Normalized to: Vallee, J.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.06798 [pdf] - 2001454
Statistics on 24 spiral galaxies having different observed arm locations
using different arm tracers
Submitted: 2019-11-15
The density wave theory predicted some physical offsets among different
tracers of star formation. To test this prediction, here we compiled data on 40
galaxies searched observationally for a physical offset between spiral arm
tracers, and found that 24 of them have a positive offset. In a spiral arm, an
arm tracer in a region with a given temperature may be at a different location
(offset) than an arm tracer in a region with a colder temperature. Some
conditions are found to be necessary or sufficient in order to detect an offset
between two arm tracers. To find the offset of a tracer from another tracer,
one needs a proper linear resolution. Starting in the dust lane and going
across the spiral arm, we seek the observed physical width of the star-forming
zone (offset). In our sample of 24 galaxies with measured offsets, we find
offsets with a median value near 326 pc and a mean near 370 pc. These offsets
are comparable to those found in our Milky Way galaxy, between the cold diffuse
CO 1-0 gas set at 0 pc, and the hot dust near 350 pc. Preliminary statistics
are performed on the angular velocity of the gas and stars and angular velocity
of the spiral pattern. Their observed orbital velocity of 200 km/s at a typical
galactic radius near 4 kpc yields an angular speed of the gas and stars near 60
km/s/kpc. Their deduced angular rotation for the spiral pattern averages 36
km/s/kpc. These observational results are close to the results predicted by the
shock-induced star-forming density wave theory. These mean or median property
values will be useful for finding other galaxies that can support density
waves.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.04177 [pdf] - 1960385
Spatial offsets between interstellar bone-like filaments, radio masers,
and cold diffuse CO gas, in the Scutum spiral arm
Submitted: 2019-09-09
The advent of more precise measurements of distance estimates for some
objects (bayesian estimates for filaments, trigonometric estimates for masers)
permits a better comparison of their relative locations, and a comparison with
a most recent spiral arm model fitted to the diffuse CO 1-0 gas. Our results
support the idea that some bone-like filaments, greater than 10 pc (labeled
elsewhere as bones, mst, herschel) and smaller than 100 pc, are observed near
the potential minimum of the Scutum spiral arm (bone-like filaments are offset
outward from masers by about 200 pc).
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.11473 [pdf] - 1959815
Spatial and velocity offsets of Galactic masers from the centers of
spiral arms
Submitted: 2019-08-29
Some galactic theories of spiral arms predict an offset between different
tracers of star formation. Our goal here is to find such an offset between the
observed location of radio masers and the location of the arms, using a recent
4-arm model fitted to the CO 1-0 gas. Our method here is to compare a recent
global 4-arm spiral model (as fitted to the arm tangents in the observed broad
CO 1-0 gas) with the recent results for the trigonometric distances of radio
masers, for the main arms (Cygnus-Norma, Perseus, Sagittarius-Carina, Scutum,
and Norma). Our results indicate that most radio masers are near the inner arm
edge (toward the Galactic Center) of spiral arms. These masers are offsets from
the model arm (where the broad CO 1-0 molecular region resides) by 0.34 (plus
or minus 0.06) kpc inward. In radial velocity space, the median offset between
masers and the CO-fitted model is around 10 (plus or minus 1) km/s. Based on
the masers being observed here to be radially inward of the broad CO gas in the
Cygnus arm at 15 kpc along the Galactic Meridian, the corotation radius of the
Milky Way disk is more than 15 kpc distant from the Galactic Centre and the
density-wave angular pattern speed is less than 15 km/s/kpc. Arm pitch angle
should be measured using many arm tracers, and located on both side of the
Galactic Meridian, to ensure better precision and avoid a bias pertinent to a
single tracer.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.12995 [pdf] - 1777945
Meta-analysis from different tracers of the small Local Arm around the
Sun - extent, shape, pitch, origin
Submitted: 2018-10-30
The Sun in not located in a major spiral arm, and sits in a small Local Arm
(variously called arm, armlet, blob, branch, bridge, feather, finger, segment,
spur, sub-arm, swath, etc). The diversity of names for the Local Arm near the
Sun indicates an uncertainty about its shape or pitch or its extent from the
Sun in each galactic quadrant, as well as an uncertainty about its origin. Here
we extract data about the small Local Arm near the Sun, from the recent
observational literature, over many arm tracers, and we use statistics in order
to find the its mean extent from the Sun, its possible shape and pitch angle
from the direction of galactic longitude 90 degrees. Employing all tracers, the
Local Arm is about 4 kpc long by 2 kpc large. The Sun is within 1 kpc of the
center of the local arm.
Proposed bridges and fingers are assessed. These bridges to nearby spiral
arms and fingers across spiral arms may not reach the nearest spiral arms,
owing to kinematic and photometric distance effects. We then compare these
statistical results with some predictions from recent models proposed to
explain the local arm (perturbations, resonances, density wave, halo
supercloud, debris trail from a dwarf galaxy).
The least controversial models involve importing materials from elsewhere
(halo supercloud, debris trail) as a first step, and to be later deformed in a
second step (by the Galactic differential rotation into become roughly parallel
to spiral arms) and then subjected to ongoing forces (global density waves,
local perturbations).
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.01379 [pdf] - 1732837
Offsets of masers with respect to the middle of the Perseus arm, and the
co-rotation radius in the Milky Way
Submitted: 2018-08-03
The radial distance to the co-rotation radius Rcoro (where the angular speed
of the gas and stars in orbit around the Galactic Centre is equal to the
angular speed of the spiral arm pattern) has often been predicted (at various
places), but not measured with a high precision.
Here we test the locations of masers with respect to the Perseus arm (Table
1). Our analysis of the masers and HII regions near the Perseus arm (mostly
located on the inner arm side, by about 0.4 kpc from the cold CO mid-arm) shows
that the co-rotation Rcoro must be > 10.8 kpc from the Galactic Center (Figure
1). This implies that the angular rotation speed of the spiral pattern < 21.3
km/s/kpc.
Another test in galactic quadrant II shows that the radial velocity of the
masers are generally more negative than that of the CO mid-arm (Figure 2),
indicating a deceleration with respect to the CO mid-arm, by about 9 km/s. This
implies that a spiral pattern angular rotation < 20.7 km/s/kpc, and thus Rcoro
> 11.1 kpc.
Finally, comparing our results with other published results (Table 2), we
find a statistical mean co-rotation radius Rcoro predicted to be near 12 kpc
from the Galactic Center (beyond the Perseus arm; before the Cygnus arm), and a
mean angular spiral pattern angular rotation predicted to be near 19 km/s/kpc.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1711.05228 [pdf] - 1592775
A guided map to the Spiral arms in the galactic disk of the Milky Way
Submitted: 2017-11-14
An up-to-date overview of the recent history is given, aiming to present a
helpful working guide to the literature and at the same time introduce key
systems and observational results, starting from the Sun and going towards the
Galactic Center and parts of the Zona Galactica Incognita, and beyond.
We start by presenting an observational view of the Milky Way's disk plane
(cartographic. dynamical, chemical cross-cut, magnetic). This included the four
long spiral arms in the disk of the Milky Way (fig.1), their geometry (fig.2),
component, velocity (fig.3), their widths and internal layers as well as
onion-like ordered offsets (fig.4), the central galactic bars, arm tangents,
arm pitch and arm shape, arm origins near the Galactic Center (fig.5), and
other possible players in the spiral arms, such as the magnetic field (fig.6)
and the dark matter content.
After, we present a basic analysis of some theoretical predictions from
galactic arm formation: numerical simulations or analytical theories, and
observations are checked against predictions from various numerical simulations
and analytical (theoretical) models.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.05303 [pdf] - 1588446
Constraining the pitch angle of the Galactic spiral arms in the Milky
Way
Submitted: 2017-09-15
We carry out analyses of some parameters of the galactic spiral arms, in the
currently available samples. We present a catalog of the observed pitch angle
for each spiral arm in the Milky Way disk. For each long spiral arm in the
Milky Way, we investigate for each individual arm its pitch angle, as measured
through different methods (parallaxes, twin-tangent arm, kinematical, etc), and
assess their answers.
Second, we catalog recent advances in the cartography of the Galaxy (global
mean arm pitch, arm number, arm shape, interarm distance at the Sun). We
statistically compare the results over a long time frame, from 1980 to 2017.
Histograms of about 90 individual results published in recent years (since
mid-2015) are compared to 66 earlier results (from 1980 to 2005), showing the
ratio of primary to secondary peaks to have increased by almost a factor of 3.
Similarly, many earlier discrepancies (expressed in r.m.s.) have been reduced
by almost a factor 3.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.09318 [pdf] - 1561244
On the many '3-kiloparsec arms' - shocked wave and nuclear rotation
Submitted: 2017-03-27
Many features near the Galactic Center have been called 3-kiloparsec arms. We
reached a point of having too many divergent data, making it difficult to be
constrained by a single physical model. Their differing characteristics suggest
different physical and dynamical objects.
Radial velocity data on the so-called 3-kpc arms do not coincide with radial
velocities of major spiral arms near 3kpc, nor near 2 kpc, nor near 4 kpc from
the Galactic Center (Fig. 1 and 2).
Different 3-kpc arm features may require different models: turbulence around
a shock in a Galactic density wave between 2 and 4 kpc from the Galactic Center
(Table 1), or nuclear rotation between 0 and 2 kpc from the Galactic Center
region (Table 2), or a putative radial expansion between 0 and 4 kpc from the
Galactic Center.
Despite their naming as Near 3-kiloparsec arms or Far 3-kiloparsec arms,
these features are not major arms. Those 3-kpc arm features nearer the Galactic
Center (within 13o of Galactic longitude) may be different than those farther
out (Table 2).
Here we show that the plethora of observed '3-kpc arm' features can be
separated in two: those with Galactic longitude of 13 degrees or more away from
the Galactic Center (Table 1 - some of which are possibly associated with the
observed major spiral arms), and those within 13 degrees from the Galactic
Center (Table 2 - some of which are possibly associated with the observed
central bars; Fig.1 and Fig.2).
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.08871 [pdf] - 1391880
A substructure inside spiral arms, and a mirror image across the
Galactic Meridian
Submitted: 2016-03-29
While the galactic density wave theory is over 50 years old and well known in
science, whether it fits our own Milky Way disk has been difficult to say. Here
we show a substructure inside the spiral arms. This substructure is reversing
with respect to the Galactic Meridian (longitude zero), and crosscuts of the
arms at negative longitudes appear as mirror images of crosscuts of the arms at
positive longitudes. Four lanes are delineated: mid-arm (extended 12CO gas at
mid arm, HI atoms), in-between offset by about 100 pc (synchrotron, radio
recombination lines), in between offset by about 200 pc (masers, colder dust),
and inner edge (hotter dust seen in Mid-IR and Near-IR).
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.02183 [pdf] - 1360839
The start of the Sagittarius spiral arm (Sagittarius origin) and the
start of the Norma spiral arm (Norma origin) - model-computed and observed
arm tangents at galactic longitudes -20 degrees < l < +23 degrees
Submitted: 2016-02-05
Here we fitted a 4-arm spiral structure to the more accurate data on global
arm pitch angle and arm longitude tangents, to get the start of each spiral arm
near the Galactic nucleus. We find that the tangent to the 'start of the
Sagittarius' spiral arm (arm middle) is at l= -17 degrees +/- 0.5 degree, while
the tangent to the 'start of the Norma' spiral arm (arm middle) is at l= +20
degrees +/- 0.5 degree.
Earlier, we published a compilation of observations and analysis of the
tangent to each spiral arm tracer, from longitudes +23 degrees to +340 degrees;
here we cover the arm tracers in the remaining longitudes +340 degrees (=- 20
degrees) to +23 degrees. Our model arm tangents are confirmed through the
recent observed masers data (at the arm's inner edge). Observed arm tracers in
the inner Galaxy show an offset from the mid-arm; this was also found elsewhere
in the Milky Way disk (Vallee 2014c).
In addition, we collated the observed tangents to the so-called '3-kpc-arm'
features; here they are found statistically to be near l= -18 degrees +/- 2
degrees and near l= +21 degrees +/- 2 degrees, after excluding misidentified
spiral arms. We find that the model-computed arm tangents in the inner Galaxcy
are spatially coincident with the mean longitude of the observed tangents to
the '3-kpc-arm' features (same galactic longitudes, within the errors). These
spatial similarities may be suggestive of a contiguous space.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.01202 [pdf] - 1265695
Different studies of the global pitch angle of the Milky Way's spiral
arms
Submitted: 2015-05-05
There are many published values for the pitch angle of individual spiral
arms, and their wide distribution (from -3 to -28 degrees) begs for various
attempts for a single value. Each of the four statistical methods used here
yields a mean pitch angle in a small range, between -12 and -14 degrees (table
7, figure 2). The final result of our meta-analysis yields a mean global pitch
angle in the Milky Way's spiral arms of -13.1 degrees, plus or minus 0.6
degree.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.4801 [pdf] - 984899
Catalog of observed tangents to the spiral arms in the Milky Way galaxy
Submitted: 2014-09-16
From the sun's location in the Galactic disk, one can use different arm
tracers (CO, HII, thermal or ionized or relativistic electrons, masers, cold or
hot dust, etc) to locate a tangent to each spiral arm in the disk of the Milky
Way galaxy. We present a Master catalog of the astronomically observed tangents
to the Galaxy's spiral arms, using different arm tracers from the literature.
Some arm tracers can have slightly divergent results from several papers, so a
mean is taken - see Appendix for CO, HII, and masers. The Master catalog of
means currently consists of 63 mean tracer entries, spread over many arms
(Carina, Crux-Centaurus, Norma, Perseus origin, near 3-kpc, Scutum,
Sagittarius), stemming from 107 original arm tracer entries.
Additionally, we updated and revised a previous a previous statistical
analysis of the angular offset and linear separation from the mid-arm, for each
different mean arm tracer. Given enough arm tracers, and summing and averaging
over all spiral arms, one could determine if arm tracers have separate and
parallel lanes in the Milky Way. This statistical analysis allows a cross-cut
of a galactic spiral arm to be made, confirming a recent discovery of a linear
separation between arm tracers. Here, from the mid-arm's CO to the inner edge's
hot dust, the arm half-width is about 340 parsecs; doubling would yield a full
arm width of 680 parsecs. We briefly compare these observations with the
predictions of many spiral arm theories, notably the density wave theory.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1102.5057 [pdf] - 617140
Sensitive Observations of Radio Recombination Lines in Orion and W51:
The Data and Detection of Systematic Recombination Line Blueshifts
Proportional to Impact Broadening
Submitted: 2011-02-24
Sensitive spectral observations made in two frequency bands near 6.0 and 17.6
GHz are described for Orion and W51. Using frequency switching we were able to
achieve a dynamic range in excess of 10,000 without fitting sinusoidal or
polynomial baselines. This enabled us to detect lines as weak as T$_{A} ~1mK in
these strong continuum sources. Hydrogen recombination lines with $\Delta n$ as
high as 25 have been detected in Orion. In the Orion data, where the lines are
stronger, we have also detected a systematic shift in the line center
frequencies proportional to linewidth that cannot be explained by normal
optical depth effects.