Normalized to: Savani, N.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.02359 [pdf] - 1661883
Fitting and Reconstruction of Thirteen Simple Coronal Mass Ejections
Submitted: 2018-04-06
Coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are the main drivers of geomagnetic
disturbances, but the effects of their interaction with Earth's magnetic field
depend on their magnetic configuration and orientation. Fitting and
reconstruction techniques have been developed to determine the important
geometrical and physical CME properties. In many instances, there is
disagreement between such different methods but also between fitting from in
situ measurements and reconstruction based on remote imaging. Here, we compare
three methods based on different assumptions for measurements of thirteen CMEs
by the Wind spacecraft from 1997 to 2015. These CMEs are selected from the
interplanetary coronal mass ejections catalog on
https://wind.nasa.gov/ICMEindex.php due to their simplicity in terms of 1)
small expansion speed throughout the CME and 2) little asymmetry in the
magnetic field profile. This makes these thirteen events ideal candidates to
compare codes that do not include expansion nor distortion. We find that, for
these simple events, the codes are in relatively good agreement in terms of the
CME axis orientation for six out of the 13 events. Using the Grad-Shafranov
technique, we can determine the shape of the cross-section, which is assumed to
be circular for the other two models, a force-free fitting and a
circular-cylindrical non-force-free fitting. Five of the events are found to
have a clear circular cross-section, even when this is not a pre-condition of
the reconstruction. We make an initial attempt at evaluating the adequacy of
the different assumptions for these simple CMEs. The conclusion of this work
strongly suggests that attempts at reconciling in situ and remote-sensing views
of CMEs must take in consideration the compatibility of the different models
with specific CME structures to better reproduce flux ropes.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.08739 [pdf] - 1535173
Planar magnetic structures in coronal mass ejection-driven sheath
regions
Submitted: 2017-01-30
Planar magnetic structures (PMSs) are periods in the solar wind during which
interplanetary magnetic field vectors are nearly parallel to a single plane.
One of the specific regions where PMSs have been reported are coronal mass
ejection (CME)-driven sheaths. We use here an automated method to identify PMSs
in 95 CME sheath regions observed in-situ by the Wind and ACE spacecraft
between 1997 and 2015. The occurrence and location of the PMSs are related to
various shock, sheath and CME properties. We find that PMSs are ubiquitous in
CME sheaths; 85% of the studied sheath regions had PMSs with the mean duration
of 6.0 hours. In about one-third of the cases the magnetic field vectors
followed a single PMS plane that covered a significant part (at least 67%) of
the sheath region. Our analysis gives strong support for two suggested PMS
formation mechanisms: the amplification and alignment of solar wind
discontinuities near the CME-driven shock and the draping of the magnetic field
lines around the CME ejecta. For example, we found that the shock and PMS plane
normals generally coincided for the events where the PMSs occurred near the
shock (68% of the PMS plane normals near the shock were separated by less than
20{\deg} from the shock normal), while deviations were clearly larger when PMSs
occurred close to the ejecta leading edge. In addition, PMSs near the shock
were generally associated with lower upstream plasma beta than the cases where
PMSs occurred near the leading edge of the CME. We also demonstrate that the
planar parts of the sheath contain a higher amount of strongly southward
magnetic field than the non-planar parts, suggesting that planar sheaths are
more likely to drive magnetospheric activity.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1509.06477 [pdf] - 1300336
Propagation of the 7 January 2014 CME and Resulting Geomagnetic
Non-Event
Mays, M. L.;
Thompson, B. J.;
Jian, L. K.;
Colaninno, R. C.;
Odstrcil, D.;
Möstl, C.;
Temmer, M.;
Savani, N. P.;
Taktakishvili, A.;
MacNeice, P. J.;
Zheng, Y.
Submitted: 2015-09-22
On 7 January 2014 an X1.2 flare and CME with a radial speed $\approx$2500 km
s$^{-1}$ was observed from near an active region close to disk center. This led
many forecasters to estimate a rapid arrival at Earth ($\approx$36 hours) and
predict a strong geomagnetic storm. However, only a glancing CME arrival was
observed at Earth with a transit time of $\approx$49 hours and a $K_{\rm P}$
geomagnetic index of only $3-$. We study the interplanetary propagation of this
CME using the ensemble Wang-Sheeley-Arge (WSA)-ENLIL+Cone model, that allows a
sampling of CME parameter uncertainties. We explore a series of simulations to
isolate the effects of the background solar wind solution, CME shape, tilt,
location, size, and speed, and the results are compared with observed in-situ
arrivals at Venus, Earth, and Mars. Our results show that a tilted ellipsoid
CME shape improves the initial real-time prediction to better reflect the
observed in-situ signatures and the geomagnetic storm strength. CME parameters
from the Graduated Cylindrical Shell model used as input to WSA--ENLIL+Cone,
along with a tilted ellipsoid cloud shape, improve the arrival-time error by
14.5, 18.7, 23.4 hours for Venus, Earth, and Mars respectively. These results
highlight that CME orientation and directionality with respect to observatories
play an important role in understanding the propagation of this CME, and for
forecasting other glancing CME arrivals. This study also demonstrates the
importance of three-dimensional CME fitting made possible by multiple viewpoint
imaging.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1502.02067 [pdf] - 1212334
Predicting the magnetic vectors within coronal mass ejections arriving
at Earth: 1. Initial Architecture
Submitted: 2015-02-06, last modified: 2015-06-17
The process by which the Sun affects the terrestrial environment on short
timescales is predominately driven by the amount of magnetic reconnection
between the solar wind and Earth's magnetosphere. Reconnection occurs most
efficiently when the solar wind magnetic field has a southward component. The
most severe impacts are during the arrival of a coronal mass ejection (CME)
when the magnetosphere is both compressed and magnetically connected to the
heliospheric environment. Unfortunately, forecasting magnetic vectors within
coronal mass ejections remains elusive. Here we report how, by combining a
statistically robust helicity rule for a CME's solar origin with a simplified
flux rope topology the magnetic vectors within the Earth-directed segment of a
CME can be predicted. In order to test the validity of this proof-of-concept
architecture for estimating the magnetic vectors within CMEs, a total of eight
CME events (between 2010 and 2014) have been investigated. With a focus on the
large false alarm of January 2014, this work highlights the importance of
including the early evolutionary effects of a CME for forecasting purposes. The
angular rotation in the predicted magnetic field closely follows the broad
rotational structure seen within the in situ data. This time-varying field
estimate is implemented into a process to quantitatively predict a time-varying
Kp index that is described in detail in paper II. Future statistical work,
quantifying the uncertainties in this process, may improve the more heuristic
approach used by early forecasting systems.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1311.6895 [pdf] - 1201888
Inner Heliospheric Evolution of a "Stealth" CME Derived From Multi-view
Imaging and Multipoint In--situ observations: I. Propagation to 1 AU
Submitted: 2013-11-27
Coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are the main driver of Space Weather.
Therefore, a precise forecasting of their likely geo-effectiveness relies on an
accurate tracking of their morphological and kinematical evolution throughout
the interplanetary medium. However, single view-point observations require many
assumptions to model the development of the features of CMEs, the most common
hypotheses were those of radial propagation and self-similar expansion. The use
of different view-points shows that at least for some cases, those assumptions
are no longer valid. From radial propagation, typical attributes that can now
been confirmed to exist are; over-expansion, and/or rotation along the
propagation axis. Understanding of the 3D development and evolution of the CME
features will help to establish the connection between remote and in-situ
observations, and hence help forecast Space Weather. We present an analysis of
the morphological and kinematical evolution of a STEREO B-directed CME on 2009
August 25-27. By means of a comprehensive analysis of remote imaging
observations provided by SOHO, STEREO and SDO missions, and in-situ
measurements recorded by Wind, ACE, and MESSENGER, we prove in this paper that
the event exhibits signatures of deflection, which are usually associated to
changes in the direction of propagation and/or also with rotation. The
interaction with other magnetic obstacles could act as a catalyst of deflection
or rotation effects. We propose, also, a method to investigate the change of
the CME Tilt from the analysis of height-time direct measurements. If this
method is validated in further work, it may have important implications for
space weather studies because it will allow infer ICME orientation.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.4747 [pdf] - 1180022
A Plasma {\beta} Transition Within a Propagating Flux Rope
Submitted: 2013-10-17, last modified: 2013-11-27
We present a 2.5D MHD simulation of a magnetic flux rope (FR) propagating in
the heliosphere and investigate the cause of the observed sharp plasma beta
transition. Specifically, we consider a strong internal magnetic field and an
explosive fast start, such that the plasma beta is significantly lower in the
FR than the sheath region that is formed ahead. This leads to an unusual FR
morphology in the first stage of propagation, while the more traditional view
(e.g. from space weather simulations like Enlil) of a `pancake' shaped FR is
observed as it approaches 1 AU. We investigate how an equipartition line,
defined by a magnetic Weber number, surrounding a core region of a propagating
FR can demarcate a boundary layer where there is a sharp transition in the
plasma beta. The substructure affects the distribution of toroidal flux, with
the majority of the flux remaining in a small core region which maintains a
quasi-cylindrical structure. Quantitatively, we investigate a locus of points
where the kinetic energy density of the relative inflow field is equal to the
energy density of the transverse magnetic field (i.e. effective tension force).
The simulation provides compelling evidence that at all heliocentric distances
the distribution of toroidal magnetic flux away from the FR axis is not linear;
with 80% of the toroidal flux occurring within 40% of the distance from the FR
axis. Thus our simulation displays evidence that the competing ideas of a
pancaking structure observed remotely can coexist with a quasi-cylindrical
magnetic structure seen in situ.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1303.2574 [pdf] - 1165164
Tracking the momentum flux of a CME and quantifying its influence on
geomagnetically induced currents at Earth
Submitted: 2013-03-08
We investigate a CME propagating towards Earth on 29 March 2011. This event
is specifically chosen for its predominately northward directed magnetic field,
so that the influence from the momentum flux onto Earth can be isolated. We
focus our study on understanding how a small Earth-directed segment propagates.
Mass images are created from the white-light cameras onboard STEREO which are
also converted into mass height-time maps (mass J-maps). The mass tracks on
these J-maps correspond to the sheath region between the CME and its associated
shock front as detected by in situ measurements at L1. A time-series of mass
measurements from the STEREO COR-2A instrument are made along the Earth
propagation direction. Qualitatively, this mass time-series shows a remarkable
resemblance to the L1 in situ density series. The in situ measurements are used
as inputs into a 3D magnetospheric space weather simulation from CCMC. These
simulations display a sudden compression of the magnetosphere from the large
momentum flux at the leading edge of the CME and predictions are made for the
time-derivative of the magnetic field (dB/dt) on the ground. The predicted
dB/dt were then compared with observations from specific equatorially-located
ground stations and show notable similarity. This study of the momentum of a
CME from the Sun down to its influence on magnetic ground stations on Earth is
presented as preliminary proof of concept, such that future attempts may try to
use remote sensing to create density and velocity time-series as inputs to
magnetospheric simulations.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.6394 [pdf] - 1151704
Magnetic Field Configuration Models and Reconstruction Methods for
Interplanetary Coronal Mass Ejections
Submitted: 2012-09-27
This study aims to provide a reference to different magnetic field models and
reconstruction methods for interplanetary coronal mass ejections (ICMEs). In
order to understand the differences in the outputs of those models and codes,
we analyze 59 events from the Coordinated Data Analysis Workshop (CDAW) list,
using four different magnetic field models and reconstruction techniques;
force-free fitting (Goldstein,1983,Burlaga,1988,Lepping et al.,1990),
magnetostatic reconstruction using a numerical solution to the Grad-Shafranov
equation (Hu and Sonnerup, 2001), fitting to a self-similarly expanding
cylindrical configuration (Marubashi and Lepping, 2007) and elliptical,
non-force free fitting (Hidalgo,2003). The resulting parameters of the
reconstructions for the 59 events are compared statistically, as well as in
selected case studies. The ability of a method to fit or reconstruct an event
is found to vary greatly: the Grad-Shafranov reconstruction is successful for
most magnetic clouds (MCs) but for less than 10% of the non-MC ICMEs; the other
three methods provide a successful fit for more than 65% of all events. The
differences between the reconstruction and fitting methods are discussed, and
suggestions are proposed as to how to reduce them. We find that the magnitude
of the axial field is relatively consistent across models but not the
orientation of the axis of the ejecta. We also find that there are a few cases
for which different signs of the magnetic helicity are found for the same event
when we do not fix the boundaries, illustrating that this simplest of
parameters is not necessarily always well constrained by fitting and
reconstruction models. Finally, we look at three unique cases in depth to
provide a comprehensive idea of the different aspects of how the fitting and
reconstruction codes work.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.1990 [pdf] - 581982
A study of the Heliocentric dependence of Shock Standoff Distance and
Geometry using 2.5D MHD Simulations of CME-driven shocks
Submitted: 2012-09-10
We perform four numerical magnetohydrodynamic simulations in 2.5 dimensions
(2.5D) of fast Coronal Mass Ejections (CMEs) and their associated shock fronts
between 10Rs and 300Rs. We investigate the relative change in the shock
standoff distance, Sd, as a fraction of the CME radial half-width, Dob (i.e.
Sd/Dob). Previous hydrodynamic studies have related the shock standoff distance
for Earths magnetosphere to the density compression ratio (DR,Ru/Rd) measured
across the bow shock (Spreiter, Summers and Alksne 1966). The DR coefficient,
kdr, which is the proportionality constant between the relative standoff
distance (Sd/Dob) and the compression ratio, was semi-empirically estimated as
1.1. For CMEs, we show that this value varies linearly as a function of
heliocentric distance and changes significantly for different radii of
curvature of the CMEs leading edge. We find that a value of 0.8+-0.1 is more
appropriate for small heliocentric distances (<30Rs) which corresponds to the
spherical geometry of a magnetosphere presented by Seiff (1962). As the CME
propagates its cross section becomes more oblate and the kdr value increases
linearly with heliocentric distance, such that kdr= 1.1 is most appropriate at
a heliocentric distance of about 80Rs. For terrestrial distances (215Rs) we
estimate kdr= 1.8+-0.3, which also indicates that the CME cross-sectional
structure is generally more oblate than that of Earths magnetosphere. These
alterations to the proportionality coefficients may serve to improve
investigations into the estimates of the magnetic field in the corona upstream
of a CME as well as the aspect ratio of CMEs as measured in situ.