Normalized to: Usher, C.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.09636 [pdf] - 2093313
Searching for globular cluster chemical anomalies on the main sequence
of a young massive cluster
Cabrera-Ziri, I.;
Speagle, J. S.;
Dalessandro, E.;
Usher, C.;
Bastian, N. J.;
Salaris, M.;
Martocchia, S.;
Kozhurina-Platais, V.;
Niederhofer, F.;
Lardo, C.;
Larsen, S. S.;
Saracino, S.
Submitted: 2020-04-20
The spectroscopic and photometric signals of the star-to-star abundance
variations found in globular clusters seem to be correlated with global
parameters like the cluster's metallicity, mass and age. Understanding this
behaviour could bring us closer to the origin of these intriguing abundance
spreads. In this work we use deep HST photometry to look for evidence of
abundance variations in the main sequence of a young massive cluster NGC 419
($\sim10^5$ M$_{\odot}$, $\sim1.4$ Gyr). Unlike previous studies, here we focus
on stars in the same mass range found in old globulars ($\sim0.75-1$
M$_{\odot}$), where light elements variations are detected. We find no evidence
for N abundance variations among these stars in the $Un-B$ and $U-B$ CMD of NGC
419. This is at odds with the N-variations found in old globulars like 47 Tuc,
NGC 6352 and NGC 6637 with similar metallicity to NGC 419. Although the
signature of the abundance variations characteristic of old globulars appears
to be significantly smaller or absent in this young cluster, we cannot conclude
if this effect is mainly driven by its age or its mass.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.03428 [pdf] - 2069102
Searching for Multiple Populations in the Integrated Light of the Young
and Extremely Massive Clusters in the Merger Remnant NGC~7252
Bastian, Nate;
Lardo, Carmela;
Usher, Christopher;
Kamann, Sebastian;
Larsen, Soeren S.;
Cabrera-Ziri, Ivan;
Chantereau, William;
Martocchia, Silvia;
Salaris, Maurizio;
Asa'd, Randa;
Hilker, Michael
Submitted: 2020-03-06
Recent work has shown that the properties of multiple populations within
massive stellar clusters (i.e., in the extent of their abundance variations as
well as the fraction of stars that show the anomalous chemistry) depend on the
mass as well as the age of the host cluster. Such correlations are largely
unexpected in current models for the formation of multiple populations and
hence provide essential insight into their origin. Here we extend or previous
study into the presence or absence of multiple populations using integrated
light spectroscopy of the $\sim600$~Myr, massive ($\sim10^7 - 10^8$~\msun)
clusters, W3 and W30, in the galactic merger remnant, NGC 7252. Due to the
extreme mass of both clusters, the expectation is that they should host rather
extreme abundance spreads, manifested through, e.g., high mean [Na/Fe]
abundances. However, we do not find evidence for a strong [Na/Fe] enhancement,
with the observations being consistent with the solar value. This suggests that
age is playing a key role, or alternatively that multiple populations only
manifest below a certain stellar mass, as the integrated light at all ages
above $\sim100$~Myr is dominated by stars near or above the main sequence
turn-off.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.04145 [pdf] - 2034604
Photometric characterization of multiple populations in star clusters:
The impact of the first dredge-up
Submitted: 2020-01-13
The existence of star-to-star light-element abundance variations (multiple
populations, MPs) in massive Galactic and extragalactic star clusters older
than about 2 Gyr is by now well established. Photometry of red giant branch
(RGB) stars has been and still is instrumental in enabling the detection and
characterization of cluster MPs, through the appropriate choices of filters,
colours and colour combinations, that are mainly sensitive to N and --to a
lesser degree-- C stellar surface abundances. An important issue not yet
properly addressed is that the translation of the observed widths of the
cluster RGBs to abundance spreads must account for the effect of the first
dredge-up on the surface chemical patterns, hence on the spectral energy
distributions of stars belonging to the various MPs. We have filled this gap by
studying theoretically the impact of the dredge-up on the predicted widths of
RGBs in clusters hosting MPs. We find that for a given initial range of N
abundances, the first dredge up reduces the predicted RGB widths in N-sensitive
filters compared to the case when its effect on the stellar spectral energy
distributions is not accounted for. This reduction is a strong function of age
and has also a dependence on metallicity. The net effect is an underestimate of
the initial N-abundance ranges from RGB photometry if the first dredge-up is
not accounted for in the modelling, and also the potential determination of
spurious trends of N-abundance spreads with age.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.01810 [pdf] - 2038433
The WAGGS project -- III. Discrepant mass-to-light ratios of Galactic
globular clusters at high metallicity
Dalgleish, H.;
Kamann, S.;
Usher, C.;
Baumgardt, H.;
Bastian, N.;
Veitch-Michaelis, J.;
Bellini, A.;
Martocchia, S.;
Da Costa, G. S.;
Mackey, D.;
Bellstedt, S.;
Pastorello, N.;
Cerulo, P.
Submitted: 2020-01-06
Observed mass-to-light ratios (M/L) of metal-rich globular clusters (GCs)
disagree with theoretical predictions. This discrepancy is of fundamental
importance since stellar population models provide the stellar masses that
underpin most of extragalactic astronomy, near and far. We have derived radial
velocities for 1,622 stars located in the centres of 59 Milky Way GCs - twelve
of which have no previous kinematic information - using integral-field unit
data from the WAGGS project. Using N-body models, we then determine dynamical
masses and M/L ratios for the studied clusters. Our sample includes NGC 6528
and NGC 6553, which extend the metallicity range of GCs with measured M/L up to
[Fe/H] ~ -0.1 dex. We find that metal-rich clusters have M/L more than two
times lower than what is predicted by simple stellar population models. This
confirms that the discrepant M/L-[Fe/H] relation remains a serious concern. We
explore how our findings relate to previous observations, and the potential
causes for the divergence, which we conclude is most likely due to dynamical
effects.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.01731 [pdf] - 2034571
How stellar rotation shapes the colour magnitude diagram of the massive
intermediate-age star cluster NGC 1846
Kamann, Sebastian;
Bastian, Nate;
Gossage, Seth;
Baade, Dietrich;
Cabrera-Ziri, Ivan;
Da Costa, Gary;
de Mink, Selma E.;
Georgy, Cyril;
Giesers, Benjamin;
Göttgens, Fabian;
Hilker, Michael;
Husser, Tim-Oliver;
Lardo, Carmela;
Larsen, Søren;
Mackey, Dougal;
Martocchia, Silvia;
Mucciarelli, Alessio;
Platais, Imants;
Roth, Martin M.;
Salaris, Maurizio;
Usher, Christopher;
Yong, David
Submitted: 2020-01-06
We present a detailed study of stellar rotation in the massive 1.5 Gyr old
cluster NGC 1846 in the Large Magellanic Cloud. Similar to other clusters at
this age, NGC 1846 shows an extended main sequence turn-off (eMSTO), and
previous photometric studies have suggested it could be bimodal. In this study,
we use MUSE integral-field spectroscopy to measure the projected rotational
velocities (vsini) of around 1400 stars across the eMSTO and along the upper
main sequence of NGC 1846. We measure vsini values up to ~250 km/s and find a
clear relation between the vsini of a star and its location across the eMSTO.
Closer inspection of the distribution of rotation rates reveals evidence for a
bimodal distribution, with the fast rotators centred around vsini = 140 km/s
and the slow rotators centred around vsini = 60 km/s. We further observe a lack
of fast rotating stars along the photometric binary sequence of NGC 1846,
confirming results from the field that suggest that tidal interactions in
binary systems can spin down stars. However, we do not detect a significant
difference in the binary fractions of the fast and slowly rotating
sub-populations. Finally, we report on the serendipitous discovery of a
planetary nebula associated with NGC 1846.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.02075 [pdf] - 2026254
Extended main sequence turnoffs in open clusters as seen by Gaia -- II.
The enigma of NGC 2509
Submitted: 2019-11-05
We investigate the morphology of the colour-magnitude diagram (CMD) of the
open cluster NGC 2509 in comparison with other Galactic open clusters of
similar age using Gaia photometry. At $\sim900$ Myr Galactic open clusters in
our sample all show an extended main sequence turn off (eMSTO) with the
exception of NGC 2509, which presents an exceptionally narrow CMD. Our analysis
of the Gaia data rules out differential extinction, stellar density, and
binaries as a cause for the singular MSTO morphology in this cluster. We
interpret this feature as a consequence of the stellar rotation distribution
within the cluster and present the analysis with MIST stellar evolution models
that include the effect of stellar rotation on which we based our conclusion.
In particular, these models point to an unusually narrow range of stellar
rotation rates ($\Omega/\Omega_{\rm{crit,ZAMS}} = [0.4, 0.6]$) within the
cluster as the cause of this singular feature in the CMD of NGC 2509.
Interestingly, models that do not include rotation are not as good at
reproducing the morphology of the observed CMD in this cluster.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.10118 [pdf] - 1975343
Young star cluster populations in the E-MOSAICS simulations
Submitted: 2019-07-23, last modified: 2019-09-25
We present an analysis of young star clusters (YSCs) that form in the
E-MOSAICS cosmological, hydrodynamical simulations of galaxies and their star
cluster populations. Through comparisons with observed YSC populations, this
work aims to test models for YSC formation and obtain an insight into the
formation processes at work in part of the local galaxy population. We find
that the models used in E-MOSAICS for the cluster formation efficiency and
high-mass truncation of the initial cluster mass function ($M_\mathrm{c,\ast}$)
both quantitatively reproduce the observed values of cluster populations in
nearby galaxies. At higher redshifts ($z \geq 2$, near the peak of globular
cluster formation) we find that, at a constant star formation rate (SFR)
surface density, $M_\mathrm{c,\ast}$ is larger than at $z=0$ by a factor of
four due to the higher gas fractions in the simulated high-redshift galaxies.
Similar processes should be at work in local galaxies, offering a new way to
test the models. We find that cluster age distributions may be sensitive to
variations in the cluster formation rate (but not SFR) with time, which may
significantly affect their use in tests of cluster mass loss. By comparing
simulations with different implementations of cluster formation physics, we
find that (even partially) environmentally-independent cluster formation is
inconsistent with the brightest cluster-SFR and specific
luminosity-$\Sigma_\mathrm{SFR}$ relations, whereas these observables are
reproduced by the fiducial, environmentally-varying model. This shows that
models in which a constant fraction of stars form in clusters are inconsistent
with observations.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.05753 [pdf] - 1971451
The SLUGGS Survey: Measuring globular cluster ages using both photometry
and spectroscopy
Submitted: 2019-09-12
Globular cluster ages provide both an important test of models of globular
cluster formation and a powerful method to constrain the assembly history of
galaxies. Unfortunately, measuring the ages of unresolved old stellar
populations has proven challenging. Here, we present a novel technique that
combines optical photometry with metallicity constraints from near-infrared
spectroscopy in order to measure ages. After testing the method on globular
clusters in the Milky Way and its satellite galaxies, we apply our technique to
three massive early-type galaxies using data from the SLUGGS Survey. The three
SLUGGS galaxies and the Milky Way show dramatically different globular cluster
age and metallicity distributions, with NGC 1407 and the Milky Way showing
mostly old globular clusters while NGC 3115 and NGC 3377 show a range of
globular ages. This diversity implies different galaxy formation histories and
that the globular cluster optical colour-metallicity relation is not universal
as is commonly assumed in globular cluster studies. We find a correlation
between the median age of the metal rich globular cluster populations and the
age of the field star populations, in line with models where globular cluster
formation is a natural outcome of high intensity star formation.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.01404 [pdf] - 1967047
Multiple Populations in Integrated Light Spectroscopy of Intermediate
Age Clusters
Bastian, Nate;
Usher, Christopher;
Kamann, Sebastian;
Lardo, Carmela;
Larsen, Søren S.;
Cabrera-Ziri, Ivan;
Chantereau, William;
Martocchia, Silvia;
Salaris, Maurizio;
Schiavon, Ricardo P.;
Asa'd, Randa;
Hilker, Michael
Submitted: 2019-09-03
The presence of star-to-star light-element abundance variations (a.k.a.
multiple populations, MPs) appears to be ubiquitous within old and massive
clusters in the Milky Way and all studied nearby galaxies. Most previous
studies have focussed on resolved images or spectroscopy of individual stars,
although there has been significant effort in the past few years to look for
multiple population signatures in integrated light spectroscopy. If proven
feasible, integrated light studies offer a potential way to vastly open
parameter space, as clusters out to tens of Mpc can be studied. We use the NaD
lines in the integrated spectra of two clusters with similar ages ($2-3$ Gyr)
but very different masses, NGC 1978 ($\sim3\times10^5$ Msun) in the LMC and
G114 ($1.7\times10^7$ Msun) in NGC 1316. For NGC 1978, our findings agree with
resolved studies of individual stars which did not find evidence for Na
spreads. However, for G114, we find clear evidence for the presence of multiple
populations. The fact that the same anomalous abundance patterns are found in
both the intermediate age and ancient GCs lends further support to the notion
that young massive clusters are effectively the same as the ancient globular
clusters, only separated in age.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.10845 [pdf] - 1929918
No evidence for intermediate-mass black holes in the globular clusters
$\omega$ Cen and NGC 6624
Baumgardt, Holger;
He, Chenyu;
Sweet, Sarah M.;
Drinkwater, Michael;
Sollima, Antonio;
Hurley, Jarrod;
Usher, Christopher;
Kamann, Sebastian;
Dalgleish, Hannah S.;
Dreizler, Stefan;
Husser, Tim-Oliver
Submitted: 2019-07-25
We compare the results of a large grid of N-body simulations with the surface
brightness and velocity dispersion profiles of the globular clusters $\omega$
Cen and NGC 6624. Our models include clusters with varying stellar-mass black
hole retention fractions and varying masses of a central intermediate-mass
black hole (IMBH). We find that an $\sim 45,000$ M$_\odot$ IMBH, whose presence
has been suggested based on the measured velocity dispersion profile of
$\omega$ Cen, predicts the existence of about 20 fast-moving, $m>0.5$ M$_\odot$
main-sequence stars with a (1D) velocity $v>60$ km/sec in the central 20 arcsec
of $\omega$ Cen. However no such star is present in the HST/ACS proper motion
catalogue of Bellini et al. (2017), strongly ruling out the presence of a
massive IMBH in the core of $\omega$ Cen. Instead, we find that all available
data can be fitted by a model that contains 4.6% of the mass of $\omega$ Cen in
a centrally concentrated cluster of stellar-mass black holes. We show that this
mass fraction in stellar-mass BHs is compatible with the predictions of stellar
evolution models of massive stars.
We also compare our grid of $N$-body simulations with NGC 6624, a cluster
recently claimed to harbor a 20,000 M$_\odot$ black hole based on timing
observations of millisecond pulsars. However, we find that models with
$M_{IMBH}>1,000$ M$_\odot$ IMBHs are incompatible with the observed velocity
dispersion and surface brightness profile of NGC 6624,ruling out the presence
of a massive IMBH in this cluster. Models without an IMBH provide again an
excellent fit to NGC 6624.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.03273 [pdf] - 1902011
The search for multiple populations in Magellanic Clouds clusters - V.
Correlation between cluster age and abundance spreads
Martocchia, S.;
Dalessandro, E.;
Lardo, C.;
Cabrera-Ziri, I.;
Bastian, N.;
Kozhurina-Platais, V.;
Salaris, M.;
Chantereau, W.;
Geisler, D.;
Hilker, M.;
Kacharov, N.;
Larsen, S.;
Mackey, D.;
Mucciarelli, A.;
Niederhofer, F.;
Platais, I.;
Usher, C.
Submitted: 2019-06-07
In our HST photometric survey, we have been searching for multiple stellar
populations (MPs) in Magellanic Clouds (MCs) massive star clusters which span a
significant range of ages ($\sim 1.5-11$ Gyr). In the previous papers of the
series, we have shown that the age of the cluster represents one of the key
factors in shaping the origin of the chemical anomalies. Here we present the
analysis of four additional clusters in the MCs, namely Lindsay 38, Lindsay
113, NGC 2121 and NGC 2155, for which we recently obtained new UV HST
observations. These clusters are more massive than $\sim 10^4M_{\odot}$ and
have ages between $\sim 2.5-6$ Gyr, i.e. located in a previously unexplored
region of the cluster age/mass diagram. We found chemical anomalies, in the
form of N spreads, in three out of four clusters in the sample, namely in NGC
2121, NGC 2155 and Lindsay 113. By combining data from our survey and HST
photometry for 3 additional clusters in the Milky Way (namely 47 Tuc, M15 and
NGC 2419), we show that the extent of the MPs in the form of N spread is a
strong function of age, with older clusters having larger N spreads with
respect to the younger ones. Hence, we confirm that cluster age plays a
significant role in the onset of MPs.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.02297 [pdf] - 1830712
Spectroscopic detection of multiple populations in the ~2 Gyr old
cluster Hodge 6 in the LMC
Hollyhead, K.;
Martocchia, S.;
Lardo, C.;
Bastian, N.;
Kacharov, N.;
Niederhofer, F.;
Cabrera-Ziri, I.;
Dalessandro, E.;
Mucciarelli, A.;
Salaris, M.;
Usher, C.
Submitted: 2019-02-06
We report the spectroscopic discovery of abundance spreads (i.e. multiple
populations) in the ~2 Gyr old cluster in the LMC, Hodge 6. We use low
resolution VLT FORS2 spectra of 15 member stars in the cluster to measure their
CN and CH band strengths at ~3883 and 4300 A, respectively, as well as [C/Fe]
and [N/Fe] abundances. We find a sub-population of 2 stars that are enriched in
nitrogen, and we conclude that this sub-population is evidence of multiple
populations in Hodge 6. This is the second ~2 Gyr old cluster (the first being
NGC 1978 in the LMC) to show multiple populations and the first spectroscopic
detection of MPs in a cluster of this age. This result is interesting as it
hints at a possible relationship between the disappearance of extended main
sequence turn-offs in clusters younger than ~2 Gyr and the onset of multiple
populations at ~2 Gyr, which should be explored further.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.07650 [pdf] - 1763117
The WAGGS project - II. The reliability of the calcium triplet as a
metallicity indicator in integrated stellar light
Usher, Christopher;
Beckwith, Thomas;
Bellstedt, Sabine;
Alabi, Adebusola;
Chevalier, Leonie;
Pastorello, Nicola;
Cerulo, Pierluigi;
Dalgleish, Hannah S.;
Fraser-McKelvie, Amelia;
Kamann, Sebastian;
Penny, Samantha;
Foster, Caroline;
McDermid, Richard;
Schiavon, Ricardo P.;
Villaume, Alexa
Submitted: 2018-09-20
Using data from the WiFeS Atlas of Galactic Globular cluster Spectra we study
the behaviour of the calcium triplet (CaT), a popular metallicity indicator in
extragalactic stellar population studies. A major caveat of these studies is
that the potential sensitivity to other stellar population parameters such as
age, calcium abundance and the initial mass function has not yet been
empirically evaluated. Here we present measurements of the strength of the CaT
feature for 113 globular clusters in the Milky Way and its satellite galaxies.
We derive empirical calibrations between the CaT index and both the iron
abundance ([Fe/H]) and calcium abundance ([Ca/H]), finding a tighter
relationship for [Ca/H] than for [Fe/H]. For stellar populations 3 Gyr and
older the CaT can be used to reliably measure [Ca/H] at the 0.1 dex level but
becomes less reliable for ages of $\sim 2$ Gyr and younger. We find that the
CaT is relatively insensitive to the horizontal branch morphology. The stellar
mass function however affects the CaT strengths significantly only at low
metallicities. Using our newly derived empirical calibration, we convert our
measured CaT indices into [Ca/H] values for the globular clusters in our
sample.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.10779 [pdf] - 1729195
Extended Main Sequence Turnoffs in Open Clusters as Seen by Gaia: I. NGC
2818 and the Role of Stellar Rotation
Submitted: 2018-07-27
We present an analysis of the relatively low mass ($\sim2400$~M$_{\odot}$),
$\sim800$~Myr, Galactic open cluster, NGC~2818, using Gaia DR2 results combined
with VLT/FLAMES spectroscopy. Using Gaia DR2 proper motions and parallax
measurements we are able to select a clean sample of cluster members. This
cluster displays a clear extended main sequence turn-off (eMSTO), a phenomenon
previously studied mainly in young and intermediate age massive clusters in the
Magellanic clouds. The main sequence of NGC~2818 is extremely narrow, with a
width of $\sim0.01$ magnitudes (G$_{\rm BP} - $ G$_{\rm RP}$), suggesting very
low levels of differential extinction. Using VLT/FLAMES spectroscopy of 60
cluster members to measure the rotational velocity of the stars (Vsini) we find
that stars on the red side of the eMSTO have high Vsini ($>160$~km/s) while
stars on the blue side have low Vsini ($<160$~km/s), in agreement with model
predictions. The cluster also follows the previously discovered trend between
the age of the cluster and the extent of the eMSTO. We conclude that stellar
rotation is the likely cause of the eMSTO phenomenon.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.10612 [pdf] - 1729189
Cluster kinematics and stellar rotation in NGC 419 with MUSE and
adaptive optics
Kamann, Sebastian;
Bastian, Nathan J.;
Husser, Tim-Oliver;
Martocchia, Silvia;
Usher, Christopher;
Brok, Mark den;
Dreizler, Stefan;
Kelz, Andreas;
Krajnović, Davor;
Richard, Johan;
Steinmetz, Matthias;
Weilbacher, Peter M.
Submitted: 2018-07-27
We present adaptive optics (AO) assisted integral-field spectroscopy of the
intermediate-age star cluster NGC 419 in the Small Magellanic Cloud. By
investigating the cluster dynamics and the rotation properties of main sequence
turn-off stars (MSTO), we demonstrate the power of AO-fed MUSE observations for
this class of objects. Based on 1 049 radial velocity measurements, we
determine a dynamical cluster mass of 1.4+/-0.2x10^5 M_sun and a dynamical
mass-to-light ratio of 0.67+/-0.08, marginally higher than simple stellar
population predictions for a Kroupa initial mass function. A stacking analysis
of spectra at both sides of the extended MSTO reveals significant rotational
broadening. Our analysis further provides tentative evidence that red MSTO
stars rotate faster than their blue counterparts. We find average V sin i
values of 87+/-16 km/s and 130+/-22 km/s for blue and red MSTO stars,
respectively. Potential systematic effects due to the low spectral resolution
of MUSE can reach 30 km/s but the difference in V sin i between the populations
is unlikely to be affected.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.03084 [pdf] - 1725053
The origin of the 'blue tilt' of globular cluster populations in the
E-MOSAICS simulations
Submitted: 2018-07-09
The metal-poor sub-population of globular cluster (GC) systems exhibits a
correlation between the GC average colour and luminosity, especially in those
systems associated with massive elliptical galaxies. More luminous (more
massive) GCs are typically redder and hence more metal-rich. This 'blue tilt'
is often interpreted as a mass-metallicity relation stemming from GC
self-enrichment, whereby more massive GCs retain a greater fraction of the
enriched gas ejected by their evolving stars, fostering the formation of more
metal-rich secondary generations. We examine the E-MOSAICS simulations of the
formation and evolution of galaxies and their GC populations, and find that
their GCs exhibit a colour-luminosity relation similar to that observed in
local galaxies, without the need to invoke mass-dependent self-enrichment. We
find that the blue tilt is most appropriately interpreted as a dearth of
massive, metal-poor GCs: the formation of massive GCs requires high
interstellar gas surface densities, conditions that are most commonly fostered
by the most massive, and hence most metal rich, galaxies, at the peak epoch of
GC formation. The blue tilt is therefore a consequence of the intimate coupling
between the small-scale physics of GC formation and the evolving properties of
interstellar gas hosted by hierarchically-assembling galaxies.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.05343 [pdf] - 1686925
Multiple populations within globular clusters in Early-type galaxies
Exploring their effect on stellar initial mass function estimates
Submitted: 2018-05-14
It is now well-established that most (if not all) ancient globular clusters
host multiple popula- tions, that are characterised by distinct chemical
features such as helium abundance variations along with N-C and Na-O
anti-correlations, at fixed [Fe/H]. These very distinct chemical fea- tures are
similar to what is found in the centres of the massive early-type galaxies and
may influence measurements of the global properties of the galaxies.
Additionally, recent results have suggested that M/L variations found in the
centres of massive early-type galaxies might be due to a bottom-heavy stellar
initial mass function. We present an analysis of the effects of globular
cluster-like multiple populations on the integrated properties of early-type
galaxies. In particular, we focus on spectral features in the integrated
optical spectrum and the global mass-to-light ratio that have been used to
infer variations in the stellar initial mass function. To achieve this we
develop appropriate stellar population synthesis models and take into account,
for the first time, an initial-final mass relation which takes into
consideration a varying He abundance. We conclude that while the multiple
populations may be present in massive early-type galaxies, they are likely not
responsible for the observed variations in the mass- to-light ratio and IMF
sensitive line strengths. Finally, we estimate the fraction of stars with
multiple populations chemistry that come from disrupted globular clusters
within massive ellipticals and find that they may explain some of the observed
chemical patterns in the centres of these galaxies.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.04141 [pdf] - 1675021
The search for multiple populations in Magellanic Cloud Clusters IV:
Coeval multiple stellar populations in the young star cluster NGC 1978
Martocchia, S.;
Niederhofer, F.;
Dalessandro, E.;
Bastian, N.;
Kacharov, N.;
Usher, C.;
Cabrera-Ziri, I.;
Lardo, C.;
Cassisi, S.;
Geisler, D.;
Hilker, M.;
Hollyhead, K.;
Kozhurina-Platais, V.;
Larsen, S.;
Mackey, D.;
Mucciarelli, A.;
Platais, I.;
Salaris, M.
Submitted: 2018-04-11
We have recently shown that the $\sim2$ Gyr old Large Magellanic Cloud star
cluster NGC 1978 hosts multiple populations in terms of star-to-star abundance
variations in [N/Fe]. These can be seen as a splitting or spread in the
sub-giant and red giant branches (SGB and RGB) when certain photometric filter
combinations are used. Due to its relative youth, NGC 1978 can be used to place
stringent limits on whether multiple bursts of star-formation have taken place
within the cluster, as predicted by some models for the origin of multiple
populations. We carry out two distinct analyses to test whether multiple
star-formation epochs have occurred within NGC 1978. First, we use UV CMDs to
select stars from the first and second population along the SGB, and then
compare their positions in optical CMDs, where the morphology is dominantly
controlled by age as opposed to multiple population effects. We find that the
two populations are indistinguishable, with age differences of $1\pm20$ Myr
between them. This is in tension with predictions from the AGB scenario for the
origin of multiple populations. Second, we estimate the broadness of the main
sequence turnoff (MSTO) of NGC 1978 and we report that it is consistent with
the observational errors. We find an upper limit of $\sim$65 Myr on the age
spread in the MSTO of NGC 1978. This finding is in conflict with the age spread
scenario as origin of the extended MSTO in intermediate age clusters, while it
fully supports predictions from the stellar rotation model.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.00831 [pdf] - 1593666
Age as a Major Factor in the Onset of Multiple Populations in Stellar
Clusters
Martocchia, S.;
Cabrera-Ziri, I.;
Lardo, C.;
Dalessandro, E.;
Bastian, N.;
Kozhurina-Platais, V.;
Usher, C.;
Niederhofer, F.;
Cordero, M.;
Geisler, D.;
Hollyhead, K.;
Kacharov, N.;
Larsen, S.;
Li, C.;
Mackey, D.;
Hilker, M.;
Mucciarelli, A.;
Platais, I.;
Salaris, M.
Submitted: 2017-10-02
It is now well established that globular clusters (GCs) exhibit star-to-star
light-element abundance variations (known as multiple stellar populations,
MPs). Such chemical anomalies have been found in (nearly) all the ancient GCs
(more than 10 Gyr old) of our Galaxy and its close companions, but so far no
model for the origin of MPs is able to reproduce all the relevant observations.
To gain new insights into this phenomenon, we have undertaken a photometric
Hubble Space Telescope survey to study clusters with masses comparable to that
of old GCs, where MPs have been identified, but with significantly younger
ages. Nine clusters in the Magellanic Clouds with ages between $\sim$ 1.5-11
Gyr have been targeted in this survey. We confirm the presence of multiple
populations in all clusters older than 6 Gyr and we add NGC 1978 to the group
of clusters for which MPs have been identified. With an age of $\sim$ 2 Gyr,
NGC 1978 is the youngest cluster known to host chemical abundance spreads found
to date. We do not detect evident star-to-star variations for slightly younger
massive clusters ($\sim$ 1.7 Gyr), thus pointing towards an unexpected age
dependence for the onset of multiple populations. This discovery suggests that
the formation of MPs is not restricted to the early Universe and that GCs and
young massive clusters share common formation and evolutionary processes.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.05904 [pdf] - 1574620
The SLUGGS Survey: Dark matter fractions at large radii and assembly
epochs of early-type galaxies from globular cluster kinematics
Alabi, Adebusola B.;
Forbes, Duncan A.;
Romanowsky, Aaron J.;
Brodie, Jean P.;
Strader, Jay;
Janz, Joachim;
Usher, Christopher;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Bellstedt, Sabine;
Ferré-Mateu, Anna
Submitted: 2017-01-20, last modified: 2017-04-10
We use globular cluster kinematics data, primarily from the SLUGGS survey, to
measure the dark matter fraction ($f_{\rm DM}$) and the average dark matter
density ($\left< \rho_{\rm DM} \right>$) within the inner 5 effective radii
($R_{\rm e}$) for 32 nearby early--type galaxies (ETGs) with stellar mass log
$(M_*/\rm M_\odot)$ ranging from $10.1$ to $11.8$. We compare our results with
a simple galaxy model based on scaling relations as well as with cosmological
hydrodynamical simulations where the dark matter profile has been modified
through various physical processes.
We find a high $f_{\rm DM}$ ($\geq0.6$) within 5~$R_{\rm e}$ in most of our
sample, which we interpret as a signature of a late mass assembly history that
is largely devoid of gas-rich major mergers. However, around log $(M_*/M_\odot)
\sim 11$, there is a wide range of $f_{\rm DM}$ which may be challenging to
explain with any single cosmological model. We find tentative evidence that
lenticulars (S0s), unlike ellipticals, have mass distributions that are similar
to spiral galaxies, with decreasing $f_{\rm DM}$ within 5~$R_{\rm e}$ as galaxy
luminosity increases. However, we do not find any difference between the
$\left< \rho_{\rm DM} \right>$ of S0s and ellipticals in our sample, despite
the differences in their stellar populations. We have also used $\left<
\rho_{\rm DM} \right>$ to infer the epoch of halo assembly ($z{\sim}2-4$). By
comparing the age of their central stars with the inferred epoch of halo
formation, we are able to gain more insight into their mass assembly histories.
Our results suggest a fundamental difference in the dominant late-phase mass
assembly channel between lenticulars and elliptical galaxies.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.07397 [pdf] - 1574695
The WAGGS project - I. The WiFeS Atlas of Galactic Globular cluster
Spectra
Usher, Christopher;
Pastorello, Nicola;
Bellstedt, Sabine;
Alabi, Adebusola;
Cerulo, Pierluigi;
Chevalier, Leonie;
Fraser-McKelvie, Amelia;
Penny, Samantha;
Foster, Caroline;
McDermid, Richard M.;
Schiavon, Ricardo P.;
Villaume, Alexa
Submitted: 2017-03-21
We present the WiFeS Atlas of Galactic Globular cluster Spectra, a library of
integrated spectra of Milky Way and Local Group globular clusters. We used the
WiFeS integral field spectrograph on the Australian National University 2.3 m
telescope to observe the central regions of 64 Milky Way globular clusters and
22 globular clusters hosted by the Milky Way's low mass satellite galaxies. The
spectra have wider wavelength coverage (3300 {\AA} to 9050 {\AA}) and higher
spectral resolution (R = 6800) than existing spectral libraries of Milky Way
globular clusters. By including Large and Small Magellanic Cloud star clusters,
we extend the coverage of parameter space of existing libraries towards young
and intermediate ages. While testing stellar population synthesis models and
analysis techniques is the main aim of this library, the observations may also
further our understanding of the stellar populations of Local Group globular
clusters and make possible the direct comparison of extragalactic globular
cluster integrated light observations with well understood globular clusters in
the Milky Way. The integrated spectra are publicly available via the project
website.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.04631 [pdf] - 1571039
The Search for Multiple Populations in Magellanic Cloud Clusters III: No
evidence for Multiple Populations in the SMC cluster NGC 419
Martocchia, S.;
Bastian, N.;
Usher, C.;
Kozhurina-Platais, V.;
Niederhofer, F.;
Cabrera-Ziri, I.;
Dalessandro, E.;
Hollyhead, K.;
Kacharov, N.;
Lardo, C.;
Larsen, S.;
Mucciarelli, A.;
Platais, I.;
Salaris, M.;
Cordero, M.;
Geisler, D.;
Hilker, M.;
Li, C.;
Mackey, D.
Submitted: 2017-03-14
We present the third paper about our ongoing HST survey for the search for
multiple stellar populations (MPs) within Magellanic Cloud clusters. We report
here the analysis of NGC 419, a $\sim 1.5$ Gyr old, massive ($\gtrsim 2 \times
10^5 \, {\rm M_{\odot}}$) star cluster in the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC). By
comparing our photometric data with stellar isochrones, we set a limit on
[N/Fe] enhancement of $\lesssim$+0.5 dex and hence we find that no MPs are
detected in this cluster. This is surprising because, in the first two papers
of this series, we found evidence for MPs in 4 other SMC clusters (NGC 121;
Lindsay 1, NGC 339, NGC 416), aged from 6 Gyr up to $\sim 10-11$ Gyr. This
finding raises the question whether age could play a major role in the MPs
phenomenon. Additionally, our results appear to exclude mass or environment as
the only key factors regulating the existence of a chemical enrichment, since
all clusters studied so far in this survey are equally massive ($\sim 1-2
\times 10^5 \, {\rm M_{\odot}}$) and no particular patterns are found when
looking at their spatial distribution in the SMC.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.04835 [pdf] - 1534684
The SLUGGS Survey: a catalog of over 4000 globular cluster radial
velocities in 27 nearby early-type galaxies
Forbes, Duncan A.;
Alabi, Adebusola;
Brodie, Jean P.;
Romanowsky, Aaron J.;
Strader, Jay;
Foster, Caroline;
Usher, Christopher;
Spitler, Lee;
Bellstedt, Sabine;
Pastorello, Nicola;
Villaume, Alexa;
Wasserman, Asher;
Pota, Vincenzo
Submitted: 2017-01-17
Here we present positions and radial velocities for over 4000 globular
clusters (GCs) in 27 nearby early-type galaxies from the SLUGGS survey. The
SLUGGS survey is designed to be representative of elliptical and lenticular
galaxies in the stellar mass range 10 $<$ log M$_{\ast}$/M$_{\odot}$ $<$ 11.7.
The data have been obtained over many years, mostly using the very stable
multi-object spectrograph DEIMOS on the Keck II 10m telescope. Radial
velocities are measured using the calcium triplet lines with a velocity
accuracy of $\pm$ 10-15 km/s. We use phase space diagrams (i.e.
velocity--position diagrams) to identify contaminants such as foreground stars
and background galaxies, and to show that the contribution of GCs from
neighboring galaxies is generally insignificant. Likely ultra-compact dwarfs
are tabulated separately. We find that the mean velocity of the GC system is
close to that of the host galaxy systemic velocity, indicating that the GC
system is in overall dynamical equilibrium within the galaxy potential. We also
find that the GC system velocity dispersion scales with host galaxy stellar
mass in a similar manner to the Faber-Jackson relation for the stellar velocity
dispersion. Publication of these GC radial velocity catalogs should enable
further studies in many areas, such as GC system substructure, kinematics, and
host galaxy mass measurements.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1611.06705 [pdf] - 1532734
A high fraction of Be stars in young massive clusters: evidence for a
large population of near-critically rotating stars
Submitted: 2016-11-21
Recent photometric analysis of the colour-magnitude diagrams (CMDs) of young
massive clusters (YMCs) have found evidence for splitting in the main sequence
and extended main sequence turn-offs, both of which have been suggested to be
caused by stellar rotation. Comparison of the observed main sequence splitting
with models has led various authors to suggest a rather extreme stellar
rotation distribution, with a minority ($10-30$\%) of stars with low rotational
velocities and the remainder ($70-90$\%) of stars rotating near the critical
rotation (i.e., near break-up). We test this hypothesis by searching for Be
stars within two YMCs in the LMC (NGC 1850 and NGC 1856), which are thought to
be critically rotating stars with decretion disks that are (partially) ionised
by their host stars. In both clusters we detect large populations of Be stars
at the main sequence turn-off ($\sim30-60$\% of stars), which supports previous
suggestions of large populations of rapidly rotating stars within massive
clusters.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.02037 [pdf] - 1528278
The SLUGGS Survey: stellar masses and effective radii of early-type
galaxies from Spitzer Space Telescope 3.6$\mu$m imaging
Submitted: 2016-10-06
Galaxy starlight at 3.6$\mu$m is an excellent tracer of stellar mass. Here we
use the latest 3.6$\mu$m imaging from the Spitzer Space Telescope to measure
the total stellar mass and effective radii in a homogeneous way for a sample of
galaxies from the SLUGGS survey. These galaxies are representative of nearby
early-type galaxies in the stellar mass range of 10 $<$ log
M$_{\ast}$/M$_{\odot}$ $<$ 11.7, and our methodology can be applied to other
samples of early-type galaxies. We model each galaxy in 2D and estimate its
total asymptotic magnitude from a 1D curve-of-growth. Magnitudes are converted
into stellar masses using a 3.6$\mu$m mass-to-light ratio from the latest
stellar population models of R\"ock et al., assuming a Kroupa IMF. We apply a
ratio based on each galaxy's mean mass-weighted stellar age within one
effective radius (the mass-to-light ratio is insensitive to galaxy metallicity
for the generally old stellar ages and high metallicities found in massive
early-type galaxies). Our 3.6$\mu$m stellar masses agree well with masses
derived from 2.2$\mu$m data. From the 1D surface brightness profile we fit a
single Sersic law, excluding the very central regions. We measure the effective
radius, Sersic n parameter and effective surface brightness for each galaxy. We
find that galaxy sizes derived from shallow optical imaging and the 2MASS
survey tend to underestimate the true size of the largest, most massive
galaxies in our sample. We adopt the 3.6$\mu$m stellar masses and effective
radii for the SLUGGS survey galaxies.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.06101 [pdf] - 1443991
The SLUGGS Survey: The mass distribution in early-type galaxies within
five effective radii and beyond
Alabi, Adebusola B.;
Forbes, Duncan A.;
Romanowsky, Aaron J.;
Brodie, Jean P.;
Strader, Jay;
Janz, Joachim;
Pota, Vincenzo;
Pastorello, Nicola;
Usher, Christopher;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Foster, Caroline;
Jennings, Zachary G.;
Villaume, Alexa;
Kartha, Sreeja
Submitted: 2016-05-19
We study mass distributions within and beyond 5~effective radii ($R_{\rm e}$)
in 23 early-type galaxies from the SLUGGS survey, using their globular cluster
(GC) kinematic data. The data are obtained with Keck/DEIMOS spectrograph, and
consist of line-of-sight velocities for ~$3500$ GCs, measured with a high
precision of ~15 $\rm km\ s^{-1}$ per GC and extending out to $~13 R_{\rm e}$.
We obtain the mass distribution in each galaxy using the tracer mass estimator
of Watkins et al. and account for kinematic substructures, rotation of the GC
systems and galaxy flattening in our mass estimates.
The observed scatter between our mass estimates and results from the
literature is less than 0.2 dex. The dark matter fraction within $5R_{\rm e}$
($f_{\rm DM}$) increases from ~$0.6$ to ~$0.8$ for low- and high-mass galaxies,
respectively, with some intermediate-mass galaxies ($M_*{\sim}10^{11}M_\odot$)
having low $f_{\rm DM}\sim0.3$, which appears at odds with predictions from
simple galaxy models. We show that these results are independent of the adopted
orbital anisotropy, stellar mass-to-light ratio, and the assumed slope of the
gravitational potential. However, the low $f_{\rm DM}$ in the ~$10^{11}M_\odot$
galaxies agrees with the cosmological simulations of Wu et al. where the
pristine dark matter distribution has been modified by baryons during the
galaxy assembly process. We find hints that these $M_*\sim10^{11}M_\odot$
galaxies with low $f_{\rm DM}$ have very diffuse dark matter haloes, implying
that they assembled late. Beyond $5R_{\rm e}$, the $M/L$ gradients are steeper
in the more massive galaxies and shallower in both low and intermediate mass
galaxies.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.01105 [pdf] - 1370386
The SLUGGS Survey: globular clusters and the dark matter content of
early-type galaxies
Submitted: 2016-02-02
A strong correlation exists between the total mass of a globular cluster (GC)
system and the virial halo mass of the host galaxy. However, the total halo
mass in this correlation is a statistical measure conducted on spatial scales
that are some ten times that of a typical GC system. Here we investigate the
connection between GC systems and galaxy's dark matter on comparable spatial
scales, using dynamical masses measured on a galaxy-by-galaxy basis. Our sample
consists of 17 well-studied massive (stellar mass $\sim$10$^{11}$ M$_{\odot}$)
early-type galaxies from the SLUGGS survey. We find the strongest correlation
to be that of the blue (metal-poor) GC subpopulation and the dark matter
content. This correlation implies that the dark matter mass of a galaxy can be
estimated to within a factor of two from careful imaging of its GC system. The
ratio of the GC system mass to that of the enclosed dark matter is nearly
constant. We also find a strong correlation between the fraction of blue GCs
and the fraction of enclosed dark matter, so that a typical galaxy with a blue
GC fraction of 60 per cent has a dark matter fraction of 86 per cent over
similar spatial scales. Both halo growth and removal (via tidal stripping) may
play some role in shaping this trend. In the context of the two-phase model for
galaxy formation, we find galaxies with the highest fractions of accreted stars
to have higher dark matter fractions for a given fraction of blue GCs.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1601.02597 [pdf] - 1359195
The SLUGGS Survey: The Assembly Histories of Individual Early-type
Galaxies
Submitted: 2016-01-11
Early-type (E and S0) galaxies may have assembled via a variety of different
evolutionary pathways. Here we investigate these pathways by comparing the
stellar kinematic properties of 24 early-type galaxies from the SLUGGS survey
with the hydrodynamical simulations of Naab et al. (2014). In particular, we
use the kinematics of starlight up to 4 effective radii (R$_e$) as diagnostics
of galaxy inner and outer regions, and assign each galaxy to one of six Naab et
al. assembly classes.
The majority of our galaxies (14/24) have kinematic characteristics that
indicate an assembly history dominated by gradual gas dissipation and accretion
of many gas-rich minor mergers. Three galaxies, all S0s, indicate that they
have experienced gas-rich major mergers in their more recent past. One
additional elliptical galaxy is tentatively associated with a gas-rich merger
which results in a remnant galaxy with low angular momentum. Pathways dominated
by gas-poor (major or minor) mergers dominate the mass growth of six galaxies.
Most SLUGGS galaxies appear to have grown in mass (and size) via the accretion
of stars and gas from minor mergers, with late major mergers playing a much
smaller role.
We find that the fraction of accreted stars correlates with the stellar mean
age and metallicity gradient, but not with the slope of the total mass density
profile. We briefly mention future observational and modelling approaches that
will enhance our ability to accurately reconstruct the assembly histories of
individual present day galaxies.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.06130 [pdf] - 1347814
The SLUGGS Survey: stellar kinematics, kinemetry and trends at large
radii in 25 early-type galaxies
Foster, Caroline;
Pastorello, Nicola;
Roediger, Joel;
Brodie, Jean P.;
Forbes, Duncan A.;
Kartha, Sreeja S.;
Pota, Vincenzo;
Romanowsky, Aaron J.;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Strader, Jay;
Usher, Christopher;
Arnold, Jacob A.
Submitted: 2015-12-18
Due to longer dynamical timescales, the outskirts of early-type galaxies
retain the footprint of their formation and assembly. Under the popular
two-phase galaxy formation scenario, an initial in-situ phase of star formation
is followed by minor merging and accretion of ex-situ stars leading to the
expectation of observable transitions in the kinematics and stellar populations
on large scales. However, observing the faint galactic outskirts is
challenging, often leaving the transition unexplored. The large scale,
spatially-resolved stellar kinematic data from the SAGES Legacy Unifying
Galaxies and GlobularS (SLUGGS) survey are ideal for detecting kinematic
transitions. We present kinematic maps out to 2.6 effective radii on average,
kinemetry profiles, measurement of kinematic twists and misalignments, and the
average outer intrinsic shape of 25 SLUGGS galaxies. We find good overall
agreement in the kinematic maps and kinemetry radial profiles with literature.
We are able to confirm significant radial modulations in rotational versus
pressure support of galaxies with radius so that the central and outer
rotational properties may be quite different. We also test the suggestion that
galaxies may be more triaxial in their outskirts and find that while fast
rotating galaxies were already shown to be axisymmetric in their inner regions,
we are unable to rule out triaxiality in their outskirts. We compare our
derived outer kinematic information to model predictions from a two-phase
galaxy formation scenario. We find that the theoretical range of local outer
angular momentum agrees well with our observations, but that radial modulations
are much smaller than predicted.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.07882 [pdf] - 1259081
The SLUGGS Survey: Globular cluster kinematics in a "double sigma"
galaxy - NGC 4473
Submitted: 2015-06-25
NGC 4473 is a so--called double sigma (2$\sigma$) galaxy, i.e. a galaxy with
rare, double peaks in its 2D stellar velocity dispersion. Here, we present the
globular cluster (GC) kinematics in NGC 4473 out to $\sim10\,R_e$ (effective
radii) using data from combined HST/ACS and Subaru/Suprime--Cam imaging and
Keck/DEIMOS spectroscopy. We find that the 2$\sigma$ nature of NGC 4473
persists up to 3 $R_e$, though it becomes misaligned to the photometric major
axis. We also observe a significant offset between the stellar and GC rotation
amplitudes. This offset can be understood as a co--addition of
counter--rotating stars producing little net stellar rotation. We identify a
sharp radial transition in the GC kinematics at $\sim4\,R_e$ suggesting a well
defined kinematically distinct halo. In the inner region ($<4\,R_e$), the blue
GCs rotate along the photometric major axis, but in an opposite direction to
the galaxy stars and red GCs. In the outer region ($>4\,R_e$), the red GCs
rotate in an opposite direction compared to the inner region red GCs, along the
photometric major axis, while the blue GCs rotate along an axis intermediate
between the major and minor photometric axes. We also find a kinematically
distinct population of very red GCs in the inner region with elevated rotation
amplitude and velocity dispersion. The multiple kinematic components in NGC
4473 highlight the complex formation and evolutionary history of this 2$\sigma$
galaxy, as well as a distinct transition between the inner and outer
components.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.06820 [pdf] - 1259063
The SLUGGS survey: inferring the formation epochs of metal-poor and
metal-rich globular clusters
Submitted: 2015-06-22
We present a novel, observationally-based framework for the formation epochs
and sites of globular clusters (GCs) in a cosmological context. Measuring
directly the mean ages of the metal-poor and metal-rich GC subpopulations in
our own Galaxy, and in other galaxies, is observationally challenging. Here we
apply an alternative approach utilising the property that the galaxy
mass-metallicity relation is a strong function of redshift (or look-back age)
but is relatively insensitive to galaxy mass for massive galaxies. Assuming
that GCs follow galaxy mass-metallicity relations that evolve with redshift,
one can estimate the mean formation epochs of the two GC subpopulations by
knowing their mean metallicities and the growth in host galaxy mass with
redshift. Recently, the SLUGGS survey has measured the spectroscopic
metallicities for over 1000 GCs in a dozen massive early-type galaxies. Here we
use these measurements, and our new metallicity matching method, to infer a
mean age for metal-rich GCs of 11.5 Gyr (z = 2.9) and a range of 12.2 to 12.8
Gyr (4.8 < z < 5.9) for the metal- poor GCs, depending on whether they mostly
formed in accreted satellites or in-situ within the main host galaxy. We
compare our values to direct age measurements for Milky Way GCs and predictions
from cosmological models. Our findings suggest that reionisation preceded most
GC formation, and that it is unlikely to be the cause of GC bimodal metallicity
distributions.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.04795 [pdf] - 1043274
The SLUGGS survey: Combining stellar and globular cluster metallicities
in the outer regions of early-type galaxies
Pastorello, Nicola;
Forbes, Duncan A.;
Usher, Christopher;
Brodie, Jean P.;
Romanowsky, Aaron J.;
Strader, Jay;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Alabi, Adebusola B.;
Foster, Caroline;
Jennings, Zachary G.;
Kartha, Sreeja S.;
Pota, Vincenzo
Submitted: 2015-05-18
The outer halo regions of early-type galaxies carry key information about
their past accretion history. However, spectroscopically probing the stellar
component at such galactocentric radii is still challenging. Using Keck/DEIMOS,
we have been able to measure the metallicities of the stellar and globular
cluster components in 12 early-type galaxies out to more than $10~\rm{R_{e}}$.
We find similar metallicity gradients for the metal-poor and metal-rich
globular cluster subpopulations, suggesting a common formation process for the
two subpopulations. This is in conflict with most current theoretical
predictions, where the metal-poor globular clusters are thought to be purely
accreted and metal-rich globular clusters mostly formed in-situ. Moreover, we
find that the globular cluster metallicity gradients show a trend with galaxy
mass, being steeper in lower-mass galaxies than in higher-mass galaxies. This
is similar to what we find for the outermost galaxy stars and suggests a more
active accretion history, with a larger role played by major mergers, in the
most massive galaxies. This conclusion is qualitatively consistent with
expectations from two-phase galaxy assembly models. Finally, we find that the
small difference in metallicity between galaxy stars and metal-rich globular
clusters at $1~\rm{R_{e}}$ may correlate with galaxy mass. The origin of this
difference is not currently clear.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1504.00075 [pdf] - 986650
Small scatter and nearly-isothermal mass profiles to four half-light
radii from two-dimensional stellar dynamics of early-type galaxies
Cappellari, Michele;
Romanowsky, Aaron J.;
Brodie, Jean P.;
Forbes, Duncan A.;
Strader, Jay;
Foster, Caroline;
Kartha, Sreeja S.;
Pastorello, Nicola;
Pota, Vincenzo;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Usher, Christopher;
Arnold, Jacob A.
Submitted: 2015-03-31
We study the total mass-density profile for a sample of 14 fast-rotator
early-type galaxies (stellar masses $10.2<\log M_\ast/M_\odot<11.7$). We
combine observations from the SLUGGS and Atlas3D surveys to map out the stellar
kinematics in two-dimensions, out to a median radius for the sample of four
half-light radii $R_e$ (or 10 kpc), and a maximum radius of 2.0-6.2 $R_e$ (or
4-21 kpc). We use axisymmetric dynamical models based on the Jeans equations,
which allow for a spatially varying anisotropy, and employ quite general
profiles for the dark halos, and in particular do not place any restriction on
the profile slope. This is made possible by the availability of spatially
extended two-dimensional kinematics. We find that our relatively simple models
provide a remarkably good description of the observed kinematics. The resulting
total density profiles are well described by a nearly-isothermal power law
$\rho_{\rm tot}(r)\propto r^{-\gamma}$ from $R_e$/10 to at least 4$R_e$, the
largest average deviation being 11%. The average logarithmic slope is
$\langle\gamma\rangle=2.19\pm0.03$ with observed rms scatter of just
$\sigma_\gamma=0.11$. This scatter out to large radii, where dark matter
dominates, is as small as previously reported by lensing studies around
$r\approx R_e/2$, where the stars dominate. Our bulge-halo conspiracy places
much tighter constraints on galaxy formation models. It illustrates the power
of two-dimensional stellar kinematics observations at large radii. It would now
be important to test the generality of our results for different galaxy types
and larger samples.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.07520 [pdf] - 1232108
A SLUGGS and Gemini/GMOS combined study of the elliptical galaxy M60:
wide-field photometry and kinematics of the globular cluster system
Pota, Vincenzo;
Brodie, Jean P.;
Bridges, Terry;
Strader, Jay;
Romanowsky, Aaron J.;
Villaume, Alexa;
Jennings, Zachary;
Faifer, Favio R.;
Pastorello, Nicola;
Forbes, Duncan A.;
Campbell, Ainsley;
Usher, Christopher;
Foster, Caroline;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Caldwell, Nelson;
Forte, Juan C.;
Norris, Mark A.;
Zepf, Stephen E.;
Beasley, Michael A.;
Gebhardt, Karl;
Hanes, David A.;
Sharples, Ray M.;
Arnold, Jacob A.
Submitted: 2015-03-25
We present new wide-field photometry and spectroscopy of the globular
clusters (GCs) around NGC 4649 (M60), the third brightest galaxy in the Virgo
cluster. Imaging of NGC 4649 was assembled from a recently-obtained HST/ACS
mosaic, and new Subaru/Suprime-Cam and archival CFHT/MegaCam data. About 1200
sources were followed up spectroscopically using combined observations from
three multi-object spectrographs: Keck/DEIMOS, Gemini/GMOS and MMT/Hectospec.
We confirm 431 unique GCs belonging to NGC 4649, a factor of 3.5 larger than
previous datasets and with a factor of 3 improvement in velocity precision. We
confirm significant GC colour bimodality and find that the red GCs are more
centrally concentrated, while the blue GCs are more spatially extended. We
infer negative GC colour gradients in the innermost 20 kpc and flat gradients
out to large radii. Rotation is detected along the galaxy major axis for all
tracers: blue GCs, red GCs, galaxy stars and planetary nebulae. We compare the
observed properties of NGC 4649 with galaxy formation models. We find that
formation via a major merger between two gas-poor galaxies, followed by
satellite accretion, can consistently reproduce the observations of NGC 4649 at
different radii. We find no strong evidence to support an interaction between
NGC 4649 and the neighbouring spiral galaxy NGC 4647. We identify interesting
GC kinematic features in our data, such as counter-rotating subgroups and bumpy
kinematic profiles, which encode more clues about the formation history of NGC
4649.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.8676 [pdf] - 903811
The SLUGGS survey: Globular cluster stellar population trends from weak
absorption lines in stacked spectra
Usher, Christopher;
Forbes, Duncan A.;
Brodie, Jean P.;
Romanowsky, Aaron J.;
Strader, Jay;
Conroy, Charlie;
Foster, Caroline;
Pastorello, Nicola;
Pota, Vincenzo;
Arnold, Jacob A.
Submitted: 2014-09-30
As part of the SLUGGS survey, we stack 1137 Keck DEIMOS spectra of globular
clusters from 10 galaxies to study their stellar populations in detail. The
stacked spectra have median signal to noise ratios of $\sim 90$ \AA$^{-1}$.
Besides the calcium triplet, we study weaker sodium, magnesium, titanium and
iron lines as well as the H$\alpha$ and higher order Paschen hydrogen lines. In
general, the stacked spectra are consistent with old ages and a Milky Way-like
initial mass function. However, we see different metal line index strengths at
fixed colour and magnitude, and differences in the calcium triplet--colour
relation from galaxy to galaxy. We interpret this as strong evidence for
variations in the globular cluster colour--metallicity relation between
galaxies. Two possible explanations for the colour--metallicity relation
variations are that the average ages of globular clusters vary from galaxy to
galaxy or that the average abundances of light elements (i.e. He, C, N and O)
differ between galaxies. Stacking spectra by magnitude, we see that the colours
become redder and metal line indices stronger with brighter magnitudes. These
trends are consistent with the previously reported `blue tilts' being
mass--metallicity relations.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.2079 [pdf] - 1209443
The SAGES Legacy Unifying Globulars and GalaxieS Survey (SLUGGS): Sample
definition, methods, and initial results
Brodie, Jean P.;
Romanowsky, Aaron J.;
Strader, Jay;
Forbes, Duncan A.;
Foster, Caroline;
Jennings, Zachary G.;
Pastorello, Nicola;
Pota, Vincenzo;
Usher, Christopher;
Blom, Christina;
Kader, Justin;
Roediger, Joel C.;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Villaume, Alexa;
Arnold, Jacob A.;
Kartha, Sreeja S.;
Woodley, Kristin A.
Submitted: 2014-05-08, last modified: 2014-09-10
We introduce and provide the scientific motivation for a wide-field
photometric and spectroscopic chemodynamical survey of nearby early-type
galaxies (ETGs) and their globular cluster (GC) systems. The SLUGGS (SAGES
Legacy Unifying Globulars and GalaxieS) survey is being carried out primarily
with Subaru/Suprime-Cam and Keck/DEIMOS. The former provides deep gri imaging
over a 900 arcmin^2 field-of-view to characterize GC and host galaxy colors and
spatial distributions, and to identify spectroscopic targets. The NIR CaII
triplet provides GC line-of-sight velocities and metallicities out to typically
~8 R_e, and to ~15 R_e in some cases. New techniques to extract integrated
stellar kinematics and metallicities to large radii (~2-3 R_e) are used in
concert with GC data to create two-dimensional velocity and metallicity maps
for comparison with simulations of galaxy formation. The advantages of SLUGGS
compared with other, complementary, 2D-chemodynamical surveys are its superior
velocity resolution, radial extent, and multiple halo tracers. We describe the
sample of 25 nearby ETGs, the selection criteria for galaxies and GCs, the
observing strategies, the data reduction techniques, and modeling methods. The
survey observations are nearly complete and more than 30 papers have so far
been published using SLUGGS data. Here we summarize some initial results,
including signatures of two-phase galaxy assembly, evidence for GC metallicity
bimodality, and a novel framework for the formation of extended star clusters
and ultracompact dwarfs. An integrated overview of current chemodynamical
constraints on GC systems points to separate, in-situ formation modes at high
redshifts for metal-poor and metal-rich GCs.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.2607 [pdf] - 862405
The SLUGGS Survey: Wide-field Stellar Kinematics of Early-type Galaxies
Arnold, Jacob A.;
Romanowsky, Aaron J.;
Brodie, Jean P.;
Forbes, Duncan A.;
Strader, Jay;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Foster, Caroline;
Blom, Christina;
Kartha, Sreeja S.;
Pastorello, Nicola;
Pota, Vincenzo;
Usher, Christopher;
Woodley, Kristin A.
Submitted: 2013-10-09, last modified: 2014-08-20
We present stellar kinematics of 22 nearby early-type galaxies (ETGs), based
on two-dimensional (2D) absorption line stellar spectroscopy out to ~2-4 R_e
(effective radii), as part of the ongoing SLUGGS Survey. The galaxies span a
factor of 20 in intrinsic luminosity, as well as a full range of environment
and ETG morphology. Our data consist of good velocity resolution (sigma_inst ~
25 km/s) integrated stellar-light spectra extracted from the individual
slitlets of custom made Keck/DEIMOS slitmasks. We extract stellar kinematics
measurements (V, sigma, h_3, and h_4) for each galaxy. Combining with
literature values from smaller radii, we present 2D spatially resolved maps of
the large-scale kinematic structure in each galaxy. We find that the kinematic
homogeneity found inside 1 R_e often breaks down at larger radii, where a
variety of kinematic behaviors are observed. While central slow rotators remain
slowly rotating in their halos, central fast rotators show more diversity,
ranging from rapidly increasing to rapidly declining specific angular momentum
profiles in the outer regions. There are indications that the outer trends
depend on morphological type, raising questions about the proposed unification
of the elliptical and lenticular (S0) galaxy families in the ATLAS^3D survey.
Several galaxies in our sample show multiple lines of evidence for distinct
disk components embedded in more slowly rotating spheroids, and we suggest a
joint photometric-kinematic approach for robust bulge-disk decomposition. Our
observational results appear generally consistent with a picture of two-phase
(in-situ plus accretion) galaxy formation.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.2338 [pdf] - 1209459
The SLUGGS survey: Exploring the metallicity gradients of nearby
early-type galaxies to large radii
Submitted: 2014-05-09
Stellar metallicity gradients in the outer regions of galaxies are a critical
tool for disentangling the contributions of in-situ and ex-situ formed stars.
In the two-phase galaxy formation scenario, the initial gas collapse creates
steep metallicity gradients, while the accretion of stars formed in satellites
tends to flatten these gradients in the outskirts, particularly for massive
galaxies. This work presents the first compilation of extended metallicity
profiles over a wide range of galaxy mass. We use the DEIMOS spectrograph on
the Keck telescope in multi-slit mode to obtain radial stellar metallicity
profiles for 22 nearby early-type galaxies. From the calcium triplet lines in
the near-infrared we measure the metallicity of the starlight up to 3 effective
radii. We find a relation between the outer metallicity gradient and galaxy
mass, in the sense that lower mass systems show steeper metallicity gradients
than more massive galaxies. This result is consistent with a picture in which
the ratio of ex-situ to in-situ formed stars is lower in less massive galaxies
as a consequence of the smaller contribution by accretion. In addition, we
infer a correlation between the strength of the calcium triplet feature in the
near-infrared and the stellar initial mass function slope that is consistent
with recent models in the literature.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.0687 [pdf] - 1203162
Ultra compact dwarfs in the Perseus Cluster: UCD formation via tidal
stripping
Submitted: 2014-02-04
We present the results of a Keck/DEIMOS survey of Ultra Compact Dwarfs (UCDs)
in the Perseus Cluster core. We confirm cluster membership for 14 UCDs, with
radial velocities ~5300 km s$^{-1}$. Two of these confirmed Perseus UCDs have
extremely blue colours ($B-R < 0.6$ mag), reside in star forming filaments
surrounding NGC 1275, and have likely formed as massive star clusters in the
last ~100 Myr. We also measure a central velocity dispersion of a third, UCD13
($\sigma_0 = 38 \pm 8$ km s$^{-1}$), the most extended UCD in our sample. We
determine it to have radius $R_{e} = 85 \pm 1.1$ pc, a dynamical mass of ($2.3
\pm 0.8)\times10^{8}$ M$_{\odot}$, and a metallicity [Z/H]$=
-0.52^{+0.33}_{-0.29}$ dex. UCD13 and the cluster's central galaxy, NGC 1275,
have a projected separation of 30 kpc and a radial velocity difference of ~20
km s$^{-1}$. Based on its size, red colour, internal velocity dispersion,
dynamical mass, metallicity and proximity to NGC 1275, we argue that UCD13 is
likely the remnant nucleus of a tidally stripped dE, with this progenitor dE
having $M_{B} \approx -16$ mag and mass $\sim10^{9}$ M$_{\odot}$.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:1308.6585 [pdf] - 750697
The SLUGGS Survey: Wide Field Imaging of the Globular Cluster System of
NGC 4278
Submitted: 2013-08-29
We use multi-pointing HST ACS and wide field Subaru Suprime-Cam imaging to
study the globular cluster system of the L* elliptical galaxy NGC 4278. We have
also obtained a handful of new globular cluster spectra with Keck/DEIMOS. We
determine the globular cluster surface density profile and use it to calculate
the total number of globular clusters, finding the system to be slightly more
populous than average for galaxies of its luminosity. We find clear evidence
for bimodality in the globular cluster colour distribution and for a
colour-magnitude relation in the blue subpopulation (a 'blue tilt'). We also
find negative radial colour gradients in both colour subpopulations of equal
strength which are similar in strength to those reported in other galaxies. The
sizes of NGC 4278's globular clusters decrease with redder colours and increase
with galactocentric radius. The ratio of the sizes of blue to red globular
clusters is independent of galactocentric radius demonstrating that internal
effects are responsible for the size difference with colour.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:1307.7707 [pdf] - 1173040
The Densest Galaxy
Strader, Jay;
Seth, Anil;
Forbes, Duncan;
Fabbiano, Giuseppina;
Romanowsky, Aaron;
Brodie, Jean;
Conroy, Charlie;
Caldwell, Nelson;
Pota, Vincenzo;
Usher, Christopher;
Arnold, Jacob
Submitted: 2013-07-29, last modified: 2013-08-14
We report the discovery of a remarkable ultra-compact dwarf galaxy around the
massive Virgo elliptical galaxy NGC 4649 (M60), which we term M60-UCD1. With a
dynamical mass of 2.0 x 10^8 M_sun but a half-light radius of only ~ 24 pc,
M60-UCD1 is more massive than any ultra-compact dwarfs of comparable size, and
is arguably the densest galaxy known in the local universe. It has a
two-component structure well-fit by a sum of Sersic functions, with an
elliptical, compact (r_h=14 pc; n ~ 3.3) inner component and a round,
exponential, extended (r_h=49 pc) outer component. Chandra data reveal a
variable central X-ray source with L_X ~ 10^38 erg/s that could be an active
galactic nucleus associated with a massive black hole or a low-mass X-ray
binary. Analysis of optical spectroscopy shows the object to be old (~> 10 Gyr)
and of solar metallicity, with elevated [Mg/Fe] and strongly enhanced [N/Fe]
that indicates light element self-enrichment; such self-enrichment may be
generically present in dense stellar systems. The velocity dispersion (~ 70
km/s) and resulting dynamical mass-to-light ratio (M/L_V=4.9 +/- 0.7) are
consistent with---but slightly higher than---expectations for an old,
metal-rich stellar population with a Kroupa initial mass function. The presence
of a massive black hole or a mild increase in low-mass stars or stellar
remnants is therefore also consistent with this M/L_V. The stellar density of
the galaxy is so high that no dynamical signature of dark matter is expected.
However, the properties of M60-UCD1 suggest an origin in the tidal stripping of
a nucleated galaxy with M_B ~ -18 to -19.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.5245 [pdf] - 1172213
Filling the gap: a new class of old star cluster?
Submitted: 2013-06-21
It is not understood whether long-lived star clusters possess a continuous
range of sizes and masses (and hence densities), or if rather, they should be
considered as distinct types with different origins. Utilizing the Hubble Space
Telescope (HST) to measure sizes, and long exposures on the Keck 10m telescope
to obtain distances, we have discovered the first confirmed star clusters that
lie within a previously claimed size-luminosity gap dubbed the `avoidance zone'
by Hwang et al (2011). The existence of these star clusters extends the range
of sizes, masses and densities for star clusters, and argues against current
formation models that predict well-defined size-mass relationships (such as
stripped nuclei, giant globular clusters or merged star clusters). The red
colours of these gap objects suggests that they are not a new class of object
but are related to Faint Fuzzies observed in nearby lenticular galaxies. We
also report a number of low luminosity UCDs with sizes of up to 50 pc. Future,
statistically complete, studies will be encouraged now that it is known that
star clusters possess a continuous range of structural properties.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.5390 [pdf] - 1151601
The SLUGGS Survey: NGC 3115, A Critical Test Case for Metallicity
Bimodality in Globular Cluster Systems
Submitted: 2012-09-24
Due to its proximity (9 Mpc) and the strongly bimodal color distribution of
its spectroscopically well-sampled globular cluster (GC) system, the early-type
galaxy NGC 3115 provides one of the best available tests of whether the color
bimodality widely observed in GC systems generally reflects a true metallicity
bimodality. Color bimodality has alternatively been attributed to a strongly
nonlinear color--metallicity relation reflecting the influence of hot
horizontal branch stars. Here we couple Subaru Suprime-Cam gi photometry with
Keck/DEIMOS spectroscopy to accurately measure GC colors and a CaT index that
measures the CaII triplet. We find the NGC 3115 GC system to be unambiguously
bimodal in both color and the CaT index. Using simple stellar population
models, we show that the CaT index is essentially unaffected by variations in
horizontal branch morphology over the range of metallicities relevant to GC
systems (and is thus a robust indicator of metallicity) and confirm bimodality
in the metallicity distribution. We assess the existing evidence for and
against multiple metallicity subpopulations in early and late-type galaxies and
conclude that metallicity bi/multimodality is common. We briefly discuss how
this fundamental characteristic links directly to the star formation and
assembly histories of galaxies.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.4351 [pdf] - 1151508
The SLUGGS Survey: Kinematics for over 2500 Globular Clusters in Twelve
Early-type Galaxies
Pota, Vincenzo;
Forbes, Duncan A.;
Romanowsky, Aaron J.;
Brodie, Jean P.;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Strader, Jay;
Foster, Caroline;
Arnold, Jacob A.;
Benson, Andrew;
Blom, Christina;
Hargis, Jonathan R.;
Rhode, Katherine L.;
Usher, Christopher
Submitted: 2012-09-19
We present a spectro-photometric survey of 2522 extragalactic globular
clusters (GCs) around twelve early-type galaxies, nine of which have not been
published previously. Combining space-based and multi-colour wide field
ground-based imaging, with spectra from the Keck DEIMOS instrument, we obtain
an average of 160 GC radial velocities per galaxy, with a high velocity
precision of 15 km/s per GC. After studying the photometric properties of the
GC systems, such as their spatial and colour distributions, we focus on the
kinematics of metal-poor (blue) and metal-rich (red) GC subpopulations to an
average distance of ~8 effective radii from the galaxy centre. Our results show
that for some systems the bimodality in GC colour is also present in GC
kinematics. The kinematics of the red GC subpopulations are strongly coupled
with the host galaxy stellar kinematics. The blue GC subpopulations are more
dominated by random motions, especially in the outer regions, and decoupled
from the red GCs. Peculiar GC kinematic profiles are seen in some galaxies: the
blue GCs in NGC 821 rotate along the galaxy minor axis, whereas the GC system
of the lenticular galaxy NGC 7457 appears to be strongly rotation supported in
the outer region. We supplement our galaxy sample with data from the literature
and carry out a number of tests to study the kinematic differences between the
two GC subpopulations. We confirm that the GC kinematics are coupled with the
host galaxy properties and find that the velocity kurtosis and the slope of
their velocity dispersion profiles is different between the two GC
subpopulations in more massive galaxies.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.6402 [pdf] - 712802
The SLUGGS Survey: Calcium Triplet-based Spectroscopic Metallicities for
Over 900 Globular Clusters
Submitted: 2012-07-26
Although the colour distribution of globular clusters in massive galaxies is
well known to be bimodal, the spectroscopic metallicity distribution has been
measured in only a few galaxies. After redefining the calcium triplet
index-metallicity relation, we use our relation to derive the metallicity of
903 globular clusters in 11 early-type galaxies. This is the largest sample of
spectroscopic globular cluster metallicities yet assembled. We compare these
metallicities with those derived from Lick indices finding good agreement. In 6
of the 8 galaxies with sufficient numbers of high quality spectra we find
bimodality in the spectroscopic metallicity distribution. Our results imply
that most massive early-type galaxies have bimodal metallicity, as well as
colour, distributions. This bimodality suggests that most massive galaxies
early-type galaxies experienced two periods of star formation.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:1004.2715 [pdf] - 1026344
The nature of proximate damped Lyman alpha systems
Submitted: 2010-04-15
We present high resolution echelle spectra of 7 proximate damped Lyman alpha
(PDLA) systems whose relative velocity separation from the background quasar is
Delta V < 3000 km/s. Combining our sample with a further 9 PDLAs from the
literature we compare the chemical properties of the proximate systems with a
control sample of intervening DLAs. Taken at face value, the sample of 16 PDLAs
exhibits a wide range of metallicities, ranging from Z ~ 1/3 Z_sun down to Z ~
1/1000 Z_sun, including the DLA with the lowest N(SiII)/N(HI) yet reported in
the literature. We find several pieces of evidence that indicate enhanced
ionization and the presence of a hard ionizing spectrum in PDLAs which lead to
properties that contrast with the intervening DLAs, particularly when the N(HI)
is low. The abundances of Zn, Si and S in PDLAs with log N(HI) > 21, where
ionization corrections are minimized, are systematically higher than the
intervening population by a factor of around 3. We also find possible evidence
for a higher fraction of NV absorbers amongst the PDLAs, although the
statistics are still modest. 6/7 of our echelle sample show high ionization
species (SiIV, CIV, OVI or NV) offset by >100 km/s from the main low ion
absorption. We analyse fine-structure transitions of CII* and SiII* to
constrain the PDLA distance from the QSO. Lower limits range from tens of kpc
up to >160 kpc for the most stringent limit. We conclude that (at least some)
PDLAs do exhibit different characteristics relative to the intervening
population out to 3000 km/s (and possibly beyond). Nonetheless, the PDLAs
appear distinct from lower column density associated systems and the inferred
QSO-absorber separations mean they are unlikely to be associated with the QSO
host. We speculate that the PDLAs preferentially sample more massive galaxies
in more highly clustered regions of the high redshift universe.