Normalized to: Moradi, H.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.01297 [pdf] - 1347749
3D simulations of realistic power halos in magneto-hydrostatic sunspot
atmospheres: linking theory and observation
Submitted: 2015-12-03
The well-observed acoustic halo is an enhancement in time-averaged Doppler
velocity and intensity power with respect to quiet-sun values which is
prominent for weak and highly inclined field around the penumbra of sunspots
and active regions. We perform 3D linear wave modelling with realistic
distributed acoustic sources in a MHS sunspot atmosphere and compare the
resultant simulation enhancements with multi-height SDO observations of the
phenomenon. We find that simulated halos are in good qualitative agreement with
observations. We also provide further proof that the underlying process
responsible for the halo is the refraction and return of fast magnetic waves
which have undergone mode conversion at the critical $a=c$ atmospheric layer.
In addition, we also find strong evidence that fast-Alfv\'en mode conversion
plays a significant role in the structure of the halo, taking energy away from
photospheric and chromospheric heights in the form of field-aligned Alfv\'en
waves. This conversion process may explain the observed "dual-ring" halo
structure at higher ($> 8 $ mHz) frequencies.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.04270 [pdf] - 1232030
Directional Time-Distance Probing of Model Sunspot Atmospheres
Submitted: 2015-03-14
A crucial feature not widely accounted for in local helioseismology is that
surface magnetic regions actually open a window from the interior into the
solar atmosphere, and that the seismic waves leak through this window, reflect
high in the atmosphere, and then re-enter the interior to rejoin the seismic
wave field normally confined there. In a series of recent numerical studies
using translation invariant atmospheres, we utilised a "directional
time-distance helioseismology" measurement scheme to study the implications of
the returning fast and Alfv\'en waves higher up in the solar atmosphere on the
seismology at the photosphere (Cally & Moradi 2013; Moradi & Cally 2014). In
this study, we extend our directional time-distance analysis to more realistic
sunspot-like atmospheres to better understand the direct effects of the
magnetic field on helioseismic travel-time measurements in sunspots. In line
with our previous findings, we uncover a distinct frequency-dependant
directional behaviour in the travel-time measurements, consistent with the
signatures of MHD mode conversion. We found this to be the case regardless of
the sunspot field strength or depth of its Wilson depression. We also isolated
and analysed the direct contribution from purely thermal perturbations to the
measured travel times, finding that waves propagating in the umbra are much
more sensitive to the underlying thermal effects of the sunspot.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1501.01074 [pdf] - 1223871
MHD wave refraction and the acoustic halo effect around solar active
regions - a 3D study
Submitted: 2015-01-05
An enhancement in high-frequency acoustic power is commonly observed in the
solar photosphere and chromosphere surrounding magnetic active regions. We
perform 3D linear forward wave modelling with a simple wavelet pulse acoustic
source to ascertain whether the formation of the acoustic halo is caused by MHD
mode conversion through regions of moderate and inclined magnetic fields. This
conversion type is most efficient when high frequency waves from below
intersect magnetic field lines at a large angle. We find a strong relationship
between halo formation and the equipartition surface at which the Alfv\'en
speed $a$ matches the sound speed $c$, lending support to the theory that
photospheric and chromospheric halo enhancement is due to the creation and
subsequent reflection of magnetically dominated fast waves from essentially
acoustic waves as they cross $a=c$. In simulations where we have capped $a$
such that waves are not permitted to refract after reaching the $a=c$ height,
halos are non-existent, which suggests that the power enhancement is wholly
dependent on returning fast waves. We also reproduce some of the observed halo
properties, such as a dual 6 and 8 mHz enhancement structure and a spatial
spreading of the halo with height.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.0696 [pdf] - 1179670
The PLATO 2.0 Mission
Rauer, H.;
Catala, C.;
Aerts, C.;
Appourchaux, T.;
Benz, W.;
Brandeker, A.;
Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.;
Deleuil, M.;
Gizon, L.;
Goupil, M. -J.;
Güdel, M.;
Janot-Pacheco, E.;
Mas-Hesse, M.;
Pagano, I.;
Piotto, G.;
Pollacco, D.;
Santos, N. C.;
Smith, A.;
-C., J.;
Suárez;
Szabó, R.;
Udry, S.;
Adibekyan, V.;
Alibert, Y.;
Almenara, J. -M.;
Amaro-Seoane, P.;
Eiff, M. Ammler-von;
Asplund, M.;
Antonello, E.;
Ball, W.;
Barnes, S.;
Baudin, F.;
Belkacem, K.;
Bergemann, M.;
Bihain, G.;
Birch, A. C.;
Bonfils, X.;
Boisse, I.;
Bonomo, A. S.;
Borsa, F.;
Brandão, I. M.;
Brocato, E.;
Brun, S.;
Burleigh, M.;
Burston, R.;
Cabrera, J.;
Cassisi, S.;
Chaplin, W.;
Charpinet, S.;
Chiappini, C.;
Church, R. P.;
Csizmadia, Sz.;
Cunha, M.;
Damasso, M.;
Davies, M. B.;
Deeg, H. J.;
DÍaz, R. F.;
Dreizler, S.;
Dreyer, C.;
Eggenberger, P.;
Ehrenreich, D.;
Eigmüller, P.;
Erikson, A.;
Farmer, R.;
Feltzing, S.;
Fialho, F. de Oliveira;
Figueira, P.;
Forveille, T.;
Fridlund, M.;
García, R. A.;
Giommi, P.;
Giuffrida, G.;
Godolt, M.;
da Silva, J. Gomes;
Granzer, T.;
Grenfell, J. L.;
Grotsch-Noels, A.;
Günther, E.;
Haswell, C. A.;
Hatzes, A. P.;
Hébrard, G.;
Hekker, S.;
Helled, R.;
Heng, K.;
Jenkins, J. M.;
Johansen, A.;
Khodachenko, M. L.;
Kislyakova, K. G.;
Kley, W.;
Kolb, U.;
Krivova, N.;
Kupka, F.;
Lammer, H.;
Lanza, A. F.;
Lebreton, Y.;
Magrin, D.;
Marcos-Arenal, P.;
Marrese, P. M.;
Marques, J. P.;
Martins, J.;
Mathis, S.;
Mathur, S.;
Messina, S.;
Miglio, A.;
Montalban, J.;
Montalto, M.;
Monteiro, M. J. P. F. G.;
Moradi, H.;
Moravveji, E.;
Mordasini, C.;
Morel, T.;
Mortier, A.;
Nascimbeni, V.;
Nelson, R. P.;
Nielsen, M. B.;
Noack, L.;
Norton, A. J.;
Ofir, A.;
Oshagh, M.;
Ouazzani, R. -M.;
Pápics, P.;
Parro, V. C.;
Petit, P.;
Plez, B.;
Poretti, E.;
Quirrenbach, A.;
Ragazzoni, R.;
Raimondo, G.;
Rainer, M.;
Reese, D. R.;
Redmer, R.;
Reffert, S.;
Rojas-Ayala, B.;
Roxburgh, I. W.;
Salmon, S.;
Santerne, A.;
Schneider, J.;
Schou, J.;
Schuh, S.;
Schunker, H.;
Silva-Valio, A.;
Silvotti, R.;
Skillen, I.;
Snellen, I.;
Sohl, F.;
Sousa, S. G.;
Sozzetti, A.;
Stello, D.;
Strassmeier, K. G.;
Švanda, M.;
Szabó, Gy. M.;
Tkachenko, A.;
Valencia, D.;
van Grootel, V.;
Vauclair, S. D.;
Ventura, P.;
Wagner, F. W.;
Walton, N. A.;
Weingrill, J.;
Werner, S. C.;
Wheatley, P. J.;
Zwintz, K.
Submitted: 2013-10-02, last modified: 2014-03-04
PLATO 2.0 has recently been selected for ESA's M3 launch opportunity
(2022/24). Providing accurate key planet parameters (radius, mass, density and
age) in statistical numbers, it addresses fundamental questions such as: How do
planetary systems form and evolve? Are there other systems with planets like
ours, including potentially habitable planets? The PLATO 2.0 instrument
consists of 34 small aperture telescopes (32 with 25 sec readout cadence and 2
with 2.5 sec candence) providing a wide field-of-view (2232 deg2) and a large
photometric magnitude range (4-16 mag). It focusses on bright (4-11 mag) stars
in wide fields to detect and characterize planets down to Earth-size by
photometric transits, whose masses can then be determined by ground-based
radial-velocity follow-up measurements. Asteroseismology will be performed for
these bright stars to obtain highly accurate stellar parameters, including
masses and ages. The combination of bright targets and asteroseismology results
in high accuracy for the bulk planet parameters: 2%, 4-10% and 10% for planet
radii, masses and ages, respectively. The planned baseline observing strategy
includes two long pointings (2-3 years) to detect and bulk characterize planets
reaching into the habitable zone (HZ) of solar-like stars and an additional
step-and-stare phase to cover in total about 50% of the sky. PLATO 2.0 will
observe up to 1,000,000 stars and detect and characterize hundreds of small
planets, and thousands of planets in the Neptune to gas giant regime out to the
HZ. It will therefore provide the first large-scale catalogue of bulk
characterized planets with accurate radii, masses, mean densities and ages.
This catalogue will include terrestrial planets at intermediate orbital
distances, where surface temperatures are moderate. Coverage of this parameter
range with statistical numbers of bulk characterized planets is unique to PLATO
2.0.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1401.5518 [pdf] - 1202918
Sensitivity of helioseismic travel-times to the imposition of a Lorentz
force limiter in computational helioseismology
Submitted: 2014-01-21
The rapid exponential increase in the Alfv\'en wave speed with height above
the solar surface presents a serious challenge to physical modelling of the
effects of magnetic fields on solar oscillations, as it introduces a
significant CFL time-step constraint for explicit numerical codes. A common
approach adopted in computational helioseismology, where long simulations in
excess of 10 hours (hundreds of wave periods) are often required, is to cap the
Alfv\'en wave speed by artificially modifying the momentum equation when the
ratio between Lorentz and hydrodynamic forces becomes too large. However,
recent studies have demonstrated that the Alfv\'en wave speed plays a critical
role in the MHD mode conversion process, particularly in determining the
reflection height of the upward propagating helioseismic fast wave. Using
numerical simulations of helioseismic wave propagation in constant inclined
(relative to the vertical) magnetic fields we demonstrate that the imposition
of such artificial limiters significantly affects time-distance travel times
unless the Alfv\'en wave-speed cap is chosen comfortably in excess of the
horizontal phase speeds under investigation.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1308.1184 [pdf] - 718382
Seismology of the Wounded Sun
Submitted: 2013-08-06
Active regions are open wounds in the Sun's surface. Seismic oscillations
from the interior pass through them into the atmosphere, changing their nature
in the process to fast and slow magneto-acoustic waves. The fast waves then
partially reflect and partially mode convert to upgoing and downgoing Alfv\'en
waves. The reflected fast and downgoing Alfv\'en waves then re-enter the
interior through the active regions that spawned them, infecting the surface
seismology with signatures of the atmosphere. Using numerical simulations of
waves in uniform magnetic fields, we calculate the upward acoustic and
Alfv\'enic losses in the atmosphere as functions of field inclination and wave
orientation as well as the Time-Distance `travel time' perturbations, and show
that they are related. Travel time perturbations relative to quiet Sun can
exceed 40 seconds in 1 kG magnetic field. It is concluded that active region
seismology is indeed significantly infected by waves leaving and re-entering
the interior through magnetic wounds, with differing travel times depending on
the orientation of the wave vector relative to the magnetic field. This
presages a new directional-time-distance seismology.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1302.6301 [pdf] - 1164850
Modelling Fast-Alfv\'en Mode Conversion Using SPARC
Submitted: 2013-02-25
We successfully utilise the SPARC code to model fast-Alfv\'en mode conversion
in the region $c_A \gg c_S$ via 3-D MHD numerical simulations of helioseismic
waves within constant inclined magnetic field configurations. This was achieved
only after empirically modifying the background density and gravitational
stratifications in the upper layers of our computational box, as opposed to
imposing a traditional Lorentz Force limiter, to ensure a manageable timestep.
We found that the latter approach inhibits the fast-Alfv\'en mode conversion
process by severely damping the magnetic flux above the surface.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1210.5293 [pdf] - 1152275
The Current State-Of-The-Art In Active Region Seismology
Submitted: 2012-10-18
Helioseismology is the study of the variations in the internal structure and
properties of the dynamics of the Sun from measurements of its surface
oscillations. With the 2010 launch of the Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) we
are undoubtedly approaching a new dawn for local helioseismology, as the extent
and quality of raw surface oscillation data has never been better. However,
advances in theory and modelling are still required to fully utilise these
data, especially in magnetic active regions and sunspots, where the physics is
poorly understood.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1105.0219 [pdf] - 1076339
Constructing and Characterising Solar Structure Models for Computational
Helioseismology
Submitted: 2011-05-01, last modified: 2011-06-06
In this paper, we construct background solar models that are stable against
convection, by modifying the vertical pressure gradient of Model S
(Christensen-Dalsgaard et al., 1996, Science, 272, 1286) relinquishing
hydrostatic equilibrium. However, the stabilisation affects the eigenmodes that
we wish to remain as close to Model S as possible. In a bid to recover the
Model S eigenmodes, we choose to make additional corrections to the sound speed
of Model S before stabilisation. No stabilised model can be perfectly
solar-like, so we present three stabilised models with slightly different
eigenmodes. The models are appropriate to study the f and p1 to p4 modes with
spherical harmonic degrees in the range from 400 to 900. Background model CSM
has a modified pressure gradient for stabilisation and has eigenfrequencies
within 2% of Model S. Model CSM_A has an additional 10% increase in sound speed
in the top 1 Mm resulting in eigenfrequencies within 2% of Model S and
eigenfunctions that are, in comparison with CSM, closest to those of Model S.
Model CSM_B has a 3% decrease in sound speed in the top 5 Mm resulting in
eigenfrequencies within 1% of Model S and eigenfunctions that are only
marginally adversely affected. These models are useful to study the interaction
of solar waves with embedded three-dimensional heterogeneities, such as
convective flows and model sunspots. We have also calculated the response of
the stabilised models to excitation by random near-surface sources, using
simulations of the propagation of linear waves. We find that the simulated
power spectra of wave motion are in good agreement with an observed SOHO/MDI
power spectrum. Overall, our convectively stabilised background models provide
a good basis for quantitative numerical local helioseismology. The models are
available for download from http://www.mps.mpg.de/projects/seismo/NA4/.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1101.0125 [pdf] - 285928
Deep-Focus Diagnostics of Sunspot Structure
Submitted: 2010-12-30
In sequel to Moradi et al. [2009, ApJ, 690, L72], we employ two established
numerical forward models (a 3D ideal MHD solver and MHD ray theory) in
conjunction with time-distance helioseismology to probe the lateral extent of
wave-speed perturbations produced in regions of strong, near-surface magnetic
fields. We continue our comparisons of forward modeling approaches by extending
our previous surface-focused travel-time measurements with a common midpoint
deep-focusing scheme that avoids the use of oscillation signals within the
sunspot region. The idea is to also test MHD ray theory for possible
application in future inverse methods.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.4982 [pdf] - 1018908
Modeling the Subsurface Structure of Sunspots
Moradi, H.;
Baldner, C.;
Birch, A. C.;
Braun, D.;
Cameron, R.;
Duvall, T. L.;
Gizon, L.;
Haber, D.;
Hanasoge, S.;
Hindman, B. W.;
Jackiewicz, J.;
Khomenko, E.;
Komm, R.;
Rajaguru, P.;
Rempel, M.;
Roth, M.;
Schlichenmaier, R.;
Schunker, H.;
Spruit, H.;
Strassmeier, K.;
Thompson, M. J.;
Zharkov, S.
Submitted: 2009-12-25, last modified: 2010-08-23
While sunspots are easily observed at the solar surface, determining their
subsurface structure is not trivial. There are two main hypotheses for the
subsurface structure of sunspots: the monolithic model and the cluster model.
Local helioseismology is the only means by which we can investigate
subphotospheric structure. However, as current linear inversion techniques do
not yet allow helioseismology to probe the internal structure with sufficient
confidence to distinguish between the monolith and cluster models, the
development of physically realistic sunspot models are a priority for
helioseismologists. This is because they are not only important indicators of
the variety of physical effects that may influence helioseismic inferences in
active regions, but they also enable detailed assessments of the validity of
helioseismic interpretations through numerical forward modeling. In this paper,
we provide a critical review of the existing sunspot models and an overview of
numerical methods employed to model wave propagation through model sunspots. We
then carry out an helioseismic analysis of the sunspot in Active Region 9787
and address the serious inconsistencies uncovered by
\citeauthor{gizonetal2009}~(\citeyear{gizonetal2009,gizonetal2009a}). We find
that this sunspot is most probably associated with a shallow, positive
wave-speed perturbation (unlike the traditional two-layer model) and that
travel-time measurements are consistent with a horizontal outflow in the
surrounding moat.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1004.4312 [pdf] - 160838
German Science Center for the Solar Dynamics Observatory
Submitted: 2010-04-24, last modified: 2010-05-06
A data and computation center for helioseismology has been set up at the Max
Planck Institute for Solar System Research in Germany to prepare for the SDO
mission. Here we present the system infrastructure and the scientific aims of
this project, which is funded through grants from the German Aerospace Center
and the European Research Council.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:0808.3628 [pdf] - 15703
Numerical Models of Travel-Time Inhomogeneities in Sunspots
Submitted: 2008-08-27, last modified: 2008-11-09
We investigate the direct contribution of strong, sunspot-like magnetic
fields to helioseismic wave travel-time shifts via two numerical forward
models, a 3D ideal MHD solver and MHD ray theory. The simulated data cubes are
analyzed using the traditional time-distance center-to-annulus measurement
technique. We also isolate and analyze the direct contribution from purely
thermal perturbations to the observed travel-time shifts, confirming some
existing ideas and bring forth new ones: (i) that the observed travel-time
shifts in the vicinity of sunspots are largely governed by MHD physics, (ii)
the travel-time shifts are sensitively dependent on frequency and phase-speed
filter parameters and the background power below the $p_1$ ridge, and finally,
(iii) despite its seeming limitations, ray theory succeeds in capturing the
essence of the travel-time variations as derived from the MHD simulations.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:0807.3783 [pdf] - 14807
Helioseismic analysis of the solar flare-induced sunquake of 2005
January 15. II: A magneto-seismic study
Submitted: 2008-07-23
On 2005 January 15, the active region AR10720 produced an X1.2 solar flare
that induced high levels of seismicity into the photospheric layers. The
seismic source was detected using helioseismic holography and analysed in
detail in Paper I. Egression power maps at 6 mHz with a 2 mHz bandwidth
revealed a compact acoustic source strongly correlated with the footpoints of
the coronal loop that hosted the flare. We present a magneto-seismic study of
this active region in order to understand, for the first time, the magnetic
topological structure of a coronal field that hosts an acoustically active
solar flare. The accompanying analysis attempts to answer questions such as:
Can the magnetic field act as a barrier and prevent seismic waves from
spreading away from the focus of the sunquake? And, what is the most efficient
magnetic structure that would facilitate the development of a strong seismic
source in the photosphere?
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:0804.2716 [pdf] - 11839
Time-Distance Modelling In A Simulated Sunspot Atmosphere
Submitted: 2008-04-16
One of the main uncertainties associated with time-distance measurements is
how to interpret observations made in regions of strong magnetic field as
isolating the effects of the magnetic field from thermal or sound-speed
perturbations has proved to be quite complex. One possible way to decouple
these effects is by using a 3D sunspot model, with a surrounding stratified,
quiet-Sun atmosphere to model the magneto-acoustic ray propagation, and analyze
the resulting ray travel-time perturbations that will directly account for the
magnetic field. These artificial travel-time perturbation profiles have
provided us with several related but distinct observations: i) that strong
surface magnetic fields have a dual effect on helioseismic rays -- increasing
their skip distance while at the same time speeding them up considerably
compared to their quiet-Sun counterparts, ii) there is a clear and significant
frequency dependence of both skip-distance and travel-time perturbations across
the simulated sunspot radius, iii) the negative sign and magnitude of these
perturbations appears to be directly related to the sunspot magnetic-field
strength and inclination, iv) by ``switching off'' the magnetic field inside
the sunspot, we are able to completely isolate the thermal component of the
travel-time perturbations observed, which is seen to be both opposite in sign
and much smaller in magnitude than those measured when the magnetic field is
present. These results tend to suggest that purely thermal perturbations are
unlikely to be the main effect seen in travel times through sunspots and that
strong, near-surface magnetic fields may be directly and significantly altering
the magnitude and lateral extent of sound-speed inversions of sunspots made by
time-distance helioseismology.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:0801.0898 [pdf] - 8684
Seismic Emissions from a Highly Impulsive M6.7 Solar Flare
Submitted: 2008-01-06, last modified: 2008-01-09
On 10 March 2001 the active region NOAA 9368 produced an unusually impulsive
solar flare in close proximity to the solar limb. This flare has previously
been studied in great detail, with observations classifying it as a type 1
white-light flare with a very hard spectrum in hard X-rays. The flare was also
associated with a type II radio burst and coronal mass ejection. The flare
emission characteristics appeared to closely correspond with previous instances
of seismic emission from acoustically active flares. Using standard local
helioseismic methods, we identified the seismic signatures produced by the
flare that, to date, is the least energetic (in soft X-rays) of the flares
known to have generated a detectable acoustic transient. Holographic analysis
of the flare shows a compact acoustic source strongly correlated with the
impulsive hard X-ray, visible continuum, and radio emission. Time-distance
diagrams of the seismic waves emanating from the flare region also show faint
signatures, mainly in the eastern sector of the active region. The strong
spatial coincidence between the seismic source and the impulsive visible
continuum emission reinforces the theory that a substantial component of the
seismic emission seen is a result of sudden heating of the low photosphere
associated with the observed visible continuum emission. Furthermore, the
low-altitude magnetic loop structure inferred from potential--field
extrapolations in the flaring region suggests that there is a significant
inverse correlation between the seismicity of a flare and the height of the
magnetic loops that conduct the particle beams from the corona.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:0707.2019 [pdf] - 3062
From GHz to mHz: A Multiwavelength Study of the Acoustically Active 14
August 2004 M7.4 Solar Flare
Submitted: 2007-07-13
We carried out an electromagnetic acoustic analysis of the solar flare of 14
August 2004 in active region AR10656 from the radio to the hard X-ray spectrum.
The flare was a GOES soft X-ray class M7.4 and produced a detectable sun quake,
confirming earlier inferences that relatively low-energy flares may be able to
generate sun quakes. We introduce the hypothesis that the seismicity of the
active region is closely related to the heights of coronal magnetic loops that
conduct high-energy particles from the flare. In the case of relatively short
magnetic loops, chromospheric evaporation populates the loop interior with
ionized gas relatively rapidly, expediting the scattering of remaining trapped
high-energy electrons into the magnetic loss cone and their rapid precipitation
into the chromosphere. This increases both the intensity and suddenness of the
chromospheric heating, satisfying the basic conditions for an acoustic emission
that penetrates into the solar interior.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:0704.3472 [pdf] - 774
Helioseismic analysis of the solar flare-induced sunquake of 2005
January 15
Submitted: 2007-04-26
We report the discovery of one of the most powerful sunquakes detected to
date, produced by an X1.2-class solar flare in active region 10720 on 2005
January 15. We used helioseismic holography to image the source of seismic
waves emitted into the solar interior from the site of the flare. Acoustic
egression power maps at 3 and 6 mHz with a 2 mHz bandpass reveal a compact
acoustic source strongly correlated with impulsive hard X-ray and
visible-continuum emission along the penumbral neutral line separating the two
major opposing umbrae in the $\delta$-configuration sunspot that predominates
AR10720. The acoustic emission signatures were directly aligned with both hard
X-ray and visible continuum emission that emanated during the flare. The
visible continuum emission is estimated at $2.0 \times 10^{23}$ J,
approximately 500 times the seismic emission of $\sim 4 \times 10^{20}$ J. The
flare of 2005 January 15 exhibits the same close spatial alignment between the
sources of the seismic emission and impulsive visible continuum emission as
previous flares, reinforcing the hypothesis that the acoustic emission may be
driven by heating of the low photosphere. However, it is a major exception in
that there was no signature to indicate the inclusion of protons in the
particle beams thought to supply the energy radiated by the flare. The
continued strong coincidence between the sources of seismic emission and
impulsive visible continuum emission in the case of a proton-deficient
white-light flare lends substantial support to the ``back -- warming''
hypothesis, that the low photosphere is significantly heated by intense Balmer
and Paschen continuum-edge radiation from the overlying chromosphere in
white-light flares.