Normalized to: Mouschovias, T.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.05508 [pdf] - 1045063
Magnetic Field - Gas Density Relation and Observational Implications
Revisited
Submitted: 2015-05-20
We revisit the relation between magnetic-field strength ($B$) and gas density
($\rho$) for contracting interstellar clouds and fragments (or, cores), which
is central in observationally determining the dynamical importance of magnetic
fields in cloud evolution and star formation. Recently, it has been claimed
that a relation $B \propto \rho^{2/3} $ is statistically preferred over $B
\propto \rho^{1/2}$ in molecular clouds, when magnetic field detections and
nondetections from Zeeman observations are combined. This finding has unique
observational implications on cloud and core geometry: The relation $B \propto
\rho^{2/3} $ can only be realized under spherical contraction. However, no
indication of spherical geometry can be found for the objects used in the
original statistical analysis of the $B-\rho$ relation. We trace the origin of
the inconsistency to simplifying assumptions in the statistical model used to
arrive at the $B\propto \rho^{2/3}$ conclusion and to an underestimate of
observational uncertainties in the determination of cloud and core densities.
We show that, when these restrictive assumptions are relaxed, $B \propto
\rho^{1/2}$ is the preferred relation for the (self-gravitating)
molecular-cloud data, as theoretically predicted four decades ago.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1103.6037 [pdf] - 338435
Hydromagnetic Waves in Weakly Ionised Media. I. Basic Theory, and
Application to Interstellar Molecular Clouds
Submitted: 2011-03-30
We present a comprehensive study of MHD waves and instabilities in a weakly
ionised system, e.g., an interstellar molecular cloud. We determine all the
critical wavelengths of perturbations across which the sustainable wave modes
can change radically (and so can their decay rates), and various instabilities
are present or absent. These critical wavelengths are essential for
understanding the effects of MHD waves (or turbulence) on the structure and
evolution of molecular clouds. Depending on the angle of propagation relative
to the magnetic field and the physical parameters of a cloud, there are
wavelength ranges in which no wave can be sustained as such. Yet, for other
directions of propagation or different properties of a model cloud, there may
exist some wave mode(s) at all wavelengths. For a typical cloud,
magnetically-driven ambipolar diffusion leads to removal of any support against
gravity that most short-wavelength waves (or turbulence) may have had, and
gravitationally-driven ambipolar diffusion sets in and leads to cloud
fragmentation into stellar-size masses, as first suggested by Mouschovias three
decades ago -- a single-stage fragmentation theory of star formation, distinct
from the hierarchical fragmentation picture. Phase velocities, decay times, and
eigenvectors (the densities and velocities of neutral particles and the plasma,
and components of the magnetic field) are determined as functions of the
wavelength of the disturbances and are explained physically. Comparison of the
results with nonlinear analytical or numerical calculations is also presented,
excellent agreement is found, and confidence in the analytical, linear approach
is gained to explore phenomena difficult to study through numerical
simulations. Mode splitting and mode merging, which are impossible in
single-fluid systems for linear perturbations, occur naturally in multifluid
systems.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1007.3741 [pdf] - 1033826
Self-Consistent Analysis of OH-Zeeman Observations: Too Much Noise about
Noise
Submitted: 2010-07-21
We had recently re-analyzed in a self-consistent way OH-Zeeman observations
in four molecular-cloud envelopes and we had shown that, contrary to claims by
Crutcher et al., there is no evidence that the mass-to-flux ratio decreases
from the envelopes to the cores of these clouds. The key difference between our
data analysis and the earlier one by Crutcher et al. is the relaxation of the
overly restrictive assumption made by Crutcher et al, that the magnetic field
strength is independent of position in each of the four envelopes. In a more
recent paper, Crutcher et al. (1) claim that our analysis is not
self-consistent, in that it misses a cosine factor, and (2) present new
arguments to support their contention that the magnetic-field strength is
indeed independent of position in each of the four envelopes. We show that the
claim of the missing cosine factor is false, that the new arguments contain
even more serious problems than the Crutcher et al. original data analysis, and
we present new observational evidence, independent of the OH-Zeeman data, that
suggests significant variations in the magnetic-field strength in the four
cloud envelopes.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1006.2826 [pdf] - 1033105
Do Lognormal Column-Density Distributions in Molecular Clouds Imply
Supersonic Turbulence?
Submitted: 2010-06-14
Recent observations of column densities in molecular clouds find lognormal
distributions with power-law high-density tails. These results are often
interpreted as indications that supersonic turbulence dominates the dynamics of
the observed clouds. We calculate and present the column-density distributions
of three clouds, modeled with very different techniques, none of which is
dominated by supersonic turbulence. The first star-forming cloud is simulated
using smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH); in this case gravity, opposed only
by thermal-pressure forces, drives the evolution. The second cloud is
magnetically subcritical with subsonic turbulence, simulated using nonideal
MHD; in this case the evolution is due to gravitationally-driven ambipolar
diffusion. The third cloud is isothermal, self-gravitating, and has a smooth
density distribution analytically approximated with a uniform inner region and
an r^-2 profile at larger radii. We show that in all three cases the
column-density distributions are lognormal. Power-law tails develop only at
late times (or, in the case of the smooth analytic profile, for strongly
centrally concentrated configurations), when gravity dominates all opposing
forces. It therefore follows that lognormal column-density distributions are
generic features of diverse model clouds, and should not be interpreted as
being a consequence of supersonic turbulence.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1003.2722 [pdf] - 1025696
The nonisothermal stage of magnetic star formation. II. Results
Submitted: 2010-03-13
In a previous paper we formulated the problem of the formation and evolution
of fragments (or cores) in magnetically-supported, self-gravitating molecular
clouds in axisymmetric geometry, accounting for the effects of ambipolar
diffusion and Ohmic dissipation, grain chemistry and dynamics, and radiative
transfer. Here we present results of star formation simulations that accurately
track the evolution of a protostellar fragment over eleven orders of magnitude
in density (from 300 cm^-3 to \approx 10^14 cm^-3), i.e., from the early
ambipolar-diffusion--initiated fragmentation phase, through the magnetically
supercritical, dynamical-contraction phase and the subsequent magnetic
decoupling stage, to the formation of a protostellar core in near hydrostatic
equilibrium. As found by Fiedler & Mouschovias (1993), gravitationally-driven
ambipolar diffusion leads to the formation and subsequent dynamic contraction
of a magnetically supercritical core. Moreover, we find that ambipolar
diffusion, not Ohmic dissipation, is responsible for decoupling all the species
except the electrons from the magnetic field, by a density \approx 3 x 10^12
cm^-3. Magnetic decoupling precedes the formation of a central stellar object
and ultimately gives rise to a concentration of magnetic flux (a `magnetic
wall') outside the hydrostatic core --- as also found by Tassis & Mouschovias
(2005a,b) through a different approach. At approximately the same density at
which Ohmic dissipation becomes more important than ambipolar diffusion
(\gtrsim 7 x 10^12 cm^-3), the grains carry most of the electric charge as well
as the electric current. The prestellar core remains disclike down to radii ~
10 AU, inside which thermal pressure becomes important. The magnetic flux
problem of star formation is resolved for at least strongly magnetic newborn
stars by this stage of the evolution, i.e., by a central density \approx 10^14
cm^-3. The hydrostatic core has radius \approx 2 AU, density \approx 10^14
cm^-3, temperature \approx 300 K, magnetic field strength \approx 0.2 G,
magnetic flux \approx 5 x 10^18 Wb, luminosity ~ 10^-3 L_\odot, and mass ~
10^-2 M_\odot.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:0909.2031 [pdf] - 1017476
Testing Molecular-Cloud Fragmentation Theories: Self-Consistent Analysis
of OH Zeeman Observations
Submitted: 2009-09-10
The ambipolar-diffusion theory of star formation predicts the formation of
fragments in molecular clouds with mass-to-flux ratios greater than that of the
parent-cloud envelope. By contrast, scenarios of turbulence-induced
fragmentation do not yield such a robust prediction. Based on this property,
Crutcher et al. (2009) proposed an observational test that could potentially
discriminate between fragmentation theories. However, the analysis applied to
the data severely restricts the discriminative power of the test: the authors
conclude that they can only constrain what they refer to as the "idealized"
ambipolar-diffusion theory that assumes initially straight-parallel magnetic
field lines in the parent cloud. We present an original, self-consistent
analysis of the same data taking into account the nonuniformity of the magnetic
field in the cloud envelopes, which is suggested by the data themselves, and we
discuss important geometrical effects that must be accounted for in using this
test. We show quantitatively that the quality of current data does not allow
for a strong conclusion about any fragmentation theory. Given the
discriminative potential of the test, we urge for more and better-quality data.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:0908.0102 [pdf] - 1003230
The Initial Core Mass Function due to Ambipolar Diffusion in Molecular
Clouds
Submitted: 2009-08-01
We show that the ambipolar-diffusion--initiated fragmentation of molecular
clouds leads simply and naturally to an initial core mass function (CMF) which
is very similar to the initial stellar mass function (IMF) and in excellent
agreement with existing observations. This agreement is robust provided that
the three (input) free parameters remain within their range of values suggested
by observations. Other, observationally testable, predictions are made.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:0901.0914 [pdf] - 1001270
Formation of Interstellar Clouds: Parker Instability with Phase
Transitions
Submitted: 2009-01-07
We follow numerically the nonlinear evolution of the Parker instability in
the presence of phase transitions from a warm to a cold HI interstellar medium
in two spatial dimensions. The nonlinear evolution of the system favors modes
that allow the magnetic field lines to cross the galactic plane. Cold HI clouds
form with typical masses ~= 10^5 M_sun, mean densities ~= 20 cm^-3, mean
magnetic field strengths ~= 4.3 muG (rms field strengths ~= 6.4 muG),
mass-to-flux ratios ~= 0.1 - 0.3 relative to critical, temperatures ~= 50 K,
(two-dimensional) turbulent velocity dispersions ~= 1.6 km s^-1, and
separations ~= 500 pc, in agreement with observations. The maximum density and
magnetic field strength are ~= 10^3 cm^-3 and ~= 20 muG, respectively.
Approximately 60% of all HI mass is in the warm neutral medium. The cold
neutral medium is arranged into sheet-like structures both perpendicular and
parallel to the galactic plane, but it is also found almost everywhere in the
galactic plane, with the density being highest in valleys of the magnetic field
lines. `Cloudlets' also form whose physical properties are in quantitative
agreement with those observed for such objects by Heiles (1967). The nonlinear
phase of the evolution takes ~< 30 Myr, so that, if the instability is
triggered by a nonlinear perturbation such as a spiral density shock wave,
interstellar clouds can form within a time suggested by observations.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:0812.1791 [pdf] - 315382
The Nonisothermal Stage of Magnetic Star Formation. I. Formulation of
the Problem and Method of Solution
Submitted: 2008-12-09
We formulate the problem of the formation and subsequent evolution of
fragments (or cores) in magnetically-supported, self-gravitating molecular
clouds in two spatial dimensions. The six-fluid (neutrals, electrons, molecular
and atomic ions, positively-charged, negatively-charged, and neutral grains)
physical system is governed by the radiative, nonideal magnetohydrodynamic
(RMHD) equations. The magnetic flux is not assumed to be frozen in any of the
charged species. Its evolution is determined by a newly-derived generalized
Ohm's law, which accounts for the contributions of both elastic and inelastic
collisions to ambipolar diffusion and Ohmic dissipation. The species abundances
are calculated using an extensive chemical-equilibrium network. Both MRN and
uniform grain size distributions are considered. The thermal evolution of the
protostellar core and its effect on the dynamics are followed by employing the
grey flux-limited diffusion approximation. Realistic temperature-dependent
grain opacities are used that account for a variety of grain compositions. We
have augmented the publicly-available Zeus-MP code to take into consideration
all these effects and have modified several of its algorithms to improve
convergence, accuracy and efficiency. Results of magnetic star formation
simulations that accurately track the evolution of a protostellar fragment from
a density ~10^3 cm^-3 to a density ~10^15 cm^-3, while rigorously accounting
for both nonideal MHD processes and radiative transfer, are presented in a
separate paper.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:0807.4571 [pdf] - 14947
Recent OH Zeeman Observations: Do they Really Contradict the
Ambipolar-Diffusion Theory of Star Formation?
Submitted: 2008-07-28
Until recently, many of the dozens of quantitative predictions of the
ambipolar-diffusion theory of gravitational fragmentation (or core formation)
of molecular clouds have been confirmed by observations and, just as
importantly, no prediction has been contradicted by any observation. A recent
paper, however, claims that measurements of the variation of the mass-to-flux
ratio from envelopes to cores in four clouds {\it de}creases, in direct
contrast to a prediction of the theory but in agreement with turbulent
fragmentation (in the absence of gravity) and, therefore, the
ambipolar-diffusion theory is invalid (Crutcher et al 2008). The paper treats
magnetic-field nondetections as if they were detections. We show that the
analysis of the data is fundamentally flawed and, moreover, the comparison with
the theoretical prediction ignores major geometrical effects, suggested by the
data themselves if taken at face value. The magnetic fluxes of the envelopes
are also miscalculated. We carry out a proper error analysis and treatment of
the nondetections and we show that the claimed measurement of the variation of
the mass-to-flux ratio from envelopes to cores is not valid, no contradiction
with the ambipolar-diffusion theory can be concluded, and no theory can be
tested on the basis of these data.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:0803.1272 [pdf] - 10790
Constraining the Earliest Circumstellar Disks and their Envelopes
Submitted: 2008-03-08
Using interferometric data from BIMA observations, combined with detailed
modeling in Fourier space of the physical structures predicted by models, we
constrain the circumstellar envelope parameters for four Class 0 young stellar
objects, as well as their embedded circumstellar disks. The envelopes of these
objects are still undergoing collapse, and theoretical collapse models can be
compared to the observations. Since it has been suggested in a previous study
that both the Larson-Penston and Shu similarity solutions underestimate the age
of the system, we adopt Tassis & Mouschovias' model of the collapse process,
which includes all relevant magnetic fields effects. The results of the model
fitting show a good consistency between theory and data; furthermore, no age
problem exists since the Tassis & Mouschovias' model is age independent for the
first 255 kyr. Although the majority of the continuum dust emission arises from
the circumstellar envelopes, these objects have well known outflows, which
suggest the presence of circumstellar disks. At the highest resolution, most of
the large-scale envelope emission is resolved out by interferometry, but the
small-scale residual emission remains, making it difficult to observe only the
compact disk component. By modeling the emission of the envelope and
subtracting it from the total emission, we constrain the disk masses in our
four systems to be comparable to or smaller than the typical disk masses for T
Tauri systems.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0702037 [pdf] - 316809
Protostar Formation in Magnetic Molecular Clouds beyond Ion Detachment:
II. Typical Axisymmetric Solution
Submitted: 2007-02-01
We follow the ambipolar-diffusion--driven formation and evolution of a
fragment in a magnetically supported molecular cloud, until a hydrostatic
protostellar core forms at its center. This problem was formulated in Paper I.
We determine the density, velocity and magnetic field as functions of space and
time, and the contribution of ambipolar diffusion and Ohmic dissipation to the
resolution of the magnetic flux problem of star formation. The issue of whether
the magnetic field ever decouples from the (neutral) matter is also addressed.
We also find that the electrons do not decouple from the field lines before
thermal ionization becomes important and recouples the magnetic field to the
neutral matter. Ohmic dissipation becomes more effective than ambipolar
diffusion as a flux reduction mechanism only at the highest densities (a few
times 10^12 particles per cubic cm). In the high-density central parts of the
core, the magnetic field acquires an almost spatially uniform structure, with a
value that, at the end of the calculation (number density ~ 5 times 10^14
particles per cubic cm), is found to be in excellent agreement with meteoritic
measurements of magnetic fields in the protosolar nebula. Outside the
hydrostatic protostellar core, a concentration of magnetic flux (a "magnetic
wall") forms, which gives rise to a magnetic shock. This magnetic shock is the
precursor of the repeated shocks found by Tassis & Mouschovias (2005) which
cause spasmodic accretion onto the hydrostatic core at later times.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0702036 [pdf] - 316808
Protostar Formation in Magnetic Molecular Clouds beyond Ion Detachment:
I. Formulation of the Problem and Method of Solution
Submitted: 2007-02-01
We formulate the problem of the formation of magnetically supercritical cores
in magnetically subcritical parent molecular clouds, and the subsequent
collapse of the cores to high densities, past the detachment of ions from
magnetic field lines and into the opaque regime. We employ the six-fluid MHD
equations, accounting for the effects of grains (negative, positive and
neutral) including their inelastic collisions with other species. We do not
assume that the magnetic flux is frozen in any of the charged species. We
derive a generalized Ohm's law that explicitly distinguishes between flux
advection (and the associated process of ambipolar diffusion) and Ohmic
dissipation, in order to assess the contribution of each mechanism to the
increase of the mass-to-flux ratio of the central parts of a collapsing core
and possibly to the resolution of the magnetic flux problem of star formation.
We show how our formulation is related to and can be transformed into the
traditional, directional formulation of the generalized Ohm's law, and we
derive formulae for the perpendicular, parallel and Hall conductivities
entering the latter, which include, for the first time, the effect of inelastic
collisions between grains. In addition, we present a general (valid in any
geometry) solution for the velocities of charged species as functions of the
velocity of the neutrals and of the effective flux velocity (which can in turn
be calculated from the dynamics of the system and Faraday's law). The last two
sets of formulae can be adapted for use in any general non-ideal MHD code to
study phenomena beyond star formation in magnetic clouds. The results,
including a detailed parameter study, are presented in two accompanying papers.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0702038 [pdf] - 316810
Protostar Formation in Magnetic Molecular Clouds beyond Ion Detachment:
III. A Parameter Study
Submitted: 2007-02-01
In two previous papers we formulated and solved, for a fiducial set of free
parameters, the problem of the formation and evolution of a magnetically
supercritical core inside a magnetically subcritical parent cloud. In this
paper we present a parameter study to assess the sensitivity of the results (1)
to the density at which the equation of state becomes adiabatic; (2) to the
initial mass-to-flux ratio of the parent cloud; and (3) to ionization by
radioactive decay of different nuclei (40K and 26Al) at high densities (number
density > 10^12 particles per cubic cm). We find that (1) the results depend
only slightly on the density at which the onset of adiabaticity occurs; (2)
memory of the initial mass-to-flux ratio is completely lost at late times,
which emphasizes the relevance of this work, idependently of the adopted theory
of core formation; and (3) the precise source of radioactive ionization alters
the degree of attachment of the electrons to the field lines (at high
densities), and the relative importance of ambipolar diffusion and Ohmic
dissipation in reducing the magnetic flux of the protostar. The value of the
magnetic field at the end of the runs is insensitive to the values of the free
parameters and in excellent agreement with meteoritic measurements of the
protosolar nebula magnetic field. The magnetic flux problem of star formation
is resolved for at least strongly magnetic newborn stars. A complete detachment
of the magnetic field from the matter is unlikely. The formation of a "magnetic
wall" (with an associated magnetic shock) is independent of the assumed
equation of state, although the process is enhanced and accelerated by the
formation of a central hydrostatic core.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0512043 [pdf] - 78243
Observational Constraints on the Ages of Molecular Clouds and the
Star-Formation Timescale: Ambipolar-Diffusion--Controlled or
Turbulence-Induced Star Formation?
Submitted: 2005-12-01
We revisit the problem of the star formation timescale and the ages of
molecular clouds. The apparent overabundance of star-forming molecular clouds
over clouds without active star formation has been thought to indicate that
molecular clouds are "short-lived" and that star formation is "rapid". We show
that this statistical argument lacks self-consistency and, even within the
rapid star-formation scenario, implies cloud lifetimes of approximately 10 Myr.
We discuss additional observational evidence from external galaxies that
indicate lifetimes of molecular clouds and a timescale of star formation of
approximately 10 Myr . These long cloud lifetimes in conjunction with the rapid
(approximately 1 Myr) decay of supersonic turbulence present severe
difficulties for the scenario of turbulence-controlled star formation. By
contrast, we show that all 31 existing observations of objects for which the
linewidth, the size, and the magnetic field strength have been reliably
measured are in excellent quantitative agreement with the predictions of the
ambipolar-diffusion theory. Within the ambipolar-diffusion-controlled star
formation theory the linewidths may be attributed to large-scale non-radial
cloud oscillations (essentially standing large-amplitude, long-wavelength
Alfven waves), and the predicted relation between the linewidth, the size, and
the magnetic field is a natural consequence of magnetic support of
self-gravitating clouds.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0409769 [pdf] - 67850
Magnetically Controlled Spasmodic Accretion During Star Formation. I.
Formulation of the Problem and Method of Solution
Submitted: 2004-09-30, last modified: 2004-10-27
We formulate the problem of the late accretion phase of the evolution of an
isothermal magnetic disk surrounding a forming star. The evolution is described
by the six-fluid MHD equations, accounting for the presence of neutrals, atomic
and molecular ions, electrons, and neutral, positively, and negatively charged
grains. Only the electron fluid is assumed to be attached to the magnetic
field, in order to investigate the effect of the detachment of the ions from
the magnetic field lines that begins at densities as low as 10^8 cm^-3. The
"central sink approximation" is used to circumvent the problem of describing
the evolution inside the opaque central region for densities greater than 10^11
cm^-3. In this way, the structure and evolution of the isothermal disk
surrounding the forming star can be studied at late times without having to
implement the numerically costly radiative transfer required by the physics of
the opaque core. The mass and magnetic flux accumulating in the forming star
arecalculated, as are their effects on the structure & evolution of the
surrounding disk. The numerical method of solution first uses an adaptive grid
and later, after a central region a few AU in radius becomes opaque, switches
to a stationary but nonuniform grid with a central sink cell. It also involves
an implicit time integrator, an advective difference scheme that possesses the
transportive property, a second-order difference approximation of forces inside
a cell, an integral approximation of the gravitational and magnetic fields, and
tensor artificial viscosity that permits an accurate investigation of the
formation and evolution of shocks in the neutral fluid.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0410002 [pdf] - 67852
Magnetically Controlled Spasmodic Accretion During Star Formation. II.
Results
Submitted: 2004-09-30
The problem of the late accretion phase of the evolution of an axisymmetric,
isothermal magnetic disk surrounding a forming star has been formulated in a
companion paper. The "central sink approximation" is used to circumvent the
problem of describing the evolution inside the opaque central region for
densities greater than 10^11 cm^-3 and radii smaller than a few AUs. Only the
electrons are assumed to be attached to the magnetic field lines, and the
effects of both negatively and positively charged grains are accounted for.
After a mass of 0.1 solar mass accumulates in the central cell (forming star),
a series of magnetically driven outflows and associated outward propagating
shocks form in a quasi-periodic fashion. As a result, mass accretion onto the
protostar occurs in magnetically controlled bursts. We refer to this process as
spasmodic accretion. The shocks propagate outward with supermagnetosonic
speeds. The period of dissipation and revival of the outflow decreases in time,
as the mass accumulated in the central sink increases. We evaluate the
contribution of ambipolar diffusion to the resolution of the magnetic flux
problem of star formation during the accretion phase, and we find it to be very
significant although not sufficient to resolve the entire problem yet. Ohmic
dissipation is completely negligible in the disk during this phase of the
evolution. The protostellar disk is found to be stable against interchange-like
instabilities, despite the fact that the mass-to-flux ratio has temporary local
maxima.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0409089 [pdf] - 67170
Ambipolar-Diffusion Timescale, Star-Formation Timescale, and the Ages of
Molecular Clouds: Is There a Discrepancy?
Submitted: 2004-09-03
We re-examine critically the estimates of the duration of different phases of
star formation and the lifetimes of molecular clouds, based on the ages of
T-Tauri stars, age spreads of stars in clusters, and statistics of pre-stellar
cores. We show that all available observational data are consistent with
lifetimes of molecular clouds comparable to 10 Myr, as well as with the
predictions of the theory of self-initiated, ambipolar-diffusion--controlled
star formation. We conclude that there exists no observational support for
either "young" molecular clouds or "rapid" star formation.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0404209 [pdf] - 64117
Multifluid, Magnetohydrodynamic Shock Waves with Grain Dynamics II. Dust
and the Critical Speed for C Shocks
Submitted: 2004-04-09
This is the second in a series of papers on the effects of dust on
multifluid, MHD shock waves in weakly ionized molecular gas. We investigate the
influence of dust on the critical shock speed, v_crit, above which C shocks
cease to exist. Chernoff showed that v_crit cannot exceed the grain
magnetosound speed, v_gms, if dust grains are dynamically well coupled to the
magnetic field. We present numerical simulations of steady shocks where the
grains may be well- or poorly coupled to the field. We use a time-dependent,
multifluid MHD code that models the plasma as a system of interacting fluids:
neutral particles, ions, electrons, and various ``dust fluids'' comprised of
grains with different sizes and charges. Our simulations include grain inertia
and grain charge fluctuations but to highlight the essential physics we assume
adiabatic flow, single-size grains, and neglect the effects of chemistry. We
show that the existence of a phase speed v_phi does not necessarily mean that C
shocks will form for all shock speeds v_s less than v_phi. When the grains are
weakly coupled to the field, steady, adiabatic shocks resemble shocks with no
dust: the transition to J type flow occurs at v_crit = 2.76 v_nA, where v_nA is
the neutral Alfven speed, and steady shocks with v_s > 2.76 v_nA are J shocks
with magnetic precursors in the ion-electron fluid. When the grains are
strongly coupled to the field, v_crit = min(2.76 v_nA, v_gms). Shocks with
v_crit < v_s < v_gms have magnetic precursors in the ion-electron-dust fluid.
Shocks with v_s > v_gms have no magnetic precursor in any fluid. We present
time-dependent calculations to study the formation of steady multifluid shocks.
The dynamics differ qualitatively depending on whether or not the grains and
field are well coupled.