Normalized to: Régulo, C.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.10717 [pdf] - 1846949
Oscillations in the Sun with SONG: Setting the scale for asteroseismic
investigations
Andersen, M. Fredslund;
Pallé, P.;
Jessen-Hansen, J.;
Wang, K.;
Grundahl, F.;
Bedding, T. R.;
Cortes, T. Roca;
Yu, J.;
Mathur, S.;
Gacia, R. A.;
Arentoft, T.;
Régulo, C.;
Tronsgaard, R.;
Kjeldsen, H.;
Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.
Submitted: 2019-02-27
Context. We present the first high-cadence multi-wavelength radial-velocity
observations of the Sun-as-a-star, carried out during 57 consecutive days using
the stellar \'echelle spectrograph at the Hertzsprung SONG Telescope operating
at the Teide Observatory. Aims. The aim was to produce a high-quality data set
and reference values for the global helioseismic parameters {\nu_{max}}, and
{\Delta \nu} of the solar p-modes using the SONG instrument. The obtained data
set or the inferred values should then be used when the scaling relations are
applied to other stars showing solar-like oscillations which are observed with
SONG or similar instruments. Methods. We used different approaches to analyse
the power spectrum of the time series to determine {\nu_{max}}; simple Gaussian
fitting and heavy smoothing of the power spectrum. {\Delta\nu} was determined
using the method of autocorrelation of the power spectrum. The amplitude per
radial mode was determined using the method described in Kjeldsen et al.
(2008). Results. We found the following values for the solar oscillations using
the SONG spectrograph: {\nu_{max}} = 3141 {\pm} 12 {\mu}Hz, {\Delta\nu} =
134.98 {\pm} 0.04 {\mu}Hz and an average amplitude of the strongest radial
modes of 16.6 {\pm} 0.4 cm/s. These values are consistent with previous
measurements with other techniques.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1712.05691 [pdf] - 1659635
On the frequency dependence of p-mode frequency shifts induced by
magnetic activity in Kepler solar-like stars
Submitted: 2017-12-15
The variations of the frequencies of the low-degree acoustic oscillations in
the Sun induced by magnetic activity show a dependence with radial order. The
frequency shifts are observed to increase towards higher-order modes to reach a
maximum of about 0.8 muHz over the 11-yr solar cycle. A comparable frequency
dependence is also measured in two other main-sequence solar-like stars, the
F-star HD49933, and the young 1-Gyr-old solar analog KIC10644253, although with
different amplitudes of the shifts of about 2 muHz and 0.5 muHz respectively.
Our objective here is to extend this analysis to stars with different masses,
metallicities, and evolutionary stages. From an initial set of 87 Kepler
solar-like oscillating stars with already known individual p-mode frequencies,
we identify five stars showing frequency shifts that can be considered reliable
using selection criteria based on Monte Carlo simulations and on the
photospheric magnetic activity proxy Sph. The frequency dependence of the
frequency shifts of four of these stars could be measured for the l=0 and l=1
modes individually. Given the quality of the data, the results could indicate
that a different physical source of perturbation than in the Sun is dominating
in this sample of solar-like stars.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.09581 [pdf] - 1574554
Kepler Observations of the Asteroseismic Binary HD 176465
White, T. R.;
Benomar, O.;
Aguirre, V. Silva;
Ball, W. H.;
Bedding, T. R.;
Chaplin, W. J.;
Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.;
Garcia, R. A.;
Gizon, L.;
Stello, D.;
Aigrain, S.;
Antia, H. M.;
Appourchaux, T.;
Bazot, M.;
Campante, T. L.;
Creevey, O. L.;
Davies, G. R.;
Elsworth, Y. P.;
Gaulme, P.;
Handberg, R.;
Hekker, S.;
Houdek, G.;
Howe, R.;
Huber, D.;
Karoff, C.;
Marques, J. P.;
Mathur, S.;
McQuillan, A.;
Metcalfe, T. S.;
Mosser, B.;
Nielsen, M. B.;
Régulo, C.;
Salabert, D.;
Stahn, T.
Submitted: 2016-09-29
Binary star systems are important for understanding stellar structure and
evolution, and are especially useful when oscillations can be detected and
analysed with asteroseismology. However, only four systems are known in which
solar-like oscillations are detected in both components. Here, we analyse the
fifth such system, HD 176465, which was observed by Kepler. We carefully
analysed the system's power spectrum to measure individual mode frequencies,
adapting our methods where necessary to accommodate the fact that both stars
oscillate in a similar frequency range. We also modelled the two stars
independently by fitting stellar models to the frequencies and complementary
parameters. We are able to cleanly separate the oscillation modes in both
systems. The stellar models produce compatible ages and initial compositions
for the stars, as is expected from their common and contemporaneous origin.
Combining the individual ages, the system is about 3.0$\pm$0.5 Gyr old. The two
components of HD 176465 are young physically-similar oscillating solar
analogues, the first such system to be found, and provide important constraints
for stellar evolution and asteroseismology.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.01035 [pdf] - 1513569
Detection of Solar-Like Oscillations, Observational Constraints, and
Stellar Models for $\theta$ Cyg, the Brightest Star Observed by the {\it
Kepler} Mission
Guzik, J. A.;
Houdek, G.;
Chaplin, W. J.;
Smalley, B.;
Kurtz, D. W.;
Gilliland, R. L.;
Mullally, F.;
Rowe, J. F.;
Bryson, S. T.;
Still, M. D.;
Antoci, V.;
Appourchaux, T.;
Basu, S.;
Bedding, T. R.;
Benomar, O.;
Garcia, R. A.;
Huber, D.;
Kjeldsen, H.;
Latham, D. W.;
Metcalfe, T. S.;
Pápics, P. I.;
White, T. R.;
Aerts, C.;
Ballot, J.;
Boyajian, T. S.;
Briquet, M.;
Bruntt, H.;
Buchhave, L. A.;
Campante, T. L.;
Catanzaro, G.;
Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.;
Davies, G. R.;
Doğan, G.;
Dragomir, D.;
Doyle, A. P.;
Elsworth, Y.;
Frasca, A.;
Gaulme, P.;
Gruberbauer, M.;
Handberg, R.;
Hekker, S.;
Karoff, C.;
Lehmann, H.;
Mathias, P.;
Mathur, S.;
Miglio, A.;
Molenda-Żakowicz, J.;
Mosser, B.;
Murphy, S. J.;
Régulo, C.;
Ripepi, V.;
Salabert, D.;
Sousa, S. G.;
Stello, D.;
Uytterhoeven, K.
Submitted: 2016-07-04
$\theta$ Cygni is an F3 spectral-type main-sequence star with visual
magnitude V=4.48. This star was the brightest star observed by the original
Kepler spacecraft mission. Short-cadence (58.8 s) photometric data using a
custom aperture were obtained during Quarter 6 (June-September 2010) and
subsequently in Quarters 8 and 12-17. We present analyses of the solar-like
oscillations based on Q6 and Q8 data, identifying angular degree $l$ = 0, 1,
and 2 oscillations in the range 1000-2700 microHz, with a large frequency
separation of 83.9 plus/minus 0.4 microHz, and frequency with maximum amplitude
1829 plus/minus 54 microHz. We also present analyses of new ground-based
spectroscopic observations, which, when combined with angular diameter
measurements from interferometry and Hipparcos parallax, give T_eff = 6697
plus/minus 78 K, radius 1.49 plus/minus 0.03 solar radii, [Fe/H] = -0.02
plus/minus 0.06 dex, and log g = 4.23 plus/minus 0.03. We calculate stellar
models matching the constraints using several methods, including using the Yale
Rotating Evolution Code and the Asteroseismic Modeling Portal. The best-fit
models have masses 1.35-1.39 solar masses and ages 1.0-1.6 Gyr. theta Cyg's
T_eff and log g place it cooler than the red edge of the gamma Doradus
instability region established from pre-Kepler ground-based observations, but
just at the red edge derived from pulsation modeling. The pulsation models show
gamma Dor gravity-mode pulsations driven by the convective-blocking mechanism,
with frequencies of 1 to 3 cycles/day (11 to 33 microHz). However, gravity
modes were not detected in the Kepler data, one signal at 1.776 cycles/day
(20.56 microHz) may be attributable to a faint, possibly background, binary.
Asteroseismic studies of theta Cyg and other A-F stars observed by Kepler and
CoRoT, will help to improve stellar model physics and to test pulsation driving
mechanisms.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1403.7046 [pdf] - 1208640
Oscillation mode linewidths and heights of 23 main-sequence stars
observed by Kepler
Appourchaux, T.;
Antia, H. M.;
Benomar, O.;
Campante, T. L.;
Davies, G. R.;
Handberg, R.;
Howe, R.;
Régulo, C.;
Belkacem, K.;
Houdek, G.;
García, R. A.;
Chaplin, W. J.
Submitted: 2014-03-27
Solar-like oscillations have been observed by Kepler and CoRoT in many
solar-type stars, thereby providing a way to probe the stars using
asteroseismology. We provide the mode linewidths and mode heights of the
oscillations of various stars as a function of frequency and of effective
temperature. We used a time series of nearly two years of data for each star.
The 23 stars observed belong to the simple or F-like category. The power
spectra of the 23 main-sequence stars were analysed using both maximum
likelihood estimators and Bayesian estimators, providing individual mode
characteristics such as frequencies, linewidths, and mode heights. We study the
source of systematic errors in the mode linewidths and mode heights, and we
present a way to correct these errors with respect to a common reference fit.
Using the correction, we could explain all sources of systematic errors, which
could be reduced to less than $\pm$15% for mode linewidths and heights, and
less than $\pm$5% for amplitude, when compared to the reference fit. The effect
of a different estimated stellar background and a different estimated splitting
will provide frequency-dependent systematic errors that might affect the
comparison with theoretical mode linewidth and mode height, therefore affecting
the understanding of the physical nature of these parameters. All other sources
of relative systematic errors are less dependent upon frequency. We also
provide the dependence of the so-called linewidth dip, in the middle of the
observed frequency range, as a function of effective temperature. We show that
the depth of the dip decreases with increasing effective temperature. The
dependence of the dip on effective temperature may imply that the mixing length
parameter $\alpha$ or the convective flux may increase with effective
temperature.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1312.3943 [pdf] - 1202244
Kepler-91b: a planet at the end of its life. Planet and giant host star
properties via light-curve variations
Lillo-Box, J.;
Barrado, D.;
Moya, A.;
Montesinos, B.;
Montalbán, J.;
Bayo, A.;
Barbieri, M.;
Régulo, C.;
Mancini, L.;
Bouy, H.;
Henning, T.
Submitted: 2013-12-14
The evolution of planetary systems is intimately linked to the evolution of
their host star. Our understanding of the whole planetary evolution process is
based on the large planet diversity observed so far. To date, only few tens of
planets have been discovered orbiting stars ascending the Red Giant Branch.
Although several theories have been proposed, the question of how planets die
remains open due to the small number statistics. In this work we study the
giant star Kepler-91 (KOI-2133) in order to determine the nature of a
transiting companion. This system was detected by the Kepler Space Telescope.
However, its planetary confirmation is needed. We confirm the planetary nature
of the object transiting the star Kepler-91 by deriving a mass of $
M_p=0.88^{+0.17}_{-0.33} ~M_{\rm Jup}$ and a planetary radius of
$R_p=1.384^{+0.011}_{-0.054} ~R_{\rm Jup}$. Asteroseismic analysis produces a
stellar radius of $R_{\star}=6.30\pm 0.16 ~R_{\odot}$ and a mass of
$M_{\star}=1.31\pm 0.10 ~ M_{\odot} $. We find that its eccentric orbit
($e=0.066^{+0.013}_{-0.017}$) is just $1.32^{+0.07}_{-0.22} ~ R_{\star}$ away
from the stellar atmosphere at the pericenter. Kepler-91b could be the previous
stage of the planet engulfment, recently detected for BD+48 740. Our
estimations show that Kepler-91b will be swallowed by its host star in less
than 55 Myr. Among the confirmed planets around giant stars, this is the
planetary-mass body closest to its host star. At pericenter passage, the star
subtends an angle of $48^{\circ}$, covering around 10% of the sky as seen from
the planet. The planetary atmosphere seems to be inflated probably due to the
high stellar irradiation.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.2009 [pdf] - 1380630
Differential asteroseismic study of seismic twins observed by CoRoT;
Comparison of HD 175272 with HD 181420
Ozel, N.;
Mosser, B.;
Dupret, M. A.;
Bruntt, H.;
Barban, C.;
Deheuvels, S.;
García, R. A.;
Michel, E.;
Samadi, R.;
Baudin, F.;
Mathur, S.;
Régulo, C.;
Auvergne, M.;
Morel, P.;
Pichon, B.
Submitted: 2013-09-08
The CoRoT short asteroseismic runs give us the opportunity to observe a large
variety of late-type stars through their solar-like oscillations. We report the
observation and modeling of the F5V star HD 175272. Our aim is to define a
method for extracting as much information as possible from a noisy oscillation
spectrum. We followed a differential approach that consists of using a
well-known star as a reference to characterize another star. We used classical
tools such as the envelope autocorrelation function to derive the global
seismic parameters of the star. We compared HD 175272 with HD 181420 through a
linear approach, because they appear to be asteroseismic twins. The comparison
with the reference star enables us to substantially enhance the scientific
output for HD 175272. First, we determined its global characteristics through a
detailed seismic analysis of HD 181420. Second, with our differential approach,
we measured the difference of mass, radius and age between HD 175272 and HD
181420. We have developed a general method able to derive asteroseismic
constraints on a star even in case of low-quality data. %This method is based
on the comparison to a star with common seismic and classical properties.
Seismic data allow accurate measurements of radii and masses differences
between the two stars. This method can be applied to stars with interesting
properties but low signal-to-noise ratio oscillation spectrum, such as stars
hosting an exoplanet or members of a binary system.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1308.4352 [pdf] - 708554
Seismic constraints on rotation of Sun-like star and mass of exoplanet
Gizon, Laurent;
Ballot, Jérome;
Michel, Eric;
Stahn, Thorsten;
Vauclair, Gérard;
Bruntt, Hans;
Quirion, Pierre-Olivier;
Benomar, Othman;
Vauclair, Sylvie;
Appourchaux, Thierry;
Auvergne, Michel;
Baglin, Annie;
Barban, Caroline;
Baudin, Fréderic;
Bazot, Michaël;
Campante, Tiago;
Catala, Claude;
Chaplin, William;
Creevey, Orlagh;
Deheuvels, Sébastien;
Dolez, Noël;
Elsworth, Yvonne;
García, Rafael;
Gaulme, Patrick;
Mathis, Stéphane;
Mathur, Savita;
Mosser, Benoît;
Régulo, Clara;
Roxburgh, Ian;
Salabert, David;
Samadi, Réza;
Sato, Kumiko;
Verner, Graham;
Hanasoge, Shravan;
Sreenivasan, Katepalli R.
Submitted: 2013-08-20
Rotation is thought to drive cyclic magnetic activity in the Sun and Sun-like
stars. Stellar dynamos, however, are poorly understood owing to the scarcity of
observations of rotation and magnetic fields in stars. Here, inferences are
drawn on the internal rotation of a distant Sun-like star by studying its
global modes of oscillation. We report asteroseismic constraints imposed on the
rotation rate and the inclination of the spin axis of the Sun-like star HD
52265, a principal target observed by the CoRoT satellite that is known to host
a planetary companion. These seismic inferences are remarkably consistent with
an independent spectroscopic observation (rotational line broadening) and with
the observed rotation period of star spots. Furthermore, asteroseismology
constrains the mass of exoplanet HD 52265b. Under the standard assumption that
the stellar spin axis and the axis of the planetary orbit coincide, the minimum
spectroscopic mass of the planet can be converted into a true mass of 1.85
(+0.52,-0.42) M_Jupiter, which implies that it is a planet, not a brown dwarf.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.2765 [pdf] - 1124762
Calibrating Convective properties of Solar-like Stars in the Kepler
Field of View
Bonaca, Ana;
Tanner, Joel D.;
Basu, Sarbani;
Chaplin, William J.;
Metcalfe, Travis S.;
Monteiro, Mário J. P. F. G.;
Ballot, Jérôme;
Bedding, Timothy R.;
Bonanno, Alfio;
Broomhall, Anne-Marie;
Bruntt, Hans;
Campante, Tiago L.;
Christensen-Dalsgaard, Jørgen;
Corsaro, Enrico;
Elsworth, Yvonne;
García, Rafael A.;
Hekker, Saskia;
Karoff, Christoffer;
Kjeldsen, Hans;
Mathur, Savita;
Régulo, Clara;
Roxburgh, Ian;
Stello, Dennis;
Trampedach, Regner;
Barclay, Thomas;
Burke, Christopher J.;
Caldwell, Douglas A.
Submitted: 2012-07-11
Stellar models generally use simple parametrizations to treat convection. The
most widely used parametrization is the so-called "Mixing Length Theory" where
the convective eddy sizes are described using a single number, \alpha, the
mixing-length parameter. This is a free parameter, and the general practice is
to calibrate \alpha using the known properties of the Sun and apply that to all
stars. Using data from NASA's Kepler mission we show that using the
solar-calibrated \alpha is not always appropriate, and that in many cases it
would lead to estimates of initial helium abundances that are lower than the
primordial helium abundance. Kepler data allow us to calibrate \alpha for many
other stars and we show that for the sample of stars we have studied, the
mixing-length parameter is generally lower than the solar value. We studied the
correlation between \alpha and stellar properties, and we find that \alpha
increases with metallicity. We therefore conclude that results obtained by
fitting stellar models or by using population-synthesis models constructed with
solar values of \alpha are likely to have large systematic errors. Our results
also confirm theoretical expectations that the mixing-length parameter should
vary with stellar properties.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1204.3147 [pdf] - 1117978
Oscillation mode frequencies of 61 main sequence and subgiant stars
observed by Kepler
Appourchaux, T.;
Chaplin, W. J.;
Garcia, R. A.;
Gruberbauer, M.;
Verner, G. A.;
Antia, H. M.;
Benomar, O.;
Campante, T. L.;
Davies, G. R.;
Deheuvels, S.;
Handberg, R.;
Hekker, S.;
Howe, R.;
Régulo, C.;
Salabert, D.;
Bedding, T. R.;
White, T. R.;
Ballot, J.;
Mathur, S.;
Aguirre, V. Silva;
Elsworth, Y. P.;
Basu, S.;
Gilliland, R. L.;
Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.;
Kjeldsen, H.;
Uddin, K.;
Stumpe, M. C.;
Barclay, T.
Submitted: 2012-04-14, last modified: 2012-05-10
Solar-like oscillations have been observed by Kepler and CoRoT in several
solar-type stars, thereby providing a way to probe the stars using
asteroseismology.
We provide the mode frequencies of the oscillations of various stars required
to perform a comparison with those obtained from stellar modelling.
We used a time series of nine months of data for each star. The 61 stars
observed were categorised in three groups: simple, F-like and mixed-mode. The
simple group includes stars for which the identification of the mode degree is
obvious. The F-like group includes stars for which the identification of the
degree is ambiguous. The mixed-mode group includes evolved stars for which the
modes do not follow the asymptotic relation of low-degree frequencies.
Following this categorisation, the power spectra of the 61 main sequence and
subgiant stars were analysed using both maximum likelihood estimators and
Bayesian estimators, providing individual mode characteristics such as
frequencies, linewidths, and mode heights. We developed and describe a
methodology for extracting a single set of mode frequencies from multiple sets
derived by different methods and individual scientists. We report on how one
can assess the quality of the fitted parameters using the likelihood ratio test
and the posterior probabilities.
We provide the mode frequencies of 61 stars (with their 1-sigma error bars),
as well as their associated echelle diagrams.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1112.2165 [pdf] - 1092280
Kepler-21b: A 1.6REarth Planet Transiting the Bright Oscillating F
Subgiant Star HD 179070
Howell, Steve B.;
Rowe, Jason F.;
Bryson, Stephen T.;
Quinn, Samuel N.;
Marcy, Geoffrey W.;
Isaacson, Howard;
Ciardi, David R.;
Chaplin, William J.;
Metcalfe, Travis S.;
Monteiro, Mario J. P. F. G.;
Appourchaux, Thierry;
Basu, Sarbani;
Creevey, Orlagh L.;
Gilliland, Ronald L.;
Quirion, Pierre-Olivier;
Stello, Denis;
Kjeldsen, Hans;
Christensen-Dalsgaard, Jorgen;
Elsworth, Yvonne;
García, Rafael A.;
Houdek, Gunter;
Karoff, Christoffer;
Molenda-Żakowicz, Joanna;
Thompson, Michael J.;
Verner, Graham A.;
Torres, Guillermo;
Fressin, Francois;
Crepp, Justin R.;
Adams, Elisabeth;
Dupree, Andrea;
Sasselov, Dimitar D.;
Dressing, Courtney D.;
Borucki, William J.;
Koch, David G.;
Lissauer, Jack J.;
Latham, David W.;
Gautier, Thomas N.;
Everett, Mark;
Horch, Elliott;
Batalha, Natalie M.;
Dunham, Edward W.;
Szkody, Paula;
Silva, David R.;
Mighel, Ken;
Holberg, Jay;
Ballot, Jer^ome;
Bedding, Timothy R.;
Bruntt, Hans;
Campante, Tiago L.;
Handberg, Rasmus;
Hekker, Saskia;
Huber, Daniel;
Mathur, Savita;
Mosser, Benoit;
Régulo, Clara;
White, Timothy R.;
Christiansen, Jessie L.;
Middour, Christopher K.;
Haas, Michael R.;
Hall, Jennifer R.;
Jenkins, Jon M.;
McCaulif, Sean;
Fanelli, Michael N.;
Kulesa, Craig;
McCarthy, Don;
Henze, Christopher E.
Submitted: 2011-12-09
We present Kepler observations of the bright (V=8.3), oscillating star HD
179070. The observations show transit-like events which reveal that the star is
orbited every 2.8 days by a small, 1.6 R_Earth object. Seismic studies of HD
179070 using short cadence Kepler observations show that HD 179070 has a
frequencypower spectrum consistent with solar-like oscillations that are
acoustic p-modes. Asteroseismic analysis provides robust values for the mass
and radius of HD 179070, 1.34{\pm}0.06 M{\circ} and 1.86{\pm}0.04 R{\circ}
respectively, as well as yielding an age of 2.84{\pm}0.34 Gyr for this F5
subgiant. Together with ground-based follow-up observations, analysis of the
Kepler light curves and image data, and blend scenario models, we
conservatively show at the >99.7% confidence level (3{\sigma}) that the transit
event is caused by a 1.64{\pm}0.04 R_Earth exoplanet in a 2.785755{\pm}0.000032
day orbit. The exoplanet is only 0.04 AU away from the star and our
spectroscopic observations provide an upper limit to its mass of ~10 M_Earth
(2-{\sigma}). HD 179070 is the brightest exoplanet host star yet discovered by
Kepler.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.4615 [pdf] - 442333
Fundamental properties of five Kepler stars using global asteroseismic
quantities and ground-based observations
Creevey, O. L.;
Dogan, G.;
Frasca, A.;
Thygesen, A. O.;
Basu, S.;
Bhattacharya, J.;
Biazzo, K.;
Brandão, I. M.;
Bruntt, H.;
Mazumdar, A.;
Niemczura, E.;
Shrotriya, T.;
Sousa, S. G.;
Stello, D.;
Subramaniam, A.;
Campante, T. L.;
Handberg, R.;
Mathur, S.;
Bedding, T. R.;
García, R. A.;
Régulo, C.;
Salabert, D.;
Molenda-Żakowicz, J.;
Quirion, P. -O.;
White, T. R.;
Bonanno, A.;
Chaplin, W. J.;
Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.;
Christiansen, J. L.;
Elsworth, Y.;
Fanelli, M. N.;
Karoff, C.;
Kinemuchi, K.;
Kjeldsen, H.;
Gai, N.;
Monteiro, M. J. P. F. G.;
Suárez, J. C.
Submitted: 2011-11-20
We present an asteroseismic study of the solar-like stars KIC 11395018, KIC
10273246, KIC 10920273, KIC 10339342, and KIC 11234888 using short-cadence time
series of more than eight months from the Kepler satellite. For four of these
stars, we derive atmospheric parameters from spectra acquired with the Nordic
Optical Telescope. The global seismic quantities (average large frequency
separation and frequency of maximum power), combined with the atmospheric
parameters, yield the mean density and surface gravity with precisions of 2%
and ~0.03 dex, respectively. We also determine the radius, mass, and age with
precisions of 2-5%, 7-11%, and ~35%, respectively, using grid-based analyses.
We determine asteroseismic distances to these stars with a precision better
than 10%, and constrain the stellar inclination for three of the stars. An Li
abundance analysis yields an independent estimate of the age, but this is
inconsistent with the asteroseismically determined age for one of the stars. We
compare the results from five different grid-based analyses, and we find that
they all provide radius and mass values to within 2.4sigma. The absence of a
metallicity constraint when the average large frequency separation is measured
with a precision of 1% biases the fitted radius and mass for the stars with
non-solar metallicity (metal-rich KIC 11395018 and metal-poor KIC 10273246),
while including a metallicity constraint reduces the uncertainties in both of
these parameters by almost a factor of two. We found that including the average
small frequency separation improves the determination of the age only for KIC
11395018 and KIC 11234888, and for the latter this improvement was due to the
lack of strong atmospheric constraints. (Abridged).
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1110.2384 [pdf] - 1084788
Planetary transit candidates in the CoRoT LRa01 field
Carone, L.;
Gandolfi, D.;
Cabrera, J.;
Hatzes, A. P.;
Deeg, H. J.;
Csizmadia, Sz.;
Paetzold, M.;
Weingrill, J.;
Aigrain, S.;
Alonso, R.;
Alapini, A.;
Almenara, J. -M.;
Auvergne, M.;
Baglin, A.;
Barge, P.;
Bonomo, A. S.;
Bordé, P.;
Bouchy, F.;
Bruntt, H.;
Carpano, S.;
Cochran, W. D.;
Deleuil, M.;
Díaz, R. F.;
Dreizler, S.;
Dvorak, R.;
Eisloeffel, J.;
Eigmueller, P.;
Endl, M.;
Erikson, A.;
Ferraz-Mello, S.;
Fridlund, M.;
Gazzano, J. -C.;
Gibson, N.;
Gillon, M.;
Gondoin, P.;
Grziwa, S.;
Guenther, E. W.;
Guillot, T.;
Hartmann, M.;
Havel, M.;
Hébrard, G.;
Jorda, L.;
Kabath, P.;
Léger, A.;
Llebaria, A.;
Lammer, H.;
Lovis, C.;
MacQueen, P. J.;
Mayor, M.;
Mazeh, T.;
Moutou, C.;
Nortmann, L.;
Ofir, A.;
Ollivier, M.;
Parviainen, H.;
Pepe, F.;
Pont, F.;
Queloz, D.;
Rabus, M.;
Rauer, H.;
Régulo, C.;
Renner, S.;
de la Reza, R.;
Rouan, D.;
Santerne, A.;
Samuel, B.;
Schneider, J.;
Shporer, A.;
Stecklum, B.;
Tal-Or, L.;
Tingley, B.;
Udry, S.;
Wuchterl, G.
Submitted: 2011-10-11
Context: CoRoT is a pioneering space mission whose primary goals are stellar
seismology and extrasolar planets search. Its surveys of large stellar fields
generate numerous planetary candidates whose lightcurves have transit-like
features. An extensive analytical and observational follow-up effort is
undertaken to classify these candidates. Aims: The list of planetary transit
candidates from the CoRoT LRa01 star field in the Monoceros constellation
towards the Galactic anti-center is presented. The CoRoT observations of LRa01
lasted from 24 October 2007 to 3 March 2008. Methods: 7470 chromatic and 3938
monochromatic lightcurves were acquired and analysed. Instrumental noise and
stellar variability were treated with several filtering tools by different
teams from the CoRoT community. Different transit search algorithms were
applied to the lightcurves. Results: Fifty-one stars were classified as
planetary transit candidates in LRa01. Thirty-seven (i.e., 73 % of all
candidates) are "good" planetary candidates based on photometric analysis only.
Thirty-two (i.e., 87 % of the "good" candidates) have been followed-up. At the
time of this writing twenty-two cases have been solved and five planets have
been discovered: three transiting hot-Jupiters (CoRoT-5b, CoRoT-12b, and
CoRoT-21b), the first terrestrial transiting planet (CoRoT-7b), and another
planet in the same system (CoRoT-7c, detected by radial velocity survey only).
Evidences of another non-transiting planet in the CoRoT-7 system, namely
CoRoT-7d, have been recently found.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1110.1375 [pdf] - 1084696
Asteroseismic diagrams from a survey of solar-like oscillations with
Kepler
White, Timothy R.;
Bedding, Timothy R.;
Stello, Dennis;
Appourchaux, Thierry;
Ballot, Jérôme;
Benomar, Othman;
Bonanno, Alfio;
Broomhall, Anne-Marie;
Campante, Tiago L.;
Chaplin, William J.;
Christensen-Dalsgaard, Jørgen;
Corsaro, Enrico;
Doğan, Gülnur;
Elsworth, Yvonne P.;
Fletcher, Stephen T.;
García, Rafael A.;
Gaulme, Patrick;
Handberg, Rasmus;
Hekker, Saskia;
Huber, Daniel;
Karoff, Christoffer;
Kjeldsen, Hans;
Mathur, Savita;
Mosser, Benoit;
Monteiro, Mario J. P. F. G.;
Régulo, Clara;
Salabert, David;
Aguirre, Victor Silva;
Thompson, Michael J.;
Verner, Graham;
Morris, Robert L.;
Sanderfer, Dwight T.;
Seader, Shawn E.
Submitted: 2011-10-06
Photometric observations made by the NASA Kepler Mission have led to a
dramatic increase in the number of main-sequence and subgiant stars with
detected solar-like oscillations. We present an ensemble asteroseismic analysis
of 76 solar-type stars. Using frequencies determined from the Kepler
time-series photometry, we have measured three asteroseismic parameters that
characterize the oscillations: the large frequency separation (\Delta \nu), the
small frequency separation between modes of l=0 and l=2 (\delta \nu_02), and
the dimensionless offset (\epsilon). These measurements allow us to construct
asteroseismic diagrams, namely the so-called C-D diagram of \delta \nu_02
versus \Delta \nu, and the recently re-introduced {\epsilon} diagram. We
compare the Kepler results with previously observed solar-type stars and with
theoretical models. The positions of stars in these diagrams places constraints
on their masses and ages. Additionally, we confirm the observational
relationship between {\epsilon} and T_eff that allows for the unambiguous
determination of radial order and should help resolve the problem of mode
identification in F stars.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1109.4723 [pdf] - 415276
Ensemble Asteroseismology of Solar-Type Stars with the NASA Kepler
Mission
Chaplin, W. J.;
Kjeldsen, H.;
Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.;
Basu, S.;
Miglio, A.;
Appourchaux, T.;
Bedding, T. R.;
Elsworth, Y.;
García, R. A.;
Gilliland, R. L.;
Girardi, L.;
Houdek, G.;
Karoff, C.;
Kawaler, S. D.;
Metcalfe, T. S.;
Molenda-Zakowicz, J.;
Monteiro, M. J. P. F. G.;
Thompson, M. J.;
Verner, G. A.;
Ballot, J.;
Bonanno, A.;
Brandao, I. M.;
Broomhall, A. -M.;
Bruntt, H.;
Campante, T. L.;
Corsaro, E.;
Creevey, O. L.;
Dogan, G.;
Esch, L.;
Gai, N.;
Gaulme, P.;
Hale, S. J.;
Handberg, R.;
Hekker, S.;
Huber, D.;
Jiménez, A.;
Mathur, S.;
Mazumdar, A.;
Mosser, B.;
New, R.;
Pinsonneault, M. H.;
Pricopi, D.;
Quirion, P. -O.;
Régulo, C.;
Salabert, D.;
Serenelli, A. M.;
Aguirre, V. Silva;
Sousa, S. G.;
Stello, D.;
Stevens, I. R.;
Suran, M. D.;
Uytterhoeven, K.;
White, T. R.;
Borucki, W. J.;
Brown, T. M.;
Jenkins, J. M.;
Kinemuchi, K.;
Van Cleve, J.;
Klaus, T. C.
Submitted: 2011-09-22
In addition to its search for extra-solar planets, the NASA Kepler Mission
provides exquisite data on stellar oscillations. We report the detections of
oscillations in 500 solartype stars in the Kepler field of view, an ensemble
that is large enough to allow statistical studies of intrinsic stellar
properties (such as mass, radius and age) and to test theories of stellar
evolution. We find that the distribution of observed masses of these stars
shows intriguing differences to predictions from models of synthetic stellar
populations in the Galaxy.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1109.0869 [pdf] - 406468
Verification of the Kepler Input Catalog from Asteroseismology of
Solar-type Stars
Verner, G. A.;
Chaplin, W. J.;
Basu, S.;
Brown, T. M.;
Hekker, S.;
Huber, D.;
Karoff, C.;
Mathur, S.;
Metcalfe, T. S.;
Mosser, B.;
Quirion, P. -O.;
Appourchaux, T.;
Bedding, T. R.;
Bruntt, H.;
Campante, T. L.;
Elsworth, Y.;
García, R. A.;
Handberg, R.;
Régulo, C.;
Roxburgh, I. W.;
Stello, D.;
Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.;
Gilliland, R. L.;
Kawaler, S. D.;
Kjeldsen, H.;
Allen, C.;
Clarke, B. D.;
Girouard, F. R.
Submitted: 2011-09-05
We calculate precise stellar radii and surface gravities from the
asteroseismic analysis of over 500 solar-type pulsating stars observed by the
Kepler space telescope. These physical stellar properties are compared with
those given in the Kepler Input Catalog (KIC), determined from ground-based
multi-color photometry. For the stars in our sample, we find general agreement
but we detect an average overestimation bias of 0.23 dex in the KIC
determination of log (g) for stars with log (g)_KIC > 4.0 dex, and a resultant
underestimation bias of up to 50% in the KIC radii estimates for stars with
R_KIC < 2 R sun. Part of the difference may arise from selection bias in the
asteroseismic sample; nevertheless, this result implies there may be fewer
stars characterized in the KIC with R ~ 1 R sun than is suggested by the
physical properties in the KIC. Furthermore, if the radius estimates are taken
from the KIC for these affected stars and then used to calculate the size of
transiting planets, a similar underestimation bias may be applied to the
planetary radii.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1108.3807 [pdf] - 400010
Asteroseismology from multi-month Kepler photometry: the evolved
Sun-like stars KIC 10273246 and KIC 10920273
Campante, T. L.;
Handberg, R.;
Mathur, S.;
Appourchaux, T.;
Bedding, T. R.;
Chaplin, W. J.;
García, R. A.;
Mosser, B.;
Benomar, O.;
Bonanno, A.;
Corsaro, E.;
Fletcher, S. T.;
Gaulme, P.;
Hekker, S.;
Karoff, C.;
Régulo, C.;
Salabert, D.;
Verner, G. A.;
White, T. R.;
Houdek, G.;
Brandão, I. M.;
Creevey, O. L.;
Doğan, G.;
Bazot, M.;
Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.;
Cunha, M. S.;
Elsworth, Y.;
Huber, D.;
Kjeldsen, H.;
Lundkvist, M.;
Molenda-Żakowicz, J.;
Monteiro, M. J. P. F. G.;
Stello, D.;
Clarke, B. D.;
Girouard, F. R.;
Hall, J. R.
Submitted: 2011-08-18
The evolved main-sequence Sun-like stars KIC 10273246 (F-type) and KIC
10920273 (G-type) were observed with the NASA Kepler satellite for
approximately ten months with a duty cycle in excess of 90%. Such continuous
and long observations are unprecedented for solar-type stars other than the
Sun.
We aimed mainly at extracting estimates of p-mode frequencies - as well as of
other individual mode parameters - from the power spectra of the light curves
of both stars, thus providing scope for a full seismic characterization.
The light curves were corrected for instrumental effects in a manner
independent of the Kepler Science Pipeline. Estimation of individual mode
parameters was based both on the maximization of the likelihood of a model
describing the power spectrum and on a classic prewhitening method. Finally, we
employed a procedure for selecting frequency lists to be used in stellar
modeling.
A total of 30 and 21 modes of degree l=0,1,2 - spanning at least eight radial
orders - have been identified for KIC 10273246 and KIC 10920273, respectively.
Two avoided crossings (l=1 ridge) have been identified for KIC 10273246,
whereas one avoided crossing plus another likely one have been identified for
KIC 10920273. Good agreement is found between observed and predicted mode
amplitudes for the F-type star KIC 10273246, based on a revised scaling
relation. Estimates are given of the rotational periods, the parameters
describing stellar granulation and the global asteroseismic parameters
$\Delta\nu$ and $\nu_{\rm{max}}$.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1105.3551 [pdf] - 360975
Accurate p-mode measurements of the G0V metal-rich CoRoT target HD 52265
Ballot, J.;
Gizon, L.;
Samadi, R.;
Vauclair, G.;
Benomar, O.;
Bruntt, H.;
Mosser, B.;
Stahn, T.;
Verner, G. A.;
Campante, T. L.;
García, R. A.;
Mathur, S.;
Salabert, D.;
Gaulme, P.;
Régulo, C.;
Roxburgh, I. W.;
Appourchaux, T.;
Baudin, F.;
Catala, C.;
Chaplin, W. J.;
Deheuvels, S.;
Michel, E.;
Bazot, M.;
Creevey, O.;
Dolez, N.;
Elsworth, Y.;
Sato, K. H.;
Vauclair, S.;
Auvergne, M.;
Baglin, A.
Submitted: 2011-05-18
The star HD 52265 is a G0V metal-rich exoplanet-host star observed in the
seismology field of the CoRoT space telescope from November 2008 to March 2009.
The satellite collected 117 days of high-precision photometric data on this
star, showing that it presents solar-like oscillations. HD 52265 was also
observed in spectroscopy with the Narval spectrograph at the same epoch. We
characterise HD 52265 using both spectroscopic and seismic data. The
fundamental stellar parameters of HD 52265 were derived with the semi-automatic
software VWA, and the projected rotational velocity was estimated by fitting
synthetic profiles to isolated lines in the observed spectrum. The parameters
of the observed p modes were determined with a maximum-likelihood estimation.
We performed a global fit of the oscillation spectrum, over about ten radial
orders, for degrees l=0 to 2. We also derived the properties of the
granulation, and analysed a signature of the rotation induced by the
photospheric magnetic activity. Precise determinations of fundamental
parameters have been obtained: Teff = 6100 +- 60 K, log g = 4.35 +- 0.09, [M/H]
= 0.19 +- 0.05, as well as vsini = 3.6 +0.3 -1.0 km/s. We have measured a mean
rotation period P_rot = 12.3 +- 0.15 days, and find a signature of differential
rotation. The frequencies of 31 modes are reported in the range 1500-2550
micro-Hz. The large separation exhibits a clear modulation around the mean
value <Dnu> = 98.3 +- 0.1 micro-Hz. Mode widths vary with frequency along an
S-shape with a clear local maximum around 1800 micro-Hz. We deduce lifetimes
ranging between 0.5 and 3 days for these modes. Finally, we find a maximal
bolometric amplitude of about 3.96 +- 0.24 ppm for radial modes.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1105.0571 [pdf] - 406366
Global asteroseismic properties of solar-like oscillations observed by
Kepler : A comparison of complementary analysis methods
Verner, G. A.;
Elsworth, Y.;
Chaplin, W. J.;
Campante, T. L.;
Corsaro, E.;
Gaulme, P.;
Hekker, S.;
Huber, D.;
Karoff, C.;
Mathur, S.;
Mosser, B.;
Appourchaux, T.;
Ballot, J.;
Bedding, T. R.;
Bonanno, A.;
Broomhall, A-M.;
García, R. A.;
Handberg, R.;
New, R.;
Stello, D.;
Régulo, C.;
Roxburgh, I. W.;
Salabert, D.;
White, T. R.;
Caldwell, D. A.;
Christiansen, J. L.;
Fanelli, M. N.
Submitted: 2011-05-03
We present the asteroseismic analysis of 1948 F-, G- and K-type main-sequence
and subgiant stars observed by the NASA {\em Kepler Mission}. We detect and
characterise solar-like oscillations in 642 of these stars. This represents the
largest cohort of main-sequence and subgiant solar-like oscillators observed to
date. The photometric observations are analysed using the methods developed by
nine independent research teams. The results are combined to validate the
determined global asteroseismic parameters and calculate the relative precision
by which the parameters can be obtained. We correlate the relative number of
detected solar-like oscillators with stellar parameters from the {\em Kepler
Input Catalog} and find a deficiency for stars with effective temperatures in
the range $5300 \lesssim T_\mathrm{eff} \lesssim 5700$\,K and a drop-off in
detected oscillations in stars approaching the red edge of the classical
instability strip. We compare the power-law relationships between the frequency
of peak power, $\nu_\mathrm{max}$, the mean large frequency separation,
$\Delta\nu$, and the maximum mode amplitude, $A_\mathrm{max}$, and show that
there are significant method-dependent differences in the results obtained.
This illustrates the need for multiple complementary analysis methods to be
used to assess the robustness and reproducibility of results derived from
global asteroseismic parameters.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1011.2690 [pdf] - 261254
Possible detection of phase changes from the non-transiting planet HD
46375b by CoRoT
Gaulme, P.;
Vannier, M.;
Guillot, T.;
Mosser, B.;
Mary, D.;
Weiss, W. W.;
Schmider, F. -X.;
Bourguignon, S.;
Deeg, H. J.;
Régulo, C.;
Aigrain, S.;
Schneider, J.;
Bruntt, H.;
Deheuvels, S.;
Donati, J. -F.;
Appourchaux, T.;
Auvergne, M.;
Baglin, A.;
Baudin, F.;
Catala, C.;
Michel, E.;
Samadi, R.
Submitted: 2010-11-11
The present work deals with the detection of phase changes in an exoplanetary
system. HD 46375 is a solar analog known to host a non-transiting Saturn-mass
exoplanet with a 3.0236 day period. It was observed by the CoRoT satellite for
34 days during the fall of 2008. We attempt to identify at optical wavelengths,
the changing phases of the planet as it orbits its star. We then try to improve
the star model by means of a seismic analysis of the same light curve and the
use of ground-based spectropolarimetric observations. The data analysis relies
on the Fourier spectrum and the folding of the time series. We find evidence of
a sinusoidal signal compatible in terms of both amplitude and phase with light
reflected by the planet. Its relative amplitude is Delta Fp/F* = [13.0, 26.8]
ppm, implying an albedo A=[0.16, 0.33] or a dayside visible brightness
temperature Tb ~ [1880,2030] K by assuming a radius R=1.1 R_Jup and an
inclination i=45 deg. Its orbital phase differs from that of the
radial-velocity signal by at most 2 sigma_RV. However, the tiny planetary
signal is strongly blended by another signal, which we attribute to a telluric
signal with a 1 day period. We show that this signal is suppressed, but not
eliminated, when using the time series for HD 46179 from the same CoRoT run as
a reference. This detection of reflected light from a non-transiting planet
should be confirmable with a longer CoRoT observation of the same field. In any
case, it demonstrates that non-transiting planets can be characterized using
ultra-precise photometric lightcurves with present-day observations by CoRoT
and Kepler. The combined detection of solar-type oscillations on the same
targets (Gaulme et al. 2010a) highlights the overlap between exoplanetary
science and asteroseismology and shows the high potential of a mission such as
Plato.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:0910.3060 [pdf] - 1017973
A fresh look at the seismic spectrum of HD49933: analysis of 180 days of
CoRoT photometry
Benomar, O.;
Baudin, F.;
Campante, T. L.;
Chaplin, W. J.;
García, R. A.;
Gaulme, P.;
Toutain, T.;
Verner, G. A.;
Appourchaux, T.;
Ballot, J.;
Barban, C.;
Elsworth, Y.;
Mathur, S.;
Mosser, B.;
Régulo, C.;
Roxburgh, I. W.;
Auvergne, M.;
Baglin, A.;
Catala, C.;
Michel, E.;
Samadi, R.
Submitted: 2009-10-16, last modified: 2009-10-19
Solar-like oscillations have now been observed in several stars, thanks to
ground-based spectroscopic observations and space-borne photometry. CoRoT,
which has been in orbit since December 2006, has observed the star HD49933
twice. The oscillation spectrum of this star has proven difficult to interpret.
Thanks to a new timeseries provided by CoRoT, we aim to provide a robust
description of the oscillations in HD49933, i.e., to identify the degrees of
the observed modes, and to measure mode frequencies, widths, amplitudes and the
average rotational splitting. Several methods were used to model the Fourier
spectrum: Maximum Likelihood Estimators and Bayesian analysis using Markov
Chain Monte-Carlo techniques. The different methods yield consistent result,
and allow us to make a robust identification of the modes and to extract
precise mode parameters. Only the rotational splitting remains difficult to
estimate precisely, but is clearly relatively large (several microHz in size).
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:0907.5150 [pdf] - 1003171
Planetary transit candidates in COROT-IRa01 field
Carpano, S.;
Cabrera, J.;
Alonso, R.;
Barge, P.;
Aigrain, S.;
Almenara, J. -M.;
Bordé, P.;
Bouchy, F.;
Carone, L.;
Deeg, H. J.;
De la Reza, R.;
Deleuil, M.;
Dvorak, R.;
Erikson, A.;
Fressin, F.;
Fridlund, M.;
Gondoin, P.;
Guillot, T.;
Hatzes, A.;
Jorda, L.;
Lammer, H.;
Léger, A.;
Llebaria, A.;
Magain, P.;
Moutou, C.;
Ofir, A.;
Ollivier, M.;
Pacheco, E. J.;
Pátzold, M.;
Pont, F.;
Queloz, D.;
Rauer, H.;
Régulo, C.;
Renner, S.;
Rouan, D.;
Samuel, B.;
Schneider, J.;
Wuchterl, G.
Submitted: 2009-07-29
Context: CoRoT is a pioneering space mission devoted to the analysis of
stellar variability and the photometric detection of extrasolar planets.
Aims: We present the list of planetary transit candidates detected in the
first field observed by CoRoT, IRa01, the initial run toward the Galactic
anticenter, which lasted for 60 days.
Methods: We analysed 3898 sources in the coloured bands and 5974 in the
monochromatic band. Instrumental noise and stellar variability were taken into
account using detrending tools before applying various transit search
algorithms.
Results: Fifty sources were classified as planetary transit candidates and
the most reliable 40 detections were declared targets for follow-up
ground-based observations. Two of these targets have so far been confirmed as
planets, COROT-1b and COROT-4b, for which a complete characterization and
specific studies were performed.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:0906.0766 [pdf] - 24912
Radius determination of solar-type stars using asteroseismology: What to
expect from the Kepler mission
Stello, D.;
Chaplin, W. J.;
Bruntt, H.;
Creevey, O. L.;
García-Hernández, A.;
Monteiro, M. J. P. F. G.;
Moya, A.;
Quirion, P. -O.;
Sousa, S. G.;
Suárez, J. -C.;
Appourchaux, T.;
Arentoft, T.;
Ballot, J.;
Bedding, T. R.;
Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.;
Elsworth, Y.;
Fletcher, S. T.;
García, R. A.;
Houdek, Günter;
Jiménez-Reyes, S. J.;
Kjeldsen, H.;
New, R.;
Régulo, C.;
Salabert, D.;
Toutain, T.
Submitted: 2009-06-03
For distant stars, as observed by the NASA Kepler satellite, parallax
information is currently of fairly low quality and is not complete. This limits
the precision with which the absolute sizes of the stars and their potential
transiting planets can be determined by traditional methods. Asteroseismology
will be used to aid the radius determination of stars observed during NASA's
Kepler mission. We report on the recent asteroFLAG hare-and-hounds Exercise#2,
where a group of `hares' simulated data of F-K main-sequence stars that a group
of `hounds' sought to analyze, aimed at determining the stellar radii. Based on
the asteroseismic large frequency spacing, obtained from simulations of 4-year
time series data from the Kepler mission, we demonstrate that the stellar radii
can be correctly and precisely determined, when combined with traditional
stellar parameters from the Kepler Input Catalogue. The radii found by the
various methods used by each independent hound generally agree with the true
values of the artificial stars to within 3%, when the large frequency spacing
is used. This is 5--10 times better than the results where seismology is not
applied. These results give strong confidence that radius estimation can be
performed to better than 3% for solar-like stars using automatic pipeline
reduction. Even when the stellar distance and luminosity are unknown we can
obtain the same level of agreement.