Normalized to: Walsworth, R.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.09830 [pdf] - 2089239
The spectral impact of magnetic activity on disk-integrated HARPS-N
solar observations: exploring new activity indicators
Thompson, A. P. G.;
Watson, C. A.;
Haywood, R. D.;
Costes, J. C.;
de Mooij, E.;
Cameron, A. Collier;
Dumusque, X.;
Phillips, D. F.;
Saar, S. H.;
Mortier, A.;
Milbourne, T. W.;
Aigrain, S.;
Cegla, H. M.;
Charbonneau, D.;
Cosentino, R.;
Ghedina, A.;
Latham, D. W.;
López-Morales, M.;
Micela, G.;
Molinari, E.;
Poretti, E.;
Sozzetti, A.;
Thompson, S.;
Walsworth, R.
Submitted: 2020-04-21
Stellar activity is the major roadblock on the path to finding true
Earth-analogue planets with the Doppler technique. Thus, identifying new
indicators that better trace magnetic activity (i.e. faculae and spots) is
crucial to aid in disentangling these signals from that of a planet's Doppler
wobble. In this work, we investigate activity related features as seen in
disk-integrated spectra from the HARPS-N solar telescope. We divide
high-activity spectral echelle orders by low-activity master templates (as
defined using both log R'HK and images from the Solar Dynamics Observatory,
SDO), creating "relative spectra". With resolved images of the surface of the
Sun (via SDO), the faculae and spot filling factors can be calculated, giving a
measure of activity independent of, and in addition to, log R'HK. We find
pseudo-emission (and pseudo-absorption) features in the relative spectra that
are similar to those reported in our previous work on alpha Cen B. In alpha Cen
B, the features are shown to correlate better to changes in faculae filling
factor than spot filling factor. In this work we more confidently identify
changes in faculae coverage of the visible hemisphere of the Sun as the source
of features produced in the relative spectra. Finally, we produce trailed
spectra to observe the RV component of the features, which show that the
features move in a redward direction as one would expect when tracking active
regions rotating on the surface of a star.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.09038 [pdf] - 2032852
Testing the Spectroscopic Extraction of Suppression of Convective
Blueshift
Miklos, M.;
Milbourne, T. W.;
Haywood, R. D.;
Phillips, D. F.;
Saar, S. H.;
Meunier, N.;
Cegla, H. M.;
Dumusque, X.;
Langellier, N.;
Maldonado, J.;
Malavolta, L.;
Mortier, A.;
Thompson, S.;
Watson, C. A.;
Cecconi, M.;
Cosentino, R.;
Ghedina, A.;
Li, C-H.;
López-Morales, M.;
Molinari, E.;
Poretti, E.;
Sasselov, D.;
Sozzetti, A.;
Walsworth, R. L.
Submitted: 2019-10-20, last modified: 2020-01-15
Efforts to detect low-mass exoplanets using stellar radial velocities (RVs)
are currently limited by magnetic photospheric activity. Suppression of
convective blueshift is the dominant magnetic contribution to RV variability in
low-activity Sun-like stars. Due to convective plasma motions, the magnitude of
RV contributions from the suppression of convective blueshift is related to the
depth of formation of photospheric spectral lines of a given species used to
compute the RV time series. Meunier et al. (2017), used this relation to
demonstrate a method for spectroscopic extraction of the suppression of
convective blueshift in order to isolate RV contributions, including planetary
RVs, that contribute equally to the timeseries for each spectral line. Here, we
extract disk-integrated solar RVs from observations over a 2.5 year time span
made with the solar telescope integrated with the HARPS-N spectrograph at the
Telescopio Nazionale Galileo (La Palma, Canary Islands, Spain). We apply the
methods outlined by Meunier et al. (2017). We are not, however, able to isolate
physically meaningful contributions of the suppression of convective blueshift
from this solar dataset, potentially because our dataset is from solar minimum
when the suppression of convective blueshift may not sufficiently dominate
activity contributions to RVs. This result indicates that, for low-activity
Sun-like stars, one must include additional RV contributions from activity
sources not considered in the Meunier et al. (2017) model at different
timescales as well as instrumental variation in order to reach the sub-meter
per second RV sensitivity necessary to detect low-mass planets in orbit around
Sun-like stars.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.07578 [pdf] - 1951402
Probing Dark Matter Using Precision Measurements of Stellar
Accelerations
Submitted: 2018-12-18, last modified: 2019-08-29
Dark matter comprises the bulk of the matter in the universe but its particle
nature and cosmological origin remain mysterious. Knowledge of the dark matter
density distribution in the Milky Way Galaxy is crucial to both our
understanding of the standard cosmological model and for grounding direct and
indirect searches for the particles comprising dark matter. Current
measurements of Galactic dark matter content rely on model assumptions to infer
the forces acting upon stars from the distribution of observed velocities.
Here, we propose to apply the precision radial velocity method, optimized in
recent years for exoplanet astronomy, to measure the change in the velocity of
stars over time, thereby providing a direct probe of the local gravitational
potential in the Galaxy. Using numerical simulations, we develop a realistic
strategy to observe the differential accelerations of stars in our Galactic
neighborhood with next-generation telescopes, at the level of $10^{-8}$
cm/s$^{2}$. Our simulations show that detecting accelerations at this level
with an ensemble of $10^{3}$ stars requires the effect of stellar noise on
radial velocity measurements to be reduced to $<10$ cm/s. The measured stellar
accelerations may then be used to extract the local dark matter density and
morphological parameters of the density profile.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.12186 [pdf] - 1894339
Three years of Sun-as-a-star radial-velocity observations on the
approach to solar minimum
Cameron, A. Collier;
Mortier, A.;
Phillips, D.;
Dumusque, X.;
Haywood, R. D.;
Langellier, N.;
Watson, C. A.;
Cegla, H. M.;
Costes, J.;
Charbonneau, D.;
Coffinet, A.;
Latham, D. W.;
Lopez-Morales, M.;
Malavolta, L.;
Maldonado, J.;
Micela, G.;
Milbourne, T.;
Molinari, E.;
Saar, S. H.;
Thompson, S.;
Buchschacher, N.;
Cecconi, M.;
Cosentino, R.;
Ghedina, A.;
Glenday, A.;
Li, M. Gonzalez C. -H.;
Lodi, M.;
Lovis, C.;
Pepe, F.;
Poretti, E.;
Rice, K.;
Sasselov, D.;
Sozzetti, A.;
Szentgyorgyi, A.;
Udry, S.;
Walsworth, R.
Submitted: 2019-04-27
The time-variable velocity fields of solar-type stars limit the precision of
radial-velocity determinations of their planets' masses, obstructing detection
of Earth twins. Since 2015 July we have been monitoring disc-integrated
sunlight in daytime using a purpose-built solar telescope and fibre feed to the
HARPS-N stellar radial-velocity spectrometer. We present and analyse the solar
radial-velocity measurements and cross-correlation function (CCF) parameters
obtained in the first 3 years of observation, interpreting them in the context
of spatially-resolved solar observations. We describe a Bayesian mixture-model
approach to automated data-quality monitoring. We provide dynamical and daily
differential-extinction corrections to place the radial velocities in the
heliocentric reference frame, and the CCF shape parameters in the sidereal
frame. We achieve a photon-noise limited radial-velocity precision better than
0.43 m s$^{-1}$ per 5-minute observation. The day-to-day precision is limited
by zero-point calibration uncertainty with an RMS scatter of about 0.4 m
s$^{-1}$. We find significant signals from granulation and solar activity.
Within a day, granulation noise dominates, with an amplitude of about 0.4 m
s$^{-1}$ and an autocorrelation half-life of 15 minutes. On longer timescales,
activity dominates. Sunspot groups broaden the CCF as they cross the solar
disc. Facular regions temporarily reduce the intrinsic asymmetry of the CCF.
The radial-velocity increase that accompanies an active-region passage has a
typical amplitude of 5 m s$^{-1}$ and is correlated with the line asymmetry,
but leads it by 3 days. Spectral line-shape variability thus shows promise as a
proxy for recovering the true radial velocity.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.05656 [pdf] - 1849268
Direct Acceleration: Cosmic and Exoplanet Synergies
Erskine, David;
Kim, Alex;
Linder, Eric;
Buschmann, Malte;
Easther, Richard;
Ferraro, Simone;
Muirhead, Philip;
Phillips, David;
Ravi, Aakash;
Safdi, Benjamin;
Schaan, Emmanuel;
Silverwood, Hamish;
Walsworth, Ronald
Submitted: 2019-03-13
Direct measurement of acceleration is a key scientific goal for both
cosmology and exoplanets. For cosmology, the concept of redshift drift (more
than 60 years old by the 2020s) could directly establish the
Friedmann-Lema{\^\i}tre-Robertson-Walker model. It would increase the dark
energy figure of merit by a factor of 3 beyond Stage 4 experiments, in
combination with cosmic microwave background measurements. For exoplanets, the
same technology required provides unprecedented radial velocity accuracy,
enabling detection of Earth mass planets in the habitable zone. Other science
cases include mapping the Milky Way gravitational potential and testing its
dark matter distribution.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.04184 [pdf] - 1860009
HARPS-N Solar Radial-Velocity Variations Are Dominated By Large, Bright
Magnetic Regions
Milbourne, T. W.;
Haywood, R. D.;
Phillips, D. F.;
Saar, S. H.;
Cegla, H. M.;
Cameron, A. C.;
Costes, J.;
Dumusque, X.;
Langellier, N.;
Latham, D. W.;
Maldonado, J.;
Malavolta, L.;
Mortier, A.;
Palumbo, M. L.;
Thompson, S.;
Watson, C. A.;
Bouchy, F.;
Buchschacher, N.;
Cecconi, M.;
Charbonneau, D.;
Cosentino, R.;
Ghedina, A.;
Glenday, A. G.;
Gonzalez, M.;
Li, C-H.;
Lodi, M.;
López-Morales, M.;
Lovis, C.;
Mayor, M.;
Micela, G.;
Molinari, E.;
Pepe, F.;
Piotto, G.;
Rice, K.;
Sasselov, D.;
Ségransan, D.;
Sozzetti, A.;
Szentgyorgyi, A.;
Udry, S.;
Walsworth, R. L.
Submitted: 2019-02-11
State of the art radial-velocity (RV) exoplanet searches are currently
limited by RV signals arising from stellar magnetic activity. We analyze solar
observations acquired over a 3-year period during the decline of Carrington
Cycle 24 to test models of RV variation of Sun-like stars. A purpose-built
solar telescope at the High Accuracy Radial velocity Planet Searcher for the
Northern hemisphere (HARPS-N) provides disk-integrated solar spectra, from
which we extract RVs and $\log{R'_{\rm HK}}$. The Solar Dynamics Observatory
(SDO) provides disk-resolved images of magnetic activity. The Solar Radiation
and Climate Experiment (SORCE) provides near-continuous solar photometry,
analogous to a Kepler light curve. We verify that the SORCE photometry and
HARPS-N $\log{R'_{\rm HK}}$ correlate strongly with the SDO-derived magnetic
filling factor, while the HARPS-N RV variations do not. To explain this
discrepancy, we test existing models of RV variations. We estimate the
contributions of the suppression of convective blueshift and the rotational
imbalance due to brightness inhomogeneities to the observed HARPS-N RVs. We
investigate the time variation of these contributions over several rotation
periods, and how these contributions depend on the area of active regions. We
find that magnetic active regions smaller than $60 \ \rm Mm^2$ do not
significantly suppress convective blueshift. Our area-dependent model reduces
the amplitude of activity-induced RV variations by a factor of two. The present
study highlights the need to identify a proxy that correlates specifically with
large, bright magnetic regions on the surfaces of exoplanet-hosting stars.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.07857 [pdf] - 1774050
Visible-spanning flat supercontinuum for astronomical applications
Submitted: 2018-07-18, last modified: 2018-10-09
We demonstrate a broad, flat, visible supercontinuum spectrum that is
generated by a dispersion-engineered tapered photonic crystal fiber pumped by a
1 GHz repetition rate turn-key Ti:sapphire laser outputting $\sim$ 30 fs pulses
at 800 nm. At a pulse energy of 100 pJ, we obtain an output spectrum that is
flat to within 3 dB over the range 490-690 nm with a blue tail extending below
450 nm. The mode-locked laser combined with the photonic crystal fiber forms a
simple visible frequency comb system that is extremely well-suited to the
precise calibration of astrophysical spectrographs, among other applications.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.07192 [pdf] - 1583663
Astro-comb calibrator and spectrograph characterization using a turn-key
laser frequency comb
Ravi, Aakash;
Phillips, David F.;
Beck, Matthias;
Martin, Leopoldo L.;
Cecconi, Massimo;
Ghedina, Adriano;
Molinari, Emilio;
Bartels, Albrecht;
Sasselov, Dimitar;
Szentgyorgyi, Andrew;
Walsworth, Ronald L.
Submitted: 2017-05-19, last modified: 2017-11-10
Using a turn-key Ti:sapphire femtosecond laser frequency comb, an
off-the-shelf supercontinuum device, and Fabry-Perot mode filters, we report
the generation of a 16 GHz frequency comb spanning a 90 nm band about a center
wavelength of 566 nm. The light from this astro-comb is used to calibrate the
HARPS-N astrophysical spectrograph for precision radial velocity measurements.
The comb-calibrated spectrograph achieves a stability of $\sim$ 1 cm/s within
half an hour of averaging time. We also use the astro-comb as a reference for
measurements of solar spectra obtained with a compact telescope, and as a tool
to study intrapixel sensitivity variations on the CCD of the spectrograph.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1606.01859 [pdf] - 1530796
Gravitational wave detection with optical lattice atomic clocks
Submitted: 2016-06-06, last modified: 2016-12-28
We propose a space-based gravitational wave detector consisting of two
spatially separated, drag-free satellites sharing ultra-stable optical laser
light over a single baseline. Each satellite contains an optical lattice atomic
clock, which serves as a sensitive, narrowband detector of the local frequency
of the shared laser light. A synchronized two-clock comparison between the
satellites will be sensitive to the effective Doppler shifts induced by
incident gravitational waves (GWs) at a level competitive with other proposed
space-based GW detectors, while providing complementary features. The detected
signal is a differential frequency shift of the shared laser light due to the
relative velocity of the satellites, and the detection window can be tuned
through the control sequence applied to the atoms' internal states. This scheme
enables the detection of GWs from continuous, spectrally narrow sources, such
as compact binary inspirals, with frequencies ranging from ~3 mHz - 10 Hz
without loss of sensitivity, thereby bridging the detection gap between
space-based and terrestrial optical interferometric GW detectors. Our proposed
GW detector employs just two satellites, is compatible with integration with an
optical interferometric detector, and requires only realistic improvements to
existing ground-based clock and laser technologies.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.02267 [pdf] - 1319742
HARPS-N observes the Sun as a star
Dumusque, Xavier;
Glenday, Alex;
Phillips, David F.;
Buchschacher, Nicolas;
Cameron, Andrew Collier;
Cecconi, Massimo;
Charbonneau, David;
Cosentino, Rosario;
Ghedina, Adriano;
Latham, David W.;
Li, Chih-Hao;
Lodi, Marcello;
Lovis, Christophe;
Molinari, Emilio;
Pepe, Francesco;
Udry, Stephane;
Sasselov, Dimitar;
Szentgyorgyi, Andrew;
Walsworth, Ronald
Submitted: 2015-11-06
Radial velocity perturbations induced by stellar surface inhomogeneities
including spots, plages and granules currently limit the detection of
Earth-twins using Doppler spectroscopy. Such stellar noise is poorly understood
for stars other than the Sun because their surface is unresolved. In
particular, the effects of stellar surface inhomogeneities on observed stellar
radial velocities are extremely difficult to characterize, and thus developing
optimal correction techniques to extract true stellar radial velocities is
extremely challenging. In this paper, we present preliminary results of a solar
telescope built to feed full-disk sunlight into the HARPS-N spectrograph, which
is in turn calibrated with an astro-comb. This setup enables long-term
observation of the Sun as a star with state-of-the-art sensitivity to radial
velocity changes. Over seven days of observing in 2014, we show an average
50\cms radial velocity rms over a few hours of observation. After correcting
observed radial velocities for spot and plage perturbations using full-disk
photometry of the Sun, we lower by a factor of two the weekly radial velocity
rms to 60\cms. The solar telescope is now entering routine operation, and will
observe the Sun every clear day for several hours. We will use these radial
velocities combined with data from solar satellites to improve our
understanding of stellar noise and develop optimal correction methods. If
successful, these new methods should enable the detection of Venus over the
next two to three years, thus demonstrating the possibility of detecting
Earth-twins around other solar-like stars using the radial velocity technique.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1006.0492 [pdf] - 1032895
\emph{In-situ} determination of astro-comb calibrator lines to better
than 10 cm s$^{-1}$
Li, C. -H.;
Glenday, A.;
Benedick, A. J.;
Chang, G.;
Chen, L. -J.;
Cramer, C.;
Fendel, P.;
Furesz, G.;
Kärtner, F.;
Korzennik, S.;
Phillips, D.;
Sasselov, D.;
Szentgyorgyi, A.;
Walsworth, R.
Submitted: 2010-06-02
Improved wavelength calibrators for high-resolution astrophysical
spectrographs will be essential for precision radial velocity (RV) detection of
Earth-like exoplanets and direct observation of cosmological deceleration. The
astro-comb is a combination of an octave-spanning femtosecond laser frequency
comb and a Fabry-P\'erot cavity used to achieve calibrator line spacings that
can be resolved by an astrophysical spectrograph. Systematic spectral shifts
associated with the cavity can be 0.1-1 MHz, corresponding to RV errors of
10-100 cm/s, due to the dispersive properties of the cavity mirrors over broad
spectral widths. Although these systematic shifts are very stable, their
correction is crucial to high accuracy astrophysical spectroscopy. Here, we
demonstrate an \emph{in-situ} technique to determine the systematic shifts of
astro-comb lines due to finite Fabry-P\'erot cavity dispersion. The technique
is practical for implementation at a telescope-based spectrograph to enable
wavelength calibration accuracy better than 10 cm/s.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1003.4680 [pdf] - 1579310
Toward a Broadband Astro-comb: Effects of Nonlinear Spectral Broadening
in Optical Fibers
Submitted: 2010-03-24
We propose and analyze a new approach to generate a broadband astro-comb by
spectral broadening of a narrowband astro-comb inside a highly nonlinear
optical fiber. Numerical modeling shows that cascaded four-wave-mixing
dramatically degrades the input comb's side-mode suppression and causes
side-mode amplitude asymmetry. These two detrimental effects can systematically
shift the center-of-gravity of astro-comb spectral lines as measured by an
astrophysical spectrograph with resolution \approx100,000; and thus lead to
wavelength calibration inaccuracy and instability. Our simulations indicate
that this performance penalty, as a result of nonlinear spectral broadening,
can be compensated by using a filtering cavity configured for double-pass. As
an explicit example, we present a design based on an Yb-fiber source comb (with
1 GHz repetition rate) that is filtered by double-passing through a low finesse
cavity (finesse = 208), and subsequent spectrally broadened in a 2-cm,
SF6-glass photonic crystal fiber. Spanning more than 300 nm with 16 GHz line
spacing, the resulting astro-comb is predicted to provide 1 cm/s (~10 kHz)
radial velocity calibration accuracy for an astrophysical spectrograph. Such
extreme performance will be necessary for the search for and characterization
of Earth-like extra-solar planets, and in direct measurements of the change of
the rate of cosmological expansion.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:0711.0304 [pdf] - 6649
Quantum Physics Exploring Gravity in the Outer Solar System: The Sagas
Project
Wolf, P.;
Bordé, Ch. J.;
Clairon, A.;
Duchayne, L.;
Landragin, A.;
Lemonde, P.;
Santarelli, G.;
Ertmer, W.;
Rasel, E.;
Cataliotti, F. S.;
Inguscio, M.;
Tino, G. M.;
Gill, P.;
Klein, H.;
Reynaud, S.;
Salomon, C.;
Peik, E.;
Bertolami, O.;
Gil, P.;
Páramos, J.;
Jentsch, C.;
Johann, U.;
Rathke, A.;
Bouyer, P.;
Cacciapuoti, L.;
Izzo, D.;
De Natale, P.;
Christophe, B.;
Touboul, P.;
Turyshev, S. G.;
Anderson, J. D.;
Tobar, M. E.;
Schmidt-Kaler, F.;
Vigué, J.;
Madej, A.;
Marmet, L.;
Angonin, M-C.;
Delva, P.;
Tourrenc, P.;
Metris, G.;
Müller, H.;
Walsworth, R.;
Lu, Z. H.;
Wang, L.;
Bongs, K.;
Toncelli, A.;
Tonelli, M.;
Dittus, H.;
Lämmerzahl, C.;
Galzerano, G.;
Laporta, P.;
Laskar, J.;
Fienga, A.;
Roques, F.;
Sengstock, K.
Submitted: 2007-11-02, last modified: 2008-08-12
We summarise the scientific and technological aspects of the SAGAS (Search
for Anomalous Gravitation using Atomic Sensors) project, submitted to ESA in
June 2007 in response to the Cosmic Vision 2015-2025 call for proposals. The
proposed mission aims at flying highly sensitive atomic sensors (optical clock,
cold atom accelerometer, optical link) on a Solar System escape trajectory in
the 2020 to 2030 time-frame. SAGAS has numerous science objectives in
fundamental physics and Solar System science, for example numerous tests of
general relativity and the exploration of the Kuiper belt. The combination of
highly sensitive atomic sensors and of the laser link well adapted for large
distances will allow measurements with unprecedented accuracy and on scales
never reached before. We present the proposed mission in some detail, with
particular emphasis on the science goals and associated measurements.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:0804.0955 [pdf] - 11526
A laser frequency comb that enables radial velocity measurements with a
precision of 1 cm s$^{-1}$
Submitted: 2008-04-06
Searches for extrasolar planets using the periodic Doppler shift of stellar
spectral lines have recently achieved a precision of 60 cm/s (ref 1), which is
sufficient to find a 5-Earth-mass planet in a Mercury-like orbit around a
Sun-like star. To find a 1-Earth-mass planet in an Earthlike orbit, a precision
of 5 cm/s is necessary. The combination of a laser frequency comb with a
Fabry-Perot filtering cavity has been suggested as a promising approach to
achieve such Doppler shift resolution via improved spectrograph wavelength
calibration, with recent encouraging results. Here we report the fabrication of
such a filtered laser comb with up to 40- GHz (1-A) line spacing, generated
from a 1- GHz repetition-rate source, without compromising long-term stability,
reproducibility or spectral resolution. This wide-line-spacing comb, or
`astro-comb', is well matched to the resolving power of high-resolution
astrophysical spectrographs. The astro-comb should allow a precision as high as
1 cm/s in astronomical radial velocity measurements.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:0711.0150 [pdf] - 341917
Space-based research in fundamental physics and quantum technologies
Turyshev, S. G.;
Israelsson, U. E.;
Shao, M.;
Yu, N.;
Kusenko, A.;
Wright, E. L.;
Everitt, C. W. F.;
Kasevich, M. A.;
Lipa, J. A.;
Mester, J. C.;
Reasenberg, R. D.;
Walsworth, R. L.;
Ashby, N.;
Gould, H.;
Paik, H. -J.
Submitted: 2007-11-01, last modified: 2008-03-03
Space-based experiments today can uniquely address important questions
related to the fundamental laws of Nature. In particular, high-accuracy physics
experiments in space can test relativistic gravity and probe the physics beyond
the Standard Model; they can perform direct detection of gravitational waves
and are naturally suited for precision investigations in cosmology and
astroparticle physics. In addition, atomic physics has recently shown
substantial progress in the development of optical clocks and atom
interferometers. If placed in space, these instruments could turn into powerful
high-resolution quantum sensors greatly benefiting fundamental physics.
We discuss the current status of space-based research in fundamental physics,
its discovery potential, and its importance for modern science. We offer a set
of recommendations to be considered by the upcoming National Academy of
Sciences' Decadal Survey in Astronomy and Astrophysics. In our opinion, the
Decadal Survey should include space-based research in fundamental physics as
one of its focus areas. We recommend establishing an Astronomy and Astrophysics
Advisory Committee's interagency ``Fundamental Physics Task Force'' to assess
the status of both ground- and space-based efforts in the field, to identify
the most important objectives, and to suggest the best ways to organize the
work of several federal agencies involved. We also recommend establishing a new
NASA-led interagency program in fundamental physics that will consolidate new
technologies, prepare key instruments for future space missions, and build a
strong scientific and engineering community. Our goal is to expand NASA's
science objectives in space by including ``laboratory research in fundamental
physics'' as an element in agency's ongoing space research efforts.