Normalized to: Vio, R.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.06268 [pdf] - 2112728
Modeling high-dimensional dependence among astronomical data
Submitted: 2020-06-11
Fixing the relationship among a set of experimental quantities is a
fundamental issue in many scientific disciplines. In the two-dimensional case,
the classical approach is to compute the linear correlation coefficient from a
scatterplot. This method, however, implicitly assumes a linear relationship
between the variables. Such assumption is not always correct. With the use of
the partial correlation coefficients, an extension to the multi-dimensional
case is possible. However, the problem of the assumed mutual linear
relationship among the variables still remains. A relatively recent approach
which permits to avoid this problem is modeling the joint probability density
function (PDF) of the data with copulas. These are functions which contain all
the information on the relationship between two random variables. Although in
principle this approach can work also with multi-dimensional data, theoretical
as well computational difficulties often limit its use to the two-dimensional
case. In this paper, we consider an approach, based on so-called vine copulas,
which overcomes this limitation and at the same time is amenable to a
theoretical treatment and feasible from the computational point of view. We
apply this method to published data on the near-IR and far-IR luminosities and
atomic and molecular masses of the Herschel Reference Sample. We determine the
relationship among the luminosities and gas masses and show that the far-IR
luminosity can be considered as the key parameter which relates all the other
three galaxy properties. Once removed from the 4D relation, the residual
relation among the other three is negligible. This may be interpreted as that
the correlation between the gas masses and near-IR luminosity is driven by the
far-IR luminosity, likely by the star-formation activity of the galaxy.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.01595 [pdf] - 2112544
A critical comparison of the Lomb-Scargle and the classical periodograms
Submitted: 2018-07-04, last modified: 2020-06-11
The detection of signals hidden in noise is one of the oldest and common
problems in astronomy. Various solutions have been proposed in the past such as
the parametric approaches based on the least-squares fit of theoretical
templates or the non-parametric techniques as the phase-folding method. Most of
them, however, are suited only for signals with specific time evolution. For
generic signals the spectral approach based on the periodogram is potentially
the most effective. In astronomy the main problem in working with the
periodogram is that often the sampling of the signals is irregular. This
complicates its efficient computation (the fast Fourier transform cannot be
directly used) but overall the determination of its statistical
characteristics. The Lomb-Scargle periodogram (LSP) provides a solution to this
last important issue, but its main drawback is the assumption of a very
specific model of the datawhich is not correct for most of the practical
applications. These issues are not always considered in literature with
theoretical and practical consequences of no easy solution. Moreover, apart
from pathological samplings, it is common believe that the LSP and the
classical periodogram (CP) usually provide almost identical results. In
general, this is true but here it is shown that there are situations where the
LSP is less effective than the CP in the detection of signals in noise. There
are no compelling reasons, therefore, to use the LSP instead of the CP which is
directly connected to the correlation function of the observed signal with the
sinusoidal functions at the various frequencies of interest.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.01465 [pdf] - 1912995
Correct estimate of the probability of false detection of the matched
filter in weak-signal detection problems. III (Peak distribution method
versus the Gumbel distribution method)
Submitted: 2019-07-02
The matched filter (MF) represents one of the main tools to detect signals
from known sources embedded in the noise. In the Gaussian case the noise is
assumed to be the realization of a Gaussian random field (GRF). The most
important property of the MF, the maximization of the probability of detection
subject to a constant probability of false detection or false alarm (PFA),
makes it one of the most popular techniques. However, the MF technique relies
upon the a priori knowledge of the number and the position of the searched
signals in the GRF which usually are not available. A typical way out is to
assume that the position of a signal coincides with one of the peaks in the
matched filtered data. A detection is claimed when the probability that a given
peak is due only to the noise (i.e. the PFA) is smaller than a prefixed
threshold. In this case the probability density function (PDF) of the
amplitudes has to be used for the computation of the PFA, which is different
from the Gaussian. Moreover, the probability that a detection is false depends
on the number of peaks present in the filtered GRF, the greater the number of
peaks in a GRF, the higher the probability of peaks due to the noise that
exceed the detection threshold. If not taken into account, the PFA can be
severely underestimated. Many solutions proposed to this problem are
non-parametric hence not able to exploit all the available information. This
limitation has been overcome by means of two efficient parametric approaches,
one based on the PDF of the peak amplitudes of a smooth and isotropic GRF
whereas the other uses the Gumbel distribution (the asymptotic PDF of the
corresponding extreme). Simulations and ALMA maps show that, although the two
methods produce almost identical results, the first is more flexible and allows
us to check the reliability of the detection procedure.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.03995 [pdf] - 1812934
Comments on arXiv:1811.00154 [astro-ph.IM] "AGN Variability Analysis
Handbook"
Submitted: 2018-12-10, last modified: 2019-01-10
Why do we write this note?
It is erroneous to pretend to extract physical information from the
experimental light curves (time series) of astrophysical systems by means of
linear stochastic differential equations (LSDE). In general, the time evolution
of these systems is governed by a set of nonlinear differential equations.
Hence, the LSDEs are not suitable to model their dynamics. In spite of this,
recently the LSDEs have been proposed as tools for the analysis of AGN light
curves. Their use in this context seems to be dictated by their simplicity
rather than by a real physical argument. We stress in this note that the
correct approach to the analysis of signals coming from systems with nonlinear
dynamics is to tackle the problem using methodologies in well defined physical
contexts.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1806.02567 [pdf] - 1751860
The bivariate luminosity and mass functions of the local HRS galaxy
sample. The stellar, dust, gas mass functions
Submitted: 2018-06-07
We discuss the results of the relationships between the K-band and stellar
mass, far-infrared luminosities, star formation rate, dust and gas masses of
nearby galaxies computing the bivariate K-band Luminosity Function (BLF) and
bivariate K-band Mass Function (BMF) of the Herschel Reference Survey (HRS), a
volume-limited sample with full wavelength coverage. We derive the BLFs and
BMFs from the K-band and stellar mass, far-infrared luminosities, star
formation rate, dust and gas masses cumulative distributions using a copula
method which is outlined in detail. The use of the bivariate computed taking
into account the upper limits allows us to derive on a more solid statistical
ground the relationship between the observed physical quantities. The analysis
shows that the behaviour of the morphological (optically selected) subsamples
is quite different. A statistically meaningful result can be obtained over the
whole HRS sample only from the relationship between the K-band and the stellar
mass, while for the remaining physical quantities (dust and gas masses, far-IR
luminosity and star formation rate), the analysis is distinct for late-type
(LT) and early-type galaxies (ETG). However, the number of ETGs is small to
perform a robust statistical analysis, and in most of the case results are
discussed only for the LTG subsample. The Luminosity and Mass Functions (LFs,
MFs) of LTGs are generally dependent on the K-band and the various dependencies
are discussed in detail. We are able to derive the corresponding LFs and MFs
and compare them with those computed with other samples. Our statistical
analysis allows us to characterise the HRS, that, although non homogeneously
selected and partially biased towards low IR luminosities, may be considered as
representative of the local LT galaxy population.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.02859 [pdf] - 1728844
Matched filter in the low-number count Poisson noise regime: an
efficient and effective implementation
Submitted: 2018-01-09, last modified: 2018-04-25
The matched filter (MF) is widely used to detect signals hidden within the
noise. If the noise is Gaussian, its performances are well-known and
describable in an elegant analytical form. The treatment of non-Gaussian noises
is often cumbersome as in most cases there is no analytical framework. This is
true also for Poisson noise which, especially in the low-number count regime,
presents the additional difficulty to be discrete. For this reason in the past
methods have been proposed based on heuristic or semi-heuristic arguments.
Recently, an analytical form of the MF has been introduced but the computation
of the probability of false detection or false alarm (PFA) is based on
numerical simulations. To overcome this inefficient and time consuming approach
we propose here an effective method to compute the PFA based on the saddle
point approximation (SA). We provide the theoretical framework and support our
findings by means of numerical simulations. We discuss also the limitations of
the MF in practical applications.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.03285 [pdf] - 1583250
The correct estimate of the probability of false detection of the
matched filter in the detection of weak signals. II. (Further results with
application to a set of ALMA and ATCA data)
Submitted: 2017-05-09, last modified: 2017-05-26
The matched filter (MF) is one of the most popular and reliable techniques to
the detect signals of known structure and amplitude smaller than the level of
the contaminating noise. Under the assumption of stationary Gaussian noise, MF
maximizes the probability of detection subject to a constant probability of
false detection or false alarm (PFA). This property relies upon a priori
knowledge of the position of the searched signals, which is usually not
available. Recently, it has been shown that when applied in its standard form,
MF may severely underestimate the PFA. As a consequence the statistical
significance of features that belong to noise is overestimated and the
resulting detections are actually spurious. For this reason, an alternative
method of computing the PFA has been proposed that is based on the probability
density function (PDF) of the peaks of an isotropic Gaussian random field. In
this paper we further develop this method. In particular, we discuss the
statistical meaning of the PFA and show that, although useful as a preliminary
step in a detection procedure, it is not able to quantify the actual
reliability of a specific detection. For this reason, a new quantity is
introduced called the specific probability of false alarm (SPFA), which is able
to carry out this computation. We show how this method works in targeted
simulations and apply it to a few interferometric maps taken with the Atacama
Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) and the Australia Telescope Compact
Array (ATCA). We select a few potential new point sources and assign an
accurate detection reliability to these sources.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.02392 [pdf] - 1385478
On the Correct Estimate of the Probability of False Detection of the
Matched Filter in Weak-Signal Detection Problems
Submitted: 2016-02-07
The detection reliability of weak signals is a critical issue in many
astronomical contexts and may have severe consequences for determining number
counts and luminosity functions, but also for optimising the use of telescope
time in follow-up observations. Because of its optimal properties, one of the
most popular and widely-used detection technique is the matched filter (MF).
This is a linear filter designed to maximise the detectability of a signal of
known structure that is buried in additive Gaussian random noise. In this work
we show that in the very common situation where the number and position of the
searched signals within a data sequence (e.g. an emission line in a spectrum)
or an image (e.g. a point-source in an interferometric map) are unknown, this
technique, when applied in its standard form, may severely underestimate the
probability of false detection. This is because the correct use of the MF
relies upon a-priori knowledge of the position of the signal of interest. In
the absence of this information, the statistical significance of features that
are actually noise is overestimated and detections claimed that are actually
spurious. For this reason, we present an alternative method of computing the
probability of false detection that is based on the probability density
function (PDF) of the peaks of a random field. It is able to provide a correct
estimate of the probability of false detection for the one-, two- and
three-dimensional case. We apply this technique to a real two-dimensional
interferometric map obtained with ALMA.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.6627 [pdf] - 844796
The bivariate K-band-submillimetre luminosity functions of the local HRS
galaxy sample
Submitted: 2014-02-26
We study the relationship between the K-band and the sub-millimetre (submm)
emissions of nearby galaxies by computing the bivariate K-band-submm luminosity
function (BLF) of the Herschel Reference Survey (HRS), a volume-limited sample
observed in submm with Hersche/SPIRE. We derive the BLF from the K-band and
submm cumulative distributions using a copula method. Using the BLF allows us
to derive the relationship between the luminosities on more solid statistical
ground. The analysis shows that over the whole HRS sample, no statistically
meaningful conclusion can be derived for any relationship between the K-band
and the submm luminosity. However, a very tight relationship between these
luminosities is highlighted, by restricting our analysis to late-type galaxies.
The luminosity function of late-type galaxies computed in the K-band and in the
submm are dependent and the dependence is caused by the link, between the
stellar mass and the cold dust mass, which has been already observed
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.4050 [pdf] - 1171439
An approach for the detection of point-sources in very high resolution
microwave maps
Submitted: 2013-05-17, last modified: 2013-07-12
This paper deals with the detection problem of extragalactic point-sources in
multi-frequency, microwave sky maps that will be obtainable in future cosmic
microwave background radiation (CMB) experiments with instruments capable of
very high spatial resolution. With spatial resolutions that can be of order of
0.1-1.0 arcsec or better, the extragalactic point-sources will appear isolated.
The same holds also for the compact structures due to the Sunyaev-Zeldovich
(SZ) effect (both thermal and kinetic). This situation is different from the
maps obtainable with instruments as WMAP or PLANCK where, because of the
smaller spatial resolution (approximately 5-30 arcmin), the point-sources and
the compact structures due to the SZ effect form a uniform noisy background
(the "confusion noise"). Hence, the point-source detection techniques developed
in the past are based on the assumption that all the emissions that contribute
to the microwave background can be modeled with homogeneous and isotropic
(often Gaussian) random fields and make use of the corresponding spatial
power-spectra. In the case of very high resolution observations such an
assumption cannot be adopted since it still holds only for the CMB. Here, we
propose an approach based on the assumption that the diffuse emissions that
contribute to the microwave background can be locally approximated by
two-dimensional low order polynomials. In particular, two sets of numerical
techniques are presented containing two different algorithms each. The
performance of the algorithms is tested with numerical experiments that mimic
the physical scenario expected for high Galactic latitude observations with the
Atacama Large Millimeter/Submillimeter Array (ALMA).
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1301.4826 [pdf] - 616848
Irregular time series in astronomy and the use of the Lomb-Scargle
periodogram
Submitted: 2013-01-21
Detection of a signal hidden by noise within a time series is an important
problem in many astronomical searches, i.e. for light curves containing the
contributions of periodic/semi-periodic components due to rotating objects and
all other astrophysical time-dependent phenomena. One of the most popular tools
for use in such studies is the "periodogram", whose use in an astronomical
context is often not trivial. The "optimal" statistical properties of the
periodogram are lost in the case of irregular sampling of signals, which is a
common situation in astronomical experiments. Parts of these properties are
recovered by the "Lomb-Scargle" (LS) technique, but at the price of theoretical
difficulties, that can make its use unclear, and of algorithms that require the
development of dedicated software if a fast implementation is necessary. Such
problems would be irrelevant if the LS periodogram could be used to
significantly improve the results obtained by approximated but simpler
techniques. In this work we show that in many astronomical applications simpler
techniques provide results similar to those obtainable with the LS periodogram.
The meaning of the "Nyquist frequency" is also discussed in the case of
irregular sampling.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.4536 [pdf] - 527465
Two modified ILC methods to detect point sources in Cosmic Microwave
Background maps
Submitted: 2012-06-20
We propose two detection techniques that take advantage of a small sky area
approximation and are based on modifications of the "internal linear
combination" (ILC) method, an approach widely used in Cosmology for the
separation of the various components that contribute to the microwave
background. The main advantage of the proposed approach, especially in handling
multi-frequency maps of the same region, is that it does not require the "a
priori" knowledge of the spatial power-spectrum of either the CMB and/or the
Galactic foreground. Hence, it is more robust, easier and more intuitive to
use. The performance of the proposed algorithms is tested with numerical
experiments that mimic the physical scenario expected for high Galactic
latitude observations with the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array
(ALMA).
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1009.1493 [pdf] - 1034796
Detection of new point-sources in WMAP Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB)
maps at high Galactic latitude. A new technique to extract point sources from
CMB maps
Submitted: 2010-09-08, last modified: 2011-01-13
In experimental microwave maps, point-sources can strongly affect the
estimation of the power-spectrum and/or the test of Gaussianity of the Cosmic
Microwave Background (CMB) component. As a consequence, their removal from the
sky maps represents a critical step in the analysis of the CMB data. Before
removing a source, however, it is necessary to detect it and source extraction
consists of a delicate preliminary operation. In the literature, various
techniques have been presented to detect point-sources in the sky maps. The
most sophisticated ones exploit the multi-frequency nature of the observations
that is typical of the CMB experiments. These techniques have "optimal"
theoretical properties and, at least in principle, are capable of remarkable
performances. Actually, they are rather difficult to use and this deteriorates
the quality of the obtainable results. In this paper, we present a new
technique, the "weighted matched filter" (WMF), that is quite simple to use and
hence more robust in practical applications. Such technique shows particular
efficiency in the detection of sources whose spectra have a slope different
from zero. We apply this method to three Southern Hemisphere sky regions - each
with an area of 400 square degrees - of the seven years Wilkinson Microwave
Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) maps and compare the resulting sources with those of
the two seven-year WMAP point-sources catalogues. In these selected regions we
find seven additional sources not previously listed in WMAP catalogues and
discuss their most likely identification and spectral properties.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1006.2473 [pdf] - 1033078
Unevenly-sampled signals: a general formalism of the Lomb-Scargle
periodogram
Submitted: 2010-06-12
The periodogram is a popular tool that tests whether a signal consists only
of noise or if it also includes other components. The main issue of this method
is to define a critical detection threshold that allows identification of a
component other than noise, when a peak in the periodogram exceeds it. In the
case of signals sampled on a regular time grid, determination of such a
threshold is relatively simple. When the sampling is uneven, however, things
are more complicated. The most popular solution in this case is to use the
"Lomb-Scargle" periodogram, but this method can be used only when the noise is
the realization of a zero-mean, white (i.e. flat-spectrum) random process. In
this paper, we present a general formalism based on matrix algebra, which
permits analysis of the statistical properties of a periodogram independently
of the characteristics of noise (e.g. colored and/or non-stationary), as well
as the characteristics of sampling.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:0910.4294 [pdf] - 29816
Considerations on some neglected but impotant issues concerning the In
ternal Linear Combination method in Astronomy
Submitted: 2009-10-22
Although the ``internal linear'' combination method (ILC) is a technique
widely used for the separation of the Cosmic Microwave Background signal from
the Galactic foregrounds, its characteristics are not yet well defined. This
can lead to misleading conclusions about the actual potentialities and limits
of such approach in real applications. Here we discuss briefly some facts about
ILC that to our knowledge are not fully worked out in literature and yet have
deep effects in the interpretation of the results.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:0810.4755 [pdf] - 17842
A theoretical framework for the detection of point-sources in Cosmic
Microwave Background maps
Submitted: 2008-10-27, last modified: 2009-07-14
The detection of point-sources in microwave maps is a critical step in the
analysis of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) data. If not properly
removed, these sources have adverse effects on the estimation of the
power-spectrum and/or the test of Gaussianity of the CMB component. The
techniques to extract point sources from an observed image used up to now do
not show a general consensus about their real performance and properties. Their
characteristics have been studied essentially through numerical simulations
based on semi-empirical models of the CMB and the Galactic foreground. Such
models often have different levels of sophistication and/or are based on
different physical assumptions (e.g. the number of Galactic components and
level of the noise). Moreover, the application of a given technique to a set of
data (either simulated or experimental) requires the tuning of one or more
parameters that unavoidably is a subjective operation. Hence, a reliable
comparison is difficult. What is missing is a statistical analysis of the
properties of the proposed methodologies. This is the aim of the present paper.
The statistical properties of the detection techniques in the context of two
different criteria, i.e. the Neyman-Pearson criterion and the maximization of
the signal-to-noise ratio, are analyzed through an analytical approach. Various
examples, techniques and the conditions under which they work satisfactorily
are shown together with their limits and implementation details. Exploiting
some a priori information, it is possible to develop simple algorithms with
performances similar to those of more sophisticated but complex techniques. In
this respect, a detection algorithm, useful in future ground-based experiments
as, for example the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array, is presented.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:0811.4277 [pdf] - 18912
"Internal Linear Combination" method for the separation of CMB from
Galactic foregrounds in the harmonic domain
Submitted: 2008-11-26
Foreground contamination is the fundamental hindrance to the cosmic microwave
background (CMB) signals and its separation from it represents a fundamental
question in Cosmology. One of the most popular algorithm used to disentangle
foregrounds from the CMB signals is the "internal linear combination" method
(ILC). In its original version, this technique is applied directly to the
observed maps. In recent literature, however, it is suggested that in the
harmonic (Fourier) domain it is possible to obtain better results since a
separation can be attempted where the various Fourier frequencies are given
different weights. This is seen as a useful characteristic in the case of noisy
data. Here, we argue that the benefits of using such an approach are
overestimated. Better results can be obtained if a classic procedure is adopted
where data are filtered before the separation is carried out.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:0806.0520 [pdf] - 1000758
A Statistical Analysis of the "Internal Linear Combination" Method in
Problems of Signal Separation as in CMB Observations
Submitted: 2008-06-03
AIMS: The separation of foreground contamination from cosmic microwave
background (CMB) observations is one of the most challenging and important
problem of digital signal processing in Cosmology. In literature, various
techniques have been presented, but no general consensus about their real
performances and properties has been reached. This is due to the
characteristics of these techniques that have been studied essentially through
numerical simulations based on semi-empirical models of the CMB and the
Galactic foregrounds. Such models often have different level of sophistication
and/or are based on different physical assumptions (e.g., the number of the
Galactic components and the level of the noise). Hence, a reliable comparison
is difficult. What actually is missing is a statistical analysis of the
properties of the proposed methodologies. Here, we consider the "Internal
Linear Combination" method (ILC) which, among the separation techniques,
requires the smallest number of "a priori" assumptions. This feature is of
particular interest in the context of the CMB polarization measurements at
small angular scales where the lack of knowledge of the polarized backgrounds
represents a serious limit. METHODS: The statistical characteristics of ILC are
examined through an analytical approach and the basic conditions are fixed in a
way to work satisfactorily. RESULTS: ILC provides satisfactory results only
under rather restrictive conditions. This is a critical fact to take into
consideration in planning the future ground-based observations (e.g., with
ALMA) where, contrary to the satellite experiments, there is the possibility to
have a certain control of the experimental conditions.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:0802.0400 [pdf] - 9725
A Modified ICA Approach for Signal Separation in CMB Maps
Submitted: 2008-02-04
AIMS: One of the most challenging and important problem of digital signal
processing in Cosmology is the separation of foreground contamination from
cosmic microwave background (CMB). This problem becomes even more difficult in
situations, as the CMB polarization observations, where the amount of available
"a priori" information is limited. In this case, it is necessary to resort to
the "blind separation" methods. One important member of this class is
represented by the "Independent Components Analysis" (ICA). In its original
formulation, this method has various interesting characteristics, but also some
limits. One of the most serious is the difficulty to take into account any
information available in advance. In particular, ICA is not able to exploit the
fact that emission of CMB is the same at all the frequencies of observations.
Here, we show how to deal with this question. The connection of the proposed
methodology with the "Internal Linear Composition" (ILC) technique is also
illustrated.
METHODS: A modification of the classic ICA approach is presented and its
characteristics are analyzed both analytically and by means of numerical
experiments.
RESULTS: The modified version of ICA appears to provide more stable results
and of better quality.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0701895 [pdf] - 89024
Ly-alpha forest: efficient unbiased estimation of second-order
properties with missing data
Submitted: 2007-01-31
Context. One important step in the statistical analysis of the Ly-alpha
forest data is the study of their second order properties. Usually, this is
accomplished by means of the two-point correlation function or, alternatively,
the K-function. In the computation of these functions it is necessary to take
into account the presence of strong metal line complexes and strong Ly-alpha
lines that can hidden part of the Ly-alpha forest and represent a non
negligible source of bias. Aims. In this work, we show quantitatively what are
the effects of the gaps introduced in the spectrum by the strong lines if they
are not properly accounted for in the computation of the correlation
properties. We propose a geometric method which is able to solve this problem
and is computationally more efficient than the Monte Carlo (MC) technique that
is typically adopted in Cosmology studies. The method is implemented in two
different algorithms. The first one permits to obtain exact results, whereas
the second one provides approximated results but is computationally very
efficient. The proposed approach can be easily extended to deal with the case
of two or more lists of lines that have to be analyzed at the same time.
Methods. Numerical experiments are presented that illustrate the consequences
to neglect the effects due to the strong lines and the excellent performances
of the proposed approach. Results. The proposed method is able to remarkably
improve the estimates of both the two-point correlation function and the
K-function.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0605089 [pdf] - 81777
Comments on the paper "The Mexican Hat Wavelet Family. Application to
point source detection in CMB maps" by J. Gonzalez-Nuevo et al.
(astro-ph/0604376)
Submitted: 2006-05-03
The arguments presented by Gonzalez-Nuevo et. al (2006) in favour of the
Mexican Hat Wavelet Family (MHWF) are critically discussed here. These authors
allege the optimal properties of this new class of filters in the detection of
point sources embedded in a noise background but their claim is not based upon
a solid mathematical foundation and proof.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0602200 [pdf] - 1469020
Stochastic modeling of kHz QPO light curves
Submitted: 2006-02-08
The Kluzniak & Abramowicz model explains high frequency, double peak, "3:2"
QPOs observed in neutron star and black hole sources in terms of a non-linear
parametric resonance between radial and vertical epicyclic oscillations of an
almost Keplerian accretion disk. The 3:2 ratio of epicyclic frequencies occurs
only in strong gravity. Rebusco (2004) and Horak (2004) studied the model
analytically: they proved that a small forcing may indeed excite the parametric
3:2 resonance, but they have not explained the physical nature of the forcing.
Here we integrate their equations numerically, dropping the ad hoc forcing, and
adding instead a stochastic term to mimic the action of the very complex
processes that occur in disks as, for example,
MRI turbulence. We demonstrate that the presence of the stochastic term
triggers the resonance in epicyclic oscillations of nearly Keplerian disks, and
influences their pattern.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0510477 [pdf] - 76973
Some further comments on the paper "biparametric scale adaptive filter
design" for the detection of compact sources as proposed by M. Lopez-Caniego
et. al 2005, MNRAS 359, 993
Submitted: 2005-10-17
In this note we re-propose the arguments presented in Vio (2005) examining
the superiority of the 'bi-parametric scale adaptive filter' (BSAF) when
dealing with source detection as claimed by (Lopez-Caniego 2005a) and confirmed
in Lopez-Caniego (2005b). We suggest here that the dispute can be easily solved
if these authors provide the community with a detailed derivation of a basic
equation.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0509394 [pdf] - 75976
Some comments on the paper "Filter design for the detection of compact
sources based on the Neyman-Pearson detector" by M. Lopez-Caniego et. al
(2005, MNRAS 359, 993)
Submitted: 2005-09-14
In this note we stress the necessity of a careful check of both the
theoretical arguments and the numerical experiments used by Lopez-Caniego et
al. (2005) to support the superior performances of the biparametric scale
adaptive filter (BSAF) with respect to the classic matched filter (MF) in the
detection of sources on a random Gaussian background.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0410367 [pdf] - 68216
Time series analysis in Astronomy: limits and potentialities
Submitted: 2004-10-15
In this paper we consider the problem of the limits concerning the physical
information that can be extracted from the analysis of one or more time series
(light curves) typical of astrophysical objects. On the basis of theoretical
considerations and numerical simulations, we show that with no a priori
physical model there are not so many possibilities to obtain interpretable
results. For this reason, the practice to develop more and more sophisticated
statistical methods of time series analysis is not very productive. Only
techniques of data analysis developed in a specific physical context can be
expected to provide useful results. The field of {\it stochastic dynamics}
appears to be an useful framework for such an approach. In particular, it is
shown that modelling the experimental time series by means of the stochastic
differential equations (SDE) represents a valuable tool of analysis. For
example, the use of SDE permits to make the analysis of a continuous signal
independent from the frequency sampling with which the experimental time series
have been obtained. In this respect, an efficient approach based on the
extended Kalman-filter technique is presented. Freely downloadable software is
made available.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0409535 [pdf] - 67616
Least-squares methods with Poissonian noise: an analysis and a
comparison with the Richardson-Lucy algorithm
Submitted: 2004-09-22
It is well-known that the noise associated with the collection of an
astronomical image by a CCD camera is, in large part, Poissonian. One would
expect, therefore, that computational approaches that incorporate this a priori
information will be more effective than those that do not. The Richardson-Lucy
(RL) algorithm, for example, can be viewed as a maximum-likelihood (ML) method
for image deblurring when the data noise is assumed to be Poissonian.
Least-squares (LS) approaches, on the other hand, arises from the assumption
that the noise is Gaussian with fixed variance across pixels, which is rarely
accurate. Given this, it is surprising that in many cases results obtained
using LS techniques are relatively insensitive to whether the noise is
Poissonian or Gaussian. Furthermore, in the presence of Poisson noise, results
obtained using LS techniques are often comparable with those obtained by the RL
algorithm. We seek an explanation of these phenomena via an examination of the
regularization properties of particular LS algorithms. In addition, a careful
analysis of the RL algorithm yields an explanation as to why it is more
effective than LS approaches for star-like objects, and why it provides similar
reconstructions for extended objects. We finish with a convergence analysis of
the RL algorithm. Numerical results are presented throughout the paper. It is
important to stress that the subject treated in this paper is not academic. In
fact, in comparison with many ML algorithms, the LS algorithms are much easier
to use and to implement, often provide faster convergence rates, and are much
more flexible regarding the incorporation of constraints on the solution.
Consequently, if little to no improvement is gained in the use of an ML
approach over an LS algorithm, the latter will often be the preferred approach.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0405545 [pdf] - 65065
Estimation of Regularization Parameters in Multiple-Image Deblurring
Submitted: 2004-05-27
We consider the estimation of the regularization parameter for the
simultaneous deblurring of multiple noisy images via Tikhonov regularization.
We approach the problem in three ways. We first reduce the problem to a
single-image deblurring for which the regularization parameter can be estimated
through a classic generalized cross-validation (GCV) method. A modification of
this function is used for correcting the undersmoothing typical of the original
technique. With a second method, we minimize an average least-squares fit to
the images and define a new GCV function. In the last approach, we use the
classical $GCV$ on a single higher-dimensional image obtained by concatanating
all the images into a single vector. With a reliable estimator of the
regularization parameter, one can fully exploit the excellent computational
characteristics typical of direct deblurring methods, which, especially for
large images, makes them competitive with the more flexible but much slower
iterative algorithms. The performance of the techniques is analyzed through
numerical experiments. We find that under the independent homoscedastic and
Gaussian assumptions made on the noise, the three approaches provide almost
identical results with the first single image providing the practical advantage
that no new software is required and the same image can be used with other
deblurring algorithms.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0311592 [pdf] - 61172
A simple but efficient algorithm for multiple-image deblurring
Submitted: 2003-11-26
We consider the simultaneous deblurring of a set of noisy images whose point
spread functions are different but known and spatially invariant, and the noise
is Gaussian. Currently available iterative algorithms that are typically used
for this type of problem are computationally expensive, which makes their
application for very large images impractical. We present a simple extension of
a classical least-squares (LS) method where the multi-image deblurring is
efficiently reduced to a computationally efficient single-image deblurring. In
particular, we show that it is possible to remarkably improve the
ill-conditioning of the LS problem by means of stable operations on the
corresponding normal equations, which in turn speed up the convergence rate of
the iterative algorithms. The performance and limitations of the method are
analyzed through numerical simulations. Its connection with a column weighted
least-squares approach is also considered in an appendix.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0305246 [pdf] - 56719
Some Good Reasons to Use Matched Filters for the Detection of Point
Sources in CMB Maps
Submitted: 2003-05-14, last modified: 2003-10-22
In this draft we comment on the results concerning the performances of
matched filters, scale adaptive filters and Mexican hat wavelet that recently
appeared in literature in the context of point source detection in Cosmic
Microwave Background maps. In particular, we show that, contrary to what has
been claimed, the use of the matched filters still appear to be the most
reliable and efficient method to disantangle point sources from the
backgrounds, even when using detection criterion that, differently from the
classic $n\sigma$ thresholding rule, takes into account not only the height of
the peaks in the signal corresponding to the candidate sources but also their
curvature.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0309145 [pdf] - 58972
Digital Deblurring of CMB Maps II: Asymmetric Point Spread Function
Submitted: 2003-09-04
In this second paper in a series dedicated to developing efficient numerical
techniques for the deblurring Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) maps, we
consider the case of asymmetric point spread functions (PSF). Although
conceptually this problem is not different from the symmetric case, there are
important differences from the computational point of view because it is no
longer possible to use some of the efficient numerical techniques that work
with symmetric PSFs. We present procedures that permit the use of efficient
techniques even when this condition is not met. In particular, two methods are
considered: a procedure based on a Kronecker approximation technique that can
be implemented with the numerical methods used with symmetric PSFs but that has
the limitation of requiring only mildly asymmetric PSFs. The second is a
variant of the classic Tikhonov technique that works even with very asymmetric
PSFs but that requires discarding the edges of the maps. We provide details for
efficient implementations of the algorithms. Their performance is tested on
simulated CMB maps.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0301493 [pdf] - 54464
Digital Deblurring of CMB Maps: Performance and Efficient Implementation
Submitted: 2003-01-24
Digital deblurring of images is an important problem that arises in
multifrequency observations of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) where,
because of the width of the point spread functions (PSF), maps at different
frequencies suffer a different loss of spatial resolution. Deblurring is useful
for various reasons: first, it helps to restore high frequency components lost
through the smoothing effect of the instrument's PSF; second, emissions at
various frequencies observed with different resolutions can be better studied
on a comparable resolution; third, some map-based component separation
algorithms require maps with similar level of degradation. Because of
computational efficiency, deblurring is usually done in the frequency domain.
But this approach has some limitations as it requires spatial invariance of the
PSF, stationarity of the noise, and is not flexible in the selection of more
appropriate boundary conditions. Deblurring in real space is more flexible but
usually not used because of its high computational cost. In this paper (the
first in a series on the subject) we present new algorithms that allow the use
of real space deblurring techniques even for very large images. In particular,
we consider the use of Tikhonov deblurring of noisy maps with applications to
{\it PLANCK}. We provide details for efficient implementations of the
algorithms. Their performance is tested on Gaussian and non-Gaussian simulated
CMB maps, and PSFs with both circular and elliptical symmetry. Matlab code is
made available.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0207311 [pdf] - 50454
Numerical Simulation of Non-Gaussian Random Fields with Prescribed
Marginal Distributions and Cross-Correlation Structure II: Multivariate
Random Fields
Submitted: 2002-07-15
We provide theoretical procedures and practical recipes to simulate
non-Gaussian correlated, homogeneous random fields with prescribed marginal
distributions and cross-correlation structure, either in a N-dimensional
Cartesian space or on the celestial sphere. We illustrate our methods using
far-infrared maps obtained with the Infrared Space Observatory. However, the
methodology presented here can be used in other astrophysical applications that
require modeling correlated features in sky maps, for example, the simulation
of multifrequency sky maps where backgrounds, sources and noise are correlated
and can be modeled by random fields.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0204186 [pdf] - 48731
Joint Time--Frequency Analysis: a tool for exploratory analysis and
filtering of non-stationary time series
Submitted: 2002-04-10
It is the purpose of the paper to describe the virtues of time-frequency
methods for signal processing applications, having astronomical time series in
mind. Different methods are considered and their potential usefulness
respectively drawbacks are discussed and illustrated by examples. As areas
where one can hope for a successful application of joint time-frequency
analysis (JTFA), we describe specifically the problem of signal denoising as
well as the question of signal separation which allows to separate signals
(possibly overlapping in time or frequency, but) which are living on disjoint
parts of the time-frequency plane. Some recipes for practical use of the
algorithms are also provided.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0204101 [pdf] - 48646
On Optimal Detection of Point Sources in CMB Maps
Submitted: 2002-04-05
Point-source contamination in high-precision Cosmic Microwave Background
(CMB) maps severely affects the precision of cosmological parameter estimates.
Among the methods that have been proposed for source detection, wavelet
techniques based on ``optimal'' filters have been proposed.In this paper we
show that these filters are in fact only restrictive cases of a more general
class of matched filters that optimize signal-to-noise ratio and that have, in
general, better source detection capabilities, especially for lower amplitude
sources. These conclusions are confirmed by some numerical experiments.
\keywords{Methods: data analysis -- Methods: statistical
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0105107 [pdf] - 42336
Numerical Simulation of Non-Gaussian Random Fields with Prescribed
Correlation Structure
Submitted: 2001-05-07
In this paper we will consider the problem of the numerical simulation of
non-Gaussian, scalar random fields with a prescribed correlation structure
provided either by a theoretical model or computed on a set of observational
data. Although, the numerical generation of a generic, non-Gaussian random
field is a trivial operation, the task becomes tough when constraining the
field with a prefixed correlation structure. At this regards, three numerical
methods, useful for astronomical applications, are presented. The limits and
capabilities of each method are discussed and the pseudo-codes describing the
numerical implementation are provided for two of them.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9703091 [pdf] - 1234932
The Nature of the Broad--Line--Region in the Radio--Loud AGN 3C390.3
Submitted: 1997-03-13
We present an analysis of the ultraviolet and X-Ray variability of the Broad-
Line-Radio Galaxy 3C390.3 over 15 years. The UV continuum showed large
variations with amplitudes of up to a factor of 10. We find: (1) The variations
of CIV and Ly_alpha are highly correlated with the UV continuum, and are
delayed with respect to the continuum variations by 50-110 days with the red
wing of both CIV and Ly_alpha , leading the blue wing; (2) The CIV/Ly_alpha
ratio is positively correlated with both the continuum flux and UV line
strength, a behavior different from other AGNs studied so far; (3) The blue
sides of the Ly_alpha and CIV profiles are similar to the blue side of the
Balmer lines, while the red sides are different, suggesting a different origin
for the red peak in the Balmer lines. Our results suggest: (1) The broad CIV
and Ly_alpha emitting gas is infalling towards the central object; (2) The
overall behaviour of the CIV/Ly_alpha ratio and the absence of a big blue bump,
strongly indicate the coexistence of optically thick as well as optically thin
BLR clouds; (3) Assuming circular symmetry and predominantly circular motion,
the BLR gas is situated at 83$\pm$25 lightdays from the central source; (4)
Under these assumptions and with the derived circular velocity of $v_{rot}
\simeq$ 2850 km s$^{-1}$, the central mass inside this radius is confined to
$1.3~10^8 M\odot < M_{CM}< 4.0~10^8 M\odot$; (6) Comparing our results with
those obtained from VLBI and observations of the Fe $K\alpha$ line, suggests
the association of the BLR with a disk, inclined at 98$\pm$12 degrees with
respect to the direction of superluminal motion of the radio blobs.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9506140 [pdf] - 92930
The Optical Variability of QSO's
Submitted: 1995-06-30
The long-term variability of a sample of 486 optically selected QSOs in the
fields of the SA94, SA57 and SGP has been studied. The relations of variability
with luminosity and redshift have been investigated by means of statistical
estimators that are ``robust'' and allow at the same time to eliminate the
influence of the measurement errors. The analysis in the QSOs rest frame of
both the ensemble structure function ($SF$) and individual variability indices
show: 1) a negative correlation between variability and luminosity; 2) a
significant positive correlation between variability and $z$; 3) such
correlations may be equally well parameterized either with a model in which the
timescale of the variability is fixed for all the QSOs ($\tau \sim 2.4$ yr),
while the amplitude linearly increases with the absolute magnitude and $z$, or
with a model in which the timescale of the variability linearly depends on the
absolute magnitude and the amplitude is only a function of $z$. The same
analysis carried out in the observer's frame shows: 1) a negative correlation
between variability and luminosity; 2) the timescale of variability does not
depend significantly either on the absolute magnitude or on $z$; 3) the
ensemble structure function is well represented by a parameterization in which,
with a fixed timescale of about 5.5 yr, the amplitude linearly increases with
the absolute magnitude; 4) although the general behaviour of the $SF$ does not
show a systematic variation of the timescale and/or amplitude with $z$, if we
examine the average variability index for objects with $-25>M_B>-27$, we find
that below $z=1$ QSOs are significantly less variable than at higher redshift.
Implications in terms of the black-hole, starburst and microlensing models are
briefly discussed.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9505133 [pdf] - 92775
The ESO Key-Programme ``A Homogeneous Bright QSO Survey'' - I The
Methods and the ``Deep'' Fields
Cristiani, S.;
La Franca, F.;
Andreani, P.;
Gemmo, A.;
Goldschmidt, P.;
Miller, L.;
Vio, R.;
Barbieri, C.;
Bodini, L.;
Iovino, A.;
Lazzarin, M.;
Clowes, R.;
MacGillivray, H.;
Gouiffes, Ch.;
Lissandrini, C.;
Savage, A.
Submitted: 1995-05-29
This is the first paper in a series aimed at defining a statistically
significant sample of QSOs in the range $ 15 < B < 18.75$ and $ 0.3 < z < 2.2$.
The selection is carried out using direct plates obtained at the ESO and UK
Schmidt Telescopes, scanned with the COSMOS facility and searched for objects
with an ultraviolet excess. Follow-up spectroscopy, carried out at ESO La
Silla, is used to classify each candidate. In this initial paper, we describe
the scientific objectives of the survey; the selection and observing techniques
used. We present the first sample of 285 QSOs ($M_B < -23$) in a 153 deg$^2$
area, covered by the six ``deep'' fields, intended to obtain significant
statistics down $B \simeq 18.75$ with unprecedented photometric accuracy. From
this database, QSO counts are determined in the magnitude range $ 17 < B <
18.75$.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9412029 [pdf] - 363093
On the Relationship between Optical and X-Ray Luminosity of Quasars
Submitted: 1994-12-08
The issue of the X-ray to optical luminosity relationship ($L_o-L_x$) is
addressed for both optically and X-ray selected quasar samples. We have applied
a generalized regression algorithm for the case of samples involving censored
data, with errors on both the dependent and the independent variable. Contrary
to some previous results, we find that such relationship is consistent with
being a linear one ($L_x\propto L_o$). We argue that previous reports of
non-linear relationships (i.e. $L_x\propto L_o^e$ with $e < 1$) are due to the
neglect of the influence of the photometric errors, the precise knowledge of
which strongly influences the reliability of the results. Further progresses in
the determination of the $L_o-L_x$ relationship can be achieved with ROSAT
observations of the new generation of large bright quasar surveys.