude lower than previous experiments in the literature. In
the wide range between bouncing and disruptive collisions, only one of the
samples fragmented in the encounter while the other gained mass. The accretion
efficiency in the order of a few percent of the particle's mass is depending on
the impact velocity and the sample porosity. Our results will have consequences
for dust evolution models in protoplanetary disks as well as for the strength
of large, porous planetesimal bodies.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:1102.4525 [pdf] - 321296
Dust Ejection from Planetary Bodies by Temperature Gradients: Laboratory
Experiments
Submitted: 2011-02-22
Laboratory experiments show that dusty bodies in a gaseous environment eject
dust particles if they are illuminated. We find that even more intense dust
eruptions occur when the light source is turned off. We attribute this to a
compression of gas by thermal creep in response to the changing temperature
gradients in the top dust layers. The effect is studied at a light flux of 13
kW/(m*m) and 1 mbar ambient pressure. The effect is applicable to
protoplanetary disks and Mars. In the inner part of protoplanetary disks,
planetesimals can be eroded especially at the terminator of a rotating body.
This leads to the production of dust which can then be transported towards the
disk edges or the outer disk regions. The generated dust might constitute a
significant fraction of the warm dust observed in extrasolar protoplanetary
disks. We estimate erosion rates of about 1 kg/s for 100 m parent bodies. The
dust might also contribute to subsequent planetary growth in different
locations or on existing protoplanets which are large enough not to be
susceptible to particle loss by light induced ejection. Due to the ejections,
planetesimals and smaller bodies will be accelerated or decelerated and drift
outward or inward, respectively. The effect might also explain the entrainment
of dust in dust devils on Mars, especially at high altitudes where gas drag
alone might not be sufficient.
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:1003.2924 [pdf] - 130447
Experiments on the Photophoretic Motion of Chondrules and Dust
Aggregates - Indications for the Transport of Matter in Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2010-03-15
In a set of 16 drop tower experiments the motion of sub-mm to mm-sized
particles under microgravity was observed. Illumination by a halogen lamp
induced acceleration of the particles due to photophoresis. Photophoresis on
dust-free chondrules, on chondrules, glass spheres and metal spheres covered
with SiC dust and on pure SiC dust aggregates was studied. This is the first
time that photophoretic motion of mm-sized particles has been studied
experimentally. The absolute values for the photophoretic force are consistent
with theoretical expectations for spherical particles. The strength of the
photophoretic force varies for chondrules, dust covered particles and pure dust
from low to strong, respectively. The measurements support the idea that
photophoresis in the early Solar System can be efficient to transport solid
particles outward.
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:0901.4235 [pdf] - 20724
High Velocity Dust Collisions: Forming Planetesimals in a Fragmentation
Cascade with Final Accretion
Submitted: 2009-01-27
In laboratory experiments we determine the mass gain and loss in central
collisions between cm to dm-size SiO2 dust targets and sub-mm to cm-size SiO2
dust projectiles of varying mass, size, shape, and at different collision
velocities up to ~56.5 m/s. Dust projectiles much larger than 1 mm lead to a
small amount of erosion of the target but decimetre targets do not break up.
Collisions produce ejecta which are smaller than the incoming projectile.
Projectiles smaller than 1 mm are accreted by a target even at the highest
collision velocities. This implies that net accretion of decimetre and larger
bodies is possible. Independent of the original size of a projectile
considered, after several collisions all fragments will be of sub-mm size which
might then be (re)-accreted in the next collision with a larger body. The
experimental data suggest that collisional growth through fragmentation and
reaccretion is a viable mechanism to form planetesimals.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:0709.1259 [pdf] - 4738
Light-induced disassembly of dusty bodies in inner protoplanetary discs:
implications for the formation of planets
Submitted: 2007-09-09
Laboratory experiments show that a solid-state greenhouse effect in
combination with thermophoresis can efficiently erode a dust bed in a
low-pressure gaseous environment. The surface of an illuminated, light
absorbing dusty body is cooler than the dust below the surface (solidstate
greenhouse effect). This temperature gradient leads to a directed momentum
transfer between gas and dust particles and the dust particles are subject to a
force towards the surface(thermophoresis). If the thermophoretic force is
stronger than gravity and cohesion, dust particles are ejected. Applied to
protoplanetary discs, dusty bodies smaller than several kilometres in size
which are closer to a star than about 0.4 au are subject to a rapid and
complete disassembly to submillimetre size dust aggregates by this process.
While an inward-drifting dusty body is destroyed, the generated dust is not
lost for the disc by sublimation or subsequent accretion on to the star but can
be reprocessed by photophoresis or radiation pressure. Planetesimals cannot
originate through aggregation of dust inside the erosion zone. If objects
larger than several kilometres already exist, they prevail and further grow by
collecting dust from disassembled smaller bodies. The pile-up of solids in a
confined inner region of the disc, in general, boosts the formation of planets.
Erosion is possible in even strongly gas-depleted inner regions as observed for
TW Hya. Reprocessing of dust through light-induced erosion offers one possible
explanation for growth of large cores of gas-poor giant planets in a
gas-starved region as recently found around HD 149026b.
[55]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0611757 [pdf] - 87143
The photophoretic sweeping of dust in transient protoplanetary disks
Submitted: 2006-11-24
Protoplanetary disks start their lives with a dust free inner region where
the temperatures are higher than the sublimation temperature of solids. As the
star illuminates the innermost particles, which are immersed in gas at the
sublimation edge, these particles are subject to a photophoretic force. We
examine the motion of dust particles at the inner edge of protoplanetary disks
due to photophoretic drag. We find that, in a laminar disk, photophoretic drag
increases the size of the inner hole after accretion onto the central body has
become subdued. This region within the hole becomes an optically transparent
zone containing gas and large dusty particles (>>10 cm), but devoid of, or
strongly depleted in, smaller dust aggregates. Photophoresis can clear the
inner disk of dust out to 10 AU in less than 1 Myr. At late times, the edge
reaches a stable equilibrium between inward drift and photophoretic outward
drift, at a distance of some tens of AU. Eventually, the edge will move inwards
again as the disk disperses, shifting the equilibrium position back from about
40 AU to below 30 AU in 1-2 Myr in the disk model. In a turbulent disk,
diffusion can delay the clearing of a disk by photophoresis. Smaller and/or
age-independent holes of radii of a few AU are also possible outcomes of
turbulent diffusion counteracting photophoresis. This outward and then inward
moving edge marks a region of high dust concentration. This density
enhancement, and the efficient transport of particles from close to the star to
large distances away, can explain features of comets such as high measured
ratios of crystalline to amorphous silicates, and has a large number of other
applications.
[56]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0602617 [pdf] - 80193
Growth of Dust as the Initial Step Toward Planet Formation
Submitted: 2006-02-28
We discuss the results of laboratory measurements and theoretical models
concerning the aggregation of dust in protoplanetary disks, as the initial step
toward planet formation. Small particles easily stick when they collide and
form aggregates with an open, often fractal structure, depending on the growth
process. Larger particles are still expected to grow at collision velocities of
about 1m/s. Experiments also show that, after an intermezzo of destructive
velocities, high collision velocities above 10m/s on porous materials again
lead to net growth of the target. Considerations of dust-gas interactions show
that collision velocities for particles not too different in surface-to-mass
ratio remain limited up to sizes about 1m, and growth seems to be guaranteed to
reach these sizes quickly and easily. For meter sizes, coupling to nebula
turbulence makes destructive processes more likely. Global aggregation models
show that in a turbulent nebula, small particles are swept up too fast to be
consistent with observations of disks. An extended phase may therefore exist in
the nebula during which the small particle component is kept alive through
collisions driven by turbulence which frustrates growth to planetesimals until
conditions are more favorable for one or more reasons.