Normalized to: Pedersen, K.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.04650 [pdf] - 1563387
Big Universe, Big Data: Machine Learning and Image Analysis for
Astronomy
Submitted: 2017-04-15
Astrophysics and cosmology are rich with data. The advent of wide-area
digital cameras on large aperture telescopes has led to ever more ambitious
surveys of the sky. Data volumes of entire surveys a decade ago can now be
acquired in a single night and real-time analysis is often desired. Thus,
modern astronomy requires big data know-how, in particular it demands highly
efficient machine learning and image analysis algorithms. But scalability is
not the only challenge: Astronomy applications touch several current machine
learning research questions, such as learning from biased data and dealing with
label and measurement noise. We argue that this makes astronomy a great domain
for computer science research, as it pushes the boundaries of data analysis. In
the following, we will present this exciting application area for data
scientists. We will focus on exemplary results, discuss main challenges, and
highlight some recent methodological advancements in machine learning and image
analysis triggered by astronomical applications.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.05424 [pdf] - 1550268
Sacrificing information for the greater good: how to select photometric
bands for optimal accuracy
Submitted: 2015-11-17, last modified: 2016-07-06
Large-scale surveys make huge amounts of photometric data available. Because
of the sheer amount of objects, spectral data cannot be obtained for all of
them. Therefore it is important to devise techniques for reliably estimating
physical properties of objects from photometric information alone. These
estimates are needed to automatically identify interesting objects worth a
follow-up investigation as well as to produce the required data for a
statistical analysis of the space covered by a survey. We argue that machine
learning techniques are suitable to compute these estimates accurately and
efficiently. This study promotes a feature selection algorithm, which selects
the most informative magnitudes and colours for a given task of estimating
physical quantities from photometric data alone. Using k nearest neighbours
regression, a well-known non-parametric machine learning method, we show that
using the found features significantly increases the accuracy of the
estimations compared to using standard features and standard methods. We
illustrate the usefulness of the approach by estimating specific star formation
rates (sSFRs) and redshifts (photo-z's) using only the broad-band photometry
from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS). For estimating sSFRs, we demonstrate
that our method produces better estimates than traditional spectral energy
distribution (SED) fitting. For estimating photo-z's, we show that our method
produces more accurate photo-z's than the method employed by SDSS. The study
highlights the general importance of performing proper model selection to
improve the results of machine learning systems and how feature selection can
provide insights into the predictive relevance of particular input features.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1403.2722 [pdf] - 1208318
NuSTAR Observations of the Bullet Cluster: Constraints on Inverse
Compton Emission
Wik, Daniel R.;
Hornstrup, Allan;
Molendi, Silvano;
Madejski, Grzegorz;
Harrison, Fiona A.;
Zoglauer, Andreas;
Grefenstette, Brian W.;
Gastaldello, Fabio;
Madsen, Kristin K.;
Westergaard, Niels J.;
Ferreira, Desiree D. M.;
Kitaguchi, Takao;
Pedersen, Kristian;
Boggs, Steven E.;
Christensen, Finn E.;
Craig, William W.;
Hailey, Charles J.;
Stern, Daniel;
Zhang, William W.
Submitted: 2014-03-11
The search for diffuse non-thermal inverse Compton (IC) emission from galaxy
clusters at hard X-ray energies has been undertaken with many instruments, with
most detections being either of low significance or controversial. Background
and contamination uncertainties present in the data of non-focusing
observatories result in lower sensitivity to IC emission and a greater chance
of false detection. We present 266ks NuSTAR observations of the Bullet cluster,
detected from 3-30 keV. NuSTAR's unprecedented hard X-ray focusing capability
largely eliminates confusion between diffuse IC and point sources; however, at
the highest energies the background still dominates and must be well
understood. To this end, we have developed a complete background model
constructed of physically inspired components constrained by extragalactic
survey field observations, the specific parameters of which are derived locally
from data in non-source regions of target observations. Applying the background
model to the Bullet cluster data, we find that the spectrum is well - but not
perfectly - described as an isothermal plasma with kT=14.2+/-0.2 keV. To
slightly improve the fit, a second temperature component is added, which
appears to account for lower temperature emission from the cool core, pushing
the primary component to kT~15.3 keV. We see no convincing need to invoke an IC
component to describe the spectrum of the Bullet cluster, and instead argue
that it is dominated at all energies by emission from purely thermal gas. The
conservatively derived 90% upper limit on the IC flux of 1.1e-12 erg/s/cm^2
(50-100 keV), implying a lower limit on B>0.2{\mu}G, is barely consistent with
detected fluxes previously reported. In addition to discussing the possible
origin of this discrepancy, we remark on the potential implications of this
analysis for the prospects for detecting IC in galaxy clusters in the future.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1208.4598 [pdf] - 566668
Spatial Anisotropy of Galaxy Kinematics in Sloan Digital Sky Survey
Galaxy Clusters
Submitted: 2012-08-22, last modified: 2012-09-24
Measurements of galaxy cluster kinematics are important in understanding the
dynamical state and evolution of clusters of galaxies, as well as constraining
cosmological models. While it is well established that clusters exhibit
non-spherical geometries, evident in the distribution of galaxies on the sky,
azimuthal variations of galaxy kinematics within clusters have yet to be
observed. Here we measure the azimuthal dependence of the line-of-sight
velocity dispersion profile in a stacked sample of 1743 galaxy clusters from
the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS). The clusters are drawn from the SDSS DR8
redMaPPer catalog. We find that the line-of-sight velocity dispersion of
galaxies lying along the major axis of the central galaxy is larger than those
that lie along the minor axis. This is the first observational detection of
anisotropic kinematics of galaxies in clusters. We show that the result is
consistent with predictions from numerical simulations. Furthermore we find
that the degree of projected anisotropy is strongly dependent on the
line-of-sight orientation of the galaxy cluster, opening new possibilities for
assessing systematics in optical cluster finding.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1201.3636 [pdf] - 465849
Mass Reconstruction using Particle Based Lensing II: Quantifying
substructure with Strong+Weak lensing and X-rays
Submitted: 2012-01-17
We report a mass reconstruction of A1689 using Particle Based Lensing (PBL),
a new technique for Strong+Weak lensing that allows a variable resolution
depending on the data density and the signal-to-noise. Using PBL we also
calculate the covariance matrix for the resulting mass map. The reconstruction
of A1689 shows a secondary mass peak in the north-east direction confirming
previous optical observations. This indicates that the central region of the
cluster is still undergoing a weak merger. We have used this mass map to
measure power ratios of the dark matter distribution and compared it to the
X-ray distribution. We find that the power in the X-ray distribution is lower
suggesting a smoother and rounder gas distribution compared to the dark matter
distribution. We fitted an NFW profile to the profile derived from the mass map
and we find that the lensing mass within 1 Mpc is $1.5\pm0.33\times
10^{15}M_\odot$. This is higher than the X-ray mass.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1110.3193 [pdf] - 429544
Euclid Definition Study Report
Laureijs, R.;
Amiaux, J.;
Arduini, S.;
Auguères, J. -L.;
Brinchmann, J.;
Cole, R.;
Cropper, M.;
Dabin, C.;
Duvet, L.;
Ealet, A.;
Garilli, B.;
Gondoin, P.;
Guzzo, L.;
Hoar, J.;
Hoekstra, H.;
Holmes, R.;
Kitching, T.;
Maciaszek, T.;
Mellier, Y.;
Pasian, F.;
Percival, W.;
Rhodes, J.;
Criado, G. Saavedra;
Sauvage, M.;
Scaramella, R.;
Valenziano, L.;
Warren, S.;
Bender, R.;
Castander, F.;
Cimatti, A.;
Fèvre, O. Le;
Kurki-Suonio, H.;
Levi, M.;
Lilje, P.;
Meylan, G.;
Nichol, R.;
Pedersen, K.;
Popa, V.;
Lopez, R. Rebolo;
Rix, H. -W.;
Rottgering, H.;
Zeilinger, W.;
Grupp, F.;
Hudelot, P.;
Massey, R.;
Meneghetti, M.;
Miller, L.;
Paltani, S.;
Paulin-Henriksson, S.;
Pires, S.;
Saxton, C.;
Schrabback, T.;
Seidel, G.;
Walsh, J.;
Aghanim, N.;
Amendola, L.;
Bartlett, J.;
Baccigalupi, C.;
Beaulieu, J. -P.;
Benabed, K.;
Cuby, J. -G.;
Elbaz, D.;
Fosalba, P.;
Gavazzi, G.;
Helmi, A.;
Hook, I.;
Irwin, M.;
Kneib, J. -P.;
Kunz, M.;
Mannucci, F.;
Moscardini, L.;
Tao, C.;
Teyssier, R.;
Weller, J.;
Zamorani, G.;
Osorio, M. R. Zapatero;
Boulade, O.;
Foumond, J. J.;
Di Giorgio, A.;
Guttridge, P.;
James, A.;
Kemp, M.;
Martignac, J.;
Spencer, A.;
Walton, D.;
Blümchen, T.;
Bonoli, C.;
Bortoletto, F.;
Cerna, C.;
Corcione, L.;
Fabron, C.;
Jahnke, K.;
Ligori, S.;
Madrid, F.;
Martin, L.;
Morgante, G.;
Pamplona, T.;
Prieto, E.;
Riva, M.;
Toledo, R.;
Trifoglio, M.;
Zerbi, F.;
Abdalla, F.;
Douspis, M.;
Grenet, C.;
Borgani, S.;
Bouwens, R.;
Courbin, F.;
Delouis, J. -M.;
Dubath, P.;
Fontana, A.;
Frailis, M.;
Grazian, A.;
Koppenhöfer, J.;
Mansutti, O.;
Melchior, M.;
Mignoli, M.;
Mohr, J.;
Neissner, C.;
Noddle, K.;
Poncet, M.;
Scodeggio, M.;
Serrano, S.;
Shane, N.;
Starck, J. -L.;
Surace, C.;
Taylor, A.;
Verdoes-Kleijn, G.;
Vuerli, C.;
Williams, O. R.;
Zacchei, A.;
Altieri, B.;
Sanz, I. Escudero;
Kohley, R.;
Oosterbroek, T.;
Astier, P.;
Bacon, D.;
Bardelli, S.;
Baugh, C.;
Bellagamba, F.;
Benoist, C.;
Bianchi, D.;
Biviano, A.;
Branchini, E.;
Carbone, C.;
Cardone, V.;
Clements, D.;
Colombi, S.;
Conselice, C.;
Cresci, G.;
Deacon, N.;
Dunlop, J.;
Fedeli, C.;
Fontanot, F.;
Franzetti, P.;
Giocoli, C.;
Garcia-Bellido, J.;
Gow, J.;
Heavens, A.;
Hewett, P.;
Heymans, C.;
Holland, A.;
Huang, Z.;
Ilbert, O.;
Joachimi, B.;
Jennins, E.;
Kerins, E.;
Kiessling, A.;
Kirk, D.;
Kotak, R.;
Krause, O.;
Lahav, O.;
van Leeuwen, F.;
Lesgourgues, J.;
Lombardi, M.;
Magliocchetti, M.;
Maguire, K.;
Majerotto, E.;
Maoli, R.;
Marulli, F.;
Maurogordato, S.;
McCracken, H.;
McLure, R.;
Melchiorri, A.;
Merson, A.;
Moresco, M.;
Nonino, M.;
Norberg, P.;
Peacock, J.;
Pello, R.;
Penny, M.;
Pettorino, V.;
Di Porto, C.;
Pozzetti, L.;
Quercellini, C.;
Radovich, M.;
Rassat, A.;
Roche, N.;
Ronayette, S.;
Rossetti, E.;
Sartoris, B.;
Schneider, P.;
Semboloni, E.;
Serjeant, S.;
Simpson, F.;
Skordis, C.;
Smadja, G.;
Smartt, S.;
Spano, P.;
Spiro, S.;
Sullivan, M.;
Tilquin, A.;
Trotta, R.;
Verde, L.;
Wang, Y.;
Williger, G.;
Zhao, G.;
Zoubian, J.;
Zucca, E.
Submitted: 2011-10-14
Euclid is a space-based survey mission from the European Space Agency
designed to understand the origin of the Universe's accelerating expansion. It
will use cosmological probes to investigate the nature of dark energy, dark
matter and gravity by tracking their observational signatures on the geometry
of the universe and on the cosmic history of structure formation. The mission
is optimised for two independent primary cosmological probes: Weak
gravitational Lensing (WL) and Baryonic Acoustic Oscillations (BAO). The Euclid
payload consists of a 1.2 m Korsch telescope designed to provide a large field
of view. It carries two instruments with a common field-of-view of ~0.54 deg2:
the visual imager (VIS) and the near infrared instrument (NISP) which contains
a slitless spectrometer and a three bands photometer. The Euclid wide survey
will cover 15,000 deg2 of the extragalactic sky and is complemented by two 20
deg2 deep fields. For WL, Euclid measures the shapes of 30-40 resolved galaxies
per arcmin2 in one broad visible R+I+Z band (550-920 nm). The photometric
redshifts for these galaxies reach a precision of dz/(1+z) < 0.05. They are
derived from three additional Euclid NIR bands (Y, J, H in the range 0.92-2.0
micron), complemented by ground based photometry in visible bands derived from
public data or through engaged collaborations. The BAO are determined from a
spectroscopic survey with a redshift accuracy dz/(1+z) =0.001. The slitless
spectrometer, with spectral resolution ~250, predominantly detects Ha emission
line galaxies. Euclid is a Medium Class mission of the ESA Cosmic Vision
2015-2025 programme, with a foreseen launch date in 2019. This report (also
known as the Euclid Red Book) describes the outcome of the Phase A study.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1104.2048 [pdf] - 576598
ORIGIN: Metal Creation and Evolution from the Cosmic Dawn
Herder, J. W. den;
Piro, L.;
Ohashi, T.;
Kouveliotou, C.;
Hartmann, D. H.;
Kaastra, J. S.;
Amati, L.;
Andersen, M. I.;
Arnaud, M.;
Attéia, J-L.;
Bandler, S.;
Barbera, M.;
Barcons, X.;
Barthelmy, S.;
Basa, S.;
Basso, S.;
Boer, M.;
Branchini, E.;
Branduardi-Raymont, G.;
Borgani, S.;
Boyarsky, A.;
Brunetti, G.;
Budtz-Jorgensen, C.;
Burrows, D.;
Butler, N.;
Campana, S.;
Caroli, E.;
Ceballos, M.;
Christensen, F.;
Churazov, E.;
Comastri, A.;
Colasanti, L.;
Cole, R.;
Content, R.;
Corsi, A.;
Costantini, E.;
Conconi, P.;
Cusumano, G.;
de Plaa, J.;
De Rosa, A.;
Del Santo, M.;
Di Cosimo, S.;
De Pasquale, M.;
Doriese, R.;
Ettori, S.;
Evans, P.;
Ezoe, Y.;
Ferrari, L.;
Finger, H.;
Figueroa-Feliciano, T.;
Friedrich, P.;
Fujimoto, R.;
Furuzawa, A.;
Fynbo, J.;
Gatti, F.;
Galeazzi, M.;
Gehrels, N.;
Gendre, B.;
Ghirlanda, G.;
Ghisellini, G.;
Gilfanov, M.;
Giommi, P.;
Girardi, M.;
Grindlay, J.;
Cocchi, M.;
Godet, O.;
Guedel, M.;
Haardt, F.;
Hartog, R. den;
Hepburn, I.;
Hermsen, W.;
Hjorth, J.;
Hoekstra, H.;
Holland, A.;
Hornstrup, A.;
van der Horst, A.;
Hoshino, A.;
Zand, J. in 't;
Irwin, K.;
Ishisaki, Y.;
Jonker, P.;
Kitayama, T.;
Kawahara, H.;
Kawai, N.;
Kelley, R.;
Kilbourne, C.;
de Korte, P.;
Kusenko, A.;
Kuvvetli, I.;
Labanti, M.;
Macculi, C.;
Maiolino, R.;
Hesse, M. Mas;
Matsushita, K.;
Mazzotta, P.;
McCammon, D.;
Méndez, M.;
Mignani, R.;
Mineo, T.;
Mitsuda, K.;
Mushotzky, R.;
Molendi, S.;
Moscardini, L.;
Natalucci, L.;
Nicastro, F.;
O'Brien, P.;
Osborne, J.;
Paerels, F.;
Page, M.;
Paltani, S.;
Pedersen, K.;
Perinati, E.;
Ponman, T.;
Pointecouteau, E.;
Predehl, P.;
Porter, S.;
Rasmussen, A.;
Rauw, G.;
Röttgering, H.;
Roncarelli, M.;
Rosati, P.;
Quadrini, E.;
Ruchayskiy, O.;
Salvaterra, R.;
Sasaki, S.;
Sato, K.;
Savaglio, S.;
Schaye, J.;
Sciortino, S.;
Shaposhnikov, M.;
Sharples, R.;
Shinozaki, K.;
Spiga, D.;
Sunyaev, R.;
Suto, Y.;
Takei, Y.;
Tanvir, N.;
Tashiro, M.;
Tamura, T.;
Tawara, Y.;
Troja, E.;
Tsujimoto, M.;
Tsuru, T.;
Ubertini, P.;
Ullom, J.;
Ursino, E.;
Verbunt, F.;
van de Voort, F.;
Viel, M.;
Wachter, S.;
Watson, D.;
Weisskopf, M.;
Werner, N.;
White, N.;
Willingale, R.;
Wijers, R.;
Yamasaki, N.;
Yoshikawa, K.;
Zane, S.
Submitted: 2011-04-11, last modified: 2011-04-15
ORIGIN is a proposal for the M3 mission call of ESA aimed at the study of
metal creation from the epoch of cosmic dawn. Using high-spectral resolution in
the soft X-ray band, ORIGIN will be able to identify the physical conditions of
all abundant elements between C and Ni to red-shifts of z=10, and beyond. The
mission will answer questions such as: When were the first metals created? How
does the cosmic metal content evolve? Where do most of the metals reside in the
Universe? What is the role of metals in structure formation and evolution? To
reach out to the early Universe ORIGIN will use Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs) to
study their local environments in their host galaxies. This requires the
capability to slew the satellite in less than a minute to the GRB location. By
studying the chemical composition and properties of clusters of galaxies we can
extend the range of exploration to lower redshifts (z ~ 0.2). For this task we
need a high-resolution spectral imaging instrument with a large field of view.
Using the same instrument, we can also study the so far only partially detected
baryons in the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium (WHIM). The less dense part of the
WHIM will be studied using absorption lines at low redshift in the spectra for
GRBs.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1001.1656 [pdf] - 1019103
Reconstructing the triaxiality of the galaxy cluster Abell 1689: solving
the X-ray and strong lensing mass discrepancy
Submitted: 2010-01-11, last modified: 2010-11-18
We present the first determination of the intrinsic triaxial shapes and
tree-dimensional physical parameters of both dark matter (DM) and intra-cluster
medium (ICM) for the galaxy cluster Abell 1689. We exploit the novel method we
recently introduced (Morandi et al. 2010) in order to infer the
tree-dimensional physical properties in triaxial galaxy clusters by combining
jointly X-ray and strong lensing data. We find that Abell 1689 can be modeled
as a triaxial galaxy cluster with DM halo axial ratios 1.24 +/- 0.13 and 2.37
+/- 0.11 on the plane of the sky and along the line of sight, respectively. We
show that accounting for the three-dimensional geometry allows to solve the
discrepancy between the mass determined from X-ray and strong gravitational
lensing observations. We also determined the inner slope of the DM density
profile alpha: we measure alpha = 0.90 +/- 0.05 by accounting explicitly for
the 3D structure for this cluster, a value which is close to the cold dark
matter (CDM) predictions, while the standard spherical modeling leads to the
biased value alpha = 1.16 +/- 0.04. Our findings dispel the potential
inconsistencies arisen in the literature between the predictions of the CDM
scenario and the observations, providing further evidences that support the CDM
scenario.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.2648 [pdf] - 902742
Unveiling the three-dimensional structure of galaxy clusters: resolving
the discrepancy between X-ray and lensing masses
Submitted: 2009-12-14, last modified: 2010-03-01
[Abridged] We present the first determination of the intrinsic
three-dimensional shapes and the physical parameters of both dark matter (DM)
and intra-cluster medium (ICM) in a triaxial galaxy cluster. While most
previous studies rely on the standard spherical modeling, our approach allows
to infer the properties of the non-spherical intra-cluster gas distribution
sitting in hydrostatic equilibrium within triaxial DM halos by combining X-ray,
weak and strong lensing observations. We present an application of our method
to the galaxy cluster MACS J1423.8+2404. This source is an example of a well
relaxed object with a unimodal mass distribution and we infer shape and
physical properties of the ICM and the DM for this source. We found that this
is a triaxial galaxy cluster with DM halo axial ratios 1.53+/-0.15 and
1.44+/-0.07 on the plane of the sky and along the line of sight, respectively.
We show that accounting for the three-dimensional geometry allows to solve the
long-standing discrepancy between galaxy cluster masses determined from X-ray
and gravitational lensing observations. We focus also on the determination of
the inner slope of the DM density profile alpha, since the cuspiness of
dark-matter density profiles is one of the critical tests of the cold dark
matter (CDM) paradigm for structure formation: we measure alpha=0.94+/-0.09 by
accounting explicitly for the 3D structure for this cluster, a value which is
close to the CDM predictions, while the standard spherical modeling leads to
the biased value alpha=1.24+/-0.07. Our findings provide further evidences that
support the CDM scenario and open a new window in recovering the intrinsic
shapes and physical parameters of galaxy clusters in a bias-free way. This has
important consequences in using galaxy clusters as cosmological probes.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.1249 [pdf] - 1025019
Gravitational lensing in the Supernova Legacy Survey (SNLS)
Kronborg, T.;
Hardin, D.;
Guy, J.;
Astier, P.;
Balland, C.;
Basa, S.;
Carlberg, R. G.;
Conley, A.;
Fouchez, D.;
Hook, I. M.;
Howell, D. A.;
Jönsson, J.;
Pain, R.;
Pedersen, K.;
Perrett, K.;
Pritchet, C. J.;
Regnault, N.;
Rich, J.;
Sullivan, M.;
Palanque-Delabrouille, N.;
Ruhlmann-Kleider, V.
Submitted: 2010-02-05
The observed brightness of Type Ia supernovae is affected by gravitational
lensing caused by the mass distribution along the line of sight, which
introduces an additional dispersion into the Hubble diagram. We look for
evidence of lensing in the SuperNova Legacy Survey 3-year data set. We
investigate the correlation between the residuals from the Hubble diagram and
the gravitational magnification based on a modeling of the mass distribution of
foreground galaxies. A deep photometric catalog, photometric redshifts, and
well established mass luminosity relations are used. We find evidence of a
lensing signal with a 2.3 sigma significance. The current result is limited by
the number of SNe, their redshift distribution, and the other sources of
scatter in the Hubble diagram. Separating the galaxy population into a red and
a blue sample has a positive impact on the significance of the signal
detection. On the other hand, increasing the depth of the galaxy catalog, the
precision of photometric redshifts or reducing the scatter in the mass
luminosity relations have little effect. We show that for the full SuperNova
Legacy Survey sample (~400 spectroscopically confirmed Type Ia SNe and ~200
photometrically identified Type Ia SNe), there is an 80% probability of
detecting the lensing signal with a 3 sigma significance.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:0903.0665 [pdf] - 22023
Hot gas halos around disk galaxies: Confronting cosmological simulations
with observations
Submitted: 2009-03-03
Models of disk galaxy formation commonly predict the existence of an extended
reservoir of accreted hot gas surrounding massive spirals at low redshift. As a
test of these models, we use X-ray and H-alpha data of the two massive,
quiescent edge-on spirals NGC 5746 and NGC 5170 to investigate the amount and
origin of any hot gas in their halos. Contrary to our earlier claim, the
Chandra analysis of NGC 5746, employing more recent calibration data, does not
reveal any significant evidence for diffuse X-ray emission outside the optical
disk, with a 3-sigma upper limit to the halo X-ray luminosity of 4e39 erg/s. An
identical study of the less massive NGC 5170 also fails to detect any
extraplanar X-ray emission. By extracting hot halo properties of disk galaxies
formed in cosmological hydrodynamical simulations, we compare these results to
expectations for cosmological accretion of hot gas by spirals. For Milky
Way-sized galaxies, these high-resolution simulations predict hot halo X-ray
luminosities which are lower by a factor of ~2 compared to our earlier results
reported by Toft et al. (2002). We find the new simulation predictions to be
consistent with our observational constraints for both NGC 5746 and NGC 5170,
while also confirming that the hot gas detected so far around more actively
star-forming spirals is in general probably associated with stellar activity in
the disk. Observational results on quiescent disk galaxies at the high-mass end
are nevertheless providing powerful constraints on theoretical predictions, and
hence on the assumed input physics in numerical studies of disk galaxy
formation and evolution.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:0811.2793 [pdf] - 315332
Resolving the discrepancy between lensing and X-ray mass estimates of
the complex galaxy cluster Abell 1689
Submitted: 2008-11-18
There is a long-standing discrepancy between galaxy cluster masses determined
from X-ray and gravitational lensing observations of which Abell 1689 is a
well-studied example. In this work we take advantage of 180 ks of Chandra X-ray
observations and a new weak gravitational study based on a Hubble Space
Telescope mosaic covering the central 1.8 Mpc x 1.4 Mpc to eliminate the mass
discrepancy. In contrast to earlier X-ray analyses where the very circular
surface brightness has been inferred as Abell 1689 being spherically symmetric
and in hydrostatic equilibrium, a hardness ratio map analysis reveals a regular
and symmetric appearing main clump with a cool core plus some substructure in
the North Eastern part of the cluster. The gravitational lensing mass model
supports the interpretation of Abell 1689 being composed of a main clump, which
is possibly a virialized cluster, plus some substructure. In order to avoid
complications and mis-interpretations due to X-ray emission from the
substructure, we exclude it from the mass reconstruction. Comparing X-ray and
lensing mass profiles of the regular main part only, shows no significant
discrepancy between the two methods and the obtained mass profiles are
consistent over the full range where the mass can be reconstructed from X-rays
(out to approx. 1 Mpc). The obtained cluster mass within approx. 875 kpc
derived from X-rays alone is 6.4 plus/minus 2.1 x 10^14 solar masses compared
to a weak lensing mass of 8.6 plus/minus 3.0 x 10^14 solar masses within the
same radius.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:0712.2453 [pdf] - 8152
Sunyaev-Zeldovich profiles for clusters and groups of galaxies
Submitted: 2007-12-17
The Sunyaev-Zeldovich (SZ) effect gives a measure of the thermal energy and
electron pressure in groups and clusters of galaxies. In the near future SZ
surveys will map hundreds of systems, shedding light on the pressure
distribution in the systems. The thermal energy is related to the total mass of
a system of galaxies, but it is only a projection that is observed through the
SZ effect. A model for the 3D distribution of pressure is needed to link the SZ
signal to the total mass of the system. In this work we construct an empirical
model for the 2D and 3D SZ profile, and compare it to a set of realistic high
resolution SPH simulations of galaxy clusters and groups, and to a stacked SZ
profile for massive clusters derived from WMAP data. Furthermore, we combine
observed temperature profiles with dark matter potentials to yield an
additional constraint, under the assumption of hydrostatic equilibrium. We find
a very tight correlation between the characteristic scale in the model, the
integrated SZ signal, and the total mass in the systems with a scatter of only
4%. The model only contains two free parameters, making it readily applicable
even to low resolution SZ observations of galaxy clusters. A fitting routine
for the model that can be applied to observed or simulated data can be found at
http://www.phys.au.dk/~haugboel/software.shtml
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:0710.5636 [pdf] - 6549
Where is the matter in the Merging Cluster Abell 2218?
Submitted: 2007-10-30
We present a parametric strong lensing model of the cluster Abell 2218 based
on HST ACS data. We constrain the lens model using 8 previously known multiply
imaged systems, of which 7 have spectroscopically confirmed redshifts. In
addition, we propose five candidate multiply imaged systems and estimate their
redshifts using our mass model. The model parameters are optimized in the
source plane by a bayesian Monte Carlo Markov Chain as implemented in the the
publicly available software Lenstool. We find rms=0."12 for the scatter of the
sources in the source plane, which translates into rms=1."49 between the
predicted and measured image positions in the image plane. We find that the
projected mass distribution of Abell 2218 is bimodal, which is supported by an
analysis of the light distribution. We also find evidence for two structures in
velocity space, separated by ~1000 km/s, corresponding to the two large scale
dark matter clumps. We find that the lensing constraints can not be well
reproduced using only dark matter halos associated with the cluster galaxies,
but that the dark matter is required to be smoothly distributed in large scale
halos. At 100" the enclosed projected mass is 3.8e14 solar masses. At that
radius, the large scale halos contribute ~85% of the mass. We find that the
model is not very sensitive to the fainter galaxy sized halos, unless they
locally perturb a given multiply imaged system. Therefore, dark galaxy sized
substructure can be reliably constrained only if it locally perturbs one of the
systems. In an appendix we give a self-contained description of the parametric
profile we use, the dual pseudo isothermal elliptical mass distribution (dPIE).
This profile is a two component pseudo isothermal mass distribution (PIEMD)
with both a core radii and a scale radii. (Abridged)
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:0706.1070 [pdf] - 436155
A multi-wavelength study of z = 3.15 Lyman-alpha emitters in the GOODS
South Field
Nilsson, Kim K.;
Moeller, P.;
Moeller, O.;
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Michalowski, M. J.;
Watson, D.;
Ledoux, C.;
Rosati, P.;
Pedersen, K.;
Grove, L. F.
Submitted: 2007-06-07
Context: Ly-alpha-emitters have proven to be excellent probes of faint,
star-forming galaxies in the high redshift universe. However, although the
sample of known emitters is increasingly growing, their nature (e.g. stellar
masses, ages, metallicities, star-formation rates) is still poorly constrained.
Aims: We aim to study the nature of Ly-alpha-emitters, to find the properties
of a typical Ly-alpha-emitting galaxy and to compare these properties with the
properties of other galaxies at similar redshift, in particular Lyman-break
galaxies.
Methods: We have performed narrow-band imaging at the VLT, focused on
Ly-alpha at redshift z ~ 3.15, in the GOODS-S field. We have identified a
sample of Ly-alpha-emitting candidates, and we have studied their Spectral
Energy Distributions (SEDs).
Results: We find that the emitters are best fit by an SED with low
metallicity (Z/Z_sun = 0.005), low dust extinction (A_V ~ 0.32) and medium
stellar masses of approximately 10^9 M_sun. The age is not very well
constrained. One object out of 24 appears to be a high redshift
Ly-alpha-emitting dusty starburst galaxy. We find filamentary structure as
traced by the Ly-alpha-emitters at the 4 sigma level. The rest-frame UV SED of
these galaxies is very similar to that of Lyman Break Galaxies (LBGs) and
comply with the selection criteria for U-band drop-outs, except they are
intrinsically fainter than the current limit for LBGs.
Conclusion: Ly-alpha-emitters are excellent probes of galaxies in the distant
universe, and represent a class of star-forming, dust and AGN free, medium mass
objects.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0603260 [pdf] - 80469
Calibration of the Mass-Temperature Relation for Clusters of Galaxies
Using Weak Gravitational Lensing
Submitted: 2006-03-10, last modified: 2007-05-25
The main uncertainty in current determinations of the power spectrum
normalization, sigma_8, from abundances of X-ray luminous galaxy clusters
arises from the calibration of the mass-temperature relation. We use our weak
lensing mass determinations of 30 clusters from the hitherto largest sample of
clusters with lensing masses, combined with X-ray temperature data from the
literature, to calibrate the normalization of this relation at a temperature of
8 keV, M_{500c,8 keV}=(8.7 +/- 1.6) h^{-1} 10^{14} M_sun. This normalization is
consistent with previous lensing-based results based on smaller cluster
samples, and with some predictions from numerical simulations, but higher than
most normalizations based on X-ray derived cluster masses. Assuming the
theoretically expected slope alpha=3/2 of the mass-temperature relation, we
derive sigma_8 = 0.88 +/-0.09 for a spatially-flat LambdaCDM universe with
Omega_m = 0.3. The main systematic errors on the lensing masses result from
extrapolating the cluster masses beyond the field-of-view used for the
gravitational lensing measurements, and from the separation of
cluster/background galaxies, contributing each with a scatter of 20%. Taking
this into account, there is still significant intrinsic scatter in the
mass-temperature relation indicating that this relation may not be very tight,
at least at the high mass end. Furthermore, we find that dynamically relaxed
clusters are 75 +/-40% hotter than non-relaxed clusters.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0703553 [pdf] - 90362
The Representative XMM-Newton Cluster Structure Survey (REXCESS) of an
X-ray Luminosity Selected Galaxy Cluster Sample
Boehringer, H.;
Schuecker, P.;
Pratt, G. W.;
Arnaud, M.;
Ponman, T. J.;
Croston, J. H.;
Borgani, S.;
Bower, R. G.;
Briel, U. G.;
Collins, C. A.;
Donahue, M.;
Forman, W. R.;
Finoguenov, A.;
Geller, M. J.;
Guzzo, L.;
Henry, J. P.;
Kneissl, R.;
Mohr, J. J.;
Matsushita, K.;
Mullis, C. R.;
Ohashi, T.;
Pedersen, K.;
Pierini, D.;
Quintana, H.;
Raychaudhury, S.;
Reiprich, T. H.;
Romer, A. K.;
Rosati, P.;
Sabirli, K.;
Temple, R. F.;
Viana, P. T. P.;
Vikhlinin, A.;
Voit, G. M.;
Zhang, Y. -Y.
Submitted: 2007-03-21, last modified: 2007-03-22
The largest uncertainty for cosmological studies using clusters of galaxies
is introduced by our limited knowledge of the statistics of galaxy cluster
structure, and of the scaling relations between observables and cluster mass.
To improve on this situation we have started an XMM-Newton Large Programme for
the in-depth study of a representative sample of 33 galaxy clusters, selected
in the redshift range z=0.055 to 0.183 from the REFLEX Cluster Survey, having
X-ray luminosities above 0.4 X 10^44 h_70^-2 erg s^-1 in the 0.1 - 2.4 keV
band. This paper introduces the sample, compiles properties of the clusters,
and provides detailed information on the sample selection function. We describe
the selection of a nearby galaxy cluster sample that makes optimal use of the
XMM-Newton field-of-view, and provides nearly homogeneous X-ray luminosity
coverage for the full range from poor clusters to the most massive objects in
the Universe. For the clusters in the sample, X-ray fluxes are derived and
compared to the previously obtained fluxes from the ROSAT All-Sky Survey. We
find that the fluxes and the flux errors have been reliably determined in the
ROSAT All-Sky Survey analysis used for the REFLEX Survey. We use the sample
selection function documented in detail in this paper to determine the X-ray
luminosity function, and compare it with the luminosity function of the entire
REFLEX sample. We also discuss morphological peculiarities of some of the
sample members. The sample and some of the background data given in this
introductory paper will be important for the application of these data in the
detailed studies of cluster structure, to appear in forthcoming publications.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0703342 [pdf] - 90151
Searching for decaying axion-like dark matter from clusters of galaxies
Submitted: 2007-03-13
We consider the possibility of constraining the lifetime of radiatively
decaying dark matter particles in clusters of galaxies inspired from generic
axions of the Kaluza-Klein type. Such axions have been invoked as a possible
explanation for the coronal X-ray emission from the Sun. These axions, or
similar particles, can be produced inside stars and some of them remain
confined by the deep gravitational potential of clusters of galaxies.
Specifically, we consider regions within merging galaxy clusters (Abell 520 and
the "Bullet Cluster"), where gravitational lensing observations have identified
massive, but baryon poor, structures. From an analysis of X-ray observations of
these mass concentrations, and the expected photon spectrum of decaying solar
KK-axions, we derive lower limits to the lifetime of such axions of tau approx.
10^23 sec. However, if KK-axions constitute less than a few percent of the dark
matter mass, this lifetime constraint is similar to that derived from solar
KK-axions.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0510368 [pdf] - 1456446
A log N(HI) = 22.6 DLA in a dark gamma-ray burst: the environment of GRB
050401
Watson, D.;
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Ledoux, C.;
Vreeswijk, P.;
Hjorth, J.;
Smette, A.;
Andersen, A. C.;
Aoki, K.;
Augusteijn, T.;
Beardmore, A. P.;
Bersier, D.;
Cerón, J. M. Castro;
D'Avanzo, P.;
Diaz-Fraile, D.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Hirst, P.;
Jakobsson, P.;
Jensen, B. L.;
Kawai, N.;
Kosugi, G.;
Laursen, P.;
Levan, A.;
Masegosa, J.;
Näränen, J.;
Page, K. L.;
Pedersen, K.;
Pozanenko, A.;
Reeves, J. N.;
Rumyantsev, V.;
Shahbaz, T.;
Sharapov, D.;
Sollerman, J.;
Starling, R. L. C.;
Tanvir, N.;
Torstensson, K.;
Wiersema, K.
Submitted: 2005-10-12, last modified: 2006-11-09
The optical afterglow spectrum of GRB050401 (at z=2.8992+/-0.0004) shows the
presence of a DLA, with log(nHI)=22.6+/-0.3. This is the highest column density
ever observed in a DLA, and is about five times larger than the strongest DLA
detected so far in any QSO spectrum. From the optical spectrum, we also find a
very large Zn column density, allowing us to infer an abundance of
[Zn/H]=-1.0+/-0.4. These large columns are supported by the X-ray spectrum from
Swift-XRT which shows a column density (in excess of Galactic) of
log(nH)=22.21^{+0.06}_{-0.08} assuming solar abundances (at z=2.9). The
comparison of this X-ray column density, which is dominated by absorption due
to alpha-chain elements, and the HI column density derived from the Ly-alpha
absorption line, allows us to derive a metallicity for the absorbing matter of
[alpha/H]=-0.4+/-0.3. The optical spectrum is reddened and can be well
reproduced with a power-law with SMC extinction, where A_V=0.62+/-0.06. But the
total optical extinction can also be constrained in a way which is independent
of the shape of the extinction curve: from the optical-to-X-ray spectral energy
distribution we find, 0.5<~A_V<~4.5. However, even this upper limit,
independent of the shape of the extinction curve, is still well below the dust
column that is inferred from the X-ray column density, i.e.
A_V=9.1^{+1.4}_{-1.5}. This discrepancy might be explained by a small dust
content with high metallicity (low dust-to-metals ratio). `Grey' extinction
cannot explain the discrepancy since we are comparing the metallicity to a
measurement of the total extinction (without reference to the reddening).
Little dust with high metallicity may be produced by sublimation of dust grains
or may naturally exist in systems younger than a few hundred Myr.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0610893 [pdf] - 86317
Investigating hot gas in the halos of two massive spirals: Observations
and cosmological simulations
Submitted: 2006-10-30
Models of disk galaxy formation commonly predict the existence of an extended
reservoir of hot gas surrounding massive spirals at low redshift. As a test of
these models, we have obtained X-ray and optical data of the two massive
edge-on spirals NGC 5746 and NGC 5170, in order to investigate the amount and
origin of hot gas in their disks and halos. Chandra observations of NGC 5746
reveal evidence for diffuse X-ray emission with a total luminosity of ~7 x
10^39 erg/s surrounding this galaxy out to at least ~20 kpc from the disk,
whereas an identical study of the less massive NGC 5170 fails to detect any
extraplanar X-ray emission. Unlike the case for other disk galaxies with
detected X-ray halos, the halo emission around NGC 5746 is not accompanied by
extraplanar H-alpha or radio emission, and there is no evidence for significant
nuclear or starburst activity in the disk. In contrast to these other cases,
the emission around NGC 5746 therefore appears to arise from the cooling of
externally accreted material rather than from disk outflows. To verify this
idea, we present results of cosmological simulations of galaxy formation and
evolution, showing our observations to be in good agreement with expectations
for cosmological accretion, while also confirming that the X-ray halos of other
spirals do not fit well into an accretion scenario. We find that the estimated
cooling rate of hot halo gas around NGC 5746 would provide sufficient material
for star formation in the disk to proceed at its present rate. This lends
support to the idea that a supply of hot ambient gas is potentially available
as fuel for star formation in massive, nearby spirals, and suggests that
accretion of hot gas could be important for maintaining the stellar disks of
such galaxies.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0609450 [pdf] - 1471054
HI column densities of z > 2 Swift gamma-ray bursts
Jakobsson, P.;
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Ledoux, C.;
Vreeswijk, P.;
Kann, D. A.;
Hjorth, J.;
Priddey, R. S.;
Tanvir, N. R.;
Reichart, D.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Klose, S.;
Watson, D.;
Sollerman, J.;
Fruchter, A. S.;
Postigo, A. de Ugarte;
Wiersema, K.;
Björnsson, G.;
Chapman, R.;
Thöne, C. C.;
Pedersen, K.;
Jensen, B. L.
Submitted: 2006-09-15, last modified: 2006-10-13
Context: Before the launch of the Swift satellite, the majority of the
gamma-ray burst (GRB) afterglows for which Ly-alpha was redshifted into the
observable spectrum showed evidence for a damped Ly-alpha absorber. This small
sample indicated that GRBs explode either in galaxies, or regions within them,
having high neutral hydrogen column densities.
Aims: To increase the spectroscopic sample of GRBs with z > 2 and hence
establish the N(HI) distribution along GRB lines-of-sight.
Methods: We have obtained six z > 2 GRB afterglow spectra and fitted the
Ly-alpha absorption line in each case to determine N(HI). This has been
complemented with 12 other Swift N(HI) values from the literature.
Results: We show that the peak of the GRB N(HI) distribution is qualitatively
consistent with a model where GRBs originate in Galactic-like molecular clouds.
However, a systematic difference, in particular an excess of low column-density
systems compared to the predictions, indicates that selection effects and
conditions within the cloud (e.g. strong ionization) influence the observed
N(HI) range. We also report the discovery of Ly-alpha emission from the GRB
060714 host, corresponding to a star-formation rate of approximately 0.8
M_Sun/year. Finally, we present accurate redshifts of the six bursts: z = 3.240
+/- 0.001 (GRB 050319), z = 2.198 +/- 0.002 (GRB 050922C), z = 3.221 +/- 0.001
(GRB 060526), z = 3.425 +/- 0.002 (GRB 060707), z = 2.711 +/- 0.001 (GRB
060714) and z = 3.686 +/- 0.002 (GRB 060906).
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0610034 [pdf] - 85458
Probing the nature of dark matter with Cosmic X-rays: Constraints from
"Dark blobs" and grating spectra of galaxy clusters
Submitted: 2006-10-02
Gravitational lensing observations of galaxy clusters have identified dark
matter ``blobs'' with remarkably low baryonic content. We use such a system to
probe the particle nature of dark matter with X-ray observations. We also study
high resolution X-ray grating spectra of a cluster of galaxies. From these
grating spectra we improve the conservative constraints on a particular dark
matter candidate, the sterile neutrino, by more than one order of magnitude.
Based on these conservative constraints obtained from Cosmic X-ray observations
alone, the low mass (m_s < 10keV) and low mixing angle (sin^2(2\theta) 10^{-6})
sterile neutrino is still a viable dark matter candidate.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0604153 [pdf] - 81222
Are short gamma-ray bursts collimated? GRB050709, a flare but no break
Submitted: 2006-04-07, last modified: 2006-06-12
From the small sample of afterglow lightcurves of short duration gamma-ray
bursts (GRBs), the decays are rapid, roughly following a power-law in time. It
has been assumed that the afterglow emission in short GRBs is collimated in
jets in the same way as in long GRBs. An achromatic break in a short GRB
afterglow lightcurve would therefore be strong evidence in favour of
collimation in short GRBs. We examine the optical lightcurve of the afterglow
of the short GRB 050709, the only short GRB where a jet break has been claimed
from optical data. We show that (1) the decay follows a single power-law from
1.4 to 19 days after the burst and has a decay index alpha =
1.73_{-0.04}^{+0.11}, (2) that an optical flare at ~10 days is required by the
data, roughly contemporaneous with a flare in the X-ray data, and (3) that
there is no evidence for a break in the lightcurve. This means that so far
there is no direct evidence for collimation in the outflows of short GRBs. The
available limits on the collimation angles in short GRBs now strongly suggest
much wider opening angles than found in long GRBs.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0602444 [pdf] - 1455118
Probing Cosmic Chemical Evolution with Gamma-Ray Bursts: GRB060206 at
z=4.048
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Starling, R. L. C.;
Ledoux, C.;
Wiersema, K.;
Thöne, C. C.;
Sollerman, J.;
Jakobsson, P.;
Hjorth, J.;
Watson, D.;
Vreeswijk, P. M.;
Møller, P.;
Rol, E.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Näränen, J.;
Wijers, R. A. M. J.;
Björnsson, G.;
Cerón, J. M. Castro;
Curran, P.;
Hartmann, D. H.;
Holland, S. T.;
Jensen, B. L.;
Levan, A. J.;
Limousin, M.;
Kouveliotou, C.;
Nelemans, G.;
Pedersen, K.;
Priddey, R. S.;
Tanvir, N. R.
Submitted: 2006-02-20, last modified: 2006-04-09
Aim: We present early optical spectroscopy of the afterglow of the gamma-ray
burst GRB 060206 with the aim of determining the metallicity of the GRB
absorber and the physical conditions in the circumburst medium. We also discuss
how GRBs may be important complementary probes of cosmic chemical evolution.
Method: Absorption line study of the GRB afterglow spectrum. Results: We
determine the redshift of the GRB to be z=4.04795+/-0.00020. Based on the
measurement of the neutral hydrogen column density from the damped Lyman-alpha
line and the metal content from weak, unsaturated Sii lines we derive a
metallicity of [S/H] =-0.84+/-0.10. This is one of the highest metallicities
measured from absorption lines at z~4. From the very high column densities for
the forbidden Siii*, Oi*, and Oi** lines we infer very high densities and low
temperatures in the system. There is evidence for the presence of H$_2$
molecules with logN(H_2) ~ 17.0, translating into a molecular fraction of logf
\~ -3.5 with f=2N(H_2)/(2N(H_2)+ N(Hi)). Even if GRBs are only formed by single
massive stars with metallicities below ~0.3Z(solar), they could still be fairly
unbiased tracers of the bulk of the star formation at z>2. Hence, metallicities
as derived for GRB060206 here for a complete sample of GRB afterglows will
directly show the distribution of metallicities for representative star-forming
galaxies at these redshifts.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0603661 [pdf] - 80870
Sterile neutrinos in the Milky Way: Observational constraints
Submitted: 2006-03-24
We consider the possibility of constraining decaying dark matter by looking
out through the Milky Way halo. Specifically we use Chandra blank sky
observations to constrain the parameter space of sterile neutrinos. We find
that a broad band in parameter space is still open, leaving the sterile
neutrino as an excellent dark matter candidate.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0602071 [pdf] - 79647
GRB 050814 at z = 5.3 and the Redshift Distribution of Swift GRBs
Jakobsson, P.;
Levan, A.;
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Priddey, R.;
Hjorth, J.;
Tanvir, N.;
Watson, D.;
Jensen, B. L.;
Sollerman, J.;
Natarajan, P.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Cerón, J. M. Castro;
Pedersen, K.
Submitted: 2006-02-03, last modified: 2006-02-07
We report optical, near-infrared and X-ray observations of the afterglow of
GRB 050814, which was seen to exhibit very red optical colours. By modelling
its spectral energy distribution we find that z = 5.3 +/- 0.3. We next present
a carefully selected sample of 19 Swift GRBs, intended to estimate in an
unbiased way the GRB redshift distribution, including the mean redshift
(z_mean) as well as constraints on the fraction of high-redshift bursts. We
find that z_mean = 2.7 and that at least 5% of the GRBs originate at z > 5. The
redshift distribution of the sample is qualitatively consistent with models
where the GRB rate is proportional to the star formation rate in the Universe.
The high mean redshift of this GRB sample and the wide redshift range clearly
demonstrates the suitability of GRBs as efficient probes of galaxies and the
intergalactic medium over a significant fraction of the history of the
Universe.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0511682 [pdf] - 78040
Discovery of a very extended X-ray halo around a quiescent spiral galaxy
- the "missing link" of galaxy formation
Submitted: 2005-11-23, last modified: 2006-01-13
Hot gaseous haloes surrounding galaxies and extending well beyond the
distribution of stars are a ubiquitous prediction of galaxy formation
scenarios. The haloes are believed to consist of gravitationally trapped gas
with a temperature of millions of Kelvin. The existence of such hot haloes
around massive elliptical galaxies has been established through their X-ray
emission. While gas out-flowing from starburst spiral galaxies has been
detected, searches for hot haloes around normal, quiescent spiral galaxies have
so far failed, casting doubts on the fundamental physics in galaxy formation
models. Here we present the first detection of a hot, large-scale gaseous halo
surrounding a normal, quiescent spiral galaxy, NGC 5746, alleviating a
long-standing problem for galaxy formation models. In contrast to starburst
galaxies, where the X-ray halo can be powered by the supernova energy, there is
no such power source in NGC 5746. The only compelling explanation is that we
are here witnessing a galaxy forming from gradually in-flowing hot and dilute
halo gas.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0509640 [pdf] - 76221
Outshining the quasars at reionisation: The X-ray spectrum and
lightcurve of the redshift 6.29 Gamma-Ray Burst GRB050904
Watson, D.;
Reeves, J. N.;
Hjorth, J.;
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Jakobsson, P.;
Pedersen, K.;
Sollerman, J.;
Cerón, J. M. Castro;
McBreen, S.;
Foley, S.
Submitted: 2005-09-21, last modified: 2005-12-08
Gamma-ray burst (GRB) 050904 is the most distant X-ray source known, at
z=6.295, comparable to the farthest AGN and galaxies. Its X-ray flux decays,
but not as a power-law; it is dominated by large variability from a few minutes
to at least half a day. The spectra soften from a power-law with photon index
Gamma=1.2 to 1.9, and are well-fit by an absorbed power-law with possible
evidence of large intrinsic absorption. There is no evidence for discrete
features, in spite of the high signal-to-noise ratio. In the days after the
burst, GRB 050904 was by far the brightest known X-ray source at z>4. In the
first minutes after the burst, the flux was >10^{-9} erg cm^-2 s^-1 in the
0.2-10keV band, corresponding to an apparent luminosity >10^5 times larger than
the brightest AGN at these distances. More photons were acquired in a few
minutes with Swift-XRT than XMM-Newton and Chandra obtained in ~300 ks of
pointed observations of z>5 AGN. This observation is a clear demonstration of
concept for efficient X-ray studies of the high-z IGM with large area,
high-resolution X-ray detectors, and shows that early-phase GRBs are the only
backlighting bright enough for X-ray absorption studies of the IGM at high
redshift.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0509888 [pdf] - 142643
A mean redshift of 2.8 for Swift gamma-ray bursts
Jakobsson, P.;
Levan, A.;
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Priddey, R.;
Hjorth, J.;
Tanvir, N.;
Watson, D.;
Jensen, B. L.;
Sollerman, J.;
Natarajan, P.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Cerón, J. M. Castro;
Pedersen, K.;
Pursimo, T.;
Árnadóttir, A. S.;
Castro-Tirado, A. J.;
Davis, C. J.;
Deeg, H. J.;
Fiuza, D. A.;
Mykolaitis, S.;
Sousa, S. G.
Submitted: 2005-09-29, last modified: 2005-10-28
The exceptionally high luminosities of gamma-ray bursts (GRBs), gradually
emerging as extremely useful probes of star formation, make them promising
tools for exploration of the high-redshift Universe. Here we present a
carefully selected sample of Swift GRBs, intended to estimate in an unbiased
way the GRB mean redshift (z_mean), constraints on the fraction of
high-redshift bursts and an upper limit on the fraction of heavily obscured
afterglows. We find that z_mean = 2.8 and that at least 7% of GRBs originate at
z > 5. In addition, consistent with pre-Swift observations, at most 20% of
afterglows can be heavily obscured. The redshift distribution of the sample is
qualitatively consistent with models where the GRB rate is proportional to the
star formation rate in the Universe. We also report optical, near-infrared and
X-ray observations of the afterglow of GRB 050814, which was seen to exhibit
very red optical colours. By modelling its spectral energy distribution we find
that z = 5.3 +/- 0.3. The high mean redshift of GRBs and their wide redshift
range clearly demonstrates their suitability as efficient probes of galaxies
and the intergalactic medium over a significant fraction of the history of the
Universe.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0510098 [pdf] - 1468966
The host galaxy cluster of the short gamma-ray burst GRB 050509B
Pedersen, K.;
Eliasdottir, A.;
Hjorth, J.;
Starling, R.;
Cerón, J. M. Castro;
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Jakobsson, P.;
Sollerman, J.;
Watson, D.
Submitted: 2005-10-04
The first arcsecond localization of a short gamma-ray burst, GRB 050509B, has
enabled detailed studies of a short burst environment. We here report on
studies of the environment of GRB 050509B using the Swift X-ray Telescope
(XRT). The XRT error circle of the burst overlaps with an elliptical galaxy in
the cluster of galaxies ZwCl 1234.0+02916. Based on the measured X-ray flux of
the cluster we estimate that the probability for a chance superposition of GRB
050509B and a cluster at least as X-ray bright as this cluster is $< 2\times
10^{-3}$, presenting the first strong case of a short burst located in a
cluster of galaxies. We also consider the case for GRB 050509B being located
behind ZwCl 1234.0+02916 and gravitationally lensed. From the velocity
dispersion of the elliptical galaxy and the temperature of hot intracluster
gas, we model the mass distribution in the elliptical galaxy and the cluster,
and calculate the gravitational lensing magnification within the XRT error
circle. We find that, if GRB050509B would be positioned significantly behind
the cluster, it is most likely magnified by a factor less than two, but that
the burst could be strongly lensed if it is positioned within 2 arcsec of the
center of the bright elliptical galaxy. Further mapping of arcsecond size short
burst error boxes is a new promising route to determine the spatial
distribution of old stars throughout the Universe.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0510096 [pdf] - 1468965
The optical afterglow of the short gamma-ray burst GRB 050709
Hjorth, Jens;
Watson, Darach;
Fynbo, Johan P. U.;
Price, Paul A.;
Jensen, Brian L.;
Jørgensen, Uffe G.;
Kubas, Daniel;
Gorosabel, Javier;
Jakobsson, Páll;
Sollerman, Jesper;
Pedersen, Kristian;
Kouveliotou, Chryssa
Submitted: 2005-10-04
It has long been known that there are two classes of gamma-ray bursts (GRBs),
mainly distinguished by their durations. The breakthrough in our understanding
of long-duration GRBs (those lasting more than ~2 s), which ultimately linked
them with energetic Type Ic supernovae, came from the discovery of their
long-lived X-ray and optical afterglows, when precise and rapid localizations
of the sources could finally be obtained. X-ray localizations have recently
become available for short (duration <2 s) GRBs, which have evaded optical
detection for more than 30 years. Here we report the first discovery of
transient optical emission (R-band magnitude ~23) associated with a short
burst; GRB 050709. The optical afterglow was localized with subarcsecond
accuracy, and lies in the outskirts of a blue dwarf galaxy. The optical and
X-ray afterglow properties 34 h after the GRB are reminiscent of the afterglows
of long GRBs, which are attributable to synchrotron emission from
ultrarelativistic ejecta. We did not, however, detect a supernova, as found in
most nearby long GRB afterglows, which suggests a different origin for the
short GRBs.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0509477 [pdf] - 76059
The soft X-ray blast in the apparently sub-luminous GRB 031203
Watson, D.;
Vaughan, S. A.;
Willingale, R.;
Hjorth, J.;
Foley, S.;
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Jakobsson, P.;
Levan, A.;
O'Brien, P. T.;
Osborne, J. P.;
Pedersen, K.;
Reeves, J. N.;
Tedds, J. A.;
Watson, M. G.
Submitted: 2005-09-15
GRB031203 was a very low apparent luminosity gamma-ray burst (GRB). It was
also the first GRB with a dust-scattered X-ray halo. The observation of the
halo allowed us to infer the presence of a large soft X-ray fluence in the
total burst output. It has, however, also been claimed that GRB031203 was
intrinsically sub-energetic, representative of a class of spectrally hard,
low-energy bursts quite different from other GRBs. Reanalysis of the available
data confirms our original finding that GRB031203 had a very large soft X-ray
component, the time of which can be constrained to within a few minutes after
the burst, implying that while GRB031203 did indeed have a very low apparent
luminosity, it was also very soft. Notions propagated in the literature
regarding the uncertainties in the determination of the soft X-ray fluence from
the halo data and on the available constraints from the hard X-ray data are
addressed: the properties of the scattering dust along the line of sight (grain
sizes, precise location and the geometry) are determined directly from the high
quality X-ray data so that there is little uncertainty about the scatterer;
constraints on the X-ray lightcurve from the Integral spacecraft at the time of
the soft X-ray blast are not complete because of a slew in the spacecraft
pointing shortly after the burst. Claims that GRB031203 was intrinsically
under-energetic and that it represents a deviation from the luminosity-peak
energy relation do not appear to be substantiated by the data, regardless of
whether the soft X-ray component is declared part of the prompt emission or the
afterglow. We conclude that the difference between the soft and hard X-ray
spectra from XMM-Newton and Integral indicate that a second soft pulse probably
occurred in this burst as has been observed in other GRBs, notably GRB050502B.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0509424 [pdf] - 76006
Multi-Wavelength Studies of the Optically Dark Gamma-Ray Burst 001025A
Pedersen, K.;
Hurley, K.;
Hjorth, J.;
Smith, D. A.;
Andersen, M. I.;
Christensen, L.;
Cline, T.;
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Goldsten, J.;
Golenetskii, S.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Jakobsson, P.;
Jensen, B. L.;
Milvang-Jensen, B.;
McClanahan, T.;
Moller, P.;
Palshin, V.;
Schartel, N.;
Trombka, J.;
Ulanov, M.;
Watson, D.
Submitted: 2005-09-15
We identify the fading X-ray afterglow of GRB 001025A from XMM-Newton
observations obtained 1.9-2.3 days, 2 years, and 2.5 years after the burst. The
non-detection of an optical counterpart to an upper limit of R=25.5, 1.20 days
after the burst, makes GRB 001025A a ``dark'' burst. Based on the X-ray
afterglow spectral properties of GRB 001025A, we argue that some bursts appear
optically dark because their afterglow is faint and their cooling frequency is
close to the X-ray band. This interpretation is applicable to several of the
few other dark bursts where the X-ray spectral index has been measured. The
X-ray afterglow flux of GRB 001025A is an order of magnitude lower than for
typical long-duration gamma-ray bursts. The spectrum of the X-ray afterglow can
be fitted with an absorbed synchrotron emission model, an absorbed thermal
plasma model, or a combination thereof. For the latter, an extrapolation to
optical wavelengths can be reconciled with the R-band upper limit on the
afterglow, without invoking any optical circumburst absorption, provided the
cooling frequency is close to the X-ray band. Alternatively, if the X-ray
afterglow is due to synchrotron emission only, seven magnitudes of extinction
in the observed R-band is required to meet the R-band upper limit, making GRB
001025A much more obscured than bursts with detected optical afterglows. Based
on the column density of X-ray absorbing circumburst matter, an SMC gas-to-dust
ratio is insufficient to produce this amount of extinction. The X-ray tail of
the prompt emission enters a steep temporal decay excluding that the tail of
the prompt emission is the onset of the afterglow (abridged).
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0505544 [pdf] - 73314
The Formation of Fossil Galaxy Groups in the hierarchical Universe
Submitted: 2005-05-26, last modified: 2005-08-31
We use a set of twelve high-resolution N-body/hydrodynamical simulations in
the $\Lambda$CDM cosmology to investigate the origin and formation rate of
fossil groups (FGs), which are X-ray bright galaxy groups dominated by a large
elliptical galaxy, with the second brightest galaxy being at least two
magnitudes fainter. The simulations invoke star formation, chemical evolution
with non-instantaneous recycling, metal dependent radiative cooling, strong
star burst driven galactic super winds, effects of a meta-galactic UV field and
full stellar population synthesis. We find an interesting correlation between
the magnitude gap between the first and second brightest galaxy and the
formation time of the group. It is found that FGs have assembled half of their
final dark matter mass already at $z\ga1$, and subsequently typically grow by
minor merging only, wheras non-FGs on average form later. The early assembly of
FGs leaves sufficient time for galaxies of $L \sim L_*$ to merge into the
central one by dynamical friction, resulting in the large magnitude gap at
$z=0$. A fraction of 33$\pm$16% of the groups simulated are found to be fossil,
whereas the observational estimate is $\sim$10-20%. The FGs are found to be
X-ray over-luminous relative to non-FGs of the same optical luminosity, in
qualitative agreement with observations. Finally, from a dynamical friction
analysis is found that only because infall of $L \sim L_*$ galaxies happens
along filaments with small impact parameters do FGs exist at all.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0506123 [pdf] - 73523
GRB 050509B: Constraints on short gamma-ray burst models
Hjorth, J.;
Sollerman, J.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Granot, J.;
Klose, S.;
Kouveliotou, C.;
Melinder, J.;
Ramirez-Ruiz, E.;
Starling, R.;
Thomsen, B.;
Andersen, M. I.;
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Jensen, B. L.;
Vreeswijk, P. M.;
Cerón, J. M. Castro;
Jakobsson, P.;
Levan, A.;
Pedersen, K.;
Rhoads, J. E.;
Tanvir, N. R.;
Watson, D.;
Wijers, R. A. M. J.
Submitted: 2005-06-06, last modified: 2005-08-01
We have obtained deep optical images with the Very Large Telescope at ESO of
the first well-localized short-duration gamma-ray burst, GRB 050509B. From V
and R imaging, initiated ~2 days after the GRB trigger and lasting up to three
weeks, we detect no variable object inside the small Swift/XRT X-ray error
circle down to 2sigma limits of V = 26.5 and R = 25.1. The X-ray error circle
includes a giant elliptical galaxy at z = 0.225, which has been proposed as the
likely host of this GRB. Our limits indicate that if the GRB originated at z =
0.225, any supernova-like event accompanying the GRB would have to be over 100
times fainter than normal Type Ia SNe or Type Ic hypernovae, 5 times fainter
than the faintest known Ia or Ic SNe, and fainter than the faintest known Type
II SNe. Moreover, we use the optical limits to constrain the energetics of the
GRB outflow. Simple models indicate that, unless the intrinsic energy in the
outflow from GRB 050509B was << 10^51 erg, there was very little radioactive
material with efficient decay timescales for generating a large luminosity.
These limits strongly constrain progenitor models for this short GRB.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0506686 [pdf] - 74086
On the nature of nearby GRB/SN host galaxies
Submitted: 2005-06-28
We present and discuss optical diagnostics of the low redshift (z<0.2)
galaxies that are known to have hosted supernovae associated with gamma-ray
bursts (GRBs). The three galaxies are all actively starforming sub-luminous
(L<L*) galaxies with relatively low metallicities (Z<Zsun). We find no evidence
for substantial internal extinction within any of the galaxies. We derive star
formation rates (SFR) based on H-alpha luminosities, as well as specific star
formation rates (SFFR, star formation rate per unit luminosity). For GRB 980425
(SN 1998bw) we use photometry of the supernova environment to estimate the mass
of the progentitor to > 30 Msun. These three host galaxies have global
properties (luminosities, SFR, SSFR, metallicity, colour, reddening) that
resemble those of more distant GRB host galaxies. We also compare the host
galaxies with a sample of Blue Compact Galaxies (BCGs) in the local universe,
and show that these samples have similar properties.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0506101 [pdf] - 73501
On the Afterglow and Host Galaxy of GRB021004: A Comprehensive Study
with the Hubble Space Telescope
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Smette, A.;
Fruchter, A.;
Hjorth, J.;
Pedersen, K.;
Levan, A.;
Burud, I.;
Sahu, K.;
Vreeswijk, P. M.;
Bergeron, E.;
Kouveliotou, C.;
Tanvir, N.;
Thorsett, S. E.;
Wijers, R. A. M. J.;
Cerón, J. M. Castro;
Castro-Tirado, A.;
Garnavich, P.;
Holland, S. T.;
Jakobsson, P.;
Moller, P.;
Nugent, P.;
Pian, E.;
Rhoads, J.;
Thomsen, B.;
Watson, D.;
Woosley, S.
Submitted: 2005-06-05
(Abridged) We report on HST observations of the late-time afterglow and host
galaxy of GRB021004 (z=2.33). Although this GRB is one of the best observed so
far, there is substantial disagreement between different interpretations of
data sets on this burst in the literature. We have observed the field of
GRB021004 with the HST at multiple epochs from 3 days until almost 10 months
after the burst. With STIS spectroscopy we cover the spectral region 600-1700AA
in the restframe. From the limit on the flux recovery bluewards of the
Lyman-limit we constrain the HI column density to be above 1x10^18 cm-2 Based
on ACS and NICMOS imaging we find that the afterglow evolved achromatically
within the errors. The color changes observed by other authors during the first
four days must be related to a stochastic phenomenon superimposed on an
afterglow component with a constant spectral shape. This achromaticity implies
that the cooling break has remained on the blue side of the optical part of the
spectrum for at least two weeks after the burst. The optical-to-X-ray slope is
consistent with being the same at 1.4 and 52.4 days after the burst. This
indicates that the cooling frequency is constant and hence, according to
fireball models, that the circumburst medium has a constant density profile.
The late-time slope of the lightcurve is in the range alpha_2 = 1.8-1.9, and is
inconsistent with a single power-law. This could be due to a late-time
flattening caused by the transition to non-relativistic expansion or due to
excess emission (a lightcurve `bump') 7 days after burst. The host is a
starburst galaxy with no evidence for dust and with strong Ly-alpha emission.
The afterglow was located very close (~100 pc) to the center of the host
suggesting that the progenitor was associated with a circumnuclear starburst.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0411036 [pdf] - 68635
Swift Identification of Dark Gamma-Ray Bursts
Submitted: 2004-11-01
We present an optical flux vs. X-ray flux diagram for all known gamma-ray
bursts (GRBs) for which an X-ray afterglow has been detected. We propose an
operational definition of dark bursts as those bursts that are optically
subluminous with respect to the fireball model, i.e., which have an
optical-to-X-ray spectral index beta_OX < 0.5. Out of a sample of 52 GRBs we
identify 5 dark bursts. The definition and diagram serve as a simple and quick
diagnostic tool for identifying dark GRBs based on limited information,
particularly useful for early and objective identification of dark GRBs
observed with the Swift satellite.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0409560 [pdf] - 67641
Massive star-formation rates of gamma-ray burst host galaxies: an
unobscured view in X-rays
Submitted: 2004-09-23
The hard X-ray (2-10keV) luminosity of a star-forming galaxy tracks its
population of high mass X-ray binaries and is essentially unobscured. It is
therefore a practically unbiased measure of star-formation in the host galaxies
of gamma-ray bursts (GRBs). Using recent and archival observations of GRBs with
the XMM-Newton and Chandra X-ray observatories, limits are placed on the
underlying X-ray emission from GRB hosts. Useful limits on the current massive
star-formation rates (SFRs), unaffected by obscuration, are obtained for the
hosts of three low redshift GRBs: GRB980425, GRB030329 and GRB031203. These
limits show that though the specific SFRs may be high (as in dwarf starburst
galaxies), none have massive obscured star-formation at the levels implied by
the sub-mm detection of some GRB hosts. It is also shown that in cases where
the faint luminosities of the late time afterglow or supernova emission are of
interest, the contribution of the host galaxy to the X-ray flux may be
significant.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0408041 [pdf] - 1456387
Probing a GRB progenitor at a redshift of z=2: a comprehensive observing
campaign of the afterglow of GRB 030226
Klose, S.;
Greiner, J.;
Rau, A.;
Henden, A. A.;
Hartmann, D. H.;
Zeh, A.;
Ries, C.;
Masetti, N.;
Malesani, D.;
Guenther, E.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Stecklum, B.;
Antonelli, L. A.;
Brinkworth, C.;
Cerón, J. M. Castro;
Castro-Tirado, A. J.;
Covino, S.;
Fruchter, A.;
Fynbo, J. P.;
Ghisellini, G.;
Hjorth, J.;
Hudec, R.;
Jelínek, M.;
Kaper, L.;
Kouveliotou, C.;
Lindsay, K.;
Maiorano, E.;
Mannucci, F.;
Nysewander, M.;
Palazzi, E.;
Pedersen, K.;
Pian, E.;
Reichart, D.;
Rhoads, J.;
Rol, E.;
Smail, I.;
Tanvir, N. R.;
Postigo, A. de Ugarte;
Vreeswijk, P. M.;
Wijers, R. A. M. J.;
Heuvel, E. P. J. van den
Submitted: 2004-08-03, last modified: 2004-08-13
We report results from a comprehensive follow-up observing campaign of the
afterglow of GRB 030226, including VLT spectroscopy, VLT polarimetry, and
Chandra X-ray observations. In addition, we present BOOTES-1 wide-field
observations at the time of the occurrence of the burst. First observations at
ESO started 0.2 days after the event when the GRB afterglow was at a magnitude
of R~19 and continued until the afterglow had faded below the detection
threshold (R>26). No underlying host galaxy was found. The optical light curve
shows a break around 0.8 days after the burst, which is achromatic within the
observational errors, supporting the view that it was due to a jetted
explosion. Close to the break time the degree of linear polarization of the
afterglow light was less than 1.1%, which favors a uniform jet model rather
than a structured one. VLT spectra show two absorption line systems at
redshifts z=1.962+/-0.001 and at z=1.986+/-0.001, placing the lower limit for
the redshift of the GRB close to 2. We emphasize that the kinematics and the
composition of the absorbing clouds responsible for these line systems is very
similar to those observed in the afterglow of GRB 021004. This corroborates the
picture in which at least some GRBs are physically related to the explosion of
a Wolf-Rayet star.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0407439 [pdf] - 66281
The line-of-sight towards GRB 030429 at z = 2.66: Probing the matter at
stellar, galactic and intergalactic scales
Jakobsson, P.;
Hjorth, J.;
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Weidinger, M.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Ledoux, C.;
Watson, D.;
Bjornsson, G.;
Gudmundsson, E. H.;
Wijers, R. A. M. J.;
Moller, P.;
Pedersen, K.;
Sollerman, J.;
Henden, A. A.;
Jensen, B. L.;
Gilmore, A.;
Kilmartin, P.;
Levan, A.;
Cerón, J. M. Castro;
Castro-Tirado, A. J.;
Fruchter, A.;
Kouveliotou, C.;
Masetti, N.;
Tanvir, N.
Submitted: 2004-07-20
We report the discovery of the optical afterglow (OA) of the long-duration
gamma-ray burst GRB 030429, and present a comprehensive optical/near-infrared
dataset used to probe the matter at different distance scales, i.e. in the
burst environment, in the host galaxy and in an intervening absorber. A break
in the afterglow light curve is seen approximately 1 day from the onset of the
burst. The light curve displays a significant deviation from a simple broken
power-law with a bright 1.5 magnitude bump with a duration of 2-3 days. The
optical/near-infrared spectral energy distribution is best fit with a power-law
with index beta = -0.36 +/- 0.12 reddened by an SMC-like extinction law with (a
modest) A_V = 0.34 +/- 0.04. In addition, we present deep spectroscopic
observations obtained with the Very Large Telescope. The redshift measured via
metal absorption lines in the OA is z = 2.658 +/- 0.004. Based on the damped
Ly-alpha absorption line in the OA spectrum we measure the HI column density to
be log N(HI) = 21.6 +/- 0.2. This confirms the trend that GRBs tend to be
located behind very large HI column densities. The resulting dust-to-gas ratio
is consistent with that found in the SMC, indicating a low metallicity and/or a
low dust-to-metal ratio in the burst environment. We find that a neighbouring
galaxy, at a separation of only 1.2", has z = 0.841 +/- 0.001, ruling it out as
the host of GRB 030429. The small impact parameter of this nearby galaxy, which
is responsible for MgII absorption in the OA spectrum, is in contrast to
previous identifications of most QSO absorption-selected galaxy counterparts.
Finally, we demonstrate that the OA was not affected by strong gravitational
lensing via the nearby galaxy.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0403451 [pdf] - 63642
The supernova 2003lw associated with X-ray flash 031203
Thomsen, B.;
Hjorth, J.;
Watson, D.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Jensen, B. L.;
Andersen, M. I.;
Dall, T. H.;
Rasmussen, J. R.;
Bruntt, H.;
Laurikainen, E.;
Augusteijn, T.;
Pursimo, T.;
Germany, L.;
Jakobsson, P.;
Pedersen, K.
Submitted: 2004-03-18, last modified: 2004-04-04
The X-Ray Flash (XRF), 031203 with a host galaxy at z=0.1055, is, apart from
GRB980425, the closest Gamma-Ray Burst (GRB) or XRF known to date. We monitored
its host galaxy from 1-100 days after the burst. In spite of the high
extinction to the source and the bright host, a significant increase and
subsequent decrease has been detected in the apparent brightness of the host,
peaking between 10 and 33 days after the GRB. The only convincing explanation
is a supernova (SN) associated with the XRF, SN2003lw. This is the earliest
time at which a SN signal is clearly discernible in a GRB/XRF (apart from
SN1998bw). SN2003lw is extremely luminous with a broad peak and can be
approximately represented by the lightcurve of SN1998bw brightened by ~0.55
mag, implying a hypernova, as observed in most GRB-SNe. The XRF-SN association
firmly links XRFs with the deaths of massive stars and further strengthens
their connection with GRBs. The fact that SNe are also associated with XRFs
implies that Swift may detect a significant population of intermediate redshift
SNe very soon after the SN explosions, a sample ideally suited for detailed
studies of early SN physics.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0401225 [pdf] - 386181
A very low luminosity X-ray flash: XMM-Newton observations of GRB 031203
Watson, D.;
Hjorth, J.;
Levan, A.;
Jakobsson, P.;
O'Brien, P. T.;
Osborne, J. P.;
Pedersen, K.;
Reeves, J. N.;
Tedds, J. A.;
Vaughan, S. A.;
Ward, M. J.;
Willingale, R.
Submitted: 2004-01-12, last modified: 2004-03-19
GRB031203 was observed by XMM-Newton twice, first with an observation
beginning 6 hours after the burst, and again after 3 days. The afterglow had
average 0.2-10.0keV fluxes for the first and second observations of
4.2+/-0.1x10^-13 and 1.8+/-0.1x10^-13 erg/cm^2/s respectively, decaying very
slowly according to a power-law with an index of -0.55+/-0.05. The prompt soft
X-ray flux, inferred from a detection of the dust echo of the prompt emission,
strongly implies that this burst is very soft and should be classified as an
X-ray flash (XRF) and further, implies a steep temporal slope (<~-1.7) between
the prompt and afterglow phases or in the early afterglow, very different from
the later afterglow decay slope. A power-law (Gamma=1.90+/-0.05) with
absorption at a level consistent with the Galactic foreground absorption fits
the afterglow spectrum well. A bright, low-redshift (z=0.105) galaxy lies
within 0.5 arcsec of the X-ray position and is likely to be the GRB host. At
this redshift, GRB031203 is the closest GRB or XRF known after GRB980425. It
has a very low equivalent isotropic gamma-ray energy in the burst (~3x10^49
erg) and X-ray luminosity in the afterglow (9x10^42 erg/s at 10 hours), 3-4
orders of magnitude less than typical bursts, though higher than either the
faint XRF020903 or GRB980425. The rapid initial decline and subsequent very
slow fading of the X-ray afterglow is also similar to that observed in
GRB980425, indicating that GRB031203 may be representative of low luminosity
bursts.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0401621 [pdf] - 62491
Small-scale variations in the radiating surface of the GRB 011211 jet
Jakobsson, P.;
Hjorth, J.;
Ramirez-Ruiz, E.;
Kouveliotou, C.;
Pedersen, K.;
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Watson, D.;
Jensen, B. L.;
Grav, T.;
Hansen, M. W.;
Michelsen, R.;
Andersen, M. I.;
Weidinger, M.;
Pedersen, H.
Submitted: 2004-01-29
We report the discovery of the afterglow of the X-ray rich, long-duration
gamma-ray burst GRB 011211 and present evidence for oscillatory behaviour in
its early optical light curve. The time-scale of the fluctuations, ~1 hour, is
much smaller than the time of the observations, ~12 hours from the onset of the
gamma-ray burst. The character and strength of the fluctuations are
unprecedented and are inconsistent with causally connected variations in the
emission of a symmetric, relativistic blast wave, i.e. flux variations which
are produced uniformly throughout the shell surface are ruled out. Therefore,
the wiggles are the result of spherically asymmetric density or energy
variations. Additionally, there is evidence for fluctuations in the X-ray
afterglow light curve. If real, the resulting difference in the observed time
of the peaks of the short-term variations at X-ray and optical frequencies,
would demonstrate that the energy content across the jet-emitting surface is
not uniform.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0310635 [pdf] - 60298
High-redshift X-ray properties of the haloes of simulated disc galaxies
Submitted: 2003-10-22, last modified: 2004-01-07
X-ray luminosities and surface brightness profiles of the hot gas haloes of
simulated disc galaxies at redshifts z=0-2 are presented. The galaxies are
extracted from fully cosmological simulations and correspond in mass to the
Milky Way. We find that the bolometric X-ray luminosities of the haloes
decrease by a factor 4-10 from z~1 to z~0, reflecting the decrease in the rate
at which hot halo gas cools out on to the disc. At all redshifts, most of the
emission is found to originate within 10-15 kpc of the disc. When combined with
models in which the evolution of disc X-ray luminosity is dominated by X-ray
binaries, the predicted halo luminosities at z~1 show good agreement with
constraints from spiral galaxies in Chandra Deep Field data. There is an
indication that haloes with a metal abundance of 0.3 solar overpredict observed
X-ray luminosities at z~1, suggesting that halo metallicities are lower than
this value. Prospects for direct detection of the haloes of Milky Way-sized
galaxies with current and future X-ray instrumentation are discussed. It is
found that XEUS should be able to single out the halo emission of highly
inclined Milky Way-sized disc galaxies out to approximately z=0.3. For such
galaxies in this redshift interval, we estimate a lower limit to the surface
density of detectable haloes on the sky of ~10 deg^(-2). More generally, owing
to their luminosity evolution, the optimum redshifts at which to observe such
haloes could be 0.5<z<1, depending on their assembly history.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0307222 [pdf] - 57935
The afterglow and the host galaxy of GRB 011211
Jakobsson, P.;
Hjorth, J.;
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Pedersen, K.;
Burud, I.;
Levan, A.;
Kouveliotou, C.;
Tanvir, N.;
Fruchter, A.;
Rhoads, J.;
Grav, T.;
Hansen, M. W.;
Michelsen, R.;
Andersen, M. I.;
Jensen, B. L.;
Pedersen, H.;
Thomsen, B.;
Weidinger, M.;
Bhargavi, S. G.;
Cowsik, R.;
Pandey, S. B.
Submitted: 2003-07-10
We present optical, near-infrared, and X-ray observations of the optical
afterglow (OA) of the X-ray rich, long-duration gamma-ray burst GRB 011211.
Hubble Space Telescope (HST) data obtained 14, 26, 32, and 59 days after the
burst, show the host galaxy to have a morphology that is fairly typical of blue
galaxies at high redshift. We measure its magnitude to be R = 24.95 +/- 0.11.
We detect a break in the OA R-band light curve which is naturally accounted for
by a collimated outflow geometry. By fitting a broken power-law to the data we
find a best fit with a break 1.56 +/- 0.02 days after the burst, a pre-break
slope of alpha_1 = -0.95 +/- 0.02, and a post-break slope of alpha_2 = -2.11
+/- 0.07. The UV-optical spectral energy distribution (SED) around 14 hours
after the burst is best fit with a power-law with index beta = -0.56 +/- 0.19
reddened by an SMC-like extinction law with a modest A_V = 0.08 +/- 0.08 mag.
By comparison, from the XMM-Newton X-ray data at around the same time, we find
a decay index of alpha_X = -1.62 +/- 0.36 and a spectral index of beta_X =
-1.21 +0.10/-0.15. Interpolating between the UV-optical and X-ray implies that
the cooling frequency is located close to ~10^16 Hz in the observer frame at
the time of the observations. We argue, using the various temporal and spectral
indices above, that the most likely afterglow model is that of a jet expanding
into an external environment that has a constant mean density rather than a
wind-fed density structure. We estimate the electron energy index for this
burst to be p ~ 2.3.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0306347 [pdf] - 122425
A very energetic supernova associated with the gamma-ray burst of 29
March 2003
Hjorth, Jens;
Sollerman, Jesper;
Møller, Palle;
Fynbo, Johan P. U.;
Woosley, Stan E.;
Kouveliotou, Chryssa;
Tanvir, Nial R.;
Greiner, Jochen;
Andersen, Michael I.;
Castro-Tirado, Alberto J.;
Cerón, José María Castro;
Fruchter, Andrew S.;
Gorosabel, Javier;
Jakobsson, Páll;
Kaper, Lex;
Klose, Sylvio;
Masetti, Nicola;
Pedersen, Holger;
Pedersen, Kristian;
Pian, Elena;
Palazzi, Eliana;
Rhoads, James E.;
Rol, Evert;
Heuvel, Edward P. J. van den;
Vreeswijk, Paul M.;
Watson, Darach;
Wijers, Ralph A. M. J.
Submitted: 2003-06-17
Over the past five years evidence has mounted that long-duration (> 2 s)
gamma-ray bursts (GRBs)--the most brilliant of all astronomical
explosions--signal the collapse of massive stars in our Universe. This evidence
was originally based on the probable association of one unusual GRB with a
supernova, but now includes the association of GRBs with regions of massive
star formation in distant galaxies, the appearance of supernova-like 'bumps' in
the optical afterglow light curves of several bursts and lines of freshly
synthesized elements in the spectra of a few X-ray afterglows. These
observations support, but do not yet conclusively demonstrate, the idea that
long-duration GRBs are associated with the deaths of massive stars, presumably
arising from core collapse. Here we report evidence that a very energetic
supernova (a hypernova) was temporally and spatially coincident with a GRB at
redshift z = 0.1685. The timing of the supernova indicates that it exploded
within a few days of the GRB, strongly suggesting that core-collapse events can
give rise to GRBs, thereby favouring the 'collapsar' model.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0306284 [pdf] - 57365
Delayed soft X-ray emission lines in the afterglow of GRB 030227
Submitted: 2003-06-13, last modified: 2003-06-14
Strong, delayed X-ray line emission is detected in the afterglow of GRB
030227, appearing near the end of the XMM-Newton observation, nearly twenty
hours after the burst. The observed flux in the lines, not simply the
equivalent width, sharply increases from an undetectable level (<1.7e-14
erg/cm^2/s, 3 sigma) to 4.1e-14 erg/cm^2/s in the final 9.7 ks. The line
emission alone has nearly twice as many detected photons as any previous
detection of X-ray lines. The lines correspond well to hydrogen and/or
helium-like emission from Mg, Si, S, Ar and Ca at a redshift z=1.39. There is
no evidence for Fe, Co or Ni--the ultimate iron abundance must be less than a
tenth that of the lighter metals. If the supernova and GRB events are nearly
simultaneous there must be continuing, sporadic power output after the GRB of a
luminosity >~5e46 erg/s, exceeding all but the most powerful quasars.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0208050 [pdf] - 50866
Weak Gravitational Lensing by a Sample of X-ray Luminous Clusters of
Galaxies -- III. Serendipitous Weak Lensing Detections of Dark and Luminous
Mass Concentrations
Submitted: 2002-08-02, last modified: 2003-04-04
In the course of a weak gravitational lensing survey of 39 clusters of
galaxies,covering a total sky area of ~1 square degree, we have serendipitously
discovered mass concentrations in the fields of A1705 and A1722 which are most
probably not associated with the main cluster target. By combining weak lensing
information with two-color galaxy photometry in fields centered on our sample
clusters, we identify a new cluster candidate at z~0.5 in the field of A1705.
This cluster candidate also displays strong lensing in the form of a giant
luminous arc. The new mass concentration in the field of A1722 also seems to be
associated with an optically luminous cluster of galaxies at z~0.5, but in this
case there is some evidence for additional structures along the line of sight
that may contribute to the lensing signal. A third cluster, A959, has a dark
sub-clump which shows interesting morphological evidence in the mass map for
being associated with the main cluster. This is the first case where there is
any significant evidence for a physical association between a dark sub-clump
(discovered from weak lensing) and a normal cluster. Analysis of archival X-ray
data shows that the three new mass concentrations are not firmly detected in
X-rays and that they are X-ray underluminous.
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0303663 [pdf] - 55902
Discovery of an overdensity of faint red galaxies in the vicinity of the
z=1.786 radio galaxy 3C 294
Submitted: 2003-03-31
We report the discovery of an overdensity of faint red galaxies in the
vicinity of the z=1.786 radio galaxy 3C 294. The overdensity, discovered in a
84 min Ks-band ISAAC/VLT image is significant at the 2.4 sigma level (compared
to the local field density), and overlaps with the extended X-ray emission
around 3C 294 detected with the Chandra X-ray Observatory. The near-infrared
colours of the galaxies making up the overdensity show a large scatter and the
galaxies do not follow a red sequence in the colour magnitude diagram. If the
galaxies are in a cluster at z=1.786 they must be dominated by young stellar
populations with different star-formation histories.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0211094 [pdf] - 52829
Optical Photometry of GRB 021004: The First Month
Holland, Stephen T.;
Weidinger, Michael;
Fynbo, Johan P. U.;
Gorosabel, Javier;
Hjorth, Jens;
Pedersen, Kristian;
Alvarez, Javier Mendez;
Augusteijn, Thomas;
Cerón, J. M. Castro;
Castro-Tirado, Alberto;
Dahle, Haakon;
Egholm, M. P.;
Jakobsson, Pall;
Jensen, Brian L.;
Levan, Andrew;
Moller, Palle;
Pedersen, Holger;
Pursimo, Tapio;
Ruiz-Lapuente, Pilar;
Thomsen, Bjarne
Submitted: 2002-11-05, last modified: 2003-02-12
We present U,B,V,R_C,and I_C photometry of the optical afterglow of the
gamma-ray burst GRB 021004 taken at the Nordic Optical Telescope between
approximately eight hours and 30 days after the burst. This data is combined
with an analysis of the 87 ksec Chandra X-ray observations of GRB 021004 taken
at a mean epoch of 33 hours after the burst to investigate the nature of this
GRB. We find an intrinsic spectral slope at optical wavelengths of beta_UH =
0.39 +/- 0.12 and an X-ray slope of beta_X = 0.94 +/- 0.03. There is no
evidence for colour evolution between 8.5 hours and 5.5 days after the burst.
The optical decay becomes steeper approximately five days after the burst. This
appears to be a gradual break due to the onset of sideways expansion in a
collimated outflow. Our data suggest that the extra-galactic extinction along
the line of sight to the burst is between A_V = 0.3 and A_V = 0.5 and has an
extinction law similar to that of the Small Magellanic Cloud. The optical and
X-ray data are consistent with a relativistic fireball with the shocked
electrons being in the slow cooling regime and having an electron index of p =
1.9 +/- 0.1. The burst occurred in an ambient medium that is homogeneous on
scales larger than approximately 10e18 cm but inhomogeneous on smaller scales.
The mean particle density is similar to what is seen for other bursts (0.1 < n
< 100 cm^{-3}). Our results support the idea that the brightening seen
approximately 0.1 days was due to interaction with a clumpy ambient medium
within 10^{17} and 10^{18} cm of the progenitor. The agreement between the
predicted optical decay and that observed approximately ten minutes after the
burst suggests that the physical mechanism controlling the observed flux
approximately ten minutes is the same as the one operating at t > 0.5 days.
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0210654 [pdf] - 52692
Absorption Systems in the Spectrum of GRB 021004
Møller, P.;
Fynbo, J. P. U.;
Hjorth, J.;
Thomsen, B.;
Egholm, M. P.;
Andersen, M. I.;
Gorosabel, J.;
Holland, S. T.;
Jakobsson, P.;
Jensen, B. L.;
Pedersen, H.;
Pedersen, K.;
Weidinger, M.
Submitted: 2002-10-30
We report on a 3600 s spectrum of GRB 021004 obtained with the Nordic Optical
Telecope on La Palma 10.71 hours after the burst. We identify absorption lines
from five systems at redshifts 1.3806, 1.6039, 2.2983, 2.3230, and 2.3292. In
addition we find an emission line which, if due to Ly-alpha from the host
galaxy, gives a redshift of 2.3351. The nearest absorber is blueshifted by 530
km/s with respect to this line, consistent with shifts seen in Damped Ly-alpha
and Lyman-Break galaxies at similar redshifts. The emission line flux is
2.46+-0.50 x 10^-16 erg/s/cm^2. Some of the absorption systems are
"line-locked", an effect often seen in QSO absorption systems believed to
originate close to the QSO central engine.
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0210514 [pdf] - 52552
X-ray, Ly-alpha and H-alpha Emission from Simulated Disk Galaxies
Submitted: 2002-10-23
The X-ray properties of the haloes of disk galaxies formed in fully
cosmological, hydro/gravity simulations are discussed. The results are found to
be consistent with observational X-ray detections and upper limits. Disk galaxy
haloes are predicted to be about an order of magnitude brighter in soft X-rays
at z~1 than at z=0. The Ly-alpha and H-alpha surface brightness of an edge-on,
Milky Way like model galaxy has been determined. The emission is found to be
quite extended, with a scale height of about 600 pc, neglecting extinction
corrections.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0209585 [pdf] - 51991
The Afterglow of GRB010222: A Case of Continuous Energy Injection
Submitted: 2002-09-27
The optical lightcurve of GRB010222 exhibited one of the slowest decays of
any gamma-ray burst to date. Its broadband properties have been difficult to
explain with conventional afterglow models, as they either require the power
law index of the underlying electron energy distribution to be low, $p<2$, or
that the outflow is quasi-spherical thus reviving the energy problem. We argue
that the slow decay of GRB 010222 and a linear polarization of $1.36\pm 0.64$%,
is naturally explained by a jet model with continuous energy injection. The
electron energy distribution then has $p=2.49\pm0.05$, fully consistent with
the expectation from detailed modelling of acceleration in relativistic shocks,
that $p>2$, thus alleviating the ``$p$-problem''.
[55]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0202022 [pdf] - 47517
Source Detection in Simulated XMM-Newton Observations
Submitted: 2002-02-01
We present preliminary results from our on-going study: Comparing and
optimizing source detection procedures for XMM images. By constructing
realistic spatial and spectral source distributions and ``observing'' these
through the XMM Science Simulator we study how source characteristics and
instrumental effects influence detection. We are currently undertaking a
statistical analysis on the outcome of running source detection algorithms on
the simulated EPIC pn and MOS images in various energy bands. Particular
emphasis is on the efficiency and reliability for detecting the faint, extended
emission from distant clusters of galaxies. Here we present simulated EPIC
images applicable to the XMM Large-scale Structure Survey (10 ksec pointings of
``blank fields''). However, we emphasize that our procedure is flexible,
including as many realistic source characteristics and instrumental effects as
possible, and yet modest in computational demand. As such it can be used for
simulating XMM data obtained from virtually any X-ray source. All simulation
products are made available at our website (http://www.astro.ku.dk/xcosmos/).
[56]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0201529 [pdf] - 47473
X-ray Emission from Haloes of Simulated Disc Galaxies
Submitted: 2002-01-31
Bolometric and 0.2-2 keV X-ray luminosities of the hot gas haloes of
simulated disc galaxies have been calculated at redshift z=0. The TreeSPH
simulations are fully cosmological and the sample of 44 disc galaxies span a
range in characteristic circular speeds of V_c = 130-325 km/s. The galaxies
have been obtained in simulations with a considerable range of physical
parameters, varying the baryonic fraction, the gas metallicity, the
meta-galactic UV field, the cosmology, the dark matter type, and also the
numerical resolution. The models are found to be in agreement with the (few)
relevant X-ray observations available at present. The amount of hot gas in the
haloes is also consistent with constraints from pulsar dispersion measures in
the Milky Way. Forthcoming XMM and Chandra observations should enable much more
stringent tests and provide constraints on the physical parameters. We find
that simple cooling flow models over-predict X-ray luminosities by up to two
orders of magnitude for high (but still realistic) cooling efficiencies
relative to the models presented here. Our results display a clear trend that
increasing cooling efficiency leads to decreasing X-ray luminosities at z=0.
The reason is found to be that increased cooling efficiency leads to a
decreased fraction of hot gas relative to total baryonic mass inside of the
virial radius at present. At gas metal abundances of a third solar this hot gas
fraction becomes as low as just a few percent. We also find that most of the
X-ray emission comes from the inner parts (inner about 20 kpc) of the hot
galactic haloes. Finally, we find for realistic choices of the physical
parameters that disc galaxy haloes possibly were more than one order of
magnitude brighter in soft X-ray emission at z=1, than at present.
[57]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0105487 [pdf] - 42716
Constraints on a Local Group X-ray Halo
Submitted: 2001-05-28
A simple model for a hot Local Group halo is constructed, using the standard
beta-model for the halo density and by choosing model parameters based on all
available observations of X-ray emission in other groups of galaxies and on
optical data on Local Group morphology. From the predicted X-ray intensities,
total Local Group mass, and central cooling time of the halo, we derive very
conservative upper limits on the central halo density N_0 and global
temperature T of N_0 = 5e-4 cm-3 and kT = 0.5 keV, irrespective of realistic
values of the density profile parameters r_c and beta. A typical poor group
value of beta = 0.5 requires kT < 0.15 keV and N_0 < 1e-4 cm-3, from which it
is concluded that the Local Group is very unlikely to possess a significant
X-ray halo. The prospects for further constraining of halo parameters from UV
absorption line observations are considered. We explicitly calculate the
ability of the halo to distort the cosmic microwave background (CMB) in terms
of the resulting CMB temperature variations and multipole anisotropies.
[58]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0002403 [pdf] - 34746
ISO far-infrared observations of rich galaxy clusters II. Sersic 159-03
Submitted: 2000-02-22
The far-infrared emission from rich galaxy clusters is investigated. Maps
have been obtained by ISO at 60, 100, 135, and 200 microns using the PHT-C
camera. Ground based imaging and spectroscopy were also acquired. Here we
present the results for the cooling flow cluster Sersic 159-03. An infrared
source coincident with the dominant cD galaxy is found. Some off-center sources
are also present, but without any obvious counterparts.
[59]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9705217 [pdf] - 97479
A new measurement of the baryonic fraction using the sparse NGC 3258
group of galaxies
Submitted: 1997-05-27
New X-ray observations of the sparse NGC 3258 group of galaxies made by the
ASCA satellite with good spectral and spatial resolution has revealed that this
group has a gravitational potential deep enough to prohibit significant mass
removal from the system. The baryonic fraction within 240 kpc is found to be
0.065 +0.051/-0.020 for h_{50}=1, where h_{50}=H_0/50 km/s/Mpc, in good
agreement with the universal value of 0.05 +/-0.01 predicted by standard Big
Bang nucleosynthesis for a Universe with Omega_0=1 and h_{50}=1. Since the deep
potential of the NGC 3258 group ensures that all pristine intragroup gas has
been retained, the baryonic fraction of the NGC 3258 group is indicative of the
universal value. Consequently it seems premature to rule out a critical
Universe.