Normalized to: Smitha, H.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.07007 [pdf] - 2038407
The influence of NLTE effects in Fe I lines on an inverted atmosphere I.
6301 A and 6302 A lines formed in 1D NLTE
Submitted: 2019-12-15, last modified: 2020-01-28
Ultraviolet over-ionisation of iron atoms in the solar atmosphere leads to
deviations in their level populations from the Saha-Boltzmann statistics. This
causes their line profiles to form in Non-Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium
(NLTE) conditions. While inverting such profiles to determine atmospheric
parameters, the NLTE effects are often neglected and deviations from LTE are
compensated for by tweaking other quantities. We investigate how the routinely
employed LTE inversion of iron lines formed in NLTE under- or over-estimates
atmospheric quantities such as temperature (T), line-of-sight velocity (v_LOS),
magnetic field strength (B) and inclination (gamma) while the previous papers
have focused mainly on T. We synthesize the Stokes profiles of Fe I 6301.5 A
and 6302.5 A lines in both LTE and NLTE using a snapshot of a 3D MHD
simulation. The profiles are then inverted in LTE. By considering the
atmosphere inferred from inversion of LTE profiles to be the fiducial model, we
compare atmosphere from the inversion of NLTE profiles with it. Any differences
observed are attributed to NLTE effects. Neglecting the NLTE effects introduces
errors in the inverted atmosphere. While the errors in T can go up to 13%, in
v_LOS and B the errors can be as high as 50% or more. We find these errors to
be present at all three inversion nodes. Importantly, they survive degradation
from spatial averaging of the profiles. We give an overview of how the neglect
of NLTE effects influences the values of T, v_LOS, B and gamma determined by
inverting Fe I 6300 A line pair, as observed, e.g., by Hinode. Errors are found
at the sites of granules, intergranular lanes, magnetic elements, basically in
every region susceptible to NLTE effects. For an accurate determination of
atmospheric quantities and their stratification, it is therefore important to
take account of NLTE effects.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.01078 [pdf] - 1759338
Observations of solar chromospheric heating at sub-arcsec spatial
resolution
Submitted: 2018-07-03
A wide variety of phenomena such as gentle but persistent brightening,
dynamic slender features (~100 km), and compact (~1'') ultraviolet (UV) bursts
are associated with the heating of the solar chromosphere. High spatio-temporal
resolution is required to capture the finer details of the likely magnetic
reconnection-driven, rapidly evolving bursts. Such observations are also needed
to reveal their similarities to large-scale flares, which are also thought to
be reconnection driven, and more generally their role in chromospheric heating.
Here we report observations of chromospheric heating in the form of a UV burst
obtained with the balloon-borne observatory, SUNRISE. The observed burst
displayed a spatial morphology similar to that of a large-scale solar flare
with circular ribbon. While the co-temporal UV observations at 1.5'' spatial
resolution and 24s cadence from the Solar Dynamics Observatory showed a compact
brightening, the SUNRISE observations at diffraction-limited spatial resolution
of 0.1'' at 7s cadence revealed a dynamic sub-structure of the burst that it is
composed of extended ribbon-like features and a rapidly evolving arcade of thin
(~0.1'' wide) magnetic loop-like features, similar to post-flare loops. Such a
dynamic sub-structure reveals the small-scale nature of chromospheric heating
in these bursts. Furthermore, based on magnetic field extrapolations, this
heating event is associated with a complex fan-spine magnetic topology. Our
observations strongly hint at a unified picture of magnetic heating in the
solar atmosphere from some large-scale flares to small-scale bursts, all being
associated with such a magnetic topology.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.08926 [pdf] - 1602648
Probing photospheric magnetic fields with new spectral line pairs
Submitted: 2017-09-26
The magnetic line ratio (MLR) method has been extensively used in the
measurement of photospheric magnetic field strength. It was devised for the
neutral iron line pair at 5247.1 A and 5250.2 A (5250 A pair). Other line pairs
as well-suited as this pair been have not been reported in the literature. The
aim of the present work is to identify new line pairs useful for the MLR
technique and to test their reliability. We use a three dimensional
magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulation representing the quiet Sun atmosphere to
synthesize the Stokes profiles. Then, we apply the MLR technique to the Stokes
V profiles to recover the fields in the MHD cube both, at original resolution
and after degrading with a point spread function. In both these cases, we aim
to empirically represent the field strengths returned by the MLR method in
terms of the field strengths in the MHD cube. We have identified two new line
pairs that are very well adapted to be used for MLR measurements. The first
pair is in the visible, Fe I 6820 A - 6842 A (whose intensity profiles have
earlier been used to measure stellar magnetic fields), and the other is in the
infrared (IR), Fe I 15534 A - 15542 A. The lines in these pairs reproduce the
magnetic fields in the MHD cube rather well, partially better than the original
5250 A pair. The newly identified line pairs complement the old pairs. The
lines in the new IR pair, due to their higher Zeeman sensitivity, are ideal for
the measurement of weak fields. The new visible pair works best above 300 G.
The new IR pair, due to its large Stokes V signal samples more fields in the
MHD cube than the old IR pair at $1.56\,\mu$m, even in the presence of noise,
and hence likely also on the real Sun. Owing to their low formation heights
(100-200 km above tau_5000=1), both the new line pairs are well suited for
probing magnetic fields in the lower photosphere.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1611.06432 [pdf] - 1553933
Estimation of the magnetic flux emergence rate in the quiet Sun from
Sunrise data
Submitted: 2016-11-19, last modified: 2017-03-28
Small-scale internetwork (IN) features are thought to be the major source of
fresh magnetic flux in the quiet Sun. During its first science flight in 2009,
the balloon-borne observatory Sunrise captured images of the magnetic fields in
the quiet Sun at a high spatial resolution. Using these data we measure the
rate at which the IN features bring magnetic flux to the solar surface. In a
previous paper it was found that the lowest magnetic flux in small-scale
features detected using the Sunrise observations is 9 x 10^14 Mx. This is
nearly an order of magnitude smaller than the smallest fluxes of features
detected in observations from the Hinode satellite. In this paper, we compute
the flux emergence rate (FER) by accounting for such small fluxes, which was
not possible before Sunrise. By tracking the features with fluxes in the range
10^15-10^18 Mx, we measure an FER of 1100 Mx cm^-2 day^-1. The smaller features
with fluxes less than or equal to 10^16 Mx are found to be the dominant
contributors to the solar magnetic flux. The FER found here is an order of
magnitude higher than the rate from Hinode, obtained with a similar feature
tracking technique. A wider comparison with the literature shows, however, that
the exact technique of determining the rate of the appearance of new flux can
lead to results that differ by up to two orders of magnitude, even when applied
to similar data. The causes of this discrepancy are discussed and first
qualitative explanations proposed.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1408.4247 [pdf] - 1216379
The quantum interference effects in the Sc II 4247 A line of the Second
Solar Spectrum
Submitted: 2014-08-19, last modified: 2014-09-16
The Sc II 4247 A line formed in the chromosphere is one of the lines well
known, like the Na I D_2 and Ba II D_2, for its prominent triple peak structure
in Q/I and the underlying quantum interference effects governing it. In this
paper, we try to study the nature of this triple peak structure using the
theory of F-state interference including the effects of partial frequency
redistribution (PRD) and radiative transfer (RT). We compare our results with
the observations taken in a quiet region near the solar limb. In spite of
accounting for PRD and RT effects it has not been possible to reproduce the
observed triple peak structure in Q/I. While the two wing PRD peaks (on either
side of central peak) and the near wing continuum can be reproduced, the
central peak is completely suppressed by the enhanced depolarization resulting
from the hyperfine structure splitting. This suppression remains for all the
tested widely different 1D model atmospheres or for any multi-component
combinations of them. While multidimensional radiative transfer effects may
improve the fit to the intensity profiles, they do not appear capable of
explaining the enigmatic central Q/I peak. This leads us to suspect that some
aspect of quantum physics is missing.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.0465 [pdf] - 864169
The role of quantum interference and partial redistribution in the solar
Ba II D2 4554 A line
Submitted: 2014-09-01
The Ba II D2 line at 4554 A is a good example, where the F-state interference
effects due to the odd isotopes produce polarization profiles, which are very
different from those of the even isotopes that do not exhibit F-state
interference. It is therefore necessary to account for the contributions from
the different isotopes to understand the observed linear polarization profiles
of this line. In this paper we present radiative transfer modeling with partial
frequency redistribution (PRD), which is shown to be essential to model this
line. This is because complete frequency redistribution (CRD) cannot reproduce
the observed wing polarization. We present the observed and computed Q/I
profiles at different limb distances. The theoretical profiles strongly depend
on limb distance (\mu) and the model atmosphere which fits the limb
observations fails at other \mu\ positions.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1407.5461 [pdf] - 1215802
Center to limb observations and modeling of the Ca I 4227 A line
Submitted: 2014-07-21
The observed center-to-limb variation (CLV) of the scattering polarization in
different lines of the Second Solar Spectrum can be used to constrain the
height variation of various atmospheric parameters, in particular the magnetic
fields via the Hanle effect. Here we attempt to model non-magnetic CLV
observations of the $Q/I$ profiles of the Ca I 4227 A line recorded with the
ZIMPOL-3 at IRSOL. For modeling, we use the polarized radiative transfer with
partial frequency redistribution with a number of realistic 1-D model
atmospheres. We find that all the standard FAL model atmospheres, used by us,
fail to simultaneously fit the observed ($I$, $Q/I$) at all the limb distances
($\mu$). However, an attempt is made to find a single model which can provide a
fit at least to the CLV of the observed $Q/I$ instead of a simultaneous fit to
the ($I$, $Q/I$) at all $\mu$. To this end we construct a new 1-D model by
combining two of the standard models after modifying their temperature
structures in the appropriate height ranges. This new combined model closely
reproduces the observed $Q/I$ at all the $\mu$, but fails to reproduce the
observed rest intensity at different $\mu$. Hence we find that no single 1-D
model atmosphere succeeds in providing a good representation of the real Sun.
This failure of 1-D models does not however cause an impediment to the magnetic
field diagnostic potential of the Ca I 4227 A line. To demonstrate this we
deduce the field strength at various $\mu$ positions without invoking the use
of radiative transfer.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1303.7304 [pdf] - 1165614
Modeling the quantum interference signatures of the Ba II D2 4554 A line
in the second solar spectrum
Submitted: 2013-03-29
Quantum interference effects play a vital role in shaping the linear
polarization profiles of solar spectral lines. The Ba II D2 line at 4554 A is a
prominent example, where the F-state interference effects due to the odd
isotopes produce polarization profiles, which are very different from those of
the even isotopes that have no F-state interference. It is therefore necessary
to account for the contributions from the different isotopes to understand the
observed linear polarization profiles of this line. Here we do radiative
transfer modeling with partial frequency redistribution (PRD) of such
observations while accounting for the interference effects and isotope
composition. The Ba II D2 polarization profile is found to be strongly governed
by the PRD mechanism. We show how a full PRD treatment succeeds in reproducing
the observations, while complete frequency redistribution (CRD) alone fails to
produce polarization profiles that have any resemblance with the observed ones.
However, we also find that the line center polarization is sensitive to the
temperature structure of the model atmosphere. To obtain a good fit to the line
center peak of the observed Stokes Q/I profile, a small modification of the
FALX model atmosphere is needed, by lowering the temperature in the
line-forming layers. Because of the pronounced temperature sensitivity of the
Ba II D2 line it may not be a suitable tool for Hanle magnetic-field
diagnostics of the solar chromosphere, because there is currently no
straightforward way to separate the temperature and magnetic-field effects from
each other.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.0243 [pdf] - 1151047
Polarized line formation with J-state interference in the presence of
magnetic fields: A heuristic treatment of collisional frequency
redistribution
Submitted: 2012-09-03
An expression for the partial frequency redistribution (PRD) matrix for line
scattering in a two-term atom, which includes the J-state interference between
its fine structure line components is derived. The influence of collisions
(both elastic and inelastic) and an external magnetic field on the scattering
process is taken into account. The lower term is assumed to be unpolarized and
infinitely sharp. The linear Zeeman regime in which the Zeeman splitting is
much smaller than the fine structure splitting is considered. The inelastic
collision rates between the different levels are included in our treatment. We
account for the depolarization caused by the collisions coupling the fine
structure states of the upper term, but neglect the polarization transfer
between the fine structure states. When the fine structure splitting goes to
zero, we recover the redistribution matrix that represents the scattering on a
two-level atom (which exhibits only m-state interference --- namely the Hanle
effect). The way in which the multipolar index of the scattering atom enters
into the expression for the redistribution matrix through the collisional
branching ratios is discussed. The properties of the redistribution matrix are
explored for a single scattering process for an L=0 to 1 to 0 scattering
transition with S=1/2 (a hypothetical doublet centered at 5000 A and 5001 A).
Further, a method for solving the Hanle radiative transfer equation for a
two-term atom in the presence of collisions, PRD, and J-state interference is
developed. The Stokes profiles emerging from an isothermal constant property
medium are computed.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1208.6369 [pdf] - 1151011
Polarized line transfer with F-state interference in a non-magnetic
medium: Partial frequency redistribution effects in the collisionless regime
Submitted: 2012-08-31
Quantum interference phenomena manifests itself in several ways in the
polarized solar spectrum formed due to coherent scattering processes. One such
effect arises due to interference between the fine structure (J) states giving
rise to multiplets. Another effect is that which arises due to interference
between the hyperfine structure (F) states. We extend the redistribution matrix
derived for the J-state interference to the case of F-state interference. We
then incorporate it into the polarized radiative transfer equation and solve it
for isothermal constant property slab atmospheres. The relevant transfer
equation is solved using a polarized approximate lambda iteration (PALI)
technique based on operator perturbation. An alternative method derived from
the Neumann series expansion is also proposed and is found to be relatively
more efficient than the PALI method. The effects of PRD and the F-state
interference on the shapes of the linearly polarized Stokes profiles are
discussed. The emergent Stokes profiles are computed for hypothetical line
transitions arising due to hyperfine structure splitting (HFS) of the upper
J=3/2 and lower J=1/2 levels of a two-level atom model with nuclear spin
I_s=3/2. We confine our attention to the non-magnetic scattering in the
collisionless regime.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1203.4934 [pdf] - 1117469
J-state interference signatures in the Second Solar Spectrum: Modeling
the Cr I triplet at 5204-5208 A
Submitted: 2012-03-22
The scattering polarization in the solar spectrum is traditionally modeled
with each spectral line treated separately, but this is generally inadequate
for multiplets where J-state interference plays a significant role. Through
simultaneous observations of all the 3 lines of a Cr I triplet, combined with
realistic radiative transfer modeling of the data, we show that it is necessary
to include J-state interference consistently when modeling lines with partially
interacting fine structure components. Polarized line formation theory that
includes J-state interference effects together with partial frequency
redistribution for a two-term atom is used to model the observations.
Collisional frequency redistribution is also accounted for. We show that the
resonance polarization in the Cr I triplet is strongly affected by the partial
frequency redistribution effects in the line core and near wing peaks. The Cr I
triplet is quite sensitive to the temperature structure of the photospheric
layers. Our complete frequency redistribution calculations in semi-empirical
models of the solar atmosphere cannot reproduce the observed near wing
polarization or the cross-over of the Stokes Q/I line polarization about the
continuum polarization level that is due to the J-state interference. When
however partial frequency redistribution is included, a good fit to these
features can be achieved. Further, to obtain a good fit to the far wings, a
small temperature enhancement of the FALF model in the photospheric layers is
necessary.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1105.2157 [pdf] - 1076547
Observations of the forward scattering Hanle effect in the Ca i 4227
{\AA} line
Submitted: 2011-05-11
Chromospheric magnetic fields are notoriously diffcult to measure. The
chromospheric lines are broad, while the fields are producing a minuscule
Zeeman-effect polarization. A promising diagnostic alternative is provided by
the forward-scattering Hanle effect, which can be recorded in chromospheric
lines such as the He i 10830 {\AA} and the Ca i 4227 {\AA} lines. We present a
set of spectropolarimetric observations of the full Stokes vector obtained near
the center of the solar disk in the Ca i 4227 {\AA} line with the ZIMPOL
polarimeter at the IRSOL observatory.We detect a number of interesting
forward-scattering Hanle effect signatures, which we model successfully using
polarized radiative transfer. Here we focus on the observational aspects, while
a separate companion paper deals with the theoretical modeling.