Normalized to: Thurgood, J.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.08831 [pdf] - 1815082
On the periodicity of linear and nonlinear oscillatory reconnection
Submitted: 2018-11-21
(Abridged for ArXiv) An injection of energy towards a magnetic null point can
drive reversals of current sheet polarity leading to time-dependent Oscillatory
Reconnection, which is a possible explanation of how periodic phenomena can be
generated when reconnection occurs in the solar atmosphere. However, the
details of what controls the period of these oscillations is poorly understood,
despite being crucial in assessing whether OR can account for observed periodic
behaviour. This paper aims to highlight that different types of reconnection
reversal are supported about null points, and that these are distinct from the
oscillation on the closed-boundary, linear systems considered in the 1990s. In
particular, we explore the features of a nonlinear oscillation local to the
null point, and examine the effect of resistivity and perturbation energy on
the period, contrasting it to the linear case. It is found that in the linear
systems, the inverse Lundquist number dictates the period, provided the
perturbation energy is small relative to the inverse Lundquist number defined
on the boundary, regardless of the broadband structure of the initial
perturbation. However, when the perturbation energy exceeds the threshold
required for 'nonlinear' null collapse to occur, a complex oscillation of the
magnetic field is produced which is, at best, only weakly-dependent on the
resistivity. The resultant periodicity is strongly influenced by the amount of
free energy, with more energetic perturbations producing higher-frequency
oscillations. Crucially, with regards to typical solar-based and
astrophysical-based input energies, we demonstrate that the majority far exceed
the threshold for nonlinearity to develop. This substantially alters the
properties and periodicity of both null collapse and subsequent OR. Therefore,
nonlinear regimes of OR should be considered in solar and astrophysical
contexts.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1806.08157 [pdf] - 1714350
Resistively-limited current sheet implosions in planar anti-parallel
(1D) and null-point containing (2D) magnetic field geometries
Submitted: 2018-06-21, last modified: 2018-07-11
Implosive formation of current sheets is a fundamental plasma process.
Previous studies focused on the early time evolution, while here our primary
aim is to explore the longer-term evolution, which may be critical for
determining the efficiency of energy release. To address this problem we
investigate two closely-related problems, namely: (i) 1D, pinched anti-parallel
magnetic fields and (ii) 2D, null point containing fields which are locally
imbalanced ('null-collapse' or 'X-point collapse'). Within the framework of
resistive MHD, we simulate the full nonlinear evolution through three distinct
phases: the initial implosion, its eventual halting mechanism, and subsequent
evolution post-halting. In a parameter study, we find the scaling with
resistivity of current sheet properties at the halting time is in good
agreement - in both geometries - with that inferred from a known 1D similarity
solution. We find that the halting of the implosions occurs rapidly after
reaching the diffusion scale by sudden Ohmic heating of the dense plasma within
the current sheet, which provides a pressure gradient sufficient to oppose
further collapse and decelerate the converging flow. This back-pressure grows
to exceed that required for force balance and so the post-implosion evolution
is characterised by the consequences of the current sheet `bouncing' outwards.
These are: (i) the launching of propagating fast MHD waves (shocks) outwards
and (ii) the width-wise expansion of the current sheet itself. The expansion is
only observed to stall in the 2D case, where the pressurisation is relieved by
outflow in the reconnection jets. In the 2D case, we quantify the maximum
amount of current sheet expansion as it scales with resistivity, and analyse
the structure of the reconnection region which forms post-expansion, replete
with Petschek-type slow shocks and fast termination shocks.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.07076 [pdf] - 1652493
Implosive collapse about magnetic null points: A quantitative comparison
between 2D and 3D nulls
Submitted: 2018-02-20
Null collapse is an implosive process whereby MHD waves focus their energy in
the vicinity of a null point, forming a current sheet and initiating magnetic
reconnection. We consider, for the first time, the case of collapsing 3D
magnetic null points in nonlinear, resistive MHD using numerical simulation,
exploring key physical aspects of the system as well as performing a detailed
parameter study. We find that within a particular plane containing the 3D null,
the plasma and current density enhancements resulting from the collapse are
quantitatively and qualitatively as per the 2D case in both the linear and
nonlinear collapse regimes. However, the scaling with resistivity of the 3D
reconnection rate - which is a global quantity - is found to be less favourable
when the magnetic null point is more rotationally symmetric, due to the action
of increased magnetic back-pressure. Furthermore, we find that with increasing
ambient plasma pressure the collapse can be throttled, as is the case for 2D
nulls. We discuss this pressure-limiting in the context of fast reconnection in
the solar atmosphere and suggest mechanisms by which it may be overcome. We
also discuss the implications of the results in the context of null collapse as
a trigger mechanism of Oscillatory Reconnection, a time-dependent reconnection
mechanism, and also within the wider subject of wave-null point interactions.
We conclude that, in general, increasingly rotationally-asymmetric nulls will
be more favourable in terms of magnetic energy release via null collapse than
their more symmetric counterparts.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.09662 [pdf] - 1585295
Three-dimensional oscillatory magnetic reconnection
Submitted: 2017-06-29
Here we detail the dynamic evolution of localised reconnection regions about
three-dimensional (3D) magnetic null points by using numerical simulation. We
demonstrate for the first time that reconnection triggered by the localised
collapse of a 3D null point due to an external MHD wave involves a
self-generated oscillation, whereby the current sheet and outflow jets undergo
a reconnection reversal process during which back-pressure formation at the jet
heads acts to prise open the collapsed field before overshooting the
equilibrium into an opposite-polarity configuration. The discovery that
reconnection at fully 3D nulls can proceed naturally in a time-dependent and
periodic fashion is suggestive that oscillatory reconnection mechanisms may
play a role in explaining periodicity in astrophysical phenomena associated
with magnetic reconnection, such as the observed quasi-periodicity of solar and
stellar flare emission. Furthermore, we find a consequence of oscillatory
reconnection is the generation of a plethora of freely-propagating MHD waves
which escape the vicinity of the reconnection region
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.01780 [pdf] - 1533036
Particle-in-cell simulations of the relaxation of electron beams in
inhomogeneous solar wind plasmas
Submitted: 2016-12-06, last modified: 2016-12-14
Previous theoretical considerations of electron beam relaxation in
inhomogeneous plasmas have indicated that the effects of the irregular solar
wind may account for the poor agreement of homogeneous modelling with the
observations. Quasi-linear theory and Hamiltonian models based on Zakharov's
equations have indicated that when a level of density fluctuations is above a
given threshold, density irregularities act to de-resonate the beam-plasma
interaction, restricting Langmuir wave growth on the expense of beam energy.
This work presents the first fully kinetic particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations
of beam relaxation under the influence of density irregularities. We aim to
independently determine the influence of background inhomogeneity on the
beam-plasma system, and to test theoretical predictions and alternative models
using a fully kinetic treatment. We carry out 1D PIC simulations of a
bump-on-tail unstable electron beam in the presence of increasing levels of
background inhomogeneity using the fully electromagnetic, relativistic EPOCH
PIC code. We find that in the case of homogeneous background plasma density,
Langmuir wave packets are generated at the resonant condition and then
quasi-liear relaxation leads to a dynamic increase of wavenumbers generated. No
electron acceleration is seen - unlike in the inhomogeneous experiments, all of
which produce high-energy electrons. For the inhomogeneous experiments we also
observe the generation of backwards propagating Langmuir waves, which is shown
directly to be due to the refraction of the packets off the density gradients.
Our fully kinetic PIC simulations broadly confirm the findings of quasi-linear
theory and the Hamiltonian model based on Zakharov's equations. Strong density
fluctuations modify properties of excited Langmuir waves altering their
dispersion properties.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1509.07004 [pdf] - 1319645
Self-consistent particle-in-cell simulations of fundamental and harmonic
plasma radio emission mechanisms
Submitted: 2015-09-23
Aims. The simulation of three-wave interaction based plasma emission, thought
to be the underlying mechanism for Type III solar radio bursts, is a
challenging task requiring fully-kinetic, multi-dimensional models. This paper
aims to resolve a contradiction in past attempts, whereby some studies indicate
that no such processes occur. Methods. We self-consistently simulate
three-waved based plasma emission through all stages by using 2D, fully
kinetic, electromagnetic particle-in-cell simulations of relaxing electron
beams using the EPOCH2D code. Results. Here we present the results of two
simulations; Run 1 (nb/n0 = 0.0057, vb/{\Delta}vb = vb/Ve = 16) and Run 2
(nb/n0 = 0.05, vb/{\Delta}vb = vb/Ve = 8), which we find to permit and prohibit
plasma emission respectively. We show that the possibility of plasma emission
is contingent upon the frequency of the initial electrostatic waves generated
by the bump-in-tail instability, and that these waves may be prohibited from
participating in the necessary three-wave interactions due to frequency
conservation requirements. In resolving this apparent contradiction through a
comprehensive analysis, in this paper we present the first self-consistent
demonstration of fundamental and harmonic plasma emission from a single-beam
system via fully kinetic numerical simulation. We caution against simulating
astrophysical radio bursts using unrealistically dense beams (a common approach
which reduces run time), as the resulting non-Langmiur characteristics of the
initial wave modes significantly suppresses emission. Comparison of our results
also indicates that, contrary to the suggestions of previous authors, an
alternative plasma emission mechanism based on two counter-propagating beams is
unnecessary in an astrophysical context.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1406.5348 [pdf] - 1215106
First direct measurements of transverse waves in solar polar plumes
using SDO/AIA
Submitted: 2014-06-20
There is intense interest in determining the precise contribution of
Alfv\'enic waves propagating along solar structures to the problems of coronal
heating and solar wind acceleration. Since the launch of SDO/AIA, it has been
possible to resolve transverse oscillations in off-limb solar polar plumes and
recently McIntosh et al. (2011, Nature, 475, 477) concluded that such waves are
energetic enough to play a role in heating the corona and accelerating the fast
solar wind. However, this result is based on comparisons to Monte Carlo
simulations and confirmation via direct measurements is still outstanding.
Thus, this letter reports on the first direct measurements of transverse wave
motions in solar polar plumes. Over a 4 hour period, we measure the transverse
displacements, periods and velocity amplitudes of 596 distinct oscillations
observed in the 171 \AA channel of SDO/AIA. We find a broad range of
non-uniformly distributed parameter values which are well described by
log-normal distributions with peaks at $234$ km, $121$ s and $8$ km s$^{-1}$,
and mean and standard deviations of $407\pm297$ km, $173\pm118$ s and $14\pm10$
km s$^{-1}$. Within standard deviations, our direct measurements are broadly
consistent with previous results. However, accounting for the whole of our
observed non-uniform parameter distribution we calculate an energy flux of
$9-24$ W m$^{-2}$, which is $4-10$ times below the energy requirement for solar
wind acceleration. Hence, our results indicate that transverse MHD waves as
resolved by SDO/AIA cannot be the dominant energy source for fast solar wind
acceleration in the open-field corona.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1307.7001 [pdf] - 1172997
3D Alfven wave behaviour around proper and improper magnetic null points
Submitted: 2013-07-26
Context: MHD waves and magnetic null points are both prevalent in many
astrophysical plasmas, including the solar atmosphere. Interaction between
waves and null points has been implicated as a possible mechanism for localised
heating events. Aims: Here we investigate the transient behaviour of the Alfven
wave about fully 3D proper and improper 3D magnetic null points. Previously,
the behaviour of fast magnetoacoustic waves at null points in 3D, cold MHD was
considered by Thurgood & McLaughlin (Astronomy & Astrophysics, 2012, 545, A9).
Methods: We introduce an Alfven wave into the vicinity of both proper and
improper null points by numerically solving the ideal, $\beta=0$ MHD equations
using the LARE3D code. A magnetic fieldline and flux-based coordinate system
permits the isolation of resulting wave-modes and the analysis of their
interaction. Results: We find that the Alfven wave propagates throughout the
region and accumulates near the fan-plane, causing current build up. For
different values of null point eccentricity, the qualitative behaviour changes
only by the imposition of anisotropic pulse dilation, due to the differing
rates at which fieldlines diverge from the spine. For all eccentricities, we
find that the fast and Alfven waves are linearly decoupled. During the driving
phase, an independently propagating fast wave is nonlinearly generated due to
the ponderomotive force. Subsequently, no further excitation of fast waves
occurs. Conclusions: We find that the key aspects of the theory of Alfv\'en
waves about 2D null points extends intuitively to the fully 3D case; i.e. the
wave propagates along fieldlines and thus accumulates at predictable parts of
the topology. We also highlight that unlike in the 2D case, in 3D Alfven-wave
pulses are always toroidal and thus any aspects of 2D Alfven-wave-null models
that are pulse-geometry specific must be reconsidered in 3D.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.7073 [pdf] - 1171682
Nonlinear Alfv\'en wave dynamics at a 2D magnetic null point:
ponderomotive force
Submitted: 2013-05-30
Context : In the linear, {\beta}=0 MHD regime, the transient properties of
MHD waves in the vicinity of 2D null points are well known. The waves are
decoupled and accumulate at predictable parts of the magnetic topology: fast
waves accumulate at the null point; whereas Alfv\'en waves cannot cross the
separatricies. However, in nonlinear MHD mode conversion can occur at regions
of inhomogeneous Alfv\'en speed, suggesting that the decoupled nature of waves
may not extend to the nonlinear regime. Aims: We investigate the behaviour of
low-amplitude Alfv\'en waves about a 2D magnetic null point in nonlinear,
{\beta}= 0 MHD. Methods: We numerically simulate the introduction of
low-amplitude Alfv\'en waves into the vicinity of a magnetic null point using
the nonlinear LARE2D code. Results: Unlike in the linear regime, we find that
the Alfv\'en wave sustains cospatial daughter disturbances, manifest in the
transverse and longitudinal fluid velocity, owing to the action of nonlinear
magnetic pressure gradients (viz. the ponderomotive force). These disturbances
are dependent on the Alfv\'en wave and do not interact with the medium to
excite magnetoacoustic waves, although the transverse daughter becomes focused
at the null point. Additionally, an independently propagating fast
magnetoacoustic wave is generated during the early stages, which transports
some of the initial Alfv\'en wave energy towards the null point. Subsequently,
despite undergoing dispersion and phase-mixing due to gradients in the
Alfv\'en-speed profile (Grad c_A \neq 0) there is no further nonlinear
generation of fast waves. Conclusions: We find that Alfv\'en waves at 2D cold
null points behave largely as in the linear regime, however they sustain
transverse and longitudinal disturbances - effects absent in the linear regime
- due to nonlinear magnetic pressure gradients.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1302.4340 [pdf] - 1164693
On ponderomotive effects induced by Alfven waves in inhomogeneous 2.5D
MHD plasmas
Submitted: 2013-02-18
Where spatial gradients in the amplitude of an Alfven wave are non-zero, a
nonlinear magnetic-pressure gradient acts upon the medium (the ponderomotive
force). We investigate the nature of such a force in inhomogeneous 2.5D MHD
plasmas by analysing source terms in the nonlinear wave equations for the
general case of inhomogeneous B and {\rho}, and consider supporting nonlinear
numerical simulations. Our equations indicate there are two distinct classes of
ponderomotive effect induced by Alfven waves in general 2.5D MHD, each with
both a longitudinal and transverse manifestation; i) Geometric Effects:
Gradients in the pulse geometry relative to the background magnetic field cause
the wave to sustain cospatial disturbances, the longitudinal and transverse
daughter disturbances - where we report on the transverse disturbance for the
first time. ii) Grad (c_A) Effects: Where a pulse propagates through an
inhomogeneous region (where the non-zero gradients in the Alfven-speed profile
are non-zero), the nonlinear magnetic-pressure gradient acts to accelerate the
plasma. Transverse gradients (phase mixing regions) excite independently
propagating fast magnetoacoustic waves (generalising the result of Nakariakov
et al. 1997, Solar Physics, 175, 93) and longitudinal gradients perturb along
the field (thus creating static disturbances in {\beta} = 0, and slow waves in
{\beta} \= 0).
We additionally demonstrate that mode conversion due the nonlinear Lorentz
force is a one-way process, and does not act as a mechanism to nonlinearly
generate Alfven waves due to propagating magnetoacoustic waves. We conclude
that these ponderomotive effects are induced by an Alfven wave propagating in
any MHD medium, and have the potential to have significant consequences on the
dynamics of energy transport and aspects of dissipation provided the system is
sufficiently nonlinear and inhomogeneous.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1212.1000 [pdf] - 599361
On the Periodicity of Oscillatory Reconnection
Submitted: 2012-12-05
Oscillatory reconnection is a time-dependent magnetic reconnection mechanism
that naturally produces periodic outputs from aperiodic drivers. This paper
aims to quantify and measure the periodic nature of oscillatory reconnection
for the first time. We solve the compressible, resistive, nonlinear MHD
equations using 2.5D numerical simulations. We identify two distinct periodic
regimes: the impulsive and stationary phases. In the impulsive phase, we find
the greater the amplitude of the initial velocity driver, the longer the
resultant current sheet and the earlier its formation. In the stationary phase,
we find that the oscillations are exponentially decaying and for driving
amplitudes 6.3 - 126.2 km/s, we measure stationary-phase periods in the range
56.3 - 78.9 s, i.e. these are high frequency (0.01 - 0.02 Hz) oscillations. In
both phases, we find that the greater the amplitude of the initial velocity
driver, the shorter the resultant period, but note that different physical
processes and periods are associated with both phases. We conclude that the
oscillatory reconnection mechanism behaves akin to a damped harmonic
oscillator.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1208.5885 [pdf] - 556444
Linear and nonlinear MHD mode coupling of the fast magnetoacoustic wave
about a 3D magnetic null point
Submitted: 2012-08-29
Context: Coronal magnetic null points have been implicated as possible
locations for localised heating events in 2D models. We investigate this
possibility about fully 3D null points.
Aims: We investigate the nature of the fast magnetoacoustic wave about a
fully 3D magnetic null point, with a specific interest in its propagation, and
we look for evidence of MHD mode coupling and/or conversion to the Alfv\'en
mode.
Methods: A special fieldline and flux-based coordinate system was constructed
to permit the introduction of a pure fast magnetoacoustic wave in the vicinity
of proper and improper 3D null points. We considered the ideal, {\beta} = 0,
MHD equations, which are solved using the LARE3D numerical code. The
constituent modes of the resulting wave were isolated and identified using the
special coordinate system. Numerical results were supported by analytical work
derived from perturbation theory and a linear implementation of the WKB method.
Results: An initially pure fast wave is found to be permanently decoupled
from the Alfv\'en mode both linearly and nonlinearly for both proper and
improper 3D null points. The pure fast mode also generates and sustains a
nonlinear disturbance aligned along the equilibrium magnetic field. The
resulting pure fast magnetoacoustic pulse has transient behaviour, which is
found to be governed by the (equilibrium) Alfv\'en-speed profile, and a
refraction effect focuses all the wave energy towards the null point.
Conclusions: Thus, the main results from previous 2D work do indeed carry
over to the fully 3D magnetic null points and