Normalized to: Rusli, S.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.08956 [pdf] - 1588890
NGC 307 and the Effects of Dark-Matter Haloes on Measuring Supermassive
Black Holes in Disc Galaxies
Submitted: 2017-09-26
We present stellar-dynamical measurements of the central supermassive black
hole (SMBH) in the S0 galaxy NGC 307, using adaptive-optics IFU data from
VLT-SINFONI. We investigate the effects of including dark-matter haloes as well
as multiple stellar components with different mass-to-light (M/L) ratios in the
dynamical modeling. Models with no halo and a single stellar component yield a
relatively poor fit with a low value for the SMBH mass ($7.0 \pm 1.0 \times
10^{7} M_{\odot}$) and a high stellar M/L ratio (K-band M/L = $1.3 \pm 0.1$).
Adding a halo produces a much better fit, with a significantly larger SMBH mass
($2.0 \pm 0.5 \times 10^{8} M_{\odot}$) and a lower M/L ratio ($1.1 \pm 0.1$).
A model with no halo but with separate bulge and disc components produces a
similarly good fit, with a slightly larger SMBH mass ($3.0 \pm 0.5 \times
10^{8} M_{\odot}$) and an identical M/L ratio for the bulge component, though
the disc M/L ratio is biased high (disc M/L $ = 1.9 \pm 0.1$). Adding a halo to
the two-stellar-component model results in a much more plausible disc M/L ratio
of $1.0 \pm 0.1$, but has only a modest effect on the SMBH mass ($2.2 \pm 0.6
\times 10^{8} M_{\odot}$) and leaves the bulge M/L ratio unchanged. This
suggests that measuring SMBH masses in disc galaxies using just a single
stellar component and no halo has the same drawbacks as it does for elliptical
galaxies, but also that reasonably accurate SMBH masses and bulge M/L ratios
can be recovered (without the added computational expense of modeling haloes)
by using separate bulge and disc components.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.06466 [pdf] - 1470782
The supermassive black hole and double nucleus of the core elliptical
NGC5419
Submitted: 2016-07-21
We obtained adaptive-optics assisted SINFONI observations of the central
regions of the giant elliptical galaxy NGC5419 with a spatial resolution of 0.2
arcsec ($\approx 55$ pc). NGC5419 has a large depleted stellar core with a
radius of 1.58 arcsec (430 pc). HST and SINFONI images show a point source
located at the galaxy's photocentre, which is likely associated with the
low-luminosity AGN previously detected in NGC5419. Both the HST and SINFONI
images also show a second nucleus, off-centred by 0.25 arcsec ($\approx 70$
pc). Outside of the central double nucleus, we measure an almost constant
velocity dispersion of $\sigma \sim 350$ km/s. In the region where the double
nucleus is located, the dispersion rises steeply to a peak value of $\sim 420$
km/s. In addition to the SINFONI data, we also obtained stellar kinematics at
larger radii from the South African Large Telescope. While NGC5419 shows low
rotation ($v < 50$ km/s), the central regions (inside $\sim 4 \, r_b$) clearly
rotate in the opposite direction to the galaxy's outer parts. We use
orbit-based dynamical models to measure the black hole mass of NGC5419 from the
kinematical data outside of the double nuclear structure. The models imply
M$_{\rm BH}=7.2^{+2.7}_{-1.9} \times 10^9$ M$_{\odot}$. The enhanced velocity
dispersion in the region of the double nucleus suggests that NGC5419 possibly
hosts two supermassive black holes at its centre, separated by only $\approx
70$ pc. Yet our measured M$_{\rm BH}$ is consistent with the black hole mass
expected from the size of the galaxy's depleted stellar core. This suggests,
that systematic uncertainties in M$_{\rm BH}$ related to the secondary nucleus
are small.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1601.00974 [pdf] - 1359150
The SINFONI Black Hole Survey: The Black Hole Fundamental Plane
revisited and the paths of (co-) evolution of supermassive black holes and
bulges
Saglia, R. P.;
Opitsch, M.;
Erwin, P.;
Thomas, J.;
Beifiori, A.;
Fabricius, M.;
Mazzalay, X.;
Nowak, N.;
Rusli, S. P.;
Bender, R.
Submitted: 2016-01-05, last modified: 2016-01-20
We investigate the correlations between the black hole mass $M_{BH}$, the
velocity dispersion $\sigma$, the bulge mass $M_{Bu}$, the bulge average
spherical density $\rho_h$ and its spherical half mass radius $r_h$,
constructing a database of 97 galaxies (31 core ellipticals, 17 power-law
ellipticals, 30 classical bulges, 19 pseudo bulges) by joining 72 galaxies from
the literature to 25 galaxies observed during our recent SINFONI black hole
survey. For the first time we discuss the full error covariance matrix. We
analyse the well known $M_{BH}-\sigma$ and $M_{BH}-M_{Bu}$ relations and
establish the existence of statistically significant correlations between
$M_{Bu}$ and $r_h$ and anti-correlations between $M_{Bu}$ and $\rho_h$. We
establish five significant bivariate correlations ($M_{BH}-\sigma-\rho_h$,
$M_{BH}-\sigma-r_h$, $M_{BH}-M_{Bu}-\sigma$, $M_{BH}-M_{Bu}-\rho_h$,
$M_{BH}-M_{Bu}-r_h$) that predict $M_{BH}$ of 77 core and power-law ellipticals
and classical bulges with measured and intrinsic scatter as small as $\approx
0.36$ dex and $\approx 0.33$ dex respectively, or 0.26 dex when the subsample
of 45 galaxies defined by Kormendy and Ho (2013) is considered. In contrast,
pseudo bulges have systematically lower $M_{BH}$, but approach the predictions
of all the above relations at spherical densities $\rho_h\ge 10^{10}
M_\odot/kpc^3$ or scale lengths $r_h\le 1$ kpc. These findings fit in a
scenario of co-evolution of BH and classical-bulge masses, where core
ellipticals are the product of dry mergers of power-law bulges and power-law Es
and bulges the result of (early) gas-rich mergers and of disk galaxies. In
contrast, the (secular) growth of BHs is decoupled from the growth of their
pseudo bulge hosts, except when (gas) densities are high enough to trigger the
feedback mechanism responsible for the existence of the correlations between
$M_{BH}$ and galaxy structural parameters.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1411.2599 [pdf] - 1223092
Composite Bulges: The Coexistence of Classical Bulges and Disky
Pseudobulges in S0 and Spiral Galaxies
Submitted: 2014-11-10
We study nine S0-Sb galaxies with (photometric) bulges consisting of two
distinct components. The outer component is a flattened, kinematically cool,
disklike structure: a "disky pseudobulge". Embedded inside is a rounder,
kinematically hot spheroid: a "classical bulge". This indicates that
pseudobulges and classical bulges are not mutually exclusive: some galaxies
have both.
The disky pseudobulges almost always have an exponential disk (scale lengths
= 125-870 pc, mean $\sim 440$ pc) with disk-related subcomponents: nuclear
rings, bars, and/or spiral arms. They constitute 11-59% of the galaxy stellar
mass (mean PB/T = 0.33), with stellar masses $\sim 7 \times 10^{9}$-$9 \times
10^{10} M_{\odot}$. Classical-bulge components have Sersic indices of 0.9-2.2,
effective radii of 25-430 pc and stellar masses of $5 \times 10^{8}$-$3 \times
10^{10} M_{\odot}$ (usually < 10% of the galaxy's stellar mass; mean B/T =
0.06). The classical bulges show rotation, but are kinematically hotter than
the disky pseudobulges. Dynamical modeling of three systems indicates that
velocity dispersions are isotropic in the classical bulges and equatorially
biased in the disky pseudobulges.
In the mass--radius and mass--stellar mass density planes, classical-bulge
components follow sequences defined by ellipticals and (larger) classical
bulges. Disky pseudobulges also fall on this sequence; they are more compact
than similar-mass large-scale disks. Although some classical bulges are quite
compact, they are distinct from nuclear star clusters in both size and mass,
and coexist with nuclear clusters in at least two galaxies.
Since almost all the galaxies in this study are barred, they probably also
host boxy/peanut-shaped bulges (vertically thickened inner parts of bars). NGC
3368 shows evidence for such a zone outside its disky pseudobulge, making it a
galaxy with all three types of "bulge".
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.7946 [pdf] - 1222286
Using 3D Spectroscopy to Probe the Orbital Structure of Composite Bulges
Submitted: 2014-09-28
Detailed imaging and spectroscopic analysis of the centers of nearby S0 and
spiral galaxies shows the existence of "composite bulges", where both classical
bulges and disky pseudobulges coexist in the same galaxy. As part of a search
for supermassive black holes in nearby galaxy nuclei, we obtained VLT-SINFONI
observations in adaptive-optics mode of several of these galaxies.
Schwarzschild dynamical modeling enables us to disentangle the stellar orbital
structure of the different central components, and to distinguish the differing
contributions of kinematically hot (classical bulge) and kinematically cool
(pseudobulge) components in the same galaxy.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1312.0604 [pdf] - 1201978
Molecular gas in the centre of nearby galaxies from VLT/SINFONI integral
field spectroscopy - II. Kinematics
Submitted: 2013-12-02
We present an analysis of the H2 emission-line gas kinematics in the inner <
4 arcsec radius of six nearby spiral galaxies, based on AO-assisted
integral-field observations obtained in the K-band with SINFONI/VLT. Four of
the six galaxies in our sample display ordered H2 velocity fields, consistent
with gas moving in the plane of the galaxy and rotating in the same direction
as the stars. However, the gas kinematics is typically far from simple circular
motion. We can classify the observed velocity fields into four different types
of flows, ordered by increasing complexity: (1) circular motion in a disc
(NGC3351); (2) oval motion in the galaxy plane (NGC3627 and NGC4536); (3)
streaming motion superimposed on circular rotation (NGC4501); and (4)
disordered streaming motions (NGC4569 and NGC4579). The H2 velocity dispersion
in the galaxies is usually higher than 50 km/s in the inner 1-2 arcsec radii.
The four galaxies with ordered kinematics have v/sigma < 1 at radii less than
40-80 pc. The radius at which v/sigma = 1 is independent of the type of nuclear
activity. While the low values of v/sigma could be taken as an indication of a
thick disc in the innermost regions of the galaxies, other lines of evidence
(e.g. H2 morphologies and velocity fields) argue for a thin disc interpretation
in the case of NGC3351 and NGC4536. We discuss the implications of the high
values of velocity dispersion for the dynamics of the gaseous disc and suggest
caution when interpreting the velocity dispersion of ionized and warm tracers
as being entirely dynamical. Understanding the nature and role of the velocity
dispersion in the gas dynamics, together with the full 2D information of the
gas, is essential for obtaining accurate black hole masses from gas kinematics.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.5310 [pdf] - 1180078
Depleted Galaxy Cores and Dynamical Black Hole Masses
Submitted: 2013-10-20, last modified: 2013-11-12
Shallow cores in bright, massive galaxies are commonly thought to be the
result of scouring of stars by mergers of binary supermassive black holes. Past
investigations have suggested correlations between the central black hole mass
and the stellar light or mass deficit in the core, using proxy measurements of
$M_{\rm BH}$ or stellar mass-to-light ratios ($\Upsilon$). Drawing on a wealth
of dynamical models which provide both $M_{\rm BH}$ and $\Upsilon$, we identify
cores in 23 galaxies, of which 20 have direct, reliable measurements of $M_{\rm
BH}$ and dynamical stellar mass-to-light ratios ($\Upsilon_{\star,{\rm dyn}}$).
These cores are identified and measured using Core-S\'ersic model fits to
surface brightness profiles which extend out to large radii (typically more
than the effective radius of the galaxy); for approximately one fourth of the
galaxies, the best fit includes an outer (\sersic) envelope component. We find
that the core radius is most strongly correlated with the black hole mass and
that it correlates better with total galaxy luminosity than it does with
velocity dispersion. The strong core-size-- $M_{\rm BH}$ correlation enables
estimation of black hole masses (in core galaxies) with an accuracy comparable
to the $M_{\rm BH}$--$\sigma$ relation (rms scatter of 0.30 dex in $\log M_{\rm
BH}$), without the need for spectroscopy. The light and mass deficits correlate
more strongly with galaxy velocity dispersion than they do with black hole
mass. Stellar mass deficits span a range of 0.2--39 \mbh, with almost all (87%)
being $< 10 \, M_{\rm BH}$; the median value is 2.2 $M_{\rm BH}$.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.1124 [pdf] - 1171828
The Influence of Dark Matter Halos on Dynamical Estimates of Black Hole
Mass: Ten New Measurements for High-sigma Early-Type Galaxies
Rusli, S. P.;
Thomas, J.;
Saglia, R. P.;
Fabricius, M.;
Erwin, P.;
Bender, R.;
Nowak, N.;
Lee, C. H.;
Riffeser, A.;
Sharp, R.
Submitted: 2013-06-05, last modified: 2013-07-15
Adaptive-Optics assisted SINFONI observations of the central regions of ten
early-type galaxies are presented. Based primarily on the SINFONI kinematics,
ten black hole masses occupying the high-mass regime of the M_BH-sigma relation
are derived using three-integral Schwarzschild models. The effect of dark
matter inclusion on the black hole mass is explored. The omission of a dark
matter halo in the model results in a higher stellar mass-to-light ratio,
especially when extensive kinematic data are used in the model. However, when
the diameter of the sphere of influence -- computed using the black hole mass
derived without a dark halo -- is at least 10 times the PSF FWHM during the
observations, it is safe to exclude a dark matter component in the dynamical
modeling, i.e. the change in black hole mass is negligible. When the spatial
resolution is marginal, restricting the mass-to-light ratio to the right value
returns the correct M_BH although dark halo is not present in the model.
Compared to the M_BH-sigma and M_BH-L relations of McConnell et al. (2011), the
ten black holes are all more massive than expected from the luminosities and
seven black hole masses are higher than expected from the stellar velocity
dispersions of the host bulges. Using new fitted relations which include the
ten galaxies, we find that the space density of the most massive black holes
(M_BH >~ 10^9 Msun) estimated from the M_BH-L relation is higher than the
estimate based on the M_BH-sigma relation and the latter is higher than model
predictions based on quasar counts, each by about an order of magnitude.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1210.4171 [pdf] - 1152144
Molecular gas in the centre of nearby galaxies from VLT/SINFONI integral
field spectroscopy - I. Morphology and mass inventory
Mazzalay, X.;
Saglia, R. P.;
Erwin, Peter;
Fabricius, M. H.;
Rusli, S. P.;
Thomas, J.;
Bender, R.;
Opitsch, M.;
Nowak, N.;
Williams, Michael J.
Submitted: 2012-10-15
We present the first results of an analysis of the properties of the
molecular gas in the nuclear regions (r < 300 pc) of a sample of six nearby
galaxies, based on new high spatial resolution observations obtained in the
K-band with the near-infrared integral field spectrograph SINFONI at the Very
Large Telescope. We derive two-dimensional distributions of the warm molecular
and ionized gas from the H2, Br_gamma and HeI emission lines present in the
spectra of the galaxies. We find a range of morphologies, including bar- and
ring-like distributions and either centrally peaked or off-centre emission. The
morphologies of the molecular and the ionized gas are not necessarily
coincident. The observed emission-line ratios point towards thermal processes
as the principal mechanism responsible for the H2 excitation in the nuclear and
circumnuclear regions of the galaxies, independently of the presence of an
active nucleus. We find that a rescaling of the H2 2.12 microns emission-line
luminosity by a factor beta~1200 gives a good estimate (within a factor of 2)
of the total (cold) molecular gas mass. The galaxies of the sample contain
large quantities of molecular gas in their centres, with total masses in the ~
105 - 108 Msol range. Never the less, these masses correspond to less than 3
per cent of the stellar masses derived for the galaxies in these regions,
indicating that the presence of gas should not affect black hole mass estimates
based on the dynamical modelling of the stars. The high-spatial resolution
provided by the SINFONI data allowed us to resolve a circumnuclear ring (with a
radius of ~270 pc) in the galaxy NGC 4536. The measured values of the Br_gamma
equivalent width and the HeI/Br_gamma emission-line ratio suggests that bursts
of star formation occurred throughout this ring as recently as 6.5 Myr ago.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1009.0515 [pdf] - 1034658
The central black hole mass of the high-sigma but low-bulge-luminosity
lenticular galaxy NGC 1332
Submitted: 2010-09-02
The masses of the most massive supermassive black holes (SMBHs) predicted by
the M_BH-sigma and M_BH-luminosity relations appear to be in conflict. Which of
the two relations is the more fundamental one remains an open question. NGC
1332 is an excellent example that represents the regime of conflict. It is a
massive lenticular galaxy which has a bulge with a high velocity dispersion
sigma of ~320 km/s; bulge--disc decomposition suggests that only 44% of the
total light comes from the bulge. The M_BH-sigma and the M_BH-luminosity
predictions for the central black hole mass of NGC 1332 differ by almost an
order of magnitude. We present a stellar dynamical measurement of the SMBH mass
using an axisymmetric orbit superposition method. Our SINFONI integral-field
unit (IFU) observations of NGC 1332 resolve the SMBH's sphere of influence
which has a diameter of ~0.76 arcsec. The sigma inside 0.2 arcsec reaches ~400
km/s. The IFU data allow us to increase the statistical significance of our
results by modelling each of the four quadrants separately. We measure a SMBH
mass of (1.45 \pm 0.20) x 10^9 M_sun with a bulge mass-to-light ratio of 7.08
\pm 0.39 in the R-band. With this mass, the SMBH of NGC 1332 is offset from the
M_BH-luminosity relation by a full order of magnitude but is consistent with
the M_BH-sigma relation.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0609061 [pdf] - 84653
The evolution of binary star clusters and the nature of NGC2136/NGC2137
Submitted: 2006-09-03
We study the evolution of bound pairs of star clusters by means of direct
N-body simulations. Our simulations include mass loss by stellar evolution. The
initial conditions are selected to mimic the observed binary star cluster NGC
2136 and NGC 2137 in the Large Magellanic Cloud. Based on the rather old ages
($\sim 100$ Myr), masses, sizes of the two clusters and their projected
separation, we conclude that the cluster pair must have been born with an
initial separation of 15--20 pc. Clusters with a smaller initial separation
tend to merge in $\aplt 60$ Myr due to loss of angular momentum from escaping
stars. Clusters with a larger initial separation tend to become even more
widely separated due to mass loss from the evolving stellar populations. The
early orbital evolution of a binary cluster is governed by mass loss from the
evolving stellar population and by loss of angular momentum from escaping
stars. Mass loss by stellar winds and supernovae explosions in the first $\sim
30$ Myr causes the binary to expand and the orbit to become eccentric. The
initially less massive cluster expands more quickly than the binary separation
increases, and is therefore bound to initiate mass transfer to the more massive
cluster. This process is quite contrary to stellar binaries in which the more
massive star tends to initiate mass transfer. Since mass transfer proceeds on a
thermal timescale from the less massive to the more massive cluster, this
semi-detached phase is quite stable, even in an eccentric orbit until the
orbital separation reaches the gyration radius of the two clusters, at which
point both clusters merge to one.