Visinelli and Gondolo (2015, hereafter VG15) derived analytic expressions for the evolution of the dark matter temperature in a generic cosmological model. They then calculated the dark matter kinetic decoupling temperature $T_{\mathrm{kd}}$ and compared their results to the Gelmini and Gondolo (2008, hereafter GG08) calculation of $T_{\mathrm{kd}}$ in an early matter-dominated era (EMDE), which occurs when the Universe is dominated by either a decaying oscillating scalar field or a semistable massive particle before Big Bang nucleosynthesis. VG15 found that dark matter decouples at a lower temperature in an EMDE than it would in a radiation-dominated era, while GG08 found that dark matter decouples at a higher temperature in an EMDE than it would in a radiation-dominated era. VG15 attributed this discrepancy to the presence of a matching constant that ensures that the dark matter temperature is continuous during the transition from the EMDE to the subsequent radiation-dominated era and concluded that the GG08 result is incorrect. We show that the disparity is due to the fact that VG15 compared $T_\mathrm{kd}$ in an EMDE to the decoupling temperature in a radiation-dominated universe that would result in the same dark matter temperature at late times. Since decoupling during an EMDE leaves the dark matter colder than it would be if it decoupled during radiation domination, this temperature is much higher than $T_\mathrm{kd}$ in a standard thermal history, which is indeed lower than $T_{\mathrm{kd}}$ in an EMDE, as stated by GG08.

Dark matter drops out of kinetic equilibrium with standard model particles when the momentum-transfer rate equals the expansion rate. In a radiation-dominated universe, this occurs at essentially the same time as dark matter kinetically decouples from the plasma. Dark matter may also fall out of kinetic equilibrium with standard model particles during an early matter-dominated era (EMDE), which occurs when the energy content of the Universe is dominated by either a decaying oscillating scalar field or a semistable massive particle before big bang nucleosynthesis. Until now, it has been assumed that kinetic decoupling during an EMDE happens similarly to the way it does in a radiation-dominated era. We show that this is not the case. By studying the evolution of the dark matter temperature, we establish a quasidecoupled state for dark matter in an EMDE, during which the dark matter temperature cools faster than the plasma temperature but slower than it would cool if the dark matter were fully decoupled. The dark matter does not fully decouple until the EMDE ends and the Universe becomes radiation dominated. We also extend the criteria for quasidecoupling to other nonstandard thermal histories and consider how quasidecoupling affects the free-streaming length of dark matter.