Normalized to: Svoboda, B.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.04484 [pdf] - 2109357
Hot Corinos Chemical Diversity: Myth or Reality?
De Simone, Marta;
Ceccarelli, Cecilia;
Codella, Claudio;
Svoboda, Brian E.;
Chandler, Claire;
Bouvier, Mathilde;
Yamamoto, Satoshi;
Sakai, Nami;
Caselli, Paola;
Favre, Cecile;
Loinard, Laurent;
Lefloch, Bertrand;
Liu, Hauyu Baobab;
López-Sepulcre, Ana;
Pineda, Jaime E.;
Taquet, Vianney;
Testi, Leonardo
Submitted: 2020-06-08
After almost 20 years of hunting, only about a dozen hot corinos, hot regions
enriched in interstellar complex organic molecules (iCOMs), are known. Of them,
many are binary systems with the two components showing drastically different
molecular spectra. Two obvious questions arise. Why are hot corinos so
difficult to find and why do their binary components seem chemically different?
The answer to both questions could be a high dust opacity that would hide the
molecular lines. To test this hypothesis, we observed methanol lines at
centimeter wavelengths, where dust opacity is negligible, using the Very Large
Array interferometer. We targeted the NGC 1333 IRAS 4A binary system, for which
one of the two components, 4A1, has a spectrum deprived of iCOMs lines when
observed at millimeter wavelengths, while the other component, 4A2, is very
rich in iCOMs. We found that centimeter methanol lines are similarly bright
toward 4A1 and 4A2. Their non-LTE analysis indicates gas density and
temperature ($\geq2\times10^6$ cm$^{-3}$ and 100--190 K), methanol column
density ($\sim10^{19}$ cm$^{-2}$) and extent ($\sim$35 au in radius) similar in
4A1 and 4A2, proving that both are hot corinos. Furthermore, the comparison
with previous methanol line millimeter observations allows us to estimate the
optical depth of the dust in front of 4A1 and 4A2, respectively. The obtained
values explain the absence of iCOMs line emission toward 4A1 at millimeter
wavelengths and indicate that the abundances toward 4A2 are underestimated by
$\sim$30\%. Therefore, centimeter observations are crucial for the correct
study of hot corinos, their census, and their molecular abundances.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.09555 [pdf] - 2105703
The MUSTANG-2 Galactic Plane Survey (MGPS90) pilot
Ginsburg, Adam;
Anderson, L. D.;
Dicker, Simon;
Romero, Charles;
Svoboda, Brian;
Devlin, Mark;
Galván-Madrid, Roberto;
Indebetouw, Remy;
Liu, Hauyu Baobab;
Mason, Brian;
Mroczkowski, Tony;
Armentrout, W. P.;
Bally, John;
Brogan, Crystal;
Butterfield, Natalie;
Hunter, Todd R.;
Reese, Erik D.;
Rosolowsky, Erik;
Sarazin, Craig;
Shirley, Yancy;
Sievers, Jonathan;
Stanchfield, Sara
Submitted: 2020-04-20, last modified: 2020-04-22
We report the results of a pilot program for a Green Bank Telescope (GBT)
MUSTANG Galactic Plane survey at 3 mm (90 GHz), MGPS90. The survey achieves a
typical $1\sigma$ depth of $1-2$ mJy beam$^{-1}$ with a 9" beam. We describe
the survey parameters, quality assessment process, cataloging, and comparison
with other data sets. We have identified 709 sources over seven observed fields
selecting some of the most prominent millimeter-bright regions between $0\deg <
\ell < 50\deg$ (total area $\approx 7.5 \deg^2$). The majority of these sources
have counterparts at other wavelengths. By applying flux selection criteria to
these sources, we successfully recovered several known hypercompact HII (HCHII)
regions, but did not confirm any new ones. We identify 126 sources that have
mm-wavelength counterparts but do not have cm-wavelength counterparts and are
therefore candidate HCHII regions; of these, 10 are morphologically compact and
are strong candidates for new HCHII regions. Given the limited number of
candidates in the extended area in this survey compared to the relatively large
numbers seen in protoclusters W51 and W49, it appears that most HCHII regions
exist within dense protoclusters. Comparing the counts of HCHII to ultracompact
HII (UCHII) regions, we infer the HCHII region lifetime is 16-46% that of the
UCHII region lifetime. We additionally separated the 3 mm emission into dust
and free-free emission by comparing with archival 870 $\mu$m and 20 cm data. In
the selected pilot fields, most ($\gtrsim80$%) of the 3 mm emission comes from
plasma, either through free-free or synchrotron emission.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.10374 [pdf] - 2005469
ALMA observations of fragmentation, sub-structure, and protostars in
high-mass starless clump candidates
Svoboda, Brian E.;
Shirley, Yancy L.;
Traficante, Alessio;
Battersby, Cara;
Fuller, Gary A.;
Zhang, Qizhou;
Beuther, Henrik;
Peretto, Nicolas;
Brogan, Crystal;
Hunter, Todd
Submitted: 2019-08-27
(Abridged) The initial physical conditions of high-mass stars and
protoclusters remain poorly characterized. To this end we present the first
targeted ALMA 1.3mm continuum and spectral line survey towards high-mass
starless clump candidates, selecting a sample of 12 of the most massive
candidates ($400-4000\, M_\odot$) within 5 kpc. The joint 12+7m array maps have
a high spatial resolution of $\sim 3000\, \mathrm{au}$ ($\sim
0.8^{\prime\prime}$) and have point source mass-completeness down to $\sim
0.3\, M_\odot$ at $6\sigma$ (or $1\sigma$ column density sensitivity of
$1.1\times10^{22}\, \mathrm{cm^{-2}}$). We discover previously undetected
signposts of low-luminosity star formation from CO (2-1) and SiO (5-4) bipolar
outflows and other signatures towards 11 out of 12 clumps, showing that current
MIR/FIR Galactic Plane surveys are incomplete to low- and intermediate-mass
protostars ($\lesssim 50\, L_\odot$). We compare a subset of the observed cores
with a suite of radiative transfer models of starless cores. We find a
high-mass starless core candidate with a model-derived mass consistent with
$29^{52}_{15}\, M_\odot$ when integrated over size scales of $2\times10^4\,
\mathrm{au}$. Unresolved cores are poorly fit by starless core models,
supporting the interpretation that they are protostellar even without detection
of outflows. Substantial fragmentation is observed towards 10 out of 12 clumps.
We extract sources from the maps using a dendrogram to study the characteristic
fragmentation length scale. Nearest neighbor separations when corrected for
projection are consistent with being equal to the clump average thermal Jeans
length. Our findings support a hierarchical fragmentation process, where the
highest density regions are not strongly supported against thermal
gravitational fragmentation by turbulence or magnetic fields.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.06134 [pdf] - 1811264
Thermal balance and comparison of gas and dust properties of dense
clumps in the Hi-GAL survey
Merello, Manuel;
Molinari, Sergio;
Rygl, Kazi L. J.;
Evans, Neal J.;
Elia, Davide;
Schisano, Eugenio;
Traficante, Alessio;
Shirley, Yancy;
Svoboda, Brian;
Goldsmith, Paul F.
Submitted: 2018-12-14
We present a comparative study of physical properties derived from gas and
dust emission in a sample of 1068 dense Galactic clumps. The sources are
selected from the crossmatch of the Hi-GAL survey with 16 catalogues of NH$_3$
line emission in its lowest inversion (1,1) and (2,2) transitions. The sample
covers a large range in masses and bolometric luminosities, with surface
densities above $\Sigma=0.1$ g cm$^{-2}$ and with low virial parameters
$\alpha<1$. The comparison between dust and gas properties shows an overall
agreement between $T_{\textit{kin}}$ and $T_{\textit{dust}}$ at volumetric
densities $n\gtrsim1.2\times10^{4}$ cm$^{-3}$, and a median fractional
abundance $\chi$(NH$_3$)$=1.46\times10^{-8}$. While the protostellar clumps in
the sample have small differences between $T_{\textit{kin}}$ and
$T_{\textit{dust}}$, prestellar clumps have a median ratio
$T_{\textit{kin}}/T_{\textit{dust}}=1.24$, suggesting that these sources are
thermally decoupled. A correlation is found between the evolutionary tracer
$L/M$ and the parameters $T_{\textit{kin}}/T_{\textit{dust}}$ and
$\chi$(NH$_3$) in prestellar sources and protostellar clumps with $L/M<1$
L$_\odot$ M$_\odot^{-1}$. In addition, a weak correlation is found between
non-thermal velocity dispersion and the $L/M$ parameter, possibly indicating an
increase of turbulence with protostellar evolution in the interior of clumps.
Finally, different processes are discussed to explain the differences between
gas and dust temperatures in prestellar candidates, and the origin of
non-thermal motions observed in the clumps.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.00036 [pdf] - 1728969
Searching for Inflow Towards Massive Starless Clump Candidates
Identified in the Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey
Calahan, Jenny;
Shirley, Yancy;
Svoboda, Brian;
Ivanov, Elizabeth;
Schmid, Jonathan;
Pulley, Anna;
Lautenbach, Jennifier;
Zawadzki, Nicole;
Bullivant, Christopher;
Cook, Claire;
Gray, Laurin;
Henrici, Andrew;
Pascale, Massimo;
Bosse, Carter;
Chance, Quadry;
Choi, Sarah;
Dunn, Marina;
Jame-Frias, Ramon;
Kearsley, Ian;
Kelledy, Joseph;
Lewin, Collin;
Mahmood, Qasim;
McKinley, Scott;
Mitchell, Adriana;
Robinson, Daniel
Submitted: 2018-04-30
Recent Galactic plane surveys of dust continuum emission at long wavelengths
have identified a population of dense, massive clumps with no evidence for
on-going star formation. These massive starless clump candidates are excellent
sites to search for the initial phases of massive star formation before the
feedback from massive star formation effects the clump. In this study, we
search for the spectroscopic signature of inflowing gas toward starless clumps,
some of which are massive enough to form a massive star. We observed 101
starless clump candidates identified in the Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey
(BGPS) in HCO+ J = 1-0 using the 12m Arizona Radio Observatory telescope. We
find a small blue excess of E = (Nblue - Nred)/Ntotal = 0.03 for the complete
survey. We identified 6 clumps that are good candidates for inflow motion and
used a radiative transfer model to calculate mass inflow rates that range from
500 - 2000 M /Myr. If the observed line profiles are indeed due to large-scale
inflow motions, then these clumps will typically double their mass on a free
fall time. Our survey finds that massive BGPS starless clump candidates with
inflow signatures in HCO+ J = 1-0 are rare throughout our Galaxy.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1702.02199 [pdf] - 1535546
The Lifetimes of Phases in High-Mass Star-Forming Regions
Submitted: 2017-02-07
High-mass stars form within star clusters from dense, molecular regions, but
is the process of cluster formation slow and hydrostatic or quick and dynamic?
We link the physical properties of high-mass star-forming regions with their
evolutionary stage in a systematic way, using Herschel and Spitzer data. In
order to produce a robust estimate of the relative lifetimes of these regions,
we compare the fraction of dense, molecular regions above a column density
associated with high-mass star formation, N(H2) > 0.4-2.5 x 10^22 cm^-2, in the
'starless (no signature of stars > 10 Msun forming) and star-forming phases in
a 2x2 degree region of the Galactic Plane centered at l=30deg. Of regions
capable of forming high-mass stars on ~1 pc scales, the starless (or embedded
beyond detection) phase occupies about 60-70% of the dense, molecular region
lifetime and the star-forming phase occupies about 30-40%. These relative
lifetimes are robust over a wide range of thresholds. We outline a method by
which relative lifetimes can be anchored to absolute lifetimes from large-scale
surveys of methanol masers and UCHII regions. A simplistic application of this
method estimates the absolute lifetimes of the starless phase to be 0.2-1.7 Myr
(about 0.6-4.1 fiducial cloud free-fall times) and the star-forming phase to be
0.1-0.7 Myr (about 0.4-2.4 free-fall times), but these are highly uncertain.
This work uniquely investigates the star-forming nature of high-column density
gas pixel-by-pixel and our results demonstrate that the majority of high-column
density gas is in a starless or embedded phase.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.08810 [pdf] - 1411222
The Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey. XIV. Physical Properties of Massive
Starless and Star Forming Clumps
Svoboda, Brian E;
Shirley, Yancy L;
Battersby, Cara;
Rosolowsky, Erik W;
Ginsburg, Adam G;
Ellsworth-Bowers, Timothy P;
Pestalozzi, Michele R;
Dunham, Miranda K;
Evans, Neal J;
Bally, John;
Glenn, Jason
Submitted: 2015-11-27
We sort $4683$ molecular clouds between $10^\circ< \ell <65^\circ$ from the
Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey based on observational diagnostics of star
formation activity: compact $70$ $\mu{\rm m}$ sources, mid-IR color-selected
YSOs, ${\rm H_2O}$ and ${\rm CH_3OH}$ masers, and UCHII regions. We also
present a combined ${\rm NH_3}$-derived gas kinetic temperature and ${\rm
H_2O}$ maser catalog for $1788$ clumps from our own GBT 100m observations and
from the literature. We identify a subsample of $2223$ ($47.5\%$) starless
clump candidates, the largest and most robust sample identified from a blind
survey to date. Distributions of flux density, flux concentration, solid angle,
kinetic temperature, column density, radius, and mass show strong ($>1$ dex)
progressions when sorted by star formation indicator. The median starless clump
candidate is marginally sub-virial ($\alpha \sim 0.7$) with $>75\%$ of clumps
with known distance being gravitationally bound ($\alpha < 2$). These samples
show a statistically significant increase in the median clump mass of $\Delta M
\sim 170-370$ M$_\odot$ from the starless candidates to clumps associated with
protostars. This trend could be due to (i) mass growth of the clumps at
$\dot{M}\sim200-440$ Msun Myr$^{-1}$ for an average free-fall $0.8$ Myr
time-scale, (ii) a systematic factor of two increase in dust opacity from
starless to protostellar phases, (iii) and/or a variation in the ratio of
starless to protostellar clump lifetime that scales as $\sim M^{-0.4}$. By
comparing to the observed number of ${\rm CH_3OH}$ maser containing clumps we
estimate the phase-lifetime of massive ($M>10^3$ M$_\odot$) starless clumps to
be $0.37 \pm 0.08 \ {\rm Myr} \ (M/10^3 \ {\rm M}_\odot)^{-1}$; the majority
($M<450$ M$_\odot$) have phase-lifetimes longer than their average free-fall
time.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1411.2591 [pdf] - 921504
The Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey. XII. Distance Catalog Expansion Using
Kinematic Isolation of Dense Molecular Cloud Structures With 13CO(1-0)
Submitted: 2014-11-10
We present an expanded distance catalog for 1,710 molecular cloud structures
identified in the Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey (BGPS) version 2, representing
a nearly threefold increase over the previous BGPS distance catalog. We
additionally present a new method for incorporating extant data sets into our
Bayesian distance probability density function (DPDF) methodology. To augment
the dense-gas tracers (e.g., HCO+(3-2), NH3(1,1)) used to derive line-of-sight
velocities for kinematic distances, we utilize the Galactic Ring Survey
13CO(1-0) data to morphologically extract velocities for BGPS sources. The
outline of a BGPS source is used to select a region of the GRS 13CO data, along
with a reference region to subtract enveloping diffuse emission, to produce a
line profile of 13CO matched to the BGPS source. For objects with a HCO+(3-2)
velocity, \approx 95% of the new 13CO(1-0) velocities agree with that of the
dense gas. A new prior DPDF for kinematic distance ambiguity (KDA) resolution,
based on a validated formalism for associating molecular cloud structures with
known objects from the literature, is presented. We demonstrate this prior
using catalogs of masers with trigonometric parallaxes and HII regions with
robust KDA resolutions. The distance catalog presented here contains
well-constrained distance estimates for 20% of BGPS V2 sources, with typical
distance uncertainties \lesssim 0.5 kpc. Approximately 75% of the
well-constrained sources lie within 6 kpc of the Sun, concentrated in the
Scutum-Centarus arm. Galactocentric positions of objects additionally trace out
portions of the Sagittarius, Perseus, and Outer arms in the first and second
Galactic quadrants, and we also find evidence for significant regions of
interarm dense gas.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.6586 [pdf] - 1180208
Ammonia Thermometry of Star Forming Galaxies
Submitted: 2013-10-24, last modified: 2013-11-13
With a goal toward deriving the physical conditions in external galaxies, we
present a study of the ammonia (NH$_3$) emission and absorption in a sample of
star forming systems. Using the unique sensitivities to kinetic temperature
afforded by the excitation characteristics of several inversion transitions of
NH$_3$, we have continued our characterization of the dense gas in star forming
galaxies by measuring the kinetic temperature in a sample of 23 galaxies and
one galaxy offset position selected for their high infrared luminosity. We
derive kinetic temperatures toward 13 galaxies, 9 of which possess multiple
kinetic temperature and/or velocity components. Eight of these galaxies exhibit
kinetic temperatures $>100$ K, which are in many cases at least a factor of two
larger than kinetic temperatures derived previously. Furthermore, the derived
kinetic temperatures in our galaxy sample, which are in many cases at least a
factor of two larger than derived dust temperatures, point to a problem with
the common assumption that dust and gas kinetic temperatures are equivalent. As
previously suggested, the use of dust emission at wavelengths greater than 160
$\mu$m to derive dust temperatures, or dust heating from older stellar
populations, may be skewing derived dust temperatures in these galaxies to
lower values. We confirm the detection of high-excitation OH $^2\Pi_{3/2}$
J=9/2 absorption toward Arp220 (Ott et. al. 2011). We also report the first
detections of non-metastable NH$_3$ inversion transitions toward external
galaxies in the (2,1) (NGC253, NGC660, IC342, and IC860), (3,1), (3,2), (4,3),
(5,4) (all in NGC660) and (10,9) (Arp220) transitions.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1308.4149 [pdf] - 1173488
The Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey. X. A Complete Spectroscopic Catalog
of Dense Molecular Gas Observed toward 1.1 mm Dust Continuum Sources with 7.5
<= l <= 194 degrees
Shirley, Yancy L.;
Ellsworth-Bowers, Timothy P.;
Svoboda, Brian;
Schlingman, Wayne M.;
Ginsburg, Adam;
Rosolowsky, Erik;
Gerner, Thomas;
Mairs, Steven;
Battersby, Cara;
Stringfellow, Guy;
Dunham, Miranda K.;
Glenn, Jason;
Bally, John
Submitted: 2013-08-19
The Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey (BGPS) is a 1.1 mm continuum survey of
dense clumps of dust throughout the Galaxy covering 170 square degrees. We
present spectroscopic observations using the Heinrich Hertz Submillimeter
Telescope of the dense gas tracers, HCO+ and N2H+ 3-2, for all 6194 sources in
the Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey v1.0.1 catalog between 7.5 <= l <= 194
degrees. This is the largest targeted spectroscopic survey of dense molecular
gas in the Milky Way to date. We find unique velocities for 3126 (50.5%) of the
BGPS v1.0.1 sources observed. Strong N2H+ 3-2 emission (T_{mb} > 0.5 K) without
HCO+ 3-2 emission does not occur in this catalog. We characterize the
properties of the dense molecular gas emission toward the entire sample. HCO+
is very sub-thermally populated and the 3-2 transitions are optically thick
toward most BGPS clumps. The median observed line width is 3.3 km/s consistent
with supersonic turbulence within BGPS clumps. We find strong correlations
between dense molecular gas integrated intensities and 1.1 mm peak flux and the
gas kinetic temperature derived from previously published NH3 observations.
These intensity correlations are driven by the sensitivity of the 3-2
transitions to excitation conditions rather than by variations in molecular
column density or abundance. We identify a subset of 113 sources with stronger
N2H+ than HCO+ integrated intensity, but we find no correlations between the
N2H+ / HCO+ ratio and 1.1 mm continuum flux density, gas kinetic temperature,
or line width. Self-absorbed profiles are rare (1.3%).