Normalized to: Ruszkowski, M.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.03608 [pdf] - 2057754
Chaotic cold accretion in giant elliptical galaxies heated by AGN cosmic
rays
Submitted: 2019-10-08
Black hole feedback plays a central role in shaping the circumgalactic medium
(CGM) of elliptical galaxies. We systematically study the impact of plasma
physics on the evolution of ellipticals by performing three-dimensional
non-ideal magneto-hydrodynamic simulations of the interactions of active
galactic nucleus (AGN) jets with the CGM including magnetic fields, and cosmic
rays (CRs) and their transport processes. We find that the physics of feedback
operating on large galactic scales depends very sensitively on plasma physics
operating on small scales. Specifically, we demonstrate that: (i) in the purely
hydrodynamical case, the AGN jets initially maintain the atmospheres in global
thermal balance. However, local thermal instability generically leads to the
formation of massive cold disks in the vicinity of the central black hole in
disagreement with observations; (ii) including weak magnetic fields prevents
the formation of the disks because local B-field amplification in the
precipitating cold gas leads to strong magnetic breaking, which quickly
extracts angular momentum from the accreting clouds. The magnetic fields
transform the cold clouds into narrow filaments that do not fall ballistically;
(iii) when plasma composition in the AGN jets is dominated by CRs, and CR
transport is neglected, the atmospheres exhibit cooling catastrophes due to
inefficient heat transfer from the AGN to CGM despite Coulomb/hadronic CR
losses being present; (iv) including CR streaming and heating restores
agreement with the observations, i.e., cooling catastrophes are prevented and
massive cold central disks do not form. The AGN power is reduced as its energy
is utilized efficiently.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.05494 [pdf] - 1966579
Role of Cosmic Ray Streaming and Turbulent Damping in Driving Galactic
Winds
Submitted: 2018-07-15, last modified: 2019-09-12
Large-scale galactic winds driven by stellar feedback are one phenomenon that
influences the dynamical and chemical evolution of a galaxy, redistributing
material throughout the circumgalatic medium. Non-thermal feedback from
galactic cosmic rays (CRs) -high-energy charged particles accelerated in
supernovae and young stars - can impact the efficiency of wind driving. The
streaming instability limits the speed at which they can escape. However, in
the presence of turbulence, the streaming instability is subject to suppression
that depends on the magnetization of turbulence given by its Alfv\'en Mach
number. While previous simulations that relied on a simplified model of CR
transport have shown that super-Alfv\'enic streaming of CRs enhances galactic
winds, in the present paper we take into account a realistic model of streaming
suppression. We perform three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic simulations of a
section of a galactic disk and find that turbulent damping dependent on local
magnetization of turbulent interstellar medium (ISM) leads to more spatially
extended gas and CR distributions compared to the earlier streaming
calculations, and that scale-heights of these distributions increase for
stronger turbulence. Our results indicate that the star formation rate
increases with the level of turbulence in the ISM. We also find that the
instantaneous wind mass loading is sensitive to local streaming physics with
the mass loading dropping significantly as the strength of turbulence
increases.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.09686 [pdf] - 1893386
Supermassive Black Hole Feedback
Ruszkowski, Mateusz;
Nagai, Daisuke;
Zhuravleva, Irina;
Brummel-Smith, Corey;
Li, Yuan;
Hodges-Kluck, Edmund;
Yang, Hsiang-Yi Karen;
Basu, Kaustuv;
Chluba, Jens;
Churazov, Eugene;
Donahue, Megan;
Fabian, Andrew;
Faucher-Giguère, Claude-André;
Gaspari, Massimo;
Hlavacek-Larrondo, Julie;
McDonald, Michael;
McNamara, Brian;
Nulsen, Paul;
Mroczkowski, Tony;
Mushotzky, Richard;
Reynolds, Christopher;
Vikhlinin, Alexey;
Voit, Mark;
Werner, Norbert;
ZuHone, John;
Zweibel, Ellen
Submitted: 2019-03-22
Understanding the processes that drive galaxy formation and shape the
observed properties of galaxies is one of the most interesting and challenging
frontier problems of modern astrophysics. We now know that the evolution of
galaxies is critically shaped by the energy injection from accreting
supermassive black holes (SMBHs). However, it is unclear how exactly the
physics of this feedback process affects galaxy formation and evolution. In
particular, a major challenge is unraveling how the energy released near the
SMBHs is distributed over nine orders of magnitude in distance throughout
galaxies and their immediate environments. The best place to study the impact
of SMBH feedback is in the hot atmospheres of massive galaxies, groups, and
galaxy clusters, which host the most massive black holes in the Universe, and
where we can directly image the impact of black holes on their surroundings. We
identify critical questions and potential measurements that will likely
transform our understanding of the physics of SMBH feedback and how it shapes
galaxies, through detailed measurements of (i) the thermodynamic and velocity
fluctuations in the intracluster medium (ICM) as well as (ii) the composition
of the bubbles inflated by SMBHs in the centers of galaxy clusters, and their
influence on the cluster gas and galaxy growth, using the next generation of
high spectral and spatial resolution X-ray and microwave telescopes.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.06356 [pdf] - 1850000
Physics of cosmic plasmas from high angular resolution X-ray imaging of
galaxy clusters
Markevitch, Maxim;
Bulbul, Esra;
Churazov, Eugene;
Giacintucci, Simona;
Kraft, Ralph;
Kunz, Matthew;
Nagai, Daisuke;
Roediger, Elke;
Ruszkowski, Mateusz;
Schekochihin, Alex;
van Weeren, Reinout;
Vikhlinin, Alexey;
Walker, Stephen A.;
Wang, Qian H. S.;
Werner, Norbert;
Wik, Daniel;
Zhuravleva, Irina;
ZuHone, John
Submitted: 2019-03-15
Galaxy clusters are massive dark matter-dominated systems filled with X-ray
emitting, optically thin plasma. Their large size and relative simplicity (at
least as astrophysical objects go) make them a unique laboratory to measure
some of the interesting plasma properties that are inaccessible by other means
but fundamentally important for understanding and modeling many astrophysical
phenomena -- from solar flares to black hole accretion to galaxy formation and
the emergence of the cosmological Large Scale Structure. While every cluster
astrophysicist is eagerly anticipating the direct gas velocity measurements
from the forthcoming microcalorimeters onboard XRISM, Athena and future
missions such as Lynx, a number of those plasma properties can best be probed
by high-resolution X-ray imaging of galaxy clusters. Chandra has obtained some
trailblazing results, but only grazed the surface of such studies. In this
white paper, we discuss why we need arcsecond-resolution, high collecting area,
low relative background X-ray imagers (with modest spectral resolution), such
as the proposed AXIS and the imaging detector of Lynx.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.05641 [pdf] - 1849261
Galaxy Winds in the Age of Hyperdimensional Astrophysics
Tremblay, Grant R.;
Schneider, Evan E.;
Vikhlinin, Alexey;
Hernquist, Lars;
Ruszkowski, Mateusz;
Oppenheimer, Benjamin D.;
Kraft, Ralph P.;
ZuHone, John;
McDonald, Michael A.;
Gaspari, Massimo;
Donahue, Megan;
Voit, G. Mark
Submitted: 2019-03-13
The past decade began with the first light of ALMA and will end at the start
of the new era of hyperdimensional astrophysics. Our community-wide movement
toward highly multiwavelength and multidimensional datasets has enabled immense
progress in each science frontier identified by the 2010 Decadal Survey,
particularly with regard to black hole feedback and the cycle of baryons in
galaxies. Facilities like ALMA and the next generation of integral field unit
(IFU) spectrographs together enable mapping the physical conditions and
kinematics of warm ionized and cold molecular gas in galaxies in unprecedented
detail (Fig. 1). JWST's launch at the start of the coming decade will push this
capability to the rest-frame UV at redshifts z > 6, mapping the birth of stars
in the first galaxies at cosmic dawn. Understanding of their subsequent
evolution, however, now awaits an ability to map the processes that transform
galaxies directly, rather than the consequences of those processes in
isolation. In this paper, we argue that doing so requires an equivalent
revolution in spatially resolved spectroscopy for the hot plasma that pervades
galaxies, the atmospheres in which they reside, and the winds that are the
engines of their evolution.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.04944 [pdf] - 1847100
"SZ spectroscopy" in the coming decade: Galaxy cluster cosmology and
astrophysics in the submillimeter
Basu, Kaustuv;
Erler, Jens;
Chluba, Jens;
Delabrouille, Jacques;
Hill, J. Colin;
Mroczkowski, Tony;
Niemack, Michael D.;
Remazeilles, Mathieu;
Sayers, Jack;
Scott, Douglas;
Vavagiakis, Eve M.;
Zemcov, Michael;
Aravena, Manuel;
Bartlett, James G.;
Battaglia, Nicholas;
Bertoldi, Frank;
Charmetant, Maude;
Golwala, Sunil;
Herter, Terry L.;
Klaassen, Pamela;
Komatsu, Eiichiro;
Magnelli, Benjamin;
Mantz, Adam B.;
Meerburg, P. Daniel;
Melin, Jean-Baptiste;
Nagai, Daisuke;
Parshley, Stephen C.;
Pointecouteau, Etienne;
Ramos-Ceja, Miriam E.;
Ruszkowski, Mateusz;
Sehgal, Neelima;
Stacey, Gordon G.;
Sunyaev, Rashid
Submitted: 2019-03-12
Sunyaev-Zeldovich (SZ) effects were first proposed in the 1970s as tools to
identify the X-ray emitting hot gas inside massive clusters of galaxies and
obtain their velocities relative to the cosmic microwave background (CMB). Yet
it is only within the last decade that they have begun to significantly impact
astronomical research. Thanks to the rapid developments in CMB instrumentation,
measurement of the dominant thermal signature of the SZ effects has become a
routine tool to find and characterize large samples of galaxy clusters and to
seek deeper understanding of several important astrophysical processes via
high-resolution imaging studies of many targets. With the notable exception of
the Planck satellite and a few combinations of ground-based observatories, much
of this "SZ revolution" has happened in the photometric mode, where
observations are made at one or two frequencies in the millimeter regime to
maximize the cluster detection significance and minimize the foregrounds.
Still, there is much more to learn from detailed and systematic analyses of the
SZ spectra across multiple wavelengths, specifically in the submillimeter (>300
GHz) domain. The goal of this Science White Paper is to highlight this
particular aspect of SZ research, point out what new and potentially
groundbreaking insights can be obtained from these studies, and emphasize why
the coming decade can be a golden era for SZ spectral measurements.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.01471 [pdf] - 1924981
Cosmic Ray Acceleration of Cool Clouds in the Circumgalactic Medium
Submitted: 2019-03-04
We investigate a mechanism for accelerating cool (10$^4$ K) clouds in the
circumgalactic medium (CGM) with cosmic rays (CRs), possibly explaining some
characteristics of observed high velocity clouds (HVCs). Enforcing CRs to
stream down their pressure gradient into a region of slow streaming speed
results in significant buildup of CR pressure which can accelerate the CGM. We
present the results of the first two-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic (MHD)
simulations of such `CR bottlenecks,' expanding on simpler simulations in 1D
from \cite{wiener17a}. Although much more investigation is required, we find
two main results. First, radiative cooling in the interfaces of these clouds is
sufficient to keep the cloud intact to CR wave heating. Second, cloud
acceleration depends almost linearly with the injected CR flux at low values
(comparable to that expected from a Milky Way-like star formation rate), but
scales sublinearly at higher CR fluxes in 1D simulations. 2D simulations show
hints of sublinear dependence at high CR fluxes but are consistent with pure
linear dependence up to the CR fluxes tested. It is therefore plausible to
accelerate cool clouds in the CGM to speeds of hundreds of km s$^{-1}$.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.03217 [pdf] - 1779523
AGN Feedback and Multi-phase Gas in Giant Elliptical Galaxies
Submitted: 2018-05-08
Recent observations have found extended multi-phase gas in a significant
fraction of massive elliptical galaxies. We perform high-resolution
three-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations of two idealized elliptical
galaxies -- one representing a typical galaxy characterized by initial
conditions conducive to the development of thermal instability and the other
one less likely to develop thermal instability -- in order to study the
development of thermal instability and the formation of multi-phase structures.
We analyze the interplay between radiative cooling, momentum-driven AGN
feedback, star formation, and stellar feedback from both young and old stars.
We find that in one class of elliptical galaxies, the entropy of the hot halo
gas rises sharply as a function of radius, and the hot halo is thermally stable
and run-away cooling can only happen in the very center of the galaxy. In other
class of ellipticals, the hot halo gas has a cooling to free-fall time ratio
close to 10, and the non-linear perturbation driven by AGN feedback can cause
the hot gas to frequently precipitate into extended multi-phase filaments. Both
multi- and single-phase elliptical galaxies experience cooling-driven AGN
feedback cycles. Interestingly, AGN feedback maintains the multi- or
single-phase nature of the halo but does not turn multi-phase galaxies into
single-phase ones or vice versa. Some of the extended cold gas in the
multi-phase galaxy also forms young stars. The level of star formation and its
spatial distribution are in excellent agreement with {\it Hubble} observations
of nearby elliptical galaxies.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.04808 [pdf] - 1674878
Acoustic Disturbances in Galaxy Clusters
Submitted: 2018-02-13, last modified: 2018-03-27
Galaxy cluster cores are pervaded by hot gas which radiates at far too high a
rate to maintain any semblance of a steady state; this is referred to as the
cooling flow problem. Of the many heating mechanisms that have been proposed to
balance radiative cooling, one of the most attractive is dissipation of
acoustic waves generated by Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN). Fabian (2005) showed
that if the waves are nearly adiabatic, wave damping due to heat conduction and
viscosity must be well below standard Coulomb rates in order to allow the waves
to propagate throughout the core. Because of the importance of this result, we
have revisited wave dissipation under galaxy cluster conditions in a way that
accounts for the self limiting nature of dissipation by electron thermal
conduction, allows the electron and ion temperature perturbations in the waves
to evolve separately, and estimates kinetic effects by comparing to a
semi-collisionless theory. While these effects considerably enlarge the toolkit
for analyzing observations of wavelike structures and developing a quantitative
theory for wave heating, the drastic reduction of transport coefficients
proposed in Fabian (2005) remains the most viable path to acoustic wave heating
of galaxy cluster cores.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.04298 [pdf] - 1694018
Powering of H$\alpha$ filaments by cosmic rays
Submitted: 2018-02-12, last modified: 2018-03-27
Cluster cool cores possess networks of line-emitting filaments. These
filaments are thought to originate via uplift of cold gas from cluster centers
by buoyant active galactic nuclei (AGN) bubbles, or via local thermal
instability in the hot intracluster medium (ICM). Therefore, the filaments are
either the signatures of AGN feedback or feeding of supermassive black holes.
Despite being characterized by very short cooling times, the filaments are
significant H$\alpha$ emitters, which suggests that some process continuously
powers these structures. Many cool cores host diffuse radio mini halos and AGN
injecting radio plasma, suggesting that cosmic rays (CRs) and magnetic fields
are present in the ICM. We argue that the excitation of Alfv\'en waves by CR
streaming, and the replenishment of CR energy via accretion onto the filaments
of high plasma-$\beta$ ICM characterized by low CR pressure support, can
provide the adequate amount of heating to power and sustain the emission from
these filaments. This mechanism does not require the CRs to penetrate the
filaments even if the filaments are magnetically isolated from the ambient ICM
and it may operate irrespectively of whether the filaments are dredged up from
the center or form in situ in the ICM. This picture is qualitatively consistent
with non-thermal line ratios seen in the cold filaments. Future X-ray
observations of the iron line complex with XARM, Lynx, or Athena could help to
test this model by providing constraints on the amount of CRs in the hot plasma
that is cooling and accreting onto the filaments.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.03890 [pdf] - 1643156
Unveiling the Origin of the Fermi Bubbles
Submitted: 2018-02-11, last modified: 2018-02-28
The Fermi bubbles, two giant structures above and below the Galactic center
(GC), are among the most important discoveries of the Fermi Gamma-ray Space
Telescope. Studying their physical origin has been providing valuable insights
into cosmic-ray transport, the Galactic magnetic field, and past activity at
the GC in the Milky Way galaxy. Despite their importance, the formation
mechanism of the bubbles is still elusive. Over the past few years there have
been numerous efforts, both observational and theoretical, to uncover the
nature of the bubbles. In this article, we present an overview of the current
status of our understanding of the bubbles' origin, and discuss possible future
directions that will help to distinguish different scenarios of bubble
formation.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.04579 [pdf] - 1663182
Impact of Cosmic Ray Transport on Galactic Winds
Submitted: 2017-07-14, last modified: 2018-02-23
The role of cosmic rays generated by supernovae and young stars has very
recently begun to receive significant attention in studies of galaxy formation
and evolution due to the realization that cosmic rays can efficiently
accelerate galactic winds. Microscopic cosmic ray transport processes are
fundamental for determining the efficiency of cosmic ray wind driving. Previous
studies focused on modeling of cosmic ray transport either via constant
diffusion coefficient or via streaming proportional to the Alfven speed.
However, in predominantly cold, neutral gas, cosmic rays can propagate faster
than in the ionized medium and the effective transport can be substantially
larger; i.e., cosmic rays can decouple from the gas. We perform
three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamical simulations of patches of galactic
disks including the effects of cosmic rays. Our simulations include the
decoupling of cosmic rays in the cold, neutral interstellar medium. We find
that, compared to the ordinary diffusive cosmic ray transport case, accounting
for the decoupling leads to significantly different wind properties such as the
gas density and temperature, significantly broader spatial distribution of
cosmic rays, and larger wind speed. These results have implications for X-ray,
gamma-ray and radio emission, and for the magnetization and pollution of the
circumgalactic medium by cosmic rays.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.05025 [pdf] - 1595726
The Spatially Uniform Spectrum of the Fermi Bubbles: the Leptonic AGN
Jet Scenario
Submitted: 2017-06-15, last modified: 2017-11-30
The Fermi bubbles, two giant gamma-ray bubbles above and below the Galactic
center (GC), are among the most important findings of the Fermi Gamma-ray Space
Telescope. Because of the proximity, spatially resolved, multi-wavelength
observations offer excellent opportunities to learn about the physical origin
of the bubbles. One of the unique features of the observed bubbles is that
their gamma-ray spectrum, including a high-energy cutoff at ~110 GeV and the
overall shape of the spectrum, is nearly spatially uniform. The high-energy
spectral cutoff is suggestive of a leptonic origin as it could be a signature
of synchrotron and inverse-Compton (IC) cooling of cosmic-ray (CR) electrons;
however, even for a leptonic model, it is not obvious why the spectrum should
be spatially uniform. In this work, we investigate the formation of the Fermi
bubble in the leptonic jet scenario using a newly implemented CRSPEC module in
FLASH that allows us to track the evolution of CR spectrum on-the-fly during
the simulations. We show that the high-energy cutoff is caused by fast
synchrotron and IC cooling near the GC when the jets were first launched. After
the jets propagate away from the GC, the dynamical timescale of the jets become
the shortest among all relevant timescales, and therefore the spectrum is
essentially advected with only mild cooling losses. This could explain why the
bubble spectrum is nearly spatially uniform: the CRs from different parts of
the bubbles as seen today all share the same origin near the GC at early stage
of the bubble expansion. We find that the CR spatial and spectral distribution
predicted by the leptonic jet model can simultaneously match the normalization,
spectral shape, and high-energy cutoff of the observed gamma-ray spectrum and
their spatial uniformity, suggesting that past AGN jet activity is a likely
mechanism for the formation of the Fermi bubbles.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.06954 [pdf] - 1641231
The Effects of Ram Pressure on the Cold Clouds in the Centers of Galaxy
Clusters
Submitted: 2017-03-20
We discuss the effect of ram pressure on the cold clouds in the centers of
cool-core galaxy clusters, and in particular, how it reduces cloud velocity and
sometimes causes an offset between the cold gas and young stars. The velocities
of the molecular gas in both observations and our simulations fall in the range
of $100-400$ km/s, much lower than expected if they fall from a few tens of kpc
ballistically. If the intra-cluster medium (ICM) is at rest, the ram pressure
of the ICM only slightly reduces the velocity of the clouds. When we assume
that the clouds are actually "fluffier" because they are co-moving with a
warm-hot layer, the velocity becomes smaller. If we also consider the AGN wind
in the cluster center by adding a wind profile measured from the simulation,
the clouds are further slowed down at small radii, and the resulting velocities
are in general agreement with the observations and simulations. Because ram
pressure only affects gas but not stars, it can cause a separation between a
filament and young stars that formed in the filament as they move through the
ICM together. This separation has been observed in Perseus and also exists in
our simulations. We show that the star-filament offset combined with
line-of-sight velocity measurements can help determine the true motion of the
cold gas, and thus distinguish between inflows and outflows.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.07441 [pdf] - 1581275
Cosmic ray feedback heating of the intracluster medium
Submitted: 2017-01-25
Self-regulating AGN feedback in the cool cores of galaxy clusters plays
central role in solving the decades-old cooling flow problem, but one major
problem remains unsolved - how is the AGN energy thermalized in the ICM and
what are the effective black hole feeding rates in realistic systems? We
perform a suite of 3D MHD AMR simulations of AGN feedback in a cool core
cluster including cosmic ray (CR) physics. CRs are supplied to the ICM via
collimated AGN jets and subsequently disperse in the magnetized ICM via
streaming, and interact with the ICM via hadronic, Coulomb, and streaming
instability heating. We find that CR transport is an essential model ingredient
needed for AGN feedback to self-regulate, at least within the context of the
physical model considered here. When CR streaming is neglected, the suppression
of CR mixing with the ICM by magnetic fields significantly reduces ICM heating,
which leads to cooling catastrophes. In the opposite case, CRs come into
contact with the ambient ICM and efficiently heat it, which results in globally
stable atmospheres. Moreover, the dynamical state and intermittency of the
central AGN are dramatically altered when CR streaming is present. We find that
CR streaming heating dominates over the heating due to Coulomb and hadronic
processes. Importantly, in simulations that include CR streaming, CR pressure
support in the central 100 kpc is very low and does not demonstrably violate
observational constraints. On the contrary, when CR streaming is neglected, CR
energy is not spent on the ICM heating and CR pressure builds up to the level
that is in disagreement with the data. Overall, our models demonstrate that CR
heating is a viable channel for the thermalization of AGN energy in clusters,
and likely also in elliptical galaxies, and that CRs play an important role in
determining AGN intermittency and the dynamical state of cool core atmospheres.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1611.05455 [pdf] - 1580621
AGN Heating in Simulated Cool-Core Clusters
Submitted: 2016-11-16
We analyze heating and cooling processes in an idealized simulation of a
cool-core cluster, where momentum-driven AGN feedback balances radiative
cooling in a time-averaged sense. We find that, on average, energy dissipation
via shock waves is almost an order of magnitude higher than via turbulence.
Most of the shock waves in the simulation are very weak shocks with Mach
numbers smaller than 1.5, but the stronger shocks, although rare, dissipate
energy more effectively. We find that shock dissipation is a steep function of
radius, with most of the energy dissipated within 30 kpc, while radiative
cooling loses area less concentrated. However, adiabatic processes and mixing
(of post-shock materials and the surrounding gas) are able to redistribute the
heat throughout the core. A considerable fraction of the AGN energy also
escapes the core region. The cluster goes through cycles of AGN outbursts
accompanied by periods of enhanced precipitation and star formation, over Gyr
timescales. The cluster core is under-heated at the end of each cycle, but
over-heated at the peak of the AGN outburst. During the heating-dominant phase,
turbulent dissipation alone is often able to balance radiative cooling at every
radius but, when this is occurs, shock waves inevitably dissipate even more
energy. Our simulation explains why some clusters, such as Abell 2029, are
cooling dominated, while in some other clusters, such as Perseus, various
heating mechanisms including shock heating, turbulent dissipation and bubble
mixing can all individually balance cooling, and together, overheat the core.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.08518 [pdf] - 1495827
The Efficiency of Magnetic Field Amplification at Shocks by Turbulence
Submitted: 2016-03-28, last modified: 2016-10-11
Turbulent dynamo field amplification has often been invoked to explain the
strong field strengths in thin rims in supernova shocks ($\sim 100 \, \mu$G)
and in radio relics in galaxy clusters ($\sim \mu$G). We present high
resolution MHD simulations of the interaction between pre-shock turbulence,
clumping and shocks, to quantify the conditions under which turbulent dynamo
amplification can be significant. We demonstrate numerically converged field
amplification which scales with Alfv\'en Mach number, $B/B_0 \propto {\mathcal
M}_{\rm A}$, up to ${\mathcal M}_{\rm A} \sim 150$. This implies that the
post-shock field strength is relatively independent of the seed field.
Amplification is dominated by compression at low ${\mathcal M}_{\rm A}$, and
stretching (turbulent amplification) at high ${\mathcal M}_{\rm A}$. For high
$\mathcal{M}_{\rm A}$, the $B$-field grows exponentially and saturates at
equipartition with turbulence, while the vorticity jumps sharply at the shock
and subsequently decays; the resulting field is orientated predominately along
the shock normal (an effect only apparent in 3D and not 2D). This agrees with
the radial field bias seen in supernova remnants. By contrast, for low
$\mathcal{M}_{\rm A}$, field amplification is mostly compressional, relatively
modest, and results in a predominantly perpendicular field. The latter is
consistent with the polarization seen in radio relics. Our results are
relatively robust to the assumed level of gas clumping. Our results imply that
the turbulent dynamo may be important for supernovae, but is only consistent
with the field strength, and not geometry, for cluster radio relics. For the
latter, this implies strong pre-existing $B$-fields in the ambient cluster
outskirts.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.04856 [pdf] - 1530479
Global simulations of galactic winds including cosmic ray streaming
Submitted: 2016-02-15
Galactic outflows play an important role in galactic evolution. Despite their
importance, a detailed understanding of the physical mechanisms responsible for
the driving of these winds is lacking. In an effort to gain more insight into
the nature of these flows, we perform global three-dimensional
magneto-hydrodynamical simulations of an isolated Milky Way-size starburst
galaxy. We focus on the dynamical role of cosmic rays injected by supernovae,
and specifically on the impact of the streaming and anisotropic diffusion of
cosmic rays along the magnetic fields. We find that these microphysical effects
can have a significant effect on the wind launching and mass loading factors
depending on the details of the plasma physics. Due to the cosmic ray streaming
instability, cosmic rays propagating in the interstellar medium scatter on
self-excited Alfven waves and couple to the gas. When the wave growth due to
the streaming instability is inhibited by some damping process, such as the
turbulent damping, the cosmic ray coupling to the gas is weaker and their
effective propagation speed faster than the Alfven speed. Alternatively, cosmic
rays could scatter from "extrinsic turbulence" that is driven by another
mechanism. We demonstrate that the presence of moderately super-Alfvenic cosmic
ray streaming enhances the efficiency of galactic wind driving. Cosmic rays
stream away from denser regions near the galactic disk along partially ordered
magnetic fields and, in the process, accelerate more tenuous gas away from the
galaxy. For cosmic ray acceleration efficiencies broadly consistent with the
observational constraints, cosmic rays reduce the galactic star formation rates
and significantly aid in launching galactic winds.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.06429 [pdf] - 1311952
Deep Chandra observation and numerical studies of the nearest cluster
cold front in the sky
Werner, N.;
ZuHone, J. A.;
Zhuravleva, I.;
Ichinohe, Y.;
Simionescu, A.;
Allen, S. W.;
Markevitch, M.;
Fabian, A. C.;
Keshet, U.;
Roediger, E.;
Ruszkowski, M.;
Sanders, J. S.
Submitted: 2015-06-21, last modified: 2015-11-16
We present the results of a very deep (500 ks) Chandra observation, along
with tailored numerical simulations, of the nearest, best resolved cluster cold
front in the sky, which lies 90 kpc (19 arcmin) to the north-west of M 87. The
northern part of the front appears the sharpest, with a width smaller than 2.5
kpc (1.5 Coulomb mean free paths; at 99 per cent confidence). Everywhere along
the front, the temperature discontinuity is narrower than 4-8 kpc and the
metallicity gradient is narrower than 6 kpc, indicating that diffusion,
conduction and mixing are suppressed across the interface. Such transport
processes can be naturally suppressed by magnetic fields aligned with the cold
front. Interestingly, comparison to magnetohydrodynamic simulations indicates
that in order to maintain the observed sharp density and temperature
discontinuities, conduction must also be suppressed along the magnetic field
lines. However, the northwestern part of the cold front is observed to have a
non-zero width. While other explanations are possible, the broadening is
consistent with the presence of Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities (KHI) on
length-scales of a few kpc. Based on comparison with simulations, the presence
of KHI would imply that the effective viscosity of the intracluster medium is
suppressed by more than an order of magnitude with respect to the isotropic
Spitzer-like temperature dependent viscosity. Underneath the cold front, we
observe quasi-linear features that are ~10 per cent brighter than the
surrounding gas and are separated by ~15 kpc from each other in projection.
Comparison to tailored numerical simulations suggests that the observed
phenomena may be due to the amplification of magnetic fields by gas sloshing in
wide layers below the cold front, where the magnetic pressure reaches ~5-10 per
cent of the thermal pressure, reducing the gas density between the bright
features.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.02660 [pdf] - 1284764
Cooling, AGN Feedback and Star Formation in Simulated Cool-Core Galaxy
Clusters
Submitted: 2015-03-09
Numerical simulations of active galactic nuclei (AGN) feedback in cool-core
galaxy clusters have successfully avoided classical cooling flows, but often
produce too much cold gas. We perform adaptive mesh simulations that include
momentum-driven AGN feedback, self-gravity, star formation and stellar
feedback, focusing on the interplay between cooling, AGN heating and star
formation in an isolated cool-core cluster. Cold clumps triggered by AGN jets
and turbulence form filamentary structures tens of kpc long. This cold gas
feeds both star formation and the supermassive black hole (SMBH), triggering an
AGN outburst that increases the entropy of the ICM and reduces its cooling
rate. Within 1-2 Gyr, star formation completely consumes the cold gas, leading
to a brief shutoff of the AGN. The ICM quickly cools and redevelops multiphase
gas, followed by another cycle of star formation/AGN outburst. Within 6.5 Gyr,
we observe three such cycles. There is good agreement between our simulated
cluster and the observations of cool-core clusters. ICM cooling is dynamically
balanced by AGN heating, and a cool-core appearance is preserved. The minimum
cooling time to free-fall time ratio typically varies between a few and
$\gtrsim 20$. The star formation rate (SFR) covers a wide range, from 0 to a
few hundred $\rm M_{\odot}\, yr^{-1}$, with an average of $\sim 40 \,\rm
M_{\odot}\, yr^{-1}$. The instantaneous SMBH accretion rate shows large
variations on short timescales, but the average value correlates well with the
SFR. Simulations without stellar feedback or self-gravity produce qualitatively
similar results, but a lower SMBH feedback efficiency (0.1% compared to 1%)
results in too many stars.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.3486 [pdf] - 883111
Ram pressure stripping in elliptical galaxies: II. magnetic field
effects
Submitted: 2014-09-11
We investigate the effects of magnetic fields and turbulence on ram pressure
stripping in elliptical galaxies using ideal magnetohydrodynamics simulations.
We consider weakly-magnetised interstellar medium (ISM) characterised by
subsonic turbulence, and two orientations of the magnetic fields in the
intracluster medium (ICM) - parallel and perpendicular to the direction of the
galaxy motion through the ICM. While the stronger turbulence enhances the ram
pressure stripping mass loss, the magnetic fields tend to suppress the
stripping rates, and the suppression is stronger for parallel fields. However,
the effect of magnetic fields on the mass stripping rate is mild. Nevertheless,
the morphology of the stripping tails depends significantly on the direction of
the ICM magnetic field. The effect of the magnetic field geometry on the tail
morphology is much stronger than that of the level of the ISM turbulence. The
tail has a highly collimated shape for parallel fields, while it has a
sheet-like morphology in the plane of the ICM magnetic field for perpendicular
fields. The magnetic field in the tail is amplified irrespectively of the
orientation of the ICM field. More strongly magnetised regions in the ram
pressure stripping tails are expected to have systematically higher metallicity
due to the strong concentration of the stripped ISM than the less magnetised
regions. Strong dependence of the morphology of the stripped ISM on the
magnetic field could potentially be used to constrain the relative orientation
of the ram pressure direction and the dominant component of the ICM magnetic
field.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1203.1343 [pdf] - 1618248
Impact of magnetic fields on ram pressure stripping in disk galaxies
Submitted: 2012-03-06, last modified: 2014-02-19
(abridged) Ram pressure can remove significant amounts of gas from galaxies
in clusters, and thus has a large impact on the evolution of cluster galaxies.
Recent observations have shown that key properties of ram pressure stripped
tails of galaxies are in conflict with predictions by simulations. To increase
the realism of existing simulations, we simulated for the first time a disk
galaxy exposed to a uniformly magnetized wind including radiative cooling and
self-gravity of the gas. We find that B-fields have a strong effect on the
morphology of the gas in the tail of the galaxy. While in the pure hydro case
the tail is very clumpy, the MHD case shows very filamentary structures in the
tail. The filaments can be strongly supported by magnetic pressure and, when
this is the case, the B-field vectors tend to be aligned with the filaments.
The ram pressure stripping may lead to the formation of magnetized density
tails that appear as bifurcated in the plane of the sky and resemble the double
tails observed in ESO 137-001 and ESO 137-002. Such tails can be formed under a
variety of situations, both for the disks oriented face-on with respect to the
ICM wind and for the tilted ones. While this bifurcation is due to the generic
tendency for the B-fields to produce very filamentary tail morphology, the tail
properties are further shaped by the combination of the B-field orientation and
the sliding of the field past the disk surface exposed to the wind. Magnetic
draping does not strongly change the rate of gas stripping. For a face-on
galaxy, the field tends to reduce the amount of stripping compared to the pure
hydro case, and is associated with the formation of a magnetic draping layer on
the side of the galaxy exposed to the ICM wind. For significantly tilted disks,
the stripping rate may be enhanced by the ``scraping'' of the disk surface by
the B-fields sliding past the ISM/ICM interface.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.5450 [pdf] - 1180088
The origin of cold gas in giant elliptical galaxies and its role in
fueling radio-mode AGN feedback
Werner, N.;
Oonk, J. B. R.;
Sun, M.;
Nulsen, P. E. J.;
Allen, S. W.;
Canning, R. E. A.;
Simionescu, A.;
Hoffer, A.;
Connor, T.;
Donahue, M.;
Edge, A. C.;
Fabian, A. C.;
von der Linden, A.;
Reynolds, C. S.;
Ruszkowski, M.
Submitted: 2013-10-21, last modified: 2014-01-13
We present a multi-wavelength study of the interstellar medium in eight
nearby, X-ray and optically bright, giant elliptical galaxies. Using Herschel
PACS, we map the cold gas in the lines of [CII], [OI], and [OIb]. Additionally,
we present Ha+[NII] imaging of warm ionized gas with the SOAR telescope, and a
study of the hot X-ray emitting plasma with Chandra. All systems with extended
Ha emission in our sample (6/8 galaxies) display significant [CII] line
emission indicating the presence of cold gas. This emission is co-spatial with
the Ha+[NII] emitting nebulae and the lowest entropy X-ray emitting plasma. The
entropy profiles of the hot galactic atmospheres show a clear dichotomy, with
the systems displaying extended emission line nebulae having lower entropies
beyond r~1 kpc than the cold-gas-poor systems. We show that while the hot
atmospheres of the cold-gas-poor galaxies are thermally stable outside of their
innermost cores, the atmospheres of the cold-gas-rich systems are prone to
cooling instabilities. This result indicates that the cold gas is produced
chiefly by thermally unstable cooling from the hot phase. We show that cooling
instabilities may develop more easily in rotating systems and discuss an
alternative condition for thermal instability for this case. The hot
atmospheres of cold-gas-rich galaxies display disturbed morphologies indicating
that the accretion of clumpy multiphase gas in these systems may result in
variable power output of the AGN jets, potentially triggering sporadic, larger
outbursts. In the two cold-gas-poor, X-ray morphologically relaxed galaxies of
our sample, NGC 1399 and NGC 4472, powerful AGN outbursts may have destroyed or
removed most of the cold gas from the cores, allowing the jets to propagate and
deposit most of their energy further out, increasing the entropy of the hot
galactic atmospheres and leaving their cores relatively undisturbed.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1311.6159 [pdf] - 1201843
Fermi bubble simulations: black hole feedback in the Milky Way
Submitted: 2013-11-24
The $Fermi$ gamma-ray telescope discovered a pair of bubbles at the Galactic
center. These structures are spatially-correlated with the microwave emission
detected by the WMAP and Planck satellites. These bubbles were likely inflated
by a jet launched from the vicinity of a supermassive black hole in the
Galactic center. Using MHD simulations, which self-consistently include
interactions between cosmic rays and magnetic fields, we build models of the
supersonic jet propagation, cosmic ray transport, and the magnetic field
amplification within the $Fermi$ bubbles. Our key findings are that: (1) the
synthetic $Fermi$ gamma-ray and WMAP microwave spectra based on our simulations
are consistent with the observations, suggesting that a single population of
cosmic ray leptons may simultaneously explain the emission across a range of
photon energies; (2) the model fits the observed centrally-peaked microwave
emission if a second, more recent, pair of jets embedded in the $Fermi$ bubbles
is included in the model. This is consistent with the observationally-based
suggestion made by Su & Finkbeiner (2012); (3) the radio emission from the
bubbles is expected to be strongly polarized due to the relatively high level
of field ordering caused by elongated turbulent vortices. This effect is caused
by the interaction of the shocks driven by the jets with the preexisting
interstellar medium turbulence; (4) a layer of enhanced rotation measure in the
shock-compressed region could exist in the bubble vicinity but the level of
this enhancement depends on the details of the magnetic topology.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1307.3551 [pdf] - 739033
The Fermi Bubbles: Gamma-ray, Microwave, and Polarization Signatures of
Leptonic AGN Jets
Submitted: 2013-07-12, last modified: 2013-10-29
The origin of the Fermi bubbles and the microwave haze is yet to be
determined. To disentangle different models requires detailed comparisons
between theoretical predictions and multi-wavelength observations. Our previous
simulations have demonstrated that the primary features of the Fermi bubbles
could be successfully reproduced by recent jet activity from the central active
galactic nucleus (AGN). In this work, we generate gamma-ray and microwave maps
and spectra based on the simulated properties of cosmic rays (CRs) and magnetic
fields in order to examine whether the observed bubble and haze emission could
be explained by leptons contained in the AGN jets. We also investigate the
model predictions of the polarization properties of the Fermi bubbles. We find
that: (1) The same population of leptons can simultaneously explain the bubble
and haze emission given that the magnetic fields within the bubbles are very
close to the exponentially distributed ambient field, which can be explained by
mixing in of the ambient field followed by turbulent field amplification; (2)
The centrally peaked microwave profile suggests CR replenishment, which is
consistent with the presence of a more recent second jet event; (3) The bubble
interior exhibits a high degree of polarization because of ordered radial
magnetic field lines stretched by elongated vortices behind the shocks;
highly-polarized signals could also be observed inside the draping layer; (4)
Enhancement of rotation measures could exist within the shock-compressed layer
because of increased gas density and more amplified and ordered magnetic
fields. We discuss the possibility that the deficient haze emission at b<-35
degrees is due to the suppression of magnetic fields, which is consistent with
the existence of lower-energy CRs causing the polarized emission at 2.3 GHz.
Possible AGN jet composition in the leptonic scenario is also discussed.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.3168 [pdf] - 1165890
Powering of cool filaments in cluster cores by buoyant bubbles. I.
Qualitative model
Submitted: 2013-04-10, last modified: 2013-09-11
Cool-core clusters (e.g., Perseus or M87) often possess a network of bright
gaseous filaments, observed in radio, infrared, optical and X-ray bands. We
propose that these filaments are powered by the reconnection of the magnetic
field in the wakes of buoyant bubbles. AGN-inflated bubbles of relativistic
plasma rise buoyantly in the cluster atmosphere, stretching and amplifying the
field in the wake to values of $\displaystyle \beta =8\pi P_{gas}/B^2\sim 1$.
The field lines in the wake have opposite directions and are forced together as
the bubble motion stretches the filament. This setup bears strong similarity to
the coronal loops on the Sun or to the Earth's magneto-tail. The reconnection
process naturally explains both the required level of local dissipation rate in
filaments and the overall luminosity of filaments. The original source of power
for the filaments is the potential energy of buoyant bubbles, inflated by the
central AGN.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1301.3130 [pdf] - 1159031
Chaotic cold accretion onto black holes
Submitted: 2013-01-14, last modified: 2013-04-22
Using 3D AMR simulations, linking the 50 kpc to the sub-pc scales over the
course of 40 Myr, we systematically relax the classic Bondi assumptions in a
typical galaxy hosting a SMBH. In the realistic scenario, where the hot gas is
cooling, while heated and stirred on large scales, the accretion rate is
boosted up to two orders of magnitude compared with the Bondi prediction. The
cause is the nonlinear growth of thermal instabilities, leading to the
condensation of cold clouds and filaments when t_cool/t_ff < 10. Subsonic
turbulence of just over 100 km/s (M > 0.2) induces the formation of thermal
instabilities, even in the absence of heating, while in the transonic regime
turbulent dissipation inhibits their growth (t_turb/t_cool < 1). When heating
restores global thermodynamic balance, the formation of the multiphase medium
is violent, and the mode of accretion is fully cold and chaotic. The recurrent
collisions and tidal forces between clouds, filaments and the central clumpy
torus promote angular momentum cancellation, hence boosting accretion. On
sub-pc scales the clouds are channelled to the very centre via a funnel. A good
approximation to the accretion rate is the cooling rate, which can be used as
subgrid model, physically reproducing the boost factor of 100 required by
cosmological simulations, while accounting for fluctuations. Chaotic cold
accretion may be common in many systems, such as hot galactic halos, groups,
and clusters, generating high-velocity clouds and strong variations of the AGN
luminosity and jet orientation. In this mode, the black hole can quickly react
to the state of the entire host galaxy, leading to efficient self-regulated AGN
feedback and the symbiotic Magorrian relation. During phases of overheating,
the hot mode becomes the single channel of accretion (with a different cuspy
temperature profile), though strongly suppressed by turbulence.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1211.6722 [pdf] - 1158125
The nature of filamentary cold gas in the core of the Virgo Cluster
Werner, N.;
Oonk, J. B. R.;
Canning, R. E. A.;
Allen, S. W.;
Simionescu, A.;
Kos, J.;
van Weeren, R. J.;
Edge, A. C.;
Fabian, A. C.;
von der Linden, A.;
Nulsen, P. E. J.;
Reynolds, C. S.;
Ruszkowski, M.
Submitted: 2012-11-28, last modified: 2013-03-06
We present a multi-wavelength study of the emission-line nebulae located
southeast of the nucleus of M87, the central dominant galaxy of the Virgo
Cluster. We report the detection of far-infrared (FIR) [CII] line emission from
the nebulae using observations made with Herschel PACS. The infrared line
emission is extended and cospatial with optical H{\alpha}+[NII],
far-ultraviolet CIV lines, and soft X-ray emission. The filamentary nebulae
evidently contain multi-phase material spanning a temperature range of at least
5 orders of magnitude, from ~100 K to ~10^7 K. This material has most likely
been uplifted by the AGN from the center of M87. The thermal pressure of the
10^4 K phase appears to be significantly lower than that of the surrounding hot
intra-cluster medium (ICM) indicating the presence of additional turbulent and
magnetic pressure in the filaments. If the turbulence in the filaments is
subsonic then the magnetic field strength required to balance the pressure of
the surrounding ICM is B~30-70 {\mu}G. The spectral properties of the soft
X-ray emission from the filaments indicate that it is due to thermal plasma
with kT~0.5-1 keV, which is cooling by mixing with the cold gas and/or
radiatively. Charge exchange can be ruled out as a significant source of soft
X-rays. Both cooling and mixing scenarios predict gas with a range of
temperatures. This is at first glance inconsistent with the apparent lack of
X-ray emitting gas with kT<0.5 keV. However, we show that the missing very soft
X-ray emission could be absorbed by the cold gas in the filaments with an
integrated hydrogen column density of ~1.6x10^21 cm^-2, providing a natural
explanation for the apparent temperature floor to the X-ray emission at kT~0.5
keV. The FIR through ultra-violet line emission is most likely primarily
powered by the ICM particles penetrating the cold gas following a shearing
induced mixing process.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1210.1612 [pdf] - 1151894
Simulations of bent-double radio sources in galaxy groups
Submitted: 2012-10-04, last modified: 2013-02-04
Bent-double radio sources have been used as a probe to measure the density of
intergalactic gas in galaxy groups. We carry out a series of high-resolution,
3D simulations of AGN jets moving through an external medium with a constant
density in order to develop a general formula for the radius of curvature of
the jets, and to determine how accurately the density of the intra-group medium
(IGM) can be measured. Our simulations produce curved jets ending in bright
radio lobes with an extended trail of low surface brightness radio emission.
The radius of curvature of the jets varies with time by only about 25%. The
radio trail seen in our simulations is typically not detected in known sources,
but may be detectable in lower resolution radio observations. The length of
this tail can be used to determine the age of the AGN. We also use our
simulation data to derive a formula for the kinetic luminosity of observed jets
in terms of the radius of curvature and jet pressure. In characterizing how
well observations can measure the IGM density, we find that the limited
resolution of typical radio observations leads to a systematic under-estimate
of the density of about 50%. The unknown angles between the observer and the
direction of jet propagation and direction of AGN motion through the IGM leads
to an uncertainty of about 50% in estimates of the IGM density. Previous
conclusions drawn using these sources, indicating that galaxy groups contain
significant reservoirs of baryons in their IGM, are still valid when
considering this level of uncertainty. In addition, we model the X-ray emission
expected from bent-double radio sources. We find that known sources in
reasonably dense environments should be detectable in ~100 ks Chandra
observations. X-ray observations of these sources would place constraints on
the IGM density and AGN velocity that are complementary to radio observations.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1204.6005 [pdf] - 1118307
Cold Fronts and Gas Sloshing in Galaxy Clusters with Anisotropic Thermal
Conduction
Submitted: 2012-04-26, last modified: 2012-11-11
(Abridged) Cold fronts in cluster cool cores should be erased on short
timescales by thermal conduction, unless protected by magnetic fields that are
"draped" parallel to the front surfaces, suppressing conduction perpendicular
to the fronts. We present MHD simulations of cold front formation in the core
of a galaxy cluster with anisotropic thermal conduction, exploring a parameter
space of conduction strengths parallel and perpendicular to the field lines.
Including conduction has a strong effect on the temperature of the core and the
cold fronts. Though magnetic field lines are draping parallel to the front
surfaces, the temperature jumps across the fronts are nevertheless reduced. The
field geometry is such that the cold gas below the front surfaces can be
connected to hotter regions outside via field lines along directions
perpendicular to the plane of the sloshing motions and along sections of the
front which are not perfectly draped. This results in the heating of this gas
below the front on a timescale of a Gyr, but the sharpness of the density and
temperature jumps may still be preserved. By modifying the density distribution
below the front, conduction may indirectly aid in suppressing Kelvin-Helmholtz
instabilities. If conduction along the field lines is unsuppressed, we find
that the characteristic sharp jumps in X-ray emission seen in observations of
clusters do not form. This suggests that the presence of sharp cold fronts in
hot clusters could be used to place upper limits on conduction in the {\it
bulk} of the ICM. Finally, the combination of sloshing and anisotropic thermal
conduction can result in a larger flux of heat to the core than either process
in isolation. While still not sufficient to prevent a cooling catastrophe in
the very central ($r \sim$ 5 kpc) regions of the cool core, it reduces
significantly the mass of cool gas that accumulates outside those radii.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.4185 [pdf] - 1124903
The Fermi Bubbles: Supersonic AGN Jets with Anisotropic Cosmic Ray
Diffusion
Submitted: 2012-07-17, last modified: 2012-10-26
The Fermi Gamma-ray Space Telescope reveals two large bubbles in the Galaxy,
which extend nearly symmetrically ~50 degrees above and below the Galactic
center (GC). Using three-dimensional (3D) magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations
that self-consistently include the dynamical interaction between cosmic rays
(CR) and thermal gas, and anisotropic CR diffusion along the magnetic field
lines, we show that the key characteristics of the observed gamma-ray bubbles
and the spatially-correlated X-ray features in ROSAT 1.5 keV map can be
successfully reproduced by a recent jet activity from the central active
galactic nucleus (AGN). We find that after taking into account the projection
of the 3D bubbles onto the sky, the physical heights of the bubbles can be much
smaller than previously thought, greatly reducing the formation time of the
bubbles to about a Myr. This relatively small bubble age is needed to reconcile
the simulations with the upper limit of bubbles ages estimated from the cooling
time of high-energy electrons. No additional physical mechanisms are required
to suppress large-scale hydrodynamic instabilities because the evolution time
is too short for them to develop. The simulated CR bubbles are edge-brightened,
which is consistent with the observed projected flat surface brightness
distribution. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the sharp edges of the observed
bubbles can be due to anisotropic CR diffusion along magnetic field lines that
drape around the bubbles during their supersonic expansion, with suppressed
perpendicular diffusion across the bubble surface. Possible causes of the
slight bends of the Fermi bubbles to the west are also discussed.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.6947 [pdf] - 581953
Ram pressure stripping in elliptical galaxies: I. the impact of the
interstellar medium turbulence
Submitted: 2012-06-29, last modified: 2012-09-29
Elliptical galaxies contain X-ray emitting gas that is subject to continuous
ram pressure stripping over timescales comparable to cluster ages. The gas in
these galaxies is not in perfect hydrostatic equilibrium. Supernova feedback,
stellar winds, or active galactic nuclei (AGN) feedback can significantly
perturb the interstellar medium (ISM). Using hydrodynamical simulations, we
investigate the effect of subsonic turbulence in the hot ISM on the ram
pressure stripping process in early-type galaxies. We find that galaxies with
more turbulent ISM produce longer, wider, and more smoothly distributed tails
of the stripped ISM than those characterised by weaker ISM turbulence. Our main
conclusion is that even very weak internal turbulence, at the level of <15% of
the average ISM sound speed, can significantly accelerate the gas removal from
galaxies via ram pressure stripping. The magnitude of this effect increases
sharply with the strength of turbulence. As most of the gas stripping takes
place near the boundary between the ISM and the intraclustermedium (ICM), the
boost in the ISM stripping rate is due to the "random walk" of the ISM from the
central regions of the galactic potential well to larger distances, where the
ram pressure is able to permanently remove the gas from galaxies. The ICM can
be temporarily trapped inside the galactic potential well due to the mixing of
the turbulent ISM with the ICM. The galaxies with more turbulent ISM, yet still
characterised by very weak turbulence, can hold larger amounts of the ICM.
[Abridged]
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.3305 [pdf] - 1151416
Solving the Cooling Flow Problem through Mechanical AGN Feedback
Submitted: 2012-09-14
Unopposed radiative cooling of plasma would lead to the cooling catastrophe,
a massive inflow of condensing gas, manifest in the core of galaxies, groups
and clusters. The last generation X-ray telescopes, Chandra and XMM, have
radically changed our view on baryons, indicating AGN heating as the balancing
counterpart of cooling. This work reviews our extensive investigation on
self-regulated heating. We argue that the mechanical feedback, based on massive
subrelativistic outflows, is the key to solving the cooling flow problem, i.e.
dramatically quenching the cooling rates for several Gyr without destroying the
cool-core structure. Using a modified version of the 3D hydrocode FLASH, we
show that bipolar AGN outflows can further reproduce fundamental observed
features, such as buoyant bubbles, weak shocks, metals dredge- up, and
turbulence. The latter is an essential ingredient to drive nonlinear thermal
instabilities, which cause the formation of extended cold gas, a residual of
the quenched cooling flow and, later, fuel for the feedback engine. Compared to
clusters, groups and galaxies require a gentler mechanical feedback, in order
to avoid catastrophic overheating. We highlight the essential characteristics
for a realistic AGN feedback, with emphasis on observational consistency.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1202.2357 [pdf] - 1116559
Shallow Dark Matter Cusps in Galaxy Clusters
Submitted: 2012-02-10
We study the evolution of the stellar and dark matter components in a galaxy
cluster of $10^{15} \, \rm{M_{\odot}}$ from $z=3$ to the present epoch using
the high-resolution collisionless simulations of Ruszkowski & Springel (2009).
At $z=3$ the dominant progenitor halos were populated with spherical model
galaxies with and without accounting for adiabatic contraction. We apply a
weighting scheme which allows us to change the relative amount of dark and
stellar material assigned to each simulation particle in order to produce
luminous properties which agree better with abundance matching arguments and
observed bulge sizes at $z=3$. This permits the study of the effect of initial
compactness on the evolution of the mass-size relation. We find that for more
compact initial stellar distributions the size of the final Brightest Cluster
Galaxy grows with mass according to $r\propto M^{2}$, whereas for more extended
initial distributions, $r\propto M$. Our results show that collisionless
mergers in a cosmological context can reduce the strength of inner dark matter
cusps with changes in logarithmic slope of 0.3 to 0.5 at fixed radius. Shallow
cusps such as those found recently in several strong lensing clusters thus do
not necessarily conflict with CDM, but may rather reflect on the initial
structure of the progenitor galaxies, which was shaped at high redshift by
their formation process.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1110.6063 [pdf] - 1085195
Cause and Effect of Feedback: Multiphase Gas in Cluster Cores Heated by
AGN Jets
Submitted: 2011-10-27
Multiwavelength data indicate that the X-ray emitting plasma in the cores of
galaxy clusters is not cooling catastrophically. To large extent, cooling is
offset by heating due to active galactic nuclei (AGN) via jets. The cool-core
clusters, with cooler/denser plasmas, show multiphase gas and signs of some
cooling in their cores. These observations suggest that the cool core is
locally thermally unstable while maintaining global thermal equilibrium. Using
high-resolution, three-dimensional simulations we study the formation of
multiphase gas in cluster cores heated by highly-collimated bipolar AGN jets.
Our key conclusion is that spatially extended multiphase filaments form only
when the instantaneous ratio of the thermal instability and free-fall
timescales (t_TI/t_ff) falls below a critical threshold of \approx 10. When
this happens, dense cold gas decouples from the hot ICM phase and generates
inhomogeneous and spatially extended Halpha filaments. These cold gas clumps
and filaments `rain' down onto the central regions of the core, forming a cold
rotating torus and in part feeding the supermassive black hole. Consequently,
the self-regulated feedback enhances AGN heating and the core returns to a
higher entropy level with t_TI/t_ff > 10. Eventually the core reaches
quasi-stable global thermal equilibrium, and cold filaments condense out of the
hot ICM whenever t_TI/t_ff \lesssim 10. This occurs despite the fact that the
energy from AGN jets is supplied to the core in a highly anisotropic fashion.
The effective spatial redistribution of heat is enabled in part by the
turbulent motions in the wake of freely-falling cold filaments. Increased AGN
activity can locally reverse the cold gas flow, launching cold filamentary gas
away from the cluster center. Our criterion for the condensation of spatially
extended cold gas is in agreement with observations and previous idealized
simulations.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1003.3049 [pdf] - 1025725
Swimming against the current: Simulations of central AGN evolution in
dynamic galaxy clusters
Submitted: 2010-03-15, last modified: 2010-10-16
We present a series of three-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations of
central AGN driven jets in a dynamic, cosmologically evolved galaxy cluster.
Extending previous work, we study jet powers ranging from L_jet = 10^44 erg/s
to L_jet = 10^46 erg/s and in duration from 30 Myr to 200 Myr. We find that
large-scale motions of cluster gas disrupt the AGN jets, causing energy to be
distributed throughout the centre of the cluster, rather than confined to a
narrow angle around the jet axis. Disruption of the jet also leads to the
appearance of multiple disconnected X-ray bubbles from a long-duration AGN with
a constant luminosity. This implies that observations of multiple bubbles in a
cluster are not necessarily an expression of the AGN duty cycle. We find that
the "sphere of influence" of the AGN, the radial scale within which the cluster
is strongly affected by the jet, scales as R ~ L_jet^(1/3). Increasing the
duration of AGN activity does not increase the radius affected by the AGN
significantly, but does change the magnitude of the AGN's effects. How an AGN
delivers energy to a cluster will determine where that energy is deposited: a
high luminosity is needed to heat material outside the core of the cluster,
while a low-luminosity, long-duration AGN is more efficient at heating the
inner few tens of kpc.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1010.2277 [pdf] - 1041232
Cosmological MHD simulations of cluster formation with anisotropic
thermal conduction
Submitted: 2010-10-11
(abridged) The ICM has been suggested to be buoyantly unstable in the
presence of magnetic field and anisotropic thermal conduction. We perform first
cosmological simulations of galaxy cluster formation that simultaneously
include magnetic fields, radiative cooling and anisotropic thermal conduction.
In isolated and idealized cluster models, the magnetothermal instability (MTI)
tends to reorient the magnetic fields radially. Using cosmological simulations
of the Santa Barbara cluster we detect radial bias in the velocity and magnetic
fields. Such radial bias is consistent with either the inhomogeneous radial gas
flows due to substructures or residual MTI-driven field rearangements that are
expected even in the presence of turbulence. Although disentangling the two
scenarios is challenging, we do not detect excess bias in the runs that include
anisotropic thermal conduction. The anisotropy effect is potentially detectable
via radio polarization measurements with LOFAR and SKA and future X-ray
spectroscopic studies with the IXO. We demonstrate that radiative cooling
boosts the amplification of the magnetic field by about two orders of magnitude
beyond what is expected in the non-radiative cases. At z=0 the field is
amplified by a factor of about 10^6 compared to the uniform magnetic field
evolved due to the universal expansion alone. Interestingly, the runs that
include both radiative cooling and anisotropic thermal conduction exhibit
stronger magnetic field amplification than purely radiative runs at the
off-center locations. In these runs, shallow temperature gradients away from
the cluster center make the ICM neutrally buoyant. The ICM is more easily mixed
in these regions and the winding up of the frozen-in magnetic field is more
efficient resulting in stronger magnetic field amplification.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1008.5016 [pdf] - 1034551
Galaxy Motions, Turbulence and Conduction in Clusters of Galaxies
Submitted: 2010-08-30
Unopposed radiative cooling in clusters of galaxies results in excessive mass
deposition rates. However, the cool cores of galaxy clusters are continuously
heated by thermal conduction and turbulent heat diffusion due to minor mergers
or the galaxies orbiting the cluster center. These processes can either reduce
the energy requirements for AGN heating of cool cores, or they can prevent
overcooling altogether. We perform 3D MHD simulations including field-aligned
thermal conduction and self-gravitating particles to model this in detail.
Turbulence is not confined to the wakes of galaxies but is instead
volume-filling, due to the excitation of large-scale g-modes. We systematically
probe the parameter space of galaxy masses and numbers. For a wide range of
observationally motivated galaxy parameters, the magnetic field is randomized
by stirring motions, restoring the conductive heat flow to the core. The
cooling catastrophe either does not occur or it is sufficiently delayed to
allow the cluster to experience a major merger that could reset conditions in
the intracluster medium. Whilst dissipation of turbulent motions is negligible
as a heat source, turbulent heat diffusion is extremely important; it
predominates in the cluster center. However, thermal conduction becomes
important at larger radii, and simulations without thermal conduction suffer a
cooling catastrophe. Conduction is important both as a heat source and to
reduce stabilizing buoyancy forces, enabling more efficient diffusion.
Turbulence enables conduction, and conduction enables turbulence. In these
simulations, the gas vorticity---which is a good indicator of trapped
g-modes--increases with time. The vorticity growth is approximately mirrored by
the growth of the magnetic field, which is amplified by turbulence.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.5301 [pdf] - 1018920
AGN pairs: chance superpositions or black hole binaries?
Submitted: 2009-12-29
Several active galactic nuclei (AGN) with multiple sets of emission lines
separated by over 2000 km/s have been observed recently. These have been
interpreted as being due to massive black hole (MBH) recoil following a black
hole merger, MBH binaries, or chance superpositions of AGN in galaxy clusters.
Moreover, a number of double-peaked AGN with velocity offsets of ~ a few 100
km/s have also been detected and interpreted as being due to the internal
kinematics of the narrow line regions or MBH binary systems. Here we reexamine
the superposition model. Using the Millennium Run we estimate the total number
of detectable AGN pairs as a function of the emission line offset. We show that
AGN pairs with high velocity line separations up to ~2000 km/s are very likely
to be chance superpositions of two AGN in clusters of galaxies for reasonable
assumptions about the relative fraction of AGN. No superimposed AGN pairs are
predicted for velocity offsets in excess of ~3000 km/s as the required AGN
fractions would violate observational constraints. The high velocity AGN pair
numbers predicted here are competitive with those predicted from the models
relying on MBH recoil or MBH binaries. However, the model fails to account for
the largest emission line velocity offsets that require the presence of MBH
binaries.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.5198 [pdf] - 902555
Shaken and stirred: conduction and turbulence in clusters of galaxies
Submitted: 2009-11-26, last modified: 2009-12-16
(abridged) Uninhibited radiative cooling in clusters of galaxies would lead
to excessive mass accretion rates contrary to observations. One of the key
proposals to offset radiative energy losses is thermal conduction from outer,
hotter layers of cool core clusters to their centers. However, conduction is
sensitive to magnetic field topology. In cool-core clusters the heat buoyancy
instability (HBI) leads to B-fields ordered preferentially in the direction
perpendicular to that of gravity, which significantly reduces the level of
conduction below the classical Spitzer-Braginskii value. However, the cluster
cool cores are rarely in perfect hydrostatic equilibrium. Sloshing motions due
to minor mergers, galaxy motions or AGN can significantly perturb the gas and
affect the level of thermal conduction. We perform 3D AMR MHD simulations of
the effect of turbulence on the properties of the anisotropic thermal
conduction in cool core clusters. We show that very weak subsonic motions, well
within observational constraints, can randomize the magnetic field and
significantly boost effective thermal conduction beyond the saturated values
expected in the pure unperturbed HBI case. We find that the turbulent motions
can essentially restore the conductive heat flow to the cool core to level
comparable to the theoretical maximum of 1/3 Spitzer for a highly tangled
field. Runs with radiative cooling show that the cooling catastrophe can be
averted and the cluster core stabilized. Above a critical Froude number, these
same turbulent motions also eliminate the tangential bias in the velocity and
magnetic field that is otherwise induced by the trapped g-modes. Our results
can be tested with future radio polarization measurements, and have
implications for efficient metal dispersal in clusters.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.5554 [pdf] - 1018546
AGN Feedback and Bimodality in Cluster Core Entropy
Submitted: 2009-11-30
We investigate a series of steady-state models of galaxy clusters, in which
the hot intracluster gas is efficiently heated by active galactic nucleus (AGN)
feedback and thermal conduction, and in which the mass accretion rates are
highly reduced compared to those predicted by the standard cooling flow models.
We perform a global Lagrangian stability analysis. We show for the first time
that the global radial instability in cool core clusters can be suppressed by
the AGN feedback mechanism, provided that the feedback efficiency exceeds a
critical lower limit. Furthermore, our analysis naturally shows that the
clusters can exist in two distinct forms. Globally stable clusters are expected
to have either: 1) cool cores stabilized by both AGN feedback and conduction,
or 2) non-cool cores stabilized primarily by conduction. Intermediate central
temperatures typically lead to globally unstable solutions. This bimodality is
consistent with the recently observed anticorrelation between the flatness of
the temperature profiles and the AGN activity (Dunn & Fabian 2008) and the
observation by Rafferty et al. (2008) that the shorter central cooling times
tend to correspond to significantly younger AGN X-ray cavities.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:0910.5729 [pdf] - 1018147
Dual black holes in merger remnants. II: spin evolution and
gravitational recoil
Submitted: 2009-10-29, last modified: 2009-11-30
Using high resolution hydrodynamical simulations, we explore the spin
evolution of massive dual black holes orbiting inside a circumnuclear disc,
relic of a gas-rich galaxy merger. The black holes spiral inwards from
initially eccentric co or counter-rotating coplanar orbits relative to the
disc's rotation, and accrete gas that is carrying a net angular momentum. As
the black hole mass grows, its spin changes in strength and direction due to
its gravito-magnetic coupling with the small-scale accretion disc. We find that
the black hole spins loose memory of their initial orientation, as accretion
torques suffice to align the spins with the angular momentum of their orbit on
a short timescale (<1-2 Myr). A residual off-set in the spin direction relative
to the orbital angular momentum remains, at the level of <10 degrees for the
case of a cold disc, and <30 degrees for a warmer disc. Alignment in a cooler
disc is more effective due to the higher coherence of the accretion flow near
each black hole that reflects the large-scale coherence of the disc's rotation.
If the massive black holes coalesce preserving the spin directions set after
formation of a Keplerian binary, the relic black hole resulting from their
coalescence receives a relatively small gravitational recoil. The distribution
of recoil velocities inferred from a simulated sample of massive black hole
binaries has median <70 km/s much smaller than the median resulting from an
isotropic distribution of spins.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.5201 [pdf] - 1018524
Are black holes big enough to quench cooling in cluster cool cores?
Submitted: 2009-11-27
Total energy arguments (e.g., Fabian et al. 2002) suggest that black holes
need to have masses significantly in excess of the prediction from the classic
black hole mass - velocity dispersion relation (M-sigma) in order to offset the
cooling losses in massive cool core clusters. This suggests that the black
holes may be too small to power such clusters. However, Lauer et al. (2007)
argue that the black hole mass - bulge luminosity relationship is a better
predictor of black hole masses in high luminosity galaxies and that this
relationship predicts significantly higher masses in BCGs. They find slow
increase in the velocity dispersion with luminosity and a more rapid increase
in effective radii with luminosity seen in BCGs as opposed to less luminous
galaxies. Motivated by these results and the theoretical work of Boylan-Kolchin
et al. (2006) on isolated mergers, we perform high-resolution cosmological
simulations of dry mergers in a massive galaxy cluster identified in the
Millennium Run including both the dark matter halos and stellar bulges of
merging galaxies. We demonstrate that the BCG clearly evolves away from the
size-luminosity relation as defined by the smaller galaxies (i.e., the relation
bends) and we also see a bending in the luminosity-sigma relation. As black
hole mass is expected to be proportional to the mass and luminosity of the
stellar bulge of the BCGs (if they were formed in predominantly dissipationless
mergers), our findings are consistent with those of Lauer et al. (2007) on a
qualitative level and suggest that the black holes in BCGs may indeed be more
massive than predicted from the standard M-sigma relation.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:0902.1525 [pdf] - 1001436
Dual black holes in merger remnants. I: linking accretion to dynamics
Submitted: 2009-02-09, last modified: 2009-04-15
We study the orbital evolution and accretion history of massive black hole
(MBH) pairs in rotationally supported circumnuclear discs up to the point where
MBHs form binary systems. Our simulations have high resolution in mass and
space which, for the first time, makes it feasible to follow the orbital decay
of a MBH either counter- or co-rotating with respect to the circumnuclear disc.
We show that a moving MBH on an initially counter-rotating orbit experiences an
"orbital angular momentum flip" due to the gas-dynamical friction, i.e., it
starts to corotate with the disc before a MBH binary forms. We stress that this
effect can only be captured in very high resolution simulations. Given the
extremely large number of gas particles used, the dynamical range is
sufficiently large to resolve the Bondi-Hoyle-Lyttleton radii of individual
MBHs. As a consequence, we are able to link the accretion processes to the
orbital evolution of the MBH pairs. We predict that the accretion rate is
significantly suppressed and extremely variable when the MBH is moving on a
retrograde orbit. It is only after the orbital angular momentum flip has taken
place that the secondary rapidly "lights up" at which point both MBHs can
accrete near the Eddington rate for a few Myr. The separation of the double
nucleus is expected to be around ~10 pc at this stage. We show that the
accretion rate can be highly variable also when the MBH is co-rotating with the
disc (albeit to a lesser extent) provided that its orbit is eccentric. Our
results have significant consequences for the expected number of observable
double AGNs at separations of <100 pc.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:0902.4890 [pdf] - 21887
The Evolution of Galaxy Clusters Across Cosmic Time
Arnaud, M.;
Bohringer, H.;
Jones, C.;
McNamara, B.;
Ohashi, T.;
Patnaude, D.;
Arnaud, K.;
Bautz, M.;
Blanchard, A.;
Bregman, J.;
Chartas, G.;
Croston, J.;
David, L.;
Donahue, M.;
Fabian, A.;
Finoguenov, A.;
Furuzawa, A.;
Gallagher, S.;
Haba, Y.;
Hornschemeier, A.;
Heinz, S.;
Kaastra, J.;
Kapferer, W.;
Lamer, G.;
Mahdavi, A.;
Makishima, K.;
Matsushita, K.;
Nakazawa, K.;
Nulsen, P.;
Ogle, P.;
Perlman, E.;
Ponman, T.;
Proga, D.;
Pratt, G.;
Randall, S.;
Richards, G.;
Romer, K.;
Ruszkowski, M.;
Schmidt, R.;
Smith, R.;
Tananbaum, H.;
Vrtilek, J.;
Worrall, D.
Submitted: 2009-02-27
The large scale structure of the present Universe is determined by the growth
of dark matter density fluctuations and by the dynamical action of dark energy
and dark matter. While much progress has been made in recent years in
constraining the cosmological parameters, and in reconstructing the evolution
in the large--scale structure of the dark matter distribution, we still lack an
understanding of the evolution of the baryonic component of the Universe.
Located at nodes of the cosmic web, clusters of galaxies are the largest
collapsed structures in the Universe with total masses up to 10$^{15}$
M$_{\sun}$. Over 80% of their mass resides in the form of dark matter. The
remaining mass is composed of baryons, most of which (about 85%) is a diffuse,
hot plasma that radiates primarily in X-rays. X-ray observations of the
evolving cluster population provide a unique opportunity to address such open
and fundamental questions as: How do hot diffuse baryons dynamically evolve in
dark matter potentials? How and when was the excess energy which we observe in
the intergalactic medium generated? What is the cosmic history of heavy-element
production and circulation?
Our current knowledge comes primarily from detailed studies of clusters in
the relatively nearby Universe (z$<$0.5). Major advances will come from high
throughput, high spectral and spatial resolution X-ray observations that
measure the thermodynamical properties and metal content of the first low mass
clusters emerging at z $\sim$ 2 and directly trace their evolution into today's
massive clusters.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:0902.0373 [pdf] - 163097
The role of dry mergers for the formation and evolution of brightest
cluster galaxies
Submitted: 2009-02-02
Using a resimulation technique, we perform high-resolution cosmological
simulations of dry mergers in a massive galaxy cluster identified in the
Millennium Run. Our initial conditions include well resolved compound galaxy
models consisting of dark matter halos and stellar bulges that are used to
replace the most massive cluster progenitor halos at redshift z=3. By
construction, our galaxy models obey the stellar mass-size relation initially.
We demonstrate that the brightest cluster galaxy (BCG) evolves away from the
Kormendy relation as defined by the smaller mass galaxies (i.e., the relation
bends). As a result of the comparatively large number of mergers the BCG
experiences, its total mass-to-light ratio becomes significantly higher than in
typical elliptical galaxies. We also show that the mixing processes between
dark matter and stars lead to a small but numerically robust tilt in the
fundamental plane and that the BCG lies on the tilted plane. Our model is
consistent with the observed steepening of the logarithmic mass-to-light
gradient as a function of the stellar mass. Surprisingly, we find only
tentative weak distortion in the Faber-Jackson relation that depends on the
aperture size, unlike expected based on studies of isolated merger simulations.
This may be due to differences in the distribution of galaxy orbits, which is
given in our approach directly by the cosmological context while it has to be
assumed in isolated merger simulations, and the fact that the BCG is located
deep in the cluster potential well.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:0804.3823 [pdf] - 12039
A Global Stability Analysis of Clusters of Galaxies with Conduction and
AGN Feedback Heating
Submitted: 2008-04-24, last modified: 2008-08-07
We investigate a series of steady-state models of galaxy clusters, in which
the hot intracluster gas is efficiently heated by active galactic nucleus (AGN)
feedback and thermal conduction, and in which the mass accretion rates are
highly reduced compared to those predicted by the standard cooling flow models.
We perform a global Lagrangian stability analysis. We show for the first time
that the global radial instability in cool core clusters can be suppressed by
the AGN feedback mechanism, provided that the feedback efficiency exceeds a
critical lower limit. Furthermore, our analysis naturally shows that the
clusters can exist in two distinct forms. Globally stable clusters are expected
to have either: 1) cool cores stabilized by both AGN feedback and conduction,
or 2) non-cool cores stabilized primarily by conduction. Intermediate central
temperatures typically lead to globally unstable solutions. This bimodality is
consistent with the recently observed anticorrelation between the flatness of
the temperature profiles and the AGN activity (Dunn & Fabian 2008) and the
observation by Rafferty et al. (2008) that the shorter central cooling times
tend to correspond to significantly younger AGN X-ray cavities.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:0807.3338 [pdf] - 14714
In-depth Chandra study of the AGN feedback in Virgo elliptical galaxy
M84
Submitted: 2008-07-21
Using deep Chandra observations of M84 we study the energetics of the
interaction between the black hole and the interstellar medium of this
early-type galaxy. We perform a detailed two dimensional reconstruction of the
properties of the X-ray emitting gas using a constrained Voronoi tessellation
method, identifying the mean trends and carrying out the fluctuation analysis
of the thermodynamical properties of the hot ISM. In addition to the PV work
associated with the bubble expansion, we identify and measure the wave energy
associated with the mildly supersonic bubble expansion. We show that, depending
on the age of the cavity and the associated wave, the waves can have a
substantial contribution to the total energy release from the AGN. The energy
dissipated in the waves tends to be concentrated near the center of M84 and in
the direction perpendicular to the bubble outflow, possibly due to the
interference of the waves generated by the expansion of northern and southern
bubbles. We also find direct evidence for the escape of radio plasma from the
ISM of the host galaxy into the intergalactic medium.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:0706.1869 [pdf] - 2171
Shock heating by FR I radio sources in galaxy clusters
Submitted: 2007-06-13
Feedback by active galactic nuclei (AGN) is frequently invoked to explain the
cut-off of the galaxy luminosity function at the bright end and the absence of
cooling flows in galaxy clusters. Meanwhile, there are recent observations of
shock fronts around radio-loud AGN. Using realistic 3D simulations of jets in a
galaxy cluster, we address the question what fraction of the energy of active
galactic nuclei is dissipated in shocks. We find that weak shocks that
encompass the AGN have Mach numbers of 1.1-1.2 and dissipate at least 2% of the
mechanical luminosity of the AGN. In a realistic cluster medium, even a
continuous jet can lead to multiple shock structures, which may lead to an
overestimate of the AGN duty cycles inferred from the spatial distribution of
waves.
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:0705.3235 [pdf] - 1512
Cosmic ray confinement in fossil cluster bubbles
Submitted: 2007-05-22
Most cool core clusters of galaxies possess active galactic nuclei (AGN) in
their centers. These AGN inflate buoyant bubbles containing non-thermal radio
emitting particles. If such bubbles efficiently confine cosmic rays (CR) then
this could explain ``radio ghosts'' seen far from cluster centers. We simulate
the diffusion of cosmic rays from buoyant bubbles inflated by AGN. Our
simulations include the effects of the anisotropic particle diffusion
introduced by magnetic fields. Our models are consistent with the X-ray
morphology of AGN bubbles, with disruption being suppressed by the magnetic
draping effect. We conclude that for such magnetic field topologies, a
substantial fraction of cosmic rays can be confined inside the bubbles on
buoyant rise timescales even when the parallel diffusivity coefficient is very
large. For isotropic diffusion at a comparable level, cosmic rays would leak
out of the bubbles too rapidly to be consistent with radio observations. Thus,
the long confinement times associated with the magnetic suppression of CR
diffusion can explain the presence of radio ghosts. We show that the partial
escape of cosmic rays is mostly confined to the wake of the rising bubbles, and
speculate that this effect could: (1) account for the excitation of the
H$\alpha$ filaments trailing behind the bubbles in the Perseus cluster, (2)
inject entropy into the metal enriched material being lifted by the bubbles
and, thus, help to displace it permanently from the cluster center and (3)
produce observable $\gamma$-rays via the interaction of the diffusing cosmic
rays with the thermal intracluster medium (ICM).
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0703801 [pdf] - 90610
Impact of tangled magnetic fields on AGN-blown bubbles
Submitted: 2007-03-30
There is growing consensus that feedback from AGN is the main mechanism
responsible for stopping cooling flows in clusters of galaxies. AGN are known
to inflate buoyant bubbles that supply mechanical power to the intracluster gas
(ICM). High Reynolds number hydrodynamical simulations show that such bubbles
get entirely disrupted within 100 Myr, as they rise in cluster atmospheres,
which is contrary to observations. This artificial mixing has consequences for
models trying to quantify the amount of heating and star formation in cool core
clusters of galaxies. It has been suggested that magnetic fields can stabilize
bubbles against disruption. We perform MHD simulations of fossil bubbles in the
presence of tangled magnetic fields using the high order PENCIL code. We focus
on the physically-motivated case where thermal pressure dominates over magnetic
pressure and consider randomly oriented fields with and without maximum
helicity and a case where large scale external fields drape the bubble.We find
that helicity has some stabilizing effect. However, unless the coherence length
of magnetic fields exceeds the bubble size, the bubbles are quickly shredded.
As observations of Hydra A suggest that lengthscale of magnetic fields may be
smaller then typical bubble size, this may suggest that other mechanisms, such
as viscosity, may be responsible for stabilizing the bubbles. However, since
Faraday rotation observations of radio lobes do not constrain large scale ICM
fields well if they are aligned with the bubble surface, the draping case may
be a viable alternative solution to the problem. A generic feature found in our
simulations is the formation of magnetic wakes where fields are ordered and
amplified. We suggest that this effect could prevent evaporation by thermal
conduction of cold Halpha filaments observed in the Perseus cluster.
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0512148 [pdf] - 78348
Viscosity in cosmological simulations of clusters of galaxies
Submitted: 2005-12-06
The physics of the intracluster medium, in particular the values for the
thermal conductivity and the viscosity are largely unknown and subject to an
ongoing debate. Here, we study the effect of viscosity on the thermal state of
the intracluster medium using three-dimensional cosmological simulations of
structure formation. It is shown that viscosity, provided it is not too far off
from the unmagnetised Spitzer value, has a significant effect on cluster
profiles. In particular, it aids in heating the cool cores of clusters. The
central cooling time of the most massive clusters in our simulation is
increased by more than an order of magnitude. In large clusters, viscous
heating may help to establish an entropy floor and to prevent a cooling
catastrophe.
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0508231 [pdf] - 75120
Simulations of magnetic fields in filaments
Submitted: 2005-08-10
The intergalactic magnetic field within filaments should be less polluted by
magnetised outflows from active galaxies than magnetic fields in clusters.
Therefore, filaments may be a better laboratory to study magnetic field
amplification by structure formation than galaxy clusters which typically host
many more active galaxies. We present highly resolved cosmological AMR
simulations of magnetic fields in the cosmos and make predictions about the
evolution and structure of magnetic fields in filaments. Comparing our results
to observational evidence for magnetic fields in filaments suggests that
amplification of seed fields by gravitational collapse is not sufficient to
produce IGM fields. Finally, implications for cosmic ray transport are
discussed.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0508120 [pdf] - 75009
AGN heating, thermal conduction and Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect in galaxy
groups and clusters
Submitted: 2005-08-03
(abridged) We investigate in detail the role of active galactic nuclei on the
physical state of the gas in galaxy groups and clusters, and the implications
for anisotropy in the CMB from Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect. We include the effect
of thermal conduction, and find that the resulting profiles of temperature and
entropy are consistent with observations. Unlike previously proposed models,
our model predicts that isentropic cores are not an inevitable consequence of
preheating. The model also reproduces the observational trend for the density
profiles to flatten in lower mass systems. We deduce the energy E_agn required
to explain the entropy observations as a function of mass of groups and
clusters M_cl and show that E_agn is proportional to M_cl^alpha with alpha~1.5.
We demonstrate that the entropy measurements, in conjunction with our model,
can be translated into constraints on the cluster--black hole mass relation.
The inferred relation is nonlinear and has the form M_bh\propto M_cl^alpha.
This scaling is an analog and extension of a similar relation between the black
hole mass and the galactic halo mass that holds on smaller scales. We show that
the central decrement of the CMB temperature is reduced due to the enhanced
entropy of the ICM, and that the decrement predicted from the plausible range
of energy input from the AGN is consistent with available data of SZ decrement.
We show that AGN heating, combined with the observational constraints on
entropy, leads to suppression of higher multipole moments in the angular power
spectrum and we find that this effect is stronger than previously thought.
[55]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0501175 [pdf] - 70287
AGN heating and dissipative processes in galaxy clusters
Submitted: 2005-01-10, last modified: 2005-05-23
Recent X-ray observations reveal growing evidence for heating by active
galactic nuclei (AGN) in clusters and groups of galaxies. AGN outflows play a
crucial role in explaining the riddle of cooling flows and the entropy problem
in clusters. Here we study the effect of AGN on the intra-cluster medium in a
cosmological simulation using the adaptive mesh refinement FLASH code. We pay
particular attention to the effects of conductivity and viscosity on the
dissipation of weak shocks generated by the AGN activity in a realistic galaxy
cluster. Our 3D simulations demonstrate that both viscous and conductive
dissipation play an important role in distributing the mechanical energy
injected by the AGN, offsetting radiative cooling and injecting entropy to the
gas. These processes are important even when the transport coefficients are at
a level of 10% of the Spitzer value. Provided that both conductivity and
viscosity are suppressed by a comparable amount, conductive dissipation is
likely to dominate over viscous dissipation. Nevertheless, viscous effects may
still affect the dynamics of the gas and contribute a significant amount of
dissipation compared to radiative cooling. We also present synthetic Chandra
observations. We show that the simulated buoyant bubbles inflated by the AGN,
and weak shocks associated with them, are detectable with the Chandra
observatory.
[56]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0503656 [pdf] - 72038
X-ray line tomography of AGN-induced motion in clusters of galaxies
Submitted: 2005-03-30, last modified: 2005-03-31
The thermal broadening of emission lines of heavy ions is small enough such
that Doppler shifts due to bulk motions may be detected with the next
generation of X-ray observatories. This opens up the possibility to study gas
velocities in the intra-cluster medium. Here we study the effect of bulk
motions induced by a central active galactic nucleus (AGN) on the emission
lines around the FeXXV complex. We have modelled the evolution of AGN-induced
bubbles in a realistic cosmological framework and studied the resulting FeXXV
line profiles. We found that in clusters with AGN feedback, motions induced by
the inflation of bubbles and their buoyant rise lead to distinct features in
the iron emission lines that are detectable with a spectral resolution of about
10 eV. These observations will help to determine the mechanical energy that
resides in the bubbles and thereby the kinetic luminosity of the AGN.
[57]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0403690 [pdf] - 63881
3D simulations of viscous dissipation in the intracluster medium
Submitted: 2004-03-30, last modified: 2004-07-21
We present three-dimensional simulations of viscous dissipation of AGN
induced gas motions and waves in clusters of galaxies. These simulations are
motivated by recent detections of ripples in the Perseus and Virgo clusters.
Although the sound waves generated by buoyant bubbles decay with distance from
the cluster center, we show that these waves can contribute substantially to
offsetting the radiative cooling at distances significantly exceeding the
bubble size. The energy flux of the waves declines more steeply with radius
than the inverse-square law predicted by energy conservation, implying that
dissipation plays an important role in tapping the wave energy. We show that
such dispersing sound waves/weak shocks are detectable as ripples on
unsharp-masked X-ray cluster maps, and point out that the interfaces between
the intracluster medium and old bubbles are also clearly detectable in
unsharp-masked X-ray maps. This opens up the possibility of detecting fossil
bubbles that are difficult to detect in radio emission. This mode of heating is
consistent with other observational constraints, such as the presence of cool
rims around the bubbles and the absence of strong shocks. Thus, the mechanism
offers a way of heating clusters in a spatially distributed and gentle fashion.
We also discuss the energy transfer between the central AGN and the surrounding
medium. In our numerical experiments, we find that roughly 65 per cent of the
energy injected by the AGN is transferred to the intracluster medium and
approximately 25 percent of the injected energy is dissipated by viscous
effects and contributes to heating of the gas. The overall transfer of heat
from the AGN to the gas is comparable to the radiative cooling losses. The
simulations were performed with the FLASH adaptive mesh refinement code.
[58]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0401161 [pdf] - 62031
Entropy "floor" and effervescent heating of intracluster gas
Submitted: 2004-01-09, last modified: 2004-07-08
Recent X-ray observations of clusters of galaxies have shown that the entropy
of the intracluster medium (ICM), even at radii as large as half the virial
radius, is higher than that expected from gravitational processes alone. This
is thought to be the result of nongravitational processes influencing the
physical state of the ICM. In this paper, we investigate whether heating by a
central AGN can explain the distribution of excess entropy as a function of
radius. The AGN is assumed to inject buoyant bubbles into the ICM, which heat
the ambient medium by doing pdV work as they rise and expand. Several authors
have suggested that this "effervescent heating" mechanism could allow the
central regions of clusters to avoid the ``cooling catastrophe''. Here we study
the effect of effervescent heating at large radii. Our calculations show that
such a heating mechanism is able to solve the entropy problem. The only free
parameters of the model are the time-averaged luminosity and the AGN lifetime.
The results are mainly sensitive to the total energy injected into the cluster.
Our model predicts that the total energy injected by AGN should be roughly
proportional to the cluster mass. The expected correlation is consistent with a
linear relation between the mass of the central black hole(s) and the mass of
the cluster, which is reminiscent of the Magorrian relation between the black
hole and bulge mass.
[59]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0310760 [pdf] - 60423
Cluster Heating by Viscous Dissipation of Sound Waves
Submitted: 2003-10-27, last modified: 2004-04-23
We simulate the effects of viscous dissipation of waves that are generated by
AGN activity in clusters of galaxies. We demonstrate that the amount of viscous
heating associated with the dissipation of these waves can offset radiative
cooling rates in cooling flow clusters of galaxies. This heating mechanism
leads to spatially distributed and approximately symmetrical dissipation. The
heating waves reach a given distance from the cluster center on a timescale
shorter than the cooling time. This means that this heating mechanism has the
potential of quenching cooling flows in a quasi-stable fashion. Moreover, the
heating is gentle as no strong shocks are present in the simulations. We first
investigated whether a single continuous episode of AGN activity can lead to
adequate dissipation to balance cooling rates. These simulations demonstrated
that, whereas secondary waves generated by the interaction of the rising bubble
with the intracluster medium are clearly present, viscous heating associated
with the dissipation of these waves is insufficient to balance radiative
cooling. It is only when the central source is intermittent that the viscous
dissipation of waves associated with subsequent episodes of activity can offset
cooling. This suggests that the ripples observed in the Perseus cluster can be
interpreted as being due to the AGN duty cycle, i.e., they trace AGN activity
history. The simulations were performed using the PPM adaptive mesh refinement
code FLASH in two dimensions.
[60]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0403128 [pdf] - 63319
Mechanical heating by active galaxies
Submitted: 2004-03-04
Jets and winds are significant channels for energy loss from accreting black
holes. These outflows mechanically heat their surroundings, through shocks as
well as gentler forms of heating. We discuss recent efforts to understand the
nature and distribution of mechanical heating by central AGNs in clusters of
galaxies, using numerical simulations and analytic models. Specifically, we
will discuss whether the relatively gentle `effervescent heating' mechanism can
compensate for radiative losses in the central regions of clusters, and account
for the excess entropy observed at larger radii.
[61]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0204256 [pdf] - 48801
Eddington limit and radiative transfer in highly inhomogeneous
atmospheres
Submitted: 2002-04-15, last modified: 2002-11-25
Radiation dominated accretion disks are likely to be subject to the ``photon
bubble'' instability, which may lead to strong density inhomogeneities on
scales much shorter than the disk scale height. Such disks -- and magnetized,
radiation-dominated atmospheres in general -- could radiate well above the
Eddington limit without being disrupted. When density contrasts become large
over distances of order the photon mean free path, radiative transfer cannot be
described adequately using either the standard diffusion approximation or
existing prescriptions for flux-limited diffusion. Using analytical and Monte
Carlo techniques, we consider the effects of strong density gradients deep
within radiation- and scattering-dominated atmospheres. We find that radiation
viscosity -- i.e., the off-diagonal elements of the radiation stress tensor --
has an important effect on radiative transfer under such conditions. We compare
analytical and numerical results in the specific case of a plane-parallel
density wave structure and calculate Eddington enhancement factors due to the
porosity of the atmosphere. Our results can be applied to the study of
dynamical coupling between radiation forces and density inhomogeneities in
radiation dominated accretion disks in two or three dimensions.
[62]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0210102 [pdf] - 52140
Linear and Circular Polarization Properties of Jets
Submitted: 2002-10-03
I discuss the transfer of polarized synchrotron radiation in relativistic
jets. I argue that the main mechanism responsible for the circular polarization
properties of compact synchrotron sources is likely to be Faraday conversion
and that, contrary to common expectation, a significant rate of Faraday
rotation does not necessarily imply strong depolarization. The long-term
persistence of the sign of circular polarization, observed in some sources, is
most likely due to a small net magnetic flux generated in the central engine,
carried along the jet axis and superimposed on a highly turbulent magnetic
field. I show that the mean levels of circular and linear polarizations depend
on the number of field reversals along the line of sight and that the gradient
in Faraday rotation across turbulent regions can lead to "correlation
depolarization''. The model is potentially applicable to a wide range of
synchrotron sources. In particular, I demonstrate how the model can naturally
explain the excess of circular over linear polarization in the Galactic Center
(Sgr A*) and the low-luminosity AGN M81*.
[63]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0207471 [pdf] - 142548
Heating, conduction and minimum temperatures in cooling flows
Submitted: 2002-07-22, last modified: 2002-08-12
There is mounting observational evidence from Chandra for strong interaction
between keV gas and AGN in cooling flows. It is now widely accepted that the
temperatures of cluster cores are maintained at a level of 1 keV and that the
mass deposition rates are lower than earlier ROSAT/Einstein values. Recent
theoretical results suggest that thermal conduction can be very efficient even
in magnetized plasmas. Motivated by these discoveries, we consider a ``double
heating model'' which incorporates the effects of simultaneous heating by both
the central AGN and thermal conduction from the hot outer layers of clusters.
Using hydrodynamical simulations, we demonstrate that there exists a family of
solutions that does not suffer from the cooling catastrophe. In these cases,
clusters relax to a stable final state, which is characterized by minimum
temperatures of order 1 keV and density and temperature profiles consistent
with observations. Moreover, the accretion rates are much reduced, thereby
reducing the need for excessive mass deposition rates required by the standard
cooling flow models.
[64]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0112090 [pdf] - 46463
Circular polarization from stochastic synchrotron sources
Submitted: 2001-12-04
The transfer of polarized radiation in stochastic synchrotron sources is
explored by means of analytic treatment and Monte Carlo simulations. We argue
that the main mechanism responsible for the circular polarization properties of
compact synchrotron sources is likely to be Faraday conversion and that,
contrary to common expectation, a significant rate of Faraday rotation does not
necessarily imply strong depolarization. The long-term persistence of the sign
of circular polarization, observed in many sources, is most likely due to a
small net magnetic flux generated in the central engine, carried along the jet
axis and superimposed on a highly turbulent magnetic field. We show that the
mean levels of circular and linear polarizations depend on the number of field
reversals along the line of sight and that the gradient in Faraday rotation
across turbulent regions can lead to ``correlation depolarization''. Our model
is potentially applicable to a wide range of synchrotron sources. In
particular, we demonstrate how our model can naturally explain the excess of
circular over linear polarization in the Galactic Center and the nearby spiral
galaxy M81 and discuss its application to the quasar 3C 279, the intraday
variable blazar PKS 1519-273 and the X-ray binary SS 433.
[65]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9912321 [pdf] - 109984
On the influence of resonant absorption on the iron emission line
profiles from accreting black holes
Submitted: 1999-12-15
The fluorescent iron K$\alpha$ emission line profile provides an excellent
probe of the innermost regions of active galactic nuclei. Fe XXV and Fe XXVI in
diffuse plasma above the accretion disc can affect the X-ray spectrum by iron
K$\alpha$ resonant absorption. This in turn can influence the interpretation of
the data and the estimation of the accretion disc and black hole parameters. We
embark on a fully relativistic computation of this effect and calculate the
iron line profile in the framework of a specific model in which rotating,
highly ionized and resonantly-absorbing plasma occurs close to the black hole.
This can explain the features seen in the iron K$\alpha$ line profile recently
obtained by Nandra et al. (1999) for the Seyfert 1 galaxy NGC 3516. We show
that the redshift of this feature can be mainly gravitational in origin and
accounted for without the need to invoke fast accretion of matter onto the
black hole. New X-ray satellites such as XMM, ASTRO-E and Chandra provide
excellent opportunities to test the model against high quality observational
data.
[66]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9906397 [pdf] - 355327
X-ray iron line variability for the model of an orbiting flare above a
black hole accretion disc
Submitted: 1999-06-24
The broad X-ray iron line, detected in many active galactic nuclei, is likely
to be produced by fluorescence from the X-ray illuminated central parts of an
accretion disc close to a supermassive black hole. The time-averaged shape of
the line can be explained most naturally by a combination of special and
general relativistic effects. Such line profiles contain information about the
black hole spin and the accretion disc as well as the geometry of the emitting
region and may help to test general relativity in the strong gravity regime. In
this paper we embark on the computation of the temporal response of the line to
the illuminating flux. Previous studies concentrated on the calculation of
reverberation signatures from static sources illuminating the disc. In this
paper we focus on the more physically justified case of flares located above
the accretion disc and corotating with it. We compute the time dependent iron
line taking into account all general relativistic effects and show that its
shape is of very complex nature, and also present light curves accompanying the
iron line variability. We suggest that future X-ray satellites like XMM or
Constellation-X may be capable of detecting features present in the computed
reverberation maps.
[67]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9901353 [pdf] - 104947
ROSAT HRI Monitoring of Extreme X-ray Variability in the Narrow-Line
Quasar PHL 1092
Submitted: 1999-01-25
We report results from an 18-day ROSAT HRI monitoring campaign on the
ultrasoft Narrow-Line Seyfert 1 (NLS1) class quasar PHL 1092. This luminous,
radio-quiet quasar showed strong X-ray variability in a short ROSAT PSPC
observation, and ROSAT HRI monitoring of the similar object IRAS 13224-3809
revealed extreme variability on intermediate timescales. We wanted to determine
whether remarkable X-ray variability persistently occurs in PHL 1092, and we
also wanted to search for outstanding variability events that constrain
emission processes. Given the large luminosity of PHL 1092 (about 5x10^{45}
erg/s in the HRI band), we detect extremely rapid and large-amplitude X-ray
variability throughout our monitoring. The maximum observed variability
amplitude is a factor of about 14, and in the most rapid variability event the
HRI count rate increases by a factor of about 3.8 in a rest-frame time interval
of < 3580 s. The most rapid event has a rate change of luminosity of >
1.3x10^{42} erg/s^2, making it the most extreme such event we are aware of from
a radio-quiet quasar. Standard `radiative efficiency limit' arguments imply a
radiative efficiency larger than can be achieved by accretion onto a Kerr black
hole rotating at the maximum plausible rate, although we point out that such
arguments depend upon the geometry of initial radiation release. Relativistic
motions of the X-ray source are probably causing the radiative efficiency limit
to break down; such relativistic motions have also been inferred in the similar
NLS1-class quasar PKS 0558--504.
[68]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9701172 [pdf] - 96445
Detecting gamma-ray bursts from M31 with the wide field X-ray cameras on
board BeppoSAX
Submitted: 1997-01-22
Gamma-ray bursters emit a small fraction of their flux in X rays, and because
X-ray detectors are often very sensitive they may probe the gamma-ray burst
universe more deeply than the current best gamma-ray instruments. On the
reasonable assumptions that spectra of bursts observed by BATSE may be used to
predict the X-ray fluxes of gamma-ray bursts, and that any corona of bursts
around M31 is similar to the one around the Milky Way, we predict the rate at
which the wide field cameras on board BeppoSAX should detect bursts from the
Milky Way and M31. These rates are such that a one-month observation of M31
would have to either detect bursts from M31 or exclude most galactic models of
gamma-ray bursts. (It is shown how the remainder can be dealt with.) Therefore
such an observation would settle the long-standing dispute over their location.