Normalized to: Villenave, M.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2005.09037 [pdf] - 2129359
Gap, shadows, spirals, streamers: SPHERE observations of binary-disk
interactions in GG Tau A
Keppler, M.;
Penzlin, A.;
Benisty, M.;
van Boekel, R.;
Henning, T.;
van Holstein, R. G.;
Kley, W.;
Garufi, A.;
Ginski, C.;
Brandner, W.;
Bertrang, G. H. -M.;
Boccaletti, A.;
de Boer, J.;
Bonavita, M.;
Sevilla, S. Brown;
Chauvin, G.;
Dominik, C.;
Janson, M.;
Langlois, M.;
Lodato, G.;
Maire, A. -L.;
Ménard, F.;
Pantin, E.;
Pinte, Ch.;
Stolker, T.;
Szulágyi, J.;
Thebault, P.;
Villenave, M.;
Zurlo, A.;
Rabou, P.;
Feautrier, P.;
Feldt, M.;
Madec, F.;
Wildi, F.
Submitted: 2020-05-18, last modified: 2020-06-04
A large fraction of stars is found to be part of binary or higher-order
multiple systems. The ubiquity of planets found around single stars raises the
question if and how planets in binary systems may form. Protoplanetary disks
are the birthplaces of planets, and their characterization is crucial in order
to understand the planet formation process. Our aim is to characterize the
morphology of the GG Tau A disk, one of the largest and most massive
circumbinary disks, and trace evidence for binary-disk interactions. We
obtained observations in polarized scattered light of GG Tau A using the
SPHERE/IRDIS instrument in the H-band filter. We analyze the observed disk
morphology and substructures. We run 2D hydrodynamical models simulating the
evolution of the circumbinary ring over the lifetime of the disk. The disk, as
well as the cavity and the inner region are highly structured with several
shadowed regions, spiral structures, and streamer-like filaments, some of them
detected for the first time. The streamer-like filaments appear to connect the
outer ring with the northern arc. Their azimuthal spacing suggests that they
may be generated by periodic perturbations by the binary, tearing off material
from the inner edge of the outer disk once during each orbit. By comparing
observations to hydrodynamical simulations we find that the main features, in
particular the gap size, as well as the spiral and streamer filaments, can be
qualitatively explained by the gravitational interactions of a binary with
semi-major axis of $\sim$35 au on an orbit coplanar with the circumbinary ring.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.02439 [pdf] - 2129402
Ongoing flyby in the young multiple system UX Tauri
Menard, F.;
Cuello, N.;
Ginski, C.;
van der Plas, G.;
Villenave, M.;
Gonzalez, J. -F.;
Pinte, C.;
Benisty, M.;
Boccaletti, A.;
Price, D. J.;
Boehler, Y.;
Chripko, S.;
de Boer, J.;
Dominik, C.;
Garufi, A.;
Gratton, R.;
Hagelberg, J.;
Henning, Th.;
Langlois, M.;
Maire, A. L.;
Pinilla, P.;
Ruane, G. J.;
Schmid, H. M.;
van Holstein, R. G.;
Vigan, A.;
Zurlo, A.;
Hubin, N.;
Pavlov, A.;
Rochat, S.;
Sauvage, J. -F.;
Stadler, E.
Submitted: 2020-06-03
We present observations of the young multiple system UX Tauri to look for
circumstellar disks and for signs of dynamical interactions. We obtained
SPHERE/IRDIS deep differential polarization images in the J and H bands. We
also used ALMA archival CO data. Large extended spirals are well detected in
scattered light coming out of the disk of UX Tau A. The southern spiral forms a
bridge between UX Tau A and C. These spirals, including the bridge connecting
the two stars, all have a CO (3-2) counterpart seen by ALMA. The disk of UX Tau
C is detected in scattered light. It is much smaller than the disk of UX Tau A
and has a major axis along a different position angle, suggesting a
misalignment. We performed PHANTOM SPH hydrodynamical models to interpret the
data. The scattered light spirals, CO emission spirals and velocity patterns of
the rotating disks, and the compactness of the disk of UX Tau C all point to a
scenario in which UX Tau A has been perturbed very recently (about 1000 years)
by the close passage of UX Tau C.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.08189 [pdf] - 2077076
Spirals inside the millimeter cavity of transition disk SR 21
Muro-Arena, G. A.;
Ginski, C.;
Dominik, C.;
Benisty, M.;
Pinilla, P.;
Bohn, A. J.;
Moldenhauer, T.;
Kley, W.;
Harsono, D.;
Henning, T.;
van Holstein, R. G.;
Janson, M.;
Keppler, M.;
Ménard, F.;
Pérez, L. M.;
Stolker, T.;
Tazzari, M.;
Villenave, M.;
Zurlo, A.;
Petit, C.;
Rigal, F.;
Möller-Nilsson, O.;
Llored, M.;
Moulin, T.;
Rabou, P.
Submitted: 2020-03-18
Hydrodynamical simulations of planet-disk interactions suggest that planets
may be responsible for a number of the sub-structures frequently observed in
disks in both scattered light and dust thermal emission. Despite the ubiquity
of these features, direct evidence of planets embedded in disks and of the
specific interaction features like spiral arms within planetary gaps still
remain rare. In this study we discuss recent observational results in the
context of hydrodynamical simulations in order to infer the properties of a
putative embedded planet in the cavity of a transition disk. We imaged the
transition disk SR 21 in H-band in scattered light with SPHERE/IRDIS and in
thermal dust emission with ALMA band 3 (3mm) observations at a spatial
resolution of 0.1". We combine these datasets with existing band 9 (430um) and
band 7 (870um) ALMA continuum data. The Band 3 continuum data reveals a large
cavity and a bright ring peaking at 53 au strongly suggestive of dust
trapping.The ring shows a pronounced azimuthal asymmetry, with a bright region
in the north-west that we interpret as a dust over-density. A
similarly-asymmetric ring is revealed at the same location in polarized
scattered light, in addition to a set of bright spirals inside the mm cavity
and a fainter spiral bridging the gap to the outer ring. These features are
consistent with a number of previous hydrodynamical models of planet-disk
interactions, and suggest the presence of a ~1 MJup planet at 44 au and
PA=11{\deg}. This makes SR21 the first disk showing spiral arms inside the mm
cavity, as well as one for which the location of a putative planet can be
precisely inferred. With the location of a possible planet being
well-constrained by observations, it is an ideal candidate for follow-up
observations to search for direct evidence of a planetary companion still
embedded in its disk.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.09612 [pdf] - 2068964
Shadowing and multiple rings in the protoplanetary disk of HD 139614
Muro-Arena, G. A.;
Benisty, M.;
Ginski, C.;
Dominik, C.;
Facchini, S.;
Villenave, M.;
van Boekel, R.;
Chauvin, G.;
Garufi, A.;
Henning, T.;
Janson, M.;
Keppler, M.;
Matter, A.;
Ménard, F.;
Stolker, T.;
Zurlo, A.;
Blanchard, P.;
Maurel, D.;
Moeller-Nilsson, O.;
Petit, C.;
Roux, A.;
Sevin, A.;
Wildi, F.
Submitted: 2019-11-21
Shadows in scattered light images of protoplanetary disks are a common
feature and support the presence of warps or misalignments between disk
regions. These warps are possibly due to an inclined (sub-)stellar companion
embedded in the disk. We study the morphology of the protoplanetary disk around
the Herbig Ae star HD 139614 based on the first scattered light observations of
this disk, which we model with the radiative transfer code MCMax3D. We obtained
J- and H-band observations in polarized scattered light with VLT/SPHERE that
show strong azimuthal asymmetries. In the outer disk, beyond ~30 au, a broad
shadow spans a range of ~240{\deg} in position angle, in the East. A bright
ring at ~16 au also shows an azimuthally asymmetric brightness, with the
faintest side roughly coincidental with the brightest region of the outer disk.
Additionally, two arcs are detected at ~34 au and ~50 au. We created a simple
4-zone approximation to a warped disk model of HD 139614 in order to
qualitatively reproduce these features. The location and misalignment of the
disk components were constrained from the shape and location of the shadows
they cast. We find that the shadow on the outer disk covers a range of position
angle too wide to be explained by a single inner misaligned component. Our
model requires a minimum of two separate misaligned zones -- or a continuously
warped region -- to cast this broad shadow on the outer disk. A small
misalignment of ~4{\deg} between adjacent components can reproduce most of the
observed shadow features. Multiple misaligned disk zones, potentially mimicing
a warp, can explain the observed broad shadows in the HD 139614 disk. A
planetary mass companion in the disk, located on an inclined orbit, could be
responsible for such a feature and for the dust depleted gap responsible for a
dip in the SED.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.04612 [pdf] - 1860010
Spatial segregation of dust grains in transition disks. SPHERE
observations of 2MASS J16083070-3828268 and RXJ1852.3-3700
Villenave, M.;
Benisty, M.;
Dent, W. R. F.;
Menard, F.;
Garufi, A.;
Ginski, C.;
Pinilla, P.;
Pinte, C.;
Williams, J. P.;
de Boer, J.;
Morino, J. -I.;
Fukagawa, M.;
Dominik, C.;
Flock, M.;
Henning, T.;
Juhasz, A.;
Keppler, M.;
Muro-Arena, G.;
Olofsson, J.;
Perez, L. M.;
van der Plas, G.;
Zurlo, A.;
Carle, M.;
Feautrier, P.;
Pavlov, A.;
Pragt, J.;
Ramos, J.;
Sauvage, J. -F.;
Stadler, E.;
Weber, L.
Submitted: 2019-02-12
Context. The mechanisms governing the opening of cavities in transition disks
are not fully understood. Several processes have been proposed but their
occurrence rate is still unknown. Aims. We present spatially resolved
observations of two transition disks and aim at constraining their vertical and
radial structure using multiwavelength observations. Methods. We have obtained
near-IR scattered light observations with VLT/SPHERE of the transition disks
J1608 and J1852. We complement our datasets with ALMA observations and with
unresolved photometric observations covering a wide range of wavelengths. We
performed radiative transfer modeling to analyze the morphology of the disks
and compare the results with a sample of 20 other transition disks observed
with both SPHERE and ALMA. Results. The scattered light image of J1608 reveals
a very inclined disk, with two bright lobes and a large cavity. J1852 shows an
inner ring extending beyond the coronagraphic radius up to 15au, a gap and a
second ring at 42au. Our radiative transfer model of J1608 indicates that the
millimeter-sized grains are less extended vertically and radially than the
micron-sized grains, indicating advanced settling and radial drift. We find
good agreement with the observations of J1852 with a similar model, but due to
the low inclination of the system, the model remains partly degenerate. The
analysis of 22 transition disks shows that, in general, the cavities observed
in scattered light are smaller than the ones detected at millimeter
wavelengths. Conclusions. The analysis of a sample of transition disks
indicates that the small grains can flow inward of the region where millimeter
grains are trapped. While 15 out of the 22 cavities in our sample could be
explained by a planet of less than 13 Jupiter masses, the others either require
the presence of a more massive companion or of several low-mass planets.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.04564 [pdf] - 1791144
Evolution of protoplanetary disks from their taxonomy in scattered
light: spirals, rings, cavities, and shadows
Garufi, Antonio;
Benisty, Myriam;
Pinilla, Paola;
Tazzari, Marco;
Dominik, Carsten;
Ginski, Christian;
Henning, Thomas;
Kral, Quentin;
Langlois, Maud;
Menard, Francois;
Stolker, Tomas;
Szulagyi, Judit;
Villenave, Marion;
van der Plas, Gerrit
Submitted: 2018-10-10, last modified: 2018-10-19
The variety of observed protoplanetary disks in polarimetric light motivates
a taxonomical study to constrain their evolution and establish the current
framework of this type of observations. We classified 58 disks with available
polarimetric observations into six major categories (Ring, Spiral, Giant, Rim,
Faint, and Small disks) based on their appearance in scattered light. We
re-calculated the stellar and disk properties from the newly available GAIA DR2
and related these properties with the disk categories. More than a half of our
sample shows disk sub-structures. For the remaining sources, the absence of
detected features is due to their faintness, to their small size, or to the
disk geometry. Faint disks are typically found around young stars and typically
host no cavity. There is a possible dichotomy in the near-IR excess of sources
with spiral-disks (high) and ring-disks (low). Like spirals, shadows are
associated with a high near-IR excess. If we account for the pre-main sequence
evolutionary timescale of stars with different mass, spiral arms are likely
associated to old disks. We also found a loose, shallow declining trend for the
disk dust mass with time. Protoplanetary disks may form sub-structures like
rings very early in their evolution but their detectability in scattered light
is limited to relatively old sources (more than 5 Myr) where the recurrently
detected disk cavities allow to illuminate the outer disk. The shallow decrease
of disk mass with time might be due to a selection effect, where disks observed
thus far in scattered light are typically massive, bright transition disks with
longer lifetime than most disks. Our study points toward spirals and shadows
being generated by planets of fraction-to-few Jupiter masses that leave their
(observed) imprint on both the inner disk near the star and the outer disk
cavity.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.01082 [pdf] - 1789496
Shadows and asymmetries in the T Tauri disk HD 143006: Evidence for a
misaligned inner disk
Benisty, M.;
Juhasz, A.;
Facchini, S.;
Pinilla, P.;
de Boer, J.;
Perez, L. M.;
Keppler, M.;
Muro-Arena, G.;
Villenave, M.;
Andrews, S.;
Dominik, C.;
Dullemond, C. P.;
Gallenne, A.;
Garufi, A.;
Ginski, C.;
Isella, A.
Submitted: 2018-09-04
While planet formation is thought to occur early in the history of a
protoplanetary disk, the presence of planets embedded in disks, or of other
processes driving disk evolution, might be traced from their imprints on the
disk structure. We observed the T Tauri star HD 143006, located in the 5-11
Myr-old Upper Sco region, in polarized scattered light with VLT/SPHERE at
near-infrared wavelengths, reaching an angular resolution of ~0.037" (~6 au).
We obtained two datasets, one with a 145 mas diameter coronagraph, and the
other without, enabling us to probe the disk structure down to an angular
separation of ~0.06" (~10 au). In our observations, the disk of HD 143006 is
clearly resolved up to ~0.5" and shows a clear large-scale asymmetry with the
eastern side brighter than the western side. We detect a number of additional
features, including two gaps and a ring. The ring shows an overbrightness at a
position angle (PA) of ~140 deg, extending over a range in position angle of
~60 deg, and two narrow dark regions. The two narrow dark lanes and the overall
large-scale asymmetry are indicative of shadowing effects, likely due to a
misaligned inner disk. We demonstrate the remarkable resemblance between the
scattered light image of HD 143006 and a model prediction of a warped disk due
to an inclined binary companion. The warped disk model, based on the
hydrodynamic simulations combined with 3D radiative transfer calculations,
reproduces all major morphological features. However, it does not account for
the observed overbrightness at PA~140 deg. Shadows have been detected in
several protoplanetary disks, suggesting that misalignment in disks is not
uncommon. However, the origin of the misalignment is not clear.
As-yet-undetected stellar or massive planetary companions could be responsible
for them, and naturally account for the presence of depleted inner cavities.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.03328 [pdf] - 1698038
Dust modeling of the combined ALMA and SPHERE datasets of HD163296. Is
HD163296 really a Meeus group II disk?
Muro-Arena, G. A.;
Dominik, C.;
Waters, L. B. F. M.;
Min, M.;
Klarmann, L.;
Ginski, C.;
Isella, A.;
Benisty, M.;
Pohl, A.;
Garufi, A.;
Hagelberg, J.;
Langlois, M.;
Menard, F.;
Pinte, C.;
Sezestre, E.;
van der Plas, G.;
Villenave, M.;
Delboulbé, A.;
Magnard, Y.;
Möller-Nilsson, O.;
Pragt, J.;
Rabou, P.;
Roelfsema, R.
Submitted: 2018-02-09
Context. Multi-wavelength observations are indispensable in studying disk
geometry and dust evolution processes in protoplanetary disks. Aims. We aimed
to construct a 3-dimensional model of HD 163296 capable of reproducing
simultaneously new observations of the disk surface in scattered light with the
SPHERE instrument and thermal emission continuum observations of the disk
midplane with ALMA. We want to determine why the SED of HD 163296 is
intermediary between the otherwise well-separated group I and group II Herbig
stars. Methods. The disk was modelled using the Monte Carlo radiative transfer
code MCMax3D. The radial dust surface density profile was modelled after the
ALMA observations, while the polarized scattered light observations were used
to constrain the inclination of the inner disk component and turbulence and
grain growth in the outer disk. Results. While three rings are observed in the
disk midplane in millimeter thermal emission at $\sim$80, 124 and 200 AU, only
the innermost of these is observed in polarized scattered light, indicating a
lack of small dust grains on the surface of the outer disk. We provide two
models capable of explaining this difference. The first model uses increased
settling in the outer disk as a mechanism to bring the small dust grains on the
surface of the disk closer to the midplane, and into the shadow cast by the
first ring. The second model uses depletion of the smallest dust grains in the
outer disk as a mechanism for decreasing the optical depth at optical and NIR
wavelengths. In the region outside the fragmentation-dominated regime, such
depletion is expected from state-of-the-art dust evolution models. We studied
the effect of creating an artificial inner cavity in our models, and conclude
that HD 163296 might be a precursor to typical group I sources.