Normalized to: Raaijmakers, G.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.14756 [pdf] - 2122742
Implications of the search for optical counterparts during the second
part of the Advanced LIGO's and Advanced Virgo's third observing run: lessons
learned for future follow-up observations
Coughlin, Michael W.;
Dietrich, Tim;
Antier, Sarah;
Almualla, Mouza;
Anand, Shreya;
Bulla, Mattia;
Foucart, Francois;
Guessoum, Nidhal;
Hotokezaka, Kenta;
Kumar, Vishwesh;
Raaijmakers, Geert;
Nissanke, Samaya
Submitted: 2020-06-25
Joint multi-messenger observations with gravitational waves and
electromagnetic data offer new insights into the astrophysical studies of
compact objects. The third Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo observing run began
on April 1, 2019; during the eleven months of observation, there have been 14
compact binary systems candidates for which at least one component is
potentially a neutron star. Although intensive follow-up campaigns involving
tens of ground and space-based observatories searched for counterparts, no
electromagnetic counterpart has been detected. Following on a previous study of
the first six months of the campaign, we present in this paper the next five
months of the campaign from October 2019 to March 2020. We highlight two
neutron star - black hole candidates (S191205ah, S200105ae), two binary neutron
star candidates (S191213g and S200213t) and a binary merger with a possible
neutron star and a "MassGap" component, S200115j. Assuming that the
gravitational-wave candidates are of astrophysical origin and their location
was covered by optical telescopes, we derive possible constraints on the matter
ejected during the events based on the non-detection of counterparts. We find
that the follow-up observations during the second half of the third observing
run did not meet the necessary sensitivity to constrain the source properties
of the potential gravitational-wave candidate. Consequently, we suggest that
different strategies have to be used to allow a better usage of the available
telescope time. We examine different choices for follow-up surveys to optimize
sky localization coverage vs.\ observational depth to understand the likelihood
of counterpart detection.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.11031 [pdf] - 2079295
Constraining the dense matter equation of state with joint analysis of
NICER and LIGO/Virgo measurements
Raaijmakers, G.;
Greif, S. K.;
Riley, T. E.;
Hinderer, T.;
Hebeler, K.;
Schwenk, A.;
Watts, A. L.;
Nissanke, S.;
Guillot, S.;
Lattimer, J. M.;
Ludlam, R. M.
Submitted: 2019-12-23, last modified: 2020-04-17
The NICER collaboration recently published a joint estimate of the mass and
the radius of PSR J0030+0451, derived via X-ray pulse-profile modeling.
Raaijmakers et al. (2019) explored the implications of this measurement for the
dense matter equation of state (EOS) using two parameterizations of the
high-density EOS: a piecewise-polytropic model, and a model based on the speed
of sound in neutron stars. In this work we obtain further constraints on the
EOS following this approach, but we also include information about the tidal
deformability of neutron stars from the gravitational wave signal of the
compact binary merger GW170817. We compare the constraints on the EOS to those
set by the recent measurement of a 2.14 solar mass pulsar, included as a
likelihood function approximated by a Gaussian, and find a small increase in
information gain. To show the flexibility of our method, we also explore the
possibility that GW170817 was a neutron star-black hole merger, which yields
weaker constraints on the EOS.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.13409 [pdf] - 2057775
GROWTH on S190814bv: Deep Synoptic Limits on the Optical/Near-Infrared
Counterpart to a Neutron Star-Black Hole Merger
Andreoni, Igor;
Goldstein, Daniel A.;
Kasliwal, Mansi M.;
Nugent, Peter E.;
Zhou, Rongpu;
Newman, Jeffrey A.;
Bulla, Mattia;
Foucart, Francois;
Hotokezaka, Kenta;
Nakar, Ehud;
Nissanke, Samaya;
Raaijmakers, Geert;
Bloom, Joshua S.;
De, Kishalay;
Jencson, Jacob E.;
Ward, Charlotte;
Ahumada, Tomás;
Anand, Shreya;
Buckley, David A. H.;
Caballero-García, Maria D.;
Castro-Tirado, Alberto J.;
Copperwheat, Christopher M.;
Coughlin, Michael W.;
Cenko, S. Bradley;
Gromadzki, Mariusz;
Hu, Youdong D.;
Karambelkar, Viraj R.;
Perley, Daniel A.;
Sharma, Yashvi;
Valeev, Azamat F.;
Cook, David O.;
Fremling, U. Christoffer;
Kumar, Harsh;
Taggart, Kirsty;
Bagdasaryan, Ashot;
Cooke, Jeff;
Dahiwale, Aishwarya;
Dhawan, Suhail;
Dobie, Dougal;
Gatkine, Pradip;
Golkhou, V. Zach;
Goobar, Ariel;
Chaves, Andreas Guerra;
Hankins, Matthew;
Kaplan, David L.;
Kong, Albert K. H.;
Kool, Erik C.;
Mohite, Siddharth;
Sollerman, Jesper;
Tzanidakis, Anastasios;
Webb, Sara;
Zhang, Keming
Submitted: 2019-10-29, last modified: 2019-12-31
On 2019 August 14, the Advanced LIGO and Virgo interferometers detected the
high-significance gravitational wave (GW) signal S190814bv. The GW data
indicated that the event resulted from a neutron star--black hole (NSBH)
merger, or potentially a low-mass binary black hole merger. Due to the low
false alarm rate and the precise localization (23 deg$^2$ at 90\%), S190814bv
presented the community with the best opportunity yet to directly observe an
optical/near-infrared counterpart to a NSBH merger. To search for potential
counterparts, the GROWTH collaboration performed real-time image subtraction on
6 nights of public Dark Energy Camera (DECam) images acquired in the three
weeks following the merger, covering $>$98\% of the localization probability.
Using a worldwide network of follow-up facilities, we systematically undertook
spectroscopy and imaging of optical counterpart candidates. Combining these
data with a photometric redshift catalog, we ruled out each candidate as the
counterpart to S190814bv and we placed deep, uniform limits on the optical
emission associated with S190814bv. For the nearest consistent GW distance,
radiative transfer simulations of NSBH mergers constrain the ejecta mass of
S190814bv to be $M_\mathrm{ej} < 0.04$~$M_{\odot}$ at polar viewing angles, or
$M_\mathrm{ej} < 0.03$~$M_{\odot}$ if the opacity is $\kappa <
2$~cm$^2$g$^{-1}$. Assuming a tidal deformability for the neutron star at the
high end of the range compatible with GW170817 results, our limits would
constrain the BH spin component aligned with the orbital momentum to be $ \chi
< 0.7$ for mass ratios $Q < 6$, with weaker constraints for more compact
neutron stars. We publicly release the photometry from this campaign at
http://www.astro.caltech.edu/~danny/static/s190814bv.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.05703 [pdf] - 2013922
A NICER view of PSR J0030+0451: Implications for the dense matter
equation of state
Raaijmakers, G.;
Riley, T. E.;
Watts, A. L.;
Greif, S. K.;
Morsink, S. M.;
Hebeler, K.;
Schwenk, A.;
Hinderer, T.;
Nissanke, S.;
Guillot, S.;
Arzoumanian, Z.;
Bogdanov, S.;
Gendreau, D. Chakrabarty K. C.;
Ho, W. C. G.;
Lattimer, J. M.;
Ludlam, R. M.;
Wolff, M. T.
Submitted: 2019-12-11
Both the mass and radius of the millisecond pulsar PSR J0030+0451 have been
inferred via pulse-profile modeling of X-ray data obtained by NASA's NICER
mission. In this Letter we study the implications of the mass-radius inference
reported for this source by Riley et al. (2019) for the dense matter equation
of state (EOS), in the context of prior information from nuclear physics at low
densities. Using a Bayesian framework we infer central densities and EOS
properties for two choices of high-density extensions: a piecewise-polytropic
model and a model based on assumptions of the speed of sound in dense matter.
Around nuclear saturation density these extensions are matched to an EOS
uncertainty band obtained from calculations based on chiral effective field
theory interactions, which provide a realistic description of atomic nuclei as
well as empirical nuclear matter properties within uncertainties. We further
constrain EOS expectations with input from the current highest measured pulsar
mass; together, these constraints offer a narrow Bayesian prior informed by
theory as well as laboratory and astrophysical measurements. The NICER
mass-radius likelihood function derived by Riley et al. (2019) using
pulse-profile modeling is consistent with the highest-density region of this
prior. The present relatively large uncertainties on mass and radius for PSR
J0030+0451 offer, however, only a weak posterior information gain over the
prior. We explore the sensitivity to the inferred geometry of the heated
regions that give rise to the pulsed emission, and find a small increase in
posterior gain for an alternative (but less preferred) model. Lastly, we
investigate the hypothetical scenario of increasing the NICER exposure time for
PSR J0030+0451.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.11246 [pdf] - 2026128
Implications of the search for optical counterparts during the first six
months of the Advanced LIGO's and Advanced Virgo's third observing run:
possible limits on the ejecta mass and binary properties
Submitted: 2019-10-24, last modified: 2019-12-04
GW170817 showed that neutron star mergers not only emit gravitational waves
but also can release electromagnetic signatures in multiple wavelengths. Within
the first half of the third observing run of the Advanced LIGO and Virgo
detectors, there have been a number of gravitational wave candidates of compact
binary systems for which at least one component is potentially a neutron star.
In this article, we look at the candidates S190425z, S190426c, S190510g,
S190901ap, and S190910h, predicted to have potentially a non-zero remnant mass,
in more detail. All these triggers have been followed up with extensive
campaigns by the astronomical community doing electromagnetic searches for
their optical counterparts; however, according to the released classification,
there is a high probability that some of these events might not be of
extraterrestrial origin. Assuming that the triggers are caused by a compact
binary coalescence and that the individual source locations have been covered
during the EM follow-up campaigns, we employ three different kilonova models
and apply them to derive possible constraints on the matter ejection consistent
with the publicly available gravitational-wave trigger information and the lack
of a kilonova detection. These upper bounds on the ejecta mass can be related
to limits on the maximum mass of the binary neutron star candidate S190425z and
to constraints on the mass-ratio, spin, and NS compactness for the potential
black hole-neutron star candidate S190426c. Our results show that deeper
electromagnetic observations for future gravitational wave events near the
horizon limit of the advanced detectors are essential.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.03035 [pdf] - 1845076
STROBE-X: X-ray Timing and Spectroscopy on Dynamical Timescales from
Microseconds to Years
Ray, Paul S.;
Arzoumanian, Zaven;
Ballantyne, David;
Bozzo, Enrico;
Brandt, Soren;
Brenneman, Laura;
Chakrabarty, Deepto;
Christophersen, Marc;
DeRosa, Alessandra;
Feroci, Marco;
Gendreau, Keith;
Goldstein, Adam;
Hartmann, Dieter;
Hernanz, Margarita;
Jenke, Peter;
Kara, Erin;
Maccarone, Tom;
McDonald, Michael;
Nowak, Michael;
Phlips, Bernard;
Remillard, Ron;
Stevens, Abigail;
Tomsick, John;
Watts, Anna;
Wilson-Hodge, Colleen;
Wood, Kent;
Zane, Silvia;
Ajello, Marco;
Alston, Will;
Altamirano, Diego;
Antoniou, Vallia;
Arur, Kavitha;
Ashton, Dominic;
Auchettl, Katie;
Ayres, Tom;
Bachetti, Matteo;
Balokovic, Mislav;
Baring, Matthew;
Baykal, Altan;
Begelman, Mitch;
Bhat, Narayana;
Bogdanov, Slavko;
Briggs, Michael;
Bulbul, Esra;
Bult, Petrus;
Burns, Eric;
Cackett, Ed;
Campana, Riccardo;
Caspi, Amir;
Cavecchi, Yuri;
Chenevez, Jerome;
Cherry, Mike;
Corbet, Robin;
Corcoran, Michael;
Corsi, Alessandra;
Degenaar, Nathalie;
Drake, Jeremy;
Eikenberry, Steve;
Enoto, Teruaki;
Fragile, Chris;
Fuerst, Felix;
Gandhi, Poshak;
Garcia, Javier;
Goldstein, Adam;
Gonzalez, Anthony;
Grefenstette, Brian;
Grinberg, Victoria;
Grossan, Bruce;
Guillot, Sebastien;
Guver, Tolga;
Haggard, Daryl;
Heinke, Craig;
Heinz, Sebastian;
Hemphill, Paul;
Homan, Jeroen;
Hui, Michelle;
Huppenkothen, Daniela;
Ingram, Adam;
Irwin, Jimmy;
Jaisawal, Gaurava;
Jaodand, Amruta;
Kalemci, Emrah;
Kaplan, David;
Keek, Laurens;
Kennea, Jamie;
Kerr, Matthew;
van der Klis, Michiel;
Kocevski, Daniel;
Koss, Mike;
Kowalski, Adam;
Lai, Dong;
Lamb, Fred;
Laycock, Silas;
Lazio, Joseph;
Lazzati, Davide;
Longcope, Dana;
Loewenstein, Michael;
Maitra, Dipankair;
Majid, Walid;
Maksym, W. Peter;
Malacaria, Christian;
Margutti, Raffaella;
Martindale, Adrian;
McHardy, Ian;
Meyer, Manuel;
Middleton, Matt;
Miller, Jon;
Miller, Cole;
Motta, Sara;
Neilsen, Joey;
Nelson, Tommy;
Noble, Scott;
O'Brien, Paul;
Osborne, Julian;
Osten, Rachel;
Ozel, Feryal;
Palliyaguru, Nipuni;
Pasham, Dheeraj;
Patruno, Alessandro;
Pelassa, Vero;
Petropoulou, Maria;
Pilia, Maura;
Pohl, Martin;
Pooley, David;
Prescod-Weinstein, Chanda;
Psaltis, Dimitrios;
Raaijmakers, Geert;
Reynolds, Chris;
Riley, Thomas E.;
Salvesen, Greg;
Santangelo, Andrea;
Scaringi, Simone;
Schanne, Stephane;
Schnittman, Jeremy;
Smith, David;
Smith, Krista Lynne;
Snios, Bradford;
Steiner, Andrew;
Steiner, Jack;
Stella, Luigi;
Strohmayer, Tod;
Sun, Ming;
Tauris, Thomas;
Taylor, Corbin;
Tohuvavohu, Aaron;
Vacchi, Andrea;
Vasilopoulos, Georgios;
Veledina, Alexandra;
Walsh, Jonelle;
Weinberg, Nevin;
Wilkins, Dan;
Willingale, Richard;
Wilms, Joern;
Winter, Lisa;
Wolff, Michael;
Zand, Jean in 't;
Zezas, Andreas;
Zhang, Bing;
Zoghbi, Abdu
Submitted: 2019-03-07, last modified: 2019-03-08
We present the Spectroscopic Time-Resolving Observatory for Broadband Energy
X-rays (STROBE-X), a probe-class mission concept selected for study by NASA. It
combines huge collecting area, high throughput, broad energy coverage, and
excellent spectral and temporal resolution in a single facility. STROBE-X
offers an enormous increase in sensitivity for X-ray spectral timing, extending
these techniques to extragalactic targets for the first time. It is also an
agile mission capable of rapid response to transient events, making it an
essential X-ray partner facility in the era of time-domain, multi-wavelength,
and multi-messenger astronomy. Optimized for study of the most extreme
conditions found in the Universe, its key science objectives include: (1)
Robustly measuring mass and spin and mapping inner accretion flows across the
black hole mass spectrum, from compact stars to intermediate-mass objects to
active galactic nuclei. (2) Mapping out the full mass-radius relation of
neutron stars using an ensemble of nearly two dozen rotation-powered pulsars
and accreting neutron stars, and hence measuring the equation of state for
ultradense matter over a much wider range of densities than explored by NICER.
(3) Identifying and studying X-ray counterparts (in the post-Swift era) for
multiwavelength and multi-messenger transients in the dynamic sky through
cross-correlation with gravitational wave interferometers, neutrino
observatories, and high-cadence time-domain surveys in other electromagnetic
bands. (4) Continuously surveying the dynamic X-ray sky with a large duty cycle
and high time resolution to characterize the behavior of X-ray sources over an
unprecedentedly vast range of time scales. STROBE-X's formidable capabilities
will also enable a broad portfolio of additional science.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.08188 [pdf] - 1851624
Equation of state sensitivities when inferring neutron star and dense
matter properties
Submitted: 2018-12-19, last modified: 2019-03-06
Understanding the dense matter equation of state at extreme conditions is an
important open problem. Astrophysical observations of neutron stars promise to
solve this, with NICER poised to make precision measurements of mass and radius
for several stars using the waveform modelling technique. What has been less
clear, however, is how these mass-radius measurements might translate into
equation of state constraints and what are the associated equation of state
sensitivities. We use Bayesian inference to explore and contrast the
constraints that would result from different choices for the equation of state
parametrization; comparing the well-established piecewise polytropic
parametrization to one based on physically motivated assumptions for the speed
of sound in dense matter. We also compare the constraints resulting from
Bayesian inference to those from simple compatibility cuts. We find that the
choice of equation of state parametrization and particularly its prior
assumptions can have a significant effect on the inferred global mass-radius
relation and the equation of state constraints. Our results point to important
sensitivities when inferring neutron star and dense matter properties. This
applies also to inferences from gravitational wave observations.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.09085 [pdf] - 1670777
On parametrised cold dense matter equation of state inference
Submitted: 2018-04-24
Constraining the equation of state of cold dense matter in compact stars is a
major science goal for observing programmes being conducted using X-ray, radio,
and gravitational wave telescopes. We discuss Bayesian hierarchical inference
of parametrised dense matter equations of state. In particular we generalise
and examine two inference paradigms from the literature: (i) direct posterior
equation of state parameter estimation, conditioned on observations of a set of
rotating compact stars; and (ii) indirect parameter estimation, via
transformation of an intermediary joint posterior distribution of exterior
spacetime parameters (such as gravitational masses and coordinate equatorial
radii). We conclude that the former paradigm is not only tractable for
large-scale analyses, but is principled and flexible from a Bayesian
perspective whilst the latter paradigm is not. The thematic problem of Bayesian
prior definition emerges as the crux of the difference between these paradigms.
The second paradigm should in general only be considered as an ill-defined
approach to the problem of utilising archival posterior constraints on exterior
spacetime parameters; we advocate for an alternative approach whereby such
information is repurposed as an approximative likelihood function. We also
discuss why conditioning on a piecewise-polytropic equation of state model -
currently standard in the field of dense matter study - can easily violate
conditions required for transformation of a probability density distribution
between spaces of exterior (spacetime) and interior (source matter) parameters.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.09087 [pdf] - 1686874
A pitfall of piecewise-polytropic equation of state inference
Submitted: 2018-04-24
The only messenger radiation in the Universe which one can use to
statistically probe the Equation of State (EOS) of cold dense matter is that
originating from the near-field vicinities of compact stars. Constraining
gravitational masses and equatorial radii of rotating compact stars is a major
goal for current and future telescope missions, with a primary purpose of
constraining the EOS. From a Bayesian perspective it is necessary to carefully
discuss prior definition; in this context a complicating issue is that in
practice there exist pathologies in the general relativistic mapping between
spaces of local (interior source matter) and global (exterior spacetime)
parameters. In a companion paper, these issues were raised on a theoretical
basis. In this study we reproduce a probability transformation procedure from
the literature in order to map a joint posterior distribution of Schwarzschild
gravitational masses and radii into a joint posterior distribution of EOS
parameters. We demonstrate computationally that EOS parameter inferences are
sensitive to the choice to define a prior on a joint space of these masses and
radii, instead of on a joint space interior source matter parameters. We focus
on the piecewise-polytropic EOS model, which is currently standard in the field
of astrophysical dense matter study. We discuss the implications of this issue
for the field.
