Normalized to: Schlichting, H.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.01446 [pdf] - 2127569
Losing Oceans: The Effects of Composition on the Thermal Component of
Impact-driven Atmospheric Loss
Submitted: 2020-07-02
The formation of the solar system's terrestrial planets concluded with a
period of giant impacts. Previous works examining the volatile loss caused by
the impact shock in the moon-forming impact find atmospheric losses of at most
20-30 per cent and essentially no loss of oceans. However, giant impacts also
result in thermal heating, which can lead to significant atmospheric escape via
a Parker-type wind. Here we show that H2O and other high-mean molecular weight
outgassed species can be efficiently lost through this thermal wind if present
in a hydrogen-dominated atmosphere, substantially altering the final volatile
inventory of terrestrial planets. Specifically, we demonstrate that a giant
impact of a Mars-sized embryo with a proto-Earth can remove several Earth
oceans' worth of H2O, and other heavier volatile species, together with a
primordial hydrogen-dominated atmosphere. These results may offer an
explanation for the observed depletion in Earth's light noble gas budget and
for its depleted xenon inventory, which suggest that Earth underwent
significant atmospheric loss by the end of its accretion. Because planetary
embryos are massive enough to accrete primordial hydrogen envelopes and because
giant impacts are stochastic and occur concurrently with other early
atmospheric evolutionary processes, our results suggest a wide diversity in
terrestrial planet volatile budgets.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.03732 [pdf] - 2046224
Signatures of the Core-Powered Mass-Loss Mechanism in the Exoplanet
Population: Dependence on Stellar Properties and Observational Predictions
Submitted: 2019-07-08, last modified: 2020-01-09
Recent studies have shown that atmospheric mass-loss powered by the cooling
luminosity of a planet's core can explain the observed radius valley separating
super-Earths and sub-Neptunes, even without photoevaporation. In this work, we
investigate the dependence of this core-powered mass-loss mechanism on stellar
mass ($M_\ast$), metallicity ($Z_\ast$) and age ($\tau_\ast$). Without making
any changes to the underlying planet population, we find that the core-powered
mass-loss model yields a shift in the radius valley to larger planet sizes
around more massive stars with a slope given by $\text{d log}R_p/\text{d
log}M_\ast \simeq 0.35$, in agreement with observations. To first order, this
slope is driven by the dependence of core-powered mass-loss on the bolometric
luminosity of the host star and is given by $\text{d log}R_p/\text{d log}M_\ast
\simeq (3\alpha-2)/36 \simeq 0.33$, where $(L_\ast/L_\odot) =
(M_\ast/M_\odot)^\alpha$ is the stellar mass-luminosity relation and
$\alpha\simeq 4.6$ for the CKS dataset. We therefore find, in contrast to
photoevaporation models, no evidence for a linear correlation between planet
and stellar mass, but can't rule it out either. In addition, we show that the
location of the radius valley is, to first order, independent of stellar age
and metallicity. Since core-powered mass-loss proceeds over Gyr timescales, the
abundance of super-Earths relative to sub-Neptunes increases with age but
decreases with stellar metallicity. Finally, due the dependence of the
envelope's cooling timescale on metallicity, we find that the radii of
sub-Neptunes increase with metallicity and decrease with age with slopes given
by $\text{d log}R_p/\text{d log}Z_\ast \simeq 0.1$ and $\text{d log}R_p/\text{d
log}\tau_\ast \simeq -0.1$, respectively. We conclude with a series of
observational tests that can differentiate between core-powered mass-loss and
photoevaporation models.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.12989 [pdf] - 1987536
Oxygen fugacities of extrasolar rocks: Evidence for an Earth-like
geochemistry of exoplanets
Submitted: 2019-10-28
Oxygen fugacity is a measure of rock oxidation that influences planetary
structure and evolution. Most rocky bodies in the Solar System formed at oxygen
fugacities approximately five orders of magnitude higher than a hydrogen-rich
gas of solar composition. It is unclear whether this oxidation of rocks in the
Solar System is typical among other planetary systems. We exploit the elemental
abundances observed in six white dwarfs polluted by the accretion of rocky
bodies to determine the fraction of oxidized iron in those extrasolar rocky
bodies and therefore their oxygen fugacities. The results are consistent with
the oxygen fugacities of Earth, Mars, and typical asteroids in the Solar
System, suggesting that at least some rocky exoplanets are geophysically and
geochemically similar to Earth.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.05978 [pdf] - 1961040
Near-equilibrium isotope fractionation during planetesimal evaporation
Submitted: 2019-09-12
Silicon and Mg in differentiated rocky bodies exhibit heavy isotope
enrichments that have been attributed to evaporation of partially or entirely
molten planetesimals. We evaluate the mechanisms of planetesimal evaporation in
the early solar system and the conditions that controlled attendant isotope
fractionations. Energy balance at the surface of a body accreted within ~1 Myr
of CAI formation and heated from within by 26Al decay results in internal
temperatures exceeding the silicate solidus, producing a transient magma ocean
with a thin surface boundary layer of order < 1 meter that would be subject to
foundering. Bodies that are massive enough to form magma oceans by radioisotope
decay (ge 0.1%) can retain hot rock vapor even in the absence of ambient
nebular gas. We find that a steady-state rock vapor forms within minutes to
hours and results from a balance between rates of magma evaporation and
atmospheric escape. Vapor pressure buildup adjacent to the surfaces of the
evaporating magmas would have inevitably led to an approach to equilibrium
isotope partitioning between the vapor phase and the silicate melt. Numerical
simulations of this near-equilibrium evaporation process for a body with a
radius of ~ 700 km yield a steady-state far-field vapor pressure corresponding
to 95% saturation. Approaches to equilibrium isotope fractionation between
vapor and melt should have been the norm during planet formation due to the
formation of steady-state rock vapor atmospheres and/or the presence of
protostellar gas. We model the Si and Mg isotopic composition of bulk Earth and
show that the best fit is for a carbonaceous chondrite-like source material
with about 12% loss of Mg and 15% loss of Si resulting from near-equilibrium
evaporation into the solar protostellar disk of hydrogen gas on timescales of
10,000 to 100,000 years.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.04693 [pdf] - 1944189
Using Ice and Dust Lines to Constrain the Surface Densities of
Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2017-04-15, last modified: 2019-08-16
We present a novel method for determining the surface density of
protoplanetary disks through consideration of disk 'dust lines' which indicate
the observed disk radial scale at different observational wavelengths. This
method relies on the assumption that the processes of particle growth and drift
control the radial scale of the disk at late stages of disk evolution such that
the lifetime of the disk is equal to both the drift timescale and growth
timescale of the maximum particle size at a given dust line. We provide an
initial proof of concept of our model through an application to the disk TW Hya
and are able to estimate the disk dust-to-gas ratio, CO abundance, and
accretion rate in addition to the total disk surface density. We find that our
derived surface density profile and dust-to-gas ratio are consistent with the
lower limits found through measurements of HD gas. The CO ice line also depends
on surface density through grain adsorption rates and drift and we find that
our theoretical CO ice line estimates have clear observational analogues. We
further apply our model to a large parameter space of theoretical disks and
find three observational diagnostics that may be used to test its validity.
First we predict that the dust lines of disks other than TW Hya will be
consistent with the normalized CO surface density profile shape for those
disks. Second, surface density profiles that we derive from disk ice lines
should match those derived from disk dust lines. Finally, we predict that disk
dust and ice lines will scale oppositely, as a function of surface density,
across a large sample of disks.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.03252 [pdf] - 1905805
New Constraints From Dust Lines On The Surface Densities Of
Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2019-05-08
We present new determinations of disk surface density, independent of an
assumed dust opacity, for a sample of 7 bright, diverse protoplanetary disks
using measurements of disk dust lines. We develop a robust method for
determining the location of dust lines by modeling disk interferometric
visibilities at multiple wavelengths. The disks in our sample have newly
derived masses that are 9-27% of their host stellar mass, substantially larger
than the minimum mass solar nebula. All are stable to gravitational collapse
except for one which approaches the limit of Toomre-Q stability. Our mass
estimates are 2-15 times larger than estimates from integrated optically thin
dust emission. We derive depleted dust-to-gas ratios with typical values of
~$10^{-3}$ in the outer disk. Using coagulation models we derive dust surface
density profiles that are consistent with millimeter dust observations. In
these models, the disks formed with an initial dust mass that is a factor of
~10 greater than is presently observed. Of the three disks in our sample with
resolved CO line emission, the masses of HD 163296, AS 209, and TW Hya are
roughly 3, 115, and 40 times more massive than estimates from CO respectively.
This range indicates that CO depletion is not uniform across different disks
and that dust is a more robust tracer of total disk mass. Our method of
determining surface density using dust lines is robust even if particles form
as aggregates and is useful even in the presence of dust substructure caused by
pressure traps. The low Toomre-Q values observed in this sample indicate that
at least some disks do not accrete efficiently.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.03202 [pdf] - 1888813
Sculpting the Valley in the Radius Distribution of Small Exoplanets as a
by-product of Planet Formation: The Core-Powered Mass-Loss Mechanism
Submitted: 2018-11-07, last modified: 2019-04-18
Recent observations revealed a bimodal radius distribution of small,
short-period exoplanets with a paucity in their occurrence, a radius `valley',
around $1.5-2.0$ $R_\oplus$. In this work, we investigate the effect of a
planet's own cooling luminosity on its thermal evolution and atmospheric
mass-loss (core-powered mass-loss) and determine its observational consequences
for the radius distribution of small, close-in exoplanets. Using simple
analytical descriptions and numerical simulations, we demonstrate that
planetary evolution based on the core-powered mass-loss mechanism alone (i.e.,
without any photoevaporation) can produce the observed valley in the radius
distribution. Our results match the valley's location, shape and slope in
planet radius-orbital period parameter space, and the relative magnitudes of
the planet occurrence rate above and below the valley. We find that the slope
of the valley is, to first order, dictated by the atmospheric mass-loss
timescale at the Bondi radius and given by $\text{d log} R_p/ \text{d log} P
\simeq 1/(3(1-\beta))$ which evaluates to $ -0.11$ for $ \beta \simeq 4$, where
$M_c/M_\oplus = (R_c/R_{\oplus})^{\beta} (\rho_{c*}/\rho_{\oplus})^{\beta/3}$
is the mass-radius relation of the core. This choice for $\beta$ yields good
agreement with observations and attests to the significance of internal
compression for massive planetary cores. We further find that the location of
the valley scales as $\rho_{c*}^{-4/9}$ and that the observed planet population
must have predominantly rocky cores with typical water-ice fractions of less
than $\sim 20\%$. Furthermore, we show that the relative magnitude of the
planet occurrence rate above and below the valley is sensitive to the details
of the planet-mass distribution but that the location of the valley is not.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.11778 [pdf] - 1868024
Atmospheric Mass Loss from High Velocity Giant Impacts
Submitted: 2018-11-28, last modified: 2019-04-16
Using moving mesh hydrodynamic simulations, we determine the shock
propagation and resulting ground velocities for a planet hit by a high velocity
impactor. We use our results to determine the atmospheric mass loss caused by
the resulting ground motion due to the impact shock wave. We find that there
are two distinct shock propagation regimes: In the limit in which the impactor
is significantly smaller than the target ($R_i<< R_t$), the solutions are
self-similar and the shock velocity at a fixed point on the target scale as
$m_i^{2/3}$, where $m_i$ is the mass of the impactor. In addition, the ground
velocities follow a universal profile given by
$v_g/v_i=(14.2x^2-25.3x+11.3)/(x^2-2.5x+1.9) +2\ln{R_i/R_t}$, where
$x=\sin\left(\theta/2\right)$, $\theta$ is the latitude on the target measured
from the impact site, and $v_g$ and $v_i$ are the ground velocity and impact
velocity, respectively. In contrast, in the limit in which the impactor is
comparable to the size of the target ($R_i \sim R_t$), we find that shock
velocities decline with the mass of the impactor significantly more weakly than
$m_i^{2/3}$. We use the resulting surface velocity profiles to calculate the
atmospheric mass loss for a large range of impactor masses and impact
velocities and apply them to the Kepler-36 system and the Moon forming impact.
Finally, we present and generalise our results in terms of the $v_g/v_i$ and
the impactor to target size ratio ($R_i/R_t$) such that they can easily be
applied to other collision scenarios.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.00027 [pdf] - 1871561
The Mass of Stirring Bodies in the AU Mic Debris Disk Inferred from
Resolved Vertical Structure
Daley, Cail;
Hughes, A. Meredith;
Carter, Evan S.;
Flaherty, Kevin;
Lambros, Zachary;
Pan, Margaret;
Schlichting, Hilke;
Chiang, Eugene;
Wyatt, Mark;
Wilner, David;
Andrews, Sean;
Carpenter, John
Submitted: 2019-03-29, last modified: 2019-04-08
The vertical distribution of dust in debris disks is sensitive to the number
and size of large planetesimals dynamically stirring the disk, and is therefore
well-suited for constraining the prevalence of otherwise unobservable Uranus
and Neptune analogs. Information regarding stirring bodies has previously been
inferred from infrared and optical observations of debris disk vertical
structure, but theoretical works predict that the small particles traced by
short-wavelength observations will be `puffed up' by radiation pressure,
yielding only upper limits. The large grains that dominate the disk emission at
millimeter wavelengths are much less sensitive to the effects of stellar
radiation or stellar winds, and therefore trace the underlying mass
distribution more directly. Here we present ALMA 1.3 mm dust continuum
observations of the debris disk around the nearby M star AU Mic. The 3 au
spatial resolution of the observations, combined with the favorable edge-on
geometry of the system, allows us to measure the vertical thickness of the
disk. We report a scale height-to-radius aspect ratio of $h =
0.031_{-0.004}^{+0.005}$ between radii of $\sim 23$ au and $\sim 41$ au.
Comparing this aspect ratio to a theoretical model of size-dependent velocity
distributions in the collisional cascade, we find that the perturbing bodies
embedded in the local disk must be larger than about 400 km, and the largest
perturbing body must be smaller than roughly 1.8 M$_\odot$. These measurements
rule out the presence of a gas giant or Neptune analog near the $\sim 40$ au
outer edge of the debris ring, but are suggestive of large planetesimals or an
Earth-sized planet stirring the dust distribution.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.05258 [pdf] - 1848648
The Super-Earth Opportunity - Search for Habitable Exoplanets in the
2020s
Hu, Renyu;
Beichman, Charles A.;
Brain, David;
Chen, Pin;
Damiano, Mario;
Dawson, Rebekah;
Friedson, A. James;
Hasagawa, Yasuhiro;
Howard, Andrew;
Johnson, Robert;
Kataria, Tiffany;
Kidd, Richard;
Kite, Edwin;
Knutson, Heather;
Lyra, Wladimir;
Mischna, Michael;
Planavsky, Noah;
Reinhard, Chris;
Schlichting, Hilke;
Seager, Sara;
Sotin, Christophe;
Swain, Mark;
Turner, Neal;
West, Robert;
Yung, Yuk;
Zellem, Robert
Submitted: 2019-03-12
The recent discovery of a staggering diversity of planets beyond the Solar
System has brought with it a greatly expanded search space for habitable
worlds. The Kepler exoplanet survey has revealed that most planets in our
interstellar neighborhood are larger than Earth and smaller than Neptune.
Collectively termed super-Earths and mini-Neptunes, some of these planets may
have the conditions to support liquid water oceans, and thus Earth-like
biology, despite differing in many ways from our own planet. In addition to
their quantitative abundance, super-Earths are relatively large and are thus
more easily detected than true Earth twins. As a result, super-Earths represent
a uniquely powerful opportunity to discover and explore a panoply of
fascinating and potentially habitable planets in 2020 - 2030 and beyond.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.06810 [pdf] - 1855617
Atmospheric mass loss due to giant impacts: the importance of the
thermal component for hydrogen-helium envelopes
Submitted: 2018-09-18
Systems of close-in super-Earths display striking diversity in planetary bulk
density and composition. Giant impacts are expected to play a role in the
formation of many of these worlds. Previous works, focused on the mechanical
shock caused by a giant impact, have shown that these impacts can eject large
fractions of the planetary envelope, offering a partial explanation for the
observed spread in exoplanet compositions. Here, we examine the thermal
consequences of giant impacts, and show that the atmospheric loss caused by
these effects can significantly exceed that caused by mechanical shocks for
hydrogen-helium (H/He) envelopes. When a giant impact occurs, part of the
impact energy is converted into thermal energy, heating the rocky core and the
envelope. We find that the ensuing thermal expansion of the envelope can lead
to a period of sustained, rapid mass loss through a Parker wind, resulting in
the partial or complete erosion of the H/He envelope. The fraction of the
envelope lost depends on the planet's orbital distance from its host star and
its initial thermal state, and hence age. Planets closer to their host stars
are more susceptible to thermal atmospheric loss triggered by impacts than ones
on wider orbits. Similarly, younger planets, with rocky cores which are still
hot and molten from formation, suffer greater atmospheric loss. This is
especially interesting because giant impacts are expected to occur
$10{-}100~\mathrm{Myr}$ after formation. For planets where the thermal energy
of the core is much greater than the envelope energy, the impactor mass
required for significant atmospheric removal is $M_\mathrm{imp} / M_p \sim \mu
/ \mu_c \sim 0.1$, approximately the ratio of the heat capacities of the
envelope and core. When the envelope energy dominates the total energy budget,
complete loss can occur when the impactor mass is comparable to the envelope
mass.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1708.01621 [pdf] - 1644714
Core-powered mass loss and the radius distribution of small exoplanets
Submitted: 2017-08-04, last modified: 2018-03-06
Recent observations identify a valley in the radius distribution of small
exoplanets, with planets in the range $1.5-2.0\,{\rm R}_{\oplus}$ significantly
less common than somewhat smaller or larger planets. This valley may suggest a
bimodal population of rocky planets that are either engulfed by massive gas
envelopes that significantly enlarge their radius, or do not have detectable
atmospheres at all. One explanation of such a bimodal distribution is
atmospheric erosion by high-energy stellar photons. We investigate an
alternative mechanism: the luminosity of the cooling rocky core, which can
completely erode light envelopes while preserving heavy ones, produces a
deficit of intermediate sized planets. We evolve planetary populations that are
derived from observations using a simple analytical prescription, accounting
self-consistently for envelope accretion, cooling and mass loss, and
demonstrate that core-powered mass loss naturally reproduces the observed
radius distribution, regardless of the high-energy incident flux. Observations
of planets around different stellar types may distinguish between
photoevaporation, which is powered by the high-energy tail of the stellar
radiation, and core-powered mass loss, which depends on the bolometric flux
through the planet's equilibrium temperature that sets both its cooling and
mass-loss rates.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.03090 [pdf] - 1732581
Formation of Super-Earths
Submitted: 2018-02-08
Super-Earths are the most abundant planets known to date and are
characterized by having sizes between that of Earth and Neptune, typical
orbital periods of less than 100 days and gaseous envelopes that are often
massive enough to significantly contribute to the planet's overall radius.
Furthermore, super-Earths regularly appear in tightly-packed multiple-planet
systems, but resonant configurations in such systems are rare. This chapters
summarizes current super-Earth formation theories. It starts from the formation
of rocky cores and subsequent accretion of gaseous envelopes. We follow the
thermal evolution of newly formed super-Earths and discuss their atmospheric
mass loss due to disk dispersal, photoevaporation, core-cooling and collisions.
We conclude with a comparison of observations and theoretical predictions,
highlighting that even super-Earths that appear as barren rocky cores today
likely formed with primordial hydrogen and helium envelopes and discuss some
paths forward for the future.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1708.08990 [pdf] - 1587659
Determining Exoplanetary Oblateness Using Transit Depth Variations
Submitted: 2017-08-29
The measurement of an exoplanet's oblateness and obliquity provides insights
into the planet's internal structure and formation history. Previous work using
small differences in the shape of the transit light curve has been moderately
successful, but was hampered by the small signal and extreme photometric
precision required. The measurement of changes in transit depth, caused by the
spin precession of an oblate planet, was proposed as an alternative method.
Here, we present the first attempt to measure these changes. Using Kepler
photometry, we examined the brown dwarf Kepler-39b and the warm Saturn
Kepler-427b. We could not reliably constrain the oblateness of Kepler-39b. We
find transit depth variations for Kepler-427b at $90.1\%$ significance
($1.65\sigma$) consistent with a precession period of $P_\mathrm{prec} =
5.45^{+0.46}_{-0.37}~\mathrm{years}$ and an oblateness,
$f~=~0.19^{+0.32}_{-0.16}$. This oblateness is comparable to Solar System gas
giants, and would raise questions about the dynamics and tidal synchronization
of Kepler-427b.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.00724 [pdf] - 1571154
Constraints on the Growth and Spin of the Supermassive Black Hole in M32
From High Cadence Visible Light Observations
Submitted: 2017-05-01
We present 1-second cadence observations of M32 (NGC221) with the CHIMERA
instrument at the Hale 200-inch telescope of the Palomar Observatory. Using
field stars as a baseline for relative photometry, we are able to construct a
light curve of the nucleus in the g-prime and r-prime band with 1sigma=36
milli-mag photometric stability. We derive a temporal power spectrum for the
nucleus and find no evidence for a time-variable signal above the noise as
would be expected if the nuclear black hole were accreting gas. Thus, we are
unable to constrain the spin of the black hole although future work will use
this powerful instrument to target more actively accreting black holes. Given
the black hole mass of (2.5+/-0.5)*10^6 Msun inferred from stellar kinematics,
the absence of a contribution from a nuclear time-variable signal places an
upper limit on the accretion rate which is 4.6*10^{-8} of the Eddington rate, a
factor of two more stringent than past upper limits from HST. The low mass of
the black hole despite the high stellar density suggests that the gas liberated
by stellar interactions was primarily at early cosmic times when the low-mass
black hole had a small Eddington luminosity. This is at least partly driven by
a top-heavy stellar initial mass function at early cosmic times which is an
efficient producer of stellar mass black holes. The implication is that
supermassive black holes likely arise from seeds formed through the coalescence
of 3-100 Msun mass black holes that then accrete gas produced through stellar
interaction processes.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.07836 [pdf] - 1570359
Avoiding resonance capture in multi-planet extrasolar systems
Submitted: 2017-04-25, last modified: 2017-04-28
A commonly noted feature of the population of multi-planet extrasolar systems
is the rarity of planet pairs in low-order mean-motion resonances. We revisit
the physics of resonance capture via convergent disk-driven migration. We point
out that for planet spacings typical of stable configurations for Kepler
systems, the planets can routinely maintain a small but nonzero eccentricity
due to gravitational perturbations from their neighbors. Together with the
upper limit on the migration rate needed for capture, the finite eccentricity
can make resonance capture difficult or impossible in Sun-like systems for
planets smaller than ~Neptune-sized. This mass limit on efficient capture is
broadly consistent with observed exoplanet pairs that have mass determinations:
of pairs with the heavier planet exterior to the lighter planet -- which would
have been undergoing convergent migration in their disks -- those in or nearly
in resonance are much more likely to have total mass greater than two Neptune
masses than to have smaller masses. The agreement suggests that the observed
paucity of resonant pairs around sun-like stars may simply arise from a small
resonance capture probability for lower-mass planets. Planet pairs that thereby
avoid resonance capture are much less likely to collide in an eventual close
approach than to simply migrate past one another to become a divergently
migrating pair with the lighter planet exterior. For systems around M stars we
expect resonant pairs to be much more common, since there the minimum mass
threshhold for efficient capture is about an Earth mass.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1412.4440 [pdf] - 1513472
The Formation of Super-Earths and Mini-Neptunes with Giant Impacts
Submitted: 2014-12-14, last modified: 2016-11-13
The majority of discovered exoplanetary systems harbour a new class of
planets, bodies typically several times more massive than Earth but orbiting
their host stars well inside the orbit of Mercury. The origin of these close-in
super-Earths and mini-Neptunes is a major unanswered question in planet
formation. Unlike Earth, whose atmosphere contains $<10^{-6}$ its total mass, a
large fraction of close-in planets have significant gaseous envelopes,
containing $1 -10\%$ or more of their total mass. It has been proposed that
these close-in planets formed in situ either by delivery of $50-100M_{\oplus}$
of rocky material to the inner disc, or in a disc enhanced relative to the
MMSN. In both cases, final assembly of the planets occurs by giant impacts
(GIs). Here we test the viability of these scenarios. We show that atmospheres
accreted by isolation masses are small ($10^{-3}-10^{-2}$ the core mass) and
that atmospheric mass-loss during GIs is significant, with typical post-GI
atmospheres that are $8 \times 10^{-4}$ the core mass. Such values are
consistent with terrestrial planet atmospheres but more than an order of
magnitude below atmospheric masses of $1-10\%$ inferred for many close-in
exoplanets. In the most optimistic scenario with no core luminosity, post-GI
envelope accretion from a depleted gas disc yields atmospheric masses that are
several per cent the core mass. If the gravitational potential energy due to
the last mass doubling of the planet by GIs is released over the disc
dissipation time-scale as core luminosity, then envelope masses are reduced by
about an order of magnitude. Finally we show that radial drift time-scales due
to gas drag for many isolation masses are shorter than typical disc lifetimes.
Given these challenges, we conclude that most observed close-in planets with
envelopes larger than several per cent likely formed at larger separations from
their host stars.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.07925 [pdf] - 1432932
Super-Earth Atmospheres: Self-Consistent Gas Accretion and Retention
Submitted: 2015-12-24, last modified: 2016-04-16
Some recently discovered short-period Earth to Neptune sized exoplanets
(super Earths) have low observed mean densities which can only be explained by
voluminous gaseous atmospheres. Here, we study the conditions allowing the
accretion and retention of such atmospheres. We self-consistently couple the
nebular gas accretion onto rocky cores and the subsequent evolution of gas
envelopes following the dispersal of the protoplanetary disk. Specifically, we
address mass-loss due to both photo-evaporation and cooling of the planet. We
find that planets shed their outer layers (dozens of percents in mass)
following the disk's dispersal (even without photo-evaporation), and their
atmospheres shrink in a few Myr to a thickness comparable to the radius of the
underlying rocky core. At this stage, atmospheres containing less particles
than the core (equivalently, lighter than a few % of the planet's mass) can be
blown away by heat coming from the cooling core, while heavier atmospheres cool
and contract on a timescale of Gyr at most. By relating the mass-loss timescale
to the accretion time, we analytically identify a Goldilocks region in the
mass-temperature plane in which low-density super Earths can be found: planets
have to be massive and cold enough to accrete and retain their atmospheres,
while not too massive or cold, such that they do not enter runaway accretion
and become gas giants (Jupiters). We compare our results to the observed
super-Earth population and find that low-density planets are indeed
concentrated in the theoretically allowed region. Our analytical and intuitive
model can be used to investigate possible super-Earth formation scenarios.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1601.03104 [pdf] - 1374262
CHIMERA: a wide-field, multi-color, high-speed photometer at the prime
focus of the Hale telescope
Harding, Leon K.;
Hallinan, Gregg;
Milburn, Jennifer;
Gardner, Paul;
Konidaris, Nick;
Singh, Navtej;
Shao, Michael;
Sandhu, Jagmit;
Kyne, Gillian;
Schlichting, Hilke E.
Submitted: 2016-01-12
The Caltech HIgh-speed Multi-color camERA (CHIMERA) is a new instrument that
has been developed for use at the prime focus of the Hale 200-inch telescope.
Simultaneous optical imaging in two bands is enabled by a dichroic beam
splitter centered at 567 nm, with Sloan u' and g' bands available on the blue
arm and Sloan r', i' and z_s' bands available on the red arm. Additional
narrow-band filters will also become available as required. An Electron
Multiplying CCD (EMCCD) detector is employed for both optical channels, each
capable of simultaneously delivering sub-electron effective read noise under
multiplication gain and frame rates of up to 26 fps full frame (several 1000
fps windowed), over a fully corrected 5 x 5 arcmin field of view. CHIMERA was
primarily developed to enable the characterization of the size distribution of
sub-km Kuiper Belt Objects via stellar occultation, a science case that
motivates the frame-rate, the simultaneous multi-color imaging and the wide
field of view of the instrument. In addition, it also has unique capability in
the detection of faint near-Earth asteroids and will be used for the monitoring
of short duration transient and periodic sources, particularly those discovered
by the intermediate Palomar Transient Factory (iPTF), and the upcoming Zwicky
Transient Facility (ZTF).
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1510.02090 [pdf] - 1351520
Stealing the Gas: Giant Impacts and the Large Diversity in Exoplanet
Densities
Submitted: 2015-10-07, last modified: 2015-12-10
Although current sensitivity limits are such that true Solar System analogs
remain challenging to detect, numerous planetary systems have been discovered
that are very different from our own Solar System. The majority of systems
harbor a new class of planets, bodies that are typically several times more
massive than the Earth but that orbit their host stars well inside the orbit of
Mercury. These planets frequently show evidence for large Hydrogen and Helium
envelopes containing several percent of the planet's mass and display a large
diversity in mean densities. Here we show that this wide range can be achieved
by one or two late giant impacts, which are frequently needed to achieve
long-term orbital stability in multiple planet systems once the gas disk has
disappeared. We demonstrate using hydrodynamical simulations that a single
collision between similarly sized exoplanets can easily reduce the
envelope-to-core-mass ratio by a factor of two and show that this leads to a
corresponding increase in the observed mean density by factors of 2-3. In
addition we investigate how envelope-mass-loss depends on envelope mass, planet
radius, semi-major axis, and the mass distribution inside the envelope. We
propose that a small number of giant impacts may be responsible for the large
observed spread in mean densities, especially for multiple-planet systems
containing planets with very different densities and which have not been
significantly sculpted by photo evaporation.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.01083 [pdf] - 1311278
A Search for Ringed Exoplanets using Kepler Photometry
Submitted: 2015-11-03, last modified: 2015-11-16
Models are developed to simulate lightcurves of stars dimmed by transiting
exoplanets with and without rings. These models are then applied to
\textit{Kepler} photometry to search for planetary rings in a sample of 21
exoplanets, mostly hot Jupiters, chosen to offer the best observational
opportunity for discovering potential rings. We also examine what kinds of
rings might be expected for these planets, in terms of both size and
orientation, based on arguments involving the host planet's equilibrium
temperature, its likely obliquities, and the formation and stability of
possible ring systems. Finding no evidence for rings, for each of the 21
studied planets it is determined on an observational basis which potential
rings can be rejected out of a representative set of fiducial rings, varying in
both size and orientation. For 12 of the 21 planets, we determined that
Saturn-like rings could be ruled out for at least certain orientations.
Additionally, the detectability of rings is studied, and it is found that
ringed planets with small obliquities (roughly $5^{\circ}-10^{\circ}$) can
yield large signals, which is encouraging for future work, since such small
obliquities are expected for hot Jupiters.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.1060 [pdf] - 1222398
Formation of close in Super-Earths \& Mini-Neptunes: Required Disk
Masses \& Their Implications
Submitted: 2014-10-04
Recent observations by the {\it Kepler} space telescope have led to the
discovery of more than 4000 exoplanet candidates consisting of many systems
with Earth- to Neptune-sized objects that reside well inside the orbit of
Mercury, around their respective host stars. How and where these close-in
planets formed is one of the major unanswered questions in planet formation.
Here we calculate the required disk masses for {\it in situ} formation of the
{\it Kepler} planets. We find that, if close-in planets formed as {\it
isolation masses}, then standard gas-to-dust ratios yield corresponding gas
disks that are gravitationally unstable for a significant fraction of systems,
ruling out such a scenario. We show that the maximum width of a planet's
accretion region in the absence of any migration is $2 v_{esc}/\Omega$, where
$v_{esc}$ is the escape velocity of the planet and $\Omega$ the Keplerian
frequency and use it to calculate the required disk masses for {\it in situ}
formation with giant impacts. Even with giant impacts, formation without
migration requires disk surface densities in solids at semi-major axes less
than 0.1~AU of $10^3-10^5 \rm{~g~cm^{-2}}$ implying typical enhancements above
the minimum-mass solar nebular (MMSN) by at least a factor of 20. Corresponding
gas disks are below, but not far from, the gravitational stability limit. In
contrast, formation beyond a few AU is consistent with MMSN disk masses. This
suggests that migration of either solids or fully assembled planets is likely
to have played a major role in the formation of close-in super-Earths and
mini-Neptunes.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1406.6435 [pdf] - 1215205
Atmospheric Mass Loss During Planet Formation: The Importance of
Planetesimal Impacts
Submitted: 2014-06-24, last modified: 2014-08-26
We quantify the atmospheric mass loss during planet formation by examining
the contributions to atmospheric loss from both giant impacts and planetesimal
accretion. Giant impacts cause global motion of the ground. Using analytic
self-similar solutions and full numerical integrations we find (for isothermal
atmospheres with adiabatic index ($\gamma=5/3$) that the local atmospheric mass
loss fraction for ground velocities $v_g < 0.25 v_{esc}$ is given by
$\chi_{loss}=(1.71 v_g/v_{esc})^{4.9}$, where $v_{esc}$ is the escape velocity
from the target. Yet, the global atmospheric mass loss is a weaker function of
the impactor velocity $v_{Imp}$ and mass $m_{Imp}$ and given by $X_{loss} ~
0.4x+1.4x^2-0.8x^3$ (isothermal atmosphere) and $X_{loss} ~ 0.4x+1.8x^2-1.2x^3$
(adiabatic atmosphere), where $x=(v_{Imp}m/v_{esc}M)$. Atmospheric mass loss
due to planetesimal impacts proceeds in two different regimes: 1) Large enough
impactors $m > \sqrt{2} \rho_0 (\pi h R)^{3/2}$ (25~km for the current Earth),
are able to eject all the atmosphere above the tangent plane of the impact
site, which is $h/2R$ of the whole atmosphere, where $h$, $R$ and $\rho_0$ are
the atmospheric scale height, radius of the target, and its atmospheric density
at the ground. 2) Smaller impactors, but above $m>4 \pi \rho_0 h^3$ (1~km for
the current Earth) are only able to eject a fraction of the atmospheric mass
above the tangent plane. We find that the most efficient impactors (per unit
impactor mass) for atmospheric loss are planetesimals just above that lower
limit and that the current atmosphere of the Earth could have resulted from an
equilibrium between atmospheric erosion and volatile delivery to the atmosphere
from planetesimals. We conclude that planetesimal impacts are likely to have
played a major role in atmospheric mass loss over the formation history of the
terrestrial planets. (Abridged)
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1308.4688 [pdf] - 1178701
Overstable Librations can account for the Paucity of Mean Motion
Resonances among Exoplanet Pairs
Submitted: 2013-08-21, last modified: 2013-11-21
We assess the multi-planet systems discovered by the Kepler satellite in
terms of current ideas about orbital migration and eccentricity damping due to
planet-disk interactions. Our primary focus is on mean motion resonances. Only
a few percent of planet pairs are in close proximity to a resonance. However,
predicted migration rates (parameterized by $\tau_n=n/{|\dot n|}$) imply that
during convergent migration most planets would have been captured into first
order resonances. Eccentricity damping (parameterized by $\tau_e=e/{|\dot e|}$)
offers a plausible resolution. Estimates suggest $\tau_e/\tau_n\sim (h/a)^2\sim
10^{-2}$, where $h/a$ is the ratio of disk thickness to radius. Together,
eccentricity damping and orbital migration give rise to an equilibrium
eccentricity, $e_{eq}\sim(\tau_e/\tau_n)^{1/2}$. Capture is permanent provided
$e_{eq}\lesssim \mu^{1/3}$, where $\mu$ denotes the planet to star mass ratio.
But for $e_{eq}\gtrsim \mu^{1/3}$, capture is only temporary because librations
around equilibrium are overstable and lead to passage through resonance on
timescale $\tau_e$. Most Kepler planet pairs have $e_{eq}>\mu^{1/3}$. Since
$\tau_n>> \tau_e$ is the timescale for migration between neighboring
resonances, only a modest percentage of pairs end up trapped in resonances
after the disk disappears. Planet pairs close to a mean motion resonance
typically exhibit period ratios 1-2% larger than those for exact resonance. The
direction of this shift undoubtedly reflects the same asymmetry that requires
convergent migration for resonance capture. Permanent resonance capture at
these separations from exact resonance would demand $\mu
(\tau_n/\tau_e)^{1/2}\gtrsim 0.01$, a value that estimates of $\mu$ from
transit data and $(\tau_e/\tau_n)^{1/2}$ from theory are insufficient to match.
Plausible alternatives involve eccentricity damping during or after disk
dispersal. (Abridged)
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.4325 [pdf] - 1172130
Dynamical and collisional constraints on a stochastic late veneer on the
terrestrial planets
Submitted: 2013-06-18
Given their tendency to be incorporated into the core during differentiation,
the highly-siderophile elements (HSEs) in Earth's mantle are thought to have
been accreted as a `late veneer' after the end of the giant impact phase.
Bottke et al (2010) proposed that the large Earth-to-Moon HSE abundance ratio
can be explained if the late veneer was characterized by large (D =
1000-4000km) impactors. Here we simulate the evolution of the terrestrial
planets during a stochastic late veneer phase from the end of accretion until
the start of the late heavy bombardment ~500 Myr later. We show that a late
veneer population of 0.05 Earth masses dominated by large (D > 1000km) bodies
naturally delivers a ~0.01 Earth mass veneer to Earth, consistent with
constraints. The eccentricities and inclinations of the terrestrial planets are
excited by close encounters with the largest late veneer bodies. We find the
best agreement with their post-veneer orbits if either a) the terrestrial
planets' pre-veneer angular momentum deficit AMD_0 was less than half of the
current one AMD_now, or b) AMD_0 <= AMD_now and the veneer was limited to
smaller (D_max <= 2000km) bodies. Veneer impacts on Venus, Earth and Mars were
mostly accretionary but on Mercury and the Moon they were mostly erosive. In
~20% of simulations an energetic impact occurred that could have removed >25%
of Mercury's mass, thereby increasing its iron mass fraction. We show that, due
to the erosive nature of larger impacts, the Moon cannot accrete any material
from objects larger than 500-1000km. The large Earth-to-Moon HSE abundance
ratio is explained if the late veneer included large impactors (D >=
500-1000km) regardless of their size distribution, as long as most of Earth's
veneer came from large bodies. The spin angular momenta imparted by stochastic
late veneer impacts was far in excess of the current ones for Mercury and
Venus.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1301.7433 [pdf] - 1159391
Initial Planetesimal Sizes and the Size Distribution of Small Kuiper
Belt Objects
Submitted: 2013-01-30, last modified: 2013-04-01
We show, by comparing observations with theoretical models, that the observed
Kuiper Belt size distribution is well matched by coagulation models, which
start from an initial planetesimal population with radii of about 1km, and
subsequent collisional evolution. We find that the observed size distribution
for R > 30km has not been modified by collisional evolution over the age of the
solar system, and that the size distribution below R ~ 30km has been modified
by collisions and that its slope is well matched by collisional evolution
models that use published strength laws. We investigate in detail the resulting
size distribution of bodies ranging from 0.01km to 30km and find that its slope
changes several times as a function of radius before approaching the expected
value for an equilibrium collisional cascade of material strength dominated
bodies for R < 0.1km. Compared to a single power law size distribution that
would span the whole range from 0.01km to 30km, we find a strong deficit of
bodies around R ~10km and a strong excess of bodies around 2km. This deficit
and excess are caused by an excess mass in small planetesimals in the km size
range that was left over from the runaway growth phase and that leaves a
signature in the size distribution that is not erased after 4.5 Gyrs of
collisional evolution. Observations of the small KBO size distribution can
therefore test if large KBOs grew as a result of runaway growth and constrain
the initial planetesimal sizes. We find that results from recent KBO
occultation surveys and the observed KBO size distribution can be best matched
by an initial planetesimal population that contained about equal mass per
logarithmic mass bin in bodies ranging from 0.4km to 4km in radius. In
addition, we find that we cannot match the observed KBO size distribution if
most of the planetesimal mass was contained in bodies that were 10km in radius
or larger.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1210.8155 [pdf] - 1152596
Measuring the Abundance of sub-kilometer sized Kuiper Belt Objects using
Stellar Occultations
Submitted: 2012-10-30
We present here the analysis of about 19,500 new star hours of low ecliptic
latitude observations (|b| < 20 deg) obtained by the Hubble Space Telescope's
FGS over a time span of more than nine years; which is an addition to the
12,000 star hours previously analyzed by Schlichting et al. (2009). Our search
for stellar occultations by small Kuiper belt objects (KBOs) yielded one new
candidate event corresponding to a body with a 530 +/-70m radius at a distance
of about 40AU. Using bootstrap simulations, we estimate a probability of approx
5%, that this event is due to random statistical fluctuations within the new
data set. Combining this new event with the single KBO occultation reported by
Schlichting et al. (2009) we arrive at the following results: 1) The ecliptic
latitudes of 6.6 deg and 14.4 deg of the two events are consistent with the
observed inclination distribution of larger, 100km-sized KBOs. 2) Assuming that
small, sub-km sized KBOs have the same ecliptic latitude distribution as their
larger counterparts, we find an ecliptic surface density of KBOs with radii
larger than 250m of N(r>250m) = 1.1^{+1.5}_{-0.7} x 10^7 deg^{-2}; if sub-km
sized KBOs have instead a uniform ecliptic latitude distribution for -20 deg <
b< 20 deg then N(r>250m) = 4.4^{+5.8}_{-2.8} x 10^6 deg^{-2}. This is the best
measurement of the surface density of sub-km sized KBOs to date. 3) Assuming
the KBO size distribution can be well described by a single power law given by
N(>r) \propto r^{1-q}, where N(>r) is the number of KBOs with radii greater
than r, and q is the power law index, we find q=3.8+/-0.2 for a KBO ecliptic
latitude distribution that follows the observed distribution for larger, 100-km
sized KBOs. 4) Regardless of the exact power law, our results suggest that
small KBOs are numerous enough to satisfy the required supply rate for the
Jupiter family comets. (Abridged)
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1202.6372 [pdf] - 1116965
The Last Stages of Terrestrial Planet Formation: Dynamical Friction and
the Late Veneer
Submitted: 2012-02-28, last modified: 2012-04-22
The final stage of terrestrial planet formation consists of the cleanup of
residual planetesimals after the giant impact phase. Dynamically, a residual
planetesimal population is needed to damp the high eccentricities of the
terrestrial planets after the giant impact stage. Geochemically, highly
siderophile element (HSE) abundance patterns inferred for the terrestrial
planets and the Moon suggest that a total of about 0.01 M_Earth of chondritic
material was delivered as `late veneer' by planetesimals to the terrestrial
planets after the end of giant impacts. Here we combine these two independent
lines of evidence for a leftover population of planetesimals and show that: 1)
A residual planetesimal population containing 0.01 M_Earth is able to damp the
eccentricities of the terrestrial planets after giant impacts to their observed
values. 2) At the same time, this planetesimal population can account for the
observed relative amounts of late veneer added to the Earth, Moon and Mars
provided that the majority of the late veneer was delivered by small
planetesimals with radii <10m. These small planetesimal sizes are required to
ensure efficient damping of the planetesimal's velocity dispersion by mutual
collisions, which in turn ensures that the planets' accretion cross sections
are significantly enhanced by gravitational focusing above their geometric
values. Specifically we find, in the limit that the relative velocity between
the terrestrial planets and the planetesimals is significantly less than the
terrestrial planets' escape velocities, that gravitational focusing yields an
accretion ratio Earth/Mars~17, which agrees well with the accretion ratio
inferred from HSEs of 12-23. For the Earth-Moon system, we find an accretion
ratio of ~200, which is consistent with estimates of 150-700 derived from HSE
abundances that include the lunar crust as well as mantle component. (Abridged)
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.0667 [pdf] - 1091375
Self-consistent size and velocity distributions of collisional cascades
Submitted: 2011-11-02
The standard theoretical treatment of collisional cascades derives a
steady-state size distribution assuming a single constant velocity dispersion
for all bodies regardless of size. Here we relax this assumption and solve
self-consistently for the bodies' steady-state size and size-dependent velocity
distributions. Specifically, we account for viscous stirring, dynamical
friction, and collisional damping of the bodies' random velocities in addition
to the mass conservation requirement typically applied to find the size
distribution in a steady-state cascade. The resulting size distributions are
significantly steeper than those derived without velocity evolution. For
example, accounting self-consistently for the velocities can change the
standard q=3.5 power-law index of the Dohnanyi (1969) differential size
spectrum to an index as large as q=4. Similarly, for bodies held together by
their own gravity, the corresponding power-law index range 2.88<q<3.14 of Pan &
Sari (2005) can steepen to values as large as q=3.26. Our velocity results
allow quantitative predictions of the bodies' scale heights as a function of
size. Together with our predictions, observations of the scale heights for
different sized bodies for the Kuiper belt, the asteroid belt, and extrasolar
debris disks may constrain the mass and number of large bodies stirring the
cascade as well as the colliding bodies' internal strengths.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1104.3863 [pdf] - 1053479
Warm Saturns: On the Nature of Rings around Extrasolar Planets that
Reside Inside the Ice Line
Submitted: 2011-04-19
We discuss the nature of rings that may exist around extrasolar planets.
Taking the general properties of rings around the gas giants in the Solar
System, we infer the likely properties of rings around exoplanets that reside
inside the ice line. Due to their proximity to their host star, rings around
such exoplanets must primarily consist of rocky materials. However, we find
that despite the higher densities of rock compared to ice, most of the observed
extrasolar planets with reliable radii measurements have sufficiently large
Roche radii to support rings. For the currently known transiting extrasolar
planets, Poynting-Robertson drag is not effective in significantly altering the
dynamics of individual ring particles over a time span of $10^8$ years provided
that they exceed about 1 m in size. In addition, we show that significantly
smaller ring particles can exist in optically thick rings, for which we find
typical ring lifetimes ranging from a few times $10^6$ to a few times $10^9$
years. Most interestingly, we find that many of the rings could have nontrivial
Laplacian planes due to the increased effects of the orbital quadrupole caused
by the exoplanets' proximity to their host star, allowing a constraint on the
$J_2$ of extrasolar planets from ring observations. This is particular
exciting, since a planet's $J_2$ reveals information about its interior
structure. Furthermore, measurements of an exoplanet's oblateness and of its
$J_2$, from warped rings, would together place limits on its spin period. Based
on the constraints that we have derived for extrasolar rings, we anticipate
that the best candidates for ring detections will come from transit
observations by the Kepler spacecraft of extrasolar planets with semi-major
axes $\sim 0.1$ AU and larger.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1102.1430 [pdf] - 1051953
Using Kuiper Belt Binaries to Constrain Neptune's Migration History
Submitted: 2011-02-07
Approximately 10-20% of all Kuiper belt objects (KBOs) occupy mean-motion
resonances with Neptune. This dynamical configuration likely resulted from
resonance capture as Neptune migrated outward during the late stages of planet
formation. The details of Neptune's planetesimal-driven migration, including
its radial extent and the concurrent eccentricity evolution of the planet, are
the subject of considerable debate. Two qualitatively different proposals for
resonance capture have been proposed--migration-induced capture driven by
smooth outward evolution of Neptune's orbit and chaotic capture driven by
damping of the planet's eccentricity near its current semi-major axis. We
demonstrate that the distribution of comparable-mass, wide-separation binaries
occupying resonant orbits can differentiate between these two scenarios. If
migration-induced capture occurred, this fraction records information about the
formation locations of different populations of KBOs. Chaotic capture, in
contrast, randomizes the orbits of bodies as they are placed in resonance. In
particular, migration-induced capture produces the following signatures. The
2:1 resonance should contain a dynamically cold component, with inclinations
less than 5-10 degrees, having a binary fraction comparable to that among cold
classical KBOs. If the 3:2 resonance also hosts a cold component, its binary
fraction should be 20-30% lower than in the cold classical belt. Among cold 2:1
(and if present 3:2) KBOs, objects with eccentricities e < 0.2 should have a
binary fraction ~20% larger than those with e > 0.2. Searches for cold
components in the binary fractions of resonant KBOs are currently practical.
The additional migration-generated trends described here may be distinguished
with objects discovered by LSST. (Abstract abridged.)
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1011.0201 [pdf] - 1041649
Runaway Growth During Planet Formation: Explaining the Size Distribution
of Large Kuiper Belt Objects
Submitted: 2010-10-31
Runway growth is an important stage in planet formation during which large
protoplanets form, while most of the initial mass remains in small
planetesimals. The amount of mass converted into large protoplanets and their
resulting size distribution are not well understood. Here, we use analytic
work, that we confirm by coagulation simulations, to describe runaway growth
and the corresponding evolution of the velocity dispersion. We find that
runaway growth proceeds as follows: Initially all the mass resides in small
planetesimals, with mass surface density \sigma, and large protoplanets start
to form by accreting small planetesimals. This growth continues until growth by
merging large protoplanets becomes comparable to growth by planetesimal
accretion. This condition sets in when \Sigma/\sigma ~\alpha^{3/4} ~ 10^{-3},
where \Sigma is the mass surface density in protoplanets in a given logarithmic
mass interval and \alpha is the ratio of the size of a body to its Hill radius.
From then on, protoplanetary growth and the evolution of the velocity
dispersion become self-similar and \Sigma remains roughly constant, since an
increase in \Sigma by accretion of small planetesimals is balanced by a
decrease due to merging with large protoplanets. We show that this growth leads
to a protoplanet size distribution given by N(>R) \propto R^{-3} where N(>R) is
the number of objects with radii greater than R (i.e., a differential power-law
index of 4). We apply our results to the Kuiper Belt, which is a relic of
runaway growth. Our results successfully match the observed Kuiper belt size
distribution, they illuminate the physical processes that shaped it and explain
the total mass that is present in large Kuiper belt objects (KBOs) today. This
work suggests that the current mass in large KBOs is primordial and that it has
not been significantly depleted. Abridged
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.2996 [pdf] - 1018791
A single sub-km Kuiper Belt object from a stellar Occultation in
archival data
Submitted: 2009-12-15
The Kuiper belt is a remnant of the primordial Solar System. Measurements of
its size distribution constrain its accretion and collisional history, and the
importance of material strength of Kuiper belt objects (KBOs). Small, sub-km
sized, KBOs elude direct detection, but the signature of their occultations of
background stars should be detectable. Observations at both optical and X-ray
wavelengths claim to have detected such occultations, but their implied KBO
abundances are inconsistent with each other and far exceed theoretical
expectations. Here, we report an analysis of archival data that reveals an
occultation by a body with a 500 m radius at a distance of 45 AU. The
probability of this event to occur due to random statistical fluctuations
within our data set is about 2%. Our survey yields a surface density of KBOs
with radii larger than 250 m of 2.1^{+4.8}_{-1.7} x 10^7 deg^{-2}, ruling out
inferred surface densities from previous claimed detections by more than 5
sigma. The fact that we detected only one event, firmly shows a deficit of
sub-km sized KBOs compared to a population extrapolated from objects with r>50
km. This implies that sub-km sized KBOs are undergoing collisional erosion,
just like debris disks observed around other stars.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:0906.3893 [pdf] - 25487
The Creation of Haumea's Collisional Family
Submitted: 2009-06-21
Recently, the first collisional family was discovered in the Kuiper belt. The
parent body of this family, Haumea, is one of the largest objects in the Kuiper
belt and is orbited by two satellites. It has been proposed that the Haumea
family was created from dispersed fragments that resulted from a giant impact.
This proposed origin of the Haumea family is however in conflict with the
observed velocity dispersion between the family members (\sim 140 m/s) which is
significantly less than the escape velocity from Haumea's surface (\sim 900
m/s). In this paper we propose a different formation scenario for Haumea's
collisional family. In our scenario the family members are ejected while in
orbit around Haumea. This scenario, therefore, gives naturally rise to a lower
velocity dispersion among the family members than expected from direct ejection
from Haumea's surface. In our scenario Haumea's giant impact forms a single
moon that tidally evolves outward until it suffers a destructive collision from
which the family is created. We show that this formation scenario yields a
velocity dispersion of \sim 190m/s among the family members which is in good
agreement with the observations. The probability for Haumea's initial giant
impact in todays Kuiper belt is less than 10^{-3}. In our scenario, however,
Haumea's giant impact can occur before the excitation of the Kuiper belt and
the ejection of the family members afterwards. This has the advantage that one
can preserve the dynamical coherence of the family and explain Haumea's
original giant impact, which is several orders of magnitude more likely to have
occurred in the primordial dynamically cold Kuiper belt compared to the
dynamically excited Kuiper belt today. Abridged
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:0902.3475 [pdf] - 21581
No Planet Left Behind: Investigating Planetary Diversity and
Architecture with SIM Lite
Submitted: 2009-02-19
The evidence is mounting that star formation necessarily involves planet
formation. We clearly have a vested interest in finding other Earths but a true
understanding of planet formation requires completing the census and mapping
planetary architecture in all its grandeur and diversity. Here, we show that a
2000-star survey undertaken with SIM Lite will uniquely probe planets around
B-A-F stars, bright and binary stars and white dwarfs. In addition, we show
that the high precision of SIM Lite allows us to gain unique insights into
planet formation via accurate measurements of mutual inclinations.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:0803.0329 [pdf] - 10617
The Ratio of Retrograde to Prograde Orbits: A Test for Kuiper Belt
Binary Formation Theories
Submitted: 2008-03-03, last modified: 2008-07-03
With the discovery of Kuiper Belt binaries that have wide separations and
roughly equal masses new theories were proposed to explain their formation. Two
formation scenarios were suggested by Goldreich and collaborators: In the
first, dynamical friction that is generated by a sea of small bodies enables a
transient binary to become bound ($L^2s$ mechanism); in the second, a transient
binary gets bound by an encounter with a third body ($L^3$ mechanism).
We show that these different binary formation scenarios leave their own
unique signatures in the relative abundance of prograde to retrograde binary
orbits. This signature is due to stable retrograde orbits that exist much
further out in the Hill sphere than prograde orbits. It provides an excellent
opportunity to distinguish between the different binary formation scenarios
observationally.
We predict that if binary formation proceeded while sub-Hill velocities
prevailed, the vast majority of all comparable mass ratio binaries have
retrograde orbits. This dominance of retrograde binary orbits is a result of
binary formation via the $L^2s$ mechanism, or any other mechanism that
dissipates energy in a smooth and gradual manner. For super-Hill velocities
binary formation proceeds via the $L^3$ mechanism which produces a roughly
equal number of prograde and retrograde binaries. These predictions assume that
subsequent orbital evolution due to dynamical friction and dynamical stirring
of the Kuiper belt did not alter the sense of the binary orbit after formation.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:0709.3107 [pdf] - 5141
Formation of Kuiper Belt Binaries
Submitted: 2007-09-19, last modified: 2007-11-06
The discovery that a substantial fraction of Kuiper Belt objects (KBOs)
exists in binaries with wide separations and roughly equal masses, has
motivated a variety of new theories explaining their formation. Goldreich et
al. (2002) proposed two formation scenarios: In the first, a transient binary
is formed, which becomes bound with the aid of dynamical friction from the sea
of small bodies (L^2s mechanism); in the second, a binary is formed by three
body gravitational deflection (L^3 mechanism). Here, we accurately calculate
the L^2s and L^3 formation rates for sub-Hill velocities. While the L^2s
formation rate is close to previous order of magnitude estimates, the L^3
formation rate is about a factor of 4 smaller. For sub-Hill KBO velocities (v
<< v_H) the ratio of the L^3 to the L^2s formation rate is 0.05 (v/v_H)
independent of the small bodies' velocity dispersion, their surface density or
their mutual collisions. For Super-Hill velocities (v >> v_H) the L^3 mechanism
dominates over the L^2s mechanism. Binary formation via the L^3 mechanism
competes with binary destruction by passing bodies. Given sufficient time, a
statistical equilibrium abundance of binaries forms. We show that the frequency
of long-lived transient binaries drops exponentially with the system's lifetime
and that such transient binaries are not important for binary formation via the
L^3 mechanism, contrary to Lee et al. (2007). For the L^2s mechanism we find
that the typical time, transient binaries must last, to form Kuiper Belt
binaries (KBBs) for a given strength of dynamical friction, D, increases only
logarithmically with D. Longevity of transient binaries only becomes important
for very weak dynamical friction (i.e. D \lesssim 0.002) and is most likely not
crucial for KBB formation.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0610093 [pdf] - 85517
The effect of Semi-Collisional Accretion on Planetary Spins
Submitted: 2006-10-03
Planetesimal accretion during planet formation is usually treated as
collisionless. Such accretion from a uniform and dynamically cold disk predicts
protoplanets with slow retrograde rotation. However, if the building blocks of
protoplanets, planetesimals, are small, of order of a meter in size, then they
are likely to collide within the protoplanet's sphere of gravitational
influence, creating a prograde accretion disk around the protoplanet. The
accretion of such a disk results in the formation of protoplanets spinning in
the prograde sense with the maximal spin rate allowed before centrifugal forces
break them apart. As a result of semi-collisional accretion, the final spin of
a planet after giant impacts is not completely random but is biased toward
prograde rotation. The eventual accretion of the remaining planetesimals in the
post giant-impact phase might again be in the semi-collisional regime and
delivers a significant amount of additional prograde angular momentum to the
terrestrial planets. We suggest that in our Solar System, semi-collisional
accretion gave rise to the preference for prograde rotation observed in the
terrestrial planets and perhaps the largest asteroids.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0609801 [pdf] - 85393
The Self-Similarity of Shear-Dominated Viscous Stirring
Submitted: 2006-09-28
We examine the growth of eccentricities of a population of particles with
initially circular orbits around a central massive body. Successive encounters
between pairs of particles increase the eccentricities in the disk on average.
As long as the epicyclic motions of the particles are small compared to the
shearing motion between Keplerian orbits, there is no preferred scale for the
eccentricities. The simplification due to this self-similarity allows us to
find an analytic form for the distribution function; full numerical
integrations of a disk with 200 planetesimals verify our analytical
self-similar distribution. The shape of this non-equilibrium profile is
identical to the equilibrium profile of a shear-dominated population whose
mutual excitations are balanced by dynamical friction or Epstein gas drag.