Normalized to: Sanderson, A.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1406.3362 [pdf] - 1210134
Optically selected fossil groups; X-ray observations and galaxy
properties
Submitted: 2014-06-12
We report on the X-ray and optical observations of galaxy groups selected
from the 2dfGRS group catalog, to explore the possibility that galaxy groups
hosting a giant elliptical galaxy and a large optical luminosity gap present
between the two brightest group galaxies, can be associated with an extended
X-ray emission, similar to that observed in fossil galaxy groups. The X-ray
observations of 4 galaxy groups were carried out with Chandra telescope with
10-20 ksec exposure time. Combining the X-ray and the optical observations we
find evidences for the presence of a diffuse extended X-ray emission beyond the
optical size of the brightest group galaxy. Taking both the X-ray and the
optical criteria, one of the groups is identified as a fossil group and one is
ruled out because of the contamination in the earlier optical selection. For
the two remaining systems, the X-ay luminosity threshold is close to the
convention know for fossil groups. In all cases the X-ray luminosity is below
the expected value from the X-ray selected fossils for a given optical
luminosity of the group. A rough estimation for the comoving number density of
fossil groups is obtained and found to be in broad agreement with the
estimations from observations of X-ray selected fossils and predictions of
cosmological simulations.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1307.1135 [pdf] - 1172482
LoCuSS: The steady decline and slow quenching of star formation in
cluster galaxies over the last four billion years
Haines, C. P.;
Pereira, M. J.;
Smith, G. P.;
Egami, E.;
Sanderson, A. J. R.;
Babul, A.;
Finoguenov, A.;
Merluzzi, P.;
Busarello, G.;
Rawle., T. D.;
Okabe, N.
Submitted: 2013-07-03
We present an analysis of the levels and evolution of star formation activity
in a representative sample of 30 massive galaxy clusters at 0.15<z<0.30 from
the Local Cluster Substructure Survey (LoCuSS), combining wide-field Spitzer
24um data with extensive spectroscopy of cluster members. The specific-SFRs of
massive (M>10^10 M_sun) star-forming cluster galaxies within r200 are found to
be systematically 28% lower than their counterparts in the field at fixed
stellar mass and redshift, a difference significant at the 8.7-sigma level.
This is the unambiguous signature of star formation in most (and possibly all)
massive star-forming galaxies being slowly quenched upon accretion into massive
clusters, their SFRs declining exponentially on quenching time-scales in the
range 0.7-2.0 Gyr. We measure the mid-infrared Butcher-Oemler effect over the
redshift range 0.0-0.4, finding rapid evolution in the fraction (f_SF) of
massive (M_K<-23.1) cluster galaxies within r200 with SFRs>3M_sun/yr, of the
form f_SF (1+z)^7.6. We dissect the origins of the Butcher-Oemler effect,
revealing it to be due to the combination of a ~3x decline in the mean
specific-SFRs of star-forming cluster galaxies since z~0.3 with a ~1.5x
decrease in number density. Two-thirds of this reduction in the specific-SFRs
of star-forming cluster galaxies is due to the steady cosmic decline in the
specific-SFRs among those field galaxies accreted into the clusters. The
remaining one-third reflects an accelerated decline in the star formation
activity of galaxies within clusters. The slow quenching of star-formation in
cluster galaxies is consistent with a gradual shut down of star formation in
infalling spiral galaxies as they interact with the intra-cluster medium via
ram-pressure stripping or starvation mechanisms. We find no evidence for the
build-up of cluster S0 bulges via major nuclear star-burst episodes.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1212.1613 [pdf] - 1158361
The baryon budget on the galaxy group/cluster boundary
Submitted: 2012-12-07
We present a study of the hot gas and stellar content of 5 optically-selected
poor galaxy clusters, including a full accounting of the contribution from
intracluster light (ICL) and a combined hot gas and hydrostatic X-ray mass
analysis with XMM observations. We find weighted mean stellar (including ICL),
gas and total baryon mass fractions within r500 of 0.026+/-0.003, 0.070+/-0.005
and 0.096+/-0.006, respectively, at a corresponding weighted mean M500 of
(1.08_{-0.18}^{+0.21}) x 10^14 Msun. Even when accounting for the intracluster
stars, 4 out of 5 clusters show evidence for a substantial baryon deficit
within r500, with baryon fractions (f_bary) between 50+/-6 to 59+/-8 per cent
of the Universal mean level (i.e. Omega_b / Omega_m); the remaining cluster
having f_bary = 75+/-11 per cent. For the 3 clusters where we can trace the hot
halo to r500 we find no evidence for a steepening of the gas density profile in
the outskirts with respect to a power law, as seen in more massive clusters. We
find that in all cases, the X-ray mass measurements are larger than those
originally published on the basis of the galaxy velocity dispersion (sigma) and
an assumed sigma-M500 relation, by a factor of 1.7-5.7. Despite these increased
masses, the stellar fractions (in the range 0.016-0.034, within r500) remain
consistent with the trend with mass published by Gonzalez, Zaritsky & Zabludoff
(2007), from which our sample is drawn.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1107.5115 [pdf] - 1078213
LoCuSS: The Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect and Weak Lensing Mass Scaling
Relation
Marrone, Daniel P.;
Smith, Graham P.;
Okabe, Nobuhiro;
Bonamente, Massimiliano;
Carlstrom, John E.;
Culverhouse, Thomas L.;
Gralla, Megan;
Greer, Christopher H.;
Hasler, Nicole;
Hawkins, David;
Hennessy, Ryan;
Joy, Marshall;
Lamb, James W.;
Leitch, Erik M.;
Martino, Rossella;
Mazzotta, Pasquale;
Miller, Amber;
Mroczkowski, Tony;
Muchovej, Stephen;
Plagge, Thomas;
Pryke, Clem;
Sanderson, Alastair J. R.;
Takada, Masahiro;
Woody, David;
Zhang, Yu-Ying
Submitted: 2011-07-26, last modified: 2012-07-17
We present the first weak-lensing-based scaling relation between galaxy
cluster mass, M_wl, and integrated Compton parameter Y_sph. Observations of 18
galaxy clusters at z~0.2 were obtained with the Subaru 8.2-m telescope and the
Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Array. The M_wl-Y_sph scaling relations, measured at
Delta=500, 1000, and 2500 rho_c, are consistent in slope and normalization with
previous results derived under the assumption of hydrostatic equilibrium (HSE).
We find an intrinsic scatter in M_wl at fixed Y_sph of 20%, larger than both
previous measurements of M_HSE-Y_sph scatter as well as the scatter in true
mass at fixed Y_sph found in simulations. Moreover, the scatter in our
lensing-based scaling relations is morphology dependent, with 30-40% larger
M_wl for undisturbed compared to disturbed clusters at the same Y_sph at r_500.
Further examination suggests that the segregation may be explained by the
inability of our spherical lens models to faithfully describe the
three-dimensional structure of the clusters, in particular, the structure along
the line-of-sight. We find that the ellipticity of the brightest cluster
galaxy, a proxy for halo orientation, correlates well with the offset in mass
from the mean scaling relation, which supports this picture. This provides
empirical evidence that line-of-sight projection effects are an important
systematic uncertainty in lensing-based scaling relations.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1205.6818 [pdf] - 1123786
LoCuSS: A Dynamical Analysis of X-ray AGN in Local Clusters
Haines, C. P.;
Pereira, M. J.;
Sanderson, A. J. R.;
Smith, G. P.;
Egami, E.;
Babul, A.;
Edge, A. C.;
Finoguenov, A.;
Moran, S. M.;
Okabe, N.
Submitted: 2012-05-30
We present a study of the distribution of X-ray AGN in a representative
sample of 26 massive clusters at 0.15<z<0.30, combining Chandra observations
with highly complete spectroscopy of cluster members down to M_K*+2. In total
we identify 48 X-ray AGN among the cluster members, with luminosities
2x10^41-1x10^44erg/s. In the stacked caustic diagram, the X-ray AGN appear to
preferentially lie along the caustics, suggestive of an infalling population.
They also appear to avoid the region with lowest cluster-centric radii and
relative velocities (r_proj<0.4 r_500; |v-<v>|/sigma_v<0.8), which is dominated
by the virialized population of galaxies accreted earliest into the clusters.
Moreover the velocity dispersion of the 48 X-ray AGN is 1.51x that of the
overall cluster population, which is consistent with the sqrt(2) ratio expected
by simple energetic arguments when comparing infalling versus virialized
populations. This kinematic segregation is significant at the 4.66-sigma level.
When splitting the X-ray AGN sample into two according to X-ray or infrared
(IR) luminosity, both X-ray bright and IR-bright sub-samples show higher
velocity dispersions than their X-ray dim and IR-dim counterparts at >2sigma
significance. This is consistent with the nuclear activity responsible for the
X-ray and IR emission being slowly shut down as the host galaxies are accreted
into the cluster. Overall our results provide the strongest observational
evidence to date that X-ray AGN found in massive clusters are an infalling
population, and that the cluster environment very effectively suppresses
radiatively-efficient nuclear activity in its member galaxies. These results
are consistent with the view that for galaxies to host an X-ray AGN they should
be the central galaxy within their dark matter halo and have a ready supply of
cold gas.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1101.3317 [pdf] - 1051483
Abundance profiles and cool cores in galaxy groups
Submitted: 2011-01-17
Using data from the Two Dimensional XMM-Newton Group Survey (2dXGS), we have
examined the abundance profile properties of both cool core (CC) and non cool
core (NCC) galaxy groups. The ten NCC systems in our sample represent a
population which to date has been poorly studied in the group regime. Fitting
the abundance profiles as a linear function of log radius, we find steep
abundance gradients in cool core (CC) systems, with a slope of -0.54+/-0.07. In
contrast, non cool core (NCC) groups have profiles consistent with uniform
metallicity. Many CC groups show a central abundance dip or plateau, and we
find evidence for anticorrelation between the core abundance gradient and the
1.4 GHz radio power of the brightest group galaxy (BGG) in CC systems. This may
indicate the effect of AGN-driven mixing within the central ~0.1r_500. It is
not possible to discern whether such behaviour is present in the NCC groups,
due to the small and diverse sample with the requisite radio data. The lack of
strong abundance gradients in NCC groups, coupled with their lack of cool core,
and evidence for enhanced substructure, leads us to favour merging as the
mechanism for disrupting cool cores, although we cannot rule out disruption by
a major AGN outburst. Given the implied timescales, the disruptive event must
have occurred within the past few Gyrs in most NCC groups.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1007.2196 [pdf] - 1033668
LoCuSS: Connecting the Dominance and Shape of Brightest Cluster Galaxies
with the Assembly History of Massive Clusters
Submitted: 2010-07-13
We study the luminosity gap, dm12, between the first and second ranked
galaxies in a sample of 59 massive galaxy clusters, using data from the Hale
Telescope, HST, Chandra, and Spitzer. We find that the dm12 distribution,
p(dm12), is a declining function of dm12, to which we fitted a straight line:
p(dm12) propto -(0.13+/-0.02)dm12. The fraction of clusters with "large"
luminosity gaps is p(dm12>=1)=0.37+/-0.08, which represents a 3sigma excess
over that obtained from Monte Carlo simulations of a Schechter function that
matches the mean cluster galaxy luminosity function. We also identify four
clusters with "extreme" luminosity gaps, dm12>=2, giving a fraction of
p(dm12>=2)=0.07+0.05-0.03. More generally, large luminosity gap clusters are
relatively homogeneous, with elliptical/disky brightest cluster galaxies
(BCGs), cuspy gas density profiles (i.e. strong cool cores), high
concentrations, and low substructure fractions. In contrast, small luminosity
gap clusters are heterogeneous, spanning the full range of
boxy/elliptical/disky BCG morphologies, the full range of cool core strengths
and dark matter concentrations, and have large substructure fractions. Taken
together, these results imply that the amplitude of the luminosity gap is a
function of both the formation epoch, and the recent infall history of the
cluster. "BCG dominance" is therefore a phase that a cluster may evolve
through, and is not an evolutionary "cul-de-sac". We also compare our results
with semi-analytic model predictions based on the Millennium Simulation. None
of the models are able to reproduce all of the observational results,
underlining the inability of current models to match the empirical properties
of BCGs. We identify the strength of AGN feedback and the efficiency with which
cluster galaxies are replenished after they merge with the BCG in each model as
possible causes of these discrepancies. [Abridged]
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1005.3816 [pdf] - 1032646
LoCuSS: Probing Galaxy Transformation Physics with Herschel
Smith, G. P.;
Haines, C. P.;
Pereira, M. J.;
Egami, E.;
Moran, S. M.;
Hardegree-Ullman, E.;
Babul, A.;
Rex, M.;
Rawle, T. D.;
Zhang, Y. -Y.;
Finoguenov, A.;
Okabe, N.;
Sanderson, A. J. R.;
Edge, A. C.;
Takada, M.
Submitted: 2010-05-20
We present an early broad-brush analysis of Herschel/PACS observations of
star-forming galaxies in 8 galaxy clusters drawn from our survey of 30 clusters
at z~0.2. We define a complete sample of 192 spectroscopically confirmed
cluster members down to L_TIR>3x10^10L_sun and L_K>0.25L_sun. The average
K-band and bolometric infrared luminosities of these galaxies both fade by a
factor of ~2 from clustercentric radii of 2r_200 to ~0.5r_200, indicating that
as galaxies enter the clusters ongoing star-formation stops first in the most
massive galaxies, and that the specific star-formation rate (SSFR) is
conserved. On smaller scales the average SSFR jumps by 25%, suggesting that in
cluster cores processes including ram pressure stripping may trigger a final
episode of star-formation that presumably exhausts the remaining gas. This
picture is consistent with our comparison of the Herschel-detected cluster
members with the cluster mass distributions, as measured in our previous
weak-lensing study of these clusters. For example, the spatial distribution of
the Herschel sources is positively correlated with the structures in the
weak-lensing mass maps at 5sigma significance, with the strongest signal seen
at intermediate group-like densities. The strong dependence of the total
cluster IR luminosity on cluster mass L_TIR propto M_virial^2 is also
consistent with accretion of galaxies and groups of galaxies (i.e. the
substructure mass function) driving the cluster IR luminosity. The most
surprising result is that roughly half of the Herschel-detected cluster members
have redder S_100/S_24 flux ratios than expected, based on the Rieke et al.
models. On average cluster members are redder than non-members, and the
fraction of red galaxies increases towards the cluster centers, both of which
indicate that these colors are not attributable to systematic photometric
errors. [Abridged]
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1001.0780 [pdf] - 123297
LoCuSS: A Comparison of Cluster Mass Measurements from XMM-Newton and
Subaru - Testing Deviation from Hydrostatic Equilibrium and Non-Thermal
Pressure Support
Zhang, Yu-Ying;
Okabe, Nobuhiro;
Finoguenov, Alexis;
Smith, Graham P.;
Piffaretti, Rocco;
Valdarnini, Riccardo;
Babul, Arif;
Evrard, August E.;
Mazzotta, Pasquale;
Sanderson, Alastair J. R.;
Marrone, Daniel P.
Submitted: 2010-01-05, last modified: 2010-02-23
We compare X-ray hydrostatic and weak-lensing mass estimates for a sample of
12 clusters that have been observed with both XMM-Newton and Subaru. At an
over-density of \Delta=500, we obtain 1-M^{X}/M^{WL}=0.01+/-0.07 for the whole
sample. We also divided the sample into undisturbed and disturbed sub-samples
based on quantitative X-ray morphologies using asymmetry and fluctuation
parameters, obtaining 1-M^{X}/M^{WL}=0.09+/-0.06 and -0.06+/-0.12 for the
undisturbed and disturbed clusters, respectively. In addition to non-thermal
pressure support, there may be a competing effect associated with adiabatic
compression and/or shock heating which leads to overestimate of X-ray
hydrostatic masses for disturbed clusters, for example, in the famous merging
cluster A1914. Despite the modest statistical significance of the mass
discrepancy, on average, in the undisturbed clusters, we detect a clear trend
of improving agreement between M^{X} and M^{WL} as a function of increasing
over-density, M^{X}/M^{WL}=(0.908+/-0.004)+(0.187+/-0.010) \log_{10}(\Delta
/500). We also examine the gas mass fractions, f_{gas}=M^{gas}/M^{WL}, finding
that they are an increasing function of cluster radius, with no dependence on
dynamical state, in agreement with predictions from numerical simulations.
Overall, our results demonstrate that XMM-Newton and Subaru are a powerful
combination for calibrating systematic uncertainties in cluster mass
measurements.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.3302 [pdf] - 1018400
LoCuSS: First Results from Strong-lensing Analysis of 20 Massive Galaxy
Clusters at z~0.2
Richard, Johan;
Smith, Graham P.;
Kneib, Jean-Paul;
Ellis, Richard;
Sanderson, Alastair J. R.;
Pei, Liuyi;
Targett, Thomas;
Sand, David;
Swinbank, Mark;
Dannerbauer, Helmut;
Mazzotta, Pasquale;
Limousin, Marceau;
Egami, Eiichi;
Jullo, Eric;
Hamilton-Morris, Victoria;
Moran, Sean
Submitted: 2009-11-17, last modified: 2010-01-05
We present a statistical analysis of a sample of 20 strong lensing clusters
drawn from the Local Cluster Substructure Survey (LoCuSS), based on high
resolution Hubble Space Telescope imaging of the cluster cores and follow-up
spectroscopic observations using the Keck-I telescope. We use detailed
parameterized models of the mass distribution in the cluster cores, to measure
the total cluster mass and fraction of that mass associated with substructures
within R<250kpc.These measurements are compared with the distribution of
baryons in the cores, as traced by the old stellar populations and the X-ray
emitting intracluster medium. Our main results include: (i) the distribution of
Einstein radii is log-normal, with a peak and 1sigma width of
<log(RE(z=2))>=1.16+/-0.28; (ii) we detect an X-ray/lensing mass discrepancy of
<M_SL/M_X>=1.3 at 3 sigma significance -- clusters with larger substructure
fractions displaying greater mass discrepancies, and thus greater departures
from hydrostatic equilibrium; (iii) cluster substructure fraction is also
correlated with the slope of the gas density profile on small scales, implying
a connection between cluster-cluster mergers and gas cooling. Overall our
results are consistent with the view that cluster-cluster mergers play a
prominent role in shaping the properties of cluster cores, in particular
causing departures from hydrostatic equilibrium, and possibly disturbing cool
cores. Our results do not support recent claims that large Einstein radius
clusters present a challenge to the CDM paradigm.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.1848 [pdf] - 1018699
Hydrodynamic simulations of correlation and scatter in galaxy cluster
maps
Submitted: 2009-12-09
The two dimensional structure of hot gas in galaxy clusters contains
information about the hydrodynamical state of the cluster, which can be used to
understand the origin of scatter in the thermodynamical properties of the gas,
and to improve the use of clusters to probe cosmology. Using a set of
hydrodynamical simulations, we provide a comparison between various maps
currently employed in the X-ray analysis of merging clusters and those cluster
maps anticipated from forthcoming observations of the thermal
Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect. We show the following: 1) an X-ray pseudo-pressure,
defined as square root of the soft band X-ray image times the temperature map
is a good proxy for the SZ map; 2) we find that clumpiness is the main reason
for deviation between X-ray pseudo-pressure and SZ maps; 3) the level of
clumpiness can be well characterized by X-ray pseudo-entropy maps. 4) We
describe the frequency of deviation in various maps of clusters as a function
of the amplitude of the deviation. This enables both a comparison to
observations and a comparison to effects of introduction of complex physical
processes into simulation.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:0910.3212 [pdf] - 1017981
X-ray modelling of galaxy cluster gas and mass profiles
Submitted: 2009-10-19
We present a parametric analysis of the intracluster medium and gravitating
mass distribution of a statistical sample of 20 galaxy clusters using the
phenomenological cluster model of Ascasibar and Diego. We describe an effective
scheme for the estimation of errors on model parameters and derived quantities
using bootstrap resampling. We find that the model provides a good description
of the data in all cases and we quantify the mean fractional intrinsic scatter
about the best-fit density and temperature profiles, finding this to have
median values across the sample of 2 and 5 per cent, respectively. In addition,
we demonstrate good agreement between r500 determined directly from the model
and that estimated from a core-excluded global spectrum. We compare cool core
and non-cool core clusters in terms of the logarithmic slopes of their gas
density and temperature profiles and the distribution of model parameters and
conclude that the two categories are clearly separable. In particular, we
confirm the effectiveness of the logarithmic gradient of the gas density
profile measured at 0.04 r500 in differentiating between the two types of
cluster.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:0908.3003 [pdf] - 1017156
LoCuSS: The mid-infrared Butcher-Oemler effect
Submitted: 2009-08-20
We study the mid-infrared (MIR) properties of galaxies in 30 massive galaxy
clusters at 0.02<z<0.40, using panoramic Spitzer/MIPS 24micron and NIR data.
This is the largest sample of clusters to date with MIR data covering not only
the cluster cores, but extending into the infall regions. We revisit the
Butcher-Oemler effect, measuring the fraction of massive infrared-luminous
galaxies (K<K*+1.5, L_IR>5x10^10L_sun) within r_200, finding a steady increase
in the fraction with redshift from ~3% at z=0.02 to ~10% by z=0.30, and an rms
cluster-to-cluster scatter about this trend of 0.03. The best-fit redshift
evolution model is of the form f_SF ~ (1+z)^5.7, which is stronger redshift
evolution than that of L*_IR in both clusters and the field. We find that,
statistically, this excess is associated with galaxies found at large
cluster-centric radii, implying that the MIR Butcher-Oemler effect can be
explained by a combination of both the global decline in star-formation in the
universe since z~1 and enhanced star formation in the infall regions of
clusters at intermediate redshifts. This picture is supported by a simple
infall model based on the Millennium Simulation semi-analytic galaxy catalogs,
whereby star-formation in infalling galaxies is instantaneously quenched upon
their first passage through the cluster, in that the observed radial trends of
f_SF trace those inferred from the simulations. We also find that f_SF does not
depend on simple indicators of the dynamical state of clusters, including the
offset between the brightest cluster galaxy and the peak of the X-ray emission.
This is consistent with the picture described above in that most new
star-formation in clusters occurs in the infall regions, and is thus not
sensitive to the details of cluster-cluster mergers in the core regions.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:0906.1808 [pdf] - 1002511
LoCuSS: the connection between brightest cluster galaxy activity, gas
cooling and dynamical disturbance of X-ray cluster cores
Submitted: 2009-06-10, last modified: 2009-06-11
We study the distribution of projected offsets between the cluster X-ray
centroid and the brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) for 65 X-ray selected clusters
from the Local Cluster Substructure Survey (LoCuSS), with a median redshift of
z=0.23. We find a clear correlation between X-ray/BCG projected offset and the
logarithmic slope of the cluster gas density profile at 0.04r500 (alpha),
implying that more dynamically disturbed clusters have weaker cool cores.
Furthermore, there is a close correspondence between the activity of the BCG,
in terms of detected H_alpha and radio emission, and the X-ray/BCG offset, with
the line emitting galaxies all residing in clusters with X-ray/BCG offsets of
<~15 kpc. Of the BCGs with alpha < -0.85 and an offset < 0.02r500, 96 per cent
(23/24) have optical emission and 88 per cent (21/24) are radio active, while
none has optical emission outside these criteria. We also study the cluster gas
fraction (fgas) within r500 and find a significant correlation with X-ray/BCG
projected offset. The mean fgas of the `small offset' clusters (< 0.02r500) is
0.106+/-0.005 (sigma=0.03) compared to 0.145+/-0.009 (sigma=0.04) for those
with an offset > 0.02r500, indicating that the total mass may be systematically
underestimated in clusters with larger X-ray/BCG offsets. Our results imply a
link between cool core strength and cluster dynamical state consistent with the
view that cluster mergers can significantly perturb cool cores, and set new
constraints on models of the evolution of the intracluster medium.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:0902.1747 [pdf] - 21219
A statistically-selected Chandra sample of 20 galaxy clusters -- II. Gas
properties and cool-core/non-cool core bimodality
Submitted: 2009-02-10
We investigate the thermodynamic and chemical structure of the intracluster
medium (ICM) across a statistical sample of 20 galaxy clusters analysed with
the Chandra X-ray satellite. In particular, we focus on the scaling properties
of the gas density, metallicity and entropy and the comparison between clusters
with and without cool cores (CCs). We find marked differences between the two
categories except for the gas metallicity, which declines strongly with radius
for all clusters (Z ~ r^{-0.31}), outside ~0.02 r500. The scaling of gas
entropy is non-self-similar and we find clear evidence of bimodality in the
distribution of logarithmic slopes of the entropy profiles. With only one
exception, the steeper sloped entropy profiles are found in CC clusters whereas
the flatter slope population are all non-CC clusters. We explore the role of
thermal conduction in stabilizing the ICM and conclude that this mechanism
alone is sufficient to balance cooling in non-CC clusters. However, CC clusters
appear to form a distinct population in which heating from feedback is required
in addition to conduction. Under the assumption that non-CC clusters are
thermally stabilized by conduction alone, we find the distribution of Spitzer
conduction suppression factors, f_c, to be log-normal, with a log (base 10)
mean of -1.50+/-0.03 (i.e. f_c=0.032) and log standard deviation 0.39+/-0.02.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:0801.3430 [pdf] - 1000610
Galaxy-cluster gas-density distributions of the Representative
XMM-Newton Cluster Structure Survey (REXCESS)
Croston, J. H.;
Pratt, G. W.;
Boehringer, H.;
Arnaud, M.;
Pointecouteau, E.;
Ponman, T. J.;
Sanderson, A. J. R.;
Temple, R. F.;
Bower, R. G.;
Donahue, M.
Submitted: 2008-01-22, last modified: 2008-05-06
We present a study of the structural and scaling properties of the gas
distributions in the intracluster medium (ICM) of 31 nearby (z < 0.2) clusters
observed with XMM-Newton, which together comprise the Representative XMM-Newton
Cluster Structure Survey (REXCESS). In contrast to previous studies, this
sample is unbiased with respect to cluster dynamical state, and it fully
samples the cluster X-ray luminosity function. The clusters cover a temperature
range of 2.0 -- 8.5 keV and possess a variety of morphologies. The sampling
strategy allows us to compare clusters with a wide range of central cooling
times on an equal footing. We present non-parametric gas-density profiles out
to distances ranging between 0.8 R_500 and 1.5 R_500. The central gas densities
differ greatly from system to system, with no clear correlation with system
temperature. At intermediate radii the scaled density profiles show much less
scatter, with a clear dependence on system temperature, consistent with the
presence of an entropy excess as suggested in previous literature. However, at
large scaled radii this dependence becomes weaker: clusters with kT > 3 keV
scale self-similarly, with no temperature dependence of gas-density
normalisation. We find some evidence of a correlation between dynamical state
and outer gas density slope, and between dynamical state and both central gas
normalisation and cooling time. We find no evidence of a significant bimodality
in the distributions of central density, density gradient, or cooling time.
Finally, we present the gas mass-temperature relation for the REXCESS sample,
which is consistent with the expectation of self-similar scaling modified by
the presence of an entropy excess in the inner regions of the cluster, and has
a logarithmic intrinsic scatter of ~10%.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:0804.1552 [pdf] - 11638
The impact of mergers on relaxed X-ray clusters - III. Effects on
compact cool cores
Submitted: 2008-04-09
(Abridged) We use the simulations presented in Poole et al. 2006 to examine
the effects of mergers on compact cool cores in X-ray clusters. We propose a
scheme for classifying the morphology of clusters based on their surface
brightness and entropy profiles. Three dominant morphologies emerge: two
hosting compact cores and central temperatures which are cool (CCC systems) or
warm (CWC systems) and one hosting extended cores which are warm (EWC systems).
We find that CCC states are disrupted only after direct collisions between
cluster cores in head-on collisions or during second pericentric passage in
off-axis mergers. By the time they relax, our remnant cores have generally been
heated to warm core (CWC or EWC) states but subsequently recover CCC states.
The only case resulting in a long-lived EWC state is a slightly off-axis 3:1
merger for which the majority of shock heating occurs during the accretion of a
low-entropy stream formed from the disruption of the secondary's core.
Compression prevents core temperatures from falling until after relaxation thus
explaining the observed population of relaxed CWC systems with no need to
invoke AGN feedback. The morphological segregation observed in the L_x-T_x and
beta-r_c scaling relations is reflected in our simulations as well. However,
none of the cases we have studied produce sufficiently high remnant central
entropies to account for the most under-luminous EWC systems observed. Lastly,
systems which initially host central metallicity gradients do not yield merger
remnants with flat metallicity profiles. Taken together, these results suggest
that once formed, compact core systems are remarkably stable against disruption
from mergers. It remains to be demonstrated exactly how the sizable observed
population of extended core systems was formed.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:0710.5782 [pdf] - 6575
Evolution of the Intracluster Medium Between 0.2 < z < 1.3 in a Chandra
Sample of 70 Galaxy Clusters
Submitted: 2007-10-30
We study the evolution of the ICM with a sample of 70 galaxy clusters
spanning 0.18 < z < 1.24. We find that X-ray luminosity and ICM mass at a fixed
temperature evolve with redshift in a manner inconsistent with the standard
self-similar model of cluster formation. Both luminosity and ICM mass evolve
more slowly toward high redshift than the self-similar prediction. We find that
evolution in these two observables can be modeled by a simple evolution in the
cluster gas mass fraction. Excluding cluster cores from measurements results in
evolution more consistent with the self-similar model than when the entire
cluster is used, indicating that the fraction of clusters with cool cores
increases with time, or that cool cores become more developed over time in
those clusters that have them; this is supported by direct study of the
redshift dependence of central surface brightness, which increases in scatter
and magnitude at low redshift. We find that isophotal size-temperature
relations evolve differently according to which isophote is used, indicating
that the central and outer regions of cluster ICM evolve differently. We show
that constraints on the evolution of the gas fraction and isophotal
size-temperature relations constraints can be combined to measure cluster
distances, and thus to constrain cosmological parameters. There are indications
that scaling relation scatter decreases at higher redshift, suggesting that
merging is not the dominant source of cluster structural variation. Our results
provide constraints for simulations attempting to model cluster physics,
indicate some difficulties for cosmological studies that assume constant
cluster gas fractions, and point toward other potentially more robust uses of
clusters for cosmological applications. (Abridged)
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:0707.1879 [pdf] - 3032
The dark haloes of early-type galaxies in low-density environments:
XMM-Newton and Chandra observations of NGC 57, NGC 7796 and IC 1531
Submitted: 2007-07-12
We present analysis of Chandra and XMM-Newton observations of three
early-type galaxies, NGC 57, NGC 7796 and IC 1531. All three are found in very
low density environments, and appear to have no neighbours of comparable size.
NGC 57 has a halo of kT~0.9 keV, solar metallicity gas, while NGC 7796 and IC
1531 both have ~0.55 keV, 0.5-0.6 Zsol haloes. IC 1531 has a relatively compact
halo, and we consider it likely that gas has been removed from the system by
the effects of AGN heating. For NGC 57 and NGC 7796 we estimate mass, entropy
and cooling time profiles and find that NGC 57 has a fairly massive dark halo
with a mass-to-light ratio of 44.7 (4.0,-8.5) Msol/Lsol (1 sigma uncertainties)
at 4.75 Re. This is very similar to the mass-to-light ratio found for NGC 4555
and confirms that isolated ellipticals can possess sizable dark matter haloes.
We find a significantly lower mass-to-light ratio for NGC 7796, 10.6
(+2.5,-2.3) Msol/Lsol at 5 Re, and discuss the possibility that NGC 7796 hosts
a galactic wind, causing us to underestimate its mass.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0612700 [pdf] - 88038
Missing Thermal Energy of the Intracluster Medium
Submitted: 2006-12-26, last modified: 2007-03-23
The Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect is a direct probe of thermal energy
content of the Universe, induced in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) sky
through scattering of CMB photons off hot electrons in the intracluster medium
(ICM). We report a 9-sigma detection of the SZ signal in the CMB maps of
Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) 3yr data, through study of a sample
of 193 massive galaxy clusters with observed X-ray temperatures greater than 3
keV. For the first time, we make a model-independent measurement of the
pressure profile in the outskirts of the ICM, and show that it closely follows
the profiles obtained by X-ray observations and numerical simulations. We find
that our measurements of the SZ effect would account for only half of the
thermal energy of the cluster, if all the cluster baryons were in the hot ICM
phase. Our measurements indicate that a significant fraction (35 +/- 8 %) of
baryonic mass is missing from the hot ICM, and thus must have cooled to form
galaxies, intracluster stars, or an unknown cold phase of the ICM. There does
not seem to be enough mass in the form of stars or cold gas in the cluster
galaxies or intracluster space, signaling the need for a yet-unknown baryonic
component (at 3-sigma level), or otherwise new astrophysical processes in the
ICM.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0703010 [pdf] - 89819
Bayesian modelling of the cool core galaxy group NGC 4325
Submitted: 2007-03-01
We present an X-ray analysis of the radio-quiet cool-core galaxy group NGC
4325 (z=0.026) based on Chandra and ROSAT observations. The Chandra data were
analysed using XSPEC deprojection, 2D spectral mapping and forward-fitting with
parametric models. Additionally, a Markov chain Monte Carlo method was used to
perform a joint Bayesian analysis of the Chandra and ROSAT data. The results of
the various analysis methods are compared, particularly those obtained by
forward-fitting and deprojection. The spectral mapping reveals the presence of
cool gas displaced up to 10 kpc from the group centre. The Chandra X-ray
surface brightness shows the group core to be highly disturbed, and indicates
the presence of two small X-ray cavities within 15 kpc of the group core. The
XSPEC deprojection analysis shows that the group has a particularly steep
entropy profile, suggesting that an AGN outburst may be about to occur. With
the evidence of prior AGN activity, but with no radio emission currently
observed, we suggest that the group in in a pre-outburst state, with the
cavities and displaced gas providing evidence of a previous, weak AGN outburst.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0608423 [pdf] - 84300
A statistically-selected Chandra sample of 20 galaxy clusters -- I.
Temperature and cooling time profiles
Submitted: 2006-08-21
We present an analysis of 20 galaxy clusters observed with the Chandra X-ray
satellite, focussing on the temperature structure of the intracluster medium
and the cooling time of the gas. Our sample is drawn from a flux-limited
catalogue but excludes the Fornax, Coma and Centaurus clusters, owing to their
large angular size compared to the Chandra field-of-view. We describe a
quantitative measure of the impact of central cooling, and find that the sample
comprises 9 clusters possessing cool cores and 11 without. The properties of
these two types differ markedly, but there is a high degree of uniformity
amongst the cool core clusters, which obey a nearly universal radial scaling in
temperature of the form T \propto r^~0.4, within the core. This uniformity
persists in the gas cooling time, which varies more strongly with radius in
cool core clusters (t_cool \propto r^~1.3), reaching t_cool <1Gyr in all cases,
although surprisingly low central cooling times (<5Gyr) are found in many of
the non-cool core systems. The scatter between the cooling time profiles of all
the clusters is found to be remarkably small, implying a universal form for the
cooling time of gas at a given physical radius in virialized systems, in
agreement with recent previous work. Our results favour cluster merging as the
primary factor in preventing the formation of cool cores.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0507013 [pdf] - 74182
An X-ray Galaxy Cluster Survey for Investigations of Dark Energy
Haiman, Z.;
Allen, S.;
Bahcall, N.;
Bautz, M.;
Boehringer, H.;
Borgani, S.;
Bryan, G.;
Cabrera, B.;
Canizares, C.;
Citterio, O.;
Evrard, A.;
Finoguenov, A.;
Griffiths, R.;
Hasinger, G.;
Henry, P.;
Jahoda, K.;
Jernigan, G.;
Kahn, S.;
Lamb, D.;
Majumdar, S.;
Mohr, J.;
Molendi, S.;
Mushotzky, R.;
Pareschi, G.;
Peterson, J.;
Petre, R.;
Predehl, P.;
Rasmussen, A.;
Ricker, G.;
Ricker, P.;
Rosati, P.;
Sanderson, A.;
Stanford, A.;
Voit, M.;
Wang, S.;
White, N.;
White, S.
Submitted: 2005-06-30
The amount and nature of dark energy (DE) can be tightly constrained by
measuring the spatial correlation features and evolution of a sample of ~
100,000 galaxy clusters over the redshift range 0<z < 1.5. Such an X-ray survey
will discover all collapsed structures with mass above 3.5e14 solar masss at
redshifts z<2 (i.e. the full range where such objects are expected) in the high
Galactic latitude sky. Above this mass threshold the tight correlations between
X-ray observables and mass allow direct interpretation of the data. We describe
the constraints on Dark Energy that can be inferred from such a survey, using
powerful self-calibration techniques to relate the X-ray observables
(luminosity and temperature) to the underlying mass.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0412316 [pdf] - 69720
Possible AGN Shock Heating in the Cool Core Galaxy Cluster Abell 478
Submitted: 2004-12-14, last modified: 2005-05-27
We present a detailed X-ray study of the intracluster medium (ICM) of the
nearby, cool-core galaxy cluster Abell 478, with Chandra and XMM observations.
Using a wavelet smoothing hardness analysis, we derive detailed temperature
maps of A478, revealing a surprising amount of temperature structure. The broad
band Chandra spectral fits yield temperatures which are significantly hotter
than those from XMM, but the Fe ionization temperature shows good agreement. We
show that the temperature discrepancy is slightly reduced when comparing
spectra from regions selected to enclose nearly isothermal gas. However, by
simulating multi-temperature spectra and fitting them with a single temperature
model, we find no significant difference between Chandra and XMM, indicating
that non-isothermality cannot fully explain the discrepancy. We have discovered
4 hot spots located between 30--50 kpc from the cluster center, where the gas
temperature is roughly a factor of 2 higher than in the surrounding material.
We estimate the combined excess thermal energy present in these hot spots to be
(3+/-1)x10^59 erg. The location of and amount of excess energy present in the
hot spots are suggestive of a common origin within the cluster core, which
hosts an active galactic nucleus. This cluster also possesses a pair of X-ray
cavities coincident with weak radio lobes, as reported in a previous analysis,
with an associated energy <10% of the thermal excess in the hot spots. The
presence of these hot spots could indicate strong-shock heating of the ICM from
the central radio source -- one of the first such detections in a cool core
cluster. We also probe the mass distribution in the core and find it to be
characterized by a logarithmic slope of -0.35+/-0.22, which is significantly
flatter than an NFW cusp of -1. (abridged)
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0505419 [pdf] - 73189
Cluster scaling and its redshift evolution from XMM-Newton
Submitted: 2005-05-19
We put together the results of XMM-Newton observations of a number of
representative group and cluster samples at low and high redshifts. These
results confirm the entropy ramp as an explanation of the observed scaling
relations. We observe a mild evolution in the entropy of clusters. The observed
degree of evolution is consistent with expectations of the shock heating at a
fixed overdensity (500) with respect to the critical density in LCDM. The study
of the evolution in the pressure scaling imposes strong requirements in the
definition of the average temperature of the cluster. The scaling temperature
should be consistent to better than the 10% level. Once such a consistency is
achieved, no additional evolution in the pressure has been detected in addition
to the prediction of the shock heating in the LCDM Universe.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0408560 [pdf] - 67051
WMAP constraints on the Intra-Cluster Medium
Submitted: 2004-08-30, last modified: 2005-04-28
We devise a Monte-Carlo based, optimized filter match method to extract the
thermal Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) signature of a catalog of 116 low-redshift
X-ray clusters from the first year data release of the Wilkinson Microwave
Anisotropy Probe (WMAP). We detect an over-all amplitude for the SZ signal at
the ~ 8-sigma level, yielding a combined constraint of f_{gas}h = 0.08 +/- 0.01
(ran) +/- 0.01 (sys) on the gas mass fraction of the Intra-Cluster Medium. We
also compile X-ray estimated gas fractions from the literature for our sample,
and find that they are consistent with the SZ estimates at the 2-sigma level,
while both show an increasing trend with X-ray temperature. Nevertheless, our
SZ estimated gas fraction is 30-40% smaller than the concordance LCDM cosmic
average. We also express our observations in terms of the SZ flux-temperature
relation, and compare it with other observations, as well as numerical studies.
Based on its spectral and spatial signature, we can also extract the
microwave point source signal of the clusters at the 3-sigma level, which puts
the average microwave luminosity (at ~ 41 GHz) of bright cluster members (M_K <
-21) at (2.4 +/- 0.8) x 10^{27} h^{-2} erg/s/Hz. Furthermore, we can constrain
the average dark matter halo concentration parameter to c_{vir}=3.4+0.6-0.9,
for clusters with T_x > 5 kev.
Our work serves as an example for how correlation of SZ surveys with cluster
surveys in other frequencies can significantly increase our physical
understanding of the intra-cluster medium.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0307457 [pdf] - 58170
The Birmingham-CfA cluster scaling project - II. Mass composition and
distribution
Submitted: 2003-07-25, last modified: 2004-02-29
We investigate the spatial distribution of the baryonic and non-baryonic mass
components in a sample of 66 virialized systems. We have used X-ray
measurements to determine the deprojected temperature and density structure of
the intergalactic medium and have employed these to map the underlying
gravitational potential. In addition, we have measured the deprojected spatial
distribution of galaxy luminosity for a subset of this sample, spanning over 2
decades in mass. With this combined X-ray/optical study we examine the scaling
properties of the baryons and address the issue of mass-to-light (M/L) ratio in
groups and clusters of galaxies. We measure a median mass-to-light ratio of 224
h70 M/L (solar) in the rest frame B_j band, in good agreement with other
measurements based on X-ray determined masses. There is no trend in M/L with
X-ray temperature and no significant trend for mass to increase faster than
luminosity: M \propto \L_{B,j}^{1.08 +/- 0.12}. This implied lack of
significant variation in star formation efficiency suggests that gas cooling
cannot be greatly enhanced in groups, unless it drops out to form baryonic dark
matter. Correspondingly, our results indicate that non-gravitational heating
must have played a significant role in establishing the observed departure from
self-similarity in low mass systems. The median baryon fraction for our sample
is 0.162 h70^{-3/2}, which allows us to place an upper limit on the
cosmological matter density, Omega_m <= 0.27 h70^{-1}, in good agreement with
the latest results from WMAP. We find evidence of a systematic trend towards
higher central density concentration in the coolest haloes, indicative of an
early formation epoch and consistent with hierarchical formation models.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0304048 [pdf] - 55956
The Birmingham-CfA cluster scaling project - III: entropy and similarity
in galaxy systems
Submitted: 2003-04-02
We examine profiles and scaling properties of the entropy of the
intergalactic gas in a sample of 66 virialized systems, ranging in mass from
single elliptical galaxies to rich clusters, for which we have resolved X-ray
temperature profiles. Some of the properties we derive appear to be
inconsistent with any of the models put forward to explain the breaking of
self-similarity in the baryon content of clusters. In particular, the entropy
profiles, scaled to the virial radius, are broadly similar in form across the
sample, apart from a normalization factor which differs from the simple
self-similar scaling with temperature. Low mass systems do not show the large
isentropic cores predicted by preheating models, and the high entropy excesses
reported at large radii in groups by Finoguenov et al (2002) are confirmed, and
found to extend even to moderately rich clusters. We discuss the implications
of these results for the evolutionary history of the hot gas in clusters, and
suggest that preheating may affect the entropy of intracluster gas primarily by
reducing the density of material accreting into groups and clusters along
cosmic filaments.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0303374 [pdf] - 55613
The X-ray Scaling Properties of Virialized Systems
Submitted: 2003-03-17
Virialized systems, such as clusters and groups of galaxies, represent an
ideal laboratory for investigating the formation and evolution of structure on
the largest scales. Furthermore, the properties of the gaseous intracluster
medium provide key insights into the influence of important non-gravitational
processes like energy injection and radiative cooling, resulting from feedback
associated with star formation, for example. We have assembled a very large
X-ray sample of virialized systems, spanning over two decades in halo mass.
Each object has high-quality X-ray data available, enabling a full deprojection
analysis to be made; for a subsample we have additionally determined the
deprojected optical light distribution. We find clear evidence of a departure
from the simple expectations of self-similarity. The intracluster medium is
more spatially extended and systematically less dense in smaller haloes, and
there is evidence of an entropy excess in the hot gas. Our results favour a
significant role for both non-gravitational heating and radiative cooling in
modifying the properties of this gas, although we find no clear evidence of
significantly enhanced star formation efficiency in groups.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0301049 [pdf] - 54020
The Birmingham-CfA cluster scaling project - I: gas fraction and the M-T
relation
Submitted: 2003-01-03
We have assembled a large sample of virialized systems, comprising 66 galaxy
clusters, groups and elliptical galaxies with high quality X-ray data. To each
system we have fitted analytical profiles describing the gas density and
temperature variation with radius, corrected for the effects of central gas
cooling. We present an analysis of the scaling properties of these systems and
focus in this paper on the gas distribution and M-T relation. In addition to
clusters and groups, our sample includes two early-type galaxies, carefully
selected to avoid contamination from group or cluster X-ray emission. We
compare the properties of these objects with those of more massive systems and
find evidence for a systematic difference between galaxy-sized haloes and
groups of a similar temperature. We derive a mean logarithmic slope of the M-T
relation within R_200 of 1.84+/-0.06, although there is some evidence of a
gradual steepening in the M-T relation, with decreasing mass. We recover a
similar slope using two additional methods of calculating the mean temperature.
Repeating the analysis with the assumption of isothermality, we find the slope
changes only slightly, to 1.89+/-0.04, but the normalization is increased by
30%. Correspondingly, the mean gas fraction within R_200 changes from
(0.13+/-0.01)h70^-1.5 to (0.11+/-0.01)h70^-1.5, for the isothermal case, with
the smaller fractional change reflecting different behaviour between hot and
cool systems. There is a strong correlation between the gas fraction within
0.3*R_200 and temperature. This reflects the strong (5.8 sigma) trend between
the gas density slope parameter, beta, and temperature, which has been found in
previous work. (abridged)