Normalized to: Sarazin, M.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.04751 [pdf] - 2026525
Characterisation of the ground layer of turbulence at Paranal using a
robotic SLODAR system
Submitted: 2019-12-10
We describe the implementation of a robotic SLODAR instrument at the Cerro
Paranal observatory. The instrument measures the vertical profile of the
optical atmospheric turbulence strength, in 8 resolution elements, to a maximum
altitude ranging between 100 m and 500 m. We present statistical results of
measurements of the turbulence profile on a total of 875 nights between 2014
and 2018. The vertical profile of the ground layer of turbulence is very
varied, but in the median case most of the turbulence strength in the ground
layer is concentrated within the first 50 m altitude, with relatively weak
turbulence at higher altitudes up to 500 m. We find good agreement between
measurements of the seeing angle from the SLODAR and from the Paranal DIMM
seeing monitor, and also for seeing values extracted from the Shack-Hartmann
active optics sensor of VLT UT1, adjusting for the height of each instrument
above ground level. The SLODAR data suggest that a median improvement in the
seeing angle from 0.689 arcsec to 0.481 arcsec at wavelength 500 nm would be
obtained by fully correcting the ground-layer turbulence between the height of
the UTs (taken as 10 m) and altitude 500 m.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.13767 [pdf] - 1988722
Nowcasting the turbulence at the Paranal Observatory
Milli, J.;
Gonzalez, R.;
Fluxa, P. R.;
Chacon, A.;
Navarette, J.;
Sarazin, M.;
Pena, E.;
Carrasco-Davis, R.;
Solarz, A.;
Smoker, J.;
Martayan, C.;
Melo, C.;
Sedaghati, E.;
Mieske, S.;
Hainaut, O.;
Tacconi-Garman, L.
Submitted: 2019-10-30
At Paranal Observatory, the least predictable parameter affecting the
short-term scheduling of astronomical observations is the optical turbulence,
especially the seeing, coherence time and ground layer fraction. These are
critical variables driving the performance of the instruments of the Very Large
Telescope (VLT), especially those fed with adaptive optics systems. Currently,
the night astronomer does not have a predictive tool to support him/her in
decision-making at night. As most service-mode observations at the VLT last
less than two hours, it is critical to be able to predict what will happen in
this time frame, to avoid time losses due to sudden changes in the turbulence
conditions, and also to enable more aggressive scheduling. We therefore
investigate here the possibility to forecast the turbulence conditions over the
next two hours. We call this "turbulence nowcasting", analogously with weather
nowcasting, a term already used in meteorology coming from the contraction of
"now" and "forecasting". We present here the results of a study based on
historical data of the Paranal Astronomical Site Monitoring combined with
ancillary data, in a machine learning framework. We show the strengths and
shortcomings of such an approach, and present some perspectives in the context
of the Extremely Large Telescope.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.01785 [pdf] - 1842642
Site selection for the 3.4m optical telescope of the Iranian National
Observatory
Submitted: 2019-03-05
The Results of the site selection campaign conducted for the proposed 3.4m
optical telescope of the Iranian National Observatory are reported. During the
first 3 years, among 33 nominated regions throughout the country, the potential
regions were confined to four provinces, namely, Southern Khorasan located in
the East, Kerman in the South East and Qom and Esfahan in the central part by
examining the long-term meteorological and geographical parameters. Over the
following 3 years, after astro-climate considerations and short-term
atmospheric seeing measurements using differential image motion monitor (DIMM)
technique were carried out, four candidate sites were selected among these
regions. Simultaneous seeing measurements were carried out on the four
candidate sites and finally, the Dinava located at the common border of the
Esfahan and Qom provinces and Gargash in Kashan region were selected as the
most promising sites. Continuous seeing measurements during 23 months yielded a
median value of about 1.0" for both sites. The latitude and longitude of the
Dinava are 50, 54 E and 34, 09 N, respectively and is situated at an altitude
of about 3000 m and about 57 Km direct from Qom towards the south. The latitude
and longitude of the Gargash are 51, 19 E and 33, 40 N, respectively and is
situated at an altitude of about 3600 m and about 37km direct from Kashan
towards the south. With two sites in hand, further comparative measurements of
seeing and weather data continued at the two sites, which resulted in the
selection of the Gargash site for the construction of the Iranian National
Observatory.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.04013 [pdf] - 1842534
Precipitable Water Vapor, Temperature, and Wind Statistics At Sites
Suitable for mm and Submm Wavelength Astronomy in Northern Chile
Otarola, Angel;
De Breuck, Carlos;
Travouillon, Tony;
Matsushita, Satoki;
Nyman, Lars-Åke;
Wootten, Al;
Radford, Simon J. E.;
Sarazin, Marc;
Kerber, Florian;
Pérez-Beaupuits, Juan P.
Submitted: 2019-02-11
Atmospheric water vapor is the main limiting factor of atmospheric
transparency in the mm and submm wavelength spectral windows. Thus, dry sites
are needed for the installation and successful operation of radio astronomy
observatories exploiting those spectral windows. Temperature and wind are
variables of special consideration when planning the installation and operation
of large-aperture radio telescopes, as these parameters affect the mechanical
response of radio telescopes exposed to the environmental conditions.
Temperature, and in particular temperature gradients, induce thermal
deformation of mechanical structures, while high wind speeds and gusts induce
pointing jitter affecting the tracking accuracy of astronomical sources during
the observations. This work summarizes the statistics of precipitable water
vapor (PWV), temperature, and wind monitored at sites by the coastal mountain
range, as well as on the west slope of the Andes mountain range in the region
of Antofagasta, Chile. This information could prove useful for the planning of
extended baselines for the Atacama Large Millimeter and Submillimeter Array
(ALMA), and/or new radio telescope projects, such as the Atacama Large Aperture
Submm/ mm Telescope (AtLAST) initiative.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.08005 [pdf] - 1754392
Atmospheric turbulence forecasting with a General Circulation Model for
Cerro Paranal
Submitted: 2018-09-21
In addition to astro-meteorological parameters, such as seeing, coherence
time and isoplanatic angle, the vertical profile of the Earth's atmospheric
turbulence strength and velocity is important for instrument design,
performance validation and monitoring, and observation scheduling and
management. Here we compare these astro-meteorological parameters as well as
the vertical profile itself from a forecast model based on a General
Circulation Model from the European Centre for Median range Weather Forecasts
and the stereo-SCIDAR, a high-sensitivity turbulence profiling instrument in
regular operation at Paranal, Chile. The model is fast to process as no spatial
nesting or data manipulation is performed. This speed enables the model to be
reactive based on the most up to date forecasts. We find that the model is
statistically consistent with measurements from stereo-SCIDAR. The correlation
of the median turbulence profile from the model and the measurement is 0.98. We
also find that the distributions of astro-meteorological parameters are
consistent. We compare contemporaneous measurements and show that the free
atmosphere seeing, isoplanatic angle and coherence time have correlation values
of 0.64, 0.40 and 0.63 respectively. We show and compare the profile sequences
from a large number of trial nights. We see that the model is able to forecast
the evolution of dominating features. In addition to smart scheduling, ensuring
that the most sensitive astronomical observations are scheduled for the optimum
time, this model could enable remote site characterisation using a large
archive of weather forecasts and could be used to optimise the performance of
wide-field AO system.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.07551 [pdf] - 1756086
Representative optical turbulence profiles for ESO Paranal by
hierarchical clustering
Submitted: 2018-09-20
Knowledge of the optical turbulence profile is important in adaptive optics
(AO) systems, particularly tomographic AO systems such as those to be employed
by the next generation of 40 m class extremely large telescopes (ELTs). Site
characterisation and monitoring campaigns have produced large quantities of
turbulence profiling data for sites around the world. However AO system design
and performance characterisation is dependent on Monte-Carlo simulations that
cannot make use of these large datasets due to long computation times. Here we
address the question of how to reduce these large datasets into small sets of
profiles that can feasibly be used in such Monte-Carlo simulations, whilst
minimising the loss of information inherent in this effective compression of
the data. We propose hierarchical clustering to partition the dataset according
to the structure of the turbulence profiles and extract a single profile from
each cluster. This method is applied to the Stereo-SCIDAR dataset from ESO
Paranal containing over 10000 measurements of the turbulence profile from 83
nights. We present two methods of extracting turbulence profiles from the
clusters, resulting in two sets of 18 profiles providing subtly different
descriptions of the variability across the entire dataset. For generality we
choose integrated parameters of the turbulence to measure the
representativeness of our profiles and compare to others. Using these criterion
we also show that such variability is difficult to capture with small sets of
profiles associated with integrated turbulence parameters such as seeing.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.05417 [pdf] - 1708277
Performance of the extreme-AO instrument VLT/SPHERE and dependence on
the atmospheric conditions
Milli, J.;
Mouillet, D.;
Fusco, T.;
Girard, J. H.;
Masciadri, E.;
Pena, E.;
Sauvage, J. -F.;
Reyes, C.;
Dohlen, K.;
Beuzit, J. -L.;
Kasper, M.;
Sarazin, M.;
Cantalloube, F.
Submitted: 2017-10-15, last modified: 2018-07-02
SPHERE is the high-contrast exoplanet imager and spectrograph installed at
the Unit Telescope 3 of the Very Large Telescope. After more than two years of
regular operations, we analyse statistically the performance of the adaptive
optics system and its dependence on the atmospheric conditions above the
Paranal observatory, as measured by the suite of dedicated instruments which
are part of the Astronomical Site Monitor and as estimated by the SPHERE
real-time calculator. We also explain how this information can be used to
schedule the observations in order to yield the best data quality and to guide
the astronomer when processing his/her data.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1806.02585 [pdf] - 1698282
Optical turbulence profiling with Stereo-SCIDAR for VLT and ELT
Osborn, J.;
Wilson, R. W.;
Sarazin, M.;
Butterley, T.;
Chacón, A.;
Derie, F.;
Farley, O. J. D.;
Haubois, X.;
Laidlaw, D.;
LeLouarn, M.;
Masciadri, E.;
Milli, J.;
Navarrete, J.;
Townson, M. J.
Submitted: 2018-06-07
Knowledge of the Earth's atmospheric optical turbulence is critical for
astronomical instrumentation. Not only does it enable performance verification
and optimisation of existing systems but it is required for the design of
future instruments. As a minimum this includes integrated astro-atmospheric
parameters such as seeing, coherence time and isoplanatic angle, but for more
sophisticated systems such as wide field adaptive optics enabled
instrumentation the vertical structure of the turbulence is also required.
Stereo-SCIDAR is a technique specifically designed to characterise the
Earth's atmospheric turbulence with high altitude resolution and high
sensitivity. Together with ESO, Durham University has commissioned a
Stereo-SCIDAR instrument at Cerro Paranal, Chile, the site of the Very Large
Telescope (VLT), and only 20~km from the site of the future Extremely Large
Telescope (ELT).
Here we provide results from the first 18 months of operation at ESO Paranal
including instrument comparisons and atmospheric statistics. Based on a sample
of 83 nights spread over 22 months covering all seasons, we find the median
seeing to be 0.64" with 50% of the turbulence confined to an altitude below 2
km and 40% below 600 m. The median coherence time and isoplanatic angle are
found as 4.18 ms and 1.75" respectively.
A substantial campaign of inter-instrument comparison was also undertaken to
assure the validity of the data. The Stereo-SCIDAR profiles (optical turbulence
strength and velocity as a function of altitude) have been compared with the
Surface-Layer SLODAR, MASS-DIMM and the ECMWF weather forecast model. The
correlation coefficients are between 0.61 (isoplanatic angle) and 0.84
(seeing).
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1208.3824 [pdf] - 1150765
Comparison of the scintillation noise above different observatories
measured with MASS instruments
Submitted: 2012-08-19
Scintillation noise is a major limitation of ground base photometric
precision. An extensive dataset of stellar scintillation collected at 11
astronomical sites world-wide with MASS instruments was used to estimate the
scintillation noise of large telescopes in the case of fast photometry and
traditional long-exposure regime. Statistical distributions of the
corresponding parameters are given. The scintillation noise is mostly
determined by turbulence and wind in the upper atmosphere and comparable at all
sites, with slightly smaller values at Mauna Kea and largest noise at Tolonchar
in Chile. We show that the classical Young's formula under-estimates the
scintillation noise.The temporal variations of the scintillation noise are also
similar at all sites, showing short-term variability at time scales of 1 -- 2
hours and slower variations, including marked seasonal trends (stronger
scintillation and less clear sky during local winter). Some correlation was
found between nearby observatories.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.4229 [pdf] - 1124915
European Extremely Large Telescope Site Characterization II: High
angular resolution parameters
Ramió, Héctor Vázquez;
Vernin, Jean;
Muñoz-Tuñón, Casiana;
Sarazin, Marc;
Varela, Antonia M.;
Trinquet, Hervé;
Delgado, José Miguel;
Fuensalida, Jesús J.;
Reyes, Marcos;
Benhida, Abdelmajid;
Benkhaldoun, Zouhair;
Lambas, Diego García;
Hach, Youssef;
Lazrek, M.;
Lombardi, Gianluca;
Navarrete, Julio;
Recabarren, Pablo;
Renzi, Victor;
Sabil, Mohammed;
Vrech, Rubén
Submitted: 2012-07-17
This is the second article of a series devoted to European Extremely Large
Telescope (E-ELT) site characterization. In this article we present the main
properties of the parameters involved in high angular resolution observations
from the data collected in the site testing campaign of the E-ELT during the
Design Study (DS) phase. Observations were made in 2008 and 2009, in the four
sites selected to shelter the future E-ELT (characterized under the ELT-DS
contract): Aklim mountain in Morocco, Observatorio del Roque de los Muchachos
(ORM) in Spain, Mac\'on range in Argentina, and Cerro Ventarrones in Chile. The
same techniques, instruments and acquisition procedures were taken on each
site. A Multiple Aperture Scintillation Sensor (MASS) and a Differential Image
Motion Monitor (DIMM) were installed at each site. Global statistics of the
integrated seeing, the free atmosphere seeing, the boundary layer seeing and
the isoplanatic angle were studied for each site, and the results are presented
here. In order to estimate other important parameters such as the coherence
time of the wavefront and the overall parameter "coherence \'etendue"
additional information of vertical profiles of the wind speed was needed. Data
were retrieved from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)
archive. Ground wind speed was measured by Automatic Weather Stations (AWS).
More aspects of the turbulence parameters such as their seasonal trend, their
nightly evolution and their temporal stability were also obtained and analyzed.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1201.2330 [pdf] - 1092874
Active optics Shack-Hartmann sensor: using spot sizes to measure the
seeing at the focal plane of a telescope
Submitted: 2012-01-11
Real-time seeing estimation at the focus of a telescope is nowadays strongly
emphasized as this knowledge virtually drives the dimensioning of adaptive
optics systems and instrument operational aspects. In this context we study the
interest of using active optics Shack-Hartmann (AOSH) sensor images to provide
accurate estimate of the seeing. The AOSH practically delivers long exposure
spot PSFs -- at the critical location of the telescope focus -- being directly
related to the atmospheric seeing in the line of sight. Although AOSH sensors
are not specified to measure spot sizes but slopes, we show that accurate
seeing estimation from AOSH images can be obtained with a dedicated algorithm.
The sensitivity and comparison of two algorithms to various parameters is
analyzed in a systematic way, demonstrating that efficient estimation of the
seeing can be obtained by adequate means.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1110.3820 [pdf] - 1084919
Comparing radial velocities of atmospheric lines with radiosonde
measurements
Submitted: 2011-10-17
The precision of radial velocity (RV) measurements depends on the precision
attained on the wavelength calibration. One of the available options is using
atmospheric lines as a natural, freely available wavelength reference. Figueira
et al. (2010) measured the RV of O2 lines using HARPS and showed that the
scatter was only of ~10 m/s over a timescale of 6 yr. Using a simple but
physically motivated empirical model, they demonstrated a precision of 2 m/s,
roughly twice the average photon noise contribution. In this paper we take
advantage of a unique opportunity to confirm the sensitivity of the telluric
absorption lines RV to different atmospheric and observing conditions: by means
of contemporaneous in-situ wind measurements by radiosondes.
The RV model fitting yielded similar results to that of Figueira et al.
(2010), with lower wind magnitude values and varied wind direction. The probes
confirmed the average low wind magnitude and suggested that the average wind
direction is a function of time as well. The two approaches deliver the same
results in what concerns wind magnitude and agree on wind direction when
fitting is done in segments of a couple of hours. Statistical tests show that
the model provides a good description of the data on all timescales, being
always preferable to not fitting any atmospheric variation. The smaller the
timescale on which the fitting can be performed (down to a couple of hours),
the better the description of the real physical parameters. We conclude then
that the two methods deliver compatible results, down to better than 5 m/s and
less than twice the estimated photon noise contribution on O2 lines RV
measurement. However, we cannot rule out that parameters alpha and gamma
(dependence on airmass and zero-point, respectively) have a dependence on time
or exhibit some cross-talk with other parameters (abridged).
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1003.4593 [pdf] - 1025904
Atmospheric image blur with finite outer scale or partial adaptive
correction
Submitted: 2010-03-24
Seeing-limited resolution in large telescopes working over wide wavelength
range depends substantially on the turbulence outer scale and cannot be
adequately described by one "seeing" value. We attempt to clarify frequent
confusions on this matter. We study the effects of finite turbulence outer
scale and partial adaptive corrections by means of analytical calculations and
numerical simulations. If a von Karman turbulence model is adopted, a simple
approximate formula captures the dependence of atmospheric long-exposure
resolution on the outer scale over the entire practically interesting range of
telescope diameters and wavelengths. In the infrared (IR), the difference with
the standard Kolmogorov seeing formula can exceed a factor of two. We find that
low-order adaptive turbulence correction produces residual wave-fronts with
effectively small outer scale, so even very low compensation order leads to a
substantial improvement in resolution over seeing, compared to the standard
theory. Seeing-limited resolution of large telescopes, especially in the IR, is
currently under-estimated by not accounting for the outer scale. On the other
hand, adaptive-optics systems designed for diffraction-limited imaging in the
IR can improve the resolution in the visible by as much as two times.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:0704.0470 [pdf] - 90
Testing turbulence model at metric scales with mid-infrared VISIR images
at the VLT
Submitted: 2007-04-03
We probe turbulence structure from centimetric to metric scales by
simultaneous imagery at mid-infrared and visible wavelengths at the VLT
telescope and show that it departs significantly from the commonly used
Kolmogorov model. The data can be fitted by the von Karman model with an outer
scale of the order of 30 m and we see clear signs of the phase structure
function saturation across the 8-m VLT aperture. The image quality improves in
the infrared faster than the standard lambda^{-1/5} scaling and may be
diffraction-limited at 30-m apertures even without adaptive optics at
wavelengths longer than 8 micron.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0703119 [pdf] - 89928
A method of estimating time scales of atmospheric piston and its
application at DomeC (Antarctica)
Submitted: 2007-03-06
Temporal fluctuations of the atmospheric piston are critical for
interferometers as they determine their sensitivity. We characterize an
instrumental set-up, termed the piston scope, that aims at measuring the
atmospheric time constant, tau0, through the image motion in the focal plane of
a Fizeau interferometer. High-resolution piston scope measurements have been
obtained at the observatory of Paranal, Chile, in April 2006. The derived
atmospheric parameters are shown to be consistent with data from the
astronomical site monitor, provided that the atmospheric turbulence is
displaced along a single direction. Piston scope measurements, of lower
temporal and spatial resolution, were for the first time recorded in February
2005 at the Antarctic site of DomeC. Their re-analysis in terms of the new data
calibration sharpens the conclusions of a first qualitative examination.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0309002 [pdf] - 58829
High altitude wind velocity at San Pedro Martir and Mauna Kea
Submitted: 2003-08-29, last modified: 2003-09-03
We analyze the monthly average wind velocity at about 12 km above sea level,
between 1980 to 1995, for San Pedro Martir, Mauna Kea, another existing
observatorie and some sites of interest. We compare the results obtained from
two different data sets, the GGUAS and NCEP. Our results show that San Pedro
Martir and Mauna Kea are comparable and are amongst the most suitable sites to
apply slow wavefront corrugation correction techniques
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0103345 [pdf] - 41562
The Optical/Infrared Astronomical Quality of High Atacama Sites. I.
Preliminary Results of Optical Seeing
Giovanelli, Riccardo;
Darling, Jeremy;
Sarazin, Marc;
Yu, Jennifer;
Harvey, Paul;
Henderson, Charles;
Hoffman, William;
Keller, Luke;
Barry, Don;
Cordes, James;
Eikenberry, Stephen;
Gull, George;
Harrington, Joseph;
Smith, J. D.;
Stacey, Gordon;
Swain, Mark
Submitted: 2001-03-21
The region surrounding the Llano de Chajnantor, a high altitude plateau in
the Atacama Desert in northern Chile, has caught the attention of the
astronomical community for its potential as an observatory site. Combining high
elevation and extremely low atmospheric water content, the Llano has been
chosen as the future site of the Atacama Large Millimeter Array. We have
initiated a campaign to investigate the astronomical potential of the region in
the optical/infrared. Here, we report on an aspect of our campaign aimed at
establishing a seeing benchmark to be used as a reference for future activities
in the region. After a brief description of the region and its climate, we
describe the results of an astronomical seeing campaign, carried out with a
Differential Image Motion Monitor that operates at 0.5 micron wavelength. The
seeing at the Llano level of 5000 m, measured over 7 nights in May 1998,
yielded a median FWHM of 1.1". However, the seeing decreased to 0.7" at a
modest 100 m gain above the plateau (Cerro Chico), as measured over 38 nights
spread between July 1998 and October 2000. Neither of these represents the best
seeing expected in the region; the set of measurements provides a reference
base for simultaneous dual runs at Cerro Chico and at other sites of interest
in the region, currently underway. A comparison between simultaneous
measurements at Cerro Chico and Cerro Paranal indicates that seeing at Cerro
Chico is about 12% better than at Paranal. The percentage of optically
photometric nights in the Chajnantor region is about 60%, while that of nights
useful for astronomical work is near 80%.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0004065 [pdf] - 35424
New challenges for Adaptive Optics: Extremely Large Telescopes
Submitted: 2000-04-05
The performance of an adaptive optics (AO) system on a 100m diameter ground
based telescope working in the visible range of the spectrum is computed using
an analytical approach. The target Strehl ratio of 60% is achieved at 0.5um
with a limiting magnitude of the AO guide source near R~10, at the cost of an
extremely low sky coverage. To alleviate this problem, the concept of
tomographic wavefront sensing in a wider field of view using either natural
guide stars (NGS) or laser guide stars (LGS) is investigated. These methods use
3 or 4 reference sources and up to 3 deformable mirrors, which increase up to
8-fold the corrected field size (up to 60\arcsec at 0.5 um). Operation with
multiple NGS is limited to the infrared (in the J band this approach yields a
sky coverage of 50% with a Strehl ratio of 0.2). The option of open-loop
wavefront correction in the visible using several bright NGS is discussed. The
LGS approach involves the use of a faint (R ~22) NGS for low-order correction,
which results in a sky coverage of 40% at the Galactic poles in the visible.