Normalized to: Sipilä, O.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.09741 [pdf] - 2117120
Effect of grain size distribution and size-dependent grain heating on
molecular abundances in starless and pre-stellar cores
Submitted: 2020-06-17
We present a new gas-grain chemical model to constrain the effect of grain
size distribution on molecular abundances in starless and pre-stellar cores. We
introduce grain-size dependence simultaneously for cosmic-ray (CR)-induced
desorption efficiency and for grain equilibrium temperatures. We keep explicit
track of ice abundances on a set of grain populations. We find that the
size-dependent CR desorption efficiency affects ice abundances in a highly
non-trivial way that depends on the molecule. Species that originate in the gas
phase follow a simple pattern where the ice abundance is highest on the
smallest grains (the most abundant in the distribution). Some molecules, such
as HCN, are instead concentrated on large grains throughout the time evolution,
while others (like $\rm N_2$) are initially concentrated on large grains, but
at late times on small grains, due to grain-size-dependent competition between
desorption and hydrogenation. Most of the water ice is on small grains at high
medium density ($n({\rm H_2}) \gtrsim 10^6 \, \rm cm^{-3}$), where the water
ice fraction, with respect to total water ice reservoir, can be as low as $\sim
10^{-3}$ on large (> 0.1 $\mu$m) grains. Allowing the grain equilibrium
temperature to vary with grain size induces strong variations in relative ice
abundances in low-density conditions where the interstellar radiation field and
in particular its ultraviolet component are not attenuated. Our study implies
consequences not only for the initial formation of ices preceding the starless
core stage, but also for the relative ice abundances on the grain populations
going into the protostellar stage. In particular, if the smallest grains can
lose their mantles due to grain-grain collisions as the core is collapsing, the
ice composition in the beginning of the protostellar stage could be very
different to that in the pre-collapse phase.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.03362 [pdf] - 2109274
Carbon isotopic fractionation in molecular clouds
Submitted: 2020-06-05
C-fractionation has been studied from a theoretical point of view with
different models of time-dependent chemistry, including both isotope-selective
photodissociation and low-temperature isotopic exchange reactions. Recent
chemical models predict that the latter may lead to a depletion of $^{13}$C in
nitrile-bearing species, with $^{12}$C/$^{13}$C ratios two times higher than
the elemental abundance ratio of 68 in the local ISM. Since the carbon isotopic
ratio is commonly used to evaluate the $^{14}$N/$^{15}$N ratios with the
double-isotope method, it is important to study C-fractionation in detail to
avoid incorrect assumptions. In this work we implemented a gas-grain chemical
model with new isotopic exchange reactions and investigated their introduction
in the context of dense and cold molecular gas. In particular, we investigated
the $^{12}$C/$^{13}$C ratios of HNC, HCN, and CN using a grid of models, with
temperatures and densities ranging from 10 to 50 K and 2$\times$10$^{3}$ to
2$\times$10$^{7}$ cm$^{-3}$, respectively. We suggest a possible $^{13}$C
exchange through the $^{13}$C + C$_{3}$ $\rightarrow$ $^{12}$C +$^{13}$CC$_{2}$
reaction, which does not result in dilution, but rather in $^{13}$C
enhancement, for molecules formed starting from atomic carbon. This effect is
efficient in a range of time between the formation of CO and its freeze-out on
grains. Furthermore, we show that the $^{12}$C/$^{13}$C ratios of nitriles are
predicted to be a factor 0.8-1.9 different from the local value of 68 for
massive star-forming regions. This result also affects the $^{14}$N/$^{15}$N
ratio: a value of 330 obtained with the double-isotope method is predicted to
be 260-1150, depending on the physical conditions. Finally, we studied the
$^{12}$C/$^{13}$C ratios by varying the cosmic-ray ionization rate: the ratios
increase with it because of secondary photons and cosmic-ray reactions.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.04165 [pdf] - 2005528
Search for H$_3^+$ isotopologues toward CRL 2136 IRS 1
Submitted: 2019-10-09
Deuterated interstellar molecules frequently have abundances relative to
their main isotopologues much higher than the overall elemental D-to-H ratio in
the cold dense interstellar medium. The H$_3^+$ and its isotopologues play a
key role in the deuterium fractionation; however, the abundances of these
isotopologues have not been measured empirically with respect to H$_3^+$ to
date. Our aim was to constrain the relative abundances of H$_2$D$^+$ and
D$_3^+$ in the cold outer envelope of the hot core CRL 2136 IRS 1. We carried
out three observations targeting H$_3^+$ and its isotopologues using the
spectrographs CRIRES at the VLT, iSHELL at IRTF, and EXES on board SOFIA. In
addition, the CO overtone band at 2.3 $\mu$m was observed by iSHELL to
characterize the gas on the line of sight. The H$_3^+$ ion was detected toward
CRL 2136 IRS 1 as in previous observations. Spectroscopy of lines of H$_2$D$^+$
and D$_3^+$ resulted in non-detections. The 3$\sigma$ upper limits of $N({\rm
H_2D^+})/N({\rm H_3^+})$ and $N({\rm D_3^+})/N({\rm H_3^+})$ are 0.24 and 0.13,
respectively. The population diagram for CO is reproduced by two components of
warm gas with the temperatures 58 K and 530 K, assuming a local thermodynamic
equilibrium (LTE) distribution of the rotational levels. Cold gas ($<$20 K)
makes only a minor contribution to the CO molecular column toward CRL 2136 IRS
1. The critical conditions for deuterium fractionation in a dense cloud are low
temperature and CO depletion. Given the revised cloud properties, it is no
surprise that H$_3^+$ isotopologues are not detected toward CRL 2136 IRS 1. The
result is consistent with our current understanding of how deuterium
fractionation proceeds.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.04341 [pdf] - 1983953
Modeling deuterium chemistry in starless cores: full scrambling versus
proton hop
Submitted: 2019-09-10
We constructed two new models for deuterium and spin-state chemistry for the
purpose of modeling the low-temperature environment prevailing in starless and
pre-stellar cores. The fundamental difference between the two models is in the
treatment of ion-molecule proton-donation reactions of the form $\rm XH^+ + Y
\longrightarrow X + YH^+$, which are allowed to proceed either via full
scrambling or via direct proton hop, i.e., disregarding proton exchange. The
choice of the reaction mechanism affects both deuterium and spin-state
chemistry, and in this work our main interest is on the effect on deuterated
ammonia. We applied the new models to the starless core H-MM1, where several
deuterated forms of ammonia have been observed. Our investigation slightly
favors the proton hop mechanism over full scrambling because the ammonia D/H
ratios are better fit by the former model, although neither model can reproduce
the observed $\rm NH_2D$ ortho-to-para ratio of 3 (the models predict a value
of $\sim$2). Extending the proton hop scenario to hydrogen atom abstraction
reactions yields a good agreement for the spin-state abundance ratios, but
greatly overestimates the deuterium fractions of ammonia. However, one can find
a reasonably good agreement with the observations with this model by increasing
the cosmic-ray ionization rate over the commonly-adopted value of
$\sim$$10^{-17}\,\rm s^{-1}$. We also find that the deuterium fractions of
several other species, such as $\rm H_2CO$, $\rm H_2O$, and $\rm CH_3$, are
sensitive to the adopted proton-donation reaction mechanism. Whether the full
scrambling or proton hop mechanism dominates may be dependent on the reacting
system, and new laboratory and theoretical studies for various reacting systems
are needed to constrain chemical models.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.04047 [pdf] - 1994198
Gas and dust temperature in pre-stellar cores revisited: New limits on
cosmic-ray ionization rate
Submitted: 2019-09-09
We develop a self-consistent model for the equilibrium gas temperature and
size-dependent dust temperature in cold, dense pre-stellar cores, assuming an
arbitrary power-law size distribution of dust grains. Compact analytical
expressions applicable to a broad range of physical parameters are derived and
compared with predictions of the commonly used standard model. It is suggested
that combining the theoretical results with observations should allow us to
constrain the degree of dust evolution and the cosmic-ray ionization rate in
dense cores, and to help in discriminating between different regimes of
cosmic-ray transport in molecular clouds. In particular, assuming a canonical
MRN distribution of grain sizes, our theory demonstrates that the gas
temperature measurements in the pre-stellar core L1544 are consistent with an
ionization rate as high as $\sim 10^{-16}$ s$^{-1}$, an order of magnitude
higher than previously thought.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.00209 [pdf] - 1975423
The chemical structure of young high-mass star-forming clumps: (I)
Deuteration
Submitted: 2019-08-31
The chemical structure of high-mass star nurseries is important for a general
understanding of star formation. Deuteration is a key chemical process in the
earliest stages of star formation because its efficiency is sensitive to the
environment. Using the IRAM-30 m telescope at 1.3--4.3 mm wavelengths, we have
imaged two parsec-scale high-mass protostellar clumps (P1 and S) that show
different evolutionary stages but are located in the same giant filamentary
{infrared dark cloud} G28.34+0.06. Deep spectral images at subparsec resolution
reveal the dust and gas physical structures of both clumps. We find that (1)
the low-$J$ lines of $\rm N_2H^+$, HCN, HNC, and $\rm HCO^+$ isotopologues are
subthermally excited; and (2) the deuteration of $\rm N_2H^+$ is more efficient
than that of $\rm HCO^+$, HCN, and HNC by an order of magnitude. The
deuterations of these species are enriched toward the chemically younger clump
S compared with P1, indicating that this process favors the colder and denser
environment ($\rm T_{kin} \sim14 K$, $\rm N(NH_3) \sim 9\times
10^{15}\,cm^{-2}$). In contrast, single deuteration of $\rm NH_3$ is
insensitive to the environmental difference between P1 and S; and (3) single
deuteration of $\rm CH_3OH$ ($\rm > 10\%$) is detected toward the location
where CO shows a depletion of $\sim10$. This comparative chemical study between
P1 and S links the chemical variations to the environmental differences and
shows chemical similarities between the early phases of high- and low-mass
star-forming regions.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.08217 [pdf] - 1949403
High sensitivity maps of molecular ions in L1544: I. Deuteration of N2H+
and HCO+ and first evidence of N2D+ depletion
Submitted: 2019-07-18
Context. The deuterium fraction in low-mass prestellar cores is a good
diagnostic indicator of the initial phases of star formations, and it is also a
fundamental quantity to infer the ionisation degree in these objects.
Aims. With the analysis of multiple transitions of $\rm N_2H^+$, $\rm
N_2D^+$, $\rm HC^{18}O^+$ and $\rm DCO^+$ we are able to determine the
molecular column density maps and the deuterium fraction in $\rm N_2H^+$ and
$\rm HCO^+$ toward the prototypical prestellar core L1544. This is the
preliminary step to derive the ionisation degree in the source.
Methods. We use a non-local thermodynamic equilibrium (non-LTE) radiative
transfer code, combined with the molecular abundances derived from a chemical
model, to infer the excitation conditions of all the observed transitions,
which allows us to derive reliable maps of each molecule's column density. The
ratio between the column density of a deuterated species and its non-deuterated
counterpart gives the searched deuteration level.
Results. The non-LTE analysis confirms that, for the analysed molecules,
higher-J transitions are characterised by excitation temperatures $\approx
1-2\,$K lower than the lower-J ones. The chemical model that provides the best
fit to the observational data predict the depletion of $\rm N_2H^+$ and to a
lesser extent of $\rm N_2D^+$ in the innermost region. The peak values for the
deuterium fraction that we find are $\mathrm{D/H_{N_2H^+}} =
0.26^{+0.15}_{-0.14}$ and $\mathrm{D/H_{HCO^+}} = 0.035^{+0.015}_{-0.012}$, in
good agreement with previous estimates in the source.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.08653 [pdf] - 1886709
Deuterated forms of H${_3^+}$ and their importance in astrochemistry
Submitted: 2019-05-21
At the low temperatures ($\sim$10 K) and high densities ($\sim$100,000 H$_2$
molecules per cc) of molecular cloud cores and protostellar envelopes, a large
amount of molecular species (in particular those containing C and O) freeze-out
onto dust grain surfaces. It is in these regions that the deuteration of
H$_3^+$ becomes very efficient, with a sharp abundance increase of H$_2$D$^+$
and D$_2$H$^+$. The multi-deuterated forms of H$_3^+$ participate in an active
chemistry: (i) their collision with neutral species produces deuterated
molecules such as the commonly observed N$_2$D$^+$, DCO$^+$ and
multi-deuterated NH$_3$; (ii) their dissociative electronic recombination
increases the D/H atomic ratio by several orders of magnitude above the D
cosmic abundance, thus allowing deuteration of molecules (e.g. CH$_3$OH and
H$_2$O) on the surface of dust grains. Deuterated molecules are the main
diagnostic tools of dense and cold interstellar clouds, where the first steps
toward star and protoplanetary disk formation take place. Recent observations
of deuterated molecules are reviewed and discussed in view of astrochemical
models inclusive of spin-state chemistry. We present a new comparison between
models based on complete scrambling (to calculate branching ratio tables for
reactions between chemical species that include protons and/or deuterons) and
models based on non-scrambling (proton hop) methods, showing that the latter
best agree with observations of NH$_3$ deuterated isotopologues and their
different nuclear spin symmetry states.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.02384 [pdf] - 1886623
Why does ammonia not freeze out in the center of pre-stellar cores?
Submitted: 2019-05-07
We carried out a parameter-space exploration of the ammonia abundance in the
pre-stellar core L1544, where it has been observed to increase toward the
center of the core with no signs of freeze-out onto grain surfaces. We
considered static and dynamical physical models coupled with elaborate chemical
and radiative transfer calculations, and explored the effects of varying model
parameters on the (ortho+para) ammonia abundance profile. None of our models
are able to reproduce the inward-increasing tendency in the observed profile;
ammonia depletion always occurs in the center of the core. In particular, our
study shows that including the chemical desorption process, where exothermic
association reactions on the grain surface can result in the immediate
desorption of the product molecule, leads to ammonia abundances that are over
an order of magnitude above the observed level in the innermost 15000 au of the
core - at least when one employs a constant efficiency for the chemical
desorption process irrespective of the ice composition. Our results seemingly
constrain the chemical desorption efficiency of ammonia on water ice to below
1%. It is increasingly evident that time-dependent effects must be considered
so that the results of chemical models can be reconciled with observations.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.04663 [pdf] - 1740051
A study of the $c$-$\mathrm{C_{3}HD}$/$c$-$\mathrm{C_{3}H_{2}}$ ratio in
low-mass star forming regions
Submitted: 2018-07-12
We use the deuteration of $c$-$\mathrm{C_{3}H_{2}}$ to probe the physical
parameters of starless and protostellar cores, related to their evolutionary
states, and compare it to the $\mathrm{N_{2}H^{+}}$-deuteration in order to
study possible differences between the deuteration of C- and N-bearing species.
We observed the main species $c$-$\mathrm{C_{3}H_{2}}$, the singly and doubly
deuterated species $c$-$\mathrm{C_{3}HD}$ and $c$-$\mathrm{C_{3}D_{2}}$, as
well as the isotopologue $c$-$\mathrm{{H^{13}CC_{2}H}}$ toward 10 starless
cores and 5 protostars in the Taurus and Perseus Complexes. We examined the
correlation between the
$N$($c$-$\mathrm{C_{3}HD}$)/$N$($c$-$\mathrm{C_{3}H_{2}}$) ratio and the dust
temperature along with the $\mathrm{H_2}$ column density and the CO depletion
factor. The resulting
$N$($c$-$\mathrm{C_{3}HD}$)/$N$($c$-$\mathrm{C_{3}H_{2}}$) ratio is within the
error bars consistent with $10\%$ in all starless cores with detected
$c$-$\mathrm{C_{3}HD}$. This also accounts for the protostars except for the
source HH211, where we measure a high deuteration level of $23\%$. The
deuteration of $\mathrm{N_{2}H^{+}}$ follows the same trend but is considerably
higher in the dynamically evolved core L1544. Toward the protostellar cores the
coolest objects show the largest deuterium fraction in
$c$-$\mathrm{C_{3}H_{2}}$. We show that the deuteration of
$c$-$\mathrm{C_{3}H_{2}}$ can trace the early phases of star formation and is
comparable to that of $\mathrm{N_{2}H^{+}}$. However, the largest
$c$-$\mathrm{C_{3}H_{2}}$ deuteration level is found toward protostellar cores,
suggesting that while $c$-$\mathrm{C_{3}H_{2}}$ is mainly frozen onto dust
grains in the central regions of starless cores, active deuteration is taking
place on ice.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.08004 [pdf] - 1716986
Hydrodynamics with gas-grain chemistry and radiative transfer: comparing
dynamical and static models
Submitted: 2018-01-24
We quantify if the chemical abundance gradients given by a dynamical model of
core collapse including time-dependent changes in density and temperature
differ greatly from abundances derived from static models, where the density
and temperature structures of the core are kept fixed as the chemistry evolves.
For this study we developed a new one-dimensional spherically symmetric
hydrodynamics code that couples the hydrodynamics equations with a
comprehensive time-dependent gas-grain chemical model, including deuterium and
spin-state chemistry, and radiative transfer calculations to derive
self-consistent time-dependent chemical abundance gradients. We applied the
code to model the collapse of a starless core up to the point when the infall
flow becomes supersonic.
The abundances predicted by the dynamical and static models are almost
identical during the quiescent phase of core evolution, but the results start
to diverge after the onset of core collapse, where the static model
underestimates abundances at high medium density (inner core) and
underestimates them at low density (outer core), and this is clearly reflected
in simulated lines. The static model generally overestimates deuteration, which
is increasingly evident the more D atoms are substituted in the molecule. We
also find that using a limited chemical network, or a limited set of cooling
molecules, may lead to an overestimate of the collapse timescale, and in some
cases may prevent the collapse altogether. In our model, most of the line
cooling near the center of the core is due to HCN, CO, and NO. In conclusion,
the use of a static physical model is not a reliable method of simulating
chemical abundances in starless cores after the onset of gravitational
collapse. The adoption of complex chemistry and a comprehensive set of cooling
molecules is necessary to model the collapse adequately.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.03170 [pdf] - 1585772
Species-to-species rate coefficients for the $\rm H_3^+ + H_2$ reacting
system
Submitted: 2017-07-11
Aims. We study whether rotational excitation makes a difference to the
abundances of the $\rm H_3^+$ isotopologs, including spin states, in physical
conditions corresponding to starless cores and protostellar envelopes.
Methods. We developed a new rate coefficient set for the $\rm H_3^+$
isotopologs, allowing for rotational excitation, using the state-to-state rate
coefficients from Hugo et al. These new so-called species-to-species rate
coefficients are compared with previously-used ground state-to-species rate
coefficients.
Results. The species-to-species and ground state-to-species model results
differ at high density and toward increasing temperatures ($T > 10$ K). The
species-to-species model predicts a lower $\rm H_3^+$ deuteration degree at
high density owing to an increase of the rate coefficients of endothermic
reactions that decrease deuteration. At 20 K the ground state-to-species model
overestimates the abundance of $\rm H_2D^+$ by a factor of about two while the
abundance of $\rm D_3^+$ can differ by an order of magnitude between the
models. Spin-state abundance ratios are also affected, and the new model better
reproduces recent observations of ortho and para $\rm H_2D^+$ and $\rm D_2H^+$.
The applicability regime of the new rate coefficients depends on the critical
densities of the various rotational transitions.
Conclusions. The difference in the abundances of the $\rm H_3^+$ isotopologs
predicted by the two models is negligible at 10 K but excited states are very
important in studies of deuteration at higher temperatures, for example in
protostellar envelopes. The species-to-species rate coefficients provide a more
realistic approach to the chemistry of the $\rm H_3^+$ isotopologs than the
ground state-to-species rate coefficients do, and so the former should be
adopted in chemical models describing the chemistry of the $\rm H_3^+ + H_2$
reacting system.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.02526 [pdf] - 1582438
Detection of interstellar ortho-D2H+ with SOFIA
Harju, Jorma;
Sipilä, Olli;
Brünken, Sandra;
Schlemmer, Stephan;
Caselli, Paola;
Juvela, Mika;
Menten, Karl M.;
Stutzki, Jürgen;
Asvany, Oskar;
Kaminski, Tomasz;
Okada, Yoko;
Higgins, Ronan
Submitted: 2017-04-08
We report on the detection of the ground-state rotational line of ortho-D2H+
at 1.477 THz (203 micron) using the German REceiver for Astronomy at Terahertz
frequencies (GREAT) onboard the Stratospheric Observatory For Infrared
Astronomy (SOFIA). The line is seen in absorption against far-infrared
continuum from the protostellar binary IRAS 16293-2422 in Ophiuchus. The
para-D2H+ line at 691.7 GHz was not detected with the APEX telescope toward
this position. These D2H+ observations complement our previous detections of
para-H2D+ and ortho-H2D+ using SOFIA and APEX. By modeling chemistry and
radiative transfer in the dense core surrounding the protostars, we find that
the ortho-D2H+ and para-H2D+ absorption features mainly originate in the cool
(T<18 K) outer envelope of the core. In contrast, the ortho-H2D+ emission from
the core is significantly absorbed by the ambient molecular cloud. Analyses of
the combined D2H+ and H2D+ data result in an age estimate of ~500 000 yr for
the core, with an uncertainty of ~200 000 yr. The core material has probably
been pre-processed for another 500 000 years in conditions corresponding to
those in the ambient molecular cloud. The inferred time scale is more than ten
times the age of the embedded protobinary. The D2H+ and H2D+ ions have large
and nearly equal total (ortho+para) fractional abundances of ~$10^{-9}$ in the
outer envelope. This confirms the central role of H3+ in the deuterium
chemistry in cool, dense gas, and adds support to the prediction of chemistry
models that also D3+ should be abundant in these conditions.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.08609 [pdf] - 1582124
Accurate sub-millimetre rest-frequencies for HOCO$^+$ and DOCO$^+$ ions
Submitted: 2017-03-24
HOCO$^+$ is a polar molecule that represents a useful proxy for its parent
molecule CO$_2$, which is not directly observable in the cold interstellar
medium. This cation has been detected towards several lines of sight, including
massive star forming regions, protostars, and cold cores. Despite the obvious
astrochemical relevance, protonated CO$_2$ and its deuterated variant,
DOCO$^+$, still lack an accurate spectroscopic characterisation. The aim of
this work is to extend the study of the ground-state pure rotational spectra of
HOCO$^+$ and DOCO$^+$ well into the sub-millimetre region. Ground-state
transitions have been recorded in the laboratory using a frequency-modulation
absorption spectrometer equipped with a free-space glow-discharge cell. The
ions were produced in a low-density, magnetically-confined plasma generated in
a suitable gas mixture. The ground-state spectra of HOCO$^+$ and DOCO$^+$ have
been investigated in the 213-967 GHz frequency range, with the detection of 94
new rotational transitions. Additionally, 46 line positions taken from the
literature have been accurately remeasured. The newly-measured lines have
significantly enlarged the available data sets for HOCO$^+$ and DOCO$^+$, thus
enabling the determination of highly accurate rotational and centrifugal
distortion parameters. Our analysis showed that all HOCO$^+$ lines with Ka
$\geq$ 3 are perturbed by a ro-vibrational interaction that couples the ground
state with the v$_ 5$ = 1 vibrationally-excited state. This resonance has been
explicitly treated in the analysis in order to obtain molecular constants with
clear physical meaning. The improved sets of spectroscopic parameters provide
enhanced lists of very accurate, sub-millimetre rest-frequencies of HOCO$^+$
and DOCO$^+$ for astrophysical applications. These new data challenges a recent
tentative identification of DOCO$^+$ toward a pre-stellar core.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.07193 [pdf] - 1578077
On the stability of nonisothermal Bonnor-Ebert spheres. III. The role of
chemistry in core stabilization
Submitted: 2017-03-21
Aims. We investigate the effect of chemistry on the stability of starless
cores against gravitational collapse.
Methods. We combine chemical and radiative transfer simulations in the
context of a modified Bonnor-Ebert sphere to model the effect of chemistry on
the gas temperature, and study the effect of temperature changes on core
stability.
Results. We find that chemistry has in general very little effect on the
nondimensional radius $\xi_{\rm out}$ which parametrizes the core stability.
Cores that are initially stable or unstable tend to stay near their initial
states, in terms of stability (i.e., $\xi_{\rm out} \sim$ constant), as the
chemistry develops. This result is independent of the initial conditions. We
can however find solutions where $\xi_{\rm out}$ decreases at late times ($t
\gtrsim 10^6 \, \rm yr$) which correspond to increased stabilization caused by
the chemistry. Even though the core stability is unchanged by the chemistry in
most of the models considered here, we cannot rule out the possibility that a
core can evolve from an unstable to a stable state owing to chemical evolution.
The reverse case, where an initially stable core becomes ultimately unstable,
seems highly unlikely.
Conclusions. Our results indicate that chemistry should be properly accounted
for in studies of star-forming regions, and that further investigations of core
stability especially with hydrodynamical models are warranted.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.07845 [pdf] - 1533812
Chemistry of TMC-1 with multiply deuterated species and spin chemistry
of H2, H2+, H3+ and their isotopologues
Submitted: 2016-12-22
Deuterated species are unique and powerful tools in astronomy since they can
probe the physical conditions, chemistry, and ionization level of various
astrophysical media. Recent observations of several deuterated species along
with some of their spin isomeric forms have rekindled the interest for more
accurate studies on deuterium fractionation. This paper presents the first
publicly available chemical network of multiply deuterated species along with
spin chemistry implemented on the latest state-of-the-art gas-grain chemical
code `NAUTILUS'. D/H ratios for all deuterated species observed at different
positions of TMC-1 are compared with the results of our model, which considers
multiply deuterated species along with the spin chemistry of light hydrogen
bearing species H2, H2+, H3+ and their isotopologues. We also show the
differences in the modeled abundances of non-deuterated species after the
inclusion of deuteration and spin chemistry in the model. Finally, we present a
list of potentially observable deuterated species in TMC-1 awaiting detection.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.05602 [pdf] - 1557673
Deuteration of ammonia in the starless core Ophiuchus/H-MM1
Harju, Jorma;
Daniel, Fabien;
Sipilä, Olli;
Caselli, Paola;
Pineda, Jaime E.;
Friesen, Rachel K.;
Punanova, Anna;
Güsten, Rolf;
Wiesenfeld, Laurent;
Myers, Philip C.;
Faure, Alexandre;
Hily-Blant, Pierre;
Rist, Claire;
Rosolowsky, Erik;
Schlemmer, Stephan;
Shirley, Yancy L.
Submitted: 2016-04-19, last modified: 2016-12-22
Ammonia and its deuterated isotopologues probe physical conditions in dense
molecular cloud cores. With the aim of testing the current understanding of the
spin-state chemistry of these molecules, we observed spectral lines of NH3,
NH2D, NHD2, ND3, and N2D+ towards a dense, starless core in Ophiuchus with the
APEX, GBT, and IRAM 30-m telescopes. The observations were interpreted using a
gas-grain chemistry model combined with radiative transfer calculations. The
chemistry model distinguishes between the different nuclear spin states of
light hydrogen molecules, ammonia, and their deuterated forms. High deuterium
fractionation ratios with NH2D/NH3=0.4, NHD2/NH2D=0.2, and ND3/NHD2=0.06 were
found in the core. The observed ortho/para ratios of NH2D and NHD2 are close to
the corresponding nuclear spin statistical weights. The chemistry model can
approximately reproduce the observed abundances, but predicts uniformly too low
ortho/para-NH2D, and too large ortho/para-NHD2 ratios. The longevity of N2H+
and NH3 in dense gas, which is prerequisite to their strong deuteration, can be
attributed to the chemical inertia of N2 on grain surfaces. The discrepancies
between the chemistry model and the observations are likely to be caused by the
fact that the model assumes complete scrambling in principal gas-phase
deuteration reactions of ammonia, which means that all the nuclei are mixed in
reactive collisions. If, instead, these reactions occur through proton
hop/hydrogen abstraction processes, statistical spin ratios are to be expected.
The present results suggest that while the deuteration of ammonia changes with
physical conditions and time, the nuclear spin ratios of ammonia isotopologues
do not probe the evolutionary stage of a cloud.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.07379 [pdf] - 1418929
Understanding the $\rm C_3H_2$ cyclic-to-linear ratio in L1544
Submitted: 2016-05-24
Aims. We aim to understand the high cyclic-to-linear $\rm C_3H_2$ ratio ($32
\pm 4$) observed toward L1544 by Spezzano et al. (2016). Methods. We combine a
gas-grain chemical model with a physical model for L1544 to simulate the column
densities of cyclic and linear $\rm C_3H_2$ observed toward L1544. The most
important reactions for the formation and destruction of both forms of $\rm
C_3H_2$ are identified, and their relative rate coefficients are varied to find
the best match to the observations. Results. We find that the ratio of the rate
coefficients of $\rm C_3H_3^+ + e^- \longrightarrow C_3H_2 + H$ for cyclic and
linear $\rm C_3H_2$ must be $\sim 20$ in order to reproduce the observations,
depending on the branching ratios assumed for the $\rm C_3H_3^+ + e^-
\longrightarrow C_3H + H_2$ reaction. In current astrochemical networks it is
assumed that cyclic and linear $\rm C_3H_2$ are formed in a 1:1 ratio in the
aforementioned reactions. Laboratory studies and/or theoretical calculations
are needed to confirm the results of our chemical modeling based on
observational constraints.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.05031 [pdf] - 1418871
The effect of multilayer ice chemistry on gas-phase deuteration in
starless cores
Submitted: 2016-04-18
Aims. We aim to investigate whether a multilayer ice model can be as
successful as a bulk ice model in reproducing the observed abundances of
various deuterated gas-phase species toward starless cores. Methods. We
calculate abundances for various deuterated species as functions of time
adopting fixed physical conditions. We also estimate abundance gradients by
adopting a modified Bonnor-Ebert sphere as a core model. In the multilayer ice
scenario, we consider desorption from one or several monolayers on the surface.
Results. We find that the multilayer model predicts abundances of $\rm DCO^+$
and $\rm N_2D^+$ that are about an order of magnitude lower than observed,
caused by the trapping of CO and $\rm N_2$ into the grain mantle. As a result
of the mantle trapping, deuteration efficiency in the gas phase increases and
we find stronger deuterium fractionation in ammonia than what has been
observed. Another distinguishing feature of the multilayer model is that $\rm
D_3^+$ becomes the main deuterated ion at high density. The bulk ice model is
generally easily reconciled with observations. Conclusions. Our results
underline that more theoretical and experimental work is needed to understand
the composition and morphology of interstellar ices, and the desorption
processes that can act on them. With the current constraints, the bulk ice
model appears to be better in reproducing observations than the multilayer ice
model. According to our results, the $\rm H_2D^+$ to $\rm N_2D^+$ abundance
ratio is higher than 100 in the multilayer model, while only a few $\times$ 10
in the bulk model, and so observations of this ratio could provide information
on the ice morphology in starless cores. Observations of the abundance of $\rm
D_3^+$ compared to $\rm H_2D^+$ and $\rm D_2H^+$ would provide additional
constraints for the models.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1601.00162 [pdf] - 1347829
The NH$_2$D hyperfine structure revealed by astrophysical observations
Daniel, F.;
Coudert, L. H.;
Punanova, A.;
Harju, J.;
Faure, A.;
Roueff, E.;
Sipilä, O.;
Caselli, P.;
Güsten, R.;
Pon, A.;
Pineda, J. E.
Submitted: 2016-01-02
The 1$_{11}$-1$_{01}$ lines of ortho and para--NH$_2$D (o/p-NH$_2$D),
respectively at 86 and 110 GHz, are commonly observed to provide constraints on
the deuterium fractionation in the interstellar medium. In cold regions, the
hyperfine structure due to the nitrogen ($^{14}$N) nucleus is resolved. To
date, this splitting is the only one which is taken into account in the NH$_2$D
column density estimates. We investigate how the inclusion of the hyperfine
splitting caused by the deuterium (D) nucleus affects the analysis of the
rotational lines of NH$_2$D. We present 30m IRAM observations of the above
mentioned lines, as well as APEX o/p-NH$_2$D observations of the
1$_{01}$-0$_{00}$ lines at 333 GHz. The hyperfine spectra are first analyzed
with a line list that only includes the hyperfine splitting due to the $^{14}$N
nucleus. We find inconsistencies between the line widths of the
1$_{01}$-0$_{00}$ and 1$_{11}$-1$_{01}$ lines, the latter being larger by a
factor of $\sim$1.6$\pm0.3$. Such a large difference is unexpected given the
two sets of lines are likely to originate from the same region. We next employ
a newly computed line list for the o/p-NH$_2$D transitions, where the hyperfine
structure induced by both nitrogen and deuterium nuclei is included. With this
new line list, the analysis of the previous spectra leads to linewidths which
are compatible. Neglecting the hyperfine structure owing to D leads to
overestimate the linewidths of the o/p-NH$_2$D lines at 3 mm. The error for a
cold molecular core is about 50\%. This error propagates directly to the column
density estimate. It is therefore recommended to take into account the
hyperfine splittings caused by both the $^{14}$N and D nuclei in any analysis
relying on these lines.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1508.06151 [pdf] - 1292286
On the stability of non-isothermal Bonnor-Ebert spheres. II. The effect
of gas temperature on the stability
Submitted: 2015-08-25
Aims. We investigate the stability of non-isothermal Bonnor-Ebert spheres
with a model that includes a self-consistent calculation of the gas
temperature. This way we can discard the assumption of equality between the
dust and gas temperatures, and study the stability as the gas temperature
changes with chemical evolution of the gas.
Methods. We use a gas-grain chemical model including a time-dependent
treatment of depletion onto grain surfaces, which strongly influences the gas
temperature as the main coolant, CO, depletes from the gas. Dust and gas
temperatures are solved with radiative transfer. For comparison with previous
work, we assume that the cores are deeply embedded in a larger external
structure, corresponding to visual extinction $A_{\rm V}^{\rm ext}=10$ mag.
Results. We find that the critical non-dimensional radius $\xi_1$ derived
here is similar to our previous work where we assumed $T_{\rm dust}=T_{\rm
gas}$; the $\xi_1$ values lie below the isothermal critical value
$\xi_0\sim6.45$, but the difference is less than 10%. Chemical evolution does
not affect notably the stability condition of low-mass cores (<0.75 $M_\odot$).
For higher masses the decrease of cooling owing to CO depletion causes
substantial temporal changes in the temperature and density profiles of the
cores. In the mass range 1-2 $M_\odot$ , $\xi_1$ decreases with chemical
evolution, whereas above 3 $M_\odot$ , $\xi_1$ instead increases. We also find
that decreasing $A_{\rm V}^{\rm ext}$ increases the gas temperature especially
when the gas is chemically old, causing $\xi_1$ to increase with respect to
models with higher $A_{\rm V}^{\rm ext}$. The derived $\xi_1$ values are close
to $\xi_0$. The density contrast between the core center and edge varies
between 8 to 16 depending on core mass and the chemical age of the gas,
compared to the constant value $\sim$ 14.1 for the isothermal BES.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.02856 [pdf] - 1280921
Spin-state chemistry of deuterated ammonia
Submitted: 2015-07-10
Aims. We aim to develop a chemical model that contains a consistent
description of spin-state chemistry in reactions involving chemical species
with multiple deuterons. We apply the model to the specific case of deuterated
ammonia, to derive values for the various spin-state ratios.
Methods. We apply symmetry rules in the complete scrambling assumption to
calculate branching ratio tables for reactions between chemical species that
include multiple protons and/or deuterons. Reaction sets for both gas-phase and
grain-surface chemistry are generated using an automated routine that forms all
possible spin-state variants of any given reaction with up to six H/D atoms.
Single-point and modified Bonnor-Ebert models are used to study the density and
temperature dependence of ammonia and its isotopologs, and the associated
spin-state ratios.
Results. We find that the spin-state ratios of the ammonia isotopologs are,
at late times, very different from their statistical values. The ratios are
rather insensitive to variations in the density, but present strong temperature
dependence. We derive high peak values ($\sim$ 0.1) for the deuterium fraction
in ammonia, in agreement with previous (gas-phase) models. The deuterium
fractionation is strongest at high density, corresponding to a high degree of
depletion, and also presents temperature dependence. We find that in the
temperature range 5 to 20 K, the deuterium fractionation peaks at $\sim$ 15 K
while most of the ortho/para (and meta/para for $\rm ND_3$) ratios present a
minimum at 10 K (ortho/para $\rm NH_2D$ has instead a maximum at this
temperature).
Conclusions. Owing to the density and temperature dependence found in the
abundances and spin-state ratios of ammonia and its isotopologs, it is evident
that observations of ammonia and its deuterated forms can provide important
constraints on the physical structure of molecular clouds.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1312.0971 [pdf] - 1238285
The Deuterium Fractionation Timescale in Dense Cloud Cores: A Parameter
Space Exploration
Submitted: 2013-12-03, last modified: 2015-02-26
The deuterium fraction [N$_2$D$^+$]/[N$_2$H$^+$], may provide information
about the ages of dense, cold gas structures, important to compare with
dynamical models of cloud core formation and evolution. Here we introduce a
complete chemical network with species containing up to three atoms, with the
exception of the Oxygen chemistry, where reactions involving H$_3$O$^+$ and its
deuterated forms have been added, significantly improving the consistency with
comprehensive chemical networks. Deuterium chemistry and spin states of H$_2$
and H$_3^+$ isotopologues are included in this primarily gas-phase chemical
model. We investigate dependence of deuterium chemistry on model parameters:
density ($n_{\rm H}$), temperature, cosmic ray ionization rate, and gas-phase
depletion factor of heavy elements ($f_{\rm D}$). We also explore the effects
of time-dependent freeze-out of gas-phase species and dynamical evolution of
density at various rates relative to free-fall collapse. For a broad range of
model parameters, the timescales to reach large values of $D_{\rm frac}^{\rm
N_2H^+} \gtrsim 0.1$, observed in some low- and high-mass starless cores, are
relatively long compared to the local free-fall timescale. These conclusions
are unaffected by introducing time-dependent freeze-out and considering models
with evolving density, unless the initial $f_{\rm D} \gtrsim$ 10. For fiducial
model parameters, achieving $D_{\rm frac}^{\rm N_2H^+} \gtrsim 0.1$ requires
collapse to be proceeding at rates at least several times slower than that of
free-fall collapse, perhaps indicating a dynamically important role for
magnetic fields in the support of starless cores and thus the regulation of
star formation.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1501.04825 [pdf] - 1128989
Benchmarking spin-state chemistry in starless core models
Submitted: 2015-01-20
Aims. We aim to present simulated chemical abundance profiles for a variety
of important species, with special attention given to spin-state chemistry, in
order to provide reference results against which present and future models can
be compared. Methods. We employ gas-phase and gas-grain models to investigate
chemical abundances in physical conditions corresponding to starless cores. To
this end, we have developed new chemical reaction sets for both gas-phase and
grain-surface chemistry, including the deuterated forms of species with up to
six atoms and the spin-state chemistry of light ions and of the species
involved in the ammonia and water formation networks. The physical model is
kept simple in order to facilitate straightforward benchmarking of other models
against the results of this paper. Results. We find that the ortho/para ratios
of ammonia and water are similar in both gas-phase and gas-grain models, at
late times in particular, implying that the ratios are determined by gas-phase
processes. We derive late-time ortho/para ratios of ~0.5 and ~1.6 for ammonia
and water, respectively. We find that including or excluding deuterium in the
calculations has little effect on the abundances of non-deuterated species and
on the ortho/para ratios of ammonia and water, especially in gas-phase models
where deuteration is naturally hindered owing to the presence of abundant heavy
elements. Although we study a rather narrow temperature range (10-20 K), we
find strong temperature dependence in, e.g., deuteration and nitrogen
chemistry. For example, the depletion timescale of ammonia is significantly
reduced when the temperature is increased from 10 to 20 K; this is because the
increase in temperature translates into increased accretion rates, while the
very high binding energy of ammonia prevents it from being desorbed at 20 K.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.3268 [pdf] - 1209513
Multilayer formation and evaporation of deuterated ices in prestellar
and protostellar cores
Submitted: 2014-05-13
Extremely large deuteration of several molecules has been observed towards
prestellar cores and low-mass protostars for a decade. New observations
performed towards low-mass protostars suggest that water presents a lower
deuteration in the warm inner gas than in the cold external envelope. We
coupled a gas-grain astrochemical model with a one-dimension model of
collapsing core to properly follow the formation and the deuteration of
interstellar ices as well as their subsequent evaporation in the low-mass
protostellar envelopes with the aim of interpreting the spatial and temporal
evolutions of their deuteration. The astrochemical model follows the formation
and the evaporation of ices with a multilayer approach and also includes a
state-of-the-art deuterated chemical network by taking the spin states of H$_2$
and light ions into account. Because of their slow formation, interstellar ices
are chemically heterogeneous and show an increase of their deuterium
fractionation towards the surface. The differentiation of the deuteration in
ices induces an evolution of the deuteration within protostellar envelopes. The
warm inner region is poorly deuterated because it includes the whole molecular
content of ices while the deuteration predicted in the cold external envelope
scales with the highly deuterated surface of ices. We are able to reproduce the
observed evolution of water deuteration within protostellar envelopes but we
are still unable to predict the super-high deuteration observed for
formaldehyde and methanol. Finally, the extension of this study to the
deuteration of complex organics (COMs), important for the prebiotic chemistry,
shows a good agreement with the observations, suggesting that we can use the
deuteration to retrace their mechanisms and their moments of formation.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.4031 [pdf] - 1165966
HD depletion in starless cores
Submitted: 2013-04-15
Aims: We aim to investigate the abundances of light deuterium-bearing species
such as HD, H2D+ and D2H+ in a gas-grain chemical model including an extensive
description of deuterium and spin state chemistry, in physical conditions
appropriate to the very centers of starless cores. Methods: We combine a
gas-grain chemical model with radiative transfer calculations to simulate
density and temperature structure in starless cores. The chemical model
includes deuterated forms of species with up to 4 atoms and the spin states of
the light species H2, H2+ and H3+ and their deuterated forms. Results: We find
that HD eventually depletes from the gas phase because deuterium is efficiently
incorporated to grain-surface HDO, resulting in inefficient HD production on
grains. HD depletion has consequences not only on the abundances of e.g. H2D+
and D2H+, whose production depends on the abundance of HD, but also on the spin
state abundance ratios of the various light species, when compared with the
complete depletion model where heavy elements do not influence the chemistry.
Conclusions: While the eventual HD depletion leads to the disappearance of
light deuterium-bearing species from the gas phase in a relatively short
timescale at high density, we find that at late stages of core evolution the
abundances of H2D+ and D2H+ increase toward the core edge and the disributions
become extended. The HD depletion timescale increases if less oxygen is
initially present in the gas phase, owing to chemical interaction between the
gas and the dust predecing the starless core phase. Our results are greatly
affected if H2 is allowed to tunnel on grain surfaces, and therefore more
experimental data not only on tunneling but also on the O + H2 surface reaction
in particular is needed.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1205.3660 [pdf] - 1123437
Radial molecular abundances and gas cooling in starless cores
Submitted: 2012-05-16
Aims: We aim to simulate radial profiles of molecular abundances and the gas
temperature in cold and heavily shielded starless cores by combining chemical
and radiative transfer models. Methods: A determination of the dust temperature
in a modified Bonnor-Ebert sphere is used to calculate initial radial molecular
abundance profiles. The abundances of selected cooling molecules corresponding
to two different core ages are then extracted to determine the gas temperature
at two time steps. The calculation is repeated in an iterative process yielding
molecular abundances consistent with the gas temperature. Line emission
profiles for selected substances are calculated using simulated abundance
profiles. Results: The gas temperature is a function of time; the gas heats up
as the core gets older because the cooling molecules are depleted onto grain
surfaces. The contributions of the various cooling molecules to the total
cooling power change with time. Radial chemical abundance profiles are
non-trivial: different species present varying degrees of depletion and in some
cases inward-increasing abundances profiles, even at t > 10^5 years. Line
emission simulations indicate that cores of different ages can present
significantly different line emission profiles, depending on the tracer species
considered. Conclusions: Chemical abundances and the associated line cooling
power change as a function of time. Most chemical species are depleted onto
grain surfaces at densities exceeding ~10^5 cm^-3. Notable exceptions are NH_3
and N2H^+; the latter is largely undepleted even at n_H~10^6 cm-3. On the other
hand, chemical abundances are not significantly developed in regions of low gas
density even at t~10^5 years, revealed by inward-increasing abundance
gradients. The gas temperature can be significantly different from the dust
temperature; this may have implications on core stability.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1108.5275 [pdf] - 1083652
On the stability of non-isothermal Bonnor-Ebert spheres
Submitted: 2011-08-26
Aims: We aim to derive a stability condition for non-isothermal Bonnor-Ebert
spheres and compare the physical properties of critical non-isothermal and
isothermal gas spheres. These configurations can serve as models for prestellar
cores before gravitational collapse.
Methods: A stability condition for non-isothermal spheres is derived by
constructing an expression for the derivative of boundary pressure with respect
to core volume. The temperature distribution is determined by means of
radiative transfer calculations. Based on the stability analysis, we derive the
physical parameters of critical cores for the mass range 0.1 - 5.0 M_sun. In
addition, the properties of roughly Jupiter-mass cores are briefly examined.
Results: At the low-mass end the critical non-isothermal sphere has lower
central density and a slightly larger physical radius than the corresponding
isothermal sphere (i.e. one with the same mass and average temperature). The
temperature decrease towards the core centre becomes steeper towards smaller
masses as the central density becomes higher. The slope depends on the adopted
dust model. We find that the critical dimensionless radius increases above the
isothermal value xi_0 = 6.45 for very low-mass cores (< 0.2 M_sun). However, in
the mass-range studied here the changes are within 5% from the isothermal
value.
Conclusions: The density structures of non-isothermal and isothermal
Bonnor-Ebert spheres for a given mass are fairly similar. However, the present
models predict clear differences in the average temperatures for the same
physical radius. Especially for low-mass cores, the temperature gradient
probably has implications on the chemistry and the observed line emission. We
also find that hydrostatic Jupiter-mass cores with radii less than 100 AU would
have very high boundary pressures compared with typical pressures in the
interstellar space.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.1236 [pdf] - 1018259
Modelling line emission of deuterated H_3^+ from prestellar cores
Submitted: 2009-11-06, last modified: 2010-01-11
Context: The depletion of heavy elements in cold cores of interstellar
molecular clouds can lead to a situation where deuterated forms of H_3^+ are
the most useful spectroscopic probes of the physical conditions.
Aims: The aim is to predict the observability of the rotational lines of
H_2D^+ and D_2H^+ from prestellar cores.
Methods: Recently derived rate coefficients for the H_3^+ + H_2 isotopic
system were applied to the "complete depletion" reaction scheme to calculate
abundance profiles in hydrostatic core models. The ground-state lines of
H_2D^+(o) (372 GHz) and D_2H^+(p) (692 GHz) arising from these cores were
simulated. The excitation of the rotational levels of these molecules was
approximated by using the state-to-state coefficients for collisions with H_2.
We also predicted line profiles from cores with a power-law density
distribution advocated in some previous studies.
Results: The new rate coefficients introduce some changes to the complete
depletion model, but do not alter the general tendencies. One of the
modifications with respect to the previous results is the increase of the D_3^+
abundance at the cost of other isotopologues. Furthermore, the present model
predicts a lower H_2D^+ (o/p) ratio, and a slightly higher D_2H^+ (p/o) ratio
in very cold, dense cores, as compared with previous modelling results. These
nuclear spin ratios affect the detectability of the submm lines of H_2D^+(o)
and D_2H^+(p). The previously detected H_2D^+ and D_2H^+ lines towards the core
I16293E, and the H_2D^+ line observed towards Oph D can be reproduced using the
present excitation model and the physical models suggested in the original
papers.