In light of the recent discovery of ArH+ in the Crab nebula, it is shown through high-level quantum chemical comptuations that the global minima on the Ar+/Ne+ + H2 potential energy surfaces are ArH2+ and NeH2+. Hence, ArH2+ may be a necessary intermediate in the Ar+ + H2 -> ArH+ + H formation reaction proposed in the same work where ArH+ is first reported in the Crab nebula. ArH2+ is also probably an intermediate in the alternative Ar + H+2 -> ArH+ + H reaction. Additionally, it is shown that Ne+ + H2 -> NeH+2 will subsequently most likely yield Ne + H+2 and not NeH+ + H offering a possible rationale as to the absence of NeH+ in spectra obtained from the interstellar medium (ISM). Following from this, spectroscopic data (both rotational and vibrational) are provided for NeH2+ and ArH2+ through the use of highly-accurate quantum chemical quartic and cubic force fields. All possible isotopologues are also included for 20Ne, 22Ne, 36Ar, 38Ar, 40Ar, 1H, and D. The dipole moments for these systems are quite large at 5.61 D for NeH2+ and 4.37 D for ArH2+. The spectroscopic constants provided will aid in the potential detection of these open-shell noble gas dihydride cations in the ISM.