Normalized to: Shajib, A.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.02941 [pdf] - 2129480
TDCOSMO IV: Hierarchical time-delay cosmography -- joint inference of
the Hubble constant and galaxy density profiles
Birrer, S.;
Shajib, A. J.;
Galan, A.;
Millon, M.;
Treu, T.;
Agnello, A.;
Auger, M.;
Chen, G. C. -F.;
Christensen, L.;
Collett, T.;
Courbin, F.;
Fassnacht, C. D.;
Koopmans, L. V. E.;
Marshall, P. J.;
Park, J. -W.;
Rusu, C. E.;
Sluse, D.;
Spiniello, C.;
Suyu, S. H.;
Wagner-Carena, S.;
Wong, K. C.;
Barnabè, M.;
Bolton, A. S.;
Czoske, O.;
Ding, X.;
Frieman, J. A.;
Van de Vyvere, L.
Submitted: 2020-07-06
The H0LiCOW collaboration inferred via gravitational lensing time delays a
Hubble constant $H_0=73.3^{+1.7}_{-1.8}$ km s$^{-1}{\rm Mpc}^{-1}$, describing
deflector mass density profiles by either a power-law or stars plus standard
dark matter halos. The mass-sheet transform (MST) that leaves the lensing
observables unchanged is considered the dominant source of residual uncertainty
in $H_0$. We quantify any potential effect of the MST with flexible mass models
that are maximally degenerate with H0. Our calculation is based on a new
hierarchical approach in which the MST is only constrained by stellar
kinematics. The approach is validated on hydrodynamically simulated lenses. We
apply the method to the TDCOSMO sample of 7 lenses (6 from H0LiCOW) and measure
$H_0=74.5^{+5.6}_{-6.1}$ km s$^{-1}{\rm Mpc}^{-1}$. In order to further
constrain the deflector mass profiles, we then add imaging and spectroscopy for
33 strong gravitational lenses from the SLACS sample. For 9 of the SLAC lenses
we use resolved kinematics to constrain the stellar anisotropy. From the joint
analysis of the TDCOSMO+SLACS sample, we measure $H_0=67.4^{+4.1}_{-3.2}$ km
s$^{-1}{\rm Mpc}^{-1}$, assuming that the TDCOSMO and SLACS galaxies are drawn
from the same parent population. The blind H0LiCOW, TDCOSMO-only and
TDCOSMO+SLACS analyses are in mutual statistical agreement. The TDCOSMO+SLACS
analysis prefers marginally shallower mass profiles than H0LiCOW or
TDCOSMO-only. While our new analysis does not statistically invalidate the mass
profile assumptions by H0LiCOW, and thus their $H_0$ measurement relying on
those, it demonstrates the importance of understanding the mass density profile
of elliptical galaxies. The uncertainties on $H_0$ derived in this paper can be
reduced by physical or observational priors on the form of the mass profile, or
by additional data, chiefly spatially resolved kinematics of lens galaxies.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.08027 [pdf] - 2124587
TDCOSMO. I. An exploration of systematic uncertainties in the inference
of $H_0$ from time-delay cosmography
Millon, M.;
Galan, A.;
Courbin, F.;
Treu, T.;
Suyu, S. H.;
Ding, X.;
Birrer, S.;
Chen, G. C. -F.;
Shajib, A. J.;
Sluse, D.;
Wong, K. C.;
Agnello, A.;
Auger, M. W.;
Buckley-Geer, E. J.;
Chan, J. H. H.;
Collett, T.;
Fassnacht, C. D.;
Hilbert, S.;
Koopmans, L. V. E.;
Motta, V.;
Mukherjee, S.;
Rusu, C. E.;
Sonnenfeld, A.;
Spiniello, C.;
Van de Vyvere, L.
Submitted: 2019-12-17, last modified: 2020-06-30
Time-delay cosmography of lensed quasars has achieved 2.4% precision on the
measurement of the Hubble constant, $H_0$. As part of an ongoing effort to
uncover and control systematic uncertainties, we investigate three potential
sources: 1- stellar kinematics, 2- line-of-sight effects, and 3- the deflector
mass model. To meet this goal in a quantitative way, we reproduced the
H0LiCOW/SHARP/STRIDES (hereafter TDCOSMO) procedures on a set of real and
simulated data, and we find the following. First, stellar kinematics cannot be
a dominant source of error or bias since we find that a systematic change of
10% of measured velocity dispersion leads to only a 0.7% shift on $H_0$ from
the seven lenses analyzed by TDCOSMO. Second, we find no bias to arise from
incorrect estimation of the line-of-sight effects. Third, we show that
elliptical composite (stars + dark matter halo), power-law, and cored power-law
mass profiles have the flexibility to yield a broad range in $H_0$ values.
However, the TDCOSMO procedures that model the data with both composite and
power-law mass profiles are informative. If the models agree, as we observe in
real systems owing to the "bulge-halo" conspiracy, $H_0$ is recovered precisely
and accurately by both models. If the two models disagree, as in the case of
some pathological models illustrated here, the TDCOSMO procedure either
discriminates between them through the goodness of fit, or it accounts for the
discrepancy in the final error bars provided by the analysis. This conclusion
is consistent with a reanalysis of six of the TDCOSMO (real) lenses: the
composite model yields $H_0=74.2^{+1.6}_{-1.6}$ $km.s^{-1}.Mpc^{-1}$, while the
power-law model yields $74.0^{+1.7}_{-1.8}$ $km.s^{-1}.Mpc^{-1}$. In
conclusion, we find no evidence of bias or errors larger than the current
statistical uncertainties reported by TDCOSMO.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.08619 [pdf] - 2115429
Time Delay Lens modelling Challenge: II. Results
Ding, X.;
Treu, T.;
Birrer, S.;
Chen, G. C. -F.;
Coles, J.;
Denzel, P.;
Galan, M. Frigo A.;
Marshall, P. J.;
Millon, M.;
More, A.;
Shajib, A. J.;
Sluse, D.;
Tak, H.;
Xu, D.;
Auger, M. W.;
Bonvin, V.;
Chand, H.;
Courbin, F.;
Despali, G.;
Fassnacht, C. D.;
Gilman, D.;
Hilbert, S.;
Kumar, S. R.;
Lin, Y. -Y.;
Park, J. W.;
Saha, P.;
Vegetti, S.;
Van de Vyvere, L.;
Williams, L. L. R.
Submitted: 2020-06-15
In recent years, breakthroughs in methods and data have enabled gravitational
time delays to emerge as a very powerful tool to measure the Hubble constant
$H_0$. However, published state-of-the-art analyses require of order 1 year of
expert investigator time and up to a million hours of computing time per
system. Furthermore, as precision improves, it is crucial to identify and
mitigate systematic uncertainties. With this time delay lens modelling
challenge we aim to assess the level of precision and accuracy of the modelling
techniques that are currently fast enough to handle of order 50 lenses, via the
blind analysis of simulated datasets presented in paper I. The results in Rung
1 and Rung 2 show that methods that use only the point source positions tend to
have lower precision ($10 - 20\%$) while remaining accurate. In Rung 2, the
methods that exploit the full information of the imaging and kinematic datasets
can recover $H_0$ within the target accuracy ($ |A| < 2\%$) and precision ($<
6\%$ per system), even in the presence of poorly known point spread function
and complex source morphology. A post-unblinding analysis of Rung 3 showed the
numerical precision of the ray-traced cosmological simulations to be
insufficient to test lens modelling methodology at the percent level, making
the results difficult to interpret. A new challenge with improved simulations
is needed to make further progress in the investigation of systematic
uncertainties. For completeness, we present the Rung 3 results in an appendix,
and use them to discuss various approaches to mitigating against similar subtle
data generation effects in future blind challenges.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.01506 [pdf] - 2115049
Time Delay Lens Modeling Challenge: I. Experimental Design
Ding, Xuheng;
Treu, Tommaso;
Shajib, Anowar J.;
Xu, Dandan;
Chen, Geoff C. -F.;
More, Anupreeta;
Despali, Giulia;
Frigo, Matteo;
Fassnacht, Christopher D.;
Gilman, Daniel;
Hilbert, Stefan;
Marshall, Philip J.;
Sluse, Dominique;
Vegetti, Simona
Submitted: 2018-01-04, last modified: 2020-06-15
Strong gravitational lenses with measured time delay are a powerful tool to
measure cosmological parameters, especially the Hubble constant ($H_0$). Recent
studies show that by combining just three multiply-imaged AGN systems, one can
determine $H_0$ to 2.4% precision. Furthermore, the number of time-delay lens
systems is growing rapidly, enabling the determination of $H_0$ to 1% precision
in the near future. However, as the precision increases it is important to
ensure that systematic errors and biases remain subdominant. For this purpose,
challenges with simulated datasets are a key component in this process.
Following the experience of the past challenge on time delay, where it was
shown that time delays can indeed be measured precisely and accurately at the
sub-percent level, we now present the "Time Delay Lens Modeling Challenge"
(TDLMC). The goal of this challenge is to assess the present capabilities of
lens modeling codes and assumptions and test the level of accuracy of inferred
cosmological parameters given realistic mock datasets. We invite scientists to
model a set of simulated HST observations of 50 mock lens systems. The systems
are organized in rungs, with the complexity and realism increasing going up the
ladder. The goal of the challenge is to infer $H_0$ for each rung, given the
HST images, the time delay, and stellar velocity dispersion of the deflector
for a fixed background cosmology. The TDLMC challenge starts with the mock data
release on 2018 January 8th. The deadline for blind submission is different for
each rung. The deadline for Rung 0-1 is 2018 September 8; the deadline for Rung
2 is 2019 April 8 and the one for Rung 3 is 2019 September 8. This first paper
gives an overview of the challenge including the data design, and a set of
metrics to quantify the modeling performance and challenge details.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.06306 [pdf] - 2078211
STRIDES: a 3.9 per cent measurement of the Hubble constant from the
strong lens system DES J0408-5354
Shajib, A. J.;
Birrer, S.;
Treu, T.;
Agnello, A.;
Buckley-Geer, E. J.;
Chan, J. H. H.;
Christensen, L.;
Lemon, C.;
Lin, H.;
Millon, M.;
Poh, J.;
Rusu, C. E.;
Sluse, D.;
Spiniello, C.;
Chen, G. C. -F.;
Collett, T.;
Courbin, F.;
Fassnacht, C. D.;
Frieman, J.;
Galan, A.;
Gilman, D.;
More, A.;
Anguita, T.;
Auger, M. W.;
Bonvin, V.;
McMahon, R.;
Meylan, G.;
Wong, K. C.;
Abbott, T. M. C.;
Annis, J.;
Avila, S.;
Bechtol, K.;
Brooks, D.;
Brout, D.;
Burke, D. L.;
Rosell, A. Carnero;
Kind, M. Carrasco;
Carretero, J.;
Castander, F. J.;
Costanzi, M.;
da Costa, L. N.;
De Vicente, J.;
Desai, S.;
Dietrich, J. P.;
Doel, P.;
Drlica-Wagner, A.;
Evrard, A. E.;
Finley, D. A.;
Flaugher, B.;
Fosalba, P.;
García-Bellido, J.;
Gerdes, D. W.;
Gruen, D.;
Gruendl, R. A.;
Gschwend, J.;
Gutierrez, G.;
Hollowood, D. L.;
Honscheid, K.;
Huterer, D.;
James, D. J.;
Jeltema, T.;
Krause, E.;
Kuropatkin, N.;
Li, T. S.;
Lima, M.;
MacCrann, N.;
Maia, M. A. G.;
Marshall, J. L.;
Melchior, P.;
Miquel, R.;
Ogando, R. L. C.;
Palmese, A.;
Paz-Chinchón, F.;
Plazas, A. A.;
Romer, A. K.;
Roodman, A.;
Sako, M.;
Sanchez, E.;
Santiago, B.;
Scarpine, V.;
Schubnell, M.;
Scolnic, D.;
Serrano, S.;
Sevilla-Noarbe, I.;
Smith, M.;
Soares-Santos, M.;
Suchyta, E.;
Tarle, G.;
Thomas, D.;
Walker, A. R.;
Zhang, Y.
Submitted: 2019-10-14, last modified: 2020-04-14
We present a blind time-delay cosmographic analysis for the lens system DES
J0408$-$5354. This system is extraordinary for the presence of two sets of
multiple images at different redshifts, which provide the opportunity to obtain
more information at the cost of increased modelling complexity with respect to
previously analyzed systems. We perform detailed modelling of the mass
distribution for this lens system using three band Hubble Space Telescope
imaging. We combine the measured time delays, line-of-sight central velocity
dispersion of the deflector, and statistically constrained external convergence
with our lens models to estimate two cosmological distances. We measure the
"effective" time-delay distance corresponding to the redshifts of the deflector
and the lensed quasar $D_{\Delta t}^{\rm eff}=3382^{+146}_{-115}$ Mpc and the
angular diameter distance to the deflector $D_{\rm d}=1711^{+376}_{-280}$ Mpc,
with covariance between the two distances. From these constraints on the
cosmological distances, we infer the Hubble constant $H_0 = 74.2^{+2.7}_{-3.0}$
km s$^{-1}$ Mpc$^{-1}$ assuming a flat $\Lambda$CDM cosmology and a uniform
prior for $\Omega_{\rm m}$ as $\Omega_{\rm m} \sim \mathcal{U}(0.05, 0.5)$.
This measurement gives the most precise constraint on $H_0$ to date from a
single lens. Our measurement is consistent with that obtained from the previous
sample of six lenses analyzed by the $H_0$ Lenses in COSMOGRAIL's Wellspring
(H0LiCOW) collaboration. It is also consistent with measurements of $H_0$ based
on the local distance ladder, reinforcing the tension with the inference from
early Universe probes, for example, with 2.2$\sigma$ discrepancy from the
cosmic microwave background measurement.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.12117 [pdf] - 2072774
STRIDES: Spectroscopic and photometric characterization of the
environment and effects of mass along the line of sight to the gravitational
lenses DES J0408-5354 and WGD 2038-4008
Buckley-Geer, E. J.;
Lin, H.;
Rusu, C.;
Poh, J.;
Palmese, A.;
Agnello, A.;
Christensen, L.;
Frieman, J.;
Shajib, A. J.;
Treu, T.;
Collett, T.;
Birrer, S.;
Anguita, T.;
Fassnacht, C. D.;
Meylan, G.;
Mukherjee, S.;
Wong, K. C.;
Aguena, M.;
Allam, S.;
Avila, S.;
Bertin, E.;
Bhargava, S.;
Brooks, D.;
Rosell, A. Carnero;
Kind, M. Carrasco;
Carretero, J.;
Castander, F. J.;
Costanzi, M.;
da Costa, L. N.;
De Vicente, J.;
Desai, S.;
Diehl, H. T.;
Doel, P.;
Eifler, T. F.;
Everett, S.;
Flaugher, B.;
Fosalba, P.;
García-Bellido, J.;
Gaztanaga, E.;
Gruen, D.;
Gruendl, R. A.;
Gschwend, J.;
Gutierrez, G.;
Hinton, S. R.;
Honscheid, K.;
James, D. J.;
Kuehn, K.;
Kuropatkin, N.;
Maia, M. A. G.;
Marshall, J. L.;
Melchior, P.;
Menanteau, F.;
Miquel, R.;
Ogando, R. L. C.;
Paz-Chinchón, F.;
Plazas, A. A.;
Sanchez, E.;
Scarpine, V.;
Schubnell, M.;
Serrano, S.;
Sevilla-Noarbe, I.;
Smith, M.;
Soares-Santos, M.;
Suchyta, E.;
Swanson, M. E. C.;
Tarle, G.;
Tucker, D. L.;
Varga, T. N.
Submitted: 2020-03-26, last modified: 2020-03-30
In time-delay cosmography, three of the key ingredients are 1) determining
the velocity dispersion of the lensing galaxy, 2) identifying galaxies and
groups along the line of sight with sufficient proximity and mass to be
included in the mass model, and 3) estimating the external convergence
$\kappa_\mathrm{ext}$ from less massive structures that are not included in the
mass model. We present results on all three of these ingredients for two
time-delay lensed quasar systems, DES J0408-5354 and WGD 2038-4008. We use the
Gemini, Magellan and VLT telescopes to obtain spectra to both measure the
stellar velocity dispersions of the main lensing galaxies and to identify the
line-of-sight galaxies in these systems. Next, we identify 10 groups in DES
J0408-5354 and 2 groups in WGD 2038-4008using a group-finding algorithm. We
then identify the most significant galaxy and galaxy-group perturbers using the
"flexion shift" criterion. We determine the probability distribution function
of the external convergence $\kappa_\mathrm{ext}$ for both of these systems
based on our spectroscopy and on the DES-only multiband wide-field
observations. Using weighted galaxy counts, calibrated based on the Millennium
Simulation, we find that DES J0408-5354 is located in a significantly
underdense environment, leading to a tight (width $\sim3\%$), negative-value
$\kappa_\mathrm{ext}$ distribution. On the other hand, WGD 2038-4008 is located
in an environment of close to unit density, and its low source redshift results
in a much tighter $\kappa_\mathrm{ext}$ of $\sim1\%$, as long as no external
shear constraints are imposed.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.09133 [pdf] - 2065348
The STRong lensing Insights into the Dark Energy Survey (STRIDES)
2017/2018 follow-up campaign: Discovery of 10 lensed quasars and 10 quasar
pairs
Lemon, C.;
Auger, M. W.;
McMahon, R.;
Anguita, T.;
Apostolovski, Y.;
Chen, G. C. -F.;
Fassnacht, C. D.;
Melo, A.;
Motta, V.;
Shajib, A.;
Treu, T.;
Agnello, A.;
Buckley-Geer, E.;
Schechter, P. L.;
Birrer, S.;
Collett, T.;
Courbin, F.;
Rusu, C. E.;
Abbott, T. M. C.;
Allam, S.;
Annis, J.;
Avila, S.;
Bertin, E.;
Brooks, D.;
Burke, D. L.;
Rosell, A. Carnero;
Kind, M. Carrasco;
Carretero, J.;
Costanzi, M.;
da Costa, L. N.;
De Vicente, J.;
Desai, S.;
Eifler, T. F.;
Flaugher, B.;
Frieman, J.;
García-Bellido, J.;
Gaztanaga, E.;
Gerdes, D. W.;
Gruen, D.;
Gruendl, R. A.;
Gschwend, J.;
Gutierrez, G.;
Honscheid, K.;
James, D. J.;
Kim, A.;
Krause, E.;
Kuehn, K.;
Kuropatkin, N.;
Lahav, O.;
Lima, M.;
Lin, H.;
Maia, M. A. G.;
March, M.;
Marshall, J. L.;
Menanteau, F.;
Miquel, R.;
Palmese, A.;
Chinchón, F. Paz;
Plazas, A. A.;
Roodman, A.;
Sanchez, E.;
Schubnell, M.;
Serrano, S.;
Smith, M.;
Soares-Santos, M.;
Suchyta, E.;
Tarle, G.;
Walker, A. R.
Submitted: 2019-12-19
We report the results of the STRong lensing Insights from the Dark Energy
Survey (STRIDES) follow-up campaign of the late 2017/early 2018 season. We
obtained spectra of 65 lensed quasar candidates either with EFOSC2 on the NTT
or ESI on Keck, which confirm 10 new gravitationally lensed quasars and 10
quasar pairs with similar spectra, but which do not show a lensing galaxy in
DES images. Eight lensed quasars are doubly imaged with source redshifts
between 0.99 and 2.90, one is triply imaged by a group (DESJ0345-2545,
$z=1.68$), and one is quadruply imaged (quad: DESJ0053-2012, $z=3.8$). Singular
isothermal ellipsoid models for the doubles, based on high-resolution imaging
from SAMI on SOAR or NIRC2 on Keck, give total magnifications between 3.2 and
5.6, and Einstein radii between 0.49 and 1.97 arcseconds. After spectroscopic
follow-up, we extract multi-epoch $grizY$ photometry of confirmed lensed
quasars and contaminant quasar+star pairs from the first 4 years of DES data
using parametric multi-band modelling, and compare variability in each system's
components. By measuring the reduced ${\chi}^2$ associated with fitting all
epochs to the same magnitude, we find a simple cut on the less variable
component that retains all confirmed lensed quasars, while removing 94 per cent
of contaminant systems with stellar components. Based on our spectroscopic
follow-up, this variability information can improve selection of lensed quasars
and quasar pairs from 34-45 per cent to 51-70 per cent, with the majority of
remaining contaminants being compact star-forming galaxies. Using mock lensed
quasar lightcurves we demonstrate that selection based only on variability will
over-represent the quad fraction by 10 per cent over a complete DES
magnitude-limited sample (excluding microlensing differences), explained by the
magnification bias and hence lower luminosity (more variable) sources in quads.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.09338 [pdf] - 2109878
H0LiCOW XII. Lens mass model of WFI2033-4723 and blind measurement of
its time-delay distance and $H_0$
Rusu, Cristian E.;
Wong, Kenneth C.;
Bonvin, Vivien;
Sluse, Dominique;
Suyu, Sherry H.;
Fassnacht, Christopher D.;
Chan, James H. H.;
Hilbert, Stefan;
Auger, Matthew W.;
Sonnenfeld, Alessandro;
Birrer, Simon;
Courbin, Frederic;
Treu, Tommaso;
Chen, Geoff C. -F.;
Halkola, Aleksi;
Koopmans, Leon V. E.;
Marshall, Philip J.;
Shajib, Anowar J.
Submitted: 2019-05-22, last modified: 2019-12-08
We present the lens mass model of the quadruply-imaged gravitationally lensed
quasar WFI2033-4723, and perform a blind cosmographical analysis based on this
system. Our analysis combines (1) time-delay measurements from 14 years of data
obtained by the COSmological MOnitoring of GRAvItational Lenses (COSMOGRAIL)
collaboration, (2) high-resolution $\textit{Hubble Space Telescope}$ imaging,
(3) a measurement of the velocity dispersion of the lens galaxy based on
ESO-MUSE data, and (4) multi-band, wide-field imaging and spectroscopy
characterizing the lens environment. We account for all known sources of
systematics, including the influence of nearby perturbers and complex
line-of-sight structure, as well as the parametrization of the light and mass
profiles of the lensing galaxy. After unblinding, we determine the effective
time-delay distance to be $4784_{-248}^{+399}~\mathrm{Mpc}$, an average
precision of $6.6\%$. This translates to a Hubble constant $H_{0} =
71.6_{-4.9}^{+3.8}~\mathrm{km~s^{-1}~Mpc^{-1}}$, assuming a flat $\Lambda$CDM
cosmology with a uniform prior on $\Omega_\mathrm{m}$ in the range [0.05, 0.5].
This work is part of the $H_0$ Lenses in COSMOGRAIL's Wellspring (H0LiCOW)
collaboration, and the full time-delay cosmography results from a total of six
strongly lensed systems are presented in a companion paper (H0LiCOW XIII).
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.04869 [pdf] - 2109889
H0LiCOW XIII. A 2.4% measurement of $H_{0}$ from lensed quasars:
$5.3\sigma$ tension between early and late-Universe probes
Wong, Kenneth C.;
Suyu, Sherry H.;
Chen, Geoff C. -F.;
Rusu, Cristian E.;
Millon, Martin;
Sluse, Dominique;
Bonvin, Vivien;
Fassnacht, Christopher D.;
Taubenberger, Stefan;
Auger, Matthew W.;
Birrer, Simon;
Chan, James H. H.;
Courbin, Frederic;
Hilbert, Stefan;
Tihhonova, Olga;
Treu, Tommaso;
Agnello, Adriano;
Ding, Xuheng;
Jee, Inh;
Komatsu, Eiichiro;
Shajib, Anowar J.;
Sonnenfeld, Alessandro;
Blandford, Roger D.;
Koopmans, Leon V. E.;
Marshall, Philip J.;
Meylan, Georges
Submitted: 2019-07-10, last modified: 2019-11-05
We present a measurement of the Hubble constant ($H_{0}$) and other
cosmological parameters from a joint analysis of six gravitationally lensed
quasars with measured time delays. All lenses except the first are analyzed
blindly with respect to the cosmological parameters. In a flat $\Lambda$CDM
cosmology, we find $H_{0} = 73.3_{-1.8}^{+1.7}$, a 2.4% precision measurement,
in agreement with local measurements of $H_{0}$ from type Ia supernovae
calibrated by the distance ladder, but in $3.1\sigma$ tension with $Planck$
observations of the cosmic microwave background (CMB). This method is
completely independent of both the supernovae and CMB analyses. A combination
of time-delay cosmography and the distance ladder results is in $5.3\sigma$
tension with $Planck$ CMB determinations of $H_{0}$ in flat $\Lambda$CDM. We
compute Bayes factors to verify that all lenses give statistically consistent
results, showing that we are not underestimating our uncertainties and are able
to control our systematics. We explore extensions to flat $\Lambda$CDM using
constraints from time-delay cosmography alone, as well as combinations with
other cosmological probes, including CMB observations from $Planck$, baryon
acoustic oscillations, and type Ia supernovae. Time-delay cosmography improves
the precision of the other probes, demonstrating the strong complementarity.
Allowing for spatial curvature does not resolve the tension with $Planck$.
Using the distance constraints from time-delay cosmography to anchor the type
Ia supernova distance scale, we reduce the sensitivity of our $H_0$ inference
to cosmological model assumptions. For six different cosmological models, our
combined inference on $H_{0}$ ranges from
$\sim73$-$78~\mathrm{km~s^{-1}~Mpc^{-1}}$, which is consistent with the local
distance ladder constraints.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.08800 [pdf] - 1956501
H0LiCOW X: Spectroscopic/imaging survey and galaxy-group identification
around the strong gravitational lens system WFI2033-4723
Sluse, D.;
Rusu, C. E.;
Fassnacht, C. D.;
Sonnenfeld, A.;
Richard, J.;
Auger, M. W.;
Coccato, L.;
Wong, K. C.;
Suyu, S. H.;
Treu, T.;
Agnello, A.;
Birrer, S.;
Bonvin, V.;
Collett, T.;
Courbin, F.;
Hilbert, S.;
Koopmans, L. V. E.;
Tihhanova, O.;
Marshall, P. J.;
Meylan, G.;
Shajib, A. J.;
Annis, J.;
Avila, S.;
Bertin, E.;
Brooks, D.;
Buckley-Geer, E.;
Burke, D. L.;
Rosell, A. Carnero;
Kind, M. Carrasco;
Carretero, J.;
Castander, F. J.;
da Costa, L. N.;
De Vicente, J.;
Desai, S.;
Doel, P.;
Evrard, A. E.;
Flaugher, B.;
Frieman, J.;
García-Bellido, J.;
Gerdes, D. W.;
Goldstein, D. A.;
Gruendl, R. A.;
Gschwend, J.;
Hartley, W. G.;
Hollowood, D. L.;
Honscheid, K.;
James, D. J.;
Kim, A. G.;
Krause, E.;
Kuehn, K.;
Kuropatkin, N.;
Lima, M.;
Lin, H.;
Maia, M. A. G.;
Marshall, J. L.;
Melchior, P.;
Menanteau, F.;
Miquel, R.;
Plazas, A. A.;
Sanchez, E.;
Serrano, S.;
Sevilla-Noarbe, I.;
Smith, M.;
Soares-Santos, M.;
Sobreira, F.;
Suchyta, E.;
Swanson, M. E. C.;
Tarle, G.
Submitted: 2019-05-21, last modified: 2019-09-06
Galaxies and galaxy groups located along the line of sight towards
gravitationally lensed quasars produce high-order perturbations of the
gravitational potential at the lens position. When these perturbation are too
large, they can induce a systematic error on $H_0$ of a few-percent if the lens
system is used for cosmological inference and the perturbers are not explicitly
accounted for in the lens model. In this work, we present a detailed
characterization of the environment of the lens system WFI2033-4723 ($z_{\rm
src} = 1.662$, $z_{\rm lens}$ = 0.6575), one of the core targets of the H0LICOW
project for which we present cosmological inferences in a companion paper (Rusu
et al. 2019). We use the Gemini and ESO-Very Large telescopes to measure the
spectroscopic redshifts of the brightest galaxies towards the lens, and use the
ESO-MUSE integral field spectrograph to measure the velocity-dispersion of the
lens ($\sigma_{\rm {los}}= 250^{+15}_{-21}$ km/s) and of several nearby
galaxies. In addition, we measure photometric redshifts and stellar masses of
all galaxies down to $i < 23$ mag, mainly based on Dark Energy Survey imaging
(DR1). Our new catalog, complemented with literature data, more than doubles
the number of known galaxy spectroscopic redshifts in the direct vicinity of
the lens, expanding to 116 (64) the number of spectroscopic redshifts for
galaxies separated by less than 3 arcmin (2 arcmin) from the lens. Using the
flexion-shift as a measure of the amplitude of the gravitational perturbation,
we identify 2 galaxy groups and 3 galaxies that require specific attention in
the lens models. The ESO MUSE data enable us to measure the
velocity-dispersions of three of these galaxies. These results are essential
for the cosmological inference analysis presented in Rusu et al. (2019).
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.12496 [pdf] - 1945799
The Hubble Constant determined through an inverse distance ladder
including quasar time delays and Type Ia supernovae
Taubenberger, S.;
Suyu, S. H.;
Komatsu, E.;
Jee, I.;
Birrer, S.;
Bonvin, V.;
Courbin, F.;
Rusu, C. E.;
Shajib, A. J.;
Wong, K. C.
Submitted: 2019-05-29, last modified: 2019-07-31
Context. The precise determination of the present-day expansion rate of the
Universe, expressed through the Hubble constant $H_0$, is one of the most
pressing challenges in modern cosmology. Assuming flat $\Lambda$CDM, $H_0$
inference at high redshift using cosmic-microwave-background data from Planck
disagrees at the 4.4$\sigma$ level with measurements based on the local
distance ladder made up of parallaxes, Cepheids and Type Ia supernovae (SNe
Ia), often referred to as "Hubble tension". Independent,
cosmological-model-insensitive ways to infer $H_0$ are of critical importance.
Aims. We apply an inverse-distance-ladder approach, combining strong-lensing
time-delay-distance measurements with SN Ia data. By themselves, SNe Ia are
merely good relative distance indicators, but by anchoring them to strong
gravitational lenses one can obtain an $H_0$ measurement that is relatively
insensitive to other cosmological parameters. Methods. A cosmological parameter
estimate is performed for different cosmological background models, both for
strong-lensing data alone and for the combined lensing + SNe Ia data sets.
Results. The cosmological-model dependence of strong-lensing $H_0$ measurements
is significantly mitigated through the inverse distance ladder. In combination
with SN Ia data, the inferred $H_0$ consistently lies around 73-74 km s$^{-1}$
Mpc$^{-1}$, regardless of the assumed cosmological background model. Our
results agree nicely with those from the local distance ladder, but there is a
>2$\sigma$ tension with Planck results, and a ~1.5$\sigma$ discrepancy with
results from an inverse distance ladder including Planck, Baryon Acoustic
Oscillations and SNe Ia. Future strong-lensing distance measurements will
reduce the uncertainties in $H_0$ from our inverse distance ladder.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.02533 [pdf] - 1966838
A SHARP view of H0LiCOW: $H_{0}$ from three time-delay gravitational
lens systems with adaptive optics imaging
Chen, Geoff C. -F.;
Fassnacht, Christopher D.;
Suyu, Sherry. H.;
Rusu, Cristian E.;
Chan, James H. H.;
Wong, Kenneth C.;
Auger, Matthew W.;
Hilbert, Stefan;
Bonvin, Vivien;
Birrer, Simon;
Millon, Martin;
Koopmans, Leon V. E.;
Lagattuta, David J.;
McKean, John P.;
Vegetti, Simona;
Courbin, Frederic;
Ding, Xuheng;
Halkola, Aleksi;
Jee, Inh;
Shajib, Anowar J.;
Sluse, Dominique;
Sonnenfeld, Alessandro;
Treu, Tommaso
Submitted: 2019-07-04
We present the measurement of the Hubble Constant, $H_0$, with three strong
gravitational lens systems. We describe a blind analysis of both PG1115+080 and
HE0435-1223 as well as an extension of our previous analysis of RXJ1131-1231.
For each lens, we combine new adaptive optics (AO) imaging from the Keck
Telescope, obtained as part of the SHARP AO effort, with Hubble Space Telescope
(HST) imaging, velocity dispersion measurements, and a description of the
line-of-sight mass distribution to build an accurate and precise lens mass
model. This mass model is then combined with the COSMOGRAIL measured time
delays in these systems to determine $H_{0}$. We do both an AO-only and an
AO+HST analysis of the systems and find that AO and HST results are consistent.
After unblinding, the AO-only analysis gives $H_{0}=82.8^{+9.4}_{-8.3}~\rm
km\,s^{-1}\,Mpc^{-1}$ for PG1115+080, $H_{0}=70.1^{+5.3}_{-4.5}~\rm
km\,s^{-1}\,Mpc^{-1}$ for HE0435-1223, and $H_{0}=77.0^{+4.0}_{-4.6}~\rm
km\,s^{-1}\,Mpc^{-1}$ for RXJ1131-1231. The joint AO-only result for the three
lenses is $H_{0}=75.6^{+3.2}_{-3.3}~\rm km\,s^{-1}\,Mpc^{-1}$. The joint result
of the AO+HST analysis for the three lenses is $H_{0}=76.8^{+2.6}_{-2.6}~\rm
km\,s^{-1}\,Mpc^{-1}$. All of the above results assume a flat $\Lambda$ cold
dark matter cosmology with a uniform prior on $\Omega_{\textrm{m}}$ in [0.05,
0.5] and $H_{0}$ in [0, 150] $\rm km\,s^{-1}\,Mpc^{-1}$. This work is a
collaboration of the SHARP and H0LiCOW teams, and shows that AO data can be
used as the high-resolution imaging component in lens-based measurements of
$H_0$. The full time-delay cosmography results from a total of six strongly
lensed systems are presented in a companion paper.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.08263 [pdf] - 1912945
Unified lensing and kinematic analysis for any elliptical mass profile
Submitted: 2019-06-19
We demonstrate an efficient method to compute the
strong-gravitational-lensing deflection angle and magnification for any
elliptical surface-density profile. This method solves a numerical hurdle in
lens modelling that has lacked a general solution for nearly three decades. The
hurdle emerges because it is prohibitive to derive analytic expressions of the
lensing quantities for most elliptical mass profiles. In our method, we first
decompose an elliptical mass profile into Gaussian components. We introduce an
integral transform that provides us with a fast and accurate algorithm for the
Gaussian decomposition. We derive analytic expressions of the lensing
quantities for a Gaussian component. As a result, we can compute these
quantities for the total mass profile by adding up the contributions from the
individual components. This lensing analysis self-consistently completes the
kinematic description in terms of Gaussian components presented by Cappellari
(2008). Our method is general without extra computational burden unlike other
methods currently in use.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.01274 [pdf] - 1888804
H0LiCOW - IX. Cosmographic analysis of the doubly imaged quasar SDSS
1206+4332 and a new measurement of the Hubble constant
Birrer, S.;
Treu, T.;
Rusu, C. E.;
Bonvin, V.;
Fassnacht, C. D.;
Chan, J. H. H.;
Agnello, A.;
Shajib, A. J.;
Chen, G. C. -F.;
Auger, M.;
Courbin, F.;
Hilbert, S.;
Sluse, D.;
Suyu, S. H.;
Wong, K. C.;
Marshall, P.;
Lemaux, B. C.;
Meylan, G.
Submitted: 2018-09-04, last modified: 2019-05-24
We present a blind time-delay strong lensing (TDSL) cosmographic analysis of
the doubly imaged quasar SDSS 1206+4332. We combine the relative time delay
between the quasar images, Hubble Space Telescope imaging, the Keck stellar
velocity dispersion of the lensing galaxy, and wide-field photometric and
spectroscopic data of the field to constrain two angular diameter distance
relations. The combined analysis is performed by forward modelling the
individual data sets through a Bayesian hierarchical framework, and it is kept
blind until the very end to prevent experimenter bias. After unblinding, the
inferred distances imply a Hubble constant $H_0 = 68.8^{+5.4}_{-5.1}$
kms$^{-1}$Mpc$^{-1}$, assuming a flat Lambda cold dark matter cosmology with
uniform prior on $\Omega_{\rm m}$ in [0.05, 0.5]. The precision of our
cosmographic measurement with the doubly imaged quasar SDSS 1206+4332 is
comparable with those of quadruply imaged quasars and opens the path to perform
on selected doubles the same analysis as anticipated for quads. Our analysis is
based on a completely independent lensing code than our previous three H0LiCOW
systems and the new measurement is fully consistent with those. We provide the
analysis scripts paired with the publicly available software to facilitate
independent analysis. The consistency between blind measurements with
independent codes provides an important sanity check on lens modelling
systematics. By combining the likelihoods of the four systems under the same
prior, we obtain $H_0 = 72.5^{+2.1}_{-2.3}$kms$^{-1}$Mpc$^{-1}$. This
measurement is independent of the distance ladder and other cosmological
probes.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.05035 [pdf] - 1847119
Measuring the Hubble Constant Near and Far in the Era of ELT's
Beaton, Rachael L.;
Birrer, Simon;
Dell'Antonio, Ian;
Fassnacht, Chris;
Goldstein, Danny;
Lee, Chien-Hsiu;
Nugent, Peter;
Pierce, Michael;
Shajib, Anowar J.;
Treu, Tommaso
Submitted: 2019-03-12
Many of the fundamental physical constants in Physics, as a discipline, are
measured to exquisite levels of precision. The fundamental constants that
define Cosmology, however, are largely determined via a handful of independent
techniques that are applied to even fewer datasets. The history of the
measurement of the Hubble Constant (H0), which serves to anchor the expansion
history of the Universe to its current value, is an exemplar of the
difficulties of cosmological measurement; indeed, as we approach the centennial
of its first measurement, the quest for H0 still consumes a great number of
resources. In this white paper, we demonstrate how the approaching era of
Extremely Large Telescopes (ELTs) will transform the astrophysical measure of
H0 from the limited and few into a fundamentally new regime where (i) multiple,
independent techniques are employed with modest use of large aperture
facilities and (ii) 1% or better precision is readily attainable. This quantum
leap in how we approach H0 is due to the unparalleled sensitivity and spatial
resolution of ELT's and the ability to use integral field observations for
simultaneous spectroscopy and photometry, which together permit both familiar
and new techniques to effectively by-pass the conventional 'ladder' framework
to minimize total uncertainty. Three independent techniques are discussed --
(i) standard candles via a two-step distance ladder applied to metal, poor
stellar populations, (ii) standard clocks via gravitational lens cosmography,
and (iii) standard sirens via gravitational wave sources -- each of which can
reach 1% with relatively modest investment from 30-m class facilities.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.09278 [pdf] - 1821724
Is every strong lens model unhappy in its own way? Uniform modelling of
a sample of 13 quadruply+ imaged quasars
Shajib, A. J.;
Birrer, S.;
Treu, T.;
Auger, M. W.;
Agnello, A.;
Anguita, T.;
Buckley-Geer, E. J.;
Chan, J. H. H.;
Collett, T. E.;
Courbin, F.;
Fassnacht, C. D.;
Frieman, J.;
Kayo, I.;
Lemon, C.;
Lin, H.;
Marshall, P. J.;
McMahon, R.;
More, A.;
Morgan, N. D.;
Motta, V.;
Oguri, M.;
Ostrovski, F.;
Rusu, C. E.;
Schechter, P. L.;
Shanks, T.;
Suyu, S. H.;
Meylan, G.;
Abbott, T. M. C.;
Allam, S.;
Annis, J.;
Avila, S.;
Bertin, E.;
Brooks, D.;
Rosell, A. Carnero;
Kind, M. Carrasco;
Carretero, J.;
Cunha, C. E.;
da Costa, L. N.;
De Vicente, J.;
Desai, S.;
Doel, P.;
Flaugher, B.;
Fosalba, P.;
García-Bellido, J.;
Gerdes, D. W.;
Gruen, D.;
Gruendl, R. A.;
Gutierrez, G.;
Hartley, W. G.;
Hollowood, D. L.;
Hoyle, B.;
James, D. J.;
Kuehn, K.;
Kuropatkin, N.;
Lahav, O.;
Lima, M.;
Maia, M. A. G.;
March, M.;
Marshall, J. L.;
Melchior, P.;
Menanteau, F.;
Miquel, R.;
Plazas, A. A.;
Sanchez, E.;
Scarpine, V.;
Sevilla-Noarbe, I.;
Smith, M.;
Soares-Santos, M.;
Sobreira, F.;
Suchyta, E.;
Swanson, M. E. C.;
Tarle, G.;
Walker, A. R.
Submitted: 2018-07-24, last modified: 2019-01-28
Strong-gravitational lens systems with quadruply-imaged quasars (quads) are
unique probes to address several fundamental problems in cosmology and
astrophysics. Although they are intrinsically very rare, ongoing and planned
wide-field deep-sky surveys are set to discover thousands of such systems in
the next decade. It is thus paramount to devise a general framework to model
strong-lens systems to cope with this large influx without being limited by
expert investigator time. We propose such a general modelling framework
(implemented with the publicly available software Lenstronomy) and apply it to
uniformly model three-band Hubble Space Telescope Wide Field Camera 3 images of
13 quads. This is the largest uniformly modelled sample of quads to date and
paves the way for a variety of studies. To illustrate the scientific content of
the sample, we investigate the alignment between the mass and light
distribution in the deflectors. The position angles of these distributions are
well-aligned, except when there is strong external shear. However, we find no
correlation between the ellipticity of the light and mass distributions. We
also show that the observed flux-ratios between the images depart significantly
from the predictions of simple smooth models. The departures are strongest in
the bluest band, consistent with microlensing being the dominant cause in
addition to millilensing. Future papers will exploit this rich dataset in
combination with ground based spectroscopy and time delays to determine
quantities such as the Hubble constant, the free streaming length of dark
matter, and the normalization of the initial stellar mass function.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.09390 [pdf] - 1747899
Constraining the microlensing effect on time delays with new time-delay
prediction model in $H_{0}$ measurements
Chen, Geoff C. -F.;
Chan, James H. H.;
Bonvin, Vivien;
Fassnacht, Christopher D.;
Rojas, Karina;
Millon, Martin;
Courbin, Fred;
Suyu, Sherry H.;
Wong, Kenneth C.;
Sluse, Dominique;
Treu, Tommaso;
Shajib, Anowar J.;
Hsueh, Jen-Wei;
Lagattuta, David J.;
Koopmans, Leon V. E.;
Vegetti, Simona;
McKean, John P.
Submitted: 2018-04-25, last modified: 2018-08-28
Time-delay strong lensing provides a unique way to directly measure the
Hubble constant ($H_{0}$). The precision of the $H_{0}$ measurement depends on
the uncertainties in the time-delay measurements, the mass distribution of the
main deflector(s), and the mass distribution along the line of sight. Tie and
Kochanek (2018) have proposed a new microlensing effect on time delays based on
differential magnification of the coherent accretion disc variability of the
lensed quasar. If real, this effect could significantly broaden the uncertainty
on the time delay measurements by up to $30\%$ for lens systems such as
PG1115+080, which have relatively short time delays and monitoring over several
different epochs. In this paper we develop a new technique that uses the
time-delay ratios and simulated microlensing maps within a Bayesian framework
in order to limit the allowed combinations of microlensing delays and thus to
lessen the uncertainties due to the proposed effect. We show that, under the
assumption of Tie and Kochanek (2018), the uncertainty on the time-delay
distance ($D_{\Delta t}$, which is proportional to 1/$H_{0}$) of short
time-delay ($\sim18$ days) lens, PG1115+080, increases from $\sim7\%$ to
$\sim10\%$ by simultaneously fitting the three time-delay measurements from the
three different datasets across twenty years, while in the case of long
time-delay ($\sim90$ days) lens, the microlensing effect on time delays is
negligible as the uncertainty on $D_{\Delta t}$ of RXJ1131-1231 only increases
from $\sim2.5\%$ to $\sim2.6\%$.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.03939 [pdf] - 1665966
Measurement of the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect using the AllWISE data
release
Submitted: 2016-04-13, last modified: 2018-04-15
One of the physical features of a dark-energy-dominated universe is the
integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) effect on the cosmic microwave background (CMB)
radiation, which gives us a direct observational window to detect and study
dark energy. The AllWISE data release of the Wide-field Infrared Survey
Explorer (WISE) has a large number of point sources, which span over a wide
redshift range including where the ISW effect is maximized. AllWISE data is
thus very well-suited for the ISW effect studies. In this study, we
cross-correlate AllWISE galaxy and active galactic nucleus (AGN) overdensities
with the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe CMB temperature maps to detect
the ISW effect signal. We calibrate the biases for galaxies and AGNs by
cross-correlating the galaxy and AGN overdensities with the Planck lensing
convergence map. We measure the ISW effect signal amplitudes relative to the
$\Lambda$CDM expectation of $A=1$ to be $A=1.18 \pm 0.36$ for galaxies and
$A=0.64 \pm 0.74$ for AGNs . The detection significances for the ISW effect
signal are $3.3\sigma$ and $0.9\sigma$ for galaxies and AGNs respectively
giving a combined significance of $3.4\sigma$. Our result is in agreement with
the $\Lambda$CDM model.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.01517 [pdf] - 1666003
Improving time-delay cosmography with spatially resolved kinematics
Submitted: 2017-09-05, last modified: 2018-04-15
Strongly gravitational lensed quasars can be used to measure the so-called
time-delay distance $D_{\Delta t}$, and thus the Hubble constant $H_0$ and
other cosmological parameters. Stellar kinematics of the deflector galaxy play
an essential role in this measurement by: (i) helping break the mass-sheet
degeneracy; (ii) determining in principle the angular diameter distance $D_{\rm
d}$ to the deflector and thus further improving the cosmological constraints.
In this paper we simulate observations of lensed quasars with integral field
spectrographs and show that spatially resolved kinematics of the deflector
enable further progress by helping break the mass-anisotropy degeneracy.
Furthermore, we use our simulations to obtain realistic error estimates with
current/upcoming instruments like OSIRIS on Keck and NIRSPEC on the James Webb
Space Telescope for both distances (typically $\sim6$ per cent on $D_{\Delta
t}$ and $\sim10$ per cent on $D_{\rm d}$). We use the error estimates to
compute cosmological forecasts for the sample of nine lenses that currently
have well measured time delays and deep Hubble Space Telescope images and for a
sample of 40 lenses that is projected to be available in a few years through
follow-up of candidates found in ongoing wide field surveys. We find that $H_0$
can be measured with 2 per cent (1 per cent) precision from nine (40) lenses in
a flat $\Lambda$cold dark matter cosmology. We study several other cosmological
models beyond the flat $\Lambda$cold dark matter model and find that time-delay
lenses with spatially resolved kinematics can greatly improve the precision of
the cosmological parameters measured by cosmic microwave background data.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.01506 [pdf] - 1656087
Discovery of three strongly lensed quasars in the Sloan Digital Sky
Survey
Williams, Peter R.;
Agnello, Adriano;
Treu, Tommaso;
Abramson, Louis E.;
Anguita, Timo;
Apostolovski, Yordanka;
Chen, Geoff C. -F.;
Fassnacht, Christopher D.;
Hsueh, J. -W.;
Motta, Veronica;
Oldham, Lindsay;
Rojas, Karina;
Rus, Christian E.;
Shajib, Anowar J.;
Wang, Xin
Submitted: 2017-06-05
We present the discovery of 3 quasar lenses in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
(SDSS), selected using two novel photometry-based selection techniques. The
J0941+0518 system, with two point sources separated by 5.46" on either side of
a galaxy, has source and lens redshifts $z_s = 1.54$ and $z_l = 0.343$. The
AO-assisted images of J2211+1929 show two point sources separated by 1.04",
corresponding to the same quasar at $z_s = 1.07,$ besides the lens galaxy and
Einstein ring. Images of J2257+2349 show two point sources separated by 1.67"
on either side of an E/S0 galaxy. The extracted spectra show two images of the
same quasar at redshift $z_s = 2.10$. In total, the two selection techniques
identified 309 lens candidates, including 47 known lenses, and 6 previously
ruled out candidates. 55 of the remaining candidates were observed using NIRC2
and ESI at Keck Observatory, EFOSC2 at the ESO-NTT (La Silla), and SAM and the
Goodman spectrograph at SOAR. Of the candidates observed, 3 were confirmed as
lenses, 36 were ruled out, and 16 remain inconclusive. Taking into account that
we recovered known lenses, this gives us a success rate of at least 50/309
(16%). This initial campaign demonstrates the power of purely photometric
selection techniques in finding lensed quasars. Developing and refining these
techniques is essential for efficient identification of these rare lenses in
ongoing and future photometric surveys.