Normalized to: Milbourne, T.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2005.13386 [pdf] - 2103017
Unsigned magnetic flux as a proxy for radial-velocity variations in
Sun-like stars
Haywood, R. D.;
Milbourne, T. W.;
Saar, S. H.;
Mortier, A.;
Phillips, D.;
Charbonneau, D.;
Cameron, A. Collier;
Cegla, H. M.;
Meunier, N.;
Palumbo, M. L.
Submitted: 2020-05-27
We estimate disc-averaged RV variations of the Sun over the last magnetic
cycle, from the single Fe I line observed by SDO/HMI, using a physical model
for rotationally modulated magnetic activity that was previously validated
against HARPS-N solar observations. We estimate the disc-averaged, unsigned
magnetic flux and show that a simple linear fit to it reduces the RMS of RV
variations by 62%, i.e. a factor of 2.6. We additionally apply the FF' method,
which predicts RV variations based on a star's photometric variations. At cycle
maximum, we find that additional physical processes must be at play beyond
suppression of convective blueshift and velocity imablances resulting from
brightness inhomogeneities, in agreement with recent studies of solar RV
variations. By modelling RV variations over the magnetic cycle using a linear
fit to the unsigned magnetic flux, we recover injected planets at an orbital
period of about 300 days with RV semi-amplitudes down to 0.3 m/s. To reach
semi-amplitudes of 0.1 m/s, we will need to identify and model additional
physical phenomena that are not well traced by the unsigned magnetic flux or
FF'. The unsigned magnetic flux is an excellent proxy for rotationally
modulated, activity-induced RV variations, and could become a key tool in
confirming and characterising Earth analogs orbiting Sun-like stars. The
present study motivates ongoing and future efforts to develop observation and
analysis techniques to measure the unsigned magnetic flux at high precision in
slowly rotating, relatively inactive stars like the Sun.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.09830 [pdf] - 2089239
The spectral impact of magnetic activity on disk-integrated HARPS-N
solar observations: exploring new activity indicators
Thompson, A. P. G.;
Watson, C. A.;
Haywood, R. D.;
Costes, J. C.;
de Mooij, E.;
Cameron, A. Collier;
Dumusque, X.;
Phillips, D. F.;
Saar, S. H.;
Mortier, A.;
Milbourne, T. W.;
Aigrain, S.;
Cegla, H. M.;
Charbonneau, D.;
Cosentino, R.;
Ghedina, A.;
Latham, D. W.;
López-Morales, M.;
Micela, G.;
Molinari, E.;
Poretti, E.;
Sozzetti, A.;
Thompson, S.;
Walsworth, R.
Submitted: 2020-04-21
Stellar activity is the major roadblock on the path to finding true
Earth-analogue planets with the Doppler technique. Thus, identifying new
indicators that better trace magnetic activity (i.e. faculae and spots) is
crucial to aid in disentangling these signals from that of a planet's Doppler
wobble. In this work, we investigate activity related features as seen in
disk-integrated spectra from the HARPS-N solar telescope. We divide
high-activity spectral echelle orders by low-activity master templates (as
defined using both log R'HK and images from the Solar Dynamics Observatory,
SDO), creating "relative spectra". With resolved images of the surface of the
Sun (via SDO), the faculae and spot filling factors can be calculated, giving a
measure of activity independent of, and in addition to, log R'HK. We find
pseudo-emission (and pseudo-absorption) features in the relative spectra that
are similar to those reported in our previous work on alpha Cen B. In alpha Cen
B, the features are shown to correlate better to changes in faculae filling
factor than spot filling factor. In this work we more confidently identify
changes in faculae coverage of the visible hemisphere of the Sun as the source
of features produced in the relative spectra. Finally, we produce trailed
spectra to observe the RV component of the features, which show that the
features move in a redward direction as one would expect when tracking active
regions rotating on the surface of a star.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.09038 [pdf] - 2032852
Testing the Spectroscopic Extraction of Suppression of Convective
Blueshift
Miklos, M.;
Milbourne, T. W.;
Haywood, R. D.;
Phillips, D. F.;
Saar, S. H.;
Meunier, N.;
Cegla, H. M.;
Dumusque, X.;
Langellier, N.;
Maldonado, J.;
Malavolta, L.;
Mortier, A.;
Thompson, S.;
Watson, C. A.;
Cecconi, M.;
Cosentino, R.;
Ghedina, A.;
Li, C-H.;
López-Morales, M.;
Molinari, E.;
Poretti, E.;
Sasselov, D.;
Sozzetti, A.;
Walsworth, R. L.
Submitted: 2019-10-20, last modified: 2020-01-15
Efforts to detect low-mass exoplanets using stellar radial velocities (RVs)
are currently limited by magnetic photospheric activity. Suppression of
convective blueshift is the dominant magnetic contribution to RV variability in
low-activity Sun-like stars. Due to convective plasma motions, the magnitude of
RV contributions from the suppression of convective blueshift is related to the
depth of formation of photospheric spectral lines of a given species used to
compute the RV time series. Meunier et al. (2017), used this relation to
demonstrate a method for spectroscopic extraction of the suppression of
convective blueshift in order to isolate RV contributions, including planetary
RVs, that contribute equally to the timeseries for each spectral line. Here, we
extract disk-integrated solar RVs from observations over a 2.5 year time span
made with the solar telescope integrated with the HARPS-N spectrograph at the
Telescopio Nazionale Galileo (La Palma, Canary Islands, Spain). We apply the
methods outlined by Meunier et al. (2017). We are not, however, able to isolate
physically meaningful contributions of the suppression of convective blueshift
from this solar dataset, potentially because our dataset is from solar minimum
when the suppression of convective blueshift may not sufficiently dominate
activity contributions to RVs. This result indicates that, for low-activity
Sun-like stars, one must include additional RV contributions from activity
sources not considered in the Meunier et al. (2017) model at different
timescales as well as instrumental variation in order to reach the sub-meter
per second RV sensitivity necessary to detect low-mass planets in orbit around
Sun-like stars.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.02217 [pdf] - 2042365
An ultra-short period rocky super-Earth orbiting the G2-star HD 80653
Frustagli, G.;
Poretti, E.;
Milbourne, T.;
Malavolta, L.;
Mortier, A.;
Singh, Vikash;
Bonomo, A. S.;
Buchhave, L. A.;
Zeng, L.;
Vanderburg, A.;
Udry, S.;
Andreuzzi, G.;
Collier-Cameron, A.;
Cosentino, R.;
Damasso, M.;
Ghedina, A.;
Harutyunyan, A.;
Haywood, R. D.;
Latham, D. W.;
López-Morales, M.;
Lorenzi, V.;
Fiorenzano, A. F. Martinez;
Mayor, M.;
Micela, G.;
Molinari, E.;
Pepe, F.;
Phillips, D.;
Rice, K.;
Sozzetti, A.
Submitted: 2020-01-07
Ultra-short period (USP) planets are a class of exoplanets with periods
shorter than one day. The origin of this sub-population of planets is still
unclear, with different formation scenarios highly dependent on the composition
of the USP planets. A better understanding of this class of exoplanets will,
therefore, require an increase in the sample of such planets that have accurate
and precise masses and radii, which also includes estimates of the level of
irradiation and information about possible companions. Here we report a
detailed characterization of a USP planet around the solar-type star HD 80653
$\equiv$ EP 251279430 using the K2 light curve and 108 precise radial
velocities obtained with the HARPS-N spectrograph, installed on the Telescopio
Nazionale Galileo. From the K2 C16 data, we found one super-Earth planet
($R_{b}=1.613\pm0.071 R_{\oplus}$) transiting the star on a short-period orbit
($P_{\rm b}=0.719573\pm0.000021$ d). From our radial velocity measurements, we
constrained the mass of HD 80653 b to $M_{b}=5.60\pm0.43 M_{\oplus}$. We also
detected a clear long-term trend in the radial velocity data. We derived the
fundamental stellar parameters and determined a radius of
$R_{\star}=1.22\pm0.01 R_{\odot}$ and mass of $M_{\star}=1.18\pm0.04
M_{\odot}$, suggesting that HD 80653, has an age of $2.7\pm1.2$ Gyr. The bulk
density ($\rho_{b} = 7.4 \pm 1.1$ g cm$^{-3}$) of the planet is consistent with
an Earth-like composition of rock and iron with no thick atmosphere. Our
analysis of the K2 photometry also suggests hints of a shallow secondary
eclipse with a depth of 8.1$\pm$3.7 ppm. Flux variations along the orbital
phase are consistent with zero. The most important contribution might come from
the day-side thermal emission from the surface of the planet at $T\sim3480$ K.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.08755 [pdf] - 1967001
Sensitivity of low-degree solar p modes to active and ephemeral regions:
frequency shifts back to the Maunder Minimum
Chaplin, William J.;
Howe, Rachel;
Basu, Sarbani;
Elsworth, Yvonne;
Milbourne, Timothy W.;
Haywood, Raphaëlle D.;
Davies, Guy R.;
Hale, Steven J.;
Miglio, Andrea;
Ross, Eddie
Submitted: 2019-08-23
We explore the sensitivity of the frequencies of low-degree solar p-modes to
near-surface magnetic flux on different spatial scales and strengths,
specifically to active regions with strong magnetic fields and ephemeral
regions with weak magnetic fields. We also use model reconstructions from the
literature to calculate average frequency offsets back to the end of the
Maunder minimum. We find that the p-mode frequencies are at least three times
less sensitive (at 95% confidence) to the ephemeral-region field than they are
to the active-region field. Frequency shifts between activity cycle minima and
maxima are controlled predominantly by the change of active region flux.
Frequency shifts at cycle minima (with respect to a magnetically quiet Sun) are
determined largely by the ephemeral flux, and are estimated to have been
$0.1\,\rm \mu Hz$ or less over the last few minima. We conclude that at epochs
of cycle minimum, frequency shifts due to near-surface magnetic activity are
negligible compared to the offsets between observed and model frequencies that
arise from inaccurate modelling of the near-surface layers (the so-called
surface term). The implication is that this will be the case for other Sun-like
stars with similar activity, which has implications for asteroseismic modelling
of stars.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.03002 [pdf] - 1912913
Temporal evolution and correlations of optical activity indicators
measured in Sun-as-a-star observations
Maldonado, J.;
Phillips, D. F.;
Dumusque, X.;
Cameron, A. Collier;
Haywood, R. D.;
Lanza, A. F.;
Micela, G.;
Mortier, A.;
Saar, S. H.;
Sozzetti, A.;
Rice, K.;
Milbourne, T.;
Cecconi, M.;
Cegla, H. M.;
Cosentino, R.;
Costes, J.;
Ghedina, A.;
Gonzalez, M.;
Guerra, J.;
Hernández, N.;
Li, C. -H.;
Lodi, M.;
Malavolta, L.;
Molinari, E.;
Pepe, F.;
Piotto, G.;
Poretti, E.;
Sasselov, D.;
Juan, J. San;
Thompson, S.;
Udry, S.;
Watson, C.
Submitted: 2019-06-07
(Abridged) We perform a detailed study of the main optical activity
indicators (Ca II H & K, Balmer lines, Na I D$_{\rm 1}$ D$_{\rm 2}$, and He I
D$_{\rm 3}$) measured for the Sun using the data provided by the HARPS-N
solar-telescope feed at the Telescopio Nazionale Galileo. The value of the
solar rotation period is found in all the activity indicators, with the only
exception being H$\delta$. The derived values vary from 26.29 days (H$\gamma$
line) to 31.23 days (He I). From an analysis of sliding periodograms we find
that in most of the activity indicators the spectral power is split into
several "bands" of periods around 26 and 30 days, that might be explained by
the migration of active regions between the equator and a latitude of $\sim$
30$^{\circ}$, spot evolution or a combination of both effects. In agreement
with previous works a typical lifetime of active regions of $\sim$ ten rotation
periods is inferred from the pooled variance diagrams. We find that H$\alpha$,
H$\beta$, H$\gamma$, H$\epsilon$, and He I show a significant correlation with
the S index. Significant correlations between the contrast, bisector span, and
the heliocentric radial velocity with the activity indexes are also found. We
show that the full width at half maximum, the bisector, and the disc-integrated
magnetic field correlate with the radial velocity variations. The correlation
of the S index and H$\alpha$ changes with time, increasing with larger sun spot
numbers and solar irradiance. A similar tendency with the S index - radial
velocity correlation is also present in the data. Our results are consistent
with a scenario in which higher activity favours the correlation between the S
index and the H$\alpha$ activity indicators and between the S index and radial
velocity variations.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.12186 [pdf] - 1894339
Three years of Sun-as-a-star radial-velocity observations on the
approach to solar minimum
Cameron, A. Collier;
Mortier, A.;
Phillips, D.;
Dumusque, X.;
Haywood, R. D.;
Langellier, N.;
Watson, C. A.;
Cegla, H. M.;
Costes, J.;
Charbonneau, D.;
Coffinet, A.;
Latham, D. W.;
Lopez-Morales, M.;
Malavolta, L.;
Maldonado, J.;
Micela, G.;
Milbourne, T.;
Molinari, E.;
Saar, S. H.;
Thompson, S.;
Buchschacher, N.;
Cecconi, M.;
Cosentino, R.;
Ghedina, A.;
Glenday, A.;
Li, M. Gonzalez C. -H.;
Lodi, M.;
Lovis, C.;
Pepe, F.;
Poretti, E.;
Rice, K.;
Sasselov, D.;
Sozzetti, A.;
Szentgyorgyi, A.;
Udry, S.;
Walsworth, R.
Submitted: 2019-04-27
The time-variable velocity fields of solar-type stars limit the precision of
radial-velocity determinations of their planets' masses, obstructing detection
of Earth twins. Since 2015 July we have been monitoring disc-integrated
sunlight in daytime using a purpose-built solar telescope and fibre feed to the
HARPS-N stellar radial-velocity spectrometer. We present and analyse the solar
radial-velocity measurements and cross-correlation function (CCF) parameters
obtained in the first 3 years of observation, interpreting them in the context
of spatially-resolved solar observations. We describe a Bayesian mixture-model
approach to automated data-quality monitoring. We provide dynamical and daily
differential-extinction corrections to place the radial velocities in the
heliocentric reference frame, and the CCF shape parameters in the sidereal
frame. We achieve a photon-noise limited radial-velocity precision better than
0.43 m s$^{-1}$ per 5-minute observation. The day-to-day precision is limited
by zero-point calibration uncertainty with an RMS scatter of about 0.4 m
s$^{-1}$. We find significant signals from granulation and solar activity.
Within a day, granulation noise dominates, with an amplitude of about 0.4 m
s$^{-1}$ and an autocorrelation half-life of 15 minutes. On longer timescales,
activity dominates. Sunspot groups broaden the CCF as they cross the solar
disc. Facular regions temporarily reduce the intrinsic asymmetry of the CCF.
The radial-velocity increase that accompanies an active-region passage has a
typical amplitude of 5 m s$^{-1}$ and is correlated with the line asymmetry,
but leads it by 3 days. Spectral line-shape variability thus shows promise as a
proxy for recovering the true radial velocity.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.04184 [pdf] - 1860009
HARPS-N Solar Radial-Velocity Variations Are Dominated By Large, Bright
Magnetic Regions
Milbourne, T. W.;
Haywood, R. D.;
Phillips, D. F.;
Saar, S. H.;
Cegla, H. M.;
Cameron, A. C.;
Costes, J.;
Dumusque, X.;
Langellier, N.;
Latham, D. W.;
Maldonado, J.;
Malavolta, L.;
Mortier, A.;
Palumbo, M. L.;
Thompson, S.;
Watson, C. A.;
Bouchy, F.;
Buchschacher, N.;
Cecconi, M.;
Charbonneau, D.;
Cosentino, R.;
Ghedina, A.;
Glenday, A. G.;
Gonzalez, M.;
Li, C-H.;
Lodi, M.;
López-Morales, M.;
Lovis, C.;
Mayor, M.;
Micela, G.;
Molinari, E.;
Pepe, F.;
Piotto, G.;
Rice, K.;
Sasselov, D.;
Ségransan, D.;
Sozzetti, A.;
Szentgyorgyi, A.;
Udry, S.;
Walsworth, R. L.
Submitted: 2019-02-11
State of the art radial-velocity (RV) exoplanet searches are currently
limited by RV signals arising from stellar magnetic activity. We analyze solar
observations acquired over a 3-year period during the decline of Carrington
Cycle 24 to test models of RV variation of Sun-like stars. A purpose-built
solar telescope at the High Accuracy Radial velocity Planet Searcher for the
Northern hemisphere (HARPS-N) provides disk-integrated solar spectra, from
which we extract RVs and $\log{R'_{\rm HK}}$. The Solar Dynamics Observatory
(SDO) provides disk-resolved images of magnetic activity. The Solar Radiation
and Climate Experiment (SORCE) provides near-continuous solar photometry,
analogous to a Kepler light curve. We verify that the SORCE photometry and
HARPS-N $\log{R'_{\rm HK}}$ correlate strongly with the SDO-derived magnetic
filling factor, while the HARPS-N RV variations do not. To explain this
discrepancy, we test existing models of RV variations. We estimate the
contributions of the suppression of convective blueshift and the rotational
imbalance due to brightness inhomogeneities to the observed HARPS-N RVs. We
investigate the time variation of these contributions over several rotation
periods, and how these contributions depend on the area of active regions. We
find that magnetic active regions smaller than $60 \ \rm Mm^2$ do not
significantly suppress convective blueshift. Our area-dependent model reduces
the amplitude of activity-induced RV variations by a factor of two. The present
study highlights the need to identify a proxy that correlates specifically with
large, bright magnetic regions on the surfaces of exoplanet-hosting stars.