Normalized to: Pan, M.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.14506 [pdf] - 2129454
Near Mean Motion Resonance of Terrestrial Planet Pair Induced by Giant
Planet: Application to Kepler-68 System
Submitted: 2020-06-25
In this work, we investigate configuration formation of two inner terrestrial
planets near mean motion resonance (MMRs) induced by the perturbation of a
distant gas-giant for the Kepler-68 system, by conducting thousands of
numerical simulations. The results show that the formation of terrestrial
planets is relevant to the speed of Type I migration, the mass of planets, and
the existence of giant planet. The mass and eccentricity of the giant planet
may play a crucial role in shaping the final configuration of the system. The
inner planet pair can be trapped in 5:3 or 7:4 MMRs if the giant planet
revolves the central star with an eccentric orbit, which is similar to the
observed configuration of Kepler-68. Moreover, we find that the eccentricity of
the middle planet can be excited to roughly 0.2 if the giant planet is more
massive than 5 $M_J$,otherwise the terrestrial planets are inclined to remain
near-circular orbits. Our study may provide a likely formation scenario for the
planetary systems that harbor several terrestrial planets near MMRs inside and
one gas-giant exterior to them.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.00027 [pdf] - 1871561
The Mass of Stirring Bodies in the AU Mic Debris Disk Inferred from
Resolved Vertical Structure
Daley, Cail;
Hughes, A. Meredith;
Carter, Evan S.;
Flaherty, Kevin;
Lambros, Zachary;
Pan, Margaret;
Schlichting, Hilke;
Chiang, Eugene;
Wyatt, Mark;
Wilner, David;
Andrews, Sean;
Carpenter, John
Submitted: 2019-03-29, last modified: 2019-04-08
The vertical distribution of dust in debris disks is sensitive to the number
and size of large planetesimals dynamically stirring the disk, and is therefore
well-suited for constraining the prevalence of otherwise unobservable Uranus
and Neptune analogs. Information regarding stirring bodies has previously been
inferred from infrared and optical observations of debris disk vertical
structure, but theoretical works predict that the small particles traced by
short-wavelength observations will be `puffed up' by radiation pressure,
yielding only upper limits. The large grains that dominate the disk emission at
millimeter wavelengths are much less sensitive to the effects of stellar
radiation or stellar winds, and therefore trace the underlying mass
distribution more directly. Here we present ALMA 1.3 mm dust continuum
observations of the debris disk around the nearby M star AU Mic. The 3 au
spatial resolution of the observations, combined with the favorable edge-on
geometry of the system, allows us to measure the vertical thickness of the
disk. We report a scale height-to-radius aspect ratio of $h =
0.031_{-0.004}^{+0.005}$ between radii of $\sim 23$ au and $\sim 41$ au.
Comparing this aspect ratio to a theoretical model of size-dependent velocity
distributions in the collisional cascade, we find that the perturbing bodies
embedded in the local disk must be larger than about 400 km, and the largest
perturbing body must be smaller than roughly 1.8 M$_\odot$. These measurements
rule out the presence of a gas giant or Neptune analog near the $\sim 40$ au
outer edge of the debris ring, but are suggestive of large planetesimals or an
Earth-sized planet stirring the dust distribution.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.05867 [pdf] - 1583503
A Complete ALMA Map of the Fomalhaut Debris Disk
MacGregor, Meredith A.;
Matra, Luca;
Kalas, Paul;
Wilner, David J.;
Pan, Margaret;
Kennedy, Grant M.;
Wyatt, Mark C.;
Duchene, Gaspard;
Hughes, A. Meredith;
Rieke, George H.;
Clampin, Mark;
Fitzgerald, Michael P.;
Graham, James R.;
Holland, Wayne S.;
Panic, Olja;
Shannon, Andrew;
Su, Kate
Submitted: 2017-05-16
We present ALMA mosaic observations at 1.3 mm (223 GHz) of the Fomalhaut
system with a sensitivity of 14 $\mu$Jy/beam. These observations provide the
first millimeter map of the continuum dust emission from the complete outer
debris disk with uniform sensitivity, enabling the first conclusive detection
of apocenter glow. We adopt a MCMC modeling approach that accounts for the
eccentric orbital parameters of a collection of particles within the disk. The
outer belt is radially confined with an inner edge of $136.3\pm0.9$ AU and
width of $13.5\pm1.8$ AU. We determine a best-fit eccentricity of
$0.12\pm0.01$. Assuming a size distribution power law index of $q=3.46\pm
0.09$, we constrain the dust absorptivity power law index $\beta$ to be
$0.9<\beta<1.5$. The geometry of the disk is robustly constrained with
inclination $65.\!\!^\circ6\pm0.\!\!^\circ3$, position angle
$337.\!\!^\circ9\pm0.\!\!^\circ3$, and argument of periastron
$22.\!\!^\circ5\pm4.\!\!^\circ3$. Our observations do not confirm any of the
azimuthal features found in previous imaging studies of the disk with HST,
SCUBA, and ALMA. However, we cannot rule out structures $\leq10$ AU in size or
which only affect smaller grains. The central star is clearly detected with a
flux density of $0.75\pm0.02$ mJy, significantly lower than predicted by
current photospheric models. We discuss the implications of these observations
for the directly imaged Fomalhaut b and the inner dust belt detected at
infrared wavelengths.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.05868 [pdf] - 1583504
Detection of exocometary CO within the 440 Myr-old Fomalhaut belt: a
similar CO+CO$_2$ ice abundance in exocomets and Solar System comets
Matrà, L.;
MacGregor, M. A.;
Kalas, P.;
Wyatt, M. C.;
Kennedy, G. M.;
Wilner, D. J.;
Duchene, G.;
Hughes, A. M.;
Pan, M.;
Shannon, A.;
Clampin, M.;
Fitzgerald, M. P.;
Graham, J. R.;
Holland, W. S.;
Panić, O.;
Su, K. Y. L.
Submitted: 2017-05-16
Recent ALMA observations present mounting evidence for the presence of
exocometary gas released within Kuiper belt analogues around nearby main
sequence stars. This represents a unique opportunity to study their ice
reservoir at the younger ages when volatile delivery to planets is most likely
to occur. We here present the detection of CO J=2-1 emission co-located with
dust emission from the cometary belt in the 440 Myr-old Fomalhaut system.
Through spectro-spatial filtering, we achieve a 5.4$\sigma$ detection and
determine that the ring's sky-projected rotation axis matches that of the star.
The CO mass derived ($0.65-42 \times10^{-7}$ M$_{\oplus}$) is the lowest of any
circumstellar disk detected to date, and must be of exocometary origin. Using a
steady state model, we estimate the CO+CO$_2$ mass fraction of exocomets around
Fomalhaut to be between 4.6-76%, consistent with Solar System comets and the
two other belts known to host exocometary gas. This is the first indication of
a similarity in cometary compositions across planetary systems that may be
linked to their formation scenario and is consistent with direct ISM
inheritance. In addition, we find tentative evidence that $(49\pm 27)$% of the
detected flux originates from a region near the eccentric belt's pericentre. If
confirmed, the latter may be explained through a recent impact event or CO
pericentre glow due to exocometary release within a steady state collisional
cascade. In the latter scenario, we show how the azimuthal dependence of the CO
release rate leads to asymmetries in gas observations of eccentric exocometary
belts.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.07836 [pdf] - 1570359
Avoiding resonance capture in multi-planet extrasolar systems
Submitted: 2017-04-25, last modified: 2017-04-28
A commonly noted feature of the population of multi-planet extrasolar systems
is the rarity of planet pairs in low-order mean-motion resonances. We revisit
the physics of resonance capture via convergent disk-driven migration. We point
out that for planet spacings typical of stable configurations for Kepler
systems, the planets can routinely maintain a small but nonzero eccentricity
due to gravitational perturbations from their neighbors. Together with the
upper limit on the migration rate needed for capture, the finite eccentricity
can make resonance capture difficult or impossible in Sun-like systems for
planets smaller than ~Neptune-sized. This mass limit on efficient capture is
broadly consistent with observed exoplanet pairs that have mass determinations:
of pairs with the heavier planet exterior to the lighter planet -- which would
have been undergoing convergent migration in their disks -- those in or nearly
in resonance are much more likely to have total mass greater than two Neptune
masses than to have smaller masses. The agreement suggests that the observed
paucity of resonant pairs around sun-like stars may simply arise from a small
resonance capture probability for lower-mass planets. Planet pairs that thereby
avoid resonance capture are much less likely to collide in an eventual close
approach than to simply migrate past one another to become a divergently
migrating pair with the lighter planet exterior. For systems around M stars we
expect resonant pairs to be much more common, since there the minimum mass
threshhold for efficient capture is about an Earth mass.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.06798 [pdf] - 1528115
Apocenter glow in eccentric debris disks: implications for Fomalhaut and
epsilon Eridani
Submitted: 2016-07-22, last modified: 2016-09-15
Debris disks often take the form of eccentric rings with azimuthal
asymmetries in surface brightness. Such disks are often described as showing
"pericenter glow", an enhancement of the disk brightness in regions nearest the
central star. At long wavelengths, however, the disk apocenters should appear
brighter than their pericenters: in the long wavelength limit, we find the
apocenter/pericenter flux ratio scales as 1+e for disk eccentricity e. We
produce new models of this "apocenter glow" to explore its causes and
wavelength dependence and study its potential as a probe of dust grain
properties. Based on our models, we argue that several far-infrared and
(sub)millimeter images of the Fomalhaut and epsilon Eridani debris rings
obtained with Herschel, JCMT, SHARC II, ALMA, and ATCA should be reinterpreted
as suggestions or examples of apocenter glow. This reinterpretation yields new
constraints on the disks' dust grain properties and size distributions.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.01769 [pdf] - 1392825
On the mass and origin of Chariklo's rings
Submitted: 2016-02-04
Observations in 2013 and 2014 of the Centaur 10199 Chariklo and its ring
system consistently indicated that the radial width of the inner, more massive
ring varies with longitude. That strongly suggests that this ring has a finite
eccentricity despite the fast differential precession that Chariklo's large
quadrupole moment should induce. If the inferred apse alignment is maintained
by the ring's self-gravity, as it is for the Uranian rings, we estimate a ring
mass of a few times 10^16 g and a typical particle size of a few meters. These
imply a short collisional spreading time of ~10^5 years, somewhat shorter than
the typical Centaur dynamical lifetime of a few Myrs and much shorter than the
age of the solar system. In light of this time constraint, we evaluate
previously suggested ring formation pathways including collisional ejection and
satellite disruption. We also investigate in detail a contrasting formation
mechanism, the lofting of dust particles off Chariklo's surface into orbit via
outflows of sublimating CO and/or N_2 triggered after Chariklo was scattered
inward by giant planets. This latter scenario predicts that rings should be
common among 100-km class Centaurs but rare among Kuiper belt objects and
smaller Centaurs. It also predicts that Centaurs should show seasonal
variations in cometary activity with activity maxima occurring shortly after
equinox.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.2289 [pdf] - 737365
SMACK: A New Algorithm for Modeling Collisions and Dynamics of
Planetesimals in Debris Disks
Submitted: 2013-09-09
We present the Superparticle Model/Algorithm for Collisions in Kuiper belts
and debris disks (SMACK), a new method for simultaneously modeling, in 3-D, the
collisional and dynamical evolution of planetesimals in a debris disk with
planets. SMACK can simulate azimuthal asymmetries and how these asymmetries
evolve over time. We show that SMACK is stable to numerical viscosity and
numerical heating over 10^7 yr, and that it can reproduce analytic models of
disk evolution. We use SMACK to model the evolution of a debris ring containing
a planet on an eccentric orbit. Differential precession creates a spiral
structure as the ring evolves, but collisions subsequently break up the spiral,
leaving a narrower eccentric ring.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.3583 [pdf] - 1124157
Stochastic flights of propellers
Submitted: 2012-06-15, last modified: 2012-08-30
Kilometer-sized moonlets in Saturn's A ring create S-shaped wakes called
"propellers" in surrounding material. The Cassini spacecraft has tracked the
motions of propellers for several years and finds that they deviate from
Keplerian orbits having constant semimajor axes. The inferred orbital migration
is known to switch sign. We show using a statistical test that the time series
of orbital longitudes of the propeller Bl\'eriot is consistent with that of a
time-integrated Gaussian random walk. That is, Bl\'eriot's observed migration
pattern is consistent with being stochastic. We further show, using a
combination of analytic estimates and collisional N-body simulations, that
stochastic migration of the right magnitude to explain the Cassini observations
can be driven by encounters with ring particles 10-20 m in radius. That the
local ring mass is concentrated in decameter-sized particles is supported on
independent grounds by occultation analyses.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.3972 [pdf] - 525951
Care and feeding of frogs
Submitted: 2012-06-18
"Propellers" are features in Saturn's A ring associated with moonlets that
open partial gaps. They exhibit non-Keplerian motion (Tiscareno 2010); the
longitude residuals of the best-observed propeller, "Bl\'eriot," appear
consistent with a sinusoid of period ~4 years. Pan and Chiang (2010) proposed
that propeller moonlets librate in "frog resonances" with co-orbiting ring
material. By analogy with the restricted three-body problem, they treated the
co-orbital material as stationary in the rotating frame and neglected
non-co-orbital material. Here we use simple numerical experiments to extend the
frog model, including feedback due to the gap's motion, and drag associated
with the Lindblad disk torques that cause Type I migration. Because the moonlet
creates the gap, we expect the gap centroid to track the moonlet, but only
after a time delay t_diff, the time for a ring particle to travel from
conjunction with the moonlet to the end of the gap. We find that frog
librations can persist only if t_diff exceeds the frog libration period P_lib,
and if damping from Lindblad torques balances driving from co-orbital torques.
If t_diff << P_lib, then the libration amplitude damps to zero. In the case of
Bl\'eriot, the frog resonance model can reproduce the observed libration period
P_lib ~ 4 yr. However, our simple feedback prescription suggests that
Bl\'eriot's t_diff ~ 0.01P_lib, which is inconsistent with the observed
libration amplitude of 260 km. We urge more accurate treatments of feedback to
test the assumptions of our toy models.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.0667 [pdf] - 1091375
Self-consistent size and velocity distributions of collisional cascades
Submitted: 2011-11-02
The standard theoretical treatment of collisional cascades derives a
steady-state size distribution assuming a single constant velocity dispersion
for all bodies regardless of size. Here we relax this assumption and solve
self-consistently for the bodies' steady-state size and size-dependent velocity
distributions. Specifically, we account for viscous stirring, dynamical
friction, and collisional damping of the bodies' random velocities in addition
to the mass conservation requirement typically applied to find the size
distribution in a steady-state cascade. The resulting size distributions are
significantly steeper than those derived without velocity evolution. For
example, accounting self-consistently for the velocities can change the
standard q=3.5 power-law index of the Dohnanyi (1969) differential size
spectrum to an index as large as q=4. Similarly, for bodies held together by
their own gravity, the corresponding power-law index range 2.88<q<3.14 of Pan &
Sari (2005) can steepen to values as large as q=3.26. Our velocity results
allow quantitative predictions of the bodies' scale heights as a function of
size. Together with our predictions, observations of the scale heights for
different sized bodies for the Kuiper belt, the asteroid belt, and extrasolar
debris disks may constrain the mass and number of large bodies stirring the
cascade as well as the colliding bodies' internal strengths.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1009.1874 [pdf] - 1034851
The propeller and the frog
Submitted: 2010-09-09
"Propellers" in planetary rings are disturbances in ring material excited by
moonlets that open only partial gaps. We describe a new type of co-orbital
resonance that can explain the observed non-Keplerian motions of propellers.
The resonance is between the moonlet underlying the propeller, and co-orbiting
ring particles downstream of the moonlet where the gap closes. The moonlet
librates within the gap about an equilibrium point established by co-orbiting
material and stabilized by the Coriolis force. In the limit of small libration
amplitude, the libration period scales linearly with the gap azimuthal width
and inversely as the square root of the co-orbital mass. The new resonance
recalls but is distinct from conventional horseshoe and tadpole orbits; we call
it the "frog" resonance, after the relevant term in equine hoof anatomy. For a
ring surface density and gap geometry appropriate for the propeller Bl\'eriot
in Saturn's A ring, our theory predicts a libration period of ~4 years, similar
to the ~3.7 year period over which Bl\'eriot's orbital longitude is observed to
vary. These librations should be subtracted from the longitude data before any
inferences about moonlet migration are made.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1008.4152 [pdf] - 1034475
Observational biases in determining extrasolar planet eccentricities in
single-planet systems
Submitted: 2010-08-24
We investigate potential biases in the measurements of exoplanet orbital
parameters obtained from radial velocity observations for single-planet
systems. We create a mock catalog of radial velocity data, choosing input
planet masses, periods, and observing patterns from actual radial velocity
surveys and varying input eccentricities. We apply Markov Chain Monte Carlo
(MCMC) simulations and compare the resulting orbital parameters to the input
values. We find that a combination of the effective signal-to-noise ratio of
the data, the maximal gap in phase coverage, and the total number of periods
covered by observations is a good predictor of the quality of derived orbit
parameters. As eccentricity is positive definite, we find that eccentricities
of planets on nearly circular orbits are preferentially overestimated, with
typical bias of 1-2 times the median eccentricity uncertainty in a survey
(e.g., 0.04 in the Butler et al. 2006 catalog). When performing population
analysis, we recommend using the mode of the marginalized posterior
eccentricity distribution to minimize potential biases. While the Butler et al.
(2006) catalog reports eccentricities below 0.05 for just 17% of single-planet
systems, we estimate that the true fraction of e < 0.05 orbits is about
f(0.05)=38\pm 9%. For planets with P > 10 days, we find f(0.05)=28\pm 8% versus
10% from Butler et al. (2006). These planets either never acquired a large
eccentricity or were circularized following any significant eccentricity
excitation.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:0905.1986 [pdf] - 24215
Challenges facing young astrophysicists
Zakamska, N. L.;
Schulz, A. E.;
Heng, K.;
Juric, M.;
Kocsis, B.;
Kuhlen, M.;
Mandelbaum, R.;
Mitchell, J. L.;
Pan, M.;
Rudd, D. H.;
van de Ven, G.;
Zheng, Z.
Submitted: 2009-05-13
In order to attract and retain excellent researchers and diverse individuals
in astrophysics, we recommend action be taken in several key areas impacting
young scientists: (1) Maintain balance between large collaborations and
individual projects through distribution of funding; encourage public releases
of observational and simulation data for use by a broader community. (2)
Improve the involvement of women, particularly at leading institutions. (3)
Address the critical shortage of child care options and design reasonable
profession-wide parental leave policies. (4) Streamline the job application and
hiring process. We summarize our reasons for bringing these areas to the
attention of the committee, and we suggest several practical steps that can be
taken to address them.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:0802.3583 [pdf] - 1000641
Composite self-similar solutions for relativistic shocks: the transition
to cold fluid temperatures
Submitted: 2008-02-25
The flow resulting from a strong ultrarelativistic shock moving through a
stellar envelope with a polytrope-like density profile has been studied
analytically and numerically at early times while the fluid temperature is
relativistic--that is, just before and just after the shock breaks out of the
star. Such a flow should expand and accelerate as its internal energy is
converted to bulk kinetic energy; at late enough times, the assumption of
relativistic temperatures becomes invalid. Here we present a new self-similar
solution for the post-breakout flow when the accelerating fluid has bulk
kinetic Lorentz factors much larger than unity but is cooling through $p/n$ of
order unity to subrelativistic temperatures. This solution gives a relation
between a fluid element's terminal Lorentz factor and that element's Lorentz
factor just after it is shocked. Our numerical integrations agree well with the
solution. While our solution assumes a planar flow, we show that corrections
due to spherical geometry are important only for extremely fast ejecta
originating in a region very close to the stellar surface. This region grows if
the shock becomes relativistic deeper in the star.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0505176 [pdf] - 72946
Self-similar solutions for relativistic shocks emerging from stars with
polytropic envelopes
Submitted: 2005-05-09, last modified: 2005-05-10
We consider a strong ultrarelativistic shock moving through a star whose
envelope has a polytrope-like density profile. When the shock is close to the
star's outer boundary, its behavior follows the self-similar solution given by
Sari (2005) for implosions in planar geometry. Here we outline this solution
and find the asymptotic solution as the shock reaches the star's edge. We then
show that the motion after the shock breaks out of the star is described by a
self-similar solution remarkably like the solution for the motion inside the
star. In particular, the characteristic Lorentz factor, pressure, and density
vary with time according to the same power laws both before and after the shock
breaks out of the star. After emergence from the star, however, the
self-similar solution's characteristic position corresponds to a point behind
the leading edge of the flow rather than at the shock front, and the relevant
range of values for the similarity variable changes. Our numerical integrations
agree well with the analytic results both before and after the shock reaches
the star's edge.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0402138 [pdf] - 62652
Shaping the Kuiper belt size spectrum by shattering large but
strengthless bodies
Submitted: 2004-02-05
The observed size distribution of Kuiper belt objects (KBOs)--small icy and
rocky solar system bodies orbiting beyond Neptune--is well described by a power
law at large KBO sizes. However, recent work by Bernstein et al. (2003)
indicates that the size spectrum breaks and becomes shallower for KBOs smaller
than about 70 km in size. Here we show that we expect such a break at KBO
radius ~40 km since destructive collisions are frequent for smaller KBOs.
Specifically, we assume that KBOs are rubble piles with low material strength
rather than solid monoliths. This gives a power-law slope q~3 where the number
N(r) of KBOs larger than a size r is given by $N(r) \propto r^{1-q}$; the break
location follows from this slope through a self-consistent calculation. The
existence of this break, the break's location, and the power-law slope we
expect below the break are consistent with the findings of Bernstein et al.
(2003). The agreement with observations indicates that KBOs are effectively
strengthless rubble piles.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0302135 [pdf] - 54762
A generalization of the Lagrangian points: studies of resonance for
highly eccentric orbits
Submitted: 2003-02-06
We develop a framework based on energy kicks for the evolution of
high-eccentricity long-period orbits with Jacobi constant close to 3 in the
restricted circular planar three-body problem where the secondary and primary
masses have mass ratio mu << 1. We use this framework to explore mean-motion
resonances between the test particle and the secondary mass. This approach
leads to (i) a redefinition of resonance orders to reflect the importance of
interactions at periapse; (ii) a pendulum-like equation describing the
librations of resonance orbits; (iii) an analogy between these new fixed points
and the Lagrangian points as well as between librations around the fixed points
and the well known tadpole and horseshoe orbits; (iv) a condition a ~ mu^(-2/5)
for the onset of chaos at large semimajor axis a; (v) the existence of a range
mu < ~5 x 10^(-6) in secondary mass for which a test particle initially close
to the secondary cannot escape from the system, at least in the planar problem;
(vi) a simple explanation for the presence of asymmetric librations in exterior
1:N resonances.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0205511 [pdf] - 49585
An interferometric-spectroscopic orbit for the binary HD 195987: Testing
models of stellar evolution for metal-poor stars
Submitted: 2002-05-29
We report spectroscopic and interferometric observations of the moderately
metal-poor double-lined binary system HD 195987, with an orbital period of 57.3
days. By combining our radial-velocity and visibility measurements we determine
the orbital elements and derive absolute masses for the components of M(A) =
0.844 +/- 0.018 Msun and M(B) = 0.6650 +/- 0.0079 Msun, with relative errors of
2% and 1%, respectively. We also determine the orbital parallax, pi(orb) =
46.08 +/- 0.27 mas, corresponding to a distance of 21.70 +/- 0.13 pc. The
parallax and the measured brightness difference between the stars in V, H, and
K yield the component absolute magnitudes in those bands. We also estimate the
effective temperatures of the stars as Teff(A) = 5200 +/- 100 K and Teff(B) =
4200 +/- 200 K. Together with detailed chemical abundance analyses from the
literature giving [Fe/H] approximately -0.5 (corrected for binarity) and
[alpha/Fe] = +0.36, we use these physical properties to test current models of
stellar evolution for metal-poor stars. Among the four that we considered, we
find that no single model fits all observed properties at the measured
composition, although we identify the assumptions in each one that account for
the discrepancy and we conclude that a model with the proper combination of
assumptions should be able to reproduce all the radiative properties. The
indications from the isochrone fits and the pattern of enhancement of the
metals in HD 195987 are consistent with this being a thick disk object, with an
age of 10-12 Gyr.