The Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph's (STIS) BAR5 coronagraphic occulter was designed to provide high-contrast, visible-light, imaging in close (>= 0.15") angular proximity to bright point-sources. This is the smallest inner working angle (IWA) possible with HST's suite of coronagraphically augmented instruments through its mission lifetime. The STIS BAR5 image plane occulter, however, was damaged (bent and deformed) pre-launch and had not been enabled for GO science use following the installation of the instrument in 1997, during HST servicing mission SM2. With the success of the HST GO 12923 program, discussed herein, we explored and verified the functionality and utility of the BAR5 occulter. Thus, despite its physical damage, with updates to the knowledge of the aperture mask metrology and target pointing requirements, a robust determination of achievable raw and PSF-subtracted stellocentric image contrasts and fidelity was conducted. We also investigated, and herein report on, the use of the BAR10 rounded corners as narrow-angle occulters and compare IWA vs. contrast performance for the BAR5, BAR10, and Wedge occulters. With that, we provide recommendations for the most efficacious BAR5 and BAR10 use on-orbit in support of GO science. With color-matched PSF-template subtracted coronagraphy, inclusive of a small (+/- 1/4 pixel) 3-point cross-bar dithering strategy we recommend, we find BAR5 can deliver effective ~ 0.2" IWA image contrast of ~ 4 x 10^-5 pixel^-1 to ~ 1 x 10^-8 pixel^-1 at 2". With the pointing updates (to the PDB SIAF.dat file and/or implemented through APT) that we identified, and with observing strategies we explored, we recommend the use of STIS BAR5 coronagraphy as a fully "supported" capability for unique GO science.