Normalized to: Stenflo, J.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.04044 [pdf] - 2131070
Importance of Angle-dependent Partial Frequency Redistribution in
Hyperfine Structure Transitions Under Incomplete Paschen-Back Effect Regime
Submitted: 2020-07-08
Angle-frequency coupling in scattering of polarized light on atoms is
represented by the angle-dependent (AD) partial frequency redistribution (PRD)
matrices. There are several lines in the linearly polarized solar spectrum, for
which PRD combined with quantum interference between hyperfine structure states
play a significant role. Here we present the solution of the polarized line
transfer equation including the AD-PRD matrix for scattering on a two-level
atom with hyperfine structure splitting (HFS) and an unpolarized lower level.
We account for the effects of arbitrary magnetic fields (including the
incomplete Paschen-Back effect regime) and elastic collisions. For exploratory
purposes we consider a self-emitting isothermal planar atmosphere and use
atomic parameters that represent an isolated Na\,{\sc i} D$_2$ line. For this
case we show that the AD-PRD effects are significant for field strengths below
about 30G, but that the computationally much less demanding approximation of
angle-averaged (AA) PRD may be used for stronger fields.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.08614 [pdf] - 2076788
Stokes vectors and Minkowski spacetime: Structural parallels
Submitted: 2019-12-17
The Stokes formalism of polarization physics has astounding structural
parallels with the formalism used for relativity theory in Minkowski spacetime.
The structure and symmetry properties of the Mueller matrices are the same as
those for the matrix representations of the electromagnetic tensor and the
Lorentz transformation operator. The absorption terms $\eta_k$ in the Mueller
matrix correspond to the electric field components $E_k$ in the electromagnetic
tensor and the Lorentz boost terms $\gamma_k$ in the Lorentz transformation
matrix, while the anomalous dispersion terms $\rho_k$ correspond to the
magnetic field components $B_k$ and the spatial rotation angles $\phi_k$. In a
Minkowski-type space spanned by the Stokes $I,Q,U,V$ parameters, the Stokes
vector for 100 % polarized light is a null vector living on the surface of null
cones, like the energy-momentum vector of massless particles in ordinary
Minkowski space. Stokes vectors for partially polarized light live inside the
null cones like the momentum vectors for massive particles. In this description
the depolarization of Stokes vectors appears as a "mass'' term, which has its
origin in a symmetry breaking caused by the incoherent superposition of
uncorrelated fields or wave packets, without the need to refer to a ubiquitous
Higgs field as is done in particle physics. The rotational symmetry of Stokes
vectors and Mueller matrices is that of spin-2 objects, in contrast to the
spin-1 nature of the electromagnetic field. The reason for this difference is
that the Stokes objects have substructure: they are formed from bilinear tensor
products between spin-1 objects, the Jones vectors and Jones matrices. The
governing physics takes place at the substructure level.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.10913 [pdf] - 1985824
Polarized Line Formation in Arbitrary Strength Magnetic Fields: the case
of a two-level atom with hyperfine structure splitting
Submitted: 2019-10-24
Quantum interference effects together with partial frequency redistribution
(PFR) in line scattering produce subtle signatures in the so called Second
Solar Spectrum (the linearly polarized spectrum of the Sun). These signatures
are modified in the presence of arbitrary strength magnetic fields via the
Hanle, Zeeman, and Paschen-Back effects. In the present paper we solve the
problem of polarized line formation in a magnetized atmosphere taking into
account scattering in a two-level atom with hyperfine structure splitting
together with PFR. To this end we incorporate the collisionless PFR matrix
derived in Sowmya et al. (2014) in the polarized transfer equation. We apply
the scattering expansion method to solve this transfer equation. We study the
combined effects of PFR and Paschen-Back effect on polarized line profiles
formed in an isothermal one-dimensional planar atmosphere. For this purpose, we
consider the cases of D$_2$ lines of Li\,{\sc i} and Na\,{\sc i}.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.03531 [pdf] - 1701585
Spatial variations of the Sr i 4607 {\AA} scattering polarization peak
Submitted: 2018-03-09
Context. The scattering polarization signal observed in the photospheric Sr i
4607 {\AA} line is expected to vary at granular spatial scales. This variation
can be due to changes in the magnetic field intensity and orientation (Hanle
effect), but also to spatial and temporal variations in the plasma properties.
Measuring the spatial variation of such polarization signal would allow us to
study the properties of the magnetic fields at subgranular scales, but
observations are challenging since both high spatial resolution and high
spectropolarimetric sensitivity are required.
Aims. We aim to provide observational evidence of the polarization peak
spatial variations, and to analyze the correlation they might have with
granulation.
Methods. Observations conjugating high spatial resolution and high
spectropolarimetric precision were performed with the Zurich IMaging
POLarimeter, ZIMPOL, at the GREGOR solar telescope, taking advantage of the
adaptive optics system and the newly installed image derotator.
Results. Spatial variations of the scattering polarization in the Sr i 4607
{\AA} line are clearly observed. The spatial scale of these variations is
comparable with the granular size. Small correlations between the polarization
signal amplitude and the continuum intensity indicate that the polarization is
higher at the center of granules than in the intergranular lanes.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1708.03284 [pdf] - 1586971
Atlas of the solar intensity spectrum and its center to limb variation
Submitted: 2017-08-10
The solar limb darkening function is well known and is widely employed in
models of the solar atmosphere. However, there has been a lack of systematic
spectrally resolved measurements. Therefore we recently decided to start an
observing campaign with the Gregory Coud\'e Telescope at IRSOL in Locarno in
order to produce a spectral atlas obtained at 10 different heliocentric angles
$\theta$, chosen so that $\mu = \cos\theta$ covers the interval from 0.1 to 1.0
in step of 0.1. The measurements carried out till now include the spectral
range from 439 nm to 666 nm. The collected data provide information about the
anisotropy of the emergent radiation field on the solar surface, allowing a
better modeling of the Second Solar Spectrum. In addition the data give
observational constraints that should be taken into account when modeling the
solar atmosphere.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.07736 [pdf] - 1332163
Polarized scattering of light for arbitrary magnetic fields with
level-crossings from the combination of hyperfine and fine structure
splittings
Submitted: 2015-12-24
Interference between magnetic substates of the hyperfine structure states
belonging to different fine structure states of the same term influences the
polarization for some of the diagnostically important lines of the Sun's
spectrum, like the sodium and lithium doublets. The polarization signatures of
this combined interference contain information on the properties of the solar
magnetic fields. Motivated by this, in the present paper, we study the problem
of polarized scattering on a two-term atom with hyperfine structure by
accounting for the partial redistribution in the photon frequencies arising due
to the Doppler motions of the atoms. We consider the scattering atoms to be
under the influence of a magnetic field of arbitrary strength and develop a
formalism based on the Kramers--Heisenberg approach to calculate the scattering
cross section for this process. We explore the rich polarization effects that
arise from various level-crossings in the Paschen--Back regime in a single
scattering case using the lithium atomic system as a concrete example that is
relevant to the Sun.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.07731 [pdf] - 1332162
Polarized scattering with Paschen-Back effect, hyperfine structure, and
partial frequency redistribution in magnetized stellar atmospheres
Submitted: 2015-12-24
$F$-state interference significantly modifies the polarization produced by
scattering processes in the solar atmosphere. Its signature in the emergent
Stokes spectrum in the absence of magnetic fields is depolarization in the line
core. In the present paper, we derive the partial frequency redistribution
(PRD) matrix that includes interference between the upper hyperfine structure
states of a two-level atom in the presence of magnetic fields of arbitrary
strengths. The theory is applied to the Na I D$_2$ line that is produced by the
transition between the lower $J=1/2$ and upper $J=3/2$ states which split into
$F$ states because of the coupling with the nuclear spin $I_s=3/2$. The
properties of the PRD matrix for the single-scattering case is explored, in
particular, the effects of the magnetic field in the Paschen--Back regime and
their usefulness as a tool for the diagnostics of solar magnetic fields.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.06229 [pdf] - 1351655
Transition of the Sunspot Number from Zurich to Brussels in 1980: A
Personal Perspective
Submitted: 2015-12-19
The Swiss Federal Observatory, which had been founded in 1863 by Rudolf Wolf,
was dissolved in connection with the retirement of Max Waldmeier in 1979. The
determination of the Zurich sunpot number, which had been a cornerstone
activity of the observatory, was then discontinued by ETH Zurich. A smooth
transition of the responsibility for the sunspot number from Zurich to Brussels
could however be achieved in 1980, through which it was possible to avoid a
discontinuity in this important time series. Here we describe the circumstances
that led to the termination in Zurich, how Brussels was chosen for the
succession, and how the transfer was accomplished.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1508.03312 [pdf] - 1280999
History of Solar Magnetic Fields since George Ellery Hale
Submitted: 2015-08-13
As my own work on the Sun's magnetic field started exactly 50 years ago at
Crimea in the USSR, I have been a participant in the field during nearly half
the time span since Hale's discovery in 1908 of magnetic fields in sunspots.
The present historical account is accompanied by photos from my personal slide
collection, which show a number of the leading personalities who advanced the
field in different areas: measurement techniques, from photographic to
photoelectric and imaging methods in spectro-polarimetry; theoretical
foundations of MHD and the origin of cosmic magnetic fields (birth of dynamo
theory); the quest for increased angular resolution from national projects to
international consortia (for instruments both on ground and in space);
introduction of the Hanle effect in astrophysics and the Second Solar Spectrum
as its playground; small-scale nature of the field, the fundamental resolution
limit, and transcending it by resolution-independent diagnostics.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1501.02259 [pdf] - 1223950
Physics of polarized scattering at multi-level atomic systems
Submitted: 2015-01-09
The symmetric peak observed in linear polarization in the core of the solar
sodium D$_1$ line at 5896 \AA\ has remained enigmatic since its discovery
nearly two decades ago. One reason is that the theory of polarized scattering
has not been experimentally tested for multi-level atomic systems in the
relevant parameter domains, although the theory is continually being used for
the interpretation of astrophysical observations. A laboratory experiment that
was set up a decade ago to find out whether the D$_1$ enigma is a problem of
solar physics or quantum physics revealed that the D$_1$ system has a rich
polarization structure in situations where standard scattering theory predicts
zero polarization, even when optical pumping of the $m$ state populations of
the hyperfine-split ground state is accounted for. Here we show that the
laboratory results can be modeled in great quantitative detail if the theory is
extended to include the coherences in both the initial and final states of the
scattering process. Radiative couplings between the allowed dipole transitions
generate coherences in the initial state. Corresponding coherences in the final
state are then demanded by a phase closure selection rule. The experimental
results for the well understood D$_2$ line are used to constrain the two free
parameters of the experiment, collision rate and optical depth, to suppress the
need for free parameters when fitting the D$_1$ results.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.8474 [pdf] - 913140
FTS atlas of the Sun's spectrally resolved center-to-limb variation
Submitted: 2014-10-30
The Sun's spectrum varies with center-to-limb distance. This variation is
governed by the underlying temperature-density structure of the solar
atmosphere. To explore the spectrally resolved center-to-limb variation (CLV)
we make use of two spectral atlases recorded with the Fourier transform
spectrometer (FTS) at the McMath-Pierce facility at Kitt Peak. One spectral
atlas obtained 10 arcsec inside the solar limb was recorded in 1978-79 as part
of the first survey of the Second Solar Spectrum, while the other atlas is the
well used reference NSO/Kitt Peak FTS atlas for the disk center. Both atlases
represent fully resolved spectra without any spectral stray light. We then
construct an atlas of the limb/disk-center ratio between the two spectra over
the wavelength range 4084-9950 \AA. This ratio spectrum, which expresses the
CLV amplitude relative to the continuum, is as richly structured as the
intensity spectrum itself, but the line profiles differ greatly in both shape
and amplitude. It is as if we are dealing with a new, unfamiliar spectrum of
the Sun, distinctly different from both the intensity spectrum (which we here
refer to with the acronym SS1) and the linear polarization of the Second Solar
Spectrum (for which we use acronym SS2). In analogy we refer to the new ratio
spectrum as SS3. While there is hardly any resemblance between SS3 and SS2, we
are able to identify a non-linear mapping that can translate SS1 to SS3 in the
case of weak to medium-strong spectral lines that are mainly formed in LTE
(being directly coupled to the local temperature-density structure). This
non-linear mapping is successfully modeled in terms of two free parameters that
are found to vary approximately linearly over the entire wavelength range
covered. These parameters and the various SS3 line profiles provide a novel,
rich set of observational constraints on model atmospheres.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1408.4247 [pdf] - 1216379
The quantum interference effects in the Sc II 4247 A line of the Second
Solar Spectrum
Submitted: 2014-08-19, last modified: 2014-09-16
The Sc II 4247 A line formed in the chromosphere is one of the lines well
known, like the Na I D_2 and Ba II D_2, for its prominent triple peak structure
in Q/I and the underlying quantum interference effects governing it. In this
paper, we try to study the nature of this triple peak structure using the
theory of F-state interference including the effects of partial frequency
redistribution (PRD) and radiative transfer (RT). We compare our results with
the observations taken in a quiet region near the solar limb. In spite of
accounting for PRD and RT effects it has not been possible to reproduce the
observed triple peak structure in Q/I. While the two wing PRD peaks (on either
side of central peak) and the near wing continuum can be reproduced, the
central peak is completely suppressed by the enhanced depolarization resulting
from the hyperfine structure splitting. This suppression remains for all the
tested widely different 1D model atmospheres or for any multi-component
combinations of them. While multidimensional radiative transfer effects may
improve the fit to the intensity profiles, they do not appear capable of
explaining the enigmatic central Q/I peak. This leads us to suspect that some
aspect of quantum physics is missing.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.0465 [pdf] - 864169
The role of quantum interference and partial redistribution in the solar
Ba II D2 4554 A line
Submitted: 2014-09-01
The Ba II D2 line at 4554 A is a good example, where the F-state interference
effects due to the odd isotopes produce polarization profiles, which are very
different from those of the even isotopes that do not exhibit F-state
interference. It is therefore necessary to account for the contributions from
the different isotopes to understand the observed linear polarization profiles
of this line. In this paper we present radiative transfer modeling with partial
frequency redistribution (PRD), which is shown to be essential to model this
line. This is because complete frequency redistribution (CRD) cannot reproduce
the observed wing polarization. We present the observed and computed Q/I
profiles at different limb distances. The theoretical profiles strongly depend
on limb distance (\mu) and the model atmosphere which fits the limb
observations fails at other \mu\ positions.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1407.5457 [pdf] - 1215801
Polarized light scattering with Paschen-Back effect, level-crossing of
fine structure states and partial frequency redistribution
Submitted: 2014-07-21
The quantum interference between the fine structure states of an atom
modifies the shapes of the emergent Stokes profiles in the Second Solar
Spectrum. This phenomenon has been studied in great detail both in the presence
and absence of magnetic fields. By assuming a flat-spectrum for the incident
radiation, the signatures of this effect have been explored for arbitrary field
strengths. Even though the theory which takes into account the frequency
dependence of the incident radiation is well developed, it is restricted to the
regime in which the magnetic splitting is much smaller than the fine structure
splitting. In the present paper, we carry out a generalization of our
scattering matrix formalism including the effects of partial frequency
redistribution (PRD) for arbitrary magnetic fields. We test the formalism using
available benchmarks for special cases. In particular we apply it to the
Li\,{\sc i} 6708\,\AA\ D$_1$ and D$_2$ line system, for which observable
effects from the Paschen-Back regime are expected in the Sun's spectrum.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1407.5461 [pdf] - 1215802
Center to limb observations and modeling of the Ca I 4227 A line
Submitted: 2014-07-21
The observed center-to-limb variation (CLV) of the scattering polarization in
different lines of the Second Solar Spectrum can be used to constrain the
height variation of various atmospheric parameters, in particular the magnetic
fields via the Hanle effect. Here we attempt to model non-magnetic CLV
observations of the $Q/I$ profiles of the Ca I 4227 A line recorded with the
ZIMPOL-3 at IRSOL. For modeling, we use the polarized radiative transfer with
partial frequency redistribution with a number of realistic 1-D model
atmospheres. We find that all the standard FAL model atmospheres, used by us,
fail to simultaneously fit the observed ($I$, $Q/I$) at all the limb distances
($\mu$). However, an attempt is made to find a single model which can provide a
fit at least to the CLV of the observed $Q/I$ instead of a simultaneous fit to
the ($I$, $Q/I$) at all $\mu$. To this end we construct a new 1-D model by
combining two of the standard models after modifying their temperature
structures in the appropriate height ranges. This new combined model closely
reproduces the observed $Q/I$ at all the $\mu$, but fails to reproduce the
observed rest intensity at different $\mu$. Hence we find that no single 1-D
model atmosphere succeeds in providing a good representation of the real Sun.
This failure of 1-D models does not however cause an impediment to the magnetic
field diagnostic potential of the Ca I 4227 A line. To demonstrate this we
deduce the field strength at various $\mu$ positions without invoking the use
of radiative transfer.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.5454 [pdf] - 1179401
Solar magnetic fields as revealed by Stokes polarimetry
Submitted: 2013-09-21
Observational astrophysics started when spectroscopy could be applied to
astronomy. Similarly, observational work on stellar magnetic fields became
possible with the application of spectro-polarimetry. In recent decades there
have been dramatic advances in the observational tools for spectro-polarimetry.
The four Stokes parameters that provide a complete representation of partially
polarized light can now be simultaneously imaged with megapixel array detectors
with high polarimetric precision (0.001% in the degree of polarization). This
has led to new insights about the nature and properties of the magnetic field,
and has helped pave the way for the use of the Hanle effect as a diagnostic
tool beside the Zeeman effect. The magnetic structuring continues on scales
orders of magnitudes smaller than the resolved ones, but various types of
spectro-polarimetric signatures can be identified, which let us determine the
field strengths and angular distributions of the field vectors in the spatially
unresolved domain. Here we review the observational properties of the magnetic
field, from the global patterns to the smallest scales at the magnetic
diffusion limit, and relate them to the global and local dynamos.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1307.1117 [pdf] - 1172478
Calibration of the 6302/6301 Stokes V line ratio in terms of the
5250/5247 ratio
Submitted: 2013-07-03
Four decades ago the Stokes V line ratio in the Fe I 5247.06 and 5250.22
{\AA} lines was introduced as a powerful means of exploring the intrinsic field
strengths at sub-pixel scales, which led to the discovery that most of the
photospheric flux is in intermittent kG form. The "green" 5247-5250 line pair
is unique because it allows the magnetic-field effects to be isolated from the
thermodynamic effects. No other line pair with this property has since been
identified. In recent years much of the magnetic-field diagnostics has been
based on the "red" Fe I 6301.5 and 6302.5 {\AA} line pair, since it was chosen
in the design of the Hinode space observatory. Although thermodynamic effects
severely contaminate the magnetic-field signatures for this line ratio, it is
still possible to use it to extract information on intrinsic magnetic fields,
but only after it has been "renormalized", since otherwise it produces
fictitious, superstrong fields everywhere. In the present work we explore the
joint behavior of these two line ratios to determine how the "contaminated" red
line ratio can be translated into the corresponding green line ratio, which
then allows for a direct interpretation in terms of intrinsic magnetic fields.
Our observations are mainly based on recordings with the ZIMPOL-3
spectro-polarimeter at IRSOL in Locarno, Switzerland, complemented by data from
the STOP telescope at the Sayan solar observatory (Irkutsk, Russia). The IRSOL
observations are unique by allowing both the green and red line pairs to be
recorded simultaneously on the same CCD sensor. We show how the line ratios
depend on both the measured flux densities and on the heliocentric distance
(the \mu\ value on the solar disk), and finally derive the calibration function
that enables the red line ratio to be translated to the green ratio for each
\mu\ value.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.3581 [pdf] - 1172064
Horizontal or vertical magnetic fields on the quiet Sun: Angular
distributions and their height variations
Submitted: 2013-06-15
Different analyses of identical Hinode SOT/SP data of quiet-sun magnetic
fields have in the past led to contradictory answers to the question of whether
the angular distribution of field vectors is preferentially horizontal or
vertical. These answers have been obtained by combining the measured circular
and linear polarizations in different ways to derive the field inclinations. A
problem with these combinations is that the circular and linear polarizations
scale with field strength in profoundly different ways. Here, we avoid these
problems by using an entirely different approach that is based exclusively on
the fundamental symmetry properties of the transverse Zeeman effect for
observations away from the disk center without any dependence on the circular
polarization. Systematic errors are suppressed by the application of a doubly
differential technique with the 5247-5250 \AA\ line pair for observations with
the ZIMPOL-2 imaging polarimeter on the French THEMIS telescope on Tenerife.
This allows us to determine in a model- and resolution-independent way how the
angular distribution of the intranetwork magnetic fields changes from being
preferentially vertical in the lower and middle photosphere to become
preferentially horizontal in the upper photosphere.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1303.7304 [pdf] - 1165614
Modeling the quantum interference signatures of the Ba II D2 4554 A line
in the second solar spectrum
Submitted: 2013-03-29
Quantum interference effects play a vital role in shaping the linear
polarization profiles of solar spectral lines. The Ba II D2 line at 4554 A is a
prominent example, where the F-state interference effects due to the odd
isotopes produce polarization profiles, which are very different from those of
the even isotopes that have no F-state interference. It is therefore necessary
to account for the contributions from the different isotopes to understand the
observed linear polarization profiles of this line. Here we do radiative
transfer modeling with partial frequency redistribution (PRD) of such
observations while accounting for the interference effects and isotope
composition. The Ba II D2 polarization profile is found to be strongly governed
by the PRD mechanism. We show how a full PRD treatment succeeds in reproducing
the observations, while complete frequency redistribution (CRD) alone fails to
produce polarization profiles that have any resemblance with the observed ones.
However, we also find that the line center polarization is sensitive to the
temperature structure of the model atmosphere. To obtain a good fit to the line
center peak of the observed Stokes Q/I profile, a small modification of the
FALX model atmosphere is needed, by lowering the temperature in the
line-forming layers. Because of the pronounced temperature sensitivity of the
Ba II D2 line it may not be a suitable tool for Hanle magnetic-field
diagnostics of the solar chromosphere, because there is currently no
straightforward way to separate the temperature and magnetic-field effects from
each other.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1211.5529 [pdf] - 1158001
Nature of the solar dynamo at small scales
Submitted: 2012-11-23
It is often claimed that there is not only one, but two different types of
solar dynamos: the one that is responsible for the appearance of sunspots and
the 11-yr cycle, frequently referred to as the "global dynamo", and a
statistically time-invariant dynamo, generally referred to as the "local
dynamo", which is supposed to be responsible for the ubiquitous magnetic
structuring observed at small scales. Here we examine the relative
contributions of these two qualitatively different dynamos to the small-scale
magnetic flux, with the following conclusion: The local dynamo does not play a
significant role at any of the spatially resolved scales, nearly all the
small-scale flux, including the flux revealed by Hinode, is supplied by the
global dynamo. This conclusion is reached by careful determination of the Sun's
noise-corrected basal magnetic flux density while making use of a flux
cancellation function determined from Hinode data. The only allowed range where
there may be substantial or even dominating contributions from a local dynamo
seems to be the scales below about 10 km, as suggested by observations of the
Hanle depolarization effect in atomic spectral lines. To determine the fraction
of the Hanle depolarization that may be due to the action of a local dynamo, a
synoptic program is being initiated at IRSOL (Istituto Ricerche Solari
Locarno).
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1210.0122 [pdf] - 1151736
Basal magnetic flux and the local solar dynamo
Submitted: 2012-09-29
The average unsigned magnetic flux density in magnetograms of the quiet Sun
is generally dominated by instrumental noise. Due to the entirely different
scaling behavior of the noise and the solar magnetic pattern it has been
possible to determine the standard deviation of the Gaussian noise distribution
and remove the noise contribution from the average unsigned flux density for
the whole 15-yr SOHO/MDI data set and for a selection of SDO/HMI magnetograms.
There is a very close correlation between the MDI disk-averaged unsigned
vertical flux density and the sunspot number, and regression analysis gives a
residual level of 2.7 G when the sunspot number is zero. The selected set of
HMI magnetograms, which spans the most quiet phase of solar activity, has a
lower limit of 3.0 G to the noise-corrected average flux density. These
apparently cycle-independent levels may be identified as a basal flux density,
which represents an upper limit to the possible flux contribution from a local
dynamo, but not evidence for its existence. The 3.0 G HMI level, when scaled to
the Hinode spatial resolution, translates to 3.5 G, which means that the much
higher average flux densities always found by Hinode in quiet regions do not
originate from a local dynamo. The contributions to the average unsigned flux
density come almost exclusively from the extended wings of the probability
density function (PDF), also in the case of HMI magnetograms with only
basal-level magnetic flux. These wings represent intermittent magnetic flux.
While the global dynamo appears to dominate the magnetic energy spectrum at all
the resolved spatial scales, there are indications from the observed Hanle
depolarization in atomic lines that the local dynamo may dominate the spectrum
at scales of order 1-10 km and below.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.0243 [pdf] - 1151047
Polarized line formation with J-state interference in the presence of
magnetic fields: A heuristic treatment of collisional frequency
redistribution
Submitted: 2012-09-03
An expression for the partial frequency redistribution (PRD) matrix for line
scattering in a two-term atom, which includes the J-state interference between
its fine structure line components is derived. The influence of collisions
(both elastic and inelastic) and an external magnetic field on the scattering
process is taken into account. The lower term is assumed to be unpolarized and
infinitely sharp. The linear Zeeman regime in which the Zeeman splitting is
much smaller than the fine structure splitting is considered. The inelastic
collision rates between the different levels are included in our treatment. We
account for the depolarization caused by the collisions coupling the fine
structure states of the upper term, but neglect the polarization transfer
between the fine structure states. When the fine structure splitting goes to
zero, we recover the redistribution matrix that represents the scattering on a
two-level atom (which exhibits only m-state interference --- namely the Hanle
effect). The way in which the multipolar index of the scattering atom enters
into the expression for the redistribution matrix through the collisional
branching ratios is discussed. The properties of the redistribution matrix are
explored for a single scattering process for an L=0 to 1 to 0 scattering
transition with S=1/2 (a hypothetical doublet centered at 5000 A and 5001 A).
Further, a method for solving the Hanle radiative transfer equation for a
two-term atom in the presence of collisions, PRD, and J-state interference is
developed. The Stokes profiles emerging from an isothermal constant property
medium are computed.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1208.6369 [pdf] - 1151011
Polarized line transfer with F-state interference in a non-magnetic
medium: Partial frequency redistribution effects in the collisionless regime
Submitted: 2012-08-31
Quantum interference phenomena manifests itself in several ways in the
polarized solar spectrum formed due to coherent scattering processes. One such
effect arises due to interference between the fine structure (J) states giving
rise to multiplets. Another effect is that which arises due to interference
between the hyperfine structure (F) states. We extend the redistribution matrix
derived for the J-state interference to the case of F-state interference. We
then incorporate it into the polarized radiative transfer equation and solve it
for isothermal constant property slab atmospheres. The relevant transfer
equation is solved using a polarized approximate lambda iteration (PALI)
technique based on operator perturbation. An alternative method derived from
the Neumann series expansion is also proposed and is found to be relatively
more efficient than the PALI method. The effects of PRD and the F-state
interference on the shapes of the linearly polarized Stokes profiles are
discussed. The emergent Stokes profiles are computed for hypothetical line
transitions arising due to hyperfine structure splitting (HFS) of the upper
J=3/2 and lower J=1/2 levels of a two-level atom model with nuclear spin
I_s=3/2. We confine our attention to the non-magnetic scattering in the
collisionless regime.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1203.6011 [pdf] - 1117583
Scaling laws for magnetic fields on the quiet Sun
Submitted: 2012-03-27
The Sun's magnetic field is structured over a range of scales that span
approximately seven orders of magnitudes, four of which lie beyond the
resolving power of current telescopes. Here we have used a Hinode SOT/SP deep
mode data set for the quiet-sun disk center in combination with constraints
from the Hanle effect to derive scaling laws that describe how the magnetic
structuring varies from the resolved scales down to the magnetic diffusion
limit, where the field ceases to be frozen-in. The focus of the analysis is a
derivation of the magnetic energy spectrum, but we also discuss the scale
dependence of the probability density function (PDF) for the flux densities and
the role of the cancellation function for the average unsigned flux density.
Analysis of the Hinode data set with the line-ratio method reveals a collapsed
flux population in the form of flux tubes with a size distribution that is
peaked in the 10-100 km range. Magnetic energy is injected into this scale
range by the instability mechanism of flux tube collapse, which is driven by
the external gas pressure in the superadiabatic region at the top of the
convection zone. This elevates the magnetic energy spectrum just beyond the
telescope resolution limit. Flux tube decay feeds an inertial range that
cascades down the scale spectrum to the magnetic diffusion limit, and which
contains the tangled, "hidden" flux that is known to exist from observations of
the Hanle effect. The observational constraints demand that the total magnetic
energy in the hidden flux must be of the same order as the total energy in the
kG flux tubes. Both the flux tubes and the hidden flux are found to be
preferentially located in the intergranular lanes, which is to be expected
since they are physically related.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1203.4934 [pdf] - 1117469
J-state interference signatures in the Second Solar Spectrum: Modeling
the Cr I triplet at 5204-5208 A
Submitted: 2012-03-22
The scattering polarization in the solar spectrum is traditionally modeled
with each spectral line treated separately, but this is generally inadequate
for multiplets where J-state interference plays a significant role. Through
simultaneous observations of all the 3 lines of a Cr I triplet, combined with
realistic radiative transfer modeling of the data, we show that it is necessary
to include J-state interference consistently when modeling lines with partially
interacting fine structure components. Polarized line formation theory that
includes J-state interference effects together with partial frequency
redistribution for a two-term atom is used to model the observations.
Collisional frequency redistribution is also accounted for. We show that the
resonance polarization in the Cr I triplet is strongly affected by the partial
frequency redistribution effects in the line core and near wing peaks. The Cr I
triplet is quite sensitive to the temperature structure of the photospheric
layers. Our complete frequency redistribution calculations in semi-empirical
models of the solar atmosphere cannot reproduce the observed near wing
polarization or the cross-over of the Stokes Q/I line polarization about the
continuum polarization level that is due to the J-state interference. When
however partial frequency redistribution is included, a good fit to these
features can be achieved. Further, to obtain a good fit to the far wings, a
small temperature enhancement of the FALF model in the photospheric layers is
necessary.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1112.5226 [pdf] - 1092577
Bipolar Magnetic Regions on the Sun: Global Analysis of the SOHO/MDI
Data Set
Submitted: 2011-12-21
The magnetic flux that is generated by dynamo inside the Sun emerges in the
form of bipolar magnetic regions. We have analyzed the whole set of solar
magnetograms obtained with the SOHO/MDI instrument in 1995-2011, and
automatically identified 160,079 bipolar magnetic regions that span a range of
scale sizes across nearly four orders of magnitude. Their properties have been
statistically analyzed, in particular with respect to the polarity orientations
of the bipolar regions, including their tilt angle distributions. The latitude
variation of the average tilt angles (with respect to the E-W direction), known
as Joy's law, is found to closely follow the relation 32.1*sin(latitude)[deg].
There is no indication of a dependence on region size that one may expect if
the tilts were produced by the Coriolis force during the buoyant rise of flux
loops from the tachocline region. A few percent of all regions have
orientations that violate Hale's polarity law. We show examples, from different
phases of the solar cycle, where well defined medium-size bipolar regions with
opposite polarity orientations occur side by side in the same latitude zone.
Such oppositely oriented large bipolar regions cannot be part of the same
toroidal flux system, but different flux systems must coexist in the same
latitude zones. These examples are incompatible with the paradigm of coherent,
subsurface toroidal flux ropes as the source of sunspots, and instead show that
fluctuations must play a major role at all scales for the turbulent dynamo. We
see no observational support for a separation of scales or a division between a
global and a local dynamo, since also the smallest scales in the data set
retain a non-random component that significantly contributes to the accumulated
emergence of a N-S dipole moment that leads to the replacement of the old
global poloidal field with a new one that has the opposite orientation.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1105.2157 [pdf] - 1076547
Observations of the forward scattering Hanle effect in the Ca i 4227
{\AA} line
Submitted: 2011-05-11
Chromospheric magnetic fields are notoriously diffcult to measure. The
chromospheric lines are broad, while the fields are producing a minuscule
Zeeman-effect polarization. A promising diagnostic alternative is provided by
the forward-scattering Hanle effect, which can be recorded in chromospheric
lines such as the He i 10830 {\AA} and the Ca i 4227 {\AA} lines. We present a
set of spectropolarimetric observations of the full Stokes vector obtained near
the center of the solar disk in the Ca i 4227 {\AA} line with the ZIMPOL
polarimeter at the IRSOL observatory.We detect a number of interesting
forward-scattering Hanle effect signatures, which we model successfully using
polarized radiative transfer. Here we focus on the observational aspects, while
a separate companion paper deals with the theoretical modeling.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:0906.2348 [pdf] - 25209
Solar Research Programs at IRSOL, Switzerland
Submitted: 2009-06-12
The Zurich IMaging POLarimeter (ZIMPOL) developed at ETH Zurich and installed
permanently at the Gregory Coude Telescope at Istituto Ricerche Solari Locarno
(IRSOL) allows a polarimetric precision down to 10^-5 to be reached. This makes
it possible to perform several accurate spectro-polarimetric measurements of
scattering polarization and to investigate solar magnetic fields through the
signatures of the Hanle and Zeeman effects. The research programs are currently
being extended to monochromatic imaging of the Stokes vector with a recently
installed Fabry-Perot rapidly tunable filter system with a narrow pass band of
about 30mA. The spatial resolution is being improved by the installation of an
Adaptive Optics system.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:0906.2342 [pdf] - 25207
Spectropolarimetry of solar prominences
Submitted: 2009-06-12
A large set of high precision full-Stokes spectropolarimetric observations of
prominences in He-D3, Halpha and Hbeta lines has been recorded with the ZIMPOL
polarimeter at the Gregory-Coude Telescope in Locarno. The observational
technique allows us to obtain measurements free from seeing induced spurious
effects. The instrumental polarization is well under control and taken into
account in the data analysis. We present our observational results for each of
the above-mentioned lines. Of particular interest is that most of our Halpha
measurements show anti-symmetric V profiles that are a characteristic signature
of the Zeeman effect in the prominence plasma. A Stokes inversion technique
based on the quantum theory of the Hanle and Zeeman effects is being applied on
observed Stokes profiles in the He-D3 line in order to obtain information on
the magnetic field vector that confines the prominence plasma.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:0906.1184 [pdf] - 315933
Origin of spatial variations of scattering polarization in the wings of
the Ca {\sc i} 4227 \AA line
Submitted: 2009-06-05
Polarization that is produced by coherent scattering can be modified by
magnetic fields via the Hanle effect. According to standard theory the Hanle
effect should only be operating in the Doppler core of spectral lines but not
in the wings. In contrast, our observations of the scattering polarization in
the Ca {\sc i} 4227 \AA line reveals the existence of spatial variations of the
scattering polarization throughout the far line wings. This raises the question
whether the observed spatial variations in wing polarization have a magnetic or
non-magnetic origin. A magnetic origin may be possible if elastic collisions
are able to cause sufficient frequency redistribution to make the Hanle effect
effective in the wings without causing excessive collisional depolarization, as
suggested by recent theories for partial frequency redistribution with coherent
scattering in magnetic fields. To model the wing polarization we apply an
extended version of the technique based on the "last scattering approximation".
This model is highly successful in reproducing the observed Stokes $Q/I$
polarization (linear polarization parallel to the nearest solar limb),
including the location of the wing polarization maxima and the minima around
the Doppler core, but it fails to reproduce the observed spatial variations of
the wing polarization in terms of magnetic field effects with frequency
redistribution. This null result points in the direction of a non-magnetic
origin in terms of local inhomogeneities (varying collisional depolarization,
radiation-field anisotropies, and deviations from a plane-parallel atmospheric
stratification).
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:0903.4935 [pdf] - 1001794
Measuring the Hidden Aspects of Solar Magnetism
Submitted: 2009-03-27
2008 marks the 100th anniversary of the discovery of astrophysical magnetic
fields, when George Ellery Hale recorded the Zeeman splitting of spectral lines
in sunspots. With the introduction of Babcock's photoelectric magnetograph it
soon became clear that the Sun's magnetic field outside sunspots is extremely
structured. The field strengths that were measured were found to get larger
when the spatial resolution was improved. It was therefore necessary to come up
with methods to go beyond the spatial resolution limit and diagnose the
intrinsic magnetic-field properties without dependence on the quality of the
telescope used. The line-ratio technique that was developed in the early 1970s
revealed a picture where most flux that we see in magnetograms originates in
highly bundled, kG fields with a tiny volume filling factor. This led to
interpretations in terms of discrete, strong-field magnetic flux tubes embedded
in a rather field-free medium, and a whole industry of flux tube models at
increasing levels of sophistication. This magnetic-field paradigm has now been
shattered with the advent of high-precision imaging polarimeters that allow us
to apply the so-called "Second Solar Spectrum" to diagnose aspects of solar
magnetism that have been hidden to Zeeman diagnostics. It is found that the
bulk of the photospheric volume is seething with intermediately strong, tangled
fields. In the new paradigm the field behaves like a fractal with a high degree
of self-similarity, spanning about 8 orders of magnitude in scale size, down to
scales of order 10 m.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:0812.4465 [pdf] - 19811
Small-scale solar magnetic fields
Submitted: 2008-12-23
As we resolve ever smaller structures in the solar atmosphere, it has become
clear that magnetism is an important component of those small structures.
Small-scale magnetism holds the key to many poorly understood facets of solar
magnetism on all scales, such as the existence of a local dynamo, chromospheric
heating, and flux emergence, to name a few. Here, we review our knowledge of
small-scale photospheric fields, with particular emphasis on quiet-sun field,
and discuss the implications of several results obtained recently using new
instruments, as well as future prospects in this field of research.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:0709.2515 [pdf] - 5011
Hanle effect in the CN violet system with LTE modeling
Submitted: 2007-09-16
Weak entangled magnetic fields with mixed polarity occupy the main part of
the quiet Sun. The Zeeman effect diagnostics fails to measure such fields
because of cancellation in circular polarization. However, the Hanle effect
diagnostics, accessible through the second solar spectrum, provides us with a
very sensitive tool for studying the distribution of weak magnetic fields on
the Sun. Molecular lines are very strong and even dominate in some regions of
the second solar spectrum. The CN $B {}^{2} \Sigma - X {}^{2} \Sigma$ system is
one of the richest and most promising systems for molecular diagnostics and
well suited for the application of the differential Hanle effect method. The
aim is to interpret observations of the CN $B {}^{2} \Sigma - X {}^{2} \Sigma$
system using the Hanle effect and to obtain an estimation of the magnetic field
strength. We assume that the CN molecular layer is situated above the region
where the continuum radiation is formed and employ the single-scattering
approximation. Together with the Hanle effect theory this provides us with a
model that can diagnose turbulent magnetic fields. We have succeeded in fitting
modeled CN lines in several regions of the second solar spectrum to
observations and obtained a magnetic field strength in the range from 10--30 G
in the upper solar photosphere depending on the considered lines.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:0708.0599 [pdf] - 3707
A New Mechanism for Polarizing Light from Obscured Stars
Submitted: 2007-08-03
Recent spectropolarimetric observations of Herbig AeBe stellar systems show
linear polarization variability with wavelength and epoch near their obscured
H-alpha emission. Surprisingly, this polarization is not coincident with the
H-alpha emission peak but is variable near the absorptive part of the line
profile. With a new and novel model we show here that this is evidence of
optical pumping - anisotropy of the incident radiation that leads to a linear
polarization-dependent optical depth within the intervening hydrogen wind or
disk cloud. This effect can yield a larger polarization signal than scattering
polarization in these systems.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:0704.2828 [pdf] - 628
Are "EIT Waves" Fast-Mode MHD Waves?
Submitted: 2007-04-23
We examine the nature of large-scale, coronal, propagating wave fronts (``EIT
waves'') and find they are incongruous with solutions using fast-mode MHD
plane-wave theory. Specifically, we consider the following properties:
non-dispersive single pulse manifestions, observed velocities below the local
Alfven speed, and different pulses which travel at any number of constant
velocities, rather than at the ``predicted'' fast-mode speed. We discuss the
possibility of a soliton-like explanation for these phenomena, and show how it
is consistent with the above-mentioned aspects.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0610588 [pdf] - 260807
First polarimetric measurements and modeling of the Paschen-Back effect
in CaH transitions
Submitted: 2006-10-19
We report the first spectropolarimetric observations and modeling of CaH
transitions in sunspots. We have detected strong polarization signals in many
CaH lines from the A-X system, and we provide the first successful fit to the
observed Stokes profiles using the previously developed theory of the
Paschen-Back effect in arbitrary electronic states of diatomic molecules and
polarized radiative transfer in molecular lines in stellar atmospheres. We
analyze the CaH Stokes profiles together with quasi-simultaneous observations
in TiO bands and conclude that CaH provides a valuable diagnostic of magnetic
fields in sunspots, starspots, cool stars, and brown dwarfs.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0502263 [pdf] - 71054
Absence of linear polarization in Halpha emission of solar flares
Submitted: 2005-02-14
High sensitivity observations of Halpha polarization of 30 flares of
different sizes and disk positions are reported. Both filter and spectrographic
techniques have been used. The ZIMPOL system eliminates spurious polarizations
due to seeing and flat-field effects. We didn't find any clear linear
polarization signature above our sensitivity level which was usually better
than 0.1%. The observations include an X17.1 flare with gamma-ray lines
reported by the RHESSI satellite. These results cast serious doubts on previous
claims of linear polarization at the one percent level and more, attributed to
impact polarization. The absence of linear polarization limits the anisotropy
of energetic protons in the H$\alpha$ emitting region. The likely causes are
isotropization by collisions with neutrals in the chromosphere and defocusing
by the converging magnetic field.