In the framework of the scotogenic model, which features radiative generation of neutrino masses, we explore two complementary scenarios for dark matter. Throughout the paper we chiefly focus on light dark matter which can be produced either via freeze-in through the decays of the new scalars, or from the decays of next-to-lightest fermionic particle in the spectrum, which is produced through freeze-out. The latter mechanism is required to be suppressed as it typically produces a hot dark matter component. Constraints from BBN, in combination with the former production mechanism, set the scale of dark matter to $\mathcal{O}$(keV). For this scenario we consider signatures at High Luminosity LHC and proposed future hadron and lepton colliders, namely FCC-hh and CLIC, focusing on searches with two leptons and missing energy as a final state. While a potential discovery at High Luminosity LHC is in tension with limits from cosmology, the situation greatly improves for future colliders. Toward the end of the paper we also discuss a regime in which dark matter is a WIMP with the abundance set primarily through coannihilation processes and we show that the signatures of such a scenario could appear in X-ray data.