sort results by

Use logical operators AND, OR, NOT and round brackets to construct complex queries. Whitespace-separated words are treated as ANDed.

Show articles per page in mode

Lyubimkov, Leonid S.

Normalized to: Lyubimkov, L.

15 article(s) in total. 9 co-authors, from 1 to 8 common article(s). Median position in authors list is 1,0.

[1]  oai:arXiv.org:1909.01054  [pdf] - 1953886
Three nearby K-giants with planets: Accurate determination of basic parameters, including an analysis of metallicity based on Fe I lines
Comments: 22 pages, 6 figures, 6 tables
Submitted: 2019-09-03
Fundamental parameters are determined for three bright, nearby K-giants, {\beta} Gem (K0 III), {\mu} Leo (K2 III), and {\alpha} Tau (K5 III). It is notable that around all three stars the giant planets have been found. Our results are compared with published high-precision data for benchmark stars included in the Gaia project. Very good agreement was obtained for all three giants with these data for the basic parameters Teff, logg, and M. Special attention was devoted to analysis of the Fe I lines which are the basis of a simultaneous determination of the metallicity index [Fe/H] and microturbulent parameter Vt. The equivalent widths W of the Fe I lines are automatically measured from published spectra for the benchmark stars. An analysis of Fe I lines from the list of "golden lines" selected in a study of benchmark stars led to the conclusion that the excitation potential El of the low level of the lines plays an substantial role in determining [Fe/H] and Vt. It is shown that in the case of the early K-giants {\beta} Gem and {\mu} Leo for lines in the range of W from 100 to 300 m{\AA} there is a dependence of the [Fe/H] and Vt values on El. It is shown that a correct accounting for it leads an ambiguity in the determination of [Fe/H] and Vt for {\beta} Gem and {\mu} Leo. In the case of the coolest K-giant {\alpha} Tau (Aldebaran) with a temperature Teff = 3920K, this effect seems to be less pronounced. Recommendations are given for the Fe I lines selection for [Fe/H] and Vt determination. It is sonfirmed for the example of the three stars studied here that the non-LTE effects in the Fe I lines for the K-giants with normal metallicity are very minor, so they cannot be the reason of the revealed ambiguity in [Fe/H] and Vt values. The low ratios of the carbon 12C/13C and oxygen 16O/17O isotopes confirm that all three giants passed the phase of deep convective mixing.
[2]  oai:arXiv.org:1907.04634  [pdf] - 1966848
Oxygen abundance and the N/C vs N/O relation for AFG supergiants and bright giants
Comments:
Submitted: 2019-07-10, last modified: 2019-08-07
Non-LTE analysis (LTE is local thermodynamic equilibrium) of the oxygen abundances for 51 Galactic A-, F- and G-type supergiants and bright giants is performed. In contrast with carbon and nitrogen, oxygen does not show any significant systematic anomalies in their abundances log E(O). There is no marked difference from the initial oxygen abundance within errors of the log E(O) determination across the Teff interval from 4500 to 8500 K and the log g interval from 1.2 to 2.9 dex. This result agrees well with theoretical predictions for stellar models with rotation. With our new data for oxygen and our earlier non-LTE determinations of the N and C abundances for stars from the same sample, we constructed the [N/C] vs [N/O] relation for 17 stars. This relation is known to be a sensitive indicator of stellar evolution. A pronounced correlation between [N/C] vs [N/O] is found; the observed [N/C] increase from 0 to 1.6 dex is accompanied by the [N/O] increase from 0 to 0.9 dex. When comparing the observed [N/C] vs [N/O] relation with the theoretical one, we show that this relation reflects a strong dependence of the evolutionary changes in CNO abundances on the initial rotation velocities of stars. Given that the initial rotational velocities of these stars are expected to satisfy V0<150 km/s, it is found that they are mostly the post first dredge-up (post-FDU) objects. It is important that just such initial velocities V0 are typical for about 80% of stars in question (i.e. for stars with masses 4-19 M_sun). A constancy of the total C+N+O abundance during stellar evolution is confirmed. The mean value log E(C+N+O)=8.97+/-0.08 found for AFG supergiants and bright giants seems to be very close to the initial value 8.92 (the Sun) or 8.94 (the unevolved B-type MS stars).
[3]  oai:arXiv.org:1809.06129  [pdf] - 1751138
Light chemical elements in stars: mysteries and unsolved problems
Comments: 23 pages, 9 figures, 4 tables
Submitted: 2018-09-17
The first eight elements of the periodic table are discussed: H, He, Li, Be, B, C, N, and O. They are referred to as key elements, given their important role in stellar evolution. It is noteworthy that all of them were initially synthesized in the Big Bang. The primordial abundances of these elements calculated using the Standard Model of the Big Bang (SMBB) are presented in this review. The good agreement between the SMBB and observations of the primordial abundances of the isotopes of hydrogen and helium, D, 3He, and 4He, is noted, but there is a difference of ~0.5 dex for lithium (the isotope 7Li) between the SMBB and observations of old stars in the galactic halo that has not yet been explained. The abundances of light elements in stellar atmospheres depends on the initial rotation velocity, so the typical rotation velocities of young Main Sequence (MS) stars are examined. Since the data on the adundances of light elements in stars are very extensive, the main emphasis in this review is on several unsolved problems.
[4]  oai:arXiv.org:1710.04852  [pdf] - 1589685
Analysis of the non-LTE lithium abundance for a large sample of F-, G-, and K-giants and supergiants
Comments: 15 pages, 5 figures, 2 tables
Submitted: 2017-10-13
A five-dimensional interpolation method and corresponding computer program are developed for using published calculations to determine the non-LTE correction {\Delta\}NLTE to the lithium abundance log{\epsilon}(Li) derived from the Li I 6707.8 {\AA} line. The {\Delta\}NLTE values is determined from the following five parameters: {\Delta\}NLTE the effective temperature Teff, the acceleration of gravity logg, the metallicity index [Fe/H], the microturbulent velocity Vt, and the LTE Li abundance log {\epsilon}(Li). The program is used to calculate values of {\Delta\}NLTE and the non-LTE Li abundance for 91 single bright giants from the list of Lebre, et al. By combining these results with data for 55 stars, we obtain the non-LTE values of log {\epsilon}(Li) for 146 FGK-giants and supergiants. We confirm that, in the spectra of most of these stars, it is only possible to estimate for them an upper limit for the Li abundance. A large spread is confirmed in log {\epsilon}(Li) for stars with masses M<6Msun. A comparison of these results with model calculations of stars confirms the unique sensitivity of the lithium abundance to the initial rotation velocity V0. We discuss the giants and supergiants with lithium abundances log {\epsilon}(Li) = 1.4 +- 0.3, which could have a rotation velocity V0=0 km/s and have already undergone deep convective mixing. Li-rich giants with lithium abundances log {\epsilon}(Li)>2 and nearly up to the initial value of log {\epsilon}(Li) = 3.2 +- 0.1 are examined. It is shown that the fraction of Li-rich giants with V0 = 0 - 50 km/s is consistent with current evolutionary models. The other stars of this type, as well as all of the "super Li-rich" giants, for which the standard theory is untenable, can be explained by invoking the hypothesis of recent lithium synthesis in the star or an alternative hypothesis according to which a giant planet is engulfed by the star.
[5]  oai:arXiv.org:1701.06777  [pdf] - 1534923
The N/O ratio in early B-type main sequence stars as an indicator of their evolution
Comments: 14 pages, 4 figures
Submitted: 2017-01-24
It is shown that, in the case of early B-type main-sequence stars, of the three ratios N/C, C/O, and N/O which are regarded as indicators of stellar evolution, the ratio N/O is more reliable since it seems to be insensitive to overionization of the NII and OII ions. On the other hand, the N/C and C/O ratios, which include carbon, may contain systematic errors for stars with Teff > 18500 K because of neglected overionization of CII ions. The ratio N/O is studied in the atmospheres of 46 early main-sequence B stars. These values of N/O are examined as functions of the effective temperature, age, rotation speed, and mass of the stars. Most early B-stars in the main sequence are found to have [N / O] = 0 , which indicates that N/O varies little during the main sequence stage, and this result is independent of the basic parameters listed above. There are two explanations for the large number of stars with [N / O] = 0 : it is predicted theoretically that for an initial rotation velocity V0 < 100 km/s, N/O varies little toward the end of the main sequence stage ([N/O] < 0.2) and observations show that most early main-sequence B-stars do actually have low initial rotation velocities V0. The few early main-sequence B-stars with higher [N/O] = 0.4-0.8 correspond to models with rotation velocities V0 = 200-300 km/s. This conclusion is consistent with earlier data for stars with the same masses in a later stage of evolution: the AFG-supergiant and bright giant stage.
[6]  oai:arXiv.org:1701.05720  [pdf] - 1534794
Lithium in stellar atmospheres: observations and theory
Comments: 27 pages, 4 figures
Submitted: 2017-01-20
Of all the light elements, lithium is the most sensitive indicator of stellar evolution. This review discusses current data on the abundance of lithium in the atmospheres of A-, F-, G-, and K-stars of different types, as well as the consistency of these data with theoretical predictions. The variety of observed Li abundances is illustrated by the following objects in different stages of evolution: 1) Old stars in the galactic halo, which have a lithium abundance log e(Li)=2.2 (the "lithium plateau") that appears to be 0.5 dex lower than the primordial abundance predicted by cosmological models. 2) Young stars in the galactic disk, which have been used to estimate the contemporary initial lithium abundance log e(Li)=3.2 +/- 0.1 for stars in the Main sequence. Possible sources of lithium enrichment in the interstellar medium during evolution of the galaxy are discussed. 3) Evolving FGK dwarfs in the galactic disk, which have lower log e(Li) for lower effective temperature Teff and mass M. The "lithium dip" near Teff~6600 K in the distribution of log e(Li) with respect to Teff in old clusters is discussed. 4) FGK giants and supergiants, of which most have no lithium at all. This phenomenon is consistent with rotating star model calculations. 5) Lithium rich cold giants with log e(Li) > 2.0 , which form a small, enigmatic group. Theoretical models with rotation can explain the existence of these stars only in the case of low initial rotation velocities V0 < 50 km/s. In all other cases it is necessary to assume recent synthesis of lithium (capture of a giant planet is an alternative). 6) Magnetic Ap-stars, where lithium is concentrated in spots located at the magnetic poles. There the lithium abundance reaches log e(Li)=6. Discrepancies between observations and theory are noted for almost all the stars discussed in this review.
[7]  oai:arXiv.org:1602.02000  [pdf] - 1353741
The Cool Giant HD 77361 - A Super Li-Rich Star
Comments: 13 pages, 3 figures, 4 tables
Submitted: 2016-02-05
Super Li-rich stars form a very small and enigmatic group whose existence cannot be explained in terms of the standard stellar evolution theory. The goal of our study is to check the reality of this group of cool giants based on an independent technique. We have carried out such a check using the K giant HD 77361 (HR 3597), which has previously been assigned to this rare type, as an example. We have redetermined the effective temperature Teff and surface gravity log g for this star. We have applied two different methods, photometric and spectroscopic, to estimate Teff (the accuracy of the Li-abundance determination depends significantly on this parameter). The value of log g has been found from the highly accurate parallax of this nearby star. To apply the photometric method of determining Teff, we have performed UBV observations of the star, which yielded V = 6.18 +/- 0.03, B - V = 1.13 +/- 0.01, and U - B = 1.18+/-0.05. The following parameters of the star have been found: effective temperature Teff = 4370+/- 100 K, surface gravity log g = 2.30 +/- 0.10, iron abundance log e(Fe) = 7.49 +/- 0.14, microturbulence Vt = 1.1 +/- 0.2 km/s, rotational velocity V sin i = 4.5 km/s, and mass M = 1.3 +/- 0.2 Msun. The lithium abundance has been determined from a non-LTE analysis of three Li I lines: the resonance line at 6707.8 ?A and the subordinate lines at 6103.6 and 8126.4 ?A (the latter in a blend with a CN molecular line). We have found a high lithium abundance, log e(Li) = 3.75 +/- 0.11, which exceeds considerably the initial abundance log e(Li) = 3.2 +/- 0.1 for young stars in the solar neighborhood. Thus, we have confirmed that the K giant HD 77361 actually belongs to the type of super Li-rich stars.
[8]  oai:arXiv.org:1412.6950  [pdf] - 911620
Determining the effective temperatures of G- and K-type giants and supergiants based on observed photometric indices
Comments: 11 pages, 3 figures, 2 tables
Submitted: 2014-12-22
A method for determining the effective temperature Teff of G- and K-type giants and supergiants is proposed. The method is based on the use of two photometric indices free from the interstellar absorption influence: the Q index in the UBV photometric system and the [c1] index in the uvby system. Empirical relations between the Teff values found for nearby and bright G- and K-type giants and supergiants with the use of the infrared fluxes method (IRFM), on the one hand, and the observed Q and [c1] indices for these stars, on the other hand, are plotted. A systematic discrepancy between the dependences of Teff on Q for the stars with standard and reduced metallicities is found. Approximating the plotted dependences with second-order polynomials, one can obtain a relatively simple and a rather accurate method for determining the Teff value in the range of 3800 < Teff < 5100 K (based on the Q index) or 4900 < Teff < 5500 K (based on the [c1] index).
[9]  oai:arXiv.org:1411.2722  [pdf] - 895354
Carbon abundance and the N/C ratio in atmospheres of A-, F- and G-type supergiants and bright giants
Comments: 15 pages, 13 figures, 3 tables
Submitted: 2014-11-11
Based on our prior accurate determination of fundamental parameters for 36 Galactic A-, F- and G-type supergiants and bright giants (luminosity classes I and II), we undertook a non-LTE analysis of the carbon abundance in their atmospheres. It is shown that the non-LTE corrections to the C abundances derived from C I lines are negative and increase with the effective temperature Teff; the corrections are especially significant for the infrared C I lines with wavelengths 9060-9660 \AA. The carbon underabundance as a general property of the stars in question is confirmed; a majority of the stars studied has the carbon deficiency [C/Fe] between -0.1 and -0.5 dex, with a minimum at -0.7 dex. When comparing the derived C deficiency with the N excess found by us for the same stars earlier, we obtain a pronounced N vs. C anti-correlation, which could be expected from predictions of the theory.We found that the ratio [N/C] spans mostly the range from 0.3 to 1.7 dex. Both these enhanced [N/C] values and the C and N anomalies themselves are an obvious evidence of the presence on a star's surface of mixed material from stellar interiors; so, a majority of programme stars passed through the deep mixing during the main sequence (MS) and/or the first dredge-up (FD) phase. Comparison with theoretical predictions including rotationally-induced mixing shows that the stars are either post-MS objects with the initial rotational velocities V0 = 200-300 km/s or post-FD objects with V0 = 0-300 km/s. The observed N vs. C anti-correlation reflects a dependence of the C and N anomalies on the V0 value: on average the higher V0 the greater the anomalies. It is shown that an absence of detectable lithium in the atmospheres of the stars, which is accompanied with the observed N excess and C deficiency, is quite explainable.
[10]  oai:arXiv.org:1312.7234  [pdf] - 1202458
Possible Overionization of C II, N II, and O II Ions in the Atmospheres of Early B- and Late O-Type Stars
Comments:
Submitted: 2013-12-27
The reliability of C, N, and O abundances determined from the C II, N II, and O II lines in the main sequence (MS) early B- and late O-type stars is examined. This analysis is based on a fact of primary importance for this problem: the C II, N II, and O II ions in atmospheres of these stars are photoionized by radiation in the far UV. Observations show that the actual flux in this range for hot stars can be considerably higher than theoretical levels; thus, overionization of the C II, N II, and O II ions beyond the ionization calculated with the standard model atmospheres occurs in the actual atmospheres of these stars. Underestimates in the calculated ionization lead to reduced values of the C, N, and O abundances. This is confirmed by the observed dependence on the effective temperature Teff: the C, N and O abundances tend to be lower with increasing Teff. It is shown that overionization becomes significant for sufficiently hot stars, namely when Teff>18500 K for the C II lines and when Teff>26000 K for the N II and O II lines. The systematic difference in the C, N and O abundances between these relatively hot stars and the cooler B-type MS stars is about 0.2 dex. The relatively cool B-type MS stars (Teff<18100 K for C II and Teff<25000 K for N II and O II) yield the undistorted C, N and O abundances, and their average values agree very well with modern estimates for the Sun. It is noted that when an alternative method based on examining the ionization balance (e.g., He I-II, C II-III, Ne I-II, Si III-IV) is used to determine the parameters Teff and log g, the overionization problem essentially vanishes; however, this method leads to a systematic enhancement in Teff and log g. The overionization problem can be solved by shifting to the improved model atmospheres for early B- and late O-type stars that takes their sphericity into account and, possibly, stellar winds and magnetic fields.
[11]  oai:arXiv.org:1212.6057  [pdf] - 607855
Lithium abundance in atmospheres of F- and G-type supergiants and bright giants
Comments: 18 pages, 8 figures
Submitted: 2012-12-25
We present a non-local thermodynamic equilibrium abundance analysis of the resonance doublet Li I at 6707.8 A for 55 Galactic F and G supergiants and bright giants. The derived lithium abundances log \epsilon(Li) may be considered in three groups, namely: (i) 10 Li-rich giants with log \epsilon(Li) = 2.0-3.2 (all 10 are F-type or A9 stars); (ii) 13 G- to K0-type stars with Li abundances in the narrow range log \epsilon(Li) = 1.1-1.8; (iii) all other stars provide just upper limits to the Li abundance. The derived Li abundances are compared with theoretical predictions of 2-15 Msun stars. Our results are generally in good agreement with theory. In particular, the absence of detectable lithium for the majority of programme stars is explainable. The comparison suggests that the stars may be separated by mass M into two groups, namely M < 6 Msun and M > 6 Msun. All Li-rich giants and supergiants with log \epsilon(Li) > 2.0 have masses M < 6 Msun; 11 of 13 stars with log \epsilon(Li) = 1.1-1.8, specifically the stars with M < 6 Msun, show good agreement with the post-first dredge-up surface abundance log \epsilon(Li) = 1.4 predicted for the non-rotating 2-6 Msun stellar models. An absence of Li-rich stars in the range M > 6 Msun agrees with the theoretical prediction that F and G supergiants and giants with M > 6 Msun cannot show detectable lithium. We note that present theory appears unable to account for the derived Li abundances for some stars, namely for (i) a few relatively low-mass Li-rich giants (M < 6 Msun), whose high Li abundances accompanied by rather high rotational velocities or substantial nitrogen excess contradict theoretical predictions; (ii) the relatively high-mass supergiants HR 461 and HR 8313 (M > 6 Msun) with the detected abundances log \epsilon = 1.3-1.5. It is possible that the lithium in such stars was synthesized recently.
[12]  oai:arXiv.org:1212.0987  [pdf] - 1158286
Carbon, Nitrogen and Oxygen Abundances in Atmospheres of the 5-11 M B-type Main Sequence Stars
Comments: 13 pages, 9 figures
Submitted: 2012-12-05
Fundamental parameters and the carbon, nitrogen and oxygen abundances are determined for 22 B-type stars with distances up to 600 pc and slow rotation (vsini up to 66 km/s). The stars are selected according to their effective temperatures Teff and surface gravities log g, namely: Teff is between 15300 and 24100 K and log g is mostly greater than 3.75; therefore, stars with medium masses of 5-11 M are selected. Theory predicts for the stars with such parameters that the C, N and O abundances in their atmospheres should correspond to their initial values. Non-LTE analysis of C II, N II and O II lines is implemented. The following mean C, N and O abundances are obtained: log \epsilon(C) = 8.31+-0.13, log \epsilon(N) = 7.80+-0.12 and log \epsilon(O) = 8.73+-0.13. These values are in very good agreement with recent data on the C, N and O abundances for nearby B stars from other authors; it is important that different techniques are applied by us and other authors. When excluding for the stars HR 1810 and HR 2938, which can be mixed, we obtain the following mean abundances for the remaining 20 stars: log \epsilon(C) = 8.33+-0.11, log \epsilon(N) = 7.78+-0.09 and log \epsilon(O) = 8.72+-0.12; these values are in excellent agreement with a present-day Cosmic Abundance Standard (CAS) of Nieva & Przybilla.
[13]  oai:arXiv.org:1009.0054  [pdf] - 1034599
Nitrogen Enrichment in Atmospheres of A- and F- Type Supergiants
Comments: 14 pages, 13 figures
Submitted: 2010-08-31
Using new accurate fundamental parameters of 30 Galactic A and F supergiants, namely their effective temperatures Teff and surface gravities log g, we implemented a non-LTE analysis of the nitrogen abundance in their atmospheres. It is shown that the non-LTE corrections to the N abundances increase with Teff. The nitrogen overabundance as a general feature of this type of stars is confirmed. A majority of the stars has a nitrogen excess [N/Fe] between 0.2 and 0.9 dex with the maximum position of the star's distribution on [N/Fe] between 0.4 and 0.7 dex. The N excesses are discussed in light of predictions for B-type main sequence (MS) stars with rotationally induced mixing and for their next evolutionary phase, i.e. A- and F-type supergiants that have experienced the first dredge-up. Rotationally induced mixing in the MS progenitors of the supergiants may be a significant cause of the nitrogen excesses. When comparing our results with predictions of the theory developed for stars with the mixing, we find that the bulk of the supergiants (28 of 30) show the N enrichment that can be expected (i) either after the MS phase for stars with the initial rotational velocities v0 = 200-400 km s-1, (ii) or after the first dredge-up for stars with v0 = 50-400 km s-1. The latter possibility is preferred on account of the longer lifetime for stars on red-blue loops following the first dredge-up. Two supergiants without a discernible N enrichment, namely HR 825 and HR 7876, may be post-MS objects with the relatively low initial rotational velocity of about 100 km s-1. The suggested range for v0 is approximately consistent with inferences from the observed projected rotational velocities of B-type MS stars, progenitors of A and F supergiants.
[14]  oai:arXiv.org:0911.1335  [pdf] - 1018267
Accurate Fundamental Parameters or A, F, and G-type Supergiants in the Solar Neighbourhood
Comments: 12 pages, 9 figures. Will be published at MNRAS
Submitted: 2009-11-06, last modified: 2009-11-07
The following parameters are determined for 63 Galactic supergiants in the solar neighbourhood: effective temperature Teff, surface gravity log g, iron abundance log e(Fe), microturbulent parameter Vt, mass M/Msun, age t and distance d. A significant improvement in the accuracy of the determination of log g and, all parameters dependent on it, is obtained through application of van Leeuwens (2007) re-reduction of the Hipparcos parallaxes. The typical error in the log g values is now +-0.06 dex for supergiants with distances d < 300 pc and +-0.12 dex for supergiants with d between 300 and 700 pc; the mean error in Teff for these stars is +-120 K. For supergiants with d > 700 pc parallaxes are uncertain or unmeasurable, so typical errors in their log g values are 0.2-0.3 dex. A new Teff scale for A5-G5 stars of luminosity classes Ib-II is presented. Spectral subtypes and luminosity classes of several stars are corrected. Combining the Teff and log g with evolutionary tracks, stellar masses and ages are determined; a majority of the sample has masses between 4 Msun and 15 Msun and, hence, their progenitors were early to middle B-type main sequence stars. Using Fe ii lines, which are insensitive to departures from LTE, the microturbulent parameter Vt and the iron abundance log e(Fe) are determined from high-resolution spectra. The parameter Vt is correlated with gravity: Vt increases with decreasing log g. The mean iron abundance for the 48 supergiants with distances d < 700 pc is log e(Fe)=7.48+-0.09, a value close to the solar value of 7.45+-0.05, and thus the local supergiants and the Sun have the same metallicity.
[15]  oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0501389  [pdf] - 70501
Surface abundances of light elements for a large sample of early B-type stars - IV. The magnesium abundance in 52 stars - a test of metallicity
Comments: 9 pages, 6 figures. Has been accepted for publication at MNRAS
Submitted: 2005-01-18
From high-resolution spectra a non-LTE analysis of the MgII 4481.2 A feature is implemented for 52 early and medium local B stars on the main sequence (MS). The influence of the neighbouring line AlIII 4479.9 A is considered. The magnesium abundance is determined; it is found that log e(Mg) = 7.67 +- 0.21 on average. It is shown that uncertainties in the microturbulent parameter Vt are the main source of errors in log e(Mg). When using 36 stars with the most reliable Vt values derived from OII and NII lines, we obtain the mean abundance log e(Mg) = 7.59 +- 0.15. The latter value is precisely confirmed for several hot B stars from an analysis of the MgII 7877 A weak line. The derived abundance log e(Mg) = 7.59 +- 0.15 is in excellent agreement with the solar magnesium abundance log e_sun(Mg) = 7.55 +- 0.02, as well as with the proto-Sun abundance log e_ps(Mg) = 7.62 +- 0.02. Thus, it is confirmed that the Sun and the B-type MS stars in our neighbourhood have the same metallicity.