Normalized to: Steigman, G.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.10059 [pdf] - 1626598
Is The Universal Matter - Antimatter Asymmetry Fine Tuned?
Submitted: 2018-01-30
The asymmetry between matter and antimatter is key to the existence and
nature of our Universe. A measure of the matter - antimatter asymmetry of the
Universe is provided by the present value of the universal ratio of baryons
(baryons minus antibaryons) to photons (or the ratio of baryons to entropy).
The baryon asymmetry parameter is an important physical and cosmological
parameter. But how fine tuned is it? A "natural" value for this parameter is
zero, corresponding to equal amounts of matter and antimatter. Another, also
possibly natural, choice for this dimensionless parameter would be of order
unity, corresponding to nearly equal amounts (by number) of matter (and
essentially no antimatter) and photons in every comoving volume. However,
observations suggest that in the Universe we inhabit the value of this
parameter is nonzero, but smaller than this natural value by some nine to ten
orders of magnitude. In this contribution we review the evidence that our
Universe does not contain equal amounts of matter and antimatter. Any change in
the magnitude of the baryon asymmetry parameter necessarily leads to a universe
with physical characteristics different from those in our own. The degree of
fine tuning in the baryon asymmetry parameter is determined by the width of the
range over which it can be varied and still allow for the existence of life.
Our results suggest that the baryon asymmetry parameter can be varied over a
very wide range without impacting the prospects for life; this result is not
suggestive of fine tuning. [abridged]
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1502.01884 [pdf] - 1224345
CMB Constraints On The Thermal WIMP Mass And Annihilation Cross Section
Submitted: 2015-02-06, last modified: 2015-03-05
A thermal relic, often referred to as a weakly interacting massive particle
(WIMP), is a particle produced during the early evolution of the Universe whose
present (relic) abundance depends only on its mass and its thermally averaged
annihilation cross section (annihilation rate factor) sigma*v_ann. Late time
WIMP annihilation has the potential to affect the cosmic microwave background
(CMB) power spectrum. Current observational constraints on the absence of such
effects provide bounds on the mass and the annihilation cross section of relic
particles that may, but need not be dark matter candidates. For a WIMP that is
a dark matter candidate, the CMB constraint sets an upper bound to the
annihilation cross section, leading to a lower bound to its mass that depends
on whether or not the WIMP is its own antiparticle. For a self-conjugate WIMP,
m_min = 50f GeV, where f is an electromagnetic energy efficiency factor. For a
non self-conjugate WIMP, the minimum mass is a factor of two larger. For a WIMP
that is a subdominant component of the dark matter density there is no bound on
its mass and the upper bound to its annihilation cross section imposed by the
CMB transforms into a lower bound to its annihilation cross section. These
results are outlined and quantified here using the latest CMB constraints for a
stable, symmetric (equal number of particles and antiparticles), WIMP whose
annihilation is s-wave dominated, and for particles that are, or are not, their
own antiparticle.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1411.6005 [pdf] - 980206
BBN And The CMB Constrain Neutrino Coupled Light WIMPs
Submitted: 2014-11-21, last modified: 2015-02-12
(abridged) In the presence of a light WIMP (mass m_chi < 30 MeV), there are
degeneracies among the WIMP's nature, its couplings to standard model
particles, its mass, and the number of equivalent (additional) neutrinos, Delta
N_nu. These degeneracies cannot be broken by the CMB constraint on the
effective number of neutrinos, N_eff. However, since big bang nucleosynthesis
(BBN) is also affected by a light WIMP and equivalent neutrinos, complementary
BBN and CMB constraints can break some of the degeneracy. In a previous paper
BBN and CMB were combined to explore allowed ranges for m_chi, Delta N_nu, and
N_eff for light WIMPs that annihilate electromagnetically (EM) to photons
and/or electrons/positrons. In this paper BBN predictions with a light WIMP
that only couples to neutrinos are calculated. Recent observed abundances of
^2H and ^4He are used to limit m_chi, Delta N_nu, N_eff, and the present-day
baryon density. Allowing for a neutrino coupled light WIMP and nonzero Delta
N_nu, combined BBN and CMB data give lower limits to m_chi, with a best fit
m_chi > 35 MeV, equivalent to no light WIMP at all. All masses below 4--9 MeV
(depending on spin) are excluded. Without any light WIMP, BBN alone prefers
Delta N_nu = 0.50 +- 0.23, favoring neither Delta N_nu = 0, nor a fully
thermalized sterile neutrino (Delta N_nu = 1). This result is consistent with
the CMB constraint, N_eff = 3.30 +- 0.27, limiting "new physics" between BBN
and recombination. Combining BBN and CMB data gives Delta N_nu = 0.35 +- 0.16
and N_eff = 3.40 +- 0.16; while BBN and the CMB combined require Delta N_nu > 0
at ~98% confidence, they disfavor Delta N_nu > 1 at > 99% confidence. Allowing
a neutrino-coupled light WIMP extends the allowed range slightly downward for
Delta N_nu and slightly upward for N_eff simultaneously, leaving best-fit
values unchanged.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1312.5725 [pdf] - 812504
BBN And The CMB Constrain Light, Electromagnetically Coupled WIMPs
Submitted: 2013-12-19, last modified: 2014-04-04
(Abridged) In the presence of a light WIMP (< 30 MeV), there are degeneracies
among the nature of the WIMP, its couplings to standard model particles, its
mass m_chi, and the number of equivalent neutrinos beyond the standard model,
Delta N_nu. These degeneracies cannot be broken by the CMB constraint on the
effective number of neutrinos, N_eff. However, big bang nucleosynthesis (BBN)
is affected by a light WIMP and equivalent neutrinos, so the combination of BBN
and CMB can break some of the degeneracies. Here, BBN predictions for
abundances in the presence of a light WIMP and equivalent neutrinos are
explored, and estimates of their observationally determined relic abundances
are used to limit m_chi, Delta N_nu, and the present Universe baryon density
(Omega_B h^2). These constraints are explored for Majorana and Dirac fermion
WIMPs, as well as for real and complex scalar WIMPs that couple to electrons,
positrons, and photons. In a separate paper this analysis is repeated for WIMPs
that couple only to the standard model neutrinos, and constraints for the two
cases are contrasted. Without a light WIMP but allowing for equivalent
neutrinos, the combined BBN and CMB constraints favor N_eff = 3.46 +/- 0.17,
Omega_B h^2 = 0.0224 +/- 0.0003, and Delta N_nu = 0.40 +/- 0.17. In this case,
standard BBN (Delta N_nu = 0) is disfavored at ~98% confidence, and the
presence of one sterile neutrino (Delta N_nu = 1) is disfavored at > 99%
confidence. Allowing a light WIMP and Delta N_nu equivalent neutrinos together,
the combined BBN and CMB data provide lower limits to the WIMP masses (> 0.5 -
5 MeV) that depend on the nature of the WIMP, favor m_chi ~8 MeV slightly over
no WIMP, and loosen constraints on equivalent neutrinos, Delta N_nu =
0.65+0.46-0.35. While Delta N_nu = 0 is still disfavored at ~95% confidence
with a light WIMP, Delta N_nu = 1 is now allowed.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.5399 [pdf] - 787346
Light WIMPs And Equivalent Neutrinos
Submitted: 2014-02-21
Very light WIMPs (chi), thermal relics that annihilate late in the early
Universe, change the energy and entropy densities at BBN and at recombination.
BBN, in combination with the CMB, can remove some of the degeneracies among
light WIMPs and equivalent neutrinos, constraining the existence and properties
of each. Depending on the nature of the light WIMP (Majorana or Dirac fermion,
real or complex scalar) the joint BBN + CMB analyses set lower bounds to m_chi
in the range 0.5 - 5 MeV (m_chi/m_e > 1 - 10), and they identify best fit
values for m_chi in the range 5 - 10 MeV. The joint BBN + CMB analysis finds a
best fit value for the number of equivalent neutrinos, Delta N_nu ~ 0.65,
nearly independent of the nature of the WIMP. In the absence of a light WIMP
(m_chi > 20 MeV), N_eff = 3.05(1 + Delta N_nu /3). In this case, there is
excellent agreement between BBN and the CMB, but the joint fit reveals Delta
N_nu = 0.40+-0.17, disfavoring standard big bang nucleosynthesis (SBBN) (Delta
N_nu = 0) at ~ 2.4 sigma, as well as a sterile neutrino (Delta N_nu = 1) at ~
3.5 sigma. The best BBN + CMB joint fit disfavors the absence of dark radiation
(Delta N_nu = 0 at ~ 95% confidence), while allowing for the presence of a
sterile neutrino (Delta N_nu = 1 at ~ 1 sigma). For all cases considered here,
the lithium problem persists. These results, presented at the TAUP 2013
Conference, are based on Nollett & Steigman (2013).
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1401.5488 [pdf] - 774683
Light WIMPs, Equivalent Neutrinos, BBN, and the CMB
Submitted: 2014-01-21
Recent updates to the observational determinations of the primordial
abundances of helium and deuterium are compared to the predictions of BBN to
infer the universal ratio of baryons to photons (or, the present Universe
baryon mass density parameter Omega_B h^2), as well as to constrain the
effective number of neutrinos (N_eff) and the number of equivalent neutrinos
(Delta N_nu). These BBN results are compared to those derived independently
from the Planck CMB data. In the absence of a light WIMP (chi), N_eff = 3.05(1
+ Delta N_nu/3). In this case, there is excellent agreement between BBN and the
CMB, but the joint fit finds that Delta N_nu = 0.40 +/- 0.17, disfavoring
standard big bang nucleosynthesis (SBBN: Delta N_nu = 0) at 2.4 sigma, as well
as a sterile neutrino (Delta N_nu = 1) at 3.5 sigma. In the presence of a light
WIMP, the relation between N_eff and Delta N_nu depends on the WIMP mass,
leading to degeneracies among N_eff, Delta N_nu, and m_chi. The complementary
and independent BBN and CMB data can break some of these degeneracies.
Depending on the nature of the light WIMP (Majorana or Dirac fermion, real or
complex scalar) the joint BBN + CMB analyses set a lower bound to m_chi in the
range from 0.5 to 5 MeV, and they identify best fit values for m_chi in the
range from 5 to 10 MeV. The joint BBN + CMB analyses find a best fit value for
the number of equivalent neutrinos, Delta N_nu = 0.65, nearly independent of
the nature of the WIMP. The best fit still disfavors the absence of dark
radiation (Delta N_nu = 0 at 95% confidence), while allowing for the presence
of a sterile neutrino (Delta N_nu = 1 at less than 1 sigma). For all cases
considered here, the lithium problem persists. These results, presented at the
2013 Rencontres de l'Observatoire de Paris - ESO Workshop, are based on Nollett
& Steigman 2013 (arXiv:1312.5725 [astro-ph.CO]).
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1303.0049 [pdf] - 667582
Equivalent Neutrinos, Light WIMPs, and the Chimera of Dark Radiation
Submitted: 2013-02-28, last modified: 2013-03-18
According to conventional wisdom, in the standard model (SM) of particle
physics and cosmology the effective number of neutrinos is Neff=3 (more
precisely, 3.046). In extensions of the standard model allowing for the
presence of DeltaNnu equivalent neutrinos (or dark radiation), Neff is
generally >3. The canonical results are reconsidered here, revealing that a
measurement of Neff>3 can be consistent with DeltaNnu=0 (dark radiation without
dark radiation). Conversely, a measurement consistent with Neff=3 is not
inconsistent with the presence of dark radiation (DeltaNnu>0). In particular,
if there is a light WIMP that annihilates to photons after the SM neutrinos
have decoupled, the photons are heated beyond their usual heating from e+-
annihilation, reducing the late time ratio of neutrino and photon temperatures
(and number densities), leading to Neff<3. This opens the window for one or
more equivalent neutrinos, including sterile neutrinos, to be consistent with
Neff=3. By reducing the neutrino number density at present, this allows for
more massive neutrinos, relaxing the current constraints on the sum of the
neutrino masses. In contrast, if the light WIMP only couples to the SM
neutrinos and not to the photons, its late time annihilation heats the
neutrinos but not the photons, resulting in Neff>3 even in the absence of
equivalent neutrinos or dark radiation. A measurement of Neff>3 is thus no
guarantee of the presence of equivalent neutrinos or dark radiation. In the
presence of light WIMPs and/or equivalent neutrinos there are degeneracies
among the light WIMP mass and its nature (fermion or boson, as well as its
couplings to neutrinos or photons), the number and nature (fermion or boson) of
the equivalent neutrinos, and their decoupling temperature (the strength of
their interactions with the SM particles). There's more to a measurement of
Neff than meets the eye.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1211.0186 [pdf] - 1157440
Right-Handed Neutrinos as the Dark Radiation: Status and Forecasts for
the LHC
Submitted: 2012-11-01
Precision data from cosmology (probing the CMB decoupling epoch) and
light-element abundances (probing the BBN epoch) have hinted at the presence of
extra relativistic degrees of freedom, the so-called "dark radiation." We
present a model independent study to account for the dark radiation by means of
the right-handed partners of the three, left-handed, standard model neutrinos.
We show that milli-weak interactions of these Dirac states (through their
coupling to a TeV-scale Z' gauge boson) may allow the \nu_R's to decouple much
earlier, at a higher temperature, than their left-handed counterparts. If the
\nu_R's decouple during the quark-hadron crossover transition, they are
considerably cooler than the \nu_L's and contribute less than 3 extra
"equivalent neutrinos" to the early Universe energy density. For decoupling in
this transition region, the 3 \nu_R generate \Delta N_\nu = 3(T_{\nu_R}/T_{\nu_
L})^4 < 3, extra relativistic degrees of freedom at BBN and at the CMB epochs.
Consistency with present constraints on dark radiation permits us to identify
the allowed region in the parameter space of Z' masses and couplings.
Remarkably, the allowed region is within the range of discovery of LHC14.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1204.3622 [pdf] - 548032
Precise Relic WIMP Abundance and its Impact on Searches for Dark Matter
Annihilation
Submitted: 2012-04-16, last modified: 2012-08-09
If dark matter (DM) is a weakly interacting massive particle (WIMP) that is a
thermal relic of the early Universe, then its total self-annihilation cross
section is revealed by its present-day mass density. The canonical thermally
averaged cross section for a generic WIMP is usually stated as 3*10^-26
cm^3s^-1, with unspecified uncertainty, and taken to be independent of WIMP
mass. Recent searches for annihilation products of DM annihilation have just
reached the sensitivity to exclude this canonical cross section for 100%
branching ratio to certain final states and small WIMP masses. The ultimate
goal is to probe all kinematically allowed final states as a function of mass
and, if all states are adequately excluded, set a lower limit to the WIMP mass.
Probing the low-mass region is further motivated due to recent hints for a
light WIMP in direct and indirect searches. We revisit the thermal relic
abundance calculation for a generic WIMP and show that the required cross
section can be calculated precisely. It varies significantly with mass at
masses below 10 GeV, reaching a maximum of 5.2*10^-26 cm^3s^-1 at masses around
0.3 GeV, and is 2.2*10^-26 cm^3s^-1 with feeble mass-dependence for masses
above 10 GeV. These results, which differ significantly from the canonical
value and have not been taken into account in searches for annihilation
products from generic WIMPs, have a noticeable impact on the interpretation of
present limits from Fermi-LAT and WMAP+ACT.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1208.0032 [pdf] - 667547
Neutrinos And Big Bang Nucleosynthesis
Submitted: 2012-07-31
According to the standard models of particle physics and cosmology, there
should be a background of cosmic neutrinos in the present Universe, similar to
the cosmic microwave photon background. The weakness of the weak interactions
renders this neutrino background undetectable with current technology. The
cosmic neutrino background can, however, be probed indirectly through its
cosmological effects on big bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) and the cosmic microwave
background (CMB) radiation. In this BBN review, focused on neutrinos and, more
generally on dark radiation, the BBN constraints on the number of "equivalent
neutrinos" (dark radiation), on the baryon asymmetry (baryon density), and on a
possible lepton asymmetry (neutrino degeneracy) are reviewed and updated. The
BBN constraints on dark radiation and on the baryon density following from
considerations of the primordial abundances of deuterium and helium-4 are in
excellent agreement with the complementary results from the CMB, providing a
suggestive, but currently inconclusive, hint of the presence of dark radiation
and, they constrain any lepton asymmetry. For all the cases considered here
there is a "lithium problem": the BBN-predicted lithium abundance exceeds the
observationally inferred primordial value by a factor of ~3.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1107.3131 [pdf] - 1078001
Requiem for an FCHAMP?
Submitted: 2011-07-15, last modified: 2011-09-16
Fractionally charged massive particles (FCHAMPs) appear in extensions of the
standard model, especially those with superstring constructions. The lightest
FCHAMP would be absolutely stable and any produced during the early evolution
of the Universe would be present today. The production, annihilation, and
survival of L, a lepton with electroweak but no strong interactions, of mass
m_L and charge Q_L (in units of the positron charge) are explored. Since
massive charged particles behave like baryons, primordial nucleosynthesis and
the cosmic background radiation temperature anisotropies limit the FCHAMP relic
density leading to constraints on the Q_L - m_L relation. Further constraints
are provided by the invisible width of the Z and by accelerator searches for
massive, charged particles. We exploit the fact that in the early Universe the
negatively charged L will combine with alpha particles and protons forming
tightly bound, positively charged states. The Coulomb barriers between these
positively charged bound states and the free L+ suppress late time annihilation
in the Galaxy and on Earth, limiting any late-time reduction of relic FCHAMP
pairs. The surviving FCHAMP abundance on Earth is orders of magnitude higher
than the limits from terrestrial searches for fractionally charged particles,
appearing to close the window on FCHAMPs. However, as Q_L approaches an integer
these searches become increasingly insensitive, leaving some "islands" in the
Q_L - m_L plane which may be explored by searching for FCHAMPs in the cosmic
rays.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1008.4765 [pdf] - 231637
Primordial Nucleosynthesis: The Predicted and Observed Abundances and
Their Consequences
Submitted: 2010-08-27, last modified: 2010-09-24
For a brief time in its early evolution the Universe was a cosmic nuclear
reactor. The expansion and cooling of the Universe limited this epoch to the
first few minutes, allowing time for the synthesis in astrophysically
interesting abundances of only the lightest nuclides (D, 3He, 4He, 7Li). For
big bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) in the standard models of cosmology and particle
physics (SBBN), the SBBN-predicted abundances depend on only one adjustable
parameter, the baryon density parameter (the ratio by number of baryons
(nucleons) to photons). The predicted and observed abundances of the relic
light elements are reviewed, testing the internal consistency of primordial
nucleosynthesis. The consistency of BBN is also explored by comparing the
values of the cosmological parameters inferred from primordial nucleosynthesis
for the standard model and for models with non-standard early Universe
expansion rates with those determined from studies of the cosmic background
radiation, which provides a snapshot of the Universe some 400 thousand years
after BBN ended.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.1114 [pdf] - 1870161
Primordial Nucleosynthesis: A Cosmological Probe
Submitted: 2009-12-07, last modified: 2010-04-29
During its early evolution the Universe provided a laboratory to probe
fundamental physics at high energies. Relics from those early epochs, such as
the light elements synthesized during primordial nucleosynthesis when the
Universe was only a few minutes old, and the cosmic background photons, last
scattered when the protons (and alphas) and electrons (re)combined some 400
thousand years later, may be used to probe the standard models of cosmology and
of particle physics. The internal consistency of primordial nucleosynthesis is
tested by comparing the predicted and observed abundances of the light
elements, and the consistency of the standard models is explored by comparing
the values of the cosmological parameters inferred from primordial
nucleosynthesis with those determined by studying the cosmic background
radiation.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:0909.3270 [pdf] - 1870160
Primordial Nucleosynthesis After WMAP
Submitted: 2009-09-17, last modified: 2010-04-29
During its early evolution, the hot, dense Universe provided a laboratory for
probing fundamental physics at high energies. By studying the relics from those
early epochs, such as the light elements synthesized during primordial
nucleosynthesis when the Universe was only a few minutes old, and the relic,
cosmic microwave photons, last scattered when the protons, alphas, and
electrons (re)combined some 400 thousand years later, the evolution of the
Universe may be used to test the standard models of cosmology and particle
physics and to set constraints on proposals of physics beyond these standard
models.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.3604 [pdf] - 902960
Primordial Helium And the Cosmic Background Radiation
Submitted: 2010-02-18, last modified: 2010-04-29
The products of primordial nucleosynthesis and the cosmic microwave
background (CMB) photons are relics from the early evolution of the Universe
whose observations probe the standard model of cosmology and provide windows on
new physics beyond the standard models of cosmology and of particle physics. In
the standard, hot big bang cosmology, long before any stars have formed a
significant fraction (~25%) of the baryonic mass in the Universe should be in
the form of helium-4 nuclei. Since current 4He observations are restricted to
low redshift regions where stellar nucleosynthesis has occurred, observations
of high redshift, prestellar 4He would constitute a fundamental test of the
hot, big bang cosmology. At recombination, long after big bang nucleosynthesis
(BBN) has ended, the temperature anisotropy spectrum imprinted on the CMB
depends on the 4He abundance through its connection to the electron density and
the effect of the electron density on Silk damping. Since the relic abundance
of 4He is relatively insensitive to the universal density of baryons, but is
sensitive to a non-standard, early Universe expansion rate, the primordial mass
fraction of 4He, Yp, offers a test of the consistency of the standard models of
BBN and the CMB and, provides constraints on non-standard physics. Here, the
WMAP seven year data (supplemented by other CMB experiments), which lead to an
indirect determination of Yp at high redshift, are compared to the BBN
predictions and to the independent, direct observations of 4He in low redshift,
extragalactic HII regions. At present, given the very large uncertainties in
the CMB-determined primordial 4He abundance (as well as for the helium
abundances inferred from H II region observations), any differences between the
BBN predictions and the CMB observations are small, at a level < 1.5 sigma.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:0910.4961 [pdf] - 1018100
The Deuterium Abundance in the Local Interstellar Medium
Submitted: 2009-10-26, last modified: 2010-03-25
As the Galaxy evolves, the abundance of deuterium in the interstellar medium
(ISM) decreases from its primordial value: deuterium is "astrated". The
deuterium astration factor, f_D, the ratio of the primordial D abundance (the D
to H ratio by number) to the ISM D abundance, is determined by the competition
between stellar destruction and infall, providing a constraint on models of the
chemical evolution of the Galaxy. Although conventional wisdom suggests that
the local ISM (i.e., within ~1-2 kpc of the Sun) should be well mixed and
homogenized on timescales short compared to the chemical evolution timescale,
the data reveal gas phase variations in the deuterium, iron, and other metal
abundances as large as factors of ~4-5 or more, complicating the estimate of
the "true" ISM D abundance and of the deuterium astration factor. Here,
assuming that the variations in the observationally inferred ISM D abundances
result entirely from the depletion of D onto dust, rather than from unmixed
accretion of nearly primordial material, a model-independent, Bayesian approach
is used to determine the undepleted abundance of deuterium in the ISM (or, a
lower limit to it). We find the best estimate for the undepleted, ISM deuterium
abundance to be D/H_ISM >= (2.0+-0.1)x10^(-5). This result is used to provide
an estimate of (or, an upper bound to) the deuterium astration factor, f_D =
(D/H)_P/D/H_ISM <= 1.4+-0.1.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.4650 [pdf] - 124982
Cahill's Cosmological Model Exacerbates The Primordial Lithium Problem
And Creates New Problems For Primordial Deuterium And Helium
Submitted: 2010-02-24
In a recent article R. T. Cahill claims that the cosmological model based on
his "new physics of a dynamical 3-space" resolves the CMB-BBN Lithium-7 and
Helium-4 abundance anomalies. In this note it is shown that this conclusion is
wrong, resulting from a misunderstanding. In fact, primordial nucleosynthesis
in this non-standard cosmological model exacerbates the LIthium-7 problem and
creates new problems for primordial Helium-4 and Deuterium.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:0901.4333 [pdf] - 1001378
Tracking The Post-BBN Evolution Of Deuterium
Submitted: 2009-01-27
The primordial abundance of deuterium produced during Big Bang
Nucleosynthesis (BBN) depends sensitively on the universal ratio of baryons to
photons, an important cosmological parameter probed independently by the Cosmic
Microwave Background (CMB) radiation. Observations of deuterium in
high-redshift, low-metallicity QSO Absorption Line Systems (QSOALS) provide a
key baryometer, determining the baryon abundance at the time of BBN to a
precision of 5%. Alternatively, if the CMB-determined baryon to photon ratio is
used in the BBN calculation of the primordial abundances, the BBN-predicted
deuterium abundance may be compared with the primordial value inferred from the
QSOALS, testing the standard cosmological model. In the post-BBN universe, as
gas is cycled through stars, deuterium is only destroyed so that its abundance
measured anytime, anywhere in the Universe, bounds the primordial abundance
from below. Constraints on models of post-BBN Galactic chemical evolution
follow from a comparison of the relic deuterium abundance with the
FUSE-inferred deuterium abundances in the chemically enriched, stellar
processed material of the local ISM.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:0812.3912 [pdf] - 19715
An Accelerating Cosmology Without Dark Energy
Submitted: 2008-12-19
The negative pressure accompanying gravitationally-induced particle creation
can lead to a cold dark matter (CDM) dominated, accelerating Universe (Lima et
al. 1996) without requiring the presence of dark energy or a cosmological
constant. In a recent study Lima et al. (2008, LSS) demonstrated that particle
creation driven cosmological models are capable of accounting for the SNIa
observations of the recent transition from a decelerating to an accelerating
Universe. Here we test the evolution of such models at high redshift using the
constraint on z_eq, the redshift of the epoch of matter radiation equality,
provided by the WMAP constraints on the early Integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect.
Since the contribution of baryons and radiation was ignored in the work of LSS,
we include them in our study of this class of models. The parameters of these
more realistic models with continuous creation of CDM is tested and constrained
at widely-separated epochs (z = z_eq and z = 0) in the evolution of the
Universe. This comparison reveals a tension between the high redshift CMB
constraint on z_eq and that which follows from the low redshift SNIa data,
challenging the viability of this class of models.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:0808.1122 [pdf] - 383915
When Clusters Collide: Constraints On Antimatter On The Largest Scales
Submitted: 2008-08-07
Observations have ruled out the presence of significant amounts of antimatter
in the Universe on scales ranging from the solar system, to the Galaxy, to
groups and clusters of galaxies, and even to distances comparable to the scale
of the present horizon. Except for the model-dependent constraints on the
largest scales, the most significant upper limits to diffuse antimatter in the
Universe are those on the Mpc scale of clusters of galaxies provided by the
EGRET upper bounds to annihilation gamma-rays from galaxy clusters whose
intra-cluster gas is revealed through its x-ray emission. On the scale of
individual clusters of galaxies the upper bounds to the fraction of mixed
matter and antimatter for the 55 clusters from a flux-limited x-ray survey
range from < 5 x 10^(-9) to < 1 x 10^(-6), strongly suggesting that individual
clusters of galaxies are made entirely of matter or, of antimatter. X-ray and
gamma-ray observations of colliding clusters of galaxies, such as the Bullet
Cluster, permit these constraints to be extended to even larger scales. If the
observations of the Bullet Cluster, where the upper bound to the antimatter
fraction is found to be < 3 x 10^-6, can be generalized to other colliding
clusters of galaxies, cosmologically significant amounts of antimatter will be
excluded on scales of order 20 Mpc (5 x 10^(15)M_Sun).
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:0807.3004 [pdf] - 14658
Neutrinos and BBN (and the CMB)
Submitted: 2008-07-18
During Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN), in the first 20 minutes of the
evolution of the Universe, the light nuclides, D, 3He, 4He, and 7Li were
synthesized in astrophysically interesting abundances. The Cosmic Microwave
Background Radiation (CMB) observed at present was last scattered some 400
thousand years later. BBN and the CMB (supplemented by more recent Large Scale
Structure data), provide complementary probes of the early evolution of the
Universe and enable constraints on the high temperature/energy physical
processes in it. In this overview the predictions and observations of two
physical quantities, the baryon density parameter and the expansion rate
parameter, are compared to see if there is agreement between theory and
observation at these two widely separated epochs. After answering this question
in the affirmative, the consequences of this concordance for physics beyond the
standard models of particle physics and cosmology is discussed.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:0803.3465 [pdf] - 11177
Constraining The Early-Universe Baryon Density And Expansion Rate
Submitted: 2008-03-25, last modified: 2008-06-29
We explore constraints on extensions to the standard models of cosmology and
particle physics which modify the early-Universe expansion rate S = H'/H
(parametrized by the effective number of neutrinos N_nu). The constraints on
N_nu and the baryon density parameter (eta_B = n_B/n_gamma = 10^(-10)*eta_10)
from BBN at 20 minutes are compared with those from the CMB at 400 kyr and LSS
at 14 Gyr. BBN provides the strongest constraint on N_nu (1.6 < N_nu < 3.3 at
95% confidence), but a weaker constraint on eta_B. The CMB/LSS best constrain
the baryon density (5.9 < eta_10 < 6.4 at 95% confidence), independent of N_nu,
but provide a relatively weak N_nu constraint, consistent with N_nu = 3. Using
the best fit values and the allowed ranges of the CMB/LSS-derived parameters to
calculate the BBN-predicted primordial abundances yields excellent agreement
with the observationally inferred abundance of deuterium and good agreement
with 4He, confirming the consistency between the BBN and CMB/LSS results.
However, the BBN-predicted abundance of 7Li is high, by a factor of 3 or more.
We comment on the value of N_nu and a possible anomaly in the matter power
spectrum inferred from observations of the Ly-alpha forest. The good agreement
between our BBN and CMB/LSS results permit us to constrain any post-BBN entropy
production as well as to limit the production of any non-thermalized
relativistic particles and, allow us to combine them finding 95% ranges, 1.8 <
N_nu < 3.2 and 5.9 < eta_10 < 6.4.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:0806.0179 [pdf] - 13127
Constraining The Universal Lepton Asymmetry
Submitted: 2008-06-01
The relic cosmic background neutrinos accompanying the cosmic microwave
background (CMB) photons may hide a universal lepton asymmetry orders of
magnitude larger than the universal baryon asymmetry. At present, the only
direct way to probe such an asymmetry is through its effect on the abundances
of the light elements produced during primordial nucleosynthesis. The relic
light element abundances also depend on the baryon asymmetry, parameterized by
the baryon density parameter (eta_B = n_B/n_gamma = 10^(-10)*eta_10), and on
the early-universe expansion rate, parameterized by the expansion rate factor
(S = H'/H) or, equivalently by the effective number of neutrinos (N_nu = 3 +
43(S^2 - 1)/7). We use data from the CMB (and Large Scale Structure: LSS) along
with the observationally-inferred relic abundances of deuterium and helium-4 to
provide new bounds on the universal lepton asymmetry, finding for eta_L, the
analog of eta_B, 0.072 +/- 0.053 if it is assumed that N_nu = 3 and, 0.115 +/-
0.095 along with N_nu = 3.3^{+0.7}_{-0.6}, if N_nu is free to vary.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:0712.1100 [pdf] - 7840
Primordial Nucleosynthesis in the Precision Cosmology Era
Submitted: 2007-12-07
Primordial nucleosynthesis provides a probe of the Universe during its early
evolution. Given the progress exploring the constituents, structure, and recent
evolution of the Universe, it is timely to review the status of Big Bang
Nucleosynthesis (BBN) and to confront its predictions, along with the
constraints which emerge from them, with those derived from independent
observations of the Universe at much later epochs in its evolution. Following
an overview of the key physics controlling element synthesis in the early
Universe, the predictions of BBN in the standard models of cosmology and
particle physics are presented, along with those from some non-standard models.
The observational data used to infer the primordial abundances are described,
with an emphasis on the distinction between precision and accuracy. The
observationally inferred relic abundances are compared with the predicted
abundances, testing the internal consistency of BBN and enabling a comparison
of the BBN-inferred constraints with those derived from the Cosmic Background
Radiation and Large Scale Structure data. Emerging from these comparisons is
confirmation of a successful standard model along with constraints on (or hints
of) physics beyond the standard models of particle physics and of cosmology.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:0710.5300 [pdf] - 6471
Big Bang Nucleosynthesis Constraints on the Self-Gravity of Pressure
Submitted: 2007-10-28
Using big bang nucleosynthesis and present, high-precision measurements of
light element abundances, we constrain the self-gravity of radiation pressure
in the early universe. The self-gravity of pressure is strictly non-Newtonian,
and thus the constraints we set provide a direct test of this prediction of
general relativity and of the standard, Robertson-Walker-Friedmann cosmology.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0703682 [pdf] - 90491
Connecting the primordial and Galactic deuterium abundances
Submitted: 2007-03-27
The deuterium abundances inferred from observations of the interstellar
medium within 1-2 kpc of the Sun range over a factor of three and the
corresponding oxygen abundances show an even larger dispersion. While the lower
D (and O) abundances likely result from depletion onto dust, the higher D
abundances are consistent with the BBN-predicted primordial D abundance and
chemical evolution models of the Galaxy with infall of primordial or nearly
primordial material. The large ranges in deuterium and oxygen abundances
suggest that the effects of depletion and/or infall have not been homogenized
in the local interstellar medium.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:hep-ph/0611209 [pdf] - 115423
BBN And The CBR Probe The Early Universe
Submitted: 2006-11-15
Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) and the Cosmic Background Radiation (CBR)
provide complementary probes of the early evolution of the Universe and of its
particle content. Neutrinos play important roles in both cases, influencing the
primordial abundances of the nuclides produced by BBN during the first 20
minutes, as well as the spectrum of temperature fluctuations imprinted on the
CBR when the Universe is some 400 thousand years old. The physical effects
relevant at these widely separated epochs are reviewed and the theoretical
predictions are compared with observational data to explore the consistency of
the standard models of cosmology and particle physics and to constrain
beyond-the-standard-model physics and cosmology.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0606206 [pdf] - 82646
The Cosmological Evolution of the Average Mass Per Baryon
Submitted: 2006-06-08, last modified: 2006-10-25
Subsequent to the early Universe quark-hadron transition the universal baryon
number is carried by nucleons: neutrons and protons. The total number of
nucleons is preserved as the Universe expands, but as it cools lighter protons
are favored over heavier neutrons reducing the average mass per baryon. During
primordial nucleosynthesis free nucleons are transformed into bound nuclides,
primarily helium, and the nuclear binding energies are radiated away, further
reducing the average mass per baryon. In particular, the reduction in the
average mass per baryon resulting from Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) modifies
the numerical factor relating the baryon (nucleon) mass and number densities.
Here the average mass per baryon, m_B, is tracked from the early Universe to
the present. The result is used to relate the present ratio of baryons to
photons (by number) to the present baryon mass density at a level of accuracy
commensurate with that of recent cosmological data, as well as to estimate the
energy released during post-BBN stellar nucleosynthesis.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0610599 [pdf] - 86023
Probing The Universe With Neutrinos At 20 Minutes And 400 Thousand Years
Submitted: 2006-10-19
Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) and the Cosmic Background Radiation (CBR)
provide complementary probes of the early evolution of the Universe and of its
particle content. Neutrinos play important roles in both cases, influencing the
primordial abundances of the nuclides produced by BBN during the first 20
minutes as well as the spectrum of temperature fluctuations imprinted on the
CBR when the Universe is some 400 thousand years old. In this talk I review the
physical effects of neutrinos at these different epochs in the evolution of the
Universe and compare the theoretical predictions with the observational data to
explore the consistency of the standard models of cosmology and particle
physics and to constrain neutrino physics as well as more general,
beyond-the-standard-model physics.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0511534 [pdf] - 77892
Primordial Nucleosynthesis: Successes And Challenges
Submitted: 2005-11-17
Primordial nucleosynthesis provides a probe of the Universe during its early
evolution. Given the progress exploring the constituents, structure, and recent
evolution of the Universe, it is timely to review the status of Big Bang
Nucleosynthesis (BBN) and to confront its predictions, and the constraints
which emerge from them, with those derived from independent observations of the
Universe at much later epochs in its evolution. Following an overview of the
key physics controlling element synthesis in the early Universe, the
predictions of the standard models of cosmology and particle physics are
presented, along with those from some non-standard models. The observational
data used to infer the primordial abundances are described, with an emphasis on
the distinction between precision and accuracy. These relic abundances are
compared with predictions, testing the internal consistency of BBN and enabling
a comparison of the BBN constraints with those derived from the WMAP Cosmic
Background Radiation data. Emerging from these comparisons is a successful
standard model along with constraints on (or hints of) physics beyond the
standard models of particle physics and of cosmology.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0501591 [pdf] - 1233479
BBN and the Primordial Abundances
Submitted: 2005-01-26
The relic abundances of the light elements synthesized during the first few
minutes of the evolution of the Universe provide unique probes of cosmology and
the building blocks for stellar and galactic chemical evolution, while also
enabling constraints on the baryon (nucleon) density and on models of particle
physics beyond the standard model. Recent WMAP analyses of the CBR temperature
fluctuation spectrum, combined with other, relevant, observational data, has
yielded very tight constraints on the baryon density, permitting a detailed,
quantitative confrontation of the predictions of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis with
the post-BBN abundances inferred from observational data. The current status of
this comparison is presented, with an emphasis on the challenges to astronomy,
astrophysics, particle physics, and cosmology it identifies.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:hep-ph/0501100 [pdf] - 114933
Neutrinos And Big Bang Nucleosynthesis
Submitted: 2005-01-12
The early universe provides a unique laboratory for probing the frontiers of
particle physics in general and neutrino physics in particular. The primordial
abundances of the relic nuclei produced during the first few minutes of the
evolution of the Universe depend on the electron neutrinos through the
charged-current weak interactions among neutrons and protons (and electrons and
positrons and neutrinos), and on all flavors of neutrinos through their
contributions to the total energy density which regulates the universal
expansion rate. The latter contribution also plays a role in determining the
spectrum of the temperature fluctuations imprinted on the Cosmic Background
Radiation (CBR) some 400 thousand years later. Using deuterium as a baryometer
and helium-4 as a chronometer, the predictions of BBN and the CBR are compared
to observations. The successes of, as well as challenges to the standard models
of particle physics and cosmology are identified. While systematic
uncertainties may be the source of some of the current tensions, it could be
that the data are pointing the way to new physics. In particular, BBN and the
CBR are used to address the questions of whether or not the relic neutrinos
were fully populated in the early universe and, to limit the magnitude of any
lepton asymmetry which may be concealed in the neutrinos.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0406320 [pdf] - 65477
BBN For Pedestrians
Submitted: 2004-06-14
The simplest, `standard' model of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (SBBN) assumes
three light neutrinos (N_nu = 3) and no significant electron neutrino
asymmetry, leaving only one adjustable parameter: the baryon to photon ratio
eta. The primordial abundance of any one nuclide can, therefore, be used to
measure the baryon abundance and the value derived from the observationally
inferred primordial abundance of deuterium closely matches that from current,
non-BBN data, primarily from the WMAP survey. However, using this same estimate
there is a tension between the SBBN-predicted 4He and 7Li abundances and their
current, observationally inferred primordial abundances, suggesting that N_nu
may differ from the standard model value of three and/or that there may be a
non-zero neutral lepton asymmetry (or, that systematic errors in the abundance
determinations have been underestimated or overlooked). The differences are not
large and the allowed ranges of the BBN parameters permitted by the data are
quite small. Within these ranges, the BBN-predicted abundances of D, 3He, 4He,
and 7Li are very smooth, monotonic functions of eta, N_nu, and the lepton
asymmetry. It is possible to describe the dependencies of these abundances (or
powers of them) upon the three parameters by simple, linear fits which, over
their ranges of applicability, are accurate to a few percent or better. The
fits presented here have not been maximized for their accuracy but, for their
simplicity. To identify the ranges of applicability and relative accuracies,
they are compared to detailed BBN calculations; their utility is illustrated
with several examples. Given the tension within BBN, these fits should prove
useful in facilitating studies of the viability of proposals for non-standard
physics and cosmology, prior to undertaking detailed BBN calculations.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0312346 [pdf] - 880690
The Supernova Relic Neutrino Backgrounds at KamLAND and Super-Kamiokande
Submitted: 2003-12-12, last modified: 2004-04-14
We calculate the Supernova Relic Neutrino (SRN) background flux for the
KamLAND and Super-Kamiokande (SK) detectors, motivated by the reduction in
background at SK and new results for the star formation history (e.g., from the
Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS)). Our best estimate for the flux at SK is
slightly below, but very close to the current SK upper limit. The SK upper
limit is already inconsistent with a range of star formation histories allowed
by the SDSS data. We estimate that the SRN background should be detected (at
1-sigma) at SK with a total of about 9 years (including the existing 4 years)
of data. While KamLAND is a much smaller detector compared to SK, it profits
from being practically background-free and from its sensitivity to the lower
energy supernova neutrinos. KamLAND could make a 1-sigma detection of the SRN
with a total of about 5 years of data. Given the small expected SRN event rate,
we also consider the detection of the SRN in a modified SK detector with a
lower threshold and reduced background where the time to detection can be
reduced by a factor of 10 relative to the existing SK estimate.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0308511 [pdf] - 58790
Primordial Nucleosynthesis
Submitted: 2003-08-28, last modified: 2003-10-13
The primordial abundances of deuterium, helium-3, helium-4, and lithium-7
probe the baryon density of the Universe only a few minutes after the Big Bang.
Of these relics from the early Universe, deuterium is the baryometer of choice.
After reviewing the current observational status of the relic abundances (a
moving target!), the baryon density determined by big bang nucleosynthesis
(BBN) is derived. The temperature fluctuation spectrum of the cosmic background
radiation (CBR), established several hundred thousand years later, probes the
baryon density at a completely different epoch in the evolution of the
Universe. The excellent agreement between the BBN- and CBR-determined baryon
densities provides impressive confirmation of the standard model of cosmology,
permitting the study of extensions of the standard model. In combination with
the BBN- and/or CBR-determined baryon density, the relic abundance of 4He
provides an excellent chronometer, constraining those extensions of the
standard model which lead to a nonstandard early-Universe expansion rate.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:hep-ph/0309347 [pdf] - 114564
Forensic Cosmology: Probing Baryons and Neutrinos With BBN and the CBR
Submitted: 2003-09-30
The primordial abundances of the light nuclides produced by Big Bang
Nucleosynthesis (BBN) during the first 20 minutes in the evolution of the
Universe are sensitive to the universal density of baryons and to the expansion
rate of the early Universe. For example, while deuterium is an excellent
baryometer, helium-4 provides an accurate chronometer. Some 400 kyr later, when
the cosmic background radiation (CBR) was freed from the grasp of the ionized
plasma of protons and electrons, the spectrum of temperature fluctuations also
depended on (among other parameters) the baryon density and the density in
relativistic particles. The comparison between the constraints imposed by BBN
and those from the CBR reveals a remarkably consistent picture of the Universe
at two widely separated epochs in its evolution. Combining these two probes
leads to new estimates of the baryon density at present and tighter constraints
on possible physics beyond the standard model of particle physics. In this
review the consistency between these complementary probes of the universal
baryon density and the early-Universe expansion rate is exploited to provide
new constraints on any asymmetry between relic neutrinos and anti-neutrinos
(neutrino degeneracy).
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0309338 [pdf] - 59165
The Baryon Budget from BBN and the CBR
Submitted: 2003-09-11
A key pillar of modern cosmology, Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) offers a
probe of the particle content and expansion rate of the Universe a mere few
minutes after the beginning. When compared with the BBN predictions, the
observationally inferred primordial abundances of deuterium and helium-4
provide an excellent baryometer and chronometer respectively. Several hundred
thousand years later, when the Cosmic Background Radiation (CBR) photons began
progagating freely, the spectrum of temperature fluctuations imprinted on them
also encoded information about the baryon density and the expansion rate.
Comparing the constraints imposed by BBN with those from the CBR reveals a
consistent picture of the Universe at these two very widely separated epochs.
Combining these probes leads to new, tighter constraints on the baryon density
at present and on possible new physics beyond the standard model of particle
physics.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0307244 [pdf] - 57957
Big Bang Nucleosynthesis: Probing the First 20 Minutes
Submitted: 2003-07-11
Within the first 20 minutes of the evolution of the hot, dense, early
Universe, astrophysically interesting abundances of deuterium, helium-3,
helium-4, and lithium-7 were synthesized by the cosmic nuclear reactor. The
primordial abundances of these light nuclides produced during Big Bang
Nucleosynthesis (BBN) are sensitive to the universal density of baryons and to
the early-Universe expansion rate which at early epochs is governed by the
energy density in relativistic particles (``radiation'') such as photons and
neutrinos. Some 380 kyr later, when the cosmic background radiation (CBR)
radiation was freed from the embrace of the ionized plasma of protons and
electrons, the spectrum of temperature fluctuations imprinted on the CBR also
depended on the baryon and radiation densities. The comparison between the
constraints imposed by BBN and those from the CBR reveals a remarkably
consistent picture of the Universe at two widely separated epochs in its
evolution. Combining these two probes leads to new and tighter constraints on
the baryon density at present, on possible new physics beyond the standard
model of particle physics, as well as identifying some challenges to astronomy
and astrophysics. In this review the current status of BBN will be presented
along with the associated estimates of the baryon density and of the energy
density in radiation.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:hep-ph/0306061 [pdf] - 114456
Hiding relativistic degrees of freedom in the early universe
Submitted: 2003-06-06
We quantify the extent to which extra relativistic energy density can be
concealed by a neutrino asymmetry without conflicting with the baryon asymmetry
measured by the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP). In the presence of
a large electron neutrino asymmetry, slightly more than seven effective
neutrinos are allowed by Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) and WMAP at 2\sigma.
The same electron neutrino degeneracy that reconciles the BBN prediction for
the primordial helium abundance with the observationally inferred value also
reconciles the LSND neutrino with BBN by suppressing its thermalization prior
to BBN.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:hep-ph/0305075 [pdf] - 114433
Effective number of neutrinos and baryon asymmetry from BBN and WMAP
Submitted: 2003-05-08
We place constraints on the number of relativistic degrees of freedom and on
the baryon asymmetry at the epoch of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) and at
recombination, using cosmic background radiation (CBR) data from the Wilkinson
Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP), complemented by the Hubble Space Telescope
(HST) Key Project measurement of the Hubble constant, along with the latest
compilation of deuterium abundances and measurements of the primordial helium
abundance. The agreement between the derived values of these key cosmological
and particle physics parameters at these widely separated (in time or redshift)
epochs is remarkable. From the combination of CBR and BBN data, we find the
2\sigma ranges for the effective number of neutrinos and for the baryon
asymmetry (baryon to photon number ratio \eta) to be 1.7-3.0 and 5.53-6.76
\times 10^{-10}, respectively.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0210500 [pdf] - 52538
BBN And CMB Constraints On Dark Energy
Submitted: 2002-10-22, last modified: 2003-02-02
Current observational data favor cosmological models which differ from the
standard model due to the presence of some form of dark energy and, perhaps, by
additional contributions to the more familiar dark matter. Primordial
nucleosynthesis provides a window on the very early evolution of the universe
and constraints from Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) can bound the parameters of
models for dark matter/energy at redshifts of order ten billion. The spectrum
of temperature fluctuations imprinted on the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB)
radiation opens a completely different window on the universe at epochs from
redshifts of order ten thousand to nearly the present. The CMB anisotropy
spectrum provides constraints on new physics which are independent of, and
complementary to those from BBN. Here we consider three classes of models for
the dark matter/energy: extra particles which were relativistic during the
early evolution of the universe (X); Quintessence models involving a
minimally-coupled scalar field (Q); models with a non-minimally coupled scalar
field which modify the strength of gravity during the early evolution of the
universe (G). We constrain the parameters of these models using data from BBN
and the CMB and identify the allowed regions in their parameter spaces
consistent with the more demanding joint BBN and CMB constraints. For X and Q
such consistency is relatively easy to find; it is more difficult for the G
models with an inverse power law potential for the scalar field.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0209246 [pdf] - 51652
On the Variation of Deuterium and Oxygen Abundances in the Local
Interstellar Medium
Submitted: 2002-09-12, last modified: 2002-12-03
The first observations of deuterium and oxygen in the Local Interstellar
Medium (LISM) obtained with the Far Ultraviolet Spectroscopic Explorer (FUSE)
can be used to search for local abundance variations. While the very limited
sample of these first data may be consistent with no variations, they do offer
a hint of anti-correlated variations between D/H and O/H. If confirmed by more
data (which will require independently determined, accurate HI column
densities), these hints suggest that observations of interstellar gas within a
few kpc of the solar neighborhood will reveal clear signs of the evolution of
the abundance of deuterium from there and then (the Big Bang), to here and now
(the Local Interstellar Medium of the Galaxy).
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0208186 [pdf] - 51002
Primordial Alchemy: From The Big Bang To The Present Universe
Submitted: 2002-08-08
Of the light nuclides observed in the universe today, D, 3He, 4He, and 7Li
are relics from its early evolution. The primordial abundances of these relics,
produced via Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) during the first half hour of the
evolution of the universe provide a unique window on Physics and Cosmology at
redshifts of order 10^10. Comparing the BBN-predicted abundances with those
inferred from observational data tests the consistency of the standard model of
cosmology over ten orders of magnitude in redshift, constrains the baryon and
other particle content of the universe, and probes both Cosmology and Physics
beyond their current standard models. These lectures are intended to introduce
students, both of theory and observation, to those aspects of the evolution of
the universe relevant to the production and evolution of the light nuclides
from the Big Bang to the present. The current observational data is reviewed
and compared with the BBN predictions and the implications for cosmology (e.g.,
universal baryon density) and particle physics (e.g., relativistic energy
density) are discussed. While this comparison reveals the stunning success of
the standard model(s), there are currently some challenges which leave open the
door for more theoretical and observational work with potential implications
for astronomy, cosmology, and particle physics.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0202187 [pdf] - 1232839
The Baryon Density Through The (Cosmological) Ages
Submitted: 2002-02-08
The light element abundances probe the baryon density of the universe within
a few minutes of the Big Bang. Of these relics from the earliest universe,
deuterium is the baryometer of choice. By comparing its primordial abundance
inferred from observations with that predicted by Big Bang Nucleosynthesis
(BBN), the early universe baryon density is derived. This is then compared to
independent estimates of the baryon density several hundred thousand years
after the Big Bang and at present, more than 10 billion years later. The
excellent agreement among these values represents an impressive confirmation of
the standard model of cosmology.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0109071 [pdf] - 44570
The Evolution of Helium and Hydrogen Ionization Corrections as HII
Regions Age
Submitted: 2001-09-05, last modified: 2001-10-31
Helium and hydrogen recombination lines observed in low-metallicity,
extragalactic, HII regions provide the data used to infer the primordial helium
mass fraction, Y_P. In deriving abundances from observations, the correction
for unseen neutral helium or hydrogen is usually assumed to be absent; i.e.,
the ionization correction factor is taken to be unity (icf = 1). In a previous
paper (VGS), we revisited the question of the icf, confirming a "reverse"
ionization correction: icf < 1. In VGS the icf was calculated using more nearly
realistic models of inhomogeneous HII regions, suggesting that the published
values of Y_P needed to be reduced by an amount of order 0.003. As star
clusters age, their stellar spectra evolve and so, too, will their icfs. Here
the evolution of the icf is studied, along with that of two, alternate,
measures of the "hardness" of the radiation spectrum. The differences between
the icf for radiation-bounded and matter-bounded models are also explored,
along with the effect on the icf of the He/H ratio (since He and H compete for
some of the same ionizing photons). Particular attention is paid to the amount
of doubly-ionized helium predicted, leading us to suggest that observations of,
or bounds to, He++ may help to discriminate among models of HII regions ionized
by starbursts of different ages and spectra. We apply our analysis to the
Izotov & Thuan (IT) data set utilizing the radiation softness parameter, the
[OIII]/[OI] ratio, and the presence or absence of He++ to find 0.95 < icf <
0.99. This suggests that the IT estimate of the primordial helium abundance
should be reduced by Delta-Y = 0.006 +- 0.002, from 0.244 +- 0.002 to 0.238 +-
0.003.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0108148 [pdf] - 44124
Precision Neutrino Counting
Submitted: 2001-08-08
In the framework of the standard, hot big bang cosmological model the
dynamics of the early evolution of the universe is controlled by the energy
density of relativistic particles, among which neutrinos play an important
role. In equilibrium, the energy density contributed by one flavor of
relativistic neutrinos is 7/8 of that of the cosmic background radiation (CBR)
photons. As the universe expands and cools, neutrinos decouple and their
subsequent contribution to the energy density is modified by the relative
heating of the CBR photons when electron-positron pairs annihilate. The small
corrections to the post-annihilation energy density of the standard model
neutrinos due to incomplete decoupling and finite-temperature QED effects are
reviewed (correcting an error in the literature) and extended to account for
possible additional relativistic degrees of freedom whose presence might modify
the predictions of primordial nucleosynthesis and of the predicted CBR
anisotropies.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0101386 [pdf] - 40524
How Does CMB + BBN Constrain New Physics?
Submitted: 2001-01-22, last modified: 2001-07-26
Recent cosmic microwave background (CMB) results from BOOMERANG, MAXIMA, and
DASI provide cosmological constraints on new physics that can be competitive
with those derived from Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN). In particular, both CMB
and BBN can be used to place limits on models involving neutrino degeneracy and
additional relativistic degrees of freedom. However, for the case of the CMB,
these constraints are, in general, sensitive to the assumed priors. We examine
the CMB and BBN constraints on such models and study the sensitivity of ``new
physics" to the assumed priors. If we add a constraint on the age of the
universe ($t_0 \ga 11$ Gyr), then for models with a cosmological constant, the
range of baryon densities and neutrino degeneracy parameters allowed by the CMB
and BBN is fairly robust: $\eta_{10} = 6.0 \pm 0.6$, \deln $\la 6$, $\xi_e \la
0.3$. In the absence of new physics, models without a cosmological constant are
only marginally compatible with recent CMB observations (excluded at the 93%
confidence level).
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0107222 [pdf] - 43593
Tracking The Baryon Density From The Big Bang To The Present
Submitted: 2001-07-12
The primordial abundances of deuterium, helium, and lithium probe the baryon
density of the universe only a few minutes after the Big Bang. Of these relics
from the early universe, deuterium is the baryometer of choice. After reviewing
the current observational status (a moving target!), the BBN baryon density is
derived and compared to independent estimates of the baryon density several
hundred thousand years after the Big Bang (as inferred from CMB observations)
and at present, more than 10 billion years later. The excellent agreement among
these values represents an impressive confirmation of the standard model of
cosmology, justifying -- indeed, demanding -- more detailed, quantitative
scrutiny. To this end, the corresponding BBN-predicted abundances of helium and
lithium are compared with observations to further test and constrain the
standard, hot, big bang cosmological model.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0011531 [pdf] - 39537
Extended quintessence and the primordial helium abundance
Submitted: 2000-11-28, last modified: 2001-06-21
In extended quintessence models, a scalar field which couples to the
curvature scalar R provides most of the energy density of the universe. We
point out that such models can also lead naturally to a decrease in the
primordial abundance of helium-4, relieving the tension which currently exists
between the primordial helium-4 abundance inferred from observations and the
amount predicted by Standard Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (SBBN) corresponding to
the observed deuterium abundance. Using negative power-law potentials for the
quintessence field, we determine the range of model parameters which can lead
to an interesting reduction in the helium-4 abundance, and we show that it
overlaps with the region allowed by other constraints on extended quintessence
models.
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0105439 [pdf] - 42668
Stellar Mixing and the Primordial Lithium Abundance
Submitted: 2001-05-24
We compare the properties of recent samples of the lithium abundances in halo
stars to one another and to the predictions of theoretical models including
rotational mixing, and we examine the data for trends with metal abundance. We
find from a KS test that in the absence of any correction for chemical
evolution, the Ryan, Norris, & Beers (1999} sample is fully consistent with
mild rotational mixing induced depletion and, therefore, with an initial
lithium abundance higher than the observed value. Tests for outliers depend
sensitively on the threshold for defining their presence, but we find a
10$--$45% probability that the RNB sample is drawn from the rotationally mixed
models with a 0.2 dex median depletion (with lower probabilities corresponding
to higher depletion factors). When chemical evolution trends (Li/H versus Fe/H)
are treated in the linear plane we find that the dispersion in the RNB sample
is not explained by chemical evolution; the inferred bounds on lithium
depletion from rotational mixing are similar to those derived from models
without chemical evolution. We find that differences in the equivalent width
measurements are primarily responsible for different observational conclusions
concerning the lithium dispersion in halo stars. The standard Big Bang
Nucleosynthesis predicted lithium abundance which corresponds to the deuterium
abundance inferred from observations of high-redshift, low-metallicity QSO
absorbers requires halo star lithium depletion in an amount consistent with
that from our models of rotational mixing, but inconsistent with no depletion.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0102152 [pdf] - 40863
CMB (And Other) Challenges To BBN
Submitted: 2001-02-08
Primordial nucleosynthesis provides a probe of the universal abundance of
baryons when the universe was only a few minutes old. Recent observations of
anisotropy in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) probe the baryon abundance
when the universe was several hundred thousand years old. Observations of type
Ia supernovae and clusters of galaxies in the very recent past, when the
universe is several billion years old and older, provide a complementary
measure of the baryon density in excellent agreement with the early universe
values. The general agreement among the three measurements represents an
impressive confirmation of the standard model of cosmology. However, there is a
hint that the CMB observations may not be in perfect agreement with those from
big bang nucleosynthesis (BBN). If this "tension" between BBN and the CMB
persists, the standard model of cosmology may need to be modified. Here, in a
contribution dedicated to Silvia Torres-Peimbert and Manuel Peimbert, we
describe how an asymmetry between neutrinos and antineutrinos ("neutrino
degeneracy") has the potential for resolving this possible conflict between BBN
and the CMB.
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0012149 [pdf] - 39738
Global Constraints On Key Cosmological Parameters
Submitted: 2000-12-06
Data from Type Ia supernovae, along with X-ray cluster estimates of the
universal baryon fraction and Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) determinations of
the baryon-to-photon ratio, are used to provide estimates of several global
cosmological parameters at epochs near zero redshift. We show that our estimate
of the present baryon density is in remarkably good agreement with that
inferred from BBN at high redshift, provided the primordial abundance of
deuterium is relatively low and the Universe is flat. We also compare these
estimates to the baryon density at z = 1100 as inferred from the CMB angular
power spectrum.
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0009506 [pdf] - 38348
Light Element Nucleosynthesis
Submitted: 2000-09-29
An introductory review of the early evolution of the Universe relevant to the
primordial synthesis of the light nuclides deuterium, helium-3, helium-4 and
lithium-7. The predictions of the element abundances in the "standard", hot,
big bang cosmological model (SBBN) are described. After descriptions of the
evolution of the primordial abundances from "there and then" to "here and now",
the SBBN predictions are compared to current observational data. The
implications for the standard model and for physics beyond the standard model
are discussed.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9911066 [pdf] - 109194
Nucleosynthesis in Power-Law Cosmologies
Submitted: 1999-11-04, last modified: 2000-03-28
We have recently considered cosmologies in which the Universal scale factor
varies as a power of the age of the Universe and concluded that they cannot
satisfy the observational constraints on the present age, the
magnitude-redshift relation for SN Ia, and the primordial element (D, He3, He4,
and Li7) abundances. This claim has been challenged in a proposal that
suggested a high baryon density model (Omega_B*h*h = 0.3) with an expansion
factor varing linearly with time could be consistent with the observed
abundance of primoridal helium-4, while satisfying the age and
magnitude-redshift constraints. In this paper we further explore primordial
nucleosynthesis in generic power-law cosmologies, including the linear case,
concluding that models selected to satisfy the other observational constraints
are incapable of accounting for all the light element abundances.
[55]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9912391 [pdf] - 354190
The Supernova Relic Neutrino Background
Submitted: 1999-12-17, last modified: 2000-03-28
An upper bound to the supernova relic neutrino background from all past Type
II supernovae is obtained using observations of the Universal metal enrichment
history. We show that an unambiguous detection of these relic neutrinos by the
Super-Kamiokande detector is unlikely. We also analyze the event rate in the
Sudbury Neutrino Observatory (where coincident neutrons from anti-nu_e + D -->
n + n + e+ might enhance background rejection), and arrive at the same
conclusion. If the relic neutrino flux should be observed to exceed our upper
bound and if the observations of the metal enrichment history (for z<1) are not
in considerable error, then either the Type II supernova rate does not track
the metal enrichment history or some mechanism may be responsible for
transforming anti-nu_{mu,tau} --> anti-nu_e.
[56]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0002296 [pdf] - 34639
Primordial Nucleosynthesis For The New Millennium
Submitted: 2000-02-14
The physics of the standard hot big bang cosmology ensures that the early
Universe was a primordial nuclear reactor, synthesizing the light nuclides (D,
3He, 4He, and 7Li) in the first 20 minutes of its evolution. After an overview
of nucleosynthesis in the standard model (SBBN), the primordial abundance
yields will be presented, followed by a status report (intended to stimulate
further discussion during this symposium) on the progress along the road from
observational data to inferred primordial abundances. Theory will be confronted
with observations to assess the consistency of SBBN and to constrain cosmology
and particle physics. Some of the issues/problems key to SBBN in the new
millenium will be highlighted, along with a wish list to challenge theorists
and observers alike.
[57]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9909213 [pdf] - 1235388
Ionization Corrections For Low-Metallicity H II Regions and the
Primordial Helium Abundance
Submitted: 1999-09-13, last modified: 1999-11-05
Helium and hydrogen recombination lines observed in low-metallicity,
extragalactic H II regions provide the data used to infer the primordial helium
mass fraction, Y_P. The ionization corrections for unseen neutral helium (or
hydrogen) are usually assumed to be absent; i.e., the ionization correction
factor is taken to be unity (icf = 1). In this paper we revisit the question of
the icf for H II regions ionized by clusters of young, hot, metal-poor stars.
Our key result is that for the H II regions used in the determination of Y_P,
there is a ``reverse'' ionization correction: icf < 1. We explore the effect on
the icf of more realistic inhomogeneous H II region models and find that for
those regions ionized by young stars, with ``hard'' radiation spectra, the icf
is reduced further below unity. In Monte Carlos using H II region data from the
literature (Izotov and Thuan 1998) we estimate a reduction in the published
value of Y_P of order 0.003, which is roughly twice as large as the quoted
statistical error in the Y_P determination.
[58]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9905320 [pdf] - 106646
Primordial Nucleosynthesis: Theory and Observations
Submitted: 1999-05-25
We review the Cosmology and Physics underlying Primordial Nucleosynthesis and
survey current observational data in order to compare the predictions of Big
Bang Nucleosynthesis with the inferred primordial abundances. From this
comparison we report on the status of the consistency of the standard hot big
bang model, we constrain the universal density of baryons (nucleons), and we
set limits to the numbers and/or effective interactions of hypothetical new
"light" particles (equivalent massless neutrinos).
[59]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9803008 [pdf] - 100543
Omega_B and Omega_0 From MACHOs and Local Group Dynamics
Submitted: 1998-03-02, last modified: 1999-02-05
We obtain restrictions on the universal baryon fraction, f_B =
Omega_B/Omega_0, by assuming that the observed microlensing events towards the
Large Magellanic Cloud are due to baryonic MACHOs in the halo of the Galaxy and
by extracting a bound to the total mass of the Milky Way from the motion of
tracer galaxies in the Local Group. We find a lower bound f_B >
0.29^{+0.18}_{-0.15}. Consistency with the predictions of primordial
nucleosynthesis leads to the further constraint on the total mass density,
Omega_0 < 0.2.
[60]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9708016 [pdf] - 98194
Non-Nucleosynthetic Constraints on the Baryon Density and Other
Cosmological Parameters
Submitted: 1997-08-02, last modified: 1998-06-11
Because the baryon-to-photon ratio eta_{10} is in some doubt, we drop
nucleosynthetic constraints on eta_{10} and fit the three cosmological
parameters (h, Omega_M, eta_{10}) to four observational constraints: Hubble
parameter h_o = 0.70+-0.15, age of the universe t_o = 14+7-2 Gyr, cluster gas
fraction f_o \equiv f_G h^{3/2} = 0.060 +- 0.006, and effective shape parameter
Gamma_o = 0.255 +- 0.017. Errors quoted are 1 sigma, and we assume Gaussian
statistics. We experiment with a fifth constraint Omega_o = 0.2 +- 0.1 from
clusters. We set the tilt parameter n = 1 and the gas enhancement factor
Upsilon = 0.9. We consider CDM models (open and Omega_M = 1) and flat LambdaCDM
models. We test goodness of fit and draw confidence regions by the Delta chi^2
method. CDM models with Omega_M = 1 (SCDM models) are accepted only because the
large error on h_o allows h < 0.5. Baryonic matter plays a significant role in
Gamma_o when Omega_M \sim 1. Open CDM models are accepted only for Omega_M
\gtrsim 0.4. The combination of the four other constraints with Omega_o = 0.2
+- 0.1 is rejected in CDM models with 98% confidence, suggesting that light may
not trace mass. LambdaCDM models give similar results. In all of these models,
eta_{10} \gtrsim 6 is favored strongly over eta_{10} \lesssim 2. This suggests
that reports of low deuterium abundances on QSO lines of sight may be correct
and that observational determinations of primordial 4He may have systematic
errors. Plausible variations on n and Upsilon in our models do not change the
results much. If we drop or change the crucial Gamma_o constraint, lower values
of Omega_M and eta_{10} are permitted. The constraint Gamma_o = 0.15 +- 0.04,
derived recently from the IRAS redshift survey, favors Omega_M \approx 0.3 and
eta_{10} \approx 5 but does not exclude eta_{10} \approx 2.
[61]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9805114 [pdf] - 1462711
Observational Constraints On Power-Law Cosmologies
Submitted: 1998-05-08
In a class of models designed to solve the cosmological constant problem by
coupling scalar or tensor classical fields to the space-time curvature, the
universal scale factor grows as a power law in the age, $a \propto t^\alpha$,
regardless of the matter content or cosmological epoch. We investigate
constraints on such "power-law cosmologies" from the present age of the
Universe, the magnitude-redshift relation, and from primordial nucleosynthesis.
Constraints from the current age of the Universe and from the high-redshift
supernovae data require "large" $\alpha$ ($\approx 1$), while consistency with
the inferred primordial abundances of deuterium and helium-4 forces $\alpha$ to
lie in a very narrow range around a lower value ($\approx 0.55$). Inconsistency
between these independent cosmological constraints suggests that such power-law
cosmologies are not viable.
[62]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9803073 [pdf] - 354174
Halo Star Lithium Depletion
Submitted: 1998-03-06
The depletion of lithium during the pre-main sequence and main sequence
phases of stellar evolution plays a crucial role in the comparison of the
predictions of big bang nucleosynthesis with the abundances observed in halo
stars. In the past a wide range of possible depletion factors, ranging from
minimal in standard (non-rotating) stellar models to as much as an order of
magnitude in models including rotational mixing have been suggested. Using
recent progress in the study of the angular momentum evolution of low mass
stars, which now permits the construction of theoretical models that reproduce
the angular momentum evolution of low mass open cluster stars, along with the
observed distribution of initial angular momenta inferred from stellar rotation
data in young open clusters, we study lithium depletion in main sequence halo
stars. We predict a well-defined, nearly flat (in T_eff) halo lithium plateau
with modest scatter and a small population of outliers. We also examine the
relative depletions of 6Li and 7Li finding that the dispersion in the plateau
and the 6Li/7Li depletion ratio scale with the absolute 7Li depletion. Using
observational data to bound the 7Li depletion in main sequence halo stars, we
find a maximum depletion of 0.4 dex is set by the observed dispersion and the
6Li/7Li depletion ratio, and a minimum depletion of 0.2 dex is required by both
the presence of highly overdepleted halo stars and consistency with the solar
and open cluster 7Li data. The cosmological implications of these bounds on the
primordial abundance of 7Li are discussed. (Abridged)
[63]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9803055 [pdf] - 100590
Big Bang Nucleosynthesis: Current Status
Submitted: 1998-03-05
During its hot, dense, early evolution the Universe was a primordial nuclear
reactor, synthesizing the light nuclides D, 3He, 4He and 7Li in the first
thousand seconds. The presently observed abundances of these relic nuclides
provide a unique window on the early Universe. The implications of current
observations for cosmology (the universal density of nucleons) and for particle
physics (new particles beyond the standard model) will be reviewed. The present
data appear to be in rough agreement with the predictions of the standard, hot
big bang model for three species of light neutrinos, and a nucleon-to-photon
ratio restricted to a narrow range of 3-4 parts in 10 billion. On closer
inspection, however, a tension is revealed between the inferred primordial
abundances of deuterium and helium-4. Although observations of deuterium in
nearly primordial, high-redshift QSO absorbers may help to relieve this
tension, current data appear to exacerbate the crisis. Resolution of this
conflict may lie with the data (statistical uncertainties?), with the analysis
of the data (systematic uncertainties?), or with the fundamental physics
(massive, unstable, and/or degenerate neutrinos?). Independent (non-BBN)
evidence from cosmological observations of large-scale dynamics and structure
may be useful in deciding among the current options.
[64]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9802317 [pdf] - 100488
Non-BBN Constraints On The Key Cosmological Parameters
Submitted: 1998-02-24
Since the baryon-to-photon ratio "eta" is in some doubt at present, we ignore
the constraints on eta from big bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) and fit the three
key cosmological parameters (h, Omega_M, eta) to four other observational
constraints: Hubble parameter, age of the universe, cluster gas (baryon)
fraction, and effective shape parameter "Gamma". We consider open and flat CDM
models and flat "Lambda"-CDM models, testing goodness of fit and drawing
confidence regions by the Delta-chi^2 method. CDM models with Omega_M = 1 (SCDM
models) are accepted only because we allow a large error on h, permitting h <
0.5. Open CDM models are accepted only for Omega_M \gsim 0.4. Lambda-CDM models
give similar results. In all of these models, large eta (\gsim 6) is favored
strongly over small eta, supporting reports of low deuterium abundances on some
QSO lines of sight, and suggesting that observational determinations of
primordial 4He may be contaminated by systematic errors. Only if we drop the
crucial Gamma constraint are much lower values of Omega_M and eta permitted.
[65]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9706114 [pdf] - 97635
Is High Primordial Deuterium Consistent With Galactic Evolution?
Submitted: 1997-06-11, last modified: 1997-12-11
Galactic destruction of primordial deuterium is inevitably linked through
star formation to the chemical evolution of the Galaxy. The relatively high
present gas content and low metallicity suggest only modest D-destruction. In
concert with deuterium abundances derived from solar system and/or interstellar
observations this suggests a primordial deuterium abundance in possible
conflict with data from some high-redshift, low-metallicity QSO absorbers. We
have explored a variety of chemical evolution models including infall of
processed material and early, supernovae-driven winds with the aim of
identifying models with large D-destruction which are consistent with the
observations of stellar-produced heavy elements. When such models are
confronted with data we reconfirm that only modest destruction of deuterium
(less than a factor of 3) is permitted. When combined with solar system and
interstellar data these results favor the low deuterium abundances derived for
the QSO absorbers observed by Tytler et al (1996) and by Burles & Tytler
(1996).
[66]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9710035 [pdf] - 98794
Rotational Mixing And The Primordial Lithium Abundance
Submitted: 1997-10-02, last modified: 1997-12-10
There has been recent progress in the study of the angular momentum evolution
of low mass stars (Krishnamurthi et al 1997a). Theoretical models can now be
constructed which reproduce the angular momentum evolution of low mass open
cluster stars and the distribution of initial conditions can be inferred from
young clusters. In this poster we report on the application of these models to
the problem of rotational mixing in halo stars. The distribution of initial
conditions inferred from young clusters produces a well-defined halo lithium
"plateau" with modest scatter and a small population of outliers. Different
choices for the solar calibration produce a range of absolute depletion
factors. We show that both the dispersion and the ratio of $^6$Li depletion to
$^7$Li depletion increase as the absolute $^7$Li depletion increases. The
measured $^6$Li in HD 84937 and the dispersion in the plateau set independent
upper bounds on the $^7$Li depletion. Consistency with open clusters and the
Sun, along with claims of an intrinsic dispersion in the plateau, set a lower
bound. We derive a range of 0.2-0.4 dex $^7$Li depletion in halo field stars.
Implications for cosmology are discussed.
[67]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9704167 [pdf] - 1234971
Temperature Fluctuations and Abundances in HII Galaxies
Submitted: 1997-04-16
There is evidence for temperature fluctuations in Planetary Nebulae and in
Galactic HII regions. If such fluctuations occur in the low-metallicity,
extragalactic HII regions used to probe the primordial helium abundance, the
derived 4He mass fraction, Y_P, could be systematically different from the true
primordial value. For cooler, mainly high-metallicity HII regions the derived
helium abundance may be nearly unchanged but the oxygen abundance could have
been seriously underestimated. For hotter, mainly low-metallicity HII regions
the oxygen abundance is likely accurate but the helium abundance could be
underestimated. The net effect is to tilt the Y vs. Z relation, making it
flatter and resulting in a higher inferred Y_P. Although this effect could be
large, there are no data which allow us to estimate the size of the temperature
fluctuations for the extragalactic HII regions. Therefore, we have explored
this effect via Monte Carlos in which the abundances derived from a fiducial
data set are modified by \Delta-T chosen from a distribution with 0 < \Delta-T
< \Delta-T_max where \Delta-T_max is varied from 500K to 4000K. It is
interesting that although this effect shifts the locations of the HII regions
in Y vs. O/H plane, it does not introduce any significant additional
dispersion.
[68]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9611166 [pdf] - 95960
The Primordial Abundance of He4: An Update
Submitted: 1996-11-20
We include new data in an updated analysis of helium in low metallicity
extragalactic HII regions with the goal of deriving the primordial abundance of
He4 (Y_P). We show that the new observations of Izotov et al (ITL) are
consistent with previous data. However they should not be taken in isolation to
determine (Y_P) due to the lack of sufficiently low metallicity points. We use
the extant data in a semi-empirical approach to bounding the size of possible
systematic uncertainties in the determination of (Y_P). Our best estimate for
the primordial abundance of He4 assuming a linear relation between He4 and O/H
is Y_P = 0.230 \pm 0.003 (stat) based on the subset of HII regions with the
lowest metallicity; for our full data set we find Y_P = 0.234 \pm 0.002 (stat).
Both values are entirely consistent with our previous results. We discuss the
implications of these values for standard big bang nucleosynthesis (SBBN),
particularly in the context of recent measurements of deuterium in high
redshift, low metallicity QSO absorption-line systems.
[69]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9610113 [pdf] - 95637
Primordial Deuterium and Big Bang Nucleosynthesis: A Tale of Two
Abundances
Submitted: 1996-10-15
Recent confrontations of the predictions of standard big bang nucleosynthesis
(SBBN) with the primordial abundances of the light nuclides inferred from
observational data reveal a conflict. Simply put, compared to theoretical
expectations the inferred primordial abundances of either deuterium or helium-4
(or both) are ``too small". Here I outline the ``tension" between D and $^4$He
in the context of SBBN. The incipient crisis for SBBN may be resolved by
observations of deuterium in nearly pristine environments such as the
high-redshift, low-metallicity QSO absorbers. At present the big bang
abundances of deuterium inferred from such data fall into two, apparently
mutually exclusive, groups. I describe the deuterium dichotomy and its
implications for SBBN as well as for cosmology in general.
[70]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9608084 [pdf] - 95202
The Crisis Confronting Standard Big Bang Nucleosynthesis
Submitted: 1996-08-13
Primordial nucleosynthesis is inevitable during the early evolution of an
expanding universe filled with radiation and matter (baryons). However, the
precise abundance yields depend sensitively on the baryon density, the
radiation content and the early expansion rate. For ``standard" big bang
nucleosynthesis (SBBN) only D, $^3$He, $^4$He and $^7$Li are produced in
astrophysically interesting abundances which depend on only one ``free"
parameter, $\eta = n_{\rm B}/n_{\gamma}$, the ratio of baryons (nucleons) to
photons. With four primordial abundances and one adjustable parameter, SBBN is
an eminently testable theory. In the confrontation of theory with data current
observations suggest a crisis traceable to the tension between deuterium
(favoring a ``high" value of $\eta$) and helium-4 (preferring a ``low" $\eta$
value). In this contribution, the written version of the material I discussed
at the Princeton University ``Critical Dialogues in Cosmology" (June 1996), I
will present the case for a conflict and show how recent observations of
deuterium in nearly primordial QSO absorbers exacerbate the problem. I conclude
with a brief description of an alternate, ``dynamical" approach to bounding the
nucleon density which may be of some value given the current deuterium
dichotomy.
[71]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9603087 [pdf] - 94297
Cosmological Implications of Two Conflicting Deuterium Abundances
Submitted: 1996-03-17
Constraints on big bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) and on cosmological parameters
from conflicting deuterium observations in different high red-shift QSO systems
are discussed. The high deuterium observations by Carswell et al., Songaila et
al., and Rugers & Hogan is consistent with 4He and 7Li observations and
Standard BBN (N_nu =3) and allows N_nu \leq 3.6 at 95% C.L., but is
inconsistent with local observations of D and 3He in the context of
conventional theories of stellar and Galactic evolution. In contrast, the low
deuterium observations by Tytler, Fan & Burles and Burles & Tytler are
consistent with the constraints from local Galactic observations, but require
N_nu = 1.9 +/- 0.3 at 68% C.L., excluding Standard BBN at 99.9% C.L., unless
the systematic uncertainties in the 4He observations have been underestimated
by a large amount. The high and low primordial deuterium abundances imply,
respectively, Omega_B h^2 = 0.005 - 0.01 and Omega_B h^2 = 0.02 - 0.03 at 95%
C.L. When combined with the high baryon fraction inferred from x-ray
observations of rich clusters, the corresponding total mass densities (for 50
\le H_0 \le 90) are Omega_M = 0.05 - 0.20 and Omega_M = 0.2 - 0.7, respectively
(95\% C.L.) The range of Omega_M corresponding to high D is in conflict with
dynamical constraints (Omega_M > 0.2 - 0.3) and with the shape parameter
constraint (Gamma = Omega_M h = 0.25 +/- 0.05) from large scale structure
formation in CDM and Lambda-CDM models.
[72]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9602029 [pdf] - 94081
Big Bang Nucleosynthesis
Submitted: 1996-02-06
In the first thousand seconds of its evolution the Universe was a primordial
nuclear reactor synthesizing the nuclides D, $^3$He, $^4$He and $^7$Li. These
messengers from the Big Bang provide a unique window on the early, hot, dense
Universe, offering the opportunity for tests of the standard models of particle
physics and of cosmology. A new, statistically coherent comparison of the
primordial abundances of these nuclides inferred from increasingly accurate
observational data with those predicted by the standard model hints at a
possible crisis. The case for this emerging crisis is presented and several
paths towards ameliorating it are explored.
[73]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9601126 [pdf] - 93981
Testing Big Bang Nucleosynthesis
Submitted: 1996-01-23, last modified: 1996-01-24
Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN), along with the cosmic background radiation
and the Hubble expansion, is one of the pillars ofthe standard, hot, big bang
cosmology since the primordial synthesis of the light nuclides (D, $^3$He,
$^4$He, $^7$Li) must have occurred during the early evolution of a universe
described by this model. The overall consistency between the predicted and
observed abundances of the light nuclides, each of which spans a range of some
nine orders of magnitude, provides impressive support for the standard models
of cosmology and particle physics. Here, the results of recent, statistically
consistent tests of BBN are described. This new confrontation between theory
and data challenges the standard model. The crises confronting BBN are
identified and several possible resolutions are outlined.
[74]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9601117 [pdf] - 93972
Galactic Evolution Of D And 3He Including Stellar Production Of 3He
Submitted: 1996-01-22
New stellar models which track the production and destruction of $^3$He (and
D) have been evolved for a range of stellar masses $(0.65\leq M/M_{\odot}\leq
100)$, metallicities $(0.01 \leq Z/Z_{\odot} \leq 1)$ and initial (main
sequence) $^3$He mass fractions $(10^{-5} \leq X_{3,MS} \leq 10^{-3})$. Armed
with the $^3$He yields from these stellar models we have followed the evolution
of D and $^3$He using a variety of chemical evolution models with and without
infall of primordial or processed material. Production of new $^3$He by the
lower mass stars overwhelms any reasonable primordial contributions and leads
to predicted abundances in the presolar nebula and/or the present interstellar
medium in excess of the observationally inferred values. This result, which
obtains even for zero primordial D and $^3$He, and was anticipated by Rood,
Steigman \& Tinsley (1976), is insensitive to the choice of chemical evolution
model; it is driven by the large $^3$He yields from low mass stars. In an
attempt to ameliorate this problem we have considered a number of non-standard
models in which the yields from low mass stars have been modified. Although
several of these non-standard models may be consistent with the $^3$He data,
they may be inconsistent with observations of $^{12}$C/$^{13}$C, $^{18}$O and,
most seriously, the super-$^3$He rich planetary nebulae (Rood, Bania \& Wilson
1992). Even using the most extreme of these non-standard models (Hogan 1995),
we obtain a generous upper bound to pre-galactic $^3$He: X$_{3P} \leq 3.2
\times10^{-5}$ which, nonetheless, leads to a stringent lower bound to the
universal density of nucleons.
[75]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9412087 [pdf] - 92186
Predicting Big Bang Deuterium
Submitted: 1994-12-22, last modified: 1995-11-07
We present new upper and lower bounds to the primordial abundances of
deuterium and helium-3 based on observational data from the solar system and
the interstellar medium. Independent of any model for the primordial production
of the elements we find (at the 95\% C.L.): $1.5 \times 10^{-5} \le (D/H)_P \le
10.0 \times 10^{-5}$ and $(^3He/H)_P \le 2.6\times 10^{-5}$. When combined with
the predictions of standard big bang nucleosynthesis, these constraints lead to
a 95\% C.L. bound on the primordial abundance of deuterium: $(D/H)_{best} =
(3.5^{+2.7}_{-1.8})\times 10^{-5}$. Measurements of deuterium absorption in the
spectra of high redshift QSOs will directly test this prediction. The
implications of this prediction for the primordial abundances of helium-4 and
lithium-7 are discussed, as well as those for the universal density of baryons.
[76]
oai:arXiv.org:hep-ph/9505319 [pdf] - 115763
Big Bang Nucleosynthesis in Crisis?
Submitted: 1995-05-16, last modified: 1995-11-07
A new evaluation of the constraint on the number of light neutrino species
(N_nu) from big bang nucleosynthesis suggests a discrepancy between the
predicted light element abundances and those inferred from observations, unless
the inferred primordial 4He abundance has been underestimated by 0.014 +/-
0.004 (1 sigma) or less than 10% (95%C.L.) of 3He survives stellar processing.
With the quoted systematic errors in the observed abundances and a conservative
chemical evolution parameterization, the best fit to the combined data is N_nu
= 2.1 +/- 0.3 (1 sigma) and the upper limit is N_nu < 2.6 (95% C.L.). The data
are inconsistent with the Standard Model (N_nu = 3) at the 98.6% C.L.
[77]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9505059 [pdf] - 398738
Post Big Bang Processing of the Primordial Elements
Submitted: 1995-05-12
We explore the Gnedin-Ostriker suggestion that a post-Big-Bang
photodissociation process may modify the primordial abundances of the light
elements. We consider several specific models and discuss the general features
that are necessary (but not necessarily sufficient) to make the model work. We
find that with any significant processing, the final D and $^3$He abundances,
which are independent of their initial standard big bang nucleosynthesis (SBBN)
values, rise quickly to a level several orders of magnitude above the
observationally inferred primordial values. Solutions for specific models show
that the only initial abundances that can be photoprocessed into agreement with
observations are those that undergo virtually no processing and are already in
agreement with observation. Thus it is unlikely that this model can work for
any non-trivial case unless an artificial density and/or photon distribution is
invoked.
[78]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9504048 [pdf] - 92589
COSMIC LITHIUM: GOING UP OR COMING DOWN ?
Submitted: 1995-04-14
Observations of interstellar lithium provide a valuable complement to studies
of lithium in Pop I and Pop II stars. Large corrections for unseen LiII and for
non-gas phase lithium have provided obstacles to using interstellar data for
abundance determinations. An approach to surmounting these difficulties is
proposed and is applied to the Galaxy and the LMC. The key is that since
potassium and lithium behave similarly regarding ionization and depletion,
their observed ratio (LiI/KI) can be used to probe the abundance and evolution
of lithium. For ten lines-of-sight in the interstellar medium of the Galaxy
(ISM) the Li/K ratio observed $(\log (N_{Li}/N_K)_{ISM} = - 1.88 \pm 0.09)$ is
entirely consistent with the solar system value $(\log (N_{Li}/N_{K})_{\odot} =
- 1.82 \pm 0.05)$. The absence of LiI in front of SN87A in the LMC, coupled
with the observed KI, corresponds to an upper bound (at $\rsim 95 \% \ CL$) of
$\log (N_{Li}/N_K)_{LMC} < - 0.3 + \log (N_{Li}/N_K)_{ISM}.$ This low upper
bound to LMC lithium suggests that cosmic lithium is on its way up from a
primordial abundance lower, by at least a factor of two, than the present Pop I
value of $[Li]_{PopI} \equiv 12 + \log (Li/H)_{PopI} = 3.2 \pm 0.1$.
[79]
oai:arXiv.org:hep-ph/9502400 [pdf] - 1472646
A New Look At Neutrino Limits From Big Bang Nucleosynthesis
Submitted: 1995-02-27
We take a fresh look at the limits on the number of neutrino flavors derived
from big bang nucleosynthesis. In particular, recent measurements of the \he4
abundance enable one to estimate the primordial \he4 mass fraction at $Y_p =
0.232 \pm .003(stat) \pm .005(syst)$. For a baryon to photon ratio, $\eta$,
consistent with the other light elements, this leads to a best fit for the
number of neutrino flavors $N_\nu < 3$ (the precise number depends on $\eta$)
indicating a very strong upper limit to $N_\nu$. Here, we derive new upper
limits on $N_\nu$, paying special attention to the fact that the best estimate
may lie in an unphysical region ($N_\nu < 3$ if all three neutrino flavors are
light or massless; the lower bound to $N_\nu$ may even be as low as 2, if the
small window for a $\nu_\tau$ mass is exploited.) Our resulting upper limits
therefore depend on whether $N_\nu \ge 2$ or 3 is assumed. We also explore the
sensitivity of our results to the adopted value of $\eta$ and the assumed
systematic errors in $Y_p$.
[80]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9502067 [pdf] - 1469189
Generic Evolution Of Deuterium And Helium-3
Submitted: 1995-02-13
The primordial abundances of deuterium and of helium-3, produced during big
bang nucleosynthesis, depend sensitively on the baryon density. Thus, the
observed abundances of D and \he may provide useful ``baryometers'' provided
the evolution from primordial to present (or, presolar nebula) abundances is
understood. Inevitably, the derivation of primordial from observed abundances
requires the intervention of a model for galactic evolution and, so, the
inferred primordial abundances are, necessarily, model dependent. Here, an
analytic framework for the evolution of D and \he is presented which is
``generic'' in the sense that it should describe the results of any specific
galactic evolution model. The ``effective \he survival fraction'', $\Gamma _3$,
is the one free parameter which is model specific. Solar system and
interstellar data are used to infer upper and lower bounds to the primordial
deuterium mass fraction $(X_{2P})$ as a function of $\Gamma _3$ and, these
bounds are used to constrain the present baryon-to-photon ratio $(\eta)$ and
baryon density $(\Omega_B)$. For $\Gamma _3 \geq$ 1/4 it is found that (from D
and \he alone): $3.1 \leq \eta_{10} \leq 9.0$; $0.045 \leq \Omega_B h^2_{50}
\leq 0.133$ (where $H_0 = 50h_{50}$ km$\,$s$^{-1}$ Mpc$^{-1}$).
[81]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9502029 [pdf] - 1469167
THE X-RAY CLUSTER BARYON CRISIS
Submitted: 1995-02-06
Nucleosynthesis in the standard hot big bang cosmology offers a successful
account of the production of the light nuclides during the early evolution of
the Universe. Consistency among the predicted and observed abundances of D,
$^3$He, \hel4 and \li7 leads to restrictive lower and upper bounds to the
present density of nucleons. In particular, the upper bound ensures that
nucleons cannot account for more than a small fraction $(<0.06 h{^{-2} _{50}})$
of the mass in a critical density (Einstein-de Sitter) Universe. In contrast,
x-ray observations of rich clusters of galaxies suggest strongly that baryons
(in hot gas) contribute a significant fraction of the total cluster mass $(\ge
0.2 h{^{-3/2} _{50}})$. If, indeed, clusters do provide a ``fair" sample of the
mass in the Universe, this ``crisis" forces us to consider other ways of
mitigating it, including the politically incorrect possibility that $\Omega <
1$. The options, including magnetic or turbulent pressure, clumping, and
non-zero space curvature and/or cosmological constant, are discussed.
[82]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9410060 [pdf] - 91944
Big Bang Nucleosynthesis: Consistency Or Crisis ?
Submitted: 1994-10-19
The early, hot, dense, expanding Universe was a primordial reactor in which
the light nuclides D, 3He, 4He and 7Li were synthesized in astrophysically
interesting abundances. The challenge to the standard hot big bang model (Big
Bang Nucleosynthesis = BBN) is the comparison between the observed and
predicted abundances, the latter which depend only on the universal abundance
of nucleons. The current status of observations is reviewed and the inferred
primordial abundances are used to confront BBN. This comparison suggests
consistency for BBN for a narrow range in the nucleon abundance but, looming on
the horizon are some potential crises which will be outlined.
[83]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9405038 [pdf] - 1419117
Cosmic Deuterium Or A Hydrogen Interloper ?
Submitted: 1994-05-16
Two groups have independently reported the possible detection of
extragalactic deuterium in the absorption spectrum of the same high redshift,
low metalicity QSO. Although the high value for the inferred deuterium
abundance poses no problems for cosmology (i.e., big bang nucleosynthesis), it
is in apparent conflict with solar system observations of deuterium and
helium-3. This latter inconsistency is explained and made quantitative and it
is shown that, unless the inferred D/H ratio is too high by a factor of three,
these data challange our understanding of the stellar and galactic evolution of
helium-3. This conflict is resolved if the observed absorption feature is, in
fact, due to a hydrogen interloper rather than to high z, low Z deuterium.
[84]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9405022 [pdf] - 91458
On the Abundance of Primordial Helium
Submitted: 1994-05-11
We have used recent observations of helium-4, nitrogen and oxygen from some
four dozen, low metallicity, extra-galactic HII regions to define mean $N$
versus $O$, $^4He$ versus $N$ and $^4He$ versus $O$ relations which are
extrapolated to zero metallicity to determine the primordial $^4He$ mass
fraction $Y_P$. The data and various subsets of the data, selected on the basis
of nitrogen and oxygen, are all consistent with $Y_P = 0.232 \pm 0.003$. For
the 2$\sigma$ (statistical) upper bound we find $Y_P^{2\sigma} \le 0.238$.
Estimating a 2\% systematic uncertainty $(\sigma _{syst} = \pm 0.005)$ leads to
a maximum upper bound to the primordial helium mass fraction: $Y_P^{MAX} =
Y_P^{2\sigma} + \sigma_{syst} \le 0.243$. We compare these upper bounds to
$Y_P$ with recent calculations of the predicted yield from big bang
nucleosynthesis to derive upper bounds to the nucleon-to-photon ratio $\eta$
($\eta_{10} \equiv 10^{10}\eta$) and the number of equivalent light (\lsim 10
MeV) neutrino species. For $Y_P \le 0.238$ ($0.243$), we find $\eta_{10} \le
2.5 (3.9)$ and $N_\nu \leq 2.7 (3.1)$. If indeed $Y_P \le 0.238$, then BBN
predicts enhanced production of deuterium and helium-3 which may be in conflict
with the primordial abundances inferred from model dependent (chemical
evolution) extrapolations of solar system and interstellar observations. Better
chemical evolution models and more data - especially $D$-absorption in the QSO
Ly-$\alpha$ clouds - will be crucial to resolve this potential crisis for BBN.
The larger upper bound, $Y_P \leq 0.243$ is completely