Normalized to: Stammler, S.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.08799 [pdf] - 2115462
Constraining the parameter space for the Solar Nebula
Submitted: 2020-06-15
If we want to understand planetesimal formation, the only data set we have is
our own Solar System. It is particularly interesting as it is so far the only
planetary system we know of that developed life. Understanding the conditions
under which the Solar Nebula evolved is crucial in order to understand the
different processes in the disk and the subsequent dynamical interaction
between (proto-)planets, once the gas disk is gone. Protoplanetary disks
provide a plethora of different parameters to explore. The question is whether
this parameter space can be constrained, allowing simulations to reproduce the
Solar System. Models and observations of planet formation provide constraints
on the initial planetesimal mass in certain regions of the Solar Nebula. By
making use of pebble flux-regulated planetesimal formation, we perform a
parameter study with nine different disk parameters like the initial disk mass,
initial disk size, initial dust-to-gas ratio, turbulence level, and more. We
find that the distribution of mass in planetesimals in the disk depends on the
planetesimal formation timescale and the pebbles' drift timescale. Multiple
disk parameters can influence pebble properties and thus planetesimal
formation. However, it is still possible to draw some conclusions on potential
parameter ranges. Pebble flux-regulated planetesimal formation seems to be very
robust, allowing simulations with a wide range of parameters to meet the
initial planetesimal constraints for the Solar Nebula. I.e., it does not
require a lot of fine tuning.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.06522 [pdf] - 2077059
Planet-induced Vortices with Dust Coagulation in Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2020-03-13
In this work, we study how the dust coagulation/fragmentation will influence
the evolution and observational appearances of vortices induced by a massive
planet embedded in a low viscosity disk by performing global 2D high-resolution
hydrodynamical simulations. Within the vortex, due to its higher gas surface
density and steeper pressure gradients, dust coagulation, fragmentation and
drift (to the vortex center) are all quite efficient, producing dust particles
ranging from micron to $\sim 1.0\ {\rm cm}$, as well as overall high
dust-to-gas ratio (above unity). In addition, the dust size distribution is
quite non-uniform inside the vortex, with the mass weighted average dust size
at the vortex center ($\sim 4.0$ mm) being a factor of $\sim10$ larger than
other vortex regions. Both large ($\sim$ mm) and small (tens of micron)
particles contribute strongly to affect the gas motion within the vortex. As
such, we find that the inclusion of dust coagulation has a significant impact
on the vortex lifetime and the typical vortex lifetime is about 1000 orbits.
After the initial gaseous vortex is destroyed, the dust spreads into a ring
with a few remaining smaller gaseous vortices with a high dust concentration
and a large maximum size ($\sim$ mm). At late time, the synthetic dust
continuum images for the coagulation case show as a ring inlaid with several
hot spots at 1.33 mm band, while only distinct hot spots remain at 7.0 mm.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.07708 [pdf] - 2072543
Gas accretion damped by dust back-reaction at the snow line
Submitted: 2019-06-18, last modified: 2020-02-27
Context. The water snowline divides dry and icy solid material in
protoplanetary disks, and has been thought to significantly affect planet
formation at all stages. If dry particles break up more easily than icy ones,
then the snowline causes a traffic jam, because small grains drift inward at
lower speeds than larger pebbles. Aims. We aim to evaluate the effect of high
dust concentrations around the snowline onto the gas dynamics. Methods. Using
numerical simulations, we model the global radial evolution of an axisymmetric
protoplanetary disk. Our model includes particle growth, evaporation and
recondensation of water, and the back-reaction of dust onto the gas, taking
into account the vertical distribution of dust particles. Results. We find that
the dust back-reaction can stop and even reverse the net flux of gas outside
the snowline, decreasing the gas accretion rate onto the star to under $50\%$
of its initial value. At the same time the dust accumulates at the snowline,
reaching dust-to-gas ratios of $\epsilon \gtrsim 0.8$, and delivers large
amounts of water vapor towards the inner disk, as the icy particles cross the
snowline. However, the accumulation of dust at the snowline and the decrease in
the gas accretion rate only take place if the global dust-to-gas ratio is high
($\varepsilon_0 \gtrsim 0.03$), if the viscous turbulence is low ($\alpha_\nu
\lesssim 10^{-3} $), if the disk is large enough ($r_c \gtrsim 100\,
\textrm{au}$), and only during the early phases of the disk evolution ($t
\lesssim 1\, \textrm{Myr}$). Otherwise the dust back-reaction fails to perturb
the gas motion.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.11178 [pdf] - 2042344
Ring Morphology with Dust Coagulation in Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2019-12-23
Tidal interactions between the embedded planets and their surrounding
protoplanetary disks are often postulated to produce the observed complex dust
substructures, including rings, gaps, and asymmetries. In this Letter, we
explore the consequences of dust coagulation on the dust dynamics and ring
morphology. Coagulation of dust grains leads to dust size growth which, under
typical disk conditions, produces faster radial drifts, potentially threatening
the dust ring formation. Utilizing 2D hydrodynamical simulations of
protoplanetary disks which include a full treatment of dust coagulation, we
find that if the planet does not open a gap quickly enough, the formation of an
inner ring is impeded due to dust coagulation and subsequent radial drift.
Furthermore, we find that a "buildup" of sub-mm sized grains often appears in
the dust emission at the outer edge of the dust disk.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.10526 [pdf] - 2025860
Including Dust Coagulation in Hydrodynamic Models of Protoplanetary
Disks: Dust Evolution in the Vicinity of a Jupiter-mass Planet
Submitted: 2019-09-23
Dust growth is often neglected when building models of protoplanetary disks
due to its complexity and computational expense. However, it does play a major
role in shaping the evolution of protoplanetary dust and planet formation. In
this paper, we present a numerical model coupling 2-D hydrodynamic evolution of
a protoplanetary disk, including a Jupiter-mass planet, and dust coagulation.
This is obtained by including multiple dust fluids in a single grid-based
hydrodynamic simulation and solving the Smoluchowski equation for dust
coagulation on top of solving for the hydrodynamic evolution. We find that
fragmentation of dust aggregates trapped in a pressure bump outside of the
planetary gap leads to an enhancement in density of small grains. We compare
the results obtained from the full coagulation treatment to the commonly used,
fixed dust size approach and to previously applied, less computationally
intensive methods for including dust coagulation. We find that the full
coagulation results cannot be reproduced using the fixed-size treatment, but
some can be mimicked using a relatively simple method for estimating the
characteristic dust size in every grid cell.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.04674 [pdf] - 1975444
The DSHARP Rings: Evidence of Ongoing Planetesimal Formation?
Submitted: 2019-09-10
Recent high-resolution interferometric observations of protoplanetary disks
at (sub-)millimeter wavelengths reveal omnipresent substructures, such as
rings, spirals, and asymmetries. A detailed investigation of eight rings
detected in five disks by the DSHARP survey came to the conclusion that all
rings are just marginally optically thick with optical depths between 0.2 and
0.5 at a wavelength of 1.25 mm. This surprising result could either be
coincidental or indicate that the optical depth in all of the rings is
regulated by the same process.
We investigated if ongoing planetesimal formation could explain the
"fine-tuned" optical depths in the DSHARP rings by removing dust and
transforming it into "invisible" planetesimals. We performed a one-dimensional
simulation of dust evolution in the second dust ring of the protoplanetary disk
around HD 163296, including radial transport of gas and dust, dust growth and
fragmentation, and planetesimal formation via gravitational collapse of
sufficiently dense pebble concentrations.
We show that planetesimal formation can naturally explain the observed
optical depths if streaming instability regulates the midplane dust-to-gas
ratio to unity. Furthermore, our simple monodisperse analytical model supports
the hypothesis that planetesimal formation in dust rings should universally
limit their optical depth to the observed range.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.01285 [pdf] - 1901923
Effects of Ringed Structures and Dust Size Growth on Millimeter
Observations of Protoplanetary Disks
Li, Ya-Ping;
Li, Hui;
Ricci, Luca;
Li, Shengtai;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Isella, Andrea;
Ansdell, Megan;
Yuan, Feng;
Drazkowska, Joanna;
Stammler, Sebastian
Submitted: 2019-05-03
The growth of solids from sub-micron to millimeter and centimeter sizes is
the early step toward the formation of planets inside protoplanetary disks
(PPDs). However, such processes and their potential impact on the later stages
of solid growth are still poorly understood. In this work, we test the
hypothesis that most disks contain at least one ringed structure with a
relative small radius. We have carried out a large family of 1D two-fluid
(gas+dust) hydrodynamical simulations by evolving the gas and dust motion
self-consistently while allowing dust size to evolve via coagulation and
fragmentation. We investigate the joint effects of ringed structures and dust
size growth on the overall sub-millimeter and millimeter (mm) flux and spectral
index of PPDs. Ringed structures slow down the dust radial drift and speed up
the dust growth. In particular, we find that those unresolved disks with a high
fragmentation velocity ($\sim10\ {\rm m~s^{-1}}$) and a high dust surface
density ($\sim10\ {\rm g\ cm^{-2}}$ in the ring) can have mm spectral indices
as low as $\sim2.0$, consistent with mm observations of faint disks in nearby
star forming regions. Furthermore, disks with more than one ringed structure
can potentially reproduce brighter disks with spectral indices lower than
$\sim2.5$. Future multi-wavelength high-resolution observations of these low
spectral index sources can be used to test the existence of the ringed
structures in the unresolved disks and differentiate the effects of dust size
growth from optical depth.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.06194 [pdf] - 1822908
The dimming of RW Auriga. Is dust accretion preceding an outburst?
Submitted: 2018-10-15, last modified: 2019-01-08
RW Aur A has experienced various dimming events in the last years, decreasing
its brightness by $\sim 2\ \textrm{mag}$ for periods of months to years.
Multiple observations indicate that a high concentration of dust grains, from
the protoplanetary disk's inner regions, is blocking the starlight during these
events. We propose a new mechanism that can send large amounts of dust close to
the star on short timescales, through the reactivation of a dead zone in the
protoplanetary disk. Using numerical simulations we model the accretion of gas
and dust, along with the growth and fragmentation of particles in this
scenario. We find that after the reactivation of the dead zone, the accumulated
dust is rapidly accreted towards the star in around 15 years, at rates of
$\dot{M}_\textrm{d} = 6 \times 10^{-6}\, \textrm{M}_\odot/\textrm{yr}$ and
reaching dust-to-gas ratios of $\epsilon \approx 5$, preceding an increase in
the gas accretion by a few years. This sudden rise of dust accretion can
provide the material required for the dimmings, although the question of how to
put the dust into the line of sight remains open to speculation.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.08441 [pdf] - 1822954
Dusty spirals triggered by shadows in transition discs
Submitted: 2018-11-20
Context. Despite the recent discovery of spiral-shaped features in
protoplanetary discs in the near-infrared and millimetric wavelengths, there is
still an active discussion to understand how they formed. In fact, the spiral
waves observed in discs around young stars can be due to different physical
mechanisms: planet/companion torques, gravitational perturbations or
illumination effects. Aims. We study the spirals formed in the gaseous phase
due to two diametrically opposed shadows cast at fixed disc locations. The
shadows are created by an inclined non-precessing disc inside the cavity, which
is assumed to be optically thick. In particular, we analyse the effect of these
spirals on the dynamics of the dust particles and discuss their detectability
in transition discs. Methods. We perform gaseous hydrodynamical simulations
with shadows, then we compute the dust evolution on top of the gaseous
distribution, and finally we produce synthetic ALMA observations of the dust
emission based on radiative transfer calculations. Results. Our main finding is
that mm- to cm-sized dust particles are efficiently trapped inside the
shadow-triggered spirals. We also observe that particles of various sizes
starting at different stellocentric distances are well mixed inside these
pressure maxima. This dynamical effect would favour grain growth and affect the
resulting composition of planetesimals in the disc. In addition, our radiative
transfer calculations show spiral patterns in the disc at 1.6 {\mu}m and 1.3
mm. Due to their faint thermal emission (compared to the bright inner regions
of the disc) the spirals cannot be detected with ALMA. Our synthetic
observations prove however that shadows are observable as dips in the thermal
emission.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.02321 [pdf] - 1585682
Dust Density Distribution and Imaging Analysis of Different Ice Lines in
Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2017-07-07, last modified: 2017-08-02
Recent high angular resolution observations of protoplanetary disks at
different wavelengths have revealed several kinds of structures, including
multiple bright and dark rings. Embedded planets are the most used explanation
for such structures, but there are alternative models capable of shaping the
dust in rings as it has been observed. We assume a disk around a Herbig star
and investigate the effect that ice lines have on the dust evolution, following
the growth, fragmentation, and dynamics of multiple dust size particles,
covering from 1 $\mu$m to 2 m sized objects. We use simplified prescriptions of
the fragmentation velocity threshold, which is assumed to change radially at
the location of one, two, or three ice lines. We assume changes at the radial
location of main volatiles, specifically H$_2$O, CO$_2$, and NH$_3$. Radiative
transfer calculations are done using the resulting dust density distributions
in order to compare with current multiwavelength observations. We find that the
structures in the dust density profiles and radial intensities at different
wavelengths strongly depend on the disk viscosity. A clear gap of emission can
be formed between ice lines and be surrounded by ring-like structures, in
particular between the H$_2$O and CO$_2$ (or CO). The gaps are expected to be
shallower and narrower at millimeter emission than at near-infrared, opposite
to model predictions of particle trapping. In our models, the total gas surface
density is not expected to show strong variations, in contrast to other
gap-forming scenarios such as embedded giant planets or radial variations of
the disk viscosity.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.02385 [pdf] - 1564009
Redistribution of CO at the Location of the CO Ice Line in evolving Gas
and Dust Disks
Submitted: 2017-01-09, last modified: 2017-01-31
Context. Ice lines are suggested to play a significant role in grain growth
and planetesimal formation in protoplanetary disks. Evaporation fronts directly
influence the gas and ice abundances of volatile species in the disk and
therefore the coagulation physics and efficiency and the chemical composition
of the resulting planetesimals.
Aims. In this work we investigate the influence of the existence of the CO
ice line on the particle growth and on the distribution of CO in the disk.
Methods. We include the possibility of tracking the CO content and/or other
volatiles in particles and in the gas in our existing dust coagulation and disk
evolution model and developed a method for evaporation and condensation of CO
using the Hertz-Knudsen equation. Our model does not include fragmentation,
yet, which will be part of further investigations.
Results. We find no enhanced grain growth just outside the ice line where the
particle size is limited by radial drift. Instead we find a depletion of solid
material inside the ice line which is solely due to evaporation of the CO. Such
a depression inside the ice line may be observable and may help to quantify the
processes described in this work. Furthermore, we find that the viscosity and
diffusivity of the gas heavily influence the re-distribution of vaporized CO at
the ice line and can lead to an increase in the CO abundance by up to a factors
of a few in the region just inside the ice line. Depending on the strength of
the gaseous transport mechanisms the position of the ice line in our model can
change by up to 10 AU and consequently, the temperature at that location can
range from 21 K to 23 K.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.03540 [pdf] - 1454039
Forming chondrules in impact splashes - II Volatile retention
Submitted: 2016-08-11
Solving the mystery of the origin of chondrules is one of the most elusive
goals in the field of meteoritics. Recently the idea of planet(esimal)
collisions releasing splashes of lava droplets, long considered out of favor,
has been reconsidered as a possible origin of chondrules by several papers. One
of the main problems with this idea is the lack of quantitative and simple
models that can be used to test this scenario by directly comparing to the many
known observables of chondrules. In Paper I of this series we presented a
simple thermal evolution model of a spherically symmetric expanding cloud of
molten lava droplets that is assumed to emerge from a collision between two
planetesimals. In the present paper, number II of this series, we use this
model to calculate whether or not volatile elements such as Na and K will
remain abundant in these droplets or whether they will get depleted due to
evaporation. The high density of the droplet cloud (e.g. small distance between
adjacent droplets) causes the vapor to quickly reach saturation pressure and
thus shutting down further evaporation. We show to which extent, and under
which conditions, this keeps the abundances of these elements high, as is seen
in chondrules. We find that for most parameters of our model (cloud mass,
expansion velocity, initial temperature) the volatile elements Mg, Si and Fe
remain entirely in the chondrules. The Na and K abundances inside the droplets
will initially stay mostly at their initial values due to the saturation of the
vapor pressure, but at some point start to drop due to the cloud expansion.
However, as soon as the temperature starts to decrease, most or all of the
vapor recondenses again. At the end the Na and K elements retain most of their
initial abundances, albeit occasionally somewhat reduced, depending on the
parameters of the expanding cloud model.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1501.05791 [pdf] - 925680
Forming chondrules in impact splashes. I. Radiative cooling model
Submitted: 2015-01-23
The formation of chondrules is one of the oldest unsolved mysteries in
meteoritics and planet formation. Recently an old idea has been revived: the
idea that chondrules form as a result of collisions between planetesimals in
which the ejected molten material forms small droplets which solidify to become
chondrules. Pre-melting of the planetesimals by radioactive decay of 26Al would
help producing sprays of melt even at relatively low impact velocity. In this
paper we study the radiative cooling of a ballistically expanding spherical
cloud of chondrule droplets ejected from the impact site. We present results
from a numerical radiative transfer models as well as analytic approximate
solutions. We find that the temperature after the start of the expansion of the
cloud remains constant for a time t_cool and then drops with time t
approximately as T ~ T_0[(3/5)t/t_cool+ 2/5]^(-5/3) for t>t_cool. The time at
which this temperature drop starts t_cool depends via an analytical formula on
the mass of the cloud, the expansion velocity and the size of the chondrule.
During the early isothermal expansion phase the density is still so high that
we expect the vapor of volatile elements to saturate so that no large volatile
losses are expected.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1408.4651 [pdf] - 863751
A critical analysis of shock models for chondrule formation
Submitted: 2014-08-20
In recent years many models of chondrule formation have been proposed. One of
those models is the processing of dust in shock waves in protoplanetary disks.
In this model, the dust and the chondrule precursors are overrun by shock
waves, which heat them up by frictional heating and thermal exchange with the
gas. In this paper we reanalyze the nebular shock model of chondrule formation
and focus on the downstream boundary condition. We show that for large-scale
plane-parallel chondrule-melting shocks the postshock equilibrium temperature
is too high to avoid volatile loss. Even if we include radiative cooling in
lateral directions out of the disk plane into our model (thereby breaking
strict plane-parallel geometry) we find that for a realistic vertical extent of
the solar nebula disk the temperature decline is not fast enough. On the other
hand, if we assume that the shock is entirely optically thin so that particles
can radiate freely, the cooling rates are too high to produce the observed
chondrules textures. Global nebular shocks are therefore problematic as the
primary sources of chondrules.