Normalized to: Schenck, D.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1403.2369 [pdf] - 1715860
A Measurement of the Cosmic Microwave Background B-Mode Polarization
Power Spectrum at Sub-Degree Scales with POLARBEAR
The POLARBEAR Collaboration;
Ade, P. A. R.;
Akiba, Y.;
Anthony, A. E.;
Arnold, K.;
Atlas, M.;
Barron, D.;
Boettger, D.;
Borrill, J.;
Chapman, S.;
Chinone, Y.;
Dobbs, M.;
Elleflot, T.;
Errard, J.;
Fabbian, G.;
Feng, C.;
Flanigan, D.;
Gilbert, A.;
Grainger, W.;
Halverson, N. W.;
Hasegawa, M.;
Hattori, K.;
Hazumi, M.;
Holzapfel, W. L.;
Hori, Y.;
Howard, J.;
Hyland, P.;
Inoue, Y.;
Jaehnig, G. C.;
Jaffe, A. H.;
Keating, B.;
Kermish, Z.;
Keskitalo, R.;
Kisner, T.;
Jeune, M. Le;
Lee, A. T.;
Leitch, E. M.;
Linder, E.;
Lungu, M.;
Matsuda, F.;
Matsumura, T.;
Meng, X.;
Miller, N. J.;
Morii, H.;
Moyerman, S.;
Myers, M. J.;
Navaroli, M.;
Nishino, H.;
Paar, H.;
Peloton, J.;
Poletti, D.;
Quealy, E.;
Rebeiz, G.;
Reichardt, C. L.;
Richards, P. L.;
Ross, C.;
Schanning, I.;
Schenck, D. E.;
Sherwin, B. D.;
Shimizu, A.;
Shimmin, C.;
Shimon, M.;
Siritanasak, P.;
Smecher, G.;
Spieler, H.;
Stebor, N.;
Steinbach, B.;
Stompor, R.;
Suzuki, A.;
Takakura, S.;
Tomaru, T.;
Wilson, B.;
Yadav, A.;
Zahn, O.
Submitted: 2014-03-10, last modified: 2018-07-16
We report a measurement of the B-mode polarization power spectrum in the
cosmic microwave background (CMB) using the POLARBEAR experiment in Chile. The
faint B-mode polarization signature carries information about the Universe's
entire history of gravitational structure formation, and the cosmic inflation
that may have occurred in the very early Universe. Our measurement covers the
angular multipole range 500 < l < 2100 and is based on observations of an
effective sky area of 25 square degrees with 3.5 arcmin resolution at 150 GHz.
On these angular scales, gravitational lensing of the CMB by intervening
structure in the Universe is expected to be the dominant source of B-mode
polarization. Including both systematic and statistical uncertainties, the
hypothesis of no B-mode polarization power from gravitational lensing is
rejected at 97.1% confidence. The band powers are consistent with the standard
cosmological model. Fitting a single lensing amplitude parameter A_BB to the
measured band powers, A_BB = 1.12 +/- 0.61 (stat) +0.04/-0.12 (sys) +/- 0.07
(multi), where A_BB = 1 is the fiducial WMAP-9 LCDM value. In this expression,
"stat" refers to the statistical uncertainty, "sys" to the systematic
uncertainty associated with possible biases from the instrument and
astrophysical foregrounds, and "multi" to the calibration uncertainties that
have a multiplicative effect on the measured amplitude A_BB.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1509.02461 [pdf] - 1335455
POLARBEAR Constraints on Cosmic Birefringence and Primordial Magnetic
Fields
POLARBEAR Collaboration;
Ade, Peter A. R.;
Arnold, Kam;
Atlas, Matt;
Baccigalupi, Carlo;
Barron, Darcy;
Boettger, David;
Borrill, Julian;
Chapman, Scott;
Chinone, Yuji;
Cukierman, Ari;
Dobbs, Matt;
Ducout, Anne;
Dunner, Rolando;
Elleflot, Tucker;
Errard, Josquin;
Fabbian, Giulio;
Feeney, Stephen;
Feng, Chang;
Gilbert, Adam;
Goeckner-Wald, Neil;
Groh, John;
Hall, Grantland;
Halverson, Nils W.;
Hasegawa, Masaya;
Hattori, Kaori;
Hazumi, Masashi;
Hill, Charles;
Holzapfel, William L.;
Hori, Yasuto;
Howe, Logan;
Inoue, Yuki;
Jaehnig, Gregory C.;
Jaffe, Andrew H.;
Jeong, Oliver;
Katayama, Nobuhiko;
Kaufman, Jonathan P.;
Keating, Brian;
Kermish, Zigmund;
Keskitalo, Reijo;
Kisner, Theodore;
Kusaka, Akito;
Jeune, Maude Le;
Lee, Adrian T.;
Leitch, Erik M.;
Leon, David;
Li, Yun;
Linder, Eric;
Lowry, Lindsay;
Matsuda, Frederick;
Matsumura, Tomotake;
Miller, Nathan;
Montgomery, Josh;
Myers, Michael J.;
Navaroli, Martin;
Nishino, Haruki;
Okamura, Takahiro;
Paar, Hans;
Peloton, Julien;
Pogosian, Levon;
Poletti, Davide;
Puglisi, Giuseppe;
Raum, Christopher;
Rebeiz, Gabriel;
Reichardt, Christian L.;
Richards, Paul L.;
Ross, Colin;
Rotermund, Kaja M.;
Schenck, David E.;
Sherwin, Blake D.;
Shimon, Meir;
Shirley, Ian;
Siritanasak, Praween;
Smecher, Graeme;
Stebor, Nathan;
Steinbach, Bryan;
Suzuki, Aritoki;
Suzuki, Jun-ichi;
Tajima, Osamu;
Takakura, Satoru;
Tikhomirov, Alexei;
Tomaru, Takayuki;
Whitehorn, Nathan;
Wilson, Brandon;
Yadav, Amit;
Zahn, Alex;
Zahn, Oliver
Submitted: 2015-09-08, last modified: 2016-01-04
We constrain anisotropic cosmic birefringence using four-point correlations
of even-parity $E$-mode and odd-parity $B$-mode polarization in the cosmic
microwave background measurements made by the POLARization of the Background
Radiation (POLARBEAR) experiment in its first season of observations. We find
that the anisotropic cosmic birefringence signal from any parity-violating
processes is consistent with zero. The Faraday rotation from anisotropic cosmic
birefringence can be compared with the equivalent quantity generated by
primordial magnetic fields if they existed. The POLARBEAR nondetection
translates into a 95% confidence level (C.L.) upper limit of 93 nanogauss (nG)
on the amplitude of an equivalent primordial magnetic field inclusive of
systematic uncertainties. This four-point correlation constraint on Faraday
rotation is about 15 times tighter than the upper limit of 1380 nG inferred
from constraining the contribution of Faraday rotation to two-point
correlations of $B$-modes measured by Planck in 2015. Metric perturbations
sourced by primordial magnetic fields would also contribute to the $B$-mode
power spectrum. Using the POLARBEAR measurements of the $B$-mode power spectrum
(two-point correlation), we set a 95% C.L. upper limit of 3.9 nG on primordial
magnetic fields assuming a flat prior on the field amplitude. This limit is
comparable to what was found in the Planck 2015 two-point correlation analysis
with both temperature and polarization. We perform a set of systematic error
tests and find no evidence for contamination. This work marks the first time
that anisotropic cosmic birefringence or primordial magnetic fields have been
constrained from the ground at subdegree scales.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1501.07911 [pdf] - 1309971
Modeling atmospheric emission for CMB ground-based observations
Errard, J.;
Ade, P. A. R.;
Akiba, Y.;
Arnold, K.;
Atlas, M.;
Baccigalupi, C.;
Barron, D.;
Boettger, D.;
Borrill, J.;
Chapman, S.;
Chinone, Y.;
Cukierman, A.;
Delabrouille, J.;
Dobbs, M.;
Ducout, A.;
Elleflot, T.;
Fabbian, G.;
Feng, C.;
Feeney, S.;
Gilbert, A.;
Goeckner-Wald, N.;
Halverson, N. W.;
Hasegawa, M.;
Hattori, K.;
Hazumi, M.;
Hill, C.;
Holzapfel, W. L.;
Hori, Y.;
Inoue, Y.;
Jaehnig, G. C.;
Jaffe, A. H.;
Jeong, O.;
Katayama, N.;
Kaufman, J.;
Keating, B.;
Kermish, Z.;
Keskitalo, R.;
Kisner, T.;
Jeune, M. Le;
Lee, A. T.;
Leitch, E. M.;
Leon, D.;
Linder, E.;
Matsuda, F.;
Matsumura, T.;
Miller, N. J.;
Myers, M. J.;
Navaroli, M.;
Nishino, H.;
Okamura, T.;
Paar, H.;
Peloton, J.;
Poletti, D.;
Puglisi, G.;
Rebeiz, G.;
Reichardt, C. L.;
Richards, P. L.;
Ross, C.;
Rotermund, K. M.;
Schenck, D. E.;
Sherwin, B. D.;
Siritanasak, P.;
Smecher, G.;
Stebor, N.;
Steinbach, B.;
Stompor, R.;
Suzuki, A.;
Tajima, O.;
Takakura, S.;
Tikhomirov, A.;
Tomaru, T.;
Whitehorn, N.;
Wilson, B.;
Yadav, A.;
Zahn, O.
Submitted: 2015-01-30, last modified: 2015-11-12
Atmosphere is one of the most important noise sources for ground-based cosmic
microwave background (CMB) experiments. By increasing optical loading on the
detectors, it amplifies their effective noise, while its fluctuations introduce
spatial and temporal correlations between detected signals. We present a
physically motivated 3d-model of the atmosphere total intensity emission in the
millimeter and sub-millimeter wavelengths. We derive a new analytical estimate
for the correlation between detectors time-ordered data as a function of the
instrument and survey design, as well as several atmospheric parameters such as
wind, relative humidity, temperature and turbulence characteristics. Using an
original numerical computation, we examine the effect of each physical
parameter on the correlations in the time series of a given experiment. We then
use a parametric-likelihood approach to validate the modeling and estimate
atmosphere parameters from the POLARBEAR-I project first season data set. We
derive a new 1.0% upper limit on the linear polarization fraction of
atmospheric emission. We also compare our results to previous studies and
weather station measurements. The proposed model can be used for realistic
simulations of future ground-based CMB observations.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.7488 [pdf] - 894214
Development and characterization of the readout system for POLARBEAR-2
Barron, D.;
Ade, P. A. R.;
Akiba, Y.;
Aleman, C.;
Arnold, K.;
Atlas, M.;
Bender, A.;
Boettger, D.;
Borrill, J.;
Chapman, S.;
Chinone, Y.;
Cukierman, A.;
Dobbs, M.;
Elleflot, T.;
Errard, J.;
Fabbian, G.;
Feng, C.;
Gilbert, A.;
Goeckner-Wald, N.;
Halverson, N. W.;
Hasegawa, M.;
Hattori, K.;
Hazumi, M.;
Holzapfel, W. L.;
Hori, Y.;
Inoue, Y.;
Jaehnig, G. C.;
Jaffe, A. H.;
Katayama, N.;
Keating, B.;
Kermish, Z.;
Keskitalo, R.;
Kisner, T.;
Jeune, M. Le;
Lee, A. T.;
Leitch, E. M.;
Linder, E.;
Matsuda, F.;
Matsumura, T.;
Meng, X.;
Morii, H.;
Myers, M. J.;
Navaroli, M.;
Nishino, H.;
Okamura, T.;
Paar, H.;
Peloton, J.;
Poletti, D.;
Raum, C.;
Rebeiz, G.;
Reichardt, C. L.;
Richards, P. L.;
Ross, C.;
Rotermund, K.;
Schenck, D. E.;
Sherwin, B. D.;
Shirley, I.;
Sholl, M.;
Siritanasak, P.;
Smecher, G.;
Stebor, N.;
Steinbach, B.;
Stompor, R.;
Suzuki, A.;
Suzuki, J.;
Takada, S.;
Takakura, S.;
Tomaru, T.;
Wilson, B.;
Yadav, A.;
Yamaguchi, H.;
Zahn, O.
Submitted: 2014-10-27, last modified: 2014-11-06
POLARBEAR-2 is a next-generation receiver for precision measurements of the
polarization of the cosmic microwave background (Cosmic Microwave Background
(CMB)). Scheduled to deploy in early 2015, it will observe alongside the
existing POLARBEAR-1 receiver, on a new telescope in the Simons Array on Cerro
Toco in the Atacama desert of Chile. For increased sensitivity, it will feature
a larger area focal plane, with a total of 7,588 polarization sensitive
antenna-coupled Transition Edge Sensor (TES) bolometers, with a design
sensitivity of 4.1 uKrt(s). The focal plane will be cooled to 250 milliKelvin,
and the bolometers will be read-out with 40x frequency domain multiplexing,
with 36 optical bolometers on a single SQUID amplifier, along with 2 dark
bolometers and 2 calibration resistors. To increase the multiplexing factor
from 8x for POLARBEAR-1 to 40x for POLARBEAR-2 requires additional bandwidth
for SQUID readout and well-defined frequency channel spacing. Extending to
these higher frequencies requires new components and design for the LC filters
which define channel spacing. The LC filters are cold resonant circuits with an
inductor and capacitor in series with each bolometer, and stray inductance in
the wiring and equivalent series resistance from the capacitors can affect
bolometer operation. We present results from characterizing these new readout
components. Integration of the readout system is being done first on a small
scale, to ensure that the readout system does not affect bolometer sensitivity
or stability, and to validate the overall system before expansion into the full
receiver. We present the status of readout integration, and the initial results
and status of components for the full array.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1408.5123 [pdf] - 1216456
How Much Can We Learn From A Merging Cold Front Cluster? : Insights From
X-ray Temperature and Radio Maps of Abell 3667
Submitted: 2014-08-21
The galaxy cluster Abell 3667 is an ideal laboratory to study the plasma
processes in the intracluster medium (ICM). High resolution Chandra X-ray
observations show a cold front in Abell 3667. At radio wavelengths, Abell 3667
reveals a double radio-relic feature in the outskirts of the cluster. These
suggest multiple merger events in this cluster. In this paper, we analyze the
substantial archival X-ray observations of Abell 3667 from ChandraX-ray
Observatory and compare these with existing radio observations as well as
state-of-the-art AMR (Adaptive Mesh Refinement) MHD cosmological simulations
using Enzo. We have used two temperature map making techniques, Weighted
Voronoi Tessellation and Adaptive Circular Binning, to produce the high
resolution and largest field-of-view temperature maps of Abell 3667. These high
fidelity temperature maps allow us to study the X-ray shocks in the cluster
using a new 2-dimensional shock-finding algorithm. We have also estimated the
Mach numbers from the shocks inferred from previous ATCA radio observations.
The combined shock statistics from the X-ray and radio data are in agreement
with the shock statistics in a simulated MHD cluster. We have also studied the
profiles of the thermodynamic properties across the cold front using 447 ksec
from the combined Chandra observations on Abell 3667. Our results show that the
stability of the cold front in Abell 3667 can be attributed to the suppression
of the thermal conduction across the cold front by a factor of 100 - 700
compared to the classical Spitzer value.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.2366 [pdf] - 1209464
X-ray Observations of Complex Temperature Structure in the Cool-core
cluster Abell 85
Submitted: 2014-05-09
X-ray observations were used to examine the complex temperature structure of
Abell 85, a cool-core galaxy cluster. Temperature features can provide evidence
of merging events which shock heat the intracluster gas. Temperature maps were
made from both \textit{Chandra} and \textit{XMM-Newton} obervations. The
combination of a new, long-exposure \textit{XMM} observation and an improved
temperature map binning technique produced the highest fidelity temperature
maps of A85 to date. Hot regions were detected near the subclusters to the
South and Southwest in both the \textit{Chandra} and \textit{XMM} temperature
maps. The presence of these structures implies A85 is not relaxed. The hot
regions may indicate the presence of shocks. The Mach numbers were estimated to
be $\sim$1.9 at the locations of the hot spots. Observational effects will tend
to systematically reduce temperature jumps, so the measured Mach numbers are
likely underestimated. Neither temperature map showed evidence for a shock in
the vicinity of the presumed radio relic near the Southwest subcluster.
However, the presence of a weak shock cannot be ruled out. There was tension
between the temperatures measured by the two instruments.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1312.6646 [pdf] - 851338
Measurement of the Cosmic Microwave Background Polarization Lensing
Power Spectrum with the POLARBEAR experiment
POLARBEAR Collaboration;
Ade, P. A. R.;
Akiba, Y.;
Anthony, A. E.;
Arnold, K.;
Atlas, M.;
Barron, D.;
Boettger, D.;
Borrill, J.;
Chapman, S.;
Chinone, Y.;
Dobbs, M.;
Elleflot, T.;
Errard, J.;
Fabbian, G.;
Feng, C.;
Flanigan, D.;
Gilbert, A.;
Grainger, W.;
Halverson, N. W.;
Hasegawa, M.;
Hattori, K.;
Hazumi, M.;
Holzapfel, W. L.;
Hori, Y.;
Howard, J.;
Hyland, P.;
Inoue, Y.;
Jaehnig, G. C.;
Jaffe, A.;
Keating, B.;
Kermish, Z.;
Keskitalo, R.;
Kisner, T.;
Jeune, M. Le;
Lee, A. T.;
Linder, E.;
Leitch, E. M.;
Lungu, M.;
Matsuda, F.;
Matsumura, T.;
Meng, X.;
Miller, N. J.;
Morii, H.;
Moyerman, S.;
Myers, M. J.;
Navaroli, M.;
Nishino, H.;
Paar, H.;
Peloton, J.;
Quealy, E.;
Rebeiz, G.;
Reichardt, C. L.;
Richards, P. L.;
Ross, C.;
Schanning, I.;
Schenck, D. E.;
Sherwin, B.;
Shimizu, A.;
Shimmin, C.;
Shimon, M.;
Siritanasak, P.;
Smecher, G.;
Spieler, H.;
Stebor, N.;
Steinbach, B.;
Stompor, R.;
Suzuki, A.;
Takakura, S.;
Tomaru, T.;
Wilson, B.;
Yadav, A.;
Zahn, O.
Submitted: 2013-12-23, last modified: 2014-04-27
Gravitational lensing due to the large-scale distribution of matter in the
cosmos distorts the primordial Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and thereby
induces new, small-scale $B$-mode polarization. This signal carries detailed
information about the distribution of all the gravitating matter between the
observer and CMB last scattering surface. We report the first direct evidence
for polarization lensing based on purely CMB information, from using the
four-point correlations of even- and odd-parity $E$- and $B$-mode polarization
mapped over $\sim30$ square degrees of the sky measured by the POLARBEAR
experiment. These data were analyzed using a blind analysis framework and
checked for spurious systematic contamination using null tests and simulations.
Evidence for the signal of polarization lensing and lensing $B$-modes is found
at 4.2$\sigma$ (stat.+sys.) significance. The amplitude of matter fluctuations
is measured with a precision of $27\%$, and is found to be consistent with the
Lambda Cold Dark Matter ($\Lambda$CDM) cosmological model. This measurement
demonstrates a new technique, capable of mapping all gravitating matter in the
Universe, sensitive to the sum of neutrino masses, and essential for cleaning
the lensing $B$-mode signal in searches for primordial gravitational waves.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1312.6645 [pdf] - 812508
Evidence for Gravitational Lensing of the Cosmic Microwave Background
Polarization from Cross-correlation with the Cosmic Infrared Background
POLARBEAR Collaboration;
Ade, P. A. R.;
Akiba, Y.;
Anthony, A. E.;
Arnold, K.;
Atlas, M.;
Barron, D.;
Boettger, D.;
Borrill, J.;
Borys, C.;
Chapman, S.;
Chinone, Y.;
Dobbs, M.;
Elleflot, T.;
Errard, J.;
Fabbian, G.;
Feng, C.;
Flanigan, D.;
Gilbert, A.;
Grainger, W.;
Halverson, N. W.;
Hasegawa, M.;
Hattori, K.;
Hazumi, M.;
Holzapfel, W. L.;
Hori, Y.;
Howard, J.;
Hyland, P.;
Inoue, Y.;
Jaehnig, G. C.;
Jaffe, A.;
Keating, B.;
Kermish, Z.;
Keskitalo, R.;
Kisner, T.;
Jeune, M. Le;
Lee, A. T.;
Leitch, E. M.;
Linder, E.;
Lungu, M.;
Matsuda, F.;
Matsumura, T.;
Meng, X.;
Miller, N. J.;
Morii, H.;
Moyerman, S.;
Myers, M. J.;
Navaroli, M.;
Nishino, H.;
Paar, H.;
Peloton, J.;
Quealy, E.;
Rebeiz, G.;
Reichardt, C. L.;
Richards, P. L.;
Ross, C.;
Rotermund, K.;
Schanning, I.;
Schenck, D. E.;
Sherwin, B. D.;
Shimizu, A.;
Shimmin, C.;
Shimon, M.;
Siritanasak, P.;
Smecher, G.;
Spieler, H.;
Stebor, N.;
Steinbach, B.;
Stompor, R.;
Suzuki, A.;
Takakura, S.;
Tikhomirov, A.;
Tomaru, T.;
Wilson, B.;
Yadav, A.;
Zahn, O.
Submitted: 2013-12-23, last modified: 2014-03-07
We reconstruct the gravitational lensing convergence signal from Cosmic
Microwave Background (CMB) polarization data taken by the POLARBEAR experiment
and cross-correlate it with Cosmic Infrared Background (CIB) maps from the
Herschel satellite. From the cross-spectra, we obtain evidence for
gravitational lensing of the CMB polarization at a statistical significance of
4.0$\sigma$ and evidence for the presence of a lensing $B$-mode signal at a
significance of 2.3$\sigma$. We demonstrate that our results are not biased by
instrumental and astrophysical systematic errors by performing null-tests,
checks with simulated and real data, and analytical calculations. This
measurement of polarization lensing, made via the robust cross-correlation
channel, not only reinforces POLARBEAR auto-correlation measurements, but also
represents one of the early steps towards establishing CMB polarization lensing
as a powerful new probe of cosmology and astrophysics.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1210.6132 [pdf] - 579881
Jet Launching Structure Resolved Near the Supermassive Black Hole in M87
Doeleman, Sheperd S.;
Fish, Vincent L.;
Schenck, David E.;
Beaudoin, Christopher;
Blundell, Ray;
Bower, Geoffrey C.;
Broderick, Avery E.;
Chamberlin, Richard;
Freund, Robert;
Friberg, Per;
Gurwell, Mark A.;
Ho, Paul T. P.;
Honma, Mareki;
Inoue, Makoto;
Krichbaum, Thomas P.;
Lamb, James;
Loeb, Abraham;
Lonsdale, Colin;
Marrone, Daniel P.;
Moran, James M.;
Oyama, Tomoaki;
Plambeck, Richard;
Primiani, Rurik A.;
Rogers, Alan E. E.;
Smythe, Daniel L.;
SooHoo, Jason;
Strittmatter, Peter;
Tilanus, Remo P. J.;
Titus, Michael;
Weintroub, Jonathan;
Wright, Melvyn;
Young, Ken H.;
Ziurys, Lucy M.
Submitted: 2012-10-23
Approximately 10% of active galactic nuclei exhibit relativistic jets, which
are powered by accretion of matter onto super massive black holes. While the
measured width profiles of such jets on large scales agree with theories of
magnetic collimation, predicted structure on accretion disk scales at the jet
launch point has not been detected. We report radio interferometry observations
at 1.3mm wavelength of the elliptical galaxy M87 that spatially resolve the
base of the jet in this source. The derived size of 5.5 +/- 0.4 Schwarzschild
radii is significantly smaller than the innermost edge of a retrograde
accretion disk, suggesting that the M87 jet is powered by an accretion disk in
a prograde orbit around a spinning black hole.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1109.1246 [pdf] - 406991
Testing the global star formation relation: An HCO+ (3-2) mapping study
of Red MSX sources in the Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey
Submitted: 2011-09-06
We present an analysis of the relation between the star formation rate (SFR)
and mass of dense gas in Galactic clumps and nearby galaxies. Using the
bolometric luminosity as a measure of SFR and the molecular line luminosity of
HCO+ (3-2) as a measure of dense gas mass, we find that the relation between
SFR and M_{dense} is approximately linear. This is similar to published results
derived using HCN (1-0) as a dense gas tracer. HCO+ (3-2) and HCN (1-0) have
similar conditions for excitation. Our work includes 16 Galactic clumps that
are in both the Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey and the Red MSX Survey, 27 water
maser sources from the literature, and the aforementioned HCN (1-0) data. Our
results agree qualitatively with predictions of recent theoretical models which
state that the nature of the relation should depend on how the critical density
of the tracer compares with the mean density of the gas.