Normalized to: Tittley, E.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1708.04245 [pdf] - 1674722
Dark matter dynamics in Abell 3827: new data consistent with standard
Cold Dark Matter
Massey, Richard;
Harvey, David;
Liesenborgs, Jori;
Richard, Johan;
Stach, Stuart;
Swinbank, Mark;
Taylor, Peter;
Williams, Liliya;
Clowe, Douglas;
Courbin, Frederic;
Edge, Alastair;
Israel, Holger;
Jauzac, Mathilde;
Joseph, Remy;
Jullo, Eric;
Kitching, Thomas D.;
Leonard, Adrienne;
Merten, Julian;
Nagai, Daisuke;
Nightingale, James;
Robertson, Andrew;
Romualdez, Luis Javier;
Saha, Prasenjit;
Smit, Renske;
Tam, Sut Ieng;
Tittley, Eric
Submitted: 2017-08-14
We present integral field spectroscopy of galaxy cluster Abell 3827, using
ALMA and VLT/MUSE. It reveals an unusual configuration of strong gravitational
lensing in the cluster core, with at least seven lensed images of a single
background spiral galaxy. Lens modelling based on HST imaging had suggested
that the dark matter associated with one of the cluster's central galaxies may
be offset. The new spectroscopic data enable better subtraction of foreground
light, and better identification of multiple background images. The inferred
distribution of dark matter is consistent with being centered on the galaxies,
as expected by LCDM. Each galaxy's dark matter also appears to be symmetric.
Whilst we do not find an offset between mass and light (suggestive of
self-interacting dark matter) as previously reported, the numerical simulations
that have been performed to calibrate Abell 3827 indicate that offsets and
asymmetry are still worth looking for in collisions with particular geometries.
Meanwhile, ALMA proves exceptionally useful for strong lens image
identifications.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.02101 [pdf] - 1273122
Gas around galaxy haloes - II: hydrogen absorption signatures from the
environments of galaxies at redshifts 2 < z < 3
Submitted: 2015-05-08
We compare predictions of large-scale cosmological hydrodynamical simulations
for neutral hydrogen absorption signatures in the vicinity of 1e11 - 1e12.5
MSun haloes with observational measurements. Two different hydrodynamical
techniques and a variety of prescriptions for gas removal in high density
regions are examined. Star formation and wind feedback play only secondary
roles in the HI absorption signatures outside the virial radius, but play
important roles within. Accordingly, we identify three distinct gaseous regions
around a halo: the virialized region, the mesogalactic medium outside the
virial radius arising from the extended haloes of galaxies out to about two
turnaround radii, and the intergalactic medium beyond. Predictions for the
amount of absorption from the mesogalactic and intergalactic media are robust
across different methodologies, and the predictions agree with the amount of
absorption observed around star-forming galaxies and QSO host galaxies.
Recovering the measured amount of absorption within the virialized region,
however, requires either a higher dynamic range in the simulations, additional
physics, or both.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1504.03388 [pdf] - 980273
The behaviour of dark matter associated with 4 bright cluster galaxies
in the 10kpc core of Abell 3827
Massey, Richard;
Williams, Liliya;
Smit, Renske;
Swinbank, Mark;
Kitching, Thomas;
Harvey, David;
Jauzac, Mathilde;
Israel, Holger;
Clowe, Douglas;
Edge, Alastair;
Hilton, Matt;
Jullo, Eric;
Leonard, Adrienne;
Liesenborgs, Jori;
Merten, Julian;
Mohammed, Irshad;
Nagai, Daisuke;
Richard, Johan;
Robertson, Andrew;
Saha, Prasenjit;
Santana, Rebecca;
Stott, John;
Tittley, Eric
Submitted: 2015-04-13
Galaxy cluster Abell 3827 hosts the stellar remnants of four almost equally
bright elliptical galaxies within a core of radius 10kpc. Such corrugation of
the stellar distribution is very rare, and suggests recent formation by several
simultaneous mergers. We map the distribution of associated dark matter, using
new Hubble Space Telescope imaging and VLT/MUSE integral field spectroscopy of
a gravitationally lensed system threaded through the cluster core. We find that
each of the central galaxies retains a dark matter halo, but that (at least)
one of these is spatially offset from its stars. The best-constrained offset is
1.62+/-0.48kpc, where the 68% confidence limit includes both statistical error
and systematic biases in mass modelling. Such offsets are not seen in field
galaxies, but are predicted during the long infall to a cluster, if dark matter
self-interactions generate an extra drag force. With such a small physical
separation, it is difficult to definitively rule out astrophysical effects
operating exclusively in dense cluster core environments - but if interpreted
solely as evidence for self-interacting dark matter, this offset implies a
cross-section sigma/m=(1.7+/-0.7)x10^{-4}cm^2/g x (t/10^9yrs)^{-2}, where t is
the infall duration.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.07675 [pdf] - 1021930
The non-gravitational interactions of dark matter in colliding galaxy
clusters
Submitted: 2015-03-26, last modified: 2015-04-13
Collisions between galaxy clusters provide a test of the non-gravitational
forces acting on dark matter. Dark matter's lack of deceleration in the `bullet
cluster collision' constrained its self-interaction cross-section \sigma_DM/m <
1.25cm2/g (68% confidence limit) for long-ranged forces. Using the Chandra and
Hubble Space Telescopes we have now observed 72 collisions, including both
`major' and `minor' mergers. Combining these measurements statistically, we
detect the existence of dark mass at 7.6\sigma significance. The position of
the dark mass has remained closely aligned within 5.8+/-8.2 kpc of associated
stars: implying a self-interaction cross-section \sigma_DM/m < 0.47 cm2/g (95%
CL) and disfavoring some proposed extensions to the standard model.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.5812 [pdf] - 886465
Gas around galaxy haloes: methodology comparisons using hydrodynamical
simulations of the intergalactic medium
Submitted: 2014-10-21
We perform cosmological simulations of the intergalactic medium (IGM) at
redshift z ~ 3 using the numerical gravity-hydrodynamics codes GADGET-3 and
Enzo for the purpose of modelling the gaseous environments of galaxies. We
identify haloes in the simulations using three different algorithms. Different
rank orderings of the haloes by mass result, introducing a limiting factor in
identifying haloes with observed galaxies. We also compare the physical
properties of the gas between the two codes, focussing primarily on the gas
outside the virial radius, motivated by recent HI absorption measurements of
the gas around z ~ 2 - 3 galaxies. The internal dispersion velocities of the
gas in the haloes have converged for a box size of 30 comoving Mpc, but the
centre-of-mass peculiar velocities of the haloes have not up to a box size of
60 comoving Mpc. The density and temperature of the gas within the
instantaneous turn-around radii of the haloes are adequately captured for box
sizes 30 Mpc on a side, but the results are highly sensitive to the treatment
of unresolved, rapidly cooling gas, with the gas mass fraction within the
virial radius severely depleted by star formation in the GADGET-3 simulations.
Convergence of the gas peculiar velocity field on large scales requires a box
size of at least 60 Mpc. Outside the turn-around radius, the physical state of
the gas agrees to 30 percent or better both with box size and between
simulation methods. We conclude that generic IGM simulations make accurate
predictions for the intergalactic gas properties beyond the halo turn-around
radii, but the gas properties on smaller scales are highly dependent on star
formation and feedback implementations.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.1731 [pdf] - 1179746
On the cross-section of Dark Matter using substructure infall into
galaxy clusters
Submitted: 2013-10-07, last modified: 2013-11-20
We develop a statistical method to measure the interaction cross-section of
Dark Matter, exploiting the continuous minor merger events in which small
substructures fall into galaxy clusters. We find that by taking the ratio of
the distances between the galaxies and Dark Matter, and galaxies and gas in
accreting sub-halos, we form a quantity that can be statistically averaged over
a large sample of systems whilst removing any inherent line-of-sight
projections. In order to interpret this ratio as a cross-section of Dark Matter
we derive an analytical description of sub-halo infall which encompasses; the
force of the main cluster potential, the drag on a gas sub-halo, a model for
Dark Matter self-interactions and the resulting sub-halo drag, the force on the
gas and galaxies due to the Dark Matter sub-halo potential, and finally the
buoyancy on the gas and Dark Matter. We create mock observations from
cosmological simulations of structure formation and find that collisionless
Dark Matter becomes physically separated from X-ray gas by up to 20h^-1 kpc.
Adding realistic levels of noise, we are able to predict achievable constraints
from observational data. Current archival data should be able to detect a
difference in the dynamical behaviour of Dark Matter and standard model
particles at 6 sigma, and measure the total interaction cross-section sigma/m
with 68% confidence limits of +/- 1cm2g^-1. We note that this method is not
restricted by the limited number of major merging events and is easily extended
to large samples of clusters from future surveys which could potentially push
statistical errors to 0.1cm^2g^-1.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.2117 [pdf] - 741403
Dark Matter Astrometry: Accuracy of sub-halo positions for the
measurement of self-interaction cross sections
Submitted: 2013-05-09
Direct evidence for the existence of dark matter and measurements of its
interaction cross-section have been provided by the physical offset between
dark matter and intra- cluster gas in merging systems like the Bullet Cluster.
Although a smaller signal, this effect is more abundant in minor mergers where
infalling substructure dark matter and gas are segregated. In such low-mass
systems the gravitational lensing signal comes primarily from weak lensing. A
fundamental step in determining such an offset in sub- structure is the ability
to accurately measure the positions of dark matter sub-peaks. Using simulated
Hubble Space Telescope observations, we make a first assessment of the
precision and accuracy with which we can measure infalling groups using weak
gravitational lensing. We demonstrate that using an existing and well-used mass
re- construction algorithm can measure the positions of 1.5x1013 M
substructures that have parent halos ten times more massive with a bias of less
than 0.3 . In this regime, our analysis suggests the precision is sufficient to
detect (at 3 {\sigma} statistical significance) the expected mean offset
between dark matter and baryonic gas in infalling groups from a sample of 50
massive clusters.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1201.5499 [pdf] - 1093269
Infra-red emission line tomography of the intergalactic medium during
the Epoch of Reionization
Submitted: 2012-01-26
The first major star-forming galaxies and Active Galactic Nuclei will produce
Balmer and higher order extended haloes during the Epoch of Reionization
through the scattering of Lyman resonance line photons off the surrounding
neutral intergalactic gas. The optical depth dependence of the scattering rates
will produce a signal sensitive to both the density and velocity fluctuations
of the gas, offering the possibility of probing the ionization region and flow
field surrounding young star-forming galaxies. The requirements for detecting
the haloes in the infra-red using a space-based telescope are discussed, along
with an assessment of the possibility of detecting the haloes using the Tunable
Filter Imager on the James Webb Space Telescope.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1109.5037 [pdf] - 1084334
The impact of helium reionization on the structure of the intergalactic
medium
Submitted: 2011-09-23
We examine the impact of helium reionization on the structure of the
intergalactic medium (IGM). We model the reionization using a radiative
transfer (RT) code coupled to the combined gravity hydrodynamics code Enzo.
Neutral hydrogen and helium are initially ionized by a starburst spectrum,
which is allowed to gradually evolve into a power law spectrum over the
redshift interval 3 < z < 4. The temperature-density relation of the gas is
found to fan out and flatten following HeII reionization, with an inversion for
overdensities above 5. Peculiar velocities of up to 10 km/s are induced by the
increased pressure, with the gas density field distorted over large coherent
regions by 10-20%, and the dark matter by levels of 1%. The
photoionization-induced flows may thus distort the matter power spectrum at
comoving wavenumbers k > 0.5 h/Mpc by a few percent by z = 2. Absorption
spectra for HI and HeII are drawn from the simulations, and absorption lines
are fit to the spectra. A median Doppler parameter of 35 km/s is obtained for
the HI absorption systems at z = 3. Dividing into subsamples optically thick
and optically thin at line centre reveals that the optically thick systems
undergo only mild evolution while the optically thin systems evolve rapidly
following HeII reionization. A comparison between HeII and HI absorption
features shows a broad distribution in the HeII and HI column density ratio,
peaking near the measured value and only slightly narrower than measured. A
comparison with approximate simulation methods shows moderately good agreement
in the absorption line properties, but not to the precision to which they may
be measured.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1004.4765 [pdf] - 155227
Helium reionization and the thermal proximity effect
Submitted: 2010-04-27
We examine the temperature structure of the intergalactic medium IGM)
surounding a hard radiation source, such as a Quasi-Stellar Object (QSO), as it
responds to the onset of helium reionization by the source. We model the
reionization using a radiative transfer (RT) code coupled to a particle-mesh
(PM) N-body code. Neutral hydrogen and helium are initially ionized by a
starburst spectrum, which is allowed to gradually evolve into a power law
spectrum (fnu ~ nu^(-0.5)). Multiple simulations were performed with different
times for the onset and dominance of the hard spectrum, with onset redshifts
ranging from z = 3.5 to 5.5. The source is placed in a high-density region to
mimic the expected local environment of a QSO. Simulations with the source
placed in a low-density environment were also performed as control cases to
explore the role of the environment on the properties of the surrounding IGM.
We find in both cases that the IGM temperature within the HeIII region produced
exceeds the IGM temperature before full helium reionization, resulting in a
"thermal proximity effect", but that the temperature in the HeIII region
increases systematically with distance from the source. With time the
temperature relaxes with a reduced spread as a function of impact parameter
along neighbouring lines of sight, although the trend continues to persist
until z = 2. Such a trend could be detected using the widths of intervening
metal absorption systems using high resolution, high signal-to-noise ratio
spectra.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0605317 [pdf] - 82005
Reionisation scenarios and the temperature of the IGM
Submitted: 2006-05-12, last modified: 2007-07-17
We examine the temperature structure of the IGM due to the passage of
individual ionisation fronts using a radiative transfer (RT) code coupled to a
particle-mesh (PM) N-body code. Multiple simulations were performed with
different spectra of ionising radiation: a power law (goes as nu^{-0.5}),
miniquasar, starburst, and a time-varying spectrum that evolves from a
starburst spectrum to a power law. The RT is sufficiently resolved in time and
space to correctly model both the ionisation state and the temperature across
the ionisation front. We find the post-ionisation temperature of the reionised
intergalactic medium (IGM) is sensitive to the spectrum of the source of
ionising radiation, which may be used to place strong constraints on the nature
of the sources of reionisation. Radiative transfer effects also produce large
fluctuations in the HeII to HI number density ratio eta. The spread in values
is smaller than measured, except for the time-varying spectrum. For this case,
the spread evolves as the spectral nature of the ionising background changes.
Large values for eta are found in partially ionised HeII as the power-law
spectrum begins to dominate the starburst, suggesting that the large eta values
measured may be indicating the onset of the HeII reionisation epoch.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0409177 [pdf] - 880763
Cluster mergers, core oscillations, and cold fronts
Submitted: 2004-09-07
We use numerical simulations with hydrodynamics to demonstrate that a class
of cold fronts in galaxy clusters can be attributed to oscillations of the dark
matter distribution. The oscillations are initiated by the off-axis passage of
a low-mass substructure. From the simulations, we derive three observable
morphological features indicative of oscillations: 1) The existence of
compressed isophotes; 2) The regions of compression must be alternate (opposite
and staggered) and lie on an axis passing through the center of the cluster; 3)
The gradient of each compression region must pass through the center of the
cluster. Four of six clusters reported in the literature to have cold fronts
have morphologies consistent with the presence of oscillations. The clusters
with oscillations are A496, A1795, A2142, and RX J1720.1+2638. Galaxy clusters
A2256 and A3667 are not consistent so the cold fronts are interpreted as group
remnants. The oscillations may be able to provide sufficient energy to solve
the cooling-flow problem and, importantly, provide it over an extended
duration.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0308282 [pdf] - 58561
XMM-Newton Observation of the Merging Galaxy Cluster A1644
Submitted: 2003-08-16, last modified: 2004-09-01
An XMM-Newton imaging spectroscopy analysis of the galaxy cluster A1644 is
presented. A1644 is a complex merging system consisting of a main and a sub
cluster. A trail of cool, metal-rich gas has been discovered close to the sub
cluster. The combination of results from X-ray, optical, and radio data, and a
comparison to a hydrodynamical simulation suggest that the sub cluster has
passed by the main cluster off-axis and a fraction of its gas has been stripped
off during this process. Furthermore, for this merging system, simple effects
are illustrated which can affect the use of clusters as cosmological probes.
Specifically, double clusters may affect estimates of the cluster number
density when treated as a single system. Mergers, as well as cool cores, can
alter the X-ray luminosity and temperature measured for clusters, causing these
values to differ from those expected in equilibrium.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0306341 [pdf] - 57422
A Soft X-ray Component in the Abell 754 Cluster
Submitted: 2003-06-17
We have analyzed the Chandra, BeppoSax, and ROSAT observations of Abell 754
and report evidence of a soft, diffuse X-ray component. The emission is peaked
in the cluster center and is detected out to 8' from the X-ray center. Fitting
a thermal model to the combined BeppoSax and PSPC spectra show excess emission
below 1 keV in the PSPC and above 100 keV in the BeppoSax PDS. The source 26W20
is in the field of view of the PDS. The addition of a powerlaw with the
spectral parameters measured by Silverman et al. (1998) for 26W20 successfully
models the hard component in the PDS. The remaining excess soft emission can be
modeled by either a low temperature, 0.75 - 1.03 keV component, or by a
powerlaw with a steep spectral index, 2.3. Addition of a second thermal
component model provides a much better fit to the data than does the addition
of a non-thermal component. The Chandra temperature map does not show any
region cooler than 6.9 keV within the region where the cool component was
detected. Simulations of the emission from embedded groups were performed and
compared with the Chandra temperature map which show groups are a plausible
source of ~1 keV emission. The cool component is centrally peaked in the
cluster and the gas density and temperature are relatively high arguing against
the WHIM as the source of the X-ray emission. X-ray emission from elliptical
galaxies is not high enough to provide the total cool component luminosity,
7.0x10^43 ergs s^-1. The peak of the cool component is located between the low
frequency radio halos arguing against a non-thermal interpretation for the
emission. We conclude that emission from embedded groups is the most likely
origin of the cool component in Abell 754.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0207063 [pdf] - 50206
Chandra Observations of the A3266 Galaxy Cluster Merger
Submitted: 2002-07-02
Analysis of a 30,000 s X-ray observation of the Abell 3266 galaxy cluster
with the ACIS on board the Chandra Observatory has produced several new
insights into the cluster merger. The intracluster medium has a
non-monotonically decreasing radial abundance profile. We argue that the most
plausible origin for the abundance enhancement is unmixed, high abundance
subcluster gas from the merger. The enrichment consists of two stages:
off-center deposition of a higher abundance material during a subcluster merger
followed by a strong, localized intracluster wind that acts to drive out the
light elements, producing the observed abundance enhancement. The wind is
needed to account for both an increase in the heavy element abundance and the
lack of an enhancement in the gas density. Dynamical evidence for the wind
includes: (1) a large scale, low surface brightness feature perpendicular to
the merger axis that appears to be an asymmetric pattern of gas flow to the
northwest, away from the center of the main cluster, (2) compressed gas in the
opposite direction (toward the cluster center), and (3), the hottest regions
visible in the temperature map coincide with the proposed merger geometry and
the resultant gas flow. The Chandra data for the central region of the main
cluster shows a slightly cooler, filamentary region that is centered on the
central cD galaxy and is aligned with the merger axis directly linking the
dynamical state of the cD to the merger. Overall, the high spectral/spatial
resolution Chandra observations support our earlier hypothesis (Henriksen,
Donnelly, & Davis 1999) that we are viewing a minor merger in the plane of the
sky.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0001153 [pdf] - 33950
Resolving the jeans mass in hydrodynamic simulations of hierarchical
clustering
Submitted: 2000-01-10
We examine the necessity of resolving the Jeans mass in hydrodynamical
simulations of the hierarchical formation of cosmological structures. We
consider a standard two-component fluid and use smoothed particle hydrodynamics
to model the baryonic component. It is found that resolution of the Jeans mass
is not necessary to extract bulk properties of bound objects that are
independent of resolution, provided that the objects have undergone a number of
merger events. The degree of merging must be sufficient to populate the objects
with substructure of similar total mass. After this criterion is met, neither
the density profiles of structures nor their density-temperature distributions
depend appreciably on the resolution of the simulation. Resolution of the Jeans
mass by the imposition of a minimum temperature is not found to adversely
affect the state of the matter in the final clusters. The baryon concentration
profiles still indicate a deficit of gas with respect to the dark matter in the
interiors of structures.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9911460 [pdf] - 109588
Hierarchical clustering and the baryon distribution in galaxy clusters
Submitted: 1999-11-24
The baryon fraction of galaxy clusters in numerical simulations is found to
be dependant on the cluster formation method. In all cases, the gas is
anti-biased compared with the dark matter. However, clusters formed
hierarchically are found to be more depleted in baryons than clusters formed
non-hierarchically. There is a depletion of 10 to 15% for hierarchically formed
clusters while the depletion is less than 10% for those clusters formed
non-hierarchically. This difference is dependent on the mass of the clusters.
The mean baryon enrichment profile for the hierarchically formed clusters shows
an appreciable baryon enhancement around the virial radius not seen in the
clusters formed without substructure. If this phenomenon applies to real
clusters, it implies that determinations of the baryon fractions in clusters of
galaxies require data extending beyond the virial radius of the clusters in
order to achieve an unbiased value.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9911365 [pdf] - 109493
Hierarchical clustering, the universal density profile, and the
mass-temperature scaling law of galaxy clusters
Submitted: 1999-11-18
The significance of hierarchical clustering on the density profile and
mass-temperature scaling relation for galaxy clusters is examined using
hydrodynamic N-body simulations. Clusters formed hierarchically are compared
with clusters formed with the initial density fluctuations on sub-cluster
scales removed via smoothing.
The universal profile, as described by Navarro, Frenk, and White, is not a
by-product of hierarchical clustering. It is found to fit the mean profiles of
clusters formed both hierarchically and otherwise. The Hernquist profile is
also found to fit the data well. The characteristic radius, r_s, moves outward
from 0.1 R_200 to 0.2 R_200 when the initial substructure is eliminated.
Interior to r_s, rho_DM is proportional to r^-1.8, regardless of initial
smoothing. Exterior to this radius, the profile is marginally shallower in the
non-hierarchical case, with rho_DM proportional to r^-2.4 compared with rho_DM
proportional to r^-2.7.
The mass-temperature scaling relation maintains the form T proportional to
M^2/3, regardless of cluster formation method. The normalisation varies at the
20% level, which is at the level of the intrinsic scatter, with the
non-hierarchical simulations producing the cooler clusters.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9911017 [pdf] - 109145
Hydrodynamical drag in cosmological simulations
Submitted: 1999-11-02, last modified: 1999-11-09
We present a study of hydrodynamic drag forces in smoothed particle
simulations. In particular, the deceleration of a resolution-limited cold clump
of gas moving through a hot medium is examined. It is found that the drag for
subsonic velocities exceeds that predicted by simple physical approximations.
This is shown to be a result of the hydrodynamical method which encourages the
accretion of particles from the hot medium onto a shell around the cold clump,
effectively increasing the radius of the clump. For sonic and supersonic
velocities, the drag is shown to be dependent on the effective cross section of
the clump. The consequences for cosmological simulations are discussed.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9809221 [pdf] - 102925
Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics in cosmology: a comparative study of
implementations
Submitted: 1998-09-16, last modified: 1998-09-17
We analyse the performance of twelve different implementations of Smoothed
Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH) using seven tests designed to isolate key
hydrodynamic elements of cosmological simulations which are known to cause the
SPH algorithm problems. In order, we consider a shock tube, spherical adiabatic
collapse, cooling flow model, drag, a cosmological simulation, rotating
cloud-collapse and disc stability. In the implementations special attention is
given to the way in which force symmetry is enforced in the equations of
motion. We study in detail how the hydrodynamics are affected by different
implementations of the artificial viscosity including those with a
shear-correction modification. We present an improved first-order
smoothing-length update algorithm that is designed to remove instabilities that
are present in the Hernquist and Katz (1989) algorithm.
For all tests we find that the artificial viscosity is the most important
factor distinguishing the results from the various implementations. The second
most important factor is the way force symmetry is achieved in the equation of
motion. Most results favour a kernel symmetrization approach. The exact method
by which SPH pressure forces are included has comparatively little effect on
the results. Combining the equation of motion presented in Thomas and Couchman
(1992) with a modification of the Monaghan and Gingold (1983) artificial
viscosity leads to an SPH scheme that is both fast and reliable.