Normalized to: Threlfall, J.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.07548 [pdf] - 2061675
Particle acceleration with anomalous pitch angle scattering in 3D
separator reconnection
Submitted: 2020-01-21
Understanding how the release of stored magnetic energy contributes to the
generation of non-thermal high energy particles during solar flares is an
important open problem in solar physics. Magnetic reconnection plays a
fundamental role in the energy release and conversion processes taking place
during flares. A common approach for investigating particle acceleration is to
use test particles in fields derived from magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations
of reconnection. These MHD simulations use anomalous resistivities that are
much larger than the Spitzer resistivity based on Coulomb collisions. The
processes leading to enhanced resistivity should also affect the test
particles. We explore the link between resistivity and particle orbits building
on a previous study using a 2D MHD simulation of magnetic reconnection. This
paper extends the previous investigation to a 3D magnetic reconnection
configuration and to study the effect on test particle orbits. We carried out
orbit calculations using a 3D MHD simulation of separator reconnection. We use
the relativistic guiding centre approximation including stochastic pitch angle
scattering. The effects of varying the resistivity and the models for pitch
angle scattering on particle orbit trajectories, final positions, energy
spectra, final pitch angle distribution, and orbit duration are all studied in
detail. Pitch angle scattering widens collimated beams of orbit trajectories,
allowing orbits to access previously unaccessible field lines; this causes
final positions to spread to topological structures that were previously
inaccessible. Scattered orbit energy spectra are found to be predominantly
affected by the level of anomalous resistivity, with the pitch angle scattering
model only playing a role in isolated cases. Scattering is found to play a
crucial role in determining the pitch angle and orbit duration distributions.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1806.06760 [pdf] - 1711571
Flux Rope Formation Due to Shearing and Zipper Reconnection
Submitted: 2018-06-18, last modified: 2018-07-06
Zipper reconnection has been proposed as a mechanism for creating most of the
twist in the flux tubes that are present prior to eruptive flares and coronal
mass ejections. We have conducted a first numerical experiment on this new
regime of reconnection, where two initially untwisted parallel flux tubes are
sheared and reconnected to form a large flux rope. We describe the properties
of this experiment, including the linkage of magnetic flux between concentrated
flux sources at the base of the simulation, the twist of the newly formed flux
rope and the conversion of mutual magnetic helicity in the sheared
pre-reconnection state into the self-helicity of the newly formed flux rope.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.02907 [pdf] - 1652416
Flare particle acceleration in the interaction of twisted coronal flux
ropes
Submitted: 2018-01-09
The aim of this work is to investigate and characterise non-thermal particle
behaviour in a three-dimensional (3D) magnetohydrodynamical (MHD) model of
unstable multi-threaded flaring coronal loops. We have used a numerical scheme
which solves the relativistic guiding centre approximation to study the motion
of electrons and protons. The scheme uses snapshots from high resolution
numerical MHD simulations of coronal loops containing two threads, where a
single thread becomes unstable and (in one case) destabilises and merges with
an additional thread. The particle responses to the reconnection and
fragmentation in MHD simulations of two loop threads are examined in detail. We
illustrate the role played by uniform background resistivity and distinguish
this from the role of anomalous resistivity using orbits in an MHD simulation
where only one thread becomes unstable without destabilising further loop
threads. We examine the (scalable) orbit energy gains and final positions
recovered at different stages of a second MHD simulation wherein a secondary
loop thread is destabilised by (and merges with) the first thread. We compare
these results with other theoretical particle acceleration models in the
context of observed energetic particle populations during solar flares.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.00305 [pdf] - 1587803
Particle acceleration with anomalous pitch angle scattering in 2D MHD
reconnection simulations
Submitted: 2017-07-26
The conversion of magnetic energy into other forms during solar flares is one
of the outstanding open problems in solar physics. It is generally accepted
that magnetic reconnection plays a crucial role in these conversion processes.
To achieve the rapid energy release required in solar flares, an anomalous
resistivity, orders of magnitude higher than the Spitzer resistivity, is often
used in MHD simulations of reconnection. Spitzer resistivity is based on
Coulomb scattering, which becomes negligible at the high energies achieved by
accelerated particles. As a result, simulations of particle acceleration in
reconnection events are often performed in the absence of any interaction
between accelerated particles and any background plasma. This need not be the
case for scattering associated with anomalous resistivity caused by turbulence
within solar flares, as the higher resistivity implies an elevated scattering
rate. We present results of test particle calculations, with and without pitch
angle scattering, subject to fields derived from MHD simulations of
two-dimensional (2D) X-point reconnection. Scattering rates proportional to the
ratio of the anomalous resistivity to the local Spitzer resistivity, as well as
at fixed values, are considered. Pitch angle scattering, which is independent
of the anomalous resistivity, causes higher maximum energies in comparison to
those obtained without scattering. Scattering rates which are dependent on the
local anomalous resistivity tend to produce fewer highly energised particles
due to weaker scattering in the separatrices, even though scattering in the
current sheet may be stronger when compared to resistivity-independent
scattering. Strong scattering also causes an increase in the number of
particles exiting the computational box in the reconnection outflow region, as
opposed to along the separatrices as is the case in the absence of scattering.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.06343 [pdf] - 1445781
Particle Acceleration in Collapsing Magnetic Traps with a Braking Plasma
Jet
Submitted: 2016-05-20, last modified: 2016-07-28
Collapsing magnetic traps (CMTs) are one proposed mechanism for generating
non-thermal particle populations in solar flares. CMTs occur if an initially
stretched magnetic field structure relaxes rapidly into a lower-energy
configuration, which is believed to happen as a by-product of magnetic
reconnection. A similar mechanism for energising particles has also been found
to operate in the Earth's magnetotail. One particular feature proposed to be of
importance for particle acceleration in the magnetotail is that of a braking
plasma jet, i.e. a localised region of strong flow encountering stronger
magnetic field which causes the jet to slow down and stop. Such a feature has
not been included in previously proposed analytical models of CMTs for solar
flares. In this work we incorporate a braking plasma jet into a well studied
CMT model for the first time. We present results of test particle calculations
in this new CMT model. We observe and characterise new types of particle
behaviour caused by the magnetic structure of the jet braking region, which
allows electrons to be trapped both in the braking jet region and the loop
legs. We compare and contrast the behaviour of particle orbits for various
parameter regimes of the underlying trap by examining particle trajectories,
energy gains and the frequency with which different types of particle orbit are
found for each parameter regime.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1510.04211 [pdf] - 1358908
Particle dynamics in a non-flaring solar active region model
Submitted: 2015-10-14, last modified: 2016-01-05
The aim of this work is to investigate and characterise particle behaviour in
an (observationally-driven) 3D MHD model of the solar atmosphere above a slowly
evolving, non-flaring active region. We use a relativistic guiding-centre
particle code to investigate the behaviour of selected particle orbits,
distributed throughout a single snapshot of the 3D MHD simulation. Two distinct
particle acceleration behaviours are recovered, which affect both electrons and
protons: (i) direct acceleration along field lines and (ii) tangential drifting
of guiding centres with respect to local magnetic field. However, up to 40\% of
all particles actually experience a form of (high energy) particle trap,
because of changes in the direction of the electric field and unrelated to the
strength of the magnetic field; such particles are included in the first
category. Additionally, category (i) electron and proton orbits undergo
surprisingly strong acceleration to non-thermal energies ($\lesssim42$MeV),
because of the strength and extent of super-Dreicer electric fields created by
the MHD simulation. Reducing the electric field strength of the MHD model does
not significantly affect the efficiency of the (electric field-based) trapping
mechanism, but does reduce the peak energies gained by orbits. We discuss the
implications for future experiments, which aim to simulate non-flaring active
region heating and reconnection.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1510.04215 [pdf] - 1331047
Particle acceleration at reconnecting separator current layers
Submitted: 2015-10-14, last modified: 2015-11-12
The aim of this work is to investigate and characterise particle behaviour in
a 3D magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) model of a reconnecting magnetic separator. We
use a relativistic guiding-centre test-particle code to investigate electron
and proton acceleration in snapshots from 3D MHD separator reconnection
experiments, and compare the results with findings from an analytical separator
reconnection model studied in a previous investigation. The behaviour and
acceleration of large distributions of particles are examined in detail for
both analytical and numerical separator reconnection models. Accelerated
particle orbit trajectories are shown to follow the separator before leaving
the system along the separatrix surface of one of the nulls (determined by
particle species) in the system of both models. A sufficiently localised
electric field about the separator causes the orbits to appear to follow the
spine bounding the separatrix surface field lines instead. We analyse and
discuss the locations and spread of accelerated particle orbit final positions,
which are seen to change over time in the numerical separator reconnection
model. We deduce a simple relationship between the final energy range of
particle orbits and the model dimensions, and discuss its implications for
observed magnetic separators in the solar corona.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.05701 [pdf] - 1045095
Is Magnetic Topology Important for Heating the Solar Atmosphere?
Submitted: 2015-05-21
Magnetic fields permeate the entire solar atmosphere weaving an extremely
complex pattern on both local and global scales. In order to understand the
nature of this tangled web of magnetic fields, its magnetic skeleton, which
forms the boundaries between topologically distinct flux domains, may be
determined. The magnetic skeleton consists of null points, separatrix surfaces,
spines and separators. The skeleton is often used to clearly visualize key
elements of the magnetic configuration, but parts of the skeleton are also
locations where currents and waves may collect and dissipate.
In this review, the nature of the magnetic skeleton on both global and local
scales, over solar cycle time scales, is explained. The behaviour of wave
pulses in the vicinity of both nulls and separators is discussed and so too is
the formation of current layers and reconnection at the same features. Each of
these processes leads to heating of the solar atmosphere, but collectively do
they provide enough heat, spread over a wide enough area, to explain the energy
losses throughout the solar atmosphere? Here, we consider this question for the
three different solar regions: active regions, open-field regions and the quiet
Sun.
We find that the heating of active regions and open-field regions is highly
unlikely to be due to reconnection or wave dissipation at topological features,
but it is possible that these may play a role in the heating of the quiet Sun.
In active regions, the absence of a complex topology may play an important role
in allowing large energies to build up and then, subsequently, be explosively
released in the form of a solar flare. Additionally, knowledge of the intricate
boundaries of open-field regions (which the magnetic skeleton provides) could
be very important in determining the main acceleration mechanism(s) of the
solar wind.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1411.5094 [pdf] - 904074
Statistical Evidence for the Existence of Alfv\'enic Turbulence in Solar
Coronal Loops
Submitted: 2014-11-18
Recent observations have demonstrated that waves which are capable of
carrying large amounts of energy are ubiquitous throughout the solar corona.
However, the question of how this wave energy is dissipated (on which time and
length scales) and released into the plasma remains largely unanswered. Both
analytic and numerical models have previously shown that Alfv\'enic turbulence
may play a key role not only in the generation of the fast solar wind, but in
the heating of coronal loops. In an effort to bridge the gap between theory and
observations, we expand on a recent study [De Moortel et al., ApJL, 782:L34,
2014] by analyzing thirty-seven clearly isolated coronal loops using data from
the Coronal Multi-channel Polarimeter (CoMP) instrument. We observe Alfv\'enic
perturbations with phase speeds which range from 250-750 km/s and periods from
140-270 s for the chosen loops. While excesses of high frequency wave-power are
observed near the apex of some loops (tentatively supporting the onset of
Alfv\'enic turbulence), we show that this excess depends on loop length and the
wavelength of the observed oscillations. In deriving a proportional
relationship between the loop length/wavelength ratio and the enhanced wave
power at the loop apex, and from the analysis of the line-widths associated
with these loops, our findings are supportive of the existence of Alfv\'enic
turbulence in coronal loops.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.6465 [pdf] - 923446
Particle acceleration at a reconnecting magnetic separator
Submitted: 2014-10-23, last modified: 2014-10-30
While the exact acceleration mechanism of energetic particles during solar
flares is (as yet) unknown, magnetic reconnection plays a key role both in the
release of stored magnetic energy of the solar corona and the magnetic
restructuring during a flare. Recent work has shown that special field lines,
called separators, are common sites of reconnection in 3D numerical
experiments. To date, 3D separator reconnection sites have received little
attention as particle accelerators. We investigate the effectiveness of
separator reconnection as a particle acceleration mechanism for electrons and
protons. We study the particle acceleration using a relativistic guiding-centre
particle code in a time-dependent kinematic model of magnetic reconnection at a
separator. The effect upon particle behaviour of initial position, pitch angle
and initial kinetic energy are examined in detail, both for specific (single)
particle examples and for large distributions of initial conditions. The
separator reconnection model contains several free parameters and we study the
effect of changing these parameters upon particle acceleration, in particular
in view of the final particle energy ranges which agree with observed energy
spectra.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1311.2538 [pdf] - 744628
The Evolving Magnetic Scales of the Outer Solar Atmosphere and Their
Potential Impact on Heliospheric Turbulence
Submitted: 2013-11-11
The presence of turbulent phenomena in the outer solar atmosphere is a given.
However, because we are reduced to remotely sensing the atmosphere of a star
with instruments of limited spatial and/or spectral resolution, we can only
infer the physical progression from macroscopic to microscopic phenomena. Even
so, we know that many, if not all, of the turbulent phenomena that pervade
interplanetary space have physical origins at the Sun and so in this brief
article we consider some recent measurements which point to sustained potential
source(s) of heliospheric turbulence in the magnetic and thermal domains. In
particular, we look at the scales of magnetism that are imprinted on the outer
solar atmosphere by the relentless magneto-convection of the solar interior and
combine state-of-the-art observations from the Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO)
and the Coronal Multi-channel Polarimeter (CoMP) which are beginning to hint at
the origins of the wave/plasma interplay prevalent closer to the Earth. While
linking these disparate scales of observation and understanding of their
connection is near to impossible, it is clear that the constant evolution of
subsurface magnetism on a host of scales guides and governs the flow of mass
and energy at the smallest scales. In the near future significant progress in
this area will be made by linking observations from high resolution platforms
like the Interface Region Imaging Spectrograph (IRIS) and Advanced Technology
Solar Telescope (ATST) with full-disk synoptic observations such as those
presented herein.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.3354 [pdf] - 1172036
First comparison of wave observations from CoMP and AIA/SDO
Submitted: 2013-06-14, last modified: 2013-06-20
Waves have long been thought to contribute to the heating of the solar corona
and the generation of the solar wind. Recent observations have demonstrated
evidence of quasi-periodic longitudinal disturbances and ubiquitous transverse
wave propagation in many different coronal environments. This paper
investigates signatures of different types of oscillatory behaviour, both above
the solar limb and on-disk, by comparing findings from the Coronal
Multi-channel Polarimeter (CoMP) and the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA) on
board the Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) for the same active region. We study
both transverse and longitudinal motion by comparing and contrasting
time-distance images of parallel and perpendicular cuts along/across active
region fan loops. Comparisons between parallel space-time features in CoMP
Doppler velocity and transverse oscillations in AIA images are made, together
with space-time analysis of propagating quasi-periodic intensity features seen
near the base of loops in AIA. Signatures of transverse motions are observed
along the same magnetic structure using CoMP Doppler velocity
(Vphase=600-750km/s, P=3-6mins) and in AIA/SDO above the limb (P=3-8mins).
Quasi-periodic intensity features (Vphase=100-200km/s, P=6-11mins) also travel
along the base of the same structure. On the disk, signatures of both
transverse and longitudinal intensity features were observed by AIA; both show
similar properties to signatures found along structures anchored in the same
active region three days earlier above the limb. Correlated features are
recovered by space-time analysis of neighbouring tracks over perpendicular
distances of <2.6Mm.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1202.3648 [pdf] - 1116700
Nonlinear wave propagation and reconnection at magnetic X-points in the
Hall MHD regime
Submitted: 2012-02-16, last modified: 2012-05-16
The highly dynamical, complex nature of the solar atmosphere naturally
implies the presence of waves in a topologically varied magnetic environment.
Here, the interaction of waves with topological features such as null points is
inevitable and potentially important for energetics. The low resistivity of the
solar coronal plasma implies that non-MHD effects should be considered in
studies of magnetic energy release in this environment. This paper investigates
the role of the Hall term in the propagation and dissipation of waves, their
interaction with 2D magnetic X-points and the nature of the resulting
reconnection. A Lagrangian remap shock-capturing code (Lare2d) is used to study
the evolution of an initial fast magnetoacoustic wave annulus for a range of
values of the ion skin depth in resistive Hall MHD. A magnetic null-point
finding algorithm is also used to locate and track the evolution of the
multiple null-points that are formed in the system. Depending on the ratio of
ion skin depth to system size, our model demonstrates that Hall effects can
play a key role in the wave-null interaction. In particular, the initial
fast-wave pulse now consists of whistler and ion-cyclotron components; the
dispersive nature of the whistler wave leads to (i) earlier interaction with
the null, (ii) the creation of multiple additional, transient nulls and, hence,
an increased number of energy release sites. In the Hall regime, the relevant
timescales (such as the onset of reconnection and the period of the oscillatory
relaxation) of the system are reduced significantly, and the reconnection rate
is enhanced.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1007.4752 [pdf] - 1033944
Alfv\`en wave phase-mixing and damping in the ion cyclotron range of
frequencies
Submitted: 2010-07-27, last modified: 2010-10-08
Aims. To determine the effect of the Hall term in the generalised Ohm's law
on the damping and phase mixing of Alfven waves in the ion cyclotron range of
frequencies in uniform and non-uniform equilibrium plasmas. Methods. Wave
damping in a uniform plasma is treated analytically, whilst a Lagrangian remap
code (Lare2d) is used to study Hall effects on damping and phase mixing in the
presence of an equilibrium density gradient. Results. The magnetic energy
associated with an initially Gaussian field perturbation in a uniform resistive
plasma is shown to decay algebraically at a rate that is unaffected by the Hall
term to leading order in k^2di^2 where k is wavenumber and di is ion skin
depth. A similar algebraic decay law applies to whistler perturbations in the
limit k^2di^2>>1. In a non-uniform plasma it is found that the
spatially-integrated damping rate due to phase mixing is lower in Hall MHD than
it is in MHD, but the reduction in the damping rate, which can be attributed to
the effects of wave dispersion, tends to zero in both the weak and strong phase
mixing limits.