Normalized to: Owen, J.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.03334 [pdf] - 2129532
A review of possible planetary atmospheres in the TRAPPIST-1 system
Submitted: 2020-07-07
TRAPPIST-1 is a fantastic nearby (~39.14 light years) planetary system made
of at least seven transiting terrestrial-size, terrestrial-mass planets all
receiving a moderate amount of irradiation. To date, this is the most
observationally favourable system of potentially habitable planets. Since the
announcement of the discovery of TRAPPIST-1 planets in 2016, a growing number
of techniques and approaches have been used and proposed to reveal its true
nature. Here we have compiled a state-of-the-art overview of all the
observational and theoretical constraints that have been obtained so far using
these techniques and approaches. The goal is to get a better understanding of
whether or not TRAPPIST-1 planets can have atmospheres, and if so, what they
are made of. For this, we surveyed the literature on TRAPPIST-1 about topics as
broad as irradiation environment, orbital architecture, transit observations,
density measurements, stellar contamination, and numerical climate and escape
models. Each of these topics adds a brick to our understanding of the likely
atmospheres of the seven planets. We show that (i) HST transit observations,
(ii) density measurements, (iii) atmospheric escape modelling, and (iv) gas
accretion modelling altogether offer solid evidence against the presence of
H2-dominated atmospheres around TRAPPIST-1 planets. This means they likely have
either (i) a high molecular weight atmosphere or (ii) no atmosphere at all.
There are several key challenges ahead to characterize the bulk compositions of
the atmospheres (if present) of TRAPPIST-1 planets. The main one so far is
characterizing and correcting for the effects of stellar contamination.
Fortunately, a new wave of observations with the James Webb Space Telescope and
near-infrared high-resolution ground-based spectrographs on very large
telescopes will bring significant advances in the coming decade.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2005.03665 [pdf] - 2097461
Snow-lines can be thermally unstable
Submitted: 2020-05-07
Volatile species in protoplanetary discs can undergo a phase change from
vapour to solid. These "snow-lines" can play vital roles in planet formation at
all scales, from dust coagulation to planetary migration. In the outer regions
of protoplanetary discs, the temperature profile is set by the absorption of
reprocessed stellar light by the solids. Further, the temperature profile sets
the distribution of solids through sublimation and condensation at various
snow-lines. Hence the snow-line position depends on the temperature profile and
vice-versa. We show that this coupling can be thermally unstable, such that a
patch of the disc at a snow-line will produce either run-away sublimation or
condensation. This thermal instability arises at moderate optical depths, where
heating by absorption of reprocessed stellar light from the disc's atmosphere
is optically thick, yet cooling is optically thin. Since volatiles in the solid
phase drift much faster than volatiles in the vapour phase, this thermal
instability results in a limit-cycle. The snow-line progressively moves in,
condensing volatiles, before receding, as the volatiles sublimate. Using
numerical simulations, we study the evolution of the CO snow-line. We find the
CO snow-line is thermally unstable under typical disc conditions and evolves
inwards from $\sim50$ to $\sim30$~AU on timescales from 1,000-10,000 years. The
CO snow-line spends between $\sim 10\%-50\%$ of its time at smaller
separations, where the exact value is sensitive to the total opacity and
turbulent viscosity. The evolving snow-line also creates ring-like structures
in the solid distribution interior to the snow-line. Multiple ring-like
structures created by moving snow-lines could potentially explain the
sub-structures seen in many {\it ALMA} images.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2005.01902 [pdf] - 2101513
Formation of Orion Fingers
Submitted: 2020-05-04
"Orion fingers" are a system of dozens of bowshocks, with the wings of shocks
pointing to a common system of origin, which is centered on a dynamically
disintegrating system of several massive stars. The shock heads propagate with
velocities of up to 300-400 km/s, but the formation and physical properties of
the "bullets" leading the shocks are not known. Here we summarize two possible
scenarios for the formation of the "bullets" and the resulting bowshocks
("fingers"). In the first scenario, bullets are self-gravitating, Jupiter-mass
objects which were formed rapidly and then ejected during the strong dynamical
interactions of massive stars and their disks. This scenario naturally explains
the similar timescales for the outflow of bullets and for the dynamical
interaction of the massive stars, but has some difficulty explaining the
observed high velocities of the bullets. In the second scenario, bullets are
formed via hydrodynamic instabilities in a massive, infrared-driven wind,
naturally explaining the high velocities and the morphology of outflow, but the
bullets are not required to be self-gravitating. The processes that created the
Orion fingers are likely not unique to this particular star-forming region and
may result in free-floating, high-velocity, core-less planets.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.06225 [pdf] - 2076838
Massive discs around low-mass stars
Submitted: 2020-01-17, last modified: 2020-03-27
We use a suite of SPH simulations to investigate the susceptibility of
protoplanetary discs to the effects of self-gravity as a function of star-disc
properties. We also include passive irradiation from the host star using
different models for the stellar luminosities. The critical disc-to-star mass
ratio for axisymmetry (for which we produce criteria) increases significantly
for low-mass stars. This could have important consequences for increasing the
potential mass reservoir in a proto Trappist-1 system, since even the efficient
Ormel et al. (2017) formation model will be influenced by processes like
external photoevaporation, which can rapidly and dramatically deplete the dust
reservoir. The aforementioned scaling of the critical $M_d/M_*$ for axisymmetry
occurs in part because the Toomre $Q$ parameter has a linear dependence on
surface density (which promotes instability) and only an $M_*^{1/2}$ dependence
on shear (which reduces instability), but also occurs because, for a given
$M_d/M_*$, the thermal evolution depends on the host star mass. The early phase
stellar irradiation of the disc (for which the luminosity is much higher than
at the zero age main sequence, particularly at low stellar masses) can also
play a key role in significantly reducing the role of self-gravity, meaning
that even Solar mass stars could support axisymmetric discs a factor two higher
in mass than usually considered possible. We apply our criteria to the DSHARP
discs with spirals, finding that self-gravity can explain the observed spirals
so long as the discs are optically thick to the host star irradiation.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.11135 [pdf] - 2057959
Fingerprints of giant planets in the composition of solar twins
Submitted: 2020-02-25
The Sun shows a $\sim 10$% depletion in refractory elements relative to
nearby solar twins. It has been suggested that this depletion is a signpost of
planet formation. The exoplanet statistics are now good enough to show that the
origin of this depletion does not arise from the sequestration of refractory
material inside the planets themselves. This conclusion arises because most
sun-like stars host close-in planetary systems that are on average more massive
than the Sun's. Using evolutionary models for the protoplanetary discs that
surrounded the young Sun and solar twins we demonstrate that the origin of the
depletion likely arises due to the trapping of dust exterior to the orbit of a
forming giant planet. In this scenario a forming giant planet opens a gap in
the gas disc, creating a pressure trap. If the planet forms early enough, while
the disc is still massive, the planet can trap $\gtrsim 100 $M$_\oplus$ of dust
exterior to its orbit, preventing the dust from accreting onto the star in
contrast to the gas. Forming giant planets can create refractory depletions of
$\sim 5-15$%, with the larger values occurring for initial conditions that
favour giant planet formation (e.g. more massive discs, that live longer). The
incidence of solar-twins that show refractory depletion matches both the
occurrence of giant planets discovered in exoplanet surveys and "transition"
discs that show similar depletion patterns in the material that is accreting
onto the star.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.04798 [pdf] - 2048613
The TRAPPIST-1 JWST Community Initiative
Gillon, Michaël;
Meadows, Victoria;
Agol, Eric;
Burgasser, Adam J.;
Deming, Drake;
Doyon, René;
Fortney, Jonathan;
Kreidberg, Laura;
Owen, James;
Selsis, Franck;
de Wit, Julien;
Lustig-Yaeger, Jacob;
Rackham, Benjamin V.
Submitted: 2020-02-12, last modified: 2020-02-13
The upcoming launch of the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) combined with
the unique features of the TRAPPIST-1 planetary system should enable the young
field of exoplanetology to enter into the realm of temperate Earth-sized
worlds. Indeed, the proximity of the system (12pc) and the small size (0.12
Rsun) and luminosity (0.05 Lsun) of its host star should make the comparative
atmospheric characterization of its seven transiting planets within reach of an
ambitious JWST program. Given the limited lifetime of JWST, the ecliptic
location of the star that limits its visibility to 100d per year, the large
number of observational time required by this study, and the numerous
observational and theoretical challenges awaiting it, its full success will
critically depend on a large level of coordination between the involved teams
and on the support of a large community. In this context, we present here a
community initiative aiming to develop a well-defined sequential structure for
the study of the system with JWST and to coordinate on every aspect of its
preparation and implementation, both on the observational (e.g. study of the
instrumental limitations, data analysis techniques, complementary space-based
and ground-based observations) and theoretical levels (e.g. model developments
and comparison, retrieval techniques, inferences). Depending on the outcome of
the first phase of JWST observations of the planets, this initiative could
become the seed of a major JWST Legacy Program devoted to the study of
TRAPPIST-1.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.05004 [pdf] - 2038446
The Observational Anatomy of Externally Photoevaporating Planet-Forming
Discs I: Atomic Carbon
Submitted: 2020-01-14, last modified: 2020-01-16
We demonstrate the utility of CI as a tracer of photoevaporative winds that
are being driven from discs by their ambient UV environment. Commonly observed
CO lines only trace these winds in relatively weak UV environments and are
otherwise dissociated in the wind at the intermediate to high UV fields that
most young stars experience. However, CI traces unsubtle kinematic signatures
of a wind in intermediate UV environments ($\sim1000$G$_0$) and can be used to
place constraints on the kinematics and temperature of the wind. In CI
position-velocity diagrams external photoevaporation results in velocities that
are faster than those from Keplerian rotation alone, as well as emission from
quadrants of position-velocity space in which there would be no Keplerian
emission. This is independent of viewing angle because the wind has components
that are perpendicular to the azimuthal rotation of the disc. At intermediate
viewing angles ($\sim 30-60^\circ$) moment 1 maps also exhibit a twisted
morphology over large scales (unlike other processes that result in twists,
which are typically towards the inner disc). CI is readily observable with
ALMA, which means that it is now possible to identify and characterise the
effect of external photoevaporation on planet-forming discs in intermediate UV
environments.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.09992 [pdf] - 2018333
Astro2020 APC White Paper: Theoretical Astrophysics 2020-2030
Kollmeier, Juna A.;
Anderson, Lauren;
Benson, Andrew;
Bogdanovic, Tamara;
Boylan-Kolchin, Michael;
Bullock, James S.;
Dave, Romeel;
Fraschetti, Federico;
Fuller, Jim;
Hopkins, Philip F.;
Kaplinghat, Manoj;
Kratter, Kaitlin;
Lamberts, Astrid;
Miller, M. Coleman;
Owen, James E.;
Phinney, E. Sterl;
Piro, Anthony L.;
Rix, Hans-Walter;
Robertson, Brant;
Wetzel, Andrew;
Wheeler, Coral;
Youdin, Andrew N.;
Zaldarriaga, Matias
Submitted: 2019-12-18
The past two decades have seen a tremendous investment in observational
facilities that promise to reveal new and unprecedented discoveries about the
universe. In comparison, the investment in theoretical work is completely
dwarfed, even though theory plays a crucial role in the interpretation of these
observations, predicting new types of phenomena, and informing observing
strategies. In this white paper, we argue that in order to reach the promised
critical breakthroughs in astrophysics over the next decade and well beyond,
the national agencies must take a serious approach to investment in theoretical
astrophysics research. We discuss the role of theory in shaping our
understanding of the universe, and then we provide a multi-level strategy, from
the grassroots to the national, to address the current underinvestment in
theory relative to observational work.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.01609 [pdf] - 2026484
Testing exoplanet evaporation with multi-transiting systems
Submitted: 2019-12-03
The photoevaporation model is one of the leading explanations for the
evolution of small, close-in planets and the origin of the radius-valley.
However, without planet mass measurements, it is challenging to test the
photoevaporation scenario. Even if masses are available for individual planets,
the host star's unknown EUV/X-ray history makes it difficult to assess the role
of photoevaporation. We show that systems with multiple transiting planets are
the best in which to rigorously test the photoevaporation model. By scaling one
planet to another in a multi-transiting system, the host star's uncertain
EUV/X-ray history can be negated. By focusing on systems that contain planets
that straddle the radius-valley, one can estimate the minimum-masses of planets
above the radius-valley (and thus are assumed to have retained a voluminous
hydrogen/helium envelope). This minimum-mass is estimated by assuming that the
planet below the radius-valley entirely lost its initial hydrogen/helium
envelope, then calculating how massive any planet above the valley needs to be
to retain its envelope. We apply this method to 104 planets above the radius
gap in 73 systems for which precise enough radii measurements are available. We
find excellent agreement with the photoevaporation model. Only two planets
(Kepler - 100c & 142c) appear to be inconsistent, suggesting they had a
different formation history or followed a different evolutionary pathway to the
bulk of the population. Our method can be used to identify TESS systems that
warrant radial-velocity follow-up to further test the photoevaporation model.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.02752 [pdf] - 1985719
The dispersal of protoplanetary discs I: A new generation of X-ray
photoevaporation models
Submitted: 2019-04-04, last modified: 2019-10-24
Photoevaporation of planet forming discs by high energy radiation from the
central star is potentially a crucial mechanism for disc evolution and it may
play an important role in the formation and evolution of planetary system. We
present here a new generation of X-ray photoevaporation models for solar-type
stars, based on a new set of hydrodynamical simulations, which account for
stellar irradiation via a new, significantly improved, parameterisation of gas
temperatures, based on detailed photoionisation and radiation transfer
calculations. This is the first of a series of papers aiming at providing a
library of models which cover the observed parameter space in stellar and disc
mass, metallicity and stellar X-ray properties. We focus here on solar-type
stars (0.7 M$_\odot$) with relatively low-mass discs (1% of the stellar mass)
and explore the dependence of the wind mass loss rates on stellar X-ray
luminosity. We model primordial discs as well as transition discs at various
stages of evolution. Our 2D hydrodynamical models are then used to derive
simple recipes for the mass loss rates that are suitable for inclusion in
one-dimensional disc evolution and/or planet formation models typically
employed for population synthesis studies. Line profiles from typical wind
diagnostics ([OI] 6300 $\overset{\lower.5em\circ}{\mathrm{A}}$ and [NeII] 12.8
$\mu$m) are also calculated for our models and found to be roughly in agreement
with previous studies. Finally, we perform a population study of transition
discs by means of one-dimensional viscous evolution models including our new
photoevaporation prescription and find that roughly a half of observed
transition discs cavities and accretion rates could be reproduced by our
models.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.05866 [pdf] - 1967092
Effects of Magnetic Fields on the Location of the Evaporation Valley for
Low-Mass Exoplanets
Submitted: 2019-09-12
The observed distribution of radii for exoplanets shows a bimodal form that
can be explained by mass-loss from planetary atmospheres due to high energy
radiation emitted by their host stars. The location of the minimum of this
radius distribution depends on the mass-radius relation, which in turn depends
on the composition of planetary cores. Current studies suggest that super-Earth
and mini-Neptune planets have iron-rich and hence largely Earth-like
composition cores. This paper explores how non-zero planetary magnetic fields
can decrease the expected mass-loss rates from these planets. These lower
mass-loss rates, in turn, affect the location of the minimum of the radius
distribution and the inferred chemical composition of the planetary cores.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.04265 [pdf] - 1905882
Radiation pressure clear-out of dusty photoevaporating discs
Submitted: 2019-06-10
Theoretical models of protoplanetary disc dispersal predict a phase where
photoevaporation has truncated the disc at several AU, creating a pressure trap
which is dust-rich. Previous models predicted this phase could be long-lived
(~Myr), contrary to the observational constraints. We show that dust in the
pressure trap can be removed from the disc by radiation pressure exerting a
significant acceleration, and hence radial velocity, on small dust particles
that reside in the surface layers of the disc. The dust in the pressure trap is
not subject to radial drift so it can grow to reach sizes large enough to
fragment. Hence small particles removed from the surface layers are replaced by
the fragments of larger particles. This link means radiation pressure can
deplete the dust at all particle sizes. Through a combination of 1D and 2D
models, along with secular models that follow the disc's long-term evolution,
we show that radiation pressure can deplete dust from pressure traps created by
photoevaporation in ~1e5 years, while the photoevaporation created cavity still
resides at 10s of AU. After this phase of radiation pressure removal of dust,
the disc is gas-rich and dust depleted and radially optically thin to stellar
light, having observational signatures similar to a gas-rich, young debris
disc. Indeed many of the young stars (~<10 Myr old) classified as hosting a
debris disc may rather be discs that have undergone this process.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.07609 [pdf] - 1897833
Atmospheric Escape and the Evolution of Close-in Exoplanets
Submitted: 2018-07-19, last modified: 2019-06-06
Exoplanets with substantial Hydrogen/Helium atmospheres have been discovered
in abundance, many residing extremely close to their parent stars. The extreme
irradiation levels these atmospheres experience causes them to undergo
hydrodynamic atmospheric escape. Ongoing atmospheric escape has been observed
to be occurring in a few nearby exoplanet systems through transit spectroscopy
both for hot Jupiters and lower-mass super-Earths/mini-Neptunes. Detailed
hydrodynamic calculations that incorporate radiative transfer and ionization
chemistry are now common in one-dimensional models, and multi-dimensional
calculations that incorporate magnetic-fields and interactions with the
interstellar environment are cutting edge. However, there remains very limited
comparison between simulations and observations. While hot Jupiters experience
atmospheric escape, the mass-loss rates are not high enough to affect their
evolution. However, for lower mass planets atmospheric escape drives and
controls their evolution, sculpting the exoplanet population we observe today.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.12338 [pdf] - 1858405
High-Energy Photon and Particle Effects onExoplanet Atmospheres and
Habitability
Drake, Jeremy J.;
Alvarado-Gómez, Julián D.;
Airapetian, Vladimir;
Cauley, P. Wilson;
Argiroffi, Costanza;
Browning, Matthew K.;
Christian, Damian J.;
Cohen, Ofer;
Corrales, Lia;
Danchi, William;
de Val-Borro, Miguel;
Dong, Chuanfei;
Forman, William;
France, Kevin;
Gallo, Elena;
Garcia-Sage, Katherine;
Garraffo, Cecilia;
Gelino, Dawn M.;
Gronoff, Guillaume;
Günther, H. Moritz;
Harper, Graham M.;
Haywood, Raphaëlle D.;
Karovska, Margarita;
Kashyap, Vinay;
Kastner, Joel;
Kim, Jinyoung Serena;
Leutenegger, Maurice A.;
Linsky, Jeffrey;
López-Morales, Mercedes;
Micela, Giusi;
Moschou, Sofia-Paraskevi;
Oskinova, Lidia;
Osten, Rachel A.;
Owen, James E.;
Poppenhaeger, Katja;
Principe, David A.;
Pye, John P.;
Sciortino, Salvatore;
Tzanavaris, Panayiotis;
Wargelin, Brad;
Wheatley, Peter J.;
Williams, Peter K. G.;
Winston, Elaine;
Wolk, Scott J.
Submitted: 2019-03-28
It is now recognized that energetic stellar photon and particle radiation
evaporates and erodes planetary atmospheres and controls upper atmospheric
chemistry. Key exoplanet host stars will be too faint at X-ray wavelengths for
accurate characterization using existing generation and future slated X-ray
telescopes. Observation of stellar coronal mass ejections and winds are also
beyond current instrumentation. In line with theCommittee on an Exoplanet
Science Strategy recognition that holistic observational approaches are needed,
we point out here that a full understanding of exoplanet atmospheres, their
evolution and determination of habitability requires a powerful high-resolution
X-ray imaging and spectroscopic observatory. This is the only capability that
can: (1) characterize by proxy the crucial, difficult to observe, EUV stellar
flux, its history and its variations for planet hosting stars; (2) observe the
stellar wind; (3) detect the subtle Doppler signatures of coronal mass
ejections.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.01800 [pdf] - 1815172
Close-in Super-Earths: The first and the last stages of planet formation
in an MRI-accreting disc
Submitted: 2019-01-07
We explore in situ formation and subsequent evolution of close-in
super-Earths and mini-Neptunes. We adopt a steady-state inner protoplanetary
gas disc structure that arises from viscous accretion due to the
magneto-rotational instability (MRI). We consider the evolution of dust in the
inner disc, including growth, radial drift and fragmentation, and find that
dust particles that radially drift into the inner disc fragment severely due to
the MRI-induced turbulence. This result has two consequences: (1) radial drift
of grains within the inner disc is quenched, leading to an enhancement of dust
in the inner regions which scales as dust-to-gas-mass-flux-ratio at ~1 AU; (2)
however, despite this enhancement, planetesimal formation is impeded by the
small grain size. Nevertheless, assuming that planetary cores are present in
the inner disc, we then investigate the accretion of atmospheres onto cores and
their subsequent photoevaporation. We then compare our results to the observed
exoplanet mass-radius relationship. We find that: (1) the low gas surface
densities and high temperatures in the inner disc reduce gas accretion onto
cores compared to the minimum mass solar nebula, preventing the cores from
growing into hot Jupiters, in agreement with the data; (2) however, our
predicted envelope masses are still typically larger than observed ones.
Finally, we sketch a qualitative picture of how grains may grow and
planetesimals form in the inner disc if grain effects on the ionization levels
and the MRI and the back-reaction of the dust on the gas (both neglected in our
calculations) are accounted for.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.06033 [pdf] - 1725079
Metallicity-Dependent Signatures in the Kepler Planets
Submitted: 2018-07-16
Using data from the California-Kepler-Survey (CKS) we study trends in
planetary properties with host star metallicity for close-in planets. By
incorporating knowledge of the properties of the planetary radius gap
identified by the CKS survey, we are able to investigate the properties of
planetary cores and their gaseous envelopes separately. Our primary findings
are that the solid core masses of planets are higher around higher metallicity
stars and that these more massive cores were able to accrete larger gas
envelopes. Furthermore, investigating the recently reported result that planets
with radii in the range (2-6Rearth) are more common at short periods around
higher metallicity stars in detail, we find that the average host star
metallicity of H/He atmosphere-hosting planets increases smoothly inside an
orbital period of ~20 days. We interpret the location of the metallicity
increase within the context of atmospheric photoevaporation: higher metallicity
stars are likely to host planets with higher atmospheric metallicity, which
increases the cooling in the photoevaporative outflow, lowering the mass-loss
rates. Therefore, planets with higher metallicity atmospheres are able to
resist photoevaporation at shorter orbital periods. Finally, we find evidence
at 2.8 sigma that planets that do not host H/He atmospheres at long periods are
more commonly found around lower metallicity stars. Such planets are difficult
to explain by photoevaporative stripping of planets which originally accreted
H/He atmospheres. Alternatively, this population of planets could be
representative of planets that formed in a terrestrial-like fashion, after the
gas disc dispersed.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.05398 [pdf] - 1724835
An asteroseismic view of the radius valley: stripped cores, not born
rocky
Submitted: 2017-10-15, last modified: 2018-07-02
Various theoretical models treating the effect of stellar irradiation on
planetary envelopes predict the presence of a radius valley: i.e. a bimodal
distribution of planet radii, with super-Earths and sub-Neptune planets
separated by a valley at around $\approx 2~R_\oplus$. Such a valley was
observed recently, owing to an improvement in the precision of stellar, and
therefore planetary radii. Here we investigate the presence, location and shape
of such a valley using a small sample with highly accurate stellar parameters
determined from asteroseismology, which includes 117 planets with a median
uncertainty on the radius of 3.3%. We detect a clear bimodal distribution, with
super-Earths ($\approx 1.5~R_\oplus$) and sub-Neptunes ($\approx 2.5~R_\oplus$)
separated by a deficiency around $2~R_\oplus$. We furthermore characterize the
slope of the valley as a power law $R \propto P^\gamma$ with $\gamma =
{-0.09^{+0.02}_{-0.04}}$. A negative slope is consistent with models of
photo-evaporation, but not with the late formation of rocky planets in a
gas-poor environment, which would lead to a slope of opposite sign. The exact
location of the gap further points to planet cores consisting of a significant
fraction of rocky material.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.00012 [pdf] - 1717226
Photoevaporation and High-Eccentricity Migration Created the Sub-Jovian
Desert
Submitted: 2018-06-29
The mass-period or radius-period distribution of close-in exoplanets shows a
paucity of intermediate mass/size (sub-Jovian) planets with periods ~< 3 days.
We show that this sub-Jovian desert can be explained by the photoevaporation of
highly irradiated sub-Neptunes and the tidal disruption barrier for gas giants
undergoing high-eccentricity migration. The distinctive triangular shape of the
sub-Jovain desert result from the fact that photoevaporation is more effective
closer to the host star, and that in order for a gas giant to tidally
circularise closer to the star without tidal disruption it needs to be more
massive. Our work indicates that super-Earths/mini-Neptunes and hot-Jupiters
had distinctly separate formation channels and arrived at their present
locations at different times.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1712.07049 [pdf] - 1720988
Inside-Out Planet Formation. V. Structure of the Inner Disk as Implied
by the MRI
Submitted: 2017-12-19, last modified: 2018-06-14
The large population of Earth to super-Earth sized planets found very close
to their host stars has motivated consideration of $in$ $situ$ formation
models. In particular, Inside-Out Planet Formation is a scenario in which
planets coalesce sequentially in the disk, at the local gas pressure maximum
near the inner boundary of the dead zone. The pressure maximum arises from a
decline in viscosity, going from the active innermost disk (where thermal
ionization of alkalis yields high viscosities via the magneto-rotational
instability (MRI)) to the adjacent dead zone (where the MRI is quenched).
Previous studies of the pressure maximum, based on $\alpha$-disk models, have
assumed ad hoc values for the viscosity parameter $\alpha$ in the active zone,
ignoring the detailed physics of the MRI. Here we explicitly couple the MRI
criteria to the $\alpha$-disk equations, to find steady-state (constant
accretion rate) solutions for the disk structure. We consider the effects of
both Ohmic and ambipolar resistivities, and find solutions for a range of disk
accretion rates ($\dot{M}$ = $10^{-10}$ - $10^{-8}$ ${\rm M}_{\odot}$/yr),
stellar masses ($M_{\ast}$ = 0.1 - 1 ${\rm M}_{\odot}$), and fiducial values of
the $non$-MRI $\alpha$-viscosity in the dead zone ($\alpha_{\rm {DZ}} =
10^{-5}$ - $10^{-3}$). We find that: (1) A midplane pressure maximum forms
radially $outside$ the inner boundary of the dead zone; (2) Hall resistivity
dominates near the midplane in the inner disk, which may explain why close-in
planets do $not$ form in $\sim$50% of systems; (3) X-ray ionization can be
competitive with thermal ionization in the inner disk, because of the low
surface density there in steady-state; and (4) our inner disk solutions are
viscously unstable to surface density perturbations.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.02250 [pdf] - 1640520
Atmospheric reconnaissance of the habitable-zone Earth-sized planets
orbiting TRAPPIST-1
de Wit, J.;
Wakeford, H. R.;
Lewis, N.;
Delrez, L.;
Gillon, M.;
Selsis, F.;
Leconte, J.;
Demory, B. -O.;
Bolmont, E.;
Bourrier, V.;
Burgasser, A. J.;
Grimm, S.;
Jehin, E.;
Lederer, S. M.;
Owen, J.;
Stamenkovic, V.;
Triaud, A. H. M. J.
Submitted: 2018-02-06
Seven temperate Earth-sized exoplanets readily amenable for atmospheric
studies transit the nearby ultracool dwarf star TRAPPIST-1 (refs 1,2). Their
atmospheric regime is unknown and could range from extended primordial
hydrogen-dominated to depleted atmospheres (refs 3-6). Hydrogen in particular
is a powerful greenhouse gas that may prevent the habitability of inner planets
while enabling the habitability of outer ones (refs 6-8). An atmosphere largely
dominated by hydrogen, if cloud-free, should yield prominent spectroscopic
signatures in the near-infrared detectable during transits. Observations of the
innermost planets have ruled out such signatures (ref 9). However, the
outermost planets are more likely to have sustained such a Neptune-like
atmosphere (refs 10,11). Here, we report observations for the four planets
within or near the system's habitable zone, the circumstellar region where
liquid water could exist on a planetary surface (refs 12-14). These planets do
not exhibit prominent spectroscopic signatures at near-infrared wavelengths
either, which rules out cloud-free hydrogen-dominated atmospheres for
TRAPPIST-1 d, e and f, with significance of 8, 6 and 4 sigma, respectively.
Such an atmosphere is instead not excluded for planet g. As high-altitude
clouds and hazes are not expected in hydrogen-dominated atmospheres around
planets with such insolation (refs 15,16), these observations further support
their terrestrial and potentially habitable nature.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1711.09933 [pdf] - 1593813
A likely planet-induced gap in the disk around T Cha
Hendler, Nathanial P.;
Pinilla, Paola;
Pascucci, Ilaria;
Pohl, Adriana;
Mulders, Gijs;
Henning, Thomas;
Dong, Ruobing;
Clarke, Cathie;
Owen, James;
Hollenbach, David
Submitted: 2017-11-27
We present high resolution ($0.11"\times0.06"$) 3mm ALMA observations of the
highly inclined transition disk around the star T Cha. Our continuum image
reveals multiple dust structures: an inner disk, a spatially resolved dust gap,
and an outer ring. When fitting sky-brightness models to the real component of
the 3mm visibilities, we infer that the inner emission is compact ($\le1$au in
radius), the gap width is between 18-28 au, and the emission from the outer
ring peaks at $\sim36$ au. We compare our ALMA image with previously published
1.6$\mu$m VLT/SPHERE imagery. This comparison reveals that the location of the
outer ring is wavelength dependent. More specifically, the peak emission of the
3mm ring is at a larger radial distance than that of the 1.6$\mu$m ring,
suggesting that millimeter-sized grains in the outer disk are located further
away from the central star than micron-sized grains. We discuss different
scenarios to explain our findings, including dead zones, star-driven
photoevaporation, and planet-disk interactions. We find that the most likely
origin of the dust gap is from an embedded planet, and estimate --- for a
single planet scenario --- that T Cha's gap is carved by a $1.2M_{jup}$ planet.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.03816 [pdf] - 1598210
Accreting Transition Discs with large cavities created by X-ray
photoevaporation in C and O depleted discs
Submitted: 2017-10-10
Circumstellar discs with large dust depleted cavities and vigorous accretion
onto the central star are often considered signposts for (multiple) giant
planet formation. In this letter we show that X-ray photoevaporation operating
in discs with modest (factors 3-10) gas-phase depletion of Carbon and Oxygen at
large radii (> 15 AU) yield the inner radius and accretion rates for most of
the observed discs, without the need to invoke giant planet formation. We
present one-dimensional viscous evolution models of discs affected by X-ray
photoevaporation assuming moderate gas-phase depletion of Carbon and Oxygen,
well within the range reported by recent observations. Our models use a
simplified prescription for scaling the X-ray photoevaporation rates and
profiles at different metallicity, and our quantitative result depends on this
scaling. While more rigorous hydrodynamical modelling of mass loss profiles at
low metallicities is required to constrain the observational parameter space
that can be explained by our models, the general conclusion that metal
sequestering at large radii may be responsible for the observed diversity of
transition discs is shown to be robust. Gap opening by giant planet formation
may still be responsible for a number of observed transition discs with large
cavities and very high accretion rate.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.10810 [pdf] - 1584060
The evaporation valley in the Kepler planets
Submitted: 2017-05-30, last modified: 2017-10-04
A new piece of evidence supporting the photoevaporation-driven evolution
model for low-mass, close-in exoplanets was recently presented by the
California-Kepler-Survey. The radius distribution of the Kepler planets is
shown to be bimodal, with a ``valley' separating two peaks at 1.3 and 2.6
Rearth. Such an ``evaporation-valley' had been predicted by numerical models
previously. Here, we develop a minimal model to demonstrate that this valley
results from the following fact: the timescale for envelope erosion is the
longest for those planets with hydrogen/helium-rich envelopes that, while only
a few percent in weight, double its radius. The timescale falls for envelopes
lighter than this because the planet's radius remains largely constant for
tenuous envelopes. The timescale also drops for heavier envelopes because the
planet swells up faster than the addition of envelope mass. Photoevaporation,
therefore, herds planets into either bare cores ~1.3 Rearth, or those with
double the core's radius (~2.6 Rearth). This process mostly occurs during the
first 100 Myrs when the stars' high energy flux are high and nearly constant.
The observed radius distribution further requires that the Kepler planets are
clustered around 3 Mearth in mass, are born with H/He envelopes more than a few
percent in mass, and that their cores are similar to the Earth in composition.
Such envelopes must have been accreted before the dispersal of the gas disks,
while the core composition indicates formation inside the ice-line. Lastly, the
photoevaporation model fails to account for bare planets beyond ~30-60 days, if
these planets are abundant, they may point to a significant second channel for
planet formation, resembling the Solar-System terrestrial planets.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1010.0826 [pdf] - 1579332
Protoplanetary disc evolution and dispersal: the implications of X-ray
photoevaportion
Submitted: 2010-10-05, last modified: 2017-09-01
(Abridged) We explore the role of X-ray photoevaporation in the evolution and
dispersal of viscously evolving T-Tauri discs. We show that the X-ray
photoevaporation wind rates scale linearly with X-ray luminosity, such that the
observed range of X-ray luminosities for solar-type T-Tauri stars (10e28-10e31
erg\s) gives rise to vigorous disc winds with rates of order 10e-10-10e-7
M_sun/yr. We use the wind solutions from radiation-hydrodynamic models, coupled
to a viscous evolution model to construct a population synthesis model so that
we may study the physical properties of evolving discs and so-called
`transition discs'. Current observations of disc lifetimes and accretion rates
can be matched by our model assuming a viscosity parameter alpha = 2.5e-3. Our
models confirm that X-rays play a dominant role in the evolution and dispersal
of protoplanetary discs giving rise to the observed diverse population of inner
hole `transition' sources which include those with massive outer discs, those
with gas in their inner holes and those with detectable accretion signatures.
To help understand the nature of observed transition discs we present a
diagnostic diagram based on accretion rates versus inner hole sizes that
demonstrate that, contrary to recent claims, many of the observed accreting and
non accreting transition discs can easily be explained by X-ray
photoevaporation. Finally, we confirm the conjecture of Drake et al. (2009),
that accretion is suppressed by the X-rays through `photoevaporation starved
accretion' and predict this effect can give rise to a negative correlation
between X-ray luminosity and accretion rate, as reported in the Orion data.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.05658 [pdf] - 1579755
Minimalist coupled evolution model for stellar x-ray activity, rotation,
mass loss, and magnetic field
Submitted: 2015-11-18, last modified: 2017-07-04
Late-type main sequence stars exhibit an x-ray to bolometric flux ratio that
depends on ${\tilde Ro}$, the ratio of rotation period to convective turnover
time, as ${\tilde Ro}^{-\zeta}$ with $2\le \zeta \le 3$ for ${\tilde Ro}
>0.13$, but saturates with $|\zeta| <0.2$ for ${\tilde Ro} < 0.13$. Saturated
stars are younger than unsaturated stars and show a broader spread of rotation
rates and x-ray activity. The unsaturated stars have magnetic fields and
rotation speeds that scale roughly with the square root of their age, though
possibly flattening for stars older than the sun. The connection between faster
rotators, stronger fields, and higher activity has been established
observationally, but a theory for the unified time-evolution of x-ray
luminosity, rotation, magnetic field and mass loss that captures the above
trends has been lacking. Here we derive a minimalist holistic framework for the
time evolution of these quantities built from combining a Parker wind with new
ingredients: (1) explicit sourcing of both the thermal energy launching the
wind and the x-ray luminosity via dynamo produced magnetic fields; (2) explicit
coupling of x-ray activity and mass loss saturation to dynamo saturation (via
magnetic helicity build-up and convection eddy shredding); (3) use of coronal
equilibrium to determine how magnetic energy is divided into wind and x-ray
contributions. For solar-type stars younger than the sun, we infer conduction
to be a subdominant power loss compared to x-rays and wind. For older stars,
conduction is more important, possibly quenching the wind and reducing angular
momentum loss. We focus on the time evolution for stars younger than the sun,
highlighting what is possible for further generalizations. Overall, the
approach shows promise toward a unified explanation of all of the
aforementioned observational trends.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.05032 [pdf] - 1584766
An Incipient Debris Disk in the Chamaeleon I Cloud
Submitted: 2017-06-15
The point at which a protoplanetary disk becomes a debris disk is difficult
to identify. To better understand this, here we study the $\sim$40~AU
separation binary T~54 in the Chamaeleon I cloud. We derive a K5 spectral type
for T~54~A (which dominates the emission of the system) and an age of
$\sim$2~Myr. However, the dust disk properties of T~54 are consistent with
those of debris disks seen around older and earlier-type stars. At the same
time, T~54 has evidence of gas remaining in the disk as indicated by [Ne II],
[Ne III], and [O I] line detections. We model the spectral energy distribution
of T~54 and estimate that $\sim$3$\times$10$^{-3}$ Earth-masses of small dust
grains ($<$0.25~$\mu$m) are present in an optically thin circumbinary disk
along with at least $\sim$3$\times$10$^{-7}$ Earth-masses of larger
($>$10~$\mu$m) grains within a circumprimary disk. Assuming a solar-like
mixture, we use Ne line luminosities to place a minimum limit on the gas mass
of the disk ($\sim$3$\times$10$^{-4}$ Earth-masses) and derive a gas-to-dust
mass ratio of $\sim$0.1. We do not detect substantial accretion, but we do see
H$\alpha$ in emission in one epoch, suggestive that there may be intermittent
dumping of small amounts of matter onto the star. Considering the low dust
mass, the presence of gas, and young age of T~54, we conclude that this system
is on the bridge between the protoplanetary and debris disk stages.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.09250 [pdf] - 1582161
Generating large misalignments in gapped and binary discs
Submitted: 2017-03-27
Many protostellar gapped and binary discs show misalignments between their
inner and outer discs; in some cases, $\sim70$ degree misalignments have been
observed. Here we show that these misalignments can be generated through a
"secular precession resonance" between the nodal precession of the inner disc
and the precession of the gap-opening (stellar or massive planetary) companion.
An evolving protostellar system may naturally cross this resonance during its
lifetime due to disc dissipation and/or companion migration. If resonance
crossing occurs on the right timescale, of order a few Myrs, characteristic for
young protostellar systems, the inner and outer discs can become highly
misaligned ($\gtrsim 60$ degrees). When the primary star has a mass of order a
solar mass, generating a significant misalignment typically requires the
companion to have a mass of $\sim 0.01-0.1$ M$_\odot$ and an orbital separation
of tens of AU. The recently observed companion in the cavity of the gapped,
highly misaligned system HD 142527 satisfies these requirements, indicating
that a previous resonance crossing event misaligned the inner and outer discs.
Our scenario for HD 142527's misaligned discs predicts that the companion's
orbital plane is aligned with the outer disc's; this prediction should be
testable with future observations as the companion's orbit is mapped out.
Misalignments observed in several other gapped disc systems could be generated
by the same secular resonance mechanism.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.08250 [pdf] - 1552922
Dust traps as planetary birthsites: basics and vortex formation
Submitted: 2016-07-27, last modified: 2017-03-26
We present a simple model for low-mass planet formation and subsequent
evolution within "transition" discs. We demonstrate quantitatively that the
predicted and observed structure of such discs are prime birthsites of planets.
Planet formation is likely to proceed through pebble accretion, should a
planetary embryo ($M\gtrsim 10^{-4}\,$M$_\oplus$) form. Efficient pebble
accretion is likely to be unavoidable in transition disc dust traps, as the
size of the dust particles required for pebble accretion are those which are
most efficiently trapped in the transition disc dust trap. Rapid pebble
accretion within the dust trap gives rise, not only to low-mass planets, but to
a large accretion luminosity. This accretion luminosity is sufficient to heat
the disc outside the gravitational influence of the planet and makes the disc
locally baroclinic, and a source of vorticity. Using numerical simulations we
demonstrate that this source of vorticity can lead to the growth of a single
large scale vortex in $\sim 100$ orbits, which is capable of trapping
particles. Finally, we suggest an evolutionary cycle: planet formation proceeds
through pebble accretion, followed by vortex formation and particle trapping in
the vortex quenching the planetary accretion and thus removing the vorticity
source. After the vortex is destroyed the process can begin anew. This means
transition discs should present with large scale vortices for a significant
fraction of their lifetimes and remnant planets at large ~10AU separation
should be a common outcome of this cycle.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.05652 [pdf] - 1557948
Time Dependent Models of Magnetospheric Accretion onto Young Stars
Submitted: 2017-03-16
Accretion onto Classical T Tauri stars is thought to take place through the
action of magnetospheric processes, with gas in the inner disk being channeled
onto the star's surface by the stellar magnetic field lines. Young stars are
known to accrete material in a time-variable manner and the source of this
variability remains an open problem, particularly on the shortest (~ day)
timescales. Using one-dimensional time-dependent numerical simulations that
follow the field line geometry, we find that for plausibly realistic young
stars, steady-state transonic accretion occurs naturally in the absence of any
other source of variability. However, we show that if the density in the inner
disk varies smoothly in time with ~ day long time-scales (e.g., due to
turbulence) this complication can lead to the development of shocks in the
accretion column. These shocks propagate along the accretion column and
ultimately hit the star, leading to rapid, large amplitude changes in the
accretion rate. We argue that when these shocks hit the star the observed
time-dependence will be a rapid increase in accretion luminosity followed by a
slower decline and could be an explanation for some of the short period
variability observed in accreting young stars. Our one-dimensional approach
bridges previous analytic work to more complicated, multi-dimensional
simulations, and observations.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.00616 [pdf] - 1528055
Water loss from Earth-sized planets in the habitable zones of ultracool
dwarfs: Implications for the planets of TRAPPIST-1
Submitted: 2016-05-02, last modified: 2016-10-06
Ultracool dwarfs (UCD; $T_{\rm eff}<\sim3000~$K) cool to settle on the main
sequence after $\sim$1 Gyr. For brown dwarfs, this cooling never stops. Their
habitable zone (HZ) thus sweeps inward at least during the first Gyr of their
lives. Assuming they possess water, planets found in the HZ of UCDs have
experienced a runaway greenhouse phase too hot for liquid water prior to
entering the HZ. It has been proposed that such planets are desiccated by this
hot early phase and enter the HZ as dry worlds. Here we model the water loss
during this pre-HZ hot phase taking into account recent upper limits on the XUV
emission of UCDs and using 1D radiation-hydrodynamic simulations. We address
the whole range of UCDs but also focus on the planets recently found around the
$0.08~M_\odot$ dwarf TRAPPIST-1.
Despite assumptions maximizing the FUV-photolysis of water and the XUV-driven
escape of hydrogen, we find that planets can retain significant amounts of
water in the HZ of UCDs, with a sweet spot in the $0.04$-$0.06~M_\odot$ range.
We also studied the TRAPPIST-1 system using observed constraints on the
XUV-flux. We find that TRAPPIST-1b and c may have lost as much as 15 Earth
Oceans and planet d -- which might be inside the HZ -- may have lost less than
1 Earth Ocean. Depending on their initial water contents, they could have
enough water to remain habitable. TRAPPIST-1 planets are key targets for
atmospheric characterization and could provide strong constraints on the water
erosion around UCDs.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.06319 [pdf] - 1531670
Shadows of our Former Companions: How the Single-Degenerate Binary Type
Ia Supernova Scenario Affects Remnants
Submitted: 2016-09-20
Here we present three-dimensional high resolution simulations of Type Ia
supernova in the presence of a non-degenerate companion. We find that the
presence of a nearby companion leaves a long-lived hole in the supernova
ejecta. In particular, we aim to study the long term evolution of this hole as
the supernova ejecta interacts with the surrounding interstellar medium. Using
estimates for the x-ray emission, we find that the hole generated by the
companion remains for many centuries after the interaction between the ejecta
and the interstellar medium. We also show that the hole is discernible over a
wide range of viewing angles and companion masses.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.04293 [pdf] - 1531040
Examining the Accuracy of Astrophysical Disk Simulations With a
Generalized Hydrodynamical Test Problem
Submitted: 2016-07-14
We discuss a generalization of the classic Keplerian disk test problem
allowing for both pressure and rotational support, as a method of testing
astrophysical codes incorporating both gravitation and hydrodynamics. We argue
for the inclusion of pressure in rotating disk simulations on the grounds that
realistic, astrophysical disks exhibit non-negligible pressure support. We then
apply this test problem to examine the performance of various smoothed particle
hydrodynamics (SPH) methods incorporating a number of improvements proposed
over the years to help SPH better address problems noted in modeling the
classical gravitation only Keplerian disk. We also apply this test to a newly
developed extension of SPH based on reproducing kernels called CRKSPH.
Counterintuitively, we find that pressure support worsens the performance of
traditional SPH on this problem, causing unphysical collapse away from the
steady-state disk solution even more rapidly than the purely gravitational
problem, whereas CRKSPH greatly reduces this error.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.04066 [pdf] - 1443963
Blueshifted [OI] lines from protoplanetary discs: the smoking gun of
X-ray photoevaporation
Submitted: 2016-05-13
Photoevaporation of protoplanetary discs by high energy radiation from the
central young stellar object is currently the favourite model to explain the
sudden dispersal of discs from the inside out. While several theoretical works
have provided a detailed pictured of this process, the direct observational
validation is still lacking. Emission lines produced in these slow moving
protoplanetary disc winds may bear the imprint of the wind structure and thus
provide a potential diagnostic of the underlying dispersal process. In this
paper we primarily focus on the collisionally excited neutral oxygen line at
6300A. We compare our models predictions to observational data and demonstrate
a thermal origin for the observed blueshifted low-velocity component of this
line from protoplanetary discs. Furthermore our models show that while this
line is a clear tell-tale-sign of a warm, quasi-neutral disc wind, typical of
X-ray photoevaporation, its strong temperature dependence makes it unsuitable
to measure detailed wind quantities like mass-loss-rate.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.04009 [pdf] - 1399593
Chondrule Transport in Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2015-07-14, last modified: 2016-05-01
Chondrule formation remains one of the most elusive early Solar System
events. Here, we take the novel approach of employing numerical simulations to
investigate chondrule origin beyond purely cosmochemical methods. We model the
transport of generically-produced chondrules and dust in a 1D viscous
protoplanetary disk model, in order to constrain the chondrule formation
events. For a single formation event we are able to match analytical
predictions of the memory chondrule and dust populations retain of each other
(complementarity), finding that a large mass accretion rate ($\gtrsim
10^{-7}$~M$_\odot$~yr$^{-1}$) allows for delays on the order of the disk's
viscous timescale between chondrule formation and chondrite accretion. Further,
we find older disks to be severely diminished of chondrules, with accretion
rates $\lesssim 10^{-9}$~M$_\odot$~yr$^{-1}$ for nominal parameters. We then
characterize the distribution of chondrule origins in both space and time, as
functions of disk parameters and chondrule formation rates, in runs with
continuous chondrule formation and both static and evolving disks. Our data
suggest that these can account for the observed diversity between distinct
chondrite classes, if some diversity in accretion time is allowed for.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1601.05143 [pdf] - 1396819
Habitability of Terrestrial-Mass Planets in the HZ of M Dwarfs. I.
H/He-Dominated Atmospheres
Submitted: 2016-01-19, last modified: 2016-04-20
The ubiquity of M dwarfs, combined with the relative ease of detecting
terrestrial-mass planets around them, has made them prime targets for finding
and characterising planets in the "Habitable Zone" (HZ). However, Kepler finds
that terrestrial-mass exoplanets are often born with voluminous H/He envelopes,
comprising mass-fractions ($M_{env}/M_{core}$) $\gtrsim 1$%. If these planets
retain such envelopes over Gyr timescales, they will not be "habitable" even
within the HZ. Given the strong X-ray/UV fluxes of M dwarfs, we study whether
sufficient envelope mass can be photoevaporated away for these planets to
become habitable. We improve upon previous work by using hydrodynamic models
that account for radiative cooling as well as the transition from hydrodynamic
to ballistic escape. Adopting a template active M dwarf XUV spectrum, including
stellar evolution, and considering both evaporation and thermal evolution, we
show that: (1) the mass-loss is (considerably) lower than previous estimates
that use an "energy-limited" formalism and ignore the transition to Jeans
escape, (2) at the inner edge of the HZ, planets with core mass $\lesssim 0.9$
M$_\oplus$, can lose enough H/He to become habitable if their initial envelope
mass-fraction is $\sim$1%, (3) at the outer edge of the HZ, evaporation cannot
remove a $\sim$1% H/He envelope even from cores down to 0.8 M$_\oplus$. Thus,
if planets form with bulky H/He envelopes, only those with low-mass cores may
eventually be habitable. Cores $\gtrsim$ 1 M$_\oplus$, with $\gtrsim$1% natal
H/He envelopes, will not be habitable in the HZ of M dwarfs.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.07385 [pdf] - 1374183
The initial physical conditions of Kepler-36 b & c
Submitted: 2015-11-23, last modified: 2016-02-09
The Kepler planetary system consists of two exoplanets at similar separations
(0.115 & 0.128 AU), which have dramatically different densities. The inner
planet has a density consistent with an Earth-like composition, while the outer
planet is extremely low-density, such that it must contain a voluminous H/He
envelope. Such a density difference would pose a problem for any formation
mechanism if their current densities were representative of their composition
at formation. However, both planets are at close enough separations to have
undergone significant evaporation in the past. We constrain the core-mass, core
composition, initial envelope-mass, and initial cooling-time of each planet
using evaporation models conditioned on their present-day masses and radii, as
inferred from Kepler photometry and transit timing analysis. The inner planet
is consistent with being an evaporatively stripped core, while the outer planet
has retained some of its initial envelope due to its higher core-mass.
Therefore, both planets could have had a similar formation pathway, with the
inner planet having an initial envelope-mass fraction of $\lesssim 10\%$ and
core-mass of $\sim4.4$ M$_\oplus$, while the outer had an initial envelope-mass
fraction of order 15-30\% and core-mass $\sim7.3$ M$_\oplus$. Finally, our
results indicate that the outer planet had a long ($\gtrsim30$ Myr) initial
cooling-time, much longer than would naively be predicted from simple timescale
arguments. The long initial cooling-time could be evidence for a dramatic early
cooling episode such as the recently proposed "boil-off" process.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.02781 [pdf] - 1374332
Disk-fed giant planet formation
Submitted: 2016-02-08
Massive giant planets, such as the ones being discovered by direct imaging
surveys, likely experience the majority of their growth through a
circumplanetary disc. We argue that the entropy of accreted material is
determined by boundary layer processes, unlike the "cold-" or "hot-start"
hypotheses usually invoked in the core accretion and direct collapse scenarios.
A simple planetary evolution model illustrates how a wide range of radius and
luminosity tracks become possible, depending on details of the accretion
process. Specifically, the proto-planet evolves towards "hot-start" tracks if
the scale-height of the boundary layer is $\gtrsim0.24$, a value not much
larger than the scale-height of the circumplanetary disc. Understanding the
luminosity and radii of young giant planets will thus require detailed models
of circumplanetary accretion.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1601.03761 [pdf] - 1385449
Rapid Optimal SPH Particle Distributions in Spherical Geometries For
Creating Astrophysical Initial Conditions
Submitted: 2016-01-14
Creating spherical initial conditions in smoothed particle hydrodynamics
simulations that are spherically conformal is a difficult task. Here, we
describe two algorithmic methods for evenly distributing points on surfaces,
that when paired can be used to build 3D spherical objects with optimal
equipartition of volume between particles, commensurate with an arbitrary,
radial density function. We demonstrate the efficacy of our method against
stretched lattice arrangements on the metrics of hydrodynamic stability,
spherical conformity, and the harmonic power distribution of gravitational
settling oscillations. We further demonstrate how our method is highly
optimized for simulating multi-material spheres, such as planets with
core-mantle boundaries.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.02234 [pdf] - 1359032
Rapid radiative clearing of protoplanetary discs
Submitted: 2015-12-07, last modified: 2016-01-12
The lack of observed transition discs with inner gas holes of radii greater
than ~50AU implies that protoplanetary discs dispersed from the inside out must
remove gas from the outer regions rapidly. We investigate the role of
photoevaporation in the final clearing of gas from low mass discs with inner
holes. In particular, we study the so-called "thermal sweeping" mechanism which
results in rapid clearing of the disc. Thermal sweeping was originally thought
to arise when the radial and vertical pressure scale lengths at the X-ray
heated inner edge of the disc match. We demonstrate that this criterion is not
fundamental. Rather, thermal sweeping occurs when the pressure maximum at the
inner edge of the dust heated disc falls below the maximum possible pressure of
X-ray heated gas (which depends on the local X-ray flux). We derive new
critical peak volume and surface density estimates for rapid radiative clearing
which, in general, result in rapid dispersal happening less readily than in
previous estimates. This less efficient clearing of discs by X-ray driven
thermal sweeping leaves open the issue of what mechanism can clear gas from the
outer disc sufficiently quickly to explain the non-detection of cold gas around
weak line T Tauri stars.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:1504.07170 [pdf] - 1338906
UV driven evaporation of close-in planets: energy-limited;
recombination-limited and photon-limited flows
Submitted: 2015-04-27, last modified: 2015-12-30
We have investigated the evaporation of close-in exoplanets irradiated by
ionizing photons. We find that the properties of the flow are controlled by the
ratio of the recombination time to the flow time-scale. When the recombination
time-scale is short compared to the flow time-scale the the flow is in
approximate local ionization equilibrium with a thin ionization front, where
the photon mean free path is short compared to flow scale. In this
"recombination limited" flow the mass-loss scales roughly with the square root
of the incident flux. When the recombination time is long compared to the flow
time-scale the ionization front becomes thick and encompasses the entire flow,
with the mass-loss rate scaling linearly with flux. If the planet's potential
is deep the flow is approximately "energy-limited"; however, if the planet's
potential is shallow we identify a new limiting mass-loss regime, which we term
"photon-limited". In this scenario the mass-loss rate is purely limited by the
incoming flux of ionizing photons. We have developed a new numerical approach
that takes into account the frequency dependence of the incoming ionizing
spectrum and performed a large suite of 1D simulations to characterise UV
driven mass-loss around low mass planets. We find the flow is
"recombination-limited" at high fluxes but becomes "energy-limited" at low
fluxes; however, the transition is broad occurring over several order of
magnitude in flux. Finally, we point out the transitions between the different
flow types does not occur at a single flux value, but depends on the planet's
properties, with higher mass planets becoming "energy-limited" at lower fluxes.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.02049 [pdf] - 1351432
Atmospheres of low-mass planets: the "boil-off"
Submitted: 2015-06-05, last modified: 2015-12-30
We show that, for a low-mass planet that orbits its host star within a few
tenths of an AU (like the majority of the {\it Kepler} planets), the atmosphere
it was able to accumulate while embedded in the proto-planetary disk may not
survive unscathed after the disk disperses. This gas envelope, if more massive
than a few percent of the core (with a mass below $10 M_\oplus$), has a cooling
time that is much longer than the time-scale on which the planet exits the
disk. As such, it could not have contracted significantly from its original
size, of order the Bondi radius. So a newly exposed proto-planet would be
losing mass via a Parker wind that is catalyzed by the stellar continuum
radiation. This represents an intermediate stage of mass-loss, occurring soon
after the disc has dispersed, but before the EUV/X-ray driven photoevaporation
becomes relevant. The surface mass-loss induces a mass movement within the
envelope that advects internal heat outward. As a result, the planet atmosphere
rapidly cools down and contracts, until it has reached a radius of order $0.1$
Bondi radius, at which time the mass-loss effectively shuts down. Within a
million years after the disk disperses, we find a planet that has only about
ten percent of its original envelope, and a Kelvin-Helmholtz time that is much
longer than its actual age. We suggest that this "boil-off" process may be
partially responsible for the lack of planets above a radius of $2.5 R_\oplus$
in the {\it Kepler} data, provided planet formation results in initial envelope
masses of tens of percent.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.06873 [pdf] - 1362670
The origin and evolution of transition discs: successes, problems and
open questions
Submitted: 2015-12-21
Transition discs are protoplanetary discs that show evidence for large holes
or wide gaps (with widths comparable to their radii) in their dust component.
These discs could be giving us clues about the disc destruction mechanism or
hints about the location and time-scales for the formation of planets. However,
at the moment there remain key gaps in our theoretical understanding. The vast
majority of transition discs are accreting onto their central stars, indicating
that - at least close to the star - dust has been depleted from the gas by a
very large amount. In this review, we discuss evidence for two distinct
populations of transition discs: mm-faint - those with low mm-fluxes, small
holes ($\lesssim$10AU) and low accretion rates (~1e-10-1e-9 Msun/yr) and
mm-bright - discs with large mm-fluxes, large holes ($\gtrsim$20 AU) and high
accretion rates ~1e-8 Msun/yr. MM-faint transition discs are consistent with
what would naively be expected from a disc undergoing dispersal; however,
mm-bright discs are not, and are likely to be rare and long-lived objects. We
discuss the two commonly proposed mechanisms for creating transition discs:
photoevaporation and planet-disc interactions, with a particular emphasis on
how they would evolve in these models, comparing these predictions to the
observed population. More theoretical work on explaining the lack of optically
thick, non-accreting transition discs is required in both the photoevaporation
and planetary hypothesis, before we can start to use transition discs to
constrain models of planet formation. Finally, we suggest that the few discs
with primordial looking SEDs, but serendipitously imaged, showing large
cavities in the mm (e.g. MWC758 & WSB 60) may represent a hidden population of
associated objects. Characterising and understanding how these objects fit into
the overall paradigm may allow us to unravel the mystery of transition discs.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.03070 [pdf] - 1347784
Hot Jupiter Breezes: Time-dependent Outflows from Extrasolar Planets
Submitted: 2015-12-09
We explore the dynamics of magnetically controlled outflows from Hot
Jupiters, where these flows are driven by UV heating from the central star. In
these systems, some of the open field lines do not allow the flow to pass
smoothly through the sonic point, so that steady-state solutions do not exist
in general. This paper focuses on this type of magnetic field configuration,
where the resulting flow becomes manifestly time-dependent. We consider the
case of both steady heating and time-variable heating, and find the time scales
for the corresponding time variations of the outflow. Because the flow cannot
pass through the sonic transition, it remains subsonic and leads to so-called
breeze solutions. One manifestation of the time variability is that the flow
samples a collection of different breeze solutions over time, and the mass
outflow rate varies in quasi-periodic fashion. Because the flow is subsonic,
information can propagate inward from the outer boundary, which determines, in
part, the time scale of the flow variability. This work finds the relationship
between the outer boundary scale and the time scale of flow variations. In
practice, the location of the outer boundary is set by the extent of the sphere
of influence of the planet. The measured time variability can be used, in
principle, to constrain the parameters of the system (e.g., the strengths of
the surface magnetic fields).
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:1509.04278 [pdf] - 1296299
The long-term evolution of photoevaporating transition discs with giant
planets
Submitted: 2015-09-14
Photo-evaporation and planet formation have both been proposed as mechanisms
responsible for the creation of a transition disc. We have studied their
combined effect through a suite of 2d simulations of protoplanetary discs
undergoing X-ray photoevaporation with an embedded giant planet. In a previous
work we explored how the formation of a giant planet triggers the dispersal of
the inner disc by photo-evaporation at earlier times than what would have
happened otherwise. This is particularly relevant for the observed transition
discs with large holes and high mass accretion rates that cannot be explained
by photo-evaporation alone. In this work we significantly expand the parameter
space investigated by previous simulations. In addition, the updated model
includes thermal sweeping, needed for studying the complete dispersal of the
disc. After the removal of the inner disc the disc is a non accreting
transition disc, an object that is rarely seen in observations. We assess the
relative length of this phase, to understand if it is long lived enough to be
found observationally. Depending on the parameters, especially on the X-ray
luminosity of the star, we find that the fraction of time spent as a
non-accretor greatly varies. We build a population synthesis model to compare
with observations and find that in general thermal sweeping is not effective
enough to destroy the outer disc, leaving many transition discs in a relatively
long lived phase with a gas free hole, at odds with observations. We discuss
the implications for transition disc evolution. In particular, we highlight the
current lack of explanation for the missing non-accreting transition discs with
large holes, which is a serious issue in the planet hypothesis.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.01935 [pdf] - 1508125
Far-infrared signatures and inner hole sizes of protoplanetary discs
undergoing inside-out dust dispersal
Submitted: 2015-07-07
By means of radiative transfer simulation we study the evolution of the
far-infrared colours of protoplanetary discs undergoing inside-out dispersal,
often referred to as transition discs. We show that a brightening of the mid
and far-infrared emission from these objects is a natural consequence of the
removal of the inner disc. Our results can fully explain recent observations of
transition discs in the Chamaleon and Lupus star forming regions from the
Herschel Gould Belt Survey, which show a higher median for the 70?um (Herschel
PACS 1) band of known transition objects compared with primordial discs. Our
theoretical results hence support the suggestion that the 70?um band may be a
powerful diagnostic for the identification of transition discs from photometry
data, provided that the inner hole is larger than tens of AU, depending on
spectral type. Furthermore we show that a comparison of photometry in the K ,
12?um and 7u0?m bands to model tracks can provide a rough, but quick estimate
of the inner hole size of these objects, provided their inclination is below
?85 degrees and the inner hole size is again larger than tens of AU.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:1504.01680 [pdf] - 1258803
Torque on an exoplanet from an anisotropic evaporative wind
Submitted: 2015-04-07
Winds from short-period Earth and Neptune mass exoplanets, driven by high
energy radiation from a young star, may evaporate a significant fraction of a
planet's mass. If the momentum flux from the evaporative wind is not aligned
with the planet/star axis, then it can exert a torque on the planet's orbit.
Using steady-state one-dimensional evaporative wind models we estimate this
torque using a lag angle that depends on the product of the speed of the
planet's upper atmosphere and a flow timescale for the wind to reach its sonic
radius. We also estimate the momentum flux from time-dependent one-dimensional
hydrodynamical simulations. We find that only in a very narrow regime in planet
radius, mass and stellar radiation flux is a wind capable of exerting a
significant torque on the planet's orbit. Similar to the Yarkovsky effect, the
wind causes the planet to drift outward if atmospheric circulation is prograde
(super-rotating) and in the opposite direction if the circulation is
retrograde. A close-in super Earth mass planet that loses a large fraction of
its mass in a wind could drift a few percent of its semi-major axis. While this
change is small, it places constraints on the evolution of resonant pairs such
as Kepler 36 b and c.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:1411.0093 [pdf] - 1222928
Probing X-ray photoevaporative winds through their interaction with
ionising radiation in cluster environments: the case for X-ray proplyds
Submitted: 2014-11-01
We show that if young low mass stars undergo vigorous X-ray driven disc
winds, these may be detected in clusters through their interaction with
ionising radiation from massive stars. We argue that in the ONC (Orion Nebula
Cluster) one should see $\sim$ 10s of `X-ray proplyds' ( objects with optically
imaged offset ionisation fronts) in the range $0.3-0.6$pc from $\theta_1$C Ori
(the dominant O star in the ONC). Such objects lie outside the central `FUV
zone' in the ONC where proplyds are instead well explained by neutral winds
driven by external Far Ultraviolet (FUV) emission from $\theta_1$C. We show
that the predicted numbers and sizes of X-ray proplyds are compatible with
those observed and that this may also explain at least some of the far flung
proplyds seen in the Carina nebula. We compare the sizes of observed proplyds
outside the FUV region of the ONC with model predictions based on the current
observed X-ray luminosities of these sources ( bearing in mind that the current
size is actually set by the X-ray luminosity a few hundred years ago, $\sim$
the flow time to the ionisation front). We discuss whether variability on this
timescale can plausibly explain proplyd size data on a case by case basis. We
also show that the predicted radio free-free emission signature of X-ray
proplyds is readily detectable. Monitoring is however required to distinguish
such emission from non-thermal emission from active coronae. We also predict
that it is only at $> 1$ pc from $\theta_1$C that the free-free emission from
such offset ionised structures would be clearly distinguishable from an
externally driven ionised disc wind. We argue that the fortuitous proximity of
massive stars in the ONC can be used as a beacon to light up internally driven
X-ray winds and that this is a promising avenue for observationally testing
X-ray photoevaporation.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.6844 [pdf] - 1222793
Astro & cosmo-chemical consequences of accretion bursts I: the D/H ratio
of water
Submitted: 2014-10-24
The D/H ratio of water in protostellar systems is a result of both
inheritance from the parent molecular cloud and isotopic exchange in the disc.
A possibly widespread feature of disc evolution, ignored in previous studies,
is accretion bursts (or FU Orionis outbursts), which may thermally process a
large fraction of the water. One proposed underlying mechanism for FU Orionis
outbursts relies on the presence of a magnetically dead zone. Here we examine
the evolution of (D/H)$_{\rm water}$ in 1D simulations of a disc's evolution
that include dead zones and infall from an envelope with given D/H ratio in the
infalling water ($\sim 10^{-3}$), and compare the results with similar
calculations without dead zones. We find that the accretion bursts result in a
significantly lower (D/H)$_{\rm water}$ ratio and a more extended region
(radius up to $\sim 1-3$ AU) where water is equilibrated with hydrogen gas
(D/H=$2\times 10^{-5}$), when compared to burst-free models. Solar system
constraints suggest that our solar nebula either experienced no accretion
bursts and had a Schmidt number $\lesssim 0.2$ or had a Schmidt number closer
to "nominal" values ($\sim 1$) and experienced several accretion bursts.
Finally, future observations of (D/H)$_{\rm water}$ in protoplanetary discs
will allow inferences about angular momentum properties of the disc during disc
building and the role of accretion bursts.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.6544 [pdf] - 870708
Magnetically Controlled Outflows from Planets
Submitted: 2014-09-21
Hot Jupiters can experience mass loss driven by heating from UV radiation
from their host stars, and this flow is often controlled by magnetic fields.
More specifically, near the planetry surface, the magnetic pressure dominates
the ram pressure of the outflow by several orders of magnitude. After leaving
the vicinity of the planet, the flow must connect onto the background
environment provided by the stellar wind and the stellar magnetic field. This
contribution considers magnetically controlled planetary outflows and extends
previous work by comparing two different geometries for the background magnetic
field provided by the star. In the first case, stellar field is assumed to
retain the form of a dipole, which is anti-aligned with the dipole field of the
planet. In the second case, the stellar outflow opens up the stellar magnetic
field structure so that the background field at the location of the planet is
perpendicular to the planetary dipole. Using numerical simulations, we consider
the launch of the planetary wind with these field configurations.
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.4245 [pdf] - 1216944
Importance of thermal diffusion in the gravo-magnetic limit cycle
Submitted: 2014-09-15
We consider the role of thermal diffusion due to turbulence and radiation on
accretion bursts that occur in protoplanetary discs which contain dead zones.
Using 1D viscous disc models we show that diffusive radial transport of heat is
important during the gravo-magnetic limit cycle, and can strongly modify the
duration and frequency of accretion outbursts. When the Prandtl number is large
- such that turbulent diffusion of heat is unimportant - radial radiative
diffusion reduces the burst duration compared to models with no diffusive
transport of heat. When the Prandtl number is small ($\lesssim 25$) we find
that turbulent diffusion dominates the radial transport of heat, reducing the
burst duration to $\lesssim 10^3$ years as well as increasing the burst
frequency. Furthermore, inclusion of radial transport of heat extends the range
of infall rates under which the disc undergoes accretion bursts from $10^{-8}$
to $10^{-6}$ M$_\odot$ yr$^{-1}$ with no diffusion, to $10^{-8}$ to
$\gtrsim10^{-4}$ M$_\odot$ yr$^{-1}$ with radiative and strong turbulent
diffusion. The relative roles of radiative and turbulent thermal diffusion are
likely to vary during an accretion burst, but simple estimates suggest that the
expected Prandtl numbers are of the order of 10 in protoplanetary discs, and
hence that turbulent diffusion is likely to be an important process during
accretion outbursts due to the gravo-magnetic limit cycle.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:1408.3636 [pdf] - 1216331
Magnetically controlled mass loss from extrasolar planets in close
orbits
Submitted: 2014-08-15
We consider the role magnetic fields play in guiding and controlling
mass-loss via evaporative outflows from exoplanets that experience UV
irradiation. First we present analytic results that account for planetary and
stellar magnetic fields, along with mass-loss from both the star and planet. We
then conduct series of numerical simulations for gas giant planets, and vary
the planetary field strength, background stellar field strength, UV heating
flux, and planet mass. These simulations show that the flow is magnetically
controlled for moderate field strengths and even the highest UV fluxes, i.e.,
planetary surface fields $B_P\gtrsim 0.3$ gauss and fluxes $F_{UV}\sim10^{6}$
erg s$^{-1}$. We thus conclude that outflows from all hot Jupiters with
moderate surface fields are magnetically controlled. The inclusion of magnetic
fields highly suppresses outflow from the night-side of the planet. Only the
magnetic field lines near the pole are open and allow outflow to occur. The
fraction of open field lines depends sensitively on the strength (and geometry)
of the background magnetic field from the star, along with the UV heating rate.
The net effect of the magnetic field is to suppress the mass loss rate by
(approximately) an order of magnitude. Finally, some open field lines do not
allow the flow to pass smoothly through the sonic point; flow along these
streamlines does not reach steady-state, resulting in time-variable mass-loss.
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:1406.6707 [pdf] - 1215229
Snow-lines as probes of turbulent diffusion in protoplanetary discs
Submitted: 2014-06-25
Sharp chemical discontinuities can occur in protoplanetary discs,
particularly at `snow-lines' where a gas-phase species freezes out to form ice
grains. Such sharp discontinuities will diffuse out due to the turbulence
suspected to drive angular momentum transport in accretion discs. We
demonstrate that the concentration gradient - in the vicinity of the snow-line
- of a species present outside a snow-line but destroyed inside is strongly
sensitive to the level of turbulent diffusion (provided the chemical and
transport time-scales are decoupled) and provides a direct measurement of the
radial `Schmidt number' (the ratio of the angular momentum transport to radial
turbulent diffusion). Taking as an example the tracer species N$_2$H$^+$, which
is expected to be destroyed inside the CO snow-line (as recently observed in TW
Hya) we show that ALMA observations possess significant angular resolution to
constrain the Schmidt number. Since different turbulent driving mechanisms
predict different Schmidt numbers, a direct measurement of the Schmidt number
in accretion discs would allow inferences about the nature of the turbulence to
be made.
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.3283 [pdf] - 1209515
Accreting planets as dust dams in `transition' discs
Submitted: 2014-05-13
We investigate under what circumstances an embedded planet in a
protoplanetary disc may sculpt the dust distribution such that it
observationally presents as a `transition' disc. We concern ourselves with
`transition' discs that have large holes ($\gtrsim 10$ AU) and high accretion
rates ($\sim 10^{-9}-10^{-8}$ M$_\odot$ yr$^{-1}$). Particularly, those discs
which photoevaporative models struggle to explain. Assuming the standard
picture for how massive planets sculpt their parent discs, along with the
observed accretion rates in `transition' discs, we find that the accretion
luminosity from the forming planet is significant, and can dominate over the
stellar luminosity at the gap edge. This planetary accretion luminosity can
apply a significant radiation pressure to small ($s\lesssim 1\mu$m) dust
particles provided they are suitably decoupled from the gas. Secular evolution
calculations that account for the evolution of the gas and dust components in a
disc with an embedded, accreting planet, show that only with the addition of
the radiation pressure can we explain the full observed characteristics of a
`transition' disc (NIR dip in the SED, mm cavity and high accretion rate). At
suitably high planet masses ($\gtrsim 3-4$ M$_J$), radiation pressure from the
accreting planet is able to hold back the small dust particles, producing a
heavily dust-depleted inner disc that is optically thin (vertically and
radially) to Infra-Red radiation. We use our models to calculate synthetic
observations and present a observational evolutionary scenario for a forming
planet, sculpting its parent disc. The planet-disc system will present as a
`transition' disc with a dip in the SED, only when the planet mass and
planetary accretion rate is high enough. At other times it will present as a
disc with a primordial SED, but with a cavity in the mm, as observed in a
handful of protoplanetary discs.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:1312.3154 [pdf] - 791814
The Mdot - M* relation of pre-main sequence stars: a consequence of
X-ray driven disc evolution
Submitted: 2013-12-11
We analyse current measurements of accretion rates onto pre-main sequence
stars as a function of stellar mass, and conclude that the steep dependance of
accretion rates on stellar mass is real and not driven by selection/detection
threshold, as has been previously feared. These conclusions are reached by
means of statistical tests including a survival analysis which can account for
upper limits. The power-law slope of the Mdot-M* relation is found to be in the
range of 1.6-1.9 for young stars with masses lower than 1 Msun. The measured
slopes and distributions can be easily reproduced by means of a simple disc
model which includes viscous accretion and X-ray photoevaporation. We conclude
that the Mdot-M* relation in pre-main sequence stars bears the signature of
disc dispersal by X-ray photoevaporation, suggesting that the relation is a
straight- forward consequence of disc physics rather than an imprint of initial
conditions.
[55]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.0508 [pdf] - 1178948
Characterising thermal sweeping: a rapid disc dispersal mechanism
Submitted: 2013-09-02
(Abridged) We consider the properties of protoplanetary discs that are
undergoing inside-out clearing by photoevaporation. In particular, we aim to
characterise the conditions under which a protoplanetary disc may undergo
`thermal sweeping', a rapid (< 1e4 years) disc destruction mechanism proposed
to occur when a clearing disc reaches sufficiently low surface density at its
inner edge and where the disc is unstable to runaway penetration by the X-rays.
We use a large suite of 1D radiation-hydrodynamic simulations to probe the
observable parameter space, which is unfeasible in higher dimensions. These
models allow us to determine the surface density at which thermal sweeping will
take over the disc's evolution and to evaluate this critical surface density as
a function of X-ray luminosity, stellar mass and inner hole radius. We find
that this critical surface density scales linearly with X-ray luminosity,
increases with inner hole radius and decreases with stellar mass and we develop
an analytic model that reproduces these results.
This surface density criterion is then used to determine the evolutionary
state of protoplanetary discs at the point that they become unstable to
destruction by thermal sweeping. We find that transition discs created by
photoevaporation will undergo thermal sweeping when their inner holes reach
20-40 AU, implying that transition discs with large holes and no accretion
(which were previously a predicted outcome of the later stages of all flavours
of photoevaporation model) will not form.
We emphasise that the surface density criteria that we have developed apply
to all situations where the disc develops an inner hole that is optically thin
to X-rays. It thus applies not only to the case of holes originally created by
photoevaporation but also to holes formed, for example, by the tidal influence
of planets.
[56]
oai:arXiv.org:1303.3899 [pdf] - 1165295
Kepler planets: a tale of evaporation
Submitted: 2013-03-15, last modified: 2013-08-06
(Abridged) Inspired by the Kepler planet discoveries, we consider the thermal
contraction of planets close to their parent star, under the influence of
evaporation. The mass-loss rates are based on hydrodynamic models of
evaporation that include both X-ray and EUV irradiation. We find that only
low-mass planets with hydrogen envelopes are significantly affected by
evaporation, with evaporation being able to remove massive hydrogen envelopes
inward of 0.1 AU for Neptune-mass objects.
We construct a theoretical population of planets with varying core masses,
envelope masses, orbital separations, and stellar spectral types, and compare
these against the sizes and densities measured for low-mass planets, both in
the Kepler mission and from radial velocity surveys. This exercise leads us to
conclude that evaporation is the driving force of evolution for close-in Kepler
planets. In fact, some 50% of the Kepler planet candidates may have been
significantly eroded. Evaporation explains two striking correlations observed
in these objects: a lack of large radius/low density planets close to the
stars, and a bimodal distribution in planet sizes with a deficit of planets
around 2R_E. Planets that have experienced high X-ray exposures are generally
smaller than this size, and those with lower X-ray exposures are typically
larger. A bimodal distribution is naturally explained by the evaporation model,
where, depending on their X-ray exposure, close-in planets can either hold on
to hydrogen envelopes 1% in mass, or be stripped entirely.
To quantitatively reproduce the observed features, we argue that not only do
low-mass Kepler planets need to be made of rocky cores overlaid with hydrogen
envelopes, but few of them should have initial masses above 20 M_E, and the
majority of them should have core masses of a few Earth masses.
[57]
oai:arXiv.org:1307.2240 [pdf] - 1172568
Testing protoplanetary disc dispersal with radio emission
Submitted: 2013-07-08, last modified: 2013-07-10
We consider continuum free-free radio emission from the upper atmosphere of
protoplanetary discs as a probe of the ionized luminosity impinging upon the
disc. Making use of previously computed hydrodynamic models of disc
photoevaporation within the framework of EUV and X-ray irradiation, we use
radiative transfer post-processing techniques to predict the expected free-free
emission from protoplanetary discs. In general, the free-free luminosity scales
roughly linearly with ionizing luminosity in both EUV and X-ray driven
scenarios, where the emission dominates over the dust tail of the disc and is
partial optically thin at cm wavelengths. We perform a test observation of GM
Aur at 14-18 Ghz and detect an excess of radio emission above the dust tail to
a very high level of confidence. The observed flux density and spectral index
are consistent with free-free emission from the ionized disc in either the EUV
or X-ray driven scenario. Finally, we suggest a possible route to testing the
EUV and X-ray driven dispersal model of protoplanetary discs, by combining
observed free-free flux densities with measurements of mass-accretion rates. On
the point of disc dispersal one would expect to find a M_dot^2 scaling with
free-free flux in the case of EUV driven disc dispersal or a M_dot scaling in
the case of X-ray driven disc dispersal.
[58]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.2483 [pdf] - 1166569
Evolutionary constraints on the planetary hypothesis for transition
discs
Submitted: 2013-05-11
We assume a scenario in which transition discs (i.e. discs around young stars
that have signatures of cool dust but lack significant near infra-red emission
from warm dust) are associated with the presence of planets (or brown dwarfs).
These are assumed to filter the dust content of any gas flow within the
planetary orbit and produce an inner `opacity hole'. In order to match the
properties of transition discs with the largest (~50 A.U. scale) holes, we
place such `planets' at large radii in massive discs and then follow the
evolution of the tidally coupled disc-planet system, comparing the system's
evolution in the plane of mm flux against hole radius with the properties of
observed transition discs. We find that, on account of the high disc masses in
these systems, all but the most massive `planets' (100 Jupiter masses) are
conveyed to small radii by Type II migration without significant fading at
millimetre wavelengths. Such behaviour would contradict the observed lack of mm
bright transition discs with small (<10 A.U.) holes. On the other hand, imaging
surveys clearly rule out the presence of such massive companions in transition
discs. We conclude that this is a serious problem for models that seek to
explain transition discs in terms of planetary companions unless some mechanism
can be found to halt inward migration and/or suppress mm flux production. We
suggest that the dynamical effects of substantial accretion on to the
planet/through the gap may offer the best prospect for halting such migration
but that further long term simulations are required to clarify this issue.
[59]
oai:arXiv.org:1301.3015 [pdf] - 1159016
The interplay between X-ray photoevaporation and planet formation
Submitted: 2013-01-14
We assess the potential of planet formation instigating the early formation
of a photoevaporation driven gap, up to radii larger than typical for
photoevaporation alone. For our investigation we make use of hydrodynamics
models of photoevaporating discs with a giant planet embedded. We find that, by
reducing the mass accretion flow onto the star, discs that form giant planets
will be dispersed at earlier times than discs without planets by X-ray
photoevaporation. By clearing the portion of the disc inner of the planet
orbital radius, planet formation induced photoevaporation (PIPE) is able to
produce transition disc that for a given mass accretion rate have larger holes
when compared to standard X-ray photoevaporation. This constitutes a possible
route for the formation of the observed class of accreting transition discs
with large holes, which are otherwise difficult to explain by planet formation
or photoevaporation alone. Moreover, assuming that a planet is able to filter
dust completely, PIPE produces a transition disc with a large hole and may
provide a mechanism to quickly shut down accretion. This process appears to be
too slow however to explain the observed desert in the population of transition
disc with large holes and low mass accretion rates.
[60]
oai:arXiv.org:1208.6243 [pdf] - 1150998
Radiative Transfer in Star Formation: Testing FLD and Hybrid Methods
Submitted: 2012-08-30
We perform a comparison between two radiative transfer algorithms commonly
employed in hydrodynamical calculations of star formation: grey flux limited
diffusion and the hybrid scheme, in addition we compare these algorithms to
results from the Monte-Carlo radiative transfer code MOCASSIN. In disc like
density structures the hybrid scheme performs significantly better than the FLD
method in the optically thin regions, with comparable results in optically
thick regions. In the case of a forming high mass star we find the FLD method
significantly underestimates the radiation pressure by a factor of ~100.
[61]
oai:arXiv.org:1205.5564 [pdf] - 1123655
Two populations of transition discs?
Submitted: 2012-05-24, last modified: 2012-08-13
We examine the distribution of transition discs as a function of mm flux. We
confirm that as expected in any model in which most primordial discs turn into
transition discs and in which mm flux declines with time, transition discs have
lower mm fluxes on average than primordial discs. However, we find that the
incidence of transition discs does not, as expected, fall monotonically towards
large mm fluxes and we investigate the hypothesis that these mm bright
transition discs may have a distinct physical origin. We find that mm bright
transition discs occupy a separate region of parameter space. Transition discs
in the bright mm sub-sample have systematically higher accretion rates and
inner hole radii than those in the faint mm sub-sample, along with being
systematically weighted to earlier spectral types.
[62]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.2367 [pdf] - 1124042
Planetary evaporation by UV & X-ray radiation: basic hydrodynamics
Submitted: 2012-06-11
We consider the evaporation of close in planets by the star's intrinsic EUV
and X-ray radiation. We calculate evaporation rates by solving the
hydrodynamical problem for planetary evaporation including heating from both
X-ray and EUV radiation. We show that most close-in planets (a<0.1 AU) are
evaporating hydrodynamically, with the evaporation occurring in two distinct
regimes: X-ray driven, in which the X-ray heated flow contains a sonic point,
and EUV driven, in which the X-ray region is entirely sub-sonic. The mass-loss
rates scale as L_X/a^2 for X-ray driven evaporation, and as Phi_*^{1/2}/a for
EUV driven evaporation at early times, with mass-loss rates of order
10e10-10e14 g/s. No exact scaling exists for the mass-loss rate with planet
mass and planet radius, however, in general evaporation proceeds more rapidly
for planets with lower densities and higher masses. Furthermore, we find that
in general the transition from X-ray driven to EUV driven evaporation occurs at
lower X-ray luminosities for planets closer to their parent stars and for
planets with lower densities.
Coupling our evaporation models to the evolution of the high energy radiation
- which falls with time - we are able to follow the evolution of evaporating
planets. We find that most planets start off evaporating in the X-ray driven
regime, but switch to EUV driven once the X-ray luminosity falls below a
critical value. The evolution models suggest that while `hot Jupiters' are
evaporating, they are not evaporating at a rate sufficient to remove the entire
gaseous envelope on Gyr time-scales. However, we do find that close in Neptune
mass planets are more susceptible to complete evaporation of their envelopes.
Thus we conclude that planetary evaporation is more important for lower mass
planets, particularly those in the `hot Neptune'/`super Earth' regime.
[63]
oai:arXiv.org:1112.1087 [pdf] - 1092172
On the theory of disc photoevaporation
Submitted: 2011-12-05
We discuss a hydrodynamical model for the dispersal of protoplanetary discs
around young, low mass (<1.5 M_sun) stars by photoevaporation from the central
object's energetic radiation, which considers the far-ultraviolet as well as
the X-ray component of the radiation field. We present analytical scaling
relations and derive estimates for the total mass-loss rates, as well as
discussing the existence of similarity solutions for flows from primordial
discs and discs with inner holes. Furthermore, we perform numerical
calculations, which span a wide range of parameter space and allow us to
provide accurate scalings of the mass-loss rates with the physical parameters
of the systems (X-ray and FUV luminosity, stellar mass, disc mass, disc
temperature and inner hole radius).
The model suggest that the X-ray component dominates the photoevaporative
mass-loss rates from the inner disc. The mass-loss rates have values in the
range from 10e-11 to 10e-7 M_sun/yr and scale linearly with X-ray luminosity,
with only a weak dependence on the other parameters explored. However, in the
case of high FUV to X-ray (L_FUV/L_X>100) luminosity ratios, the FUV constricts
the X-ray flow and may dominate the mass-loss.
Simulations of low mass discs with inner holes demonstrate a further stage of
disc clearing, which we call `thermal sweeping'. This process occurs when the
mid-plane pressure drops to sufficiently low values. At this stage a bound,
warm, X-ray heated region becomes sufficiently large and unstable, such that
the remaining disc material is cleared on approximately dynamical time-scales.
This process significantly reduces the time taken to clear the outer regions of
the disc, resulting in an expected transition disc population that will be
dominated by accreting objects, as indicated by recent observations.
[64]
oai:arXiv.org:1105.2406 [pdf] - 1076572
On the lifetime of discs around late type stars
Submitted: 2011-05-12
We address the question of whether protoplanetary discs around low mass stars
(e.g. M-dwarfs) may be longer lived than their solar-type counterparts. This
question is particularly relevant to assess the planet-making potential of
these lower mass discs. Given the uncertainties inherent to age-dating young
stars, we propose an alternative approach that is to analyse the spatial
distribution of disc-bearing low-mass stars and compare it to that of
disc-bearing solar-type stars in the same cluster. A significant age difference
between the two populations should be reflected in their average nearest
neighbour distance (normalised to the number of sources), where the older
population should appear more spread out.
To this aim, we perform a Minimum Spanning Tree (MST) analysis on the spatial
distribution of disc-bearing young stellar objects (YSOs) in six nearby low
mass star forming regions. We find no evidence for significant age differences
between the disc-bearing low-mass (later than M2) and 'solar-type' (earlier
than M2) stars in these regions. We model our results by constructing and
analysing synthetic fractal distributions that we evolve for typical values of
the velocity dispersions. A comparison of simple models to our MST analysis
suggests that the lifetime of discs around M-stars is similar to that of discs
around solar-type stars. Furthermore, a model-independent spatial analysis of
the observations robustly shows that any age differences between the two
samples must be smaller than the average age difference between disc-bearing
classical T-Tauri stars and disc-less Weak-Lined T-Tauri stars.
[65]
oai:arXiv.org:1010.1079 [pdf] - 1041097
The imprint of photoevaporation on edge-on discs
Submitted: 2010-10-06
We have performed hydrodynamic and radiative transfer calculations of a
photoevaporating disc around a Herbig Ae/Be star to determine the evolution and
observational impact of dust entrained in the wind. We find that the wind
selectively entrains grains of different sizes at different radii resulting in
a dust population that varies spatially and increases with height above the
disc at radii > 10 AU. This variable grain population results in a 'wingnut'
morphology to the dust density distribution. We calculate images of this dust
distribution at NIR wavelengths that also show a wingnut morphology at all
wavelengths considered. We have also considered the contribution that
crystalline dust grains will have in the wind and show that a photoevaporative
wind can result in a significant crystallinity fraction at all radii, when the
disc is edge-on. However, when the disc's photosphere is unobscured, a
photoevaporative wind makes no contribution to the observable crystallinity
fraction in the disc. Finally, we conclude that the analysis of extended
emission around edge-on discs could provide a new and independent method of
testing photoevaporation models.
[66]
oai:arXiv.org:1006.0891 [pdf] - 1032927
The JCMT Legacy Survey of the Gould Belt: a first look at Serpens with
HARP
Graves, S. F.;
Richer, J. S.;
Buckle, J. V.;
Duarte-Cabral, A.;
Fuller, G. A.;
Hogerheijde, M. R.;
Owen, J. E.;
Brunt, C.;
Butner, H. M.;
Cavanagh, B.;
Chrysostomou, A.;
Curtis, E. I.;
Davis, C. J.;
Etxaluze, M.;
Di Francesco, J.;
Friberg, P.;
Friesen, R. K.;
Greaves, J. S.;
Hatchell, J.;
Johnstone, D.;
Matthews, B.;
Matthews, H.;
Matzner, C. D.;
Nutter, D.;
Rawlings, J. M. C.;
Roberts, J. F.;
Sadavoy, S.;
Simpson, R. J.;
Tothill, N. F. H.;
Tsamis, Y. G.;
Viti, S.;
Ward-Thompson, D.;
White, G. J.;
Wouterloot, J. G. A.;
Yates, J.
Submitted: 2010-06-04
The Gould Belt Legacy Survey (GBS) on the JCMT has observed a region of 260
square arcminutes in 12CO J=3--2 emission, and a 190 square arcminute subset of
this in 13CO and C18O towards the Serpens molecular cloud. We examine the
global velocity structure of the non-outflowing gas, and calculate excitation
temperatures and opacities. The large scale mass and energetics of the region
are evaluated, with special consideration for high velocity gas. We find the
cloud to have a mass of 203 solar masses, and to be gravitationally bound, and
that the kinetic energy of the outflowing gas is approximately seventy percent
of the turbulent kinetic energy of the cloud. We identify compact outflows
towards some of the submillimetre Class 0/I sources in the region
[67]
oai:arXiv.org:1004.1203 [pdf] - 1026179
Theoretical spectra of photoevaporating protoplanetary discs: An atlas
of atomic and low-ionisation emission lines
Submitted: 2010-04-07, last modified: 2010-04-26
We present a calculation of the atomic and low-ionisation emission line
spectra of photoevaporating protoplanetary discs. Line luminosities and
profiles are obtained from detailed photoionisation calculations of the disc
and wind structures surrounding young active solar-type stars. The disc and
wind density and velocity fields were obtained from the recently developed
radiation-hydrodynamic models of Owen et al., that include stellar X-ray and
EUV irradiation of protoplanetary discs at various stages of clearing, from
primordial sources to inner hole sources of various hole sizes.
Our models compare favourably with currently available observations, lending
support to an X-ray driven photoevaporation model for disc dispersal. In
particular, we find that X-rays drive a warm, predominantly neutral flow where
the OI 6300A line can be produced by neutral hydrogen collisional excitation.
Our models can, for the first time, provide a very good match to both
luminosities and profiles of the low-velocity component of the OI 6300A line
and other forbidden lines observed by Hartigan et al., which covered a large
sample of T-Tauri stars.
We find that the OI 6300A and the NeII 12.8um lines are predominantly
produced in the X-ray-driven wind and thus appear blue-shifted by a few km/s
for some of the systems when observed at non-edge-on inclinations. We note
however that blue-shifts are only produced under certain conditions: X-ray
luminosity, spectral shape and inner hole size all affect the location of the
emitting region and the physical conditions in the wind. We caution therefore
that while a blueshifted line is a tell-tale sign of an outflow, the lack of a
blueshift should not be necessarily interpreted as a lack of outflow.
[68]
oai:arXiv.org:0909.4309 [pdf] - 1017673
Radiation-Hydrodynamic Models of X-Ray & EUV Photoevaporating
Protoplanetary Discs
Submitted: 2009-09-24
(Abridged) We present the first radiation-hydrodynamic model of a
protoplanetary disc irradiated with an X-EUV spectrum. In a model where the
total ionizing luminosity is divided equally between X-ray and EUV luminosity,
we find a photoevaporation rate of 1.4e-8 M_sun/yr, which is two orders of
magnitude greater than the case of EUV photoevaporation alone. Thus it is clear
that the X-rays are the dominant driving mechanism for photoevaporation. This
can be understood inasmuch as X-rays are capable of penetrating much larger
columns (~1e22 cm^-2) and can thus effect heating in denser regions and at
larger radius than the EUV can. The radial extent of the launching region of
the X-ray heated wind is 1-70AU compared with the pure EUV case where the
launch region is concentrated around a few AU. When we couple our wind
mass-loss rates with models for the disc's viscous evolution, we find that, as
in the pure EUV case, there is a photoevaporative switch, such that an inner
hole develops at ~ 1 AU at the point that the accretion rate in the disc drops
below the wind mass loss rate. At this point, the remaining disc material is
quickly removed in the final 15-20% of the disc's lifetime. This is consistent
with the 1e5 yr transitional timescale estimated from observations of T-Tauri
stars. We also caution that although our mass-loss rates are high compared to
some accretion rates observed in young stars, our model has a rather large
X-ray luminosity of 2e30 erg/s; further modeling is required in order to
investigate the evolutionary implications of the large observed spread of X-ray
luminosities in T-Tauri stars.
[69]
oai:arXiv.org:0906.3029 [pdf] - 25330
A compatibly differenced total energy conserving form of SPH
Submitted: 2009-06-16
We describe a modified form of Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH) in which
the specific thermal energy equation is based on a compatibly differenced
formalism, guaranteeing exact conservation of the total energy. We compare the
errors and convergence rates of the standard and compatible SPH formalisms on
analytic test problems involving shocks. We find that the new compatible
formalism reliably achieves the expected first-order convergence in such tests,
and in all cases improves the accuracy of the numerical solution over the
standard formalism.
[70]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9906160 [pdf] - 106881
The Santa Barbara cluster comparison project: a comparison of
cosmological hydrodynamics solutions
Frenk, C. S.;
White, S. D. M.;
Bode, P.;
Bond, J. R.;
Bryan, G. L.;
Cen, R.;
Couchman, H. M. P.;
Evrard, A. E.;
Gnedin, N.;
Jenkins, A.;
Khokhlov, A. M.;
Klypin, A.;
Navarro, J. F.;
Norman, M. L.;
Ostriker, J. P.;
Owen, J. M.;
Pearce, F. R.;
Pen, U. -L.;
Steinmetz, M.;
Thomas, P. A.;
Villumsen, J. V.;
Wadsley, J. W.;
Warren, M. S.;
Xu, G.;
Yepes, G.
Submitted: 1999-06-09
We have simulated the formation of an X-ray cluster in a cold dark matter
universe using 12 different codes. The codes span the range of numerical
techniques and implementations currently in use, including SPH and grid methods
with fixed, deformable or multilevel meshes. The goal of this comparison is to
assess the reliability of cosmological gas dynamical simulations of clusters in
the simplest astrophysically relevant case, that in which the gas is assumed to
be non-radiative. We compare images of the cluster at different epochs, global
properties such as mass, temperature and X-ray luminosity, and radial profiles
of various dynamical and thermodynamical quantities. On the whole, the
agreement among the various simulations is gratifying although a number of
discrepancies exist. Agreement is best for properties of the dark matter and
worst for the total X-ray luminosity. Even in this case, simulations that
adequately resolve the core radius of the gas distribution predict total X-ray
luminosities that agree to within a factor of two. Other quantities are
reproduced to much higher accuracy. For example, the temperature and gas mass
fraction within the virial radius agree to about 10%, and the ratio of specific
kinetic to thermal energies of the gas agree to about 5%. Various factors
contribute to the spread in calculated cluster properties, including
differences in the internal timing of the simulations. Based on the overall
consistency of results, we discuss a number of general properties of the
cluster we have modelled.
[71]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9805097 [pdf] - 101318
Cosmological Simulations with Scale-Free Initial Conditions II:
Radiative Cooling
Submitted: 1998-05-07
The growth of structure from scale-free initial conditions is one of the most
important tests of cosmological simulation methods, providing a realistically
complex problem in which numerical results can be compared to rigorous analytic
scaling laws. Previous studies of this problem have incorporated gravitational
dynamics and adiabatic gas dynamics, but radiative cooling, an essential
element of the physics of galaxy formation, normally violates the conditions
necessary for self-similar evolution. We show that for any specified value of
the initial power spectrum index n [where P(k)~k^n], there is a family of
power-law cooling functions that preserves self-similarity by ensuring that the
cooling time in an object of the characteristic mass M_* is a fixed fraction
t_C of the Hubble time. We perform hydrodynamic numerical simulations with an
Einstein-de Sitter cosmology, a baryon fraction of 5%, Gaussian initial
conditions, two different power spectrum indices, and four values of t_C for
each index, ranging from no cooling to strong cooling. We restrict the
numerical simulations to two dimensions in order to allow exploration of a wide
parameter space with adequate dynamic range. In all cases, the simulations are
remarkably successful at reproducing the analytically predicted scalings of the
mass function of dissipated objects and the gas temperature distributions and
cooled gas fractions in collapsed systems. While similar success with 3-D
simulations must still be demonstrated, our results have encouraging
implications for numerical studies of galaxy formation, indicating that
simulations with resolution comparable to that in many current studies can
accurately follow the collapse and dissipation of baryons into the dense, cold
systems where star formation is likely to occur.
[72]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9705109 [pdf] - 97371
Cosmological Simulations with Scale-Free Initial Conditions I: Adiabatic
Hydrodynamics
Submitted: 1997-05-14, last modified: 1998-04-24
We analyze hierarchical structure formation based on scale-free initial
conditions in an Einstein-de Sitter universe, including a baryonic component.
We present three independent, smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH)
simulations, performed with two different SPH codes (TreeSPH and P3MSPH) at two
resolutions. Each simulation is based upon identical initial conditions, which
consist of Gaussian distributed initial density fluctuations that have an n=-1
power spectrum. The baryonic material is modeled as an ideal gas subject only
to shock heating and adiabatic heating and cooling. The evolution is expected
to be self-similar in time, and under certain restrictions we identify the
expected scalings for many properties of the distribution of collapsed objects
in all three realizations. The distributions of dark matter masses, baryon
masses, and mass and emission weighted temperatures scale quite reliably.
However, the density estimates in the central regions of these structures are
determined by the degree of numerical resolution. As a result, mean gas
densities and luminosities obey the expected scalings only when calculated
within a limited dynamic range in density contrast. The temperatures and
luminosities of the groups show tight correlations with the baryon masses,
which can be well-represented by power-laws. The Press-Schechter (PS)
approximation predicts the distribution of group dark matter and baryon masses
fairly well, though it tends to overestimate the baryon masses. Combining the
PS mass distribution with the measured relations for T(M) and L(M) predicts the
temperature and luminosity distributions reasonably, though there are some
discrepancies at high temperatures/luminosities. The three simulations agree
well for the properties of groups that are resolved by 32 or more particles.
[73]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9512078 [pdf] - 1234536
Adaptive Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics: Methodology II
Submitted: 1995-12-12, last modified: 1997-12-24
This paper presents an alternative formulation of the ASPH algorithm for
evolving anisotropic smoothing kernels, in which the geometric approach of
Shapiro et al. (1996; Paper I) is replaced by an approach involving a local
transformation of coordinates to those in which the underlying anisotropic
volume changes appear to be isotropic. The ASPH method is presented in 2D and
3D, including a number of details not previously included in Paper I, some of
which represent either advances or different choices with respect to Paper I.
Among the advances included here are an asynchronous time-integration scheme
with different time steps for different particles and the generalization of the
ASPH method to 3D. The shock-tracking algorithm described in Paper I for
locally adapting the artificial viscosity to restrict viscous heating just to
particles encountering shocks, is not included here. Instead, we adopt a
different interpolation kernel for use with the artificial viscosity, which has
the effect of spatially localizing effects of the artificial viscosity. This
version of the ASPH method in 2D and 3D is then applied to a series of 1D, 2D,
and 3D test problems, and the results are compared to those of standard SPH
applied to the same problems. These include the problem of cosmological pancake
collapse, the Riemann shock tube, cylindrical and spherical Sedov blast waves,
the collision of two strong shocks, and problems involving shearing disks
intended to test the angular momentum conservation properties of the method.
These results further support the idea that ASPH has significantly better
resolving power than standard SPH for a wide range of problems, including that
of cosmological structure formation. (Abridged)
[74]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9603156 [pdf] - 94366
Baryons, Dark Matter, and the Jeans Mass in Simulations of Cosmological
Structure Formation
Submitted: 1996-03-28, last modified: 1997-01-01
We investigate the properties of hybrid gravitational/hydrodynamical
simulations, examining both the numerics and the general physical properties of
gravitationally driven, hierarchical collapse in a mixed baryonic/dark matter
fluid. We demonstrate that, under certain restrictions, such simulations
converge with increasing resolution to a consistent solution. The dark matter
achieves convergence provided that the relevant scales dominating nonlinear
collapse are resolved. If the gas has a minimum temperature (as expected when
intergalactic gas is heated by photoionization due to the ultraviolet
background) and the corresponding Jeans mass is resolved, then the baryons also
converge. However, if there is no minimum baryonic collapse mass or if this
scale is not resolved, then the baryon results err in a systematic fashion. In
such a case, as resolution is increased the baryon distribution tends toward a
higher density, more tightly bound state. We attribute this to the fact that
under hierarchical structure formation on all scales there is always an earlier
generation of smaller scale collapses, causing shocks which irreversibly alter
the state of the baryon gas. In a simulation with finite resolution we miss
such earlier generation collapses, unless a physical scale is introduced below
which structure formation is suppressed in the baryons. We also find that the
baryon/dark matter ratio follows a characteristic pattern, such that collapsed
structures possess a baryon enriched core (enriched by factors of 2 or more
over the universal average) which is embedded within a dark matter halo, even
without accounting for radiative cooling of the gas. The dark matter is
unaffected by changing the baryon distribution (at least in the dark matter
dominated case investigated here).