Normalized to: Thronson, H.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.00369 [pdf] - 1927031
Using Artificial Intelligence to Augment Science Prioritization for
Astro2020
Submitted: 2019-08-01
Science funding agencies (NASA, DOE, and NSF), the science community, and the
US taxpayer have all benefited enormously from the several-decade series of
National Academies Decadal Surveys. These Surveys are one of the primary means
whereby these agencies may align multi-year strategic priorities and funding to
guide the scientific community. They comprise highly regarded subject matter
experts whose goal is to develop a set of science and program priorities that
are recommended for major investments in the subsequent 10+ years. They do this
using both their own professional knowledge and by synthesizing details from
many thousands of existing and solicited documents.
Congress, the relevant funding agencies, and the scientific community have
placed great respect and value on these recommendations. Consequently, any
significant changes to the process of determining these recommendations should
be scrutinized carefully. That said, we believe that there is currently
sufficient justification for the National Academies to consider some changes.
We advocate that they supplement the established survey process with
predictions of promising science priorities identified by application of
current Artificial Intelligence (AI) techniques These techniques are being
applied elsewhere in long-range planning and prioritization.
We present a proposal to apply AI to aid the Decadal Survey panel in
prioritizing science objectives. We emphasize that while AI can assist a mass
review of papers, the decision-making remains with humans. In our paper below
we summarize the case for using AI in this manner and suggest small inexpensive
demonstration trials, including an AI/ML assessment of the white papers
submitted to Astro2020 and backcasting to evaluate AI in making predictions for
the 2010 Decadal Survey.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1611.09736 [pdf] - 1580730
Finding the UV-Visible Path Forward: Proceedings of the Community
Workshop to Plan the Future of UV/Visible Space Astrophysics
Scowen, Paul A.;
Tripp, Todd;
Beasley, Matt;
Ardila, David;
Andersson, B-G;
Apellániz, Jesús Maíz;
Barstow, Martin;
Bianchi, Luciana;
Calzetti, Daniela;
Clampin, Mark;
Evans, Christopher J.;
France, Kevin;
García, Miriam García;
de Castro, Ana Gomez;
Harris, Walt;
Hartigan, Patrick;
Howk, J. Christopher;
Hutchings, John;
Larruquert, Juan;
Lillie, Charles F.;
Matthews, Gary;
McCandliss, Stephan;
Polidan, Ron;
Perez, Mario R.;
Rafelski, Marc;
Roederer, Ian U.;
Sana, Hugues;
Sanders, Wilton T.;
Schiminovich, David;
Thronson, Harley;
Tumlinson, Jason;
Vallerga, John;
Wofford, Aida
Submitted: 2016-11-29
We present the science cases and technological discussions that came from the
workshop entitled "Finding the UV-Visible Path Forward" held at NASA GSFC June
25-26, 2015. The material presented outlines the compelling science that can be
enabled by a next generation space-based observatory dedicated for UV-visible
science, the technologies that are available to include in that observatory
design, and the range of possible alternative launch approaches that could also
enable some of the science. The recommendations to the Cosmic Origins Program
Analysis Group from the workshop attendees on possible future development
directions are outlined.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1508.06661 [pdf] - 1342817
ATLAST detector needs for direct spectroscopic biosignature
characterization in the visible and near-IR
Submitted: 2015-08-26
Are we alone? Answering this ageless question will be a major focus for
astrophysics in coming decades. Our tools will include unprecedentedly large
UV-Optical-IR space telescopes working with advanced coronagraphs and
starshades. Yet, these facilities will not live up to their full potential
without better detectors than we have today. To inform detector development,
this paper provides an overview of visible and near-IR (VISIR;
$\lambda=0.4-1.8~\mu\textrm{m}$) detector needs for the Advanced Technology
Large Aperture Space Telescope (ATLAST), specifically for spectroscopic
characterization of atmospheric biosignature gasses. We also provide a brief
status update on some promising detector technologies for meeting these needs
in the context of a passively cooled ATLAST.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.1886 [pdf] - 1123997
Breakthrough capability for the NASA Astrophysics Explorer Program:
Reaching the darkest sky
Submitted: 2012-06-08
We describe a mission architecture designed to substantially increase the
science capability of the NASA Science Mission Directorate (SMD) Astrophysics
Explorer Program for all AO proposers working within the near-UV to
far-infrared spectrum. We have demonstrated that augmentation of Falcon 9
Explorer launch services with a 13 kW Solar Electric Propulsion (SEP) stage can
deliver a 700 kg science observatory payload to extra-Zodiacal orbit. This new
capability enables up to ~13X increased photometric sensitivity and ~160X
increased observing speed relative to a Sun-Earth L2, Earth-trailing, or Earth
orbit with no increase in telescope aperture. All enabling SEP stage
technologies for this launch service augmentation have reached sufficient
readiness (TRL-6) for Explorer Program application in conjunction with the
Falcon 9. We demonstrate that enabling Astrophysics Explorers to reach
extra-zodiacal orbit will allow this small payload program to rival the science
performance of much larger long development time systems; thus, providing a
means to realize major science objectives while increasing the SMD Astrophysics
portfolio diversity and resiliency to external budget pressure. The SEP
technology employed in this study has strong applicability to SMD Planetary
Science community-proposed missions. SEP is a stated flight demonstration
priority for NASA's Office of the Chief Technologist (OCT). This new mission
architecture for astrophysics Explorers enables an attractive realization of
joint goals for OCT and SMD with wide applicability across SMD science
disciplines.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:0904.0941 [pdf] - 542628
Advanced Technology Large-Aperture Space Telescope (ATLAST): A
Technology Roadmap for the Next Decade
Postman, Marc;
Argabright, Vic;
Arnold, Bill;
Aronstein, David;
Atcheson, Paul;
Blouke, Morley;
Brown, Tom;
Calzetti, Daniela;
Cash, Webster;
Clampin, Mark;
Content, Dave;
Dailey, Dean;
Danner, Rolf;
Doxsey, Rodger;
Ebbets, Dennis;
Eisenhardt, Peter;
Feinberg, Lee;
Fruchter, Andrew;
Giavalisco, Mauro;
Glassman, Tiffany;
Gong, Qian;
Green, James;
Grunsfeld, John;
Gull, Ted;
Hickey, Greg;
Hopkins, Randall;
Hraba, John;
Hyde, Tupper;
Jordan, Ian;
Kasdin, Jeremy;
Kendrick, Steve;
Kilston, Steve;
Koekemoer, Anton;
Korechoff, Bob;
Krist, John;
Mather, John;
Lillie, Chuck;
Lo, Amy;
Lyon, Rick;
McCullough, Peter;
Mosier, Gary;
Mountain, Matt;
Oegerle, Bill;
Pasquale, Bert;
Purves, Lloyd;
Penera, Cecelia;
Polidan, Ron;
Redding, Dave;
Sahu, Kailash;
Saif, Babak;
Sembach, Ken;
Shull, Mike;
Smith, Scott;
Sonneborn, George;
Spergel, David;
Stahl, Phil;
Stapelfeldt, Karl;
Thronson, Harley;
Thronton, Gary;
Townsend, Jackie;
Traub, Wesley;
Unwin, Steve;
Valenti, Jeff;
Vanderbei, Robert;
Werner, Michael;
Wesenberg, Richard;
Wiseman, Jennifer;
Woodgate, Bruce
Submitted: 2009-04-06, last modified: 2009-05-08
The Advanced Technology Large-Aperture Space Telescope (ATLAST) is a set of
mission concepts for the next generation of UVOIR space observatory with a
primary aperture diameter in the 8-m to 16-m range that will allow us to
perform some of the most challenging observations to answer some of our most
compelling questions, including "Is there life elsewhere in the Galaxy?" We
have identified two different telescope architectures, but with similar optical
designs, that span the range in viable technologies. The architectures are a
telescope with a monolithic primary mirror and two variations of a telescope
with a large segmented primary mirror. This approach provides us with several
pathways to realizing the mission, which will be narrowed to one as our
technology development progresses. The concepts invoke heritage from HST and
JWST design, but also take significant departures from these designs to
minimize complexity, mass, or both.
Our report provides details on the mission concepts, shows the extraordinary
scientific progress they would enable, and describes the most important
technology development items. These are the mirrors, the detectors, and the
high-contrast imaging technologies, whether internal to the observatory, or
using an external occulter. Experience with JWST has shown that determined
competitors, motivated by the development contracts and flight opportunities of
the new observatory, are capable of achieving huge advances in technical and
operational performance while keeping construction costs on the same scale as
prior great observatories.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0006328 [pdf] - 36708
Probing the Interstellar Medium in Early type galaxies with ISO
observations
Malhotra, S.;
Hollenbach, D.;
Helou, G.;
Silbermann, N.;
Valjavec, E.;
Rubin, R. H.;
Dale, D.;
Hunter, D.;
Lu, N.;
Lord, S.;
Dinerstein, H.;
Thronson, H.
Submitted: 2000-06-22
Four IRAS-detected early type galaxies were observed with ISO. With the
exception of the 15 micron image of NGC1052, the mid-IR emission from NGC1052,
NGC1155, NGC5866 and NGC6958 at 4.5, 7 and 15 microns show extended emission.
Mid-IR emission from NGC1052, NGC1155, and NGC6958 follows a de Vaucouleurs
profile. The ratio of 15/7 micron flux decreases with radius in these galaxies,
approaching the values empirically observed for purely stellar systems. In
NGC5866, the 7 and 15 micron emission is concentrated in the edge-on dust lane.
All the galaxies are detected in the [CII] line, and the S0s NGC1155 and
NGC5866 are detected in the [OI] line as well. The ISO-LWS observations of the
[CII] line are more sensitive measures of cool, neutral ISM than HI and CO by
about a factor of 10-100. Three of four early type galaxies, namely NGC1052,
NGC6958 and NGC5866, have low ratio FIR/Blue and show a lower [CII]/FIR, which
is due to a softer radiation field from old stellar populations. The low
[CII]/CO ratio in NGC5866 ([CII]/CO(1-0) < 570) confirms this scenario. We
estimate the UV radiation expected from the old stellar populations in these
galaxies and compare it to that needed to heat the gas to account for the
cooling observed [CII] and [OI] lines. In three out of four galaxies, NGC1052,
NGC5866 and NGC6958, the predicted UV radiation falls short by a factor of 2-3.
In view of the observed intrinsic scatter in the "UV-upturn" in elliptical
galaxies and its great sensitivity to age and metallicity effects, this is not
significant. However, the much larger difference (about a factor of 20) between
the UV radiation from old stars and that needed to produce the FIR lines for
NGC 1155 is strong evidence for the presence of young stars, in NGC1155.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9710220 [pdf] - 98979
ISO measurements of [CII] line variations in galaxies
Malhotra, S.;
Helou, G.;
Stacey, G.;
Hollenbach, D.;
Lord, S.;
Beichman, C. A.;
Dinerstein, H.;
Hunter, D. A.;
Lo, K. Y.;
Lu, N. Y.;
Rubin, R. H.;
Silbermann, N.;
Thronson, H. A.;
Werner, M. W.
Submitted: 1997-10-21
We report measurements of the [CII] fine structure line at 157.714 micron in
30 normal star-forming galaxies with the Long Wavelength Spectrometer (LWS) on
the Infrared Space Observatory (ISO). The ratio of the line to total
far-infrared luminosity, [CII]/FIR, measures the ratio of the cooling of gas to
that of dust; and thus the efficiency of the grain photoelectric heating
process. This ratio varies by a factor of 40 in the current sample. About
two-thirds of the galaxies have [CII]/FIR = 2-7 x 10^{-3}. The other one-third
show trends of decreasing [CII]/FIR with increasing dust temperature, indicated
by the ratio of infrared emission at 60 and 100 microns; and with increasing
star-formation activity, measured by the ratio of far-infrared and blue band
luminosity. We find three FIR bright galaxies with undetected [CII] line at
3-sigma upper limits of [CII]/FIR < 0.5-2 x 10^{-4}. The trend in the [CII]/FIR
ratio with the temperature of dust and with star-formation activity may be due
to decreased efficiency of photoelectric heating of gas at high UV radiation
intensity as dust grains become positively charged, decreasing the yield and
the energy of the photoelectrons. The three galaxies with no observed PDR lines
have among the highest ratios of FIR to Blue luminosity and the ratio of 60 and
100 micron emission. Their lack of [CII] lines may be due to a continuing trend
of decreasing [CII]/FIR with increasing star-formation activity and dust
temperature seen in one-third of the sample with warm IRAS colors. In that case
the upper limits on [CII]/FIR imply a ratio of UV flux to gas density G_0/n >
10 cm$^3. The low [CII]/FIR could also be due to either weak [CII] because of
self-absorption or strong FIR continuum from regions weak in [CII], such as
dense HII regions or plasma ionized by hard radiation of AGNs.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9610242 [pdf] - 95766
An ISOPHOT of the disk of galaxy NGC 6946: 60 micron infrared and radio
continuum correlation
Submitted: 1996-10-29
We use the ISOPHOT 60 micron image of Tuffs et al. (1996) to study the 60
micron light distribution and its correlation with radio continuum within the
disk of spiral galaxy NGC6946, and to resolve the long-standing IRAS
controversy as to whether the infrared-to-radio continuum ratio, Q, decreases
radially out in galaxy disks. Our main results are: (1) The disk at 60 microns
also appears to follow an exponential fall-off. Its e-folding scale-length lies
between 1'.3 and an upper limit of 1'.9, obtained from the mean radial profile
between 1'.5 and 4' in radius. This scale length is smaller than that derived
from the radio continuum data at either 20cm or 6cm, with or without the
thermal component removed, at a significance level of >~ 2 sigma. From 1'.5 to
4' in radius, the 60 micron -to-radio continuum surface brightness ratio, Q,
decreases by a factor of 1.5 to 1.7 on average. These quantitative results
agree with that of Marsh & Helou (1995) using IRAS HiRes data, but not with
that of Fitt et al. (1992) based on IRAS CPC data. Our results also fit into
the picture of the radio disk as a ``smeared'' version of the infrared disk,
but are not consistent with the picture in which the variation of Q is a result
of the thermal and non-thermal radio components having two distinct, constant
values of the infrared-to-radio ratio.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9610241 [pdf] - 95765
The Mid-Infrared Color of NGC 6946
Helou, G.;
Malhotra, S.;
Beichman, C. A.;
Dinerstein, H.;
Hollenbach, D. J.;
Hunter, D. A.;
Lo, K. Y.;
Lord, S.;
Lu, N.;
Rubin, R. H.;
Stacey, G.;
Thronson, H.;
Werner, M. W.
Submitted: 1996-10-29
We analyze the new mid-infrared maps of NGC 6946 for variations in the color
ratio of the 7-to-15 micron emission. Our preliminary findings are that this
mid-infrared color is remarkably constant between arms and inter-arm regions,
and as a function of radius in the disk, excluding the nuclear region. As
surface brightness ranges by more than an order of magnitude and the radius
runs from about 0.5 to 3kpc, the color ratio remains constant to about +/-20%.
Our interpretation is that (1) hard UV radiation from OB stars does not
dominate the heating of the grains radiating in the mid-infrared; and (2) that
surface brightness variations are driven primarily by surface-filling fraction
in the disk, and by radiation intensity increases in starburst environments,
such as the nucleus of NGC 6946.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9610240 [pdf] - 95764
ISOCAM Observations of NGC 6946: Mid-IR Structure
Malhotra, S.;
Helou, G.;
van Buren, D.;
Kong, M.;
Beichman, C. A.;
Dinerstein, H.;
Hollenbach, D. J.;
Hunter, D. A.;
Lo, K. Y.;
Lord, S.;
Lu, N.;
Rubin, R. H.;
Stacey, G.;
Thronson, H.;
Werner, M. W.
Submitted: 1996-10-29
The nearby spiral galaxy NGC 6946 was observed with ISO-CAM in the
mid-infrared, achieving 7 arcsec resolution and sub-MJy/steradian sensitivity.
Images taken with CAM filters LW2 (7 microns) and LW3 (15 microns) are analysed
to determine the morphology of this galaxy and understand better the emission
mechanisms. The mid-infrared emission follows an exponential disk with a scale
length 75 arcsec. This is 60% of the scale length in the optical R-band and
radio continuum. The nuclear starburst region is too bright for reliable
measurement in these images. Its surface brightness exceeds the inner disk by
at least a factor of 12. The arms and interarm regions are clearly detected,
with each of these components contributing about equally to the disk emission.
The arm-interarm contrast is 2-4 in the mid-IR, close to that measured in the
visible R band light and lower than the contrast in $H\alpha$, suggesting that
non-ionizing radiation contributes significantly to dust heating.