The space-based detector LISA may observe gravitational waves from the early inspiral of stellar-mass black hole binaries, some of which could have significant eccentricity. Current gravitational waveform templates are only valid for small orbital velocities (i.e., in a post-Newtonian expansion) and small initial eccentricity $e_0$ ("post-circular" expansion). We conventionally define $e_0$ as the eccentricity corresponding to an orbital frequency of $5 \text{ mHz}$, and we study the convergence properties of frequency-domain inspiral templates that are accurate up to 2PN and order $e_0^6$ in eccentricity. We compute the so-called "unfaithfulness" between the full template and "reduced" templates obtained by dropping some terms in the phasing series; we investigate the conditions under which systematic errors are negligible with respect to statistical errors, and we study the convergence properties of statistical errors. In general, eccentric waveforms lead to larger statistical errors than circular waveforms due to correlations between the parameters, but the error estimates do not change significantly as long as we include terms of order $e_0^2$ or higher in the phasing.