Normalized to: Turchi, A.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.02819 [pdf] - 2078688
New achievements in optical turbulence forecast systems in operational
mode
Submitted: 2019-11-07, last modified: 2020-04-16
In this contribution, we present the most recent progresses we obtained in
the context of a long-term program we undertook since a few years towards the
implementation of operational forecast systems (a) on top-class ground-based
telescopes assisted by AO systems to support the flexible scheduling of
observational scientific programs in night as well in day time and (b) on
ground-stations to support free space optical communication. Two topics have
been treated and presented in the Conference AO4ELT6:
1. ALTA is an operational forecast system for the OT and all the critical
atmospheric parameters affecting the astronomical ground-based observations
conceived for the LBT. It operates since 2016 and it is in continuous evolution
to match with necessities/requirements of instruments assisted by AO of the LBT
(SOUL, SHARK-NIR, SHARK-VIS, LINC-NIRVANA,...). In this contribution, we
present a new implemented version of ALTA that, thanks to an auto-regression
method making use of numerical forecasts and real-time OT measurements taken in
situ, can obtain model performances (for forecasts of atmospherical and
astroclimatic parameters) never achieved before on time scales of the order of
a few hours.
2. We will go through the main differences between optical turbulence
forecast performed with mesoscale and general circulation models (GCM) by
clarifying some fundamental concepts and by correcting some erroneous
information circulating recently in the literature.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.12658 [pdf] - 2112604
Filtering techniques to enhance optical turbulence forecast performances
at short time scales
Submitted: 2020-02-28
The efficiency of the management of top-class ground-based astronomical
facilities supported by Adaptive Optics (AO) relies on our ability to forecast
the optical turbulence (OT) and a set of relevant atmospheric parameters.
Indeed, in spite of the fact that the AO is able to achieve, at present,
excellent levels of wavefront corrections (a Strehl Ratio up to 90% in H band),
its performances strongly depend on the atmospheric conditions. Knowing in
advance the turbulence conditions allows an optimization of the AO use. It has
already been proven that it is possible to provide reliable forecasts of the
optical turbulence (CN2 profiles and integrated astroclimatic parameters such
as seeing, isoplanantic angle, wavefront coherence time, ...) for the next
night. In this paper we prove that it is possible to improve the forecast
performances on shorter time scales (order of one or two hours) with consistent
gains (order of 2 to 8) using filtering techniques. This has permitted us to
achieve forecasts accuracies never obtained before and reach a fundamental
milestone for the astronomical applications. The time scale of one or two hours
is the most critical one for an efficient management of the ground-based
telescopes supported by AO. Results shown here open, therefore, to an important
revolution in the field. We implemented this method in the operational forecast
system of the Large Binocular Telescope, named ALTA Center that is, at our
knowledge, the first operational system providing forecasts of turbulence and
atmospheric parameters at short time scales to support science operations.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.07974 [pdf] - 1836076
Evaluation of filtering techniques to increase the reliability of meteo
forecasts for ground-based telescopes
Submitted: 2019-02-21
In this contribution we evaluate the impact of filtering techniques in
enhancing the accuracy of forecasts of optical turbulence and atmospheric
parameters critical for ground-based telescopes. These techniques make use of
the data continuously provided by the telescope sensors and instruments to
improve the performances of real-time forecasts which have an impact on the
telescope operation. In previous works we have already shown how a mesoscale
high-frequency forecast (Meso-NH and Astro-Meso-Nh models) can produce reliable
predictions of different atmospheric parameters and the optical turbulence. The
mesoscale forecast has an advantage on the global model in having a better
implementation of the physical atmospheric processes, including turbulence, and
produces an output with greater spatial resolution (up to 100m or beyond).
Filtering techniques that make use of the real-time sensor data at the
telescope may help in removing potential biases and trends which have an impact
on short term mesoscale forecast and, as a consequence, may increase the
accuracy of the final output. Given the complexity and cost of present and
future top-class telescope installations, each improvement of forecasts of
future observing conditions will definitely help in better allocating observing
time, especially in queue-mode operation, and will definitely benefit the
scientific community in medium-long term.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.07989 [pdf] - 1836079
Optical turbulence forecast in the Adaptive Optics realm
Submitted: 2019-02-21
(35-words maximum) In this talk I present the scientific drivers related to
the optical turbulence forecast applied to the ground-based astronomy supported
by Adaptive Optics, the state of the art of the achieved results and the most
relevant challenges for future progresses.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.07977 [pdf] - 1836077
Towards the forecast of atmospheric parameters and optical turbulence
above an astronomical site on 24h time scale
Submitted: 2019-02-21
Forecast of the atmospheric parameters and optical turbulence applied to the
ground-based astronomy is very crucial mainly for the queue scheduling. So far,
most efforts have been addressed by our group in developing algorithms for the
optical turbulence (CN2) and annexed integrated astroclimatic parameters and
quantifying the performances of the Astro-Meso-Nh package in reconstructing
such parameters. Besides, intensive analyses on the Meso-Nh performances= in
reconstructing atmospheric parameters relevant for the ground-based astronomy
has been carried out. Our studies referred always to the night time regime. To
extend the applications of our studies to the day time regime, we present, in
this contribution, preliminary results obtained by comparing model outputs and
measurements of classical atmospheric parameter relevant for the ground-based
astronomy in night and day time. We chose as a test case, the Roque de los
Muchachos Observatory (Canary Islands), that offers a very extended set of
measurements provided by different sensors belonging to different telescopes on
the same summit/Observatory. The convective regime close to the ground typical
of the day time is pretty different from the stable regime characterising the
night time. This study aims therefore to enlarge the domain of validity of the
Astro-Meso-Nh code to new turbulence regimes and it permits to cover the total
24 hours of a day. Such an approach will permit not only an application to
solar telescopes (e.g. EST) but also applications to a much extended set of
scientific fields, not only in astronomical context such as satellite
communications.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.11056 [pdf] - 1767705
Forecasting water vapour above the sites of ESO's Very Large Telescope
(VLT) and the Large Binocular Telescope (LBT)
Submitted: 2018-09-28
Water vapour in the atmosphere is the main source of the atmospheric opacity
in the infrared and sub-millimetric regimes and its value plays a critical role
in observations done with instruments working at these wavelengths on
ground-based telescopes. The scheduling of scientific observational programs
with instruments such as the VLT Imager and Spectrometer for mid Infrared
(VISIR) at Cerro Paranal and the Large Binocular Telescope Interferometer
(LBTI) at Mount Graham would definitely benefit from the ability to forecast
the atmospheric water vapour content. In this contribution we present a study
aiming at validating the performance of the non-hydrostatic mesoscale Meso-NH
model in reliably predicting precipitable water vapour (PWV) above the two
sites. For the VLT case we use, as a reference, measurements done with a Low
Humidity and Temperature PROfiling radiometer (LHATPRO) that, since a few
years, is operating routinely at the VLT. LHATPRO has been extensively
validated on previous studies. We obtain excellent performances on forecasts
performed with this model, including for the extremely low values of the PWV
(<= 1 mm). For the LBTI case we compare one solar year predictions obtained
with the Meso-NH model with satellite estimates again obtaining an excellent
agreement. This study represents a further step in validating outputs of
atmospheric parameters forecasts from the ALTA Center, an operational and
automatic forecast system conceived to support observations at LBT and LBTI.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.07494 [pdf] - 1623876
Towards an automatic wind speed and direction profiler for Wide Field AO
systems
Submitted: 2018-01-23
Wide Field Adaptive Optics (WFAO) systems are among the most sophisticated AO
systems available today on large telescopes. The knowledge of the vertical
spatio-temporal distribution of the wind speed (WS) and direction (WD) are
fundamental to optimize the performance of such systems. Previous studies
already proved that the Gemini Multi-Conjugated AO system (GeMS) is able to
retrieve measurements of the WS and WD stratification using the SLODAR
technique and to store measurements in the telemetry data. In order to assess
the reliability of these estimates and of the SLODAR technique applied to such
a kind of complex AO systems, in this study we compared WS and WD retrieved
from GeMS with those obtained with the atmospherical model Meso-Nh on a rich
statistical sample of nights. It has been previously proved that, the latter
technique, provided an excellent agreement with a large sample of
radiosoundings both, in statistical terms and on individual flights. It can be
considered, therefore, as an independent reference. The excellent agreement
between GeMS measurements and the model that we find in this study, proves the
robustness of the SLODAR approach. To by-pass the complex procedures necessary
to achieve automatic measurements of the wind with GeMS, we propose a simple
automatic method to monitor nightly WS and WD using the Meso-Nh model
estimates. Such a method can be applied to whatever present or new generation
facilities supported by WFAO systems. The interest of this study is, therefore,
well beyond the optimization of GeMS performance.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.07341 [pdf] - 1535019
Forecasting surface layer atmospheric parameters at the LBT site
Submitted: 2017-01-25
In this paper we quantify the performances of an automated weather forecast
system implemented on the Large Binocular Telescope (LBT) site at Mt. Graham
(Arizona) in forecasting the main atmospheric parameters close to the ground.
The system employs a mesoscale non-hydrostatic numerical model (Meso-Nh). To
validate the model we compare the forecasts of wind speed, wind direction,
temperature and relative humidity close to the ground with the respective
values measured by instrumentation installed on the telescope dome. The study
is performed over a large sample of nights uniformly distributed over two
years. The quantitative analysis is done using classical statistical operators
(bias, RMSE and $\sigma$) and contingency tables, which allows to extract
complementary key information, such as the percentage of correct detection (PC)
and the probability to obtain a correct detection within a defined interval of
values (POD). Results of our study indicate that the model performances in
forecasting the atmospheric parameters we have just cited are very good, in
some cases excellent: RMSE for temperature is below 1{\deg} C, for relative
humidity is 14%, for the wind speed is around 2.5m/s. The relative error of the
RMSE for wind direction varies from 9% to 17% depending on the wind speed
conditions. This work is performed in the context of ALTA (Advanced LBT
Turbulence and Atmosphere) Center project, which final goal is to provide
forecasts of all the atmospheric parameters and the optical turbulence to
support LBT observations, adaptive optics facilities and interferometric
facilities.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.00711 [pdf] - 1526404
Optical turbulence forecast: ready for an operational application
Submitted: 2016-12-02
One of the main goals of the feasibility study MOSE (MOdellig ESO Sites) is
to evaluate the performances of a method conceived to forecast the optical
turbulence above the ESO sites of the Very Large Telescope and the
European-Extremely Large Telescope in Chile. The method implied the use of a
dedicated code conceived for the optical turbulence (OT) called Astro-Meso-Nh.
In this paper we present results we obtained at conclusion of this project
concerning the performances of this method in forecasting the most relevant
parameters related to the optical turbulence (CN2, seeing , isoplanatic angle
theta_0 and wavefront coherence time tau_0). Numerical predictions related to a
very rich statistical sample of nights uniformly distributed along a solar year
and belonging to different years have been compared to observations and
different statistical operators have been analyzed such as classical bias, RMSE
and and more sophisticated statistical operators derived by the contingency
tables that are able to quantify the score of success of a predictive method
such as the percentage of correct detection (PC) and the probability to detect
a parameter within a specific range of values (POD). The main conclusions of
the study tell us that the Astro-Meso-Nh model provides performances that are
already very good to definitely guarantee a not negligible positive impact on
the Service Mode of top-class telescopes and ELTs. A demonstrator for an
automatic and operational version of the Astro-Meso-Nh model will be soon
implemented on the sites of VLT and E-ELT.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.00237 [pdf] - 1473006
Forecasts of the atmospherical parameters close to the ground at the LBT
site in the context of the ALTA project
Submitted: 2016-09-01
In this paper we study the abilities of an atmospherical mesoscale model in
forecasting the classical atmospherical parameters relevant for astronomical
applications at the surface layer (wind speed, wind direction, temperature,
relative humidity) on the Large Binocular Telescope (LBT) site - Mount Graham,
Arizona. The study is carried out in the framework of the ALTA project aiming
at implementing an automated system for the forecasts of atmospherical
parameters (Meso-Nh code) and the optical turbulence (Astro-Meso-Nh code) for
the service-mode operation of the LBT. The final goal of such an operational
tool is to provide predictions with high time frequency of atmospheric and
optical parameters for an optimized planning of the telescope operation (dome
thermalization, wind-dependent dome orientation, observation planning based on
predicted seeing, adaptive optics optimization, etc...). Numerical simulations
are carried out with the Meso-Nh and Astro-Meso-Nh codes, which were proven to
give excellent results in previous studies focused on the two ESO sites of
Cerro Paranal and Cerro Armazones (MOSE Project). In this paper we will focus
our attention on the comparison of atmospherical parameters forescasted by the
model close to the ground with measurements taken by the observatory
instrumentations and stored in the LBT telemetry in order to validate the
numerical predictions. As previously done for Cerro Paranal (Lascaux et al.,
2015), we will also present an analysis of the model performances based on the
method of the contingency tables, that allows us to provide complementary key
information with the respect to the bias and RMSE (systematic and statistical
errors), such as the percentage of correct detection and the probability to
obtain a correct detection inside a defined interval of values.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.06506 [pdf] - 1461045
Operational optical turbulence forecast for the Service Mode of
top-class ground based telescopes
Submitted: 2016-08-23
In this contribution we present the most relevant results obtained in the
context of a feasibility study (MOSE) undertaken for ESO. The principal aim of
the project was to quantify the performances of a mesoscale model
(Astro-Meso-NH code) in forecasting all the main atmospherical parameters
relevant for the ground-based astronomical observations and the optical
turbulence (CN2 and associated integrated astroclimatic parameters) above Cerro
Paranal (site of the VLT) and Cerro Armazones (site of the E-ELT). A detailed
analysis on the score of success of the predictive capacities of the system
have been carried out for all the astroclimatic as well as for the
atmospherical parameters. Considering the excellent results that we obtained,
this study proved the opportunity to implement on these two sites an automatic
system to be run nightly in an operational configuration to support the
scheduling of scientific programs as well as of astronomical facilities
(particularly those supported by AO systems) of the VLT and the E-ELT. At the
end of 2016 a new project for the implementation of a demonstrator of an
operational system to be run on the two ESO's sites will start. Our team is
also responsible for the implementation of a similar automatic system at
Mt.Graham, site of the LBT (ALTA Project). Our system/method will permit
therefore to make a step ahead in the framework of the Service Mode for new
generation telescopes. Among the most exciting achieved results we cite the
fact that we proved to be able to forecast CN2 profiles with a vertical
resolution as high as 150 m. Such a feature is particularly crucial for all
WFAO systems that require such detailed information on the OT vertical
stratification on the whole 20 km above the ground. This important achievement
tells us that all the WFAO systems can rely on automatic systems that are able
to support their optimized use.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.06489 [pdf] - 1461041
Towards an automatic system for monitoring of CN2 and wind speed
profiles with GeMS
Submitted: 2016-08-23
Wide Field Adaptive Optics (WFAO) systems represent the more sophisticated AO
systems available today at large telescopes. A critical aspect for these WFAO
systems in order to deliver an optimised performance is the knowledge of the
vertical spatiotemporal distribution of the CN2 and the wind speed. Previous
studies (Cortes et al., 2012) already proved the ability of GeMS (the Gemini
Multi-Conjugated AO system) in retrieving CN2 and wind vertical stratification
using the telemetry data. To assess the reliability of the GeMS wind speed
estimates a preliminary study (Neichel et al., 2014) compared wind speed
retrieved from GeMS with that obtained with the atmospherical model Meso-Nh on
a small sample of nights providing promising results. The latter technique is
very reliable for the wind speed vertical stratification. The model outputs
gave, indeed, an excellent agreement with a large sample of radiosoundings (~
50) both in statistical terms and on individual flights (Masciadri et al.,
2013). Such a tool can therefore be used as a valuable reference in this
exercise of cross calibrating GeMS on-sky wind estimates with model
predictions. In this contribution we achieved a two-fold results: (1) we
extended analysis on a much richer statistical sample (~ 43 nights), we
confirmed the preliminary results and we found an even better correlation
between GeMS observations and the atmospherical model with basically no cases
of not-negligible uncertainties; (2) we evaluate the possibility to use, as an
input for GeMS, the Meso-Nh estimates of the wind speed stratification in an
operational configuration. Under this configuration these estimates can be
provided many hours in advanced with respect to the observations and with a
very high temporal frequency (order of 2 minutes or less).