Normalized to: Nanayakkara, T.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.01878 [pdf] - 2128466
XV. The mean rest-UV spectra of Ly-alpha emitters at z>3
Feltre, Anna;
Maseda, Michael V.;
Bacon, Roland;
Pradeep, Jayadev;
Leclercq, Floriane;
Kusakabe, Haruka;
Wisotzki, Lutz;
Hashimoto, Takuya;
Schmidt, Kasper B.;
Blaizot, Jeremy;
Brinchmann, Jarle;
Boogaard, Leindert;
Cantalupo, Sebastiano;
Carton, David;
Inami, Hanae;
Kollatschny, Wolfram;
Marino, Raffaella A.;
Matthee, Jorryt;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Richard, Johan;
Schaye, Joop;
Tresse, Laurence;
Urrutia, Tanya;
Verhamme, Anne;
Weilbacher, Peter M.
Submitted: 2020-07-03
We investigate the ultraviolet (UV) spectral properties of faint
Lyman-$\alpha$ emitters (LAEs) in the redshift range 2.9<z<4.6 and provide
material to prepare future observations of the faint Universe. We use data from
the MUSE Hubble Ultra Deep Survey to construct mean rest-frame spectra of
continuum-faint (median M$_{UV}$ of -18 and down to M$_{UV}$ of -16), low
stellar mass (median value of $10^{8.4}$ and down to $10^{7}M_{\odot}$) LAEs at
redshift z>3. We compute various averaged spectra of LAEs sub-sampled on the
basis of their observational (e.g., Ly$\alpha$ strength, UV magnitude and
spectral slope) and physical (e.g., stellar mass and star-formation rate)
properties. We search for UV spectral features other than Ly$\alpha$, such as
higher-ionization nebular emission lines and absorption features. We
successfully observe the OIII]1666 and CIII]909 collisionally excited emission
lines and the HeII1640 recombination feature, as well as the resonant CIV1550
doublet either in emission or P-Cygni. We compare the observed spectral
properties of the different mean spectra and find the emission lines to vary
with the observational and physical properties of the LAEs. In particular, the
mean spectra of LAEs with larger Ly$\alpha$ equivalent widths, fainter UV
magnitudes, bluer UV spectral slopes and lower stellar masses show the
strongest nebular emission. The line ratios of these lines are similar to those
measured in the spectra of local metal-poor galaxies, while their equivalent
widths are weaker compared to the handful of extreme values detected in
individual spectra of z>2 galaxies. This suggests that weak UV features are
likely ubiquitous in high z, low-mass and faint LAEs. We publicly release the
stacked spectra as they can serve as empirical templates for the design of
future observations, such as those with the James Webb Space Telescope and the
Extremely Large Telescope.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.13079 [pdf] - 2085298
MOSEL: Strong [OIII]5007 \AA\ Emitting Galaxies at (3<z<4) from the
ZFOURGE Survey
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Forrest, Ben;
Alcorn, Leo Y.;
Yuan, Tiantian;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Cohn, Jonathan;
Cowley, Michael;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Gupta, Anshu;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Kewley, Lisa;
Labbe, Ivo;
Papovich, Casey;
Spitler, Lee;
Straatman, Caroline M. S.;
Tomczak, Adam
Submitted: 2020-04-27
To understand how strong emission line galaxies (ELGs) contribute to the
overall growth of galaxies and star formation history of the universe, we
target Strong ELGs (SELGs) from the ZFOURGE imaging survey that have blended
(Hb+[OIII]) rest-frame equivalent widths of >230A and 2.5<zphot<4.0. Using
Keck/MOSFIRE, we measure 49 redshifts for galaxies brighter than Ks=25 mag as
part of our Multi-Object Spectroscopic Emission Line (MOSEL) survey. Our
spectroscopic success rate is ~53% and zphot uncertainty is sigma_z=
[Delta(z)/(1+z)]=0.0135. We confirm 31 ELGs at 3<zspec<3.8 and show that Strong
ELGs have spectroscopic rest-frame [OIII]5007A equivalent widths of 100-500A
and tend to be lower mass systems [log(Mstar/Msun)~8.2-9.6] compared to more
typical star-forming galaxies. The Strong ELGs lie ~0.9 dex above the
star-forming main-sequence at z~3.5 and have high inferred gas fractions of
fgas~>60%, i.e. the inferred gas masses can easily fuel a starburst to double
stellar masses within ~10-100 Myr. Combined with recent results using ZFOURGE,
our analysis indicates that 1) strong [OIII]5007A emission signals an early
episode of intense stellar growth in low mass (Mstar<0.1M*) galaxies and 2)
many, if not most, galaxies at z>3 go through this starburst phase. If true,
low-mass galaxies with strong [OIII]5007A emission (EW_rest>200A) may be an
increasingly important source of ionizing UV radiation at z>3.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.01725 [pdf] - 2077006
MOSEL Survey: Tracking the Growth of Massive Galaxies at 2<z<4 using
Kinematics and the IllustrisTNG Simulation
Gupta, Anshu;
Tran, Kim-Vy;
Cohn, Jonathan;
Alcorn, Leo Y.;
Yuan, Tiantian;
Rodriguez-Gomez, Vicente;
Harshan, Anishya;
Forrest, Ben;
Kewley, Lisa J.;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Straatman, Caroline M.;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Labbé, Ivo;
Papovich, Casey;
Cowley, Michael
Submitted: 2020-03-03
We use K-band spectroscopic data from the Multi-Object Spectroscopic Emission
Line (MOSEL) survey to analyze the kinematic properties of galaxies at z>3. Our
sample consists of 34 galaxies at 3.0<zspec<3.8 between 9.0<log(M_star)<11.0.
We find that galaxies with log(M_star) > 10.2 at z > 3 have 56 +/- 21 km/s
lower integrated velocity dispersion compared to galaxies at z ~ 2 of similar
stellar mass. Massive galaxies at z > 3 have either a flat or declining star
formation history (SFH), whereas similar stellar mass galaxies at z~2.0 exhibit
a slight peak in the past 500 Myrs. Comparing with the IllustrisTNG
cosmological simulation, we find that (i) the dynamical mass of massive
galaxies in simulations (log(M_star) > 10.0) increases by ~0.1 dex at a fixed
stellar mass between z=2.0-3.0, and (ii) dynamical mass growth is coupled with
a rapid rise in the ex-situ stellar mass fraction (stars accreted from other
galaxies) for massive galaxies at z < 3.5. We speculate that the rising
contribution of ex-situ stellar mass to the total stellar mass growth of
massive galaxies is driving the higher integrated velocity dispersion and
rising SFHs of massive galaxies at z~2.0 compared to galaxies of similar
stellar masses at z > 3.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.11117 [pdf] - 2061769
Elevated ionizing photon production efficiency in faint
high-equivalent-width Lyman-alpha emitters
Maseda, Michael V.;
Bacon, Roland;
Lam, Daniel;
Matthee, Jorryt;
Brinchmann, Jarle;
Schaye, Joop;
Labbe, Ivo;
Schmidt, Kasper B.;
Boogaard, Leindert;
Bouwens, Rychard;
Cantalupo, Sebastiano;
Franx, Marijn;
Hashimoto, Takuya;
Inami, Hanae;
Kusakabe, Haruka;
Mahler, Guillaume;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Richard, Johan;
Wisotzki, Lutz
Submitted: 2020-02-25
While low-luminosity galaxies dominate number counts at all redshifts, their
contribution to cosmic Reionization is poorly understood due to a lack of
knowledge of their physical properties. We isolate a sample of 35 z~4-5
continuum-faint Lyman-alpha emitters from deep VLT/MUSE spectroscopy and
directly measure their Halpha emission using stacked Spitzer/IRAC Ch. 1
photometry. Based on Hubble Space Telescope imaging, we determine that the
average UV continuum magnitude is fainter than -16 (~0.01 L_star), implying a
median Lyman-alpha equivalent width of 249 Angstroms. By combining the Halpha
measurement with the UV magnitude we determine the ionizing photon production
efficiency, xi_ion, a first for such faint galaxies. The measurement of log
(xi_ion [Hz/erg]) = 26.28 (+0.28; -0.40) is in excess of literature
measurements of both continuum- and emission line-selected samples, implying a
more efficient production of ionizing photons in these lower-luminosity,
Lyman-alpha-selected systems. We conclude that this elevated efficiency can be
explained by stellar populations with metallicities between 4e-4 and 0.008,
with light-weighted ages less than 3 Myr.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.08353 [pdf] - 2076927
ZFIRE: Measuring Electron Density with [OII] as a function of
environment at z = 1.62
Harshan, Anishya;
Gupta, Anshu;
Tran, Kim-Vy;
Alcorn, Leo Y.;
Yuan, Tiantian;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Kewley, Lisa J.;
Labb'e, Ivo;
Papovich, Casey
Submitted: 2020-02-19, last modified: 2020-02-25
The global star formation rates (SFR) of galaxies at fixed stellar masses
increase with redshift and are known to vary with environment unto z~2. We
explore here whether the changes in the star formation rates can also apply to
the electron densities of the inter-stellar medium (ISM) by measuring the [OII]
(3727A/3729A) ratio for cluster and field galaxies at z~2. We measure a median
electron density of ne = 366+/-84 cm-3 for six galaxies (with 1-sigma scatter =
163 cm-3) in the UDS proton-cluster at z=1.62. We find that the median electron
density of galaxies in the UDS photo-cluster environment is three times higher
compared to the median electron density of field galaxies (ne = 113+/- 63 cm-3
and 1-sigma scatter = 79 cm-3) at comparable redshifts, stellar mass and SFR.
However, we note that a sample of six photo-cluster galaxies is insufficient to
reliably measure the electron density in the average porto-cluster environment
at z~2. We conclude that the electron density increases with redshift in both
cluster and field environments up to z~2 (ne = 30 +/- 1 cm-3 for z ~ 0 to ne
=254+/- 76 cm-3 for z~1.5). We find tentative evidence (~2.6 sigma ) for a
possible dependence of electron density on environment, but the results require
confirmation with larger sample sizes.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.02693 [pdf] - 2046463
Reconstructing the observed ionizing photon production efficiency at z~2
using stellar population models
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Brinchmann, Jarle;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Bouwens, Rychard;
Kewley, Lisa;
Tran, Kim-Vy;
Cowley, Michael;
Fisher, Deanne;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Labbe, Ivo;
Straatman, Caroline
Submitted: 2020-01-08
The ionizing photon production efficiency, $\xi_{ion}$, is a critical
parameter that provides a number of physical constraints to the nature of the
early Universe, including the contribution of galaxies to the timely completion
of the reionization of the Universe. Here we use KECK/MOSFIRE and ZFOURGE
multi-band photometric data to explore the $\xi_{ion}$ of a population of
galaxies at $z\sim2$ with $log_{10}(M_*/M_\odot)\sim9.0-11.5$. Our 130 \Halpha\
detections show a median $log_{10}(\xi_{ion}[Hz/erg])$ of $24.8\pm0.5$ when
dust corrected using a Calzetti et al. (2000) dust prescription. Our values are
typical of mass/magnitude selected $\xi_{ion}$ values observed in the $z\sim2$
Universe. Using BPASSv2.2.1 and Starburst99 stellar population models with
simple parametric star-formation-histories (SFH), we find that even with models
that account for effects of stellar evolution with binaries/stellar rotation,
model galaxies at $log_{10}(\xi_{ion}[Hz/erg])\lesssim25.0$ have low H$\alpha$
equivalent widths (EW) and redder colors compared to our $z\sim2$ observed
sample. We find that introducing star-bursts to the SFHs resolve the tension
with the models, however, due to the rapid time evolution of $\xi_{ion}$,
H$\alpha$ EWs, and rest-frame optical colors, our Monte Carlo simulations of
star-bursts show that random distribution of star-bursts in evolutionary time
of galaxies are unlikely to explain the observed distribution. Thus, either our
observed sample is specially selected based on their past SFH or stellar models
require additional mechanisms to reproduce the observed high UV luminosity of
galaxies for a given production rate of hydrogen ionizing photons.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.08151 [pdf] - 2015927
Stellar populations and physical properties of starbursts in the
Antennae galaxy from self-consistent modelling of MUSE spectra
Submitted: 2019-12-13
We have modelled the stellar and nebular continua and emission-line intensity
ratios of massive stellar populations in the Antennae galaxy using high
resolution and self-consistent libraries of model HII regions around central
clusters of aging stars. The model libraries are constructed using the stellar
population synthesis code, Starburst99, and photoionisation model, Cloudy. The
Geneva and PARSEC stellar evolutionary models are plugged into Starburst99 to
allow comparison between the two models. Using a spectrum-fitting methodology
that allows the spectral features in the stellar and nebular continua (e.g.
Wolf-Rayet features, Paschen jump), and emission-line diagnostics to constrain
the models, we apply the libraries to the high-resolution MUSE spectra of the
starbursting regions in the Antennae galaxy. Through this approach, we were
able to model the continuum emission from Wolf-Rayet stars and extract stellar
and gas metallicities, ages, electron temperatures and densities of starbursts
by exploiting the full spectrum. From the application to the Antennae galaxy,
we find that (1) the starbursts in the Antennae galaxy are characterised by
stellar and gas metallicities of around solar, (2) the star-forming gas in
starbursts in the Western loop of NGC 4038 appear to be more enriched, albeit
slightly, than the rest of galaxy, (3) the youngest starbursts are found across
the overlap region and over parts of the western-loop, though in comparison,
the regions in the western-loop appear to be at a slightly later stage in
star-formation than the overlap region, and (4) the results obtained from
fitting the Geneva and Parsec models are largely consistent.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.07057 [pdf] - 1975397
A Tale of Two Clusters: An Analysis of Gas-Phase Metallicity and Nebular
Gas Conditions in Proto-cluster Galaxies at z~2
Alcorn, Leo Y.;
Gupta, Anshu;
Tran, Kim-Vy;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Yuan, Tiantian;
Cohn, Jonathan;
Forrest, Ben;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Harshan, Anishya;
Kewley, Lisa J.;
Labbé, Ivo;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Papovich, Casey;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Straatman, Caroline M. S.
Submitted: 2019-08-19
The ZFIRE survey has spectroscopically confirmed two proto-clusters using the
MOSFIRE instrument on Keck 1: one at z=2.095 in COSMOS and another at z=1.62 in
UDS. Here we use an updated ZFIRE dataset to derive the properties of ionized
gas regions of proto-cluster galaxies by extracting fluxes from emission lines
H$\beta$ 4861\AA, [OIII] 5007\AA, H$\alpha$ 6563\AA, [NII] 6585\AA, and [SII]
6716,6731\AA. We measure gas-phase metallicity of members in both
proto-clusters using two indicators, including a strong-line indicator
relatively independent of ionization parameter and electron density.
Proto-cluster and field galaxies in both UDS and COSMOS lie on the same
Mass-Metallicity Relation with both metallicity indicators. We compare our
results to recent IllustrisTNG results, which reports no significant gas-phase
metallicity offset between proto-cluster and field galaxies until z=1.5. This
is in agreement with our observed metallicities, where no offset is measured
between proto-cluster and field populations. We measure tentative evidence from
stacked spectra that UDS high mass proto-cluster and field galaxies have
differing [OIII]/H$\beta$ ratios, however these results are dependent on the
sample size of the high mass stacks.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.02786 [pdf] - 1926431
The mean H$\alpha$ EW and Lyman-continuum photon production efficiency
for faint $z\approx4-5$ galaxies
Lam, Daniel;
Bouwens, Rychard J.;
Labbe, Ivo;
Schaye, Joop;
Schmidt, Kasper B.;
Maseda, Michael V.;
Bacon, Roland;
Boogaard, Leindert A.;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Richard, Johan;
Mahler, Guillaume;
Urrutia, Tanya
Submitted: 2019-02-07, last modified: 2019-07-31
We present the first measurements of the Lyman-continuum photon production
efficiency $\xi_{\textrm{ion,0}}$ at $z\sim4$-5 for galaxies fainter than 0.2
$L^*$ ($-$19 mag). $\xi_{\textrm{ion,0}}$ quantifies the production rate of
ionizing photons with respect to the UV luminosity density assuming a fiducial
escape fraction of zero. Extending previous measurements of
$\xi_{\textrm{ion,0}}$ to the faint population is important, as ultra-faint
galaxies are expected to contribute the bulk of the ionizing emissivity. We
probe $\xi_{\textrm{ion,0}}$ to such faint magnitudes by taking advantage of
200-hour depth Spitzer/IRAC observations from the GREATS program and
$\approx$300 3<$z$<6 galaxies with spectroscopic redshifts from the MUSE GTO
Deep + Wide programs. Stacked IRAC [3.6]$-$[4.5] colors are derived and used to
infer the H$\alpha$ rest-frame equivalent widths, which range from 403\r{A} to
2818\r{A}. The derived $\xi_{\textrm{ion,0}}$ is
$\log_{10}(\xi_{\textrm{ion,0}} / \textrm{Hz erg}^{-1}) = 25.36 \pm 0.08$ over
$-$20.5 < M$_{\textrm{UV}}$ < $-$17.5, similar to those derived for brighter
galaxy samples at the same redshift and therefore suggesting that
$\xi_{\textrm{ion}}$ shows no strong dependence on $M_{UV}$. The
$\xi_{\textrm{ion,0}}$ values found in our sample imply that the
Lyman-continuum escape fraction for $M_{\textrm{UV}} \approx -19$ star-forming
galaxies cannot exceed $\approx$8-20\% in the reionization era.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.11586 [pdf] - 1926494
Resolved scaling relations and metallicity gradients on sub-kiloparsec
scales at z=1
Patrício, V.;
Richard, J.;
Carton, D.;
Péroux, C.;
Contini, T.;
Brinchmann, J.;
Schaye, J.;
Weilbacher, P. M.;
Nanayakkara, T.;
Maseda, M.;
Mahler, G.;
Wisotzki, L.
Submitted: 2019-07-26
The existence of a spatially resolved Star-Forming Main Sequence (rSFMS) and
a spatially resolved Mass-Metallicity Relation (rMZR) is now well established
for local galaxies. Moreover, gradients with metallicity decreasing with radius
seem to be common in local disc galaxies. These observations suggest that
galaxy formation is a self-regulating process, and provide constraints for
galaxy evolution models. Studying the evolution of these relations at higher
redshifts is still however very challenging. In this paper, we analyse three
gravitationally lensed galaxies at z = 0.6, 0.7 and 1, observed with MUSE and
SINFONI. These galaxies are highly magnified by galaxy clusters, which allow us
to observe resolved scaling relations and metallicity gradients on physical
scales of a couple of hundred parsecs, comparable to studies of local galaxies.
We confirm that the rSFMS is already in place at these redshifts on sub-kpc
scales, and establish, for the first time, the existence of the rMZR at higher
redshifts. We develop a forward-modelling approach to fit 2D metallicity
gradients of multiply imaged lensed galaxies in the image plane, and derive
gradients of -0.027+/-0.003, -0.019+/-0.003 and -0.039+/-0.060 dex/kpc. Despite
the fact that these are clumpy galaxies, typical of high redshift discs, the
metallicity variations in the galaxies are well described by global linear
gradients, and we do not see any difference in metallicity associated with the
star-forming clumps.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.06347 [pdf] - 1925105
A giant Ly$\alpha$ nebula and a small-scale clumpy outflow in the system
of the exotic quasar J0952+0114 unveiled by MUSE
Marino, R. A.;
Cantalupo, S.;
Pezzulli, G.;
Lilly, S. J.;
Gallego, S.;
Mackenzie, R.;
Matthee, J.;
Brinchmann, J.;
Bouché, N.;
Feltre, A.;
Muzahid, S.;
Schroetter, I.;
Johnson, S. D.;
Nanayakkara, T.
Submitted: 2019-06-14
The well-known quasar SDSS J095253.83+011421.9 (J0952+0114) at z=3.02 has one
of the most peculiar spectra discovered so far, showing the presence of narrow
Ly$\alpha$ and broad metal emission lines. Although recent studies have
suggested that a Proximate Damped Ly$\alpha$ system (PDLA) causes this peculiar
spectrum, the origin of the gas associated with the PDLA is unknown. Here we
report the results of MUSE observations that reveal a new giant ($\approx$ 100
physical kpc) Lyman $\alpha$ nebula. The detailed analysis of the Ly$\alpha$
velocity, velocity dispersion, and surface brightness profiles suggests that
the J0952+0114 Ly$\alpha$ nebula shares similar properties of other QSO nebulae
previously detected with MUSE, implying that the PDLA in J0952+0144 is covering
only a small fraction of the QSO emission solid angle. We also detected bright
and spectrally narrow CIV$\lambda$1550 and HeII$\lambda$1640 extended emission
around J0952+0114 with velocity centroids similar to the peak of the extended
and central narrow Ly$\alpha$ emission. The presence of a peculiarly bright,
unresolved, and relatively broad HeII$\lambda$1640 emission in the central
region at exactly the same PDLA redshift hints at the possibility that the PDLA
originates in a clumpy outflow with a bulk velocity of about 500 km/s. The
smaller velocity dispersion of the large scale Ly$\alpha$ emission suggests
that the high-speed outflow is confined to the central region. Lastly, the
derived spatially resolved HeII/Ly$\alpha$ and CIV/Ly$\alpha$ maps show a
positive gradient with the distance to the QSO hinting at a non-homogeneous
ionization parameter distribution.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.05202 [pdf] - 1925041
Newly Discovered Bright z~9-10 Galaxies and Improved Constraints on
Their Prevalence Using the Full CANDELS Area
Submitted: 2019-05-13, last modified: 2019-05-24
We report the results of an expanded search for z~9-10 candidates over the
~883 arcmin^2 CANDELS+ERS fields. This study adds 147 arcmin^2 to the search
area we consider over the CANDELS COSMOS, UDS, and EGS fields, while expanding
our selection to include sources with bluer J_{125}-H_{160} colors than our
previous J_{125}-H_{160}>0.5 mag selection. In searching for new z~9-10
candidates, we make full use of all available HST, Spitzer/IRAC, and
ground-based imaging data. As a result of our expanded search and use of
broader color criteria, 3 new candidate z~9-10 galaxies are identified. We also
find again the z=8.683 source previously confirmed by Zitrin+2015. This brings
our sample of probable z~9-11 galaxy candidates over the CANDELS+ERS fields to
19 sources in total, equivalent to 1 candidate per 47 arcmin^2 (1 per 10
WFC3/IR fields). To be comprehensive, we also discuss 28 mostly lower
likelihood z~9-10 candidates, including some sources that seem to be reliably
at z>8 using the HST+IRAC data alone, but which the ground-based data show are
much more likely at z<4. One case example is a bright z~9.4 candidate COS910-8
which seems instead to be at z~2. Based on this expanded sample, we obtain a
more robust LF at z~9 and improved constraints on the volume density of bright
z~9 and z~10 galaxies. Our improved z~9-10 results again reinforce previous
findings for strong evolution in the UV LF at z>8, with a factor of ~10
evolution seen in the luminosity density from z~10 to z~8.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.08177 [pdf] - 1853136
Detection of a Lensed z$\approx$11 Galaxy in the Rest-Optical with
Spitzer/IRAC and the Inferred SFR, Stellar Mass, and Physical Size
Lam, Daniel;
Bouwens, Rychard J.;
Coe, Dan;
Zitrin, Adi;
Barber, Christopher;
Labbe, Ivo;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Donahue, Megan;
Smit, Renske;
Shu, Xinwen;
Chary, Ranga-Ram;
Moustakas, John;
Nonino, Mario;
Kelson, Daniel D.;
Broadhurst, Tom;
Bradley, Larry;
Carrasco, Mauricio;
Rosati, Piero
Submitted: 2019-03-19
We take advantage of new 100-hour Spitzer/IRAC observations available for
MACS0647-JD, a strongly lensed $z\approx11$ galaxy candidate, to provide
improved constraints on its physical properties. Probing the physical
properties of galaxies at $z>8$ is challenging due to the inherent faintness of
such sources and the limited wavelength coverage available. Thanks to the high
$\approx$2-6$\times$ lensing magnification of the multiple images of
MACS0647-JD, we can use the sensitive Spitzer/IRAC data to probe the rest-frame
optical fluxes of MACS0647-JD and investigate its physical properties including
the age and the stellar mass. In deriving Spitzer/IRAC fluxes for MACS0647-JD,
great care is taken in coping with the impact of three bright ($\approx$8-16
mag) stars in our field to ensure robust results. Assuming a constant star
formation rate, the age, stellar mass, and rest-frame UV slope we estimate for
MACS0647-JD based on a stack of the photometry are log$_{10}$(age/yr) =
8.6$^{+0.1}_{-2.1}$, log$_{10}$(M$_{*}$/M$_{\odot}$) = 9.1$^{+0.2}_{-1.4}$, and
$\beta = -$1.3$\pm$0.6, respectively. We compare our results with expectations
from the EAGLE simulation and find that MACS0647-JD has properties consistent
with corresponding to the most massive and rapidly star-forming galaxies in the
simulation. We also find that its radius, 105$\pm$28 pc, is a factor of
$\approx$2 smaller than the mean size in a separate simulation project DRAGONS.
Interestingly enough, the observed size is similar to the small sizes seen in
very low-luminosity $z\approx$6-10 galaxies behind lensing clusters.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.06549 [pdf] - 1875258
The MUSE-Wide Survey: Survey Description and First Data Release
Urrutia, T.;
Wisotzki, L.;
Kerutt, J.;
Schmidt, K. B.;
Herenz, E. C.;
Klar, J.;
Saust, R.;
Werhahn, M.;
Diener, C.;
Caruana, J.;
Krajnović, D.;
Bacon, R.;
Boogaard, L.;
Brinchman, J.;
Enke, H.;
Maseda, M.;
Nanayakkara, T.;
Richard, J.;
Steinmetz, M.;
Weilbacher, P. M.
Submitted: 2018-11-15, last modified: 2019-02-25
We present the MUSE-Wide survey, a blind, 3D spectroscopic survey in the
CANDELS/GOODS-S and CANDELS/COSMOS regions. Each MUSE-Wide pointing has a depth
of 1 hour and hence targets more extreme and more luminous objects over 10
times the area of the MUSE-Deep fields (Bacon et al. 2017). The legacy value of
MUSE-Wide lies in providing "spectroscopy of everything" without photometric
pre-selection. We describe the data reduction, post-processing and PSF
characterization of the first 44 CANDELS/GOODS-S MUSE-Wide pointings released
with this publication. Using a 3D matched filtering approach we detected 1,602
emission line sources, including 479 Lyman-$\alpha$ (Lya) emitting galaxies
with redshifts $2.9 \lesssim z \lesssim 6.3$. We cross-match the emission line
sources to existing photometric catalogs, finding almost complete agreement in
redshifts and stellar masses for our low redshift (z < 1.5) emitters. At high
redshift, we only find ~55% matches to photometric catalogs. We encounter a
higher outlier rate and a systematic offset of $\Delta$z$\simeq$0.2 when
comparing our MUSE redshifts with photometric redshifts. Cross-matching the
emission line sources with X-ray catalogs from the Chandra Deep Field South, we
find 127 matches, including 10 objects with no prior spectroscopic
identification. Stacking X-ray images centered on our Lya emitters yielded no
signal; the Lya population is not dominated by even low luminosity AGN. A total
of 9,205 photometrically selected objects from the CANDELS survey lie in the
MUSE-Wide footprint, which we provide optimally extracted 1D spectra of. We are
able to determine the spectroscopic redshift of 98% of 772 photometrically
selected galaxies brighter than 24th F775W magnitude. All the data in the first
data release - datacubes, catalogs, extracted spectra, maps - are available on
the website https://musewide.aip.de. [abridged]
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.05960 [pdf] - 1868090
Exploring HeII${\lambda}$1640 emission line properties at ${z\sim2-4}$
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Brinchmann, Jarle;
Boogaard, Leindert;
Bouwens, Rychard;
Cantalupo, Sebastiano;
Feltre, Anna;
Kollatschny, Wolfram;
Marino, Raffaella Anna;
Maseda, Michael;
Matthee, Jorryt;
Paalvast, Mieke;
Richard, Johan;
Verhamme, Anne
Submitted: 2019-02-15
Deep optical spectroscopic surveys of galaxies provide us a unique
opportunity to investigate rest-frame ultra-violet (UV) emission line
properties of galaxies at ${z \sim 2-4.5}$. Here we combine VLT/MUSE Guaranteed
Time Observations of the Hubble Deep Field South, Ultra Deep Field, COSMOS, and
several quasar fields with other publicly available data from VLT/VIMOS and
VLT/FORS2 to construct a catalogue of HeII${\lambda}$1640 emitters at
${z\sim2}$. The deepest areas of our MUSE pointings reach a ${3\sigma}$ line
flux limit of 3.1${\times}$10-19 erg/ s/ cm$^2$. After discarding broad line
active galactic nuclei we find 13 HeII${\lambda}$1640 detections from MUSE with
a median MUV = $-20.1$ and 21 tentative HeII${\lambda}$1640 detections from
other public surveys. Excluding Ly${\alpha}$, all except two galaxies in our
sample show at least one other rest-UV emission line, with
CIII]${\lambda}$1907,${\lambda}$1909 being the most prominent. We use
multi-wavelength data available in the Hubble legacy fields to derive basic
galaxy properties of our sample via spectral energy distribution fitting
techniques. Taking advantage of the high quality spectra obtained by MUSE
(${\sim10 - 30}$h of exposure time per pointing), we use photo-ionisation
models to study the rest-UV emission line diagnostics of the
HeII${\lambda}$1640 emitters. Line ratios of our sample can be reproduced by
moderately sub-solar photo-ionisation models, however, we find that including
effects of binary stars lead to degeneracies in most free parameters. Even
after considering extra ionising photons produced by extreme sub-solar
metallicity binary stellar models, photo-ionisation models are unable to
reproduce rest-frame HeII${\lambda}$1640 equivalent widths (${\sim}$ 0.2 - 10
A), thus additional mechanisms are necessary in models to match the observed
HeII${\lambda}$1640 properties.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.11783 [pdf] - 1815104
The large and small scale properties of the intergalactic gas in the
Slug Ly-alpha nebula revealed by MUSE HeII emission observations
Cantalupo, Sebastiano;
Pezzulli, Gabriele;
Lilly, Simon J.;
Marino, Raffaella A.;
Gallego, Sofia G.;
Schaye, Joop;
Bacon, Roland;
Feltre, Anna;
Kollatschny, Wolfram;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Richard, Johan;
Wendt, Martin;
Wisotzki, Lutz;
Prochaska, J. Xavier
Submitted: 2018-11-28, last modified: 2018-12-20
With a projected size of about 450 kpc at z~2.3, the Slug Ly-alpha nebula is
a rare laboratory to study, in emission, the properties of the intergalactic
gas in the Cosmic Web. Since its discovery, the Slug has been the subject of
several spectroscopic follow-ups to constrain the properties of the emitting
gas. Here we report the results of a deep MUSE integral-field spectroscopic
search for non-resonant, extended HeII1640 and metal emission. Extended HeII
radiation is detected on scales of about 100 kpc, but only in some regions
associated with the bright Ly-alpha emission and a continuum-detected source,
implying large and abrupt variations in the line ratios across adjacent regions
in projected space. The recent detection of associated H-alpha emission and
similar abrupt variations in the Ly-alpha kinematics, strongly suggest that the
HeII/Ly-alpha gradient is due to large variations in the physical distances
between the associated quasar and these regions. This implies that the overall
length of the emitting structure could extend to physical Mpc scales and be
mostly oriented along our line of sight. At the same time, the relatively low
HeII/Ly-alpha values suggest that the emitting gas has a broad density
distribution that - if expressed in terms of a lognormal - implies dispersions
as high as those expected in the interstellar medium of galaxies. These results
strengthen the possibility that the density distribution of intergalactic gas
at high-redshift is extremely clumpy and multiphase on scales below our current
observational spatial resolution of a few physical kpc.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.04129 [pdf] - 1800048
On the Lack of Correlation Between [OIII]/[OII] and Lyman-Continuum
Escape Fraction
Bassett, R.;
Ryan-Weber, E. V.;
Cooke, J.;
Diaz, C. G.;
Nanayakkara, T.;
Yuan, T. -T.;
Spitler, L. R.;
Meštrić, U.;
Garel, T.;
Sawicki, M.;
Gwyn, S.;
Golob, A.
Submitted: 2018-12-10
We present the first results of our pilot study of 8 photometrically selected
Lyman continuum (LyC) emitting galaxy candidates from the COSMOS field and
focus on their optical emission line ratios. Observations were performed in the
H and K bands using the Multi-Object Spectrometer for Infra-Red Exploration
(MOSFIRE) instrument at the Keck Observatory, targeting the [OII], H$\beta$,
and [OIII] emission lines. We find that photometrically selected LyC emitting
galaxy candidates have high ionization parameters, based on their high
[OIII]/[OII] ratios (O32), with an average ratio for our sample of 2.5$\pm$0.2.
Preliminary results of our companion Low Resolution Imaging Spectrometer (LRIS)
observations, targeting LyC and Ly$\alpha$, show that those galaxies with the
largest O32 are typically found to also be Ly$\alpha$ emitters. High O32
galaxies are also found to have tentative non-zero LyC escape fractions
($f_{esc}(LyC)$) based on $u$ band photometric detections. These results are
consistent with samples of highly ionized galaxies, including confirmed LyC
emitting galaxies from the literature. We also perform a detailed comparison
between the observed emission line ratios and simulated line ratios from
density bounded H$_{\textrm{II}}$ regions modeled using the photoionization
code MAPPINGS V. Estimates of $f_{esc}(LyC)$ for our sample fall in the range
from 0.0-0.23 and suggest possible tension with published correlations between
O32 and $f_{esc}(LyC)$, adding weight to dichotomy of arguments in the
literature. We highlight the possible effects of clumpy geometry and mergers
that may account for such tension.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.00025 [pdf] - 1806172
ZFOURGE: Extreme 5007$\AA$ emission may be a common early-lifetime phase
for star-forming galaxies at $z > 2.5$
Cohn, Jonathan H.;
Leja, Joel;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Forrest, Ben;
Johnson, Benjamin D.;
Tillman, Megan;
Alcorn, Leo;
Conroy, Charlie;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Kelson, Daniel D.;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Papovich, Casey;
van Dokkum, Pieter G.;
Yuan, Tiantian
Submitted: 2018-10-31
Using the \prospector\ spectral energy distribution (SED) fitting code, we
analyze the properties of 19 Extreme Emission Line Galaxies (EELGs) identified
in the bluest composite SED in the \zfourge\ survey at $2.5 \leq z \leq 4$.
\prospector\ includes a physical model for nebular emission and returns
probability distributions for stellar mass, stellar metallicity, dust
attenuation, and nonparametric star formation history (SFH). The EELGs show
evidence for a starburst in the most recent 50 Myr, with the median EELG having
a specific star formation rate (sSFR) of 4.6 Gyr$^{-1}$ and forming 15\% of its
mass in this short time. For a sample of more typical star-forming galaxies
(SFGs) at the same redshifts, the median SFG has a sSFR of 1.1 Gyr$^{-1}$ and
forms only $4\%$ of its mass in the last 50 Myr. We find that virtually all of
our EELGs have rising SFHs, while most of our SFGs do not. From our analysis,
we hypothesize that many, if not most, star-forming galaxies at $z \geq 2.5$
undergo an extreme H$\beta$+$[\hbox{{\rm O}\kern 0.1em{\sc iii}}]$ emission
line phase early in their lifetimes. In a companion paper, we obtain
spectroscopic confirmation of the EELGs as part of our {\sc MOSEL} survey. In
the future, explorations of uncertainties in modeling the UV slope for galaxies
at $z>2$ are needed to better constrain their properties, e.g. stellar
metallicities.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.10970 [pdf] - 1769048
MUSE HeII$\lambda1640$ analysis at $z=2-4$
Submitted: 2018-09-28, last modified: 2018-10-17
HeII is the most sought-after emission line to detect and characterize metal
free stellar populations. However, current stellar population/photo-ionization
models lack sufficient He$^+$ ionising photons to reproduce observed HeII
fluxes while being consistent with other emission lines. Using $\sim10-30$ hour
deep pointings from MUSE, we obtain $\sim10$ $z\sim2-4$ HeII$\lambda1640$
emitters to study their inter-stellar medium (ISM) and stellar population
properties. Emission line ratio diagnostics of our sample suggest that emission
lines are driven by star-formation in solar to moderately sub-solar ($\sim
1/20$th) metallicity conditions. However, we find that even after considering
effects from binary stars, we are unable to reproduce the HeII$\lambda1640$
equivalent widths (EWs). Our analysis suggest that extremely sub-solar
metallicities ($\sim1/200$th) are required to reproduce observed
HeII$\lambda1640$ luminosities. Thus, current stellar populations may require
alternative mechanisms such as sub-dominant active galactic nuclei (AGN) or top
heavy initial-mass-functions (IMFs) to compensate for the missing He$^+$
ionising photons.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.00843 [pdf] - 1759396
Nearly all the sky is covered by Lyman-alpha emission around high
redshift galaxies
Wisotzki, L.;
Bacon, R.;
Brinchmann, J.;
Cantalupo, S.;
Richter, P.;
Schaye, J.;
Schmidt, K. B.;
Urrutia, T.;
Weilbacher, P. M.;
Akhlaghi, M.;
Bouche, N.;
Contini, T.;
Guiderdoni, B.;
Herenz, E. C.;
Inami, H.;
Kerutt, J.;
Leclercq, F.;
Marino, R. A.;
Maseda, M.;
Monreal-Ibero, A.;
Nanayakkara, T.;
Richard, J.;
Saust, R.;
Steinmetz, M.;
Wendt, M.
Submitted: 2018-10-01, last modified: 2018-10-02
Galaxies are surrounded by large reservoirs of gas, mostly hydrogen, fed by
inflows from the intergalactic medium and by outflows due to galactic winds.
Absorption-line measurements along the sightlines to bright and rare background
quasars indicate that this circumgalactic medium pervades far beyond the extent
of starlight in galaxies, but very little is known about the spatial
distribution of this gas. A new window into circumgalactic environments was
recently opened with the discovery of ubiquitous extended Lyman-alpha emission
from hydrogen around high-redshift galaxies, facilitated by the extraordinary
sensitivity of the MUSE instrument at the ESO Very Large Telescope. Due to the
faintness of this emission, such measurements were previously limited to
especially favourable systems or to massive statistical averaging. Here we
demonstrate that low surface brightness Lyman-alpha emission surrounding faint
galaxies at redshifts between 3 and 6 adds up to a projected sky coverage of
nearly 100%. The corresponding rate of incidence (the mean number of
Lyman-alpha emitters penetrated by any arbitrary line of sight) is well above
unity and similar to the incidence rate of high column density absorbers
frequently detected in the spectra of distant quasars. This similarity suggests
that most circumgalactic atomic hydrogen at these redshifts has now been
detected also in emission.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.01142 [pdf] - 1756036
MUSE Spectroscopic Identifications of Ultra-Faint Emission Line Galaxies
with M$_{\mathrm{UV}}\sim$ -15
Maseda, Michael V.;
Bacon, Roland;
Franx, Marijn;
Brinchmann, Jarle;
Schaye, Joop;
Boogaard, Leindert A.;
Bouche, Nicolas;
Bouwens, Rychard J.;
Cantalupo, Sebastiano;
Contini, Thierry;
Hashimoto, Takuya;
Inami, Hanae;
Marino, Raffaella A.;
Muzahid, Sowgat;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Richard, Johan;
Schmidt, Kasper B.;
Verhamme, Anne;
Wisotzki, Lutz
Submitted: 2018-09-04
Using an ultra-deep blind survey with the MUSE integral field spectrograph on
the ESO Very Large Telescope, we obtain spectroscopic redshifts to a depth
never explored before: galaxies with observed magnitudes m > 30 - 32.
Specifically, we detect objects via Lyman-alpha emission at 2.9 < z < 6.7
without individual continuum counterparts in areas covered by the deepest
optical/near-infrared imaging taken by the Hubble Space Telescope, the Hubble
Ultra Deep Field. In total, we find 102 such objects in 9 square arcminutes at
these redshifts. Detailed stacking analyses confirm the Lyman-alpha emission as
well as the 1216 Angstrom-breaks and faint UV continua (M_UV ~ -15). This makes
them the faintest spectroscopically-confirmed objects at these redshifts,
similar to the sources believed to reionize the universe. A simple model for
the expected fraction of detected/undetected Lyman-alpha emitters as a function
of luminosity is consistent with these objects being the high-equivalent width
tail of the normal Lyman-alpha-emitter population at these redshifts.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.04899 [pdf] - 1767576
Properties and redshift evolution of star-forming galaxies with high
[OIII]/[OII] ratios with MUSE at 0.28<z<0.85
Paalvast, M.;
Verhamme, A.;
Straka, L. A.;
Brinchmann, J.;
Herenz, E. C.;
Carton, D.;
Gunawardhana, M. L. P.;
Boogaard, L. A.;
Cantalupo, S.;
Contini, T.;
Epinat, B.;
Inami, H.;
Marino, R. A.;
Maseda, M. V.;
Michel-Dansac, L.;
Muzahid, S.;
Nanayakkara, T.;
Pezzulli, G.;
Richard, J.;
Schaye, J.;
Segers, M. C.;
Urrutia, T.;
Wendt, M.;
Wisotzki, L.
Submitted: 2018-08-14
We present a study of the [OIII]5007/[OII]3727 (O32) ratios of star-forming
galaxies drawn from MUSE data spanning a redshift range 0.28<z<0.85. Recently
discovered Lyman continuum (LyC) emitters have extremely high oxygen line
ratios: O32>4. Here we aim to understand the properties and the occurrences of
galaxies with such high line ratios. Combining data from several MUSE GTO
programmes, we select a population of star-forming galaxies with bright
emission lines, from which we draw 406 galaxies for our analysis based on their
position in the z-dependent star formation rate (SFR) - stellar mass (M*)
plane. Out of this sample 15 are identified as extreme oxygen emitters based on
their O32 ratios (3.7%) and 104 galaxies have O32>1 (26%). Our analysis shows
no significant correlation between M*, SFR, and the distance from the SFR-M*
relation with O32. We find a decrease in the fraction of galaxies with O32>1
with increasing M*, however, this is most likely a result of the relationship
between O32 and metallicity, rather than between O32 and M*. We draw a
comparison sample of local analogues with <z>~0.03 from SDSS, and find similar
incidence rates for this sample. In order to investigate the evolution in the
fraction of high O32 emitters with redshift, we bin the sample into three
redshift subsamples of equal number, but find no evidence for a dependence on
redshift. Furthermore, we compare the observed line ratios with those predicted
by nebular models with no LyC escape and find that most of the extreme oxygen
emitters can be reproduced by low metallicity models. The remaining galaxies
are likely LyC emitter candidates. Finally, based on a comparison between
electron temperature estimates from the [OIII4363]/[OIII]5007 ratio of the
extreme oxygen emitters and nebular models, we argue that the galaxies with the
most extreme O32 ratios have young light-weighted ages.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.04900 [pdf] - 1779604
The MUSE Hubble Ultra Deep Field Survey XI. Constraining the low-mass
end of the stellar mass - star formation rate relation at $z<1$
Boogaard, Leindert A.;
Brinchmann, Jarle;
Bouché, Nicolas;
Paalvast, Mieke;
Bacon, Roland;
Bouwens, Rychard J.;
Contini, Thierry;
Gunawardhana, Madusha L. P.;
Inami, Hanae;
Marino, Raffaella A.;
Maseda, Michael V.;
Mitchell, Peter;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Richard, Johan;
Schaye, Joop;
Schreiber, Corentin;
Tacchella, Sandro;
Wisotzki, Lutz;
Zabl, Johannes
Submitted: 2018-08-14
Star-forming galaxies have been found to follow a relatively tight relation
between stellar mass ($M_{*}$) and star formation rate (SFR), dubbed the `star
formation sequence'. A turnover in the sequence has been observed, where
galaxies with $M_{*} < 10^{10} {\rm M}_{\odot}$ follow a steeper relation than
their higher mass counterparts, suggesting that the low-mass slope is (nearly)
linear. In this paper, we characterise the properties of the low-mass end of
the star formation sequence between $7 \leq \log M_{*}[{\rm M}_{\odot}] \leq
10.5$ at redshift $0.11 < z < 0.91$. We use the deepest MUSE observations of
the Hubble Ultra Deep Field and the Hubble Deep Field South to construct a
sample of 179 star-forming galaxies with high signal-to-noise emission lines.
Dust-corrected SFRs are determined from H$\beta$ $\lambda 4861$ and H$\alpha$
$\lambda 6563$. We model the star formation sequence with a Gaussian
distribution around a hyperplane between $\log M_{*}$, $\log {\rm SFR}$, and
$\log (1+z)$, to simultaneously constrain the slope, redshift evolution, and
intrinsic scatter. We find a sub-linear slope for the low-mass regime where
$\log {\rm SFR}[{\rm M}_{\odot}/{\rm yr}] = 0.83^{+0.07}_{-0.06} \log
M_{*}[{\rm M}_{\odot}] + 1.74^{+0.66}_{-0.68} \log (1+z)$, increasing with
redshift. We recover an intrinsic scatter in the relation of $\sigma_{\rm intr}
= 0.44^{+0.05}_{-0.04}$ dex, larger than typically found at higher masses. As
both hydrodynamical simulations and (semi-)analytical models typically favour a
steeper slope in the low-mass regime, our results provide new constraints on
the feedback processes which operate preferentially in low-mass halos.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.02894 [pdf] - 1728809
First Data Release of the COSMOS Lyman-Alpha Mapping And Tomography
Observations: 3D Lyman-$\alpha$ Forest Tomography at 2.05 < z < 2.55
Lee, Khee-Gan;
Krolewski, Alex;
White, Martin;
Schlegel, David;
Nugent, Peter E.;
Hennawi, Joseph F.;
Müller, Thomas;
Pan, Richard;
Prochaska, J. Xavier;
Font-Ribera, Andreu;
Suzuki, Nao;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Kartaltepe, Jeyhan S.;
Koekemoer, Anton M.;
Févre, Olivier Le;
Lemaux, Brian C.;
Maier, Christian;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Rich, R. Michael;
Sanders, D. B.;
Salvato, Mara;
Tasca, Lidia;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.
Submitted: 2017-10-08, last modified: 2018-08-03
Faint star-forming galaxies at $z\sim 2-3$ can be used as alternative
background sources to probe the Lyman-$\alpha$ forest in addition to quasars,
yielding high sightline densities that enable 3D tomographic reconstruction of
the foreground absorption field. Here, we present the first data release from
the COSMOS Lyman-Alpha Mapping And Mapping Observations (CLAMATO) Survey, which
was conducted with the LRIS spectrograph on the Keck-I telescope. Over an
observational footprint of 0.157$\mathrm{deg}^2$ within the COSMOS field, we
used 240 galaxies and quasars at $2.17<z<3.00$, with a mean comoving transverse
separation of $2.37\,h^{-1}\,\mathrm{Mpc^3}$, as background sources probing the
foreground Lyman-$\alpha$ forest absorption at $2.05<z<2.55$. The
Lyman-$\alpha$ forest data was then used to create a Wiener-filtered
tomographic reconstruction over a comoving volume of $3.15\,\times
10^5\,h^{-3}\,\mathrm{Mpc^3}$ with an effective smoothing scale of
$2.5\,h^{-1}\,\mathrm{Mpc}$. In addition to traditional figures, this map is
also presented as a virtual-reality YouTube360 video visualization and
manipulable interactive figure. We see large overdensities and underdensities
that visually agree with the distribution of coeval galaxies from spectroscopic
redshift surveys in the same field, including overdensities associated with
several recently-discovered galaxy protoclusters in the volume. This data
release includes the redshift catalog, reduced spectra, extracted
Lyman-$\alpha$ forest pixel data, and tomographic map of the absorption.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.03785 [pdf] - 1740038
ZFOURGE: Using Composite Spectral Energy Distributions to Characterize
Galaxy Populations at 1<z<4
Forrest, Ben;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Broussard, Adam;
Cohn, Jonathan H.;
Kennicutt, Robert C.;
Papovich, Casey;
Allen, Rebecca;
Cowley, Michael;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Kawinwanichakij, Lalitwadee;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Salmon, Brett;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Straatman, Caroline M. S.
Submitted: 2018-07-10
We investigate the properties of galaxies as they shut off star formation
over the 4 billion years surrounding peak cosmic star formation. To do this we
categorize $\sim7000$ galaxies from $1<z<4$ into $90$ groups based on the shape
of their spectral energy distributions (SEDs) and build composite SEDs with
$R\sim 50$ resolution. These composite SEDs show a variety of spectral shapes
and also show trends in parameters such as color, mass, star formation rate,
and emission line equivalent width. Using emission line equivalent widths and
strength of the 4000\AA\ break, $D(4000)$, we categorize the composite SEDs
into five classes: extreme emission line, star-forming, transitioning,
post-starburst, and quiescent galaxies. The transitioning population of
galaxies show modest H$\alpha$ emission ($EW_{\rm REST}\sim40$\AA) compared to
more typical star-forming composite SEDs at $\log_{10}(M/M_\odot)\sim10.5$
($EW_{\rm REST}\sim80$\AA). Together with their smaller sizes (3 kpc vs. 4 kpc)
and higher S\'ersic indices (2.7 vs. 1.5), this indicates that morphological
changes initiate before the cessation of star formation. The transitional group
shows a strong increase of over one dex in number density from $z\sim3$ to
$z\sim1$, similar to the growth in the quiescent population, while
post-starburst galaxies become rarer at $z\lesssim1.5$. We calculate average
quenching timescales of 1.6 Gyr at $z\sim1.5$ and 0.9 Gyr at $z\sim2.5$ and
conclude that a fast quenching mechanism producing post-starbursts dominated
the quenching of galaxies at early times, while a slower process has become
more common since $z\sim2$.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.02523 [pdf] - 1771595
Near infrared spectroscopy and star-formation histories of 3<z<4
quiescent galaxies
Schreiber, C.;
Glazebrook, K.;
Nanayakkara, T.;
Kacprzak, G. G.;
Labbe, I.;
Oesch, P.;
Yuan, T.;
Tran, K. -V.;
Papovich, C.;
Spitler, L.;
Straatman, C.
Submitted: 2018-07-06
We present Keck-MOSFIRE H and K spectra for a sample of 24 candidate
quiescent galaxies (QGs) at 3<z<4, identified from UVJ colors and photometric
redshifts in the ZFOURGE and 3DHST surveys. We obtain spectroscopic redshifts
for half of the sample, using absorption or emission lines, and confirm the
high accuracy of the photometric redshifts with a median error of 1.2%. Two
galaxies turn out to be dusty objects at lower redshifts (z<2.5), and are the
only two detected in the sub-mm with ALMA. High equivalent-width [OIII] was
observed in two galaxies, contributing up to 30% of the K-band flux and
mimicking the colors of an old stellar population. This implies a failure rate
of only 20% for the UVJ selection at these redshifts. Balmer absorption was
identified in 4 of the brighest galaxies, confirming the absence of OB stars.
Modeling all QGs with a wide range of star-formation histories, we find sSFR a
factor of 10 below the main sequence (MS) for all but one galaxy, and less than
0.01 Gyr$^{-1}$ for half of the sample. This is consistent with the H$\beta$
and [OII] luminosities, and the ALMA non-detections. We then find that these
QGs have quenched on average 300 Myr before observation, between z=3.5 and 5,
and that they formed at z~5.5 with a mean SFR~300 Msun/yr. Considering an
alternative selection of QGs based solely on the sSFR from SED modeling, we
find that galaxies a factor 10 below the MS are 40% more numerous than
UVJ-quiescent galaxies, implying that the UVJ selection is pure but incomplete.
Current models fail at reproducing our observations and underestimate either
the number density of QGs by more than an order of magnitude or the duration of
their quiescence by a factor two. Overall, these results confirm the existence
of an unexpected population of QGs at z>3, and offer the first insights on
their formation history. [abridged]
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.08131 [pdf] - 1711067
First gas-phase metallicity gradients of $0.1 \lesssim z \lesssim 0.8$
galaxies with MUSE
Carton, David;
Brinchmann, Jarle;
Contini, Thierry;
Epinat, Benoît;
Finley, Hayley;
Richard, Johan;
Patrício, Vera;
Schaye, Joop;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Weilbacher, Peter M.;
Wisotzki, Lutz
Submitted: 2018-05-21, last modified: 2018-07-05
Galaxies at low-redshift typically possess negative gas-phase metallicity
gradients (centres more metal-rich than their outskirts). Whereas, it is not
uncommon to observe positive metallicity gradients in higher-redshift galaxies
($z \gtrsim 0.6$). Bridging these epochs, we present gas-phase metallicity
gradients of 84 star-forming galaxies between $0.08 < z < 0.84$. Using the
galaxies with reliably determined metallicity gradients, we measure the median
metallicity gradient to be negative ($-0.039^{+0.007}_{-0.009}$ dex/kpc).
Underlying this, however, is significant scatter: $(8\pm3)\%\ [7]$ of galaxies
have significantly positive metallicity gradients, $(38 \pm 5)\%\ [32]$ have
significantly negative gradients, $(31\pm5)\%\ [26]$ have gradients consistent
with being flat. (The remaining $(23\pm5)\%\ [19]$ have unreliable gradient
estimates.) We notice a slight trend for a more negative metallicity gradient
with both increasing stellar mass and increasing star formation rate (SFR).
However, given the potential redshift and size selection effects, we do not
consider these trends to be significant. Indeed, once we normalize the SFR
relative to that of the main sequence, we do not observe any trend between the
metallicity gradient and the normalized SFR. This is contrary to recent studies
of galaxies at similar and higher redshifts. We do, however, identify a novel
trend between the metallicity gradient of a galaxy and its size. Small galaxies
($r_d < 3$ kpc) present a large spread in observed metallicity gradients (both
negative and positive gradients). In contrast, we find no large galaxies ($r_d
> 3$ kpc) with positive metallicity gradients, and overall there is less
scatter in the metallicity gradient amongst the large galaxies. These large
(well-evolved) galaxies may be analogues of present-day galaxies, which also
show a common negative metallicity gradient.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.03669 [pdf] - 1682658
ZFIRE: 3D Modeling of Rotation, Dispersion, and Angular Momentum of
Star-Forming Galaxies at z~2
Alcorn, Leo Y.;
Tran, Kim-Vy;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Straatman, Caroline M.;
Cowley, Michael;
Forrest, Ben;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Kewley, Lisa J.;
Labbé, Ivo;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Tomczak, Adam;
Yuan, Tiantian
Submitted: 2018-04-10
We perform a kinematic and morphological analysis of 44 star-forming galaxies
at $z\sim2$ in the COSMOS legacy field using near-infrared spectroscopy from
Keck/MOSFIRE and F160W imaging from CANDELS/3D-HST as part of the ZFIRE survey.
Our sample consists of cluster and field galaxies from $2.0 < z < 2.5$ with K
band multi-object slit spectroscopic measurements of their H$\alpha$ emission
lines. H$\alpha$ rotational velocities and gas velocity dispersions are
measured using the Heidelberg Emission Line Algorithm (HELA), which compares
directly to simulated 3D data-cubes. Using a suite of simulated emission lines,
we determine that HELA reliably recovers input S$_{0.5}$ and angular momentum
at small offsets, but $V_{2.2}/\sigma_g$ values are offset and highly
scattered. We examine the role of regular and irregular morphology in the
stellar mass kinematic scaling relations, deriving the kinematic measurement
S$_{0.5}$, and finding $\log(S_{0.5}) = (0.38\pm0.07)\log(M/M_{\odot}-10) +
(2.04\pm0.03)$ with no significant offset between morphological populations and
similar levels of scatter ($\sim0.16$ dex). Additionally, we identify a
correlation between M$_{\star}$ and $V_{2.2}/\sigma_g$ for the total sample,
showing an increasing level of rotation dominance with increasing M$_{\star}$,
and a high level of scatter for both regular and irregular galaxies. We
estimate the specific angular momenta ($j_{disk}$) of these galaxies and find a
slope of $0.36\pm0.12$, shallower than predicted without mass-dependent disk
growth, but this result is possibly due to measurement uncertainty at
M$_{\star}$ $<$ 9.5. However, through a K-S test we find irregular galaxies to
have marginally higher $j_{disk}$ values than regular galaxies, and high
scatter at low masses in both populations.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.03505 [pdf] - 1652324
Jekyll & Hyde: quiescence and extreme obscuration in a pair of massive
galaxies 1.5 Gyr after the Big Bang
Schreiber, Corentin;
Labbé, Ivo;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Bekiaris, Georgios;
Papovich, Casey;
Costa, Tiago;
Elbaz, David;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Oesch, Pascal;
Pannella, Maurilio;
Spitler, Lee;
Straatman, Caroline;
Tran, Kim-Vy;
Wang, Tao
Submitted: 2017-09-11, last modified: 2017-12-08
We obtained ALMA spectroscopy and imaging to investigate the origin of the
unexpected sub-mm emission toward the most distant quiescent galaxy known to
date, ZF-COSMOS-20115 at z=3.717. We show here that this sub-mm emission is
produced by another massive, compact and extremely obscured galaxy, located
only 3.1 kpc away from the quiescent galaxy. We dub the quiescent and dusty
galaxies Jekyll and Hyde, respectively. No dust emission is detected at the
location of Jekyll, implying SFR < 13 Msun/yr, which is the most stringent
upper limit ever obtained for a quiescent galaxy at these redshifts. The two
sources are confirmed to lie at the same redshift thanks to the detection of
[CII]158 in Hyde, which provides one the few robust redshifts for an
"H-dropout" galaxy. The line has a rotating-disk velocity profile blueshifted
from Jekyll by 549+/-60 km/s, demonstrating that it is produced by another
galaxy. Careful de-blending of the Spitzer imaging confirms the existence of
Hyde, and its non-detection with Hubble requires extreme attenuation by dust.
Modeling the photometry of both galaxies shows that Jekyll has fully quenched
>200 Myr prior to observation and still presents a challenge for models, while
Hyde only harbors moderate star-formation (SFR<120 Msun/yr) and is located at
least a factor 1.4 below the z~4 main sequence. Hyde could also have stopped
forming stars <200 Myr before being observed, which would be consistent with
its hight compactness similar to z~4 quiescent galaxies and its low [CII]/FIR
ratio, but significant SF cannot be ruled out. Finally, we show that Hyde hosts
a dense reservoir of gas comparable to that of extreme starbursts, suggesting
that its SFR was reduced without expelling the gas outside of the galaxy. We
argue that Jekyll and Hyde can be seen as two stages of quenching, and provide
a unique laboratory to study this poorly understood phenomenon. [abridged]
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1702.01751 [pdf] - 1581399
A massive, quiescent galaxy at redshift of z=3.717
Glazebrook, Karl;
Schreiber, Corentin;
Labbé, Ivo;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Oesch, Pascal A.;
Papovich, Casey;
Spitler, Lee R;
Straatman, Caroline M. S.;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Yuan, Tiantian
Submitted: 2017-02-06, last modified: 2017-10-23
In the early Universe finding massive galaxies that have stopped forming
stars present an observational challenge as their rest-frame ultraviolet
emission is negligible and they can only be reliably identified by extremely
deep near-infrared surveys. These have revealed the presence of massive,
quiescent early-type galaxies appearing in the universe as early as z$\sim$2,
an epoch 3 Gyr after the Big Bang. Their age and formation processes have now
been explained by an improved generation of galaxy formation models where they
form rapidly at z$\sim$3-4, consistent with the typical masses and ages derived
from their observations. Deeper surveys have now reported evidence for
populations of massive, quiescent galaxies at even higher redshifts and earlier
times, however the evidence for their existence, and redshift, has relied
entirely on coarsely sampled photometry. These early massive, quiescent
galaxies are not predicted by the latest generation of theoretical models.
Here, we report the spectroscopic confirmation of one of these galaxies at
redshift z=3.717 with a stellar mass of 1.7$\times$10$^{11}$ M$_\odot$ whose
absorption line spectrum shows no current star-formation and which has a
derived age of nearly half the age of the Universe at this redshift. The
observations demonstrates that the galaxy must have quickly formed the majority
of its stars within the first billion years of cosmic history in an extreme and
short starburst. This ancestral event is similar to those starting to be found
by sub-mm wavelength surveys pointing to a possible connection between these
two populations. Early formation of such massive systems is likely to require
significant revisions to our picture of early galaxy assembly.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.04225 [pdf] - 1589598
Decoupled Black Hole Accretion and Quenching: The Relationship Between
BHAR, SFR, and Quenching in Milky Way and Andromeda-mass Progenitors Since z
= 2.5
Cowley, Michael J.;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Quadri, Ryan F.;
Goulding, Andy D.;
Papovich, Casey;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Labbe, Ivo;
Alcorn, Leo;
Allen, Rebecca J.;
Forrest, Ben;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Morrison, Glenn;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Straatman, Caroline M. S.;
Tomczak, Adam R.
Submitted: 2017-10-11
We investigate the relationship between the black hole accretion rate (BHAR)
and star-formation rate (SFR) for Milky Way (MW) and Andromeda (M31)-mass
progenitors from z = 0.2 - 2.5. We source galaxies from the Ks-band selected
ZFOURGE survey, which includes multi-wavelenth data spanning 0.3 - 160um. We
use decomposition software to split the observed SEDs of our galaxies into
their active galactic nuclei (AGN) and star-forming components, which allows us
to estimate BHARs and SFRs from the infrared (IR). We perform tests to check
the robustness of these estimates, including a comparison to BHARs and SFRs
derived from X-ray stacking and far-IR analysis, respectively. We find as the
progenit- ors evolve, their relative black hole-galaxy growth (i.e. their
BHAR/SFR ratio) increases from low to high redshift. The MW-mass progenitors
exhibit a log-log slope of 0.64 +/- 0.11, while the M31-mass progenitors are
0.39 +/- 0.08. This result contrasts with previous studies that find an almost
flat slope when adopting X-ray/AGN-selected or mass-limited samples and is
likely due to their use of a broad mixture of galaxies with different
evolutionary histories. Our use of progenitor-matched samples highlights the
potential importance of carefully selecting progenitors when searching for
evolutionary relationships between BHAR/SFRs. Additionally, our finding that
BHAR/SFR ratios do not track the rate at which progenitors quench casts doubts
over the idea that the suppression of star-formation is predominantly driven by
luminous AGN feedback (i.e. high BHARs).
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.03780 [pdf] - 1584574
Effect of local environment and stellar mass on galaxy quenching and
morphology at $0.5<z<2.0$
Kawinwanichakij, Lalitwadee;
Papovich, Casey;
Quadri, Ryan F.;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Allen, Rebecca J.;
Bell, Eric F.;
Croton, Darren J.;
Dekel, Avishai;
Ferguson, Henry C.;
Forrest, Ben;
Grogin, Norman A.;
Guo, Yicheng;
Kocevski, Dale D.;
Koekemoer, Anton M.;
Labbé, Ivo;
Lucas, Ray A.;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Straatman, Caroline M. S.;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Tomczak, Adam;
van Dokkum, Pieter
Submitted: 2017-06-12, last modified: 2017-09-20
We study galactic star-formation activity as a function of environment and
stellar mass over 0.5<z<2.0 using the FourStar Galaxy Evolution (ZFOURGE)
survey. We estimate the galaxy environment using a Bayesian-motivated measure
of the distance to the third nearest neighbor for galaxies to the stellar mass
completeness of our survey, $\log(M/M_\odot)>9 (9.5)$ at z=1.3 (2.0). This
method, when applied to a mock catalog with the photometric-redshift precision
($\sigma_z / (1+z) \lesssim 0.02$), recovers galaxies in low- and high-density
environments accurately. We quantify the environmental quenching efficiency,
and show that at z> 0.5 it depends on galaxy stellar mass, demonstrating that
the effects of quenching related to (stellar) mass and environment are not
separable. In high-density environments, the mass and environmental quenching
efficiencies are comparable for massive galaxies ($\log (M/M_\odot)\gtrsim$
10.5) at all redshifts. For lower mass galaxies ($\log (M/M)_\odot) \lesssim$
10), the environmental quenching efficiency is very low at $z\gtrsim$ 1.5, but
increases rapidly with decreasing redshift. Environmental quenching can account
for nearly all quiescent lower mass galaxies ($\log(M/M_\odot) \sim$ 9-10),
which appear primarily at $z\lesssim$ 1.0. The morphologies of lower mass
quiescent galaxies are inconsistent with those expected of recently quenched
star-forming galaxies. Some environmental process must transform the
morphologies on similar timescales as the environmental quenching itself. The
evolution of the environmental quenching favors models that combine gas
starvation (as galaxies become satellites) with gas exhaustion through
star-formation and outflows ("overconsumption"), and additional processes such
as galaxy interactions, tidal stripping and disk fading to account for the
morphological differences between the quiescent and star-forming galaxy
populations.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.01511 [pdf] - 1585560
MOSFIRE Spectroscopy of Galaxies in Cosmic Noon
Submitted: 2017-07-05
The recent development of sensitive, multiplexed near infra-red instruments
has presented astronomers the unique opportunity to survey mass/magnitude
complete samples of galaxies at \emph{Cosmic Noon}, a time period where
$\sim80\%$ of the observed baryonic mass is generated and galaxies are actively
star-forming and evolving rapidly. This thesis takes advantage of the recently
commissioned MOSFIRE spectrograph on Keck, to conduct a survey (ZFIRE) of
galaxies at $1.5<z<2.5$ to measure accurate spectroscopic redshifts and basic
galaxy properties derived from multiple emission lines.
The majority of the thesis work involved survey planning, observing, data
reduction, and catalogue preparation of the ZFIRE survey and is described in
detail in this thesis. Using the ZFIRE spectroscopic redshifts, I show why
spectroscopy is instrumental to determine fundamental galaxy properties via SED
fitting techniques and to probe gravitationally bound structures in the early
universe. The thesis further presents basic properties of the ZFIRE data
products publicly released for the benefit of the astronomy community.
The high mass-completeness of the ZFIRE spectroscopic data at $z\sim2$ makes
it ideal to study fundamental galaxy properties such as, star formation rates,
metallicities, inter-stellar medium properties, galaxy kinematics, and the
stellar initial mass functions in unbiased star-forming galaxies. This thesis
focuses on one such aspect, the IMF.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.04536 [pdf] - 1557053
ZFIRE: Using H$\alpha$ equivalent widths to investigate the in situ
initial mass function at z~2
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Yuan, Tiantian;
Fisher, David B.;
Tran, Kim-Vy;
Kewley, Lisa;
Spitler, Lee;
Alcorn, Leo;
Cowley, Michael;
Labbe, Ivo;
Straatman, Caroline;
Tomczak, Adam
Submitted: 2017-03-13, last modified: 2017-04-03
We use the ZFIRE survey (http://zfire.swinburne.edu.au) to investigate the
high mass slope of the initial mass function (IMF) for a mass-complete
(log10(M$_*$/M$_\odot$)~9.3) sample of 102 star-forming galaxies at z~2 using
their H$\alpha$ equivalent widths (H$\alpha$-EW) and rest-frame optical
colours. We compare dust-corrected H$\alpha$-EW distributions with predictions
of star-formation histories (SFH) from PEGASE.2 and Starburst99 synthetic
stellar population models. We find an excess of high H$\alpha$-EW galaxies that
are up to 0.3--0.5 dex above the model-predicted Salpeter IMF locus and the
H$\alpha$-EW distribution is much broader (10--500 \AA) than can easily be
explained by a simple monotonic SFH with a standard Salpeter-slope IMF. Though
this discrepancy is somewhat alleviated when it is assumed that there is no
relative attenuation difference between stars and nebular lines, the result is
robust against observational biases, and no single IMF (i.e. non-Salpeter
slope) can reproduce the data. We show using both spectral stacking and Monte
Carlo simulations that starbursts cannot explain the EW distribution. We
investigate other physical mechanisms including models with variations in
stellar rotation, binary star evolution, metallicity, and the IMF upper-mass
cutoff. IMF variations and/or highly rotating extreme metal poor stars
(Z~0.1Z$_\odot$) with binary interactions are the most plausible explanations
for our data. If the IMF varies, then the highest H$\alpha$-EWs would require
very shallow slopes ($\Gamma$>-1.0) with no one slope able to reproduce the
data. Thus, the IMF would have to vary stochastically. We conclude that the
stellar populations at z~2 show distinct differences from local populations and
there is no simple physical model to explain the large variation in
H$\alpha$-EWs at z~2.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.03814 [pdf] - 1557048
Discovery of Extreme [OIII]+H$\beta$ Emitting Galaxies Tracing an
Overdensity at z~3.5 in CDF-South
Forrest, Ben;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Broussard, Adam;
Allen, Rebecca J.;
Apfel, Miranda;
Cowley, Michael J.;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Labbé, Ivo;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Papovich, Casey;
Quadri, Ryan F.;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Straatman, Caroline M. S.;
Tomczak, Adam
Submitted: 2017-03-10
Using deep multi-wavelength photometry of galaxies from ZFOURGE, we group
galaxies at $2.5<z<4.0$ by the shape of their spectral energy distributions
(SEDs). We identify a population of galaxies with excess emission in the
$K_s$-band, which corresponds to [OIII]+H$\beta$ emission at $2.95<z<3.65$.
This population includes 78% of the bluest galaxies with UV slopes steeper than
$\beta = -2$. We de-redshift and scale this photometry to build two composite
SEDs, enabling us to measure equivalent widths of these Extreme [OIII]+H$\beta$
Emission Line Galaxies (EELGs) at $z\sim3.5$. We identify 60 galaxies that
comprise a composite SED with [OIII]+H$\beta$ rest-frame equivalent width of
$803\pm228$\AA\ and another 218 galaxies in a composite SED with equivalent
width of $230\pm90$\AA. These EELGs are analogous to the `green peas' found in
the SDSS, and are thought to be undergoing their first burst of star formation
due to their blue colors ($\beta < -1.6$), young ages
($\log(\rm{age}/yr)\sim7.2$), and low dust attenuation values. Their strong
nebular emission lines and compact sizes (typically $\sim1.4$ kpc) are
consistent with the properties of the star-forming galaxies possibly
responsible for reionizing the universe at $z>6$. Many of the EELGs also
exhibit Lyman-$\alpha$ emission. Additionally, we find that many of these
sources are clustered in an overdensity in the Chandra Deep Field South, with
five spectroscopically confirmed members at $z=3.474 \pm 0.004$. The spatial
distribution and photometric redshifts of the ZFOURGE population further
confirm the overdensity highlighted by the EELGs.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.00016 [pdf] - 1564084
ZFIRE: The Evolution of the Stellar Mass Tully-Fisher Relation to
Redshift 2.0 < Z < 2.5 with MOSFIRE
Straatman, Caroline M. S.;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Labbé, Ivo;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Alcorn, Leo;
Cowley, Michael;
Kewley, Lisa J.;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Yuan, Tiantian
Submitted: 2017-02-28
Using observations made with MOSFIRE on Keck I as part of the ZFIRE survey,
we present the stellar mass Tully-Fisher relation at 2.0 < z < 2.5. The sample
was drawn from a stellar mass limited, Ks-band selected catalog from ZFOURGE
over the CANDELS area in the COSMOS field. We model the shear of the Halpha
emission line to derive rotational velocities at 2.2X the scale radius of an
exponential disk (V2.2). We correct for the blurring effect of a
two-dimensional PSF and the fact that the MOSFIRE PSF is better approximated by
a Moffat than a Gaussian, which is more typically assumed for natural seeing.
We find for the Tully-Fisher relation at 2.0 < z < 2.5 that logV2.2 =(2.18 +/-
0.051)+(0.193 +/- 0.108)(logM/Msun - 10) and infer an evolution of the
zeropoint of Delta M/Msun = -0.25 +/- 0.16 dex or Delta M/Msun = -0.39 +/- 0.21
dex compared to z = 0 when adopting a fixed slope of 0.29 or 1/4.5,
respectively. We also derive the alternative kinematic estimator S0.5, with a
best-fit relation logS0.5 =(2.06 +/- 0.032)+(0.211 +/- 0.086)(logM/Msun - 10),
and infer an evolution of Delta M/Msun= -0.45 +/- 0.13 dex compared to z < 1.2
if we adopt a fixed slope. We investigate and review various systematics,
ranging from PSF effects, projection effects, systematics related to stellar
mass derivation, selection biases and slope. We find that discrepancies between
the various literature values are reduced when taking these into account. Our
observations correspond well with the gradual evolution predicted by
semi-analytic models.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.05262 [pdf] - 1533478
The Size Evolution of Star-forming Galaxies Since z~7 Using ZFOURGE
Allen, Rebecca J.;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Labbe, Ivo;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Cowley, Michael;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Papovich, Casey;
Quadri, Ryan;
Straatman, Caroline M. S.;
Tilvi, Vithal;
van Dokkum, Pieter
Submitted: 2016-12-15
For the first time, we present the size evolution of a mass-complete
(log(M*/Msol)>10) sample of star-forming galaxies over redshifts z=1-7,
selected from the FourStar Galaxy Evolution Survey (ZFOURGE). Observed H-band
sizes are measured from the Cosmic Assembly Near-Infrared Deep Extragalactic
Legacy Survey (CANDELS) Hubble Space Telescope (HST)/F160W imaging.
Distributions of individual galaxy masses and sizes illustrate that a clear
mass-size relation exists up to z~7. At z~7, we find that the average galaxy
size from the mass-size relation is more compact at a fixed mass of
log(M*/Msol)=10.1, with r_1/2,maj=1.02+/-0.29 kpc, than at lower redshifts.
This is consistent with our results from stacking the same CANDELS HST/F160W
imaging, when we correct for galaxy position angle alignment. We find that the
size evolution of star-forming galaxies is well fit by a power law of the form
r_e = 7.07(1 + z)^-0.89 kpc, which is consistent with previous works for normal
star-formers at 1<z<4. In order to compare our slope with those derived Lyman
break galaxy studies, we correct for different IMFs and methodology and find a
slope of -0.97+/-0.02, which is shallower than that reported for the evolution
of Lyman break galaxies at z>4 (r_e\propto(1 +z)^-1.2+/-0.06). Therefore, we
conclude the Lyman break galaxies likely represent a subset of highly
star-forming galaxies that exhibit rapid size growth at z>4.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.01534 [pdf] - 1533016
ZFIRE: Similar Stellar Growth in H$\alpha$-emitting Cluster and Field
Galaxies at z~2
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Alcorn, Leo Y.;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Straatman, Caroline;
Yuan, Tiantian;
Cowley, Michael;
Davé, Romeel;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Kewley, Lisa J.;
Labbé, Ivo;
Martizzi, Davidé;
Papovich, Casey;
Quadri, Ryan;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Tomczak, Adam
Submitted: 2016-12-05
We compare galaxy scaling relations as a function of environment at $z\sim2$
with our ZFIRE survey where we have measured H$\alpha$ fluxes for 90
star-forming galaxies selected from a mass-limited
[$\log(M_{\star}/M_{\odot})>9$] sample based on ZFOURGE. The cluster galaxies
(37) are part of a confirmed system at z=2.095 and the field galaxies (53) are
at $1.9<z<2.4$; all are in the COSMOS legacy field. There is no statistical
difference between H$\alpha$-emitting cluster and field populations when
comparing their star formation rate (SFR), stellar mass ($M_{\star}$), galaxy
size ($r_{eff}$), SFR surface density [$\Sigma$(H$\alpha_{star}$)], and stellar
age distributions. The only difference is that at fixed stellar mass, the
H$\alpha$-emitting cluster galaxies are $\log(r_{eff})\sim0.1$ larger than in
the field. Approximately 19% of the H$\alpha$-emitters in the cluster and 26%
in the field are IR-luminous ($L_{IR}>2\times10^{11} L_{\odot}$). Because the
LIRGs in our combined sample are $\sim5$ times more massive than the low-IR
galaxies, their radii are $\sim70$% larger. To track stellar growth, we
separate galaxies into those that lie above, on, and below the H$\alpha$
star-forming main sequence (SFMS) using $\Delta$SFR$(M_{\star})=\pm0.2$ dex.
Galaxies above the SFMS (starbursts) tend to have higher H$\alpha$ SFR surface
densities and younger light-weighted stellar ages compared to galaxies below
the SFMS. Our results indicate that starbursts (+SFMS) in the cluster and field
at $z\sim2$ are growing their stellar cores. Lastly, we compare to the
(SFR-$M_{\star}$) relation from RHAPSODY cluster simulations and find the
predicted slope is nominally consistent with the observations. However, the
predicted cluster SFRs tend to be too low by a factor of $\sim2$ which seems to
be a common problem for simulations across environment.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.07579 [pdf] - 1498412
The FourStar Galaxy Evolution Survey (ZFOURGE): ultraviolet to
far-infrared catalogs, medium-bandwidth photometric redshifts with improved
accuracy, stellar masses, and confirmation of quiescent galaxies to z~3.5
Straatman, Caroline M. S.;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Quadri, Ryan F.;
Labbe, Ivo;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Persson, S. Eric;
Papovich, Casey;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Brammer, Gabriel B.;
Cowley, Michael;
Tomczak, Adam;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Alcorn, Leo;
Allen, Rebecca;
Broussard, Adam;
van Dokkum, Pieter;
Forrest, Ben;
van Houdt, Josha;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Kawinwanichakij, Lalitwadee;
Kelson, Daniel D.;
Lee, Janice;
McCarthy, Patrick J.;
Mehrtens, Nicola;
Monson, Andrew;
Murphy, David;
Rees, Glen;
Tilvi, Vithal;
Whitaker, Katherine E.
Submitted: 2016-08-26, last modified: 2016-08-30
The FourStar galaxy evolution survey (ZFOURGE) is a 45 night legacy program
with the FourStar near-infrared camera on Magellan and one of the most
sensitive surveys to date. ZFOURGE covers a total of $400\ \mathrm{arcmin}^2$
in cosmic fields CDFS, COSMOS and UDS, overlapping CANDELS. We present
photometric catalogs comprising $>70,000$ galaxies, selected from ultradeep
$K_s$-band detection images ($25.5-26.5$ AB mag, $5\sigma$, total), and $>80\%$
complete to $K_s<25.3-25.9$ AB. We use 5 near-IR medium-bandwidth filters
($J_1,J_2,J_3,H_s,H_l$) as well as broad-band $K_s$ at $1.05\ - 2.16\ \mu m$ to
$25-26$ AB at a seeing of $\sim0.5$". Each field has ancillary imaging in
$26-40$ filters at $0.3-8\ \mu m$. We derive photometric redshifts and stellar
population properties. Comparing with spectroscopic redshifts indicates a
photometric redshift uncertainty $\sigma_z={0.010,0.009}$, and 0.011 in CDFS,
COSMOS, and UDS. As spectroscopic samples are often biased towards bright and
blue sources, we also inspect the photometric redshift differences between
close pairs of galaxies, finding $\sigma_{z,pairs}= 0.01-0.02$ at $1<z<2.5$. We
quantify how $\sigma_{z,pairs}$ depends on redshift, magnitude, SED type, and
the inclusion of FourStar medium bands. $\sigma_{z,pairs}$ is smallest for
bright, blue star-forming samples, while red star-forming galaxies have the
worst $\sigma_{z,pairs}$. Including FourStar medium bands reduces
$\sigma_{z,pairs}$ by 50\% at $1.5<z<2.5$. We calculate SFRs based on
ultraviolet and ultradeep far-IR $Spitzer$/MIPS and Herschel/PACS data. We
derive rest-frame $U-V$ and $V-J$ colors, and illustrate how these correlate
with specific SFR and dust emission to $z=3.5$. We confirm the existence of
quiescent galaxies at $z\sim3$, demonstrating their SFRs are suppressed by
$>\times15$.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.00013 [pdf] - 1467722
ZFIRE: A KECK/MOSFIRE Spectroscopic Survey of Galaxies in Rich
Environments at z~2
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Yuan, Tiantian;
Tran, Kim-Vy;
Spitler, Lee;
Kewley, Lisa;
Straatman, Caroline;
Cowley, Michael;
Fisher, David;
Labbe, Ivo;
Tomczak, Adam;
Allen, Rebecca;
Alcorn, Leo
Submitted: 2016-06-30, last modified: 2016-08-28
We present an overview and the first data release of ZFIRE, a spectroscopic
redshift survey of star-forming galaxies that utilizes the MOSFIRE instrument
on Keck-I to study galaxy properties in rich environments at $1.5<z<2.5$. ZFIRE
measures accurate spectroscopic redshifts and basic galaxy properties derived
from multiple emission lines. The galaxies are selected from a stellar mass
limited sample based on deep near infra-red imaging ($\mathrm{K_{AB}<25}$) and
precise photometric redshifts from the ZFOURGE and UKIDSS surveys as well as
grism redshifts from 3DHST. Between 2013--2015 ZFIRE has observed the COSMOS
and UDS legacy fields over 13 nights and has obtained 211 galaxy redshifts over
$1.57<z<2.66$ from a combination of nebular emission lines (such as \Halpha,
\NII, \Hbeta, \OII, \OIII, \SII) observed at 1--2\micron. Based on our
medium-band NIR photometry, we are able to spectrophotometrically flux
calibrate our spectra to \around10\% accuracy. ZFIRE reaches $5\sigma$ emission
line flux limits of \around$\mathrm{3\times10^{-18}~erg/s/cm^2}$ with a
resolving power of $R=3500$ and reaches masses down to \around10$^{9}$\msol. We
confirm that the primary input survey, ZFOURGE, has produced photometric
redshifts for star-forming galaxies (including highly attenuated ones) accurate
to $\Delta z/(1+z\mathrm{_{spec})}=0.015$ with $0.7\%$ outliers. We measure a
slight redshift bias of $<0.001$, and we note that the redshift bias tends to
be larger at higher masses. We also examine the role of redshift on the
derivation of rest-frame colours and stellar population parameters from SED
fitting techniques. The ZFIRE survey extends spectroscopically-confirmed $z\sim
2$ samples across a richer range of environments, here we make available the
first public release of the data for use by the
community.\footnote{\url{http://zfire.swinburne.edu.au}}
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.00014 [pdf] - 1444135
Cold-Mode Accretion: Driving the Fundamental Mass-Metallicity Relation
at z~2
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
van de Voort, Freeke;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Yuan, Tiantian;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Allen, Rebecca J.;
Alcorn, Leo;
Cowley, Michael;
Labbe, Ivo;
Spitler, Lee;
Straatman, Caroline;
Tomczak, Adam
Submitted: 2016-06-30
We investigate the star formation rate (SFR) dependence on the stellar mass
and gas-phase metallicity relation at z=2 with MOSFIRE/Keck as part of the
ZFIRE survey. We have identified 117 galaxies (1.98 < z < 2.56), with
$8.9\leq$log(M/M$_{\odot}$)$\leq11.0$, for which we can measure gas-phase
metallicities. For the first time, we show discernible difference between the
mass-metallicity relation, using individual galaxies, when deviding the sample
by low ($<10$~M$_{\odot}$yr$^{-1}$) and high ($>10$~M$_{\odot}$yr$^{-1}$) SFRs.
At fixed mass, low star-forming galaxies tend to have higher metallicity than
high star-forming galaxies. Using a few basic assumptions, we further show that
the gas masses and metallicities required to produce the fundamental
mass--metallicity relation, and its intrinsic scatter, are consistent with
cold-mode accretion predictions obtained from the OWLS hydrodynamical
simulations. Our results from both simulations and observations are suggestive
that cold-mode accretion is responsible for the fundamental mass-metallicity
relation at $z=2$ and demonstrates the direct relationship between cosmological
accretion and the fundamental properties of galaxies.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:1606.00528 [pdf] - 1429540
ZFIRE: The Kinematics of Star-Forming Galaxies as a Function of
Environment at z~2
Alcorn, Leo Y.;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Straatman, Caroline;
Yuan, Tiantian;
Allen, Rebecca J.;
Cowley, Michael;
Davé, Romeel;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Kewley, Lisa J.;
Labbé, Ivo;
Quadri, Ryan;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Tomczak, Adam
Submitted: 2016-06-01
We perform a kinematic analysis of galaxies at $z\sim2$ in the COSMOS legacy
field using near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy from Keck/MOSFIRE as part of the
ZFIRE survey. Our sample consists of 75 Ks-band selected star-forming galaxies
from the ZFOURGE survey with stellar masses ranging from
log(M$_{\star}$/M$_{\odot}$)$=9.0-11.0$, 28 of which are members of a known
overdensity at $z=2.095$. We measure H$\alpha$ emission-line integrated
velocity dispersions ($\sigma_{\rm int}$) from 50$-$230 km s$^{-1}$, consistent
with other emission-line studies of $z\sim2$ field galaxies. From these data we
estimate virial, stellar, and gas masses and derive correlations between these
properties for cluster and field galaxies at $z\sim2$. We find evidence that
baryons dominate within the central effective radius. However, we find no
statistically significant differences between the cluster and the field, and
conclude that the kinematics of star-forming galaxies at $z\sim2$ are not
significantly different between the cluster and field environments.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.07176 [pdf] - 1447771
Large scale structure around a z=2.1 cluster
Hung, Chao-Ling;
Casey, Caitlin M.;
Chiang, Yi-Kuan;
Capak, Peter;
Cowley, Michael J.;
Darvish, Behnam;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Kovac, K.;
Lilly, Simon J.;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Yuan, Tiantian
Submitted: 2016-05-23
The most prodigious starburst galaxies are absent in massive galaxy clusters
today, but their connection with large scale environments is less clear at
$z\gtrsim2$. We present a search of large scale structure around a galaxy
cluster core at $z=2.095$ using a set of spectroscopically confirmed galaxies.
We find that both color-selected star-forming galaxies (SFGs) and dusty
star-forming galaxies (DSFGs) show significant overdensities around the
$z=2.095$ cluster. A total of 8 DSFGs (including 3 X-ray luminous active
galactic nuclei, AGNs) and 34 SFGs are found within a 10 arcmin radius
(corresponds to $\sim$15 cMpc at $z\sim2.1$) from the cluster center and within
a redshift range of $\Delta z=0.02$, which leads to galaxy overdensities of
$\delta_{\rm DSFG}\sim12.3$ and $\delta_{\rm SFG}\sim2.8$. The cluster core and
the extended DSFG- and SFG-rich structure together demonstrate an active
cluster formation phase, in which the cluster is accreting a significant amount
of material from large scale structure while the more mature core may begin to
virialize. Our finding of this DSFG-rich structure, along with a number of
other protoclusters with excess DSFGs and AGNs found to date, suggest that the
overdensities of these rare sources indeed trace significant mass
overdensities. However, it remains puzzling how these intense star formers are
triggered concurrently. Although an increased probability of galaxy
interactions and/or enhanced gas supply can trigger the excess of DSFGs, our
stacking analysis based on 850 $\mu$m images and morphological analysis based
on rest-frame optical imaging do not show such enhancements of merger fraction
and gas content in this structure.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.05314 [pdf] - 1443982
Differences in the structural properties and star-formation rates of
field and cluster galaxies at z~1
Submitted: 2016-05-17
We investigate the dependance of galaxy sizes and star-formation rates (SFRs)
on environment using a mass-limited sample of quiescent and star-forming
galaxies with M>10^9.5 at z=0.92 selected from the NMBS survey. Using the GEEC2
spectroscopic cluster catalog and the accurate photometric redshifts from NMBS,
we select quiescent and star-forming cluster (sigma=490 km/s) galaxies within
two virial radius, Rvir, intervals of 0.5<Rvir<2 and Rvir<0.5. Galaxies
residing outside of 2 Rvir of both the cluster centres and additional candidate
over-densities are defined as our field sample. Galaxy structural parameters
are measured from the COSMOS legacy HST/ACS F814W image. The sizes and Sersic
indices of quiescent field and cluster galaxies have the same distribution
regardless of Rvir. However, cluster star-forming galaxies within 0.5 Rvir have
lower mass-normalised average sizes, by 16${\pm}7\%$, and a higher fraction of
Sersic indices with n>1, than field star-forming galaxies. The average SFRs of
star-forming cluster galaxies show a trend of decreasing SFR with clustocentric
radius. The mass-normalised average SFR of cluster star-forming galaxies is a
factor of 2-2.5 (7-9 sigma) lower than that of star-forming galaxies in the
field. While we find no significant dependence on environment for quiescent
galaxies, the properties of star-forming galaxies are affected, which could be
the result of environment acting on their gas content.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.01096 [pdf] - 1359281
UV to IR Luminosities and Dust Attenuation Determined from ~4000
K-Selected Galaxies at 1<z<3 in the ZFOURGE Survey
Forrest, Ben;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Tomczak, Adam R.;
Broussard, Adam;
Labbé, Ivo;
Papovich, Casey;
Kriek, Mariska;
Allen, Rebecca J.;
Cowley, Michael;
Dickinson, Mark;
Glazebrook, Karl;
van Houdt, Josha;
Inami, Hanae;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Kawinwanichakij, Lalitwadee;
Kelson, Daniel;
McCarthy, Patrick J.;
Monson, Andrew;
Morrison, Glenn;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Persson, S. Eric;
Quadri, Ryan F.;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Straatman, Caroline;
Tilvi, Vithal
Submitted: 2016-02-02
We build a set of composite galaxy SEDs by de-redshifting and scaling
multi-wavelength photometry from galaxies in the ZFOURGE survey, covering the
CDFS, COSMOS, and UDS fields. From a sample of ~4000 K_s-band selected
galaxies, we define 38 composite galaxy SEDs that yield continuous
low-resolution spectra (R~45) over the rest-frame range 0.1-4 um. Additionally,
we include far infrared photometry from the Spitzer Space Telescope and the
Herschel Space Observatory to characterize the infrared properties of our
diverse set of composite SEDs. From these composite SEDs we analyze the
rest-frame UVJ colors, as well as the ratio of IR to UV light (IRX) and the UV
slope ($\beta$) in the IRX$-\beta$ dust relation at 1<z<3. Blue star-forming
composite SEDs show IRX and $\beta$ values consistent with local relations;
dusty star-forming galaxies have considerable scatter, as found for local IR
bright sources, but on average appear bluer than expected for their IR fluxes.
We measure a tight linear relation between rest-frame UVJ colors and dust
attenuation for star-forming composites, providing a direct method for
estimating dust content from either (U-V) or (V-J) rest-frame colors for
star-forming galaxies at intermediate redshifts.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:1601.02016 [pdf] - 1347841
ZFOURGE catalogue of AGN candidates: an enhancement of 160{\mu}m-derived
star-formation rates in active galaxies to $z$ = 3.2
Cowley, Michael J.;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Rees, Glen A.;
Labbé, Ivo;
Allen, Rebecca J.;
Brammer, Gabriel B.;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Hopkins, Andrew M.;
Juneau, Stéphanie;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Mullaney, James R.;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Papovich, Casey;
Quadri, Ryan F.;
Straatman, Caroline M. S.;
Tomczak, Adam R.;
van Dokkum, Pieter G.
Submitted: 2016-01-08
We investigate active galactic nuclei (AGN) candidates within the FourStar
Galaxy Evolution Survey (ZFOURGE) to determine the impact they have on
star-formation in their host galaxies. We first identify a population of radio,
X-ray, and infrared-selected AGN by cross-matching the deep $K_{s}$-band
imaging of ZFOURGE with overlapping multi-wavelength data. From this, we
construct a mass-complete (log(M$_{*}$/M$_{\odot}$) $\ge$ 9.75), AGN luminosity
limited sample of 235 AGN hosts over z = 0.2 - 3.2. We compare the rest-frame U
- V versus V - J (UVJ) colours and specific star-formation rates (sSFRs) of the
AGN hosts to a mass-matched control sample of inactive (non-AGN) galaxies. UVJ
diagnostics reveal AGN tend to be hosted in a lower fraction of quiescent
galaxies and a higher fraction of dusty galaxies than the control sample. Using
160{\mu}m Herschel PACS data, we find the mean specific star-formation rate of
AGN hosts to be elevated by 0.34$\pm$0.07 dex with respect to the control
sample across all redshifts. This offset is primarily driven by
infrared-selected AGN, where the mean sSFR is found to be elevated by as much
as a factor of ~5. The remaining population, comprised predominantly of X-ray
AGN hosts, is found mostly consistent with inactive galaxies, exhibiting only a
marginal elevation. We discuss scenarios that may explain these findings and
postulate that AGN are less likely to be a dominant mechanism for moderating
galaxy growth via quenching than has previously been suggested.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.02862 [pdf] - 1347605
Satellite Quenching and Galactic Conformity at 0.3 < z < 2.5
Kawinwanichakij, Lalitwadee;
Quadri, Ryan F.;
Papovich, Casey;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Labbé, Ivo;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Straatman, Caroline;
Tran, Kim-Vy;
Allen, Rebecca;
Behroozi, Peter S.;
Cowley, Michael;
Dekel, Avishai;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Hartley, William G.;
Kelson, Daniel D.;
Koo, David C.;
Lee, Seong-Kook;
Lu, Yu;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Persson, Eric;
Primack, Joel R.;
Tilvi, Vithal;
Tomczak, Adam R.;
van Dokkum, Pieter
Submitted: 2015-11-09
We measure the evolution of the quiescent fraction and quenching efficiency
of satellites around star-forming and quiescent central galaxies with stellar
mass $\log(M_{\mathrm{cen}}/M_{\odot})>10.5$ at $0.3<z<2.5$. We combine imaging
from three deep near-infrared-selected surveys (ZFOURGE/CANDELS, UDS, and
UltraVISTA), which allows us to select a stellar-mass complete sample of
satellites with $\log(M_{\mathrm{sat}}/M_{\odot})>9.3$. Satellites for both
star-forming and quiescent central galaxies have higher quiescent fractions
compared to field galaxies matched in stellar mass at all redshifts. We also
observe "galactic conformity": satellites around quiescent centrals are more
likely to be quenched compared to the satellites around star-forming centrals.
In our sample, this conformity signal is significant at $\gtrsim3\sigma$ for
$0.6<z<1.6$, whereas it is only weakly significant at $0.3<z<0.6$ and
$1.6<z<2.5$. Therefore, conformity (and therefore satellite quenching) has been
present for a significant fraction of the age of the universe. The satellite
quenching efficiency increases with increasing stellar mass of the central, but
does not appear to depend on the stellar mass of the satellite to the mass
limit of our sample. When we compare the satellite quenching efficiency of
star-forming centrals with stellar masses 0.2 dex higher than quiescent
centrals (which should account for any difference in halo mass), the conformity
signal decreases, but remains statistically significant at $0.6<z<0.9$. This is
evidence that satellite quenching is connected to the star-formation properties
of the central as well as to the mass of the halo. We discuss physical effects
that may contribute to galactic conformity, and emphasize that they must allow
for continued star-formation in the central galaxy even as the satellites are
quenched.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.01988 [pdf] - 1319740
Radio galaxies in ZFOURGE/NMBS: no difference in the properties of
massive galaxies with and without radio-AGN out to z = 2.25
Rees, G. A.;
Spitler, L. R.;
Norris, R. P.;
Cowley, M. J.;
Papovich, C.;
Glazebrook, K.;
Quadri, R. F.;
Straatman, C. M. S.;
Allen, R.;
Kacprzak, G. G.;
Labbe, I.;
Nanayakkara, T.;
Tomczak, A. R.;
Tran, K. -V.
Submitted: 2015-11-06
In order to reproduce the high-mass end of the galaxy mass-distribution, some
process must be responsible for the suppression of star-formation in the most
massive of galaxies. Commonly Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) are invoked to
fulfil this role, but the exact means by which they do so is still the topic of
much debate, with studies finding evidence for both the suppression and
enhancement of star-formation in AGN hosts. Using the ZFOURGE and NMBS galaxy
surveys, we investigate the host galaxy properties of a mass-limited
(M$_{\odot}$ $\ge$ 10$^{10.5}$ M$_{\odot}$), high-luminosity (L$_{1.4}$ $>$
10$^{24}$ W Hz$^{-1}$) sample of radio-loud Active Galactic Nuclei to a
redshift of z = 2.25. In contrast to low redshift studies, which associate
radio-AGN activity with quiescent hosts, we find that the majority of z $>$ 1.5
radio-AGN are hosted by star-forming galaxies. Indeed, the stellar populations
of radio-AGN are found to evolve with redshift in a manner that is consistent
with the non-AGN mass-similar galaxy population. Interestingly, we find the
radio-AGN fraction is constant across a redshift range of 0.25 $\le$ z $<$
2.25, perhaps indicating that the radio-AGN duty cycle has little dependence on
redshift or galaxy type. We do however see a strong relation between the
radio-AGN fraction and stellar mass, with radio-AGN becoming rare below $\sim$
10$^{10.5}$ M$_{\odot}$ or a halo-mass of 10$^{12}$ M$_{\odot}$. This halo-mass
threshold is in good agreement with simulations that initiate radio-AGN
feedback at this mass limit. Despite this we find that radio-AGN host
star-formation rates are consistent with the non-AGN mass-similar galaxy
sample, suggesting that while radio-AGN are in the right place to suppress
star-formation in massive galaxies they are not necessarily responsible for
doing so.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:1510.06072 [pdf] - 1351539
The SFR-M* Relation and Empirical Star-Formation Histories from ZFOURGE
at 0.5 < z < 4
Tomczak, Adam R.;
Quadri, Ryan F.;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Labbe, Ivo;
Straatman, Caroline M. S.;
Papovich, Casey;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Allen, Rebecca;
Brammer, Gabreil B.;
Cowley, Michael;
Dickinson, Mark;
Elbaz, David;
Inami, Hanae;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Morrison, Glenn E.;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Persson, S. Eric;
Rees, Glen A.;
Salmon, Brett;
Schreiber, Corentin;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Whitaker, Katherine E.
Submitted: 2015-10-20, last modified: 2015-11-03
We explore star-formation histories (SFHs) of galaxies based on the evolution
of the star-formation rate stellar mass relation (SFR-M*). Using data from the
FourStar Galaxy Evolution Survey (ZFOURGE) in combination with far-IR imaging
from the Spitzer and Herschel observatories we measure the SFR-M* relation at
0.5 < z < 4. Similar to recent works we find that the average infrared SEDs of
galaxies are roughly consistent with a single infrared template across a broad
range of redshifts and stellar masses, with evidence for only weak deviations.
We find that the SFR-M* relation is not consistent with a single power-law of
the form SFR ~ M*^a at any redshift; it has a power-law slope of a~1 at low
masses, and becomes shallower above a turnover mass (M_0) that ranges from
10^9.5 - 10^10.8 Msol, with evidence that M_0 increases with redshift. We
compare our measurements to results from state-of-the-art cosmological
simulations, and find general agreement in the slope of the SFR-M* relation
albeit with systematic offsets. We use the evolving SFR-M* sequence to generate
SFHs, finding that typical SFRs of individual galaxies rise at early times and
decline after reaching a peak. This peak occurs earlier for more massive
galaxies. We integrate these SFHs to generate mass-growth histories and compare
to the implied mass-growth from the evolution of the stellar mass function. We
find that these two estimates are in broad qualitative agreement, but that
there is room for improvement at a more detailed level. At early times the SFHs
suggest mass-growth rates that are as much as 10x higher than inferred from the
stellar mass function. However, at later times the SFHs under-predict the
inferred evolution, as is expected in the case of additional growth due to
mergers.
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:1508.03057 [pdf] - 1280992
ZFIRE: Galaxy Cluster Kinematics, H$\alpha$ Star Formation Rates, and
Gas-Phase Metallicities of XMM-LSS J02182-05102 at z=1.6233
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Yuan, Tiantian;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Kewley, Lisa J.;
Momcheva, Ivelina;
Papovich, Casey J.;
Quadri, Ryan;
Rudnick, Greg;
Saintonge, Amélie;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Straatman, Caroline;
Tomczak, Adam
Submitted: 2015-08-12
We spectroscopically survey the galaxy cluster XMM-LSS J02182-05102
(hereafter IRC 0218) using LRIS (optical) and MOSFIRE (near-infrared) on Keck I
as part of the ZFIRE survey. IRC 0218 has a narrow redshift range of
$1.612<z_{\rm spec}<1.635$ defined by 33 members of which 20 are at R$_{\rm
proj}<1$ Mpc. The cluster redshift and velocity dispersion are $z_{\rm
cl}=1.6233\pm0.0003$ and $\sigma_{\rm cl}=254\pm50$ km s$^{-1}$. We reach NIR
line sensitivities of $\sim0.3\times10^{-17}$ erg s$^{-1}$ cm$^{-2}$ that,
combined with multi-wavelength photometry, provide extinction-corrected
H$\alpha$ star formation rates (SFR), gas phase metallicities from
[NII]/H$\alpha$, and stellar masses. We measure an integrated H$\alpha$ SFR of
$\sim325{\rm M}_{\odot}$ yr$^{-1}$ (26 members; R$_{\rm proj}<2$ Mpc) and show
that the elevated star formation in the cluster core (R$_{\rm proj}<0.25$ Mpc)
is driven by the concentration of star-forming members, but the average SFR per
H$\alpha$-detected galaxy is half that of members at R$_{\rm proj}\sim1$ Mpc.
However, we do not detect any environmental imprint when comparing attenuation
and gas phase metallicities: the cluster galaxies show similar trends with
M$_{\star}$ as to the field, e.g. more massive galaxies have larger stellar
attenuation. IRC 0218's gas phase metallicity-M$_{\star}$ relation (MZR) is
offset to lower metallicities relative to $z\sim0$ and has a slope of
$0.13\pm0.10$. Comparing the MZR in IRC 0218 to the COSMOS cluster at $z=2.1$
shows no evolution ($\Delta t\sim1$ Gyr): the MZR for both galaxy clusters are
remarkably consistent with each other and virtually identical to several field
surveys at $z\sim2$.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.07525 [pdf] - 1374069
Z-FIRE: ISM properties of the z = 2.095 COSMOS Cluster
Kewley, Lisa J.;
Yuan, Tiantian;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Spitler, Lee;
Cowley, Michael;
Dopita, Michael;
Straatman, Caroline;
Labbe, Ivo;
Tomczak, Adam
Submitted: 2015-06-24
We investigate the ISM properties of 13 star-forming galaxies within the z~2
COSMOS cluster. We show that the cluster members have [NII]/Ha and [OIII]/Hb
emission-line ratios similar to z~2 field galaxies, yet systematically
different emission-line ratios (by ~0.17 dex) from the majority of local
star-forming galaxies. We find no statistically significant difference in the
[NII]/Ha and [OIII]/Hb line ratios or ISM pressures among the z~2 cluster
galaxies and field galaxies at the same redshift. We show that our cluster
galaxies have significantly larger ionization parameters (by up to an order of
magnitude) than local star-forming galaxies. We hypothesize that these high
ionization parameters may be associated with large specific star formation
rates (i.e. a large star formation rate per unit stellar mass). If this
hypothesis is correct, then this relationship would have important implications
for the geometry and/or the mass of stars contained within individual star
clusters as a function of redshift.
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.01380 [pdf] - 1258961
The sizes of massive quiescent and star forming galaxies at z~4 with
ZFOURGE and CANDELS
Straatman, Caroline M. S.;
Labbe, Ivo;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Tomczak, Adam;
Allen, Rebecca;
Brammer, Gabriel B.;
Cowley, Michael;
van Dokkum, Pieter;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Kawinwanichakij, Lalit;
Mehrtens, Nicola;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Papovich, Casey;
Persson, S. Eric;
Quadri, Ryan F.;
Rees, Glen;
Tilvi, Vithal;
Tran, Kim-Vy;
Whitaker, Katherine E.
Submitted: 2015-06-03
We study the rest-frame ultra-violet sizes of massive (~0.8 x 10^11 M_Sun)
galaxies at 3.4<z<4.2, selected from the FourStar Galaxy Evolution Survey
(ZFOURGE), by fitting single Sersic profiles to HST/WFC3/F160W images from the
Cosmic Assembly Near-Infrared Deep Extragalactic Legacy Survey (CANDELS).
Massive quiescent galaxies are very compact, with a median circularized
half-light radius r_e = 0.63 +/- 0.18 kpc. Removing 5/16 (31%) sources with
signs of AGN activity does not change the result. Star-forming galaxies have
r_e = 2.0 +/- 0.60 kpc, 3.2 +/- 1.3 x larger than quiescent galaxies. Quiescent
galaxies at z~4 are on average 6.0 +\- 0.17 x smaller than at z~0 and 1.9 +/-
0.7 x smaller than at z~2. Star-forming galaxies of the same stellar mass are
2.4 +/- 0.7 x smaller than at z~0. Overall, the size evolution at 0<z<4 is well
described by a powerlaw, with r_e = 5.08 +/- 0.28 (1+z)^(-1.44+/-0.08) kpc for
quiescent and r_e = 6.02 +/- 0.28 (1+z)^(-0.72+/-0.05) kpc for star-forming
galaxies. Compact star-forming galaxies are rare in our sample: we find only
1/14 (7%) with r_e / (M / 10^11 M_Sun)^0.75 < 1.5, whereas 13/16 (81%) of the
quiescent galaxies is compact. The number density of compact quiescent galaxies
at z~4 is 1.8 +/- 0.8 x 10^-5 Mpc^-3 and increases rapidly, by >5 x, between
2<z<4. The paucity of compact star-forming galaxies at z~4 and their large
rest-frame ultra-violet median sizes suggest that the formation phase of
compact cores is very short and/or highly dust obscured.
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:1504.03326 [pdf] - 1154901
The Differential Size Growth of Field and Cluster Galaxies at z=2.1
Using the ZFOURGE Survey
Allen, Rebecca J.;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Labbé, Ivo;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Straatman, Caroline M. S.;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Quadri, Ryan F.;
Cowley, Michael;
Monson, Andy;
Papovich, Casey;
Persson, S. Eric;
Rees, Glen;
Tilvi, V.;
Tomczak, Adam R.
Submitted: 2015-04-13
There is ongoing debate regarding the extent that environment affects galaxy
size growth beyond z>1. To investigate the differences in star-forming and
quiescent galaxy properties as a function of environment at z=2.1, we create a
mass-complete sample of 59 cluster galaxies Spitler et al. (2012) and 478 field
galaxies with log(M)>9 using photometric redshifts from the ZFOURGE survey. We
compare the mass-size relation of field and cluster galaxies using measured
galaxy semi-major axis half-light radii ($r_{1/2,maj}$) from CANDELS HST/F160W
imaging. We find consistent mass normalized (log(M)=10.7) sizes for quiescent
field galaxies ($r_{1/2,maj}=1.81\pm0.29$ kpc) and quiescent cluster galaxies
($r_{1/2,maj}=2.17\pm0.63$ kpc). The mass normalized size of star-forming
cluster galaxies ($r_{1/2,maj}=4.00\pm0.26$ kpc ) is 12% larger (KS test
$2.1\sigma$) than star-forming field galaxies ($r_{1/2,maj}=3.57\pm0.10$ kpc).
From the mass-color relation we find that quiescent field galaxies with
9.7<log(M)<10.4 are slightly redder (KS test $3.6\sigma$) than quiescent
cluster galaxies, while cluster and field quiescent galaxies with log(M)>10.4
have consistent colors. We find that star-forming cluster galaxies are on
average 20% redder than star-forming field galaxies at all masses. Furthermore,
we stack galaxy images to measure average radial color profiles as a function
of mass. Negative color gradients are only present for massive star-forming
field and cluster galaxies with log(M)>10.4, the remaining galaxy masses and
types have flat profiles. Our results suggest given the observed differences in
size and color of star-forming field and cluster galaxies, that the environment
has begun to influence/accelerate their evolution. However, the lack of
differences between field and cluster quiescent galaxies indicates that the
environment has not begun to significantly influence their evolution at z~2.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.05559 [pdf] - 1232067
The Absence of an Environmental Dependence in the Mass-Metallicity
Relation at z=2
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Yuan, Tiantian;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Kobayashi, Chiaki;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Kewley, Lisa J.;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Spitler, Lee;
Taylor, Philip;
Cowley, Michael;
Labbé, Ivo;
Straatman, Caroline;
Tomczak, Adam
Submitted: 2015-03-18
We investigate the environmental dependence of the mass-metallicity relation
at z=2 with MOSFIRE/Keck as part of the ZFIRE survey. Here, we present the
chemical abundance of a Virgo-like progenitor at z=2.095 that has an
established red sequence. We identified 43 cluster ($<z>=2.095\pm0.004$) and 74
field galaxies ($<z>=2.195\pm0.083$) for which we can measure metallicities.
For the first time, we show that there is no discernible difference between the
mass-metallicity relation of field and cluster galaxies to within 0.02dex. Both
our field and cluster galaxy mass-metallicity relations are consistent with
recent field galaxy studies at z~2. We present hydrodynamical simulations for
which we derive mass-metallicity relations for field and cluster galaxies. We
find at most a 0.1dex offset towards more metal-rich simulated cluster
galaxies. Our results from both simulations and observations are suggestive
that environmental effects, if present, are small and are secondary to the
ongoing inflow and outflow processes that are governed by galaxy halo mass.
[55]
oai:arXiv.org:1412.3806 [pdf] - 1223611
ZFOURGE/CANDELS: On the Evolution of M* Galaxy Progenitors from z=3 to
0.5
Papovich, Casey;
Labbé, I.;
Quadri, R.;
Tilvi, V.;
Behroozi, P.;
Bell, E. F.;
Glazebrook, K.;
Spitler, L.;
Straatman, C. M. S.;
Tran, K. -V.;
Cowley, M.;
Davé, R.;
Dekel, A.;
Dickinson, M.;
Ferguson, H.;
Finkelstein, S. L.;
Gawiser, E.;
Inami, H.;
Faber, S. M.;
Kacprzak, G. G.;
Kawinwanchakij, L.;
Kocevski, D.;
Koekemoer, A.;
Koo, D. C.;
Kurczynski, P.;
Lotz, J. M.;
Lu, Y.;
Lucas, R. A.;
McIntosh, D.;
Mehrtens, N.;
Mobasher, B.;
Monson, A.;
Morrison, G.;
Nanayakkara, T.;
Perrson, S. E.;
Salmon, B.;
Simons, R.;
Tomczak, A.;
van Dokkum, P.;
Weiner, B.;
Willner, S. P.
Submitted: 2014-12-11
Galaxies with stellar masses near M* contain the majority of stellar mass in
the universe, and are therefore of special interest in the study of galaxy
evolution. The Milky Way (MW) and Andromeda (M31) have present day stellar
masses near M*, at 5x10^10 Msol (MW-mass) and 10^11 Msol (M31-mass). We study
the typical progenitors of these galaxies using ZFOURGE, a deep medium-band
near-IR imaging survey, which is sensitive to the progenitors of these galaxies
out to z~3. We use abundance-matching techniques to identify the main
progenitors of these galaxies at higher redshifts. We measure the evolution in
the stellar mass, rest-frame colors, morphologies, far-IR luminosities, and
star-formation rates combining our deep multiwavelength imaging with near-IR
HST imaging from CANDELS, and far-IR imaging from GOODS-H and CANDELS-H. The
typical MW-mass and M31-mass progenitors passed through the same evolution
stages, evolving from blue, star-forming disk galaxies at the earliest stages,
to redder dust-obscured IR-luminous galaxies in intermediate stages, and to
red, more quiescent galaxies at their latest stages. The progenitors of the
MW-mass galaxies reached each evolutionary stage at later times (lower
redshifts) and with stellar masses that are a factor of 2-3 lower than the
progenitors of the M31-mass galaxies. The process driving this evolution,
including the suppression of star-formation in present-day M* galaxies requires
an evolving stellar-mass/halo-mass ratio and/or evolving halo-mass threshold
for quiescent galaxies. The effective size and star-formation rates imply that
the baryonic cold-gas fractions drop as galaxies evolve from high redshift to
z~0 and are strongly anticorrelated with an increase in the S\'ersic index.
Therefore, the growth of galaxy bulges in M* galaxies corresponds to a rapid
decline in the galaxy gas fractions and/or a decrease in the star-formation
efficiency.
[56]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.0690 [pdf] - 1222368
KECK/MOSFIRE spectroscopic confirmation of a Virgo-like cluster ancestor
at z=2.095
Yuan, T. -T.;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Kewley, Lisa J.;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Poole, Gregory B.;
Labbé, Ivo;
Straatman, Caroline M. S.;
Tomczak, Adam R.
Submitted: 2014-10-02
We present the spectroscopic confirmation of a galaxy cluster at $z=2.095$ in
the COSMOS field. This galaxy cluster was first reported in the ZFOURGE survey
as harboring evolved massive galaxies using photometric redshifts derived with
deep near-infrared (NIR) medium-band filters. We obtain medium resolution ($R
\sim$ 3600) NIR spectroscopy with MOSFIRE on the Keck 1 telescope and secure
180 redshifts in a $12'\times12'$ region. We find a prominent spike of 57
galaxies at $z=2.095$ corresponding to the galaxy cluster. The cluster velocity
dispersion is measured to be $\sigma_{\rm v1D}$ = 552 $\pm$ 52 km/s. This is
the first study of a galaxy cluster in this redshift range ($z \gt 2.0$) with
the combination of spectral resolution ($\sim$26 km/s) and the number of
confirmed members (${>}50$) needed to impose a meaningful constraint on the
cluster velocity dispersion and map its members over a large field of view. Our
$\Lambda$CDM cosmological simulation suggests that this cluster will most
likely evolve into a Virgo-like cluster with ${\rm M_{vir}}{=}10^{14.4\pm0.3}
{\rm M_\odot}$ ($68\%$ confidence) at $z\sim$ 0. The theoretical expectation of
finding such a cluster is $\sim$ $4\%$. Our results demonstrate the feasibility
of studying galaxy clusters at $z > 2$ in the same detailed manner using
multi-object NIR spectrographs as has been done in the optical in lower
redshift clusters.
[57]
oai:arXiv.org:1406.6056 [pdf] - 862993
The distribution of satellites around massive galaxies at 1<z<3 in
ZFOURGE/CANDELS: dependence on star formation activity
Kawinwanichakij, Lalitwadee;
Papovich, Casey;
Quadri, Ryan F.;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Spitler, Lee R.;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Labbe, Ivo;
Straatman, Caroline M. S.;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Allen, Rebecca;
Cowley, Michael;
Davé, Romeel;
Dekel, Avishai;
Ferguson, Henry C.;
Hartley, W. G;
Koekemoer, Anton M.;
Koo, David C.;
Lu, Yu;
Mehrtens, Nicola;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Persson, S. Eric;
Rees, Glen;
Salmon, Brett;
Tilvi, Vithal;
Tomczak, Adam R.;
van Dokkum, Pieter
Submitted: 2014-06-23, last modified: 2014-07-07
We study the statistical distribution of satellites around star-forming and
quiescent central galaxies at 1<z<3 using imaging from the FourStar Galaxy
Evolution Survey (ZFOURGE) and the Cosmic Assembly Near-IR Deep Extragalactic
Legacy Survey (CANDELS). The deep near-IR data select satellites down to
$\log(M/M_\odot)>9$ at z<3. The radial satellite distribution around centrals
is consistent with a projected NFW profile. Massive quiescent centrals,
$\log(M/M_\odot)>10.78$, have $\sim$2 times the number of satellites compared
to star-forming centrals with a significance of 2.7$\sigma$ even after
accounting for differences in the centrals' stellar-mass distributions. We find
no statistical difference in the satellite distributions of intermediate-mass
quiescent and star-forming centrals, $10.48<\log(M/M_\odot)<10.78$. Comparing
to the Guo2011 semi-analytic model, the excess number of satellites indicates
that quiescent centrals have halo masses 0.3 dex larger than star-forming
centrals, even when the stellar-mass distributions are fixed. We use a simple
toy model that relates halo mass and quenching, which roughly reproduces the
observed quenched fractions and the differences in halo mass between
star-forming and quenched galaxies only if galaxies have a quenching
probability that increases with halo mass from $\sim$0 for
$\log(M_h/M_\odot)\sim$11 to $\sim$1 for $\log(M_h/M_\odot)\sim$13.5. A single
halo-mass quenching threshold is unable to reproduce the quiescent fraction and
satellite distribution of centrals. Therefore, while halo quenching may be an
important mechanism, it is unlikely to be the only factor driving quenching. It
remains unclear why a high fraction of centrals remain star-forming even in
relatively massive halos.
[58]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.1048 [pdf] - 826696
Exploring the z=3-4 massive galaxy population with ZFOURGE: the
prevalence of dusty and quiescent galaxies
Spitler, Lee R.;
Straatman, Caroline M. S.;
Labbe, Ivo;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Tran, Kim-Vy H.;
Kacprzak, Glenn G.;
Quadri, Ryan F.;
Papovich, Casey;
Persson, S. Eric;
van Dokkum, Pieter;
Allen, Rebecca;
Kawinwanichakij, Lalitwadee;
Kelson, Daniel D.;
McCarthy, Patrick J.;
Mehrtens, Nicola;
Monson, Andrew J.;
Nanayakkara, Themiya;
Rees, Glen;
Tilvi, Vithal;
Tomczak, Adam R.
Submitted: 2014-05-05
Our understanding of the redshift $z>3$ galaxy population relies largely on
samples selected using the popular "dropout" technique, typically consisting of
UV-bright galaxies with blue colors and prominent Lyman breaks. As it is
currently unknown if these galaxies are representative of the massive galaxy
population, we here use the FourStar Galaxy Evolution (ZFOURGE) Survey to
create a stellar mass-limited sample at $z=3-4$. Uniquely, ZFOURGE uses deep
near-infrared medium-bandwidth filters to derive accurate photometric redshifts
and stellar population properties. The mass-complete sample consists of 57
galaxies with log M $>10.6$, reaching below $M^{\star}$ at $z=3-4$.
On average, the massive $z=3-4$ galaxies are extremely faint in the observed
optical with median $R_{tot}^{AB}=27.48\pm0.41$ (restframe
$M_{1700}=-18.05\pm0.37$). They lie far below the UV luminosity-stellar mass
relation for Lyman break galaxies and are about $\sim100\times$ fainter at the
same mass. The massive galaxies are red ($R-Ks_{AB}=3.9\pm0.2$; restframe
UV-slope $\beta=-0.2\pm0.3$) likely from dust or old stellar ages. We classify
the galaxy SEDs by their restframe $U-V$ and $V-J$ colors and find a diverse
population: $46^{+6+10}_{-6-17}$% of the massive galaxies are quiescent,
$54^{+8+17}_{-8-10}$% are dusty star-forming galaxies, and only
$14^{+3+10}_{-3-4}$% resemble luminous blue star forming Lyman break galaxies.
This study clearly demonstrates an inherent diversity among massive galaxies at
higher redshift than previously known. Furthermore,we uncover a reservoir of
dusty star-forming galaxies with $4\times$ lower specific star-formation rates
compared to submillimeter-selected starbursts at $z>3$. With $5\times$ higher
numbers, the dusty galaxies may represent a more typical mode of star formation
compared to submillimeter-bright starbursts.