Normalized to: Roukema, B.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.03307 [pdf] - 2129529
An optimised tiling pattern for multi-object spectroscopic surveys:
application to the 4MOST survey
Tempel, E.;
Tuvikene, T.;
Muru, M. M.;
Stoica, R. S.;
Bensby, T.;
Chiappini, C.;
Christlieb, N.;
Cioni, M. -R. L.;
Comparat, J.;
Feltzing, S.;
Hook, I.;
Koch, A.;
Kordopatis, G.;
Krumpe, M.;
Loveday, J.;
Minchev, I.;
Norberg, P.;
Roukema, B. F.;
Sorce, J. G.;
Storm, J.;
Swann, E.;
Taylor, E. N.;
Traven, G.;
Walcher, C. J.;
de Jong, R. S.
Submitted: 2020-07-07
Large multi-object spectroscopic surveys require automated algorithms to
optimise their observing strategy. One of the most ambitious upcoming
spectroscopic surveys is the 4MOST survey. The 4MOST survey facility is a
fibre-fed spectroscopic instrument on the VISTA telescope with a large enough
field of view to survey a large fraction of the southern sky within a few
years. Several Galactic and extragalactic surveys will be carried out
simultaneously, so the combined target density will strongly vary. In this
paper, we describe a new tiling algorithm that can naturally deal with the
large target density variations on the sky and which automatically handles the
different exposure times of targets. The tiling pattern is modelled as a marked
point process, which is characterised by a probability density that integrates
the requirements imposed by the 4MOST survey. The optimal tilling pattern with
respect to the defined model is estimated by the tiles configuration that
maximises the proposed probability density. In order to achieve this
maximisation a simulated annealing algorithm is implemented. The algorithm
automatically finds an optimal tiling pattern and assigns a tentative sky
brightness condition and exposure time for each tile, while minimising the
total execution time that is needed to observe the list of targets in the
combined input catalogue of all surveys. Hence, the algorithm maximises the
long-term observing efficiency and provides an optimal tiling solution for the
survey. While designed for the 4MOST survey, the algorithm is flexible and can
with simple modifications be applied to any other multi-object spectroscopic
survey.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.06528 [pdf] - 2107301
Cosmological signatures of torsion and how to distinguish torsion from
the dark sector
Submitted: 2020-03-13
Torsion is a non-Riemannian geometrical extension of general relativity that
allows including the spin of matter and the twisting of spacetime. Cosmological
models with torsion have been considered in the literature to solve problems of
either the very early (high redshift $z$) or the present-day Universe. This
paper focuses on distinguishable observational signatures of torsion that could
not be otherwise explained with a scalar field in pseudo-Riemannian geometry.
We show that when torsion is present, the cosmic duality relation between the
angular diameter distance, $D_{\mathrm A}$, and the luminosity distance,
$D_{\mathrm L}$, is broken. We show how the deviation described by the
parameter $\eta = D_{\mathrm L}/[ D_{\mathrm A}(1+z)^2] -1 $ is linked to
torsion and how different forms of torsion lead to special-case
parametrisations of $\eta$, including $\eta_0 z$, $\eta_0 z/(1+z)$, and $\eta_0
\ln (1+z)$. We also show that the effects of torsion could be visible in
low-redshift data, inducing biases in supernovae-based $H_0$ measurements. We
also show that torsion can impact the Clarkson-Bassett-Lu (CBL) function ${\cal
C}(z) = 1 + H^2 (D D'' - D'^2) + H H' D D'$, where $D$ is the transverse
comoving distance. If $D$ is inferred from the luminosity distance, then, in
general non-zero torsion models, ${\cal C}(z) \ne 0$. For pseudo-Riemannian
geometry, the Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) metric has ${\cal
C}(z) \equiv 0$; thus, measurement of the CBL function could provide another
diagnostic of torsion.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.09348 [pdf] - 2065378
Probabilistic fibre-to-target assignment algorithm for multi-object
spectroscopic surveys
Tempel, E.;
Norberg, P.;
Tuvikene, T.;
Bensby, T.;
Chiappini, C.;
Christlieb, N.;
Cioni, M. -R. L.;
Comparat, J.;
Davies, L. J. M.;
Guiglion, G.;
Koch, A.;
Kordopatis, G.;
Krumpe, M.;
Loveday, J.;
Merloni, A.;
Micheva, G.;
Minchev, I.;
Roukema, B. F.;
Sorce, J. G.;
Starkenburg, E.;
Storm, J.;
Swann, E.;
Thi, W. F.;
Traven, G.;
de Jong, R. S.
Submitted: 2020-01-25, last modified: 2020-02-04
Context. Several new multi-object spectrographs are currently planned or
under construction that are capable of observing thousands of Galactic and
extragalactic objects simultaneously.
Aims. In this paper we present a probabilistic fibre-to-target assignment
algorithm that takes spectrograph targeting constraints into account and is
capable of dealing with multiple concurrent surveys. We present this algorithm
using the 4-metre Multi-Object Spectroscopic Telescope (4MOST) as an example.
Methods. The key idea of the proposed algorithm is to assign probabilities to
fibre-target pairs. The assignment of probabilities takes the fibre
positioner's capabilities and constraints into account. Additionally, these
probabilities include requirements from surveys and take the required exposure
time, number density variation, and angular clustering of targets across each
survey into account. The main advantage of a probabilistic approach is that it
allows for accurate and easy computation of the target selection function for
the different surveys, which involves determining the probability of observing
a target, given an input catalogue.
Results. The probabilistic fibre-to-target assignment allows us to achieve
maximally uniform completeness within a single field of view. The proposed
algorithm maximises the fraction of successfully observed targets whilst
minimising the selection bias as a function of exposure time. In the case of
several concurrent surveys, the algorithm maximally satisfies the scientific
requirements of each survey and no specific survey is penalised or prioritised.
Conclusions. The algorithm presented is a proposed solution for the 4MOST
project that allows for an unbiased targeting of many simultaneous surveys.
With some modifications, the algorithm may also be applied to other
multi-object spectroscopic surveys.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.09064 [pdf] - 2015691
Does spatial flatness forbid the turnaround epoch of collapsing
structures?
Submitted: 2019-02-24, last modified: 2019-12-11
Cosmological observational analysis frequently assumes that the Universe is
spatially flat. We aim to non-perturbatively check the conditions under which a
flat or nearly flat expanding dust universe, including the LCDM model if
interpreted as strictly flat, forbids the gravitational collapse of structure.
We quantify spatial curvature at turnaround. We use the Hamiltonian constraint
to determine the pointwise conditions required for an overdensity to reach its
turnaround epoch in an exactly flat spatial domain. We illustrate this with a
plane-symmetric, exact, cosmological solution of the Einstein equation,
extending earlier work. More generally, for a standard initial power spectrum,
we use the relativistic Zel'dovich approximation implemented in 'inhomog' to
numerically estimate how much positive spatial curvature is required for
turnaround to be allowed at typical epochs/length scales in almost-EdS and
almost-LCDM models with inhomogeneous curvature. We find that gravitational
collapse in a spatially exactly flat, irrotational, expanding, dust universe is
relativistically forbidden pointwise. In the spatially flat plane-symmetric
model considered here, pancake collapse is excluded both pointwise and in
averaged domains. In an almost-EdS or LCDM model, the per-domain average
curvature in collapsing domains almost always becomes strongly positive prior
to turnaround, with the expansion-normalised curvature functional reaching
$\Omega_{\cal R}^{\cal D} \sim -5$. We show analytically that a special case
gives $\Omega_{\cal R}^{\cal D} = -5$ exactly (if normalised using the EdS
expansion rate) at turnaround. An interpretation of LCDM as literally 3-Ricci
flat would forbid structure formation. The difference between relativistic
cosmology and a strictly flat LCDM model is fundamental in principle, but we
find that the geometrical effect is weak.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.02464 [pdf] - 1859121
4MOST: Project overview and information for the First Call for Proposals
de Jong, R. S.;
Agertz, O.;
Berbel, A. Agudo;
Aird, J.;
Alexander, D. A.;
Amarsi, A.;
Anders, F.;
Andrae, R.;
Ansarinejad, B.;
Ansorge, W.;
Antilogus, P.;
Anwand-Heerwart, H.;
Arentsen, A.;
Arnadottir, A.;
Asplund, M.;
Auger, M.;
Azais, N.;
Baade, D.;
Baker, G.;
Baker, S.;
Balbinot, E.;
Baldry, I. K.;
Banerji, M.;
Barden, S.;
Barklem, P.;
Barthélémy-Mazot, E.;
Battistini, C.;
Bauer, S.;
Bell, C. P. M.;
Bellido-Tirado, O.;
Bellstedt, S.;
Belokurov, V.;
Bensby, T.;
Bergemann, M.;
Bestenlehner, J. M.;
Bielby, R.;
Bilicki, M.;
Blake, C.;
Bland-Hawthorn, J.;
Boeche, C.;
Boland, W.;
Boller, T.;
Bongard, S.;
Bongiorno, A.;
Bonifacio, P.;
Boudon, D.;
Brooks, D.;
Brown, M. J. I.;
Brown, R.;
Brüggen, M.;
Brynnel, J.;
Brzeski, J.;
Buchert, T.;
Buschkamp, P.;
Caffau, E.;
Caillier, P.;
Carrick, J.;
Casagrande, L.;
Case, S.;
Casey, A.;
Cesarini, I.;
Cescutti, G.;
Chapuis, D.;
Chiappini, C.;
Childress, M.;
Christlieb, N.;
Church, R.;
Cioni, M. -R. L.;
Cluver, M.;
Colless, M.;
Collett, T.;
Comparat, J.;
Cooper, A.;
Couch, W.;
Courbin, F.;
Croom, S.;
Croton, D.;
Daguisé, E.;
Dalton, G.;
Davies, L. J. M.;
Davis, T.;
de Laverny, P.;
Deason, A.;
Dionies, F.;
Disseau, K.;
Doel, P.;
Döscher, D.;
Driver, S. P.;
Dwelly, T.;
Eckert, D.;
Edge, A.;
Edvardsson, B.;
Youssoufi, D. El;
Elhaddad, A.;
Enke, H.;
Erfanianfar, G.;
Farrell, T.;
Fechner, T.;
Feiz, C.;
Feltzing, S.;
Ferreras, I.;
Feuerstein, D.;
Feuillet, D.;
Finoguenov, A.;
Ford, D.;
Fotopoulou, S.;
Fouesneau, M.;
Frenk, C.;
Frey, S.;
Gaessler, W.;
Geier, S.;
Fusillo, N. Gentile;
Gerhard, O.;
Giannantonio, T.;
Giannone, D.;
Gibson, B.;
Gillingham, P.;
González-Fernández, C.;
Gonzalez-Solares, E.;
Gottloeber, S.;
Gould, A.;
Grebel, E. K.;
Gueguen, A.;
Guiglion, G.;
Haehnelt, M.;
Hahn, T.;
Hansen, C. J.;
Hartman, H.;
Hauptner, K.;
Hawkins, K.;
Haynes, D.;
Haynes, R.;
Heiter, U.;
Helmi, A.;
Aguayo, C. Hernandez;
Hewett, P.;
Hinton, S.;
Hobbs, D.;
Hoenig, S.;
Hofman, D.;
Hook, I.;
Hopgood, J.;
Hopkins, A.;
Hourihane, A.;
Howes, L.;
Howlett, C.;
Huet, T.;
Irwin, M.;
Iwert, O.;
Jablonka, P.;
Jahn, T.;
Jahnke, K.;
Jarno, A.;
Jin, S.;
Jofre, P.;
Johl, D.;
Jones, D.;
Jönsson, H.;
Jordan, C.;
Karovicova, I.;
Khalatyan, A.;
Kelz, A.;
Kennicutt, R.;
King, D.;
Kitaura, F.;
Klar, J.;
Klauser, U.;
Kneib, J.;
Koch, A.;
Koposov, S.;
Kordopatis, G.;
Korn, A.;
Kosmalski, J.;
Kotak, R.;
Kovalev, M.;
Kreckel, K.;
Kripak, Y.;
Krumpe, M.;
Kuijken, K.;
Kunder, A.;
Kushniruk, I.;
Lam, M. I;
Lamer, G.;
Laurent, F.;
Lawrence, J.;
Lehmitz, M.;
Lemasle, B.;
Lewis, J.;
Li, B.;
Lidman, C.;
Lind, K.;
Liske, J.;
Lizon, J. -L.;
Loveday, J.;
Ludwig, H. -G.;
McDermid, R. M.;
Maguire, K.;
Mainieri, V.;
Mali, S.;
Mandel, H.;
Mandel, K.;
Mannering, L.;
Martell, S.;
Delgado, D. Martinez;
Matijevic, G.;
McGregor, H.;
McMahon, R.;
McMillan, P.;
Mena, O.;
Merloni, A.;
Meyer, M. J.;
Michel, C.;
Micheva, G.;
Migniau, J. -E.;
Minchev, I.;
Monari, G.;
Muller, R.;
Murphy, D.;
Muthukrishna, D.;
Nandra, K.;
Navarro, R.;
Ness, M.;
Nichani, V.;
Nichol, R.;
Nicklas, H.;
Niederhofer, F.;
Norberg, P.;
Obreschkow, D.;
Oliver, S.;
Owers, M.;
Pai, N.;
Pankratow, S.;
Parkinson, D.;
Parry, I.;
Paschke, J.;
Paterson, R.;
Pecontal, A.;
Phillips, D.;
Pillepich, A.;
Pinard, L.;
Pirard, J.;
Piskunov, N.;
Plank, V.;
Plüschke, D.;
Pons, E.;
Popesso, P.;
Power, C.;
Pragt, J.;
Pramskiy, A.;
Pryer, D.;
Quattri, M.;
Queiroz, A. B. de Andrade;
Quirrenbach, A.;
Rahurkar, S.;
Raichoor, A.;
Ramstedt, S.;
Rau, A.;
Recio-Blanco, A.;
Reiss, R.;
Renaud, F.;
Revaz, Y.;
Rhode, P.;
Richard, J.;
Richter, A. D.;
Rix, H. -W.;
Robotham, A. S. G.;
Roelfsema, R.;
Romaniello, M.;
Rosario, D.;
Rothmaier, F.;
Roukema, B.;
Ruchti, G.;
Rupprecht, G.;
Rybizki, J.;
Ryde, N.;
Saar, A.;
Sadler, E.;
Sahlén, M.;
Salvato, M.;
Sassolas, B.;
Saunders, W.;
Saviauk, A.;
Sbordone, L.;
Schmidt, T.;
Schnurr, O.;
Scholz, R. -D.;
Schwope, A.;
Seifert, W.;
Shanks, T.;
Sheinis, A.;
Sivov, T.;
Skúladóttir, Á.;
Smartt, S.;
Smedley, S.;
Smith, G.;
Smith, R.;
Sorce, J.;
Spitler, L.;
Starkenburg, E.;
Steinmetz, M.;
Stilz, I.;
Storm, J.;
Sullivan, M.;
Sutherland, W.;
Swann, E.;
Tamone, A.;
Taylor, E. N.;
Teillon, J.;
Tempel, E.;
ter Horst, R.;
Thi, W. -F.;
Tolstoy, E.;
Trager, S.;
Traven, G.;
Tremblay, P. -E.;
Tresse, L.;
Valentini, M.;
van de Weygaert, R.;
Ancker, M. van den;
Veljanoski, J.;
Venkatesan, S.;
Wagner, L.;
Wagner, K.;
Walcher, C. J.;
Waller, L.;
Walton, N.;
Wang, L.;
Winkler, R.;
Wisotzki, L.;
Worley, C. C.;
Worseck, G.;
Xiang, M.;
Xu, W.;
Yong, D.;
Zhao, C.;
Zheng, J.;
Zscheyge, F.;
Zucker, D.
Submitted: 2019-03-06, last modified: 2019-04-01
We introduce the 4-metre Multi-Object Spectroscopic Telescope (4MOST), a new
high-multiplex, wide-field spectroscopic survey facility under development for
the four-metre-class Visible and Infrared Survey Telescope for Astronomy
(VISTA) at Paranal. Its key specifications are: a large field of view (FoV) of
4.2 square degrees and a high multiplex capability, with 1624 fibres feeding
two low-resolution spectrographs ($R = \lambda/\Delta\lambda \sim 6500$), and
812 fibres transferring light to the high-resolution spectrograph ($R \sim
20\,000$). After a description of the instrument and its expected performance,
a short overview is given of its operational scheme and planned 4MOST
Consortium science; these aspects are covered in more detail in other articles
in this edition of The Messenger. Finally, the processes, schedules, and
policies concerning the selection of ESO Community Surveys are presented,
commencing with a singular opportunity to submit Letters of Intent for Public
Surveys during the first five years of 4MOST operations.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.02474 [pdf] - 1859131
4MOST Consortium Survey 8: Cosmology Redshift Survey (CRS)
Richard, J.;
Kneib, J. -P.;
Blake, C.;
Raichoor, A.;
Comparat, J.;
Shanks, T.;
Sorce, J.;
Sahlén, M.;
Howlett, C.;
Tempel, E.;
McMahon, R.;
Bilicki, M.;
Roukema, B.;
Loveday, J.;
Pryer, D.;
Buchert, T.;
Zhao, C.
Submitted: 2019-03-06, last modified: 2019-04-01
The 4MOST Cosmology Redshift Survey (CRS) will perform stringent cosmological
tests via spectroscopic clustering measurements that will complement the best
lensing, cosmic microwave background and other surveys in the southern
hemisphere. The combination of carefully selected samples of bright galaxies,
luminous red galaxies, emission-line galaxies and quasars, totalling about 8
million objects over the redshift range $z = 0.15$ to $3.5$, will allow
definitive tests of gravitational physics. Many key science questions will be
addressed by combining CRS spectra of these targets with data from current or
future facilities such as the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope, the Square
Kilometre Array and the Euclid mission.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.06179 [pdf] - 1641247
Replacing dark energy by silent virialisation
Submitted: 2017-06-19, last modified: 2017-10-31
Standard cosmological $N$-body simulations have background scale factor
evolution that is decoupled from non-linear structure formation. Prior to
gravitational collapse, kinematical backreaction ($Q_D$) justifies this
approach in a Newtonian context. However, the final stages of a gravitational
collapse event are sudden; a globally imposed expansion rate thus forces at
least one expanding region to suddenly decelerate. This is relativistically
unrealistic. Instead, we allow non-collapsed domains to evolve in volume
according to the $Q_D$ Zel'dovich Approximation (QZA). We study the inferred
average expansion under this "silent" virialisation hypothesis. We set standard
(mpgrafic) EdS cosmological $N$-body initial conditions. Using RAMSES, we call
DTFE to estimate the initial values of the three invariants of the extrinsic
curvature tensor in Lagrangian domains $D$. We integrate the Raychaudhuri
equation in each domain using inhomog, adopt the stable clustering hypothesis
(VQZA), and average spatially. We adopt an early-epoch--normalised EdS
reference-model Hubble constant $H_1^{bg} = 37.7$ km/s/Mpc and an effective
Hubble constant $H_0^{eff} = 67.7$ km/s/Mpc. From 2000 simulations at
resolution $256^3$, a unity effective scale factor is reached at 13.8~Gyr (16%
above EdS) for an averaging scale of $L_{13.8}=2.5^{+0.1}_{-0.4}$
Mpc/$h^{eff}$. Relativistically interpreted, this corresponds to strong average
negative curvature evolution. The virialisation fraction and super-EdS
expansion correlate strongly at fixed cosmological time. Thus, starting from
EdS initial conditions and averaging on a typical non-linear structure
formation scale, the VQZA dark-energy--free average expansion matches
$\Lambda$CDM expansion to first order. The software packages used here are
free-licensed.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.04516 [pdf] - 1935364
Exploring Cosmic Origins with CORE: Survey requirements and mission
design
Delabrouille, J.;
de Bernardis, P.;
Bouchet, F. R.;
Achúcarro, A.;
Ade, P. A. R.;
Allison, R.;
Arroja, F.;
Artal, E.;
Ashdown, M.;
Baccigalupi, C.;
Ballardini, M.;
Banday, A. J.;
Banerji, R.;
Barbosa, D.;
Bartlett, J.;
Bartolo, N.;
Basak, S.;
Baselmans, J. J. A.;
Basu, K.;
Battistelli, E. S.;
Battye, R.;
Baumann, D.;
Benoît, A.;
Bersanelli, M.;
Bideaud, A.;
Biesiada, M.;
Bilicki, M.;
Bonaldi, A.;
Bonato, M.;
Borrill, J.;
Boulanger, F.;
Brinckmann, T.;
Brown, M. L.;
Bucher, M.;
Burigana, C.;
Buzzelli, A.;
Cabass, G.;
Cai, Z. -Y.;
Calvo, M.;
Caputo, A.;
Carvalho, C. -S.;
Casas, F. J.;
Castellano, G.;
Catalano, A.;
Challinor, A.;
Charles, I.;
Chluba, J.;
Clements, D. L.;
Clesse, S.;
Colafrancesco, S.;
Colantoni, I.;
Contreras, D.;
Coppolecchia, A.;
Crook, M.;
D'Alessandro, G.;
D'Amico, G.;
da Silva, A.;
de Avillez, M.;
de Gasperis, G.;
De Petris, M.;
de Zotti, G.;
Danese, L.;
Désert, F. -X.;
Desjacques, V.;
Di Valentino, E.;
Dickinson, C.;
Diego, J. M.;
Doyle, S.;
Durrer, R.;
Dvorkin, C.;
Eriksen, H. -K.;
Errard, J.;
Feeney, S.;
Fernández-Cobos, R.;
Finelli, F.;
Forastieri, F.;
Franceschet, C.;
Fuskeland, U.;
Galli, S.;
Génova-Santos, R. T.;
Gerbino, M.;
Giusarma, E.;
Gomez, A.;
González-Nuevo, J.;
Grandis, S.;
Greenslade, J.;
Goupy, J.;
Hagstotz, S.;
Hanany, S.;
Handley, W.;
Henrot-Versillé, S.;
Hernández-Monteagudo, C.;
Hervias-Caimapo, C.;
Hills, M.;
Hindmarsh, M.;
Hivon, E.;
Hoang, D. T.;
Hooper, D. C.;
Hu, B.;
Keihänen, E.;
Keskitalo, R.;
Kiiveri, K.;
Kisner, T.;
Kitching, T.;
Kunz, M.;
Kurki-Suonio, H.;
Lagache, G.;
Lamagna, L.;
Lapi, A.;
Lasenby, A.;
Lattanzi, M.;
Brun, A. M. C. Le;
Lesgourgues, J.;
Liguori, M.;
Lindholm, V.;
Lizarraga, J.;
Luzzi, G.;
Macìas-Pérez, J. F.;
Maffei, B.;
Mandolesi, N.;
Martin, S.;
Martinez-Gonzalez, E.;
Martins, C. J. A. P.;
Masi, S.;
Massardi, M.;
Matarrese, S.;
Mazzotta, P.;
McCarthy, D.;
Melchiorri, A.;
Melin, J. -B.;
Mennella, A.;
Mohr, J.;
Molinari, D.;
Monfardini, A.;
Montier, L.;
Natoli, P.;
Negrello, M.;
Notari, A.;
Noviello, F.;
Oppizzi, F.;
O'Sullivan, C.;
Pagano, L.;
Paiella, A.;
Pajer, E.;
Paoletti, D.;
Paradiso, S.;
Partridge, R. B.;
Patanchon, G.;
Patil, S. P.;
Perdereau, O.;
Piacentini, F.;
Piat, M.;
Pisano, G.;
Polastri, L.;
Polenta, G.;
Pollo, A.;
Ponthieu, N.;
Poulin, V.;
Prêle, D.;
Quartin, M.;
Ravenni, A.;
Remazeilles, M.;
Renzi, A.;
Ringeval, C.;
Roest, D.;
Roman, M.;
Roukema, B. F.;
Rubino-Martin, J. -A.;
Salvati, L.;
Scott, D.;
Serjeant, S.;
Signorelli, G.;
Starobinsky, A. A.;
Sunyaev, R.;
Tan, C. Y.;
Tartari, A.;
Tasinato, G.;
Toffolatti, L.;
Tomasi, M.;
Torrado, J.;
Tramonte, D.;
Trappe, N.;
Triqueneaux, S.;
Tristram, M.;
Trombetti, T.;
Tucci, M.;
Tucker, C.;
Urrestilla, J.;
Väliviita, J.;
Van de Weygaert, R.;
Van Tent, B.;
Vennin, V.;
Verde, L.;
Vermeulen, G.;
Vielva, P.;
Vittorio, N.;
Voisin, F.;
Wallis, C.;
Wandelt, B.;
Wehus, I.;
Weller, J.;
Young, K.;
Zannoni, M.
Submitted: 2017-06-14
Future observations of cosmic microwave background (CMB) polarisation have
the potential to answer some of the most fundamental questions of modern
physics and cosmology. In this paper, we list the requirements for a future CMB
polarisation survey addressing these scientific objectives, and discuss the
design drivers of the CORE space mission proposed to ESA in answer to the "M5"
call for a medium-sized mission. The rationale and options, and the
methodologies used to assess the mission's performance, are of interest to
other future CMB mission design studies. CORE is designed as a near-ultimate
CMB polarisation mission which, for optimal complementarity with ground-based
observations, will perform the observations that are known to be essential to
CMB polarisation scienceand cannot be obtained by any other means than a
dedicated space mission.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.07263 [pdf] - 1935304
Exploring Cosmic Origins with CORE: Extragalactic sources in Cosmic
Microwave Background maps
De Zotti, G.;
Gonzalez-Nuevo, J.;
Lopez-Caniego, M.;
Negrello, M.;
Greenslade, J.;
Hernandez-Monteagudo, C.;
Delabrouille, J.;
Cai, Z. -Y.;
Bonato, M.;
Achucarro, A.;
Ade, P.;
Allison, R.;
Ashdown, M.;
Ballardini, M.;
Banday, A. J.;
Banerji, R.;
Bartlett, J. G.;
Bartolo, N.;
Basak, S.;
Bersanelli, M.;
Biesiada, M.;
Bilicki, M.;
Bonaldi, A.;
Borrill, J.;
Bouchet, F.;
Boulanger, F.;
Brinckmann, T.;
Bucher, M.;
Burigana, C.;
Buzzelli, A.;
Calvo, M.;
Carvalho, C. S.;
Castellano, M. G.;
Challinor, A.;
Chluba, J.;
Clements, D. L.;
Clesse, S.;
Colafrancesco, S.;
Colantoni, I.;
Coppolecchia, A.;
Crook, M.;
D'Alessandro, G.;
de Bernardis, P.;
de Gasperis, G.;
Diego, J. M.;
Di Valentino, E.;
Errard, J.;
Feeney, S. M.;
Fernandez-Cobos, R.;
Ferraro, S.;
Finelli, F.;
Forastieri, F.;
Galli, S.;
Genova-Santos, R. T.;
Gerbino, M.;
Grandis, S.;
Hagstotz, S.;
Hanany, S.;
Handley, W.;
Hervias-Caimapo, C.;
Hills, M.;
Hivon, E.;
Kiiveri, K.;
Kisner, T.;
Kitching, T.;
Kunz, M.;
Kurki-Suonio, H.;
Lagache, G.;
Lamagna, L.;
Lasenby, A.;
Lattanzi, M.;
Brun, A. Le;
Lesgourgues, J.;
Lewis, A.;
Liguori, M.;
Lindholm, V.;
Luzzi, G.;
Maffei, B.;
Mandolesi, N.;
Martinez-Gonzalez, E.;
Martins, C. J. A. P.;
Masi, S.;
Massardi, M.;
McCarthy, D.;
Melchiorri, A.;
Melin, J. -B.;
Molinari, D.;
Monfardini, A.;
Natoli, P.;
Notari, A.;
Paiella, A.;
Paoletti, D.;
Partridge, R. B.;
Patanchon, G.;
Piat, M.;
Pisano, G.;
Polastri, L.;
Polenta, G.;
Pollo, A.;
Poulin, V.;
Quartin, M.;
Remazeilles, M.;
Roman, M.;
Rossi, G.;
Roukema, B. F.;
Rubino-Martin, J. -A.;
Salvati, L.;
Scott, D.;
Serjeant, S.;
Tartari, A.;
Toffolatti, L.;
Tomasi, M.;
Trappe, N.;
Triqueneaux, S.;
Trombetti, T.;
Tucci, M.;
Tucker, C.;
Valiviita, J.;
van de Weygaert, R.;
Van Tent, B.;
Vennin, V.;
Vielva, P.;
Vittorio, N.;
Young, K.
Submitted: 2016-09-23, last modified: 2017-05-18
We discuss the potential of a next generation space-borne Cosmic Microwave
Background (CMB) experiment for studies of extragalactic sources. Our analysis
has particular bearing on the definition of the future space project, CORE,
that has been submitted in response to ESA's call for a Medium-size mission
opportunity as the successor of the Planck satellite. Even though the effective
telescope size will be somewhat smaller than that of Planck, CORE will have a
considerably better angular resolution at its highest frequencies, since, in
contrast with Planck, it will be diffraction limited at all frequencies. The
improved resolution implies a considerable decrease of the source confusion,
i.e. substantially fainter detection limits. In particular, CORE will detect
thousands of strongly lensed high-z galaxies distributed over the full sky. The
extreme brightness of these galaxies will make it possible to study them, via
follow-up observations, in extraordinary detail. Also, the CORE resolution
matches the typical sizes of high-z galaxy proto-clusters much better than the
Planck resolution, resulting in a much higher detection efficiency; these
objects will be caught in an evolutionary phase beyond the reach of surveys in
other wavebands. Furthermore, CORE will provide unique information on the
evolution of the star formation in virialized groups and clusters of galaxies
up to the highest possible redshifts. Finally, thanks to its very high
sensitivity, CORE will detect the polarized emission of thousands of radio
sources and, for the first time, of dusty galaxies, at mm and sub-mm
wavelengths, respectively.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.04191 [pdf] - 1581899
Order-unity argument for structure-generated "extra" expansion
Submitted: 2017-03-12
Self-consistent treatment of cosmological structure formation and expansion
within the context of classical general relativity may lead to "extra"
expansion above that expected in a structureless universe. We argue that in
comparison to an early-epoch, extrapolated Einstein-de Sitter model, about
10-15% "extra" expansion is sufficient at the present to render superfluous the
"dark energy" 68% contribution to the energy density budget, and that this is
observationally realistic.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.04189 [pdf] - 1581898
Mass function of galaxy clusters in relativistic inhomogeneous cosmology
Submitted: 2017-03-12
The current cosmological model ($\Lambda$CDM) with the underlying FLRW metric
relies on the assumption of local isotropy, hence homogeneity of the Universe.
Difficulties arise when one attempts to justify this model as an average
description of the Universe from first principles of general relativity, since
in general, the Einstein tensor built from the averaged metric is not equal to
the averaged stress--energy tensor. In this context, the discrepancy between
these quantities is called "cosmological backreaction" and has been the subject
of scientific debate among cosmologists and relativists for more than $20$
years. Here we present one of the methods to tackle this problem, i.e.
averaging the scalar parts of the Einstein equations, together with its
application, the cosmological mass function of galaxy clusters.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.06004 [pdf] - 1531325
The background Friedmannian Hubble constant in relativistic
inhomogeneous cosmology and the age of the Universe
Submitted: 2016-08-21, last modified: 2016-11-28
In relativistic inhomogeneous cosmology, structure formation couples to
average cosmological expansion. A conservative approach to modelling this
assumes an Einstein--de Sitter model (EdS) at early times and extrapolates this
forward in cosmological time as a "background model" against which average
properties of today's Universe can be measured. This requires adopting an
early-epoch--normalised background Hubble constant $H_1^{bg}$. Here, we show
that the $\Lambda$CDM model can be used as an observational proxy to estimate
$H_1^{bg}$ rather than choose it arbitrarily. We assume (i) an EdS model at
early times; (ii) a zero dark energy parameter; (iii) bi-domain scalar
averaging---division of the spatial sections into over- and underdense regions;
and (iv) virialisation (stable clustering) of collapsed regions. We find
$H_1^{bg}= 37.7 \pm 0.4$ km/s/Mpc (random error only) based on a Planck
$\Lambda$CDM observational proxy. Moreover, since the scalar-averaged expansion
rate is expected to exceed the (extrapolated) background expansion rate, the
expected age of the Universe should be much less than $2/(3 H_1^{bg}) = 17.3$
Gyr. The maximum stellar age of Galactic Bulge microlensed low-mass stars (most
likely: 14.7 Gyr; 68\% confidence: 14.0--15.0 Gyr) suggests an age about a Gyr
older than the (no-backreaction) $\Lambda$CDM estimate.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.03578 [pdf] - 1522532
The comptonization parameter from simulations of single-frequency,
single-dish, dual-beam, cm-wave observations of galaxy clusters and
mitigating CMB confusion using the Planck sky survey
Submitted: 2016-08-11, last modified: 2016-11-18
Systematic effects in dual-beam, differential, radio observations of extended
objects are discussed in the context of the One Centimeter Receiver Array
(OCRA). We use simulated samples of Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) galaxy clusters at
low ($z<0.4$) and intermediate ($0.4<z<1.0$) redshifts to study the
implications of operating at a single frequency (30 GHz) on the accuracy of
extracting SZ flux densities and of reconstructing comptonization parameters
with OCRA. We analyze dependences on cluster mass, redshift, observation
strategy, and telescope pointing accuracy. Using $Planck$ data to make primary
cosmic microwave background (CMB) templates, we test the feasibility of
mitigating CMB confusion effects in observations of SZ profiles at angular
scales larger than the separation of the receiver beams.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.03313 [pdf] - 1354257
Observational Challenges for the Standard FLRW Model
Submitted: 2015-12-10, last modified: 2016-02-08
We summarise some of the main observational challenges for the standard
Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker cosmological model and describe how results
recently presented in the parallel session `Large--scale Structure and
Statistics' (DE3) at the `Fourteenth Marcel Grossman Meeting on General
Relativity' are related to these challenges.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.00302 [pdf] - 1608317
On the relativistic mass function and averaging in cosmology
Submitted: 2016-01-31
The general relativistic description of cosmological structure formation is
an important challenge from both the theoretical and the numerical point of
views. In this paper we present a brief prescription for a general relativistic
treatment of structure formation and a resulting mass function on galaxy
cluster scales in a highly generic scenario. To obtain this we use an exact
scalar averaging scheme together with the relativistic generalization of
Zel'dovich's approximation (RZA) that serves as a closure condition for the
averaged equations.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.09348 [pdf] - 1608314
The baryon acoustic oscillation peak: a flexible standard ruler
Submitted: 2015-12-31
For about a decade, the baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) peak at about 105
Mpc/h has provided a standard ruler test of the LCDM cosmological model, a
member of the Friedmann--Lemaitre--Robertson--Walker (FLRW) family of
cosmological models---according to which comoving space is rigid. However,
general relativity does not require comoving space to be rigid. During the
virialisation epoch, when the most massive structures form by gravitational
collapse, it should be expected that comoving space evolves inhomogeneous
curvature as structure grows. The BAO peak standard ruler should also follow
this inhomogeneous evolution if the comoving rigidity assumption is false. This
"standard" ruler has now been detected to be flexible, as expected under
general relativity.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.02947 [pdf] - 1608313
On the Green and Wald formalism
Submitted: 2015-12-09
Backreaction in the cosmological context is a longstanding problem that is
especially important in the present era of precise cosmology. The standard
model of a homogeneous background plus density perturbations is most probably
oversimplified and is expected to fail to fully account for the near-future
observations of sub-percent precision. From a theoretical point of view, the
problem of backreaction is very complicated and deserves careful examination.
Recently, Green and Wald claimed in a series of papers to have developed a
formalism to properly describe the influence of density inhomogeneities on
average properties of the Universe, i.e., the backreaction effect. A brief
discussion of this framework is presented, focussing on its drawbacks and on
misconceptions that have arisen during the "backreaction debate".
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.07800 [pdf] - 1294034
Is there proof that backreaction of inhomogeneities is irrelevant in
cosmology?
Buchert, T.;
Carfora, M.;
Ellis, G. F. R.;
Kolb, E. W.;
MacCallum, M. A. H.;
Ostrowski, J. J.;
Räsänen, S.;
Roukema, B. F.;
Andersson, L.;
Coley, A. A.;
Wiltshire, D. L.
Submitted: 2015-05-28, last modified: 2015-10-15
No. In a number of papers Green and Wald argue that the standard FLRW model
approximates our Universe extremely well on all scales, except close to strong
field astrophysical objects. In particular, they argue that the effect of
inhomogeneities on average properties of the Universe (backreaction) is
irrelevant. We show that this latter claim is not valid. Specifically, we
demonstrate, referring to their recent review paper, that (i) their
two-dimensional example used to illustrate the fitting problem differs from the
actual problem in important respects, and it assumes what is to be proven; (ii)
the proof of the trace-free property of backreaction is unphysical and the
theorem about it fails to be a mathematically general statement; (iii) the
scheme that underlies the trace-free theorem does not involve averaging and
therefore does not capture crucial non-local effects; (iv) their arguments are
to a large extent coordinate-dependent, and (v) many of their criticisms of
backreaction frameworks do not apply to the published definitions of these
frameworks. It is therefore incorrect to infer that Green and Wald have proven
a general result that addresses the essential physical questions of
backreaction in cosmology.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.05478 [pdf] - 1318685
Is the baryon acoustic oscillation peak a cosmological standard ruler?
Submitted: 2015-06-17, last modified: 2015-09-24
In the standard model of cosmology, the Universe is static in comoving
coordinates; expansion occurs homogeneously and is represented by a global
scale factor. The baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) peak location is a
statistical tracer that represents, in the standard model, a fixed
comoving-length standard ruler. Recent gravitational collapse should modify the
metric, rendering the effective scale factor, and thus the BAO standard ruler,
spatially inhomogeneous. Using the Sloan Digital Sky Survey, we show to high
significance (P < 0.001) that the spatial compression of the BAO peak location
increases as the spatial paths' overlap with superclusters increases. Detailed
observational and theoretical calibration of this BAO peak location environment
dependence will be needed when interpreting the next decade's cosmological
surveys.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.1687 [pdf] - 986944
Evidence for an environment-dependent shift in the baryon acoustic
oscillation peak
Submitted: 2014-10-07, last modified: 2015-04-30
The Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) metric assumes comoving
spatial rigidity of metrical properties. The curvature term in comoving
coordinates is environment-independent and cannot evolve. In the standard
model, structure formation is interpreted accordingly: structures average out
on the chosen metrical background, which remains rigid in comoving coordinates
despite nonlinear structure growth. The latter claim needs to be tested, since
it is a hypothesis that is not derived using general relativity. We introduce a
test of the comoving rigidity assumption by measuring the two-point
auto-correlation function on comoving scales---assuming FLRW comoving spatial
rigidity---in order to detect shifts in the baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO)
peak location for Large Red Galaxy (LRG) pairs of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
Data Release 7. In tangential directions, subsets of pairs overlapping with
superclusters or voids show the BAO peak. The tangential BAO peak location for
overlap with Nadathur & Hotchkiss superclusters is $4.3\pm1.6$ Mpc/h less than
that for LRG pairs unselected for supercluster overlap, and $6.6\pm2.8$ Mpc/h
less than that of the complementary pairs. Liivamagi et al. superclusters give
corresponding differences of $3.7\pm2.9$ Mpc/h and $6.3\pm2.6$ Mpc/h,
respectively. We have found moderately significant evidence
(Kolmogorov--Smirnov tests suggest very significant evidence) that the BAO peak
location for supercluster-overlapping pairs is compressed by about 6% compared
to that of the complementary sample, providing a potential challenge to FLRW
models and a benchmark for predictions from models based on an averaging
approach that leaves the spatial metric a priori unspecified.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1501.02170 [pdf] - 1182844
Extragalactic sources in Cosmic Microwave Background maps
De Zotti, G.;
Castex, G.;
Gonzalez-Nuevo, J.;
Lopez-Caniego, M.;
Negrello, M.;
Cai, Z. -Y.;
Clemens, M.;
Delabrouille, J.;
Herranz, D.;
Bonavera, L.;
Melin, J. -B.;
Tucci, M.;
Serjeant, S.;
Bilicki, M.;
Andreani, P.;
Clements, D. L.;
Toffolatti, L.;
Roukema, B. F.
Submitted: 2015-01-09, last modified: 2015-01-30
We discuss the potential of a next generation space-borne CMB experiment for
studies of extragalactic sources with reference to COrE+, a project submitted
to ESA in response to the M4 call. We consider three possible options for the
telescope size: 1m, 1.5m and 2m (although the last option is probably
impractical, given the M4 boundary conditions). The proposed instrument will be
far more sensitive than Planck and will have a diffraction-limited angular
resolution. These properties imply that even the 1m telescope option will
perform substantially better than Planck for studies of extragalactic sources.
The source detection limits as a function of frequency have been estimated by
means of realistic simulations. The most significant improvements over Planck
results are presented for each option. COrE+ will provide much larger samples
of truly local star-forming galaxies, making possible analyses of the
properties of galaxies (luminosity functions, dust mass functions, star
formation rate functions, dust temperature distributions, etc.) across the
Hubble sequence. Even more interestingly, COrE+ will detect, at |b|> 30 deg,
thousands of strongly gravitationally lensed galaxies. Such large samples are
of extraordinary astrophysical and cosmological value in many fields. Moreover,
COrE+ high frequency maps will be optimally suited to pick up proto-clusters of
dusty galaxies, i.e. to investigate the evolution of large scale structure at
larger redshifts than can be reached by other means. Thanks to its high
sensitivity COrE+ will also yield a spectacular advance in the blind detection
of extragalactic sources in polarization. This will open a new window for
studies of radio source polarization and of the global properties of magnetic
fields in star forming galaxies and of their relationships with SFRs.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1311.5402 [pdf] - 749846
Virialization-induced curvature versus dark energy
Submitted: 2013-11-21
The concordance model is successful in explaining numerous observable
phenomena at the price of introducing an exotic source of unknown origin: dark
energy. Dark energy dominance occurs at recent epochs, when we expect most
cosmological structures to have already formed, and thus, when the error
induced by forcing the homogeneous FLRW metric onto the data is expected to be
the most significant. We propose a way to quantify the impact of deviations
from homogeneity on the evolution of cosmological parameters. Using a
multi-scale partitioning approach and the virialization fraction estimated from
numerical simulations in an Einstein-de Sitter model, we obtain an
observationally realistic distance modulus over redshifts 0 < z < 3 by a
relativistic correction of the FLRW metric.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1302.4425 [pdf] - 766595
Deep redshift topological lensing: strategies for the T^3 candidate
Submitted: 2013-02-18, last modified: 2013-11-02
The 3-torus (T^3) FLRW model better fits the nearly zero large-scale
auto-correlation of the WMAP CMB sky maps than the infinite flat model. The T^3
model's WMAP parameters imply approximately equal-redshift topological lensing
at z \sim 6. We investigate observational strategies for rejecting the T^3
solution or providing candidate topologically lensed galaxy pairs. T^3
holonomies are applied to (i) existing z \sim 6 observations and (ii) simulated
observations, creating multiply connected catalogues. Corresponding simply
connected catalogues are generated. Each catalogue is analysed using a
successive filter method and collecting matched quadruples. Quadruple
statistics between the multiply and simply connected catalogues are compared.
The expected rejection of the hypothesis, or detection of candidate
topologically lensed galaxies, is possible at a significance of 5% for a pair
of T^3 axis-centred northern and southern surveys if photometric redshift
accuracy is \sigma(\zphot) < 0.01 for a pair of nearly complete 100 deg^2
surveys with a total of > 500 galaxies over 4.3 < z < 6.6, or for a pair of 196
deg^2 surveys with > 400 galaxies and \sigma(\zphot) < 0.02 over 4<z<7.
Dropping the maximum time interval in a pair from \Delta t =1 Gyr/h to \Delta t
=0.1 Gyr/h yields a requirement of \sigma(\zphot) < 0.005 or \sigma(\zphot) <
0.01, respectively. Millions of z \sim 6 galaxies will be observed over fields
of these sizes during the coming decades, implying much stronger constraints.
The question is not if the hypothesis will be rejected or confirmed, it is
when.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1303.4444 [pdf] - 736861
Virialisation-induced curvature as a physical explanation for dark
energy
Submitted: 2013-03-18, last modified: 2013-09-19
The geometry of the dark energy and cold dark matter dominated cosmological
model (LambdaCDM) is commonly assumed to be given by a
Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) metric, i.e. it assumes homogeneity
in the comoving spatial section. The homogeneity assumption fails most strongly
at (i) small distance scales and (ii) recent epochs, implying that the FLRW
approximation is most likely to fail at these scales. We use the virialisation
fraction to quantify (i) and (ii), which approximately coincide with each other
on the observational past light cone. For increasing time, the virialisation
fraction increases above 10% at about the same redshift (sim 1-3) at which
Omega_Lambda grows above 10% (approx 1.8). Thus, instead of non-zero
Omega_Lambda, we propose an approximate, general-relativistic correction to the
matter-dominated (Omega_m =1, Omega_Lambda=0), homogeneous metric (Einstein de
Sitter, EdS). A low-redshift effective matter-density parameter of
Omega_m^eff(0) = 0.26 pm 0.05 is inferred. Over redshifts 0 < z < 3, the
distance modulus of the virialisation-corrected EdS model approximately matches
the LambdaCDM distance modulus. This rough approximation assumes "old physics"
(general relativity), not "new physics". Thus, pending more detailed
calculations, we strengthen the claim that "dark energy" should be considered
as an artefact of emerging average curvature in the void-dominated Universe,
via a novel approach that quantifies the relation between virialisation and
average curvature evolution.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.4415 [pdf] - 679781
Dark energy with rigid voids versus relativistic voids alone
Submitted: 2013-05-19
The standard model of cosmology is dominated - at the present epoch - by dark
energy. Its voids are rigid and Newtonian within a relativistic background. The
model prevents them from becoming hyperbolic. Observations of rapid velocity
flows out of voids are normally interpreted within the standard model that is
rigid in comoving coordinates, instead of allowing the voids' density parameter
to drop below critical and their curvature to become negative. Isn't it time to
advance beyond nineteenth century physics and relegate dark energy back to the
"no significant evidence" box?
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1201.5845 [pdf] - 968247
Topological implications of inhomogeneity
Submitted: 2012-01-27, last modified: 2013-01-18
The approximate homogeneity of spatial sections of the Universe is well
supported observationally, but the inhomogeneity of the spatial sections is
even better supported. Here, we consider the implications of inhomogeneity in
dust models for the connectedness of spatial sections at early times. We
consider a non-global Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi (LTB) model designed to match
observations, a more general, heuristic model motivated by the former, and two
specific, global LTB models. We propose that the generic class of solutions of
the Einstein equations projected back in time from the spatial section at the
present epoch includes subclasses in which the spatial section evolves (with
increasing time) smoothly (i) from being disconnected to being connected, or
(ii) from being simply connected to being multiply connected, where the
coordinate system is comoving and synchronous. We show that (i) and (ii) each
contain at least one exact solution. These subclasses exist because the
Einstein equations allow non-simultaneous big bang times. The two types of
topology evolution occur over time slices that include significantly
post-quantum epochs if the bang time varies by much more than a Planck time. In
this sense, it is possible for cosmic topology evolution to be "mostly"
classical.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1212.6223 [pdf] - 1158707
A new look at the long-period eclipsing binary V383 Sco
Gałan, Cezary;
Tomov, Toma;
Kato, Taichi;
Pojmański, Grzegorz;
Szczygieł, Dorota M.;
Pilecki, Bogumił;
Graczyk, Dariusz;
Gromadzki, Mariusz;
Mikołajewski, Maciej;
Gieren, Wolfgang;
Strobel, Andrzej;
Roukema, Boudewijn F.
Submitted: 2012-12-26
V383Sco was discovered to be an eclipsing binary at the beginning of the XX
century. This system has one of the longest orbital periods known (13.5yr) and
was initially classified as a zet_Aur-type variable. It was then forgotten for
decades.
This study provides a detailed look at the V383Sco, using new data obtained
around the last eclipse in 2007/8. There was a suspicion that this system could
be similar to eclipsing systems with extensive dusty disks like EECep and
eps_Aur. This and other, alternative hypotheses are considered.
The ASAS-3 VI light curves have been used to examine photometric changes.
Low-(LRS) and high-res.(HRS) spectra have been used for spectral
classification, to analyse line profiles, as well as to determine the
reddening, radial velocities (RVs) and distance. The SED was analysed. Using
original numerical code, we performed a simplified model of the eclipse, taking
into account the pulsations of one of the components.
The LRS shows traces of molecular bands, characteristic of an M-type
supergiant. The presence of this star in the system is confirmed by SED, by a
strong dependence of the eclipse depth on the photometric bands, and by
pulsational changes. The presence of a low excitation nebula around the system
has been inferred from [OI] 6300A emission. Analysis of the RVs, reddening, and
P-L relation for Mira-type stars imply a distance to the V383Sco of 8.4+-0.6
kpc. The distance to the nearby V381Sco is 6.4+-0.8 kpc. The very different and
oppositely directed RVs of these systems (89.8 vs -178.8 km/s) seem to be in
agreement with a bulge/bar kinematic model of the Galactic centre and
inconsistent with purely circular motion.
We have found evidence for the presence of a pulsating M-type supergiant in
the V383Sco which periodically obscures the much more luminous F0I-type star,
causing the deep (possibly total) eclipses which vary in duration and shape.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1212.5426 [pdf] - 1158664
Topological acceleration in relativistic cosmology
Submitted: 2012-12-21
Heuristic approaches in cosmology bypass more difficult calculations that
would more strictly agree with the standard Einstein equation. These give us
the well-known Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) models, and, more
recently, the feedback effect of the global topology of spatial sections on the
acceleration of test particles. Forcing the FLRW heuristic model on
observations leads to dark energy, which, pending fully relativistic
calculations, is best interpreted as an artefact. Could topological
acceleration also be an artefact of using a heuristic approach? A multiply
connected exact solution of the Einstein equation shows that topological
acceleration is present in at least one fully relativistic case---it is not an
artefact of Newtonian-like thinking.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1205.0028 [pdf] - 1118372
International observational campaigns of the last two eclipses in EE
Cephei: 2003 and 2008/9
Gałan, C.;
Mikołajewski, M.;
Tomov, T.;
Graczyk, D.;
Apostolovska, G.;
Barzova, I.;
Bellas-Velidis, I.;
Bilkina, B.;
Blake, R. M.;
Bolton, C. T.;
Bondar, A.;
Brát, L.;
Brożek, T.;
Budzisz, B.;
Cikała, M.;
Csák, B.;
Dapergolas, A.;
Dimitrov, D.;
Dobierski, P.;
Drahus, M.;
Dróżdż, M.;
Dvorak, S.;
Elder, L.;
Frcakowiak, S.;
Galazutdinov, G.;
Gazeas, K.;
Georgiev, L.;
Gere, B.;
Goździewski, K.;
Grinin, V. P.;
Gromadzki, M.;
Hajduk, M.;
Heras, T. A.;
Hopkins, J.;
Iliev, I.;
Janowski, J.;
Kocián, R.;
Kołaczkowski, Z.;
Kolev, D.;
Kopacki, G.;
Krzesiński, J.;
Kučáková, H.;
Kuligowska, E.;
Kundera, T.;
Kurpińska-Winiarska, M.;
Kuźmicz, A.;
Liakos, A.;
Lister, T. A.;
Maciejewski, G.;
Majcher, A.;
Majewska, A.;
Marrese, P. M.;
Michalska, G.;
Migaszewski, C.;
Miller, I.;
Munari, U.;
Musaev, F.;
Myers, G.;
Narwid, A.;
Németh, P.;
Niarchos, P.;
Niemczura, E.;
Ogłoza, W.;
Ögmen, Y.;
Oksanen, A.;
Osiwała, J.;
Peneva, S.;
Pigulski, A.;
Popov, V.;
Pych, W.;
Pye, J.;
Ragan, E.;
Roukema, B. F.;
Różański, P. T.;
Semkov, E.;
Siwak, M.;
Staels, B.;
Stateva, I.;
Stempels, H. C.;
Stȩślicki, M.;
Świerczyński, E.;
Szymański, T.;
Tomov, N.;
Waniak, W.;
Wieȩk, M.;
Winiarski, M.;
Wychudzki, P.;
Zajczyk, A.;
Zoła, S.;
Zwitter, T.
Submitted: 2012-04-30, last modified: 2012-09-26
Two observational campaigns were carried out during the eclipses of EE Cep in
2003 and 2008/9 to verify whether the eclipsing body in the system is indeed a
dark disk and to understand the observed changes in the depth and durations of
the eclipses. Multicolour photometric data and spectroscopic observations at
both low and high resolution were collected. We numerically modelled the
variations in brightness and colour during the eclipses. We tested models with
different disk structure. We considered the possibility of disk precession. The
complete set of observational data collected during the last three eclipses are
made available to the astronomical community. Two blue maxima in the colour
indices were detected during these two eclipses, one before and one after the
photometric minimum. The first (stronger) blue maximum is simultaneous with a
"bump" that is very clear in all the UBVRI light curves. Variations in the
spectral line profiles seem to be recurrent during each cycle. NaI lines always
show at least three absorption components during the eclipse minimum and strong
absorption is superimposed on the H_alpha emission. These observations confirm
that the eclipsing object in EE Cep system is indeed a dark, dusty disk around
a low luminosity object. The primary appears to be a rapidly rotating Be star
that is strongly darkened at the equator and brightened at the poles. Some of
the conclusions of this work require verification in future studies: (i) a
complex, possibly multi-ring structure of the disk in EE Cep; (ii) our
explanation of the "bump" observed during the last two eclipses in terms of the
different times of obscuration of the hot polar regions of the Be star by the
disk; and (iii) our suggested period of the disk precession (~11-12 P_orb) and
predicted depth of about 2 mag the forthcoming eclipse in 2014.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1109.1596 [pdf] - 545457
A relativistic model of the topological acceleration effect
Submitted: 2011-09-07, last modified: 2012-07-05
It has previously been shown heuristically that the topology of the Universe
affects gravity, in the sense that a test particle near a massive object in a
multiply connected universe is subject to a topologically induced acceleration
that opposes the local attraction to the massive object. This effect
distinguishes different comoving 3-manifolds, potentially providing a
theoretical justification for the Poincar\'e dodecahedral space observational
hypothesis and a dynamical test for cosmic topology. It is necessary to check
if this effect occurs in a fully relativistic solution of the Einstein
equations that has a multiply connected spatial section. A Schwarzschild-like
exact solution that is multiply connected in one spatial direction is checked
for analytical and numerical consistency with the heuristic result. The T$^1$
(slab space) heuristic result is found to be relativistically correct. For a
fundamental domain size of $L$, a slow-moving, negligible-mass test particle
lying at distance $x$ along the axis from the object of mass $M$ to its nearest
multiple image, where $GM/c^2 \ll x \ll L/2$, has a residual acceleration away
from the massive object of $4\zeta(3) G(M/L^3)\,x$, where $\zeta(3)$ is
Ap\'ery's constant. For $M \sim 10^14 M_\odot$ and $L \sim 10$ to $20\hGpc$,
this linear expression is accurate to $\pm10%$ over $3\hMpc \ltapprox x
\ltapprox 2\hGpc$. Thus, at least in a simple example of a multiply connected
universe, the topological acceleration effect is not an artefact of
Newtonian-like reasoning, and its linear derivation is accurate over about
three orders of magnitude in $x$.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.0727 [pdf] - 1077071
The size of the Universe according to the Poincare dodecahedral space
hypothesis
Submitted: 2011-06-03, last modified: 2011-07-25
One of the FLRW models that best fits the WMAP sky maps of the CMB is the
Poincare dodecahedral space. The optimal fit of this model to WMAP data was
recently found using an optimal cross-correlation method, but the systematic
error in the estimate of the matched-circle angular radius \alpha, or
equivalently, the (comoving) size of the Universe 2\rinj (twice the injectivity
radius), might be much higher than the random error. In order to increase the
falsifiability of the model, it would be useful to reduce the uncertainty in
this estimate and to estimate the fraction of the sky where multiply imaged
gravitationally bound objects should potentially be detectable. "Matched discs"
are defined in order to describe a useful subset of multiply imaged objects.
The cross-correlation method at \ltapprox 1 \hGpc is applied to WMAP 7-year
data in order to improve the estimate of \alpha. The improved matched-circle
radius estimate is \alpha = 23 \pm 1.4 deg, where the uncertainty represents
systematic error dependent on the choices of galactic mask and all-sky map.
This is equivalent to 2\rinj = 18.2\pm 0.5 \hGpc for matter density parameter
Omega_m=0.28\pm 0.02. The lowest redshift of multiply imaged objects is
z=106\pm18. Multiply imaged high overdensity (rare) peaks visible during
200>z>106 should be present in matched discs of radius 14.8\pm2.3 deg. The
accuracy in the matched circle radius estimate is considerably improved by
using the higher resolution signal. The predicted matched discs (over
200>z>106) project to about 20% of the full sky. Since any object located
exactly in the discs would be multiply imaged at equal redshifts, evolutionary
effects would be small for objects that are nearly located in the discs.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.3766 [pdf] - 1077399
Sunyaev Zel'dovich observations of a statistically complete sample of
galaxy clusters with OCRA-p
Lancaster, Katy;
Birkinshaw, Mark;
Gawronski, Marcin P.;
Battye, Richard;
Browne, Ian;
Davis, Richard;
Giles, Paul;
Feiler, Roman;
Kus, Andrzej;
Lew, Bartosz;
Lowe, Stuart;
Maughan, Ben;
Mohammad, Abdulaziz;
Pazderska, Bogna;
Pazderski, Eugeniusz;
Peel, Mike;
Roukema, Boud;
Wilkinson, Peter
Submitted: 2011-06-19
We present 30 GHz Sunyaev Zel'dovich observations of a statistically complete
sample of galaxy clusters with OCRA-p. The clusters are the 18 most X-ray
luminous clusters at z > 0.2 in the ROSAT Brightest Cluster Sample. We correct
for contaminant radio sources via supplementary observations with the Green
Bank Telescope, also at 30 GHz, and remove a cluster that is contaminated by an
unresolved X-ray source. All 17 remaining clusters have central SZ effects with
Comptonisation parameter y_0 exceeding 1.9x10^-4, and 13 are detected at
significance > 3 sigma. We use our data to examine scalings between y_0 and
X-ray temperature, X-ray luminosity, and the X-ray mass proxy Y_X, and find
good agreement with predictions from self-similar models of cluster formation,
with an intrinsic scatter in y_0 of about 25%. We also comment on the success
of the observations in the face of the contaminant source population, and the
implications for upcoming cm-wave surveys.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1007.5242 [pdf] - 1033997
One Centimetre Receiver Array-prototype observations of the CRATES
sources at 30 GHz
Peel, M. W.;
Gawronski, M. P.;
Battye, R. A.;
Birkinshaw, M.;
Browne, I. W. A.;
Davis, R. J.;
Feiler, R.;
Kus, A. J.;
Lancaster, K.;
Lowe, S. R.;
Pazderska, B. M.;
Pazderski, E.;
Roukema, B. F.;
Wilkinson, P. N.
Submitted: 2010-07-29, last modified: 2011-05-17
Knowledge of the population of radio sources in the range ~2-200 GHz is
important for understanding their effects on measurements of the Cosmic
Microwave Background power spectrum. We report measurements of the 30 GHz flux
densities of 605 radio sources from the Combined Radio All-sky Targeted
Eight-GHz Survey (CRATES), which have been made with the One Centimetre
Receiver Array prototype (OCRA-p) on the Torun 32-m telescope. The flux
densities of sources that were also observed by WMAP and previous OCRA surveys
are in broad agreement with those reported here, however a number of sources
display intrinsic variability. We find a good correlation between the 30 GHz
and Fermi gamma-ray flux densities for common sources. We examine the radio
spectra of all observed sources and report a number of Gigahertz-peaked and
inverted spectrum sources. These measurements will be useful for comparison to
those from the Low Frequency Instrument of the Planck satellite, which will
make some of its most sensitive observations in the region covered here.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1007.5307 [pdf] - 254456
On the suspected timing-offset-induced calibration error in the
Wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe time-ordered data
Submitted: 2010-07-29, last modified: 2010-11-05
In the time-ordered data (TOD) files of the WMAP CMB observations, there is
an undocumented timing offset of -25.6 ms between the spacecraft attitude and
radio flux density timestamps. If the offset induced an error during
calibration of the raw TOD, then estimates of the WMAP CMB quadrupole might be
substantially in error. A timing error during calibration would not only induce
an artificial quadrupole-like signal in the mean sky map, it would also add
variance per pixel. This variance would be present in the calibrated TOD.
Low-resolution map-making as a function of timing offset should show a minimum
variance for the correct timing offset. Three years of the calibrated, filtered
WMAP 3-year TOD are compiled into sky maps at HEALPix resolution N_side=8,
individually for each of the K, Ka, Q, V and W band differencing assemblies
(DA's), as a function of timing offset. The median per map of the temperature
fluctuation variance per pixel is calculated and minimised against timing
offset. Minima are clearly present. The timing offsets that minimise the median
variance are -38 \pm 8 ms (K, Ka), -27 \pm 3 ms (Q), -43 \pm 8 ms (V), and -47
\pm 194 ms (W), i.e. an average of -30 \pm 3 ms, where the WMAP collaboration's
preferred offset is 0 \pm 1.7 ms. A non-parametric bootstrap analysis rejects
the latter at a significance of 99.999%. The hypothesis of a -25.6 ms offset,
suggested by Liu, Xiong & Li from the TOD file timing offset, is consistent
with these minima. It is difficult to avoid the conclusion that the WMAP
calibrated TOD and inferred maps are wrongly calibrated. CMB quadrupole
estimates (3/pi)C_2 based on the incorrectly calibrated TOD are overestimated
by roughly 64 \pm 6% (KQ85 mask) to 94 \pm 10% (KQ75 mask). Ideally, the WMAP
map-making pipelines should be redone starting from the uncalibrated TOD and
using the -25.6 ms timing offset correction.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.2300 [pdf] - 951117
A measure on the set of compact Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker
models
Submitted: 2009-12-11, last modified: 2010-09-28
Compact, flat Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) models have recently
regained interest as a good fit to the observed cosmic microwave background
temperature fluctuations. However, it is generally thought that a globally,
exactly-flat FLRW model is theoretically improbable. Here, in order to obtain a
probability space on the set F of compact, comoving, 3-spatial sections of FLRW
models, a physically motivated hypothesis is proposed, using the density
parameter Omega as a derived rather than fundamental parameter. We assume that
the processes that select the 3-manifold also select a global mass-energy and a
Hubble parameter. The inferred range in Omega consists of a single real value
for any 3-manifold. Thus, the obvious measure over F is the discrete measure.
Hence, if the global mass-energy and Hubble parameter are a function of
3-manifold choice among compact FLRW models, then probability spaces
parametrised by Omega do not, in general, give a zero probability of a flat
model. Alternatively, parametrisation by the injectivity radius r_inj ("size")
suggests the Lebesgue measure. In this case, the probability space over the
injectivity radius implies that flat models occur almost surely (a.s.), in the
sense of probability theory, and non-flat models a.s. do not occur.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1008.1167 [pdf] - 211532
Galactic Plane image sharpness as a check on cosmic microwave background
mapmaking
Submitted: 2010-08-06
The largest uncollapsed inhomogeneity in the observable Universe is
statistically represented in the quadrupole signal of the cosmic microwave
background (CMB) sky maps as observed by the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy
Probe (WMAP). The constant temporal offset of -25.6 ms between the timestamps
of the spacecraft attitude and observational data records in the time-ordered
data (TOD) of the WMAP observations was suspected to imply that previously
derived all-sky CMB maps are erroneous, and that the quadrupole is in large
part an artefact. The optimal focussing of bright objects in the Galactic Plane
plays a key role in showing that no error occurred at the step of mapmaking
from the calibrated TOD. Instead, the error had an effect when the uncalibrated
TOD were calibrated. Estimates of the high-latitude quadrupole based on the
wrongly calibrated WMAP maps are overestimated by about 15-60%.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1004.4506 [pdf] - 1026521
On the suspected timing error in WMAP map-making
Submitted: 2010-04-26, last modified: 2010-06-08
A large fraction of the previously estimated WMAP CMB quadrupole signal would
be an artefact of incorrect Doppler dipole subtraction if the hypothesis of a
small timing interpolation error were correct. Observations of bright
foreground objects constitute part of the time-ordered-data (TOD). Scans of an
object in different directions should be shifted by the would-be timing error,
causing a blurring effect. Three half-years of the calibrated, filtered WMAP
TOD are compiled individually for the four W band differencing assemblies
(DA's), with no masking of bright objects, giving 12 maps for each timing
offset. Percentiles of the temperature-fluctuation distribution in each map at
HEALPix resolution N_side=2048 are used to determine the dependence of all-sky
image sharpness on the timing offset. In the W band, the 99.999% percentile,
i.e. the temperature fluctuation in the approx 503-rd brightest pixel, is the
least noisy percentile. Using this statistic, the hypothesis that a -25.6 ms
offset relative to the timing adopted by the WMAP collaboration gives a focus
at least as sharp as the uncorrected timing is rejected at 4.6\sigma
significance. The Q and V band maps also reject the -25.6 ms offset hypothesis
at high statistical significance. The requirement that the correct choice of
timing offset must maximise image sharpness implies that the hypothesis of a
timing error in the WMAP collaboration's compilation of the WMAP calibrated,
filtered TOD is rejected at high statistical significance in each of the Q, V
and W wavebands. However, the hypothesis that a timing error was applied during
calibration of the raw TOD, leading to a dipole-induced difference signal, is
not excluded by this method.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.3528 [pdf] - 1513442
Which FLRW comoving 3-manifold is preferred observationally and
theoretically?
Submitted: 2010-02-18
The lack of structure greater than 10 Gpc/h in Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy
Probe (WMAP) observations of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) favours
compact Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) models of the Universe. The
present best candidates based on observations are the Poincare dodecahedral
space S^3/I^* and the 3-torus T^3. The residual gravity effect favours the
Poincare space, while a measure space argument where the density parameter is a
derived parameter favours flat spaces almost surely.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.1205 [pdf] - 1018257
There was movement that was stationary, for the four-velocity had passed
around
Submitted: 2009-11-06, last modified: 2009-12-11
Is the Doppler interpretation of galaxy redshifts in a
Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) model valid in the context of the
approach to comoving spatial sections pioneered by de Sitter, Friedmann,
Lemaitre and Robertson, i.e. according to which the 3-manifold of comoving
space is characterised by both its curvature and topology? Holonomy
transformations for flat, spherical and hyperbolic FLRW spatial sections are
proposed. By quotienting a simply-connected FLRW spatial section by an
appropriate group of holonomy transformations, the Doppler interpretation in a
non-expanding Minkowski space-time, obtained via four-velocity parallel
transport along a photon path, is found to imply that an inertial observer is
receding from herself at a speed greater than zero, implying contradictory
world-lines. The contradiction in the multiply-connected case occurs for
arbitrary redshifts in the flat and spherical cases, and for certain large
redshifts in the hyperbolic case. The link between the Doppler interpretation
of redshifts and cosmic topology can be understood physically as the link
between parallel transport along a photon path and the fact that the comoving
spatial geodesic corresponding to a photon's path can be a closed loop in an
FLRW model of any curvature. Closed comoving spatial loops are fundamental to
cosmic topology.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:0904.0975 [pdf] - 23124
Dark energy as a spatial continuity condition
Submitted: 2009-04-06, last modified: 2009-12-02
Observational evidence of dark energy that makes the Universe nearly flat at
the present epoch is very strong. We study the link between spatial continuity
and dark energy. We assume that comoving space is a compact 3-manifold of
constant curvature, described by a homogeneous
Friedman-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker metric. We assume that spatial continuity
cannot be violated, i.e. that the global topology of the comoving section of
the Universe cannot change during post-quantum epochs. We find that if the
Universe was flat and compact during early epochs, then the presently low
values of the radiation and matter densities imply that dark energy was created
as a spatial continuity effect. Moreover, if the Universe is compact, then
Omega_tot=1 is dynamically stable, where Omega_tot is the total density
parameter in units of the critical density. Dark energy was observationally
detected as a geometrical phenomenon. It is difficult to imagine a simpler
explanation for dark energy than spatial continuity, finiteness and
homogeneity.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.2739 [pdf] - 902426
A residual acceleration effect due to an inhomogeneity
Submitted: 2009-11-13
The perturbed Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker models allow many different
possibilities for the 3-manifold of the comoving spatial section of the
Universe. It used to be thought that global properties of the spatial section,
including the topology of the space, have no feedback effect on dynamics.
However, an elementary, weak-limit calculation shows that in the presence of a
density perturbation, a gravitational feedback effect that is algebraically
similar to dark energy does exist. Moreover, the effect differs between
different 3-spaces. Among the well-proportioned spaces, the effect disappears
down to third order in several cases, and down to fifth order for the Poincare
dodecahedral space S^3/I^*. The Poincare space, that which also is preferred in
many observational analyses, is better-balanced than the other spaces.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:0910.5837 [pdf] - 902253
Some spaces are more equal than others
Submitted: 2009-10-30
It has generally been thought that in perturbed
Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker models of the Universe, global topology
should not have any feedback effects on dynamics. However, a weak-field limit
heuristical argument, assuming a finite particle horizon for the transmission
of gravitational signals, shows that a residual acceleration effect can occur.
The nature of this effect differs algebraically between different constant
curvature 3-manifolds. This potentially provides a selection mechanism for the
3-manifold of comoving space.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:0909.1189 [pdf] - 1017403
30 GHz observations of sources in the VSA fields
Gawronski, M. P.;
Peel, M. W.;
Lancaster, K.;
Battye, R. A.;
Birkinshaw, M.;
Browne, I. W. A.;
Davies, M. L.;
Davis, R. J.;
Feiler, R.;
Franzen, T. M. O.;
Genova-Santos, R.;
Kus, A. J.;
Lowe, S. R.;
Pazderska, B. M.;
Pazderski, E.;
Pooley, G. G.;
Roukema, B. F.;
Waldram, E. M.;
Wilkinson, P. N.
Submitted: 2009-09-07
Small angular scale (high l) studies of cosmic microwave background
anisotropies require accurate knowledge of the statistical properties of
extragalactic sources at cm-mm wavelengths. We have used a 30 GHz dual-beam
receiver (OCRA-p) on the Torun 32-m telescope to measure the flux densities of
121 sources in VSA fields selected at 15 GHz with the Ryle Telescope. We have
detected 57 sources above a limiting flux density of 5mJy, of which 31 sources
have a flux density greater than 10mJy, which is our effective completeness
limit. From these measurements we derive a surface density of sources above
10mJy at 30 GHz of 2.0+/-0.4 per square degree. This is consistent with the
surface density obtained by Mason et al. (2009) who observed a large sample of
sources selected at a much lower frequency (1.4 GHz). We have also investigated
the dependence of the spectral index distribution on flux density by comparing
our results with those for sources above 1 Jy selected from the WMAP 22 GHz
catalogue. We conclude that the proportion of steep spectrum sources increases
with decreasing flux density, qualitatively consistent with the predictions of
deZotti et al. (2005). We find no evidence for an unexpected population of
sources whose spectra rise towards high frequencies, which would affect our
ability to interpret current high resolution CMB observations at 30 GHz and
above.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:0902.3402 [pdf] - 1001488
The residual gravity acceleration effect in the Poincare dodecahedral
space
Submitted: 2009-02-19, last modified: 2009-05-15
In a flat space, the global topology of comoving space can induce a weak
acceleration effect similar to dark energy. Does a similar effect occur in the
case of the Poincare dodecahedral space S^3/I^*? Does the effect distinguish
the Poincare space from other well-proportioned spaces? The residual
acceleration effect in the Poincare space is studied here using a massive
particle and a nearby test particle of negligible mass, in S^3 embedded in R^4.
The weak limit gravitational attraction on a test particle at distance r is set
\propto [r_C \sin(r/r_C)]^{-2}, where r_C = curvature radius, in order to
satisfy Stokes' theorem. A finite particle horizon large enough to include the
adjacent topological images of the massive particle is assumed. The regular,
flat, 3-torus T^3 is re-examined, and two other well-proportioned spaces,
S^3/T^* and S^3/O^*, are also studied. The residual gravity effect occurs in
all four cases. In a perfectly regular 3-torus of side length L_a, and in
S^3/T^* and S^3/O^*, the highest order term in the residual acceleration is the
third order term in the Taylor expansion of r/L_a (3-torus), or r/r_C,
respectively. However, the Poincare dodecahedral space is unique among the four
spaces. The third order cancels, leaving the fifth order term \sim \pm 300
(r/r_C)^5 as the most significant. Not only are three of the four perfectly
regular well-proportioned spaces better balanced than most other multiply
connected spaces in terms of the residual acceleration effect by a factor of
about a million (setting r/L_a = r/r_C \sim 10^{-3}), but the fourth of these
spaces is about 10^4 times better balanced than the other three. This is the
Poincare dodecahedral space. Is this unique dynamical property of the Poincare
space a clue towards a theory of cosmic topology?
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:0905.2543 [pdf] - 121241
Does gravity prefer the Poincare dodecahedral space?
Submitted: 2009-05-15
The missing fluctuations problem in cosmic microwave background observations
is naturally explained by well-proportioned small universe models. Among the
well-proportioned models, the Poincare dodecahedral space is empirically
favoured. Does gravity favour this space? The residual gravity effect is the
residual acceleration induced by weak limit gravity from multiple topological
images of a massive object on a nearby negligible mass test object. At the
present epoch, the residual gravity effect is about a million times weaker in
three of the well-proportioned spaces than in ill-proportioned spaces. However,
in the Poincare space, the effect is 10,000 times weaker still, i.e. the
Poincare space is about 10^{10} times "better balanced" than ill-proportioned
spaces. Both observations and weak limit dynamics select the Poincare space to
be special.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:0807.4260 [pdf] - 14892
Poincare dodecahedral space parameter estimates
Submitted: 2008-07-26, last modified: 2008-10-31
We aim to improve the surface of last scattering (SLS) optimal
cross-correlation method in order to refine estimates of the Poincar\'e
dodecahedral space (PDS) cosmological parameters. We analytically derive the
formulae required to exclude points on the sky that cannot be members of close
SLS-SLS cross-pairs. These enable more efficient pair selection without
sacrificing uniformity of the underlying selection process. In certain cases
this decreases the calculation time and increases the number of pairs per
separation bin. (i) We recalculate Monte Carlo Markov Chains (MCMC) on the
five-year WMAP data; and (ii) we seek PDS solutions in a small number of
Gaussian random fluctuation (GRF) simulations. For 5 < alpha/deg < 60, a
calculation speed-up of 3-10 is obtained. (i) The best estimates of the PDS
parameters for the five-year WMAP data are similar to those for the three-year
data. (ii) Comparison of the optimal solutions found by the MCMC chains in the
observational map to those found in the simulated maps yields a slightly
stronger rejection of the simply connected model using $\alpha$ than using the
twist angle $\phi$. The best estimate of $\alpha$ implies that_given a large
scale auto-correlation as weak as that observed,_ the PDS-like
cross-correlation signal in the WMAP data is expected with a probability of
less than about 10%. The expected distribution of $\phi$ from the GRF
simulations is approximately Gaussian around zero, it is not uniform on
$[-\pi,\pi]$. We infer that for an infinite, flat, cosmic concordance model
with Gaussian random fluctuations, the chance of finding_both_ (a) a large
scale auto-correlation as weak as that observed,_and_ (b) a PDS-like signal
similar to that observed is less than about 0.015% to 1.25%.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0606559 [pdf] - 82999
Homotopy symmetry in the multiply connected twin paradox of special
relativity
Submitted: 2006-06-22, last modified: 2008-07-23
In a multiply connected space, the two twins of the special relativity twin
paradox move with constant relative speed and meet a second time without
acceleration. The twins' situations appear to be symmetrical despite the need
for one to be younger due to time dilation. Here, the suggestion that the
apparent symmetry is broken by homotopy classes of the twins' worldlines is
reexamined using space-time diagrams. It is found that each twin finds her own
spatial path to have zero winding index and that of the other twin to have
unity winding index, i.e. the twins' worldlines' relative homotopy classes are
symmetrical. Although the twins' apparent symmetry is in fact broken by the
need for the non-favoured twin to non-simultaneously identify spatial domain
boundaries, the non-favoured twin {\em cannot} detect her disfavoured state if
she only measures the homotopy classes of the two twins' projected worldlines,
contrary to what was previously suggested. We also note that for the
non-favoured twin, the fundamental domain can be chosen by identifying time
boundaries (with a spatial offset) instead of space boundaries (with a temporal
offset).
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:0801.0006 [pdf] - 8525
The optimal phase of the generalised Poincare dodecahedral space
hypothesis implied by the spatial cross-correlation function of the WMAP sky
maps
Submitted: 2008-01-01, last modified: 2008-05-12
Several studies have proposed that the shape of the Universe may be a
Poincare dodecahedral space (PDS) rather than an infinite, simply connected,
flat space. Both models assume a close to flat FLRW metric of about 30% matter
density. We study two predictions of the PDS model. (i) For the correct model,
the spatial two-point cross-correlation function, $\ximc$, of temperature
fluctuations in the covering space, where the two points in any pair are on
different copies of the surface of last scattering (SLS), should be of a
similar order of magnitude to the auto-correlation function, $\xisc$, on a
single copy of the SLS. (ii) The optimal orientation and identified circle
radius for a "generalised" PDS model of arbitrary twist $\phi$, found by
maximising $\ximc$ relative to $\xisc$ in the WMAP maps, should yield $\phi \in
\{\pm 36\deg\}$. We optimise the cross-correlation at scales < 4.0 h^-1 Gpc
using a Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) method over orientation, circle size
and $\phi$. Both predictions were satisfied: (i) an optimal "generalised" PDS
solution was found, with a strong cross-correlation between points which would
be distant and only weakly correlated according to the simply connected
hypothesis, for two different foreground-reduced versions of the WMAP 3-year
all-sky map, both with and without the kp2 Galaxy mask: the face centres are
$(l,b)_{i=1,6}\approx (184d, 62d), (305d, 44d), (46d, 49d), (117d, 20d), (176d,
-4d), (240d, 13d) to within ~2d, and their antipodes; (ii) this solution has
twist \phi= (+39 \pm 2.5)d, in agreement with the PDS model. The chance of this
occurring in the simply connected model, assuming a uniform distribution $\phi
\in [0,2\pi]$, is about 6-9%.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:0801.1358 [pdf] - 8810
A test of the Poincare dodecahedral space topology hypothesis with the
WMAP CMB data
Submitted: 2008-01-09, last modified: 2008-04-24
It has been suggested by Roukema and coworkers (hereafter R04) that the
topology of the Universe as probed by the ``matched circles'' method using the
first year release of the WMAP CMB data, might be that of the Poincar\'e
dodecahedral space (PDS) model. An excess in the correlation of the
``identified circles'' was reported by R04, for circles of angular radius of
~11 deg for a relative phase twist -36deg, hinting that this could be due to a
Clifford translation, if the hypothesized model were true.
R04 did not however specify the statistical significance of the correlation
signal.
We investigate the statistical significance of the signal using Monte Carlo
CMB simulations in a simply connected Universe, and present an updated analysis
using the three-year WMAP data. We find that our analyses of the first and
three year WMAP data provide results that are consistent with the simply
connected space at a confidence level as low as 68%.
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0602159 [pdf] - 79735
A weak acceleration effect due to residual gravity in a multiply
connected universe
Submitted: 2006-02-07, last modified: 2006-12-08
Could cosmic topology imply dark energy? We use a weak field (Newtonian)
approximation of gravity and consider the gravitational effect from distant,
multiple copies of a large, collapsed (virialised) object today (i.e. a massive
galaxy cluster), taking into account the finite propagation speed of gravity,
in a flat, multiply connected universe, and assume that due to a prior epoch of
fast expansion (e.g. inflation), the gravitational effect of the distant copies
is felt locally, from beyond the naively calculated horizon. We find that for a
universe with a $T^1xR^2$ spatial section, the residual Newtonian gravitational
force (to first order) provides an anisotropic effect that repels test
particles from the cluster in the compact direction, in a way algebraically
similar to that of dark energy. For a typical test object at comoving distance
$\chi$ from the nearest dense nodes of the cosmic web of density perturbations,
the pressure-to-density ratio $w$ of the equation of state in an FLRW universe,
is w \sim - (\chi/L)^3, where $L$ is the size of the fundamental domain, i.e.
of the universe. Clearly, |w|<<1. For a T^3 spatial section of exactly equal
fundamental lengths, the effect cancels to zero. For a T^3 spatial section of
unequal fundamental lengths, the acceleration effect is anisotropic in the
sense that it will *tend to equalise the three fundamental lengths*. Provided
that at least a modest amount of inflation occurred in the early Universe, and
given some other conditions, multiple connectedness does generate an effect
similar to that of dark energy, but the amplitude of the effect at the present
epoch is too small to explain the observed dark energy density and its
anisotropy makes it an unrealistic candidate for the observed dark energy.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0602401 [pdf] - 1536194
WMAP First Year Sky Map: Hints of Poincare Dodecahedral Topology
Submitted: 2006-02-17, last modified: 2006-03-06
Several analyses of the cosmic microwave background map made by the satellite
WMAP suggest that the global shape of a spatial section of the Universe is that
of a Poincare dodecahedral space. A summary of some of these analyses and a
description of independent tests which should be able to either increase
confidence in the hypothesis or else refute it to extremely high significance
will be presented.
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0509154 [pdf] - 75736
A new approach for constraining the Hubble constant from proper motions
of radio jets
Submitted: 2005-09-06, last modified: 2006-02-26
Withdrawn due to a mistake in jets' Doppler factor modeling. An updated
version will appear after revisiting this work.
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0409694 [pdf] - 387080
A constraint on any topological lensing hypothesis in the spherical
case: it must be a root of the identity
Submitted: 2004-09-28, last modified: 2005-06-27
Three-dimensional catalogues of objects at cosmological distances can
potentially yield candidate topologically lensed pairs of sets of objects,
which would be a sign of the global topology of the Universe. In the spherical
case, a necessary condition, which does not exist for either null or negative
curvature, can be used to falsify such hypotheses, without needing to loop
through a list of individual spherical 3-manifolds. This condition is that the
isometry between the two sets of objects must be a root of the identity
isometry in the covering space S^3. This enables numerical falsification of
topological lensing hypotheses without needing to assume any particular
spherical 3-manifold. By embedding S^3 in R^4, this condition can be expressed
as the requirement that M^n = I for an integer n, where M is the matrix
representation of the hypothesised lensing isometry and I is the identity.
Moreover, this test becomes even simpler with the requirement that the two
rotation angles, theta, phi, corresponding to the given isometry, satisfy 2\pi
/ \theta, 2\pi / \phi \in Z. The calculation of this test involves finding the
two eigenplanes of the matrix M. A GNU General Public Licence numerical
package, called eigenplane, is made available at
http://cosmo.torun.pl/GPLdownload/eigen/ for finding the rotation angles and
eigenplanes of an arbitrary isometry M of S^3.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0412181 [pdf] - 387082
Cosmic crystallography using short-lived objects - active galactic
nuclei
Submitted: 2004-12-08, last modified: 2005-02-10
Cosmic crystallography is based on the principle that peaks in the pair
separation histogram (PSH) of objects in a catalogue should be induced by the
high number of topologically lensed pairs that are separated by Clifford
translations, in excess to ``random'' pairs of objects. Here we present
modifications of this method that successively improve the signal-to-noise
ratio by removing a large part of the noise and then false signals induced by
selection effects. Given the transient nature of the most readily available
tracer objects, active galactic nuclei (AGNs), the former is possible because a
natural filter for removing many of the noise pairs is available: when counting
pairs of objects in order to create PSHs, only those with nearly identical
redshifts need to be counted. This redshift filter (a maximum value of $\Delta
z/z = 0.005$) was applied to a compilation of AGN catalogues. Further noise was
removed by applying a second filter, a maximum angle $\Delta \theta =0.075$
rad, and a minimum number of pairs $\protect\npairs=3$ to find each ``bunch of
pairs'' (BoP) where the {\em vectors} (in Euclidean comoving space) defined by
pairs are required to be nearly equal, whereas in the PSH only the {\em
lengths} must be nearly equal. These filters reveal significant signals, which,
however, are due to selection effects. A third filter, a minimum length
$\Lselec=150$ {\hMpc} between the (parallel) vectors in a BoP, is found to
effectively remove these selection effect pairs. After application of these
successive filters, no significant topological signal was found.
[55]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0409533 [pdf] - 67614
A Solution to the Isolatitude, Equi-area, Hierarchical Pixel-Coordinate
System
Submitted: 2004-09-22, last modified: 2004-11-10
Gorski et al (1999b) have earlier presented the outline of a
pixelisation-to-spherical-coordinate transformation scheme which simultaneously
satisfies three properties which are especially useful for rapid analyses of
maps on a sphere: (i) equal spacing of pixels along lines of constant latitude,
(ii) equal pixel `areas' (solid angles) and (iii) hierarchical scaling with
increasing numbers of pixels. Their outline is based on the division of the
sphere into twelve regions covering equal solid angles, which are
hierarchically subdivided in a way compatible with these three criteria. In
this paper, a complete derivation of this scheme is presented, including, in
particular, (1) the angle theta^* defining the limit between polar and
equatorial regions, and (2) the transformations from the unit interval [0,1]
\wedge [0,1] to spherical coordinates in a polar region.
[56]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0402608 [pdf] - 387074
A Hint of Poincar\'e Dodecahedral Topology in the WMAP First Year Sky
Map
Submitted: 2004-02-25, last modified: 2004-06-03
Luminet et al. (2003) suggested that WMAP data are better matched by a
Poincar\'e dodecahedral FLRW model of global geometry, rather than by an
infinite flat model. The analysis by Cornish et al. (2003) for angular radii
25-90 degrees failed to support this. Here, a matched circles analysis
specifically designed to detect dodecahedral patterns of matched circles is
performed over angular radii in the range 1-40 degrees on the one-year WMAP ILC
map, using a correlation statistic and an rms difference statistic. Extreme
value distributions of these statistics are calculated for left-handed and
right-handed 36 degree `screw motions' (Clifford translations) when matching
circles and for a zero (unphysical) rotation. The most correlated circles
appear for circle radii of 11\pm1 degrees, for the left-handed screw motion,
but not for the right-handed one, nor for the zero rotation. The favoured six
dodecahedral face centres in galactic coordinates are (l,b)= (252, +65), (51,
+51), (144,+38), (207,+10), (271,+3), (332,+25) and their opposites. The six
pairs of circles_independently_ each favour a circle angular radius of 11\pm1
degrees. Whether or not these six circle pairs centred on dodecahedral faces
match via a 36 degree rotation only due to unexpected statistical properties of
the WMAP ILC map, or whether they match due to global geometry, it is clear
that the WMAP ILC map has some unusual statistical properties which mimic a
potentially interesting cosmological signal. The software for reading the WMAP
data and for carrying out this analysis are released under the GNU General
Public License.
[57]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0212169 [pdf] - 53559
Constraints on dark energy and quintessence with a comoving standard
ruler applied to 2dF quasars
Submitted: 2002-12-06
Structures on very large scales (> 100 Mpc) have negligible peculiar motions,
and are thus roughly fixed in comoving space. We looked for significant peaks
at very large separation in the two-point correlation function -- corrected for
redshift selection effects -- of a well convered subsample of 2378 quasars of
the recently released 10k sample of the 2dF quasar survey. Dividing our sample
in three redshift intervals, we find a peak at 244/h Mpc, which is perfectly
comoving for a restricted set of cosmological parameters, namely Omega_m =
0.25+/-0.15 and Omega_Lambda=0.65+/-0.35 (both at 95% confidence). Assuming a
flat Universe, we constrain the quintessence parameter w_Q < -0.35 (95%
confidence). We discuss the compatibility of our analysis with possible peaks
in the power spectrum.
[58]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0201092 [pdf] - 47036
Observational Constraints on the Topology (Global Geometry) of the
Universe
Submitted: 2002-01-07
The Universe is a physical object. Physical objects have shapes and sizes.
General relativity is insufficient to describe the global shape and size of the
Universe: the Hilbert-Einstein equations only treat limiting quantities towards
an arbitrary point. Empirical work on measuring the shape and size of the
Universe (formally: the ``3-manifold of the spatial hypersurface at constant
cosmological time'', and, e.g. the ``injectivity diameter'' respectively) has
progressed significantly in the late 1980's and the 1990's, using observational
catalogues of galaxy clusters, of quasars and of the microwave background,
though the analyses are still hindered by simplifying (and often
observationally unsupported) assumptions. A review of the different
observational strategies and claimed constraints was presented at the meeting.
[59]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0111051 [pdf] - 45817
Where the Very Bright Matter is a Standard Ruler
Submitted: 2001-11-02
Where's the matter? The answer seems to be: ``distributed according to a
power spectrum with at least one feature (local maximum) near 120-130h^-1Mpc''.
Analyses of the Iovino, Clowes & Shaver quasar candidate catalogue at z~2 and
the 2dF Quasar Survey 10K Release (2QZ-10K) support this claim, which has
previously been made both for low redshift survey analyses and for high z~3)
redshift surveys will be presented. This feature (i) offers a comoving standard
ruler which can lift the matter density-cosmological constant
(Omega_m-Omega_Lambda) degeneracy and (ii) might be due either to baryonic
acoustic oscillations or to Planck epoch physics which survives through
inflation. (i) The 95% confidence constraint from the 2QZ-10K is Omega_m=
0.25\pm0.15, Omega_Lambda=0.60{\pm0.35}. This constraint is independent of
cosmic microwave background constraints and type Ia supernovae constraints. The
only assumptions required are (a) that the Universe satisfies a perturbed
Friedmann-Lema\^{\i}tre-Robertson-Walker model with a possibly non-zero
cosmological constant, (b) that the density perturbations in this model on
large scales (>> 10h^-1Mpc) remain small (``linear'') and approximately
spatially fixed in comoving coordinates, (c) that the statistics (power
spectrum or correlation function) of the perturbations are redshift
independent, and (d) that quasar redshifts are cosmological.
[60]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0106135 [pdf] - 42931
The Cosmological Constant and Quintessence from a Correlation Function
Comoving Fine Feature in the 2dF Quasar Redshift Survey
Submitted: 2001-06-07, last modified: 2001-11-02
Detections of local maxima in the density perturbation spectrum at
characteristic comoving scales L~100-200h^{-1}Mpc have previously been claimed.
Here, this cosmic standard ruler is sought in the ``10K'' release of the 2dF
QSO Redshift Survey (2QZ-10K), by estimating the comoving, spatial correlation
functions \xi(r) of the three-dimensional distribution of the N=2378 quasars in
the most completely observed and ``covered'' sky regions, over the three
redshift ranges 0.6 < z < 1.1, 1.1 < z < 1.6 and 1.6 < z < 2.2. Because of the
selection method of the survey and sparsity of the data, the analysis was done
conservatively to avoid non-cosmological artefacts.
(i) Avoiding 'a priori' estimates of the length scales of features, local
maxima in \xi(r) are found in all three redshift ranges. The requirement that a
local maximum be present in all three redshift ranges at a fixed comoving
length scale implies strong, purely geometric constraints on the local
cosmological parameters. The length scale of the local maximum common to the
three redshift ranges is 2L= (244\pm17)h^{-1}Mpc.
(ii) For a standard FLRW model, the matter density \Omm and cosmological
constant \Omega_\Lambda are constrained to \Omm= 0.25\pm0.10,
\Omega_\Lambda=0.65\pm0.25 (68% confidence), \Omm= 0.25\pm0.15,
\Omega_\Lambda=0.60\pm0.35 (95%), respectively, *from the 2QZ-10K alone*.
Independently of the SNe Ia data, the zero cosmological constant model
(\Omega_\Lambda=0) is rejected at the 99.7% confidence level.
(iii) For an effective quintessence (w_Q) model and zero curvature, w_Q<-0.5
(68%), w_Q<-0.35 (95%) are found, again *from the 2QZ-10K alone*.
[61]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0111052 [pdf] - 45818
Topological Lensing: Is the Matter Both Here and There?
Submitted: 2001-11-02
If the Universe satisfies a perturbed Friedmann-Lema\^{\i}tre model, then the
bright matter (e.g. radio-loud active galactic nuclei, RLAGNs) may be
topologically lensed by global geometry. The generation of candidate
topological lensing pairs of RLAGNs, which may be double images of single
objects seen at very different celestial positions, provides very easily
falsifiable (given moderate telescope time) cosmological geometry hypotheses.
[62]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0106272 [pdf] - 43068
The Milky Way as the Ultimate Extragalactic Source
Submitted: 2001-06-14
The GAIA satellite will observe the Galaxy and its closest satellites in
great detail. This should allow (i) dating past events of dwarf galaxies
merging or interacting with the Galaxy, and much improved orbital parameters of
the nine dwarf spheroidals and the Magellanic Clouds and (ii) dating of active
galactic nucleus (AGN) phases of the Galaxy several Gigayears in the past, by
detecting coeval star formation (e.g. open star clusters) that occurred along
kpc scale Galactic jets. Both predictions (i) and (ii) of past history will be
highly valuable for searching for or excluding topologically lensed images of
the Milky Way at high redshift.
[63]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0105548 [pdf] - 42777
Clusters of Galaxies as Standard Candles for Global Observational
Cosmology
Submitted: 2001-05-31
As the largest gravitationally collapsed objects, and as objects with a
relatively low space density, clusters of galaxies offer one of the best sets
of standard candles for trying to measure basic cosmological parameters such as
the injectivity diameter 2r_{inj} (the shortest distance between two
topologically lensed images of any object, e.g. cluster) and the out-diameter
2r_{+} (the maximum `size' of the Universe). Present constraints indicate that
either of these may be smaller or larger than the horizon diameter.
[64]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0105152 [pdf] - 42381
Star formation losses due to tidal debris in `hierarchical' galaxy
formation
Submitted: 2001-05-09
Bottom-up hierarchical formation of dark matter haloes is not as monotonic as
implicitly assumed in the Press-Schechter formalism: matter can be ejected into
tidal tails, shells or low density `atmospheres'. The implications that the
possible truncation of star formation in these tidal `debris' may have for
observational galaxy statistics are examined here using the ArFus N-body plus
semi-analytical galaxy modelling software.
Upper and lower bounds on stellar losses implied by a given set of N-body
simulation output data can be investigated by choice of the merging/identity
criterion of haloes between successive N-body simulation output times. A median
merging/identity criterion is defined and used to deduce an upper estimate of
possible star formation and stellar population losses. A largest successor
merging/identity criterion is defined to deduce an estimate which minimises
stellar losses.
In the N-body simulations studied, the debris losses are short range in
length and temporary; maximum loss is around 16%.
The induced losses for star formation and luminosity functions are strongest
(losses of 10%-30%) for low luminosity galaxies and at intermediate redshifts
(1 < z < 3). This upper bound on likely losses is smaller than present
observational uncertainties. Hence, Press-Schechter based galaxy formation
models are approximately valid despite ignoring loss of debris, provided that
dwarf galaxy statistics are not under study.
[65]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0102095 [pdf] - 40806
How to distinguish a nearly flat Universe from a flat Universe using the
orientation independence of a comoving standard ruler
Submitted: 2001-02-06
Several recent observations using standard rulers and standard candles now
suggest, either individually or in combination, that the Universe is close to
flat, i.e. that the curvature radius is about as large as the horizon radius
(\sim 10h^{-1}Gpc) or larger. Here, a method of distinguishing an almost flat
universe from a precisely flat universe using a single observational data set,
without using any microwave background information, is presented. The method
(i) assumes that a standard ruler should have no preferred orientation (radial
versus tangential) to the observer, and (ii) requires that the (comoving)
length of the standard ruler be known independently (e.g. from low redshift
estimates). The claimed feature at fixed {\em comoving} length in the power
spectrum of density perturbations, detected among quasars, Lyman break galaxies
or other high redshift objects, would provide an adequate standard candle to
prove that the Universe is curved, if indeed it is curved. For example, a
combined intrinsic and measurement uncertainty of 1% in the length of the
standard ruler $\llss$ applied at a redshift of $z=3$ would distinguish an
hyperbolic $(\Omega_m=0.2,\Omega_\Lambda=0.7)$ or a spherical
$(\Omega_m=0.4,\Omega_\Lambda=0.7)$ universe from a flat one to 1-P > 95%
confidence.
[66]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0102099 [pdf] - 40810
On the comoving distance as an arc-length in four dimensions
Submitted: 2001-02-06
The inner product provides a conceptually and algorithmically simple method
for calculating the comoving distance between two cosmological objects given
their redshifts, right ascension and declination, and arbitrary constant
curvature. The key to this is that just as a distance between two points `on'
the surface of the ordinary 2-sphere ${\cal S}^2$ is simply an arc-length
(angle multiplied by radius) in ordinary Euclidean 3-space ${\cal E}^3$, the
distance between two points `on' a 3-sphere ${\cal S}^3$ (a 3-hyperboloid
${\cal H}^3$) is simply an `arc-length' in Euclidean 4-space ${\cal E}^4$
(Minkowski 4-space ${\cal M}^4$), i.e. an `hyper-angle' multiplied by the
curvature radius of the 3-sphere (3-hyperboloid).
[67]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0101191 [pdf] - 40329
How to Avoid the Ambiguity in Applying the Copernican Principle for
Cosmic Topology: Take the Observational Approach
Submitted: 2001-01-11
It is often stated that homogeneity and isotropy of the Universe are
assumptions of the almost Friedmann-Lema^itre (FL) model (the hot big bang
model), inspired from the Copernican Principle. However, only local homogeneity
and isotropy are required by the model: multiply connected almost FL models are
locally homogeneous and isotropic, but they can be globally anisotropic and/or
globally inhomogeneous. Toy models are used here to show how global anisotropy
and/or global inhomogeneity of an almost FL model could be shown directly in
observations. This approach may avoid having to make any assumptions regarding
global anisotropy and inhomogeneity.
[68]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0010511 [pdf] - 38858
Lifting cosmic degeneracy within a single quasar survey
Submitted: 2000-10-25, last modified: 2000-12-22
In the almost Friedmann-Lema^itre model of the Universe, the density
parameter, Omega_matter, and the cosmological constant, Omega_Lambda, measure
curvature. Several linearly degenerate relations between these two parameters
have recently been measured. Here, large scale structure correlations at
\~100-150 h^-1 Mpc are found in the comoving three-dimensional separations of
redshift z \approx 2 quasars. These function as a comoving standard rod of
length L_LSS \approx 130+-10 h^-1 Mpc. A local maximum in the correlation
function at \approx L_LSS/2 also appears to be significant. By combining
separate radial and tangential standard ruler analyses, the lifting of the
Omega_matter - Omega_Lambda linear degeneracy within a single data set is
demonstrated for the first time.
[69]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0010189 [pdf] - 1591847
Observational Approaches to the Topology of the Universe
Submitted: 2000-10-10
Many different and complementary strategies for translating the basic
principle of multiple topological imaging into observational analysis are now
available, both for three-dimensional and two-dimensional catalogues.
[70]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0010185 [pdf] - 880476
The Topology of the Universe
Submitted: 2000-10-10
The Hilbert-Einstein equations are insufficient to describe the geometry of
the Universe, as they only constrain a local geometrical property: curvature. A
global knowledge of the geometry of space, if possible, would require
measurement of the topology of the Universe. Since the subject was discussed in
1900 by Schwarzschild, observational attempts to measure global topology have
been rare for most of this century, but have accelerated in the 1990's due to
the rapidly increasing amount of observations of non-negligible fractions of
the observational sphere. A brief review of basic concepts of cosmic topology
and of the rapidly growing gamut of diverse and complementary observational
strategies for measuring the topology of the Universe is provided here.
[71]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0010170 [pdf] - 38517
Cosmological Topology in Paris 1998
Submitted: 2000-10-09
Quel est, ou pourrait \^etre, la topologie globale de la partie spatiale de
l'Univers ? L'Univers entier (pr\'ecis\'ement, l'hypersurface spatiale de
celui-ci) est-il observable ? Les math\'ematiciens, les physiciens et les
cosmologistes observationnels ont des approches diff\'erentes pour aborder ces
questions qui restent ouvertes.
What is, or could be, the global topology of spatial sections of the
Universe? Is the entire Universe (spatial hypersurface thereof) observable ?
Mathematicians, physicists and observational cosmologists have different
strategies to approaching these questions which are not yet fully answered.
[72]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0007140 [pdf] - 36978
A Counterexample to Claimed COBE Constraints on Compact Toroidal
Universe Models
Submitted: 2000-07-11
It has been suggested that if the Universe satisfies a flat, multiply
connected, perturbed Friedmann-Lema^itre model, then cosmic microwave
background data from the COBE satellite implies that the minimum size of the
injectivity diameter (shortest closed spatial geodesic) must be larger than
about two fifths of the horizon diameter. To show that this claim is
misleading, a simple $T^2 \times R$ universe model of injectivity diameter a
quarter of this size, i.e. a tenth of the horizon diameter, is shown to be
consistent with COBE four year observational maps of the cosmic microwave
background. This is done using the identified circles principle.
[73]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9911413 [pdf] - 1469862
Tangential Large Scale Structure as a Standard Ruler: Curvature
Parameters from Quasars
Submitted: 1999-11-22, last modified: 2000-04-18
Several observational analyses suggest that matter is spatially structured at
$\approx 130h^{-1}Mpc$ at low redshifts. This peak in the power spectrum
provides a standard ruler in comoving space which can be used to compare the
local geometry at high and low redshifts, thereby constraining the curvature
parameters.
It is shown here that this power spectrum peak is present in the observed
quasar distribution at $z\sim 2$: qualitatively, via wedge diagrams which
clearly show a void-like structure, and quantitatively, via one-dimensional
Fourier analysis of the quasars' tangential distribution. The sample studied
here contains 812 quasars.
The method produces strong constraints (68% confidence limits) on the density
parameter $\Omega_0$ and weaker constraints on the cosmological constant
$\lambda_0$, which can be expressed by the relation $ \Omega_0 = (0.24 \pm0.15)
+ (0.10\pm0.08) \lambda_0 $. Independently of $\lambda_0$ (in the range
$\lambda_0 \in [0,1]$), the constraint is $0.1 < \Omega_0 < 0.45$.
Combination of the present results with SN Type Ia results yields $\Omega_0 =
(0.30\pm0.11) + (0.57\pm0.11) (\lambda_0-0.7),$ $0.55 < \lambda_0 < 0.95,$ (68%
confidence limits). This strongly supports the possibility that the observable
universe satisfies a nearly flat, perturbed
Friedmann-Lema\^{\i}tre-Robertson-Walker model, independently of any cosmic
microwave background observations.
[74]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9910270 [pdf] - 1469841
Evolution of the correlation function as traced by the HDF galaxies
Submitted: 1999-10-14
An initially highly biased value of the spatial correlation function, which
decreases with time up to a transition redshift z_t ~ 1-2, was predicted
theoretically at least as early as 1993, and shown to be consistent with the
HDF-N angular correlation function estimates in 1997.
Observational analyses are presented here which show (i) an HDF-N estimate of
the correlation function amplitude of galaxies selected at z ~ 2 (by the UV
drop-{\em in} technique), which supports the estimate z_t ~ 2 and (ii) an HDF-N
estimate of the correlation function amplitude of galaxies selected at z ~ 3.7
by using photometric redshifts, which suggests that the correlation function
amplitude evolves as (1+z)^{2\pm3.5} during epochs earlier than z_t.
[75]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9910272 [pdf] - 108826
COBE and Global Topology: An Example of the Application of the
Identified Circles Principle
Submitted: 1999-10-14
The significance to which the cosmic microwave background observations by the
satellite COBE can be used to refute a specific observationally based
hypothesis for the global topology (3-manifold) of the Universe is
investigated, by a new method of applying the principle of matched circle
pairs. Moreover, it is shown that this can be done without assuming Gaussian
distributions for the density perturbation spectrum.
The Universe is assumed to correspond to a flat Friedmann-Lema\^{\i}tre model
with a zero value of the cosmological constant. The 3-manifold is hypothesised
to be a 2-torus in two directions, with a third axis larger than the horizon
diameter. The positions and lengths of the axes are determined by the relative
positions of the galaxy clusters Coma, RX~J1347.5-1145 and CL 09104+4109,
assumed to be multiple topological images of a single, physical cluster.
If the following two assumptions are valid: (i) the error estimates in the
COBE DMR data are accurate estimates of the total random plus systematic error;
and (ii) the temperature fluctuations are dominated by the na\"{\i}ve
Sachs-Wolfe effect; then the distribution of the temperature differences
between multiply imaged pixels is significantly wider than the uncertainty in
the differences, and the candidate is rejected at the 94% level.
This result is valid for either the `subtracted' or `combined' Analysed
Science Data Sets, for either $10\deg$ or $20\deg$ smoothing, and is
strengthened if suspected contaminated regions from the galactic centre and the
Ophiuchus and Orion complexes are removed.
[76]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9903453 [pdf] - 363272
Constraining Curvature Parameters via Topology
Submitted: 1999-03-30, last modified: 1999-05-19
If the assumption that physical space has a trivial topology is dropped, then
the Universe may be described by a multiply connected Friedmann-Lema\^{\i}tre
model on a sub-horizon scale. Specific candidates for the multiply connected
space manifold have already been suggested. How precisely would a significant
detection of multiple topological images of a single object, or a region on the
cosmic microwave background, (due to photons arriving at the observer by
multiple paths which have crossed the Universe in different directions),
constrain the values of the curvature parameters $\Omega_0$ and $\lambda_0$?
The way that the constraints on $\Omega_0$ and $\lambda_0$ depend on the
redshifts of multiple topological images and on their radial and tangential
separations is presented and calculated. The tangential separations give the
tighter constraints: multiple topological images of known types of
astrophysical objects at redshifts $z \ltapprox 3$ would imply values of
$\Omega_0$ and $\lambda_0$ preciser than $\sim 1%$ and $\sim 10%$ respectively.
Cosmic microwave background `spots' identified with lower redshift objects by
the Planck or MAP satellites would provide similar precision. This method is
purely geometrical: no dynamical assumptions (such as the virial theorem) are
required and the constraints are independent of the Hubble constant, $H_0.$
[77]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9901364 [pdf] - 104958
Topology of the Universe: Theory and Observations
Submitted: 1999-01-26, last modified: 1999-05-19
``One could imagine that as a result of enormously extended astronomical
experience, the entire universe consists of countless identical copies of our
Milky Way, that the infinite space can be partitioned into cubes each
containing an exactly identical copy of our Milky Way. Would we really cling on
to the assumption of infinitely many identical repetitions of the same world?
>... We would be much happier with the view that these repetitions are
illusory, that in reality space has peculiar connection properties so that if
we leave any one cube through a side, then we immediately reenter it through
the opposite side.'' (Schwarzschild 1900, translation 1998)
Developments in the theoretical and observational sides of cosmic topology
were slow for most of the century, but are now progressing rapidly, at the
scale of most interest which is 1-10 h^-1 Gpc rather than 10kpc.
The historical, mathematical and observational sides of this subject are
briefly reviewed in this course.
[78]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9904113 [pdf] - 106010
Topology of the Universe: background and recent observational approaches
Submitted: 1999-04-09
Is the Universe (a spatial section thereof) finite or infinite? Knowing the
global geometry of a Friedmann-Lema\^{\i}tre (FL) universe requires knowing
both its curvature and its topology. A flat or hyperbolic (``open'') FL
universe is {\em not} necessarily infinite in volume.
Multiply connected flat and hyperbolic models are, in general, as consistent
with present observations on scales of 1-20{\hGpc} as are the corresponding
simply connected flat and hyperbolic models. The methods of detecting multiply
connected models (MCM's) are presently in their pioneering phase of development
and the optimal observationally realistic strategy is probably yet to be
calculated. Constraints against MCM's on ~1-4 h^{-1} Gpc scales have been
claimed, but relate more to inconsistent assumptions on perturbation statistics
rather than just to topology. Candidate 3-manifolds based on hypothesised
multiply imaged objects are being offered for observational refutation.
The theoretical and observational sides of this rapidly developing subject
have yet to make any serious contact, but the prospects of a significant
detection in the coming decade may well propel the two together.
[79]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9903038 [pdf] - 105443
Transverse Galaxy Velocities from Multiple Topological Images
Submitted: 1999-03-02
The study of the kinematics of galaxies within clusters or groups has the
limitation that only one of the three velocity components and only two of the
three spatial components of a galaxy position in six-dimensional phase space
can normally be measured. However, if multiple topological images of a cluster
exist, then the radial positions and sky plane mean velocities of galaxies in
the cluster may also be measurable from photometry of the two cluster images.
The vector arithmetic and principles of the analysis are presented. These are
demonstrated by assuming the suggested topological identification of the
clusters RX J1347.5-1145 and CL 09104+4109 to be correct and deducing the
sky-plane relative velocity component along the axis common to both images of
this would-be single cluster.
Three out of four of the inferred transverse velocities are consistent with
those expected in a rich cluster. A control sample of random `common' sky-plane
axes, independent of the topological hypothesis, implies that this is not
surprising. This shows that while galaxy kinematics are deducible from
knowledge of cosmological topology, it is not easy to use them to refute a
specific candidate manifold.
[80]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9901299 [pdf] - 1469741
Galaxy Clustering at z ~ 2 and Halo Radii
Submitted: 1999-01-21
The amplitude of the angular two-point galaxy correlation function w(\theta)
for galaxies at z~2 is estimated for galaxies in the Hubble Deep Field by using
a U < 27 complete sub-sample.
(i) It is confirmed that the amplitude of the correlation can be corrected
for the integral constraint without having to make assumptions about the shape
of the correlation function and by avoiding the introduction of linear error
terms. The estimate using this technique is w(5'') = 0.10 \pm 0.09.
(ii) If the biases introduced in faint galaxy selection due to obscuration by
large objects are not corrected for by masking areas around them, then the
estimate would be w(5'') =0.16\pm 0.07.
(iii) The effective (3-D) galaxy pair separation at 5'' and this redshift
range is ~ 25-250 /h kpc, so the correction to the spatial correlation function
\xi(r) due to exclusion of overlapping galaxy dark matter haloes should be
considered. For clustering stable in proper units in an \Omega=1,\lambda=0
universe, our w(5\arcs) estimate (a) implies a present-day correlation length
of r_0 ~ 2.6^{+1.1}_{-1.7}/h Mpc if halo overlapping is ignored, but (b) for a
present-day correlation length of r_0=5.5/h Mpc implies that a typical halo
exclusion radius is r_halo=70^{+420}_{-30}/h kpc.
(iv) The decreasing correlation period (DCP) of a high initial bias in the
spatial correlation function is not detected at this redshift. For an
\Omega=1,\lambda=0 universe and (proper) stable clustering, possible detections
of the DCP in other work would imply that \xi at redshifts greater than z_t =
1.7\pm0.9 would be [(1+z)/(1+z_t)]^{2.1\pm3.6} times higher than at z_t, which
is consistent with our lack of a detection at z ~ 2.
[81]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9806111 [pdf] - 101704
Dwarf Galaxies from Cosmology
Submitted: 1998-06-08
A local property of standard cosmology - growth of primordial perturbations -
implies at least six different formation mechanisms of dwarf galaxies. A global
property - the topology of the Universe - may enable direct observational study
of the aging of individual galaxies.
Dwarfs (by mass) can form by star formation in low mass dark matter haloes,
which generally collapse early in hierarchical galaxy formation scenarios.
However, several other formation paths exist, including that of low redshift,
recently collapsed, low mass dark haloes containing low metallicity stellar
populations. The latter possibility is purely a property of gravitational
collapse --- no special mechanisms to retard star formation are required.
Dwarfs by ``nurture'', as opposed to ``nature'', are also possible.
[82]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9802083 [pdf] - 345109
Three-dimensional Topology-Independent Methods to Look for Global
Topology
Submitted: 1998-02-06, last modified: 1998-05-30
The space-like hypersurface of the Universe at the present cosmological time
is a three-dimensional manifold. A non-trivial global topology of this
space-like hypersurface would imply that the apparently observable universe
(the sphere of particle horizon radius) could contain several images of the
single, physical Universe. Recent three-dimensional techniques for constraining
and/or detecting this topology are reviewed. Initial applications of these
techniques using X-ray bright clusters of galaxies and quasars imply (weak)
candidates for a non-trivial topology.
[83]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9801225 [pdf] - 100074
M\'ethodes aux grandes \'echelles pour mesurer la topologie (globale) de
l'Univers
Submitted: 1998-01-23
Several recent large length scale methods of detecting the topology of the
Universe are briefly reviewed. Three-dimensional methods include those of
Lehoucq, Luminet & Lachi\`eze-Rey (1996), Roukema (1996) and Roukema & Edge
(1997). The two-dimensional ``circles'' method of Cornish, Spergel & Starkman
(1996b) is also mentioned.
[84]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9707294 [pdf] - 1235056
Merging History Trees of Dark Matter Haloes: a Tool for Exploring Galaxy
Formation Models
Submitted: 1997-07-26
A method of deriving and using merging history trees of dark matter galaxy
haloes directly from pure gravity N-body simulations is presented. This
combines the full non-linearity of N-body simulations with the flexibility of
the semi-analytical approach.
Merging history trees derived from power-law initial perturbation spectrum
simulations (for indices $n=-2$ and $n=0$) by Warren et al. (1992) are shown.
As an example of a galaxy formation model, these are combined with evolutionary
stellar population synthesis, via simple scaling laws for star formation rates,
showing that if most star formation occurs during merger-induced bursts, then a
nearly flat faint-end slope of the galaxy luminosity function may be obtained
in certain cases.
Interesting properties of hierarchical halo formation are noted: (1) In a
given model, merger rates may vary widely between individual haloes, and
typically 20%-30% of a halo's mass may be due to infall of uncollapsed
material. (2) Small mass haloes continue to form at recent times: as expected,
the existence of young, low redshift, low metallicity galaxies (e.g., Izotov et
al. 1997) is consistent with hierarchical galaxy formation models. (3) For
$n=-2,$ the halo spatial correlation function can have a very high initial bias
due to the high power on large scales.
[85]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9706166 [pdf] - 1235016
Constraining Cosmological Topology via Highly Luminous X-ray Clusters
Submitted: 1997-06-16
The topology of the observable Universe is not yet known. The most
significant observational sign of a non-trivial topology would be multiple
images (``ghosts'') of a single object at (in general) different sky positions
and redshifts.
It is pointed out that the previous search by Gott (1980) for ghost images of
the Coma cluster can be extended by using highly X-ray luminous clusters of
galaxies. This is likely to be more efficient than with other astrophysical
objects viewable on these scales since (1) X-ray clusters would be at least as
easy to identify if viewed from other angles as any other objects and (2) the
X-ray emitting thermally heated gas is likely to be simpler than for other
objects.
Possibilities that the highly luminous cluster RXJ~1347.5-1145 ($z=0\.45$)
has a ``ghost image'' at lower redshift are analysed. It is noted that
RXJ~1347.5-1145, the Coma cluster and the cluster CL~09104+4109 form nearly a
right angle ($\approx 88\deg$) with arms of nearly identical length
($970h^{-1}$ and $960h^{-1}$ Mpc respectively) for $\Omega_0=1, \lambda_0=0$
curvature ($h\equiv H_0/100 kms^{-1} Mpc^{-1}$). This is a clue that the three
clusters could be ghost images of one and the same cluster, for a hypertoroidal
topology. However, several arguments are presented that this relation is not
physical.
[86]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9705124 [pdf] - 1469529
On the Effective Spatial Separations in the Clustering of Faint Galaxies
Submitted: 1997-05-16
Several recent measurements have been made of the angular correlation
function $w(\theta,m)$ of faint galaxies in deep surveys (e.g., Hubble Deep
Field, HDF). Are the measured correlations indicative of gravitational growth
of primordial perturbations or of the relationship between galaxies and (dark
matter dominated) galaxy haloes? A first step in answering this question is to
determine the typical spatial separations of galaxies whose spatial
correlations, $\xi(r,z),$ contribute most to w.
The median spatial separation of galaxy pairs contributing to a fraction $p$
of $w$ for a galaxy survey is denoted by r_{eff} and compared with the
perpendicular distance, $r_\perp,$ at the median redshift, z_{median}, of the
galaxies. Over a wide range in $\xi$ growth rates $\epsilon$ and in
$z_{median}, \r_eff(50%) \ltsim r_\perp$ and $\r_eff(90%) \sim 4 r_\perp.$
Values of r_eff for typical redshift distributions indicate that many $w$
measurements correspond to spatial correlations at comoving length scales well
below 1 h^-1 Mpc. For $\Omega_0=1$ and $\lambda_0=0$, the correlation signal at
4\arcsec predominant in the Villumsen et al. (1996) estimates of $w$ for faint
HDF galaxies corresponds to r_eff(50%)(HDF) \approx 40 h^-1 kpc; other
cosmologies and angles up to 10\arcsec can increase this to r_eff(50%)(HDF)
$\ltsim 200 h^-1 kpc. The proper separations are (1+z) times smaller.
These scales are small: the faint galaxy $w$ measurements are at scales where
halo and/or galaxy existence, let alone interactions, may modify the spatial
correlation function. These measurements could maybe be used to probe the
radial extent of haloes at high redshift.
[87]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9703158 [pdf] - 96919
A Possible Effect of the Period of Galaxy Formation on the Angular
Correlation Function
Submitted: 1997-03-25
During the epoch of galaxy formation, the formation of the first galaxies in
regions of high overdensity may lead to an initial amplitude of the spatial
correlation function of galaxies, $\xi_0,$ much higher than that expected in
linear perturbation theory. This initially high ``bias'' would consequently
decrease to the near-unityvalues expected from local observations. Such a
``Decreasing Correlation Period'' (DCP), detected in N-body simulations under
certain conditions by several authors, is parametrised in a simple way, ending
at a ``transition'' redshift $z_t.$ Consequences on $w_0,$ the amplitude of the
angular correlation function of faint galaxies (for a fixed apparent magnitude
range), have been estimated. The sensitivity of $w_0$ to $z_t,$ and how this is
affected by the redshift distribution of the galaxies in the sample, by low
redshift spatial correlation function behaviour, by cosmology, and by the rate
at which $\xi_0$ decreases during the DCP, are shown and discussed. This simple
model is intended as a first exploration of the effects of the DCP for a likely
range of parameter space. Comparison with the Hubble Deep Field (HDF) estimate
of $w_0$ (Villumsen et al. 1996) indicates that the DCP is compatible with
observation for values of $z_t$ in the theoretically expected range $z_t
\gtapprox 1.$ However, tighter observational constraints on the HDF redshift
distribution and on low redshift correlation function growth will be needed
either to detect the DCP unambiguously or to constrain $z_t$ to redshifts
greater than those of galaxies in existing surveys.
[88]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9603052 [pdf] - 1234610
On Determining the Topology of the Observable Universe via 3-D Quasar
Positions
Submitted: 1996-03-12
Hot big bang cosmology says nothing about the topology of the Universe. A
topology-independent algorithm is presented which is complementary to that of
Lehoucq et al. 1996 and which searches for evidence of multi-connectedness
using catalogues of astrophysically observed objects. The basis of this
algorithm is simply to search for a quintuplet of quasars (over a region of a
few hundred comoving Mpc) which can be seen in two different parts of our past
time cone, allowing for a translation, an arbitrary rotation and possibly a
reflection. This algorithm is demonstrated by application to the distribution
of quasars between redshifts of $z=1$ and $z\approx4,$ i.e., at a comoving
distance from the observer $1700 h^{-1}\mbox{\rm Mpc} \ltapprox d \ltapprox
3300 h^{-1}\mbox{\rm Mpc}.$ Two pairs of isometric quintuplets separated by
more than {$300$\hMpc} are found. This is consistent with the number expected
from Monte Carlo simulations in a simply connected Universe if the detailed
anisotropy of sky coverage by the individual quasar surveys is taken into
account. The linear transformation in (flat) comoving space from one quintuplet
to another requires translations of {$353$\hMpc} and {4922\hMpc} respectively,
plus a reflection in the former case, and plus both a rotation and a reflection
in the latter. Since reflections are required, if these two matches were due to
multi-connectedness, then the Universe would be non-orientable.