Normalized to: Thakur, N.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.10506 [pdf] - 2038527
On the properties of solar energetic particle events associated with
metric type II radio bursts
Submitted: 2020-01-28
Metric type II solar radio bursts and solar energetic particles (SEPs) are
both associated with shock fronts driven by coronal mass ejections (CMEs) in
the solar corona. Recent studies of ground level enhancements (GLEs), regular
large solar energetic particle (SEP) events and filament eruption (FE)
associated large SEP events have shown that SEP events are organized by
spectral index of proton fluence spectra and by the average starting
frequencies of the associated type II radio bursts. Both these results indicate
a hierarchical relationship between CME kinematics and SEP event properties. In
this study, we expand the investigations to fluence spectra and the
longitudinal extent of metric type II associated SEP events including
low-intensity SEP events. We utilize SEP measurements of particle instruments
on the Solar and Heliospheric Observatory (SOHO) and Solar Terrestrial
Relations Observatory (STEREO) spacecraft together with radio bursts
observations by ground-based radio observatories during solar cycle 24. Our
results show that low-intensity SEP events follow the hierarchy of spectral
index or the hierarchy of the starting frequency of type II radio bursts. We
also find indications of a trend between the onset frequency of metric type II
bursts and the estimated longitudinal extent of the SEP events although the
scatter of data points is quite large. These two results strongly support the
idea of SEP acceleration by shocks. Stronger shocks develop closer to the Sun.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.03816 [pdf] - 2050361
Source of Energetic Protons in the 2014 September 1 Sustained Gamma-ray
Emission Event
Submitted: 2020-01-11
We report on the source of greater than 300 MeV protons during the
SOL2014-09-01 sustained gamma-ray emission (SGRE) event based on
multi-wavelength data from a wide array of space- and ground-based instruments.
Based on the eruption geometry we provide concrete explanation for the
spatially and temporally extended {\gamma}-ray emission from the eruption. We
show that the associated flux rope is of low inclination (roughly oriented in
the east-west direction), which enables the associated shock to extend to the
frontside. We compare the centroid of the SGRE source with the location of the
flux rope leg to infer that the high-energy protons must be precipitating
between the flux rope leg and the shock front. The durations of the
SOL2014-09-01 SGRE event and the type II radio burst agree with the linear
relationship between these parameters obtained for other SGRE events with
duration exceeding 3 hrs. The fluence spectrum of the SEP event is very hard,
indicating the presence of high-energy (GeV) particles in this event. This is
further confirmed by the presence of an energetic coronal mass ejection (CME)
with a speed more than 2000 km/s, similar to those in ground level enhancement
(GLE) events. The type II radio burst had emission components from metric to
kilometric wavelengths as in events associated with GLE events. All these
factors indicate that the high-energy particles from the shock were in
sufficient numbers needed for the production of {\gamma}-rays via neutral pion
decay.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.10979 [pdf] - 1740087
Sun-to-Earth Propagation of the 2015 June 21 Coronal Mass Ejection
Revealed by Optical, EUV, and Radio Observations
Submitted: 2018-07-28, last modified: 2018-08-11
We investigate the propagation of the 2015 June 21 CME-driven shock as
revealed by the type II bursts at metric and longer wavelengths and coronagraph
observations. The CME was associated with the second largest geomagnetic storm
of solar cycle 24 and a large solar energetic particle (SEP) event. The
eruption consisted of two M-class flares, with the first one being confined,
with no metric or interplanetary radio bursts. However, there was intense
microwave burst, indicating accelerated particles injected toward the Sun. The
second flare was eruptive that resulted in a halo CME. The CME was deflected
primarily by an equatorial coronal hole that resulted in the modification of
the intensity profile of the associated SEP event and the duration of the CME
at Earth. The interplanetary type II burst was particularly intense and was
visible from the corona all the way to the vicinity of the Wind spacecraft with
fundamental-harmonic structure. We computed the shock speed using the type II
drift rates at various heliocentric distances and obtained information on the
evolution of the shock that matched coronagraph observations near the Sun and
in-situ observations near Earth. The depth of the geomagnetic storm is
consistent with the 1-AU speed of the CME and the magnitude of the southward
component.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.00209 [pdf] - 1585391
A Hierarchical Relationship between the Fluence Spectra and CME
Kinematics in Large Solar Energetic Particle Events: A Radio Perspective
Submitted: 2017-07-01
We report on further evidence that solar energetic particles are organized by
the kinematic properties of coronal mass ejections (CMEs)[1]. In particular, we
focus on the starting frequency of type II bursts, which is related to the
distance from the Sun where the radio emission starts. We find that the three
groups of solar energetic particle (SEP) events known to have distinct values
of CME initial acceleration, also have distinct average starting frequencies of
the associated type II bursts. SEP events with ground level enhancement (GLE)
have the highest starting frequency (107 MHz), while those associated with
filament eruption (FE) in quiescent regions have the lowest starting frequency
(22 MHz); regular SEP events have intermediate starting frequency (81 MHz).
Taking the onset time of type II bursts as the time of shock formation, we
determine the shock formation heights measured from the Sun center. We find
that the shocks form on average closest to the Sun (1.51 Rs) in GLE events,
farthest from the Sun in FE SEP events (5.38 Rs), and at intermediate distances
in regular SEP events (1.72 Rs). Finally, we present the results of a case
study of a CME with high initial acceleration (~3 km s^-2) and a type II radio
burst with high starting frequency (~200 MHz) but associated with a minor SEP
event. We find that the relation between the fluence spectral index and CME
initial acceleration continues to hold even for this minor SEP event.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.05790 [pdf] - 1532139
The 2012 July 23 Backside Eruption: An Extreme Energetic Particle Event?
Submitted: 2016-10-18, last modified: 2016-12-04
The backside coronal mass ejection (CME) of 2012 July 23 had a short Sun to
Earth shock transit time (18.5 hours). The associated solar energetic particle
(SEP) event had a >10 MeV proton flux peaking at ~5000 pfu, and the energetic
storm particle (ESP) event was an order of magnitude larger, making it the most
intense event in the space era at these energies. By a detailed analysis of the
CME, shock, and SEP characteristics, we find that the July 23 event is
consistent with a high-energy SEP event (accelerating particles to GeV
energies). The time of maximum and fluence spectra in the range 10-100 MeV were
very hard, similar to those of ground level enhancement (GLE) events. We found
a hierarchical relationship between the CME initial speeds and the fluence
spectral indices: CMEs with low initial speeds had SEP events with the softest
spectra, while those with highest initial speeds had SEP events with the
hardest spectra. CMEs attaining intermediate speeds result in moderately hard
spectra. The July 23 event was in the group of hard-spectrum events. During the
July 23 event, the shock speed (>2000 km s^-1), the initial acceleration (~1.70
km s^-2), and the shock formation height (~1.5 solar radii) were all typical of
GLE events. The associated type II burst had emission components from metric to
kilometric wavelengths suggesting a strong shock. These observation confirm
that the 2012 July 23 event is likely to be an extreme event in terms of the
energetic particles it accelerated.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.01267 [pdf] - 1470531
Measurements of cosmic-ray proton and helium spectra from the BESS-Polar
long-duration balloon flights over Antarctica
Abe, K.;
Fuke, H.;
Haino, S.;
Hams, T.;
Hasegawa, M.;
Horikoshi, A.;
Itazaki, A.;
Kim, K. C.;
Kumazawa, T.;
Kusumoto, A.;
Lee, M. H.;
Makida, Y.;
Matsuda, S.;
Matsukawa, Y.;
Matsumoto, K.;
Mitchell, J. W.;
Myers, Z.;
Nishimura, J.;
Nozaki, M.;
Orito, R.;
Ormes, J. F.;
Picot-Clemente, N.;
Sakai, K.;
Sasaki, M.;
Seo, E. S.;
Shikaze, Y.;
Shinoda, R.;
Streitmatter, R. E.;
Suzuki, J.;
Takasugi, Y.;
Takeuchi, K.;
Tanaka, K.;
Thakur, N.;
Yamagami, T.;
Yamamoto, A.;
Yoshida, T.;
Yoshimura, K.
Submitted: 2015-06-03, last modified: 2016-08-30
The BESS-Polar Collaboration measured the energy spectra of cosmic-ray
protons and helium during two long-duration balloon flights over Antarctica in
December 2004 and December 2007, at substantially different levels of solar
modulation. Proton and helium spectra probe the origin and propagation history
of cosmic rays in the galaxy, and are essential to calculations of the expected
spectra of cosmic-ray antiprotons, positrons, and electrons from interactions
of primary cosmic-ray nuclei with the interstellar gas, and to calculations of
atmospheric muons and neutrinos. We report absolute spectra at the top of the
atmosphere for cosmic-ray protons in the kinetic energy range 0.2-160 GeV and
helium nuclei 0.15-80 GeV/nucleon. The corresponding magnetic rigidity ranges
are 0.6-160 GV for protons and 1.1-160 GV for helium. These spectra are
compared to measurements from previous BESS flights and from ATIC-2, PAMELA,
and AMS-02. We also report the ratio of the proton and helium fluxes from 1.1
GV to 160 GV and compare to ratios from PAMELA and AMS-02.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.09644 [pdf] - 1415295
A Study of the 2012 January 19 Complex Type II Radio Burst Using Wind,
SOHO, and STEREO Observations
Submitted: 2016-05-31
We report on a case study of the complex type II radio burst of 2012 January
19 and its association with a white light coronal mass ejection (CME). The
complexity can be described as the appearance of an additional type II burst
component and strong intensity variation. The dynamic spectrum shows a pair of
type II bursts with fundamental harmonic structures, one confined to
decameter-hectometric (DH) wavelengths and the other extending to kilometric
(km) wavelengths. By comparing the speeds obtained from white-light images with
that speed of the shock inferred from the drift rate, we show that the source
of the short-lived DH component is near the nose.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1509.04216 [pdf] - 1280080
CMEs during the Two Activity Peaks in Cycle 24 and their Space Weather
Consequences
Submitted: 2015-09-14, last modified: 2015-09-21
We report on a comparison between space weather events that occurred around
the two peaks in the sunspot number (SSN) during solar cycle 24. The two SSN
peaks occurred in the years 2012 and 2014. Even though SSN was larger during
the second peak, we find that there were more space weather events during the
first peak. The space weather events we considered are large solar energetic
particle (SEP) events and major geomagnetic storms associated with coronal mass
ejections (CMEs). We also considered interplanetary type II radio bursts, which
are indicative of energetic CMEs driving shocks. When we compared the CME
properties between the two SSN peaks, we find that more energetic CMEs occurred
during the 2012 peak. In particular, we find that CMEs accompanying IP type II
bursts had an average speed of 1543 km/s during the 2012 peak compared to 1201
km/s during the 2014 peak. This result is consistent with the reduction in the
average speed of the general population of CMEs during the second peak. All SEP
events were associated with the interplanetary type II bursts, which are better
than halo CMEs as indicators of space weather. The comparison between the two
peaks also revealed that the discordant behavior between the CME rate and SSN
was more pronounced during the second peak. None of the 14 disk-center halo
CMEs was associated with a major storm in 2014. The lone major storm in 2014
was due to the intensification of the (southward) magnetic field in the
associated magnetic cloud by a shock that caught up and propagated into the
magnetic cloud.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.06162 [pdf] - 1300240
High-energy solar particle events in cycle 24
Submitted: 2015-07-22
The Sun is already in the declining phase of cycle 24, but the paucity of
high-energy solar energetic particle (SEP) events continues with only two
ground level enhancement (GLE) events as of March 31, 2015. In an attempt to
understand this, we considered all the large SEP events of cycle 24 that
occurred until the end of 2014. We compared the properties of the associated
CMEs with those in cycle 23. We found that the CME speeds in the sky plane were
similar, but almost all those cycle-24 CMEs were halos. A significant fraction
of (16%) of the frontside SEP events were associated with eruptive prominence
events. CMEs associated with filament eruption events accelerate slowly and
attain peak speeds beyond the typical GLE release heights. When we considered
only western hemispheric events that had good connectivity to the CME nose,
there were only 8 events that could be considered as GLE candidates. One turned
out to be the first GLE event of cycle 24 (2012 May 17). In two events, the
CMEs were very fast (>2000 km/s) but they were launched into a tenuous medium
(high Alfven speed). In the remaining five events, the speeds were well below
the typical GLE CME speed (~2000 km/s). Furthermore, the CMEs attained their
peak speeds beyond the typical heights where GLE particles are released. We
conclude that several factors contribute to the low rate of high-energy SEP
events in cycle 24: (i) reduced efficiency of shock acceleration (weak
heliospheric magnetic field), (ii) poor latitudinal and longitudinal
connectivity), and (iii) variation in local ambient conditions (e.g., high
Alfven speed).
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1504.00709 [pdf] - 1154883
Large Solar Energetic Particle Events Associated with Filament Eruptions
Outside of Active Regions
Submitted: 2015-04-02
We report on four large filament eruptions (FEs) from solar cycles 23 and 24
that were associated with large solar energetic particle (SEP) events and
interplanetary type II radio bursts. The post-eruption arcades corresponded to
mostly C-class soft X-ray enhancements, but an M1.0 flare was associated with
one event. However, the associated coronal mass ejections (CMEs) were fast
(speeds about 1000 km/s) and appeared as halo CMEs in the coronagraph field of
view. The interplanetary type II radio bursts occurred over a wide wavelength
range indicating the existence of strong shocks throughout the inner
heliosphere. No metric type II bursts were present in three events, indicating
that the shocks formed beyond 2 to 3 Rs. In one case, there was a metric type
II burst with low starting frequency indicating a shock formation height of
about 2 Rs. The FE-associated SEP events did have softer spectra (spectral
index greater than 4) in the 10 to 100 MeV range, but there were other
low-intensity SEP events with spectral indices >/=4. Some of these events are
likely FE-SEP events, but were not classified so in the literature because they
occurred close to active regions. Some were definitely associated with large
active region flares, but the shock formation height was large. We definitely
find a diminished role for flares and complex type III burst durations in these
large SEP events. Fast CMEs and shock formation at larger distances from the
Sun seem to be the primary characteristics of the FE-associated SEP events.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1502.00935 [pdf] - 1224302
PAMELA's Measurements of Magnetospheric Effects on High Energy Solar
Particles
Adriani, O.;
Barbarino, G. C.;
Bazilevskaya, G. A.;
Bellotti, R.;
Boezio, M.;
Bogomolov, E. A.;
Bongi, M.;
Bonvicini, V.;
Bottai, S.;
Bravar, U.;
Bruno, A.;
Cafagna, F.;
Campana, D.;
Carbone, R.;
Carlson, P.;
Casolino, M.;
Castellini, G.;
Christian, E. C.;
De Donato, C.;
de Nolfo, G. A.;
De Santis, C.;
De Simone, N.;
Di Felice, V.;
Formato, V.;
Galper, A. M.;
Karelin, A. V.;
Koldashov, S. V.;
Koldobskiy, S.;
Krutkov, S. Y.;
Kvashnin, A. N.;
Lee, M.;
Leonov, A.;
Malakhov, V.;
Marcelli, L.;
Martucci, M.;
Mayorov, A. G.;
Menn, W.;
Mergé, M.;
Mikhailov, V. V.;
Mocchiutti, E.;
Monaco, A.;
Mori, N.;
Munini, R.;
Osteria, G.;
Palma, F.;
Panico, B.;
Papini, P.;
Pearce, M.;
Picozza, P.;
Ricci, M.;
Ricciarini, S. B.;
Ryan, J. M.;
Sarkar, R.;
Scotti, V.;
Simon, M.;
Sparvoli, R.;
Spillantini, P.;
Stochaj, S.;
Stozhkov, Y. I.;
Thakur, N.;
Vacchi, A.;
Vannuccini, E.;
Vasilyev, G. I.;
Voronov, S. A.;
Yurkin, Y. T.;
Zampa, G.;
Zampa, N.
Submitted: 2015-02-03
The nature of particle acceleration at the Sun, whether through flare
reconnection processes or through shocks driven by coronal mass ejections
(CMEs), is still under scrutiny despite decades of research. The measured
properties of solar energetic particles (SEPs) have long been modeled in
different particle-acceleration scenarios. The challenge has been to
disentangle to the effects of transport from those of acceleration. The Payload
for Antimatter Matter Exploration and Light-nuclei Astrophysics (PAMELA)
instrument, enables unique observations of SEPs including composition and the
angular distribution of the particles about the magnetic field, i.e. pitch
angle distribution, over a broad energy range (>80 MeV) -- bridging a critical
gap between space-based measurements and ground-based. We present high-energy
SEP data from PAMELA acquired during the 2012 May 17 SEP event. These data
exhibit differential anisotropies and thus transport features over the
instrument rigidity range. SEP protons exhibit two distinct pitch angle
distributions; a low-energy population that extends to 90{\deg} and a
population that is beamed at high energies (>1 GeV), consistent with neutron
monitor measurements. To explain a low-energy SEP population that exhibits
significant scattering or redistribution accompanied by a high-energy
population that reaches the Earth relatively unaffected by dispersive transport
effects, we postulate that the scattering or redistribution takes place
locally. We believe these are the first comprehensive measurements of the
effects of solar energetic particle transport in the Earth's magnetosheath.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1406.7172 [pdf] - 1215265
Ground Level Enhancement in the 2014 January 6 Solar Energetic Particle
Event
Submitted: 2014-06-27, last modified: 2014-06-30
We present a study of the 2014 January 6 solar energetic particle (SEP)
event, which produced a small ground level enhancement (GLE), making it the
second GLE of this unusual solar cycle 24. This event was primarily observed by
the South Pole neutron monitors (increase of ~2.5%) whereas a few other neutron
monitors recorded smaller increases. The associated coronal mass ejection (CME)
originated behind the western limb and had the speed of 1960 km/s. The height
of the CME at the start of the associated metric type II radio burst, which
indicates the formation of a strong shock, was measured to be 1.61 Rs using a
direct image from STEREO-A/EUVI. The CME height at the time of GLE particle
release (determined using the South Pole neutron monitor data) was directly
measured as 2.96 Rs, from the STEREO-A/COR1 white-light observations. These CME
heights are consistent with those obtained for the GLE71, the only other GLE of
the current cycle as well as cycle-23 GLEs derived using back-extrapolation.
GLE72 is of special interest because it is one of the only two GLEs of cycle
24, one of the two behind-the-limb GLEs and one of the two smallest GLEs of
cycles 23 and 24.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1201.2967 [pdf] - 1092966
Search for Antihelium with the BESS-Polar Spectrometer
Abe, K.;
Fuke, H.;
Haino, S.;
Hams, T.;
Hasegawa, M.;
Horikoshi, A.;
Itazaki, A.;
Kim, K. C.;
Kumazawa, T.;
Kusumoto, A.;
Lee, M. H.;
Makida, Y.;
Matsuda, S.;
Matsukawa, Y.;
Matsumoto, K.;
Mitchell, J. W.;
Myers, Z.;
Nishimura, J.;
Nozaki, M.;
Orito, R.;
Ormes, J. F.;
Sakai, K.;
Sasaki, M.;
Seo, E. S.;
Shikaze, Y.;
Shinoda, R.;
Streitmatter, R. E.;
Suzuki, J.;
Takasugi, Y.;
Takeuchi, K.;
Tanaka, K.;
Thakur, N.;
Yamagami, T.;
Yamamoto, A.;
Yoshida, T.;
Yoshimura, K.
Submitted: 2012-01-13
In two long-duration balloon flights over Antarctica, the BESS-Polar
collaboration has searched for antihelium in the cosmic radiation with higher
sensitivity than any reported investigation. BESS- Polar I flew in 2004,
observing for 8.5 days. BESS-Polar II flew in 2007-2008, observing for 24.5
days. No antihelium candidate was found in BESS-Polar I data among 8.4\times
10^6 |Z| = 2 nuclei from 1.0 to 20 GV or in BESS-Polar II data among 4.0\times
10^7 |Z| = 2 nuclei from 1.0 to 14 GV. Assuming antihelium to have the same
spectral shape as helium, a 95% confidence upper limit of 6.9 \times 10^-8 was
determined by combining all the BESS data, including the two BESS-Polar
flights. With no assumed antihelium spectrum and a weighted average of the
lowest antihelium efficiencies from 1.6 to 14 GV, an upper limit of 1.0 \times
10^-7 was determined for the combined BESS-Polar data. These are the most
stringent limits obtained to date.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1107.6000 [pdf] - 1083080
Measurement of the cosmic-ray antiproton spectrum at solar minimum with
a long-duration balloon flight over Antarctica
Abe, K.;
Fuke, H.;
Haino, S.;
Hams, T.;
Hasegawa, M.;
Horikoshi, A.;
Kim, K. C.;
Kusumoto, A.;
Lee, M. H.;
Makida, Y.;
Matsuda, S.;
Matsukawa, Y.;
Mitchell, J. W.;
Nishimura, J.;
Nozaki, M.;
Orito, R.;
Ormes, J. F.;
Sakai, K.;
Sasaki, M.;
Seo, E. S.;
Shinoda, R.;
Streitmatter, R. E.;
Suzuki, J.;
Tanaka, K.;
Thakur, N.;
Yamagami, T.;
Yamamoto, A.;
Yoshida, T.;
Yoshimura, K.
Submitted: 2011-07-29, last modified: 2011-12-10
The energy spectrum of cosmic-ray antiprotons from 0.17 to 3.5 GeV has been
measured using 7886 antiprotons detected by BESS-Polar II during a
long-duration flight over Antarctica near solar minimum in December 2007 and
January 2008. This shows good consistency with secondary antiproton
calculations. Cosmologically primary antiprotons have been investigated by
comparing measured and calculated antiproton spectra. BESS-Polar II data show
no evidence of primary antiprotons from evaporation of primordial black holes.