Normalized to: Walbrugh, W.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.05175 [pdf] - 1791160
Characterizing Signal Loss in the 21 cm Reionization Power Spectrum: A
Revised Study of PAPER-64
Cheng, Carina;
Parsons, Aaron R.;
Kolopanis, Matthew;
Jacobs, Daniel C.;
Liu, Adrian;
Kohn, Saul A.;
Aguirre, James E.;
Pober, Jonathan C.;
Ali, Zaki S.;
Bernardi, Gianni;
Bradley, Richard F.;
Carilli, Chris L.;
DeBoer, David R.;
Dexter, Matthew R.;
Dillon, Joshua S.;
Klima, Pat;
MacMahon, David H. E.;
Moore, David F.;
Nunhokee, Chuneeta D.;
Walbrugh, William P.;
Walker, Andre
Submitted: 2018-10-11
The Epoch of Reionization (EoR) is an uncharted era in our Universe's history
during which the birth of the first stars and galaxies led to the ionization of
neutral hydrogen in the intergalactic medium. There are many experiments
investigating the EoR by tracing the 21cm line of neutral hydrogen. Because
this signal is very faint and difficult to isolate, it is crucial to develop
analysis techniques that maximize sensitivity and suppress contaminants in
data. It is also imperative to understand the trade-offs between different
analysis methods and their effects on power spectrum estimates. Specifically,
with a statistical power spectrum detection in HERA's foreseeable future, it
has become increasingly important to understand how certain analysis choices
can lead to the loss of the EoR signal. In this paper, we focus on signal loss
associated with power spectrum estimation. We describe the origin of this loss
using both toy models and data taken by the 64-element configuration of the
Donald C. Backer Precision Array for Probing the Epoch of Reionization (PAPER).
In particular, we highlight how detailed investigations of signal loss have led
to a revised, higher 21cm power spectrum upper limit from PAPER-64.
Additionally, we summarize errors associated with power spectrum error
estimation that were previously unaccounted for. We focus on a subset of
PAPER-64 data in this paper; revised power spectrum limits from the PAPER
experiment are presented in a forthcoming paper by Kolopanis et al. (in prep.)
and supersede results from previously published PAPER analyses.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1502.06016 [pdf] - 1708241
PAPER-64 Constraints on Reionization: The 21cm Power Spectrum at z=8.4
Ali, Zaki S.;
Parsons, Aaron R.;
Zheng, Haoxuan;
Pober, Jonathan C.;
Liu, Adrian;
Aguirre, James E.;
Bradley, Richard F.;
Bernardi, Gianni;
Carilli, Chris L.;
Cheng, Carina;
DeBoer, David R.;
Dexter, Matthew R.;
Grobbelaar, Jasper;
Horrell, Jasper;
Jacobs, Daniel C.;
Klima, Pat;
MacMahon, David H. E.;
Maree, Matthys;
Moore, David F.;
Razavi, Nima;
Stefan, Irina I.;
Walbrugh, William P.;
Walker, Andre
Submitted: 2015-02-20, last modified: 2018-06-29
In this paper, we report new limits on 21cm emission from cosmic reionization
based on a 135-day observing campaign with a 64-element deployment of the
Donald C. Backer Precision Array for Probing the Epoch of Reionization (PAPER)
in South Africa. This work extends the work presented in Parsons et al. (2014)
with more collecting area, a longer observing period, improved redundancy-based
calibration, optimal fringe-rate filtering, and improved power-spectral
analysis using optimal quadratic estimators. The result is a new $2\sigma$
upper limit on $\Delta^{2}(k)$ of (22.4 mK)$^2$ in the range $0.15 < k < 0.5h\
{\rm Mpc}^{-1}$ at $z = 8.4$. This represents a three-fold improvement over the
previous best upper limit. As we discuss in more depth in a forthcoming paper
(Pober et al. 2015, in prep), this upper limit supports and extends previous
evidence against extremely cold reionization scenarios. We conclude with a
discussion of implications for future 21cm reionization experiments, including
the newly funded Hydrogen Epoch of Reionization Array (HERA). $\textbf{The
limits presented in this paper have been retracted: The erratum can be found in
Appendix A.}$
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1502.05072 [pdf] - 1644078
New Limits on Polarized Power Spectra at 126 and 164 MHz: Relevance to
Epoch of Reionization Measurements
Moore, David;
Aguirre, James E.;
Kohn, Saul;
Parsons, Aaron;
Ali, Zaki;
Bradley, Richard;
Carilli, Chris;
DeBoer, David;
Dexter, Matthew;
Gugliucci, Nicole;
Jacobs, Daniel;
Klima, Pat;
Liu, Adrian;
MacMahon, David;
Manley, Jason;
Pober, Jonathan;
Stefan, Irina;
Walbrugh, William
Submitted: 2015-02-17, last modified: 2017-02-07
Polarized foreground emission is a potential contaminant of attempts to
measure the fluctuation power spectrum of highly redshifted 21 cm HI emission
from the epoch of reionization. Using the Donald C. Backer Precision Array for
Probing the Epoch of Reionization (PAPER), we present limits on the observed
power spectra of all four Stokes parameters in two frequency bands, centered at
126 MHz ($z=10.3$) and 164 MHz ($z=7.66$) for a three-month observing campaign
of a 32-antenna deployment, for which unpolarized power spectrum results have
been reported at $z=7.7$ (Parsons et al 2014) and $7.5 < z < 10.5$ (Jacobs et
al 2014). The power spectra in this paper are processed in the same way as in
those works, and show no definitive detection of polarized power. This
non-detection appears to be largely due to the suppression of polarized power
by ionospheric rotation measure fluctuations, which strongly affect Stokes Q
and U. We are able to show that the net effect of polarized leakage is a
negligible contribution at the levels of of the limits reported in Parsons et
al 2014 and Jacobs et al 2014.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.02187 [pdf] - 1451346
The African Very Long Baseline Interferometry Network:The Ghana Antenna
Conversion
Copley, C. J.;
Thondikulam, V.;
Loots, A.;
Bangani, S.;
Cloete, K.;
Combrinck, L.;
Gioio, S.;
Ludick, J.;
Nicolson, G.;
Pollak, A. W.;
Pretorius, P.;
Quick, J. F. H.;
Taylor, G.;
Ebrahim, F.;
Humphreys, C.;
Maake, K.;
Maganane, R.;
Majinjiva, R.;
Mapunda, A.;
Manzini, M.;
Mogakwe, N.;
Moseki, A.;
Qwabe, N.;
Royi, N.;
Rosie, K.;
Smith, J.;
Schietekat, S.;
Toruvanda, O.;
Tong, C.;
van Niekerk, B.;
Walbrugh, W.;
Zeeman, W.
Submitted: 2016-08-07
The African Very Long Baseline Interferometry Network (AVN) is a pan-African
project that will develop Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) observing
capability in several countries across the African continent, either by
conversion of existing telecommunications antennas into radio telescopes, or by
building new ones. This paper focuses on the conversion of the Nkutunse
satellite communication station (near Accra, Ghana), specifically the early
mechanical and infrastructure upgrades, together with the development of a
custom ambient receiver and digital backend. The paper concludes with what
remains to be done, before the station can be commissioned as an operational
VLBI station.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.02635 [pdf] - 1415071
Constraining Polarized Foregrounds for EoR Experiments I: 2D Power
Spectra from the PAPER-32 Imaging Array
Kohn, S. A.;
Aguirre, J.;
Nunhokee, C.;
Bernardi, G.;
Pober, J.;
Ali, Z.;
Bradley, R.;
Carilli, C.;
DeBoer, D.;
Gugliucci, N.;
Jacobs, D.;
Klima, P.;
MacMahon, D.;
Manley, J.;
Moore, D.;
Parsons, A.;
Stefan, I.;
Walbrugh, W.
Submitted: 2016-02-08, last modified: 2016-03-29
Current-generation low frequency interferometers constructed with the
objective of detecting the high-redshift 21 cm background, aim to generate
power spectra of the brightness-temperature contrast of neutral hydrogen in
primordial intergalactic medium. Two-dimensional power spectra (power in
Fourier modes parallel and perpendicular to the line of sight) formed from
interferometric visibilities have been shown to delineate a boundary between
spectrally-smooth foregrounds (known as the wedge) and spectrally-structured 21
cm background emission (the EoR-window). However, polarized foregrounds are
known to possess spectral structure due to Faraday rotation, which can leak
into the EoR window. In this work, we create and analyze 2D power spectra from
the PAPER-32 imaging array in Stokes I, Q, U and V. These allow us to observe
and diagnose systematic effects in our calibration at high signal-to-noise
within the Fourier space most relevant to EoR experiments. We observe
well-defined windows in the Stokes visibilities, with Stokes Q, U and V power
spectra sharing a similar wedge shape to that seen in Stokes I. With modest
polarization calibration, we see no evidence that polarization calibration
errors move power outside the wedge in any Stokes visibility, to the noise
levels attained. Deeper integrations will be required to confirm that this
behavior persists to the depth required for EoR detection.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.00045 [pdf] - 1278344
PAPER-64 Constraints On Reionization II: The Temperature Of The z=8.4
Intergalactic Medium
Pober, Jonathan C.;
Ali, Zaki S.;
Parsons, Aaron R.;
McQuinn, Matthew;
Aguirre, James E.;
Bernardi, Gianni;
Bradley, Richard F.;
Carilli, Chris L.;
Cheng, Carina;
DeBoer, David R.;
Dexter, Matthew R.;
Furlanetto, Steven R.;
Grobbelaar, Jasper;
Horrell, Jasper;
Jacobs, Daniel C.;
Klima, Patricia J.;
Kohn, Saul A.;
Liu, Adrian;
MacMahon, David H. E.;
Maree, Matthys;
Mesinger, Andrei;
Moore, David F.;
Razavi-Ghods, Nima;
Stefan, Irina I.;
Walbrugh, William P.;
Walker, Andre;
Zheng, Haoxuan
Submitted: 2015-02-27, last modified: 2015-09-15
We present constraints on both the kinetic temperature of the intergalactic
medium (IGM) at z=8.4, and on models for heating the IGM at high-redshift with
X-ray emission from the first collapsed objects. These constraints are derived
using a semi-analytic method to explore the new measurements of the 21 cm power
spectrum from the Donald C. Backer Precision Array for Probing the Epoch of
Reionization (PAPER), which were presented in a companion paper, Ali et al.
(2015). Twenty-one cm power spectra with amplitudes of hundreds of mK^2 can be
generically produced if the kinetic temperature of the IGM is significantly
below the temperature of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB); as such, the
new results from PAPER place lower limits on the IGM temperature at z=8.4.
Allowing for the unknown ionization state of the IGM, our measurements find the
IGM temperature to be above ~5 K for neutral fractions between 10% and 85%,
above ~7 K for neutral fractions between 15% and 80%, or above ~10 K for
neutral fractions between 30% and 70%. We also calculate the heating of the IGM
that would be provided by the observed high redshift galaxy population, and
find that for most models, these galaxies are sufficient to bring the IGM
temperature above our lower limits. However, there are significant ranges of
parameter space that could produce a signal ruled out by the PAPER
measurements; models with a steep drop-off in the star formation rate density
at high redshifts or with relatively low values for the X-ray to star formation
rate efficiency of high redshift galaxies are generally disfavored. The PAPER
measurements are consistent with (but do not constrain) a hydrogen spin
temperature above the CMB temperature, a situation which we find to be
generally predicted if galaxies fainter than the current detection limits of
optical/NIR surveys are included in calculations of X-ray heating.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1408.3389 [pdf] - 1216306
Multi-redshift limits on the 21cm power spectrum from PAPER
Jacobs, Daniel C.;
Pober, Jonathan C.;
Parsons, Aaron R.;
Aguirre, James E.;
Ali, Zaki;
Bowman, Judd;
Bradley, Richard F.;
Carilli, Chris L.;
DeBoer, David R.;
Dexter, Matthew R.;
Gugliucci, Nicole E.;
Klima, Pat;
Liu, Adrian;
MacMahon, Dave H. E.;
Manley, Jason R.;
Moore, David F.;
Stefan, Irina I.;
Walbrugh, William P.
Submitted: 2014-08-14, last modified: 2014-08-15
The epoch of reionization power spectrum is expected to evolve strongly with
redshift, and it is this variation with cosmic history that will allow us to
begin to place constraints on the physics of reionization. The primary obstacle
to the measurement of the EoR power spectrum is bright foreground emission. We
present an analysis of observations from the Donald C. Backer Precision Array
for Probing the Epoch of Reionization (PAPER) telescope which place new limits
on the HI power spectrum over the redshift range of $7.5<z<10.5$, extending
previously published single redshift results to cover the full range accessible
to the instrument. To suppress foregrounds, we use filtering techniques that
take advantage of the large instrumental bandwidth to isolate and suppress
foreground leakage into the interesting regions of $k$-space. Our 500 hour
integration is the longest such yet recorded and demonstrates this method to a
dynamic range of $10^4$. Power spectra at different points across the redshift
range reveal the variable efficacy of the foreground isolation. Noise limited
measurements of $\Delta^2$ at $k=$0.2hMpc$^{-1}$ and z$=7.55$ reach as low as
(48mK)$^2$ ($1\sigma$). We demonstrate that the size of the error bars in our
power spectrum measurement as generated by a bootstrap method is consistent
with the fluctuations due to thermal noise. Relative to this thermal noise,
most spectra exhibit an excess of power at a few sigma. The likely sources of
this excess include residual foreground leakage, particularly at the highest
redshift, and unflagged RFI. We conclude by discussing data reduction
improvements that promise to remove much of this excess.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.4991 [pdf] - 843041
New Limits on 21cm EoR From PAPER-32 Consistent with an X-Ray Heated IGM
at z=7.7
Parsons, Aaron R.;
Liu, Adrian;
Aguirre, James E.;
Ali, Zaki S.;
Bradley, Richard F.;
Carilli, Chris L.;
DeBoer, David R.;
Dexter, Matthew R.;
Gugliucci, Nicole E.;
Jacobs, Daniel C.;
Klima, Pat;
MacMahon, David H. E.;
Manley, Jason R.;
Moore, David F.;
Pober, Jonathan C.;
Stefan, Irina I.;
Walbrugh, William P.
Submitted: 2013-04-17, last modified: 2014-06-26
We present new constraints on the 21cm Epoch of Reionization (EoR) power
spectrum derived from 3 months of observing with a 32-antenna,
dual-polarization deployment of the Donald C. Backer Precision Array for
Probing the Epoch of Reionization (PAPER) in South Africa. In this paper, we
demonstrate the efficacy of the delay-spectrum approach to avoiding
foregrounds, achieving over 8 orders of magnitude of foreground suppression (in
$\textrm{mK}^2$). Combining this approach with a procedure for removing
off-diagonal covariances arising from instrumental systematics, we achieve a
best 2-sigma upper limit of $(41\,\textrm{mK})^2$ for $k=0.27
h\textrm{Mpc}^{-1}$ at $z=7.7$. This limit falls within an order of magnitude
of the brighter predictions of the expected 21cm EoR signal level. Using the
upper limits set by these measurements, we generate new constraints on the
brightness temperature of 21cm emission in neutral regions for various
reionization models. We show that for several ionization scenarios, our
measurements are inconsistent with cold reionization. That is, heating of the
neutral intergalactic medium (IGM) is necessary to remain consistent with the
constraints we report. Hence, we have suggestive evidence that by $z=7.7$, the
HI has been warmed from its cold primordial state, probably by X-rays from
high-mass X-ray binaries or mini-quasars. The strength of this evidence depends
on the ionization state of the IGM, which we are not yet able to constrain.
This result is consistent with standard predictions for how reionization might
have proceeded.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1307.7716 [pdf] - 1173045
A Flux Scale for Southern Hemisphere 21cm EoR Experiments
Jacobs, Daniel C.;
Parsons, Aaron R.;
Aguirre, James E.;
Ali, Zaki;
Bowman, Judd;
Bradley, Richard F.;
Carilli, Christopher L.;
DeBoer, David R.;
Dexter, Matthew;
Gugliucci, Nicole E.;
Klima, Pat;
MacMahon, Dave H. E.;
Manley, Jason R.;
Moore, David F.;
Pober, Jonathan C.;
Stefan, Irina I.;
Walbrugh, William P.
Submitted: 2013-07-29
We present a catalog of spectral measurements covering a 100-200 MHz band for
32 sources, derived from observations with a 64-antenna deployment of the
Donald C. Backer Precision Array for Probing the Epoch of Reionization (PAPER)
in South Africa. For transit telescopes such as PAPER, calibration of the
primary beam is a difficult endeavor, and errors in this calibration are a
major source of error in the determination of source spectra. In order to
decrease reliance on accurate beam calibration, we focus on calibrating sources
in a narrow declination range from -46d to -40d. Since sources at similar
declinations follow nearly identical paths through the primary beam, this
restriction greatly reduces errors associated with beam calibration, yielding a
dramatic improvement in the accuracy of derived source spectra. Extrapolating
from higher frequency catalogs, we derive the flux scale using a Monte-Carlo
fit across multiple sources that includes uncertainty from both catalog and
measurement errors. Fitting spectral models to catalog data and these new PAPER
measurements, we derive new flux models for Pictor A and 31 other sources at
nearby declinations. 90% of these confirm and refine a power-law model for flux
density. Of note is the new Pictor A flux model, which is accurate to 1.4% and
shows, in contrast to previous models, that between 100 MHz and 2 GHz, the
spectrum of Pictor A is consistent with a single power law given by a flux at
150 MHz of 382+/-5.4 Jy, and a spectral index of -0.76+/-0.01. This accuracy
represents an order of magnitude improvement over previous measurements in this
band, and is limited by the uncertainty in the catalog measurements used to
estimate the absolute flux scale. The simplicity and improved accuracy of
Pictor A's spectrum make it an excellent calibrator for experiments seeking to
measure 21cm emission from the Epoch of Reionization.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1301.7099 [pdf] - 1159364
Opening the 21cm EoR Window: Measurements of Foreground Isolation with
PAPER
Pober, Jonathan C.;
Parsons, Aaron R.;
Aguirre, James E.;
Ali, Zaki;
Bradley, Richard F.;
Carilli, Chris L.;
DeBoer, Dave;
Dexter, Matthew;
Gugliucci, Nicole E.;
Jacobs, Daniel C.;
Klima, Patricia J.;
MacMahon, Dave;
Manley, Jason;
Moore, David F.;
Stefan, Irina I.;
Walbrugh, William P.
Submitted: 2013-01-29, last modified: 2013-05-03
We present new observations with the Precision Array for Probing the Epoch of
Reionization (PAPER) with the aim of measuring the properties of foreground
emission for 21cm Epoch of Reionization experiments at 150 MHz. We focus on the
footprint of the foregrounds in cosmological Fourier space to understand which
modes of the 21cm power spectrum will most likely be compromised by foreground
emission. These observations confirm predictions that foregrounds can be
isolated to a "wedge"-like region of 2D (k-perpendicular, k-parallel)-space,
creating a window for cosmological studies at higher k-parallel values. We also
find that the emission extends past the nominal edge of this wedge due to
spectral structure in the foregrounds, with this feature most prominent on the
shortest baselines. Finally, we filter the data to retain only this "unsmooth"
emission and image specific k-parallel modes of it. The resultant images show
an excess of power at the lowest modes, but no emission can be clearly
localized to any one region of the sky. This image is highly suggestive that
the most problematic foregrounds for 21cm EoR studies will not be easily
identifiable bright sources, but rather an aggregate of fainter emission.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1212.1624 [pdf] - 1158364
Imaging on PAPER: Centaurus A at 148 MHz
Stefan, Irina I.;
Carilli, Chris L.;
Green, David A.;
Ali, Zaki;
Aguirre, James E.;
Bradley, Richard F.;
DeBoer, Dave;
Dexter, Matthew;
Gugliucci, Nicole E.;
Harris, D. E.;
Jacobs, Daniel C.;
Klima, Pat;
MacMahon, Dave;
Manley, Jason;
Moore, David F.;
Parsons, Aaron R.;
Pober, Jonathan C.;
Walbrugh, William P.
Submitted: 2012-12-07, last modified: 2013-03-26
We present observations taken with the Precision Array for Probing the Epoch
of Reionization (PAPER) of the Centaurus A field in the frequency range 114 to
188 MHz. The resulting image has a 25' resolution, a dynamic range of 3500 and
an r.m.s. of 0.5 Jy\beam (for a beam size of 25' x 23'). A spectral index map
of Cen A is produced across the full band. The spectral index distribution is
qualitatively consistent with electron reacceleration in regions of excess
turbulence in the radio lobes, as previously identified morphologically. Hence,
there appears to be an association of 'severe weather' in radio lobes with
energy input into the relativistic electron population. We compare the PAPER
large scale radio image with the X-ray image from the ROSAT All Sky Survey.
There is a tentative correlation between radio and X-ray features at the end of
the southern lobe, some 200 kpc from the nucleus, as might be expected from
inverse Compton scattering of the CMB by the relativistic electrons also
responsible for the radio synchrotron emission. The magnetic fields derived
from the (possible) IC and radio emission are of similar magnitude to fields
derived under the minimum pressure assumptions, ~ 1 {\mu}G. However, the X-ray
field is complex, with large scale gradients and features possibly unrelated to
Cen A. If these X-ray features are unrelated to Cen A, then these fields are
lower limits.