Normalized to: Ngan, H.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.09613 [pdf] - 2042338
OGLE-2013-BLG-0911Lb: A Secondary on the Brown-Dwarf Planet Boundary
around an M-dwarf
Miyazaki, Shota;
Sumi, Takahiro;
Bennett, David P.;
Udalski, Andrzej;
Shvartzvald, Yossi;
Street, Rachel;
Bozza, Valerio;
Yee, Jennifer C.;
Bond, Ian A.;
Rattenbury, Nicholas;
Koshimoto, Naoki;
Suzuki, Daisuke;
Fukui, Akihiko;
Abe, F.;
Bhattacharya, A.;
Barry, R.;
Donachie, M.;
Fujii, H.;
Hirao, Y.;
Itow, Y.;
Kamei, Y.;
Kondo, I.;
Li, M. C. A.;
Ling, C. H.;
Matsubara, Y.;
Matsuo, T.;
Muraki, Y.;
Nagakane, M.;
Ohnishi, K.;
Ranc, C.;
Saito, T.;
Sharan, A.;
Shibai, H.;
Suematsu, H.;
Sullivan, D. J.;
Tristram, P. J.;
Yamakawa, T.;
Yonehara, A.;
Skowron, J.;
Poleski, R.;
Mr'oz, P.;
Szyma'nski, M. K.;
Soszy'nski, I.;
Pietrukowicz, P.;
KozLowski, S.;
Ulaczyk, K.;
Wyrzykowski, L.;
Friedmann, Matan;
Kaspi, Shai;
Maoz, Dan;
Albrow, M.;
Christie, G.;
DePoy, D. L.;
Gal-Yam, A.;
Gould, A.;
Lee, C. -U.;
Manulis, I.;
McCormick, J.;
Natusch, T.;
Ngan, H.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Porritt, I.;
Tsapras, Y.;
Bachelet, E.;
Hundertmark, M. P. G.;
Dominik, M.;
Bramich, D. M.;
Cassan, A.;
Jaimes, R. Figuera;
Horne, K.;
Schmidt, R.;
Snodgrass, C.;
Wambsganss, J.;
Steele, I. A.;
Menzies, J.;
Mao, S.;
Jorgensen, U. G.;
Burgdorf, M. J.;
Ciceri, S.;
Novati, S. Calchi;
D'Ago, G.;
Evans, D. F.;
Hinse, T. C.;
Kains, N.;
Kerins, E.;
Korhonen, H.;
Mancini, L.;
Popovas, A.;
Rabus, M.;
Rahvar, S.;
Scarpetta, G.;
Skottfelt, J.;
Southworth, J.;
D'Ago, G.;
Peixinho, N.;
Verma, P.
Submitted: 2019-12-19
We present the analysis of the binary-lens microlensing event
OGLE-2013-BLG-0911. The best-fit solutions indicate the binary mass ratio of
q~0.03 which differs from that reported in Shvartzvald+2016. The event suffers
from the well-known close/wide degeneracy, resulting in two groups of solutions
for the projected separation normalized by the Einstein radius of s~0.15 or
s~7. The finite source and the parallax observations allow us to measure the
lens physical parameters. The lens system is an M-dwarf orbited by a massive
Jupiter companion at very close (M_{host}=0.30^{+0.08}_{-0.06} M_{Sun},
M_{comp}=10.1^{+2.9}_{-2.2} M_{Jup}, a_{exp}=0.40^{+0.05}_{-0.04} au) or wide
(M_{host}=0.28^{+0.10}_{-0.08} M_{Sun}, M_{comp}=9.9^{+3.8}_{-3.5}M_{Jup},
a_{exp}=18.0^{+3.2}_{-3.2} au) separation. Although the mass ratio is slightly
above the planet-brown dwarf (BD) mass-ratio boundary of q=0.03 which is
generally used, the median physical mass of the companion is slightly below the
planet-BD mass boundary of 13M_{Jup}. It is likely that the formation
mechanisms for BDs and planets are different and the objects near the
boundaries could have been formed by either mechanism. It is important to probe
the distribution of such companions with masses of ~13M_{Jup} in order to
statistically constrain the formation theories for both BDs and massive
planets. In particular, the microlensing method is able to probe the
distribution around low-mass M-dwarfs and even BDs which is challenging for
other exoplanet detection methods.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.08520 [pdf] - 1988589
Spitzer Microlensing Program as a Probe for Globular Cluster Planets.
Analysis of OGLE-2015-BLG-0448
Poleski, Radosław;
Zhu, Wei;
Christie, Grant W.;
Udalski, Andrzej;
Gould, Andrew;
Bachelet, Etienne;
Skottfelt, Jesper;
Novati, Sebastiano Calchi;
Szymański, M. K.;
Soszyński, I.;
Pietrzyński, G.;
Wyrzykowski, Ł.;
Ulaczyk, K.;
Pietrukowicz, P.;
Kozłowski, Szymon;
Skowron, J.;
Mróz, P.;
Pawlak, M.;
Beichman, C.;
Bryden, G.;
Carey, S.;
Fausnaugh, M.;
Gaudi, B. S.;
Henderson, C. B.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Shvartzvald, Y.;
Wibking, B.;
Yee, J. C.;
Beatty, T. G.;
Eastman, J. D.;
Drummond, J.;
Friedmann, M.;
Henderson, M.;
Johnson, J. A.;
Kaspi, S.;
Maoz, D.;
McCormick, J.;
McCrady, N.;
Natusch, T.;
Ngan, H.;
Porritt, I.;
Relles, H. M.;
Sliski, D. H.;
Tan, T. -G.;
Wittenmyer, R. A.;
Wright, J. T.;
Street, R. A.;
Tsapras, Y.;
Bramich, D. M.;
Horne, K.;
Snodgrass, C.;
Steele, I. A.;
Menzies, J.;
Jaimes, R. Figuera;
Wambsganss, J.;
Schmidt, R.;
Cassan, A.;
Ranc, C.;
Mao, S.;
Bozza, V.;
Dominik, M.;
Hundertmark, M. P. G.;
Jørgensen, U. G.;
Andersen, M. I.;
Burgdorf, M. J.;
Ciceri, S.;
D'Ago, G.;
Evans, D. F.;
Gu, S. -H.;
Hinse, T. C.;
Kains, N.;
Kerins, E.;
Korhonen, H.;
Kuffmeier, M.;
Mancini, L.;
Popovas, A.;
Rabus, M.;
Rahvar, S.;
Rasmussen, R. T.;
Southworth, G. Scarpetta J.;
Surdej, J.;
Unda-Sanzana, E.;
Verma, P.;
von Essen, C.;
Wang, Y. -B.;
Wertz, O.
Submitted: 2015-12-28, last modified: 2019-10-29
The microlensing event OGLE-2015-BLG-0448 was observed by Spitzer and lay
within the tidal radius of the globular cluster NGC 6558. The event had
moderate magnification and was intensively observed, hence it had the potential
to probe the distribution of planets in globular clusters. We measure the
proper motion of NGC 6558 ($\mu_{\rm cl}$(N,E) = (+0.36+-0.10, +1.42+-0.10)
mas/yr) as well as the source and show that the lens is not a cluster member.
Even though this particular event does not probe the distribution of planets in
globular clusters, other potential cluster lens events can be verified using
our methodology. Additionally, we find that microlens parallax measured using
OGLE photometry is consistent with the value found based on the light curve
displacement between Earth and Spitzer.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.08850 [pdf] - 1347475
OGLE-2012-BLG-0563Lb: a Saturn-mass Planet around an M Dwarf with the
Mass Constrained by Subaru AO imaging
Fukui, A.;
Gould, A.;
Sumi, T.;
Bennett, D. P.;
Bond, I. A.;
Han, C.;
Suzuki, D.;
Beaulieu, J. -P.;
Batista, V.;
Udalski, A.;
Street, R. A.;
Tsapras, Y.;
Hundertmark, M.;
Abe, F.;
Bhattacharya, A.;
Freeman, M.;
Itow, Y.;
Ling, C. H.;
Koshimoto, N.;
Masuda, K.;
Matsubara, Y.;
Muraki, Y.;
Ohnishi, K.;
Philpott, L. C.;
Rattenbury, N.;
Saito, T.;
Sullivan, D. J.;
Tristram, P. J.;
Yonehara, A.;
Choi, J. -Y.;
Christie, G. W.;
DePoy, D. L.;
Dong, Subo;
Drummond, J.;
Gaudi, B. S.;
Hwang, K. -H.;
Kavka, A.;
Lee, C. U.;
McCormick, J.;
Natusch, T.;
Ngan, H.;
Park, H.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Shin, I-G.;
Tan, T. -G.;
Yee, J. C.;
Szymański, M. K.;
Pietrzyński, G.;
Soszyński, I.;
Poleski, R.;
Kozłowski, S.;
Pietrukowicz, P.;
Ulaczyk, K.;
Bramich, Ł. Wyrzykowski D. M.;
Browne, P.;
Dominik, M.;
Horne, K.;
Ipatov, S.;
Kains, N.;
Snodgrass, C.;
Steele, I. A.
Submitted: 2015-06-29, last modified: 2016-01-26
We report the discovery of a microlensing exoplanet OGLE-2012-BLG-0563Lb with
the planet-star mass ratio ~1 x 10^{-3}. Intensive photometric observations of
a high-magnification microlensing event allow us to detect a clear signal of
the planet. Although no parallax signal is detected in the light curve, we
instead succeed at detecting the flux from the host star in high-resolution
JHK'-band images obtained by the Subaru/AO188 and IRCS instruments, allowing us
to constrain the absolute physical parameters of the planetary system. With the
help of a spectroscopic information about the source star obtained during the
high-magnification state by Bensby et al., we find that the lens system is
located at 1.3^{+0.6}_{-0.8} kpc from us, and consists of an M dwarf
(0.34^{+0.12}_{-0.20} M_sun) orbited by a Saturn-mass planet
(0.39^{+0.14}_{-0.23} M_Jup) at the projected separation of
0.74^{+0.26}_{-0.42} AU (close model) or 4.3^{+1.5}_{-2.5} AU (wide model). The
probability of contamination in the host star's flux, which would reduce the
masses by a factor of up to three, is estimated to be 17%. This possibility can
be tested by future high-resolution imaging. We also estimate the (J-Ks) and
(H-Ks) colors of the host star, which are marginally consistent with a low
metallicity mid-to-early M dwarf, although further observations are required
for the metallicity to be conclusive. This is the fifth sub-Jupiter-mass
(0.2<m_p/M_Jup<1) microlensing planet around an M dwarf with the mass well
constrained. The relatively rich harvest of sub-Jupiters around M dwarfs is
contrasted with a possible paucity of ~1--2 Jupiter-mass planets around the
same type of star, which can be explained by the planetary formation process in
the core-accretion scheme.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.8252 [pdf] - 1222886
OGLE-2011-BLG-0265Lb: a Jovian Microlensing Planet Orbiting an M Dwarf
Skowron, J.;
Shin, I. -G.;
Udalski, A.;
Han, C.;
Sumi, T.;
Shvartzvald, Y.;
Gould, A.;
Dominis-Prester, D.;
Street, R. A.;
Jørgensen, U. G.;
Bennett, D. P.;
Bozza, V.;
Szymański, M. K.;
Kubiak, M.;
Pietrzyński, G.;
Soszyński, I.;
Poleski, R.;
Kozłowski, S.;
Pietrukowicz, P.;
Ulaczyk, K.;
Wyrzykowski, Ł.;
Abe, F.;
Bhattacharya, A.;
Bond, I. A.;
Botzler, C. S.;
Freeman, M.;
Fukui, A.;
Fukunaga, D.;
Itow, Y.;
Ling, C. H.;
Koshimoto, N.;
Masuda, K.;
Matsubara, Y.;
Muraki, Y.;
Namba, S.;
Ohnishi, K.;
Philpott, L. C.;
Rattenbury, N.;
Saito, T.;
Sullivan, D. J.;
Suzuki, D.;
Tristram, P. J.;
Yock, P. C. M.;
Maoz, D.;
Kaspi, S.;
Friedman, M.;
Almeida, L. A.;
Batista, V.;
Christie, G.;
Choi, J. -Y.;
DePoy, D. L.;
Gaudi, B. S.;
Henderson, C.;
Hwang, K. -H.;
Jablonski, F.;
Jung, Y. K.;
Lee, C. -U.;
McCormick, J.;
Natusch, T.;
Ngan, H.;
Park, H.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Yee, J.;
Albrow, M. D.;
Bachelet, E.;
Beaulieu, J. -P.;
Brillant, S.;
Caldwell, J. A. R.;
Cassan, A.;
Cole, A.;
Corrales, E.;
Coutures, Ch.;
Dieters, S.;
Donatowicz, J.;
Fouqué, P.;
Greenhill, J.;
Kains, N.;
Kane, S. R.;
Kubas, D.;
Marquette, J. -B.;
Martin, R.;
Menzies, J.;
Pollard, K. R.;
Ranc, C.;
Sahu, K. C.;
Wambsganss, J.;
Williams, A.;
Wouters, D.;
Tsapras, Y.;
Bramich, D. M.;
Horne, K.;
Hundertmark, M.;
Snodgrass, C.;
Steele, I. A.;
Alsubai, K. A.;
Browne, P.;
Burgdorf, M. J.;
Novati, S. Calchi;
Dodds, P.;
Dominik, M.;
Dreizler, S.;
Fang, X. -S.;
Gu, C. -H.;
Hardis;
Harpsøe, K.;
Hessman, F. V.;
Hinse, T. C.;
Hornstrup, A.;
Jessen-Hansen, J.;
Kerins, E.;
Liebig, C.;
Lund, M.;
Lundkvist, M.;
Mancini, L.;
Mathiasen, M.;
Penny, M. T.;
Rahvar, S.;
Ricci, D.;
Scarpetta, G.;
Skottfelt, J.;
Southworth, J.;
Surdej, J.;
Tregloan-Reed, J.;
Wertz, O.
Submitted: 2014-10-30, last modified: 2015-02-23
We report the discovery of a Jupiter-mass planet orbiting an M-dwarf star
that gave rise to the microlensing event OGLE-2011-BLG-0265. Such a system is
very rare among known planetary systems and thus the discovery is important for
theoretical studies of planetary formation and evolution. High-cadence temporal
coverage of the planetary signal combined with extended observations throughout
the event allows us to accurately model the observed light curve. The final
microlensing solution remains, however, degenerate yielding two possible
configurations of the planet and the host star. In the case of the preferred
solution, the mass of the planet is $M_{\rm p} = 0.9\pm 0.3\ M_{\rm J}$, and
the planet is orbiting a star with a mass $M = 0.22\pm 0.06\ M_\odot$. The
second possible configuration (2$\sigma$ away) consists of a planet with
$M_{\rm p}=0.6\pm 0.3\ M_{\rm J}$ and host star with $M=0.14\pm 0.06\ M_\odot$.
The system is located in the Galactic disk 3 -- 4 kpc towards the Galactic
bulge. In both cases, with an orbit size of 1.5 -- 2.0 AU, the planet is a
"cold Jupiter" -- located well beyond the "snow line" of the host star.
Currently available data make the secure selection of the correct solution
difficult, but there are prospects for lifting the degeneracy with additional
follow-up observations in the future, when the lens and source star separate.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1407.1115 [pdf] - 1215402
A Terrestrial Planet in a ~1 AU Orbit Around One Member of a ~15 AU
Binary
Gould, A.;
Udalski, A.;
Shin, I. -G.;
Porritt, I.;
Skowron, J.;
Han, C.;
Yee, J. C.;
Kozłowski, S.;
Choi, J. -Y.;
Poleski, R.;
Wyrzykowski, Ł.;
Ulaczyk, K.;
Pietrukowicz, P.;
Mróz, P.;
Szymański, M. K.;
Kubiak, M.;
Soszyński, I.;
Pietrzyński, G.;
Gaudi, B. S.;
Christie, G. W.;
Drummond, J.;
McCormick, J.;
Natusch, T.;
Ngan, H.;
Tan, T. -G.;
Albrow, M.;
DePoy, D. L.;
Hwang, K. -H.;
Jung, Y. K.;
Lee, C. -U.;
Park, H.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Abe, F.;
Bennett, D. P.;
Bond, I. A.;
Botzler, C. S.;
Freeman, M.;
Fukui, A.;
Fukunaga, D.;
Itow, Y.;
Koshimoto, N.;
Larsen, P.;
Ling, C. H.;
Masuda, K.;
Matsubara, Y.;
Muraki, Y.;
Namba, S.;
Ohnishi, K.;
Philpott, L.;
Rattenbury, N. J.;
Saito, To.;
Sullivan, D. J.;
Sumi, T.;
Suzuki, D.;
Tristram, P. J.;
Tsurumi, N.;
Wada, K.;
Yamai, N.;
Yock, P. C. M.;
Yonehara, A.;
Shvartzvald, Y.;
Maoz, D.;
Kaspi, S.;
Friedmann, M.
Submitted: 2014-07-03
We detect a cold, terrestrial planet in a binary-star system using
gravitational microlensing. The planet has low mass (2 Earth masses) and lies
projected at $a_{\perp,ph}$ ~ 0.8 astronomical units (AU) from its host star,
similar to the Earth-Sun distance. However, the planet temperature is much
lower, T<60 Kelvin, because the host star is only 0.10--0.15 solar masses and
therefore more than 400 times less luminous than the Sun. The host is itself
orbiting a slightly more massive companion with projected separation
$a_{\perp,ch}=$10--15 AU. Straightforward modification of current microlensing
search strategies could increase their sensitivity to planets in binary
systems. With more detections, such binary-star/planetary systems could place
constraints on models of planet formation and evolution. This detection is
consistent with such systems being very common.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1403.2134 [pdf] - 1208276
MOA-2013-BLG-220Lb: Massive Planetary Companion to Galactic-Disk Host
Yee, J. C.;
Han, C.;
Gould, A.;
Skowron, J.;
Bond, I. A.;
Udalski, A.;
Hundertmark, M.;
Monard, L. A. G.;
Porritt, I.;
Nelson, P.;
Bozza, V.;
Albrow, M. D.;
Choi, J. -Y.;
Christie, G. W.;
DePoy, D. L.;
Gaudi, B. S.;
Hwang, K. -H.;
Jung, Y. K.;
Lee, C. -U.;
McCormick, J.;
Natusch, T.;
Ngan, H.;
Park, H.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Shin, I. -G.;
Tan, T. -G.;
Abe, F.;
Bennett, D. P.;
Botzler, C. S.;
Freeman, M.;
Fukui, A.;
Fukunaga, D.;
Itow, Y.;
Koshimoto, N.;
Larsen, P.;
Ling, C. H.;
Masuda, K.;
Matsubara, Y.;
Muraki, Y.;
Namba, S.;
Ohnishi, K.;
Philpott, L.;
Rattenbury, N. J.;
Saito, To.;
Sullivan, D. J.;
Sumi, T.;
Sweatman, W. L.;
Suzuki, D.;
Tristram, P. J.;
Tsurumi, N.;
Wada, K.;
Yamai, N.;
Yock, P. C. M.;
Yonehara, A.;
Szymański, M. K.;
Ulaczyk, K.;
Kozłowski, S.;
Poleski, R.;
Wyrzykowski, Ł.;
Kubiak, M.;
Pietrukowicz, P.;
Pietrzyński, G.;
Soszyński, I.;
Bramich, D. M.;
Browne, P.;
Jaimes, R. Figuera;
Horne, K.;
Ipatov, S.;
Kains, N.;
Snodgrass, C.;
Steele, I. A.;
Street, R.;
Tsapras, Y.
Submitted: 2014-03-09, last modified: 2014-05-29
We report the discovery of MOA-2013-BLG-220Lb, which has a super-Jupiter mass
ratio $q=3.01\pm 0.02\times 10^{-3}$ relative to its host. The proper motion,
$\mu=12.5\pm 1\, {\rm mas}\,{\rm yr}^{-1}$, is one of the highest for
microlensing planets yet discovered, implying that it will be possible to
separately resolve the host within $\sim 7$ years. Two separate lines of
evidence imply that the planet and host are in the Galactic disk. The planet
could have been detected and characterized purely with follow-up data, which
has important implications for microlensing surveys, both current and into the
LSST era.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1403.1672 [pdf] - 1208235
OGLE-2012-BLG-0455/MOA-2012-BLG-206: Microlensing event with ambiguity
in planetary interpretations caused by incomplete coverage of planetary
signal
Park, H.;
Han, C.;
Gould, A.;
Udalski, A.;
Sumi, T.;
Fouqué, P.;
Choi, J. -Y.;
Christie, G.;
Depoy, D. L.;
Dong, Subo;
Gaudi, B. S.;
Hwang, K. -H.;
Jung, Y. K.;
Kavka, A.;
Lee, C. -U.;
Monard, L. A. G.;
Natusch, T.;
Ngan, H.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Shin, I. -G.;
Yee, J. C.;
Szymański, M. K.;
Kubiak, M.;
Soszyński, I.;
Pietrzyński, G.;
Poleski, R.;
Ulaczyk, K.;
Pietrukowicz, P.;
Kozłowski, S.;
Skowron, J.;
Wyrzykowski, Ł.;
Abe, F.;
Bennett, D. P.;
Bond, I. A.;
Botzler, C. S.;
Chote, P.;
Freeman, M.;
Fukui, A.;
Fukunaga, D.;
Harris, P.;
Itow, Y.;
Koshimoto, N.;
Ling, C. H.;
Masuda, K.;
Matsubara, Y.;
Muraki, Y.;
Namba, S.;
Ohnishi, K.;
Rattenbury, N. J.;
Saito, To.;
Sullivan, D. J.;
Sweatman, W. L.;
Suzuki, D.;
Tristram, P. J.;
Wada, K.;
Yamai, N.;
Yock, P. C. M.;
Yonehara, A.
Submitted: 2014-03-07, last modified: 2014-04-10
Characterizing a microlensing planet is done from modeling an observed
lensing light curve. In this process, it is often confronted that solutions of
different lensing parameters result in similar light curves, causing
difficulties in uniquely interpreting the lens system, and thus understanding
the causes of different types of degeneracy is important. In this work, we show
that incomplete coverage of a planetary perturbation can result in degenerate
solutions even for events where the planetary signal is detected with a high
level of statistical significance. We demonstrate the degeneracy for an
actually observed event OGLE-2012-BLG-0455/MOA-2012-BLG-206. The peak of this
high-magnification event $(A_{\rm max}\sim400)$ exhibits very strong deviation
from a point-lens model with $\Delta\chi^{2}\gtrsim4000$ for data sets with a
total number of measurement 6963. From detailed modeling of the light curve, we
find that the deviation can be explained by four distinct solutions, i.e., two
very different sets of solutions, each with a two-fold degeneracy. While the
two-fold (so-called "close/wide") degeneracy is well-understood, the degeneracy
between the radically different solutions is not previously known. The model
light curves of this degeneracy differ substantially in the parts that were not
covered by observation, indicating that the degeneracy is caused by the
incomplete coverage of the perturbation. It is expected that the frequency of
the degeneracy introduced in this work will be greatly reduced with the
improvement of the current lensing survey and follow-up experiments and the
advent of new surveys.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1403.3092 [pdf] - 1208350
Candidate Gravitational Microlensing Events for Future Direct Lens
Imaging
Henderson, C. B.;
Park, H.;
Sumi, T.;
Udalski, A.;
Gould, A.;
Tsapras, Y.;
Han, C.;
Gaudi, B. S.;
Bozza, V.;
Abe, F.;
Bennett, D. P.;
Bond, I. A.;
Botzler, C. S.;
Freeman, M.;
Fukui, A.;
Fukunaga, D.;
Itow, Y.;
Koshimoto, N.;
Ling, C. H.;
Masuda, K.;
Matsubara, Y.;
Muraki, Y.;
Namba, S.;
Ohnishi, K.;
Rattenbury, N. J.;
Saito, To.;
Sullivan, D. J.;
Suzuki, D.;
Sweatman, W. L.;
Tristram, P. J.;
Tsurumi, N.;
Wada, K.;
Yamai, N.;
Yock, P. C. M.;
Yonehara, A.;
Szymański, M. K.;
Kubiak, M.;
Pietrzyński, G.;
Soszyński, I.;
Skowron, J.;
Kozłowski, S.;
Poleski, R.;
Ulaczyk, K.;
Wyrzykowski, Ł.;
Pietrukowicz, P.;
Almeida, L. A.;
Bos, M.;
Choi, J. -Y.;
Christie, G. W.;
Depoy, D. L.;
Dong, Subo;
Friedmann, M.;
Hwang, K. -H.;
Jablonski, F.;
Jung, Y. K.;
Kaspi, S.;
Lee, C. -U.;
Maoz, D.;
McCormick, J.;
Moorhouse, D.;
Natusch, T.;
Ngan, H.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Shin, I. -G.;
Shvartzvald, Y.;
Tan, T. -G.;
Thornley, G.;
Yee, J. C.;
Allan, A.;
Bramich, D. M.;
Browne, P.;
Dominik, M.;
Horne, K.;
Hundertmark, M.;
Jaimes, R. Figuera;
Kains, N.;
Snodgrass, C.;
Steele, I. A.;
Street, R. A.
Submitted: 2014-03-12
The mass of the lenses giving rise to Galactic microlensing events can be
constrained by measuring the relative lens-source proper motion and lens flux.
The flux of the lens can be separated from that of the source, companions to
the source, and unrelated nearby stars with high-resolution images taken when
the lens and source are spatially resolved. For typical ground-based adaptive
optics (AO) or space-based observations, this requires either inordinately long
time baselines or high relative proper motions. We provide a list of
microlensing events toward the Galactic Bulge with high relative lens-source
proper motion that are therefore good candidates for constraining the lens mass
with future high-resolution imaging. We investigate all events from 2004 --
2013 that display detectable finite-source effects, a feature that allows us to
measure the proper motion. In total, we present 20 events with mu >~ 8 mas/yr.
Of these, 14 were culled from previous analyses while 6 are new, including
OGLE-2004-BLG-368, MOA-2005-BLG-36, OGLE-2012-BLG-0211, OGLE-2012-BLG-0456,
MOA-2012-BLG-532, and MOA-2013-BLG-029. In <~12 years the lens and source of
each event will be sufficiently separated for ground-based telescopes with AO
systems or space telescopes to resolve each component and further characterize
the lens system. Furthermore, for the most recent events, comparison of the
lens flux estimates from images taken immediately to those estimated from
images taken when the lens and source are resolved can be used to empirically
check the robustness of the single-epoch method currently being used to
estimate lens masses for many events.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.2428 [pdf] - 1179818
A Super-Jupiter orbiting a late-type star: A refined analysis of
microlensing event OGLE-2012-BLG-0406
Tsapras, Y.;
Choi, J. -Y.;
Street, R. A.;
Han, C.;
Bozza, V.;
Gould, A.;
Dominik, M.;
Beaulieu, J. -P.;
Udalski, A.;
Jørgensen, U. G.;
Sumi, T.;
Bramich, D. M.;
Browne, P.;
Horne, K.;
Hundertmark, M.;
Ipatov, S.;
Kains, N.;
Snodgrass, C.;
Steele, I. A.;
Alsubai, K. A.;
Andersen, J. M.;
Novati, S. Calchi;
Damerdji, Y.;
Diehl, C.;
Elyiv, A.;
Giannini, E.;
Hardis, S.;
Harpsøe, K.;
Hinse, T. C.;
Juncher, D.;
Kerins, E.;
Korhonen, H.;
Liebig, C.;
Mancini, L.;
Mathiasen, M.;
Penny, M. T.;
Rabus, M.;
Rahvar, S.;
Scarpetta, G.;
Skottfelt, J.;
Southworth, J.;
Surdej, J.;
Tregloan-Reed, J.;
Vilela, C.;
Wambsganss, J.;
Skowron, J.;
Poleski, R.;
Kozłowski, S.;
Wyrzykowski, Łukasz;
Szymański, M. K.;
Kubiak, M.;
Pietrukowicz, P.;
Pietrzyński, G.;
Soszyński, I.;
Ulaczyk, K.;
Albrow, M. D.;
Bachelet, E.;
Barry, R.;
Batista, V.;
Bhattacharya, A.;
Brillant, S.;
Caldwell, J. A. R.;
Cassan, A.;
Cole, A.;
Corrales, E.;
Coutures, Ch.;
Dieters, S.;
Prester, D. Dominis;
Donatowicz, J.;
Fouqué, P.;
Greenhill, J.;
Kane, S. R.;
Kubas, D.;
Marquette, J. -B.;
Menzies, J.;
P`ere, C.;
Pollard, K. R.;
Wouters, D.;
Christie, G.;
DePoy, D. L.;
Dong, S.;
Drummond, J.;
Gaudi, B. S.;
Henderson, C. B.;
Hwang, K. H.;
Jung, Y. K.;
Kavka, A.;
Koo, J. -R.;
Lee, C. -U.;
Maoz, D.;
Monard, L. A. G.;
Natusch, T.;
Ngan, H.;
Park, H.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Porritt, I.;
Shin, I. -G.;
Shvartzvald, Y.;
Tan, T. G.;
Yee, J. C.;
Abe, F.;
Bennett, D. P.;
Bond, I. A.;
Botzler, C. S.;
Freeman, M.;
Fukui, A.;
Fukunaga, D.;
Itow, Y.;
Koshimoto, N.;
Ling, C. H.;
Masuda, K.;
Matsubara, Y.;
Muraki, Y.;
Namba, S.;
Ohnishi, K.;
Rattenbury, N. J.;
Saito, To.;
Sullivan, D. J.;
Sweatman, W. L.;
Suzuki, D.;
Tristram, P. J.;
Tsurumi, N.;
Wada, K.;
Yamai, N.;
Yonehara, P. C. M. Yock A.
Submitted: 2013-10-09, last modified: 2013-12-05
We present a detailed analysis of survey and follow-up observations of
microlensing event OGLE-2012-BLG-0406 based on data obtained from 10 different
observatories. Intensive coverage of the lightcurve, especially the
perturbation part, allowed us to accurately measure the parallax effect and
lens orbital motion. Combining our measurement of the lens parallax with the
angular Einstein radius determined from finite-source effects, we estimate the
physical parameters of the lens system. We find that the event was caused by a
$2.73\pm 0.43\ M_{\rm J}$ planet orbiting a $0.44\pm 0.07\ M_{\odot}$ early
M-type star. The distance to the lens is $4.97\pm 0.29$\ kpc and the projected
separation between the host star and its planet at the time of the event is
$3.45\pm 0.26$ AU. We find that the additional coverage provided by follow-up
observations, especially during the planetary perturbation, leads to a more
accurate determination of the physical parameters of the lens.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1307.6335 [pdf] - 1172942
Microlensing Discovery of a Tight, Low Mass-ratio Planetary-mass Object
around an Old, Field Brown Dwarf
Han, C.;
Jung, Y. K.;
Udalski, A.;
Sumi, T.;
Gaudi, B. S.;
Gould, A.;
Bennett, D. P.;
Tsapras, Y.;
Szymański, M. K.;
Kubiak, M.;
Pietrzyński, G.;
Soszyński, I.;
Skowron, J.;
Kozłowski, S.;
Poleski, R.;
Ulaczyk, K.;
Wyrzykowski, Ł.;
Pietrukowicz, P.;
Abe, F.;
Bond, I. A.;
Botzler, C. S.;
Chote, P.;
Freeman, M.;
Fukui, A.;
Furusawa, K.;
Harris, P.;
Itow, Y.;
Ling, C. H.;
Masuda, K.;
Matsubara, Y.;
Muraki, Y.;
Ohnishi, K.;
Rattenbury, N. J.;
Saito, To.;
Sullivan, D. J.;
Sweatman, W. L.;
Suzuki, D.;
Tristram, P. J.;
Wada, K.;
Yock, P. C. M.;
Batista, V.;
Christie, G.;
Choi, J. -Y.;
DePoy, D. L.;
Dong, Subo;
Hwang, K. -H.;
Kavka, A.;
Lee, C. -U.;
Monard, L. A. G.;
Natusch, T.;
Ngan, H.;
Park, H.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Porritt, I.;
Shin, I. -G.;
Tan, T. G.;
Yee, J. C.;
Alsubai, K. A.;
Bozza, V.;
Bramich, D. M.;
Browne, P.;
Dominik, M.;
Horne, K.;
Hundertmark, M.;
Ipatov, S.;
Kains, N.;
Liebig, C.;
Snodgrass, C.;
Steele, I. A.;
Street, R. A.
Submitted: 2013-07-24, last modified: 2013-07-25
Observations of accretion disks around young brown dwarfs have led to the
speculation that they may form planetary systems similar to normal stars. While
there have been several detections of planetary-mass objects around brown
dwarfs (2MASS 1207-3932 and 2MASS 0441-2301), these companions have relatively
large mass ratios and projected separations, suggesting that they formed in a
manner analogous to stellar binaries. We present the discovery of a
planetary-mass object orbiting a field brown dwarf via gravitational
microlensing, OGLE-2012-BLG-0358Lb. The system is a low secondary/primary mass
ratio (0.080 +- 0.001), relatively tightly-separated (~0.87 AU) binary composed
of a planetary-mass object with 1.9 +- 0.2 Jupiter masses orbiting a brown
dwarf with a mass 0.022 M_Sun. The relatively small mass ratio and separation
suggest that the companion may have formed in a protoplanetary disk around the
brown dwarf host, in a manner analogous to planets.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1303.1184 [pdf] - 1165025
A Giant Planet beyond the Snow Line in Microlensing Event
OGLE-2011-BLG-0251
Kains, N.;
Street, R.;
Choi, J. -Y.;
Han, C.;
Udalski, A.;
Almeida, L. A.;
Jablonski, F.;
Tristram, P.;
Jorgensen, U. G.;
Szymanski, M. K.;
Kubiak, M.;
Pietrzynski, G.;
Soszynski, I.;
Poleski, R.;
Kozlowski, S.;
Pietrukowicz, P.;
Ulaczyk, K.;
Wyrzykowski, L.;
Skowron, J.;
Alsubai, K. A.;
Bozza, V.;
Browne, P.;
Burgdorf, M. J.;
Novati, S. Calchi;
Dodds, P.;
Dominik, M.;
Dreizler, S.;
Fang, X. -S.;
Grundahl, F.;
Gu, C. -H.;
Hardis, S.;
Harpsoe, K.;
Hessman, F. V.;
Hinse, T. C.;
Hornstrup, A.;
Hundertmark, M.;
Jessen-Hansen, J.;
Kerins, E.;
Liebig, C.;
Lund, M.;
Lundkvist, M.;
Mancini, L.;
Mathiasen, M.;
Penny, M. T.;
Rahvar, S.;
Ricci, D.;
Sahu, K. C.;
Scarpetta, G.;
Skottfelt, J.;
Snodgrass, C.;
Southworth, J.;
Surdej, J.;
Tregloan-Reed, J.;
Wambsganss, J.;
Wertz, O.;
Bajek, D.;
Bramich, D. M.;
Horne, K.;
Ipatov, S.;
Steele, I. A.;
Tsapras, Y.;
Abe, F.;
Bennett, D. P.;
Bond, I. A.;
Botzler, C. S.;
Chote, P.;
Freeman, M.;
Fukui, A.;
Furusawa, K.;
Itow, Y.;
Ling, C. H.;
Masuda, K.;
Matsubara, Y.;
Miyake, N.;
Muraki, Y.;
Ohnishi, K.;
Rattenbury, N.;
Saito, T.;
Sullivan, D. J.;
Sumi, T.;
Suzuki, D.;
Suzuki, K.;
Sweatman, W. L.;
Takino, S.;
Wada, K.;
Yock, P. C. M.;
Allen, W.;
Batista, V.;
Chung, S. -J.;
Christie, G.;
DePoy, D. L.;
Drummond, J.;
Gaudi, B. S.;
Gould, A.;
Henderson, C.;
Jung, Y. -K.;
Koo, J. -R.;
Lee, C. -U.;
McCormick, J.;
McGregor, D.;
Munoz, J. A.;
Natusch, T.;
Ngan, H.;
Park, H.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Shin, I. -G.;
Yee, J.;
Albrow, M. D.;
Bachelet, E.;
Beaulieu, J. -P.;
Brillant, S.;
Caldwell, J. A. R.;
Cassan, A.;
Cole, A.;
Corrales, E.;
Coutures, Ch.;
Dieters, S.;
Prester, D. Dominis;
Donatowicz, J.;
Fouque, P.;
Greenhill, J.;
Kane, S. R.;
Kubas, D.;
Marquette, J. -B.;
Martin, R.;
Meintjes, P.;
Menzies, J.;
Pollard, K. R.;
Williams, A.;
Wouters, D.;
Zub, M.
Submitted: 2013-03-05
We present the analysis of the gravitational microlensing event
OGLE-2011-BLG-0251. This anomalous event was observed by several survey and
follow-up collaborations conducting microlensing observations towards the
Galactic Bulge. Based on detailed modelling of the observed light curve, we
find that the lens is composed of two masses with a mass ratio q=1.9 x 10^-3.
Thanks to our detection of higher-order effects on the light curve due to the
Earth's orbital motion and the finite size of source, we are able to measure
the mass and distance to the lens unambiguously. We find that the lens is made
up of a planet of mass 0.53 +- 0.21,M_Jup orbiting an M dwarf host star with a
mass of 0.26 +- 0.11 M_Sun. The planetary system is located at a distance of
2.57 +- 0.61 kpc towards the Galactic Centre. The projected separation of the
planet from its host star is d=1.408 +- 0.019, in units of the Einstein radius,
which corresponds to 2.72 +- 0.75 AU in physical units. We also identified a
competitive model with similar planet and host star masses, but with a smaller
orbital radius of 1.50 +- 0.50 AU. The planet is therefore located beyond the
snow line of its host star, which we estimate to be around 1-1.5 AU.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1210.4265 [pdf] - 1152158
The second multiple-planet system discovered by microlensing:
OGLE-2012-BLG-0026Lb, c, a pair of jovian planets beyond the snow line
Han, C.;
Udalski, A.;
Choi, J. -Y.;
Yee, J. C.;
Gould, A.;
Christie, G.;
Tan, T. -G.;
Szymański, M. K.;
Kubiak, M.;
Soszyński, I.;
Pietrzyński, G.;
Poleski, R.;
Ulaczyk, K.;
Pietrukowicz, P.;
Kozłowski, S.;
Skowron, J.;
Wyrzykowski, Ł.;
Almeida, L. A.;
Batista, V.;
Depoy, D. L.;
Dong, Subo;
Drummond, J.;
Gaudi, B. S.;
Hwang, K. -H.;
Jablonski, F.;
Jung, Y. -K.;
Lee, C. -U.;
Koo, J. -R.;
McCormick, J.;
Monard, L. A. G.;
Natusch, T.;
Ngan, H.;
Park, H.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Porritt, Ian;
Shin, I. -G.
Submitted: 2012-10-16, last modified: 2012-12-04
We report the discovery of a planetary system from observation of the
high-magnification microlensing event OGLE-2012-BLG-0026. The lensing light
curve exhibits a complex central perturbation with multiple features. We find
that the perturbation was produced by two planets located near the Einstein
ring of the planet host star. We identify 4 possible solutions resulting from
the well-known close/wide degeneracy. By measuring both the lens parallax and
the Einstein radius, we estimate the physical parameters of the planetary
system. According to the best-fit model, the two planet masses are ~0.11
M_Jupiter and 0.68 M_Jupiter and they are orbiting a G-type main sequence star
with a mass ~0.82 M_Sun. The projected separations of the individual planets
are beyond the snow line in all four solutions, being ~3.8 AU and 4.6 AU in the
best-fit solution. The deprojected separations are both individually larger and
possibly reversed in order. This is the second multi-planet system with both
planets beyond the snow line discovered by microlensing. This is the only such
a system (other than the Solar System) with measured planet masses without
sin(i) degeneracy. The planetary system is located at a distance 4.1 kpc from
the Earth toward the Galactic center. It is very likely that extra light from
stars other than the lensed star comes from the lens itself. If this is
correct, it will be possible to obtain detailed information about the
planet-host star from follow-up observation.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1204.2869 [pdf] - 1453901
Characterizing Low-Mass Binaries From Observation of Long Time-scale
Caustic-crossing Gravitational Microlensing Events
Shin, I. -G.;
Han, C.;
Choi, J. -Y.;
Udalski, A.;
Sumi, T.;
Gould, A.;
Bozza, V.;
Dominik, M.;
Fouqué, P.;
Horne, K.;
M.;
Szymański, K.;
Kubiak, M.;
Soszyński, I.;
Pietrzyński, G.;
Poleski, R.;
Ulaczyk, K.;
Pietrukowicz, P.;
Kozłowski, S.;
Skowron, J.;
Wyrzykowski, Ł.;
Abe, F.;
Bennett, D. P.;
Bond, I. A.;
Botzler, C. S.;
Chote, P.;
Freeman, M.;
Fukui, A.;
Furusawa, K.;
Itow, Y.;
Kobara, S.;
Ling, C. H.;
Masuda, K.;
Matsubara, Y.;
Miyake, N.;
Muraki, Y.;
Ohmori, K.;
Ohnishi, K.;
Rattenbury, N. J.;
Saito, To.;
Sullivan, D. J.;
Suzuki, D.;
Suzuki, K.;
Sweatman, W. L.;
Takino, S.;
Tristram, P. J.;
Wada, K.;
Yock, P. C. M.;
Bramich, D. M.;
Snodgrass, C.;
Steele, I. A.;
Street, R. A.;
Tsapras, Y.;
Alsubai, K. A.;
Browne, P.;
Burgdorf, M. J.;
Novati, S. Calchi;
Dodds, P.;
Dreizler, S.;
Fang, X. -S.;
Grundahl, F.;
Gu, C. -H.;
Hardis, S.;
Harpsøe, K.;
Hinse, T. C.;
Hornstrup, A.;
Hundertmark, M.;
Jessen-Hansen, J.;
Jørgensen, U. G.;
Kains, N.;
Kerins, E.;
Liebig, C.;
Lund, M.;
Lunkkvist, M.;
Mancini, L.;
Mathiasen, M.;
Penny, M. T.;
Rahvar, S.;
Ricci, D.;
Scarpetta, G.;
Skottfelt, J.;
Southworth, J.;
Surdej, J.;
Tregloan-Reed, J.;
Wambsganss, J.;
Wertz, O.;
Almeida, L. A.;
Batista, V.;
Christie, G.;
DePoy, D. L.;
Dong, Subo;
Gaudi, B. S.;
Henderson, C.;
Jablonski, F.;
Lee, C. -U.;
McCormick, J.;
McGregor, D.;
Moorhouse, D.;
Natusch, T.;
Ngan, H.;
Park, S. -Y.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Tan, T. -G.;
Thornley, G.;
Yee, J. C.;
Albrow, M. D.;
Bachelet, E.;
Beaulieu, J. -P.;
Brillant, S.;
Cassan, A.;
Cole, A. A.;
Corrales, E.;
Coutures, C.;
Dieters, S.;
Prester, D. Dominis;
Donatowicz, J.;
Greenhill, J.;
Kubas, D.;
Marquette, J. -B.;
Menzies, J. W.;
Sahu, K. C.;
Zub, M.
Submitted: 2012-04-12, last modified: 2012-06-12
Despite astrophysical importance of binary star systems, detections are
limited to those located in small ranges of separations, distances, and masses
and thus it is necessary to use a variety of observational techniques for a
complete view of stellar multiplicity across a broad range of physical
parameters. In this paper, we report the detections and measurements of 2
binaries discovered from observations of microlensing events MOA-2011-BLG-090
and OGLE-2011-BLG-0417. Determinations of the binary masses are possible by
simultaneously measuring the Einstein radius and the lens parallax. The
measured masses of the binary components are 0.43 $M_{\odot}$ and 0.39
$M_{\odot}$ for MOA-2011-BLG-090 and 0.57 $M_{\odot}$ and 0.17 $M_{\odot}$ for
OGLE-2011-BLG-0417 and thus both lens components of MOA-2011-BLG-090 and one
component of OGLE-2011-BLG-0417 are M dwarfs, demonstrating the usefulness of
microlensing in detecting binaries composed of low-mass components. From
modeling of the light curves considering full Keplerian motion of the lens, we
also measure the orbital parameters of the binaries. The blended light of
OGLE-2011-BLG-0417 comes very likely from the lens itself, making it possible
to check the microlensing orbital solution by follow-up radial-velocity
observation. For both events, the caustic-crossing parts of the light curves,
which are critical for determining the physical lens parameters, were resolved
by high-cadence survey observations and thus it is expected that the number of
microlensing binaries with measured physical parameters will increase in the
future.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1204.4789 [pdf] - 1118180
A New Type of Ambiguity in the Planet and Binary Interpretations of
Central Perturbations of High-Magnification Gravitational Microlensing Events
Choi, J. -Y.;
Shin, I. -G.;
Han, C.;
Udalski, A.;
Sumi, T.;
Gould, A.;
Bozza, V.;
Dominik, M.;
Fouqué, P.;
Horne, K.;
Szymański, M. K.;
Kubiak, M.;
Soszyński, I.;
Pietrzyński, G.;
Poleski, R.;
Ulaczyk, K.;
Pietrukowicz, P.;
Kozłowski, S.;
Skowron, J.;
Wyrzykowski, Ł.;
Abe, F.;
Bennett, D. P.;
Bond, I. A.;
Botzler, C. S.;
Chote, P.;
Freeman, M.;
Fukui, A.;
Furusawa, K.;
Itow, Y.;
Kobara, S.;
Ling, C. H.;
Masuda, K.;
Matsubara, Y.;
Miyake, N.;
Muraki, Y.;
Ohmori, K.;
Ohnishi, K.;
Rattenbury, N. J.;
Saito, To.;
Sullivan, D. J.;
Suzuki, D.;
Suzuki, K.;
Sweatman, W. L.;
Takino, S.;
Tristram, P. J.;
Wada, K.;
Yock, P. C. M.;
Bramich, D. M.;
Snodgrass, C.;
Steele, I. A.;
Street, R. A.;
Tsapras, Y.;
Alsubai, K. A.;
Browne, P.;
Burgdorf, M. J.;
Novati, S. Calchi;
Dodds, P.;
Dreizler, S.;
Fang, X. -S.;
Grundahl, F.;
Gu, C. -H.;
Hardis, S.;
Harpsøe, K.;
Hinse, T. C.;
Hornstrup, A.;
Hundertmark, M.;
Jessen-Hansen, J.;
Jørgensen, U. G.;
Kains, N.;
Kerins, E.;
Liebig, C.;
Lund, M.;
Lunkkvist, M.;
Mancini, L.;
Mathiasen, M.;
Penny, M. T.;
Rahvar, S.;
Ricci, D.;
Scarpetta, G.;
Skottfelt, J.;
Southworth, J.;
Surdej, J.;
Tregloan-Reed, J.;
Wambsganss, J.;
Wertz, O.;
Almeida, L. A.;
Batista, V.;
Christie, G.;
DePoy, D. L.;
Dong, Subo;
Gaudi, B. S.;
Henderson, C.;
Jablonski, F.;
Lee, C. -U.;
McCormick, J.;
McGregor, D.;
Moorhouse, D.;
Natusch, T.;
Ngan, H.;
Park, S. -Y.;
Pogge, R. W.;
Tan, T. -G.;
Thornley, G.;
Yee, J. C.;
Albrow, M. D.;
Bachelet, E.;
Beaulieu, J. -P.;
Brillant, S.;
Cassan, A.;
Cole, A. A.;
Corrales, E.;
Coutures, C.;
Dieters, S.;
Prester, D. Dominis;
Donatowicz, J.;
Greenhill, J.;
Kubas, D.;
Marquette, J. -B.;
Menzies, J. W.;
Sahu, K. C.;
Zub, M.
Submitted: 2012-04-21, last modified: 2012-04-25
High-magnification microlensing events provide an important channel to detect
planets. Perturbations near the peak of a high-magnification event can be
produced either by a planet or a binary companion. It is known that central
perturbations induced by both types of companions can be generally
distinguished due to the basically different magnification pattern around
caustics. In this paper, we present a case of central perturbations for which
it is difficult to distinguish the planetary and binary interpretations. The
peak of a lensing light curve affected by this perturbation appears to be blunt
and flat. For a planetary case, this perturbation occurs when the source
trajectory passes the negative perturbation region behind the back end of an
arrowhead-shaped central caustic. For a binary case, a similar perturbation
occurs for a source trajectory passing through the negative perturbation region
between two cusps of an astroid-shaped caustic. We demonstrate the degeneracy
for 2 high-magnification events of OGLE-2011-BLG-0526 and
OGLE-2011-BLG-0950/MOA-2011-BLG-336. For OGLE-2011-BLG-0526, the $\chi^2$
difference between the planetary and binary model is $\sim$ 3, implying that
the degeneracy is very severe. For OGLE-2011-BLG-0950/MOA-2011-BLG-336, the
stellar binary model is formally excluded with $\Delta \chi^2 \sim$ 105 and the
planetary model is preferred. However, it is difficult to claim a planet
discovery because systematic residuals of data from the planetary model are
larger than the difference between the planetary and binary models. Considering
that 2 events observed during a single season suffer from such a degeneracy, it
is expected that central perturbations experiencing this type of degeneracy is
common.