Normalized to: Stockmann, M.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.10721 [pdf] - 2107249
Stellar Velocity Dispersion of a Massive Quenching Galaxy at z=4.01
Tanaka, Masayuki;
Valentino, Francesco;
Toft, Sune;
Onodera, Masato;
Shimakawa, Rhythm;
Ceverino, Daniel;
Faisst, Andreas L.;
Gallazzi, Anna;
Gomez-Guijarro, Carlos;
Kubo, Mariko;
Magdis, Georgios E.;
Steinhardt, Charles L.;
Stockmann, Mikkel;
Yabe, Kiyoto;
Zabl, Johannes
Submitted: 2019-09-24, last modified: 2020-06-03
We present the first stellar velocity dispersion measurement of a massive
quenching galaxy at z=4.01. The galaxy is first identified as a massive z>~4
galaxy with suppressed star formation from photometric redshifts based on deep
multi-band data in the UKIDSS Ultra Deep Survey field. A follow-up
spectroscopic observation with MOSFIRE on Keck revealed strong multiple
absorption features, which are identified as Balmer absorption lines, giving a
secure redshift of z=4.01. Thanks to the high S/N of the spectrum, we are able
to estimate the stellar velocity dispersion, sigma=268+/-59 km/s. This velocity
dispersion is consistent with that of massive galaxies today, implying no
significant evolution in stellar velocity dispersion over the last 12 Gyr.
Based on an upper limit on its physical size from deep optical images
(r_eff<1.3 kpc), we find that its dynamical mass is consistent with the stellar
mass inferred from photometry. Furthermore, the galaxy is located on the mass
fundamental plane extrapolated from lower redshift galaxies. Combining all
these results, we find that the velocity dispersion does not significantly
evolve with redshift, although the size and mass of massive quenched galaxies
do. This suggests that the mass in the core of massive galaxies does not evolve
significantly, while most of the mass growth occurs in the outskirts of the
galaxies, which also increases the size. This picture is consistent with a
two-phase formation scenario in which mass and size growth is due to accretion
in the outskirts of galaxies via mergers.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.10540 [pdf] - 2046268
Quiescent galaxies 1.5 billion years after the Big Bang and their
progenitors
Valentino, Francesco;
Tanaka, Masayuki;
Davidzon, Iary;
Toft, Sune;
Gomez-Guijarro, Carlos;
Stockmann, Mikkel;
Onodera, Masato;
Brammer, Gabriel;
Ceverino, Daniel;
Faisst, Andreas L.;
Gallazzi, Anna;
Hayward, Christopher C.;
Ilbert, Olivier;
Kubo, Mariko;
Magdis, Georgios E.;
Selsing, Jonatan;
Shimakawa, Rhythm;
Sparre, Martin;
Steinhardt, Charles;
Yabe, Kiyoto;
Zabl, Johannes
Submitted: 2019-09-23, last modified: 2019-12-20
We report two secure ($z=3.775, 4.012$) and one tentative ($z\approx3.767$)
spectroscopic confirmations of massive and quiescent galaxies through $K$-band
observations with Keck/MOSFIRE and VLT/X-Shooter. The stellar continuum
emission, the absence of strong nebular emission lines and the lack of
significant far-infrared detections confirm the passive nature of these
objects, disfavoring the alternative solution of low-redshift dusty
star-forming interlopers. We derive stellar masses of
$\mathrm{log}(M_{\star}/M_\odot)\sim11$ and ongoing star formation rates
placing these galaxies $\gtrsim 1-2$ dex below the main sequence at their
redshifts. The adopted parametrization of the star formation history suggests
that these sources experienced a strong ($\langle \rm SFR \rangle \sim
1200-3500\,M_\odot\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1}$) and short ($\sim 50$ Myr) burst of star
formation, peaking $\sim 150-500$ Myr before the time of observation, all
properties reminiscent of the characteristics of sub-millimeter galaxies (SMGs)
at $z>4$. We investigate this connection by comparing the comoving number
densities and the properties of these two populations. We find a fair agreement
only with the deepest sub-mm surveys detecting not only the most extreme
starbursts, but also more normal galaxies. We support these findings by further
exploring the Illustris-TNG cosmological simulation, retrieving populations of
both fully quenched massive galaxies at $z\sim3-4$ and SMGs at $z\sim4-5$, with
number densities and properties in agreement with the observations at $z\sim3$,
but in increasing tension at higher redshift. Nevertheless, as suggested by the
observations, not all the progenitors of quiescent galaxies at these redshifts
shine as bright SMGs in their past and, similarly, not all bright SMGs quench
by $z\sim3$, both fractions depending on the threshold assumed to define the
SMGs themselves.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.01619 [pdf] - 2026487
X-shooter Spectroscopy and HST Imaging of 15 Ultra Massive Quiescent
Galaxies at $z\gtrsim2$
Stockmann, Mikkel;
Toft, Sune;
Gallazzi, Anna;
Zibetti, Stefano;
Conselice, Christopher J.;
Margalef-Bentabol, Berta;
Zabl, Johannes;
Jørgensen, Inger;
Magdis, Georgios E.;
Gómez-Guijarro, Carlos;
Valentino, Francesco M.;
Brammer, Gabriel B.;
Ceverino, Daniel;
Cortzen, Isabella;
Davidzon, Iary;
Demarco, Richardo;
Faisst, Andreas;
Hirschmann, Michaela;
Krogager, Jens-Kristian;
Lagos, Claudia D.;
Man, Allison W. S.;
Mundy, Carl J.;
Peng, Yingjie;
Selsing, Jonatan;
Steinhardt, Charles L.;
Whitaker, Kathrine E.
Submitted: 2019-12-03
We present a detailed analysis of a large sample of spectroscopically
confirmed ultra-massive quiescent galaxies
(${\rm{log}}(M_{\ast}/M_{\odot})\sim11.5$) at $z\gtrsim2$. This sample
comprises 15 galaxies selected in the COSMOS and UDS fields by their bright
K-band magnitudes and followed up with VLT/X-shooter spectroscopy and HST/WFC3
$H_{F160W}$ imaging. These observations allow us to unambiguously confirm their
redshifts ascertain their quiescent nature and stellar ages, and to reliably
assess their internal kinematics and effective radii. We find that these
galaxies are compact, consistent with the high mass end of the mass-size
relation for quiescent galaxies at $z=2$. Moreover, the distribution of the
measured stellar velocity dispersions of the sample is consistent with the most
massive local early-type galaxies from the MASSIVE Survey showing that
evolution in these galaxies, is dominated by changes in size. The HST images
reveal, as surprisingly high, that $40\ \%$ of the sample have tidal features
suggestive of mergers and companions in close proximity, including three
galaxies experiencing ongoing major mergers. The absence of velocity dispersion
evolution from $z=2$ to $0$, coupled with a doubling of the stellar mass, with
a factor of four size increase and the observed disturbed stellar morphologies
support dry minor mergers as the primary drivers of the evolution of the
massive quiescent galaxies over the last 10 billion years.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.02572 [pdf] - 2025775
Compact Star-Forming Galaxies as Old Starbursts Becoming Quiescent
Gómez-Guijarro, C.;
Magdis, G. E.;
Valentino, F.;
Toft, S.;
Man, A. W. S.;
Ivison, R. J.;
Tisanić, K.;
van der Vlugt, D.;
Stockmann, M.;
Martin-Alvarez, S.;
Brammer, G.
Submitted: 2019-09-05
Optically-compact star-forming galaxies (SFGs) have been proposed as
immediate progenitors of quiescent galaxies, although their origin and nature
are debated. Were they formed in slow secular processes or in rapid
merger-driven starbursts? Addressing this question would provide fundamental
insight into how quenching occurs. We explore the location of the general
population of galaxies with respect to fundamental star-forming and structural
relations, identify compact SFGs based on their stellar core densities, and
study three diagnostics of the burstiness of star formation: 1) Star formation
efficiency, 2) interstellar medium (ISM), and 3) radio emission. The overall
distribution of galaxies in the fundamental relations points towards a smooth
transition towards quiescence while galaxies grow their stellar cores, although
some galaxies suddenly increase their specific star-formation rate when they
become compact. From their star formation efficiencies compact and extended
SFGs appear similar. In relation to the ISM diagnostic, by studying the CO
excitation, the density of the neutral gas, and the strength of the ultraviolet
radiation field, compact SFGs resemble galaxies located in the upper envelope
of the SFGs main sequence, although yet based on a small sample size. Regarding
the radio emission diagnostic we find that galaxies become increasingly compact
as the starburst ages, implying that at least some compact SFGs are old
starbursts. We suggest that compact SFGs could be starburts winding down and
eventually crossing the main sequence towards quiescence.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.05178 [pdf] - 1771728
PAHs as tracers of the molecular gas in star-forming galaxies
Cortzen, I.;
Garrett, J.;
Magdis, G.;
Rigopoulou, D.;
Valentino, F.;
Pereira-Santaella, M.;
Combes, F.;
Alonso-Herrero, A.;
Toft, S.;
Daddi, E.;
Elbaz, D.;
Gómez-Guijarro, C.;
Stockmann, M.;
Huang, J.;
Kramer, C.
Submitted: 2018-10-11
[Abridged] We combine new CO(1-0) line observations of 24 intermediate
redshift galaxies (0.03 < z < 0.28) along with literature data of galaxies at
0<z<4 to explore scaling relations between the dust and gas content using PAH
6.2 $\mu$m ($L_{6.2}$), CO ($L'_{\rm CO}$), and infrared ($L_{\rm IR}$)
luminosities for a wide range of redshifts and physical environments. Our
analysis confirms the existence of a universal $L_{6.2}-L_{\rm CO}$ correlation
followed by normal star-forming galaxies (SFGs) and starbursts (SBs) at all
redshifts. This relation is also followed by local ULIRGs that appear as
outliers in the $L_{6.2}-L_{\rm IR}$ and $L_{\rm IR}-L'_{\rm CO}$ relations
from the sequence defined by normal SFGs. The emerging tight ($\sigma \approx
0.26$ dex) and linear ($\alpha = 1.03$) relation between $L_{6.2}$ and $L_{\rm
CO}$ indicates a $L_{6.2}$ to molecular gas ($M_{\rm H_2}$) conversion factor
of $\alpha_{6.2} = M_{\rm H2}/L_{6.2} = (2.7\pm1.3) \times \alpha_{\rm CO}$,
where $\alpha_{\rm CO}$ is the $L'_{\rm CO}$ to $M_{\rm H_2}$ conversion
factor. We also find that on galaxy integrated scales, PAH emission is better
correlated with cold rather than with warm dust emission, suggesting that PAHs
are associated with the diffuse cold dust, which is another proxy for $M_{\rm
H_2}$. Focusing on normal SFGs among our sample, we employ the dust continuum
emission to derive $M_{\rm H_2}$ estimates and find a constant $M_{\rm
H_2}/L_{6.2}$ ratio of $\alpha_{6.2} = 12.3 \ M_{\rm H_2}/{\rm L}_{\odot}$
($\sigma\approx 0.3$ dex). We propose that the presented $L_{6.2}-L'_{\rm CO}$
and $L_{6.2}-M_{\rm H_2}$ relations will serve as useful tools for the
determination of the physical properties of high-$z$ SFGs, for which PAH
emission will be routinely detected by the James Webb Space Telescope.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.00543 [pdf] - 1775711
The rest-frame optical sizes of massive galaxies with suppressed star
formation at $z\sim4$
Submitted: 2018-10-01
We present the rest-frame optical sizes of massive quiescent galaxies (QGs)
at $z\sim4$ measured at $K'$-band with the Infrared Camera and Spectrograph
(IRCS) and AO188 on the Subaru telescope. Based on a deep multi-wavelength
catalog in the Subaru XMM-Newton Deep Survey Field (SXDS), covering a wide
wavelength range from the $u$-band to the IRAC $8.0\mu m$ over 0.7 deg$^2$, we
evaluate photometric redshift to identify massive ($M_{\star}\sim10^{11}\
M_\odot$) galaxies with suppressed star formation. These galaxies show a
prominent 4000$\rm \AA$ break feature at $z\sim4$, suggestive of an evolved
stellar population. We then conduct follow-up $K'$-band imaging with adaptive
optics for the five brightest galaxies ($K_{AB,total}=22.5\sim23.4$). Compared
to lower redshift ones, QGs at $z\sim4$ have smaller physical sizes of
effective radii $r_{eff}=0.2$ to $1.8$ kpc. The mean size measured by stacking
the four brightest objects is $r_{eff}=0.7\rm\ kpc$. This is the first
measurement of the rest-frame optical sizes of QGs at $z\sim4$. We evaluate the
robustness of our size measurements using simulations and find that our size
estimates are reasonably accurate with an expected systematic bias of $\sim0.2$
kpc. If we account for the stellar mass evolution, massive QGs at $z\sim4$ are
likely to evolve into the most massive galaxies today. We find their size
evolution with cosmic time in a form of $\log(r_e/{\rm kpc})= -0.44+1.77
\log(t/\rm Gyr)$. Their size growth is proportional to the square of stellar
mass, indicating the size-stellar mass growth driven by minor dry mergers.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.07751 [pdf] - 1663347
Starburst to quiescent from HST/ALMA: Stars and dust unveil minor
mergers in submillimeter galaxies at $z \sim 4.5$
Gómez-Guijarro, C.;
Toft, S.;
Karim, A.;
Magnelli, B.;
Magdis, G. E.;
Jiménez-Andrade, E. F.;
Capak, P. L.;
Fraternali, F.;
Fujimoto, S.;
Riechers, D. A.;
Schinnerer, E.;
Smolčić, V.;
Aravena, M.;
Bertoldi, F.;
Cortzen, I.;
Hasinger, G.;
Hu, E. M.;
Jones, G. C.;
Koekemoer, A. M.;
Lee, N.;
McCracken, H. J.;
Michałowski, M. J.;
Navarrete, F.;
Pović, M.;
Puglisi, A.;
Romano-Díaz, E.;
Sheth, K.;
Silverman, J. D.;
Staguhn, J.;
Steinhardt, C. L.;
Stockmann, M.;
Tanaka, M.;
Valentino, F.;
van Kampen, E.;
Zirm, A.
Submitted: 2018-02-21
Dust-enshrouded, starbursting, submillimeter galaxies (SMGs) at $z \geq 3$
have been proposed as progenitors of $z \geq 2$ compact quiescent galaxies
(cQGs). To test this connection, we present a detailed spatially resolved study
of the stars, dust and stellar mass in a sample of six submillimeter-bright
starburst galaxies at $z \sim 4.5$. The stellar UV emission probed by HST is
extended, irregular and shows evidence of multiple components. Informed by HST,
we deblend Spitzer/IRAC data at rest-frame optical finding that the systems are
undergoing minor mergers, with a typical stellar mass ratio of 1:6.5. The FIR
dust continuum emission traced by ALMA locates the bulk of star formation in
extremely compact regions (median $r_{\rm{e}} = 0.70 \pm 0.29$ kpc) and it is
in all cases associated with the most massive component of the mergers (median
$\log (M_{*}/M_{\odot}) = 10.49 \pm 0.32$). We compare spatially resolved UV
slope ($\beta$) maps with the FIR dust continuum to study the infrared excess
($\rm{IRX} = L_{\rm{IR}}/L_{\rm{UV}}$)-$\beta$ relation. The SMGs display
systematically higher $\rm{IRX}$ values than expected from the nominal trend,
demonstrating that the FIR and UV emissions are spatially disconnected.
Finally, we show that the SMGs fall on the mass-size plane at smaller stellar
masses and sizes than cQGs at $z = 2$. Taking into account the expected
evolution in stellar mass and size between $z = 4.5$ and $z = 2$ due to the
ongoing starburst and mergers with minor companions, this is in agreement with
a direct evolutionary connection between the two populations.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.00133 [pdf] - 1628280
Thirty-fold: Extreme gravitational lensing of a quiescent galaxy at
$z=1.6$
Submitted: 2018-01-31
We report the discovery of eMACSJ1341-QG-1, a quiescent galaxy at $z=1.594$
located behind the massive galaxy cluster eMACSJ1341.9$-$2442 ($z=0.835$). The
system was identified as a gravitationally lensed triple image in Hubble Space
Telescope images obtained as part of a snapshot survey of the most X-ray
luminous galaxy clusters at $z>0.5$ and spectroscopically confirmed in
ground-based follow-up observations with the ESO/X-Shooter spectrograph. From
the constraints provided by the triple image, we derive a first, crude model of
the mass distribution of the cluster lens, which predicts a gravitational
amplification of a factor of $\sim$30 for the primary image and a factor of
$\sim$6 for the remaining two images of the source, making eMACSJ1341-QG-1 by
far the most strongly amplified quiescent galaxy discovered to date. Our
discovery underlines the power of SNAPshot observations of massive, X-ray
selected galaxy clusters for lensing-assisted studies of faint background
populations.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.07030 [pdf] - 1584999
A massive, dead disk galaxy in the early Universe
Toft, Sune;
Zabl, Johannes;
Richard, Johan;
Gallazzi, Anna;
Zibetti, Stefano;
Prescott, Moire;
Grillo, Claudio;
Man, Allison W. S.;
Lee, Nicholas Y.;
Gomez-Guijarro, Carlos;
Stockmann, Mikkel;
Magdis, Georgios;
Steinhardt, Charles L.
Submitted: 2017-06-21
At redshift z = 2, when the Universe was just three billion years old, half
of the most massive galaxies were extremely compact and had already exhausted
their fuel for star formation(1-4). It is believed that they were formed in
intense nuclear starbursts and that they ultimately grew into the most massive
local elliptical galaxies seen today, through mergers with minor
companions(5,6), but validating this picture requires higher-resolution
observations of their centres than is currently possible. Magnification from
gravitational lensing offers an opportunity to resolve the inner regions of
galaxies(7). Here we report an analysis of the stellar populations and
kinematics of a lensed z = 2.1478 compact galaxy, which surprisingly turns out
to be a fast-spinning, rotationally supported disk galaxy. Its stars must have
formed in a disk, rather than in a merger-driven nuclear starburst(8). The
galaxy was probably fed by streams of cold gas, which were able to penetrate
the hot halo gas until they were cut off by shock heating from the dark matter
halo(9). This result confirms previous indirect indications(10-13) that the
first galaxies to cease star formation must have gone through major changes not
just in their structure, but also in their kinematics, to evolve into
present-day elliptical galaxies.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.02350 [pdf] - 1579885
The COSMOS2015 Catalog: Exploring the 1<z<6 Universe with half a million
galaxies
Laigle, C.;
McCracken, H. J.;
Ilbert, O.;
Hsieh, B. C.;
Davidzon, I.;
Capak, P.;
Hasinger, G.;
Silverman, J. D.;
Pichon, C.;
Coupon, J.;
Aussel, H.;
Borgne, D. Le;
Caputi, K.;
Cassata, P.;
Chang, Y. -Y.;
Civano, F.;
Dunlop, J.;
Fynbo, J.;
kartaltepe, J. S.;
Koekemoer, A.;
Fevre, O. Le;
Floc'h, E. Le;
Leauthaud, A.;
Lilly, S.;
Lin, L.;
Marchesi, S.;
Milvang-Jensen, B.;
Salvato, M.;
Sanders, D. B.;
Scoville, N.;
Smolcic, V.;
Stockmann, M.;
Taniguchi, Y.;
Tasca, L.;
Toft, S.;
Vaccari, M.;
Zabl, J.
Submitted: 2016-04-08
We present the COSMOS2015 catalog which contains precise photometric
redshifts and stellar masses for more than half a million objects over the
2deg$^{2}$ COSMOS field. Including new $YJHK_{\rm s}$ images from the
UltraVISTA-DR2 survey, $Y$-band from Subaru/Hyper-Suprime-Cam and infrared data
from the Spitzer Large Area Survey with the Hyper-Suprime-Cam Spitzer legacy
program, this near-infrared-selected catalog is highly optimized for the study
of galaxy evolution and environments in the early Universe. To maximise catalog
completeness for bluer objects and at higher redshifts, objects have been
detected on a $\chi^{2}$ sum of the $YJHK_{\rm s}$ and $z^{++}$ images. The
catalog contains $\sim 6\times 10^5$ objects in the 1.5 deg$^{2}$
UltraVISTA-DR2 region, and $\sim 1.5\times 10^5$ objects are detected in the
"ultra-deep stripes" (0.62 deg$^{2}$) at $K_{\rm s}\leq 24.7$ (3$\sigma$, 3",
AB magnitude). Through a comparison with the zCOSMOS-bright spectroscopic
redshifts, we measure a photometric redshift precision of $\sigma_{\Delta
z/(1+z_s)}$ = 0.007 and a catastrophic failure fraction of $\eta=0.5$%. At
$3<z<6$, using the unique database of spectroscopic redshifts in COSMOS, we
find $\sigma_{\Delta z/(1+z_s)}$ = 0.021 and $\eta=13.2\% $. The deepest
regions reach a 90\% completeness limit of 10$^{10}M_\odot$ to $z=4$. Detailed
comparisons of the color distributions, number counts, and clustering show
excellent agreement with the literature in the same mass ranges. COSMOS2015
represents a unique, publicly available, valuable resource with which to
investigate the evolution of galaxies within their environment back to the
earliest stages of the history of the Universe. The COSMOS2015 catalog is
distributed via anonymous ftp
(ftp://ftp.iap.fr/pub/from_users/hjmcc/COSMOS2015/) and through the usual
astronomical archive systems (CDS, ESO Phase 3, IRSA).