Normalized to: Steinberg, E.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.05562 [pdf] - 2077434
Direct evidence for shock-powered optical emission in a nova
Aydi, Elias;
Sokolovsky, Kirill V.;
Chomiuk, Laura;
Steinberg, Elad;
Li, Kwan Lok;
Vurm, Indrek;
Metzger, Brian D.;
Strader, Jay;
Mukai, Koji;
Pejcha, Ondřej;
Shen, Ken J.;
Wade, Gregg A.;
Kuschnig, Rainer;
Moffat, Anthony F. J.;
Pablo, Herbert;
Pigulski, Andrzej;
Popowicz, Adam;
Weiss, Werner;
Zwintz, Konstanze;
Izzo, Luca;
Pollard, Karen R.;
Handler, Gerald;
Ryder, Stuart D.;
Filipović, Miroslav D.;
Alsaberi, Rami Z. E.;
Manojlović, Perica;
de Oliveira, Raimundo Lopes;
Walter, Frederick M.;
Vallely, Patrick J.;
Buckley, David A. H.;
Brown, Michael J. I.;
Harvey, Eamonn J.;
Kawash, Adam;
Kniazev, Alexei;
Kochanek, Christopher S.;
Linford, Justin;
Mikolajewska, Joanna;
Molaro, Paolo;
Orio, Marina;
Page, Kim L.;
Shappee, Benjamin J.;
Sokoloski, Jennifer L.
Submitted: 2020-04-12
Classical novae are thermonuclear explosions that occur on the surfaces of
white dwarf stars in interacting binary systems (Bode & Evans 2008). It has
long been thought that the luminosity of classical novae is powered by
continued nuclear burning on the surface of the white dwarf after the initial
runaway (Gallaher & Starrfield 1978). However, recent observations of GeV
$\gamma$-rays from classical novae have hinted that shocks internal to the nova
ejecta may dominate the nova emission. Shocks have also been suggested to power
the luminosity of events as diverse as stellar mergers (Metzger & Pejcha 2017),
supernovae (Moriya et al. 2018), and tidal disruption events (Roth et al.
2016), but observational confirmation has been lacking. Here we report
simultaneous space-based optical and $\gamma$-ray observations of the 2018 nova
V906 Carinae (ASASSN-18fv), revealing a remarkable series of distinct
correlated flares in both bands. The optical and $\gamma$-ray flares occur
simultaneously, implying a common origin in shocks. During the flares, the nova
luminosity doubles, implying that the bulk of the luminosity is shock-powered.
Furthermore, we detect concurrent but weak X-ray emission from deeply embedded
shocks, confirming that the shock power does not appear in the X-ray band and
supporting its emergence at longer wavelengths. Our data, spanning the spectrum
from radio to $\gamma$-ray, provide direct evidence that shocks can power
substantial luminosity in classical novae and other optical transients.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.01700 [pdf] - 2025673
Internal Shocks from Variable Outflows in Classical Novae
Submitted: 2019-08-05, last modified: 2019-11-21
We present one-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations including radiative
losses, of internal shocks in the outflows from classical novae, to explore the
role of shocks in powering multi-wavelength emission from radio to gamma-ray
wavelengths. Observations support a picture in which the initial phases of some
novae generate a slow, equatorially-focused outflow (directly from the outer
Lagrange point, or from a circumbinary disk), which then transitions to, or is
overtaken by, a faster more isotropic outflow from the white dwarf which
collides and shocks the slower flow, powering gamma-ray and optical emission
through reprocessing by the ejecta. However, the common occurence of multiple
peaks in nova light curves suggests that the outflow's acceleration need not be
monotonic, but instead can involve successive transitions between "fast" and
"slow" modes. Such a time-fluctuating outflow velocity naturally can reproduce
several observed properties of nova, such as correlated gamma-ray and optical
flares, expansion of the photosphere coincident with (though lagging slightly)
the peak flare luminosity, and complex time-evolution of spectral lines
(including accelerating, decelerating, and merging velocity components). While
the shocks are still deeply embedded during the gamma-ray emission, the onset
of $\sim$ keV X-ray and $\sim 10$ GHz radio synchrotron emission is typically
delayed until the forward shock of the outermost monolithic shell (created by
merger of multiple internal shock-generated shells) reaches a sufficiently low
column through the dense external medium generated by the earliest phase of the
outburst.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.02575 [pdf] - 1901835
Radio Emission from the unbound Debris of Tidal Disruption Events
Submitted: 2019-03-06, last modified: 2019-06-04
When a star gets too close to a supermassive black hole, it is torn apart by
the tidal forces. Roughly half of the stellar mass becomes unbound and flies
away at tremendous velocities - around $10^4$ km/s. In this work we explore the
idea that the shock produced by the interaction of the unbound debris with the
ambient medium gives rise to the synchrotron radio emission observed in several
TDEs. We use a moving mesh numerical simulation to study the evolution of the
unbound debris and the bow shock around it. We find that as the periapse
distance of the star decreases, the outflow becomes faster and wider. A tidal
disruption event whose periapse distance is a factor of 7 smaller than the
tidal radius can account for the radio emission observed in ASASSN-14li. This
model also allows us to obtain a more accurate estimate for the gas density
around the centre of the host galaxy of ASASSN-14li.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.03898 [pdf] - 1868150
Thawing the frozen-in approximation: implications for self-gravity in
deeply plunging tidal disruption events
Submitted: 2019-03-09, last modified: 2019-04-02
The tidal destruction of a star by a massive black hole, known as a tidal
disruption event (TDE), is commonly modeled using the "frozen-in"
approximation. Under this approximation, the star maintains exact hydrostatic
balance prior to entering the tidal sphere (radius $r_{\rm t}$), after which
point its internal pressure and self-gravity become instantaneously negligible
and the debris undergoes ballistic free fall. We present a suite of
hydrodynamical simulations of TDEs with high penetration factors $\beta \equiv
r_{\rm t}/r_{\rm p} = 5-7$, where $r_{\rm p}$ is the pericenter of the stellar
center of mass, calculated using a Voronoi-based moving-mesh technique. We show
that basic assumptions of the frozen-in model, such as the neglect of
self-gravity inside $r_{\rm t}$, are violated. Indeed, roughly equal fractions
of the final energy spread accumulate exiting and entering the tidal sphere,
though the frozen-in prediction is correct at the order-of-magnitude level. We
also show that an $\mathcal{O}(1)$ fraction of the debris mass remains
transversely confined by self-gravity even for large $\beta$ which has
implications for the radio emission from the unbound debris and, potentially,
for the circularization efficiency of the bound streams.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.08134 [pdf] - 1851879
Astro2020 Science White Paper: A Shocking Shift in Paradigm for
Classical Novae
Chomiuk, Laura;
Aydi, Elias;
Babul, Aliya-Nur;
Derdzinski, Andrea;
Kawash, Adam;
Li, Kwan-Lok;
Linford, Justin;
Metzger, Brian D.;
Mukai, Koji;
Rupen, Michael P.;
Sokoloski, Jennifer;
Sokolovsky, Kirill;
Steinberg, Elad
Submitted: 2019-03-19
The discovery of GeV gamma-rays from classical novae has led to a
reassessment of these garden-variety explosions, and highlighted their
importance for understanding radiative shocks, particle acceleration, and dust
formation in more exotic, distant transients. Recent collaboration between
observers and theorists has revealed that shocks in novae are energetically
important, and can even dominate their bolometric luminosity. Shocks may also
explain long-standing mysteries in novae such as dust production,
super-Eddington luminosities, and `flares' in optical light curves. Here, we
highlight the multi-wavelength facilities of the next decade that will further
test our nova shock model and fulfill the promise of novae as powerful
astrophysical laboratories.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.03223 [pdf] - 1709457
The Multi-Dimensional Structure of Radiative Shocks: Suppressed Thermal
X-rays and Relativistic Ion Acceleration
Submitted: 2018-05-08, last modified: 2018-06-08
Radiative shocks, behind which gas cools faster than the dynamical time, play
a key role in many astrophysical transients, including classical novae and
young supernovae interacting with circumstellar material. The dense layer
behind high Mach number $\mathcal{M} \gg 1$ radiative shocks is susceptible to
thin-shell instabilities, creating a "corrugated" shock interface. We present
two and three-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations of optically-thin
radiative shocks to study their thermal radiation and acceleration of
non-thermal relativistic ions. We employ a moving-mesh code and a specialized
numerical technique to eliminate artificial heat conduction across grid cells.
The fraction of the shock's luminosity $L_{\rm tot}$ radiated at X-ray
temperatures $kT_{\rm sh} \approx (3/16)\mu m_p v_{\rm sh}^{2}$ expected from a
one-dimensional analysis is suppressed by a factor $L(>T_{\rm sh}/3)/L_{\rm
tot} \approx 4.5/\mathcal{M}^{4/3}$ for $\mathcal{M} \approx 4-36$. This
suppression results in part from weak shocks driven into under-pressured cold
filaments by hot shocked gas, which sap thermal energy from the latter faster
than it is radiated. Combining particle-in-cell simulation results for
diffusive shock acceleration with the inclination angle distribution across the
shock (relative to an upstream magnetic field in the shock plane$-$the expected
geometry for transient outflows), we predict the efficiency and energy spectrum
of ion acceleration. Though negligible acceleration is predicted for adiabatic
shocks, the corrugated shock front enables local regions to satisfy the
quasi-parallel magnetic field geometry required for efficient acceleration,
resulting in an average acceleration efficiency of $\epsilon_{\rm nth} \sim
0.005-0.02$ for $\mathcal{M} \approx 12-36$, in agreement with modeling of the
gamma-ray nova ASASSN-16ma.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.09105 [pdf] - 1663414
Instability of Supersonic Cold Streams Feeding Galaxies II. Nonlinear
Evolution of Surface and Body Modes of Kelvin-Helmholtz Instability
Submitted: 2018-03-24
As part of our long-term campaign to understand how cold streams feed massive
galaxies at high redshift, we study the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability (KHI) of a
supersonic, cold, dense gas stream as it penetrates through a hot, dilute
circumgalactic medium (CGM). A linear analysis (Paper I) showed that, for
realistic conditions, KHI may produce nonlinear perturbations to the stream
during infall. Therefore, we proceed here to study the nonlinear stage of KHI,
still limited to a two-dimensional slab with no radiative cooling or gravity.
Using analytic models and numerical simulations, we examine stream breakup,
deceleration and heating via surface modes and body modes. The relevant
parameters are the density contrast between stream and CGM ($\delta$), the Mach
number of the stream velocity with respect to the CGM ($M_{\rm b}$) and the
stream radius relative to the halo virial radius ($R_{\rm s}/R_{\rm v}$). We
find that sufficiently thin streams disintegrate prior to reaching the central
galaxy. The condition for breakup ranges from $R_{\rm s} < 0.03 R_{\rm v}$ for
$(M_{\rm b} \sim 0.75, \delta \sim 10)$ to $R_{\rm s} < 0.003 R_{\rm v}$ for
$(M_{\rm b} \sim 2.25, \delta \sim 100)$. However, due to the large stream
inertia, KHI has only a small effect on the stream inflow rate and a small
contribution to heating and subsequent Lyman-$\alpha$ cooling emission.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.00941 [pdf] - 1643707
Ignition of detonation in accreted helium
Submitted: 2018-03-02
Sub-Chandrasekhar CO white dwarfs accreting helium have been considered as
candidates for Type Ia supernova(SNIa) progenitors since the early 1980s
(helium shell mass $> 0.1 M_\odot $). These models, once detonated did not fit
the observed spectra and light curve of typical SNIa observations. New
theoretical work examined detonations on much less massive ($< 0.05 M_\odot $)
envelopes. They find stable detonations that lead to light curves, spectra and
abundances that compare relatively well with the observational data. The exact
mechanism leading to the ignition of helium detonation is a key issue, since it
is a mandatory first step for the whole scenario. As the flow of the accreted
envelope is unstable to convection long before any hydrodynamic phenomena
develops, a multidimensional approach is needed in order to study the ignition
process. The complex convective reactive flow is challenging to any
hydrodynamical solver. To the best of our knowledge, all previous 2D studies
ignited the detonation artificially. We present here, for the first time, fully
consistent results from two hydrodynamical 2D solvers that adopt two
independent accurate schemes. For both solvers an effort was made to overcome
the problematics raised by the finite resolution and numerical diffusion by the
advective terms. Our best models lead to the ignition of a detonation in a
convective cell. Our results are robust and the agreement between the two
different numerical approaches is very good.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.10337 [pdf] - 1771463
Probing the Gas Density in our Galactic Center: Moving Mesh Simulations
of G2
Steinberg, Elad;
Sari, Re'em;
Gnat, Orly;
Gillessen, Stefan;
Plewa, Philipp;
Genzel, Reinhard;
Eisenhauer, Frank;
Ott, Thomas;
Pfuhl, Oliver;
Habibi, Maryam;
Waisberg, Idel;
von Fellenberg, Sebastiano;
Dexter, Jason;
Bauböck, Michi
Submitted: 2017-05-29, last modified: 2017-09-28
The G2 object has recently passed its pericenter passage in our Galactic
Center. While the $Br_\gamma$ emission shows clear signs of tidal interaction,
the change in the observed luminosity is only of about a factor of 2, in
contention with all previous predictions.
We present high resolution simulations performed with the moving mesh code,
RICH, together with simple analytical arguments that reproduce the observed
$Br_\gamma$ emission. In our model, G2 is a gas cloud that undergoes tidal
disruption in a dilute ambient medium. We find that during pericenter passage,
the efficient cooling of the cloud results in a vertical collapse, compressing
the cloud by a factor of $\sim5000$. By properly taking into account the
ionization state of the gas, we find that the cloud is UV starved and are able
to reproduce the observed $Br_\gamma$ luminosity.
For densities larger than $\approx500\;\mathrm{cm}^{-3}$ at pericenter, the
cloud fragments, due to cooling instabilities and the emitted radiation is
inconsistent with observations. For lower densities, the cloud survives the
pericenter passage intact and its emitted radiation matches the observed
lightcurve.
From the duration of $Br_\gamma$ emission which contains both redshifted and
blueshifted components, we show that the cloud is not spherical but rather
elongated with a size ratio of 4 at year 2001. The simulated cloud's elongation
grows as it travels towards pericenter and is consistent with observations, due
to viewing angles. The simulation is also consistent with having a spherical
shape at apocenter.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1606.06289 [pdf] - 1482289
Instability of Supersonic Cold Streams Feeding Galaxies I: Linear
Kelvin-Helmholtz Instability with Body Modes
Submitted: 2016-06-20, last modified: 2016-09-18
Massive galaxies at high redshift are predicted to be fed from the cosmic web
by narrow, dense, cold streams. These streams penetrate supersonically through
the hot medium encompassed by a stable shock near the virial radius of the
dark-matter halo. Our long-term goal is to explore the heating and dissipation
rate of the streams and their fragmentation and possible breakup, in order to
understand how galaxies are fed, and how this affects their star-formation rate
and morphology. We present here the first step, where we analyze the linear
Kelvin-Helmholtz instability (KHI) of a cold, dense slab or cylinder flowing
through a hot, dilute medium in the transonic regime. The current analysis is
limited to the adiabatic case with no gravity and assuming equal pressure in
the stream and the medium. By analytically solving the linear dispersion
relation, we find a transition from a dominance of the familiar rapidly growing
surface modes in the subsonic regime to more slowly growing body modes in the
supersonic regime. The system is parameterized by three parameters: the density
contrast between the stream and the medium, the Mach number of stream velocity
with respect to the medium, and the stream width with respect to the halo
virial radius. We find that a realistic choice for these parameters places the
streams near the mode transition, with the KHI exponential-growth time in the
range 0.01-10 virial crossing times for a perturbation wavelength comparable to
the stream width. We confirm our analytic predictions with idealized
hydrodynamical simulations. Our linear-KHI estimates thus indicate that KHI may
in principle be effective in the evolution of streams by the time they reach
the galaxy. More definite conclusions await the extension of the analysis to
the nonlinear regime and the inclusion of cooling, thermal conduction, the halo
potential well, self-gravity and magnetic fields.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.06753 [pdf] - 1392941
Grid Noise in Moving Mesh Codes: Fixing The Volume Inconsistency Problem
Submitted: 2016-03-18
Current Voronoi based moving mesh hydro codes suffer from "grid noise". We
identify the cause of this noise as the volume inconsistency error, where the
volume that is transferred between cells is inconsistent with the
hydrodynamical calculations. As a result, the codes do not achieve second order
convergence. In this paper we describe how a simple fix allows Voronoi based
moving mesh codes to attain second order convergence. The fix is based on the
understanding that the volume exchanged between cells should be consistent with
the hydrodynamical calculations. We benchmark our fix with three test problems
and show that it can significantly improve the computational accuracy. We also
examine the effect of initial mesh initialization and present an improved model
for the Green-Gauss based gradient estimator.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1406.5730 [pdf] - 937692
Spins of large asteroids: Hint on a primordial distribution of their
spin rates
Submitted: 2014-06-22, last modified: 2015-02-19
The Asteroid Belt and the Kuiper Belt are relics from the formation of our
solar system. Understanding the size and spin distribution of the two belts is
crucial for a deeper understanding of the formation of our solar system and the
dynamical process that govern it. In this paper, we investigate the effect of
collisions on the evolution of the spin distribution of asteroids and KBO's.
We find that the power law nature of the impactors' size distribution leads
to a L\'evy distribution of the spin rates. This results in a power law tail of
the spin distribution, in stark contrast to the usually quoted Maxwellian
distribution. We show that for bodies larger than 10 km, collisions alone lead
to spin rates peaking at 0.15-0.5 revolutions per day. Comparing that to the
observed spin rates of large asteroids ($R>50$ km), we find that the spins of
large asteroids, peaking at $\sim1-2$ revolutions per day, are dominated by a
primordial component that reflects the formation mechanism of the asteroids.
Similarly, the Kuiper Belt has undergone virtually no collisional spin
evolution, assuming current day density. Collisions contribute a spin rate of
$\sim0.01$ revolutions per day, thus the observed fast spin rates of KBOs are
also primordial in nature.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1408.3196 [pdf] - 1216299
Balancing the load: A Voronoi based scheme for parallel computations
Submitted: 2014-08-14, last modified: 2014-12-16
The use of numerical simulations in science is ever increasing and with it
the computational size. In many cases single processors are no longer adequate
and simulations are run on multiple core machines or supercomputers. One of the
key issues when running a simulation on multiple CPUs is maintaining a proper
load balance throughout the run and minimizing communications between CPUs.
We propose a novel method of utilizing a Voronoi diagram to achieve a nearly
perfect load balance without the need of any global redistributions of data. As
a show case, we implement our method in RICH, a 2D moving mesh hydrodynamical
code, but it can be extended trivially to other codes in 2D or 3D. Our tests
show that this method is indeed efficient and can be used in a large variety of
existing hydrodynamical codes as well as other applications.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1407.4354 [pdf] - 1215710
The Galactic Center cloud G2 and its gas streamer
Pfuhl, Oliver;
Gillessen, Stefan;
Eisenhauer, Frank;
Genzel, Reinhard;
Plewa, Philipp M.;
Ott, Thomas;
Ballone, Alessandro;
Schartmann, Marc;
Burkert, Andreas;
Fritz, Tobias K.;
Sari, Re'em;
Steinberg, Elad;
Madigan, Ann-Marie
Submitted: 2014-07-16, last modified: 2014-11-05
We present new, deep near-infrared SINFONI @ VLT integral field spectroscopy
of the gas cloud G2 in the Galactic Center, from late summer 2013 and spring
2014. G2 is visible in recombination line emission. The spatially resolved
kinematic data track the ongoing tidal disruption. As expected for an
observation near pericenter passage, roughly half of the gas in 2014 is found
at the redshifted, pre-pericenter side of the orbit, while the other half is at
the post-pericenter, blueshifted side. We also present an orbital solution for
the gas cloud G1, which was discovered a decade ago in L'-band images when it
was spatially almost coincident with Sgr A*. The orientation of the G1 orbit in
the three angles is almost identical to the one of G2, but it has a lower
eccentricity and smaller semi-major axis. We show that the observed astrometric
positions and radial velocities of G1 are compatible with the G2 orbit,
assuming that (i) G1 was originally on the G2 orbit preceding G2 by 13 years
and (ii) a simple drag force acted on it during pericenter passage. Taken
together with the previously described tail of G2, which we detect in
recombination line emission and thermal broadband emission, we propose that G2
may be a bright knot in a much more extensive gas streamer. This matches purely
gaseous models for G2, such as a stellar wind clump or the tidal debris from a
partial disruption of a star.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.3219 [pdf] - 1222528
Rich: Open Source Hydrodynamic Simulation on a Moving Voronoi Mesh
Submitted: 2014-10-13
We present here RICH, a state of the art 2D hydrodynamic code based on
Godunov's method, on an unstructured moving mesh (the acronym stands for Racah
Institute Computational Hydrodynamics). This code is largely based on the code
AREPO. It differs from AREPO in the interpolation and time advancement scheme
as well as a novel parallelization scheme based on Voronoi tessellation. Using
our code we study the pros and cons of a moving mesh (in comparison to a static
mesh). We also compare its accuracy to other codes. Specifically, we show that
our implementation of external sources and time advancement scheme is more
accurate and robust than AREPO's, when the mesh is allowed to move. We
performed a parameter study of the cell rounding mechanism (Llyod iterations)
and it effects. We find that in most cases a moving mesh gives better results
than a static mesh, but it is not universally true. In the case where matter
moves in one way, and a sound wave is traveling in the other way (such that
relative to the grid the wave is not moving) a static mesh gives better results
than a moving mesh. Moreover, we show that Voronoi based moving mesh schemes
suffer from an error, that is resolution independent, due to inconsistencies
between the flux calculation and change in the area of a cell. Our code is
publicly available as open source and designed in an object oriented, user
friendly way that facilitates incorporation of new algorithms and physical
processes.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1203.6072 [pdf] - 540166
Sterile and Fertile Planetary Systems - Statistical Analysis of
Multi-Planet Systems in Kepler's data
Submitted: 2012-03-27, last modified: 2012-07-20
The Kepler mission has discovered a large number of planetary systems. We
analyze the implications of the discovered single/multi-exoplanet systems from
Kepler's data.
As done in previous works, we test a simple model in which the intrinsic
occurrence of planet is an independent process, and with equal probability
around all planet producing stars. This leads to a Poisson distribution for the
intrinsic number of planets around each host. However, the possibility of
zero/low mutual inclination is taken into account, creating a correlation
between detecting different planets in a given stellar system, leading to a non
Poisson distribution for the number of transiting planets per system. Comparing
the model's predictions with the observations made by Kepler, we find that the
correlation produced by planarity is insufficient and a higher correlation is
needed; either the formation of one planet in the system enhances the
likelihood of other planets to form, and/or that some stars are considerably
more fertile than others. Kepler's data presents evidences that both
correlations might play a part, in particular a significant dependency in the
radial distribution of planets in multi-planet systems is shown. Followup
observations on Kepler planet's hosts can help pinpoint the physical nature of
this correlation.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1010.2676 [pdf] - 291088
Binary YORP and Evolution of Binary Asteroids
Submitted: 2010-10-13, last modified: 2010-12-21
The rotation states of kilometer sized near earth asteroids are known to be
affected by the YORP effect. In a related effect, Binary YORP (BYORP) the
orbital properties of a binary asteroid evolves under a radiation effect mostly
acting on a tidally locked secondary. The BYORP effect can alter the orbital
elements in $\sim 10^{4-5}$ years for a $D_{p}=2\;km$ primary with a
$D_{s}=0.4\; km$ secondary at $1\; AU$. It can either separate the binary
components or cause them to collide. In this paper we devise a simple approach
to calculate the YORP effect on asteroids and BYORP effect on binaries
including $J_2$ effects due to primary oblateness and the sun. We apply this to
asteroids with known shapes as well as a set of randomly generated bodies with
various degrees of smoothness. We find a strong correlation between the
strengths of an asteroid's YORP and BYORP effects. Therefore, a statistical
knowledge on one, could be used to estimate the effect of the other. We show
that the action of BYORP preferentially shrinks rather than expands the binary
orbit and that YORP preferentially slows down asteroids. This conclusion holds
for the two extremes of thermal conductivities studied in this work and
assuming the asteroid reaches a stable point, but may break down for moderate
thermal conductivity. The YORP and BYORP effects are shown to be smaller than
what could be naively expected due to near cancellation of the effects on small
scales. Taking this near cancellation into account, a simple order of magnitude
estimate of the YORP and BYORP effects as function of the sizes and smoothness
of the bodies is calculated. Finally, we provide a simple proof showing that
there is no secular effect due to absorption of radiation in BYORP.