Normalized to: Maron, N.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:0712.3796 [pdf] - 8424
Criteria for mixing rules application for inhomogeneous astrophysical
grains
Submitted: 2007-12-21, last modified: 2008-09-06
The analysis presented in this paper verifies which of the mixing rules are
best for real components of interstellar dust in possible wide range of
wavelengths.The DDA method with elements of different components with various
volume fractions has been used. We have considered 6 materials: ice, amorphous
carbon, graphite, SiC, silicates and iron, and the following mixing rules:
Maxwell-Garnett, Bruggeman, Looyenga, Hanay and Lichtenecker which must satisfy
rigorous bounds. The porous materials have also been considered. We have
assumed simplified spatial distribution, shape and size of inclusions. The
criteria given by \citet{draine1988} have been used to determine the range of
wavelengths for the considered mixtures in order to calculate the ${\rm
Q_{ext}}$ using the DDA. From all chosen mixing rules for the examined
materials in majority of cases (13 out of 20) the best results have been
obtained using the Lichtenecker mixing rule. In 5 cases this rule is better for
some volume fraction of inclusions.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0402249 [pdf] - 62763
On the mixing rules for interstellar inhomogeneous grains
Submitted: 2004-02-11, last modified: 2004-10-28
We present the computation of effective refractive coefficients for
inhomogeneous two-component grains with 3 kinds of inclusions with ${\rm
m_{incl}=3.0+4.0i, 2.0+1.0i, 2.5+0.0001i}$ and a matrix with ${\rm
m_m=1.33+0.01i}$ for 11 volume fractions of inclusions from 0% to 50% and
wavelengths ${\rm\lambda}$=0.5, 1.0, 2.0 and 5.0 ${\rm \mu m}$. The
coefficients of extinction for these grains have been computed using a discrete
dipole approximation (DDA). Computation of the extinction by the same method
for grains composed of a matrix material with randomly embedded inclusions has
been carried out for different volume fractions of inclusions. A comparison of
extinction coefficients obtained for both models of grain materials allows to
choose the best mixing rule for a mixture. In cases of inclusions with ${\rm
m_{incl}}$=2.0+1.0i and 2.5+0.0001i the best fit for the whole wavelengths
range and volume fractions of inclusions from 0 to 50% has been obtained for
Lichtenecker mixing rule. In case of ${\rm m_{incl}=3.0+4.0i}$ the fit for the
whole wavelength range and volume fractions of inclusions from 0 to 50% is not
very significant but the best has been obtained for Hanai rule. For volume
fractions of inclusion from 0 to 15% a very good fit has been obtained for the
whole wavelength range for Rayleigh and Maxwell-Garnett mixing rules.